Visa Inc. (V) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
April 27, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Jennifer Como
executiveThank you, Jordan. Hello, everyone, and good afternoon. We appreciate you joining us for the earnings call covering Visa's fiscal second quarter of 2021. With us on this call are Al Kelly, who serves as Visa's Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, along with Vasant Prabhu, our Vice Chairman and Chief Financial Officer. A webcast of this call is available through the Investor Relations area of our site, www.investor.visa.com. For 30 days, a replay can be accessed in our archives. You'll also find a slide deck featuring financial and statistical highlights posted on our IR website. I'd like to point out as well that forward-looking statements are part of this presentation. Such statements shouldn't be viewed as guarantees regarding future performance, and a number of factors could cause our actual results to differ materially. You can locate more details about those factors in our latest reports on Forms 10-K and 10-Q, which are accessible on the SEC's website as well as the Investor Relations portion of our website. Regarding non-GAAP financial information discussed during this call, the corresponding GAAP measures and reconciliation appear in today's earnings release. Having said that, I'll now hand things over to Al.
Al Kelly
executiveJennifer, thank you, and congratulations on reaching your second anniversary with Visa. Good afternoon to all of you, and I appreciate you being here today. I'll give a handful of brief figures regarding the quarter, and after that I'll offer my perspective on what lies ahead while the world keeps moving toward recovery. That recovery will assume many distinct forms, and its timing will vary globally according to vaccination rollouts and how restrictions are loosened. Even so, we think we are witnessing the start of the end of this pandemic. Moreover, recovery is already progressing well, certainly across a number of markets. To begin, Q2 results: revenue fell 2% year-over-year, yet it would be marginally positive, at 20 basis points, if service revenues were recognized on current quarter payments volume. Non-GAAP EPS came in at $1.38, which is a decrease of 1%. As you examine volumes and transactions growth, remember that we are now lapping the onset of the pandemic, since growth rates have become less indicative of performance and the business trajectory. We will also give some metrics measured against 2019 on a constant dollar basis; thus payments volume rose 11%, an improvement of seven points from Q1, and hit 116% of 2019, which is three points above Q1. Cross-border volume, excluding inter-Europe, dropped 21%, yet it improved 12 points from Q1 and stands at 75% of 2019 levels, three points better than Q1. Process transactions growth of 8% improved four points from Q1 and accounted for 116% of 2019, which matches the first quarter. During this quarter, we kept advancing across our three growth levers. First, consumer payments: in Asia-Pacific, we renewed our partnership with Rakuten Card, a subsidiary of Rakuten Group, the biggest e-commerce marketplace in Japan. In Korea, Visa captured the country's first hotel chain co-brand, together with Marriott and Shinhan Card, Korea's largest issuer; in China, we renewed our credit portfolios with CITIC Bank and Agricultural Bank of China, two of the country's top 10 largest banks. Also on the co-brand side in Brazil, Samsung, in partnership with Banco Itaú, will issue their inaugural co-brand in Latin America with Visa, targeting Samsung's 57 million Brazilian users. In Europe, Visa secured incremental business with BNP Paribas Fortis in Belgium; this widens our relationship to encompass four million debit cards, on top of our existing credit relationship. In Switzerland, we achieved significant traction in growing Visa Debit. Since this January of 2019, we have signed 13 new debit deals, representing an incremental 2.6 million cards. In new flows, Visa Direct transactions grew almost 60% in the second quarter. We're pleased that clients are now going live with Visa Direct payouts, which offers a flexible set of API for Visa partners globally to use a single point of connection for push payments to cards and accounts. MoneyGram, Goldman Sachs' Transaction Banking, Standard Chartered Bank Hong Kong and KyckGlobal are among the first to begin utilizing Visa Direct payouts for B2C, cross-border P2P and B2b payouts. Some other notable examples involving specific Visa Direct applications: when it comes to marketplace payouts, Airbnb—boasting 4 million hosts worldwide—will provide host payouts through Visa Direct in certain markets. On the cross-border P2P side, Remitly, a leading digital remittance FinTech, has renewed its Visa Direct relationship, extending a partnership that has spanned the last 2 years. Meanwhile, Monobank in Ukraine switched on cross-border P2P for its 1.7 million cardholders. Within payroll, the earned wage access segment keeps expanding, with 25 earned wage access platforms now making Visa Direct available so employees can reach their earnings quickly and conveniently. G2C is also expanding: Global Blue, a major tax-free shopping solutions provider spanning 52 countries and 35 million tax-free transactions in 2019, is using Visa Direct to send out tax refund payments throughout Europe. Beyond Visa Direct, we have backed the U.S. government's distribution of economic impact payments to close to 13 million Visa prepaid credentials in the U.S. so far this year; and adding to our third growth area, our value-added services keep seeing robust uptake. Let me call out a few examples; regarding CyberSource, Planet, our European acquirer and payment services provider that supplies payment processing and currency conversion solutions to more than 600,000 merchants. We will partner with CyberSource to streamline payments across hospitality, food and beverage and retail. KeyBanc, a leading U.S. acquirer, will start offering CyberSource to its merchant clients. And with e-commerce continuing to expand, Decision Manager, a core risk offering from CyberSource, saw transactions rise over 30% fiscal year-to-date. Our other risk, fraud and authentication capabilities also grew. For instance, we have now passed the 2 billion token milestone, up from 1.4 billion tokens just in September. One of our main authentication capabilities, CardinalCommerce, lifted revenue nearly 50% year-over-year this quarter by quickly extending beyond its U.S. origins. Over the next year, we intend to more than double our clients in Europe and Central Europe, Middle East and Africa; so although the pandemic has upended the world, it has not altered our strategy. In fact, it has strengthened our conviction that our three areas of focus will produce robust growth for years ahead. As we look forward with COVID recovery underway, a few key important realities, namely how consumers feel about e-commerce, cash and travel, will especially affect Visa. The pandemic has sped up e-commerce, global card-not-present credentials, excluding travel, increased over 20% in the quarter versus last year. Our growth in card-not-present payment volume, excluding travel, has averaged at least 30% in the United States, Canada, Brazil, the United Kingdom, Italy, Germany, India, and Singapore across the last three quarters. And in global cross-border, excluding into Europe, it has averaged 20% growth; we believe this shift will likely endure as the convenience of e-commerce is undeniable and its growth remains robust even as card-present starts to come back. During March in the U.S., with certain states easing restrictions on transactions, the share of card-present activity relative to 2019 spending climbed 11 points compared with February. Meanwhile, card-not-present volume, excluding travel, continued to rise, gaining eight points. Consider Germany — and Japan, where limitations were similarly relaxed: card-present rose six points, while card-not-present excluding travel still gained four points across that same March-to-February comparison. Digitization of cash has been sped up by the pandemic. We observe the effect, along with tap to pay. Examining cash usage over the past 12 months, for the Visa brand alone, for instance through ATM withdrawals, global debit cash volumes show a 7% decline, whereas growth in debit payments — the payments side — reached 16%, each measured on a constant dollar basis; that 20-point gap is over twice historic growth rates and fairly uniform worldwide, illustrating cash digitization across both mature and emerging regions. Broadly, tap to pay transactions rose more than 30% year-over-year during March; throughout Europe, under a year after contact limits were raised region-wide, Visa has recorded an extra $1 billion in touch-free transactions. Within the U.S., 1 in 10 face-to-face Visa transactions now involves a tap, which is over a twofold rise since the pandemic's onset.
