Synchrony Financial (SYF) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
October 16, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Kathryn Miller
executiveThanks, and good morning to all of you. It's a pleasure to have you join our quarterly earnings conference call. Along with the press release issued today, we've put together a presentation that walks through the subjects we intend to cover on this call. You can find the press release, the detailed financial schedules, and the presentation on our website, synchronyfinancial.com. To access this material, simply navigate to the Investor Relations section of that site. Before we begin, I'd like to note that forward-looking statements will be part of what we say today. Such statements carry risks and uncertainty, and it's possible for actual results to differ materially. The factors that could lead actual results to differ materially are listed in our SEC filings, which you can access on our website. Throughout this call, we will discuss the company's performance using non-GAAP financial measures. A reconciliation of those measures to GAAP financial measures appears in our materials for today's call. Lastly, Synchrony Financial bears no responsibility for, and neither edits nor guarantees the accuracy of, earnings teleconference transcripts supplied by third-parties. Our website is the sole location of authorized webcasts. Joining us this morning are Brian Doubles, who serves as Synchrony's President and Chief Executive Officer, and Brian Wenzel, Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer.
Brian Doubles
executiveThanks, Kathryn, and good morning, everyone. Synchrony announced robust results for the third quarter today, with net earnings reaching $789 million, or $1.94 per diluted share, alongside a return on average assets of 2.6% and a return on tangible common equity of 24.3%. These figures demonstrate Synchrony's dedication to creating value for our customers, partners, providers, small businesses, and shareholders, even as the operating environment keeps changing. Throughout the quarter, we kept providing responsible credit access via strong omni-channel experiences. Our wide array of flexible financing options and attractive value propositions keep appealing to customers, who are engaging across our diversified portfolio. We brought in 4.7 million new accounts and achieved $45 billion in purchase volume. Growth in both new accounts and purchase volume remains affected by a slight decrease in consumer spending, along with the credit measures Synchrony has implemented since the middle of 2023 to strengthen our portfolio's credit trajectory in 2024 and beyond. Even with those measures, average active accounts held steady compared to last year, and ending receivables increased 4%. At the platform level, purchase volume and receivables showed a continuation of the trends we talked about throughout this year. Customers remain selective about how and where they spend, especially as they adjust their spending to deal with inflation's effects on necessities such as groceries, utilities, and rent. Platform purchase volume growth varied from down 3% to down 7% year-over-year, largely indicating reduced spend per account, as customers cut back on both larger ticket and discretionary purchases, especially in areas like furniture, electronics, cosmetic, and vision, plus the effect of Synchrony's credit measures. Receivables growth across platforms ranged from 3% to 10% higher compared to last year, mainly due to moderation in payment rates. Dual and co-branded cards made up 43% of total purchase volume for the quarter and dropped 2%, mostly because of more selective consumer spending habits and the impact of our credit measures. The trends we observe in out-of-partner spend on these products have largely stayed in line with those at the platform level. Our customers remain careful with discretionary purchases, particularly in larger ticket categories like home furnishing, travel and entertainment, and are focusing on non-discretionary spending such as groceries and pharmacy. As we typically anticipate, our customers across credit grades are spending less per transaction in most categories, with average transaction values falling 3% compared to last year. To be more specific, our non-prime customers lowered their average transaction values by roughly 5% compared to last year, while prime transaction values decreased by 3%. Our super-prime customers keep driving more out-of-partner spend, with transaction value declines of about 2% year-over-year. That said, customers across credit grades are making transactions with fairly stable frequency relative to last year, which has partly counterbalanced the effect of lower transaction values. From a payment behavior standpoint, we keep seeing relative stability in our non-prime segments. At the same time, among our prime and super-prime cardholders, there's been a steady movement away from paying above the minimum toward paying just the minimum. Looking at our portfolio, the share of payments below the minimum is still under the average for 2017 to 2019 across every credit segment. Putting those two things together, the spending and payment patterns we see in our portfolio suggest, in our view, a consumer making sound choices consistent with their own priorities and budget. And as what customers need and prioritize keeps changing, Synchrony stays committed to offering financial solutions that carry strong value and wide usefulness wherever life may lead them. That capacity to adapt and improve what we offer also lets us produce loyalty along with resilient risk-adjusted returns for our partners, providers, and merchants, and it makes Synchrony's standing as a partner of choice even stronger. In Q3, we brought on or renewed over 15 partners, among them Dick's Sporting Goods and Gibson, plus strategic relationships such as Albertsons; extending our tie-up with Dick's, which rests on a relationship spanning more than 20 years, is something we're proud of. Through our Score Rewards credit card program, we'll keep our dedication to athletes by giving them the chance to earn rewards at twice the speed, member-only offers they can't get elsewhere, and digital account management. Athletes can keep using those cards both online and in stores at the company's 800 plus retail locations, among them Dick's Sporting Goods, House of Sport, Golf Galaxy, and Public Lands. At the same time, Synchrony's tie-up with Gibson, the most iconic brand in the music industry, amounts to what we consider an industry first. It comes through Gibson's introduction of a direct-to-consumer credit program, offered on Gibson.com and at the Gibson Garage Nashville flagship store. Gibson will additionally take part in our manufacturer OEM sponsorship program to boost customer engagement with their dealer framework, and with the Synchrony Music and Sound Network as well. Synchrony is likewise eager to kick off a strategic partnership between CareCredit and Albertsons Companies, a leading food and drug retailer in our communities. Thanks to this collaboration, customers can pay with their CareCredit card for select health and wellness items at nearly 2200 Albertsons company stores, among them Albertsons, Safeway, Bonds, Acme, Shaw's, and Jewel-Osco; that joins our growing roster of partners like Sam's Club, Walgreens, and Walmart, where CareCredit is accepted as payment for select health and wellness products and services. And finally, we at Synchrony (ph) take pride in rolling out a first-of-its-kind payment experience for pet parents, using our patent pending insurance reimbursement functionality, which will make managing pet health care expenses simpler. Customers holding both a CareCredit and a Pets Best Insurance product will now be able to have their Pets Best Insurance claims reimbursed straight to their CareCredit health and wellness credit card. This seamless new technology shows Synchrony's emphasis on creating best-in-class experiences and, through our work with Independence Pet Holdings, advances our commitment to helping more pets receive the veterinary care they require. Be it by providing scalable, creative financial products that give our customers more power, or by bringing on new partners and renewing existing ones across nearly every category where consumers spend. Synchrony delivers access, flexibility, and usefulness to both our customers and our partners. And because of that, we're creating more long-term value for those with a stake in our company. So with that, I'll hand things over to Brian, who will walk through how we performed financially in more detail.
