CarMax, Inc. (KMX) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
April 14, 2026
What were the key takeaways from CarMax, Inc.'s April 14, 2026 earnings call?
CarMax's Q4 FY2026 results showed a mixed performance with total sales of $5.9 billion, down 1% YoY, and a net loss per diluted share of $0.85, impacted by restructuring costs and a noncash goodwill impairment. Adjusted EPS was $0.34, down from $0.60 last year. The company improved sales trends by lowering prices and enhancing digital capabilities, but margins decreased due to price reductions. Management maintained its guidance for FY2027, expecting used margins to decline at a rate similar to Q4 trends. The company also increased its SG&A reduction target to $200 million.
What topics did CarMax, Inc. cover?
- Sales and Pricing Strategy: CarMax improved sales trends by lowering prices, which management stated had the biggest impact on sales. Used unit comps improved significantly from previous quarters, with Q4 comps down 1.9% compared to negative 6.3% and 9% in prior quarters. Management emphasized the importance of affordability and competitive pricing.
- SG&A Reduction: CarMax made progress on its SG&A reduction goals, increasing its FY2027 exit rate reduction target to $200 million from $150 million. Management is focused on balancing cost reductions with growth ambitions, indicating a strategic reallocation of resources.
- Digital and Omnichannel Enhancements: The company invested in digital enhancements to drive conversion and improve the customer experience. New CEO Keith Barr emphasized reducing friction in the customer journey and leveraging technology for efficiency.
- CarMax Auto Finance (CAF) Strategy: CAF penetration increased to 42.8%, with a focus on expanding Tier 2 penetration. Management expects this growth to accelerate in FY2027, contributing to higher finance income.
- Inventory and Cost Management: CarMax is focusing on optimizing inventory levels and reducing logistics and reconditioning costs. This is seen as a key lever for maintaining competitive pricing and improving margins.
What were CarMax, Inc.'s April 14, 2026 results?
- Total Sales: $5.9B (down 1% YoY)
- Net Loss per Diluted Share: $0.85 (vs $0.58 in earnings last year)
- Adjusted EPS: $0.34 (down from $0.60 last year)
- Used Unit Comps: -1.9% (improved from -6.3% and -9% in prior quarters)
- SG&A Expenses: $577M (down 5% YoY, excluding restructuring costs)
- CAF Penetration: 42.8% (up from 42.3% last year)
CarMax's Q4 results highlight a strategic shift towards competitive pricing and digital enhancements, which have improved sales trends. However, the company faces challenges in maintaining margins amidst price reductions. The new CEO's focus on customer-centric strategies and digital transformation is promising, but execution will be key. Investors should watch for further developments in cost management and the impact of digital initiatives on sales and margins.
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
David Lowenstein
executiveAppreciate that, Angela. Morning, everyone, and thanks for being with us on the conference call covering our fiscal 2026 fourth quarter earnings. Joining me today are Tom Folliard, our Interim Executive Chair of the Board; Keith Barr, President and CEO; Enrique Mayor-Mora, Executive Vice President and CFO; and Jon Daniels, Executive Vice President, CarMax Auto Finance. A reminder before we begin: anything we say today that isn't a statement of historical fact — including, without limitation, statements about future business plans, prospects, and financial performance — counts as a forward-looking statement made under the Safe Harbor provisions of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Such statements rest on what we currently know, expect, and assume, and they carry substantial risks and uncertainties that might cause actual results to differ materially from what we expect. When we provide projections or other forward-looking statements, we disclaim any intent or obligation to update them. For more detail on the important factors and risks that could affect these expectations, please refer to our Form 8-K filed with the SEC this morning, our annual report on Form 10-K for fiscal year 2025, and our quarterly reports on Form 10-Q previously filed with the SEC. Also note that beyond our earnings release, we've prepared a quarterly investor presentation, and you can find both documents in the Investor Relations section of our website. If any follow-up questions come up after the call, feel free to reach our Investor Relations department at 804 to 747 to 0422, extension 7865. Finally, thanks ahead of time for limiting yourself to one question and then rejoining the queue for any follow-ups. Tom?
Tom Folliard
executiveThanks, David. Morning, everyone, and I appreciate you being here. On today's call, I'll give a short review of how we performed this quarter. I'll also take a moment to introduce Keith Barr, our new President and Chief Executive Officer, and then hand things over so he can share a few remarks. Following that, Enrique and Jon will walk through the fourth quarter results in greater depth and point out some important expectations for fiscal year 2027, after which we'll open the line for your questions. In the fourth quarter, we delivered solid progress against the priorities we laid out on the last call for strengthening the business. We improved sales trends by cutting our prices, putting money into acquisition marketing, and rolling out an initial set of digital enhancements aimed at driving conversion. We kept streamlining our cost structure as well, and we lowered the cost of bringing cars to market, which helps us offer more affordable vehicles. At the same time, we achieved meaningful progress on our SG&A reduction goals, our CAF full spectrum ambitions, and our extended protection plan redesigns. Before I bring Keith in, I want to thank David McCreight for taking on the Interim President and CEO role over the past several months. While we look for the right leader to guide CarMax through its next phase of growth, David's leadership mattered critically in strengthening the business near term and in solidifying the foundation for the growth ahead. David will remain a tremendous asset to the company as an Independent Director of the Board. The Board and I are delighted to welcome Keith to CarMax. In our CEO search, we sought several attributes. Above all, a people-first leader who fits well with CarMax's award-winning culture; an established, proven leader with experience running a complex business; someone strongly focused on the customer, with a track record of driving growth and strengthening brands; experience getting the most out of an integrated omnichannel model; and lastly, experience leading digital transformations. Keith embodies each of these characteristics, which makes him the right choice to lead CarMax through a critical juncture and drive the company's next chapter of growth. I'll now hand the call to Keith so he can introduce himself and say a few words. Keith?