Al Kelly
executiveIn New York City, penetration stands at close to 30%, which shows what targeted issuance plus merchant enablement along transit can achieve; over just the last 3 years, we have brought nearly 250 transit systems online worldwide. Our research also tells us that turning on tap to pay for transit can deliver an increase of over 15% in transactions for nearby merchants. The drop in travel is only temporary, and some early recovery signals are beginning to appear. Spending tied to cross-border travel, leaving out Intra-Europe, got better versus Q1 because of 2 factors. First, people who were abroad are spending more, likely thanks to fewer restrictions; during this quarter, basically the entire improvement in cross-border travel spend came from a higher spend per card instead of a larger number of active cards. Second, pressure persists from countries with open borders; as an illustration, U.S. to Mexico volume for the quarter was nearly 20% higher than 2019 levels. We additionally observed a number of top corridors linking the U.S. and Latin America improve by over 10 points during the quarter compared with 2019. Recovery for travel will definitely take longer than for other sectors, yet we think personal travel especially will return, and that benefits Visa for 2 main reasons. First, because the vast bulk of travel spending on our cards comes from consumers. Second, we're number one worldwide in travel co-brands. With that travel context, plus the shift to digital cash and online shopping, here's a brief look at where our three growth levers are headed. In consumer payments, we've grown our credentials to $3.6 billion and our physical merchant locations to over $70 million across the past two years — up 7% and 34%, respectively. And remember, our merchant location figure treats partners like PayPal and Square as just one each. Even with that, there's still a great deal of opportunity as we zero in on what particular regions need. Now let's look at our regions. We hold a top spot in both emerging and developed markets, and our approach of letting the market pull our credential growth is paying off — Europe shows this well. From 2018 through 2020, our active card credentials went up by 10%. Looking ahead, we see room to add more than 25 million credentials across 50 clients over the coming years. A few recent deals show just how fast this is happening. Revolut, the fintech, signed a worldwide agreement in September 2019 and picked us as their main issuing partner; by December 2020, their card count and payments volume had each climbed by more than 200%. Since 2018, Visa cards have been introduced by Crypto.com throughout 39 markets, serving its user base of 10 million. In just this quarter, the two companies completed a worldwide expansion deal that spans 12 markets, and there are intentions to expand into additional ones. A number of other partners are also launching credentials and developing acceptance networks. To illustrate, wallet providers could eventually account for as many as 2 billion credentials and 70 billion acceptance points, and this area is expanding rapidly. YooMoney, a Russian company, joined recently as a Visa credential issuer, surpassing 1 million credentials within a mere five months. During fiscal Q2 of last year, we shared that stc pay — Saudi Arabia's biggest wireless operator, with 25 million subscribers — intends to embed credentials in their stc wallet, the pay wallet. As of now, upwards of a 1 million Visa credentials have been issued. Through our continuing partnership with Paytm, we've been able to add over 250,000 contactless-enabled acceptance locations at merchants that are new to card, and the count of Visa credentials Paytm has issued has grown by more than twofold since September of 2020, hitting 3 million in total. Globally, tap to phone has likewise been a major acceptance push. Currently, over 35 markets have it available, with 13 additional ones coming on board this year. According to our view, wallets and tap-to-phone are just a couple of the next-generation partners and capabilities that should help bring the $1.7 billion unbanked population into the financial mainstream, which would enlarge the digital payments pie. That expansion will come from a regional approach and a readiness to work with established and emerging players alike, along with developing new ways to involve the ecosystem — all built on our strong brand and on technology; regarding new flows, what we've accomplished in the United States is a real strength. Although they've felt the effects of the pandemic, our approaches targeting a $120 trillion opportunity amount to near, medium and longer term growth for Visa; over the near-term, our emphasis is on backing businesses both small and large. So far, we've assisted 12 million micro and small businesses in digitizing and expanding, against our 50 million global target; and we keep concentrating on card-based solutions. Visa currently has roughly 20% more commercial issuers than was the case four years back. Over the medium-term, Visa B2B Connect tackles the primary pain points associated with today's leading solution in cross-border B2B. And we're persistently bringing banks on to achieve scale. Looking further out, we're working alongside important partners to untangle the problems we're seeing with accounts payable and accounts receivable. As for the remaining $65 trillion in new flows, there are five separate competitive edges that Visa Direct holds, and in our view these will continue driving growth. Reach comes first. When you use Visa Direct, the endpoints are bank accounts along with card credentials, and we can connect to $5 billion endpoints globally. That's something nobody else is able to do. Operating scale is the second advantage; Visa Direct is built on VisaNet's operating scale and taps into its capabilities for real-time authorization, clearing and settlement. Because of this, we can deliver industry-leading solutions while keeping marginal cost low. Third, there's a commitment to network strategy. Visa Direct truly operates as multi-rail, which gives clients both flexibility and efficiency. Over the last twelve months alone, this system has tapped 16 networks built around cards, 65 ACM programs, seven RTP networks, and five gateways for payments. No other set of network offerings we've seen delivers that much connectivity, reach, or functionality. Point four: regarding investment in our capabilities, we've assembled a best-in-class tech stack that powers both disbursements and account funding. Consider our crowdfunding product as an example — it comes with unique codes enabling customers to manage risk, compliance, and authorization of money movement