CarMax, Inc. (KMX) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

April 2, 2020

New York Stock Exchange US Consumer Discretionary Specialty Retail earnings 54 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Stacy Frole

executive
#1

Thanks, Carol. Hello, everyone. I appreciate you being on the call for our fiscal 2020 fourth quarter and year-end results. With me today are Bill Nash, our President and CEO, Tom Reedy, our Executive Vice President of Finance, and Enrique Mayor-Mora, our Senior Vice President and CFO. I want to remind everyone that what we say today about future business plans, prospects, and financial performance consists of forward-looking statements made under the Safe Harbor provisions of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Those statements reflect management's current knowledge and assumptions about future events and involve risks and uncertainties that might cause actual results to differ materially from what we expect. When we provide projections and other forward-looking statements, the company disclaims any intent or obligation to update them. For more information on important factors that could affect these expectations, please refer to the company's annual report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended February 28, 2019 filed with the SEC. If you have follow-up questions after the call, please contact our Investor Relations department at 804 to 747 to 0422, extension 7865. Finally, thank you in advance for asking only one question and getting back in the queue for more follow-ups. Bill?

Bill Nash

executive
#2

Thank you, Stacy. Everyone, good morning. We appreciate you being with us. As was outlined in the earnings announcement we put out earlier today, we achieved all-time highs for used vehicle sales and EPS across both the fourth quarter and the entire year; we accomplished that while keeping GPU levels appealing and carrying out the biggest overhaul ever undertaken by this company; during calendar 2019, our share of the 0 to 10-year-old vehicle comp market also rose to 4.7%, representing growth of 4.2%. We take great pride in those results, but with the fast-moving and never-before-seen circumstances we find ourselves in right now, there is no plan to restate the earnings remarks contained in this morning's release. Rather, we'd like to use this opportunity to concentrate on where things stand today and take any questions from you. Above all, our communities—every one of which has felt the impact of the coronavirus—are in our thoughts. I'd also like to express gratitude to everyone fighting this pandemic each and every day. In recent weeks, we have implemented substantial steps aimed at lowering the danger of exposure to and additional transmission of the virus within our communities. The well-being and safety of our associates, customers, and communities matter greatly to us. We are complying with directives from public health authorities and government bodies, which includes rolling out stronger cleaning protocols, rules for social distancing, and shuttering our stores in numerous localities. Our team has performed admirably in getting corporate-based associates set up to work remotely, with just a small essential group still coming into our offices. Through this difficult period, we stay dedicated to embodying our values; right now we are offering pay along with benefits for as much as 14 days for associates affected by store closures or who must be quarantined. Beyond that, we are looking at ways to extend support past 14 days. We're also continuing to contribute to our communities through backing our national partners as they respond to the coronavirus. Turning to the business, roughly 50% of our stores right now are shut or functioning with reduced operations; a central response team has been established, crafting and executing strategies for several scenarios since this situation keeps shifting, with stores opening and closing every day. Our aim is to keep our locations operating for as long as we can to serve customers' essential needs, and at the same time provide income for our associates. All through this period, we will continually track and operate in line with what each locality requires. As our news release mentioned, roughly 60% of our customers had access to our omnichannel experience. In the markets left over, we are shifting course and putting the most applicable pieces of the omni experience into place—things like online self-progression and curbside or express pickup—as fast and widely as we can, given what our customers need at present. Though it isn't what we normally do, we're offering a look at March sales so you can see the current conditions. Throughout my entire tenure with CarMax, no other month has matched what we went through in March — that was hands down the wildest stretch I have ever witnessed. The encouraging traction we built over the last year rolled right into the start of the month, with strong comparable sales during March's first week. From that point on, though, COVID-19's spread across the US accelerated sharply, and our sales fell off considerably. During the last several weeks, roughly 50% of our locations have either shut their doors or are operating with restrictions, and customer demand has steadily weakened; on the wholesale side, about a third of our auction sites are shut down because of state orders, and nearly 50% of wholesale vehicle sales are happening through digital channels right now. Thanks to technological progress, we were able to shift sales onto an online platform quickly, and within the next few weeks every sale will take place online. Regarding retail and wholesale GPUs alike, we expect pressure for some period as we work to right-size inventory in response to today's conditions. Right now we cannot completely measure how big the impact will be, since it hinges mostly on how long stores stay closed — something that shifts constantly — along with consumer demand and the magnitude of changes in underlying valuations. As the biggest used-car buyer and seller in the US, we feel it matters to keep our appraisal lanes operating wherever we can, so customers who wish to or must sell their vehicles are able to; we'll keep using our professional buyers and proprietary algorithms to make sure customers get the right price at the right moment in this fast-moving environment. While we concentrate on managing inventory nationwide, I want to highlight our diversified business model, which combines a strong store footprint, a sophisticated logistics network, and an enormous competitive edge. Beyond that, we've faced difficult periods in the past, and we know our associates' experience plus the strength of our inventory management systems are essential when we must move cars rapidly and efficiently out of markets where stores and auctions are shutting down. It's long been our view that our associates, culture, financial stability, and operational excellence are what distinguish us, enabling us to grow market share through every economic cycle. We're confident the proactive measures we're taking now will help us weather the present situation and come out of this crisis as a stronger company still. At this point, I'd like to hand the call to Tom, who will cover our business continuity efforts regarding CAF, and after him Enrique will address our financial stability.

