Synchrony Financial (SYF) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

July 17, 2024

New York Stock Exchange US Financials Consumer Finance earnings 57 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Kathryn Miller

executive
#1

Thanks, and hello to all of you on this morning's call. It's a pleasure to have you join our discussion of the quarter's results. Alongside the press release issued today, we've also made available a presentation that walks through the subjects we intend to cover on this call. You can find the press release, the in-depth financial schedules, and the presentation on our site, synchronyfinancial.com. To reach this material, simply navigate to the Investor Relations portion of the site. Prior to beginning, I'd like to remind everyone that forward-looking statements will be part of what we say today; such statements carry risks and uncertainty, and outcomes may diverge materially from what is stated. The elements that could lead outcomes to diverge materially are listed in our SEC filings, which you can access on our site. Throughout this call, non-GAAP financial measures will come up as we discuss how the company performed. A reconciliation linking those measures to GAAP financial measures appears in our materials for today's call. Lastly, Synchrony Financial bears no responsibility for, and neither edits nor guarantees the accuracy of, earnings teleconference transcripts that third parties provide. Webcasts that are authorized exist solely on our site. Joining us on the call this morning are Brian Doubles, Synchrony's President and Chief Executive Officer, and Brian Wenzel, Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer. At this point, I'll hand the call over to Brian Doubles.

Brian Doubles

executive
#2

Thanks, Kathryn, and hello everyone on this call. For the second quarter, Synchrony delivered strong performance, with net earnings of $643 million, or $1.55 per diluted share, plus a 2.2% return on average assets and a 20.2% return on tangible common equity. These figures reflect how powerful our differentiated business model is. By continuing to leverage our varied portfolio of products and sales channels, our rigorous approach to credit underwriting and management, and cutting-edge digital tools, we can keep moving forward on our strategic goals and generate lasting, risk-adjusted growth and returns over time. During Q2, customer interest in what Synchrony offers—both its products and its value propositions—remained robust. We opened 5.1 million new accounts, lifted average active accounts by 2%, generated $47 billion in purchase volume, and finished with receivables growth of 8% compared with a year earlier. Our proprietary data and analytics, combined with adaptable financing options and a dynamic technology platform, have been central to how we've performed as market conditions shifted, particularly as we strive to serve our customers and partners in a responsible way. Even though our credit performance relative to pre-pandemic benchmarks has outpaced much of the industry up to now, we've leveraged those advantages to take action inside our portfolio in any areas where we saw indications of elevated default risk. Those credit measures, combined with a consumer who is being more deliberate about spending, produced slower growth in new accounts and purchase volume during the second quarter, but they've also improved our delinquency trends as of late and should strengthen the credit direction of our portfolio in 2024 and afterward. Looking at the platform level, purchase volume and receivables patterns stayed mostly steady throughout the second quarter. When you look at purchase volume, the range was an increase of 2% to a decline of 3% versus the prior-year period, which mostly comes down to consumers spending less on higher-priced goods — furniture, jewelry, and vision are good examples — along with the impact of the credit actions we took. Meanwhile, receivables were up across the platforms, with growth between 6% and 15% compared with a year ago, primarily because payment rates have moderated. For the quarter, dual and co-branded cards made up 42% of total purchase volume and were up 2%. Because our offerings are broadly useful and our value propositions are compelling, customers make purchases across many categories, industries, and products, and Synchrony's out-of-partner spend gives us a deeper read on recent customer trends. When it comes to discretionary buying, our customers are still careful — particularly in bigger-ticket areas like home furnishings, travel, and entertainment. At restaurants, though, they're opening their wallets more, and they continue to spend at the pharmacy and on health and wellness needs, which along with other essentials is driving broader growth in non-discretionary purchases. That said, per-transaction spending is down somewhat for most categories and credit grades — average transaction values dropped roughly 2% versus a year ago. During Q2, the only credit segment that saw average ticket values rise was our top tier. Still, customers in every credit grade are making more transactions, and that has largely made up for the impact of smaller transaction values. Taking everything into account, we see these spending patterns as suitable and in line with the payment rate normalization that started within our portfolio during 2023 and has carried on ever since. Yet across the initial 6 months of 2024, the speed of this payment rate moderation has slowed down among credit grades. Based on the outside deposit data we track, savings balances remain comparatively steady relative to the swift tapering seen through the middle of last year. Considered as a whole, we think these spending, payment, and savings patterns back our belief that consumers are making sound choices to actively manage their cash flows. The way these trends line up with the results of our credit measures makes us optimistic that Synchrony's net charge-off rate should land below first-half levels once we get into the back half of this year. We continue to monitor how consumers are doing, how our portfolio's credit metrics are behaving, and conditions across the broader industry, and at the same time Synchrony is leveraging its own data-driven knowledge and underwriting skill to position the company for durable, risk-adjusted expansion over the long term. During Q2, we added or renewed more than 15 partners. That includes expanding and extending our program with Verizon, as well as bringing Virgin Red on board. Our partnership with Verizon continues to excite us, and we see a real opportunity to create the greatest possible value for customers when they buy at Verizon. In addition, we take pride in being the sole issuer of Virgin Red's multi-category travel card — the Virgin Red Rewards World Elite Mastercard, a first of its kind — which will connect members across the entire Virgin family, covering flights, cruises, hotels, and experiences, through points with no expiration. People who hold the Virgin Red Rewards card are going to collect Virgin points whenever they use it, and those points can be redeemed for all sorts of gifts and rewards, plus they get a top-notch digital journey from the moment they apply through ongoing account servicing. As Synchrony continues widening its footprint and getting better results for customers and partners alike, the company is bringing in partnerships focused on strategy and technology to deliver digital experiences that feel even more seamless. Synchrony chooses to partner with second-look financing providers in a targeted way, which improves how customers feel about their experience and strengthens ties with partners. Just recently, Synchrony shared news of a relationship that has grown, one that relies on a completely integrated offering covering the entire apply-and-buy journey for customers at every point of sale. Synchrony is going to hold ownership of the point-of-sale platform, and it will link up with the second-source provider in a manner that feels seamless both to the partner and to the customer filling out an application; through this collaboration, our innovative technology and data will be used to responsibly broaden credit access for more consumers, while at the same time generating stronger loyalty and sales for the numerous small businesses, healthcare providers, and retail partners we serve. In addition, Synchrony kicked off our partnership with Installation Made Easy, a top enterprise software and services company that backs retail-based home improvement programs. Through this collaboration, people holding Floor & Decor cards will be able to finance, with a single simplified process, both the supplies and the installation work needed for projects improving their homes, using the credit card issued by Synchrony. We are eager about the chance we perceive to reinforce where we stand within the home improvement marketplace, and our intention is to grow this offering to more retailers as time goes on. Therefore, regardless of whether it happens via ongoing growth of our distribution networks, the introduction and renewal of programs covering the majority of consumer spending categories, or better point-of-sale capabilities, Synchrony is putting to work our proprietary data and analytics, our wide-ranging product suite, and our innovative technology in order to generate increased access, flexibility, and utility for our customers as well as our partners. Having said that, I will now hand the call to Brian so he can go over our financial performance in more detail.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#3