Keith Barr
executiveThanks, Tom, and good morning to all of you. I'd like to say how grateful I am to the Board for the confidence they've shown in me. Being part of CarMax and leading this iconic company alongside our talented associates is truly an honor. For over 30 years, CarMax has played a role in shaping the way people buy and sell used cars, and in doing so it has gained something few companies achieve — the trust of its customers. Leading with a focus on customers and associates is central to my approach, and I saw immediately that it's just as central at CarMax; that's among the many things that drew me to this team. CarMax has created a genuinely remarkable company — a brand people love, a mix of a physical footprint no competitor matches and a robust digital backbone, plus a people-first culture that has earned awards. That strong base, I believe, gives us room to do more for customers and to capture the considerable opportunity in front of us. My own career before CarMax was in hospitality, where I held many leadership positions across commercial, operations, and technology, and finished with a six-year stint as CEO of IHG Hotels & Resorts. There I drove a transformation that delivered shareholder value by empowering associates and breaking new ground on customer experience — an approach that is now the industry standard. At first glance, hotels and used cars might look quite different, yet fundamentally both industries thrive when they provide customers with the correct offering, at the correct price, delivered in the correct manner. Throughout my career in hospitality, the guiding principle was always putting the guest first in every choice we made. The automotive sector is changing rapidly, and I think bringing a new viewpoint from outside can offer genuine benefits—particularly if that perspective respects how complex this industry is, understands the competitive environment deeply, and stays sharply focused on shifting what customers expect. I see an enormous opportunity in front of us to serve today's buyers better. CarMax's scale in this market—among other things, the fact that we reach 85% of the U.S. population—provides a competitive advantage. Along with our brand and culture, that means we're positioned well for success. Lately our results haven't lived up to our potential, and bridging that gap is precisely where our attention is directed. Over my first few weeks, I've devoted my time to getting deeply acquainted with all facets of the business. That has meant meeting numerous talented associates throughout the organization, in our corporate offices as well as in the field, examining how customers and associates experience both the buying and the selling journeys, evaluating our omnichannel capabilities, and coming to understand how we handle reconditioning, inventory, pricing, marketing, and cash. Beyond the steps Tom and David set in motion in Q4, we are working diligently to pinpoint areas for improvement. Once we have further specifics, we will share our plans with you. One thing I can state with complete confidence right now is that the customer will sit at the center of every choice we make as we push for stronger results. With that as our guide, here is what we will focus on first. We must establish CarMax as the obvious, straightforward choice—and that starts with consistently delivering the three things customers value above all: a competitive price they trust is fair, a broad selection of high-quality vehicles they can access, and an end-to-end experience suited to what today’s consumer requires. Moving on, technology will help us deliver more unique experiences and bigger efficiency gains. Our plan is to put software, data, and AI to work in hands-on ways—ones that simplify vehicle transactions for buyers and sellers alike and help our associates assist them more easily. That means removing obstacles at every stage, personalizing each interaction, improving how we match stock and pricing to what customers want, and ensuring quality holds up in our stores as well as online. As a third point, we'll move faster and with clearer intent, keeping the whole organization in step. Anything that isn't working gets changed, whatever is working gets pushed harder, and we'll keep evaluating opportunities and risks along the way. We are going to act decisively, take ownership, and operate with speed as we create a lasting engine for growth over the long term. Those three priorities are our starting point, and I anticipate that our efforts will change as I continue listening, learning, and engaging with our teams and investors. A substantial opportunity lies before us as we reinforce the business and enhance how we execute in order to generate growth and returns. I look forward to sharing additional detail on our strategy and long-term objectives at the appropriate time, and I have confidence in what we can achieve. At this point I would like to turn the call over to Enrique so he can walk through our fourth quarter financial performance in greater detail. Enrique?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveKeith, thanks, and good morning to everyone. In Q4, our sales trends got better, and we made headway on the SG&A reduction goal — which we now anticipate exceeding the FY 2027 exit rate reduction targets we'd set earlier. Earnings per share for the quarter took a hit from restructuring costs and a non-cash goodwill impairment, and margins fell versus the year-ago quarter as we kept emphasizing targeted price cuts and pushing sales. Total sales in the quarter came to $5.9 billion, a decline of 1% from last year. Combined across retail and wholesale, we moved roughly 304,000 vehicles, 1% higher than Q4 of last year. Within retail, total unit sales were off 0.8%, and used unit comps fell 1.9%. That represented a strong improvement in trend versus the second and third quarters, when used unit comps came in at -6.3% and -9%, respectively. Our Q4 sales performance drew support from the actions Tom mentioned. Average selling price stood at $26,019, which is $114 less per unit year over year. Wholesale unit sales rose 3% against last year's fourth quarter. The average wholesale selling price dropped $268 per unit, landing at $7,776. We purchased about 270,000 vehicles in the quarter, slightly above last year. The steps we took also drove a strong positive shift in trend compared with the third quarter, which had been down 12% year over year; we bought roughly 229,000 vehicles from consumers, and about half of those purchases came via our online instant appraisal experience. With help from our Edmunds sales teams, we sourced the remaining roughly 41,000 vehicles through dealers — a 9% decline from last year. Net loss per diluted share for Q4 was $0.85, versus $0.58 of earnings in last year's fourth quarter. Adjusted earnings per diluted share, a non-GAAP measure, came to $0.34 for the quarter, compared with $0.64 a year ago. A few items weighed on our EPS this quarter. Among them: a non-cash goodwill impairment of $0.99, caused by a drop in our market capitalization that coincided with a prescriptive impairment measurement period and pressured financial performance. Restructuring charges of $0.20 tied to corporate workforce reductions and the early abandonment of underutilized space at our Edmunds office. Taken together, those items cut EPS by $1.19 this quarter. Total gross profit was $605 million, 9% below last year's fourth quarter. Used retail margin of $383 million fell 10%, mainly because profit per used unit slipped to $2,115, down $207 per unit from last year's record-high fourth quarter. Wholesale vehicle margin of $115 million was 7% lower than