Tom Reedy

executive
#3

Thanks, Bill. Morning, everyone. The current conditions across the country and in our stores are unlike anything we've seen, but people who've tracked us across the years understand this team has faced comparable capital market situations before. Lately at CAF and within our consumer finance group, the emphasis has been on our associates, our customers, and our funding channels. Like Bill said a bit earlier, our teams have performed really well at getting our associates set up to work from home, even as they handle rising customer demand. For the small number whose jobs mean they must be on-site, CAF stresses social distancing protocols. Amid this uncertainty, we're trying to act in our customers' best interest. In these conditions, we recognize certain customers could use assistance; at CAF we've put several measures in place that we think will help customers through hard times while also improving long-term collectability for the portfolio; these include halting repossessions, waiving the late fee for March and April, and offering extra loan payment extensions where available upon request. As you'd expect, origination volume moved in step with our sales results during March, beginning strong and then falling off as stores shut and demand eased. Right now, we've pulled back on our in-house tier 3 lending, yet our core lending standards remain untouched, since it's too soon to spot any particular trends and customer demographics in credit mix. Even so, we're monitoring it carefully. Understandably, through the latter part of March, we saw delinquencies rise along with more requests for payment extensions. Right now, we can't forecast what this will mean for portfolio performance down the road. Still, we'll keep examining the data as it comes in. Either way, we'll keep balancing what our customers need with keeping the portfolio sound. Clearly, we'd also anticipate some unfavorable loss experience, yet again it's far too soon to pin down the total effect on the quarter. As we said on our previous call, the new current expected credit loss accounting standard, usually called CECL, applies to us starting March 1. The CARES Act that Congress passed last week grants temporary relief from applying CECL standards for certain companies. With conditions as they are, we're assessing whether we qualify for that relief and whether we'd choose to take it simply to postpone our adoption of the standard. More details will come in our 10-K filed later this month; we anticipate our customers will keep having a range of choices to finance their vehicle purchases via CAF and our partner lenders. Lending partners have said they plan to keep supporting the CarMax channel. As I've said often over the years, our partners have historically told us they put CarMax business first in capital allocation decisions, largely because they get superior performance from our superior origination channel, and also because of our long-term emphasis on relationships. When FY 2020 came to a close, our warehouse facilities still had $1.3 billion in available room, and that sum would be enough to fund CAF activity for a number of months, especially given how sales are trending right now. The public ABS market may be unsettled at the moment, but we view the feds latest moves to shore up liquidity in credit markets, TALF's return among them, as a positive sign. Regardless, we are busy reviewing other options, much like the inventive approaches we turned to when the Great Recession hit, in case disruption in the ABS market drags on for a long stretch; it helps that our finance teams have already been through crises side by side. Our belief is that the know-how, assets and partners are in place to guide us through this tough and constantly shifting landscape. With that, I'll hand the call to Enrique, who will cover our financial strength and flexibility.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#4

Thanks, Tom, and good morning to all of you. CarMax's edge over rivals comes from how we bring together several things: our dedication to our associates, the strength and variety of our business model, our capacity to navigate difficult periods, and our robust balance sheet. That puts us in a strong spot for the eventual economic recovery and ought to let us widen the gap between us and our competitors. When the year closed, our adjusted debt to capital ratio sat at the bottom end of the 35% 45% range we target. Because we aren't heavily levered, we enjoy flexibility that comes in handy during the tough conditions we face now. Keeping a sound balance sheet and a strong liquidity profile has always been our priority. That approach preserves flexibility in our capital structure and helps protect us from macroeconomic environments that could prove difficult. Let me walk you through a snapshot of liquidity as of the close of March. On March 31, we held roughly $700 million in cash and cash equivalents. We had over $300 million of unused capacity on our revolving credit facility, plus more than $2.5 billion of inventory. Beyond that, we own the real estate and buildings at over 140 locations nationwide, carrying a net book value above $1.8 billion. Turning to debt, we presently carry about $2.5 billion of long-term debt, made up of roughly $1.1 billion drawn on our revolving credit facility, $800 million of senior notes and term loans, and about $535 million in financing obligations, mostly tied to sale leasebacks on certain stores. Another key point: we face no near-term maturities, since the earliest one falls in 2023. As this shows, our financial position is solid; even so, given today's conditions, it also matters that we control costs over the shorter term in light of lower sales volumes and limited visibility into what lies ahead. We've demonstrated before that we can make sensible calls to safeguard the long-term health of our business and to protect cash flows, even when times are hard. We plan to bring that same mindset to the present situation, unprecedented though it is. With that in mind, we've already started acting to conserve cash through targeted steps that will best set us up to come out of this financially strong. During recent weeks, we've been bringing inventory down, putting most capital expenditures on hold, and matching operating expenses to how the business is performing. Simultaneously, we're making sure we build in enough flexibility to seize the sales rebound once it comes. Before the coronavirus, we had intended to launch 13 new stores in fiscal year 2021 and a comparable count of stores in fiscal year 2022; we've put store expansion work and our remodels on hold until things settle down. On top of that, though we stay committed to giving capital back to our shareholders, circumstances today require that we stop our share repurchase program. I'm going to hand the call back to Bill now.

