Synchrony Financial (SYF) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
January 23, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Kathryn Miller
executiveThanks, and good morning to all of you. It's a pleasure to have you join our conference call covering this quarter's earnings. Along with the press release issued today, we've also made available a presentation addressing the subjects we intend to discuss on this call. You can find the press release, the detailed financial schedules, and the presentation on our site, synchronyfinancial.com; to get to this material, simply navigate to the Investor Relations portion of the site. Prior to beginning, I'd like to note that forward-looking statements will be part of what we say today; such statements carry risks and uncertainty, and actual results might differ materially; the factors that could lead actual results to differ materially are set out in our SEC filings, which you can access on our website. Throughout this call, we'll be citing non-GAAP financial measures when discussing how the Company performed. A reconciliation of those measures to GAAP financial measures appears in our materials for today's call. Last, Synchrony Financial bears no responsibility for, and neither edits nor guarantees the accuracy of, earnings teleconference transcripts supplied by third parties. Authorized webcasts can be found only on our website. Joining us this morning are Brian Doubles, who serves as Synchrony's President and Chief Executive Officer, and Brian Wenzel, Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer. At this point, I'll hand the call over to Brian Doubles.
Brian Doubles
executiveThanks, Kathryn. Good morning to all of you. Synchrony announced robust Q4 performance today, with net earnings reaching $440 million, equivalent to $1.03 per diluted share, alongside a return on average assets of 1.5% and a return on tangible common equity of 14.7%. Those Q4 figures fed into net earnings for the entirety of 2023 of $2.2 billion, or $5.19 per diluted share, a return on average assets of 2%, and a return on tangible common equity of 19.8%; underpinning this solid financial showing was ongoing consumer resilience, made possible by our multiproduct strategy along with diversified sales platforms. We posted yet another year of record purchase volume, amounting to $185 billion across the full year, which rose 3% versus last year. Our attractive products and value propositions fueled roughly 23 million new accounts originated during 2023, while also lifting our average active accounts by 2.5%. The wide-ranging utility and worth of what we offer keeps resonating strongly among our customers, producing yet another record year for purchase volume. That, paired with payment rates that continued to moderate, generated loan receivables growth of 11.4%. Credit kept normalizing during Q4, with net charge-offs hitting pre-pandemic levels, matching what we had anticipated and helping produce a net charge-off rate of 4.87% for the full year, which remains under our target underwriting range of 5.5% to 6%; we likewise made ongoing strides toward our target operating efficiency ratio, showing cost discipline, all while preserving investments needed to secure our franchise's long-term success; and via solid execution and prudent capital management over time, Synchrony extended our lengthy track record of returning capital, including $1.5 billion given back to shareholders this year. Going back to 2016, we've distributed $3.6 billion in dividends and shrunk our outstanding shares by 50%. Synchrony's capacity to reliably produce and return capital to shareholders stems from our distinctive business model, one that puts priority on delivering attractive risk-adjusted returns consistently across shifting market conditions and economic cycles. Our disciplined execution on key strategic priorities allowed Synchrony's resilient returns by strengthening our core strengths and supporting our continued evolution to match changing preferences and needs; keeping that in mind, Synchrony kept growing and bringing on new partners throughout the past year, adding more than 25 partners and renewing over 30 relationships. Among the new partnerships, we were thrilled to share that J.Crew picked Synchrony to debut its first co-branded credit card, which will be a digital-first program featuring mobile wallet provisioning, strong pre-approval capabilities, scan-to-apply, and direct-to-device credit applications. This competitive win demonstrates our culture of innovation, steady investment in our digital ecosystem, and a strategic focus on empowering our customers and partners to connect seamlessly via best-in-class omnichannel experiences. We also kept diversifying our programs, products, and markets throughout 2023. Broadening the utility of our offerings and extending our reach. Synchrony puts a lot of stock in giving people options — whether that's our customers, our partners, providers, or merchants — as they interact face-to-face or through digital channels, drawing on a complete range of everyday financing products. During this year, we rolled out pre-qualification across multiple products and started showing customers offers placed side by side for both revolving and installment plans, so that choice sits front and center. Thanks to these improvements, customers can compare what each possibility offers them right away and pick whatever fits their financing requirements best at that particular moment. We keep growing our pay later offerings, which are available today at more than 200 provider sites within our health and wellness platform, plus 18 retail partners. When it comes to our partners and providers, pay later fits smoothly within the larger relationship and product lineup, giving them one more way to strengthen ties with customers, and the reaction has been robust. From the time we introduced these offerings, partners carrying them have recorded a 20% increase in new accounts, and 95% of pay later sales originate from net new customers. Synchrony's ongoing efforts to diversify and broaden what we offer over the past year were helped along by chances to extend our reach; during the fourth quarter, we revealed the divestiture of our Pets Best insurance business, and via a minority stake from that transaction, the chance to form a strategic partnership with Independence Pet Holdings, or IPH, which ranks among the top pet-focused firms in North America. Ever since we bought the Pets Best business back in 2019, we've expanded pets in force at an average of more than 45% annually, exceeding twice the growth rate of the industry, making us a top pet insurance provider in the US. We take real pride in what we've managed to accomplish with such an excellent business and team, which gave us substantial understanding of the pet industry at large across the past four years, and we feel sure IPH can leverage its know-how in pet insurance to open up fresh possibilities for Pets Best and deliver even more value to Pets Best customers. What's more, thanks to the strategic relationship built between IPH and us, Synchrony stands ready to obtain even more exposure and insight into the fast-expanding pet industry, as we work to broaden access to adaptable pet care financing nationwide. More recently, Synchrony revealed yet another chance to grow our business and speed up our expansion by purchasing Ally Lending's point-of-sale financing operation. This loan portfolio worth $2.2 billion is made up of partnerships with close to 2,500 merchant locations, and it backs over 450,000 active borrowers in the home improvement services and healthcare sectors. With this purchase, Synchrony will establish a solution in the industry that stands apart, providing revolving credit and installment loans together at the point-of-sale within the home-improvement vertical. Presenting multiple products this way advances our strategy of diversifying our offerings, giving consumers choices while boosting conversions and sales for our partners. This chance additionally lets Synchrony broaden the home specialty financing we provide in roofing, windows, and electrical services; we're enthusiastic about the organic synergies that exist between Ally Lending and the Home & Auto plus Health & Wellness platforms at Synchrony. We're eager to harness our sector knowledge and size to generate operating efficiency and speed up growth across platforms that hold appealing market opportunities and return profiles as time goes on. And naturally, Synchrony's capacity to effectively provide a wide range of financing solutions through an extensive distribution network depends on delivering best-in-class experiences in every single customer interaction. During this year, we keep enhancing how prominent and useful our offerings are in both in-person and digital transactions by introducing digital wallet provisioning capabilities for eight partners, among them PayPal and Venmo, Verizon, TJX and Belk; meanwhile our digital sales kept expanding at a rate beyond the norm, rising 9% to reach close to 39% of all our 2023 sales. Across the past year, Synchrony introduced the initial phase of our marketplace on synchrony.com and inside our native app, where shoppers may discover hundreds of offers highlighting our partner brands combined with tailored multiproduct financing solutions from Synchrony. Indeed, since Synchrony used our analytics and marketing capabilities to build compelling cross-shopping opportunities during this initial launch, the marketplace drew more than 220 million visits from shoppers on behalf of our partners, providers, and merchants, while we more than doubled how many partners took part. To sum up, Synchrony is increasingly present wherever our customer intends to make a purchase or a payment, whether large or small, in-person or digitally, and throughout a constantly widening array of markets and industries; we can serve them at any time and in any manner they wish to be served, with a range of flexible financing solutions that fit their needs at any given moment. Our capacity to seamlessly deliver the versatility of our financial ecosystem across channels, industries, partners and providers alike is precisely what placed Synchrony so well to grow sustainably and deliver appealing risk-adjusted returns, especially as customer needs and market conditions change; having said that, I'll hand the call over to Brian so he can talk about our financial performance in more detail.
