The Hanover Insurance Group, Inc. (THG) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
April 30, 2026
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Oksana Lukasheva
executiveThanks, operator. Good morning, everyone, and I appreciate you being with us on this quarterly conference call. We'll kick things off today with prepared comments from Jack Roche, who serves as our President and Chief Executive Officer, along with Jeff Farber, our Chief Financial Officer. Once those prepared remarks wrap up, Dick Lavey, our Chief Operating Officer and President of Agency Markets, and Bryan Salvatore, President of Specialty Lines, will be on hand to take your questions. Before handing things to Jack, I want to point out that you can find our earnings press release, financial supplement, and the full slide presentation for today's call in the investor section of our website, hanover.com. Following the presentation, we'll take questions during the Q&A session. Anything we say in our prepared remarks and in response to your questions today that isn't a statement of historical fact constitutes a forward-looking statement as defined under the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Such statements may concern, among other things, our outlook, profitability, growth, and strategic initiatives, the effect of recently revised policy terms and conditions and targeted property actions, economic and geopolitical conditions and related effects, including economic and social inflation, tariffs, and other risks and uncertainties such as severe weather and catastrophes that could affect the company's performance and/or cause actual results to differ materially from those anticipated. We urge caution when relying on forward-looking statements, and in that regard, we direct you to the forward-looking statements section of our press release, the presentation deck, and our filings with the SEC. Today's discussion will also touch on certain non-GAAP financial measures, including operating income and accident year loss and combined ratios excluding catastrophes, among others. You can find a reconciliation of these non-GAAP financial measures to the closest GAAP measure on a historical basis in the press release, the slide presentation, or the financial supplement, all of which are posted on our website. With that, I'll hand the call over to Jack.
Jack Roche
executiveThanks, Oksana, and good morning to all of you. We've opened 2026 on very solid footing, delivering outstanding results for the first quarter and positioning ourselves for ongoing success. What stands out about this quarter's performance is how consistently disciplined our execution was throughout the entire organization, along with the staying power of a portfolio we've intentionally built to withstand shocks, adapt quickly, and deliver strong outcomes no matter where we are in the market cycle. Margins on an underlying basis kept moving in a positive direction across the book, which largely reflects the pricing we've put through recently as well as the underwriting steps we've taken in a targeted way. Meanwhile, our solid financial position and premium investment holdings kept working in our favor, delivering strong yields once more thanks to careful asset allocation and investment management. We posted our best-ever first quarter results, with operating return on equity reaching 20.3% and operating earnings per share coming in at $5.25. Our all-in combined ratio came down by just about 2.5 points, landing at 91.7%, and our ex-CAT combined ratio saw a comparable improvement, reaching 85.4% — both marking first quarter records. Even though we saw more weather activity than usual across the areas we serve, these numbers show our core earnings engine is firing on all cylinders. On top of that, we're feeling good about how much better than we'd anticipated the improved terms and conditions plus the targeted property actions have played out — and we see that as what's behind the meaningful favorable development on catastrophe losses from the prior year; net written premium growth for the first quarter came in balanced at 3.2%. In places where property conditions are softening, we're moving carefully. Doing it this way lets us keep margin integrity intact while setting ourselves up for stronger growth opportunities. When we built our 2026 plan, we assumed the first quarter would be the low point for growth over the year. Now shifting to our segment results, and starting with Personal Lines. What we delivered this quarter shows a business that's tracking well, even with external conditions still in flux. Personal Lines net written premiums came in 2.7% higher, which shows our state-by-state growth plans are working. We kept our focus on writing profitable business in states where we have room to grow, while keeping a close watch on our Midwest exposure so it fits with our broader strategy of diversifying. New business picked up as the quarter went on, which gives us more confidence in where Personal Lines is headed. On top of that, pricing across the entire Personal Lines book stayed ahead of loss cost trends, and we feel good about holding the line on margins. When it comes to quoting activity, close rates, and conversion metrics, those are still at healthy levels too — which shows a solid match among our pricing, the risks we choose, and the value customers receive. Profitability stayed excellent during the quarter, and you can see that in our underlying loss ratio, which got better by over one point compared with the same period last year. Taking it all together, our Personal Lines operation sits in a good spot thanks to the preferred full account approach we favor, pricing that stays disciplined, and customer behavior that isn't shifting around — even though Personal Auto has grown more competitive across numerous states. Now turning to Core Commercial: during the quarter we posted healthy growth of 4.3%, with Small Commercial driving strong premium gains and Middle Market picking up momentum. These results show we're executing better, and they line up nicely with what we're aiming for on profitability. In Small Commercial, net written premiums picked up pace compared with the previous quarter, helped by new business expanding at a double-digit rate. Transactional flow, digital engagement, and consolidation activity each contributed favorably and are performing in line with what we anticipated; we feel we are exceptionally well-positioned given our base of small account customers and our strong agency position, which improved retention demonstrates. Going forward, we anticipate that our growth initiatives will let us keep driving the top line while we hold