Brian Wenzel
executiveBrian, thanks, and good morning to all. Once again Synchrony delivered strong quarterly financial performance, demonstrating the resilience of our distinctive business model and our strong execution on key strategic priorities, which consistently produces compelling results for stakeholders. In the third quarter, ending loan receivables reached $102 million, a 4% increase from the prior year, since the advantage of an approximately 60 basis point drop in payment rate outweighed the 4% decrease in purchase volume. Net revenue climbed 10% to $3.8 billion, reflecting the combined effects of greater interest and fees, reduced RSA, and increased other income. Net interest income rose 6% to $4.6 billion, driven by a 7% increase in interest and fees. That growth mostly came from higher average loan receivables and an improved loan receivable yield. Our loan receivable yield increased 30 basis points, which was the result of our product, pricing, and policy changes, or PPPCs, along with a lower payment rate, partly offset by higher reversals. The cost of total interest-bearing liabilities was $4.78, up 44 basis points from a year earlier, because benchmark rates were higher. RSAs totaled $914 million, equal to 3.57% of average loan receivables in the third quarter, and were down $65 million compared with the prior year, mainly due to higher net charge-offs. Additionally, other income rose to $119 million, largely driven by the effect of our PPPC fees, though that was partly offset by the impact from our Pets Best disposition along with gains and losses on venture investments. The provision for credit losses climbed to $1.6 billion, reflecting increased net charge-offs and a reserve build of $47 million. Meanwhile, other expenses were up 3% to $1.2 billion, pushed higher by costs tied to the Ally Lending acquisition, technology investments, and preparatory expenses for the late fee rule change, with lower operational losses providing a partial offset. We had $11 million in extra expenses tied to getting ready for the Late Fee rule change — that covers both carrying out our PPPCs and the costs of putting the rule itself into effect once it takes hold. Despite those added costs, our efficiency ratio came in at 31.2% for the third quarter, which is roughly 200 basis points better than the same period a year ago — that shows how Synchrony keeps holding the line on costs and stays focused on generating operational leverage across our business. All told, Synchrony posted net earnings of $789 million, equal to $1.94 per diluted share, which translated into a 2.6% return on average assets and a 24.3% return on tangible common equity. Now I'll walk through our key credit trends, starting on Slide 9. When the quarter wrapped up, accounts more than 30 days past due made up 4.78%, compared with 4.40% a year earlier and 16 basis points higher than the typical level we saw across the third quarters of 2017 through 2019. For accounts more than 90 days past due, the figure came to 2.33%, against 2.06% the previous year, which puts it 20 basis points above that same historical average spanning the third quarter of 2017 to 2019. Net charge-offs for the third quarter landed at 6.06%, versus 4.60% in the year-ago period, and that's 97 basis points above our historical average covering the third quarter of 2017 to 2019. Our credit loss reserve worked out to 10.79% of loan receivables, which is about even with the 10.74% coverage ratio we reported in the second quarter. If you look at Slide 10, it shows how the credit actions we implemented between mid-2023 and early 2024 are contributing to better delinquency trends, because the year-over-year growth rate for both 30-plus and 90-plus delinquencies continues to decelerate. Given that we are a share consumer, we will continue monitoring how our portfolio performs as well as credit patterns throughout the wider industry, and we are prepared to take additional credit measures if necessary. While the actions taken since last year have reduced growth in new accounts and purchase volume for now, we think this positions our portfolio to be stronger as we finish out 2024 and supports delivering the risk-adjusted returns we are targeting over the long term. Let's turn to Slide 11. Synchrony's funding, capital and liquidity are still a strong base for the company. During Q3, Symphony increased our direct deposits by about $780 million, reduced broker deposits by $1.5 billion, and sold $750 million in senior unsecured fixed-to-floating rate notes that mature in 2030. When the quarter closed, deposits represented 84% of our total funding, and secured and unsecured debt were each 8% of our total funding. Our total liquid assets plus undrawn credit facilities reached $22.4 billion, which is $1.9 billion more than last year, and amounted to 18.8% of total assets, an improvement of 60 basis points year over year. Now let's turn to our capital ratios. Just to note, we opted into the transition guidance for CECL put out by the joint federal banking agencies. Come January 2025, Synchrony will apply one last transition adjustment to our regulatory capital metrics of roughly 50 basis points. Our income statement and balance sheet already reflect the CECL impact. Following the CECL transition guidance, we closed the third quarter with a CET1 ratio of 13.1%, which is 30 basis points higher than last year's 12.8%. Our Tier 1 capital ratio came in at 14.3%, 70 basis points above the prior year. Our total capital ratio rose 70 basis points to 16.4%. On a fully phased-in foundation, our ratio of Tier 1 capital plus reserves rose to 24.5%, up from 22.9% a year earlier. During the third quarter, we gave back $399 million to shareholders, made up of $300 million of share repurchases along with $99 million of common stock dividends. At the close of the quarter, $700 million was still available under our share repurchase authorization for the period ending June 30, 2025. Synchrony stays well positioned to return capital to shareholders, guided by our business performance, market conditions, regulatory restrictions and subject to our capital plan. Now to our outlook. Synchrony remains focused on executing its core strategic priorities and taking the steps needed to improve business performance in the coming years—particularly our ability to achieve the long-term financial goal on an averaged basis. We have monitored the portfolio carefully and believe our credit metrics, as well as the PPPCs, are performing as we had expected. With the PPPCs' first quarter now in progress, paper statement fee income is arriving somewhat under our forecast, while e-bill enrollment is coming in stronger. Customer attrition has also been lower than we projected, which reflects the strength of the value proposition behind the products we offer. We're going to stay on top of how all this is affecting our customers, our partners, and our portfolios from both a financial and an operational standpoint. That way, working alongside our partners, we can figure out whether any changes to our strategies make sense, so we can hit our share objectives: growth that's sustainable and risk-adjusted, delivered at the long-term returns we're aiming for. Before we go further, a quick note on how we're framing things: with the late fee rule change still pending and our PPPCs in play, we can't be sure when the litigation over late fees filed in March will resolve or how it will turn out. We also can't predict whether consumers will behave differently once the late fee rule change takes effect, or how they might respond to the PPPCs (ph) that we and the rest of the industry have introduced in light of the new rule. Whatever actually happens with these unknowns could change our outlook. Keeping that framing in mind, let's turn to what we expect for the rest of 2024.
