CarMax, Inc. (KMX) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
September 25, 2025
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
David Lowenstein
executiveThanks, Nikki. Hello, all. We appreciate you being on this call about our results for the second quarter of fiscal 2026. Joining me now are Bill Nash, who serves as our President and CEO, Enrique Mayor-Mora, our Executive Vice President and CFO, and Jon Daniels, our Executive Vice President of CarMax Auto Finance.
Bill Nash
executiveI want to start by noting that anything we say today which isn't a recounting of historical fact — covering, among other things, our plans for the business going forward, our prospects, and how we expect to perform financially — counts as forward-looking, and we're offering it under the safe harbor protections established by the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Such statements rest on what we know, expect, and assume right now, and they carry meaningful risks and uncertainties that might make real outcomes diverge substantially from what we anticipate; when we give projections or other forward-looking statements, we renounce any intention or duty to revise them. To learn more about the significant factors and risks that might influence these expectations, kindly consult the Form 8-K we submitted to the SEC this morning, the Form 10-K annual report covering fiscal year 2025, and the Form 10-Q quarterly reports we filed earlier with the SEC. Also note that alongside our earnings release, a quarterly investor presentation has been prepared, and you can find both on the Investor Relations portion of our website. If anything comes up after this call that you'd like to ask about, don't hesitate to reach our investor relations team at (804) 747 to 0422 extension 7865. Finally, thank you ahead of time for limiting yourself to a single question and then rejoining the queue for any further follow-ups. Bill? Thanks, David. Morning, everybody, and I appreciate you being here. I'd like to begin today with what we're prioritizing. Our second quarter results came in below what we had expected, yet our attention stays fixed on boosting sales, taking share of the market, and producing substantial earnings growth compared with last year across many years ahead. We offer a differentiated, best-in-class omnichannel customer experience, and our aim is to get the most from that edge through greater operational efficiency and a sharper go-to-market approach. With that in mind, here are our main priorities. First, price and selection. That means keeping our prices competitive while limiting the effect of macro factors, and stocking the vehicles shoppers want at the high-quality standards CarMax holds. Second, building consumer awareness of the differentiated experience we offer. That covers our new brand campaign "Wanna Drive" as well as improving the conversion waterfall from web traffic through to the final buy and/or sell decision. Third, achieving at least $150 million in incremental SG&A reductions across the next eighteen months. This effort will be broad-based, and it involves using technology to generate efficiencies and pushing our net promoter score to new heights. And last, creating extra profit via components of our diversified business. That means growing CAF penetration and profitability in a responsible and thoughtful manner. It also means chasing other opportunities throughout our business to generate incremental flow through to our bottom line; progress is already underway on these fronts, and we have confidence in our strategy and our earnings model, which will deliver high teen EPS growth alongside mid-single-digit retail unit growth. On our first quarter call, I noted that we experienced a rise in sales volume during March and April stemming from the tariff speculation. That had an effect on how we did in Q2 in a couple of respects. For one, we built up stock in advance of Q2 to back that expansion. From May through June, depreciation came to roughly $1,000, which hurt how competitive our pricing was and also our sales. For another, though it's tough to measure, we think some demand got pulled forward into Q1; in Q2, our response was to cut retail margin to push sell-through, and we deliberately reduced buy to bring inventory in line with sales. That approach paid off, since pricing competitiveness and inventory standing have both gotten better since then and have set us up more favorably for Q3. Over the quarter, total sales came to $6.6 billion, a 6% drop versus the prior year, driven by lower volume. Within our retail business, total unit sales fell 5.4%, and used unit comps declined 6.3%. Weak results in our age zero to five inventory were partly made up for by stronger sales of older, higher mileage vehicles. Average selling price stood at $26,000, roughly $250 per unit below the prior year. Q2 retail gross profit per used unit came in close to last year's figure but was down about $200 versus Q1. That sequential drop was more than double what we typically see, mirroring the steps I described earlier. We'll keep zeroing in on staying price competitive, and we stay disciplined while remaining nimble in how we use selection and margins to generate sales. Wholesale unit sales fell 2.2% against Q2 of last year. Average wholesale selling price rose about $125 per unit, reaching $7,900, and wholesale gross profit per unit was historically strong, close to last year's level; we acquired roughly 293,000 vehicles in the quarter, 2% fewer than last year. From consumers we bought about 262,000 vehicles, and over half of those purchases came via our online instant appraisal experience. With help from our Edmond sales team, we obtained the other 31,000 vehicles via dealers, a slight increase over last year. The outperformance this quarter stems directly from a choice to scale back offers in order to rightsize inventory. We've stopped deliberately reducing buy and expect year-over-year gains in Q3. In August, we introduced our new "Wanna Drive" brand positioning campaign, which highlights our distinctive omnichannel experience. Our net promoter score is the best it's been since we brought our digital capabilities to the whole country. That's fueled by record-high satisfaction among customers who bought online and those who used our omnichannel experience. "Wanna Drive" shines a light on this distinctive offering, giving customers the power to buy their way, with the clarity, confidence, and control to navigate the journey on their terms. "Wanna Drive" runs across TV, streaming, social, digital, and audio and marks the first phase of a sustained multiphase strategy; we'll pair this approach with higher advertising spend, showing our dedication to long-term brand investment that backs our growth objectives. Like we talked about before, our attention has been on achieving SG&A efficiencies. The progress we've made to this point makes us happy, and we can see a path to no less than an extra $150 million in SG&A cuts across the coming eighteen months. Our growth strategy won't be affected by this, since we'll keep putting money into initiatives that set us up for what's ahead. Enrique will later speak about how broad we expect these efforts to be and when they'll likely happen. Right now, I'm handing the call to John so he can give you further specifics on CarMax Auto financing and how we remain focused on expanding across the full credit spectrum.
