Synchrony Financial (SYF) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

January 28, 2025

New York Stock Exchange US Financials Consumer Finance earnings 76 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Kathryn Miller

executive
#1

Thanks, and good morning to all of you. We're glad you could join us for this quarterly earnings conference call. Along with the press release issued today, we've made available a presentation that addresses the subjects we intend to cover on this call. The press release, along with the detailed financial schedules and the presentation, can be found on our website, synchronyfinancial.com. To access this material, simply navigate to the Investor Relations section of that site. Before we begin, please allow me to note that forward-looking statements will be part of what we discuss today. Such statements carry risks and uncertainty, and actual results might differ materially. The factors that could lead actual results to differ materially are listed in our SEC filings, which you can find on our website. Throughout this call, we will reference non-GAAP financial measures when discussing how the company performed. A reconciliation of those measures to GAAP financial measures appears in our materials for today's call. Lastly, Synchrony Financial bears no responsibility for, and neither edits nor guarantees the accuracy of, our earnings teleconference transcripts that third parties provide. The only authorized webcasts can be found on our website. Joining us this morning are Brian Doubles, Synchrony's President and Chief Executive Officer, and Brian Wenzel, Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer. I'll now hand the call over to Brian Doubles.

Brian Doubles

executive
#2

Thanks, Kathryn, and good morning, everyone. First, I want to pause and recognize everyone touched by the destruction caused by the California wildfires. Synchrony has colleagues, customers, partners and providers who were affected. And although we aren't anticipating a significant financial hit to our business, we're watching the situation closely and providing assistance in multiple ways to everyone impacted. Now on to Synchrony's performance in the fourth quarter. We brought in 5 million new accounts, produced $48 billion of purchase volume and increased ending loan receivables by 2%. Beyond that, we keep seeing year-over-year gains in delinquency trends across our portfolios. Our RSA continued to bring Synchrony's interests and those of our partners into alignment, and we held on to our cost discipline to generate fourth quarter net earnings of $774 million, or $1.91 per diluted share, a return on average assets of 2.6% and a return on tangible common equity of 23%. Those fourth quarter results made for a strong finish to 2024, a year in which Synchrony acquired almost 20 million new accounts and financed over $182 billion of purchase volume; this year represented our second highest level of purchase volume and stands as a key testament to the enduring appeal of our varied and adaptable financing solutions and the compelling value propositions we provide. Synchrony has a deep understanding of what our many stakeholders need. So even as customers grew more selective in how they spent and the effects of sustained inflation and our credit actions set in as the year went on, Synchrony used our scale, our data analytics, deep lending expertise and advanced digital capabilities to stay nimble and responsive in a fast-moving environment. Consequently, Synchrony produced full year 2024 net earnings of $3.5 billion, or $8.55 per diluted share, a return on average assets of 2.9% and a return on tangible common equity of 27.5%. That financial performance reflected both the favorable and unfavorable effects of several nonrecurring events in our business, from selling 1 business and buying another to undertaking an unprecedented multiphase plan to get ready for a possible regulatory change, with wide-ranging consequences for the consumer lending industry. Still, through all the intricacies of these opportunities and amid a constantly shifting landscape, Synchrony performed at a high level on every one of our key strategic priorities to optimize our business and put us in position for sustainable growth at strong risk-adjusted returns over the long-term. In 2024, we brought on more than 45 new partners, among them iconic brands such as Virgin, Gibson and BRP, plus technology-focused relationships like Adit Practice Management Software and ServiceTitan. Every one of these additions further diversified the industry's products and services for which Synchrony can offer flexible financing solutions, while also broadening our customer reach. Synchrony likewise grew and expanded existing partnerships over the year by renewing more than 45 programs, among them Verizon and Generac and, more recently, 2 of our top 5 partners, Sam's Club and JCPenney. We're thrilled to share that back in January, we renewed and extended our relationship with Sam's Club — one that goes back more than three decades — and this builds on the strong emphasis we place on delivering digital experiences and value centered on members. Our partnership with JCPenney has likewise changed over roughly a quarter century, shaped by working together and by innovation as customer needs shifted. The extension and expansion of this long-term program will now bring in Synchrony Pay Later, our buy now, pay later financing offering featuring installment payments over 6, 12 or 24 months. Shoppers can scan a QR code inside the store, complete an application on their own device, and once approved, choose the financing option they prefer and make their purchase right away. And much as Synchrony keeps evolving and widening the ways we bring value through the partner programs we provide, we're equally focused on making the programs and markets we serve more diverse, along with the breadth and usefulness of what we offer; during 2024, we finished acquiring the Ally Lending business and are now transitioning merchants over to Synchrony Pay Later. We're eager to keep building out our multiproduct capabilities and to continue the expanded integration of this vertical in 2025. We also closed the sale of Pets Best, Independence Pet Holdings, and beyond a substantial financial gain, we broadened our reach into the fast-growing pet industry via an equity interest in IPH; we're enthusiastic about the recent introduction of Better. Together. with CareCredit and Pets Best, a patent pending, simple and seamless innovation that links the 2 solutions by directly reimbursing insurance claims to the CareCredit Health and Wellness card. We think this simplified payment process will create a unified experience for pet parents and fuel our growth in the pet care financing industry. And we brought CareCredit into wellness markets to finance fertility, nutrition and dietitian products and services, which drove close to 15% growth in wellness-related purchase volume during 2024. Beyond that, Synchrony improved the usefulness of several of our private label credit cards by widening where they're accepted and expanding their distribution channels. An evolution made possible by delivering our financial ecosystem through more of our merchant acquirer partners. As an example, the Amazon store card can now be used at every Whole Foods location via mobile QR code and for 1 medical memberships. The results have surpassed expectations and build on our solid foundation of acceptance, including Amazon.com, Amazon Pay and Audible. What's more, CareCredit can now be used to pay for select health and wellness products and services across a growing list of roughly 18,000 retail acceptance locations, including Albertsons Companies, Sam's Club, Walgreens and Walmart. And staying true to our strategy of broadening product utility, we've continued rolling out our CareCredit Dual Card over the past year, which increased open accounts by 16%, thanks to its strong value proposition in utility, about 60% of this product's out of partner spend in 2024 was outside of traditional health and wellness categories. Today, Synchrony provides a broad range of creative financing products and services, all built to meet each customer's needs responsibly — at any time, in any way, they want to make a purchase. That chance is happening more and more in digital channels, whether through a phone or in person at the point of sale via wallet apps and digital payments. So over the last year, Synchrony has traveled a path toward making our customer experience real by way of content that is more engaging and unified throughout our digital presence. Starting with our native apps and extending to our marketplace and website, we're widening and deepening the part Synchrony plays with our customers and our partner relationships. Indeed, because of what we've done to grow Synchrony's digital footprint, we've improved our cross-marketing abilities and made partner and product awareness stronger for our customers; we're also watching customers interact with Synchrony far more, coming to our sites with greater frequency, and as their time on our properties grows longer, that interaction has driven added new accounts and sales, plus reduced acquisition costs. At Synchrony Bank, we've increased by more than 35% the count of new Synchrony Bank accounts opened via our synchrony.com website, with essentially no acquisition costs tied to them.