Brian Wenzel
executiveOur expectation is that the consumer will keep managing our spending, and that—taken together with the credit actions we've taken—ought to produce a decline in purchase volume in the low single digits for the fourth quarter. We still anticipate that payment rates will moderate, and combined with what we expect for purchase volume, that should contribute to growth in the low single digits and to ending loan receivables versus a year ago. Because the late fee rule did not go into effect on October 1, which our earlier outlook had assumed, and because uncertainty surrounding late fee litigation persists, our assumption now is that the late fee rule will not take effect during 2024. Consequently, we anticipate that net interest income will stay flat on a sequential basis, since seasonally higher reversals offset the effects of our PPPCs. We expect other income to hold at a level consistent with the third quarter. RSA will keep aligning program performance with company performance, and it should decline both sequentially in dollar terms and as a percentage of average loan receivables, reflecting the net effect on flat revenue of seasonally higher net charge-offs. Other expenses are expected to rise sequentially along with the seasonally higher growth. On the credit side, our expectation is that delinquencies will follow their seasonal pattern during the fourth quarter. We also still expect that the net charge-off rate for the second half of 2024 will come in below that of the first half. Finally, our expectation remains that our reserve rate at the end of 2024 will be broadly in line with the rate at the end of 2023. On the basis of these assumptions, Synchrony anticipates delivering fully diluted earnings per share of between $8.45 and $8.55 for the full year 2024. The roughly $0.80 improvement from the midpoint of our earlier full year EPS outlook comes from a mix of factors. First, the <<inaudible>> assumption that the late fee rule would be implemented on October 1, 2024, and therefore the elimination of the associated benefit from the RSA offset as well. Second, the effect of our PPPCs and the increase in RSA tied to those changes; and last, the strong performance of our core business as we head into the fourth quarter. In summary, Synchrony has kept delivering on the key strategic priorities that matter most to our stakeholders. We stay confident in the steps we have taken so far to strengthen our business within an evolving environment, and we believe we are well positioned to generate resilient risk-adjusted returns over the long term. With that, I will hand the call back to Brian for his closing thoughts.
Brian Doubles
executiveAppreciate that, Brian. Synchrony draws on its own proprietary data and analytics, its extensive lending know-how, and its cutting-edge digital tools to deliver smooth customer experiences, attractive value offers, and greater usefulness every time we engage with a customer. More and more, we are present wherever our customers wish to encounter financial solutions that fuel loyalty and sales for our partners, providers, and small businesses, and we keep strengthening our leading position, all while generating sustainable risk-adjusted growth and long-term value for our shareholders. With that said, I'll hand the call back to Kathryn so we can begin the Q&A.
Kathryn Miller
executiveThose remarks bring the prepared portion to a close. We're moving into the Q&A portion now, and to give as many of you as possible a chance to speak, I'd ask everyone on the line to keep it to one main question plus a single follow-up. Should anything further come to mind, our Investor Relations group will be around once this call wraps up. Operator, go ahead and open the Q&A.
Ryan Nash
analystHi, good morning everyone.
Brian Doubles
executiveHi, Ryan.
Brian Wenzel
executiveMorning, Ryan.
Ryan Nash
analystBrian, could you break down the NII guidance a bit for us? I get that the fourth quarter runs seasonally lower because of reversals, like you pointed out. But where do the PPPCs come into that, plus your liability-sensitive stance, which I believe you didn't mention in what you said? And then, just based on forward curve expectations apart from seasonality, do you think the NIM keeps trending upward across the coming several quarters? Thanks.
Brian Wenzel
executiveYes, thank you, Ryan. So if you consider NII on a sequential basis and just move into Q4, first, when you look at the patterns around delinquency and units moving into delinquency, dollars assessed on late fees ought to be lower in Q4 compared with Q3. Combine that with greater reversals, that basically offsets the positive you ought to observe and will observe on interest income and the gain we see on interest expense, so it roughly nets out for the quarter, more simply a result of how the favorability from delinquencies affects late fees. If you begin thinking about the net interest margin for a moment, you ought to keep seeing the interest component relative to the PPPCs, plus the raw rates (ph) payment rates decline, rise and push the NIM up. And you ought to also see a gain on interest expense. That will trail somewhat owing to the reset of the debt stack, especially the CDs, which occurs across the first half of the year. So generally there are more tailwinds when you consider margin as you go into next year, though it will be somewhat lagged because of the CD reset in the first half of the year, both of which occurred in Q2.
Ryan Nash
analystUnderstood. And for my next question, your credit guidance assumes delinquencies will track normal seasonal patterns. I suppose, first, do you anticipate losses behaving the same way? And regarding delinquencies tracking seasonality, what does that imply for how losses trend as we head into '25? And should they track seasonality, is it possible for losses to drop back under 6% next year? Thanks.