Bill Nash

executive
#5

Thanks, Enrique. Thanks, Tom. Like you've heard from us many times today, this is a fluid situation, shifting fast — at times hour to hour, and place to place. Even so, our varied business model and a team that's been through downturns has a lengthy history of making careful choices to protect the business over the long haul. Things will be tough in the short run, but as Enrique said, our finances are solid, and we think we're doing the right things to make sure we get through what's happening now and end up well positioned once the economy and the consumer come back. Beyond that, let's not forget that we entered this crisis with an extremely sturdy base. We hit record vehicle sales and EPS in FY 2020, and we achieved that while keeping GPUs appealing, growing our market share, and going through the biggest transformation ever in our company's history. FY 2020 was an excellent year, and we're eager to keep building on that success going forward; at this point, we'd be glad to take your questions.

Scot Ciccarelli

analyst
#6

Morning, everyone. I hope all of you are doing fine down in Richmond and staying healthy right now. Bill, I believe it's fairly clear to everybody that things shifted quite dramatically at the start of March. And naturally, you're facing the fact that half your locations are shut, on top of what I'd consider a pretty widespread freeze in consumer spending when it comes to expensive purchases. So, having said that, I was hoping you could give us a bit more detail and quantification regarding what you've observed across the recent weeks, since that kind of context would likely be useful to investors. Thanks.

Bill Nash

executive
#7

Absolutely. Thanks, Scot, for asking. Yeah, let me begin by giving you some detail on the store closures. So, as I said, roughly half are currently shut on limited operations — and I say currently since it shifts hour by hour, this is an extremely fluid situation. We have about 70 stores that are entirely closed. We have roughly 25 more or so that are running modified operations; and when you consider that, consider modified operations as mainly appointment only. So, the consumer cannot simply walk in at the location. Every other location is affected by this because of social distancing rules, which are determined by each locality. So, for instance, at certain stores, you cannot have over 10 customers in the showroom at any given moment. As for providing a bit more detail on the sales, all of the open stores are significantly down on sales year-over-year throughout the last two weeks. Most of the stores that have been open during that time, so for the last two weeks, are selling 50% or less than 50% of what they sold last year. Now, I don't think that should surprise anybody because I think, during that time period, essentially 70% to 80% of the US have been told to stay at home. So, given that, consumer demand has been progressively going down. So, hopefully, that detail adds a little bit.

Scot Ciccarelli

analyst
#8

Yeah, that helps a lot. Let me see if I can get some clarity on what you mentioned regarding GPUs — that remark about gross profit per unit being squeezed. Is it a situation where we're looking at roughly a couple hundred dollars, yet you're still seeing a positive spread? Or does it lean more toward selling at cost, or perhaps even under cost, simply because you need to move inventory and bring in cash? Thanks.

Bill Nash

executive
#9

Yeah, Scot, honestly it's a bit too soon to say, since we're only discussing the last two weeks. Thinking back to the Great Recession, my recollection is that we saw a couple hundred dollars during that stretch. This time, though, is quite different — in many ways unprecedented. So right now, it's genuinely difficult to give you an answer beyond saying I'm sure we'll face some pressure.

Scot Ciccarelli

analyst
#10

Understood. Many thanks, everyone. Best of luck.

Bill Nash

executive
#11

Appreciate it, Scot.

Armintas Sinkevicius

analyst
#12

Great. Thanks for taking my question. When I consider the world before the coronavirus and after it, our expectation was that SG&A in fiscal 2021 would rise compared to the prior year, though by a smaller amount than in fiscal 2020, driven by the omnichannel build-out. You just brought up halting capital expenditures and new store openings. What should our view be regarding the omnichannel expansion? At times, it's logical to keep pushing ahead with expansion since customers aren't entering the stores. It's logical to attempt to connect with them through other channels they prefer, but it would help if you could walk us through your pace — whether you've sped up, halted, or reduced it — plus the effect on SG&A.

