Visa Inc. (V) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
July 28, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Mike Milotich
executiveThank you, Jordan. Hello, everyone, and welcome to Visa's earnings call for the fiscal third quarter of 2020. Joining us are Al Kelly, our Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, and Vasant Prabhu, our Vice Chairman and Chief Financial Officer. You can listen to this call via webcast on the Investor Relations portion of our site, www.investor.visa.com. A recording will remain available there for 30 days. We've also posted a slide presentation with financial and statistical highlights on the IR website. Please note that this presentation contains forward-looking statements. Such statements don't guarantee future performance, and a variety of factors could cause our actual results to differ materially. You can find further details about those factors in our latest reports on Forms 10-K, 10-Q, and 8-K, which are posted on the SEC's website as well as in the Investor Relations section of our own site. Regarding any historical non-GAAP financial information discussed on this call, today's earnings release contains the corresponding GAAP measures along with the reconciliation. With that said, I'll now hand things over to Al.
Al Kelly
executiveMike, thanks so much. These last several months have definitely remained difficult, and our attention has always been—and will continue to be—on the welfare of the people who work for us, the clients we serve, and the communities where we do business. Despite major hits to economies across the globe, plenty of parts of Visa's operations have shown themselves to be durable and have carried on—and we've kept investing to drive Visa's growth far into the future across consumer payments, new flows and value-added services. Later today, after we go through our results, I'll give you a picture of how COVID-19 is changing the way consumers, businesses and governments wish to pay and get paid, and how Visa, in turn, is assisting them. I'll finish with some noteworthy deal highlights from the quarter that show how we keep enabling money to move around the world. So let's begin with our third quarter results. Net revenues for the fiscal third quarter came to $4.8 billion, down 17%, or 16% in constant dollars. Every one of the business drivers took a significant hit from the pandemic. Payments volume fell 10% globally this quarter, or 9% with China excluded. During the quarter, our network handled 30.7 billion transactions—over 337 million daily—which represents a 13% decline versus the same period last year. Cross-border volume excluding intra-Europe, the key factor driving our international transaction revenue, fell 47% on a constant-dollar basis, largely due to the lack of travel. When intra-Europe volume is counted, the decrease was 37%. Even so, the underlying business trends improved month by month throughout the quarter—substantially for payments volume and processed transactions, though only slightly for cross-border volume. Regarding new flows, Visa Direct's worldwide transaction count climbed by a percentage in the mid-60s compared with the same period a year earlier; value-added services revenue also grew at a mid-teens rate year over year; expenses stayed firmly under control, falling 5%, and crucially that reduction came while leaving spending on our core growth programs intact. Non-GAAP EPS fell 23%. COVID-19 undoubtedly shaped our fiscal third-quarter results, yet numerous trends are accelerating demand across consumer payments, new flows and value-added services, which should work in our favor going forward. Turning to consumer payments, despite all that Visa has achieved in digitizing payments, $18 trillion worldwide is still settled using cash and checks. Right now, folks are wary of physical contact with surfaces—including cash and checks—and that's reflected in growing curiosity about and adoption of tap to pay. We know this feature helps digitize cash at low ticket sizes, and in mature markets around the world it has typically lifted transaction counts by roughly 20% over time. Between Q2 and Q3, close to 50 nations saw tap to pay penetration climb by over five percentage points, while more than 10 countries gained at least 10 percentage points. We've assisted over 55 countries in increasing their tap to pay limits, reducing the portion of transactions needing consumer contact by over 40% in quite a few of them. In the U.S. between January and June of 2020, we issued more than 80 million contactless cards, as multiple banking partners accelerated when they brought those cards out. Use of tap-to-pay likely will accelerate following COVID, especially when people head back to workplaces, since that is where they tend to handle smaller purchases tied to getting around—covering transit fares and buying meals and beverages. Another positive development we have seen is the shift to online shopping. This works in our favor, since Visa accounts for about triple the share of digital commerce—where paying with cash isn't possible—compared with what it holds at brick-and-mortar points of sale. In the U.S., the number of Visa credentials active in e-commerce, travel excluded, was up more than 12% in June versus January. On top of that, average spend for each active credential climbed more than 6% over the same stretch, which is striking because newcomers usually spend less than those who are used to buying online. In fact, when you look only at the active credentials that are considerably more engaged in e-commerce, spend per active credential rose by more than 25%. And the U.S. isn't the only place seeing these patterns. In the U.K. over this timeframe, the number of active e-commerce credentials climbed 16%, and spend for each active credential was up 3%. For Brazil, active e-commerce credentials increased 11%, with spend per active credential up 12%. Where e-commerce is less mature, some markets show striking adoption jumps. Argentina posted growth above 100% in active e-commerce cards, and Romania reached 70%. On new flows, we remained focused on the $185 trillion opportunity; within B2B, that opportunity covers card-based payments, accounts payable and receivable, and cross-border payments. Although B2B volume has declined amid this work-from-home period with very limited travel, we keep expanding our capabilities and relationships to support future growth. A few brief points from the quarter. We just formed a worldwide partnership with Conferma Pay, a U.K. fintech, that allows businesses to put virtual Visa commercial cards into employees' digital wallets, which makes tap-to-pay possible and streamlines expense reimbursement; as for Visa B2B Connect, our large-ticket cross-border B2B offering, we're still expanding that network. A lot of banks are currently implementing it. And once they're all live by the end of this year, Visa will be handling cross-border transactions in half of the 80 markets where Visa's B2B Connect capability is offered. Now let's turn to the rest of new flows. In the U.S., P2P is up nearly 80%. Latin America also showed advancement, particularly with peer-to-peer applications in Peru, where Q3 transaction volume rose almost 400% compared with Q2. In addition, Visa is pleased to reveal a worldwide collaboration with PayPal that encompasses Venmo, Braintree, Zoom, iZettle and Hyperwallet. This builds upon a regional relationship with PayPal that has existed for a long time. This fresh worldwide arrangement is going to let PayPal and every one of its brands provide rapid domestic and cross-border payments enabled by Visa Direct, and it will extend PayPal's real-time transfer capabilities across the globe; within the gig economy food and grocery delivery segment, transactions have grown almost 50% compared with pre-COVID levels, and we've kept adding new program launches like Instacart for shopper earnings payouts in Canada. G2C government-to-consumer use cases are building momentum through a combination of Visa Direct and prepaid cards; this quarter, allow me to highlight a few of the card examples. In the U.S., the Treasury sent out close to four million economic impact payments using Visa prepaid cards. We also worked with CaixaBank in Spain on three initiatives, distributing 330,000 prepaid Visa cards carrying government-allocated funds to support vulnerable families across the region; in France, Natixis joined forces with Visa to issue 15,000 cards as a gesture of thanks to frontline hospital workers, with government financing. On the value-added services front, a growing number of clients are approaching us for help. With e-commerce expanding and new sellers looking to offer safe and secure omnicommerce payment capabilities, our CyberSource and fraud and risk capabilities have seen growth. Here are two recent examples.