Jon Daniels
executiveThank you, Bill, and good morning to all of you. In Q2, CarMax Auto Finance funded more than $2 billion, producing a sales penetration rate of 42.6% net of three-day payoffs, an improvement of 60 basis points compared with a year ago. The weighted average contract rate we charged to new customers came in at 11.2%, compared with 11.4% during the prior quarter, and this mirrors the downward rate testing we carried out during the period. Although CAF's penetration gain for the entire quarter might look modest, we think the tariff pull forward in Q1 weighed on CAF share during the earlier portion of the quarter. Since the fiscal year began, we have implemented underwriting adjustments that equate to 100 to 200 basis points of growth, though the complete achievement of that growth may be affected by factors we cannot control, including customer credit mix and the behavior of partner lenders; it is worth noting that over half of the effect of those adjustments stems from recaptured Tier one segments, but with extra criteria layered on to lower risk. The rest originates from inside the upper half of the tier two space, which we have been testing across the past year. Third party Tier two and Tier three penetration together accounted for 23.8% of sales this quarter, against 24.4% a year ago, since CAF growth affected partner volume. CAF income for the quarter totaled $103 million, a decline of $13 million from FY 2025. Net interest margin on the portfolio reached 6.6%, an increase of more than 50 basis points versus last year and roughly consistent with the previous quarter. GAAP's loan loss provision of $142 million brings the total reserve balance to $507 million, or 3.02% of managed receivables exclusive of auto loans held for sale. Out of that $142 million, $71 million relates to new originations during the quarter, while the other $71 million represents an adjustment to the loss expectation for the existing portfolio; also noteworthy, as was observed in the first quarter, was a reduction in the required provision arising from $16 million in reserves allocated to loans booked prior to Q2 that are now classified as held for sale. The main reason for the $71 million adjustment on the existing portfolio is additional losses anticipated within the 2022 and 2023 vintages. Keep in mind, these customers have been hit hardest by the combination of rapidly rising vehicle prices and broader inflation. Even with the worsening we have observed, these vintages remain highly profitable, with an estimated lifetime profit of $1,500 per unit, compared with $1,800 envisioned at origination. Furthermore, they keep shrinking in size and in their contribution to the overall portfolio as they get replaced by more recently originated Tier one receivables carrying significantly lower loss rates. Note that 2024 and 2025 post contraction vintages remain right in line with the loss expectations we originally had. As for the funding side of our full spectrum efforts, yesterday we closed our 25-B transaction, our second non-prime securitization this year. The deal ended up being increased to a total of $900 million in notes, and this marked the first occasion where we sold the majority of the remaining financial interest in the transaction to outside investors, which gave us off-balance sheet treatment as a result. For the third quarter, we anticipate the gain on sale will come in at roughly $5 million to $30 million in income. Over the life of the transaction, we also anticipate bringing in about $40 million to $45 million in extra CAF income tied to servicing fees and the retained beneficial interest. Just a reminder, moving forward, no loss allowance or provision will apply to this pool of loans. At this point, I'd like to hand things over to Enrique so he can walk us through our second quarter financial performance in greater detail.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveThank you, John, and good morning to all of you. For the second quarter, net earnings per diluted share came in at $0.64, compared with $0.85 during the same period last year. Lower volume and the CAF loss provision adjustment were the main factors behind that decline. Gross profit in total reached $718 million, a 6% drop from the second quarter of last year. Used retail margin came to $443 million, falling 8%, reflecting reduced volume alongside per unit margins that stayed relatively stable. On each used unit, retail gross profit was $2,216, which aligns with our historical average. Wholesale vehicle margin totaled $137 million, slipping by under 1% versus a year ago, as lower volume was partly offset by a modest rise in per unit margins. Wholesale gross profit per unit came in at $993. Other gross profit was $138 million, 4% below the prior year. The main driver here was EPP, which fell $6 million because of reduced retail unit volume. Service posted a $4 million margin, a slight gain compared with last year's quarter. Ongoing gains in efficiency and cost coverage were partly offset by the deleverage that comes with lower second quarter sales year over year. Turning to SG&A, second quarter expenses were $601 million, 2% lower than the prior year, mainly because of reduced stock-based compensation. We keep achieving expense savings, though cost pressures during the quarter offset them. SG&A to gross profit deleveraged 350 basis points, reaching 84%, since lower volume more than outweighed lower costs. Deploying AI technology on an ongoing basis continues to be a major source of efficiency gains and better experiences throughout our operations. As an example, during this quarter Sky, our AI-powered virtual assistant, kept producing year-over-year double-digit percent gains in containment rate, customer experience consultants productivity, and web and phone response rate SLAs. We have now fully rolled out Sky 2.0, which draws on AgenTeq AI, and we anticipate that this release will generate still greater efficiency and experience improvements. As Bill mentioned, we remain committed to cutting our SG&A further by continuing to generate efficiency gains throughout the business. The investments in technology, systems, and processes made as part of our omni transformation will enable us to cut spend substantially through a number of key initiatives. Modernizing and consolidating our technology infrastructure, automating manual processes, renegotiating and reducing third-party contracts, and eliminating redundancies across the organization. Our objective of at least $150 million in SG&A reductions over the coming eighteen months amounts to a material improvement in our cost profile, and it reflects carrying out a plan we have been developing with outside support. Although we anticipate realizing a portion of these savings during this fiscal year, we expect the vast majority to show up in our exit rate by the close of fiscal 2027; beyond offsetting inflationary pressures, these ongoing savings will give us added flexibility to reinvest in areas that directly drive sales. At the same time, they will act as a tailwind to our already strong earnings model of a high teens EPS growth CAGR when retail unit growth sits in the mid-single digits. We'll keep sharing news about this effort on upcoming earnings calls. Moving ahead, there are a few things I want to touch on. On the marketing side, we anticipate higher spend per total unit during the back half of the year, especially in Q3, since we're properly backing the launch of our new brand positioning. We expect service margin to come under pressure in the back half of the year because of seasonal sales volumes. For the full year, we still anticipate delivering positive margin, which stems directly from our efficiency improvements and cost coverage measures. Switching to capital allocation. In Q2, we kept up our share repurchases at a faster pace, buying back roughly 2.9 million shares and spending $180 million in total. At quarter's end, about $1.56 billion of our repurchase authorization was still available. At this point I'll hand the call back to Bill.