transactions, plus an API that simplifies integration for apps, neobanks, and fintechs. To the best of our knowledge, no competitor provides anything like it. That's what commercialization means. We've already switched on more than twenty use cases, and there have been over 450 new program launches. Our expansion will keep going in three ways. First, we'll scale up use cases we already have, such as marketplaces and cross-border P2P. Second, we'll take existing use cases — P2P payroll and earned wage access, for instance — into additional new markets. Third, we'll build out brand-new use cases, tipping being one example. Visa Direct also delivers a network effect that benefits Visa itself. Roughly fifty cents of every dollar that lands on a debit card via Visa Direct ends up being spent on debit card purchases. Additionally, people holding cards who get funds via Visa Direct have the ability to spend as much as half again compared with those who don't; thus Visa Direct isn't merely supporting new flows — it's also boosting consumer payments. Finally, let's look at value added services, which our clients are increasingly making use of.
Al Kelly
executiveDuring fiscal 2020, over 60% of the clients we serve relied on a minimum of five value-added services from Visa, while greater than 30% of those clients used 10 or more. We have an extensive toolbox featuring hands-on consulting, advanced and adaptable technology platforms, valuable data and insight, plus card benefits — all of which are set to improve alongside the recovery. We also operate three platform businesses that scale very profitably: CyberSource, issuer processing, and risk identity and authentication. Given the recovery along with sustained momentum in e-commerce and debit, these capabilities line up well with the shift toward digitization. Let me use CyberSource as an illustration — our approach of partnering with acquirers generates a leveraged opportunity for growth ahead, encompassing both transaction growth and cross-selling of value-added services. As we noted last year, the Japanese acquirer SMCC was going to begin providing CyberSource capabilities to its merchant customers, starting with a single nationwide convenience store chain and quickly expanding past 30,000 merchants. SMCC now delivers next-generation acquiring solutions to Japanese merchants, and CyberSource handles more than 500,000 e-commerce and in-person transactions every day. With all this opportunity across the three levers, we are investing heavily to fuel future growth in multiple areas, among them simple and compelling user experiences — for instance Tap to Pay, Tap to Phone, and quick to that. Capabilities to scale new flows and value-added services include new needs and direct use cases, plus advancing fraud and identity solutions. Specific markets that can gain from targeted resources, such as Europe and Africa. Innovations in payment — within the payments ecosystem, such as crypto API for banks and digital currency settlement. In closing, Visa has weathered the COVID storm and is emerging from the pandemic even stronger. Significant opportunity lies ahead, and Visa's existing presence, scale, and capabilities position us well to capture more growth going forward. With that, let me now hand it over to Vasant for more color on our financials and what lies ahead. Vasant, over to you.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveThanks, Al. Good afternoon, everybody. Our results for the fiscal second quarter came in above what we had anticipated, with net revenue falling 2%, mostly because cross model volumes improved and client incentives were lower than we had projected. GAAP EPS came in even with the prior year, while non-GAAP EPS dropped 1%, aided by a reduced tax rate. Movement in exchange rates lifted net revenue by 0.5 point, though it pushed EPS down 0.5 point, reflecting currency-related gains in the same quarter a year earlier. As Al noted, since we were up against the heaviest COVID-19 effect beginning in March, 2020, year-over-year growth figures aren't the ideal gauge of the underlying trend. To help you get a better read on the size and the path of the recovery thus far, growth rates for key performance metrics were also given relative to fiscal year 2019. In constant dollars, global payments volume rose more than 11% year-over-year, driven by sustained debit strength along with improving credit spending. Measured against the matching quarter in 2019, the other payments volume came in 16% higher, a 3 point acceleration from the first quarter. Leaving out China, total payments volume growth reached 13%, or 20% above 2019, since Chinese domestic volumes remain affected by dual branded card conversion, which carries minimal revenue impact. U.S. payments volume growth was 18%, and up 24% from 2019, helped by economic impact payments in early January and mid-March, plus the loosening of COVID-related restrictions across many States, partly offset by bad weather that reduced spending in mid-February. Even once economic impact payments are factored out, U.S. payments volumes have returned to the people that trend line. Debit growth sped up 13 points to 34%, up 44% from 2019, lifted by the two economic impact payments during this quarter. Credit growth of 2%, up 6% from 2019, with credit improving in health through gains in retail, travel, restaurant and entertainment spending, mostly beginning in early March as restrictions eased across many States. It's worth noting that credit has strengthened without debits volume, which points to faster cash displacement. Card not present volume, excluding travel, kept growing over 30% in the quarter and reached 55% above 2019 levels, mainly from retail spend. The clearest signal of a domestic recovery was card presence spent rising 4%, which is up 3% over 2019 and an 8 point acceleration from the first quarter, led by retail and restaurant spending. Stronger card presence spending didn't hold back e-commerce, suggesting that the e-commerce trend will likely persist even as card presence spent recovers. International constant dollars payments volume growth was 6%, up 9% from 2019, with a few regional highlights. CEMEA stays our fastest growing region, expanding 26%, up 50% from 2019 levels. The easing of COVID-related restrictions, especially in the Middle East and Russia, along with 0:25:52 drove the robust growth. Latin America expanded 23%, which is 40% higher than 2019, though the region's consistently solid results were largely driven by quicker e-commerce adoption and usage plus client wins. Europe was up 2%, an 8% increase over 2019, yet it slowed down versus the prior quarter, since numerous nations imposed major COVID restrictions, especially