Brian Wenzel
executiveThank you, Brian, and good morning to all of you. The results Synchrony posted for the fourth quarter show what our distinctive business and financial model can accomplish when it works exactly as intended. Because our sales platform and spending categories are diversified, we achieved record growth in purchase volume, while our careful underwriting and credit management kept credit performance aligned with what we had expected. Through our retail share arrangements, the economic interests of Synchrony and its partners stayed aligned. When credit conditions normalized toward pre-COVID norms and higher benchmark rates pushed up what we pay for funding, our RSA payments decreased. That gave us some offset against the broader economic backdrop and let Synchrony continue producing steady, appealing returns on a risk-adjusted basis. Beyond that, having a strong balance sheet means we can both return capital to shareholders and put money into opportunities that move us toward our longer-term strategic objectives, while at the same time supporting our customers and partners and addressing what they need today as those needs evolve. Overall, by managing the business carefully and relying on our unique financial approach, Synchrony has been positioned to deliver lasting results for customers, partners, and shareholders through an unpredictable macro environment during the past year and going forward into 2024. Now, turning to what happened in the fourth quarter. Compared with a year earlier, purchase volume increased 3%, demonstrating both the scope and strength of our sales platforms along with the strong value our products deliver in reaching a resilient consumer. In Health & Wellness, purchase volume grew 10%, driven by widespread gains in active accounts, with dental, pet, and cosmetic verticals leading the way. Digital purchase volume went up 5%, driven by more average active accounts and solid engagement from customers. In diversified value, purchase volume increased 4%, reflecting greater spending both in and out of partner locations. Lifestyle purchase volume was up 3%, helped by higher average transaction values in Outdoor and Luxury. Turning to Home & Auto, purchase volume declined 4%, as reduced customer traffic, fewer big-ticket buys, and lower gas prices outweighed gains in Home Specialty, Auto network, and commercial. For Synchrony Dual and co-branded cards, purchase volume climbed 9% and accounted for 43% of total purchase volume in the quarter, showing the wide-ranging utility and value these products offer our customers. Like we mentioned earlier, spending that happens outside of our partner network splits about fifty-fifty between discretionary and nondiscretionary buckets, and that split held fairly consistent across the year. In Q4, we did observe some movement within those buckets — for example, people pulled back on travel and put more toward clothing, and they moved away from gasoline and autos toward grocery and discount retailers — but the broader mix of discretionary versus nondiscretionary didn't shift in any notable way. Ending loan receivables rose 11.4%, a result of both widespread growth in purchase volume and a decline of roughly 110 basis points in payment rates. At 15.9% in the fourth quarter, our payment rate is still about 115 basis points above the five-year pre-pandemic average we use as a benchmark. Net interest income came in at $4.5 billion, up 9%, and that was powered by a 16% increase in interest and fees. The gain in interest and fees came from several things working together: more loan receivables, higher benchmark rates, and a lower payment rate. Net interest margin landed at 15.10%, a decline of 48 basis points compared with the prior year. The main cause of that decline was higher costs on interest-bearing liabilities, which climbed 169 basis points to 4.55% and subtracted 138 basis points from net interest margin. Offsetting some of that pressure, yields on loan receivables improved by 66 basis points, which added 55 basis points to net interest margin. Stronger yield from our liquidity portfolio gave another 29 basis points to net interest margin. A better mix of interest-earning assets resulted from loan receivable growth, which contributed 6 basis points to net interest margin. In the fourth quarter, RSAs came to $878 million, equal to 3.49% of average loan receivables. That figure declined by $165 million versus the prior year, a result of greater net charge-offs that was partially offset by higher net interest income. Provision for credit losses climbed to $1.8 billion, reflecting increased net charge-offs plus a $402 million reserve build that primarily stemmed from loan receivable growth. Other expenses increased 14%, reaching $1.3 billion. The rise was mostly attributable to growth-related items amid continuing strong volume growth, as well as operational losses that have returned to pre-pandemic average levels when measured as a percent of our purchase volume. Several one-time items showed up in this quarter's cost base. A voluntary early retirement program drove $43 million of personnel-related expense. We also booked $9 million tied to restructuring our real estate as we continue reshaping our office presence for a hybrid workforce. The FDIC's special assessment added another $9 million. Then there was $7 million spent getting ready for a possible change to late fee rules, plus $5 million of costs connected to the Pets Best sale. Year over year, our fourth-quarter efficiency ratio came in at 36%, an improvement of about 120 basis points. Strip out the one-time items I just listed, and that ratio would have landed roughly 200 basis points lower for the quarter. Taking everything into account, Synchrony's net earnings came to $440 million, which works out to $1.03 per diluted share, alongside a 1.5% return on average assets and a 14.7% return on tangible common equity. Turning now to Slide 10, I want to walk through the main credit trends we're seeing. Overall, consumers have continued to hold up well even as they dealt with inflation and rising interest rates. That same picture shows up in the external deposit information we monitor, which indicates that average savings account balances drew nearer to where they stood before the pandemic over the course of 2023, then remained fairly stable across the third and fourth quarters. As the year closed out, average savings balances for the industry were still roughly 9% higher than they were in 2020. Thanks to underwriting that stays disciplined across the cycle and the active way we manage credit, we're in a solid position going into 2024. Looking at how we closed out the year, our delinquency ratios came in a bit higher than what we'd typically seen on average between 2017 and 2019, prior to the pandemic. For our 30-plus delinquency rate, the year-end figure stood at 4.74%, which compares with 3.65% the year before and sits 12 basis points above the average we recorded during the fourth quarters of 2017 through 2019. On the 90-plus delinquency side, we landed at 2.28%, up from 1.69% in the same period a year ago, and that figure is 4 basis points above the fourth-quarter average from 2017 to 2019. Then, as anticipated, Synchrony's net charge-offs reached 5.58% in the fourth quarter, versus 3.48% during the comparable period last year, and against an average of 5.49% for the fourth quarters of 2017, 2018, and 2019. We continue to monitor our portfolio closely and act as necessary, allowing us to position the company proactively for 2024 and the years ahead. Turning to reserves, our credit loss allowance represented 10.26% of loan receivables, a decrease of 14 basis points compared with 10.40% during the third quarter. Receivables growth largely drove the $402 million reserve build in the quarter. Moving to slide 12, Synchrony's balance sheet continues to be an area that provides us with flexibility and strength. Demand for our consumer bank products remained strong among customers in the fourth quarter, driving over $3 billion in total deposit growth for that period, which equals 13% growth relative to the previous year. When the quarter closed, 84% of our overall funding came from deposits. Securitized debt was 7%, and unsecured funding made up 9%. Liquid assets plus undrawn credit facilities totaled $19.8 billion, an increase of $2.6 billion versus a year ago, and by the end of the quarter those represented 16.8% of total assets, which is 42 basis points higher than last year.