onto underwriting discipline. Middle Market posted positive growth in the first quarter, showing better momentum that we intend to build upon ahead. With property conditions softening, we continue to hold underwriting discipline wherever pricing pressure shows up, staying focused on preserving margin. Simultaneously, we are rolling out pricing and underwriting actions throughout Commercial Auto and Umbrella to tackle ongoing industry loss ratio pressure. Meanwhile, segmentation efforts let us sharpen our portfolio toward risk profiles that are more appealing. On the whole, we are happy with the solid growth achieved in Core Commercial, backed by strategic portfolio positioning and powerful momentum in Small Commercial. Now to Specialty. What we deliver keeps confirming the intrinsic strengths of our Specialty business, our sharp focus on pricing for risk and returns, and our capacity to produce strong profitability beyond what was expected. Our 2.3% growth reflects a deliberate approach in segments where competition has intensified, particularly in property-heavy lines like Hanover Specialty Property. The pressure on the top line also demonstrates how we're holding resources in reserve, protecting our most valuable accounts, and pulling back in a targeted way from inadequately priced, lower-caliber business that offers weaker returns. In our Programs operation, for example, net written premiums declined during Q1. Even though our book's profitability looks strong at present, we're taking a careful approach to the MGA landscape and remain highly selective when it comes to distribution partnerships. At the same time, we've seen growth reach double digits in Management liability, Surety, and Specialty GL, climb into the upper single digits in E&S, and turn positive in Professional Lines and Marine. Discipline in pricing remains a foundational element of how Specialty operates. As competition heats up and property conditions soften, loss costs and a focus on margin keep guiding the calls we make on price. Now for the first quarter's Specialty sub-segment highlights: a new operating model is being used by Professional and Executive Lines to improve execution in underwriting, capacity planning, and workflow modernization. Mix quality gets an additional boost from cross-selling and pipeline discipline, helped along by closer coordination with our Core Commercial Lines team. E&S was up 8.1%, supported by offerings centered on liability, while growth in property was held back in response to competitive market conditions. Broadening our footprint in the small E&S market remains a priority for our team, since we continue to see appealing opportunities there. For Marine, we'd anticipated this quarter would mark the softest stretch of the year, and the actual figures came in a touch better than we'd projected. The leadership we have in place across that Marine operation continues to deliver real returns at the moment, and looking at the rest of the year, we expect growth to climb back into the upper single digits. Our Marine colleagues remain focused on extending capacity in a selective manner and pursuing opportunities that protect margin quality while preserving how relevant our agency remains. Turning to the full year, we anticipate overall Specialty growth will accelerate from here; we maintain confidence in our ability to drive top-line expansion across a highly diversified Specialty book, all while continuing to produce exceptionally strong profitability through disciplined execution and targeted investments. Moving away from segment results, the effect of what we've invested in technology is becoming more and more apparent throughout the organization; we're pushing everyday innovation forward together with a transformation of our operating model. By speeding up our quoting processes, boosting our speed to answer, and reinforcing claims execution, we're producing improved outcomes for customers, agents, and employees. We're deliberately creating reusable AI capabilities for the enterprise tasks that come up most often, in order to cut complexity, bolster execution, and make scale possible; consider risk scoring and AI-enabled triage, which assist underwriters in prioritizing submissions and in streamlining intake and decision-making. So these abilities rest on an enterprise ingestion base that is now in use throughout many underwriting, customer service, and claims functions, and they continue to grow. All of this adds up to a careful, company-wide transformation that is grounded in strong data, up-to-date technology, and responsible AI, and it leaves the company ready to operate more efficiently and expand with confidence. We will continue refining our strategy and business model so that risk, price, and capital line up more closely, so that our agents and customers get the most inventive and responsive products and services we can offer, and so that we produce top-tier results. Catastrophe-driven swings will always be part of what this business throws at us. Even so, the results we keep posting demonstrate two things: the exposure management moves we made in the past are paying off, and we hold up well no matter what conditions we face. Going forward, our plan is to stay strict about underwriting discipline while pursuing growth only in areas where the returns make sense, making sure capital is deployed productively, and putting more money into the skills and tools we need as the P&C marketplace continues to shift. Most importantly, our belief remains strong that we can produce dependable, profitable expansion and appealing value over the long haul by sticking to a steady, execution-focused playbook. That belief gets constant reinforcement from our unique model of selective distribution partnerships with the top independent agents in the nation. Actually, we hosted our yearly President's Club gathering this month, where the top 5% of our agents are invited. During that event, we had a lot of great discussions with our agent partners about our business strategies, operational tactics, and the best ways to work together in this complex marketplace. The response from our agents has been very positive, particularly regarding our efforts to transform underwriting and claims. We've successfully navigated dynamic industry environments in the past, staying sharply focused, acting decisively, and executing with discipline, and we're committed to doing so going forward. Our strategy centers on agility, alignment, and performance, and that gives us confidence we can hit our goals for 2026 and beyond, creating value for shareholders and for the many other stakeholders involved. With that, I'll hand things over to Jeff.