Al Kelly
executiveWe recently had a win in Saudi Arabia with Al Rajhi Bank, which is the largest acquiring bank in that country, and they'll use CyberSource to power an e-commerce payments platform serving all Saudi Arabian government services via a centralized interface with the Ministry of Finance. Buying online and picking up in-store has grown quite popular with consumers and is a key way for sellers to operate in this environment. That said, this use case does carry a higher potential for fraud. One home improvement partner picked Decision Manager, a CyberSource fraud offering, to review online orders for fraud risk quickly and meet customer expectations for a two-hour pickup. That generated a huge increase in Decision Manager transactions just in May for this merchant. For all CyberSource risk products combined in Q3, transaction volume rose close to 50% compared with a year earlier. We're also seeing more interest in our authentication offerings. CardinalCommerce, whose network-agnostic products let sellers and issuers take advantage of the 3D Secure standard, experienced faster transaction growth this quarter than it did last year. 3D Secure is also advancing steadily across Europe, where the ecosystem is building momentum before the secure customer authentication mandate takes effect in December for most of Europe. As that deadline nears, we keep collaborating with ecosystem participants, since some of them aren't prepared for it. During the third quarter, EMV 3D Secure transaction volumes rose by more than 100% relative to the second quarter. Our data and consulting offerings continue to be valuable to clients as they steer through this environment. Clients turned to our consulting services at a faster pace, completing nearly 60% more projects than they did in the third quarter of last year. Visa is essential in delivering data and analysis that assist clients in running their businesses through the pandemic. Client activity on our Visa Analytics Platform alone climbed 60% from the second quarter. Let me now turn to new deals, an area where we achieved strong progress this quarter. To begin, our European momentum is carrying forward. We renewed our agreement with Nordea, among the largest banks in the Nordics, to expand debit portfolios throughout the region. Our relationship with Permanent TSB has grown — that's a major Irish issuer holding more than 800,000 active cards, and thanks to this, Visa now serves as the main card across most Irish wallets. In Switzerland, we just broadened our UBS tie-up into debit. Processing wins are coming our way too. Over in Spain, we landed a sizable agreement that extends our domestic transaction processing. Banco Caminos is set to shift both its issuing and acquiring volume off its local processor and onto Visa. When it came to forging and refreshing partnerships this quarter, Europe proved no exception. In Singapore, we’ve renewed our partnership with the second-largest debit issuer, OCBC Bank, so that we remain the preferred debit card issued to OCBC Bank’s personal savings and current account customers. In Korea, we recently secured a renewal with South Korea’s biggest issuer, Shinhan Card. We renewed our credit and debit partnership with Banco de Bogota, our largest issuer client in Colombia. We recently secured a new issuance win with Kaspi Bank, which ranks among Kazakhstan’s biggest retail banks. Over the coming few years, that bank is transitioning fully — 100% — to Visa. And our co-brand leadership also carried forward. During this quarter, Visa renewed and broadened its strategic alliance with Best Buy, which includes an extension of the My Best Buy co-brand relationship. Ford and Visa are going to work together on Ford's new FordPass Rewards Visa Card, made available to the 4 million members of FordPass Rewards as well as other Ford customers. One more recent co-brand victory came with Verizon, to launch a Visa credit card delivering savings on Verizon's industry-leading products and services, plus benefits for everyday and essential purposes. We also signed a co-brand agreement with Tiki, among Vietnam's leading e-commerce platforms. A crucial element in building issuance and acceptance involves fintechs; and in this quarter we landed numerous wallet and neobank wins around the world. Let me mention a few. Careem, the largest ride-hailing app across the Middle East and Africa, will provide driver payouts through Visa Direct as well as credentials to its user base of more than 35 million. Octopus, Hong Kong's digital transit card, will accept Visa wallet top-ups, letting commuters pay for transport and pay at 35,000 retail outlets. In Saudi Arabia, we entered a strategic partnership with Hala <<inaudible>>, a rising challenger bank that could potentially reach an unbanked population of as many as 7 million people. Vivid Money, a neobank, has formally entered the German market. It provides Visa debit cards through a single mobile app that bundles inventive savings features along with cash-back offerings. Over in the United States, Chime — which is U.S.-based and holds more than 8 million accounts — rolled out access to a fresh Visa secured credit card. That product enables consumers to establish credit as they spend on routine items like groceries and monthly subscriptions. Partnerships, as I have frequently noted, sit at the core of Visa's business model, and these renewed agreements plus new ones will undoubtedly assist in fueling growth going forward. Prior to wrapping up, I would be failing in my duty if I did not address the race situation both in this country and across the globe. Over 400 years, Black and African-American people have faced numerous kinds of social injustice and discrimination. That is offensive, it is frustrating, and it is unacceptable. This has to end. Here at Visa, we are dedicated to contributing our share. Visa recently shared the next steps on our path toward fostering inclusion and diversity throughout our company. We have announced several actions, among them the creation of a Visa scholars and jobs program. And crucially, last week we announced our commitment to raising the count of underrepresented U.S. vice presidents and above by 50% over the coming three years, along with boosting the number of underrepresented U.S. colleagues across Visa as a whole by 50% over the coming five years. To wrap up, although the near term certainly carries some uncertainty, we continue to feel confident in our long-term strategy, our growth prospects, and our capacity to make a positive difference in the world. During this quarter, net revenue, EPS, overall payments volume, cross-border volume, and processed transactions all declined. Even so, we achieved growth in debit and in e-commerce volumes within Visa Direct transactions, along with growth in tap to pay and click-to-pay enablement and in value-added services revenue. In addition, our discipline has been evident: we reduced expenses by 5% this quarter while still investing in future growth, and we returned capital to shareholders at historic levels and maintained our dividend. Every one of those factors shows the strength and durability of how we operate. Thanks to our size, a brand people trust, digital offerings, financial flexibility, and most importantly a gifted team, we're set to emerge from this pandemic in an even better position. We still believe strongly in how effective our worldwide network strategy is, because we enable money to move for everyone, everywhere; for more detail, I'll hand things over to Vasant.