Brian, thanks, and good morning to all. Synchrony's Q2 results yet again demonstrate the resilience of our distinctive business model in a shifting landscape. People are carefully handling their spending and cash flow, and the impact of the credit measures we've taken is beginning to mature, though our attention remains on generating sustainable growth that's adjusted for risk. Turning to our financials: loan receivables finished the second quarter at $102 billion, a 7.9% increase, aided by a payment rate that dropped by about 80 basis points and by gains in every one of our sales platforms. Net revenue climbed 13% to $3.7 billion, driven by greater interest and fees, a reduced RSA, and more other income. Net interest income climbed 7%, reaching $4.4 billion. That came as interest and fees expanded 10%, largely because average loan receivables grew. A 14 basis point improvement in our loan receivable yield was supported by repricing moves on products and a reduced payment rate, though it was partially counterbalanced by larger reversals tied to rising net charge-offs. In the second quarter, RSAs totaled $810 million, equaling 3.21% of average loan receivables — a $77 million decline from a year earlier, which stemmed from elevated net charge-offs and was partly offset by stronger net interest income. Higher other income mainly came from a $51 million gain on exchanging our Visa Class B-1 shares, along with the early fee-related effects of our product pricing and policy changes, known as PPPCs. The Pets Best divestiture's effect worked against those gains to some degree. We saw the provision for credit losses climb to $1.7 billion, a move attributable to greater net charge-offs along with a $70 million addition to reserves. Turning to other expenses, these rose 1% to reach $1.2 billion. Several factors pushed this higher: our spending on technology, costs incurred preparing for the late fee rule change, and servicing expenses tied to businesses we recently acquired. Working against those increases were operational losses as well as cost discipline stemming from reduced employee and marketing spending. Within those preparatory costs for the late fee rule changes, $23 million in incremental expenses came from carrying out our PPPCs and from implementing the rule itself, assuming it takes effect. Despite those added expenses, our efficiency ratio at Synchrony came in at 31.7% during Q2 — roughly 380 basis points better than the same period a year ago. All told, net earnings reached $643 million, equal to $1.55 per diluted share. That translated into a 2.2% return on average assets and a 20.2% return on tangible common equity. Turning to slide nine, I'll walk through the main credit trends. When the quarter closed, our 30-plus delinquency rate stood at 4.47%, compared with 3.84% a year earlier — 19 basis points higher than the average we saw across the second quarters of 2017 through 2019. For the 90-plus delinquency rate, we came in at 2.19%. That compares with 1.77% a year ago, and it's 18 basis points above the average we saw historically across the second quarters of 2017 to 2019. Net charge-offs for the second quarter were 6.42%, versus 4.75% in the same period last year, putting us 62 basis points above that same historical second-quarter average from 2017 through 2019. When we look at our credit loss allowance as a share of loan receivables, it was 10.74% — 2 basis points above the 10.72% we had in the first quarter. Growth in loan receivables was the main factor behind the reserve build we recorded during the period. On slide 10, you can see that the credit actions we have implemented so far are helping our delinquency trajectory improve, since the pace of year-over-year growth keeps slowing down; we will keep watching our portfolio performance closely along with broader industry credit trends, given the consumer we share, and we will take further credit actions when needed. Although in the near term these actions are slowing growth in new accounts and purchase volume, we anticipate they will leave our portfolio better positioned as we close out 2024, and bolster our capacity to achieve our targeted risk-adjusted returns over the long run. Now on slide 11, Synchrony's funding, capital, and liquidity continue to be a source of strength. During this quarter, we saw a rise in direct deposits because customers reacted well to the attractive products we offer, and at the same time we reduced our brokered deposits. When the quarter closed, deposits represented 84% of all our funding, with secured debt and unsecured debt each making up 8% of the total. Our liquid assets plus undrawn credit facilities came to $23 billion, which is $3.6 billion more than a year ago, and that amounted to 19.1% of total assets — a gain of 124 basis points over last year. Turning now to capital ratios: keep in mind that we made the decision to use the CECL transition rules that the joint federal banking agencies put out. Synchrony is going to make one last transitional change to its regulatory capital metrics, and that will be roughly 50 basis points, happening in January 2025. When it comes to CECL, the effects are already showing up in both our income statement and our balance sheet. Because of the CECL transition rules, we closed out the second quarter with a CET1 ratio of 12.6%, and that's 20 basis points under the 12.8% we had a year ago. As for our Tier One capital ratio, it came in at 13.8%, which is 20 basis points above where it was last year. Our total capital ratio went up 10 basis points, reaching 15.8%. And our Tier One capital plus reserves ratio, measured on a fully phased-in basis, moved up to 23.9%, compared with 22.8% a year earlier. During Q2, we gave back $400 million to shareholders. That breaks down as $300 million through buybacks and $100 million paid out as dividends on common stock. When the quarter closed, $1 billion remained available under the authorization for repurchasing shares, which runs through June 30th, 2025. Synchrony remains in a strong position to keep returning capital to shareholders, in line with what our business results, market conditions, regulatory restrictions, and capital plan dictate. Taking all of this together, Synchrony's Q2 results came in mostly as we had anticipated. Our attention remains on making the correct moves so the business is positioned for future years. That covers our capacity to hit the loss rate we target over the long term, which sits between 5.5% and 6%, along with an average return on assets of no less than 2.5% when averaged across time. We've been monitoring our performance carefully and have put reasonable credit steps in place to push these aims forward. To prepare for the late fee regulation that's coming and to respond to its operational impact as fast as possible, Synchrony has wrapped up the first phase of our PPPCs. The majority of these steps will start taking effect during the latter six months of 2024, and we will keep monitoring how they affect our customers, partners, and portfolio financially and operationally so we can decide, together with our partners, if any adjustments to our approaches are needed to reach the goal we share. As a reminder, particularly regarding the structure surrounding the upcoming late fee rules and our PPPCs, uncertainty persists about when the late fee litigation filed in March will be resolved and what its result will be, about possible shifts in consumer behavior stemming from the late fee rule changes, and about any possible shifts in consumer behavior reacting to the PPPCs we put in place because of the new rule. How things actually turn out and perform in relation to these uncertainties might affect our outlook; with that structure in mind, let's move to the outlook for the latter six months of 2024. We anticipate that consumers will keep managing their cash flows and spending, which, combined with our credit measures, ought to produce purchase volume that is flat to down by a low single-digit percentage; we still anticipate that payment rates will moderate, which, combined with what we expect for purchase volume, ought to help generate more moderate growth in loan receivables during the latter half. Setting aside the effect of putting the late fee rule into practice, we anticipate that net interest income and other income will grow progressively in the third and fourth quarters once our PPPCs take effect. From a credit standpoint, delinquency ought to keep moving in line with seasonality or better; we anticipate that our net charge-off rate will be lower during the latter six months of this year than during the first six months. Our reserve coverage ratio when 2024 ends is anticipated to be broadly consistent with our reserve rate at the close of 2023. RSA will keep matching program and company performance. And last, we anticipate that other expenses will move in line with the first half average measured in dollars. Once you put these elements together and factor in the effect of the fee rule, assuming it takes effect on October 1st, 2024, together with the different offsets from putting our PPPCs in place and a gain of $1.96 per share from selling our Pets Best business in 1Q 2024, Synchrony anticipates delivering fully diluted earnings per share of between $7.60 and $7.80 for the entire year. This consolidated and updated EPS range sits at the upper end of our earlier guidance and shows Synchrony's commitment to producing optimized results for our numerous stakeholders, among them strong risk-adjusted returns for our shareholders. I will now hand the call back to Brian for his closing thoughts.