Bill Nash
executiveAppreciate it, Enrique and John. The way we buy and sell cars with the customer at the center is a major point of distinction in a market that's both enormous and highly fragmented, and it sets us up nicely going forward. Our attention is squarely on delivering that unique, best-in-class experience while achieving better efficiency along the way. As we shared with you today, we're hard at work carrying out our main priorities, and those include pushing sales, moving forward with innovations that enhance how customers and associates experience us, strengthening our marketing programs, finding efficiencies throughout the company, and broadening CAF involvement across the full credit spectrum. Each of these priorities is going to provide us with more flexibility and make us stronger down the road. On that note, we're ready to take whatever questions you have. Operator?
Brian Nagel
analystHey, guys. Good morning.
Bill Nash
executiveMorning, Brian.
Brian Nagel
analystThe first thing I'd like to ask about is used unit sales. Bill, if I understood you right, it sounds like the biggest disruption in fiscal Q2 was a clearer or earlier pull forward of demand into the fiscal first quarter. What I want to know is whether you can share any figures that help us gauge that disruption better. And then, looking across the quarter — I realize you usually don't talk about sales trends within a quarter — but after that pull forward effect, has the business, or have sales, returned to a more typical run rate, and what would that be?
Bill Nash
executiveYeah. Brian, to begin with, as I mentioned, we believe it's actually two factors. I'd probably list the other factor first, since it's difficult to pin down precisely how much each one contributes; but my comments about buying inventory up and then watching that depreciation occur — I'd say that's likely the most impactful, and then the pull forward. Again, though, it's tough to quantify precisely how much each of those amounts to. For the quarter, each month was down year over year, and each month became a bit weaker as the quarter went on. What I can tell you is that for September and month to date, it's stronger than the quarter and any of the months in the second quarter. But looking at it year over year, it's still a little soft on a year over year basis. Still, we certainly put ourselves in a better position at the start of this quarter, both on an inventory position and from a pricing standpoint.
Brian Nagel
analystThat's useful. Could I pose one more question?
Bill Nash
executiveOf course.
Brian Nagel
analystRegarding pricing — CarMax has discussed for quite a while having appealing prices in the market. From hearing what you've said, it sounds like this is getting more of your attention now. Is that right? And my other question: are you noticing anything out there, or are rivals becoming more aggressive on price, such that CarMax might need to adjust its position?
Bill Nash
executiveOn the pricing remarks — first, you're correct. Pricing always gets our attention. We aim to stay competitive. During the quarter, we ended up in a place where we weren't competitive enough. I feel better about our current position. The only other point I'd make is that we simply have to keep being as agile as we can when it comes to pricing. You saw during the quarter that we had South dollar depreciation over a 1 month period, and we began responding to it very fast. A lot factors into that choice — what you do with your prices once you see depreciation, that sort of thing. But the main thing I want you to take away is that competitive pricing always gets our attention, and going forward the emphasis is definitely on staying as agile as we can, since it's an aggressive environment out there.
Brian Nagel
analystRight. Appreciate all the color. Thanks.
Bill Nash
executiveSure, Brian.
Rajat Gupta
analystThanks, and good to get the chance to ask. I've got two things. Starting with CAF: during the previous quarter's call, you said CAF income would rise compared with last year on a full-year basis. Could you tell us where that stands now? If your view has shifted, what catches me off guard is simply how large the provision increase is, since your prior earnings call happened only two months ago. So I'm wondering how things could have moved so sharply in such a brief window. Any detail on that would be useful. Then I have a quick SG&A follow-up.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveOf course, Rajat. Thanks for asking. Starting with capital income: as we said, this quarter took a bigger hit from provisions. We also noted our enthusiasm for the $25 billion transaction, which is going to produce a gain in Q3. When you add those pieces up — yes, we had pointed out that we expected capital income to rise compared with last year. My sense now is we'll land flat to lower. There are still two quarters left, of course, but flat to somewhat down. That said, I believe some favorable offsets are emerging. Naturally, every caveat applies around things like, you know, how the consumer behaves and what sales volume materializes, since that would produce provision origination for us. Still, I hope that provides some sense of the income cadence. On the topic of provision, that's definitely a reasonable question. Beyond what I covered in my prepared remarks, I'll add a bit of detail about what the quarter looked like for us. So let's focus on the 22 and 23 vintages. That customer, as I noted, had a high ASP, and you know, was certainly facing a higher APR environment and a larger overall payment. They entered the purchasing cycle, yeah, with extra cash left over from COVID. Additionally, they hadn't yet been through the full impact of inflation, so there was still a great deal for us to figure out regarding that borrower. At first, what we observed — well, keep in mind, we were emerging from exceptionally low trough loss rates tied to the 19, 20, and 21 vintages. That made it difficult to predict how the twenty two and twenty three vintages would turn out. Early on, losses rose, though that isn't unexpected when you're starting from lower trough vintages — meaning prior years. So as we monitored how that borrower behaved, we looked at it and suspected it might just be losses pulled forward. In the end, we noticed a modest uptick, which could reflect a shift in the timing curve. After that, we observed this customer starting to face difficulties, and those difficulties persisted somewhat. We implemented certain changes that struck us as quite beneficial both for the consumer and for our business, and events have confirmed that judgment. Specifically, we revised our extension policy during the fall. As a result, we collected extra payments that would never have come in without that action, so that counted as a win. Still, we had to keep watching how things played out; over the course of Q1, quite a few of those customers fell back into delinquency and loss. Beyond that, this is obviously tax season, which only adds to how hard it is to interpret the picture. So an adjustment was made in Q1. And we wanted to let everything run its course. At first, performance looked solid with those extensions, again. We were eager to find out how much would return to delinquency. Sadly, throughout the quarter, we observed a greater number going back into delinquency and loss. With that said, as you can see, we've made a substantial adjustment this quarter; last quarter we made what we'd call a sizeable adjustment, and I believe we now have a far better grip on where these accounts will end up, since we've now tracked those extensions nearly all the way through. Additionally, when you consider the full set of those vintages, roughly two thirds have been worked through. That leaves about a third remaining. So ultimately, it will, you know, run its course. More is still ahead. Yet it genuinely has played out. Then, looking at the twenty four and twenty five vintages, we're very happy with them. So, you know, we're monitoring those early losses. We're now twelve, fifteen months in, and that performance matches exactly what we projected. So, yeah, it was frustrating to need another adjustment. I believe plenty of, you know, complicating factors needed to resolve. We sense that we now understand them far better. And to wrap up, and, again, just to remind everyone, these are unbelievably profitable. You know, $1,800 rather than the $1,500 we might have expected, due to these loss adjustments. About half a billion dollars in lifetime value is what we'll realize across the 2223 vintages. So there's plenty to cover, since I wanted to clarify what was happening there. But with luck, that addresses your question.