Brian Wenzel
executiveTurning now to our capital ratios. Just to reiterate, we chose to adopt the CECL transition rules that were put out by the joint federal banking agencies. Each January through 2025, Synchrony will keep applying its yearly transitional adjustments to the regulatory capital metrics, worth roughly 50 basis points. CECL's effect is already reflected in our income statement and balance sheet. On top of that, during Q4, Synchrony altered how its balance sheet presents contractual amounts tied to our retailer partner agreements. At year-end, about $500 million in assets that had been classified as intangible assets were moved into other assets, and prior periods were reclassified so they conform to this presentation; this presentation change had a matching effect on each of our regulatory capital metrics and produced roughly a 50 basis point increase to our capital ratios in both the current and prior years. Under the CECL transition rules and counting this balance sheet change, we closed the fourth quarter with a CET1 ratio of 12.2%, which is 110 basis points below last year's 13.3%. The Tier 1 capital ratio came in at 12.9% versus 14.1% a year ago. The total capital ratio fell 60 basis points to 14.9%. And the Tier 1 capital plus reserve ratio, on a fully phased-in basis, dropped to 22.1% from 22.8% last year. In Q4, we gave back $353 million to shareholders, made up of $250 million in share repurchases plus $103 million in common stock dividends. We finished the quarter with $600 million left under our share repurchase authorization. We're still well-positioned to return capital to shareholders, guided by our business performance, market conditions, regulatory restrictions, and subject to our capital plan; we'll also keep looking for opportunities to finish developing our capital structure by issuing additional preferred stock when conditions permit. Synchrony stays committed to our capital allocation framework, which puts priority on investment in organic growth and paying our regular dividends, then share repurchases and investments in inorganic growth opportunities where rates of return meet or beat those of our other potential uses of capital. Along those lines, as Brian noted, Synchrony announced it is acquiring the Ally Lending point-of-sale financing business, which we see as a terrific chance to extend our leadership position in home improvement and health and wellness verticals, while using our industry expertise and scale to unlock even greater value. We've agreed to buy roughly $2.2 billion of loan receivables at a discount. Once the transaction closes and subject to completion of purchase accounting, we anticipate our CET1 ratio will drop by about 50 basis points, inclusive of our provision for credit losses of roughly $200 million tied to the initial reserve builds. Synchrony expects this acquisition to be accretive to full-year 2024 earnings per share, excluding the impact of the initial reserve build for credit losses. Once we bring the business together, move it onto the PRISM underwriting model, and carry out our strategy, we anticipate delivering an appealing internal rate of return, with tangible book value earned back in roughly 3.5 years. On top of that, selling our Pets Best business should generate a gain of about $750 million after tax during 2024, and that will add roughly 80 basis points to our CET1 ratio, including the capital we must hold against the minority interest in IPH. If you set aside the gain from the sale, we anticipate the transaction will have no effect on earnings. We're enthusiastic about the opportunities we've pinpointed to keep generating steady growth at suitable risk-adjusted returns, and we've built a lengthy record of delivering on both strategic and financial goals. Through 2023, we produced robust growth in purchase volume, which, alongside moderation in the payment rate, gave us solid growth in loan receivables. We took advantage of opportunities in funding net growth, kept broadening our deposit franchise, and as a result turned in appealing net interest income. Credit normalized as we had expected, our RSA performed exactly as intended, and lastly, we honored our pledge to produce positive operating leverage. Now on Slide 14, we'll go over our 2024 outlook. The baseline assumptions behind this discussion are a stable macroeconomic backdrop, GDP growth of about 1.7% for the full year, an unemployment rate of 4.0% at the end of 2024, and a Fed funds rate finishing at 4.75%, with reductions starting in the back half of 2024. This outlook further presumes we close both our Pets Best and Ally Lending transactions during the first quarter of 2024. And because the timing and implementation of a possible final rule on late fees remain uncertain, we haven't factored any related effect into our 2024 financial outlook. Should that final late fee rule be published, we'll come back with an update covering how it affects our financial guidance. Beginning with loan receivables, we believe our compelling value propositions and the wide-ranging utility of our products will keep fueling purchase volume growth. We also expect payment rates to keep moderating, though we think they'll stay above where they were before the pandemic all through 2024. Taken together, these forces ought to produce ending loan receivables growth of 6% to 8%. For the full year, we expect net interest income between $17.5 billion and $18.5 billion. Net interest income ought to track normal seasonal patterns over the course of the year, adjusted for a few things. First, greater interest-bearing liabilities expense as our fixed-rate debt re-prices against higher benchmark rates. Second, how competition for retail deposits plays out and how quickly deposits re-price once rate cuts get underway. Our expectation is that betas will move toward 30% as rates start falling later in the year, which lowers the effect on interest expense during 2024. And third, growth in interest and fee yield, partly offset by larger income reversals. We expect net charge-offs between 5.75% and 6%, which sits inside our targeted underwriting range of 5.5% to 6%. We anticipate that losses will reach their highest point during the first half, then go back to the seasonal patterns seen before the pandemic once delinquency metrics normalize in 2023. For the entire year, we're looking at RSAs between 3.5% and 3.75% of average loan receivables; that figure captures ongoing credit normalization, increased interest expense, and the composition of growth in our loan receivables, with purchase volume growth providing a partial offset. This lower RSA shows how the RSA is built to function and how our interests stay aligned with those of our partners. Lastly, we anticipate hitting an operating efficiency ratio between 32.5% and 33.5% for the year, mostly because our loan yields should improve as credit normalization takes place. This guidance does not include the effect from the Pets Best gain on sale, which we recorded within other income. We stay dedicated to producing operating leverage throughout the year and to putting more resources into the long-term success of our business. As has been shown once more over the last year, Synchrony's business and financial model, built for its specific purpose, is delivering the results it was designed to achieve. Amid a shifting environment, our varied collection of products and platforms keeps fueling growth. Our top-tier credit management guarantees appealing risk-adjusted returns, our RSA offers protection when economic performance shifts, and our solid balance sheet opens up possibilities.