Brian Doubles

executive
#3

And because we combine a dynamic tech platform, sophisticated analytics, and real scale — over 140 million reported trade lines plus trillions of customer and spend data points — we're able to apply proprietary insights across our digital financial ecosystem and along the customer journey, creating deeply personalized, engaging experiences. A growing piece of that ecosystem is Synchrony's Marketplace, which builds stronger connections linking our customers and partners. During the past year, we introduced curated campaigns and differentiated offers into our Marketplace, generating over 600 million impressions and 1 million referrals among participating partners. On top of that, Marketplace welcomed nearly 228 million customer visits and produced greater than 17% growth in newly submitted applications inside Marketplace. Big progress also came in 2024 from Synchrony's digital wallet strategy, which delivered stronger engagement, utility, and purchasing power for our customers; in fact, unique active wallet users at Synchrony rose 85% versus 2023 and helped push digital wallet sales in 2024 to more than double; that growth additionally underpinned an improvement of over 200 basis points in our wallet penetration rate for Dual and co-brand cards, which ought to increase the stickiness of those products and create natural tailwinds for Synchrony's mobile wallet share as we keep investing in this strategy. We're also energized by the opportunities ahead to push digital penetration even further in 2025. That includes our recent announcement that eligible Synchrony Mastercard holders may now select paying under the standard terms of their credit card or instead use a promotional offer featuring fixed monthly payments when they check out with Apple Pay Online, in an app on an iPhone or an iPad. This improves how users pay and gives them added choice and flexibility. And later this year we intend to build on this Apple Pay integration even more by giving users the ability to view and redeem rewards from eligible Synchrony issued cards. Synchrony also intends to collaborate with our Apple Pay-enabled partners to extend this capability throughout our portfolio; and as Synchrony keeps innovating and delivering an even greater financing experience and value for everyone we serve, we're holding onto our discipline and drawing on our core strengths to grow sustainably and deepen our leadership position. Our refined approach to customer lifetime value is creating incremental, deeper connections linking roughly 70 million customers with hundreds of thousands of partners and providers in the small and midsized businesses we serve. With our diversified portfolio of products, programs, and spend categories, customers gain financing flexibility for whatever moment of life they're in. Our broad distribution channels and omnichannel capabilities increasingly bring our financial ecosystem to wherever a purchase can happen; and our distinctive approach to underwriting and credit management is delivering stability in our portfolio's post-pandemic credit performance relative to most other lenders in the industry. Everything we've achieved stems from an amazing group of colleagues and a workplace culture that brought Synchrony the distinction of landing at number five on Fortune magazine and Great Places to Work's 2024 list of the best companies to work for in the U.S. So as our sights set on 2025 and the years after, Synchrony stands on solid ground. We're delivering on our main strategic priorities and generating robust results for the numerous stakeholders we support; we're strengthening our position at the center of American Commerce and readying our business for profitable growth well into the future, and we're creating substantial long-term value for our shareholders. With that, I'll hand the call over to Brian, who will walk through our financial performance in more detail.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#4

Thanks, Brian, and good morning to all of you. Our performance in the fourth quarter showed the resilience that naturally stems from having a diversified mix of products and spend categories, a balanced strategy for underwriting and managing credit, and a sophisticated technology platform. That distinctive blend of strengths allows the business to adjust quickly as conditions evolve. In the fourth quarter, customers kept turning to our flexible financing options, since the strong value propositions and wide utility of what we offer create durable value even with inflation persisting. Because of that, we brought in 5 million new accounts, kept roughly 70 million active accounts, and produced $48 billion in purchase volume, even with the ongoing effects of the credit actions taken from mid-2023 through early 2024. Receivables rose 2% to $105 billion, while payment rates kept moderating, declining about 10 basis points from a year earlier. At the platform level, purchase volume and receivables carried forward the trends we talked about throughout the year, with customers staying selective in how they spend and generally favoring nondiscretionary items and seasonal holiday goods. Platform purchase volume growth ranged from down 1% to down 6% versus a year ago, largely mirroring lower spend per account as customers pulled back on both bigger ticket and discretionary purchases, especially in areas such as furniture, electronics, cosmetic and outdoor, along with the effect of Synchrony's credit actions. Receivables growth across the platforms ranged from flat to 6% higher compared with a year earlier, mainly because purchase volume growth slowed and payment rates moderated. Dual and co-branded cards made up 44% of total purchase volume in the quarter and rose 1%, showing the benefit of these products' broad-based utility, offset by the combined effects of selected customer spend and Synchrony's credit actions. Net revenue went up 4% to $3.8 billion. The increase came from higher interest and fees along with higher other income, though higher RSA and interest expense partly offset that. Net interest income rose 3% to $4.6 billion, as interest and fees grew 3%, largely driven by higher interest and fees on loans, partly offset by an increase in interest expense tied to higher interest-bearing liabilities. The yield on our loan receivables was up 8 basis points, primarily because of our pricing actions, which include the impact of our product, pricing and policy changes, or PPPCs, plus a lower payment rate, partly offset by higher reversals and fewer late fee incidents. Total interest-bearing liabilities cost reached 4.58%, which is 3 basis points higher than last year. During Q4, RSA came in at $919 million, representing 3.57% of average loan receivables. That figure was up $41 million from the same period last year, largely driven by how our programs performed, including the effect of our PPPCs. Meanwhile, other income climbed by $128 million, mostly because of fees connected to our PPPCs, though the impact from our Pets Best disposition offset part of that gain. Our provision for credit losses dropped to $1.6 billion, primarily due to a $100 million reserve release in Q4, compared with a $402 million reserve build the year before, with elevated net charge-offs partially counteracting that benefit. On the expense side, we saw a 4% decline, bringing the total to $1.3 billion. The main drivers were the absence of last year's restructuring charges and other special items you can find detailed on Slide 17 of the earnings presentation, along with fewer operational losses in the current year. Working against those improvements were expenses related to the Ally Lending acquisition as well as continued spending on technology. For Q4, our efficiency ratio landed at 33.3%, an improvement of about 270 basis points compared to a year ago, driven by Synchrony's ongoing expense management alongside top-line growth. On the bottom line, Synchrony delivered $774 million in net earnings, equal to $1.91 per diluted share. We also recorded a 2.6% return on average assets, a 23% return on tangible common equity, and tangible book value per share grew 23%. Moving on, I want to take you through the main credit developments, which you'll find on Slide 11. When the quarter closed, the rate of accounts 30 or more days past due came in at 4.70%. That's a decline of 4 basis points versus the 4.74% recorded at the same point last year, and it runs 8 basis points above the typical fourth-quarter level we saw across 2017 through 2019. As for accounts 90 or more days past due, that rate reached 2.40%, which is 12 basis points greater than the 2.28% figure from a year ago and 16 basis points over the average for fourth quarters spanning 2017 to 2019. Finally, net charge-offs during the fourth quarter amounted to a rate of 6.45%. That represents an increase of 87 basis points relative to 5.58% in the prior-year period, and it exceeds the 2017 to 2019 fourth-quarter historical average by 96 basis points. Our credit loss reserve equaled 10.44% of loan receivables, roughly 35 basis points lower than the 10.79% recorded in Q3. Slide 12 illustrates that the credit measures implemented between mid-2023 and early 2024 are changing the way delinquencies develop, because growth compared with a year earlier for delinquency rates at both 30-plus and 90-plus days continued to decelerate; these patterns bolster our confidence that we can get back to our long-term net charge-off target. Turning to Slide 13. At Synchrony, funding, capital and liquidity continue to serve as a solid base for our operations. During Q4, Synchrony grew direct deposits by about $716 million while reducing broker deposits by $938 million. Closing out the quarter, our funding mix was led by deposits at 84%, while secured and unsecured debt contributed 8% apiece. We held $19.8 billion in total liquid assets and available undrawn credit facilities, which was basically unchanged from a year ago, and equaled 16.6% of total assets — down 26 basis points year over year. Now on to capital ratios. Just to reiterate, we opted to apply the CECL transition provisions put out by the joint federal banking agencies. In January 2025, Synchrony will apply a final transition adjustment of roughly 50 basis points to our regulatory capital metrics, reflecting CECL's fully phased-in impacts. CECL's effects are already showing up on both our income statement and our balance sheet. Because of how the CECL transition rules work, we closed out Q4 with a CET1 ratio of 13.3%, which is 110 basis points above the 12.2% we posted a year earlier. Our Tier 1 capital ratio came in at 14.5%, 160 basis points greater than the prior year. The total capital ratio rose 160 basis points, reaching 16.5%. And on a fully phased-in basis, our Tier 1 capital plus reserves ratio climbed to 24.3%, up from 22.1% a year ago. In the fourth quarter, Synchrony returned $197 million to shareholders. That breaks down as $100 million in buybacks and $97 million in dividends on common stock. For all of 2024, that puts total capital returned at $1.4 billion. At year-end, our share repurchase authorization still had $600 million left, and that program runs through June 30, 2025. We remain well positioned to keep returning capital to shareholders, consistent with our business results, market conditions, regulatory limits and our capital plan. Moving on to what we expect in 2025, which you'll find on Slide 14: we're working from a few core premises. The economy should hold steady. We anticipate 2.2% GDP expansion across the entire year. Unemployment should sit at 4.1% when the year closes. The Fed Funds rate should reach 4.25% by year-end. And deposits ought to average roughly 60% over the full twelve months.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#5