Brian Doubles

executive
#4

Appreciate that, Brian. In a shifting landscape, Synchrony keeps performing at an elevated standard. By drawing on our size, our analytics and credit management instruments, our sophisticated digital tools, and our extensive lending know-how, we stay agile and quick to respond, all while delivering even stronger experiences and added value to the customers, partners, providers, and small businesses we serve; we reliably produce impressive outcomes for our numerous stakeholders, and that traction is drawing in fresh and expanding current possibilities for ongoing risk-adjusted growth, further positioning Synchrony at the center of American commerce. Having said that, I'll hand the call back to Kathryn so we can begin the Q&A.

Kathryn Miller

executive
#5

That wraps up the remarks we had prepared. At this point we're going to move into the Q&A portion. To give as many of you a chance as we can, I'd ask those participating to keep it to one main question plus one follow-up. Should you have further questions, our Investor Relations team will be around once the call ends. Operator, go ahead and open the Q&A.

Mihir Bhatia

analyst
#6

Morning, and thanks for taking my question. I'd like to begin with the state of the consumer. From what you're saying, it seems like the consumer is entering a bit softer than perhaps you'd expected — purchase volume is coming in lower and the reserve rate is somewhat higher. First off, is that an accurate way to put it? And if it is, could you talk about what other shifts that's causing? Does this mean you need to tighten underwriting? Are you still tightening underwriting? Is it happening broadly? Is it more a matter of making small adjustments? How are you viewing the consumer as we head into, say, the back-to-school period, and I'm just trying to get a handle on your take regarding consumer health?