Brian Wenzel
executiveAll things considered, throughout 2023 our operations kept generating value for every group with a stake in us, and we entered 2024 in a strong position. At this point I'll hand things back to Brian so he can share his final remarks.
Brian Doubles
executiveBrian, thank you. In 2023, Synchrony once again turned in a robust set of results. We carried out the strategic priorities that matter most, widening and deepening how we bring customers in and keep them engaged, taking further steps to diversify our products, services, and the value we offer, and lifting the quality of the experiences we create for our customers, partners, providers, and merchants. By concentrating on strengthening what we do best while keeping pace with commerce as it constantly changes, Synchrony has been able to post solid financial results and returns for our shareholders, and at the same time get our business ready for what lies ahead; we have confidence in our capacity to keep growing in a sustainable way and to produce resilient risk-adjusted returns as time goes on, and we are enthusiastic about the opportunities, both near-term and further out, that we see in front of us to create even greater value for the many stakeholders we serve; and with that, I'll hand the call back to Kathryn so she can open the Q&A.
Kathryn Miller
executiveThose are all the remarks we had ready. At this point we'll move into the question-and-answer portion. In order to get to as many people as we can, I'd ask everyone on the line to keep it to one main question plus one follow-up. Should anything further come to mind, our Investor Relations team will be around once this call wraps up. Operator, go ahead and open the Q&A.
Terry Ma
analystThanks, and good morning. Could you discuss what pattern we ought to anticipate for delinquencies during 2024? Is it likely that Q4 or Q1 will represent the peak for delinquencies? Then, when we project ahead into 2025, could you share how confident you are that you will remain inside that net charge-off band of 5.75% to 6%?
Brian Wenzel
executiveCertainly. Thanks, Terry. Regarding how our delinquencies form, and specifically in Q4, first I believe it's necessary to acknowledge that our normalization has happened more slowly than that of every one of our competitors, something partly explained by the reality that we largely held the credit box steady throughout the pandemic. Our sophisticated underwriting instrument PRISM—into which we've poured significant resources starting in 2017—along with the data elements we incorporate, played a major role in shaping that formation as we came out of 2023. It's worth noting that, if you examine both the 30-plus and 90-plus delinquency rates for Q4, those figures sit just 12 basis points and 4 basis points, in that order, above the three-year average spanning 2017 to 2019. Moreover, the current delinquency credit mix looks largely the same as the credit mix from 2019. Given that, I next consider the trending and performance of delinquency a bit, Terry. Looking at it, the steadiness of growth on a month-on-month and year-over-year basis for 30-plus and 90-plus has revealed no deterioration. It's remained extremely steady, falling in a band of 109 basis points to 116 basis points monthly. For 90-plus, the band has been 55 basis points to 63 basis points. So it has been extremely steady. With respect to seasonality, it's largely tracked in line. So I weigh those factors as we sort of—the entry rate is still superior to 2019. Now, as I project that forward, what we anticipate on the charge-off side is that first-half charge-offs will be greater in the first half and smaller in the second half, and that ought to produce a band of 5.75% to 6% across the year; thus, within our underwriting target. Once more, keep in mind that we took steps during Q2 and Q3, which we described. Those are starting to be seen, and you ought to observe their impact beginning to hit delinquencies here in the first half of 2024. With that, we feel positive about where credit stands. We'll keep watching credit trends and what's rolling in, but the favorable entry rate, which has a somewhat negative impact on the float to loss, is genuinely encouraging to us as we head into the year.
Terry Ma
analystUnderstood, thanks. Then for my follow-up regarding the NIM and NII guidance — it seems your assumption was roughly 2 rate cuts. Could you discuss what we ought to anticipate should we end up with more than 2 rate cuts this year?
Brian Wenzel
executiveYes. I appreciate the question, Terry. When I look at our projections, we actually assumed 3 rate cuts, starting in September 2024 and running through the close of the year, and regarding betas, which I mentioned, that figure is 30%. So when you consider rate cuts arriving that late in the year, digital banks typically lag somewhere between 30 and 90 days in terms of when they begin adjusting rates, plus you must also factor in that during Q4, we aim to keep a higher level of financing in place to support seasonal growth; that explains why the beta comes in somewhat lower. Should rate increases occur — either more than that or earlier in the year — you would theoretically see some gain to the net interest margin along with reduced interest on interest-bearing liabilities.
Terry Ma
analystGot it. Thank you.
Brian Wenzel
executiveThanks, Terry.
Rick Shane
analystThanks, everyone, for fielding my questions today. I mainly wanted to discuss how NCOs and RSAs relate when we consider the 2024 guidance. The 2024 guidance from an NCO standpoint essentially places you at the upper end but still inside the range of NCO targets. RSA appears somewhat lower than what we would have observed before the pandemic. I'm assuming that's not really due to credit, but rather due to interest rates. And looking ahead, if we assume net charge-offs end up in that 5.5% to 6% target range, but interest rates begin to decline, will the RSA move back up? Rick, I'd like to understand what the typical range for that RSA ratio would be under ordinary conditions.