Beyond that, because of the ambiguity around the litigation process and the political environment related to the late fee rule, our guidance presumes no effect from a possible change to that late fee rule, yet it does incorporate the effect of our PPPCs. Should the late fee rule take effect, then this guidance would cease to apply. Beginning with ending loan receivables, we anticipate that purchase volume and new account growth will keep mirroring the consequences of our credit actions and selective customer spend behavior. We also anticipate that the payment rate in 2025 will broadly stay level with 2024 levels, owing to our past credit actions, which have steadied the mix of customer payment behaviors. As a result, for the entire year 2025, we expect ending loan receivables to grow in the low single digits. After factoring in all seasonal patterns, we expect net revenue for the full year to come in somewhere between $15.2 billion and $15.7 billion. We expect both interest income and other income to increase compared with last year as our PPPCs build up. That will be partly offset by several things: the pass-through of a lower average prime rate on our variable rate receivables, fewer late fees as delinquency performance gets better, a lower-yielding investment portfolio due to lower benchmark rates, and reversals of finance charges and late fees related to the seasonality of our credit performance. Declining benchmark rates on average should likewise assist in reducing what we pay for funding when our certificates of deposit roll over, even though how aggressively deposit pricing responds to additional cuts, should they occur, will influence the outcome. Past that, we expect to hold liquidity at elevated levels, around 17%, across the coming several quarters, which mirrors our intent to put deposit customer relationships first and to fund upcoming expansion in advance. Finally, RSA should land in the 3.60% to 3.85% range as a share of average loan receivables, reflecting better program results from lower net charge-offs alongside the rising impact of our PPPCs. Looking ahead to the entire year, we expect the net charge-off rate for our portfolio to come in somewhere in the range of 5.8% to 6.1%. That mostly mirrors the upside from credit moves we made earlier, along with how we set ourselves apart in both underwriting and managing credit. We also see our efficiency ratio finishing somewhere between 31.5% and 32.5%, given that Synchrony stays committed to generating operating leverage throughout our business. Ahead of turning things over to Q&A, I want to share 3 main points from what we covered today. To start, Synchrony sits in a strong spot to get our growth speeding up again. The money we've put in and the credit steps we've taken were built to put sustainable, profitable growth first as market conditions keep shifting. Since we came out of the pandemic in 2021, our results show how disciplined we've been: ending loan receivables grew by roughly 9% on average, while return on assets averaged about 3% and return on tangible common equity averaged about 25%. And the reason we've been able to put up that kind of track record is that our portfolio's credit performance has outpaced the industry's, and where our delinquency formation has been heading lately makes us confident about our credit outlook as well as our ability to get profitable growth accelerating again. Before we can gradually ease up on our credit restrictions, we need the macro backdrop to remain stable, consumers to spend with more confidence, and our delinquency trends to continue getting better. Additionally, Synchrony's robust capital standing clearly works in our favor—it's going to drive expansion for us and, at the same time, allow us to return more capital to shareholders down the road. Taking everything together, the way Synchrony performed at a high level throughout 2024 has set us up well for 2025 and the years that follow, as we move closer to the long-term financial goals we've laid out. Kathryn, I'll now turn things back over to you so we can begin the Q&A.

Kathryn Miller

executive
#6

That wraps up what we had prepared to say, and now it's time for the question-and-answer portion. In order to fit in as many of you as we can, I'd ask those joining us to keep it to 1 main question plus 1 follow-up. Should anything further come to mind, our Investor Relations group will be around once this call ends. Operator, let's go ahead and open up the Q&A.