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveThanks, Al, and good afternoon, everyone. Just like we did last quarter, we'll give you a good deal of detail on the business trends we're seeing as we work our way through this unprecedented period. I'll start with the main business drivers, then go over our financial results, and finish with a few thoughts on the next quarter. Beginning with U.S. payments volume. During the quarter, U.S. payments volume fell 7%, and a steep drop from mid-April was followed by a V-shaped recovery in domestic spending. April volumes were down 18%, before turning positive in June. July volumes through the 21st are up 7%; this rebound got its start from the economic impact payments and enhanced unemployment benefits, was aided by fulfillment of pent-up demand, and was accelerated by the easing of shelter in place requirements. Debit beat credit by almost 30 points. Debit spending rose 8%, while credit spending fell 21% in the quarter. Credit spending recovered 21 points, going from a 30% decline in April to a 9% decline in July through the 21st. Debit spending jumped 30 points, from down 5% in April to up 25% in July. Several factors explain why debit outperformed credit. Some are more likely to last than others. First, the government's economic impact payments went directly into consumers' checking accounts, which benefited debit. Second, when the economy is uncertain, consumers tend to shift spending away from money they borrow toward money they have in the bank. Third, as you know, there's been a big shift to online purchases in almost every — in most everyday spend categories, and that favors debit. Fourth, affluent customers tend to use credit for discretionary spending in categories like travel, entertainment and restaurants, which the pandemic has hit especially hard. Fifth, the last tranche of economic impact payments, along with unemployment benefits in over 20 states, were distributed through Visa prepaid cards, which lifted debit growth by several points in May and June. Finally, in the U.S., Visa Direct was up over 75% this quarter, thanks to strong growth across a variety of use cases ranging from P2P to insurance payouts to payroll. The substantial growth in debit shows how the pandemic has accelerated the secular shift from cash to digital forms of payment. The COVID crisis has also significantly sped up the secular shift to e-commerce. Card not present spend excluding travel has grown over 25% every week since mid-April, which is 2x the pre-COVID growth rate. Card present spending improved steadily through the quarter as reopenings took effect, going from a decline of almost 50% in early April to a decline in the high single-digits by late June, but there's been little improvement since; it's too early to tell what all the underlying causes of this recent stabilization are. Recovery trajectories for card present volumes are relatively similar across states; in terms of U.S. When we look at spending by category, leaving Visa Direct aside, performance falls into three groups according to how COVID affected them and the recovery we have witnessed so far. Each of these groups accounts for approximately one-third of our U.S. payments volume. Group one covers categories like food and drug stores, home improvement, and retail goods. Week after week since mid-April, these have grown steadily at or above their pre-COVID rates — in the high teens or better. Group two takes in categories that saw spending fall between 10% and 50% in April and had fully returned to growth by the close of June; this segment covers automotive, retail services, department and apparel stores, health care, education, government and business supplies. Group three is made up of the categories suffering most from this pandemic: travel, entertainment, fuel and restaurants. In April these fell over 50% and they are still contracting year-over-year, though each one gained between 20 and 45 points over the course of the quarter. Travel is still the hardest-hit category, remaining down over 50%. Fuel gallons purchased are rising once more, yet spend is more than 15% lower in July because of cheaper prices. Inside the restaurant category, card present spend keeps falling, whereas card not present spend is still climbing substantially, with quick-service restaurants doing better than others. Now turning to trends elsewhere in the world. International payments volume was down over 12% in constant dollars during the third quarter. As in the U.S., debit clearly beat credit, with debit falling only 3% while credit dropped 20%. Card present spend got better as the quarter went on and countries reopened, while card not present spend, excluding travel, stayed elevated. Category performance was broadly comparable to the U.S. CEMEA remains our strongest region, down 5% in constant dollars. Inside CEMEA, Russia, Eastern Europe and Central Asia posted positive growth for the quarter, helped by a swift rebound following April declines along with client wins. Europe payments volume fell 10% in constant dollars in the third quarter. Central and Southeastern Europe — including Poland, the Czech Republic and Hungary — bounced back quickly and posted positive growth for the quarter. The U.K. went back to growth in June, powered by consistently strong card not present growth. Italy, after one of Europe's strictest lockdowns, is nearly back to prior year levels in June. Canada was down 15% and Latin America was down 13% in constant dollars. Brazil's spend decline early in the quarter was among the shallowest, yet its recovery has also been slow. Brazil is now close to 2019 levels of domestic spending, lifted by strong card not present growth. Asia Pacific payments volume fell 16% in constant dollars. Reopening across Asian economies has come gradually, in multiple phases depending on the country. Korea and New Zealand were two of the least affected countries, both roughly flat for the quarter. By late June, domestic spending in Japan and Australia had returned to 2019 levels. India is still among the markets most impacted worldwide. Processed transactions were down 13% for the quarter. While that trails volume growth because of a mix shift, the recovery path for processed transactions looks much the same, improving from a 24% decline in April to a 4% decline in June. For July through the 21st, growth is flat. Within the domestic market, the mix of spend has moved away from low ticket toward higher ticket categories. Cross-border transactions, by contrast, are holding up better than volumes, thanks to the mix shift from high ticket travel-related spending toward lower ticket non-travel e-commerce. Cross-border — constant dollar cross-border volume excluding volume within Europe fell 47% in the third quarter. Volumes were down 51% in April and improved slightly in May to a 45% decline, but there has been little change since. For the month of June and in July through the 21st, the rate of decline has remained at 44%. Constant dollar cross-border volume including volume within Europe was down 37% in the quarter. It's important to remind you that cross-border volume excluding volume within Europe is what drives our international fees. As you know, the decline in cross-border spend is driven by travel. Travel-related spend, which includes both card present and card not present in travel categories, accounted for roughly two-third of our pre-COVID cross-border volume excluding volume within Europe.