Bill Nash

executive
#13

Okay, sure. So, look, if we discuss the pre-coronavirus period, as we entered FY 2021, I believe what we'd stated previously was that for FY 2020, we required comps of 5% to 8%. And had we entered FY 2021 and simply kept our focus solely on omnichannel, we believed we could actually perform slightly better than that, assuming we weren't pursuing other initiatives. And frankly, we intended to pursue other initiatives. So, leveraging for FY 2021 would probably still have required a comp of 5% to 8%. Clearly, we're in a different world at the moment. As Enrique discussed, some of the actions we're taking. I share your view on the omnichannel expansion; we will keep pushing forward with that. As I mentioned, we will prioritize some of the items that matter most in the current environment first. And I think it might help somewhat to explain how our rollout has been done and how it will shift. So, in the past, when rolling out omnichannel, it's been extremely systematic; we have excellent change management and process. Typically we begin the process 6 weeks in advance. We go in, we train the managers, we train the associates. And then, it's an extremely systematic rollout as we keep ramping up our CECs, our customer experience centers, so they can support those methods. Clearly, the in-store training is no longer possible at this point, but the stores clearly have less volume, so we can concentrate more on training, which is why we will move as quickly as possible to ensure that we get, first of all, the customer self-progression. So, that's the hub online that really lets a customer complete the whole transaction or as much as they want to online in advance, as well as the express pickup, which in every case, we're calling it the curbside pickup, but think of it as what we used to refer to as express pickup where a customer can do everything online, they can swing by the store, and previously they could take the car for the test drive, they can come in and sign any few documents that remained. The term we use now is curbside, since customers truly don't need to step inside the shop at all — they can arrive, the vehicle is right there waiting, and it's essentially contact-free. Our aim is to have that available in every location, and after that we'll keep scaling up so the CECs are able to handle it. In the meantime, certain stores will be performing the same functions as the CECs while that scaling continues. So we'll bring everybody along. When we entered this year, our objective was to complete the rollout; we're simply taking a different route to get there.

Armintas Sinkevicius

analyst
#14

Alright. So it sounds like what you're adjusting isn't really the speed of the rollout or your ultimate goals. It's more the way you're going about it.

Bill Nash

executive
#15

I would say the speed is something we're adjusting, in that we're going to get these two features out as fast as we can. Our goal is to have curbside pickup available at every one of our locations in roughly the next week. So yes, we're accelerating certain things. That said, we'll keep rolling out omni. I'm genuinely happy that we began investing in both the technology and the full omni experience a number of years back. Given where things stand right now, I think having these options available to customers — even though volume is at a low level — will matter a great deal. We're seeing customers every day for all sorts of reasons, and they require dependable transportation, so we want to ensure the experience we provide makes them feel secure doing business with us.

Armintas Sinkevicius

analyst
#16

Got it. Much appreciated.

Bill Nash

executive
#17

Thank you.

Sharon Zackfia

analyst
#18

Good morning, everyone. I'd like to dig deeper into the conditions you're observing within the asset-backed sector. And since I went through this myself, roughly 12 or 13 years back by now, how might you draw similarities and differences between today's situation and what happened in 2008, 2009, and what's your sense of the liquidity you hold? Sales clearly have declined. That therefore lengthens the amount of time you have. Yet given the pace at which you're currently selling, how many months could you last before you'd need to secure some form of extra financing?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#19

Yeah. Hey, Sharon. Like I said during my prepared remarks, the — I suppose you might describe it as the bright spot is, with the slower selling rate <<inaudible>> regarding how much money is required to continue funding CAF; and so, as I noted, I think we feel there are a number of months of room remaining prior to our needing to reach for another kind of financing. Having said that, you brought up the ABS market. Right now, it's in disarray. My view is that the government acted far more swiftly on this occasion compared with the prior episode. If you recall, back in 2008 and 2009, we found ourselves blocked, possibly shut out of the public ABS market for more than a year. And throughout that period, we managed in the first year to piece together deals alongside partners and lending banks in order to finance CAF originations during the entirety of 2008 prior to TALF arriving, after which we completed a few TALF transactions. So drawing firm conclusions about how this stacks up against that is genuinely difficult. Even so, I believe we're picking up chatter about activity and appetite in the ABS markets. I have confidence that — we've encountered this situation previously. The very same team is handling it. We'll deploy every instrument available to us to maintain momentum. But we possess all the strategies we employed throughout the recession. We're examining each of those kinds of efforts. With luck, it won't reach that point. Still, I'm quite optimistic about our capacity to keep supplying funding to our customers, just as we managed throughout the Great Recession spanning the whole credit spectrum.

Bill Nash

executive
#20

Thanks, Sharon.

Brian Nagel

analyst
#21

Morning, everybody. To begin with, I trust all of you are doing okay. Also, I really want to say congrats on a really strong Q4 prior to when all of this chaos began. So, I have a few questions. I'd like to combine them into a single one. All right. So, to start with, regarding — Bill, you mentioned certain steps either being taken now or possibly needed later concerning how you value inventory. What I'm wondering there is, and let me get this phrased properly, is this mostly driven by — when you consider reassessing that inventory potential amid the current climate, is it mostly an accounting matter? Or is it about repricing those cars so they sell faster in a greatly weakened selling climate? So, how should we view that, simply the movement of those vehicles? And after that, question two, I suppose this one's really directed at Tom regarding the CAF segment and follows up on a few earlier questions, so when we examine where things stand now and you've said the securitization market has been disrupted, has CarMax thus far bypassed what would normally be a standard securitization? And if so, might you complete a securitization at this moment on possibly less favorable terms? Thanks.