Jeffrey M. Farber
executiveThanks, Jack, and hello everybody. The first-quarter results we posted make us quite happy, and they show how well our team has executed and how varied our operations are. Every area of the company added to these impressive numbers: Personal Lines kept delivering exceptional margins, Specialty profits came in above what we had projected, and Core Commercial recorded steady, sound margins — all of it supported by our investment portfolio, which keeps generating very robust returns. Catastrophe losses accounted for 6.3 points of the combined ratio. We booked 3.1 points of favorable prior year catastrophe development, mostly because 2025 events came in with lower severity. In our view, this shows the benefits from changes to terms and conditions, along with other property management and risk prevention efforts, have been greater than we first assumed. Take hail events, for instance: we have seen reduced severity thanks to higher policy deductibles in both personal and commercial lines. What we are seeing gives us a lot of encouragement and strengthens our confidence that these steps will produce greater stability in underwriting results down the road. Current accident year CAT losses came mainly from a hail and wind event of unusual severity at the start of March, hitting Illinois and Michigan hardest and, to a smaller degree, Winter Storm Fern in January, which affected numerous states nationwide. Combined, those 2 events represented more than half of current year CAT losses. Once claims develop and mature, we will be well positioned to evaluate the favorable effect our underwriting actions deliver. Leaving out catastrophes, our combined ratio came in extremely strong at 85.4%, which is a 2.4 point gain versus the prior year quarter, with loss ratio gains in every segment. The expense ratio for the quarter stood at 30.7%, matching what we expected. We keep taking a careful approach to expenses, matching costs to strategic priorities while making focused investments that support profitable growth ahead; for the full year, we still anticipate an expense ratio of 30.3%, since the advantage of growth leverage leans toward the later portion of the year. First quarter favorable ex-CAT prior year reserve development of $25 million featured favorability in every segment. Within Specialty, favorable prior year reserve development reached $14.2 million, or 3.9 points, with broad favorability across numerous coverages. Within Personal Lines, favorable prior year reserve development reached $9.2 million, or 1.4 points, with favorability in Home and, to a smaller degree, in Auto, driven by property coverages. Within Core Commercial, favorable prior year reserve development reached $1.6 million, or 0.3 points, with small adjustments by line. Our reserve position stays strong and suited to today's uncertain environment. Now I will go into each segment's current accident year results in more detail, beginning with Personal Lines. This business produced an excellent current accident year ex-CAT combined ratio of 83.8% for the first quarter, a 0.7 point improvement from the prior year period. Gains from earned pricing across both Auto and Home, along with favorable frequency, contributed to a 1.1 point betterment in the underlying loss ratio, led by Homeowners. Within that line, we posted an excellent ex-CAT current accident year loss ratio of 46.7%, which is two points better than the same quarter a year ago and ahead of what we had anticipated, aided by the gains from strong earned pricing. We also kept seeing reduced attritional loss frequency, and we partly credit deductible adjustments that result in fewer smaller claims across both CAT and ex-CAT outcomes. For personal auto, our ex-CAT current accident year loss ratio came in at 66.7%, which is 0.2 points better than the comparable quarter last year. Collision frequency continues to look stable, apart from what severe winter weather brought. Personal Lines expanded 2.7% during the first quarter, with PIF unchanged from the prior quarter, marking an improvement versus the fourth quarter of 2025. Our expectation remains that PIF will grow in 2026. Auto and home both posted robust pricing gains in the first quarter, with auto rising 6.7% and home rising 10.8%. Pricing increases for Umbrella also stayed strong, at roughly 19%. Now shifting to our Core Commercial segment. We recorded a current accident year ex-CAT combined ratio of 91.5%, which is a 3.6 point gain over the prior year quarter. The current accident year loss ratio, excluding catastrophes of 58.8%, came in 2.9 points better than the prior year quarter. The first quarter of 2025 had contained some elevated property large losses, whereas large loss performance landed within expectations during the first quarter of 2026. Core Commercial net written premiums rose 4.3% in the quarter, fueled by stronger momentum in both Small Commercial and Middle Market. Small Commercial was up 6.4%, an improvement of more than 1.5 points relative to the fourth quarter of 2025. Middle Market net written premiums climbed 1.5%. Pricing remains healthy and elevated, especially for Commercial Auto and Umbrella. Now on to Specialty. This business kept delivering very strong results, with a current accident year ex-CAT combined ratio of 85.4%. The current accident year loss ratio, excluding catastrophes, stood at 49% for the quarter, which beat our expectations as well as our low 50s target for the segment, thanks to property favorability, while liability stayed in line with expectations. The segment's ongoing outstanding performance and profitability underscore the quality and positioning of our Specialty business. Although growth faced pressure during the quarter, that mirrors our cautious stance and our determination to safeguard the business's strong profitability. We are working relentlessly to accelerate premium growth. Shifting to our recent investment results. Net investment income rose an impressive 19.6% in the quarter, powered by expansion in our asset base from