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveSpending tied to travel fell 78% during the quarter and was still down more than 70% as June came to a close. A rebound in cross-border travel requires borders to reopen. Right now, most borders are still shut. At the close of June, the World Tourism Organization reported that 189 of 217 countries — 87% — had fully or partly closed their borders to foreign visitors. Among the other 28 countries, 10 had fully or partly suspended flights. A number of others, such as the U.K., require quarantines, while the remainder imposed visa limits or require medical certificates. As things stand, crossing borders, particularly by air, is either impossible or very hard. While no individual route makes up a large portion of our volume — contributes significantly to our volume — some of our major routes remain shut. We can't predict how cross-border recovery will unfold until borders open again. In the few routes where border crossing is currently allowed, we've seen substantial recoveries. For example, Americans are traveling to Mexico and the Caribbean once more. Cross-border card-present volumes in those routes have recovered by 30 to 40 points since the April low. Travel among Switzerland, France and Germany is almost back to usual levels. Russian travel to neighboring nations has increased. Travel from Europe to the UAE is building momentum; it matters to note that the overwhelming bulk of cross-border travel spending sits on personal cards rather than business travel. Consumer demand for travel to see friends and relatives and for vacations is more apt to stay intact after COVID — perhaps even grow. The consumer travel rebound will probably begin with people visiting countries inside their geographic comfort zone. That is already apparent in short-haul cross-border travel, which we define as under 3,000 miles. Short-haul air travel is bouncing back faster than longer-haul corridors. In the same way, drive-to hotels are performing better, as are leisure hotels compared with business hotels. Since the middle of April, cross-border e-commerce spending growth, when travel is excluded, has stayed steady in the high teens to low 20s. Retail spending, which is up about 30% since mid-April and accounts for most non-travel e-commerce spend, is driving that strong growth. In most countries, when a consumer chooses to buy online rather than go to a local store, the likelihood increases that the transaction becomes cross-border, and they pay little heed to the item's shipping origin. Offsetting retail's strength are declines in entertainment, education, and government, several of which tie to travel and represent a significant portion of card-not-present non-travel spend. A good deal of the detail I just provided omits volume within Europe. Within the EU, borders have mostly reopened. Intra-Europe cross-border card-present spend has risen 40 points from the April trough through three weeks in July — one more sign of the potential path of cross-border recovery once borders do reopen. Let me give you a brief rundown of the third quarter's financial results. Net revenues fell 17% for the quarter, or 16% on a constant-dollar basis. Service revenues in the third quarter were flat versus the prior year and mirror the volumes from last quarter. Data processing revenues were down 5%, helped by robust growth in value-added services along with acquisition-related revenue. International transaction revenues fell 44%, consistent with the drop in cross-border volumes when volume within Europe is excluded. Compared with the prior year, other revenues declined 8%, reflecting the impact of the pandemic on value-added services. The value-added services affected by the pandemic include diminished utilization of card benefits tied to travel, a decrease in marketing-related services provided to clients as numerous clients reduced their marketing efforts, and fees that were waived for certain services that experienced a surge when the pandemic initially struck. It is important to note that had we reported service fees without a lag, service fees would have declined 11%, and reported net revenues would have decreased by an additional 4.5 points, to approximately 21.5%. These reduced service fees will impact our reported revenues in the next quarter. Before I proceed, allow me to provide a bit more detail regarding where value-added services revenues appear in the P&L. In the third quarter, total revenue from value-added services increased by a mid-teens percentage, with acquisitions included. Since a lot of our value-added services consist of transaction-based revenue streams, approximately two-thirds of that revenue falls under data processing. Growth in these services was in the mid-teens, powered by U.S. debit and prepaid issuer processing, CyberSource, and authentication and fraud services, as Al pointed out. Service fees and other revenue account for the remaining value-added services revenue, split roughly evenly between them. Service fees and value-added services likewise rose in the mid-teens. Value-added services recorded in other revenues posted mid-single-digit growth, aided by acquisitions, increased adoption of our data products, and consulting, which was partly offset by reduced use of the card benefits and marketing services I mentioned earlier. Client incentives declined 2% versus a year ago, representing 23.8% of gross revenue. As we have noted before, the vast majority of incentives are linked to payments volumes. However, incentives decreased by a smaller amount than gross revenue, causing incentives to rise as a share of gross revenue. Let me walk through the reasons. First, incentives are typically tied to total payments volumes and only in select cases to cross-border volumes. Since cross-border volumes have declined more sharply than total payments volumes, and cross-border volumes carry higher yields, the drop in incentives lags the drop in gross revenue. Second, elevated renewal activity, similar to what occurred in fiscal year 2019, causes incentives to increase more rapidly than gross revenue. So as revenue falls, incentive costs don't drop as fast. The service fee lag is partly offsetting these dynamics. As I mentioned before, that lag made this quarter's gross revenue decline look smaller. Next quarter, it will work against us. Third quarter GAAP and non-GAAP operating expenses were down 5%, since we managed to execute further cost management efforts, particularly in marketing and G&A. We achieved these reductions while continuing to fund our longer-term growth initiatives. Acting early and with conviction let us lower expenses rapidly. For the fiscal third quarter, non-GAAP non-operating expense was $118 million. Interest income was lower due to a sharp drop in interest rates. Higher interest expense came from the $4 billion in debt we issued. Our non-GAAP tax rate was 19%. Let me offer some perspective on the fourth quarter. Revenue forecasting remains difficult in the current environment. When borders will reopen is hard to predict, and so is the shape of cross-border travel recovery once they do. In most countries, domestic volumes have bounced back well, and inevitably the recovery pace will decelerate. Additional uncertainties include how the recent infection spike plays out and the economic effects as stimulus payments taper or come to an end worldwide. Here are a few things to keep in mind as you model revenue growth for next quarter. Like I mentioned before, if service revenues had been reported with no lag, our Q3 net revenue would have been 4.5% lower than what we posted; because of that, assuming key business drivers don't shift in trend, reported net revenue growth for Q4 will come in below the third quarter's figure.