Ryan Nash

analyst
#7

Maybe we could start with the net revenue outlook. Brian, you noted growth in fees and NII. Can we break out some of the components affecting net interest income? First, I guess, what are we assuming about how rates will impact things? I know you're planning around a Fed Funds level of 4.25, and as rates come down, the balance sheet should benefit, right? Second, in your guidance, how are the PPPCs coming through, and how much of the total benefit you expect is already reflected in this year's run rate? Then I have one more question.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#8

Yes. Great. I'll try to unpack part of that for you, Ryan. When you look at the net revenue outlook, and I'll tie this somewhat to NII for you, you're going to notice a meaningful increase that comes from the PPPCs making their way through net revenue. You're also going to see a lift that shows up from growth as well as the revolve rate, but two fairly sizable offsets are coming back into the picture. The first is RSAs, and that carries an impact both from a net charge-off rate that's lower in 2025 and from the PPPCs that are passing through it. There's also a pretty sizable drop in late fee revenue showing up in that line, along with lower charge-offs. Those are the main pieces in motion. You'll notice NII growth looks more pronounced, since the RSA effect gets taken out, but the same late fee pattern, the revolve rate, all of that carries through. On net funding, it's a bit negative across the full year. It's more about timing, in terms of when the rate cut worked its way in, with prime rate already beginning to come down early this year. Honestly, it comes down more to timing. Consider what happens with the prime rate coming down: the investment portfolio reprices pretty fast, and then there's the funding side, which again depends on when those CD maturities stack back up. So NII growth ends up more pronounced. As for PPPC — let me answer that before you ask — performance is broadly in line with what we expected financially. We've noted a bit of a mix shift: retention is stronger and yields on the interest side are stronger, while paper statement fees run a little lighter, perhaps because customers are moving to e-bill. That's roughly the framework I use for thinking about both net revenue and NII.

Ryan Nash

analyst
#9

Understood. Perhaps to follow up regarding capital: you're currently more than 200 bps over the goal, particularly during a quarter that's seasonally slow; and I believe you repurchased $100 billion worth of shares. Could you perhaps discuss your strategy for returning capital, specifically why it was somewhat muted this quarter; and maybe just alternate between — are there greater chances to use it inorganically? Or I know you said two times in your previous comments, Brian, about growth picking up speed again. Are you restraining yourself somewhat in expectation of loan growth coming back? I'm just attempting to grasp the reasoning behind the reduced near-term buyback and its implications for using capital across the coming few quarters.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#10

Yes. I appreciate that inquiry, Ryan. I realize many folks will attempt to infer something from our actions and the pace for the quarter. I simply wish to clarify. The pace for the quarter being below several earlier quarters reflected more our perspective on the marketplace and what might be a potentially more unstable market due to the presidential election and the consequences regardless of which an administration sort of emerged and the resulting knock-on impact; so we sort of decided in advance that this wasn't a quarter where we would be aggressively stepping in regarding buybacks. I wouldn't infer anything from that — the $600 million still available under the existing authorization, we intend to finish it. And at present, we're working through finalizing our 2025 capital plan while conducting our lost stress tests for them — and once more, we recognize that capital represents a strength for us. It does give us the chance to act inorganically; but I wish to clarify, we didn't accumulate capital because of the reduced repurchases, yet not because of awaiting extra growth AV inorganic. It was simply more our perspective on the markets possibly being somewhat more disruptive or disjointed during the fourth quarter, and we stay dedicated to lowering capital back nearer to our goal.

Sanjay Sakhrani

analyst
#11

Brian Wenzel, perhaps we could dig a bit deeper into that PPPC effect. Would it be reasonable to figure that as this year wraps up, you'd still essentially be carrying the complete run rate of the mitigation you expected to place into the figures? And then, how ought we to consider the ROA impact if late fee regulation never materializes? I'm simply attempting to reason through normalizing your long-term ROI and the timing for reaching it; and my assumption was that mitigation lifts that higher, so when would we arrive there?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#12

Yes. I appreciate that, Sanjay. When I consider how you come out of 2025 and the PPPCs, looking at a few separate pieces, you still won't be entirely there regarding finance charges. If you remember, we stated roughly half 1 year out, around 75% 2 years out. So incremental run rate will flow to the interest line as you finish '25 and move nearer to '26. That's the first point. Paper statements ought to — which — I'd describe as a more stable level, but afterward will be — then we'll increase at a rate tied to our average active accounts and how that expansion occurs depending on mix and given that not every account carries that paper statement fee — possibly, a slight headwind could arise should more individuals opt for e-bill, and then you'll capture the advantage on the expense line rather than the other income line. And the final item I'd mention concerns the promotional fees, which ought to accumulate across 2025 since that took effect somewhat later in 2024. As promotional volume rises, it has run somewhat under our historical amounts, correct? Purely from a buying standpoint, that ought to rise and amortize in gradually. So I believe as you finish '25, there remains space to grow on the interest line from promo fees and interest income, interest from the interest charges, plus a modest amount on the paper statement fees.

Sanjay Sakhrani

analyst
#13

All right. Then what about return on assets — any perspective on that?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#14

Clearly we aren't — we aren't providing guidance on ROA. That said, when you examine how the outlook is built; conceptually, starting from a position where this year has to be removed, it's genuinely critical to remove the pets gain along with the Visa <<inaudible>>. Conceptually, the PPPCs absent a late fee offset toward reduced late fees, you'd typically end up with something that pushes ROA progressively upward.

Sanjay Sakhrani

analyst
#15

All right. All right. One more question for Brian Doubles. Perhaps you could discuss what the deal landscape looks like. I'm aware a few RFPs are circulating. There's plenty of talk regarding them. Maybe you could describe how things appear from your side. And beyond that, loan growth continues to be soft. Purchase volume also continues to be soft. I mean, is there anything that might help move those? Are you being cautious in that area?

Brian Doubles

executive
#16

Yeah, absolutely. Broadly speaking, I'd say we're happy with the current operating environment. Let me address your second question first, the one about growth. Honestly, the consumer looks to be in fairly solid shape. We're pleased with conditions as they stand; we did implement certain credit actions. Those are performing precisely as intended; accordingly, 30-plus reversed its trend. The way things are positioned for the coming year is quite favorable; thus we're very optimistic about conditions. On the competitive front, I can tell you there's still solid discipline across the market. We're evaluating numerous fresh opportunities, as is our habit. Our pipeline is strong. And right now, that discipline remains fairly solid. Part of that, I believe, stems from — the prior year carried some uncertainty regarding the economy, inflation's impact, the election. And during stretches like those, I think you typically observe solid discipline when it comes to pricing fresh opportunities, and that's what we're seeing. So, as you're aware, we bid in a disciplined manner. A solid risk-adjusted return is always our focus; we seek programs featuring truly strong alignment between our firm and the partner. Those items matter greatly; for us they're completely nonnegotiable; and we keep winning new business; so I feel — once more, I feel positive about conditions. I feel quite positive about the way we're competing for new business. And that was evident with a pair of significant renewals we completed last quarter involving Sam's and JCPenney.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#17

Yeah. Sanjay, let me just clarify one thing Brian mentioned. Regarding the purchase line growth in Q4 — I realize that's getting a lot of attention — a big chunk of it came from credit actions. What we were doing there was positioning credit so that in 2025 we'd be moving back toward our longer-term target range. That matters a great deal. I'm aware we'll reach the credit target at some point, but this is also helping us return to that trajectory more quickly than our competitors. The purchase volume, though, is intentional. And the new accounts were intentional too, essentially setting ourselves up on the credit side.