Brian Doubles

executive
#7

Yeah. Yeah, no, I appreciate the question. I'd say, well, overall, when you look at the aggregate, the consumer remains in fairly good shape. The trends we're observing look quite similar throughout the industry. Clearly, the labor market is strong, and that's certainly a help. So far, most of the indicators are broadly consistent with what we thought we'd see. That said, when you dig into the portfolio, there are definitely some variations too, when you examine different customer cohorts. The more affluent, higher income segments continue to spend. You know, they aren't really affected as much by inflation. At the other end of the spectrum, you're beginning to see the lower income consumer reduce spending somewhat. They're shifting toward non-discretionary categories. So it's evident that, you know, they're experiencing the impact of inflation, and they're sticking to a budget. And so even though you're seeing that effect, you know, on purchase volume a bit, and new accounts, we actually view that as a positive from a credit standpoint. You know, people are showing discipline. That's a good thing; we don't see, you know, we don't see people taking on too much, you know, so they're controlling their spending and their cash flows, which once again, I think, is a positive from a credit standpoint.

Mihir Bhatia

analyst
#8

Okay, so perhaps remaining on the topic of credit, specifically regarding the guidance on reserve rate, it has shifted, and I believe you're now indicating that by the end of 2024 it will match 2023. Previously, I thought it was slightly favorable compared to 2023. That being said, you did point out, and we can see it in the data, correct? The delinquency rate is moving toward or even surpassing typical seasonal patterns. Were you anticipating greater enhancements than what materialized? I'm simply attempting to grasp what's causing the elevated forecast for the reserve rate, and whether that suggests net charge-offs for 2025 will resemble those in 2024.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#9

Yes, I appreciate the question, Mihir. When we started this year, I believe everybody held a view about the trajectory of the economy, the possible direction of inflation, and the likelihood that interest rates would decline, correct? As Brian noted, the consumer is coping, but the more time they spend dealing with elevated expenses, especially those in the lower to middle income brackets, that creates varying risks. As we find ourselves here midway through the year, we had hoped for, likely, more significant advancement toward the inflation goal, despite our awareness that it was persistent, and we had hoped for — even though we initially expected three rate cuts, or rather rate — excuse me, rate reductions in the latter half of the year, now we're down to just one. So I believe circumstances have been delayed somewhat; therefore, we are simply exercising a bit more prudence regarding our outlook on the macroeconomic environment ahead, until we observe evidence that inflation is genuinely overcoming some of that persistence, and you begin to see relief for those consumers. Thus, I don't view it as a drastically altered stance. It's merely somewhat more cautious in how you approach your quantitative reserves as opposed to your qualitative reserves.

Mihir Bhatia

analyst
#10

All right. I appreciate you letting me ask something.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#11

Sure thing, Mihir.

Terry Ma

analyst
#12

Hello, and thank you. Good morning. So, I suppose, given how your PPPCs have been rolled out, would $650 million to $700 million still be roughly the correct range to consider for the back half? And next, could you somehow put a number on how that range would shift should the cap on late fees fail to take effect during this year?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#13

Yes, I appreciate that question, Terry. Let me begin with the point you raised at the end. As things stand right now, there is still ongoing activity in the courts of Texas, and just as Brian said, and I said during our remarks, that remains unclear. Therefore, our current best estimate is an implementation date of October 1. And unless we obtain a more conclusive picture about whether that rule takes effect on that day or on another day, we truly lack any fresh information concerning the consequences and the effect should it not come into force. So once more, when we gain better certainty about when implementation will occur, we will absolutely return to this. As for what the PPPCs do, we issued revised guidance today. Again, should you take the midpoint for both the core and the late fee, assuming an October 1 implementation date, and then add Pets Best, you arrive at the midpoint to the high end of the range on an EPS basis, which ought to give you a sense of how we view both the core business and the steps we are taking concerning the possible change to late fees.

Terry Ma

analyst
#14

Understood. Alright, that helps. Then regarding the RSA, what's the right way to approach it? How will it move during the back half, given that you're once again beginning to roll in?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#15

Yes, Terry, one way to frame it is to consider the components that will pass through. Clearly, as we said, the loss rate for the latter six months is going to come in below that of the first six months, so that clearly pushes the RSA percentage upward. Certainly, I believe during Q3, you'll observe that as certain PPPC measures take effect, that will drive the RSA higher. Then when that reverses in Q4, again, if we assume an October 1 start date for late fees, that kicks in. After that, I think it will simply move alongside NII growth, which should be somewhat favorable given marginally reduced purchase volume. There will be pluses and minuses, with some generating headwinds and others generating tailwinds.

Terry Ma

analyst
#16

Yep. Got it. Thank you.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#17

Thanks, Terry.

Mark DeVries

analyst
#18

Yeah, thanks. So I realize there are plenty of shifting components when it comes to NIM across the latter six months, particularly with certain PPPCs being put into place and the possible introduction of the late fee effect; but Brian, could you perhaps simply provide us with some idea of what those shifting components look like and what your expectations might be regarding NIM over the second half of the year?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#19

Absolutely. I appreciate that question, Mark. Let me lay out how I view the various dynamics that need to be factored in. First, as we previously discussed, with net charge-offs declining in the latter six months compared to the initial six months, there's an upside for the net interest margin. That's in relation to reduced reversals. Therefore, that's a favorable impact on the net interest margin. When examining the net funding cost — meaning interest expense plus investment income — it will likely stay roughly level through the latter half of the year. You'll see gains, and there will be an advantage for the net interest margin tied to the composition between average loan receivables and average interest-earning assets. So that's a plus for NIM. You'll also see, and it ought to show up during the third quarter, certain PPPC measures that affect yield; so once more, certain items that were purely tied to APR, some connected to practice, how interest got calculated, and a bit involving promotional fees that come into effect. And you should observe, again, ideally some modest upside on the interest and fee line. So on the whole, this ought to be an improving trajectory from where we are now as we head into the latter portion of the year.