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveOngoing improvement in domestic payment volumes and transactions is going to help the trajectory for data processing revenue, though it won't help reported service revenues. Higher incentives tied to rising volumes will partly counteract that. So the single biggest factor that would lift the fourth quarter net revenue growth rate is cross-border volume excluding intra-Europe. Another thing worth noting, given these turbulent times: should the cross-border recovery stay weak through the fourth quarter, the shift in revenue mix away from cross-border will continue. Factor in the service fee lag as well, and incentives as a percent of gross revenues will probably rise by two to three points compared with third quarter levels; that percentage ought to normalize as cross-border volumes pick up and the domestic volume recovery settles. For the fourth quarter, non-GAAP operating expenses should come down about in line with the reductions we achieved in the third quarter. Non-GAAP non-operating expenses should land near $140 million. Despite a significant COVID-19 impact, we expect to produce a very healthy amount of free cash flow this year; we closed the quarter holding more than $17 billion in cash equivalents and investment securities. With favorable access to the commercial paper market and our $5 billion revolver, our liquidity position stays strong; during the third quarter we repurchased 5.2 million shares for almost $900 million, at an average price of $180.47. So far this year, we have bought back 36 million shares for $6.5 billion at an average price of approximately $180. Our dividend policy is unchanged. Crises bring both risks and opportunities. We have acted quickly to mitigate risk by securing strong liquidity, cutting expenses while continuing key growth investments, and keeping a close watch on network performance, security, daily settlement, fraud and other key metrics. The crisis sped up many favorable secular trends: digitization of cash, the move to e-commerce and adoption of tap to pay. Visa Direct momentum remains very strong, and value-added services have kept growing in the mid-teens. We remain focused on helping all our stakeholders, cardholders, clients, governments, regulators and, of course, our own associates as they navigate these unusual times. With that, I'll hand this back to Mike.
Al Kelly
executiveMike, I think you're on mute. Mike, you're on mute.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveAl maybe we should turn to questions. Operator, why don't we move to questions?
Al Kelly
executiveSo Vasant, I also gather there was a technical glitch, which means some folks may not have caught the tail end of what I said and the start of what you said.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveOkay.
Al Kelly
executiveI'm seeking a bit of — I was hoping Mike might offer us some guidance on whether summarizing those points would be appropriate. Perhaps...
Vasant Prabhu
executiveMike is suggesting we keep going.
Al Kelly
executiveAll right, so here's what I'd propose: let me give a quick recap of the points I made at the close, and then perhaps you could spend a moment on U.S. debit before we take questions.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveOkay.
Al Kelly
executiveWhat I said was that the future certainly will carry uncertainty with it, but our belief in the strategy and in our growth prospects remains. Sure, some things did decline during the quarter: net revenue, EPS, overall payments volume, cross-border volume and processed transactions. Yet growth showed up in a number of important areas: debit grew, e-commerce volumes grew, Visa Direct transactions grew, tap to pay grew, click-to-pay enablement advanced, and value-added services revenue grew. We also showed we can cut expenses while still investing in the future, and we returned capital to shareholders at historic levels and kept our dividend. So all in all, we believe our business model is resilient, and we have plenty of confidence in the efficacy of our global network of network strategy. I think it would help if Vasant could comment on U.S. debit, because my understanding is that a lot of people might not have heard it.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveAll right, Al. Yes. So I explained the reasons debit has been outperforming credit. You may have heard that debit has recovered roughly 30 points and now is expanding at around 25% during the first three weeks of July, while credit's rebound was smaller and it is still contracting 9% through those same first three weeks of July, while credit's rebound was smaller and it is still contracting 9% through those same first three weeks of July. I covered six explanations for this. I'll go through them fast. Economic impact payments deposited straight into checking accounts benefit debit. When the economy is uncertain, consumers do move spending away from borrowed money toward funds sitting in the bank. Reason three, the move to online has shifted many everyday spending categories into e-commerce, which has helped debit, since debit typically covers everyday purchases. Reason four, affluent customers tend to use credit for discretionary things such as travel, entertainment and restaurants, which have been particularly hard-hit during times like these. Reason five, the economic impact payments were delivered via Visa prepaid cards across 20 states, including unemployment benefits, and that boosted our debit growth in May and June. And last, Visa Direct, which supports our debit figures, rose more than 75% this quarter as many use cases did really well. So I think we'll probably stop there, Al, and take questions. I think we might have lost Mike, so we can take questions.
Mike Milotich
executiveJordanne, can you hear us? Jordanne, it would be great if we could move on to Q&A.
Lisa Ellis
analystOkay then. Hi everyone, good afternoon. I assume you're able to hear me, hopefully.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveThat's right, we can hear you.
Lisa Ellis
analystI want to bring up something that wasn't addressed on this call. Al, I have a question for you regarding big tech. Those large technology firms are under heightened regulatory scrutiny at the moment — clearly very much in evidence right now both in the U.S. and in Europe — concerning certain of their competitive practices. Could you speak to how that scrutiny, in your view, is impacting any of those companies' payment efforts? Specifically, is there anything — any practices on their part that you at Visa, or Visa, would say ought to be examined? And beyond that, do you see this kind of regulatory pressure on big tech as a positive for the payments ecosystem and for Visa, or possibly as a negative? Thank you.
Al Kelly
executiveWell, Lisa, as you can probably imagine, we maintain relationships with every one of the companies you'd classify as big techs. A few of them are somewhat broader than others, but we definitely have ties with all of them. I'm certainly not able to comment, and wouldn't comment, on the regulatory scrutiny they're going through; however, if payments are involved and we can be of assistance to them, or of assistance to the government by advocating or clarifying the situation, we will step in. There was an instance involving a payment initiative we were pursuing with Facebook in Brazil during the last month, where we did exactly that, as an illustration. I believe these big techs have — certainly, they've drawn huge numbers of users and built relationships with them. And a portion of those relationships will need money movement or payment capability. And we absolutely want to be present, and to be the partner working alongside them on those specific matters; and we'll leave it to them to sort out and handle whatever regulatory issues they face. And we're only a phone call away, should we be able to help. But I believe in most instances, it's more or less on them to resolve those. Jordanne, next question?