a year ago, with wholesale gross profit per unit at $940, a drop of $105 per unit, partly offset by higher volume. Other gross profit was $107 million, down 11% from a year ago. Service was the main driver here. Consistent with the outlook we shared on the third quarter call, service came under pressure from seasonal sales along with the annualization of cost coverage levers implemented last year. Even with sales headwinds, service got back to profitability for the full year. CarMax Auto Finance income came in at $144 million, a 10% decline year-over-year. Jon will walk through CAF details shortly. On the SG&A side, fourth quarter expenses totaled $611 million. Excluding the restructuring costs mentioned earlier, SG&A was $577 million, which is 5% lower than the prior year. Three factors mainly drove fourth quarter SG&A dollars relative to last year. First, total compensation and benefits rose by $31 million, reflecting lower corporate bonus and stock-based compensation, plus reduced CEC payroll after the actions we took last quarter. Partially offsetting those savings were $12 million in restructuring charges connected to our SG&A cost reduction efforts. Second, occupancy costs were up by $27 million, which includes a $21 million charge from exiting our Edmunds office lease. That move will help bring SG&A down going forward. The rest of the increase was largely timing-related. Third, advertising expense rose by $6 million, driven by higher acquisition marketing spend. On capital allocation, we bought back 1.3 million shares during the fourth quarter, spending $50 million in total. At quarter end, $1.31 billion remained in repurchase authorization. Looking ahead to FY 2027, I'll touch on a few key areas. We plan to manage margins more dynamically as we run the business. As a guidepost for FY 2027, we currently expect full-year used margins to decline at a rate broadly consistent with our fourth quarter year-over-year trend, though actual results may differ as we keep optimizing performance. We expect the first quarter to show the largest year-over-year decline, at closer to $300 per unit, as we lap record margins. This outlook reflects our pricing actions and our continued work to lower logistics and reconditioning COGS to support more competitive pricing and stronger sales; we have finished the EPP product redesign and testing and started our national rollout, which we expect to deliver roughly $35 per unit in margins during FY 2027. We will ramp through the year per the rollout plan. On SG&A, we expect FY 2027 exit rate reductions of $200 million, up from the previous guidance of $150 million; however, year-over-year savings within FY 2027 should be offset, mainly as we annualize the materially reduced corporate bonus and share-based compensation in FY 2026, which offsets approximately half of the FY 2027 in-year savings, along with inflationary pressures and new location growth. Given our focus on lowering vehicle pricing through lower GPUs and COGS efficiencies, we will shift our SG&A efficiency metric to a per total unit ratio, made up of retail plus wholesale units. We anticipate that SG&A will lever in FY 2027 once the restructuring charges taken in FY 2026 are excluded. Turning to capital expenditures, we expect roughly $400 million of spending in FY 2027, a material decline from the past two years. The biggest share of our CapEx continues to go toward land and the build-out of facilities that support long-term growth capacity in off-site reconditioning and auctions. In FY 2027, we intend to open four new stores, two new off-site reconditioning and auction locations, and two new off-site auction locations. On capital structure, our priority is still funding the business and preserving financial flexibility. We keep taking a disciplined approach to our capital structure, and that includes managing net leverage so that both CAF and CarMax overall retain efficient access to the capital markets; with leverage a bit above our targeted range, and with our focus on improving the business through this transitional period, we have paused share buybacks. Our $1.1 billion authorization is still in place, and we remain committed to returning capital to shareholders over time. With that, I will now hand the call to Jon, who will give more detail on CarMax Auto Finance and our ongoing focus on full credit spectrum expansion. Jon?
Jon Daniels
executiveThanks, Enrique, and good morning, everyone. In Q4, CarMax Auto Finance originated just under $1.9 billion, producing sales penetration of 42.8% net of three-day payoffs, compared with 42.3% a year earlier. The weighted average contract rate we charged new customers matched last year at 11.1%. Combined third-party Tier 2 and Tier 3 penetration for the quarter came to 25.6% of sales, also consistent with the prior year. The year-over-year rise in CAF penetration during the fourth quarter mirrors our ongoing emphasis on growing in Tier 2, backed by a flexible funding strategy and our latest underwriting models. We anticipate that our penetration growth aimed at the upper half of Tier 2 will speed up in FY 2027. CAF income for the quarter totaled $144 million, a decline of $16 million versus the same period a year ago. The loan loss provision came in at $74 million, compared with $68 million last year. Net interest margin on the portfolio rose modestly, both sequentially and year-over-year, to 6.3%. As in the third quarter, credit losses during the fourth quarter matched our expectations. CAF's $74 million loan loss provision mostly captures anticipated charge-offs on recently originated loans, including those connected to our credit spectrum expansion, chiefly into the upper half of Tier 2. Total reserves closed the quarter at $453 million, equal to 2.78% of auto loans held for investment; during the quarter we also designated a $100 million pool of non-prime loans as held for sale, which carries no loss reserve requirement. As we signaled before, we expect to strategically use future off-balance sheet funding transactions, since doing so supports our full spectrum growth strategy by balancing income against future provision risk. Although CAF income fell year-over-year in the quarter, that mostly reflects a smaller held for investment receivable base, affected by the $900 million 25B transaction completed in Q3, along with lower origination dollars over the past few years. CAF earned roughly $5 million in servicing fees in both the third and fourth quarters. The third quarter additionally included a $27 million gain on sale stemming from the 25B transaction. As our Tier 2 volume grows, we will keep refining our funding strategy and earnings model over the course of the year. We believe a diversified funding approach provides flexibility to optimize returns beyond traditional third-party lender fees while preserving suitable risk discipline. More broadly, we view CAF penetration growth as contributing to the broader strategic objective of retaining a greater percentage of finance income. As always, we will weigh the current state of the economy and the consumer carefully as we shape our strategy. I also want to give an update on our redesigned extended service plan, MaxCare, which centers on mechanical coverage, and on our new MaxCare Plus offering, which adds cosmetic protection. Redesigning these products is intended to raise penetration by enhancing affordability amid higher vehicle prices, and results so far have been encouraging across multiple markets. As Enrique noted, our product enhancement testing is now finished, and we anticipate a nationwide rollout by Q2 of FY 2027; at this point, I'd like to hand the call back to Keith. Keith?