Brian Wenzel
executiveOf course, thanks Rick. To start, I'll again point you toward Page 4 in today's materials, where we show risk-adjusted return — essentially how NCOs and RSA relate to each other, and they usually trend in the same direction. You're right about that. Looking ahead to 2024, there's still some improvement expected in net charge-offs, though that gets offset through the RSA. At the same time, interest-bearing liabilities are going to keep creating pressure — 92% of our CDs are set to reprice during 2024, and 74% of our debt will do the same. What that means is the full-year impact of the rate hikes from 2022 and 2023 will work their way through the book. And as we noted in the guidance, we don't anticipate payment rates returning to where they were before the pandemic. As a result, you're not receiving the complete benefit of interest and fee yields flowing back. Your interest-bearing liabilities are elevated, and in principle that should help the company by keeping the RSA low. If those interest-bearing liabilities decline more quickly due to other resets, then you'd see the RSA go up.
Rick Shane
analystAll right, that's all I had. Appreciate it, everyone.
Brian Doubles
executiveThank you, Rick.
Brian Wenzel
executiveAppreciate it, Rick. Enjoy the rest of your day.
Ryan Nash
analystHello, everyone, good morning.
Brian Doubles
executiveMorning to you, Ryan.
Brian Wenzel
executiveRyan, good morning.
Ryan Nash
analystBrian, I'd like to dig a bit deeper into the NII and NIM outlook, if I could, as a follow-up to that first question. Could you walk us through, first, what would take us to the bottom of that range versus the top? It's clearly quite a wide band. And then, could you expand a bit on the 30% beta — is that measured point-to-point? Does it reflect a downside scenario? I just want to be sure we've got a full grasp of it. Then finally, since you're liability-sensitive as rates rise, is there still a route to a 16% NIM, and how long would that take? Thanks.
Brian Wenzel
executiveYeah, thanks for asking, Ryan. Let me start with the beta piece. When we talk about beta here, what we mean is really the beta for the year — effectively, at year-end. If you look at betas across a longer horizon — consider what happens in any cycle where rates decline — my expectation isn't a beta of one; we never saw one during the upcycle, so on the way down we wouldn't see one either. Looking at our liabilities portfolio, on savings we ran roughly 80% beta, and on CDs, 90% beta. Over that down cycle, that's what I'd anticipate. So as time passes, what you'll likely observe is a pattern that mirrors the climb, and it will mirror the descent too. That's my framework for betas across the longer term. Now turning to net interest income, the key issue is what assumption you're using. We've got three rate cuts baked in, while the market has six, with some calling for one as soon as March. So clearly, if interest-bearing liabilities reprice sooner and rate declines are larger, that could lift your NII dollars. On the flip side, if no cuts materialize, that could drag you somewhat lower. The other major variable in play will be how this payment rate behaves. On payment rate, we've taken a conservative stance, assuming it doesn't return to where it was before the pandemic. My sense is the decline has come more slowly than we anticipated during 2023. Broadly, those are the pieces that move as you shift across a range from $17.5 billion to $18.5 billion.
Ryan Nash
analystUnderstood. Then, to follow up regarding credit, you mentioned that delinquencies are beginning to return to more typical trends, plus charge-offs (ph) picking up in Q2. Brian, should your forecast turn out right, at what point does the allowance begin to decline? When does it hit its peak and then fall? And perhaps just explain the possible size of that decline across the year. Thanks.
Brian Wenzel
executiveYes. So on a coverage rate basis, we start the year at 10.26%. My expectation is that during Q1, you'll observe a seasonal increase, with receivables declining, that's point 1. Point 2 involves <<inaudible>> totaling just under $200 million, roughly $200 million, from the Ally Lending portfolio that we're bringing in. Purchase accounting marks will also push that coverage rate up somewhat, and that doesn't flow through the P&L; therefore, you're going to witness an increase really in Q1, so to speak, on a seasonal basis. As we leave 2024 (ph), we expect it to be below 10.26%; so mostly you'll see growth builds occurring throughout the year, yet rate declines will also appear. A portion of the QAs burns off or becomes realized. And once more, should credit behave the way we anticipate, you'd finish trending down near the day-one level — we certainly won't reach day-one in 2024, but moving lower as the year progresses.
Ryan Nash
analystThanks for the color, Brian.
Brian Wenzel
executiveThanks, Ryan.
Moshe Orenbuch
analystThank you. I realize your outlook doesn't account for the late fee ruling at this point, since it hasn't come out yet, but perhaps you could — you brought up that roughly $7 billion was spent getting ready. Could you discuss what you're doing to prepare, and share any fresh perspective on the situation, given that here we are nearing the end of January and still nothing has come from the CFPB?
Brian Doubles
executiveYes, absolutely, Moshe. I'll take that one. Clearly, we're still awaiting the final rule, but even so, although a few things remain unclear regarding the implementation timeline and other details we expect in that final rule, we've now been at this for nearly a whole year; it's extremely complex. Our teams have put in substantial effort getting ready. We've dedicated considerable time to working with our partners. We've settled on pricing moves and offsets that we'd put into place once the final rule arrives. So it truly is all the effort that's been underway throughout the past year. What I mean is systems-related work. You have to send out many CITs, modify terms. So that's essentially the nature of it. I'd add that our discussions with partners have proven quite productive; they completely understand that absent those offsets, a significant share of their customers whom we approve now and whom we underwrite and extend credit to would lose their access to credit. That's obviously something we don't want, and they don't want either; so essentially no shift from what we've previously stated. Our aim is to safeguard our partners and completely counterbalance the effect of the final rule once it lands. And we intend to keep extending credit to the same customers we serve now.
Moshe Orenbuch
analystGreat, thank you. And as a follow-up question, if we consider the various verticals, clearly 2023 brought strong growth, while a few within Home & Auto were a bit softer, especially toward the end of the year. Looking ahead to 2024, do you anticipate any shifts in the growth mix, or anything regarding launches and product refreshes that will fuel those different lines?
Brian Doubles
executiveYeah, I'd say, look, overall we'd keep expecting above-average growth in Health & Wellness. That's a platform where we've ramped up investment over the last year or two. We're getting really solid growth from buying Allegro Credit. It's a large market, and we hold a leading position. This covers dental, vet, cosmetic, with strong engagement across the partner network; so that's a platform we'll keep putting money into, and we'd anticipate growth there running higher compared with the other platforms. Another one worth noting is digital. There we have Venmo, Verizon, PayPal, Amazon, so I believe you'd keep seeing above-average growth in that area. Then perhaps somewhat softer in lifestyle and home and auto. Brian, I'm not sure if you'd like to add anything there.
Brian Wenzel
executiveNo, what you'll find is that Health & Wellness along with digital are going to come in above average. Diversified value should land near the company average, possibly just a touch under, and then lifestyle is what you'll see. And look, when it comes to the trend in home and auto, especially home, what we're observing is that store foot traffic is lower, and frequency isn't necessarily way off, but it's more about transaction values. Our customers are — they're purchasing a mattress, they aren't purchasing a high-end mattress, they're purchasing one that's a bit lower. So that trend is something we'd expect to carry on into the beginning of 2024.