Matthew O'Neill
analystYes. Hello, and thanks for taking my question. I was hoping you might share some anecdotal perspectives on what I believe is likely the next stage of the secular catalyst here — the silver lining of this pandemic, if there is one, which is clearly that e-com growth has been robust. But how are bank partners and merchant partners thinking about the return to brick-and-mortar commerce, given what will inevitably be much greater demand for contactless payments? Then, if I could just ask a quick unrelated follow-up: I was wondering whether there's any update on the Plaid acquisition and any remarks regarding the lawsuit there? Thank you so much.
Al Kelly
executiveWell, interestingly enough, as you probably saw in some of our charts, card-not-present has — I'm sorry, as card-not-present has begun working its way back, it lagged; obviously card-not-present was hit much harder by the pandemic. Card-not-present volumes have held up, so no declines are showing up there. And I think all issuers and anyone rooting for economies worldwide to recover would love a situation in which both card-not-present and card-present bounce back, and bricks-and-mortar commerce on main streets and in communities across the globe keeps growing. I think the case for contactless, Matt, has been made. We've seen consumers, governments, and merchants voting through their actions, and contactless — or tap to pay — had tremendous momentum heading into COVID; and if anything, COVID accelerated tap to pay's momentum even in the United States, which we know has been further behind, but as I cited, we've added 80,000 — or I'm sorry, our issuers have added 80 million credentials that are tap to pay-enabled during the first six months of the year. Roughly 80% of the merchant volume occurring in the face-to-face world is occurring at terminals enabled for tap to pay; so I think it will simply keep growing everywhere around the world. And I believe the COVID situation will help speed up growth here in the United States at a perhaps faster pace than would otherwise have happened. As for Plaid —
Vasant Prabhu
executiveAl, let me tack on a couple of points here. As you're aware, innovation often emerges from a crisis. If anything, this situation has pushed an increasing number of merchants to concentrate on omni-channel commerce, and CyberSource sits right at the heart of that. Merchants are steadily getting more adept at serving customers seamlessly across bricks-and-mortar locations and e-commerce alike; it has also prompted plenty of categories that had never embraced e-commerce to become considerably stronger at it. You've witnessed that across numerous everyday spend categories. You've witnessed it with restaurants. And more widely in retail, people have devised more inventive approaches — curbside delivery, for instance, has been honed in many respects. That, we believe, is going to stick around, and it's essentially a model where you place an order online yet may collect it in person. So you gain an additional delivery choice: it can arrive after a delay of a day or two, or you can obtain it immediately by going to pick it up. So plenty is happening. And I think the key point Al raised was that even while card-present has improved from minus 50 to minus high single-digits, card-not-present has remained very robust, continuing to grow at those mid-20s levels for quite a while now. So lots of changes are underway.
Al Kelly
executiveMatt, I'll take your question about Plaid. Regulatory approval is still outstanding. We definitely expect to complete the deal before the calendar year ends, and we're making every effort to meet whatever the regulators reviewing it ask of us. Our enthusiasm for the Plaid acquisition is just as strong today as it was in January, when we announced it. We genuinely feel we've secured the asset we were after, and the various benefits we laid out on earlier calls, we believe, remain intact. That includes how deeply they're integrated with fintechs, the fact that they're highly appealing to many fintechs they're positioned with given how advanced they are, and we believe they have the strongest team. We also view this as the finest route for integrating into Visa. So we're — we stay very enthusiastic about Plaid and hopeful about closing before the year is out.
Mike Milotich
executiveLet's take the next question, Jordanne.
Darrin Peller
analystOkay. Hi, everyone, and thanks. I have just a couple of quick ones. First, regarding the comments on the fiscal fourth quarter: just to make sure I understand, I think you're saying the lag effect from services versus the prior quarter's volume would hit that line by four points. But we're wondering — given the trends we're seeing, with transactions processed flattening out, shouldn't those trends be sufficient to offset that as far as growth in fiscal Q4 is concerned? And then, Al, on a bigger-picture basis, when we think about services — all these other value-added services where you guys are doing well — I mean, do you see these persisting after COVID in terms of the demand you're seeing for analytics and potentially the card-not-present service fees or CyberSource?
Al Kelly
executiveSo why don't I have Vasant answer the first part, and then I'll come back and address the second part?
Vasant Prabhu
executiveAll right, turning to the various revenue line items — service fees, as you noted and as we covered in our remarks, are already settled. They'll report service fees according to our third-quarter volumes, and with luck those Q3 volumes marked the bottom. As we mentioned, absent a lag, service fees would have fallen 11% and total net revenue would have declined within that 4% to 4.5% range you referenced. So that's going to occur — it's a known fact. And even if domestic volumes and transactions pick up, the service fee figure won't shift next quarter. So it's locked in. As domestic volumes and transactions pick up—which we do expect—transaction revenue will certainly rise, and value-added services revenue will certainly rise as well. However, another item that rises is the contra-revenue line, incentives. Incentives will increase to reflect the higher volumes, since we do not record incentives with a lag. Incentives will rise, yet the revenue benefit from those higher incentives won't show up for us on the services line—the service fee line—we will definitely get it on the processing line; so there is a bit of an offset there. I just want you to be aware of that. The largest wildcard, though, is cross-border. Should that segment's trajectory shift and get better, that alone would be the top factor behind anticipating Q4 performance exceeding Q3 — while keeping in mind that the service fee lag pushes things the opposite way. These dynamics add a layer of complication given the unsettled environment we're operating in. We've made an effort to assist you with this, and we'd be glad to offer further help if you have additional questions afterward.