strong earnings, the advantage of higher reinvestment yields, and better partnership income. Our investment portfolio keeps delivering steady returns, supported by disciplined positioning and wide diversification. About 88% of all the assets we've invested sit in cash along with investment-grade fixed income, which speaks to how high-quality our portfolio's makeup is and how comparatively small our remaining exposures happen to be. For our fixed maturity portfolio, the weighted average rating stands at AA-, and 95% of what we hold is investment grade. Earned yields from the fixed maturity portfolio came to 4.42% during the first quarter, compared with 4.08% in the same period last year, and we keep putting money back to work at yields above those on the positions reaching maturity. Duration of the portfolio, leaving cash aside, held fairly steady at about 4.4 years, which lines up with how we approach asset liability alignment over the long term. Now turning to equity and our capital position. Book value per share rose 1% from the prior quarter to $101.86, thanks to robust earnings during the quarter, though that was partly offset by a larger unrealized loss position, share repurchases, and the quarterly dividend. If you set unrealized aside, book value per share climbed 2.8% quarter over quarter. We stayed active with share buybacks, purchasing roughly 503,000 shares for a total of $87 million during the first quarter. On top of that, through April 28th we bought back approximately $14 million in shares. Responsible capital management and putting shareholder value first remain our commitment. For the second quarter, our CAT load should come in at 7.9%. In closing, 2026 got off to an exceptionally strong start for us, and we feel confident about our strong market position as we head into the remainder of the year. Across every area, the company keeps performing well, aided by our diversified business and earnings stream along with our extraordinarily talented team; with that said, we're ready to open up the line for questions. Operator?
Michael Phillips
analystThanks. Morning, everyone. Jack, I want to kick things off with something that, I admit, is a pretty generic subject, but it matters a lot, and I think it might be what sets Hanover apart from other carriers during the next 2 years. Specifically, it's about where the market is going, especially on the commercial side. Let's begin with a response here. Ideally it won't be the response, but it's going to come across as all too familiar. We don't chase the market downward. Margins are our singular focus. Everyone says that. Clearly, I suppose it comes down to degree, but Jack, could you address any structural elements inside Hanover that, if we jump ahead to next year, would give us confidence that Hanover's commercial renewal rate slowdown won't be as severe as what your competitors see?
Jack Roche
executiveYes. Mike, I appreciate the question. You know, I'd begin by pointing out that our business and earnings stream is the most diversified in this company's history. That matters greatly when we confront a marketplace that, in my view, will display many cycles rather than a single overall cycle that hits every business and every geography identically. Being in a spot where each of our major business units and the bulk of our geographies are adding to our profitable growth — that carries power all on its own. Inside Commercial Lines, maintaining a fairly diversified portfolio spanning Small Commercial Middle Market, nine Specialty businesses, once again, extends that enterprise perspective; as you're aware, we operate in the small to lower end of the Middle Market. We hold a solid balance between property and casualty; we have tight alignment with our agency plan. I believe we're especially well served when we take those profit margins and translate them into suitable pricing that doesn't spark much remarketing activity in this fast-moving marketplace. I think what's unique to us is that we've discovered how to earn money in many different places, and we can steer and pull various levers along the way rather than being sort of trapped in a single business segment that's experiencing a down cycle.
Michael Phillips
analystAll right. Yeah, no, I appreciate that, Jack. I think it's a solid narrative. Thanks for the perspective. I suppose if we zero in only on Small Commercial, where someone might contend that over a longer horizon there could be added pressure stemming from technological progress, at least when it comes to how products get distributed, is that even a little bit something you feel you need to weigh?
Jack Roche
executiveWell, we're always thinking not just about how we handle the challenges and opportunities right in front of us, but also about what the longer-term picture will look like. I think, as a few of our stronger rivals have put it, Small Commercial is far more intricate than I believe folks really recognize when it comes to just how split up it is throughout the distribution system, and how you need to have both a sort of point of sale or, you know, portfolio strategy for certain portions of Small Commercial, and how you need a distinct operating model that delivers the right degree of underwriting for, say, the upper end of Small Commercial. On top of that, when you consider Small Specialty and just how much business actually reaches into that more specialized line. I wouldn't claim there's a moat around it, necessarily, but you need to have put in a great deal of investment. You need to have a great deal of history and data regarding where the profitability sits by line of business, by geography, and by business segment. If you handle that well, I believe you can navigate through at least the near-term pressures. As for the longer-term view, we're quite optimistic, because as you're aware, Dick can tell you, we've invested heavily and are enthusiastic about certain transformational opportunities that will take what we do now and, honestly, make us more efficient and more competitive going forward.