Mihir Bhatia

analyst
#18

I'd like to return to what we were discussing regarding net revenue and a few of its elements. Could you perhaps walk us through a few of the assumptions baked into that — specifically, what portion of your portfolio gets repriced as we move into 2025? And what's your outlook as we exit 2025? Would that suggest there's potentially additional net revenue upside in 2026?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#19

Yes. Once more, we really haven't altered anything. What we're doing here is giving a bit of extra detail, apart from the fact that we discussed what share of the book ought to reprice over the initial 12 months and across the following 12 months — and I'd say, based on where we are right now, we're running a touch ahead of that timeline. Naturally, we're also entering a stretch where the prime rate is going to exert some degree of influence during the first half, because of the shifts that took place in the latter part of 2024. So once more, there's no revision to the guidance we provided concerning what portion of the book will be sitting on the new APRs.

Mihir Bhatia

analyst
#20

Understood. Now, regarding credit, which you brought up — let's shift our attention there. Your guidance points to substantial gains, and delinquencies reflect that; however, I noticed your purchase volumes remain under pressure. I realize part of this stems from decisions you've made and from stepping back on stricter underwriting. So I suppose I have a few questions. First, have you finished tightening underwriting at this point? What's your read on the current environment? What signals are you picking up from consumers? A few others have noted more people making only minimum payments, and there's been some discussion about how many are maxed out on their credit lines. What does your book show? What's your view of the consumer? And where do you stand on underwriting posture?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#21

Sure. Let me attempt to break that down. First off, I'd like everyone to keep in mind that our credit normalization arrived later than it did for others. We hit what you might call a peak or a trend where our 30 pluses have now gone positive, whether you measure it quarter over quarter into Q3 or year over year in Q4, whereas many others are already there. So we avoided the highs, and ours was far more contained, mostly because of the credit actions we've implemented, and we're happy with their results. The broad-based steps we took essentially stopped back in Q2 of 2024; therefore, what we keep doing now are the usual idiosyncratic-type adjustments we evaluate across partners, channels, and the risk return of those channels and products. As we move into 2025, considering the credit trajectory — and we've now beaten seasonality for 5 months on a '17 to '19 basis — I believe we're optimistic about where credit is headed and how those actions are performing, which leads us to guide down again to that 5.8 to 6.10 range, with some of that hinging more on the denominator. Once you dig deeper and consider the consumer briefly, overall line utilization hasn't really shifted. So we aren't seeing consumers at their maximum line. That's not a problem we observe in our portfolio or across our portfolio's segments. Looking at payment behavioral patterns, when we spot movements, those movements appear broadly across all credit grades; it isn't concentrated in nonprime; we likely see it somewhat more in the upper prime category than in low prime, meaning they're sort of returning from places where they previously had excess liquidity, but we don't see anything materially different. When you examine how our payments break down, compared with 2019, the share of borrowers paying only the minimum has risen sharply across every credit grade. Take the 780 plus group — they're probably up a bit more than 400 basis points, while each of the other ratings, prime and nonprime, climbed into the high 3s; the difference isn't meaningful. Some of this is structural, since we've added more installment lending along with promotional financing. Every one of those payments lands in exact NIM pay, so that piece is structural in nature. That said, we aren't spotting any consumer cracks. As Brian discussed regarding payment behavior trends and line utilization trends, our view remains that much of the loss pressure industrywide came from extending too much credit to particular cohorts, and whether those borrowers could genuinely manage it. So nothing we're seeing worries us. I believe that as we move through the first half of the year, we'll reassess when, or whether, we might want to ease some of the credit restrictions currently in effect. One possibility is doing part of that during the back half of this year. I'm not suggesting a scenario where we undo everything, but there could be grounds for us to step back and conclude the actions have mostly accomplished what was needed to position the book correctly; that's roughly how I view credit and some of the book's performance right now, Mihir.

Terry Ma

analyst
#22

As something of a credit-related follow-up, your delinquency rate declined 4 basis points versus the prior year. As we move through the remainder of the year, do you have a sense of how much more room might exist for improvement on that year-over-year comparison?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#23

Yes. Thanks, Terry. We don't provide external forecasts for 30 plus or 90 plus. What I can do instead is offer some perspective on the credit trends we're observing, which clearly shape not just the charge-off rate but also our reserving posture. We keep seeing favorable entry rate; that improved a bit further during the fourth quarter because of certain pre-collections actions we've taken. Performance has been solid, right, when you look at our 2 flows relative to charge-off. And in fact, our late-stage collections have gotten better. So when you consider that, it gives us a very high degree of confidence as we think about bringing the net charge-off rate lower year-over-year and returning it to our target underwriting zone. If you think about the near term here, there's typically a seasonal uplift you observe, especially in the first quarter, and it continues from there. We won't see that seasonal uplift to the same degree. But historically, it has run about 50 basis points. In the first quarter of 2025, we will not have that, in our view, largely for 2 reasons. First is that performance I mentioned, especially the late-stage improvement across some of those later delinquency stages; and second, the timing of certain recovery actions we have, and while recoveries will be comparable to 2024, it's just how the timing of that plays through. So seasonally, a little bit better in the first half, or first quarter, excuse me. So based on the delinquency formation of flow, we feel good.

Terry Ma

analyst
#24

Understood, that's useful. Then perhaps to follow up regarding the allowance ratio. When you consider everything collectively, how does that shape what we can expect for the allowance ratio as we move through the remainder of this year? My sense is this quarter came in somewhat above what you'd anticipated and what was indicated earlier in the year; so perhaps some detail on the variance between the guidance and what actually occurred, and then how ought we to view the allowance ratio?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#25

Yes. I appreciate that question. Let me attempt to speak to a bit of where we landed in 2024. I believe there are truly 2 elements that contributed to that landing spot coming in perhaps above what folks had anticipated were — broadly, we indicated it would be roughly consistent with where we finished in 2023. First, the denominator obviously played a role in it being marginally elevated on a rate basis; so that accounts for a portion of it. The second element is likely somewhat of what I'd characterize as conservatism, in terms of how we approach the credit actions within the quantitative portion of the model as we head into 2025. I think stepping back, although we aren't offering guidance on the reserve, but consider the components involved, if you keep believing or believe that the net charge-off rate returns downward nearer to or within the net charge-off long-term guide, correct? That component of the model, which is the quantitative component of the model, you ought to receive a rate advantage stemming from that. The second element concerns your qualitative overlays and whether you gain clarity regarding the macroeconomic environment, correct, which currently keeps fluctuating in terms of how inflation is moving and how interest rates are funding; but those 2 are the elements we'll need to monitor. Naturally, I think if you consider charge-off rates declining and you consider a macroeconomic environment that gets better and you possess greater clarity, there would be a downward tilt as you progress into 2025 and finish 2025 on the reserve rate. Once more, it will depend somewhat on seasonality across the year, but a downward tilt ought to exist under that kind of scenario or framework.