Moshe Orenbuch
analystThanks very much.
Brian Doubles
executiveThanks, Moshe.
Brian Wenzel
executiveThanks, Moshe.
John Hecht
analystMorning, and I appreciate you both fielding my questions. A lot of what I wanted to ask has already come up, but there's one more thing on my mind — I believe recoveries tied to charge-offs have been running thin, and that's been one piece of the puzzle across the last 2 years. Brian, I'd like to know how much a recovery, or recoveries generally, might play into the NCO guide?
Brian Wenzel
executiveYes. I appreciate that, John, and good morning to you. On the recoveries front, a few moves were made during the pandemic period. First, we decided strategically to bring our recovery operations in-source. Previously a large portion was handled by outside parties, and by moving that work in-house we essentially lifted the rates on what we ultimately collect on dollars written off, so that worked in our favor as time went on. You're correct that on a rate basis — especially with some level of forward flow — that figure is lower, and your total charge-offs are lower too, yet the improvement we gained from greater efficiency via in-sourcing has I think offset that. So as a relative percentage, I'd call it flat. It really ought to climb once we get past 2023, for 2 reasons. First, you're right that we'll simply have more volume on the net charge-off basis. Second, should rates ease, the cost of capital for those buying written-off paper ought to decline, and pricing in the market improves. So there are several dynamics at play for us, and it hasn't been much of a problem on net charge-offs, and likely getting beyond '24 could deliver a tailwind.
John Hecht
analystAll right, and perhaps this is more of a big-picture question. Brian, I believe you said that spending on non-discretionary items compared with discretionary items stayed the same. What I'm curious about is this — since inflation has been leveling off and student loan payments have restarted, do you notice anything at the edges suggesting consumer habits are shifting? Or has it simply remained steady in light of those macro developments?
Brian Wenzel
executiveYes, John, as we pointed out, what we observe is a slight rotation away from certain travel categories toward other items. That pattern was stronger in the fourth quarter, and we'd anticipate travel to soften as we head into 2024, so that piece is larger. So, we don't observe a move between discretionary and nondiscretionary. We don't observe a move in which the consumer is attempting to truly stretch every dollar. We do observe our transaction values declining while frequency rises somewhat, meaning that when consumers make purchases, they aim to use their dollars efficiently, yet they aren't really pulling back sharply; so, from my perspective, I don't see any huge, dominant trends. I'd say that for the first 20 days — and I always use that as a reference point — sales came in slightly weaker than what we expected as we began 2024, though that's just 20 days of data, and if I spoke with some of my retail contacts, they'd say weather was a factor, with a number of states experiencing cold conditions and major storms; even so, foot traffic has been lower broadly across the board as 2024 got underway.
John Hecht
analystGreat. Appreciate the color.
Brian Doubles
executiveThanks, John.
Brian Wenzel
executiveThank you, John. Enjoy your day.
Mihir Bhatia
analystHello, and I appreciate you fielding my questions. To begin, I'd like to inquire about renewals within the portfolio and shifts in that portfolio. I should apologize — this has two parts. First, could you remind us what your renewal schedule looks like? Do any sizable programs have renewals approaching within the coming 24 months? The second part: we've just been through credit normalization, and the late fee rule is still pending; so I'm curious how the current climate looks for renewals and RFPs when you're speaking with retailers. Are retailers holding out for greater certainty, or — I realize you just announced J.Crew this morning, and you're also acquiring the Ally portfolio; but what about the remaining large retail programs? Could you frame your pipeline for us, describe how it appears, and give us context for it compared with a year ago, several years back, or a typical environment? Thank you.
Brian Doubles
executiveSure — I'd say, to begin, I'll address your second point first, meaning late fees and the way they're affecting the pipeline. In my view, this does render pricing for new business — and even renewals, to a degree — somewhat tougher. Even so, we've managed to navigate it. You brought up J.Crew. That new program is something we're thrilled to announce. Still, it takes time. That's simply part of negotiating, correct? There's conjecture around it, plus a degree of uncertainty. So you have to attempt to protect yourself against those potential scenarios, and we think we've accomplished that; consequently, pricing new business or renewals becomes, in my view, somewhat tougher. I believe some clarity will arrive within the coming month or two, which should resolve it and smooth things somewhat from that standpoint; nevertheless, it has affected, I'd argue, not just us but other players in the market too. Once she gets through, it's a major element of the conversation. When I consider the BD or sales process, much of it revolves around capabilities, technology, data analytics, data sharing — all of that. Yet once you reach the financials, this has become a major element of the discussion that's worked its way in over the past 12 months, purely because of the uncertainty. Another point, regarding our renewal pipeline: the overwhelming majority of our programs sit in 2026 and later. That said, whenever an opportunity arises, as always, if an early renewal opportunity arises, or if the partner wishes to alter something in the deal, or we wish to alter something, we'll meet and determine whether the term can be extended a few years. So that's something we're constantly and actively pursuing alongside our partners.
Brian Wenzel
executiveRight, the sole point I'll address is, or rather just tack on, that in February you'll see — once again, we'll keep refreshing the figure for revenue secured by contract for 2026 and afterward. So look for that come February.
Mihir Bhatia
analystGreat, thanks. Moving on to a different topic — regarding how healthy the consumer is, it sounds stable and you still seem fairly positive. So I wanted to ask about your approach to underwriting. A soft landing is clearly turning into the mainstream expectation. I realize you don't tend to make drastic swings there, but what's your take on that underwriting stance? Perhaps you could describe what your criteria look like now compared with a year back, or even 2019. Does 2024 count as more of a typical year? Is it still somewhat restrictive, with room to ease up and fuel expansion? Any thoughts would be welcome.
Brian Wenzel
executiveYeah, once more we find ourselves here — there have been plenty of problems and difficulties from attempts to underwrite growth in the ‘21 and ‘22 vintages, and folks are dealing with the consequences today. Certain people call it growth mass. Others call it abandoning standards and accepting lower returns; so using credit purely as a growth tool isn't something we'll do, and we're more battle-tested than 12 months ago. As we've mentioned, we make idiosyncratic moves on partners and channels — I won't claim daily, but definitely we monitor it each day; we implemented wider-ranging measures in both 2Q and 3Q because of the shared consumer and what others have done regarding underwriting. We felt somewhat heartened in the fourth quarter when we observed at the bureaus that other issuers had started taking credit measures, which should help the industry later in 2024. Still, I believe we'll stay careful as the year progresses. We'll keep monitoring consumer patterns. Once more, we haven't observed the consumer stretching. Looking at payment rates, shifts in payment rate by credit tier have stayed pretty steady, and likely the largest change has occurred in the 6.60 to 7.20 (ph) bracket, which is what you'd find with a non-prime individual. So once more, we examine it and conclude, alright, I don't detect the consumer stretching when it comes to spending and having trouble. We don't notice the payment rate shifting. We'll keep watching the flow and the delinquency. Once again, entry rate remains stronger than 2019, and of course, the flow to loss deteriorates whenever entry rate declines. But on the whole — we're on the whole cautiously optimistic about credit, and that's shown in the guidance of 5.75% to 6%.
