CarMax, Inc. (KMX) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

June 17, 2026

New York Stock Exchange US Consumer Discretionary Specialty Retail earnings 57 min

What were the key takeaways from CarMax, Inc.'s June 17, 2026 earnings call?

In the first quarter of fiscal year 2027, CarMax, Inc. reported total sales of $8 billion, reflecting a 6.2% year-over-year increase, while retail unit sales grew slightly despite a challenging comparison to the previous year's strong performance. The company delivered earnings per share of $1.31, a decrease from $1.38 in the prior year, but marked an improvement in year-over-year trends. Management maintained its guidance for SG&A savings of $200 million for the fiscal year, indicating a focus on operational efficiency and cost management as part of their growth strategy.

What topics did CarMax, Inc. cover?

  • Strategic Growth Initiatives: Management introduced a four-pillar strategy aimed at enhancing customer experience and operational efficiency. CEO Keith Barr emphasized, "We know exactly what needs to change, and we're moving forward with urgency," signaling a proactive approach to address operational inefficiencies.
  • Sales Performance: CarMax sold approximately 392,000 vehicles in the quarter, up 3.3% year-over-year. The average selling price increased to $27,288, which was a $1,168 rise per unit, indicating a positive trend in pricing despite a slight decline in used unit comps.
  • Cost Management and SG&A: SG&A expenses decreased by 4% year-over-year to $635 million, with management on track to achieve the $200 million savings target. Enrique Mayor-Mora stated, "We are on track to deliver on our $200 million savings target and we continue to drive toward expense efficiencies," highlighting effective cost control measures.
  • Dynamic Pricing Strategy: The company is shifting towards a more dynamic pricing model, integrating competitive market insights into their pricing algorithms. Barr noted, "We're understanding kind of pricing by markets, pricing by vehicle types," which is expected to enhance sales and profitability.
  • CarMax Auto Finance (CAF) Performance: CAF originated $2.4 billion in loans, achieving a penetration rate of 43.3%. Jon Daniels mentioned, "CAF was the largest Tier 2 lender during the quarter," indicating strong growth in their financing operations.

What were CarMax, Inc.'s June 17, 2026 results?

  • Total Sales: $8 billion (up 6.2% YoY)
  • Retail Unit Sales: 392,000 vehicles (up 3.3% YoY)
  • Average Selling Price: $27,288 (up $1,168 YoY)
  • Earnings Per Share (EPS): $1.31 (vs $1.38 last year)
  • SG&A Expenses: $635 million (down 4% YoY)
  • Extended Protection Plan Margin: up $35 per unit (expected by end of FY '27)

CarMax's first quarter results indicate a solid start to fiscal 2027, driven by strategic initiatives aimed at enhancing customer experience and operational efficiency. While the company faces challenges in core operations and margin management, the proactive approach to dynamic pricing and cost control positions it well for future growth. Investors should monitor the execution of these strategies and the upcoming strategic update for further insights.

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

David Lowenstein

executive
#1

Thanks, Bo. Morning, everybody. I appreciate all of you being on our conference call covering results for the first quarter of fiscal 2027. Joining me are Keith Barr, our President and CEO; Enrique Mayor-Mora, Executive Vice President and CFO; plus Jon Daniels, Executive Vice President of CarMax Auto Finance. A quick reminder: anything we say today that isn't a statement of historical fact — including but not limited to remarks about future business plans, prospects, and financial performance — counts as forward-looking, made under the safe harbor provisions of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Such statements rest on what we currently know, expect, and assume, and they carry substantial risks and uncertainties that might make actual results differ materially from what we expect; when we give projections or other forward-looking statements, we disclaim any intent or obligation to update them. For more detail on important factors and risks that could affect these expectations, please see the Form 8-K we filed with the SEC this morning and our annual report on Form 10-K for fiscal year 2026, previously filed with the SEC. Also note that beyond our earnings release, we've prepared our quarterly investor presentation, and both documents can be found in the Investor Relations section of our website. If any follow-up questions come up after the call, feel free to reach our Investor Relations department at (804) 747 0422 extension 7865. Finally, thanks ahead of time for limiting yourselves to one question and then getting back in the queue for more follow-ups. Keith?

