Synchrony Financial (SYF) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

April 24, 2024

New York Stock Exchange US Financials Consumer Finance earnings 63 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Kathryn Miller

executive
#1

Thank you, and good morning to all of you. It's a pleasure to have you join our quarterly earnings conference call. Along with the press release issued today, we've also made available a presentation that addresses the subjects we intend to talk about on this call. You can find the press release, the detailed financial schedules, and the presentation on our website, synchronyfinancial.com. To access this information, simply navigate to the Investor Relations section of that site. Before we begin, please allow me to remind everyone that forward-looking statements will be part of what we discuss today. Such statements carry risks and uncertainty, and actual results might differ materially. The factors that could lead actual results to differ materially are listed in our SEC filings, which you can access on our website. Throughout this call, we will reference non-GAAP financial measures when discussing how the company has performed. A reconciliation of those measures to GAAP financial measures is included in our materials for today's call. Lastly, Synchrony Financial bears no responsibility for, and neither edits nor guarantees the accuracy of, earnings teleconference transcripts that third parties provide. The only authorized webcast can be found on our website. Joining us this morning are Brian Doubles, who serves as Synchrony's President and Chief Executive Officer, and Brian Wenzel, our Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer. At this point, I'll hand the call over to Brian Doubles.

Brian Doubles

executive
#2

Kathryn, thanks, and good morning to all of you joining. For the first quarter, Synchrony delivered strong performance, and that figure includes the completion of two transactions we'd announced earlier. The initial one involved selling off our Pets Best insurance division, generating an after-tax gain of $802 million in the quarter, and it positions us to extend our reach into the rapidly growing pet space through a minority ownership position in international pet holdings that came to us as part of that deal. The subsequent one was our acquisition of Ally Lending's point-of-sale financing business, valued at $2.2 billion, which will complement our existing offerings in home and auto as well as health and wellness sales platforms. All told, through these agreements Synchrony's unique product lineup in the market gets broader, and our reputation as the go-to partner grows stronger as we create value over the long haul for all the stakeholders we serve. Excluding the impact from the Pets Best gain on sale, adjusted net earnings for Synchrony in the first quarter came to $491 million, equal to $1.18 per diluted share, and we also recorded a 1.7% return on average assets plus a 16.8% return on tangible common equity. What these figures show is just how durable Synchrony's capacity to earn is over time, because we turn in solid results while simultaneously positioning the business for robust risk-adjusted growth going forward. Thanks to the way our business is built, we can quickly assess and adapt no matter what point in the cycle or what conditions we're facing, since customers and partners keep responding to our broad range of products, compelling offers, and advanced technology. During Q1, we brought in 4.8 million new accounts, and average active accounts came in 3% higher. Purchase volume for the first quarter reached $42 billion through our products and value propositions — up 2% versus a year earlier and our strongest first quarter on record. In Health & Wellness, purchase volume grew 8%, with pet, dental, and cosmetic leading the way and active account growth spread across the board; on the diversifying value side, purchase volume was up 4%, fueled by spending both with our partners and elsewhere. On the digital side, purchase volume increased 3%, which shows consumers kept engaging as average active accounts grew. Within home and auto, purchase volume declined 3%: solid gains in home specialty and the auto network, plus what the Ally Lending acquisition contributed, were outweighed by a mix of reduced customer traffic, fewer purchases with large tickets, and cheaper gas. Meanwhile, lifestyle purchase volume decreased 4%, a result of lower transaction values. For the quarter, dual and co-branded cards accounted for 42% of total purchase volume and were up 6%, since our value propositions keep fueling stronger engagement and growth. When you look at spending that happens outside of our partner network, it spans a wide array of categories, industries, and products, and it gives us a closer look at how consumers behaved across the quarter. January's spending took a hit from tough weather, with average transaction frequencies falling 4% compared with the same month a year earlier. Then in February and March things bounced back, especially in nondiscretionary areas. On the whole, consumers leaned more toward nondiscretionary spending during the quarter and moved away from some discretionary areas such as home furnishings, travel, and entertainment. Even with that shift in mix, we're still seeing growth across a broad range of both discretionary and nondiscretionary categories. Looking at the whole company, Synchrony keeps picking up signals that spending from nonprime borrowers has eased off, while growth in purchase volume for our portfolio is still being powered by consumers with stronger credit grades. Among super prime cardholders, the typical transaction size keeps climbing; likewise, we're seeing growth in how often prime and super prime customers transact; on the whole, these shifts in how consumers spend point to a financially healthy customer who is growing more deliberate about what they buy and matching