Brian Wenzel
executiveYeah, so Ryan, we'll return in January to discuss next year in real depth. But a few items come to mind when I consider credit overall. To start, there are likely four points I'd mention. First, on delinquency trends themselves, we're observing a strong entry rate, which is superior to what we saw before the pandemic, and that keeps helping the flow into delinquency; early stage delinquency is holding quite steady in terms of month-on-month performance. Then we're noticing some gains over the past several months in late-stage collections, which is encouraging. So I'd say delinquency trends are performing reasonably well. If you weigh that against seasonality over the recent months, we've in fact come in low to mid-single digits ahead of seasonality when you examine the '17 to '19 stretch. So that's a positive trend that keeps persisting — keeps persisting across recent months. Once more, as I believe I've noted publicly, vintage performance in both the second half of 2023 and the first half of '24, though quite early, is trending stronger than the '18 vintages. And once more, I think you can observe it in both purchase volume and new account origination, and certainly the credit actions are producing some impact there, which I believe strengthens credit as we progress. Our underwriting is built to deliver that 5.5% to 6%. So the goal — and the goal would be for us to return to that level. Again, we are trending downward. And you can see in the slides that year-over-year growth in delinquencies for both 30-plus and 90-plus keeps shrinking. So again, in line with our expectations as we move through the rest of '24.
Ryan Nash
analystThanks Brian.
Brian Wenzel
executiveThanks Ryan. Have a good day.
Terry Ma
analystHello, and thanks. Good morning to everyone. You mentioned loan yields rose 30 basis points compared with a year earlier, driven by PPPCs and reduced payment rates, though interest reversals partly canceled that out. Could you possibly put a number on how much each piece contributed? And perhaps also give us some sense of how that PPPC piece expands as we move into next year?
Brian Wenzel
executiveSure. Terry, we won't separate the PPPCs into their specific line-item pieces, but the gain definitely does come through on the interest yield line. First, you can — it gets partly offset when you look quarter to quarter because of the Visa share gain in the second quarter. Still, it is clearly appearing in other income. Once more, this marks the initial complete quarter with phase one of the CITs included. We still anticipate that building as we go into next year. I believe when we return in January, we'll attempt to offer somewhat more insight into that. Terry, I think if you pull back, the key point — which I emphasized during my prepared remarks — is that the steps we've taken have broadly aligned with what we expected. There's something encouraging in the fact that customer attrition hasn't run as high as we had anticipated. Of course, that would have meant a reserve release. So from a financial angle it's unfavorable, yet from a customer angle it's actually better, since they see the value propositions of our cards; we did point out paper statements came in somewhat below expectations, partly from softeners, partly because our accounts were somewhat below expectations, but overall things look good. Adoption of e-bill and our customers' readiness to shift behavior and do so has been favorable. So when we examine that, broadly speaking, at a line. Thus even with somewhat less customer attrition, that usually indicates the core is doing somewhat better; so as we stand here today, we feel good about our position, but we'll keep monitoring customer behavior and we will definitely keep an eye on the market, and many issuers have already begun making changes now that this rule is taking effect.
Terry Ma
analystUnderstood, that's useful. Now, moving on to a credit-related follow-up. It appears that credit results are pretty much tracking what you'd anticipated. However, when I examine this year's charge-off rate, it's coming in a bit above 6%. I don't want to anchor it to your original guidance, but could you perhaps discuss how credit trends have shaped up compared with what you were expecting as we entered this year?
Brian Wenzel
executiveSure. The way I see it, Terry, is that we made certain moves in the latter part of the first quarter and the beginning of the second quarter, once again aiming to prepare and shield ourselves from any worsening that might occur later this year and into the next; so those steps were taken. We will definitely — I believe you've observed some of the purchase volume, which is marginally below what we had anticipated. That regrettably affects the denominator, pushing the rate somewhat above what one might assume. But once more, I think the reality that we aren't implementing wide-ranging measures now provides us a bit of credit, a bit of assurance regarding credit. And we will surely — you've heard my comments with Ryan a bit earlier concerning the four items we reviewed to conclude, look, we're feeling positive about our position as we head into the fourth quarter.
Terry Ma
analystExcellent, thanks very much.
Brian Wenzel
executiveAppreciate it, Terry. Enjoy the rest of your day.
Don Fandetti
analystHi, good morning. Brian, you brought up some gains in late-stage collections across the past few months. I was curious whether you might expand on that a bit — is it simply a mix catch-up; and more broadly, has executing on collection gotten more difficult now than it used to be.
Brian Wenzel
executiveYes. Thank you. Good morning Don. I'll take the second half of what you asked first. Has collecting gotten harder nowadays, absolutely — I believe if you compare this with several years back, reaching customers has definitely become somewhat more challenging; yet that's precisely where we've grown, and throughout the pandemic, by putting money into digital collections, putting money into other methods and other channels through which we're able to reach the customer so those collections can get completed, like texting and similar things. So it has gotten somewhat harder. I think this is a game where you need to roll out additional products rather than simply getting additional collectors onto the phones, and absolutely, the rules have changed such that how many times you may contact someone has gone down. Still, I believe we've adjusted to that. I think, considering the late stage briefly, whenever your early stage has weakened considerably, whatever moves to the back potentially can be somewhat stronger and more collectible. So although I look at the late stage, it continues to perform worse than 2019 and 2020, the period before the pandemic, it has begun improving of late, which we view as encouraging regarding performance; but once more, it's worse than it previously was; and you'd anticipate some of that when you have a very strong entry rate into delinquency — whatever flows in proves somewhat harder to collect. So we would have expected both early stage and late stage to worsen. But at present, over the last, I'd say, several months we've observed a bit of an uptick in those late-stage collections.
Don Fandetti
analystUnderstood. Then for my second question — I recognize there's plenty of anxiety about that lower tier. Your cardholders and the balances appear to be handling shifting habits, which keep shifting, yet it doesn't look like things are ramping up when it comes to a breaking point. Would you agree?