Rajat Gupta
analystThat's useful context. Regarding SG&A, might you share more detail about where those cost cuts are coming from? I ask because it looks to me like plenty of it could be connected to the omnichannel support function, since you already have achieved solid productivity from your in-store sales staff. What I want to know is whether investors ought to fear that these moves could damage your capacity to win back some of the share you've lost. How do you weigh those competing priorities?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYes. Of course. Thank you. And also, what he mentions regarding offset from pickup and advertising. Thank you. Yes. Of course, Rajat. Let me get right to it; we don't believe it will affect how we pursue growth. Like I said during my prepared remarks, the money we're putting into technology, systems, and processes will genuinely let us streamline our expenses; to be very concrete, here are a few illustrations. First, we're better positioned to shut down older systems. We can reduce licensing use, either because fewer are needed or because we can cut particular capabilities, thanks to tech investments like chat. Thanks to what we've invested in Sky. Our call centers can operate with greater efficiency, something I've discussed across several quarters now. We can automate work done by hand, and use AI to check third party contracts more often. Those are only a handful of illustrations. They'll assist us in removing that 150,000,000, and as you can see, these illustrations don't truly affect how we pursue growth; another piece of our logic is that some of this savings, once more, it's $150,000,000, no less than 150,000,000, will be steered back toward investments tied directly to sales, for instance marketing this quarter. We're putting more weight behind marketing, which makes sense, for our new brand positioning, and that's one case of something we intend to fund. I believe it matters to keep in mind that we'd been in a phase of investing while turning the company into an omni retailer. Yet after that's finished, what comes next is truly to optimize and afterward streamline that spending. That's exactly our current position.
Rajat Gupta
analystThat isn't a net reduction of $150,000,000. Can you provide a net figure for us?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYes. So it will be net of whatever SG&A expenses continue in order to achieve that figure, though it isn't net of any onetime charges we might eventually have to take on. Still, ongoing costs required to capture those savings are factored out.
Rajat Gupta
analystNo. No. What I was getting at is, you know, after accounting for things like spending on advertising plus other sales programs. As I mentioned, a portion of that money is going to be put back into the company to grow top line sales; even so, we do anticipate that the SG&A savings alone will serve as a significant tailwind for our already strong earnings model. Got it. Great. Thanks for the color, good luck.
Sharon Zackfia
analystHi. Good morning. I want to revisit Brian's question about price. And when you consider it, and I realize you're discussing putting some of the SG&A savings back into the business. And in 2019, which feels like such a long time ago, you had mentioned perhaps aiming at some lower GPU to generate incremental sales. So putting all of that together, is there a way of thinking or a strategy around taking most of the 150,000,000 and truly reinvesting it toward the consumer and your pricing and selection to grow the top line? Since it really does seem as though the steady market share narrative we used to have has turned far more volatile, you know, after the pandemic.
Bill Nash
executiveYeah. Sure. I think your approach to this is correct, though I'd add a bit more. I mean, the $150,000,000 in SG&A reductions, as Enrique noted, some portion of that we will put directly back into efforts aimed at driving sales. The other element I'd mention, which is an additional reason we're concentrating on it, the main priority, is simply being able to produce more profit from other areas of the business. That likewise provides flexibility and lets you put some of it toward price. So, again, this circles back to Brian's original questions that we want to be as agile as we can make sure we're as competitive as we can be, and we believe we'll have multiple levers available to accomplish that.
Sharon Zackfia
analystBill, may I ask a quick follow-up? Do you believe there's room in lower demand sensitivity such that being more forceful with pricing could drive sales while boosting profit?
Bill Nash
executiveYes. Well, look. Whenever you bring it in, sensitivity always exists. As you know, we've discussed this previously. Since we test constantly, we basically know — drop prices by a specific dollar figure, and we understand the return. The way you must consider it, the way we consider it, is that many elements feed into that calculation when examining price sensitivity. Take, for instance, your variable costs. So the stronger your performance on variable costs, the simpler that calculation becomes. The capacity of your operational staff. Are they maxed out? Or not? Capacity? Are you forced to compensate employees for idle hours? Your ancillary profit attachment — how effectively we're performing in areas such as ESP or finance — there are numerous factors we examine to determine, alright. Is this logical? And that calculation shifts based on market conditions. I mean, even setting aside some of those elements, sensitivity will shift purely because of what rivals are up to; so we'll keep being agile; we'll keep enhancing some of these other areas since, once more, that allows the sensitivity to yield returns.
Sharon Zackfia
analystK. Thank you.
Bill Nash
executiveSure. Thank you.