Keith Barr

executive
#2

Thanks, David. Good morning, everybody, and I appreciate you being here. Over the period since we last held an earnings call, I've kept devoting my time throughout the whole company, hearing from and learning alongside our associates, customers, and investors. What I've taken from those discussions is a clearer grasp of the strengths setting CarMax apart from rivals, plus the chances we have to do things better, boost our results, and get where we're capable of going; we possess a people-first culture that has won awards, a brand people recognize, a national footprint nobody can replace, and digital abilities that matter. At scale, no other company can copy these assets. Once fully put to work, this mix sharpens our edge over competitors and will fuel gains in market share and financial returns within one of America's biggest consumer markets, one still very fragmented. Our aim is plain: produce solid growth in units and earnings so we can reliably reward shareholders; still, it's equally plain that certain areas have held back our capacity to reach our full potential. Our core operations aren't yet quick and efficient enough. Selection and retail pricing need to keep getting better, and our expenses are still too elevated. On top of that, our digital experience is overly complicated and doesn't link smoothly with what happens in person. Once a customer shows up at one of our stores, we fail to make things as simple for them as they ought to be, considering every step already completed online. That's created friction in the customer journey, which in the end hurts conversion and stops us from fully capitalizing on our unmatched scale and store network. We understand precisely what must shift, and we're acting with urgency. Today, I'm laying out our growth strategy, which rests on 4 pillars, puts the customer at the center of all we do, and is meant to substantially enhance how we run at scale while supporting consistently solid performance. Great offering is the first pillar of our strategy; we'll give customers every reason to pick CarMax. We'll keep our pricing competitive throughout demand cycles as we simultaneously grow saleable inventory and give customers quicker access to our vehicles. As an example, to sharpen our price competitiveness further, we're folding competitive market insights into our pricing algorithms at a finer level, with greater weight on local data points. Beyond that, we're widening comparison points over a larger set of vehicles to refine pricing on individual units. Easy experience is our second pillar. Through a seamless experience, we'll make doing business with us simple. Industry studies, plus our own observations, show that buyers are looking for both digital ease and a personal tie to the physical store. Few financial commitments in someone's life are bigger than buying a vehicle, and people really want the chance to look at, feel, and take a test drive in the car that will be woven into their everyday life for many years to come; we believe there's a major opening to bring our online tools and our dealerships together in a stronger way, which would boost both conversion and the overall experience for customers. Over the near term, our focus is on removing friction from how we stay in touch with shoppers before they ever walk into a store. This is so that once they arrive, they're more prepared to move forward, and so that associates have the tools required to help drive conversion. Since our stores reach 85% of the U.S. population, that gives us access to the biggest total addressable market. Because of this initiative, we anticipate that more customers will come to our stores, and we'll sell more cars. Adding value on each transaction is our third pillar; this one is about growing profitability by maximizing value across every part of our business, and it includes our cap full spectrum ambitions along with the extended protection plan redesign initiatives that are already underway. On the cash flow side, the way we'll gauge success is through expanding penetration and building profitability over the long haul; as for EPP, progress will be tracked by margin growth across time. We showed movement on both of those fronts during this quarter, and I anticipate that momentum continuing. Our last pillar is Run lean; we'll rethink the way our costs are structured so that we can support a terrific offering. Initiatives already underway include bringing down reconditioning expenses via technology and operational efficiency, all while continuing to provide the high-quality vehicles that customers count on from CarMax. We're additionally focused on improving our logistics network and on further trimming our SG&A. What we're aiming for is to cover the cost of sharper vehicle pricing ourselves, by running leaner, instead of relying on the mix of reduced GPUs plus efficiency improvements that we're using in the current year. Progress keeps happening on that front. On the logistics side, our attention is on cutting back on transfers that don't produce results, redesigning our network, and getting better use out of our fleet, both across CarMax and with outside parties. The goal is to bring costs down and upgrade our network so things move faster. Turning to SG&A, during the prior quarter we raised the savings target for our fiscal year 2017 exit rate, taking it from $150 million up to $200 million. We're still on schedule to hit that number and will keep pushing for efficiencies in expenses. This strategy is advancing quickly. Even though this effort is going to require time, the strides our teams are making throughout the 4 pillars give us encouragement, since those strides are already producing better trends that we anticipate will carry on this year. As for our first quarter, the near-term actions we've taken in pricing, marketing and conversion to reinforce the business and boost performance are reflected in retail unit sales. Measured against the same period a year earlier, and versus our strongest quarter from fiscal 2026, we achieved slight growth. On top of that, we levered SG&A on a total unit basis, expanded CarMax Auto Finance penetration and increased extended protection plan margin, all while our year-over-year EPS trends improved. In just a little while, Enrique and Jon are going to walk everyone through how we did in the first quarter. Our goal hasn't changed, as I've said before, and it's plain to see. We turned in solid growth on both units and earnings, which puts us in a position to keep rewarding shareholders on a consistent basis. That starts with getting our unit growth higher by making what we offer customers more compelling — more affordable options, a wider range of choices, and better conversion. At the same time, we plan to strengthen our profit-generating capacity by improving how things work both digitally and inside our stores, with our physical locations serving as a moat that's built into our structure. We're going to run a leaner operating model, build stronger bonds with the people who buy from us, and take fuller advantage of the unique benefits that come with our scale. Taken together, these results are going to reinforce our standing in the market and generate long-term value for our customers as well as our shareholders. We intend to host a strategic update in the fall, at which point we'll share further specifics regarding key initiatives and milestones. Our strategic plan excites me, and I have confidence in the opportunity ahead. At this point, I'd like to hand things over to Enrique so he can go into greater detail on our first quarter financial performance. Enrique?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#3