Bill Nash

executive
#22

Hey, Brian. So, to start, I appreciate the remarks about Q4. I'll tell you, everyone on the team here feels as though that was 12 months back given all that's occurred, yet I truly value the acknowledgment. When it comes to valuing inventory, I believe right now, Brian, it's more about ensuring our cars carry the right prices so we're selling them rather than accounting at this stage. Our auctions represent a massive competitive edge. We're able to keep track of roughly how items get priced, what they sell for. So, as you're aware, we always aim to keep our inventory turning, allowing us to swap it out for less expensive vehicles. But remember, several of our stores currently are under lockdown. Consequently, we've got inventory parked at certain locations we cannot reach, even though that too is shifting every day; so, it's more about ensuring we set the right price and sell it. And now, would you like to discuss the ABS?

Tom Reedy

executive
#23

Okay, Brian. Looking at the rhythm of our prior originations, you'd likely have figured we'd bring a deal to market around this month, a few weeks out from now. Clearly, we're watching the market closely, and it's unlikely we act within the coming 1 or 2 weeks. That said, as I noted, I believe we have substantial runway through our existing facilities. Plus, we have several options available to ensure we can fund customers and keep credit accessible for them. Then, once markets reopen, we can place a deal there.

Bill Nash

executive
#24

Hi Brian. Another point, if we circle back to inventory briefly: our attention is on the entire inventory, meaning not only what's saleable, but also raw materials and work in process, bringing the total figure down, both to keep inventory moving and to reach the proper level. Still, remember that since that inventory belongs to us, it also represents extra cash flow coming in, so that's a key element to keep in mind too.

Brian Nagel

analyst
#25

Thanks, guys. Appreciate all the color.

Bill Nash

executive
#26

Thank you.

John Murphy

analyst
#27

Morning, everyone. Hearing from you folks is really great, and I appreciate all the disclosure — it's genuinely useful. One question: when we consider the possibility that the ABS market declines, and given your grasp of how TALF 2.0 will function and how much of the blockage it will clear, since word is it will pack quite a punch — and then my related second question, thinking ahead: regarding the pools that currently exist for CAF, in what way do defaults — but more crucially, waivers — apply to monthly payments, because my guess is that could set off something within the current ABS pool? Also, are waivers being obtained within those pools so that consumers can skip payments? What does that look like mechanically? And does any problem arise for you from it?

Bill Nash

executive
#28

All right, I'll take a shot at both. I'll do my best. On TALF, my hope — our hope — is that we never reach that point; back in 2009 it was an excellent instrument for unlocking markets that had been frozen for quite a while. Honestly, for investors who want to commit sufficient capital, it's a terrific bargain. You can examine the mechanics yourself. We don't yet have the full details, though we would anticipate it closely mirroring the 2009 rollout. So yes, liquidity does get created, but the process is burdensome for both investors and issuers alike. It isn't a simple transaction. Still, should the markets stay frozen, it was certainly a fix back in 2009. As I mentioned, our hope is that going there won't be necessary; we have other options we can use as a bridge should the need arise. Regarding the different pools and what happens with extensions, those instruments truly don't have — as you're aware, these are non-recourse deals, and their structure rests on the cash flows from the various pools receivable. And they pay down CAF's — the receivables get paid off. So if extensions occur, the meaning is that pay down of the loans will be delayed; however, the pools are built so they move in lockstep with actual amortization. No debt amortization schedule exists on the deal; therefore, where public deals are concerned, they are out there. We have the initial capital invested in them. And clearly, we are highly focused on maximizing the residual that comes off of it, since that represents CAF income, but they are built to stand alone and run their course as the cash flows arrive.

John Murphy

analyst
#29

So, there aren't any triggers or any risk at all if payments or defaults sit around for some time. What we're really exposed to is not gathering the residual cash flow we expected originally; however, some reputational risk might exist if pools you hold don't perform. Yet, like I said before, it's non-recourse, and nothing requires us to spend money or take action to rescue them. As for reputational risk, I believe that's somewhat irrelevant, since CarMax won't be alone in this situation, if automobile ABS deals begin getting compromised. And recalling the Great Recession, losses stepped up significantly. Yet no deals failed. Everybody was paid, us included. Okay, great. Thank you so much, guys. And best of luck with all that's happening here. Thank you.

Bill Nash

executive
#30

Thanks, John.