Michael Phillips
analystAll right, that's great. I appreciate the remarks, Jack.
Paul Newsome
analystHello, good afternoon—or good morning, depending on where you are. I'm grateful for this call. I was hoping you might elaborate a bit further on how much you earned from the program business. As someone on the outside, it's generally rather difficult to determine precisely what that includes. Are there particular pockets inside those areas—inside programs—by market, by geography, or anything else you find noteworthy that we could observe, something out of the ordinary relative to our expectations, along with pricing issues and shifts in terms and conditions?
Jack Roche
executiveYes. Paul, I'm Jack. Let me offer a few broad observations, and then I'll have Bryan address Hanover Programs. I want to remind you, and everyone else, that we produce program and programmatic business throughout numerous business units within our company. In fact, I doubt any single business lacks at least a certain amount of programmatic business involving individual distributors spanning the different lines and businesses. To be honest, our Hanover Programs operation overall is not as large as the program business we generate throughout the company in other specialized operations. As we stated during our prepared remarks, for the programs within the Hanover Programs segment that we've been addressing in order to boost its profitability, we've reached the profitability we aimed for and have enhanced it significantly; at this point, we're attempting to hold our resources in reserve for what we believe will be the coming set of opportunities. I'd note that we contracted somewhat as a result of adhering to that discipline of ours and declining to accept any substantial new programs. We feel quite confident about how we can eventually turn that into better growth down the road. Bryan, would you like to add to that?
Bryan J. Salvatore
executiveYes. To start with, I believe you captured much of that rather nicely, correct? So what I'd include, I'll simply mention it, okay? The program operation you're likely talking about represents the lesser portion of our overall program portfolio, and that portion in fact did extremely well. As Jack mentioned, we've put a great deal of effort into that Hanover Programs book. It truly is doing well. Honestly, the rates within that segment of the portfolio are pretty robust. We feel quite good about it. You know, what I'd include is that I genuinely believe it matters a lot, this idea of conserving our resources, right? We've completed or are completing a portion of that cleanup effort. You know, I'd say what we observe our agents doing is moving more and more toward this space, correct? So they can manage their book. Given everything we've accomplished, I'd say we feel, you know, truly well-positioned to assist them across various lines within programs, beyond programs. I believe we're well-positioned, and this is a significant area for our agents.
Paul Newsome
analystThat's excellent. So perhaps you could share a few reflections regarding what you mentioned about Commercial Auto along with certain other areas where severity has been problematic. A number of your competitors during this quarter, and previously as well, have truly embraced this issue, really stepping up regarding what is happening. From where you sit, would you say that some of these severity problems are speeding up, or are they simply persisting around the elevated levels that we have witnessed lately?
Jack Roche
executiveYes, I believe I would largely repeat my remarks from the prior quarter's call, which was that in my view these trends are maturing, yet they remain at an extremely elevated point. It is well understood that liability claim severity, be it Commercial Auto, slip, trip, and fall, or other liability claim categories, stands far above what it used to be in earlier times. Since we have moved further past the period of COVID-related court shutdowns, and we have begun observing how those litigation patterns manifest through certain jury and judge awards, it is unmistakably beginning to mature. What I believe you will observe is that various carriers find themselves at differing points depending on their book mix, their reserve position, and the manner in which they have actuarially tackled loss trend analysis, and we feel quite confident about how we have navigated this. Each and every day we rise, you know, keeping our focus on these liability trends since they are elevated. Paul, during this specific quarter, our Commercial Auto results came in rather benign for both the current year and the prior year. That statement does not carry a great deal of informational content, because I believe Commercial Auto across the industry has arrived at, you know, a plateau of rather high severity that all of us are contending with as we manage through it and ensure we obtain substantial rate.
Paul Newsome
analystExcellent. Well done on the quarter. As always, I appreciate the assistance.
Jack Roche
executiveThank you, Paul.
Mike Zaremski
analystThanks. Morning. Let's shift topics over to Personal Lines. When we look at the strong results that keep coming, particularly for your company, but also across the sector, should we anticipate that pricing strength will ease more significantly in line with competitors? Or given that your book is more distinct, and notably regional too, do you plan to maintain pricing considerably above the sector norm? Also, perhaps you could include thoughts on how retention factors into that. Appreciate it.