Moshe Orenbuch

analyst
#26

Brian Doubles. You said that adding the Synchrony Pay Later was one piece of the JCPenney renewal. Could you discuss the other — any additional new elements in the renewals for those 2 big programs? And also share a bit about what we ought to keep in mind regarding the economics behind those renewals?

Brian Doubles

executive
#27

Yeah. Of course, Moshe; so here's how I'd put it: to begin with, having JCPenney and Sam's Club renew is something we're delighted about. At this stage, we've partnered with both of them for decades; so having them extend is something we're very pleased about. Launching Pay Later with JCPenney has us excited. I view that as genuine proof of the multi-product ecosystem we've assembled, beginning with Lowe's, and now JCPenney, and it truly connects with our partners, both — honestly, on the renewal front, and likewise when we're out there competing with new — going after new business. And I believe the situation differs from roughly 2 or 3 years back, when you had partners turning to fintechs, chasing buy now, pay later options, essentially trying everything possible to produce and push sales. These days they've sort of pulled back and concluded, "Hey, we need a product that works as an entry point, a method of attracting new customers and then gradually moving them up to a revolving product, a co-brand card." And if you examine the economic model tied to that, it's genuinely attractive; it works very well for us. It works very well for the partners since certain entry-level offerings in buy now, pay later don't quite hit our return threshold, yet once you factor in that customer's lifetime value, it certainly does; and as I mentioned, it's a win for us and for the partner. Regarding the economics of the 2 renewals, that's not something we disclose. All I'd say is that we're very pleased with the economics and the terms of both agreements. There's strong alignment on both. I bring that up often since it's completely essential for a program to succeed. These agreements run long term. And we need to be certain that our interests and the partner's interests line up exactly. In both instances, I believe they do.

Moshe Orenbuch

analyst
#28

Understood. Then perhaps to build on that, you mentioned there could be some partial unwinding of certain tightening measures, possibly by the year's latter half. Could you give us a bit more detail on whether specific categories — not necessarily partner names, but categories of partners — would probably experience that sooner, or any other indicators we ought to watch for to confirm that this is happening?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#29

Sure, excellent question, Moshe. What I believe you'll begin to observe involves a handful of segments, correct? There may be a pickup in Dual Card, right — meaning we'd have Dual Cards, as you might imagine, in situations where currently we're perhaps down selling somewhat more into private label; we would move ahead and perform additional upgrades from the private label offering into the Dual Card offerings. That's item one. Another place you'll notice, I think, concerns where we've likely been stricter regarding credit line increases and possibly credit line decreases — you'll probably see somewhat more activity both raising and lowering credit lines, and that typically occurs within certain of the bigger balance-type platforms that we operate. So at first, what you'll really begin to observe is some expansion into growth areas, some enhancement in our approval rate for new accounts, which then starts to show up in purchase line activity. Once again, I think that's concentrated somewhat in the large-type balance platforms. Another major piece here, I think, will come when consumers possess sufficient confidence — we monitor consumer confidence pretty carefully — but possess sufficient confidence to want to make additional discretionary purchases, since that's what we're observing everywhere, whether in health and wellness, consider some of the cosmetic items or Lasix possibly, or in home and auto, consider some of the mattresses and furniture deferrals. Those ought to generate solid tailwinds once consumers gain some confidence as we move forward; they aren't credit oriented, but we'll be available to assist them. So I do believe it's somewhat broader regarding some of the actions we'd take or start to unwind under that possible scenario.

Jeff Adelson

analyst
#30

Considering the overall deceleration in purchase volume growth and account expansion that's been evident for several years, plus the credit measures you've implemented, could you perhaps discuss some of the responses and discussions you're having with your main retail partners regarding this? I realize Synchrony handles the underwriting decisions, but are you sensing a stronger inclination from certain partners to perhaps ease up a bit at this point? Also, how might that slower growth theme be influencing the competitive landscape as you aim to renew and secure new partnerships moving forward?

Brian Doubles

executive
#31

Yeah. Jeff, I believe it ties back to my earlier point, that across all our programs, we maintain strong alignment with the partners. So when we observed the industry's actions in '21, '22, and somewhat into '23, with the enormous volume of credit provided to consumers, we began quite proactively implementing these tightening measures and adjustments; and we did so fully openly with every one of our partners, just as we handle everything else concerning the program. We examine the data, we review the outcomes. We demonstrate to them precisely how it will affect the program's performance, on the growth aspect as well as the RSA component, and we reach those choices together. We manage credit. There's no ambiguity there, but we operate very transparently alongside our partners. And our interests align via the RSA. And you're witnessing that currently. I mean, as Brian mentioned, the RSA will rise slightly due to the PPPCs and the improved net charge-offs outlook for 2025. That's precisely how they should function; and thus both the credit measures and the RSA are performing as intended. And so in a partnership such as this, provided you have a solid contract where it's evident that we both succeed jointly. And don't be mistaken, we both aim to grow. We want to serve more customers; we want to assist our partners in boosting sales, but we want to accomplish it sensibly — we're steering toward the long-term credit objective, and I think we're achieving that.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#32

Yeah. The one other point I'd make there, Jeff. If you just pull back a bit, we generated the second-largest purchase volume in our history, following a record purchase volume the prior year. And we saw meaningful asset growth the previous year; so I'd call this part of a longer-term pattern. It reflects deliberate credit actions. That's why I believe — when you consider how quickly losses begin to climb and move past your long-term historical averages, we were likely the slowest to see that happen and among the quickest to recover, and our increase wasn't as steep. That came from credit actions and our intention to take them. So once more, I don't want to overlook that on the purchase line side, this is a major year for our partners and for our company.

Jeff Adelson

analyst
#33

Alright, great. And for my follow-up, I want to go back to what Sanjay asked about. If the late fee rule doesn't get finalized — and let's just suppose the CFPB goes ahead and issues it — could you describe what the next steps would be? Also, have any retail partners mentioned wanting to reduce the number of PPPCs you're processing?

Brian Doubles

executive
#34

Yes. Let me take that. Obviously, we've seen some encouraging movement on the legal side — the injunction is going to remain in effect. Judge Pittman made some favorable remarks regarding the strength of the industry's case. That being said, none of this is settled yet. There's no certainty right now. As a result, we aren't intending to alter any of our pricing measures at this moment. We need to watch how the litigation unfolds. We require a certain degree of certainty. And as I mentioned before, our approach will mirror what we did when the late fee proposal was introduced. We'll reach out, we'll engage with our partners. We'll handle it in a fully transparent way. We'll consider many different elements, such as any shifts in behavior we might have observed so far, we'll examine how other merchants and providers set prices for their programs. We'll assess the competition. We'll assess the industry. And we'll work through the financial consequences for our partners regarding the effect on the RSA; so once again, it will be highly collaborative. We'll arrive at the decision jointly, exactly as we did on credit and when that initial late fee proposal was released.