Keith Barr
executiveThank you, Jon. Before we take questions on the line, I'd like to offer a few closing remarks. My thanks go to Tom, David, and every CarMax associate for the foundation they have established. During the fourth quarter, we made headway on improving affordability and on streamlining how our costs are structured. The hours I've passed with associates in our offices and out in the field have only deepened my conviction about the opportunity that lies ahead. Ours is a solid foundation, a potent brand, and our priorities are plain. Make CarMax the obvious choice for customers, harness technology to deliver more differentiated experiences and efficiencies, and act with greater urgency and intention. Done well, that will produce a stronger, more efficient business, with the customer sitting at the center of each decision we take. Before I finish, I want to highlight something that makes CarMax a source of pride. Fortune has once again named us among the 100 Best Companies to Work For, which marks 22 consecutive years on that list. Even in my first few weeks here, I have witnessed firsthand the culture that stands behind that recognition. The trust, care, and support that associates demonstrate toward one another daily are genuine strengths of this company. It's an honor to be part of this team. I look forward to bringing you updates on our progress in the quarters to come and to sharing more about our strategy and long-term objectives in due course. Thank you for the continued trust and confidence you place in CarMax. With that, we'll open the line for questions. Operator?
Craig Kennison
analystMorning, Keith, and congratulations on the new position. I suppose I'll begin by asking: what are your overall impressions after these first few weeks? To be more specific, drawing on what you learned in the hotel business, how would you go about making the click-through experience at CarMax smoother? That strikes me as an area where you trail the best-in-class experience.
Keith Barr
executiveThank you, Craig — I'm delighted to be here, and it's great to meet you. Getting to know the team over these first few weeks has been terrific, and what has really struck me so far is the quality of our associates, in the corporate office as well as in the field, along with a culture you can genuinely feel. This company has an amazing culture. At the moment we're concentrating on sharper execution on the fundamentals of the business — pricing, selection, availability, and experience; it's a fantastic team. I believe you're right about the hotel experience. A rallying cry of mine in my previous role was: how do we reduce friction in the customer experience? If something takes us six clicks, how can we get it down to three? Which things matter most to customers? Really grasping that end-to-end customer journey, online and in store, and how we can streamline those processes. That will be one of my main focuses in the omnichannel experience — simply streamlining the experience and truly making things easier for our customers.
Brian Nagel
analystMorning, everyone. Keith, glad to have you aboard. I'm looking forward to collaborating with you.
Keith Barr
executiveThanks.
Brian Nagel
analystMy question is about this quarter specifically. I think a major part of the effort here has been the price investment, so to speak, in the used car business. Could you talk more about what you observed regarding elasticity and demand as you made price adjustments? Used car unit comps were still negative, but they improved quite substantially compared with the previous couple of quarters. How much of that improvement would you credit to these price investments? I know you provided at least some guidance for the first quarter, but how should we think about these price investments going forward?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYes, Brian, thanks for asking. The effect we had on the quarter was really — there were multiple things we did, correct? We lowered our prices. You can see that in the GPU. We also raised our acquisition marketing spend, and we made enhancements to our online selling capabilities through our website experience as well. I would say, among those three things, pricing certainly had the biggest effect in our view, though we believe all of those levers moved our trend in a positive direction. I would say the results we saw this quarter were pretty much in line with what we had expected, given the actions we took. We are really pleased with the change in direction. Coming out of the third quarter, we made it very clear that our objective right now is to get the sales flywheel going, and we're pulling these levers, and that's exactly what we saw. We have those levers in place here moving forward as well.
Brian Nagel
analystDavid, may I ask a quick follow-up on that? Is there any way to put a number on the improvement we saw in used car unit comps in fiscal Q4 compared with three and two? Can you quantify how much of that came directly from the efforts you made?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYeah. Not really; we haven't really discussed price elasticity externally. We understand price elasticity very deeply. We haven't necessarily communicated externally exactly what it is. Again, what I'd tell you is that the change in trend and that positive change in direction came from those three items: lower prices, increased marketing, better selling capabilities online. Of those items, we do believe lower pricing had the biggest impact on the quarter.
Brian Nagel
analystThat’s much appreciated, and thanks.
Tom Folliard
executiveHi, Brian — this is Tom. How’s everything with you?
Brian Nagel
analystHi, Tom. How’s it going?
Tom Folliard
executiveFine. I believe this just shows that price is important in our industry. Like we mentioned when last quarter started, we had somewhat allowed our pricing to creep upward to a point where we weren’t as competitive as we wanted. As Enrique said, we made several moves right away as the fourth quarter began, and just as you pointed out, we witnessed a big shift. The largest factor was obviously price. Now, as you’ve heard the team discuss cost, if sales can start heading the right way and we can tackle some of those cost problems underneath, whether that’s COGS or SG&A, this is going to be a fantastic business. Price truly matters to the consumer.