Brian Wenzel
executiveYeah, I'd say that's completely right. We examine this from a few angles. If you look at the rate at which people pay, and you check the patterns across credit tiers — which roughly track income deciles — the greater shift shows up among prime accounts, so within that $6.60 to $7.80 (ph) band, you observe somewhat more migration into mid-days, while among non-prime you don't really witness nearly as much of that migration. As I recall, the shift into mid-day runs roughly 1 point higher for prime, and for non-prime it was half that figure. So stress on the payment side isn't showing up. And considering the K-shaped recovery, affordability has obviously hit a portion of the lower-end consumer, who cut back their spending and are coping reasonably well. Taking those two things together, we aren't detecting consumer stress. What we actually observe is them behaving in a fairly rational manner at the moment. So it leans more toward normalization; though once more, if you compare with prime customers, their payment rate remains above where it stood in 2019. So at present we don't really see evidence of strain at the low end. Thanks Don. Have a good day.
Moshe Orenbuch
analystThanks. Brian, I wanted to ask you to discuss the deceleration in spending volume, and break it apart into the effects of your own stricter consumer criteria and, separately, possibly the changes in policy. One thing people keep asking us is — I realize you mentioned attrition wasn't impacted by that, but how about spending volume? So those are the 3 items. Thank you.
Brian Wenzel
executiveYes. To begin with, good morning Moshe. I appreciate the question; let me pick up at the point where you finished. If you examine what we did in the portfolio regarding pricing adjustments and similar moves, the encouraging part is that a control group exists against which we tested this. So if we compare volume shifts among those who got CITs versus those who did not get CITs, no material gap appears. That gives us some foundation for saying these actions have not produced meaningful attrition that has escaped our notice. So that covers, I believe, the second half of what you asked. As for the purchase activity itself, what we observe is that pretty much everywhere, nearly all transaction values are declining, meaning the consumer is trading down somewhat. We notice this — take mattresses as my illustration, where frequency may not have fallen by as much, yet the typical transaction value has dropped as customers say, look, I'm ready to buy a mattress, but I'm not prepared to pay $4,000, so I'll move down to something costing $2,500, and we've witnessed that among retailers broadly. And I believe you observe it, broadly speaking, throughout discretionary categories, and even within our health and wellness business, you notice it in cosmetics and LASIK, items that can be postponed — that's a near-term effect. Certainly, that will become a tailwind eventually, since those kinds of procedures don't disappear. And you're correct, a few of the moves we made had a slight effect on purchase volume, and a larger effect on new accounts, so we could ensure that the origination of the books delivers risk-adjusted returns that appeal to us.
Moshe Orenbuch
analystPerhaps at a broad level for either of you, Brian. When you consider the economic backdrop underneath, we've gone through a stretch in which wages have grown faster than prices, even though the consumer continues to feel some strain and remains in that phase, as you mentioned, of trading down. When you think about the kinds of things you're watching for to try to spark or turn around some of that tightening, what would those be from a macro perspective? And perhaps discuss that a bit. Thank you.
Brian Doubles
executiveYes, Moshe, perhaps I'll take this one. Look, I believe, as Brian said, the consumer remains in fairly solid shape. What we're observing are trends that look quite alike throughout the industry. Inflation is making itself felt. But I think, as you said, a robust labor market is certainly assisting in counterbalancing a portion of that strain. And consumers are reducing their spending, yet they're doing so in a highly rational, disciplined manner; we actually appreciate being able to observe that they're sticking to a budget. They're dealing with the elevated cost of goods. This isn't a fresh trend. We began noticing it at the start of this year. You're seeing it somewhat more widely spread at present, but not in a way that worries us. I think from a credit standpoint, this is precisely what we hoped to see. Part of that is the consumer pulling back, and part of that is simply the steps we took. But once more, I think, much like credit, you're just watching spending shift back toward a normal level. I think once credit flattens out and you begin to observe some steadiness, there's still plenty of uncertainty around. And I think once those clouds begin to lift, you then start returning to what we'd regard as more typical growth in the business, pushing new accounts back toward levels comparable to those before this year.
Moshe Orenbuch
analystI really appreciate it.
Brian Wenzel
executiveAppreciate it, Moshe. Enjoy your day.
Sanjay Sakhrani
analystThank you, and good morning. Perhaps, just to wrap up the discussion on credit, Brian Wenzel, could you speak to the trajectory of the reserve rate and how we ought to consider its direction as we head into next year? I realize you aren't providing guidance for next year. I realize you aren't providing guidance by the time the year ends; but just to consider when we shift back to some normalized level for the reserve rate.
Brian Wenzel
executiveYes. Thank you, good morning, Sanjay. I believe the guidance we essentially provide is that the reserve rate at the conclusion of this year will broadly align with the reserve rate at the conclusion of the prior year, which stood at 10.26% or 10.3%. I realize folks are likely concentrating on the word generally. Naturally, when you examine a figure at year-end, and that's a significant seasonal element really regarding how the receivable grows and how it unfolds. I believe certainly, I've provided you with a few of the delinquency trends that feed into the client data model. And once more, I believe we've observed — though it has been somewhat uneven. The macroeconomic environment being somewhat more steady; we're happy that the Federal Reserve did reduce rates. So once more, I believe as we conclude this year broadly in line with the prior year, I believe you essentially have a few indications regarding how you consider the loss trajectory. And certainly, I don't believe we observe anything at present that indicates to us, we will not keep progressing back toward that day 1 CECL, we will certainly, as you observe, the delinquency levels, which sit somewhat higher than where we stood during the pre-pandemic period, correct, when you draw a comparison back to both 30 plus and 90 plus. As that returns toward normal, we would anticipate the reserve rate to keep declining as the mix shift.
Sanjay Sakhrani
analystAll right, that's helpful. And turning to the CFPB's late fee regulations, Brian, you spent a good deal of time discussing how consumers are behaving. But has anything shifted regarding when you anticipate being able to completely offset the hit, assuming it takes effect at some point next year? And then — and if it doesn't materialize, what's — how are we supposed to view the strategy in that scenario? Would you reverse any of the adjustments you've implemented? Or would you pursue different measures, but I'm simply attempting to reason through what that would mean. Thank you.