John Hecht

analyst
#35

The first item I'd like to raise is, I guess, one more credit-focused perspective, Brian Wenzel. Naturally, I understand 2024 is still young, but have any early indicators emerged from particular pieces of the 2024 vintage hinting that this vintage by itself might ultimately finish within the long-term targets?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#36

Yeah. First off, thanks for bringing that up, John. Looking at the 2023 and 2024 vintages, we went over part of that early performance, though admittedly it's very early, particularly for 2024. What I'd say is these are still developing. And versus the industry, from our standpoint they're outperforming the industry's numbers for 2023 and 2024 alike; putting those vintages up against 2018, they landed slightly below 2018, but not significantly enough to concern us or hold us back as they mature. So thinking about it, those 2 vintages have us feeling pretty good, because all the credit actions are completely reflected in the 2024 vintages, and we stay encouraged — that's another reason we think we're back, ideally, inside our long-term target range of 5.50 to 6, even though next year's guidance is 5.80 to 6.10, or $550 million to $600 million and $580 million to $610 million.

John Hecht

analyst
#37

All right. Next up is Brian Doubles. Could you perhaps discuss the breakdown between digital commerce and in-store commerce? And has that path shifted in any way over the—I suppose, sort of following COVID?

Brian Doubles

executive
#38

Yeah. John, as you'd expect, it keeps growing, both regarding the kinds of partners where we're currently seeing the greatest expansion. And also regarding how the consumer does their shopping. Digital wallets are one of the major areas we're putting money into, and they're growing increasingly common. There was the Apple Pay announcement, which you saw. So that's a space where our investment continues. I believe we compete very effectively there. We possess quite advanced technology platforms that get embedded into our partners' apps along with their mobile platforms. And I think that's clearly—it goes without saying, that's the direction things are headed, and for 8 or 9 years we've really been investing heavily there. So as a competitive advantage, we feel good about it. Compared with many others in the industry, I think our platform is more sophisticated.

John Pancari

analyst
#39

Regarding how much cash we're holding, I understand you said you're sitting at elevated amounts, roughly 17%, in part to get ahead on funding future expansion. Could you share a bit more detail about why you made that call? Also, what might cause that stance to shift? And how should we think about it over a longer horizon? In your view, what level makes sense as the right amount over the long run?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#40

Sure. Appreciate you asking. When we examine the market for deposits through digital banking, our belief remains that an opportunity exists with the kind of consumers we're seeking to draw in, and that we still have an appealing route to add new customers. What we aimed to accomplish was essentially reduce how fast deposits grew near term, so we'd only need to speed that back up once expansion arrives. Right now, despite carrying more liquidity, when you look at it through EPS, it's a favorable exchange from my standpoint. If I'm able to draw in funds at a high-yield savings rate of $4.10 and earn more than that, you know, through Fed cash, that represents a good economic exchange as well as a good EPS exchange. True, it will definitely weigh on net interest margin, yet I believe the EPS dollars are the better consideration. My goal is to step back and aim to stay rate sensitive near term, then face a greater cost to acquire during the back half of the year or heading into next year when we expand. So essentially that's the plan behind it. I think we genuinely feel that our positioning is solid compared with those we classify as our peers within digital banking. When you consider that long-term rate, it typically falls in the — I'd describe it as the 15% to 17% range, based on whichever quarter you happen to be in. So a bit below that starting from here, but we simply wanted to highlight it since we won't change our approach to funding deposits near term, and we believe growth will speed back up eventually.

John Pancari

analyst
#41

Understood. Fine. My next question is brief, and it returns to the late fee rule. You mentioned recognizing the favorable remarks that came from Judge Pittman; however, what are you truly picking up from your contacts in D.C. following the election regarding possible CFPB moves, given that there are shifts within the administration? What I'm asking is, might the rule still be permitted to — might it still get resolved through the courts, or could it actually be terminated outright?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#42

Yeah; speculating about that is genuinely difficult. What I mean is, multiple possible scenarios exist. Our legal team has gotten a great deal of our time. What I can say is, looking back to the point when the litigation began, there have been plenty of highs and lows. And I believe the industry regards Judge Pittman's ruling as fairly favorable, yet in terms of how things might unfold going forward, considerable uncertainty remains. As I see it, the window for an appeal remains open through the first week of February. So I'd rather not engage in speculation; we are monitoring this very carefully. Clearly, we remain in communication with our partners, but beyond that I don't wish to speculate.

Bill Carcache

analyst
#43

To start, could you talk about how much PPPC might lift your normalized 28% return profile on a lasting basis?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#44

Sure. Our long-term view remains the same. To some extent, after the late fee rule is resolved — whether it takes effect or not, and whatever the final impact from the PPPCs turns out to be — at that stage we'll return and possibly take another look at those targets, but as of now, Bill, we haven't revised them.

Bill Carcache

analyst
#45

Got it. Perhaps I can ask something related to what you said about efficiency guidance. I apologize in case I overlooked it, but could you share some detail on what would push your efficiency ratio to the bottom end instead of the top end of that range?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#46

Sure. The first thing is simply looking at how effectively you handle and expand your current account base — if I'm able to increase the balances already on the books, that gives me operating leverage. My sense is we exercise quite a bit of discipline regarding the timing and manner in which we bring on additional FTEs, plus how we oversee certain nonexempt staff as seasonal cycles come and go. So we draw on quite a few different levers. And if you think back to the drop in net revenue that we experienced as a company during the pandemic — we returned very fast to being among the most efficient credit card companies, maybe even the single most efficient one, in terms of running the business, and our pledge is to generate that operating leverage once more in 2025.

Rob Wildhack

analyst
#47

I'd like to ask about what you expect for loan growth. I'm curious to hear how you see that developing as the year goes on, since I recall you mentioning previously a possibility where things could loosen up somewhat during the back half. So does that remain the base case, and is it baked into the outlook at this point? Also, which milestones ought we to track to determine whether that stays on course? Is it merely a matter of net charge-offs returning to normal?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#48

Yes. When you consider loan growth as you move through the year, the starting point has to be what you're measuring against on a year-over-year basis. Clearly, the toughest comparison is going to be the first quarter. During the second quarter we were pretty explicit; we observed a slowdown among consumers that actually came somewhat ahead of the credit actions we took. And then, clearly, there was the further slowdown seen in the latter half of the year, chiefly from the credit side itself along with the discerning customers. So if you frame it that way, the first quarter is likely the harder one where loan growth is concerned; after that you ought to witness something of an acceleration as you move through the second, third, and fourth quarters. As for the scenario we may have referenced once or twice involving the removal of certain credit restrictions, that isn't incorporated into the base plan; it's something we'd examine later in the year, and the effects would start showing up once we take those steps. A solid leading indicator for that will be the way charge-offs trend and whether we're able to meet the charge-off guidance, and we touched on the first quarter a bit, but truly getting back within that range and feeling at ease that the trajectory and what we're originating sits at the rate risk adjusted margin — that is genuinely the company's central focus, after which we would start removing some of those restrictions, whether that happens in the later portion of this year or going into next year.