Brian Nagel
analystThat's genuinely helpful. Thank you.
Rajat Gupta
analystGreat, and I appreciate you fielding this question — I'm looking forward to collaborating with you, Keith. To start, I'd like to follow up on what Enrique mentioned regarding SG&A. Out of that $200 million, what portion do you anticipate affecting this year's P&L? Also, could you elaborate a bit more on the accruals and stock-based comp commentary, and how we ought to think about the magnitude of that? And perhaps any guide rails on SG&A as it pertains to ad expense on your side — that would be useful. Thanks.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYeah, no, absolutely. Thanks, Rajat. There are a few points to make here. One useful way to think about this is the dollars of exit rate savings we'll carry out of FY 2026. Taken together — the CEC actions from last quarter, the home office actions from this quarter that we covered on the call, and the Edmunds lease — all of that means we finish FY 2026 with roughly $100 million in savings. As we've mentioned, we can see a path to an additional $100 million of exit rate in FY 2027. Part of that will show up during FY 2027, though the complete annualized benefit really arrives in FY 2028. Here's what I'd add, and it echoes what I mentioned in my prepared remarks: for FY 2027, we anticipate that the savings achieved within the year will be offset as we annualize the significantly lower corporate bonus and share-based compensation. That accounts for roughly 50% of what we actually expect to save in FY 2027. Under normal circumstances, we wouldn't anticipate those items persisting or carrying the same level of impact. That's precisely why, when you look at FY 2028, you can say, alright, that would represent a full annualization of the savings. That's the way to frame FY 2027 and the exit-rate savings. Look, we remain laser focused. To be completely clear, our attention is fixed on operating as efficiently as possible. The fact that we raised our goal from $150 million–$200 million reflects that commitment. We're definitely pushing ahead and enthusiastic about those savings. As I said, the complete effect will truly show up in FY 2028. Rajat, was there another part to your question?
Rajat Gupta
analystI’ve got one quick follow-up question, and it’s for Keith.
Keith Barr
executiveOf course. Fire away.
Rajat Gupta
analystYes. I'm simply wondering — I've had an opportunity to examine the portfolio a little. Would you also be willing to consider your store count, and perhaps think about trimming how many locations you need, the density you require? I'm wondering how that would fit into your thinking on rationalizing and just generating more efficiency. Thank you.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYes, this is Enrique once more. As we work through our strategic planning process here under Keith's new leadership, that's definitely something we are going to be evaluating; we're going to work through a strategic plan outlook. We'll revisit this later, and like Keith said in his prepared remarks, at the right moment we'll share those longer-term objectives, the goals, and the main foundations of that strategy. Right now, I'd say plenty is under consideration, and we'll be evaluating that as part of the strategy.
Rajat Gupta
analystUnderstood. That's great. Thanks for all the detail.
Sharon Zackfia
analystHello. Morning. Appreciate you taking my question. So as you consider making vehicles more affordable and obviously absorbing this GPU impact right now, might you also look at loosening certain CarMax requirements? Not regarding the mechanical aspect, I mean, but when it comes to cosmetic blemishes. Could there be a chance to move some vehicles that have dings or minor scratches, which would be more affordable for the consumer and could be plainly disclosed, since most of the research happens online?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYeah, Sharon, thanks for asking that. Certainly, looking back over the past year, we've increased the mix of what we call internally — and I think everyone externally knows it too — Value Max cars. We've raised the proportion of our older Value Max vehicles quite a bit this year, and that really signals that we recognize, as Tom said, pricing matters and affordability matters. One way we think about meeting the customer where they want to be met on price is simply raising our Value Max mix. At the same time, taking a harder look at how we can do that even better is something we'll consider as part of our strategy, because clearly sales over the past year haven't been where we want them to be. When it comes to going to market, we need to consider every potential lever. One thing we won't change, though, is absolutely the overall relative quality standards we hold and that we're known for. CarMax is known for a quality car, and that will continue. There are probably items around the edges we can take a harder look at and make sure we meet today's customer's demands today.
Sharon Zackfia
analystEnrique, may I ask a follow-up? I realize Keith has been in the role for a short while now, but could you give us any sort of timeline for when we might see the strategic plan, and perhaps some firmer targets on SG&A per car and similar items?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYes. You're correct that Keith has been around for a while; our planning sessions are currently in progress, and we'll begin holding those during the coming quarter. I think around June you'll likely start seeing a few headlines. I don't anticipate that a complete strategic roadmap will be in place by June. Come June, you'll begin to get a feel for the direction we're taking. Then certainly, soon after that, I would expect us to have a firm perspective on our direction, along with the key metrics that accompany it and our view of what lies ahead, which has us genuinely enthusiastic.
Sharon Zackfia
analystOkay, thank you.
Scot Ciccarelli
analystGood morning, everyone. I have a couple of strategy questions, if that's all right. The first concerns sales: if price reductions combined with a $300 GPU cut moved comps into positive territory, would you expect that to push them up further, given it's clearly working, or do you have some kind of floor in mind for GPU levels? Second, on SG&A, it sounds like you anticipate improving the customer experience, especially for online transactions. How do you reconcile that with the fairly substantial cuts you're planning to OpEx and CapEx, since presumably some of those initiatives require spending? Thank you.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYes, maybe I'll start with SG&A. Our target has been raised from $150 million to $160 million to $200 million, and we'll keep assessing whether that's the right number. What's important to understand here, I think, is that we have to balance our cost-cutting goals against our desire to grow the business, right? As you point out, there's some tension between the two, and I fully expect this will come up during our strategic planning discussions; we want to run as efficiently as possible while also ensuring the business gets the funding it needs; that could mean shifting certain resources around, it could mean trimming certain resources, and in some areas perhaps adding resources. That tension will be a central issue as we develop our strategy going forward. On the pricing side, another lever we always watch — and I believe it will grow even more important — is COGS, bringing down our COGS together with logistics costs. The reason is that doing so leaves you with several options. You can simply pass it straight through to the customer. You can apply it to margin to help offset some of that pressure, or you can blend the two approaches. That's genuinely something we're intensely focused on going forward. It will certainly be a core element of our strategy as we move ahead as well.