Brian Wenzel
executiveYes. Allow me to begin, and I'll check whether Brian wants to add anything. Regarding the first portion of what you asked, Sanjay, it doesn't truly change the neutrality threshold, correct? What matters is really the distance from where you start to that neutrality level — specifically, how deep the bottom point is, which depends on the timing of when the late fee regulation takes effect. So I don't believe this is a situation where we'd review things and conclude that the initial results we've observed alter that neutrality exit rate according to our modeling. So I think that aspect stays as is. As for when the regulation might take effect, we'll likely address that either during the fourth quarter or in January, once we have additional details and a more solid estimate regarding the timing of the rule's implementation. We're running this company, and we certainly — the current administration has expressed a desire to see the late fee regulation enacted. And we're preparing on the assumption that it will take effect; the only question is the timing of when that occurs; so what you're really asking about is whether there's a clawback — some people say roll back. As an organization, we haven't devoted any meaningful time to considering that. Once more, we expect it will take effect in some form. And should it not, then we'd need a very high level of confidence that it wouldn't be revived. And at that stage, it becomes a discussion with those who bear the economic consequences of this. And then for our properties, we'd need to conduct that evaluation. But once again, we haven't invested much time in this. We think the regulation will take effect, and we're preparing as a company to carry that out. I'm not sure, Brian, whether you have anything else you'd like to add — .
Brian Doubles
executiveRight. So, look — our planning assumed an $8 late fee would take effect, since these offsets need time to phase in, and we coordinate with our partners on that. Whether that $8 actually takes hold is difficult to predict, given that they were shifted to safe harbor. This could unfold in many different ways. Still, we're ready for any of those scenarios. As for reversing anything, I think, as Brian mentioned, that's something we discuss — with our partners, just as we did when we first introduced the pricing actions. We're very transparent in how we work with them, and that's how we handled the pricing changes, and that's how we'll handle it based on whatever ultimately happens with the late fee. Once again, our objective remains the same; we're aiming to safeguard our partners and keep making things better for the very same customers we serve today.
Sanjay Sakhrani
analystThank you.
Brian Wenzel
executiveGreat, Sanjay. Have a good day.
Mihir Bhatia
analystHello, and thanks for answering my questions. To begin with, I'd like to focus on net interest margins for a moment. In a setting where rates are falling, what performance should we anticipate from them? My reason for asking is that your portfolio differs somewhat from those of several larger competitors, containing a greater proportion of fixed-rate assets. So perhaps you could detail the various components involved, and also share any assumptions regarding deposit beta that you're comfortable disclosing?
Brian Wenzel
executiveSure. Morning, Mihir, and I appreciate the question; so regarding a structure for looking at net interest margin, I'll set the ALR mix to one side for now, and address it later. Initially, considering the interest and fee income, specifically the yield element, you ought to see some modest gain as prime rate changes work their way through for that segment of operations, since prime trails in the manner we construct it. Thus, ideally, we gain from the floating-rate portion. Naturally, with payment rates continuing to decline, the revolve-rate piece ought to increase; so both of those factors should provide tailwinds within the interest and fee part of the NIM calculation. Now, turning to the funding aspect, encompassing both the investment portfolio and interest expense. Clearly, we operate in a follow-the-market manner. Historically, we trailed the market somewhat when it comes to digital banking. What you've observed in the third quarter, I believe, is that digital banks became somewhat more aggressive in cutting rates sooner than usual, likely due to funding requirements; so we matched their reductions. That, I think, generates another tailwind. Considering that briefly, you need to separate it into the high-yield savings portion, which reacts more quickly. Yet once more, that's roughly 40% of our retail deposits; then there's the 60% in CDs, most of which will reprice during the first half, and certainly beyond, I'd say, 75% will fully reprice over the course of next year, though a large portion actually reprices in the first half, much of it during the second quarter because of how we issued certificates this year. So once more, that trails somewhat behind some of the earlier Fed actions, but we should manage to capture that downward rate shift as we move forward. And the final item I'll mention is that ALR serves as somewhat of an unpredictable factor for NIM. As I see it currently, if we're offering someone 4.3% on a high-yield savings account while receiving 4.9% from the Fed, that represents a favorable economic situation for the firm. At that moment, I'm not really certain I'd want to reduce our liquidity, since we'll require it once we start moving out of this stretch and expanding; therefore, should that trend become flatter or more negative, we would reconsider the amount of liquidity we hold; those, I believe, are the shifting elements involved, offered to help you get a feel for the way NIM ought to be viewed.
Mihir Bhatia
analystOkay, that's really useful, thanks. Maybe going back to purchase volume and picking up on what I think Moshe asked — I just want to confirm I've got it right. What makes you confident that the drop in purchase volume, or rather that purchase volumes, have settled at this point, sitting at a low single digit decline? And on a related note, do you track particular platforms as early signals for where purchase volumes are headed or for consumer financial health? Thanks.
Brian Wenzel
executiveYeah. Clearly, we review the trends every day — we monitor daily sales, track where they're going, and look at what I'd describe as a calendar adjusted year-over-year perspective along with a daily year-over-year perspective. So we're trying to pull insights to determine whether trends are emerging. And my sense is we're seeing stability at current levels. As Brian said before, we first noticed a decline in Q2, and it picked up pace in Q3, but at this point it has more or less leveled off. Of course, the holidays are always a fascinating stretch — how promotional things get and which retailers come out ahead or behind — so that's something of an unknown, though broadly, when we examine spending behavior patterns across the aggregate, nothing suggests a continued slowdown. When we dig deeper into what I'd call the credit rate segments, it's been pretty steady, with your higher credit rates still consuming more than your lower credit rates. So we review that and conclude, alright, there's some stability as we head into the holiday season. To your point about whether a platform leads your client — I think you have to ask whether some platforms are far more discretionary, or whether others aren't, correct? So the ones with more discretionary spend will likely be down somewhat more than the rest. You still find strength in specific parts of the portfolio within the platform. For instance, bets (ph) are doing better than other areas within health and wellness, and that ought to keep going.