Thank you, Keith, and hello everybody on this call. Our performance trajectory gives us reason for optimism, since we're demonstrating obvious gains in both sales and earnings trends when compared with a year ago. Keith mentioned this too — we've also moved forward with SG&A cuts, growth in EPP margins, and CAF. In Q1, we achieved total sales of $8 billion, which is 6.2% higher than the same period a year ago. Combined, across retail and wholesale, we moved roughly 392,000 vehicles, a 3.3% gain over Q1 of last year. Within retail, overall unit sales rose modestly, despite used unit comps slipping slightly by 0.8%. We achieved this sequential gain in year-over-year sales even while comping against our strongest prior-year retail comp, which was 8.1% and supported by tariffs. This quarter's sales results were bolstered by more competitive pricing on vehicles, greater spend on high-ROI acquisition marketing, and early momentum on the 4 strategic pillars Keith discussed earlier. Our average selling price came in at $27,288, which is $1,168 more per unit than a year ago. Wholesale unit sales climbed 8.4% relative to last year's first quarter. The average wholesale selling price rose $405 per unit, reaching $8,364. Net earnings per diluted share for Q1 totaled $1.31, compared with $1.38 in the first quarter a year ago — a solidly positive shift in the year-over-year trend versus the 3 quarters before it. Gross profit overall was $854 million, a 4% decline from last year's first quarter. Used retail margin came to $501 million, falling 10%, mostly because profit per used unit dropped to $2,177, which is $230 less per unit than last year's record-high first quarter. By managing margins more dynamically, we reduced GPUs by an amount smaller than the $300 per retail unit guidance we gave last quarter, as we balance demand, margins, and efficiency gains in reconditioning to support sales. Wholesale vehicle margin reached $169 million, an 8% increase from a year ago, on higher volume and gross profit per unit that was relatively flat at $1.46. Other gross profit was $184 million, unchanged from a year ago. As Jon mentioned, on our fourth quarter call, we started in Q1 our national rollout of the EPP product redesign, aimed at giving customers more affordable choices and also introducing a new wheel, tire and dent product. EPP unit margins edged up in Q1, and the full national rollout should be finished by the close of this quarter. We remain on track to generate roughly $35 per unit in incremental EPP margin in FY '27. CarMax Auto Finance income was $140 million, a 1% decline year-over-year. Jon will share CAF details shortly; turning to SG&A, first quarter expenses were $635 million, 4% lower than the prior year quarter. SG&A leveraged by $118 per unit, or 7%, to $1,619. SG&A dollars in Q1 compared with last year were primarily affected by 2 factors. To start, overall compensation and benefits went down by $25 million, which came from the steps we've taken to cut SG&A. During the quarter, the year-over-year favorability was driven by both lower CEC and corporate overhead payroll. Next, advertising expense rose by $8 million, which reflects more acquisition marketing spend backing sales and buys. The first quarter's year-over-year SG&A reductions matched the related full year expectations we laid out on the fourth quarter earnings call. As Keith mentioned, we're on track to hit our $200 million savings target, and we keep pushing toward expense efficiencies. On capital allocation, our priority is still funding the business to drive strong unit and earnings growth that lets us consistently reward our shareholders. At the same time, we'll keep a disciplined approach to our capital structure, including managing our net leverage to preserve efficient access to the capital markets for both CAF and CarMax overall. Our leverage in the first quarter stayed slightly above our targeted range. Returning capital to our shareholders is still a critical piece of our value creation plan, and our intent is to do so at the appropriate time. I'll now hand the call over to Jon to provide more detail on CarMax Auto Finance and our continuing focus on full credit spectrum expansion. Jon?

Jon Daniels

executive
#4

Appreciate that, Enrique, and hello everybody on this morning's call. In Q1, CarMax Auto Finance wrote $2.4 billion in originations, which produced a sales penetration figure of 43.3% after subtracting 3-day payoffs — a gain of 150 basis points compared with a year ago. New customers were charged a weighted average contract rate of 11.3%, which is roughly consistent with Q1 of last year. Third-party Tier 2 penetration came in at 15.7% against 17.7% a year earlier, while third-party Tier 3 reached 9% compared with 8% twelve months ago; we had already indicated this notable rise in CAF penetration, and it stems directly from our stronger funding and underwriting initiatives. Worth highlighting, CAF ranked as the biggest Tier 2 lender across the quarter, which shows further evidence of the strides we're making with our full spectrum strategy. CAF income for the period totaled $140 million, compared with $142 million in the equivalent quarter a year prior. The loan loss provision stood at $96 million, versus $102 million in FY '26. Portfolio net interest margin came to 6.7%, up 20 basis points from the prior year. As before, credit losses this quarter matched what we had anticipated. Our $96 million loan loss provision mostly captures expected charge-offs on recently originated loans and produces a total reserve balance of $475 million, equal to 2.95% of managed receivables, excluding auto loans held for sale. Keep in mind, a $25 million benefit hit this quarter's provision, tied to loans booked before the first quarter that were categorized as held for sale in Q1. We stay confident that CAF can generate meaningful added long-term value for the company. Our full spectrum capabilities keep getting stronger, and our growing capacity to use a diversified funding approach when required gives us enormous flexibility as we push CAF's penetration higher. In the end, this deliberate growth, together with our EPP work, directly backs our aim of maximizing value on every transaction and will create future income potential for both CAF and CarMax; at this point I want to hand the call back to Keith. Keith?

Keith Barr

executive
#5

Thank you, Jon. The reason I joined CarMax is that I recognized a solid base and considerable room to generate growth. After 3 months here, my conviction has only grown that this company possesses all the elements required to flourish. What lies ahead involves clearing away the obstacles that have slowed us down. The plan we're presenting today isn't just a vision — it's already underway. Our 4 strategic pillars position us to make better use of our advantages and our scale, fueling robust and profitable expansion. We'll deliver an outstanding offering, so customers have every reason to pick CarMax. We'll give shoppers a simple, smooth experience throughout their journey. We'll create value on every transaction by expanding profitability across every part of our operations, and we'll operate efficiently by rethinking how our costs are structured. Though we're at an early stage of this effort, the progress already visible gives us encouragement. Looking forward, I have every confidence that CarMax holds a distinctive position to extend its leadership and generate meaningful value over the long term. We possess a well-defined plan, a sturdy base, and a team dedicated to delivering results for both our customers and our shareholders. I appreciate the time you've given me and your ongoing interest in CarMax. I'm eager to talk with you again next quarter and to share a fuller strategic update in the fall. With that, let's take questions. Operator?

Brian Nagel

analyst
#6

Excellent work, and congratulations. For my first question, I want to zero in on the near-term picture, so I apologize in advance for that. But on GPU and sales: like you said in your prepared remarks, GPU came in lower. Let is under $300, a bit above the typical level for this fiscal first quarter. So regarding the quarter, my follow-up has maybe two parts. First, when you examine the business, how much of a lift to use unit sales do you believe came from resetting this GPU? And second, as we look ahead at GPU, have you located the sweet spot? Is it likely we'll see more adjustments in order to hit that optimal point?