Keith Barr
executiveHey Scot, I’ll just add to what Enrique said. From my past experience, becoming a more efficient business and lowering SG&A doesn’t come at the expense of a great customer experience. You can actually improve quality, leverage technology, and become a more efficient business at the same time. I think that’s what we’re going to be very focused on. Spending time with the team in the stores, there’s a number of opportunities for us to, again, make it easier for our associates to serve our customers and give a better experience for our customers, both in-store and online, more efficiently. I’ve done that before and looking forward to working with the team to do it again.
Scot Ciccarelli
analystAll right. Appreciate it, everyone.
Daniela Hagia
analystHello, Keith. Congrats on taking on the role. I'm eager to see what you and the team are going to achieve here. Thanks for laying out the goals — I realize we'll need to wait until June for the complete strategic update. So in these first 90 to 100 days, which particular changes or quick wins will you focus on to streamline that digital experience and boost conversion? And which areas or metrics can we monitor against those objectives?
Keith Barr
executiveThanks for asking. As I mentioned, it's been four weeks for me now, and it's been a terrific experience — time spent in stores, in the office, and alongside the teams. I'm genuinely enjoying getting to know the car industry and learning where our strengths lie. I'll begin there, since I believe the Company has made strong long-term investments in both its digital platform and its geographic footprint. What we're concentrating on is connecting that digital innovation with physical retail in a way that's genuinely powerful and that we can use to drive growth. At the moment the team is sharply focused on the customer experience, especially in digital, and on figuring out how we can move customers through the funnel more efficiently, cut friction, and — going back to one of the earlier questions — if something takes us 10 clicks, how do we get it done in seven or five? Really grasping which features and benefits matter most, and so making certain we're driving customer acquisition while also moving customers through the experience more effectively, both online and in the stores. On specific metrics, I think we'll need to circle back to you once we have a clear view of the long-term strategy, since the metrics that matter most to this business must line up with those outcomes. Enrique, I don't know whether you'd like to add anything else.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYeah, that's spot on. And again, June might give us some signals about where we're headed. June really isn't that far off, but I think after that we'll come back with a fuller perspective on our strategy and the metrics we'll hold ourselves accountable to—and again, we're really, really excited about where we are and the path forward from here.
Daniela Hagia
analystGreat. Thank you.
David Bellinger
analystGreat. Thank you. Keith, congratulations on the new seat. There are two areas where we were hoping for a bit more detail. The first is conversion. I know you touched on this a moment ago, but how do you evaluate the level and quality of traffic coming into your site and your app, and how do you benchmark against others in the sector on conversion? The second piece is vehicle inventories. Looking at your app, you've got 55,000 cars in there right now; that's been as high as 60,000 or 70,000. As you bring in some of these new tools—including certain AI tools—does that create a chance to operate the business with lower inventory levels while still providing that core customer with the breadth and depth they require? Thank you.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYeah, regarding the inventory side of things, look, that's definitely a crucial element we have to take into account, and we need to strike a balance on what the appropriate inventory level is for each market, how fast we can get product to customers, and I'd expect that to be an important part of our strategic discussions as well, ensuring we hold the right amount of inventory. Is it lower? Is it higher? We'll ultimately see how that plays out. On the conversion side, that's clearly going to be an important lens as well. During the quarter just reported, I'd describe conversion as essentially unchanged. Our selling opportunities were also roughly flat. Web traffic rose 14% in that quarter, and for the first time in five quarters, selling opportunities came in roughly level rather than declining versus the prior year. That's a positive sign. To repeat, conversion held roughly steady. The things Keith mentioned about making it simpler and quicker for customers to go through our website and purchase a vehicle should certainly lift our conversion rate once people reach the site. He hasn’t been in the role long at all, but he’s already pinpointing what I’d call the main chances for us going ahead. Our aim is to generate sales opportunities and improve conversion too.
Jeff Lick
analystMorning to everyone, and Keith, welcome aboard. Tom, here's my question, since this is likely the final call you'll be on, we get to take advantage of your insight. Could you perhaps offer some detail or color on how you go about cutting prices? Clearly you didn't reduce every single price by $207. A few you cut, a few you may have actually raised. Any insight into where you're seeing greater elasticity — by cohort, by vehicle age — where you're gaining more traction versus where you're gaining less, or where playing the pricing game simply isn't worth it?
Tom Folliard
executiveHey Jeff, first off, how are you doing? Earlier he discussed fine-tuning the gap between price and cost. Like I said, when we cut price, it clearly shifted where our sales were heading. And as you correctly noted, when we say margins are down $200, that doesn't mean $200 on each vehicle. Practically all our cars end in 998. So that means we're more inclined to take $1,000 off a car — roughly 20% of the cars at $1,000 — to get to that $200 reduction. We're highly analytical about it, in terms of how we tackle it and execute in a manner we believe will maximize the sales change. The context behind that is we must operate a profitable business. As Enrique said, regarding some cost items, we felt lowering prices and getting sales headed the right way, then covering it by removing cost from the business, was the way to go. I think that will also be a theme for this team going forward — figuring out how to grow the company. There's no reason we can't expand this business with the footprint we have today and do so profitably. That's a mix of pricing, margins, CAF, and all the ancillary products we offer. Look, I think coming out of the quarter with a shift in sales trajectory was great, and we believe price played a major role in that.