Mihir Bhatia
analystThank you.
Brian Wenzel
executiveThanks, Mihir. Have a good day.
Sanjay Sakhrani
analystThank you. Morning to everyone. Brian Doubles, you were quite busy when it came to deals, what with divesting the pet insurance unit along with a portion of the business, and then picking up the Ally Lending operation. Might you share a bit more about what was behind those choices, and then how the pipeline for additional transactions is shaping up? I mean, I believe there's at least one major opportunity out there when it comes to a portfolio. So, could you discuss where things stand on that front?
Brian Doubles
executiveSure, let me — well, perhaps I should begin with Ally since it's the newer of the two deals. I mean, look, I'd say we're incredibly thrilled about this purchase. I think it's genuinely beneficial for both organizations; these were discussions that JB and I kicked off during the first half of ‘23. I'd say this wasn't a scale business for Ally, but from where we sit, this is definitely a scale business; this is precisely the kind of acquisition that we pursue. These are sectors and industries we understand very well. We clearly already have a footprint in home improvement and health and wellness; actually, as we dug into this, we discovered that we serve a number of the same partners. So when I think about Ally, it truly just enhances and speeds up our existing strategy. I also believe that, and Brian touched on this, got a very appealing financial profile, it’s EPS accretive, it's got a solid ROA that'll be at or perhaps somewhat above the company average. We gain 2,500 new merchants; we gain 500,000 new customers. So there's genuinely plenty to appreciate here. I mean, this is a good bolt-on acquisition for us and will be a good addition for both Home & Auto, but also Health & Wellness; and then Pets Best was really more of a chance opportunity. We weren't seeking to offload the pet insurance business. It's been a wonderful business for us. We're clearly generating a lot of value in a fairly brief stretch of time We did a fantastic job expanding the business. Since 2019, we grew the pets in force over 5x. We moved the business from number seven or number eight to the number four pet insurance provider in the US. And when IPH came to us, it was a terrific offer, hard to reject. It's over 10x our original investment; we'll book a nice after-tax gain. But I think even more significant than that, it lets us remain invested in the pet space and do it alongside someone, a fantastic partner like IPH that has the scale, that has the expertise. And so we believe there's not only a good financial gain, but a long-term strategic play here that will benefit us; so it's a great way to wrap up the year with two, I think, really excellent transactions.
Sanjay Sakhrani
analystAny other deals? What else might be available?
Brian Doubles
executivePardon me, Sanjay, could you repeat that one more time?
Sanjay Sakhrani
analystRight, so as I was asking — what other possibilities could there be, sir? There's one major portfolio sitting out there at the moment.
Brian Doubles
executiveRight. Well, there's plenty on our plate, I'd say that first; we need to complete both of these deals, and our hope is to have that done during the first quarter. There's certainly a great deal happening in 2024. That being said, we usually receive invitations to nearly every RFP in this area, and the priorities we hold haven't shifted. We're seeking a solid risk adjusted return; we're seeking truly strong alignment with the partner. That is likely the single most crucial factor, especially when considering big deals. You have to be certain that both sides are happy with the arrangement whether times are good or bad, that our interests line up when it comes to marketing and credit and underwriting and really every element of the program; so we will remain open to opportunities matching that criteria.
Sanjay Sakhrani
analystUnderstood, and I have just one more question. Brian Wenzel, regarding your reserve coverage, what figure are you — or rather, for the full year, what level are you projecting for the unemployment rate in particular?
Brian Wenzel
executiveWhen we finish 2024, the unemployment rate stands at 4%.
Sanjay Sakhrani
analystUnderstood. Fine, excellent. Appreciate it.
Brian Doubles
executiveThank you, Sanjay. Take care.
Jeff Adelson
analystHi there, good morning, and thank you for fielding my questions. When we look back at the prior year, your loan growth ultimately landed near those original projections — that roughly 8% to 10% band you'd initially guided to. So I'm curious whether you see room for some upside, or perhaps a comparable setup, as we move through this year? Then, drilling down a bit more, could you walk through the particular factors that would push you toward the bottom versus the top of that 6% to 8% range — things like payment rate, consumer spend, new account growth, and possibly how much additional lift you believe this installment opportunity might contribute to your growth? It feels like you may be stepping in a bit more aggressively here, given the acquisition and the pre-qualification launch happening this year.
Brian Wenzel
executiveSure. Looking at the growth rate, Jeff, a handful of factors could land you at the bottom of that band, correct? A weaker consumer, right? The macro backdrop deteriorates — that's the first one. Second, if the payment rate stays higher than what we're modeling, you'd sit at the low end — potentially below that band. And should the credit moves we've made wind up hitting sales harder than anticipated — again, not significant overall — that could take you under the range too. On the flip side, thinking about the top of the band: if payment rates come down more quickly than anticipated, that's one. If the economy turns out somewhat stronger than what we're observing — we provided that GDP growth figure — but should it be a bit stronger and spending rises, you could see additional upside there. As for — well, definitely home specialty, which is a vertical within Home & Auto that's expanded well for us and will keep expanding well for us. It truly won't shift the company average, so it's a solid acquisition. The acquisition on its own generally won't be sizable enough to shift many of the underlying metrics. You'll get the day-one bump, and it will certainly grow as we build synergies linking our home specialty platform with what is a highly attractive Ally Lending point of sale platform. So the combined entity will expand somewhat quicker, yet it shouldn't shift the needle for the company overall.
Jeff Adelson
analystUnderstood, and as a quick follow-up regarding the updated expense ratio guidance—previously, you provided something closer to a quarterly dollar figure. It sounds as though you may be suggesting expense growth in the very low single digit range for next year. Is that accurate, and where do you see efficiencies being realized? Would that be in marketing, reduced compensation, or other areas?