that to their cash flow. That same pattern has carried over into how Synchrony's credit book is performing. Payment rates across the portfolio are still settling down and came in at 15.8% during the first quarter, roughly 90 basis points below the same period a year ago and roughly 60 basis points above where payment rates averaged during our first quarters spanning 2015 through 2019. Whether viewed by generation or by credit grade, payment rates are moderating at a slower clip than before, and paired with the spending patterns we've been tracking, this strengthens our belief that consumers are broadly returning to spending and repayment habits closer to what we saw before the pandemic. Several of our other measures of consumer financial health back this up as well, among them a robust job market and outside deposit information showing fairly steady balances in savings accounts throughout the industry. All of this together feeds into Synchrony's latest delinquency results, which we call out on Slide 11, where the pace of change compared with a year earlier has eased now that our portfolio sits within pre-pandemic bounds. Our delinquency figures have normalized and recently steadied at a slower tempo than what most of our competitors in the industry have seen, which highlights how potent the mix of our rigorous underwriting, cutting-edge analytics and refined credit management capabilities really is. We feel good about where things stand, and our expectation remains that the peak in net charge-offs across our portfolios will arrive within the first half of this year. We are continually monitoring the metrics within our portfolio and tracking credit trends across the broader industry, while continuing to make lending choices designed to put our portfolio in the strongest possible position for 2024 and beyond. Synchrony leverages a broad range of both proprietary data and information from third parties — including behavioral patterns in payments, billions of transactions, and alerts from credit bureaus — to produce actionable insights that inform how we approach underwriting, products, and credit management at the level of individual accounts, channels, and the overall portfolio. Being able to harness those insights and provide optimized financing solutions and experiences for our customers and partners, even as their needs change and market conditions move, is exactly what lets Synchrony reliably produce the results that count most for our numerous stakeholders and steadily establishes us as the partner of choice. Along those lines, Synchrony brought on or renewed over 25 partners during the first quarter, among them BRP, and formed 2 new technology partnerships with Adit practice management software and ServiceTitan; we're thrilled about our new tie-up with BRP, a worldwide leader in powersports and marine products, which will allow their U.S. Dealers can now offer secured installment financing for their well-liked powersports range, covering Ski-Doo, Sea-Doo, and CaN-Am on- and off-road vehicles. Thanks to Synchrony, our financing options will come with adaptable terms, whether customers apply online or complete the process at the dealership, which highlights our ability to serve the wide-ranging needs and preferences of those we serve. In addition, Synchrony's strategic technology partnerships — one with Adit practice management software and another with ServiceTitan — both represent opportunities to build smooth customer experiences while expanding reach for our diverse portfolio of financial solutions and services. Synchrony has teamed up with Adit — one of the industry's leading dental practice management software providers — and this partnership is going to expand CareCredit availability to dental offices nationwide. It also brings in an integration with AditTech on the patient side, so both patients and practitioners get something that's seamless and simple to use. When a patient sits in the dentist's chair, connecting them to payment options right there matters a lot — it helps keep their whole care experience running as smoothly as possible — and on the other end, dental practices benefit from revenue cycle management that's faster and more efficient. Along those same lines, Synchrony is going to integrate with ServiceTitan, a top software platform built to power trades businesses, which will allow contractors to provide home improvement financing using our direct-to-device application process. When flexible financing is available right where they are, it lets customers pick an option that moves them toward what they're aiming for, and at the same time contractors benefit from a sales process without friction — this holds whether we're establishing fresh connections or strengthening and improving ones we already have. Synchrony has a thorough grasp of what those we serve require and anticipate, along with what the merchants, partners, and providers we work with are trying to accomplish. The way we've been able to serve these stakeholders and keep producing solid results no matter what conditions we face speaks to how robust Synchrony's business model is and how dedicated our amazing team is. And on the subject of that team, attracting and keeping the strongest people matters more now than ever, something we accomplish thanks to our steadfast dedication to our workforce and our culture. So it makes me proud to report that Fortune magazine and Great Places to Work have put us on their list of the top best companies to work for in the U.S. In the 2024 rankings, Synchrony climbed 15 spots to reach number 5. That rise speaks to the distinctive, exceptional culture we've built and the unwavering priority we place on people, while we keep pushing to deliver top-tier experiences for all the stakeholders we serve. With that, I'll hand things over to Brian, who will walk us through the financial results in more detail.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#3