Al Kelly
executiveAnd Darrin, regarding your second question, I have a lot of confidence in what value-added services will do once we're in a post-COVID world. To start with, platform-type services make up two-thirds of our value-added services — CyberSource issuer processing risk and fraud. Demand for those offerings isn't going away. If anything, the volumes and transactions flowing through them are going to rise. The area where we have seen some declines is travel-related card benefits, and that will improve as travel recovers. We've also waived certain fees during the pandemic. Once the pandemic is behind us, we won't be waiving those fees as readily, so that volume will increase. Travel-related benefits will increase, as I mentioned, as travel returns; so I see value-added services as very well positioned coming out of COVID, and I feel very good about the contribution they'll make and how they'll keep diversifying our revenue profile over time.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveYes. I think another point worth making there is that three of our biggest value-added services should keep up the growth that has already picked up speed. Take our issuer processing business, which focuses on debit. Right now debit has turned into the driving force behind cash conversion. As you saw, debit growth rates came in at 25% during the first three weeks of July, so for as long as debit growth stays at that elevated pace, the issuer processing business will obviously post strong growth rates. CyberSource consistently gains from the move toward e-commerce. And with its current emphasis on omnicommerce, CyberSource is plainly reaping the benefits of that shift. Then lastly, our risk and fraud services surely stand to gain as more activity migrates to e-commerce, since fraud is an area where we can genuinely provide a great deal of help; so those are grounds for confidence that elevated growth rates can be maintained after COVID.
Mike Milotich
executiveJordan, you're up next.
James Friedman
analystHey, thanks. Al, during your prepared comments you went over a few P2P growth details. You were moving pretty fast there. That disclosure was new, at least as far as I knew. Could you go over again what you said, and while you're at it, share a few use cases showing how you see the P2P applications evolving?
Al Kelly
executiveSo, what I stated in my remarks is that P2P is up nearly 80% in the third quarter — that was in the United States, sorry, up 80% in Q3. And in Latin America, we made progress with two separate apps — P2P apps in Peru, where transactions in Q3 rose almost 400% versus the previous quarter, Q2. We have this enormous track record of partnering with P2P providers; and as we've mentioned before, we were heavily weighted toward the United States and Russia. But we're — and where we have ties to most of the major P2P providers; Square Cash, Venmo, Zelle and so on, I believe that at this point our P2P capability through the Visa Direct platform is becoming something people turn to us for as P2P applications grow in other nations across the globe.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveGiven the problems we ran into before, we're going to extend things. So we'll likely keep going until at least 10 minutes past the hour.
Craig Maurer
analystVasant, I wanted to ask whether you could weigh in on this: if cross-border traffic stays flat through next year while domestic volume and intra-Europe cross-border both keep growing, what should we expect incentives to look like as a share of gross revenue? How much upside risk does that percentage pose for next year? And then, Al, maybe a couple of thoughts on where the Durbin Amendment stands now — version 2 or 3, whichever we're on — and on EPI in Europe? Thanks.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveYes. Clearly, it isn't easy to make long-term projections in times like these. On cross-border recovery, sure, I guess there's a chance it stays weak. Everything hinges on borders reopening. In places where borders opened or restrictions were minimal, we've observed fairly swift rebounds; so if borders do reopen — perhaps not worldwide, but individual corridors could emerge, as we're hearing about Australia and New Zealand — you've seen the EU is largely open; other geographies within regions are beginning to open too. So I don't think cross-border recovery is simply black or white. Travel patterns might shift depending on how countries reopen. However, should cross-border activity stay weak, the mix is definitely not going to do us any favors. That means the ratio of incentives to gross revenue will remain elevated relative to what it would have been had the mix of earnings — of revenues — been normal. The second thing driving that ratio is likely at its worst in Q4, and that's the service fee lag. Typically, our service fees don't fluctuate that dramatically between quarters, since our business is fairly steady, so that service fee lag impact should ease; the way I'd frame it is that it will likely return to normal from the levels seen in the fourth quarter. Service fee stabilization should definitely cause things to return to normal. The recovery of cross-border business within corridors will likely also contribute to some normalization, though we will have to observe how quickly cross-border activity gets back to normal.
Al Kelly
executiveLet me get to the other two things you raised regarding Durbin. Visa meets every obligation under the Durbin Amendment in full. And nothing in our rules, requirements, or other restrictions stands in the way of a merchant choosing how to route transactions — they can make whatever routing decision they prefer. Merchants are free to route, and frequently do route, to the different unaffiliated networks that are enabled on a debit card; so on that front — I believe we're well positioned when it comes to Durbin. On EPI, we've long dealt with regions, groups of countries, or individual countries that develop their own scheme or intra-market network. That's something we're extremely, extremely accustomed to handling. What we do know, however, is that building a network is not a cheap undertaking, and it isn't a one-time investment. You have to keep pushing, keep investing, keep innovating, and keep being creative in order to stay ahead on every element — security, fraud prevention, risk, authentication, etcetera. So we'll keep watching and engage constructively with regulators and banks in Europe regarding EPI. On the other hand, we're going to keep investing heavily behind our various networks to make them as good as they possibly can be. And we'll stay focused on making sure our clients understand the benefits they can gain from doing business with us and running on our networks.
Mike Milotich
executiveJordan, let's go to the next question.
Tien-Tsin Huang
analystHello, thank you. My question concerns the spread in U.S. debit and credit — Vasant, I realize you've already addressed this a few times, but it's wider than what we saw in 2008 and 2009. So could you try to quantify what portion of the debit outperformance stems from secular versus stimulus benefits? And I'm also curious — I just want confirmation regarding any effect on yield differences between the two products. My assumption is there isn't one, but I wanted to be sure.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveYes. There are some modest yield differences depending on which parts of the world, and so on. In my view, that shouldn't be viewed as a major factor. Regarding the reasons that could persist moving forward, I believe we covered five reasons. First, economic impact payments and unemployment benefits being distributed on Visa prepaid cards — obviously, that is connected to the crisis and likely is not something that will continue. Affluent customers delaying certain discretionary items such as travel, entertainment and restaurants, which has affected credit in particular — that probably normalizes over time, so you can attribute that to COVID. When uncertainty hits, you often observe a tendency for consumers to draw on the funds already in hand rather than relying on borrowed money; on top of that, the economic incentive impact payments landing in checking accounts have plainly given debit a lift. Still, a handful of other factors are plainly enduring. Visa Direct remains exceptionally robust — it has supported debit over an extended period and will keep doing so. Debit has turned into the way people move cash into digital form for routine purchases—really across most spending areas—and those areas have seen e-commerce grow sharply, which has worked in debit's favor; I believe a portion of that gain endures. So the clearest way to put it is that the speeding up of cash-to-digital conversion has given debit an outsized boost, and that will in all likelihood persist.