Keith Barr

executive
#7

Yeah, Brian, thank you. What I'd say is the initiative the team launched toward the end of last year, with an emphasis on pricing, began gaining real traction within the company. We've also been honing in more closely on that piece of the puzzle. So it's clear that setting our prices correctly relative to competitors has helped us, creating positive momentum for sales. We think that trend will keep going for the rest of the year, and we'll also keep beating the wider market; so it's clearly helping — offering the right vehicle at the right cost is clearly lifting our comparable sales, and we look for that to carry on through the balance of the year. I'll hand it to Enrique to give a bit more depth on GPU.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#8

Sure. When it comes to GPU, remember that during the previous quarter we told you that, for the near term, some margin concession is needed this year to help sales growth. Past that near term, though, what we're aiming for is to fund strong competitive positioning ourselves through more efficient operations instead of bringing GPU down, which lets us stay price competitive without hyper pricing profitability. And here's the thing: we've gotten off to a strong start. We finished ahead of the guidance provided at the close of the fourth quarter, and we will keep tracking ahead. That really comes from running our business more nimbly, with greater flexibility inside the quarter; instead of being anchored to certain and running the business around that. We're actually managing to the business and the demand we see ahead of us within each quarter. You can see the results here in the first quarter. Once again, we've gotten off to a really strong start for the year. As for other sales drivers on the quarter, as I mentioned in my prepared remarks, we did increase our spend on marketing, and that's another area where, certainly, we manage the business more nimbly rather than being anchored to a certain marketing investment per quarter based on total units, reacting to what we're seeing in the market ahead of us. So we saw an opportunity to invest in accretive marketing, acquisition marketing, and we did, and that supported our sales as well.

Daniela Haigian

analyst
#9

In a similar vein, looking at things closer in, given that a larger strategic update is coming this fall. When it comes to SG&A, it got better on a per-unit basis pretty substantially, yet as you mentioned, ad spend is higher versus a year ago, and you've also discussed putting money into enhancing the digital experience. How are you approaching the trade-off between rising OpEx in those 2 areas and those $200 million in exit rate savings. And so on an absolute basis, net-net, how does that stack up against a year ago?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#10

Yes. For the year, I'd say, as we came out of the first quarter, regarding SG&A savings we're right where we expected to be, we understood the first quarter would actually show some benefit versus the prior year, mostly because of cost reductions to our CTCs, to our corporate overhead reductions, and we observed that. But as for the full year guidance we gave last quarter, for now we aren't shifting away from it. By the close of fiscal year '27, we do anticipate realizing the entire $200 million in savings reductions, yet the guidance I gave last quarter continues to hold for this year, meaning across the rest of the year, there could be a bit of pressure on a year-over-year basis for SG&A; but once more, we're on track for the $200 million exit rate. And Daniela, along the way we remain focused on SG&A efficiency opportunities.

Craig Kennison

analyst
#11

Keith, I believe you brought up an excessive number of transfers that don't generate results. Could you elaborate on that matter?

Keith Barr

executive
#12

Of course, Craig, glad to do so. As we consider our approach to growth and every one of those pillars, a crucial element involves ensuring the correct vehicle sits at the correct spot. Transfers make up a major share of what we do. Each year, we move more than 2 million cars. So in my view, unproductive transfers have 2 sides. The first involves reworking our logistics network and finding ways to cut expenses from it more effectively, while the second means being completely clear on how those transfers convert into sales, and confirming we avoid unproductive transfers and gaps. That means truly grasping the situation, since it affects the inventory we can sell. So we're putting serious emphasis on whether we're moving the correct vehicles to the correct place for the correct buyer, and on converting a greater share of those transfers straight into sales, which lowers our total logistics expense. Naturally, what we spend on logistics supports our capacity to stay competitive when it comes to pricing. Everything ties together.

Rajat Gupta

analyst
#13

I wanted to get some clarity on something said earlier regarding the GPU; it seems the first quarter outperformed expectations. Is it your implication that for the entire year, performance will likely exceed the initial guidance of a $200 decline? I just wanted to confirm whether that's what you meant. Then, a second question for Keith. In terms of recovering market share, do you believe the business has reached a turning point? And given the steps you've implemented regarding pricing and marketing, should we anticipate that the business — that CarMax as a company — can begin capturing share over the remainder of the year and going forward?

Keith Barr

executive
#14

Yes. Well, thank you, Raj. I believe we have certainly reached that turning point. Upon joining CarMax, I recognized this company's growth potential and how it could become progressively more competitive. I think the team stands united behind that reality; and our capacity to comprehend deeply the essential factors behind performance and how we can take action on them and get pricing right to successfully push higher comp sales and maintain that momentum annually and once again, exceed the BARDA marketplace. So regarding your particular question, your question in particular, yes, I believe we've reached the turning point, and we remain highly focused on the reality that this business ought to keep expanding market share on a lasting basis moving forward.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#15

Now, in response to your question about Rajat and the GPU outlook for the entire year: at this moment, we're still early on in the year, and everyone knows this is a volatile business, correct? We aren't providing full-year guidance right now. However, as you're aware, while we're managing things quarter by quarter, should chances arise to surrender less margin, we will absolutely take them—just as you witnessed during the first quarter—while simultaneously balancing demand and the reconditioning efficiencies we're observing in our operations, which is excellent support for margin management too. But when it comes to the whole year, at present, we're not necessarily offering guidance. We'll provide an update next quarter regarding the full year, though it remains early in the year.

David Bellinger

analyst
#16

I'd like to revisit the topic of GPU. There were 2 particular points you raised during the prepared remarks—one about staying price competitive through demand cycles, and another about handling margins in a more dynamic way. So what should we take from that? Could we see greater quarter-to-quarter swings in GPU, and perhaps a strategic shift in which CarMax takes a far more proactive stance on raising or lowering GPU targets from one quarter to the next so that they align with the used car cycle? Might there be a scenario where we observe more variability in GPU down the road?