Brian Doubles
executiveOkay, so another point worth considering — look at the 2 years before this one. We're coming off all-time highs in what consumers were spending, and that's true not only for us but throughout the whole sector. And I believe everyone understood that eventually, inflation would catch up with the consumer, especially those at lower income levels, and that's what we're beginning to observe now. So in this kind of environment, a slowdown isn't necessarily a negative.
Mihir Bhatia
analystOkay, I appreciate you letting me ask.
Brian Wenzel
executiveYou're welcome, Mihir. I hope your day goes well.
Mark DeVries
analystYeah, thanks. Earlier you said you'd started to notice other companies making adjustments. I'd just like to hear what you've taken away from that — has it led you to conclude you have to recalibrate in order to stay competitive? It doesn't sound that way, based on the low attrition. Or, on the other hand, did you perhaps let a chance slip by to alter terms for certain borrowers you saw as more marginal?
Brian Wenzel
executiveYes. Thank you. Good morning. So, once more, we keep up a competitive screen of the folks in the partnership base business. Broad-based general purpose cards aren't really part of your focus, since their value propositions compete on entirely different terms. That said, whenever we look at players who've adjusted things on the partnership side as a competitive move, they've generally made similar changes related to APRs. Some have introduced measures tied to APR save fees (ph). So, taking in that whole landscape, we feel good about the steps we've taken. And once more, our attention goes primarily to how our portfolio is performing, our merchant relationships, and the value proposition we offer our customers. When you set the cost of a lending offering, it obviously needs to match what customers believe they're getting in return. Should those things fall out of balance, you'll end up with buyers who simply don't want what you're selling. So our attention stays mostly on our own approach. Looking at where competitors stand, we see ourselves sitting right alongside them rather than standing apart from the rest of the field.
Mark DeVries
analystAll right, understood. Thank you. Now, regarding the forecast for reserve coverage at year-end, it suggests a larger seasonal decline than what we observed over the past 2 years. Could you explain what is causing that?
Brian Wenzel
executiveSure. To begin with, the reserve coverage rate reflects a forward-looking assessment of how you expect losses to play out across a reasonable time horizon — that's the first point. The second point is whether there are additional factors outside your quantitative model that must be taken into account, with macroeconomic conditions being one example. As we consider the close of the year, the loss content implied by the delinquency we currently observe, and our sentiment around the macro environment, I believe we are at ease, and it will largely align with where we stood at the conclusion of last year.
Mark DeVries
analystAll right, thanks.
Brian Wenzel
executiveThanks. You too.
John Hecht
analystMorning, everyone. I appreciate you fielding my questions. A lot of ground has already been covered. I wanted to ask about health and wellness — that segment has consistently driven a solid share of growth. So I'm curious whether spending patterns there, in terms of discretionary versus non-discretionary, look anything like what you're seeing elsewhere. Is there anything unique about that category worth flagging, compared with the broader portfolio?
Brian Doubles
executiveSure, John — I'll kick this off, then pass it over to Brian. Here's how I'd frame it: health and wellness has been a major priority for us these past couple of years, we believe; we've earned the right to compete and win there; it's an enormous market, roughly $400 billion; things have softened a bit as of late. That said, when you zoom out to a slightly longer horizon, we've clearly managed to speed up growth in that area. We believe our value proposition is strong. Our brand is well-recognized. In fact, those products earn us our highest customer NPS and customer satisfaction scores; so our positioning in health and wellness feels excellent. As you'd expect, the softer trends you're seeing across the wider business show up most in larger-ticket discretionary items, and some of that is visible within CareCredit. Again, nothing that worries us, you're still generally seeing stronger growth there than across the rest of the business, thanks to the investments we've made so far.
Brian Wenzel
executiveSure, I can offer a bit more detail here. If you examine what's happening within the health and wellness sales platform and consider how varied it is, pets, for instance, were highlighted as being up 4% year-over-year. That means certain portions of that portfolio are performing well, while cosmetics declined 6%, and so on. You're seeing these mixed results, and we've discussed how consumers are being selective; some of the higher-priced dental offerings, which for many represent a cost that can be postponed, are down. So that's something to consider. The encouraging part we draw from that platform is, once again, the reason the card has reached 65%, an increase of 500 basis points compared with the rest of last year. So, as Brian points out, the Net Promoter Score and how well-liked this product is, its value proposition, and the brand behind it all connect with those customers. Therefore, we keep observing the usage, and we definitely will — this is a space where, once people start gravitating back toward some of the more discretionary kinds of procedures that aren't medical in nature, we'll start to see that improvement; and once more, having 10% loan growth year-over-year remains a very robust element of the portfolio and of our company strategy.
John Hecht
analystAll right, that's excellent, thank you. And then, as I understand it, you're bracing for multiple possible scenarios given everything surrounding the late fee issue. What I'd like to know is whether you could bring us up to speed on the litigation side of things. Is there anything scheduled in court or marked on the calendar that we ought to watch for — something that might serve as a development giving us additional insight into how this will ultimately play out?
Brian Wenzel
executiveSure thing, John. What I can tell you is that a hearing took place at the close of August. As things stand at this moment, we along with the plaintiffs are awaiting a ruling on the motion currently before the court, which concerns both venue and the standing of one of the plaintiffs involved in the case. No timeline has been set for that district court to rule on the motion. So that's what we're holding for. From there, it moves to the question of whether one of the parties on the opposing side of that decision might pursue an appeal with the Fifth Circuit, or whether the following motion would center on the injunction itself and whether that injunction ought to be dissolved at that point; so once again, I'd characterize this as a situation where we're simply waiting. Anyone attempting to forecast how this turns out has, I think it's safe to say, gotten it wrong. So making predictions isn't something we're doing at this point; we therefore keep running the business on the assumption that the late fee rule takes effect. And clearly we'll see what the court has to say regarding the litigation. That said, we clearly take comfort in the strength of our position in the litigation, though the reality is that it's uncertain by its very nature.