Mark DeVries

analyst
#20

All right, that clears things up. And regarding PPPC actions, is there anything you're still considering that hasn't been implemented yet, and you're holding off either to observe consumer behavior or until the late fee rule changes actually take effect?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#21

So, regarding what our organization has experienced — you know, that initial round we've already acted on consists of items we've thoroughly reviewed on our own and alongside our partners, meaning those are completely done. Other items further out are likely somewhat more customized. We're still assessing certain things related to how products are configured, plus additional product varieties aimed at various segments within the portfolio. That stuff isn't really part of the first fix, though it could be something we respond with eventually — yet it wasn't really essential for us in pursuing the objective of reaching ROA neutrality while maintaining the same sales volume.

Mark DeVries

analyst
#22

Understood. Appreciate it.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#23

Thank you, Mark. Enjoy the rest of your day.

Mark DeVries

analyst
#24

Thanks.

Moshe Orenbuch

analyst
#25

Great, thanks. So picking up where we left off on those pricing adjustments — I realize it's still early days, but have you noticed any sort of effects on the consumer side that you're able to observe or discuss? Whether favorable or unfavorable, stemming from the pricing changes you've implemented?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#26

Yes. Moshe, I appreciate the question. We've got a comprehensive monitoring dashboard set up that tracks quite a few different metrics, Moshe. It begins with purchase active rate, sales per account. As you might expect, it covers closure rates, voluntary closure rates. It covers call volume, complaint volume, all kinds of different metrics that we'd examine in relation to this. I believe it's crucial to grasp why the first wave is now finished, since we only have the CITs that we locked in during December, with a full quarter behind them. Whenever we review that dashboard as a whole, it's broadly consistent with what we anticipated. As we move into the third quarter, I think we'll gain a broader picture concerning consumers' adoption of it. I think we've observed some favorable developments regarding e-bill adoption, and so on; so we track it closely. It gets generated, and circulated to a broad range of individuals within the organization as we carefully review it and share it with our partners.

Moshe Orenbuch

analyst
#27

Understood. Thank you. And Brian, you mentioned somewhat the delinquency and loss rates in relation to the averages from 2017 to 2019, and also 2020. Since you've stated, and reaffirmed, that they're going to keep getting better and be reduced during the back half, and maybe outperform seasonal patterns, I suppose how do you view that? Assuming employment levels stay steady right now, how would you see that moving toward those averages? How near might they come, and what would then bring you to a place where you might consider offsetting or undoing some of those tightening measures?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#28

Yes. I believe it's crucial, Moshe, to genuinely step back. To begin with, we've fallen behind the industry when it comes to normalization. When you examine how much we exceed our 2017 to 2019 range, aside from perhaps one or two issuers, we're actually doing fairly well, with our 30-plus sitting 19 basis points above a historical average, and our 90-plus at 18 basis points above a historical average. And once more, you're correct, looking at the second quarter on a 30-plus basis, we're a couple basis points better than seasonality. And for 90-plus, I believe we were, within a range of one to two basis points below, so broadly in line with or somewhat better than seasonality; so I think we consider that. I think we're going to watch how the macro environment unfolds. And again, the consumer is coping right now, and as relief starts reaching them, I think we'll reassess. I wouldn't hold an expectation that we're going to modify those refinements in the near term until we gain more clarity about the environment.

Moshe Orenbuch

analyst
#29

Okay. Thank you.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#30

Thanks, Moshe. Have a good day.

Ryan Nash

analyst
#31

Hey, good morning, everyone.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#32

Good morning. Morning, Ryan.

Ryan Nash

analyst
#33

Perhaps we should stay on the late fee subject. Given all the different items that have been introduced—APRs, paper statements, trailing interest, and so on—it's clear the market has grown optimistic that the rule might be postponed or could come down on the industry's side. I'm just wondering, in a scenario where the industry gets a favorable result, considering all the modifications you've implemented, which ones do you expect to remain in place, and which might you potentially scale back as time goes on?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#34

Yes. To start with, good morning, Ryan. The initial point, I believe, is that we need certainty, correct, about whether the late fee rule... If it gets delayed or eventually struck down by the courts, would the CFPB keep going down the road of seeking some kind of cap on late fees? So I believe you need a certain degree of certainty past that. I believe as you consider the pricing changes, first and foremost, we will examine consumer behavior and whether consumer behavior shifts here and whether shifts would be justified. I believe once you move past that, there are probably two buckets, Ryan. The first bucket involves our partners and RSAs, and there we would go and share the data with our partners and have a conversation regarding pricing and make some decisions with their input. And then bucket B is things inside our brand and control. So you consider our Synchrony Mastercard, our home and auto cards, things like that, which we would control, but obviously, we do that. It's fair to say not everything would ever get rolled back, but honestly, Ryan, we have not spent a lot of time as a team working through this scenario at present. We're really focused on implementing the PPPCs and following the developments in the court and being prepared for the outcome that the late fee rule goes into effect.