Chris Bottiglieri
analystHi, everyone. I've got a couple of credit-related questions. First, could you go into more detail about that $4,045,000,000 servicing fee? My assumption is that generating that servicing revenue likely comes with some servicing expense. I was hoping you could help us reason through that cost, given that the receivables won't appear on the balance sheet while the expenses will. Then a broader credit question. You all have typically been quite conservative — very prudent, historically speaking. Now you seem to be moving somewhat into deep subprime. The market, which I realize is largely outside your control, appears to be softening a bit. I'd like to sort of probe this. How dedicated are you to expanding into subprime at this moment, given the macro environment? Will you keep pressing ahead no matter what, or if conditions continue deteriorating, might you ease off somewhat?
Bill Nash
executiveSure. I'll kick things off, then hand it to John. I want to clear up one thing regarding deep subprime. John mentioned in his remarks moving into essentially the upper half of what we refer to as tier two. So we aren't discussing deep subprime here. I just wanted to make that clear. After that, John, I'll let you weigh in on that aspect. The first portion of the question.
Jon Daniels
executiveRight. He gave me a nudge under the table since he was after that particular one. Right. What I mean is, we want to be extremely clear on this. It isn't — it is not deep subprime in any way. Once more, we've operated in the tier three space. And we do have experience in that area and everything like that. But, once more, we're attempting to remain quite prudent, as you said, Chris. Regarding how we move down as we move down; let's be clear on this. There is money that can be earned in that space. We have partners earning enormous profit in that space. You have to price it properly, provision properly, service it properly; we think, you know, we're figuring out how to accomplish that. So but, yes, I wouldn't describe it as deep subprime. There's plenty of penetration to be achieved as we gradually move down there. Without question. As for your first question about the expenses, let me just step back since I prefer to address that once I've discussed the overall program. Once more, we're incredibly excited because it connects to the first question. The full spectrum nature; we've set out a plan, and I believe we've pursued that plan. Initially, it was, hey. We're going to bifurcate our securitization program. That's been done. We've completed multiple deals at this point there. We stated we'd recapture volume in tier one and expand into tier two. Once more, we're being extremely prudent regarding that. Then announced that we had that plan to do a deal in which we're actually going to sell the future's residual interest in that deal, and we've accomplished that very, very successfully. So we're incredibly pleased; this was meant to provide us flexibility. Clearly, you know, provide us insight into what a deal like this looks like, and I believe we've hit on all of those. Having said that, we've enjoyed the game. We'll enjoy the game that we're going to see 25 to $30,000,000 in new highlights also mentioned the additional value to be gained on the servicing side. Once more, future interest there; on the expense on the expense there, yes, there's a bit of additional volume to be gained from the servicing side. There is a cost to us, but, yes, we will make additional additional value there. Enrique, anything you want to add?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveRight. And Chris, the servicing income isn’t visible to you. It’ll appear separately under the cap contribution line, so going forward you’ll have a solid picture of it in reporting; meanwhile, servicing costs are going to sit inside what amounts to the cost of your business. Is that clear? That’s the way reporting will handle it. And you’ll observe that as we move ahead.
Jon Daniels
executiveYes. And that 40 to 45 figure also takes in retention, right? A few retainers, plus the earnings from that 5% retention too — the five and five. So our expectation is that this keeps going as well. So overall, as John said, we're genuinely happy with this deal and how it was carried out over there, and honestly very proud of the teams for pulling it off. And like John said, this aligns perfectly with our broader strategy, and we're carrying out that strategy.
Chris Bottiglieri
analystUnderstood. All right. So does the bulk of that revenue come from the beneficial interest, or does it come from the service fees? Or would I even want to bring that up?
Jon Daniels
executiveYes. It comes from a blend, really. Yeah, that's right.
Chris Bottiglieri
analystAll right. All right. And I appreciate you clearing that up, Rami. You did reference those prepared remarks; you spoke about it there, so thank you for the clarification. Yep.
David Bellinger
analystHello, good morning. I appreciate the question. Could you help us trace the route back toward positive unit comps, and what sort of timeline might apply? Bill, you brought up the aggressive environment. So perhaps if we zoom out to the industry level, is the used car market simply deteriorating substantially in your view? Or are certain macro cracks appearing alongside these CAF adjustments? Or any additional indications of a consumer under more pressure? Or would you frame this more as a competitive factor here in Q2 relative to other players in the sector, and something you folks must invest against moving forward? Just help us assemble all of that.
Bill Nash
executiveYes; so, you know, when I refer to an aggressive environment, I wouldn't claim it's necessarily more aggressive than the prior quarter. It's been aggressive for quite some time. I think, you know, regarding the strained consumer, I think we are observing where consumers, particularly your mid to high FICO customers, they're lingering on the sidelines somewhat, and we simply gauge that through pure app volume. I believe we're seeing that with, you know, it's a bit of a headwind in September, but that isn't unique to us. We've spoken with our finance partners, and they're observing something comparable. So you know, once more, I think and even with that, you know, the consumer's been distressed for some time now. I think there's some angst. You could say consumer sentiment isn't great. But once more, I think we've placed ourselves in solid shape, and I think the priorities we're concentrating on will keep paying dividends. You know, as I consider the full year, we set out this year to gain market share. And, you know, look, across the first half of the year, we feel good about it. Through the calendar June, which is where we have data through. I'd just caution people when you're examining June, July, and August, it's difficult on a year over year comparison simply because of the CDK outage last year. But you know, we're not retreating from our stance; it's like we began this year going after market share. And at this point, I don't see a reason why we would retreat from that. We expect to gain market share for the full year; so hopefully that provides a little color.