Keith Barr

executive
#17

Yes. Excellent question. Once again, pricing stood as our top near-term priority, and that effort began last year. We have stayed concentrated on it; and obviously, the key consideration there becomes how we bring down our cost so that we retain the flexibility to adjust our pricing and remain competitive in the marketplace while maximizing sales, and on top of that, we're introducing modifications to our pricing algorithm; so in the past, we possessed considerable insight into demand for CarMax. Yet at present, our pricing algorithms fold in market demands as well as unit demand in particular. That means we grasp pricing in a sense by markets, and pricing by vehicle types. As a result, we can operate more dynamically. So our focus will be on flexing GPU to maximize sales and profitability instead of remaining locked to a fixed GPU quarter after quarter after quarter. That said, we continue to stand behind our $200 reduction in GPU for the year, and we'll keep concentrating on ways to further improve on that; but indeed, there will be more dynamic movement in our pricing and in how we maximize sales and profitability moving forward. which happens across a great many other industries.

Sharon Zackfia

analyst
#18

So I suppose many elements were sitting beneath that strategic plan, moving from turning into quicker and more effective, toward better assortment, to lowering resistance and boosting conversion. When I consider each of those, I suppose, do you have the proper individuals and procedures established? Is there a single place where substantial spending will be required to reach the opposite side, and which of these would you see as roughly the easiest win that you could affect swiftly, and which one is perhaps harder and requires a longer time to reach the opposite side.

Keith Barr

executive
#19

Yeah. Well, wonderful, Sharon. Many thanks. The group here has left me tremendously impressed. I'm 3 months and a day into the job; and I keep being impressed by the expertise in the subject matter and the enthusiasm this group possesses; but at the corporate office, but in fact probably even more crucially, our people out in the field are simply outstanding; so we've got the proper individuals. There are several problems in the business that you've pointed to here when discussing pricing and assortment and such, logistics. And we have genuine clarity and will discuss more in the fall regarding a few of the central efforts that support each one; and we already have measures underway against nearly all of them and have achieved great, great progress. I think the 2 places we're concentrating on the most right now have really been making certain our pricing stays competitive. And so that's how do we bring down our cost of goods sold; and the group have, once more, a substantial number of efforts using technology, using processes and more to come on that they keep making certain that our costs remain under control, so our pricing can be competitive. And then it's — we're continuing to cut resistance in the digital experience and have it be better linked to our stores where the magic truly occurs at the end of the day. And just to offer you a couple of concrete examples. And so cutting that resistance in the digital journey, we essentially enhanced the entry point for our customers coming from online ads. We've made it simpler to navigate our website to get toward prequalification and reserving a car. We've successfully moved away from sticker prices to monthly payments. We've integrated AI-assisted both in our digital experience and in our CEC; so all these things are occurring right now to cut resistance and make it simpler for our customers to do business with us; but most crucially, as Enrique said earlier, our focus is to run lean as an organization and making certain that we can self-fund these investments. So we're not coming out today saying there's substantial increases in new investments in the company. We believe we have the capacity to do that today to move the business forward.

Jeff Lick

analyst
#20

Keith, I wanted to see whether we might dig a bit deeper into this idea of dynamic pricing and dynamic GPU management. Clearly, this is an area where you had plenty of experience in a prior chapter of your career. Obviously, you can usually secure one more hotel room booking by dropping the rate from $500 to 400, but the catch is that you then have to extend that $400 rate to every guest who would otherwise have paid $500. I'm curious how you're approaching that today when it comes to the used car business, your business, and the data you're currently looking at?

Keith Barr

executive
#21

Yeah. For me, Jeff, this has probably been the most fascinating area to step into. My earlier career gave me a foundation in pricing and revenue management, and I spend time understanding where the 2 overlap and where they diverge, because, as you pointed out with hotels, we hold an asset that cannot be sold tomorrow if it goes unsold today. With cars, what we hold is an asset whose value declines as time passes. So the real question becomes how to get the most profitability out of that asset and get the greatest possible efficiency from our inventory overall. In the past, our pricing algorithms were extremely, extremely sophisticated and we had substantial demand, yet pricing was really driven by margin; what I think we're moving toward now is more about figuring out how to adjust margin flexibly by maximizing consumer demand through external data — as I mentioned before, feeding that outside market data into our pricing algorithms, and doing so for specific vehicle categories. That means identifying where we have room to move on price so sales can be maximized, and where we ought to actually stay firm on price because profitability can be maximized there. The result may be some variation in GPU, but greater profit over time. This is also a space where our data sciences team is outstanding, and we keep putting more investment into it and broadening how we approach our algorithms and refine them as time goes on, since there is clearly an opportunity here to make our pricing sharper — though that has to rest on keeping our costs consistently where they should be.

Jeff Lick

analyst
#22

Let me squeeze in one short follow-up for Enrique. Enrique, a sizable portion of the rest of your gross profit came from the servicing side. Could you walk us through, or the service business, just how the mechanics of that function? Since clearly many of us here aren't all that acquainted with the way it truly moves through, because you lack a conventional parts and service operation.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#23

Yes. Service, in fact, during the quarter was robust. A year ago, we gave quite a bit of guidance and updates regarding how we anticipated service would genuinely get back to profitability, and it did so a year ago. We look for the same in the current year. I would say, in this quarter, the year-over-year gain wasn't large enough to really warrant mention and discussion; but I believe the way to consider it is essentially, it's the labor involved in reconditioning, and then we charge fees against that labor so as to cover the expense of reconditioning — that's the way to consider it; and so in this quarter, it's an operation that levers quite powerfully in the market, and when sales are robust, it will lever quite powerfully; and then on a seasonal basis, when sales turn softer, you deleverage on more of a fixed-cost type of basis. So that's the way to consider the service line.