Thanks, Brian, and good morning to all of you. For the first quarter, Synchrony's results showed what happens when you combine our differentiated business model with a resilient consumer in a macroeconomic environment that keeps evolving. On a reported basis, net earnings came to $1.3 billion, which works out to $3.14 per diluted share. If you set aside the $802 million after-tax gain from selling our Pets Best business, net earnings were $491 million, or $1.18 per diluted share. Ending loan receivables rose 12%, reaching $102 billion; that growth came from the ongoing rise in purchase volume, a payment rate decline of roughly 90 basis points, and the closing of our Ally Lending acquisition. Net revenue was up $1.6 billion, or 50%, helped by the roughly $1.1 billion gain on the Pets Best sale, which flowed through other income. Without that Pets Best gain, net revenue rose $530 million, or 17%. Net interest income climbed 9% to $4.4 billion, powered by interest and fees that were 50% higher. That increase in interest and fees came from the combined effects of more loan receivables, a lower payment rate, and higher benchmark rates, though higher interest expense tied to benchmark rates partly offset it. RSAs totaled $764 million for the quarter, equal to 3.04% of average loan receivables, down $153 million from a year earlier, as higher net charge-offs weighed on the figure, partly offset by greater net interest income. Provision for credit losses rose to $1.9 billion, reflecting increased net charge-offs along with $299 million of reserve builds, including a $190 million build tied to acquiring Ally Lending. Other expenses were up 8% to $1.2 billion, mostly because of higher employee costs supporting growth and our ongoing technology investment. Excluding the gain on sale, our efficiency ratio for the quarter was 32.3%, roughly 270 basis points better than last year. Now I'll walk through our key credit trends on Slide 10. When the quarter ended, our 30-plus delinquency rate stood at 4.74%, versus 3.81% a year earlier and 18 basis points above our average for the first quarters of 2017 to 2019. The 90-plus delinquency rate came in at 2.42%, compared with 1.87% last year and 14 basis points above our average for the first quarters of 2017 to 2019. Net charge-offs for the first quarter were 6.31%, against 4.49% a year earlier and an average of 5.84% in the first quarters of 2017 to 2019. Our allowance for credit losses as a percent of loan receivables reached 10.72%, 46 basis points above the 10.26% recorded in the fourth quarter, mainly due to seasonal trends. The reserve build this quarter largely came from adding the Ally Lending portfolio. As Brian mentioned, Synchrony's credit performance has matched our expectations. Since Synchrony shares the consumer with our broader industry peers, we keep watching our portfolio and the wider industry's credit performance, just as we have periodically since mid-2023, and we've been taking incremental credit actions beginning in March. In certain areas of our portfolio, that ought to strengthen how the portfolio performs in 2024 and afterward. Slide 4 shows that Synchrony has established a history of delivering steady, appealing returns adjusted for risk as market conditions shift. What has made this possible is a mix of our disciplined underwriting, aimed at an average loss rate between 5.5% and 6%, along with RSA, which brings program performance and portfolio performance into alignment; we'll keep drawing on our extensive consumer lending expertise, our varied product lineup, sales platforms and verticals, and our advanced data analytics and technology to advance that priority further. Now to Slide 12. For our business, Synchrony's funding, capital and liquidity remain a solid base. Our consumer bank products keep connecting with our customers, since deposits rose $2.4 billion during the first quarter. At quarter end, deposits made up 84% of total funding, supplemented by our securitized debt and unsecured funding strategies, each accounting for 8% of total funding. In the quarter, we issued $750 million in secured funding and finished a preferred stock issuance worth $500 million, which helped optimize our capital structure more completely. Total liquid assets and undrawn credit facilities came to $24.9 billion, an increase of $3.2 billion versus last year, and at quarter end accounted for 20.5% of total assets, 38 basis points above last year. Turning to our capital ratios. Keep in mind that we chose to take advantage of CECL transition rules put out by the joint federal banking agencies. Each January through 2025, Synchrony will keep applying its annual transition adjustment of roughly 50 basis points to our regulatory capital metrics. Our income statement and balance sheet already reflect the CECL impact. Under those CECL transition rules, we closed the first quarter with a CET1 ratio of 12.6%, which is 40 basis points below last year's 13.0%. The net capital effect from our Pets Best sale and Ally Lending acquisition contributed about 40 basis points to our CET1 ratio. Our Tier 1 capital ratio stood at 13.8%, the same as a year ago. Our total capital ratio fell 10 basis points to 15.8%, while our Tier 1 capital plus reserve ratio, on a fully phased-in basis, climbed to 23.8% from 23% last year. In the first quarter, we gave back $402 million to shareholders, made up of $300 million in share repurchases and $102 million in common stock dividends. As of March 31, 2024, $300 million was left in our share repurchase authorization. Under our capital planning as approved by the Board of Directors, our share repurchase authorization rose by $1 billion, taking our total authorization to $1.3 billion for the period ending June 30, 2025. In addition, the Board plans to keep our quarterly dividend at its present level of $0.25 per share. Synchrony is still well positioned to return capital to shareholders, guided by our business performance, market conditions, regulatory restrictions and subject to our capital plan. Moving to Slide 13, we'll walk through how our business performed in 2024. Just to remind everyone, back on March 5, 2024, Synchrony filed an 8-K that laid out a revised financial outlook, and that included EPS guidance for the entire 2024 year — tied specifically to how we're framing things around the pending late fee rule change, along with the changes we're making to product, policy, and pricing. Uncertainty still remains when it comes to both the timing and the outcome of the late fee litigation that got filed in March, the shifts in consumer behavior that might emerge because of the late fee rule changes, and any shifts in consumer behavior that come about in reaction to the product, policy, and pricing changes we put in place because of the new rule. How these uncertainties actually play out, and our real performance tied to any of them, could affect the EPS outlook. Now, as we look at what's left of the year, Synchrony will keep executing on our key strategic priorities and getting our business ready as we work through a changing operating environment. We've already begun putting our product, policy, and pricing changes into effect — most of them will wrap up within the next 2 to 3 months — and we think we'll have better clarity around what these changes mean, probably in the back half of the year. Until then, we still expect our business to show the usual seasonal patterns across a number of our key metrics. Net charge-offs should reach their high point in the first half of the year, and reserve coverage at year-end ought to come in below the rate we saw at the end of 2023. Last, we expect the RSA to keep aligning program performance and to keep working the way it was designed to. To wrap up, Synchrony is concentrating on drawing on our core strengths to make the most of our business position and to extend our long track record of producing steady growth along with strong risk-adjusted returns. The breadth of our consumer lending expertise shapes both our go-to-market approach and our product strategies. What we've invested in sophisticated credit management tools gives us our agility, and our RSA underpins our financial resilience. Taken together, our distinctive model keeps reliably creating value for every one of our stakeholders as environments shift. I'll hand the call back to Brian now for his closing thoughts.