Rob Wildhack

analyst
#49

Then I'd like a brief point of clarity regarding deposit betas. For 2024, the beta is 60%. My recollection is that around this same point 12 months ago, you mentioned an 80% or 90% beta as rates rose, plus an expectation of roughly the same as rates fell across the whole cutting cycle. So how should we interpret the 60% for this year alongside that 80 to 90 you saw during the ascent?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#50

Sure. Here's how we approach betas, Rob — and by definition, issuers or banks tend to view this a bit differently. Our frame of reference runs from the beginning of the rising-rate cycle to the beginning of the declining cycle. Looking at it that way, for both high-yield savings and CDs, the beta comes to roughly 75%, 174, 176. That's essentially our benchmark. And in the end, our expectation is that you'll return to that same kind of downward beta once you consider that initial rate hike ahead. The 60% figure, I'd say, better captures a bit of lag that shows up with digital banks, along with the actual timing of the rate cuts. As our page shows, we've got just a single rate decrease, and it lands closer to the latter portion of the year. Because of that lag, you won't observe as much deposit beta in the present year.

Brennan Crowley

analyst
#51

I believe nearly everything I had has been covered already, though — the two of you touched on Dual Cards plus the CareCredit Dual Card fueling new card growth. Could you share a bit more detail about the approach there, and which channels do you anticipate will produce substantial growth?

Brian Doubles

executive
#52

Sure, I'll handle that; well, in my view our health and wellness operation ranks among the top strategic priorities. Growth in that area has been quite strong, and plenty of big opportunities lie ahead. Given how loyal CareCredit customers are, one item we examined was introducing a Dual Card; what we've observed across the past 10 years is that people prefer to keep their health and wellness spending separate. The thinking, then, was this: if CareCredit works well for you, bring it to pharmacies, bring it to health and wellness purchases. We've teamed up with several of our other partners so the CareCredit card can be accepted. That makes for a promising growth path; we're big fans of the product. Investment there will keep going.

L. Erika Penala

analyst
#53

Okay, just a final item, and let me go back to the topic of growth. I believe the main discussion I was having with the folks who invest with you, essentially around the period when you spoke at a conference in December, centered on how growth was trending. And I simply wanted to confirm that we were genuinely breaking down each of the points you shared with us today. So the first one is quite evident: a substantial portion of the deceleration came from the credit measures you took proactively. So I believe that part is fairly evident. You said the consumer is in good shape, yet the consumer also lacks confidence. So we sort of wanted to break down what your cohort is actually like when it comes to how we're considering spending, since the data we've received across various cohorts so far during this earnings season has been quite strong, and the outlook going forward has been quite strong as well; and the third item is, I'm actually going to pose the other question regarding the PPPC, in that if late fees don't come through, I mean, in some sense, does it truly matter whether it's ROE accretive, if it's going to discourage growth, correct? For instance, a purchase APR of 32% could be a deterrent to growing. So those are just 3 items that I believe investors are genuinely weighing as we consider what the — what does growth actually look like for Synchrony specifically within your cohort as we consider a consumer. That's perhaps somewhat healthier than we anticipated they would be in '25?

Brian Doubles

executive
#54

Yes; so allow me to begin with the consumer. I think we — look, we genuinely feel positive regarding the consumer. I think regardless of what you examine, whether you're examining how they're spending, the reality that they're being disciplined, they're managing to a budget; we have observed a retrenchment among the lower income cohort, and I think that's fairly consistent throughout the industry. That's where they're experiencing the impacts of inflation. Regarding the higher income customer, they're retrenching a little, but I think still very healthy. And I think that's beneficial from — from a credit standpoint, people are being disciplined. They're not overextending, which is a positive thing. So I think it's a mix of that and what we did regarding credit; and so we're very pleased with how the measures we took are performing, we're getting credit in line with the long-term guidance; and we're prepared to give up a little bit of growth here in the near term to deliver that.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#55

Yes. Erika, let me tack on a few additional items here. From our vantage point on the consumer broadly, and specifically that upper-tier customer, that upper-tier customer came in flat for us during the quarter, correct. So indeed, it lags, yet it wasn't negative on net, whereas the greater share of the weakness sits with the lower nonprime group, and that group is precisely where more of the credit actions landed. So once more, as you break down the components, we don't feel too bad about it. Turning to the PPPC, you raise the idea about the APR and such. There are a few things I would just tack onto that. First, across every program where we rolled out PPPCs, we have a test-first control. That means we truly are able to observe purchase volume per active. We are able to observe realization rate; we are able to observe whether attrition exists, whether it's solid attrition or shifts in revolver or transactor behaviors. And no meaningful gap shows up between those sitting in the control group and those who got the terms and conditions. That provides us a certain degree of comfort that the sales decline isn't necessarily tied to PPPC, point one. Second, we had a few holdouts, and although we might have settled on terms, we hadn't implemented them until the late fee rule took effect; in those cases, they are experiencing some of the identical declines that we are experiencing everywhere. So once more, that's another data point suggesting this isn't necessarily caused by the PPPC. So as we examine that; and then the last thing I would note, when folks point to the APR, you must consider the value proposition, since these cards generally carry a higher value proposition overall when you're considering 5% discount at particular retailers or you're considering 10% off and similar things. So a stronger value proposition, which represents a bulk of the RSAs, the gap is an excellent illustration of why you could have that item sort of priced that way. That's the reason a person can charge several hundred dollars for an annual fee on a card, because that person has believed the value proposition is strong enough to back it. So I believe you have to step back and examine all the elements surrounding the product's pricing and the value proposition before you reach conclusions.

Brian Doubles

executive
#56

So that examination circles back to what I mentioned before — it's precisely the kind of thing we sit down and walk through alongside our partners. We tell them: alright, this is the test, this is the control, and this is our expectation for what occurs when you raise or lower APRs, along with what gets traded off. And clearly, our partners care a great deal about this, since it hits them, honestly, on the growth front and also because their interests line up with the RSA.

L. Erika Penala

analyst
#57

Honestly, those details about the control group really gave investors useful insight, so I'm grateful for that.

Operator

operator
#58

That brings Synchrony's earnings conference call to an end. At this point you're free to hang up, and we hope the rest of your day is wonderful. Thanks so much.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Synchrony Financial transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Synchrony Financial earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Synchrony Financial or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.