Alex Perry

analyst
#24

I wanted to build on what was said regarding marketing and the project, and ask about how the strategy has shifted. In your view, how much did the money put into acquisition marketing help drive the sequential improvement in comps? Going forward, will you keep pushing even harder on this? Should we expect advertising as a share of revenue to move upward from this point? And what's the right way for us to think about that?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#25

Yes. Great; that's a great question. So, as I mentioned earlier, we're running this business with greater agility than we used to. On the marketing side, that translates to paying less attention to a fixed cost for each unit and paying more attention to opportunities for extra sales that deliver a good return while we're managing that period. During this period, demand was strong. Once again, we were lapping last year, and that was a positive comparison, yet we still came in roughly flat, with used units up slightly. Demand was strong, and we managed accordingly. The marketing group is really strong at figuring out the places where we might put money to work. We've got solid procedures for judging whether that spend will generate added revenue and whether it will pay off. That's exactly the approach we took during this quarter. My expectation is that we'll keep running things the same way, quarter by quarter, while also examining GPUs and other things that affect revenue. If it's something we believe we can activate, and if it boosts the bottom line, then that's the step we'll take.

Keith Barr

executive
#26

I'd like to expand on that point a bit, Alex. When I joined CarMax, one thing that truly stood out to me was how strong our marketing team is when it comes to data analytics. They concentrate on marketing efforts that deliver high ROI and operate in real time, reviewing things on a weekly basis — our team gathers to discuss how sales are trending, what's going on in the wider market, where we stand on pricing, what's happening throughout the rest of the business, and then we figure out the best way to put our marketing spend to work supporting sales as well as buys, which is also a hugely important component of our business model. So it's dynamic and it happens in real time. As Enrique mentioned, we don't simply commit to spending a set amount of money this quarter no matter what's going on. We examine it week by week and month by month, making sure we're getting the most out of profitability and sales.

Scot Ciccarelli

analyst
#27

So GPU fell by $230 while ASP rose roughly $1,200 — did pricing look like what pushed GPU above expectations for the quarter? Or did that entire result come from reconditioning costs being lower? How should we tie those guidance figures together? Then second, for John, a clarification: could you give us additional detail on the $25 million benefit to CAF in this quarter?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#28

Yes. On our ASPs and use, there were really 2 things behind it. First, acquisition costs generally climbed within the marketplace, and that pushed things up. The second piece was mix; during the quarter we carried somewhat fewer older vehicles. Demand proved strong for the younger cars, essentially our core offering. Those are the 2 factors that made ASPs rise — average price going up versus the prior year.

Jon Daniels

executive
#29

Thanks. Scot, I appreciate you asking about that $25 million figure. Yeah, to be clear, that was a held-for-sale deal we completed during the quarter. When we do a hub for cell transaction, those are receivables we don't have to provision losses for anymore, whether we originate them in the quarter or originated them before the quarter. This one was before the quarter — we had receivables sitting on our books, we'd provisioned for losses, and then those receivables got included in this '26 transaction, roughly $25 million of expected loss, which in essence let you release that from your reserve, and that offsets the provision taken within the quarter.

Scot Ciccarelli

analyst
#30

Understood. Then, Enrique, what I actually wanted to ask about concerned the GPU side — specifically, what the increase in ASP and the effect coming from the — what the — pardon me, the GPU effect, did the ASP rise account for part of that?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#31

Yeah. Those two things operate separately. What I'm saying is that ASPs will be managed separately from the way our margins are managed. There's no connection between them.

Michael Montani

analyst
#32

Here's one for Jon. Could you spend a moment on the fundamental condition of the consumer as you observe it through a credit lens — delinquencies and roll rates? After that, could you walk through how we should frame provisioning along with NIM as we look toward fiscal 2Q?

Jon Daniels

executive
#33

Sure. Thanks — I appreciate that, Michael. On the consumer broadly, I suppose I should start by saying we feel quite good about the consumer sitting in our portfolio, the one behind our receivable base, and about the reserves we've established. I believe the prepared remarks reflected that; three quarters running now, we've essentially landed on losses right where we expected. When we consider the consumer overall — and I believe this pattern appears throughout the industry — they're still being pressured by inflation generally. If you look at delinquency rates for credit cards, auto loans, all of that, those are elevated. That said, we believe we've got a strong grip on the situation, and it's already reflected. Now, regarding provision, both for this quarter and every quarter going forward, there's a very reasonable question: how should you model it? My advice would be to use origination volume as your anchor. Here's how I approach it: each point of penetration that CAF achieves translates to somewhere around $50 million to $60 million in receivables. When it comes to Tier 1 receivables, the provision we'd likely earmark falls somewhere between $1.5 million and $2 million. For Tier 2 receivables, the amount we'd set aside is roughly $10 million to $12 million. To give you a sense of how Tier 1 compares with Tier 2, at present the ratio sits at about 1 to 9. Roughly 10% of our activity involves Tier 2, while around 90% involves Tier 1. So you can run those numbers yourself and conclude that's likely what I'm originating across the entire origination provision I'd need to reserve. Even so, it's clear we're carrying out hub-for-sale deals, which genuinely demonstrates how adaptable we are when it comes to funding—something that moves around each quarter. Still, that adaptability is exactly what we appreciate, and we can get those deals done. After that, clearly, the final element involves our outlook on the broader economy and our thinking on adjustments to the book we already hold. Once more, we've felt quite confident across recent quarters about the way we've provisioned and reserved against that existing book. That said, this is how I'd assemble it: I start with total origination provision, form a view on held for sale, and then factor in the wider adjustments you may need to make for macro conditions in the existing book. That's how I build provision.

Michael Montani

analyst
#34

And regarding the NIM side, would you say 67% is the correct figure, or is it a 20 bps gain compared to the prior year? Or what's the proper way for us to view it?