Brian Doubles

executive
#4

Thanks, Brian. Synchrony's Q1 performance came about because of a business model that sets us apart, plus our dedication to producing results that last and stay strong for customers, partners, and stakeholders; through our proprietary insights into industries and consumers, our varied products and platforms, and sophisticated data analytics, we keep delivering responsible financing access to our customers, sales and loyalty to our partners, and sustainable growth in the form of solid risk-adjusted returns for stakeholders. Our confidence rests on Synchrony operating from strength as we move through the coming year. We're enthusiastic about chances we see to create even more long-term value as we keep working alongside hundreds of thousands of small and midsized businesses and health providers, giving over 70 million customers access to credit for what they need and want each day. With that, I'll hand things back to Kathryn so Q&A can begin.

Kathryn Miller

executive
#5

That concludes our prepared remarks. <<operator_script>>. Operator, please start the Q&A session.

Ryan Nash

analyst
#6

It appears that charge-offs have been arriving somewhat above what was anticipated, yet we are now seeing delinquencies possibly turn and begin tracking seasonal trends. So could you discuss what that implies regarding the loss rate for the entire year? And if your forward outlook turns out to be correct, where do you expect losses within the allowance to settle across the medium-term horizon?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#7

Yeah. I appreciate that question, Ryan. So once more, I believe we have been fairly explicit that in our view, charge-offs, when you examine the delinquency pattern as we moved into 2024, ought to reach their highest point during the first half of the year and then come down. I think that is visible, well, definitely by the end of the first quarter. I think once you look at the results in April when our 8-K is released, you will observe delinquencies lower on a 30-plus as well as a 90-plus basis compared with what we reported right here today. So I think as you begin to consider that, you look at how the credit actions we took in the second and third quarter of last year have seasoned. We are confident that the charge-off rate will decrease over the latter half of the year. And certainly, our underwriting targets have not been altered, remaining in the 5.5% to 6% range, broadly speaking. So we are confident about that, and that brings us to the view that should you see that reduced net charge-off rate during the latter half of the year and then extend that forward into 2025, the reserve coverage rate ought to be under the 10.26% rate we actually had at the close of last year, and truly the rise during the first quarter here reflected seasonal patterns more than anything else.

Ryan Nash

analyst
#8

Ryan, understood. Now, as a follow-up question: RSA has outperformed for multiple consecutive quarters. In 1Q, it came in significantly under the 3.50% to 3.75% range that I believe you laid out in your earlier guidance. So could you share some thoughts on how you're viewing RSA for '24 — this is excluding late fees, naturally. And do you believe the new normal here sits beneath the 4% to 4.25%, 4.5% range you described previously? Brian, go ahead.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#9

Yes, Ryan. When I examine the RSA trend, the first quarter was clearly — looking year-over-year at the elevated net charge-offs, which accounted for a substantial portion of the RSA decline, partially offset — roughly one-third of it offset by NII growth. And NII was somewhat held down since you had the final full effect on interest-bearing liabilities. If I step back briefly and consider the core business, Ryan, my belief is we've reached a point where we've peaked, assuming no rate hikes, and peaked on interest-bearing liability costs, as I mentioned regarding the net charge-off rate topping out in the first half. You ought to see an upward bias in RSA as we move through the rest of the year. The other factor will be volume. So even looking on a linked-quarter basis, volume declining — and declining somewhat year-over-year for certain RSA clients — will come into play, but it should trend higher as we progress, given the peaking nature of interest-bearing liability costs and charge-offs.

Sanjay Sakhrani

analyst
#10

My first question, I suppose, concerns purchase volume. Clearly, that's still soft. Could we discuss how we bring it back to a level that then picks up speed? I realize inflation is somewhat a drag on the consumer. But perhaps discuss what's behind that and how and when we return it to a higher baseline.

Brian Doubles

executive
#11

Yes, Sanjay, perhaps I'll begin with this one, then hand it over to Brian. Well, look, I believe on the whole, we're quite happy with the expansion we're witnessing in the business. I believe the consumer remains in solid condition. Clearly, the labor market is extremely robust, which is a help. Yet much of that spending is being propelled by the upper-tier consumer — the higher-income consumer. And honestly, that isn't a negative. I believe they're gaining, clearly, from the labor market, home values have climbed, equity prices have climbed. At the lower end, that's where a portion of the deceleration shows up. And viewed through credit, that isn't the worst outcome. I believe we observe individuals acting cautiously. I believe they're sticking to a budget, they're sticking to their cash flows; they aren't stretching themselves too far. So I believe there's a favorable signal from a credit standpoint in that. I'm not sure, Brian, whether you'd like to add anything.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#12

First off, Sanjay, something I'd like to point out to everyone: the comparison base is what I would call an exceptionally robust quarter from a year ago. So if you're seeing a 2% increase, that's quite impressive. For our business, it marks a first-quarter record. Brian pointed out a few of the variances — I believe you're at plus 8% related to higher freight costs, and slightly lower versus the prior year on the lower freight cost side. Without question, we're observing the consumer pulling back in some of the larger-ticket categories, correct — whether that's transaction values declining, which I think shows up in the home and auto purchase line being down, and truly in lifestyle as well. Yet you do see pockets of strength there. Our home specialty business is growing at a double-digit rate, or our outdoors business is rising. So it's selective. The consumer is simply being more careful with their money. Once more, we observe transaction frequency climbing despite transaction values falling. So the consumer, I would say, is navigating this stretch; therefore I wouldn't read too much into it as though there's a major shift in who the consumer is and what they're up to.

Sanjay Sakhrani

analyst
#13

All right, that's really useful; and I wasn't going to let you two escape without asking about late fees. So perhaps, since we're all sitting around waiting on the courts right now, you could explain how you're getting ready for a mid-May rollout and how much room you'd have to maneuver if an injunction lands after the implementation period currently scheduled? Also, any initial read on the shifts in PPPC behavior? I realize the bulk of that won't show up until the second half.

Brian Doubles

executive
#14

Right, Sanjay. So the fact that this came second doesn't shock us, we figured it might come first. Clearly, we're awaiting a litigation outcome that's uncertain, but our plan is being carried out. From the start we stated we wouldn't sit around waiting for the litigation to resolve, simply because of the uncertainty; so back in December we started putting our changes into effect. More than 60% of those are already finished. We still need to distribute the changes in terms, and so on. The overwhelming majority of those will be wrapped up over the next 2 months. So, we're carrying out the plan. On the timing side, October 1 was our base case, which presumed an injunction. That said, pulling this off in May will be extraordinarily difficult from an operational standpoint, but we're getting ready for that scenario too.

Terry Ma

analyst
#15

I wanted to ask a follow-up regarding the shifts in product policy and pricing. How should we frame the way those advantages appear after everything is completely in place? Can we look at it as a gradual climb across the year, a single jump, or perhaps a faster rise?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#16

Sure. Appreciate it, Terry. I'll handle this one and check whether Brian wants to add anything. What you ought to anticipate is that an effect starts to show a bit during Q2, then grows in Q3 when it comes to the mitigants, and after that it keeps expanding. This question has come up before, and honestly we hadn't discussed it in much detail. Consider how the APR takes effect for the consumer. Once that APR kicks in — and remember, treat that as 60 days following notice — you'll start to notice the impact, roughly 50% during the initial 12 months after rollout, and 75% by 24 months. So it progressively fills in. As for certain other fees that arrive and certain other policy adjustments, those hit more quickly once they come through; we will definitely observe, as that works its way through, some uptake tied specifically to opting for e-statements and similar items, though it moves through various sections of the P&L as we anticipate. So once more, I believe you start to observe a climb from the items that hit sooner, and that provides a sense of how the APR arrives; yet that's the reason a blend was used so we could reach that neutral point somewhat earlier instead of depending solely on APRs.