Michael Montani

analyst
#31

Hey there, good morning, and thanks for fielding our questions. The first thing I'd like to check on — could you take us back to 2008 and 2009 and remind us how large bad debt expense became relative to the total size of the book? If you could refresh us on that, that would help. Then my follow-up covers two things: CapEx, and the split between fixed and variable within SG&A. Regarding CapEx for this year, what figure ought we to model, since it presumably can't drop all the way to zero given that certain amounts are likely already committed? And on the second item, the fixed versus variable mix in SG&A, how much room is there for cuts, and over what timeframe could those reductions be made, considering how unprecedented this environment is?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#32

Good morning. Enrique here. I'll begin with the CapEx piece. In the past, our annual CapEx ran roughly $350 million. With conditions as they stand, we aren't ready — or really in a spot — to issue guidance, though I can offer some color. A few points, then. We've halted most of our capital spending tied to new stores. New store expansion is on hold. Remodels are on hold. And anything from a CapEx standpoint that isn't essential right now has effectively been stopped; essential items we continue, non-essential items remain paused at present. So when it comes to giving CapEx guidance, limited visibility means we simply can't do that right now. Once visibility improves, we'll be better placed to provide it. On expenses, we're truly running the business to match its present condition; take hiring — we have a freeze in effect. Advertising has been getting trimmed. Labor hours are being adjusted, and at this stage we are scrutinizing each and every expense and dollar of spend. As for fixed versus variable, our historical lens on the business has been roughly 75% fixed and 25% variable. That said, in the situation we're in now, nothing is off the table. You could examine that fixed bucket and note that we're reviewing it too. Let me give you a bit more color on that. Marketing has traditionally been treated as a fixed cost, yet right now we're examining that spending to ensure it aligns with today's business environment.

Bill Nash

executive
#33

Also, regarding — I’ll have Tom cover the ABS; when it comes to CapEx, looking back at 2008 and 2009, as I recall, we spent roughly $20 million on what was essentially maintenance capital. Naturally, we had fewer locations at that time, but that should give a sense that we’re able to bring that figure down considerably, though as Enrique mentioned, we won’t be offering guidance right now. And then, could you say your question again…?

Tom Reedy

executive
#34

Michael, is your question about the way that loss has moved within the pool across the period of the Great Recession?

Michael Montani

analyst
#35

Yeah, and apologies if I've overlooked this, but I understand you folks made a shift in accounting away from gain on sale. I simply wanted to confirm that everyone of us got the advantage of extra detail regarding how the book did through that stretch, especially concerning losses.

Tom Reedy

executive
#36

Certainly, yeah. When you examine the pools originated in the run-up to the Great Recession, losses came in at about twice what we — our usual aim — our standard goal is 2.25% to 2.5% loss experience across the life of the loans; some of those pools went to around twice that level amid the Great Recession. Like I said, every deal stayed intact and all parties got cash, ourselves included, across that whole span. Another point I suppose I'd make is that right after that stretch — and I'm not offering any forecasts at this moment or about how long the stretch could last — the pools we originated right after that disruption turned out to be among the strongest performers in terms of losses that we've ever had.

Michael Montani

analyst
#37

Thank you.

Seth Basham

analyst
#38

Many thanks, and good morning to everyone. To start off, I wanted to ask about how much warehouse capacity you have available right now. You brought up $1.3 billion as of the end of February, but what does that figure look like at present?

Bill Nash

executive
#39

We've come down a bit over the past couple of weeks from that level. That said, as I mentioned before, I believe we still feel good about having solid runway there — several months, just as I noted earlier.

Seth Basham

analyst
#40

All right. Suppose you decided to offload a loan right now out in the market, through some form of transaction other than the ABS market — do you figure you could move those at a premium? That's guesswork on my part, but my instinct says yes, I believe — when I consider the sort of roster of players involved, the moves we made back when capital was tight during the recession, every one of those was less appealing than our plan A, which means originating and entering the ABS market and retaining all of the upside. The moment you begin getting into hold-and-sell arrangements or partner-style deals, folks are looking for a portion of the returns, so economically they wind up somewhat less appealing. Still, that's a thing we'll weigh as we balance our options moving forward. Understood. Then my follow-up concerns the cash burn as it stands today. If you could provide something more quantitative regarding how much cash is being burned each week, that would be genuinely useful.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#41

Yes. As we mentioned during our prepared remarks, we sit on a financially strong footing. Our balance sheet is very strong. Our liquidity is solid. And we're confident that we are in fact taking the steps required in an environment like this when it comes to extracting cash and extracting costs. How long the present situation will endure is not something we know precisely; even so, we are working hard to place ourselves where we can emerge from this in a financially healthy environment — situation, pardon me.

Seth Basham

analyst
#42

Very good. Thank you. Good luck.

Bill Nash

executive
#43

Thanks.

Craig Kennison

analyst
#44

Morning, and thank you for letting me ask something too. A lot of ground has already been covered. That said, would you describe what's happened with used vehicle pricing after the outbreak began? Then, on a separate note, I'd love your thoughts on what's driving the Edmunds investment. It isn't a pandemic-related subject, I realize, but I'm still interested.