the UK, France, Italy and Germany; for Asia-Pacific without China, spending in the second quarter rose 4%, 8% above 2019. Results differ across that region depending on how strict COVID restrictions were, with markets such as New Zealand and Singapore expanding robustly while places like Hong Kong and Japan, which faced restrictions through most of the quarter, came in weaker. Global profits transaction growth reached 8%, 16% above 2019, trailing volume growth because of larger ticket sizes, notably in the U.S., along with considerable code restrictions across Europe. Visa direct keeps delivering strong results. Transactions are up nearly 60% worldwide this quarter, matching the first quarter. The cross model volume recovery carried on even though most models stayed fully or partly shut. In constant dollars, cross model volume outside of transactions within Europe fell 21% during the second quarter, another 75% of 2019 volumes. Relative to 2019, this represented a feed point gain over the first quarter. We're observing the usual seasonal pickup in March and into April, a good signal as we look toward summer. Card not present volume excluding travel stayed very robust, rising 28% year-over-year and 44% above 2019, mainly from retail spending with some lift from cryptocurrency purchases. Cross model travel-related spend dropped 55% year-over-year and more than 39% of 2019 levels. Card presence spend as a share of 2019 widened 3 points compared with the first quarter. A bit of color on cross model travel as we head into the key summer travel period. Travel between the U.S. and Latin America is the strongest corridor, nearly reaching 90% of 2019 levels by March. Aided by U.S. travel, travel into Latin America broadly has bounced back to more than 80% of 2019. Travel between Russia and neighboring countries, plus travel in and out of the Gulf States, has helped CEMEA cross model travel regain two-thirds of its pre-COVID volume. Cross model travel in and out of Asian countries is still deeply depressed, down almost 75% against 2019 and flat for the last six months. Travel into the U.S., a key corridor for us, is also down 70% versus 2019 in March, and has been recovering slowly. With major U.S., Canada border restrictions, travel remains roughly 80% below 2019 in this corridor. As Europe tightened COVID restrictions, travel in and out of Europe is still badly affected, down over 50% versus 2019 in March. Now to a brief look at second quarter financial results. Net revenue fell 2%; had we recognized service revenues on current quarter payments volume, net revenue growth would have been slightly positive. We saw service revenues increase by 8%, which was supported by minor adjustments to pricing. Data processing rose 11%, and while value-added services continued to show robust expansion, that was partly counterbalanced by the mixed shift away from higher using cross-border transactions. Revenues from international transactions declined 19%, matching nominal cross-border volume once Intra-Europe is excluded. Other revenues stayed flat, hurt by weak uptake of travel related card benefits and by client marketing projects that got delayed to later in the year, though advisory services kept growing strongly. All together, value added services revenue kept performing nicely, up 14%, with particularly strong gains in CyberSource security and identity solutions. During this quarter, we moved certain prior period travel related card benefits into value-added services. Because of that, on a comparable basis, the revenue growth we had previously reported for the first quarter would have looked like the second quarter. Prime incentives came to 25.8% of gross revenues, below what we expected, since better than cross-border volume raised gross revenue and lower volumes in Europe and Asia Pacific reduced client incentives. Non-GAAP operating expenses increased 3%, matching expectations. We recorded a gain of $156 million from our equity investments. If you leave out investment gains, non-GAAP non-operating expense was $109 million for the fiscal second quarter, under our expectations, mostly because of benefits, one of which is offset within personnel expenses and the other tied to the completion of certain tax audits.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveThose finished audits additionally helped both our GAAP and non-GAAP tax rates, with the non-GAAP rate coming in below what we had anticipated, at 16.8%. On EPS, GAAP and non-GAAP both came to $1.38; during the quarter we repurchased 8.3 million Class A common shares, paying an average of $208.51 each, which totaled $1.7 billion. Add in our quarterly dividend of $0.32 per share, and roughly $2.4 billion of capital went back to shareholders across the quarter. Now shifting from what's behind us to what's ahead, I'll begin with the main business driver trends running through April 21. While examining these weekly trends, bear in mind three important elements. First, in many instances the year-over-year growth is measured against the weak points of 2020. Second, when Easter falls makes a real difference. Third, here in the U.S., debit spending spikes whenever economic impact payments land in people's bank accounts. Running through April 21, U.S. payments volume rose 64%, with U.S. debit climbing 67% and credit gaining 61%. Measured against 2019, U.S. payments volume, debit and credit were higher by 29%, 51% and 9% respectively, every one of those in line with the March trend. Beyond the U.S., the picture versus 2019 is fairly steady, with a notable exception: the UK is improving as restrictions ease, whereas India is decelerating as restrictions tighten. Profits transaction growth reached 58%, up 16% from 2019, matching what we saw in the second quarter. Cross border volume, excluding transactions within Europe and on a constant dollar basis, expanded 63% and stood at more than 78% of 2019, which is three points higher than the second quarter and one point above March. Looking forward, there are a number of encouraging cross border travel signals worth calling out. Travel bubbles are forming. The Australia, New Zealand one already exists, and bookings jumped immediately and substantially. Hong Kong, Singapore begins in late May, with additional ones probable. Thus far, everything points to at least one well-liked tourist destination in Southern Europe being open during the summer, and bookings look strong. Only this week, word came that Europe's border will welcome vaccinated visitors from the U.S. this summer. With the U.S. vaccination effort progressing quickly, travel both to and from the U.S. could build momentum as summer arrives. Airlines are already adding capacity in