Jeff Lick
analystJust a brief add-on question, and Keith, perhaps you can weigh in with your perspective. Tom, looking back roughly 10 or 15 years, when the industry was entirely brick and mortar, the approach, I believe, was to run a used car lot somewhat more customer friendly than the typical one, which would lend itself to selling newer vehicles. In your ValueMax, competition seems relatively lighter. I'm curious whether, culturally, you're now more open to exploring that seven, eight, or nine-year-old sale and, in a sense, blending the customer coming in for that three-year-old Jetta with the one coming in for the eight-year-old Ford Explorer?
Tom Folliard
executiveAgain, ours is a demand-driven business. Enrique mentioned earlier that internally we call it ValueMax. It's simply an older car with higher miles, but we want to hold it to the same quality standard. Enrique, I believe our inventory is about 50% ValueMax. That was 15%-20% 10 or 15 years ago.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYes. Once again, during this year we've definitely grown both the stock and the sales of our older vehicles so that we can reach customers at the affordability point where they want to be met, and that helps support sales. At the same time, Jeff, it's clear that, when you look at the full year overall, we aren't where we want to be. Right? I believe we have to keep evaluating things from a sales standpoint; we have to keep evaluating what the correct inventory level should be, what the correct inventory age should be, and the price points. That will certainly be part of our deliberation.
Tom Folliard
executiveYeah, Jeff, there are two sides to that. When you purchase older vehicles that have more miles on them, reconditioning costs you more, and it also takes more time to get them reconditioned.
Jeff Lick
analystAbsolutely.
Tom Folliard
executiveLike Keith mentioned before, this is the right vehicle, in the right market, at the right cost. Those factors together are what make it work.
Jeff Lick
analystGreat. Well, I appreciate you answering my question. Keith, I'm eager to be collaborating with you.
Keith Barr
executiveThanks.
Michael Montani
analystYes. Hello. Thank you. Good morning, and welcome to Keith. I'm eager to collaborate with you too.
Keith Barr
executiveThank you, Michael.
Michael Montani
analystI wanted to ask, Jon, if you could break down a little further some of the patterns we're observing regarding credit, specifically roll rates and delinquencies—both on a like-for-like footing when it comes to credit quality among applicants, and also in light of some of the mix shifts that have happened, perhaps toward more of Tier 2.
Jon Daniels
executiveSure. Yeah. I appreciate the questions, Michael. When it comes to roll rates and delinquencies, I think throughout the auto lending industry, lenders would tell you that customers—maybe with the exception of the highest credit quality, the 800+ FICO—are certainly feeling the pressure of affordability, inflation, et cetera. Consumers ranging from mid-Tier 1 down through deep subprime are under strain. Elevated delinquencies and elevated roll rates are what we're seeing, and as a lender our responsibility is to stand behind these borrowers, assist with servicing them, and then establish the reserve in anticipation of that. I believe we've accomplished that. By the close of Q3, our losses landed precisely on target in Q3 and Q4. We're comfortable with our position, yet a stressed customer does exist out there, and we remain thoughtful about that. With that said, once again, this is a highly profitable business. We deliver a fantastic car along with a fantastic experience. So that's the reason we're prepared to move into Tier 2, and that segment is expanding for us. On top of the Tier 1 business, you're looking at loan values of $3,000 to $3,500. We're eager to keep that growing. Our focus has changed. Naturally, we'll always accept every bit of Tier 1 volume, but Tier 2 is where we're expanding. We've made that clear. This quarter we're at 43% penetration. We expect that to speed up as FY 2027 unfolds. Over the past year, Q4 included, we've made market changes to drive that growth. We're looking forward to booking that Tier 2 volume. A year ago, we accounted for roughly under 10% of Tier 2. During this quarter, our Tier 2 figure is nearer to 20%, and as we leave the quarter, it's in fact somewhat above that 20% mark. We're eager to absorb that volume, serve that customer, set aside reserves appropriately, execute on it well, and clearly bring in additional income for CarMax.
Michael Montani
analystThanks.
John Babcock
analystOkay, appreciate you taking my questions. I've got two quick ones. First, regarding capital spending, you mentioned it will decline compared with the last couple of years. Could you give some detail on where the reductions are happening — is it maintenance or growth?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYeah, honestly it's a bit of each. First, on the growth side, we're lowering new store openings from six to four, which I mentioned in my prepared remarks. That's one factor. Also, when it comes to off-site reconditioning and auction, over the past several years we've been purchasing the actual real estate for those locations. What you're seeing this year is somewhat reduced real estate spending too. And overall, for our stores, there's a stronger emphasis on prioritizing resources. You really see it pretty much everywhere.
John Babcock
analystAll right, that's really useful. And with all the current events in the Middle East, I was just thinking — I know you've mentioned reducing prices and marketing expenses and all the other steps you're taking to genuinely bring in more traffic and boost consumer interest in CarMax. I'm just a bit curious, though: how have the Middle East tensions affected what you're seeing? Do you expect that to have a meaningful effect on your overall year-over-year growth trends, or do you believe you can grow in spite of it?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveGreat question. What I would say is, I'd really direct you more toward the industry, right, for the month of March; during March, the industry, helped by a fairly strong tax season, was actually pretty healthy; we won't discuss our inter-quarter performance, but what I would say is the industry itself is actually fairly healthy coming out of March, or going into March. I would say, looking ahead, yes, I do think it's something we need to keep an eye on, between inflationary pressures and between what has now been recorded as the lowest consumer sentiment on record here; it's something we're watching, right? At the same time, we're focused on what we can control. What we can control, especially now that we have a far more dynamic approach to margin management, is that we can respond to what's happening in the market quite quickly. We're excited to have that approach be a bit more dynamic, as I mentioned, and we'll control what we can control.