Jon Daniels
executiveYeah, David, I want to hop in regarding the consumer and point out a handful of items once more, specifically around that cracks issue. There's, I believe, something really distinctive regarding the twenty twenty two to twenty three consumer, and this is a problem for the whole industry. If you check with other issue lenders, they'd say those vintages are pretty rough. It's sort of a perfect storm involving IAS plus a perhaps overly confident consumer who arrives believing they've got lots of cash. Then inflation hits them. When you consider the 2425 consumer, they simply come through the door with their eyes open wider. Pricing has dropped somewhat. You know, rates of interest have dropped somewhat. Usually, folks purchasing in a more stressed environment tend to do better. Now, once more, we believe we've reserved; we monitor closely how those folks are doing, and we're aware they could do worse than perhaps pre COVID. Yeah, I believe that 24, 25 consumer is simply going to be a superior one.
Bill Nash
executiveRight. So, addressing what you mentioned, David — that item would fall in Q2, so we're talking about something happening in the second quarter. We're still squaring that away, but our position on it feels solid, and that group is shrinking more and more. Like John mentioned, the extensions have largely come back in, and cleaning that up is essentially what this was about. So where we stand right now, we feel good.
David Bellinger
analystGreat. Very helpful. Thank you.
Bill Nash
executiveThank you, guys.
Josh Shang
analystMorning, everyone. Josh Young here, filling in for Scott. When we look at the sales deceleration, would you say the issue is that traffic isn't reaching the upper part of the funnel, or is it that visitors do arrive but then drop off further down? Any perspective on how you're approaching this would be useful.
Bill Nash
executiveYeah. Sure. Listen. Web traffic for us has grown compared with a year ago. As people move deeper into the funnel, our conversion is in fact getting better. What I'd point to as the largest opening — part of which is within our ability to influence, part of which isn't — is essentially the step from web traffic to what we term a selling opportunity. Is the visitor taking an action that lets us, you know, get the process underway, rather than simply being someone who lands on the site, you know, to browse vehicles. A portion of this will be beyond our ability to influence, since certain people are just, you know, looking around without buying. With others, I believe we do have influence, specifically regarding our effectiveness at that very first impression in the presentation, and how we make the site stickier at that upper section — the top of the funnel. So I'd call it somewhat macro, though I do think there are definitely gains we're capable of making.
Josh Shang
analystGot it; that's helpful. Thanks.
Bill Nash
executiveSure.
David Whiston
analystThank you, and good morning. I was sort of following up on that earlier question. Perhaps you can assist me in filling in a few gaps here, since it seems that when the quarter began, you expected the tariff-related boost in demand to materialize, yet it didn't really occur during the period, so you were attempting to move inventory and eliminate that depreciation; however, you're now saying web traffic rose compared to the prior year while conversions are getting better. Right. Your unit volumes declined by more than 5%. Pre-owned prices have stayed high for quite a while at this point. Is it simply that the consumer is holding back, or are they still experiencing sticker shock even after this many quarters of elevated pricing?
Bill Nash
executiveYes. David, just to clarify, web traffic is indeed up. What has declined for us is what I'd describe as selling opportunities. Once a selling opportunity exists, conversion — we're actually observing decent gains in conversion further down the funnel. So the real opportunity is that when a customer reaches our site, we need to get them to take some action there. And part of that, I believe, falls within our control. Some of it does not fall within our control. There will simply be people who arrive and decide, well, you know, either they're merely browsing or they simply aren't prepared to make a purchase. So that's the clarification regarding your question about why, when your traffic is up and your conversion is up, you aren't seeing additional sales. That's the reason.
Jon Daniels
executiveAlso, once more, I'd point out that we don't treat every bit of traffic as equal. You get a 780 coming in, compared with a 580 coming in. The rates at which they convert are enormously different.
David Whiston
analystOkay, and when you say high quality, does that include even the highest prime tier?
Bill Nash
executiveYeah, it does. What we're seeing is a drop in application volume from customers with stronger FICO scores. That group is really important to us as a core customer base. John, correct me if I'm wrong here. It looks like the decline is probably happening at 600 and above, especially on the upper end. The one segment that may not be shrinking is likely low FICO, around five fifty and under. And again, I don't think this is unique to us. We can check with other lenders and other dealers. You can see it in the credit bureaus; it's it's apparent.
Bill Nash
executiveAlright, thank you. Morning, everyone. Appreciate you giving me the chance to ask. Bill, I wanted to see whether we could get into how that reserved inventory idea of yours works. From what I understand, the window is no longer than a week — typically it lands at seven days, though that isn't a hard rule. That said, what our data, or at least our own review, indicates is that at any moment, close to 40% of what you have listed online is being held. And so it seems like — consider a vehicle that draws interest precisely because somebody has put a hold on it — a different buyer who'd want it never gets to see it. Or else they're stuck waiting at the end of the line. I'm curious what you think about how this is impacting sales, and whether you might reconsider that policy. Yeah. No, look — my view is there are two separate things: reserve inventory, and the kind that isn't eligible for transfer. In most cases, reserve inventory means there's already a buyer who's shown interest in that particular vehicle. So obviously, if someone in Richmond wants a car that's sitting in Pennsylvania, we see it as a major advantage that they're actually able to purchase it — and that's where our transfer process comes in. When it comes to reserved inventory, the main thing we'd be watching is whether we're staying on top of how much time a customer is actually allowed to keep the car or hold that reservation, and whether the deal keeps moving forward. As for vehicles marked as not transferred, the sole reason they aren't transferred at that point is usually something tied to title problems. Certain states let you sell them — you'll notice it on our site, hey, this one can't be transferred, because in that state you're able to sell the car without a title. Some other states require a title before a vehicle can be sold, so in those situations we won't move that vehicle. Later, when the title comes through, it can definitely be made available for transfer since it's still in our possession. Those are the two categories we consider that would reduce your total inventory that's available.
Jeff Lick
analystAnd, you know, my guess is you're not going to share this, but when it comes to how much you sell, you know, the share of folks who put a reserve down, I'm curious how many of them actually complete a purchase versus it returning to the pool; so how much inventory really ends up hidden from the next possible buyer for seven days.