Jon Daniels

executive
#35

Yes. Clearly, we're quite happy with that 67%. What I'd note is that seasonality plays a role there. This quarter gains from having many days within it, specifically the 3 months that are counted; so going forward, for the remainder of the year, I'd likely lean toward something like a 6.5 as how I'd consider it.

Chris Bottiglieri

analyst
#36

My question is kind of along the same lines as Mike's, but I'd like to ask it regardless. Could you walk through what's driving the allowance? It came in fairly large even with a strong tax refund season. I'm just trying to get a handle on it — you also brought up the gain from moving loans into held for sale. So I want to understand the increase in the allowance rate. Is it purely mix, since you're leaning more into subprime? Or is there some underlying deterioration, given subprime delinquency trends, that you're building reserves against? Just trying to figure out the buy.

Jon Daniels

executive
#37

Thanks for that, Chris. Yes, it's a difficult metric. We disclose it, and I believe it matters that we disclose it, as we've done historically, but it is definitely not a sign of weakness in the portfolio. As we've said before, our losses are tracking with what we expected, and we've set reserves at the appropriate level. There are 2 primary factors at play this quarter. First, there is definitely a seasonal element; it's hard to put into words, but in a typical Q1, holding everything else constant, you'll see an increase in total reserve receivables. Second, you hit on it; we're bringing on Tier 2 volume. I'm very proud of the progress we've made, with that growth and penetration coming out of the Tier 2 segment. I already mentioned what you need to add in terms of provision and, in the end, the reserve from a penetration standpoint in Tier 2. So that will certainly push you higher; and the third piece you also mentioned that will make it swing is what you've done regarding held for sale. So it can shift quite a bit, but in this quarter, mainly, once again, it's seasonality plus that Tier 2 expansion.

Chris Bottiglieri

analyst
#38

That's quite useful. Next, I'd like to expand on what Keith said regarding those $2 million transfers. Where do you see the largest opportunities? My rough calculation suggests roughly $1 million per quarter comes from transfers such as customer pay, wholesale transfer stores lacking recon centers, and auction-sourced vehicles. So it appears some transfers may be unnecessary. I'm just wondering what opportunity you see there, and perhaps an explanation of how things work under the current old approach would help.

Keith Barr

executive
#39

Yes, we'll examine that area more thoroughly, and our strategic update comes in the fall. To offer a bit of insight right now, though, we truly must examine our whole logistics network and grasp what the most efficient approach is for moving vehicles, plus how to utilize both our own logistics network and third parties as well. So we're launching a major effort focused on that, through understanding what our logistics network ought to be and ensuring it can scale as we keep selling more cars annually and buying more cars annually. How do we build a network that scales efficiently, keeps our costs under control, and also ensures we truly grasp why we're moving cars from point A to point B? And are those genuine — again, does it let us sell a car ultimately, or are they unproductive transfers; so becoming much sharper on that. Some initial work is already underway, but a substantial effort is about to begin, which I'm very, very enthusiastic about. And again, we'll share more specifics in the fall. But again, we view it as an opportunity on 2 fronts. First, we can have more cars available for our customers. That means boosting our saleable inventory and the time available on 1 day, 2 days and 4 days. So that raises our saleable inventory and will also reduce our cost, which means keeping our pricing competitive as well.

John Babcock

analyst
#40

I'd like to ask something — clearly, there are 2 components to selling vehicles. One is securing the price, correct? The other, obviously, is having the appropriate vehicle. From that angle, I simply want to understand what steps you're taking to guarantee you've got the right mix? And beyond that, how does that show up in the pricing algorithm, and how do you intend to tweak it moving forward?

Keith Barr

executive
#41

Great. Yes. I mean, we're nearly at week 2, and I was speaking with the team. Getting the price right, the car right, and the location right — those are the foundational elements for running a successful business, and truly grasping that; and so we possess genuinely excellent customer insight regarding which vehicles are in demand and how that shifts across the country. And that in turn directly informs our buying strategy and our understanding of these being the vehicles we must purchase, then moving them into reconditioning so they become part of our saleable inventory. So — and that's going to shift over the course of the cycle. I mean, at this moment, for instance, it represents only a small portion of our business; but clearly, a number of consumers are moving toward hybrids and EVs. And so our buy teams are out there concentrating on ensuring we purchase hybrids and EVs efficiently so those reach our saleable inventory faster. And once more, that will shift again depending on where we are within the country and across the year; so ensuring, once more, that we truly grasp that external input of what consumer demand looks like and how it informs overall, again, our acquisition strategy, which underpins our sales strategy.

John Babcock

analyst
#42

All right. And one quick follow-up, if that's okay. Could you discuss how fuel prices affected what you posted this quarter?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#43

Sure. When you look at how we run things, fuel costs do land on us through COGS. That said, our teams have accomplished something remarkable in getting past that cost pressure within reconditioning; plus, savings from preconditioning showing up in COGS helped explain why, this quarter, we could hold our margin sacrifice to a smaller amount, so to speak, in order to back sales. So overcoming them proved easy — very easy — this quarter.

Chris Pierce

analyst
#44

We've already gone over pricing, sourcing the right vehicle, and so on. So I suppose we could turn to pillar #4, run lean. What I'd really like is to get your take on the reconditioning side of things — how recon expenses can be brought down or how the time it takes can be shortened, and what you've learned from doing a per <<inaudible>> there?