anticipation. How the cross-border travel recovery unfolds stays a crucial metric to track. We'll be watching every leading indicator, relying on border restriction data for bookings along with surveys of consumer intention, and we'll bring you updates as we learn more. Just as in prior quarters, precise forecasting is tough in this rapidly shifting environment. If trends stay stable to improving relative to FY2019, Q3 net revenue growth should land in the high teens. The path of cross border travel recovery will be the critical factor to monitor. Client incentives, as a percentage of gross revenue, should rise 1 to 1.5 points beyond the second quarter level, since client volumes are growing substantially off last year's low. And so those fees get recognized with a quarter lag. For the third quarter, our operating expenses are expected to rise in the mid-teens range, since we're ramping up spending on marketing and key initiatives to seize the substantial growth opportunities that Al described. Non-operating expense should come in at approximately $130 million, in line with the second quarter, if we exclude the non-recurring impacts I referenced earlier. On taxes, we're looking at 19% to 19.5%, which again matches what we anticipated last quarter prior to the tax audit completions in the second quarter that I mentioned earlier. To wrap up, we're increasing our investments to fuel faster growth in a post COVID world. Several things are worth noting. Our net revenue on profit stands at fiscal year 2019 levels, even though the travel rebound, particularly cross-border travel, is still in front of us once the world is vaccinated and borders reopen. There's considerable pent up demand for travel, especially personal travel. Huge numbers of new consumers around the globe have been exposed to the ease, convenience and security that digital payments provide. The proof is in the substantial worldwide growth in debit as consumers dropped cash at a quicker pace. We believe these habits will stick and will keep expanding, aided by initiatives such as staff to pay. Consumers, merchants and governments everywhere have come to appreciate the value of e-commerce during the pandemic. Governments are modernizing digital infrastructure, merchants are greatly improving their e-commerce capabilities and more consumers are embracing e-commerce in more categories and across borders too. We anticipate these trends will only speed up. Turning to our new flows business, Visa Direct has kept growing at remarkable rates. The pandemic has broadened adoption of use cases in P2P, B2C and G2C, with many use cases and markets only now beginning to scale. B2B is still a massive opportunity, and we're dedicated to our three-pronged approach to generate growth: card based, cross-border and large enterprise accounts receivables and payables, with many capabilities scaling or launching soon. Our value-added services have maintained high growth, even with lower usage of travel related services. The e-commerce acceleration has fueled growth in our debit processing, security and identity and CyberSource businesses, while recovery in travel related services is still to come. Consequently, we foresee acceleration across all three vectors of growth: consumer payments, new flows and value added services. As Al noted, we're putting money into the strategies and capabilities needed to capture these growth opportunities. With that, I'll return it to Mike for the Q&A session.
Mike Milotich
executiveThank you, Vasant. Jordan, we’re now ready to take questions.
Timothy Chiodo
analystMuch appreciated for fielding that. I'd like to dig into how the cross-border segment's composition is shifting. Inside that segment, you flag a handful of Visa Direct applications. You mentioned remittances before, and also marketplace payouts. Yet beyond those, we'd tack on certain emerging flows in cross-border B2B. So perhaps you might share a few thoughts on what's ahead for these newer cross-border pockets as they join the mix, and possibly the bigger chunk over the coming, say, 3 to 5 years.
Al Kelly
executiveWell, I believe that as our capabilities keep expanding, assuming you observe the rebound coming out of the pandemic. I'd say the payouts functionality we've recently rolled out, which essentially unites what was earth for; plus Visa Direct acting as one single connection point, will enable far more applications and render it extremely simple for individuals to move money across borders. That covers the sort of high volume, lower value transaction categories. I'd say we keep advancing on linking additional banks globally into B2B Connect. And once we finish building out that network across the coming few years, I view us as possessing strong ability to power cross-border B2B transactions of the high value, lower volume variety. So I'd say the blend of what we can do, the ongoing embrace of digitization, the capabilities we've developed internally, and the applications we're engaged with now and expect to fold into the mix gradually. I believe this will turn into a progressively vital and expanding piece of our business.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveJust to add a few points — prior to the pandemic hitting, travel accounted for two-thirds of what we did across borders, while e-commerce made up one-third. Now, during Q2, cross-border e-commerce represented two-thirds of our activity, and travel was one-third. That tells us two things: first, how substantially our cross-border e-commerce operation has expanded, and second, how much room for rebound remains in cross-border travel, since Al has noted that personal travel makes up the bulk of that segment, and a considerable volume of it will return once borders open again. So traditional cross-border e-commerce is a space where we're seeing meaningful growth, because as people shift online, they grow somewhat less concerned about the origin point for shipments. There's simply far more cross-border e-commerce happening. Another opportunity with lots of promise involves the degree to which transactions tied to crypto grow in importance and they're facilitating an enormous quantity of them. A scenario where stable coin or Bitcoin-style arrangements prove especially valuable is cross-border. That's yet another emerging use case holding considerable long-term promise.
Timothy Chiodo
analystThank you, Vasant. That's precisely the point I was hoping to reach — the blend has definitely shifted toward more e-commerce, and additional flows are arriving that hold the travel share below where it stood before COVID. So I really appreciate your taking the question.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveLet's take the next question.