Jack Roche
executiveYes, Mike, I'll have Dick address particular details regarding the Personal Lines segment, naturally, though I believe your description of where we operate and what sets us apart matters greatly to the response; within the 20 states where we opt to conduct business through the IA channel, we are the top account writer, which provides us genuine durability, I'd say; nevertheless, we operate in a competitive industry. Our account approach on its own, I'd argue, is currently delivering enormous benefits, since without question, in the direct channel and even among captives, substantial pricing strain is emerging, especially for auto. Including home within what we offer plays a significant role in how we set ourselves apart, while simultaneously avoiding that purely auto-focused pricing arena.
Dick Lavey
executiveOkay, Jack, you made a lot of really good points there. I just want to emphasize once more that we're sticking to our strategy, right? The regions we do business in and the types of customers we go after — we're confident that's the way we'll keep outperforming the market, and I think it becomes even more solid when competition gets tougher. The whole picture — 90%, the other details — you know, 76% of them share one effective date, and that gives us efficiencies because two or more policies renew on that same day. I want to mention one more thing: our state management setup is excellent. In each state, it essentially works like a co-CEO working together with a field leader, pushing those agency relationships right down to the desk level. Thanks to the analytic tools and methods we've built up over time, we've been able to stay ahead of where things are heading and remain extremely sharp about beating the competition in the market. We examine new business by way of the comparators and turn our dials fast, and we dig deep into how customers act when it comes to renewals — especially price elasticity — making certain we set renewal pricing the right way so we hold onto and keep our strongest accounts. We've spent time sharpening our skills and getting really precise, and we have a clear sense of our own identity. We remain committed to our approach, and sure, we're not shielded from everything, but we believe we can beat the competition — especially as we keep moving toward the higher end of the market with greater coverage A. Our Prestige offering is doing incredibly well, and that, you know, makes us feel good about what's ahead.
Mike Zaremski
analystAll right, excellent. Let's perhaps move over to the truly strong numbers in Specialty as well. When we look at the core loss ratio, it keeps tending to come in under the low fifties, which is wonderful. I'm just wondering, have there been any particular items you'd like to flag that have come in ahead of what was anticipated and that we ought to simply keep in mind going forward?
Bryan J. Salvatore
executiveYes.
Jack Roche
executivePlease continue, Bryan.
Bryan J. Salvatore
executiveYes. Well, honestly, I feel very good about how nearly every one of our portfolio's holdings has done. Like I mentioned, essentially the entire portfolio, correct? Across all our business lines, the core loss ratios are genuinely robust. The earnings we produced came from many places at once. I'm not sure I could point to one particular segment. What I'd likely emphasize is that from a profit standpoint, property remains extremely solid. Once more, truly excellent profitability throughout this portfolio. A portion of that resulted from hard effort in certain areas of the portfolio, a great deal of discipline in how we price and manage the portfolio. Past that, I wouldn't single out any segment. I'd simply say genuinely strong, broad-based profit.
Jack Roche
executiveMike, one more thing I'd mention is that operating mostly on the retail agency side of that operation, spread across a number of different businesses, is a real advantage — it lets us adjust as market cycles shift. Take Management liability, which we brought up last quarter: we went through a few quarters with some pressure on pricing, and we kept our book of business intact while dialing back how fast we were growing. Once 2025 wrapped up and we moved into 2026, we could push growth back up, since we'd preserved that profitability and discipline around pricing began returning to the business. That, I think, is what makes the more specialized businesses work. Can you sustain that core profitability? Do you have several areas where you can bob and weave, so you aren't stuck in a single business that turns out to be, well, too cyclical?
Bryan J. Salvatore
executiveLet me jump in very briefly to build on what you said earlier: paying attention to the small and midsize business segment is clearly a plus for us, particularly at this moment.
Mike Zaremski
analystAs a fast follow-up, purely for background, you keep bringing up Marine. Perhaps you could — I think whenever many of us hear Marine, what comes to mind is the more syndicated, big-account market, the Lloyd's of London style of operation. Could you just offer us a brief sense of how a standard Marine account appears?
Bryan J. Salvatore
executiveYeah. There's a great deal within Marine. It contains a large variety of product lines, correct? Let me return to my earlier point. Even in that area, our attention goes to the Middle Market down into the smaller segment. The overwhelming share of our business measured by PIF consists of smaller accounts, and much of that involves Builders Risk, contractors equipment, which people would term Inland Marine. Another point I'd make, regarding what is commonly labeled Ocean Marine, our book, in my view, doesn't resemble many others you may have in mind, correct? We avoid writing much hull coverage; instead we write marinas, we write brown water business, lines that have historically performed better. We're extremely lucky, given the agent relationships we have, that we've genuinely established one of the bigger marine operations in this Inland Marine area and in what I consider lower severity Ocean Marine.
Mike Zaremski
analystUnderstood. Yeah, the domestic part — that was the clarification I'd been missing. I appreciate it. Thanks.