Keith Barr

executive
#45

Sure, glad to; and if anything slips my mind, I'll have Enrique add to it. This area of our business is fascinating and hugely important, since as you know, right, acquiring the correct vehicle at the correct price matters enormously; yet after that, what we spend on reconditioning is essential for us to offer strong prices. We have terrific service ops and reconditioning teams in place today; even so, there's room for us to use technology even more to keep driving down our cost of goods sold via reconditioning. Some pieces are already live at the moment. One is our part selection tool, which the teams keep refining, and it lets them efficiently locate the correct part for the correct vehicle at the lowest cost. Another is our tire selection tool, now live and integrated with that as well. In the same way, we make certain we're scanning the whole marketplace to secure the best possible tire at the lowest cost, and those are just 2 illustrations; however, much more remains that technology can help us with, boosting our efficiency around labor and productivity and how we shift our inventory from raw to WIP to sitting on the lot at the end of the day, too; we'll certainly go deeper on that in the fall to lay out exactly what we're doing. That said, once again, it will mean investing in technology and adopting new processes, though we'll pay for it from our current overhead base, meaning our SG&A.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#46

Yeah, it's going to pay for itself. And what I would say is that for CarMax, this is hands down our largest opportunity — really, it's about digitizing the reconditioning operations, and refreshing those processes too. And we believe there's a decent amount of upside on both cost and speed simply from using technology more aggressively in reconditioning.

Keith Barr

executive
#47

Enrique, I'm completely with you on that. In my view, this is one of those places where, if we concentrate our efforts there and put the right money into the technology supporting it, we'll come out ahead — a cost edge we can hold onto, and that's how we manage to keep our pricing at the level it has to be.

Chris Pierce

analyst
#48

Could you quickly address something? I'm aware that you launched an additional stand-alone facility, and you now have a few stand-alone facilities that I believe have been operating for more than 12 months. In those areas, are you observing a meaningful advantage when it comes to reconditioning at stand-alone facilities? Or is it primarily about — I suppose I simply want to grasp, as you launch additional ones, what advantage are you currently observing, and what might you observe going forward?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#49

Yes. At this moment, 7 of them are operating. And I would say it remains somewhat early to realize reconditioning savings. They are still building up. And honestly, the point where we begin to gain leverage on those processes is when we reach a sort of peak manufacturing level, so to speak, and because they are relatively new, they have not reached that point yet. Where we are definitely realizing savings, however, is in logistics, correct? So a reduced portion of the expense of transporting those vehicles, since we are in market, we are in the appropriate markets, correct? So logistics savings, yes, preconditioning savings, you would not entirely include where we aim to be, yet the team keeps enhancing, so to speak, quarter-over-quarter. But I would not claim that is the current driver of reconditioning in <<inaudible>>, though it certainly will be.

Rajat Gupta

analyst
#50

I wanted to ask a follow-up regarding whatever preview there might be for the Analyst Day. I'm aware that you've mentioned a shift toward full-spectrum financing. That 50% figure was put out there. Has any consideration been given to perhaps raising that figure and perhaps doing so more aggressively? Would that be something you'd look at as a strategic change? I just wanted to hear your thinking on it.

Keith Barr

executive
#51

Okay, let me begin at a high level, and then I'll have Jon address that. What we intend to do is a strategic update later this fall, when we'll walk through in detail each 1 of the pillars, so you truly get it. The main takeaway is how tightly linked all of these pieces are. Individually, each one matters, but the connections between them run deep. That's likely the biggest lesson I've picked up during my first 3 months — nothing here stands alone. So we need to work through every pillar, zeroing in on the offering and the experience, figuring out how to deliver value via cash and full spectrum, and then turning our attention to COGS and similar areas. We'll dig into plenty of specifics there, covering both the initiatives themselves and the commitments you can hold us to. We're going to discuss how we think this will affect results as time goes on, allowing us to expand our business in a lasting way and beat the wider market going forward when it comes to revenue, while doing so efficiently—so that we also boost our earnings and give back to our shareholders. So this has me genuinely enthusiastic. The team has done an outstanding job laying out what that plan looks like. And once more, we'll take a closer look during our strategic update in the autumn. I'll have Jon address your specific question regarding CAF.

Jon Daniels

executive
#52

Absolutely, Rajat — thanks for bringing that up. So when it comes to the ad value pillar, capital spectrum is clearly a central backbone, and we've been signaling that for several years now. We feel genuinely good about the capabilities we've built out — the funding capabilities, the iterative underwriting capabilities — and that's reflected in the penetration we saw this quarter. As for your question about 50%, that figure is something we've put forward as essentially a midterm goal. We picked the term midterm quite deliberately; our view is it could end up bigger than that. Still, we're very enthusiastic about our capacity to reach that level. If you consider what happened on the Tier 2 side, we noted that 1 year ago we accounted for 10% of Tier 2 volume; this quarter, we're above 25% of that volume, and we expect that to keep growing methodically across the next couple of years as we arrive at that midterm goal. On the question of how quickly we can move, I'd say we've laid out a solid path. We aim to be quite deliberate, making certain our funding strategies are right. We're underwriting it properly. I don't want to get ahead of ourselves; but yes, I believe it's a strong mid-term objective. And past that, without question, I think it's certainly on the table for us.

Keith Barr

executive
#53

Okay, thank you. Appreciate all of you taking the time to be with us, and for the ongoing interest and backing you've shown toward CarMax. Ideally, what comes through is the momentum that's been established within the business along with the robust results for the quarter, and we anticipate that momentum carrying forward across the year, since we're going to beat the wider market. Truly thrilled about the plan this team has put together to, once more, generate growth that lasts, lift profitability, and deliver returns to our shareholders as time goes on; and once more, we'll have additional details to give all of you in the fall, plus we'll be speaking with you again next quarter; so thank you, everybody, and enjoy the rest of your week.

Operator

operator
#54

Appreciate that, Mr. Barr. So once more, everyone, we're now wrapping up the CarMax Earnings Release Conference Call for the First Quarter of Fiscal Year 2027; many thanks to each of you for being with us today, and we hope you all have a wonderful day. Farewell.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete CarMax, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to CarMax, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in CarMax, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.