Darrin Peller
analystThanks, and great work, everyone. Looking at that slide, the index back to 2019 was genuinely useful — it showed a 16% gain over 2019 levels. I realize there are many factors in play here, like stimulus and elevated savings rates, but obviously there are also structural shifts happening in the industry — we already touched on some of them with e-com, though there's simply more momentum moving toward debit cards throughout the entire industry. How would you break down what you consider structurally durable? E-commerce is one piece you brought up, but even past that, could you say more about perhaps small ticket items versus what might have been stimulus fueled or short lived? Thanks, everyone.
Al Kelly
executiveWell — I'll kick things off, Darrin. To begin with, we clearly are seeing millions of fresh consumers entering the world of e-com shopping who previously weren't participating, and my belief is they won't revert to old habits whatsoever. So yes, I believe that certainly holds as we emerge from the pandemic; stimulus-style funds are going to run out, and that will disappear. I believe that with folks worried about handling cash and far more at ease purchasing over the internet, those two things together will persist. I also believe we'll witness structurally far greater Tap to Pay adoption, since consumers find it a more convenient method of shopping. I believe we're observing governments throughout this pandemic turning into larger clients, and they're more and more eager to lead the way when it comes to digitizing a greater share of what a government does, and I believe we'll witness additional activity of that kind too. I believe that broadly speaking, prior to the pandemic, we had very slight divergence in growth rates between debit and credit — in any particular month or quarter, the two would typically expand within one percentage point of one another; then we witnessed astonishing divergence throughout the pandemic, with as much as 40 points of difference in income growth. This quarter, we're now observing credit recovering somewhat and then beginning to move into positive territory. Still, I believe that at minimum for the near term and perhaps longer, debit will keep expanding faster than credit, even though as travel returns that ought to definitely assist credit buyers in bouncing back, especially given that the majority of travel co-brand cards and a large number of actual travelers lean toward using credit cards.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveI mean, a few other points worth mentioning there — debit, as you're aware, has turned into the driving force behind digitizing cash. And what we're observing during this pandemic, particularly given how long it's stretched on, is that convincing people to alter their habits frequently runs into an obstacle; folks are accustomed to paying with cash, so shifting them toward digital payment methods, that doesn't happen overnight. This pandemic has triggered a whole set of behavioral shifts, since no alternative existed — be it in emerging markets, where the tendency to rely on cash ran higher, or in particular cultures, you've heard about Germany and Japan being economies heavily dependent on cash for a very long stretch, or routines where people reach for cash in specific categories such as food and drug, that's now shifting, with more individuals turning to digital at the physical point of sale, as Al mentioned, given the dirty cash concern, plus Tap to Pay smoothing transactions at the physical point of sale, we're witnessing a major move toward cash digitization, including at the physical point of sale. And then that remark you made regarding ever-smaller transactions that previously involved cash going digital — once again, Tap to Pay serves as a powerful engine behind that, and the growth path for Tap to Pay stays quite remarkable. And we're likely less than 12 months away from reaching the stage where the U.S. will experience takeoff with Tap to Pay, which is a tremendously large market.
Darrin Peller
analystDarrin, glad that was useful.
David Togut
analystDavid, thanks a lot. To pick up where Darrin left off regarding structural shifts — given the pronounced move toward e-commerce that you said will probably speed up even once COVID is behind us — could you discuss how e-commerce transactions are funded, debit against credit, and in particular how you see that mix changing as the economy reopens? As things bounce back, would you anticipate shoppers relying somewhat more on their credit cards, or is debit apt to stay the main way e-commerce gets paid for?
Vasant Prabhu
executiveSo David, one of the most remarkable aspects of the pandemic, I'd say, is that debit turned into the currency of online commerce, and compared with before the pandemic, people now handle far more of their routine purchasing after it. Think about all the food orders and takeout orders being placed, and the buying of ordinary household staples — a lot of that used to happen face to face, in most cases, and in some instances even with cash. What we observe is that the category of transaction that normally pairs with debit is everyday spending. Consequently, the genuine structural shift we observe is everyday spending on food moving heavily from in-person to e-commerce. That said, I believe credit is going to recover, especially once bigger discretionary purchases return, once wealthier consumers start booking travel again, and once the online travel agency segment begins expanding. My sense is the gap between debit growth and credit growth will narrow; even so, as I told Darrin, I doubt we return to a point where those two separate card platforms expand at an identical rate down the road. We've definitely narrowed the gap, yet for as far ahead as I can currently see, debit is going to keep growing faster than credit.
David Togut
analystThank you very much.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveThank you.
Tien-Tsin Huang
analystHi, thank you very much. You provided plenty of volume growth and some solid specifics. Building on the previous responses, I'd like to ask about credential growth in a somewhat different way. It appears that everybody is competing to capture their users by issuing cards to them, and virtual cards are generating many new use cases. So I'm curious whether, when you consider credential growth, you're either looking at it against 2019, or whether you're considering the potential for issuance, or the pipeline of new cards that could launch around the world. How is that being measured at present? If you'd like to add a caveat, is it significantly bigger than what you'd have anticipated, say, before the pandemic?
Al Kelly
executiveWell, I believe the — to begin with, it's nice to hear from you. In my view, the pandemic disturbed somewhat a genuine strengthening of credentials that came from a mix of marketplace platforms, wallets, Neobanks and so on. During my remarks I mentioned several examples illustrating our belief that there could be more than 2 billion additional credentials from many of those kinds of participants, and we have observed that, though I accomplish it through forming partnerships with numerous Fintechs across the past 1 or 2 years, a huge amount of chance to expand those credentials. Whether by turning these participants into issuers and acquirers on our behalf, which is a very significant and major trend especially in developing countries, or simply by bringing currencies and credentials into certain existing wallets. Yet we think there is a massive chance to increase how many credentials exist; and it's definitely something we're concentrating on, especially when we speak with the FinTechs, the Wallets, and the Neobank across the globe.
Tien-Tsin Huang
analystAppreciate that.