Bill Nash

executive
#45

Of course. Regarding your first point about depreciation — it's quite notable that, based on certain NAAA figures, conditions were pretty solid from January through February, leaning more toward appreciation. Vehicles typically climb in value during this period, and the strength was pretty evident. Once you reach the middle of March, though, we observed an extremely steep drop-off. Looking back at 2008 and 2009, there was a massive downturn across the entire year, with a particularly intense fall between August and November of 2008. What happened starting in early February, then mid-February and afterward, looks to me like a similarly dramatic plunge. How long this persists is unclear; as I mentioned before, it hinges on things such as stores shutting down. Still, the decline was abrupt, beginning roughly midway through the month. Turning to Edmunds: as you're aware, our emphasis across the omnichannel has been on connecting with customers, on shopping, on enabling online browsing, and truly handing them greater control and autonomy; part of that involves ensuring they receive expert advice and guidance. Edmunds stands as an extremely trusted, impartial source. They possess a wealth of thorough automotive editorial and research material. Beyond that, they've poured substantial effort over recent years into digital innovations, which fits with our ongoing emphasis on improving the online customer experience. So we sense abundant synergies linking the two organizations. We've already begun drawing on and collaborating with them regarding certain content, placing it on our car landing pages, yet we believe numerous opportunities exist that will help both businesses. As the partnership develops, we'll be able to share more at some later date.

Seth Basham

analyst
#46

Thank you.

Bill Nash

executive
#47

Thank you.

Rick Nelson

analyst
#48

Rick, thanks for that. I'm interested in whether pushing online and curbside pickup into those stores in the near term will let you reopen the locations that are shut right now and bring inventory down faster. Bill, over to you.

Bill Nash

executive
#49

Yeah, that's a solid question, Rick. So here's what we see at the moment: typically a mandate gets handed down that everybody has to close. And right away — we shut down, since often those mandates aren't totally clear when it comes to our situation. In most places that close, automotive service and sales have been exempted, but a lot of them attach conditions; take this example — you're permitted to be open, you ought to be operating, yet appointment only is the sole thing you may allow; we believe that curbside plus the shift toward online is going to make handling that appointment only kind of locality far simpler. So that gives us encouragement. And as you said, getting those locations up and running, even if only somewhat productive, is a help when it comes to inventory.

Rick Nelson

analyst
#50

Just to build on that, regarding the auction side as you move toward virtual, do you believe those auctions that have been shut can reopen?

Bill Nash

executive
#51

Yeah; so, once more, similar to what happens with our stores, a few distinct scenarios exist. There are certain auction sites, much like the stores, that have been shut entirely, and the local authorities have not even permitted removal of the inventory. Then there are other sites where removal of the inventory is possible. Whenever we can do so, we proceed with that. We'll relocate it to a different site where an online sale will be conducted. So, I believe that's among the factors driving our efforts. In past discussions we've mentioned piloting simulcast and piloting online. And this has simply put us in a great position to act swiftly on it, ensuring we keep liquidating inventory and also grasp what's happening in the marketplace; so, the online options will assist us in getting those vehicles sold even when the store sites are shut.

Rick Nelson

analyst
#52

Thanks.

Bill Nash

executive
#53

Thanks, Rick.

Derek Glynn

analyst
#54

Yeah, hello there. Wishing everyone a good morning and hoping you're all doing well.

Bill Nash

executive
#55

Morning to you, Derek.

Derek Glynn

analyst
#56

In light of this economic shock, how do you see the used-to-new value equation developing for consumers? Also, during an eventual recovery, should we anticipate a significant demand move away from new vehicles toward used ones, comparable to shifts observed during earlier downturns? Do you believe this downturn is so unlike previous ones that it might break the historical pattern we've observed?

Bill Nash

executive
#57

Yes, Derek. Honestly, that's a difficult one to answer. As we entered the fourth quarter, the gap between new and used widened, which I think provided a modest boost for late-model used vehicles. In today's climate, I've come across certain projections regarding SARS; given some figures the manufacturers are releasing, I believe it will fall sharply this year. Part of the outcome will hinge on how manufacturers behave regarding incentives once consumers begin to recover. Yet, as I've consistently noted, the wholesale market adjusts itself extremely fast. Therefore, should used car prices decline due to greater incentives, that effect will spread into the wholesale market, which will correct swiftly — one more reason to turn your inventory over very rapidly.

Derek Glynn

analyst
#58

All right, understood. And if I overlooked this, I apologize, but could you take us back through any applicable covenants we ought to bear in mind — especially regarding maximum leverage ratios, and what your current thinking is on that?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#59

Sure. Two primary covenants exist for us. One is a covenant tied to our leverage ratio, and the other concerns fixed charge coverage. Both get computed using a trailing 12-month basis. So, as you're aware from what we filed at year-end, the prior 12 months were quite strong for us, which means the cushion we hold is substantial. In fact, those two ratios could perform twice as well and we would still remain comfortably inside that cushion.

Derek Glynn

analyst
#60

Understood. Thanks, everyone. Wishing you the best of luck.

Bill Nash

executive
#61

Thanks, Derek.