Al Kelly
executiveAnd Tien-Tsin, this is Al. Let me just add one thing: looking back, I share the same observation you made about the 2008–2009 period. But e-commerce is simply far, far larger now, and it seems that consumers doing card-not-present e-com non-travel are relying on debit cards a lot more heavily than on credit cards.
Mike Milotich
executiveLet's take the next question, please.
David Togut
analystThanks. Good afternoon. Would you break down for us what's driving the 36% drop in international transaction revenue yield? My guess is a large part of it is simply the steep fall in cross-border travel; but could you walk us through those drivers in terms of how much might come from inter-European versus debit? And how should we think about international transaction revenue yield going forward?
Vasant Prabhu
executiveYes. I think it's really important that we keep directing people to the fall in cross-border volumes, excluding intra-Europe volumes. That decline came to roughly — it was 47% in cross-border constant dollar volumes excluding intra-Europe. As you can see, the revenue decline roughly follows that same pattern. The explanation is that total cross-border volume includes intra-Europe activity, which behaves more like a domestic transaction. In fact, intra-Europe transactions make up only a very small portion of our international revenue line. That line is almost entirely driven by volume outside intra-Europe. A few other factors can also play a role. Movements in exchange rates can have an effect. Shifts in currency volatility can too — that accounts for part of it — and then there are minor mix changes in terms of which corridors perform better than others, owing to yield differences among corridors. That said, it accounts for the 44% revenue drop compared with the 47% volume drop excluding intra-Europe. Still, as you can see, the volume figure excluding intra-Europe is the strongest signal to track, and that is where your attention belongs.
David Togut
analystUnderstood. And as a fast follow-up, would you mind giving some color on that 10% increase in processing transaction yield versus a year earlier, plus how you see it trending ahead?
Vasant Prabhu
executiveSure. Two things are behind that. First, cross-border transactions have proven somewhat more resilient than cross-border volume, so the mix gave us a bit of a lift, since processing cross-border transactions carries a higher yield; and second, we have value-added services plus a few acquisitions within that line; and as you heard, value-added services in that line are expanding in the mid-teens. So those two elements have pushed data processing yields higher.
David Togut
analystMuch appreciated.
Mike Milotich
executiveNext question, please.
Dave Koning
analystYeah. Hey, thanks guys. And I guess, to follow up on that last question, you mentioned that volumes outside intra-Europe were down 47% while revenue fell 44%. Is that gap likely to shift much? I know FX volatility probably helped a bit in Q3, making revenue somewhat better than the volume decline. But are there any other yield factors besides FX volatility that we should consider?
Vasant Prabhu
executiveThe variables that could make a difference there — first of all, the 44% to 47% is a fairly small delta. There will always be some differences between the two; they won't match each other exactly; but you're right, currency volatility is one factor. Another factor would be mix. Certain corridors can have better yields than others. So if the recovery of cross-border favors higher-yielding corridors, you can have something of a difference. But apart from that, it should track pretty closely to volumes, ex intra-Europe volumes.
Dave Koning
analystAll right, thanks so much.
Mike Milotich
executiveJordan, we’ll take one final question.
Harshita Rawat
analystHi there, thank you for the question. Al, I'd appreciate it if you could elaborate on the conversations you've had lately with regulators and government officials. Some merchants, on one side, are lobbying for reduced fees amid this crisis — and I understand that's not something new. Yet digital payments carry genuinely substantial benefits, especially given today's circumstances. So, if you could just walk us through how those talks with regulators and governments are progressing as this crisis unfolds? Thanks.
Al Kelly
executiveWell, I'd say governments, much like plenty of other folks, are discovering that they're operating without a map right now. And their intentions are good — they're attempting to work out what the proper course of action is. When it comes to core payments, the main thing we tell governments right now is to avoid causing problems. As we work through this pandemic, I believe having fewer moving parts is what serves everyone best. Now is not the moment for any sort of changes. Governments are also increasingly approaching us seeking the trend information we hold, since they want to grasp what is happening in their economies. In many respects, we can provide them a real-time view of the situation more quickly than they could obtain it on their own. One more point I'd make: governments are showing a great deal of enthusiasm for acting as examples themselves regarding the digital uptake they'd like to see within their own borders. So when they've assembled stimulus packages, jobless aid schemes, thank-you initiatives, and various other efforts, they turn to Visa for guidance on delivering money electronically rather than issuing paper checks. Consequently, my sense right now is that governments are being extremely careful and sensible about the statements they make, and they're listening well too. We'll keep doing our part by supplying whatever information they require, along with any advice and counsel we can offer, to assist them both as governments and lawmakers and as possible customers for various Visa services. Before we wrap up, one thing I understand didn't come through — during a brief transmission outage — was that, before I finished, I made a remark about the race situation in the country and around the world. I'd like to mention that again. For 400 years, Black and African-American men and women have endured tremendous social injustice and discrimination; that is offensive, frustrating, and unacceptable, and it must end. Here at Visa, we have pledged to contribute our share. We recently outlined the next measures in our push to further inclusion and diversity across the organization; we presented a number of initiatives, including the creation of a Visa scholars and jobs program. But most importantly, last week we announced a commitment to increase the number of underrepresented U.S. vice presidents and above by 50% within the coming three years, and to boost the number of underrepresented U.S. employees throughout Visa overall by 50% within the coming five years. We aim to play our role in wiping out social injustice in the world. It is far overdue that this be the reality; so with that, thank you, everyone. Mike, did you want to —
Mike Milotich
executiveYes. Thanks, Al. So again, I'm sorry about those technical difficulties. We'll make sure that both the replay posted on our site and the transcript capture everything; and should you have further questions, naturally feel free to get in touch with us here on the Investor Relations team, and we'll be glad to assist. So, many thanks, and have a wonderful day.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Visa Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Visa Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Visa Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.