Terry Ma

analyst
#17

Understood, that helps. For my next question, I wanted to ask about the cash balances you're holding. They seemed pretty high this quarter compared with a year ago. Could you give us some insight into how we ought to view that moving forward?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#18

Terry, honestly speaking, our liquidity is elevated this quarter. I'd trace that back mainly to how strong our deposit franchise is. When you look at core retail deposits, they rose $3.4 billion versus the close of last year. Then you factor in the seasonal inflow of cash, and that worked in our favor when we bought Ally for $2 billion, plus we received $600 million from selling the Pets Best franchise. So I'd describe liquidity as roughly at its peak. If you consider margin and how margins get affected, and you walk through it, net interest margin is likely at its lowest point of the year during the first quarter, because of all that extra liquidity. And look, I think we've heard from other lenders during the past week or two mentioning that balances are declining and balance sheets are flatter; that isn't what we anticipate; so obviously, we remain focused on gathering deposits. We haven't taken any major steps to bring in new deposits. It's simply the strength and appeal of our digital franchise.

John Hecht

analyst
#19

I suppose I'd like to dig a bit deeper into net interest margin, Brian. I realize Q1 typically carries a seasonal effect, since that's when you bring in deposits partly to get ahead on funding growth for the rest of the year. You also brought up PetSmart, which is creating some added cash balances. Still, could you help us understand — break apart — what caused the margin to fall this quarter compared with, let's say, 1Q '23? Then perhaps you could discuss deposit pricing at the margin and where things stand in the CD and savings account markets, plus when deposit costs ought to stop rising.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#20

Wonderful, wonderful. I appreciate that question, John. When I look at net interest margin on a year-over-year basis, it has dropped 67 basis points. The largest factor, if I consider net funding costs — meaning your interest-bearing liability costs netted against income generated by the investment portfolio — accounts for roughly 88 points of that decrease. An additional 19 basis points of decline came from carrying a higher liquidity portfolio versus a year ago. That has been counterbalanced by interest of fee yield, which contributes plus 40. Once more, as we consider how this plays out across the year, the asset — the ALR mix will offset itself back out. Our view is that interest-bearing liability costs have topped out at this point. Consequently, in theory, as you progress forward, net interest margin ought to genuinely strengthen as the year goes on. On your second point regarding pricing, really, consider the different tenors. If you examined our 12-month CD rate, it has fallen 50 basis points since the close of 4Q '23, landing at 48 days. We moved down alongside our peers, which is broadly unchanged versus the second quarter of 2023. Every issuer, every digital bank, offers promo rates. So we still have one promotional rate above 5%, which I believe is our 15-month, and that exists mainly to manage, ultimately, our CD retention and stay competitive with others who have somewhat off tenor. My expectation is that as we observe those attempting to manage their balance sheet and reduce liquidity, we'll track the market downward. Typically we trail the brick-and-mortar banks, yet we will move down alongside the digital banks as the year progresses. The last thing I'd mention, John, is that we still have 3 rate cuts baked in, but we didn't truly have them as of September, so nothing meaningful happens unless something larger emerged and shifted earlier in the year from the Fed.

John Hecht

analyst
#21

All right. This might be somewhat awkward to ask, but assuming — and I realize the EPS guidance has been withdrawn, yet when it comes to exchange rate fees with the — does your initial $5.75 to $6 EPS still stand? Or should we factor in other shifts that reflect the sorts of trend movements we ought to account for when modeling?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#22

Yeah. Let me clarify, John: the 8-K we issued on March 5 contained that EPS guidance, and we haven't withdrawn it; we merely chose not to repeat it since only 45 days have passed, which is why we did include it on the page this morning. Regarding that core business, what I'd tell you — and Brian would likely say the same — is that we're performing better than we anticipated. In my view, interest-bearing liability costs have risen, or rather came in more favorable than we expected. Charge-offs are broadly consistent with what we expected. Then, once you begin considering a few of the items I've been emphasizing. First, your interest-bearing liabilities cost reaching its peak; second, charge-offs reaching their peak during the second half; and as I said on this call, you'll observe a sequential drop in delinquencies. That aligns. Then, when you consider the reserve rate coming in below 10.26%, I believe that positions us consistently with the guidance we gave back on March 5. That said, it was only about 45 days ago.

Jeff Adelson

analyst
#23

Regarding the credit outlook, I'd like to go deeper into mid-'24 compared with the first half of '24. Considering the favorable improvement in delinquency formation you've observed, plus your second quarter typically being the seasonal best for NCO, I was hoping to better grasp what mid-2024 holds. Is it more a seasonally adjusted peak in year-over-year growth? Or — perhaps just walk us through your thinking there.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#24

Yeah. Let me attempt to make this simpler, Jeff, though I appreciate the question. All of it is seasonally adjusted. So our plan was constructed with seasonal overlays, and those have been subdued across the last couple of years, owing to the normalization occurring as we return to pre-pandemic delinquency levels. My suggestion is to view it this way, plainly and rather simply. Losses in the first half are going to exceed those in the second half, and I believe if you essentially extended our 30-plus and 90-plus, you could roughly observe how that plays through assuming you expect a band in April, more so in dollars. That's how it flows out. So I'd just think of it in halves for simplicity instead of attempting to pin down an exact date for the peak.