Al Kelly
executiveThanks Tien-Tsin.
Dan Dolev
analystHey everyone. Fantastic quarter. I appreciate you taking my question. Could you expand a bit — you touched on Bitcoin earlier, and on the use case for crypto and Bitcoin when it comes to cross-border transactions. Could you go into that a bit more, and also discuss the headway you're making on settlement and stablecoins, plus what you've done so far with a theory? I believe there's significant curiosity out there about what you're doing in this area and how things are moving forward. Thank you.
Al Kelly
executiveWell, thank you, Dan; this is a fascinating topic. So allow me to provide some context before discussing where the opportunities lie. To start, from our perspective there are two market segments. The first one is Bitcoin-type assets, which are mostly holdings people keep, and they aren't really utilized much for making payments. We tend to view them as digital gold. Then you have digital currencies, which include central bank digital currencies and stablecoins, and those are backed directly by fiat currencies that already exist, and they are clearly becoming a payment choice. They operate on public blockchain, which is essentially another network, similar to how an RTP or ACH functions. So we're concentrating on five distinct opportunities we've identified here; and I'd say this is an area we are embracing in an extremely, extremely major way, and I think we're positioned exceptionally well. The initial opportunity sits right at the heart of our business, which is letting consumers buy these currencies or Bitcoins, and we're working diligently with wallets and exchanges to ensure we're enabling acceptance of people's capacity to use their Visa cards for purchasing. And besides referenced in his comments that we, through our some increase, some of them by paying for people making these purchases on Visa card. The second opportunity involves letting digital currency be cashed out into fiat; that means turning a digital currency into fiat on a Visa credential, which then makes those funds usable for shopping at any of the 70 million Visa merchants and provides instant utility to the digital currency, and we're the unmistakable leader in this. More than 35 digital currency platforms and wallets have picked us as their partner. Coin based crypto.com, block five-fold BitPay are just a few examples. So that's definitely the second major opportunity. The third one is letting financial institutions and FinTech partners offer a crypto option to their customers; so what we've accomplished here is building APIs that let financial institution customers purchase custody, or even trade digital currencies held by anchorage, which is the first federally charted digital asset bank in the U.S. We just completed our initial launch together with First Boulevard, a digital Neobank whose mission centers on creating generational wealth for the Black community. That represents opportunity number three — assisting FIS and FinTechs in offering this crypto capability to their customers. The fourth point is settlement, which you began mentioning: we've enhanced our infrastructure so a financial institution can settle with Visa using a digital currency backed by stablecoin, beginning with USDC. Consider that right now we process transactions in 160 currencies daily, and each evening we settle in 25 currencies. So going forward, we'll be capable of supporting digital currencies as an extra settlement currency across our network. From our side, settling in USDC is quite comparable to settling in U.S. dollars, though the mechanics for receiving those funds differ somewhat and call for certain integration efforts with various crypto custodian players such as Anchorage. Then the fifth opportunity area involves collaborating with central banks. Central bank digital currencies are being investigated in numerous countries, and I believe they may ultimately demonstrate considerable worth in places where the infrastructure for distributing cash is either absent or constrained; it's among the elements that keep those 1.7 billion people I mentioned in my remarks — who sit outside the financial mainstream — from joining it. So we're discussing with central banks how essential public-private partnership is, and especially how essential acceptance is, since for these central bank digital currencies to carry value they must first be secure in consumers' minds — something we have a lengthy track record with and can assist on — and second, they clearly need to deliver some kind of utility. So Dan, that gives you a sense of how we're approaching crypto, with our true emphasis on digital currencies and those five opportunities.
Dan Dolev
analystThanks, Al. Yeah, it sure seems like you folks are leading the way on these. So let's recharge on that. Thank you.
Lisa Ellis
analystHi, good afternoon everyone. Al, I'll take that remark you made there—that debit is turning into the cash of online transactions—as a starting point for a question about how the online debit competitive landscape looks. Could you just point out or explain what, from Visa's point of view in your opinion, the benefits are of Visa signature debit products compared with options such as account-to-account transfers or pinless debit for online transactions? Thank you.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveAl, I believe you're on mute.
Al Kelly
executiveMy apologies, Vasant. Given the DOJ matter, I should probably choose my words carefully here. Even so, our Visa debit business is something we feel really good about. We believe our capabilities are extremely strong, and we think the innovations we can offer — standing behind customers when disputes or other situations arise — make our products something that consumers, merchants, and issuers genuinely value. Debit will keep receiving our investment as a product we hope gets used both for online activity and for purchases across the globe.
Lisa Ellis
analystGreat. Thank you. I appreciate you taking it.
Dan Perlin
analystThank you, and good evening. Consistent with the sort of structural shift that it seems all of us are focused on this evening — all these new offerings — I'm simply curious how the company's long-term growth rates can be sustained, or perhaps even speed up, from these kinds of levels. You're referencing those indexes going back to 2019, but if I think back just a couple of years, this is a considerably bigger organization. You appear to lay out numerous possible paths for growth. So I'm curious whether you've reached a stage now where the business itself has undergone a pivot such that, structurally, it will expand more quickly over the coming 5 to 10 years than it perhaps did across the previous 5 to 10 years, simply because of all the new constituents you're ultimately serving nowadays?