Jing Li
analystGood morning. Jing here, filling in for Meyer. Thanks for taking my question. My first one concerns Specialty. Just to build on that. We're noticing some slowing in pricing this quarter. I'm curious about what's behind it. You also said Specialty growth will accelerate from here. Given the softening in overall Specialty pricing, which areas are you targeting? Thanks.
Bryan J. Salvatore
executiveThank you. The first thing I'd point out, I think, is that our approach to pricing is highly deliberate, correct? You know, it's worth keeping in mind, and I think this connects somewhat to the second part of what you asked, right? Ours is a highly diversified portfolio. Nine businesses, 19 distinct product areas, all aimed at the small to middle market space, and they aren't all moving along that identical path, right? We encountered pricing pressure in property, among our most profitable areas, and we're handling it very carefully. Let me return to something Jack mentioned earlier regarding Management liability. Across our businesses, we have a history of recognizing the profit margin, grasping that we must compete, yet doing so in a measured and deliberate manner, at times giving up near-term growth so that we're well-positioned to grow going forward. That's, that's how we're approaching, you know, pricing in this environment. I do see the ability to keep driving growth in the areas where we had success. I think that was the other part of what you asked. Management liability, Surety, E&S, our Specialty General Liability. I'd add that, you know, we see growth increasing in areas such as Marine and Professional liability too.
Jack Roche
executiveJing, our expectation going into Q1 2020 was that it would mark the year's weakest quarter for growth, and when you pair that with Bryan's optimism across the different areas, it leaves us feeling confident that Specialty can accelerate its growth from this point forward.
Jing Li
analystUnderstood. That's quite useful. Thanks. For my next one, it's just a brief thing. Are there any reserve shifts sitting beneath the casualty lines?
Jeffrey M. Farber
executiveJing, I'm not really certain what the right response would be. As you know, each and every quarter, we review the whole book, so adjustments to our total reserves are something we're constantly making. If what you're asking about is prior year development, then specifically within core casualty, there was basically nothing, you know, hardly any activity across the individual lines of business.
Jing Li
analystGotcha. Thank you.
Jack Roche
executiveThank you, Jing.
Roland Meyer
analystHi there, and good morning. I'd like to ask briefly about the CAT PYD — did that come from some particular examination of the way you'd recorded the business, or are you still keeping a bit of caution regarding the underwriting adjustments in Personal Lines?
Jack Roche
executiveEvery month, without exception, we review our CAT reserves, and just like we did at the close of March, during April we examined the 24 and 25 reserves; naturally, the last thing we want is to come up short, so our approach to reviewing them is a prudent one. The degree of severity genuinely caught us off guard, and to a smaller degree the frequency, across both Personal Lines and commercial lines — especially from 2025 events — had come off better than what we'd initially projected. It amounted to fewer large losses in commercial lines, and within Personal Lines, it was, as you know, reduced severity. Across both Personal Lines and commercial lines, the terms and conditions are producing a highly significant effect. As for caution, being conservative is always our aim, yet I wouldn't expect the same magnitude of favorable development we saw in this specific quarter to happen again.
Roland Meyer
analystThanks. That's really useful. On that point, I'm curious — since the terms and conditions are turning out better than what you'd expected before, does that affect the pace at which you'd like to expand the homeowners operation or the Personal Lines PIF?
Jack Roche
executiveJack here. My hope is that down the road the answer will be yes. We'll stay prudent, but as you know, the bright side of dealing with some CAT activity, especially in parts of our footprint where we have deeper penetration, is that it genuinely lets us refine how we assess the effectiveness of those terms and conditions, how we're setting prices for them, and what effect that's having on our property aggregations. At this moment, just as we mentioned in our prepared remarks, we aren't implementing significant changes, though I'd be let down if in time none of that wound up producing the right degree of earnings volatility, along with the capacity to expand the business further than what we've been ready to do across the past couple of years.
Roland Meyer
analystThat's really useful. Thanks a lot.
Bob Huang
analystHello, good morning. I believe nearly all my questions have been covered, though there's one point I'd like to dig into a bit more. When we consider the wider advances happening in technology, plenty of businesses have talked about their readiness and their ambitions regarding AI and innovation. I'm just wondering — in this world that keeps becoming more driven by tech, where do you see yourselves fitting in competitively, and how do you expect the competitive landscape to change as a result of technology?
Jack Roche
executiveBob, I appreciate that question. This is a hugely important moment for us to speak to that with the folks who invest in us. I'm genuinely enthusiastic about how this organization is embracing what technology and AI are bringing to the table. You probably noticed a few quarters back that we gave Dick Lavey some extra duties in this space, to ensure those innovations stayed business-led alongside our tech teams. We're seeing a tremendous amount of progress, and we're eager to share more down the road about the difference we think we can deliver through those efforts. We'll probably do so later this year, when we refresh our five-year forecast, since the one we have now wraps up at the close of 2026. Dick, would you like to share your perspective on the momentum we're generating?