Jeff Adelson

analyst
#25

Understood. And once more, regarding the late fee, I believe you said how hard it would be to put into practice from an operations standpoint in May. Could you describe what that would actually involve for you? And how should we perhaps consider the $0.15 to $0.25 effect you laid out earlier, should that come to pass? And as part of that question too, I recall you said 60% of the changes are out. Could you speak a bit about consumer behavior, the response rate, in terms of how they are reacting to those changes so far?

Brian Doubles

executive
#26

Yes, I'll handle the first portion of that. So from an operational perspective, it is quite difficult from several different angles. And clearly, that applies to the issuer, but also to the vendors that issuers depend on. I think it's worth noting as well that this spans the whole industry. It isn't unique to us. Everyone faces the same obstacles. If anything, we do have to implement this on May 14. I believe we were ready to make the system changes and such. The actual difficulties arise with terms changes and updating collateral and similar items. So that is where much of the operational complexity lies. And I'll pass it to Brian.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#27

Sure. So to give you a sense of scale — really, more of a way to frame how you should be thinking about this, Jeff — when we came into this, our base case assumption was an October implementation day; that's what we expected. Between now and the point when the courts act on the litigation that's pending and on the injunction, there are plenty of possible scenarios. So speculating about any one particular scenario is hard, simply because the level of uncertainty is so high. My guess is everybody would have landed somewhere different — at a minimum, every person on this call would hold a different view. With that said, if you'd like a framework, let's take 1 second on it. First, I'd say this has no bearing on where you come out of 2025 from a projection standpoint; whether it's October or sooner than October, that exit point doesn't move at all — that's point one. Second, it has little bearing on how stable our business is and on what we're doing with our PPPC changes. Brian covered how much we've rolled out. So those 2 things, at their core, stay put. That said, if you consider a May implementation date, the effect on EPS in 2024 is considerably bigger; yet when you look at 2025, that EPS would generally be above the October scenario, or considerably above it when measured on an actual '24 to '25 basis, as you examine it. So as soon as we get better clarity on when the actual implementation date happens — or occurs, or will occur — we'll then, at that point, offer added transparency regarding the financial implications, for '24 and also to help people size up '25. But I believe it matters to grasp those frameworks for how we exit '25, and then any added detriment in '24 in theory turns into a benefit in '25.

Brian Doubles

executive
#28

Now, regarding your final question about how consumers are behaving and what effect that’s having — so far, nothing we’ve observed has diverged from what we anticipated. For the most part, it matches up. My one caveat would be that we’re still at a very early stage. Many of these term adjustments come with a transition window. Even so, what we’re currently seeing on the consumer end broadly aligns with our prior expectations.

Saul Martinez

analyst
#29

To follow up on what was said regarding the PPPC effect in the previous answer — if I'm understanding correctly, the March 5 8-K, the guidance, or rather the estimates provided there, of offsets between $650 million and $700 million pretax, suggests quite a substantial ramp when you consider how much time remains before the fourth quarter. We ought to treat those as valid reference points, since it clearly points to a meaningful step-up toward the end of the year when it comes to NII. That's in addition to the late fee effect. I simply want to confirm those figures still hold, or is there something I'm overlooking?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#30

Let me begin by noting that this assumes an October implementation date. The way to look at it: some of the PPPC changes start showing up in the second and third quarters, partly offset by RSA, and then as you reach the fourth quarter, you'd face the drag from the late fee disappearing, though with a larger RSA offset during that period. Naturally, all of this moves if implementation happened sooner. That range would shift considerably if a potential implementation day fell before October. Once again, should that occur, I think we'd return and offer more clarity regarding the effect on late fees and on the changes we're making.

Saul Martinez

analyst
#31

All right. All right, that helps. And I suppose a wider — a wider topic, I suppose. During your presentation, you restated the long-term objective: ROA of 2.5-plus percent, RPC of 28-plus percent. I understand the offsets, and your team is working to offset that completely. But it's a fairly substantial — should it be put in place, it's a fairly substantial decrease, or the revenue source that basically disappears, and we'll see what happens with Basel III, though at least perhaps it won't have an impact. But the direction of travel, at least regarding capital, is heading higher. I'm simply wondering how you're approaching the long-term profitability targets going forward, and your level of confidence in how you — where you believe those remain valid targets?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#32

Yes. Clearly, we examine it, and Brian and I have been quite clear that the organization — our aim is to be ROA neutral once the late fee rule change's impact is fully felt. And we — once more, when we receive greater clarity concerning the actual implementation date, we could discuss that timing a bit. So the aim is to return to ROA neutral; and that's the plan we are rolling out and starting to execute today. Recognize there are numerous assumptions concerning consumer behavior baked into it and other factors that can affect it; nonetheless, if you consider a more normalized environment, correct? So I believe 5.5% interest rates are not normalized. When you consider an inflation rate that's evolving as they normalize, you ought to be able to return to that ROA profile that's — and that's among the strengths of the RSA itself that sort of assists us in getting back to that. From a capital perspective, I can't truly forecast, and I'm not certain others can, precisely where the Fed may or may not go concerning Basel III. I mean most certainly, there has not been much support around that; so we'll see what those changes are. That said, we actually have excess capital, and we're going to keep moving down toward our target, which assists us in reaching the ROTCE; so again, the emphasis on being ROA neutral through the late fee rule change, first, deploying our excess capital, whether that's into our RWA, which is accretive to earnings and ROA, or when we return it to shareholders. Our aim is to get back to those medium to long-term targets we set out a couple of years ago.

Don Fandetti

analyst
#33

Your capital situation remains quite robust. I'm just wondering whether you believe the CFPB adjustments might result in certain portfolio shifts within the coming 1 or 2 years? Also, are you seeing any further opportunistic transactions similar to Ally?