Ryan Nash

analyst
#35

Understood; and then, when you examine the way new accounts have trended, clearly there's a pretty meaningful decline compared with a year ago, which stands to reason considering, you know, what's been said about stricter underwriting; but looking forward, you know, since conditions remain tight, it doesn't seem like things are going to be loosened at this point, and you also have some normalization in payment rates. How are you thinking about how quickly loans will grow over a medium-term horizon?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#36

Okay, let me spend a moment on the 14% new accounts figure. There are likely two main buckets there, Ryan. The first one is — and Brian mentioned this regarding discretionary spending and areas where customers are watching what they spend — we're observing reduced foot traffic and reduced retail traffic, both in physical locations and online. So the number of people coming through the door is definitely constraining some of the chances to open new accounts; and then clearly, credit actions have had a slight effect on that as well. That's going to affect growth more in 2025 than it truly does in 2024, correct? So, when you consider how an account builds, it likely takes roughly 12 months to reach a more mature average balance per account; so I believe you'll sense a bit of pressure here. I do believe, given where we stand with the majority of our partners, you'd likely see something above GDP level, and growth will continue. Certainly, when you look at the platforms, we're enthusiastic about the health and wellness growth we keep experiencing, even though there's some softening there in cosmetic and LASIK, for instance, but that remains a strength for us. We keep having strength in some of the other platforms, such as our own specialty business in home and auto. So, once again, we won't necessarily provide guidance, but I think there are some favorable elements within the sales platforms that will hopefully carry us into a stronger economic stretch.

Brian Doubles

executive
#37

One more point, Ryan — that expansion in active accounts is something we probably track even more closely than the growth in new accounts, since we've been putting substantial money behind life cycle marketing and working out, across every one of our platforms, ways to get that customer engaged on their second, third, and fourth purchase. So just witnessing that positive inflection year over year, I'd call that a positive. And then, well, the consumer is still in a good spot, but lower store traffic and some pullback are showing up for us. Beyond that, we're clearly taking some credit actions on our own initiative that will better the trajectory into next year. So on the whole, we feel pretty good about the trends we're seeing.

Ryan Nash

analyst
#38

Awesome. Appreciate the call.

Brian Doubles

executive
#39

Yep. Thanks, Ryan.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#40

Thanks, Ryan.

Sanjay Sakhrani

analyst
#41

Thank you. Morning to everyone. Perhaps I'll pick up on a few of those credit-quality questions. Brian Wenzel, I recall hearing you describe certain steps taken a while back aimed at tightening up the underwriting. I mean, are those gains still ahead of us, so we ought to witness a further acceleration in improvement on that second derivative for delinquency rates? And then, you know, I'm just attempting to work through a few of the earlier questions. Like, shouldn't that, when combined with the stricter underwriting and the reduced pace of loan growth, be supportive for credit quality, shouldn't it? So, I mean, is this simply conservative assumptions baked into your credit guidance, or what, for this year, regarding the flat reserve rate? Thank you.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#42

Yeah. To begin, good morning, Sanjay, and thanks for the, thanks for the question. I, I believe it's a mix in which the credit actions... You know, bear in mind we kicked this off in, in the second quarter of last year through the third, and then genuinely began once more, the back half of the first quarter through the second quarter of this year. You observe it showing up in the slowing of the year-over-year shift in delinquencies, which we presented on page 10 of the earnings presentation here. So a portion of it is becoming evident in delinquency trends. Clearly, seasoning takes time, so I think you'd anticipate the payoff from those actions to sort of keep flowing through. Now, once more, actions that we implemented in the second quarter this year probably carry a somewhat more diminished impact on this year, with greater impact as you move out of 2024 into 2025. So it's genuinely a mix. You know, I, I'd say from an efficacy standpoint, we aren't taking or aren't persisting in taking broad-based actions at this point. We remain prepared to do so should anything worsen, but at present we're carrying on with our usual refinements, which tend to be more idiosyncratic at the partner portfolio, product and channel level.

Sanjay Sakhrani

analyst
#43

All right. For Brian Doubles, I have a follow-up question. Could you perhaps describe where things stand with possible partnership chances or portfolio transactions? Has anything shifted compared with the prior quarter? Thanks.

Brian Doubles

executive
#44

Yes, of course, Sanjay. Here's how I'd put it: our pipeline of opportunities is quite healthy. That remains the case. Competitively speaking, I believe we stand apart because of what we've invested in technology, the way we work with partners, and the way we bring things together, and that keeps appealing to the partners we already have as well as to new prospects; so my confidence in all of that is strong. Also, in a climate like this one, when conditions carry some uncertainty, you usually find pricing becomes more sensible, with somewhat more discipline throughout the industry, which is once again a positive. Back in the more exuberant stretch of 2021 and 2022, things had a tendency to become somewhat irrational when you were setting prices against loss rates that were historically low. Our approach has always been to price across a cycle; that won't change, yet I'd say the current environment, both industrywide and among competitors, is quite rational. So my confidence in our positioning is strong, and our pipeline of opportunities is solid.

Sanjay Sakhrani

analyst
#45

Great. Thank you.

Brian Doubles

executive
#46

Yep. Thanks, Sanjay.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#47

Thank you, Sanjay.

Rick Shane

analyst
#48

Morning, everyone, and I appreciate your time for my questions.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#49

Hi there, Rick.