John Babcock
analystOkay, that's really useful. Thanks.
Keith Barr
executiveJohn, let me just tack on one more point there — what has genuinely struck me is the way the team discusses market conditions. Looking at supply too, asking things like: should we add more EVs to inventory? Should we also bring in more fuel-efficient gas vehicles? Always asking what the customer wants and how we can get that to them so we drive sales.
John Babcock
analystOkay, that sounds good. Thanks very much.
Chris Pierce
analystHey there, good morning. So if we jump ahead 12 months and we're looking toward 2028, I'd just like to get a sense — is it cheaper prices, reduced SG&A per unit, and a retail GPU that's structurally lower? Are there levers on the retail GPU side of things that you can pull too? I ask partly because there's a competitor getting aggressive with financing rates for customers. What would happen if that same competitor also got aggressive on price? I'm just curious — could you pull that lever once more and drive growth again? Or is this a one-time lever, meaning retail GPU has to move up over time?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYeah, no, I don't view it as a one-time lever. Look, a year from now, I think, yeah, we're laser-focused on affordability for customers. That does move the needle, and we need to now go back and work out how to deliver on it. As I said earlier, a focus on COGS and logistics costs in particular is going to get heightened attention in our strategic planning process. Because, again, that's a lever where you can either pass it to the customer, keep the margin, or do some combination of the two; it's a very powerful lever, and it's one where we believe we have opportunity and one we're laser-focused on. What I consider non-negotiable is being more price competitive. We've actually seen that happen. We do track our relative price competitiveness pretty much every week here. What we've seen is that price competitiveness has improved and is pretty much in line with what we expected for the quarter. We've been pleased with that movement, and you saw the results.
Jon Daniels
executiveChris, let me build on that point.
Chris Pierce
analystAll right.
Jon Daniels
executiveRegarding what Enrique brought up, you're touching on the retail side and retail margin. We've indicated, and made obvious through our actions on the CAF side, that there's a genuine opportunity in finance margin, and we intend to pursue it. The EPP product and the extra margin it brings have us enthusiastic. We consider this holistically and we'll approach it dynamically, and I believe we can genuinely provide support in those two buckets as well.
Chris Pierce
analystOkay. Enrique, could you help me a bit here — if I think about logistics as a piece of retail GPU, what size lever are we really talking about? Is it a couple hundred dollars, or can you just bucket it for me a little, so that if you did choose to take that back and pass something along, how big a lever is that on retail GPU, as far as you can say?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYeah, no, I mean, our total logistics spend is north of that, right? As for where the actual dollars would come from, logistics is an opportunity we're aware of. The actual labor involved in reconditioning, plus all the costs tied to that — parts, everything — is an area of opportunity; we think there's ample opportunity there to further boost and enhance how competitive our pricing is.
Chris Pierce
analystThank you, and good luck to you.
John Healy
analystWonderful. Thanks for taking my question. Keith, perhaps I should begin with something broad? We've talked about the retail strategy many times, I realize, but how do you feel about the financing business—do you like it? Are you in favor of the idea of reaching somewhat further down into that segment? Then, regarding the company's capital structure, I've long thought CarMax stands apart because it doesn't floor a large share of its inventory, or really much of it at all. Would you ever look at doing that as a way to bring in some capital, maybe to recapitalize or repurchase a large amount of stock? And how would you think about even the need to have CAF and possibly get creative with that asset, the way some other entities have done lately? I'd just love to hear your thoughts on whether that's also something you guys are considering. Thanks.
Keith Barr
executiveThanks, John. That's a pretty broad question. I'll handle the first part, and then I'll let Enrique speak about capital structure. Last week I spent time with the CAF team, and it was truly wonderful to be with Jon and his group and to observe the quality of talent we have in that organization and how we're approaching the business. As we formulate our strategy for the future—which we'll discuss further in June—the focus is really on grasping every lever available to turn this into a growing business and generate returns for shareholders. CAF will be a central component of that; it will show up in the lending space. It will also show up in the additional products we're able to offer. Where does that fit within our broader approach to selling for the company—getting pricing right, having the right vehicles, and making logistics better as well? CAF will serve as a key driver of profit growth for this company moving forward. We're really going to examine how it aligns with the wider strategy overall. I'll hand it to Enrique to discuss capital structure.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveSure, a few points. Capital structure and how we support CAF funding are definitely very dynamic, and that's an exciting space for us. First, on a floor plan, the revolver we have is the most efficient capital use for funding the CAF business. I wouldn't expect that to change. What I would say, though, is that on the overall CAF funding opportunity, as we've discussed before, we're looking at alternative funding vehicles, right? Last year we did our first residual sale, which gave us a gain on sale in the third quarter. We intend to keep leveraging that. We were very pleased with how that deal was executed and with the reception it got in the marketplace. On the other hand, we're also examining different levers, like co-loan sales. Is that an opportunity, right? There are multiple ways to access capital to support CAF, and we're exploring all of them; we have a strong portfolio of banks and capital providers we've dealt with for many years that are supportive of us. We also have some new potential partners out there, and we're exploring those options with them as well. I would expect that as the year unfolds, you'll see us exploring new ways to fund the CAF business.
John Healy
analystThank you.
Keith Barr
executiveGreat.
Keith Barr
executiveAll right, I believe that will wrap things up for the final question. Thanks for being on today's call, for the questions you raised, and for your backing — and I'm eager to become better acquainted with each of you over the quarters ahead, and we'll speak once more next quarter.
Operator
operatorThank you. Ladies and gentlemen, that brings to a close the conference call on CarMax's earnings release for the fourth quarter of fiscal year 2026. You are now free to disconnect.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete CarMax, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to CarMax, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in CarMax, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.