Bill Nash
executiveYeah. I mean, we haven't provided the details, but, obviously, you know, we examine the economics behind that. Another point I'd mention is that even for inventory that's reserved, shoppers are still able to show interest in it and say, hey. Please tell me if this doesn't actually work out with that customer. Remember, when you think about reserved inventory, you know, a third of our sales come via transfers, and those go through the reserved inventory process; so you're absolutely right; we make an economic decision, and where we stand on that is we feel really good about it. You know, could we introduce a bit more friction just to ensure cars aren't held for reserve beyond, you know, three days? Sure. But that's a minor improvement.
Jeff Lick
analystAll right, that's great. I appreciate you letting me ask. Wishing you the best of luck.
Bill Nash
executiveThanks so much.
Michael Montani
analystYes. Hi there. Two things I wanted to ask. First, on the credit side — could you provide a bit more detail about how things developed across the quarter? Specifically on delinquency rates, plus how we ought to frame provisions heading into Q3; and then the second item, let's handle that one and hopefully we'll get to the other.
Jon Daniels
executiveSure. Yeah. Thanks for asking. Yeah. When you examine delinquency rates during the quarter, there's certainly a seasonal pattern you always need to keep in mind. So you're moving past tax season into Q2. Delinquencies build — that climb will continue across the remaining months of the calendar year, then decline again during the usual delinquency period. But overall, if you look at total delinquency rates, we really examine them on a vintage basis. We look at whether they're tracking as expected — often not the strongest signal of eventual loss, loss timing, that sort of thing. Broadly though, throughout the quarter, apart from, once more, those vintages we modified, as you'd expect, delinquency patterns on the newer loans, and even the older, more seasoned ones, stayed consistent; so once again, we feel quite good that as we keep adding that lower-risk, tightened volume, it will perform well. So, hopefully, that answers what you asked.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveAlso, Mike, I believe part of what you were asking about was simply how provisions might look going forward. And the way I'd suggest approaching that — well, you've already seen the provision tied to this quarter's originations. You've seen the figure we refer to as the true-up. What you ought to take away is that this quarter's provision on newly originated loans is, I'd say, fairly typical. With the business we're moving into, it could come in somewhat above that. Still, we're comfortable with the true-up; so as far as provisions go, John, and please jump in if you'd like, our expectation would be more — you saw the $71,000,000 this quarter. Again, you can look back at periods when we lacked outsized strips, and there it was likely running a touch higher, given that we are, once more, pursuing, yes, somewhat further down the credit spectrum. That will call for a bigger provision taken upfront; but, yes, ideally the true-ups will end up being small. That's what we're aiming for throughout this. We believe that older portfolio is running off. So, yes, my sense is you'd see more within that $70.80 — definitely below a 100 thou a $100,000,000 range when it comes to provisions.
Jon Daniels
executiveAs John mentioned, correct, what we observe regarding the 2024 and 2025 vintages is that they keep aligning with our projections when it comes to loss trend patterns. So, essentially what we're discussing here — and we did absorb a significant blow to our provision during this quarter — is really the provision tied to newly originated business, which John and Bill just addressed.
Michael Montani
analystAll right, and the next thing I wanted to ask about, which is useful, concerns certain of those expense reductions. You mentioned 150,000,000, and that might translate into roughly $200 per vehicle as funds for reinvestment, assuming you chose to go that route. And regarding COGS, I think you previously indicated there could be an additional 100 or $200 in that area too. What I'm trying to figure out is whether that's a completely separate matter, and whether my rough estimate of the COGS potential is in the right area. And then, the key point: if it takes a few hundred dollars of reinvestment toward more aggressive pricing, is that a commitment you're all prepared to make so the top line can be revived?
Bill Nash
executiveYes. All right. That's a lot of questions. I'll address the COGS and the SG&A. Your thinking on this is correct; those are distinct. Different initiatives. On COGS, if you remember, a year ago, we aimed, across a span of more than a couple of years, to achieve $200 in cog savings. A year ago, we ended up getting a 125 at the start of this year. We discussed pursuing an additional 125 during this year; thus we're further along than we expected relative to the $200 target. I'll say we remain on schedule for that 125 this year, partway into the year, and that initiative stands apart and is distinct from the SG&A reductions. So we don't want confusion between the two. As for your question about whether, you know, you'd be prepared to put all of it back in so that, you know, you stay competitive? What I'd say is yes; yet I'd add that I don't believe that will be required. I believe we can send a portion to the bottom line. Certainly, but an appropriate amount will be put back in. And as I mentioned at this point, I don't foresee a situation where every bit of those savings would need to go back into pricing. Still, I also want you to realize that we will keep competing aggressively on price.
Michael Montani
analystThanks. Appreciate it, Mike.
Chris Pierce
analystHello there. Good morning. I want to build on what was asked earlier — I suppose you addressed pricing quite a bit for the quarter and what lies ahead on that front. Should we be rethinking things, given that you folks raised GPU guidance somewhat because of your performance? Does all this talk about pricing suggest investors might nudge GPU expectations down a bit? Or can we not say yet? Or how closely connected would those two things be?
Bill Nash
executiveYes. Chris, that is a really good question. What I said back when the year started was that, when you're building a model, you can roughly figure that retail GPU will look comparable on a year-over-year basis. I also mentioned that in any particular quarter, there will be certain pluses and minuses, and I believe that is what you're observing right now. We continue to feel at ease about the full year using roughly that retail GPU figure as our aim. That said, what I can share is this: when you consider Q3, and you look at Q3 of last year, that was an all-time high. So my expectation is that this certainly declines relative to that. Compared with last year, it should land more within the typical historical band. I realize you didn't raise this, but my view is that you can apply the same thinking to wholesale on a year-over-year basis. You can, I believe, hold on to that goal we discussed, which is that it stays quite comparable. Yet much like retail, Q3 of last year for wholesale was among the best — likely among the top 2 or 3 GPUs we saw in wholesale during Q3. So my expectation is that it comes down and aligns more closely with typical historical averages for that one. As far as the quarter goes.