Rick Shane

analyst
#50

I want to spend a moment on this. Your guidance has been shifted up toward the top of the range you'd previously given, so what I'm wondering is how much of that comes from timing — favorable timing tied to the PPPC rollout — as opposed to late fees? And how much could be tied to... slower growth in loans during the back half of the year, plus a helpful effect on reserves, along with any other underlying factors that could be pushing that?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#51

Yeah, I appreciate that question, Rick. From where I sit on timing, nothing meaningful stands out regarding when the execution happens. On execution itself, I'd say every deliverable we set has been achieved. Considering the steps required to make the scale of term changes we've made, we've delivered within the timelines we established, and everything is being rolled out on plan. So timing isn't really a factor there. I'd step back and say that the shift to the middle of the range — up to the upper end — really reflects overall business performance. While purchase volume could come in a bit below what we expected, it demonstrates that the consumer is coping. We aren't seeing them under pressure. As we work through the different pieces, our funding costs have leveled off and are leveling off as we head into the latter half of the year. Expenses, which we haven't discussed much, are only up 1%, and that includes $23 million tied to carrying out the change in terms — without that, they'd have declined, and I view that as a good sign going forward. So I think we keep executing on the business. This year, the business is squarely focused on what must be done to execute on the core business, on responding to the PPPC changes we're rolling out, and on integrating Ally Lending, which we're quite pleased about, and disposition if that's best. The team is concentrated on execution. That's what I'd point to as the reason we landed at the upper end of the range.

Rick Shane

analyst
#52

That's great, Brian — I really appreciate it. That's a huge help.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#53

Thank you, Rick.

Bill Carcache

analyst
#54

Thank you, and good morning to everybody. My question is regarding capital. Unlike a lot of banks that continue to wrestle with sizable AOCI marks, it looks like you folks have a clearer picture of how much capital you'll need to operate with, and as a result, it appears you might be better positioned to potentially give back capital above your target somewhat more aggressively compared with those still building capital to fill that OCI gap. Could you address that situation and how we ought to think about the path of that surplus capital position versus the 11% target you've mentioned in the past?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#55

Yes. Thank you, Bill, for asking. We've been on a journey, and you've heard me discuss this several times. When we split off from our former parent, we began and reached a CET1 peak of 18%, and then a descent has occurred, and at present we sit at 12.6%. We hold an excess compared to the target. We're still on that path, correct? However, organic RWA growth will always come first for us. The dividend comes second, and then third will be what we choose to do regarding share repurchases or inorganic activity. And Brian mentions the discipline we maintain concerning inorganic growth. So we do have the capability to do that. I believe we'll be prudent about how we give it back to shareholders. We won't simply drop it tomorrow, since clearly we have many stakeholders here who wouldn't necessarily support that move. But we are on a trajectory and heading toward our target, which has consistently been our long-term objective.

Bill Carcache

analyst
#56

Thank you. Appreciate it, Brian. That's useful. Now, to follow up on what you expect regarding a steady reserve rate at the close of 2024 compared with 2023 — it appears your assumption of a better loss path during the reasonable and supportable forecast window under CECL would, assuming nothing else changes, favor reserve releases. So should we conclude that your view has basically been de-risked and now carries more conservatism? I'm just trying to gauge when you'd be at ease bringing that reserve rate back to the day one level and whether that ought to be viewed more as something happening in 2025.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#57

Yeah. Well, one thing's for sure — it won't happen in 2024, correct? Like we mentioned, it's roughly flat versus last year. The real question is when will we have better clarity — you know, throughout the industry, everybody gains more clarity concerning the macroeconomic picture. When do we return to an interest rate setting that's more normalized, an inflation setting that's more normalized, which makes day-to-day expenses for our customers — a consumer shared across the industry — far more manageable? That uncertainty, I believe, is what will make people hesitate in how they operate the various scenarios and how they do their qualitative assessments; that's likely the biggest wild card. Clearly, you'll need to monitor how delinquencies in your portfolio evolve and how the mix shifts, but it truly comes down to gaining clarity on that environment. So once more, I believe exercising prudence at this point is the better path.

Bill Carcache

analyst
#58

Got it, that’s very clear. I appreciate your time in answering my questions once more.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#59

You’re welcome, Bill. I hope your day goes well.

Dave Rochester

analyst
#60

Hey, good morning, guys.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#61

Good morning.

Dave Rochester

analyst
#62

Once we reach October 1st, will your PPPC be in place across nearly every one of your partners by then, or are there some who chose to hold off until the rule formally kicks in? And if you have a sense, how big is that group?

Brian Doubles

executive
#63

Yeah, look, like Brian mentioned, the initial phase is done, and that accounts for a significant portion of the business. You know, there are one or two partners with whom we've mostly settled on what we'd do, but we're holding until the rule becomes effective .. again, that doesn't alter our expectation that we'll completely offset this. We'll return to, you know, ROAs from before the late fee changes, and we'll continue, you know, serving the customers and underwriting the customers we serve now.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#64

One more point to make, Dave — there's a tail involved here, correct? The reason being that for accounts we opened during the second half of last year, we wouldn't revise their terms merely six months after origination, or three months after origination. Consequently, a tail will persist in this situation across an extended stretch of time, and likewise with regard to how many inactive accounts turn active. As soon as they turn active, a CIT gets applied to them. So reaching 100% takes quite a while regardless of which scenario you consider, yet this will continue, and that falls within the usual way of doing things. And whenever a CIT is performed by us, that is, you know, more or less a standard practice.