Brian Doubles

executive
#34

Yeah. Look, we constantly seek out possible acquisitions or fresh programs, Ally matched our business model ideally; it's precisely the sort of acquisition that we pursue. It's within industries that we know very well; we get the products, an excellent cultural fit, like it just — it satisfied every criterion. So we do — we hold excess capital at present. We produce a great deal of capital throughout the calendar year; and should we get the chance to pursue something opportunistic, we definitely possess the financial means to do so.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#35

Right. The one point I would tack on there, simply to give you a sense of scale — take a look at Page 12 in the earnings deck we put out, and we laid out that this business's earnings power really does throw off that capital. Check it year over year: across the trailing 12 months, net earnings from the business alone produced 2.5% CET1. So those are genuinely strong effects you can point to and build on, and on top of that you've got the excess capital sitting between where we are and the CET1 target we're aiming for.

Brian Doubles

executive
#36

Right. The sole additional thing I would say regarding that is that we maintain a lot of discipline when it comes to acquisitions that add to earnings and offer a genuinely strong strategic fit. I believe that discipline has been evident across the years; we have not pursued M&A on a really large scale. We have been quite deliberate about identifying targets that are fairly modest in terms of the capital required, yet are businesses we can expand very effectively. That is a strong illustration of it, an ideal illustration of it, a leg row I think Ally will prove a home run for us. So we are extremely disciplined about the things we seek out.

Rick Shane

analyst
#37

This morning I have a couple of things to ask. To start with, regarding the CFPB, a consequence the industry has brought up when it comes to the rule changes — namely the elimination of deterrents — would imply that DQs are going to be elevated. I'm wondering whether you folks have talked with your accountants about the way you'd handle reserve policies in a scenario where delinquencies run higher yet you perhaps assume reduced pull-throughs?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#38

Yeah. Rick, I appreciate the question. For sure, internally we've discussed what eliminating deterrents means, and the key issue is simply how we go about modeling any possible shift in delinquency. And once more, what you've got in this situation are people who are deciding on purpose not to pay — those who were terminated from a job or experienced a health event and then move into delinquency, that person won't be rehabilitated since this wasn't a deterrent in their case. They'll progress to loss or move to settlement, and so on. This involves individuals who deliberately made the call to prioritize one payment above another. We'd need to model that, and then we will definitely make our accounts comfortable with the approach. But once more, we'll just have to wait and see, since nobody truly conducted much testing of control at this degree of deterrence. Without question, certain efforts during the CARD Act showed deterrence, yet we'll need to observe how it unfolds, Rick.

Rick Shane

analyst
#39

Understood. And regarding the idea of charge-offs reaching their highest point midway through the year, seasonal trends help you consistently for the upcoming 6 months, after which they begin to turn around during the fourth quarter. When you mention a peak, do you mean that entering the fourth quarter, charge-offs will keep falling, or that they would typically bounce back seasonally, though maybe not to the same extent as they did previously?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#40

Yes. Thanks once more for asking, Rick. We have not provided quarterly guidance. Once again, I will simply outline the framework; we used seasonal tendencies for how the loss rate behaves. We think we are closer to normal and have returned to levels seen before the pandemic. And I believe you will start to observe, once more, in April, decreases in dollar terms for 30-plus and 90-plus, and those create a flow-through impact on both the third quarter and the fourth quarter as they work their way through. So we will not offer specific quarter guidance at this time. But once more, the rates during the first half of the year are going to exceed the rates during the second half of the year.

Brian Foran

analyst
#41

Could you walk us through the yearly internal stress testing exercise? In this 2-year span, it seems a bit odd, since late fees are being incorporated, yet you'd presumably take peak losses on the business. Does that turn into any kind of limit when it comes to capital decisions? Or do you believe you hold sufficient surplus capital and sufficient visibility into ROA neutrality that you can see past what might be a stress test outcome that's temporarily higher?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#42

Yes. Thank you, Brian. To start, allow me to make one thing plain. Our capital plan has been filed with the Fed. We belong to the horizontals, we belong to the CCAR group, even though no stress capital buffer reaches us before 2026. So aside from engaging somewhat differently with the Fed compared to previously, the process stays largely unchanged from earlier years. Once more, though, the stress capital buffer arrives in 2026. Regarding the specific capital plan our Board recently gave approval to and management put before them, scenarios — or a scenario — involving late fees and their effect were included. That did not — it helped shape our broader capital choice, yet it does not really limit the plans we had. Suppose I returned and stated implementation would begin at an earlier date, something we touched on briefly during this call; even then, our capital targets and plans wouldn't really be disturbed. Naturally, all of that depends on the usual factors we'd mention, namely market conditions and so forth, Brian; however, the consequence of the late fee rule does not really affect the capital plan we made public this morning.

Brian Foran

analyst
#43

That's really useful. And perhaps, if I may slip in a question about competition. In general, do you observe rivals in the marketplace reacting in similar fashions when it comes to these sorts of PPPC initiatives? Is there any sign at any stage of major divergence, or of companies splitting away from the group? Or is it more that everybody is pursuing varying blends of comparable measures?

Brian Doubles

executive
#44

Regarding public adjustments in terms, we can only see what is visible out there; however, I'd say to you, my anticipation is that all of them will pursue a mix of the identical actions we are taking; it is a fairly — it is a comparatively typical playbook. A few issuers might handle a small number of items in another way. Yet I believe overall, what it will amount to is APR hikes, assorted categories of charges, and so forth, in order to counterbalance this. And it matters that we take these steps. From the outset, our aim has been to safeguard our partners and keep extending credit to the same customers we serve right now. And sadly, achieving that is not possible absent these offsets.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#45

The one point I'd tack on, Brian: you're likely to notice one thing — we've perhaps been somewhat more, or the surprise reflected somewhat more, of a feeling of urgency and moved ahead on this after talking with our partners. So that could help somewhat, but I believe Brian is correct about the medium term. That is where the convergence will show up.