Brian Wenzel
executiveYes, so to begin with, regarding the shift toward an efficiency ratio, Jeff, if you remember, several years back, we actually used an efficiency ratio, and that was our long-term guidance. We changed course during the pandemic due to the effects on revenue, because of the payment rate dislocation we observed; so we aimed to be more useful to investors and analysts by shifting to dollars. At this point, we are simply transitioning back to where we ought to be in terms of an efficiency ratio and where the industry typically functions, first of all. As for the expense dollars, when I examine controllable dollars—so if I exclude operational losses, which we can manage, but set that aside momentarily—and you also take out marketing, which is more contractual for us depending on volume. Our expense growth is occurring at a slower pace. Thus, we are achieving operating leverage within the company. We require several investments, as you noticed in our notable items, both for a voluntary early retirement program and for some smaller yet still significant effects on our facilities, which will generate a benefit in 2024; so from a controllable expense perspective, there will be—you will observe operating levers in that area; concerning operational losses, we have put money into some additional tools that include some new strategies; so we anticipate that growth rate will truly level off as we go from ‘23 to ‘24.
Jeff Adelson
analystThat's great, thanks.
Brian Wenzel
executiveAppreciate it, Jeff. Enjoy the rest of your day.
John Pancari
analystMorning. I’ve got a few quick follow-ups regarding the late fee issue. On the offsets, could you remind us which mechanism is probably going to matter most when it comes to softening the hit from those late fees? Would it be the additional fees, or the base interest rates you’re adjusting? Then, second, when it comes to the competition involved in negotiating those offsets you said are already in place — how intense is that competition? Are there rivals out there who would be willing to absorb the expense? And do you think it’s possible that some relationships could shift because of this?
Brian Doubles
executiveSure, I’ll take the second one first. My view is that with the new late fee proposal, everyone is competing under the same conditions; so when we’re out there working on either a renewal or new business, the effect is identical. It really boils down to the required rate of return for the issuer and which factors matter most to them. Because it hits all of us the same way, I don’t expect much change in the competitive dynamic; it truly hinges on the kind of portfolio, what the partner cares about, the sharing, the alignment, everything I mentioned; so I don’t think it will have — I don’t anticipate a major effect there. And especially once we get some clarity on a final rule, I believe it becomes even more obvious what should be factored in. And, Brian, why don’t you say a bit about the APRs and fees?
Brian Wenzel
executiveOkay, John, so we clearly have a collection of adjustments to our pricing approach that are going to take effect. Some of those will arrive on a quicker timetable during 2024, and they'll involve fees as well as certain policy shifts. On top of that, there will be APR hikes that accumulate, and you'll see a portion of those in 2024 should the rule be issued, with the rest building through 2025. So if that rule does get issued, we'll return and likely give somewhat more detail about how to think through it in the context of 2024. Certain ones among these will carry a larger near-term effect, while others will carry a larger effect over the longer term. And so, once we have a final rule and we begin rolling out some of these actions, we'll be able to offer a bit more clarity.
John Pancari
analystUnderstood. Alright, that's helpful. Thanks; and moving on to the second point, regarding your purchase volume, I appreciate the detail you provided on what's driving the various verticals. Broadly speaking, when we think about 2024, what do you anticipate for total card purchase volume, or overall purchase volume, for the entire year compared with 2023, and likewise for total account growth? Thanks.
Brian Wenzel
executiveSure, so what I'd tell you is, John, we aren't providing specific guidance on purchase volume. Clearly, you've observed that the pace of asset growth has slowed from 2023 into 2024, and there was a certain effect a year ago tied to that asset growth — coming from declines in payment rates, which, as we've said, we don't expect to carry the same weight in 2024. So my sense is you'll see something broadly in line with what we saw a year ago, most likely. I mean, a solid reference point is to step back and note that we observe GDP running at 1.7%. We expand at a multiple of that. So once more, likely broadly in line with a year ago. You also need to keep in mind that our purchase volume reached $185 billion for 2023, which was a record high for this company; as a result, we're up against a tough comparison as we enter 2024. That said, we take pride in the sales platforms and in the differentiation and diversification that exists within those platforms.
John Pancari
analystAll right, excellent. Thanks very much.
Brian Wenzel
executiveThank you, John. Enjoy the rest of your day.
Mark DeVries
analystYes, thank you. I'd like to hear your perspective on issuing preferred equity during this year. Brian, must that be additional to overall capital levels, or does it create room for you to substitute some of it with common—or give some common back? Could you discuss possible timing, what you feel you need to observe from the market's standpoint, and also the amount you might intend to issue?
Brian Wenzel
executiveYes, I appreciate the question, Mark. When we examine the capital stack, our Tier 2 is fully developed. We possess roughly 75 basis points, more or less, of capacity within Tier 1, meaning the maximum you could likely undertake merely to hit the Tier 1 target would be approximately $750 — $700 million to $750 million, which is ultimately what you'd wish to accomplish. We don't really view that in relation to common equity so much as we aim to build, most definitely, the capital structure that is the most cost-effective, and its timing will hinge on market conditions. Rates across 2023 were extremely elevated, and it wasn't really the ideal moment to issue it. We'll monitor how markets evolve in 2024 and whether there is appetite to invest or demand for the products; and we'll also examine the structure, specifically whether that's a more retail-focused preferred stock or not. So numerous different factors come into play; it truly comes down to how I fully develop every level of the capital stack from a regulatory perspective.
Mark DeVries
analystAll right, that's helpful. Now, as a quick follow-up, could you share your latest thinking regarding the ways you intend to put to work the funds that came from the Pets Best divestiture?
Brian Wenzel
executiveSure. Our list of priorities, as I see it, stays the same. Back in ’23, a few tweaks we made allowed us to build up some capital. Roughly 50 basis points of that will go toward the Ally transaction, while the Pets Best sale should bring in around 80 basis points, once you account for the investment we're taking back in IPH. So that all feeds into the overall pool, so to speak. Our first priority is organic growth, second is keeping the dividend intact, and third, we'd consider either share repurchases or any other inorganic possibilities that arise. As before, we're quite disciplined about inorganic possibilities. It needs to be the right fit. The pricing has to be exceptionally attractive, and we believe that's what we secured with Ally Lending. So we'll be careful about how we deploy that capital. That said, the Pets Best transaction isn't causing us to alter our strategy or our pace.
Mark DeVries
analystUnderstood. Appreciate it.
Brian Wenzel
executiveThank you, Mark. Enjoy your day.
Mark DeVries
analystThanks.
Operator
operatorThanks a lot. I appreciate everyone for joining in. At this point, you're free to hang up, and I hope the rest of your day is great.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Synchrony Financial transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Synchrony Financial earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Synchrony Financial or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.