Chris Pierce
analystAll right. Thanks for that. I may have my years mixed up here, but I think it was calendar 2022 when you had excess inventory during that stretch and dealers were pricing more aggressively, and it took you longer to clear it because you preferred protecting margin over cutting price, and there was a more drawn-out reset of your inventory position. I just want to make sure that isn't what we're discussing now, given what you said about September and this being more of a onetime thing, or I suppose I'd just like to hear you walk through that, and I apologize if I've got the dates wrong because of how your system lines up the quarters.
Bill Nash
executiveYour date was off, actually. What it sounds like you're referring to is the major depreciation situation. That happened during calendar '23 and twenty four. As I recall, '23 had one occurrence, while '24 had two. We got through all of those. And for everyone's benefit, with those situations, roughly $3,000 applied to each one, spread across a few months. So the severity then was not the same. As what we're seeing now. With this particular situation, there are a few distinctions. First, it amounted to a thousand dollars spread over roughly a month, after which things leveled off somewhat. We're also heading into a stretch where, as you know, seasonal depreciation tends to show up across the board. So our aim was to be certain we made it past that point. But sure, with those situations you're bringing up, essentially, during those windows, you examine how elastic things are, factoring in all the elements we mentioned before that feed into that calculation. And, you know, we protected our margins somewhat more since, back then, that was the sensible call. In this instance, honestly, it was the sensible call. Let's push this inventory out; and so, once more, we'll deal with these matters whenever they arise.
Chris Pierce
analystAlright. Thanks, and best of luck.
Rajat Gupta
analystOh, hello. Thank you. I just wanted to ask a follow-up regarding CAF. Looking back at what was said, I still anticipate flat to somewhat lower results. Can you give us a bit more detail about the third quarter? You will receive the gain on sale of 900,000,000, but at the same time you'll give up a quarter of net interest income on that 900,000,000, so it nearly seems like a wash. Is that the correct way to view it? If you could provide a little additional insight into how you'd still reach flat income even with, say, 80,000,000 in provisions during April and perhaps the fourth quarter, I'd simply like to bridge that. Thank you.
Jon Daniels
executiveCertainly. Yes. I believe there are a couple of factors at play. To begin with, yes, you have the income, but you're going to recognize it all upfront. Conversely, as I mentioned, the receivables will no longer be there. You would have earned that income gradually. So it's somewhat of a pull forward. Your overall NIM is going to be affected. There's no question about that, Rajat. You are right. But, yes. Clearly, when we consider the provision going out, that's an important element. Yet, once more, you're also adding higher NIM receivables. So I think that is helping you restore that NIM, probably by the fourth quarter, relative to where you stand in the third quarter. So I think all of that is working together. Yes. I think you have servicing income. You have the 5% retention. Correct. So there are items that should offer a tailwind.
Rajat Gupta
analystYeah.
Jon Daniels
executiveOnce more, what I'd likely describe is that it's a bit lower, and a great deal hinges on the origination provision, the NIM's direction, and where losses land. In the end; but, yes, my description would likely be a bit lower rather than unchanged. Across the entire year? Across the entire year. During the third quarter. No. No. Across the entire year. So consider the prior fiscal year, and then this fiscal year. That's the comparison I mean.
Rajat Gupta
analystGot it. Alright. Appreciate the additional detail.
Brian Nagel
analystHey, thanks for letting me jump back in. So here's my follow-up, and I believe we've covered this before, but did anything stand out to you when it comes to — I'm looking at demand in used car units. Was there anything worth noting regarding, you know, the various categories of vehicles? I mean, did one trend come through more strongly, whether high end or low end, that sort of thing? And did anything change as we moved through the fiscal year?
Bill Nash
executiveYeah. A few things I'd point out. I mean, on the whole, the industry as a whole, you're seeing older vehicles. Like, when you look at registrations for older vehicles, vehicles that are, you know, beyond ten years of age, ten years old, that segment of the market is performing better than the zero to 10. You know, during the first quarter, we had somewhat of a barbell effect, where cars under $25,000 rose year over year, and so did, like, those at 40,000 plus. This quarter, just about everything declined. The under 25,000 was, you know, as a share of sales, it was up somewhat compared with last year. But, you know, when it comes to the others, they were either lower or pretty much flat; so you still gained a bit more as a share of sales from the under $25,000 car.
Brian Nagel
analystAnd building on that, I realize you've been shifting your merchandising approach, you know, to align with what customers want. But looking ahead, are you going to lean even more into that older inventory sitting in the system?
Bill Nash
executiveYeah. Listen, Brian, we've clearly had our attention on this. I believe when we consider what we refer to as that value max sale — say 6 years or older, or beyond 60,000 miles — we saw an increase in sales there. Comparing year over year, we experienced a modest uptick, meaning we had a greater supply of those vehicles on hand. I think our aim is to keep offering more of that going forward, but I also believe we need to ensure there's a solid mix of newer pre-owned vehicles too, since that draws in a large number of CarMax shoppers as well. So, at a certain point, you can't just rely on that — the advantage of stocking older, higher-mileage cars will get canceled out because you're missing some of the models that, you know, the typical car buyer wants; so we'll navigate that carefully.
Brian Nagel
analystI appreciate it. Thanks.
Bill Nash
executiveSure. Thank you.
Bill Nash
executiveThanks, Nikki. Alright, so thanks for being on today's call, and for the questions and the backing. As ever, I want to express appreciation to our associates for all they do looking after one another along with the customers in the communities we serve, and we'll speak again in the next quarter.
Operator
operatorThanks very much, everyone. That wraps up the CarMax Earnings Release Conference Call for the second quarter of fiscal year 2026. You're free to disconnect at this point.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete CarMax, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to CarMax, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in CarMax, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.