John Pancari

analyst
#46

Morning. Regarding that final item you mentioned, they just raised the topic of certain rival card issuers with comparatively smaller private label and Co-Brand operations, who have started signaling a possible readiness to soak up the late fee — the lost late fee income stemming from the rule change. Could you address whether, if we observe that occurring among certain participants for whom late fees represent a lesser portion of total revenue, yet who compete in private label and Co-Brand, you would treat that as a competitive danger should they indeed absorb the hit?

Brian Doubles

executive
#47

At present, I don't view it as a competitive danger. Within our segment, across the bulk of what we do, my expectation is that you'll witness issuers taking the same kinds of actions we are taking. In terms of economic sharing alongside the partners, I believe that will prove extremely important. Clearly, our attention is on extending credit to the customers we serve right now. And luckily, you must take certain of these steps in order to safeguard that and safeguard our partners. So I do believe you will begin to observe — and indeed we are already observing it — that some issuers will emerge. As we evaluate new business, we are incorporating this into pricing models; as we onboard portfolios from rival firms, we are beginning to factor it in — you must take into account an $8 late fee. While we are hoping for a superior result in the litigation, you obviously must model situations in which the late fee comes in far lower. Thus, my sense is it will balance out eventually throughout the industry, chiefly within the segment where we compete at present.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#48

John, the point you just raised takes things to another plane. Suppose, hypothetically, a company smaller than ours opted to soak up a portion of that late fee — the result would be a return profile that falls short of optimal. Within a big institution, that might not matter at all. The real questions become: will it draw in capital? And for how long could you keep that going? Looking back across history, we've watched certain larger institutions let businesses fall out of favor when those businesses represent only a tiny piece of the whole. Our approach here is what we do — the same way we examine our own operations and platforms, directing capital toward the better-performing, higher-returning segments of the portfolio. Eventually, I believe, these institutions will have to follow that path. So if somebody wants to pursue that route, I question whether it works as a viable strategy over the long haul. Then again, your question is highly hypothetical.

John Pancari

analyst
#49

Understood. No, that's logical. Moving on to a different topic, returning to earnings per share — apologies for bringing that up again — but I realize you aren't restating that $5.70 to $6 guidance. What I'm trying to grasp is whether the sole reason is that merely 45 days have passed, and the fundamental elements you incorporated back in March haven't shifted significantly enough to alter your view of underlying trends? I'm aware there have been rate movements and some developments regarding late fee dynamics. Still, I simply want confirmation that the core assumptions behind that $5.7 to $6 haven't budged whatsoever.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#50

Yes. Once more, I'll repeat: that guidance was issued 45 days ago. I saw no reason to — and I believe Brian shares this view — place it back on this page or provide another sort of update. What I've stated is that the quarter, along with the points I mentioned concerning net interest margin, losses, reserves, and the positive on expenses, ought to be regarded positively compared with that sort of base — based BAU performance of the business. Thus we're quite happy with how we're finishing the first quarter and progressing on a core BAU basis.

Mihir Bhatia

analyst
#51

I just had — a couple of broad questions. Perhaps to begin, on the competitive landscape; and really more — not so much about the new programs, but regarding the financing offers that consumers already have available. To what extent is purchase volume being affected by consumers simply having additional options these days? For instance, has any market share or penetration rate data been provided about how frequently consumers choose Synchrony over competitors? As a share of your retail partner sales or something similar? I'm certain you monitor it.

Brian Doubles

executive
#52

Yes, we do. We monitor it partner by partner; we examine the penetration rate, sales on our card compared with other products. I'll say, on the whole, we're quite pleased that within the majority of our partner programs we're picking up share. I believe one factor that assists us in that, as we consider a multiproduct strategy, is that we see our partners engaging more around being able to offer a revolving product, perhaps a secured card, buy now pay later. And I think that is helping us pick up share. If you remain with a one product strategy, I believe eventually, that's a losing strategy and I think you will lose share, which is why we believe the multiproduct strategy eventually is a winning one. So we feel really good about our capacity to keep taking share within our partner programs, but also just more broadly and even in some of the smaller to midsized space.

Mihir Bhatia

analyst
#53

Alright, Brian, one last thing from me. In the remarks you prepared, and I think also in the release that came out today, you highlighted the collaboration involving health providers and small- and medium-sized businesses. It seems like there's a bit of a fresh emphasis there on SMBs relative to what we heard before, so I wanted to ask: is Synchrony's growth strategy tilting somewhat more toward smaller or possibly more proprietary programs, rather than the historical approach of just being the go-to partner for big retailers?

Brian Doubles

executive
#54

Honestly, I think that part of how we operate doesn't get enough credit. A lot of attention tends to go toward the big partner programs, yet we actually support hundreds of thousands of providers along with small- to medium-sized businesses, and that fact sometimes gets overlooked. That's why we're putting more emphasis in that direction. We've shifted investment dollars toward health and wellness, and the results show in those figures — receivables rose 20%, so those investments are clearly delivering returns for us. It's a space we find very appealing. We still see a lot of appeal in the big-partner segment, though that side of things tends to draw plenty of focus already. What we want to do is make certain we're giving adequate airtime to every small and midsize company out there, plus the hundreds of thousands of dentists and pet care specialists nationwide who count on us.

Operator

operator
#55

That brings us to the end of Synchrony's earnings conference call. At this point you're welcome to hang up, and we hope the rest of your day is great. Thanks so much.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Synchrony Financial transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Synchrony Financial earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Synchrony Financial or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.