Dick Lavey
executiveOkay, that sounds good. I believe Jack did an excellent job in his prepared remarks pointing out what we're up to. Maybe I'll offer a few high-level thoughts, then share a couple of illustrations to bring it to life, and finish with what I think is a direct answer to your question regarding how competitiveness is affected. It's now been more than 12 months since I became COO and assumed the duty of assisting our company in shaping its approach to broad transformation, as well as handling the most important priorities that we think will deliver benefit realization, doing so alongside Will Lee, our CIO, with a strong emphasis on expanding our company, correct? To generate additional growth and efficiency, I've been collaborating closely with business and functional leaders, while also devoting time externally—responding to your question—to learn about technology, vendors, and what competitors are doing. On the whole, as I take all of that in, I'd say we feel fantastic about where we stand; we are absolutely in the mix with what others are taking on. As Jack mentioned, and you've also heard me say this previously, we're addressing the shared activities throughout our value chain in underwriting, claims, and operations. Two brief illustrations. In the underwriting area—likely the one with the greatest impact, along with claims—this ingestion and triage agent will assist us in receiving, codifying, and synthesizing submissions and delivering them to the proper individual with the proper expertise as quickly as possible, with a head start on insights. Honestly, that will be among the largest benefits to emerge from this transformation effort. E&S is the first business set to gain from that ingestion and triage agent, which is truly well suited to this for efficiency. We received 70,000 submissions in E&S during the prior year, some of which, honestly, represent lost opportunity due to underwriter capacity. These tools give us underwriter capacity and effectiveness, helping them work through the stacks of submissions and then triaging them, concentrating on the more promising activities. Additional businesses are also in progress: Middle Market, Small Commercial, Marine. On the claims side, there's an AI agent—we have agents designed to help us synthesize highly complex contracts, medical records, and claims files, essentially hunting for and summarizing particular answers to essential questions concerning indemnity clauses, named parties, limits, risk transfer provisions, and similar items. These documents may run 100 to 300 pages. Tasks that once required hours now require minutes. You can picture the value to the adjusters from that. Considerable work is being done on medical records, seeking severity, fraud, and settlement insights, that sort of thing. Speed, accuracy, effectiveness. We are extremely bullish about the benefits this delivers. What matters a lot here is that we're building everything with a modular, Lego-block style architecture, so that when we create these agents, we can reuse them in many different areas. Now, stepping back from that to how you're posing this question — will it boost competitiveness? My view is that if you don't put money into these, you'll be left behind. Right? Yes, those who have put money in will be more competitive, since they'll be able to pursue the better opportunities faster and with greater precision. If you aren't playing that game, you'll be left behind. We feel confident and at ease that we're right in the middle of it.
Mike Zaremski
analystHi, thank you. I wanted to ask a brief follow-up regarding the competitive landscape, perhaps to draw out a few trends around pricing power. As you know, Jack, I believe you said that in the social inflation lines, pricing is still healthy and elevated. I think we noticed that the acceleration halted when it came to rising prices—you know, increases in pricing—in a number of those lines toward the end of last year, and maybe they're easing somewhat from healthy levels, and a few of your rivals have mentioned that pricing is sort of speeding up again just a little. I'm just wondering what you're observing in those lines. Is it roughly stable? Leaning upward? Leaning downward? Thank you.
Jack Roche
executiveYes, broadly speaking, I'd say—I think Jeff touched on this somewhat—that we are exercising genuine discipline and achieving success, or we are demonstrating genuine discipline and achieving success, in the liability lines that are the most exposed and where we see the effect of legal system abuse. Commercial Auto—we remain extremely, extremely disciplined on the general liability lines most exposed to slip, trip, and fall kinds of activity. I'd say Umbrella—not only within commercial lines, but within Personal Lines as well—we are obtaining truly strong pricing. In my view, the market is acting quite rationally. Although a portion of the pricing strain the industry is experiencing in property, you know, seems to be growing more intense, our view is that it is most exposed at the larger end of the property cycle. For the most part, we are an account writer in the small and middle market segment. We can sort of consider account pricing and avoid becoming too fixated on pricing by each individual line of business. I hope that responds to your question.
Mike Zaremski
analystOkay. Thank you.
Jack Roche
executiveThanks, Mike.
Oksana Lukasheva
executiveThanks to all of you for joining us on today's call, and we can't wait to speak with you again in the next quarter.
Operator
operatorThis concludes our call. We appreciate your participation in today's presentation. You are free to disconnect at this time.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete The Hanover Insurance Group, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to The Hanover Insurance Group, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in The Hanover Insurance Group, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.