Al Kelly
executiveWell, Dan, we generally don't provide forecasts that far out, but clearly you hopefully gathered from what I said that we believe we have 3 very strong growth drivers, and we believe every one of them still has enormous room to run. We — and our consumer payments, which has been our mainstay for years, continues to have massive upside; that brings you back to Tien-Tsin's question regarding credentials growth. We believe there's an enormous amount of growth in credentials, we believe there's an enormous amount of growth in acceptance footprint; we believe there's an enormous amount of growth when we examine different geographies, and we examine the 1.7 billion people who sit outside the financial mainstream. When we examine new flows, there's $185 trillion of opportunity there. So we believe we have 2 big efforts underway in both B2B and Visa directed at capturing those. And value-added services is fairly new as well, but we have to — regarding how we describe it, we've had numerous value-added services or capabilities or solutions for years, and they've always added nicely to our revenue, but we've increasingly concentrated on them over the last 2 years. And we're generating far more revenue and higher revenue growth than we had in consumer payments via value-added services. And so we believe there's still an enormous amount of upside there; I mentioned the fact that we're seeing heavy usage from many of our clients, but there remains a vast amount of room to grow with existing — with clients already using value-added services, as well as clients who aren't taking on as many of their value-added services. Thus, when I gaze forward, I can tell you that what lies ahead looks incredibly, incredibly promising. On top of that, much of what we have discussed regarding digitization, plus the reality that we shall emerge from this pandemic and begin to witness travel bounce back—every one of those things represents tremendously favorable trends for our company.
Dan Perlin
analystGreat, thanks a lot. I really appreciate that.
Harshita Rawat
analystHello, and good afternoon. Thanks for taking my question. What I'd like to ask about is how buy now, pay later is growing. Looking out over a really extended period, in what way do you expect the NPL to sit alongside credit and debit? I realize that on a worldwide basis it's quite tiny at present, but the rates at which it's expanding are quite compelling. With the partnerships you have involving the NPL providers and your installment relationships, from where you sit this looks like expansion as well as a chance to grow. Thank you.
Al Kelly
executiveWhere installments ultimately lands, I can't say, but we're going after it the same way we go after crypto and other areas, working on the assumption that it will succeed, that we intend to push in hard, place ourselves at the center of it, and help shape whatever may come. As you pointed out, we've got two things going: a strategy of partnering with outside providers, and also our own Visa proprietary platform, which lets issuers provide their very own buy now, pay later offering. From our standpoint, this could deliver an extremely strong outcome. What I mean is, we might see — we might operate with a wide range of choices: virtual cards issued by Visa might handle repayments, a Visa card kept on file might handle repayment, and we might look into Visa Direct as a means for paying off installments. In a lot of those situations, should that happen, the result is that one purchase becomes several installments, meaning a single transaction may turn into three, four, or five payment transactions, which is obviously extremely favorable for us. We also believe this is an area where value-added services can be sold by us — data analytics, underwriting for broadband providers, risk products, for instance — to assist some of those outside providers. So we're doing quite a bit here, we're dedicated to it, some countries have seen it really take off, while in other countries it's still nascent. Once more, exactly where it will land I cannot forecast, but to whatever extent it grows, we'll be present and involved in it.
Harshita Rawat
analystThanks, Al.
James Friedman
analystAl, during your prepared remarks, you discussed the trajectory as well as spend per card, and I was hoping you might expand on that subject. What's your view on how that will develop? My thinking is that as travel comes back, there'd be additional fuel in the tank on that front too? Still, whatever insight you can offer regarding spend per card would be welcome. Thanks.
Al Kelly
executiveSo, the point I think I made in my remarks was that within travel, we observed greater spend per card rather than a larger number of active people. And although we have not managed to study this, our belief about what's going on is that in locations where individuals are able to travel, typically there are simply fewer restrictions as well; and that alone is unlocking additional choices for people to genuinely spend. Take, for example, rather than ordering takeout, you head to a restaurant and enjoy a pricier meal, or a good bottle of wine, and so forth. Thus I believe at present, all we are observing when it comes to travel is higher spend per card. Beyond that, we have not said anything about spend per card.
James Friedman
analystGot it. Thank you.
Al Kelly
executiveOne last question, Jordan.
Jason Kupferberg
analystHi everyone, and thanks. I'm wondering whether you might walk us through a few of the assumptions sitting behind each of the gross revenue categories. When we consider that projection of high teens growth for the June quarter, I realize the macro backdrop contains plenty of shifting pieces, yet based on what April has shown so far, high teens might strike some as cautious — though I understand the comparisons won't be as favorable in May and June. So I'd really like to hear how you view the separate components of gross revenue, since the rebate component was laid out quite clearly.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveRegarding revenues — our strongest estimate is high teens. As you're aware, service revenues get recognized on a one-quarter delay. So the service revenues reported in the third quarter, keep in mind, won't mirror the revenues tied to third-quarter volumes; thus the third quarter will show a substantial volume ramp, as you're observing, since we're lapping, yet service fee revenues will mirror revenues from second-quarter volumes — that's a key point to remind everyone about. When it comes to the cross border business, the trends are, I believe, visible to you. On transactions, the trends quarter-over-quarter seem reasonably steady right now. One thing worth stating about incentives: please note that our incentives took a real hit in last year's third quarter, since volumes fell, even though we recognized and received that allowed — our incentives get recognized during the quarter according to that quarter's volumes. So in this quarter, volumes will ramp substantially versus a year ago, which will push incentives up considerably, and that gets compared against a quarter last year when they dropped. The second item is that we have these incentives linked to particular thresholds being met; last year, given all the declines, thresholds weren't met, while this year we're restoring that ability, so an extra incentive amount comes through, because clients will reach particular thresholds. Therefore you must account for the fact that incentives growth year-over-year will be rather high in the third quarter, and also account for the fact that the benefit of volumes won't reach our service fees due to the lag; so be certain you hold all of that in mind when considering our third-quarter revenue growth.
James Friedman
analystAlright, got it. Thanks for providing all that detail.
Al Kelly
executiveThat said, I want to express my appreciation to each of you for being here with us today. Should any further questions come up, feel free to get in touch with Jennifer or me, and we'll gladly assist. So, many thanks, and enjoy the rest of your day.
Operator
operatorThank you for your participation in today's conference, you may disconnect at this time.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Visa Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Visa Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Visa Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.