Brian Doubles
executiveWell, John, when you look at it, we had a plan ready, and the whole thing was put in motion to counteract the absolute worst scenario, which was 8 dollars by October 1. Clearly, that date has passed, and it's hard to predict when this will truly take effect. But when you consider it, every pricing move we introduced, along with policy adjustments and so on, was based on the assumption of an October 1 start date and 8 dollars. So as we essentially gain some time, that helps in that regard. Then again, we weren't — we lacked the option of sitting around. We moved fast on this and launched the pricing updates, and they're delivering the results we anticipated.
John Hecht
analystThat's great, and I appreciate it. Thanks a lot.
Brian Doubles
executiveGreat. Have a good day, John.
Jeff Adelson
analystHello, good morning. Thank you for fielding my question, everyone. I'd like to revisit the outlook for loan growth along with a few of the credit measures you've implemented; from what I gather, it seems you might have dialed back how aggressively you're pursuing those credit steps taken earlier this year. So if we assume that approach remains unchanged as of now, does that suggest the decelerating pattern you expect as we close out the year — roughly that low single-digit growth rate — could potentially turn around and head upward in the following year? Or what conditions would need to occur for it to speed up again? And how should we eventually view the timing for returning to that high single-digit longer-term growth rate that you aim for?
Brian Wenzel
executiveYes. Thank you, Jeff, for asking. And good morning. The first point I'd like to make clear: when we take action, many of these are strategic moves that aren't tied to a particular moment. For example, certain steps we've taken regarding debt consolidation loans and student loans — to some extent, that strategy is already in effect right now. So these are continuous; they aren't fresh initiatives; they're the same initiatives, just depending on whether an account qualifies for that initiative. So once more, the steps we're implementing now tend to be more specific, driven by a partner channel or a product's performance in relation to the risk adjusted return. I think when you consider how credit actions unfold and how the consumer behaves, as Brian pointed out earlier, we're certainly in a stretch of time that's somewhat more transitional, correct? So you've got affordability challenges for certain lower end, lower income consumers. With any luck, as interest rates decline and inflation declines, that eases somewhat and relieves some of that strain. Keep in mind, much of the strain on our credit right now comes not really from the consumer's economic situation, but rather from too much credit extended and placed into the system during '21 to early '23, which has to work its way through the system. I think once that starts to ease, which I believe you're observing among certain issuers throughout the industry, that provides us a bit of a tailwind, meaning we can start to roll back some of the restrictive credit measures we've taken over the last two years, possibly in the later portion of '25; but once again, that will depend on performance. So I don't view this as a long-term pattern for growth; it's likely beneficial during this stretch when credit is somewhat more uncertain, but clearly our long-term framework and our models are designed to produce 7% to 10% lower sales of growth.
Jeff Adelson
analystFor my follow-up — I realize you aren't quantifying the PPPC factor within that line, but might you discuss the way your monitoring compares with that original $650 million to $700 million figure you mentioned earlier in the year? And perhaps remind us about any PPPC adjustments you're delaying right now until the late fee rule gets through — or if it gets through, I should say?
Brian Wenzel
executiveYes. The way I look at it, Jeff, is definitely consistent with — when I mention customer attrition being lower, that represents movement between the BAU bucket and this bucket; so once more, I'd step back and say, if you pulled back and viewed things from 10,000 feet, I think you'd conclude the PPPC actions, PPPC actions by and large align with and correspond performing (ph) somewhat better. Yet again, at the moment I raised earlier, the neutrality point as we examine the analysis hasn't shifted for us. It's truly just the trough. So when does the rule take effect and what's our path to there. But that point hasn't been delayed. I know we haven't truly discussed that since we want to be able to grasp when that rule goes into place. And the moment it does, we'll definitely give that neutrality point. But once more, things are performing by and large in-line and the core has performed somewhat better than our expectations, which I think is shown in the outlook on Page 12.
Jeff Adelson
analystAll right, that's excellent. I appreciate it.
Rick Shane
analystHey everyone. I'm grateful you're letting me ask. I had this worry that Jeff would use up all the time before I got a chance. So, I get that thinking about the CECL reserve is hypothetical, and I also understand that any guidance regarding your reserve rate amounts to a hypothetical built on top of another hypothetical. Still, I'm wondering—when we examine the reserve rate from the third quarter, it's essentially sitting at a peak for the cycle. Meanwhile, your guidance for the fourth quarter puts it back at levels seen in '23. You've only gained 16 days of additional information, yet it seems you've shifted from an outlook that was highly cautious to one that's cautious to a lesser degree. What's different, or what is it mechanically that's causing this kind of decrease, which Mark DeVries at also mentioned?
Brian Wenzel
executiveYes. Morning to you. Rick, I'm happy we let the time expire. I realize you needed to pose your query. To put it plainly, the whole matter traces back to the denominator. At present, your loss content is substantial, correct? I mean, within your own model, you can absolutely determine what the Q4 loss figure ought to be and what the Q1 dollar losses ought to be; it simply turns into the denominator. Therefore, I wouldn't characterize this as us attempting to be more cautious or steering toward something implying we see a fundamentally altered credit path; rather, it's just the mechanics involved in computing your reserve against an end-of-period loan figure.
Rick Shane
analystGot it, okay. Thank you very much guys.
Brian Doubles
executiveThanks Rick.
Brian Wenzel
executiveThanks Rick, have a good day.
Operator
operatorAppreciate it. That brings Synchrony's earnings conference call to a close. At this point you're free to hang up, and I hope the rest of your day goes wonderfully.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Synchrony Financial transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Synchrony Financial earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Synchrony Financial or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.