Brian Nagel

analyst
#62

Hello, and thank you for answering my follow-up. I'd like to get clarity, returning to this topic, on how inventory is moving. Regarding what we're acquiring, have the auctions reopened, and is CarMax participating in them to purchase vehicles? Based on what you said in your prepared remarks, it seems you're continuing to accept trade-ins wherever you can. So the larger issue, I suppose, is the auction itself. My other question — and I realize this leans more toward subjective impressions — is that since CarMax now operates with a far greater digital emphasis and a stronger omnichannel approach, plus you understand your customers better, could you somehow look ahead and conclude that it clearly makes sense at this moment, given consumers are in a kind of paralysis, yet is it still possible — can you somehow quantify the fundamental — the genuine fundamental appetite for vehicles? Are shoppers still seeking cars, which might help us estimate what demand could resemble after this hopefully short-lived disruption ends?

Bill Nash

executive
#63

All right, Brian. To your first point, do the auctions remain operational? Currently, the two biggest auction companies, ADESA and Manheim — ADESA is shut down at the moment. So no sales are taking place there. Manheim remains operational, though all of it is done virtually. Your question about whether we're still purchasing out there — yes, we continue purchasing out there, though at a significantly lower volume, clearly, given consumer demand. Yes, our appraisal lane remains available at the stores that are open, for the reasons I mentioned before. Some customers simply need to obtain cash and get rid of their vehicle. So we want to ensure we're available for that. Regarding the omnichannel emphasis and consumer demand, I speak with the stores daily, and daily I hear accounts of who is walking into the stores at present. The people coming in and purchasing vehicles today are those who absolutely must have one. To illustrate it a bit, you've got medical providers who must ensure they can reach work. We've had customers arrive who've lost their jobs and must downsize their vehicle, so they sell a car and then downsize, or they simply sell their car to obtain cash. You see customers who previously depended on ride sharing but no longer feel at ease with it and wish to purchase a vehicle. So the consumers in there today are those who need a vehicle. You aren't seeing consumers come in who merely would like a vehicle at this point; and I believe that mirrors what we witnessed back in 2008 or 20090. As for demand moving forward, it truly will hinge on a few factors. To start, the top priority is how fast we can bring the virus under control across the country. Beyond that point, I'm certain you've come across certain jobless figures. With so many people out of work, consumer confidence clearly is suffering. That makes it genuinely difficult to gauge what level of demand will exist after we emerge from this situation, or how much time it will take before business returns to usual. Once again, this is exactly why I'm very pleased that we've put money into technology and into the omni experience, so that customers out there searching for a vehicle can be served on their own terms and receive the experience they want — something I believe will allow us to keep growing our market share no matter where we are in the economic cycle.

Derek Glynn

analyst
#64

Thanks for the color again.

Bill Nash

executive
#65

Sure.

Derek Glynn

analyst
#66

Hi, appreciate you allowing the follow-up. I just wanted to inquire regarding a few of the early takeaways from the CECs, what all of you have managed to pick up in that area, and how that effort is progressing; and then, a connected question concerns remote appraisals, roughly where we are with that initiative. Just attempting to peer forward and determine whether there are certain things being done at present that, step by step, would pay off for you once all of this is behind us?

Bill Nash

executive
#67

Yes, certainly. I believe those two are — we will keep moving forward on each of them. When it comes to the CECs, we're quite happy that we currently have 5 customer experience centers that are up and running at this stage; they're supporting the stores through this period; it's still one of those areas where we sense there's considerable upside as we keep training those associates, as we keep using technology, they're improving more and more at their tasks. So, we expect we'll keep ensuring we focus on the effectiveness. So far, it's truly been about roughly the rollout and stabilization of the CECs. At this point, we're genuinely shifting into the optimization stage for the CECs and truly using them to turn this into a superior cost alternative compared with even the traditional format. Regarding remote appraisals, clearly, as we roll omni out everywhere, you'll be able to get an appraisal completed online. Right now we've rolled out only the appraisal-only components located in non-omni markets, but it's something we keep — we will keep working on and that will be a solution available in every market, whether or not you purchase a car from us, but it is one we're still refining.

Bill Nash

executive
#68

Okay, well, thanks everybody for the questions you've raised today and for sticking with CarMax. Just a few closing thoughts before we wrap up. First, I'd like to say again that just like during other tough periods, things are going to be hard over the near term, but our expertise is there. We've got the resources, the liquidity, the financial stability, and the partners we need to get through what's happening right now and to be in a good spot when the economy and the consumer come back. When I think about the leadership and the associates we have out in the field, this team has been through crises, and there's no other group I'd choose over the one we have right now to navigate this. So that gives me a lot of encouragement. And I can't express enough how grateful I am for all that our associates are doing to look after themselves, look after the customers, and look after the communities; and to our associates, I'd just like to say that the care you show one another and our customers, that sits at the heart of our values. And being part of this team makes me enormously proud. I realize it isn't easy. I realize this is a tough stretch for every one of us. It's a tough stretch for the country. But I also realize we will get through this better and stronger than we've ever been; so once more, thank you for spending your time with us today. I hope everybody remains healthy. And we'll speak again in the next quarter.

Operator

operator
#69

Everyone, that brings us to the end of today's conference call. We appreciate your participation. You are welcome to disconnect at this time.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete CarMax, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to CarMax, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in CarMax, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.