Dave Rochester

analyst
#65

Understood. That's very clear. Thank you for that, and building on what Ryan asked about earlier — the situation in which the late fee rule gets struck down, specifically around which changes would remain. I realize you haven't spent much time on this yet, which is fair; but going purely by your initial read of how consumers have responded so far, your conversations with your partners, and the reality that implementing those changes carries a meaningful amount of expense, have you seen anything yet that would suggest you'd want to roll back the APR changes, or would those be the changes that are simplest to keep as they are? Thanks.

Brian Doubles

executive
#66

Yeah, look, I think, as Brian mentioned before, this is going to be something we discuss with the partners. For the share of the book that sits under our control, we'll be watching how consumer behavior shifts. It's genuinely still very early. These CITs are only now making their way through the statements, and we're at the very beginning of seeing how customers behave differently, which right now is only marginal. Still, we have to keep watching that. Like Brian said, we're fully on top of it, and we'll make adjustments as we go if that seems necessary. That said, we aren't planning for a situation where the rule never takes effect. My view is we have to manage what's within our control, and what's within our control is the pricing and policy changes — and those are the ones we've made. And, obviously, we believe we have a strong case when it comes to litigating the rule, but there's uncertainty there, so we have to... we have to stay focused on the things we can control.

Dave Rochester

analyst
#67

Great. Thanks, guys.

Brian Doubles

executive
#68

Yep, thanks.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#69

Appreciate it, Dave. Take care.

John Hecht

analyst
#70

Good morning, everyone, and I appreciate you fielding this. Honestly, I believe every question I had has either already been covered or raised and resolved, though I suppose there's one additional item: during the quarter you renewed Verizon, and after that you brought Virgin on board. Given, I guess, the cloud hanging over things and the lack of clarity regarding the late fee matter, I'm curious whether any sort of structural adjustments have occurred in the way you handle negotiations for these new contracts while that uncertainty persists?

Brian Doubles

executive
#71

Okay, so I'll kick things off, and then I'll turn it over to Brian for his thoughts. Look, first off, we're really thrilled to roll out what we believe is a truly distinctive, one-of-a-kind offering alongside Virgin Red. It's going to cover flights, hotels, and cruises. We're connecting with an extremely dedicated, loyal group of customers, so our excitement about working with Virgin Red on this new product couldn't be greater. We're just as enthusiastic about renewing Verizon. That's been a solid program for us, a fantastic partnership, so we're very pumped about that too. Certainly, the late fee matter has found its way into our negotiations, new business discussions, and renewals, which isn't shocking, but there are approaches to structure around it; we've definitely considered an $8 late fee in each program we've renewed since the rule came out, plus anything we've extended.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#72

Okay, one more point I'd make on that, John — when we build out the pricing structure, our assumption is that late fees come in at 8. If there's potential upside there, well, we've got protection on the downside. With respect to partners, there could be some things you'd do on the upside. It's clear that even if you look at the portfolio that we bought from a different issuer during the second quarter, we're comparatively shielded, or shielded, when it comes to that $8 late fee taking effect; it's just... You know, our pricing approach is more conservative. As much as we like the odds that the industry prevails against the rule, we aren't going to count on that when pricing a deal that will run, you know, for 7 to 10 years.

John Hecht

analyst
#73

Great. I appreciate the color, guys. Thanks very much.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#74

Thanks, John.

Brian Doubles

executive
#75

Thanks, John. Have a good day.

Don Fandetti

analyst
#76

Sure. Could you give us some detail on how the 2023 vintage is doing? You know, now that you have one more quarter behind you compared with what you expected and perhaps against 2022, and I realize you've experienced less, you know, kind of, fluctuation than in general purpose.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#77

Okay, well, thank you for bringing that up, Don. Once more, I believe — just to establish a baseline — I want to begin by comparing us with the broader industry. If you check with a few of the credit reporting agencies and examine those industry vintage curves, our portfolios on a relative basis are outperforming the industry's curves, on both a delinquency basis and a cumulative net charge-off basis. Having said that, we have discussed at length over the years that there is a shared consumer out there. What other issuers did when they came out of the pandemic does affect us — they tweaked certain credit standards or shifted the credit box in their own worlds, and they issued an enormous volume of what were among the largest vintages the credit card business has ever witnessed, so that's the context I'm using. I think when it comes to delinquencies — and I'll share a few specifics with you, Don — when it comes to delinquencies, the period from the second half of 2021 through the first half of 2023 is doing somewhat worse than, or worse than, the 2018 vintage. 2019 is distorted since that was the pandemic year. The second half of 2023, and what we're observing — and once again, it's quite early — but based on the early signals coming out of 2024, thanks to the credit actions we've implemented, those are doing better than the first half of 2023; and from a charge-off standpoint, the second half of 2023 and the first half of 2024 are doing better than 2018. So I do believe a number of the adjustments we've made through credit actions are helping the vintages. We do have some of that shared consumer in 2021 and partly into the back half of 2021, and into the early portion of 2023, that has produced for us a bit of the trends that sit above our historical delinquency rate. Yet again, though, we feel good about the way the vintages are developing.

Don Fandetti

analyst
#78

Thanks, Brian.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#79

Great. Thank you.

Operator

operator
#80

That wraps up Synchrony's Earnings Conference Call. At this point you're free to hang up, and we hope your day is a great one.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Synchrony Financial transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Synchrony Financial earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Synchrony Financial or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.