CarMax, Inc. (KMX) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

June 20, 2025

New York Stock Exchange US Consumer Discretionary Specialty Retail earnings 55 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

David Lowenstein

executive
#1

Thanks, Nicky. Hello, everyone, and I appreciate you being on the call for our first quarter of fiscal 2026 earnings discussion. Joining me are Bill Nash, who serves as our President and CEO; Enrique Mayor-Mora, our Executive Vice President and CFO; and Jon Daniels, our Executive Vice President of CarMax Auto Finance. I want to point out that anything we say today that isn't a statement of historical fact — including, though not limited to, remarks about the company's future business plans, prospects and financial performance — constitutes forward-looking statements made under the safe harbor provisions of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Such statements rest on what we currently know, expect and assume, and they carry substantial risks and uncertainties that might cause actual results to differ materially from what we expect. When we provide projections and other forward-looking statements, we disclaim any intent or obligation to update them. For more details on important facts and risks that could affect these expectations, please refer to our Form 8-K filed with the SEC this morning and an annual report on Form 10-K for fiscal year 2025 previously filed with the SEC. If any follow-up questions come up after the call, don't hesitate to reach our Investor Relations department at (804) 747 to 0422, extension 7865. Finally, I'd like to thank you ahead of time for limiting yourselves to one question and then getting back in the queue for more follow-ups. Bill?

Bill Nash

executive
#2

Appreciate that, David. Good morning, everyone, and thanks for joining us. What we delivered in Q1 demonstrates just how effective our model for growing earnings is, and that model is built on a top-tier omnichannel experience, the breadth of our business, and disciplined execution. Throughout the entire organization, we take a continuous improvement approach. Our priorities are driving sales higher, capturing more market share, growing gross profit, controlling CAFs, expanding the credit spectrum, getting leverage out of SG&A, and repurchasing shares. That discipline, combined with what we can offer customers—a distinctive experience spanning our sizable total addressable market—gives us plenty of room to grow profitably for a long time. During the first quarter, our retail and wholesale unit volume increased compared to the same period last year. We provided strong retail, wholesale, EPP, and service GPUs. We acquired additional vehicles from consumers as well as dealers, setting a new all-time high with dealers. CAF's net interest margin expanded, and we kept moving forward with our full credit spectrum underwriting and funding model. We significantly improved SG&A as a percentage of gross profit. Our share repurchase rate was twice as fast, and EPS growth reached 42%. This represents our fourth quarter in a row of positive retail unit comps along with double-digit year-over-year growth in earnings per share. For the quarter, overall revenue reached $7.5 billion, marking a 6% gain over the prior-year period. That came from increased volume, though softer pricing partly worked against it. Within retail, units sold climbed 9%, and comparable used units rose 8.1%. The typical selling price came in at $26,100, which is roughly $400 lower per vehicle than a year ago. Retail gross profit on each used vehicle during the first quarter set a company record, helped by robust demand plus efficiency gains in both our logistics network and reconditioning operations. Wholesale units moved up 1.2% from the same quarter last year. The average wholesale price fell about $150 per unit, landing at $8,000. Wholesale gross profit per unit remained strong by historical standards, roughly matching last year's figure. During the quarter, we acquired around 336,000 vehicles, which represents a 7% increase versus a year ago. Roughly 288,000 vehicles came to us from consumers, and over half of those purchases were completed via our instant online appraisal tool. The remaining 48,000 or so vehicles were sourced through dealers with help from our Edmunds sales team — a 38% jump compared to last year. In Q1, digital tools powered 80% of our retail unit sales: 66% were omni and 14% were online. When you look at traditional and online-only dealers, we're the sole nationwide retailer delivering an integrated, simple, seamless and personalized experience that serves the biggest and fastest-growing group of used car buyers. Based on research from Cox Automotive and our own findings, most people in the market for a used vehicle plan to complete their purchase through a combined online and in-person approach. What sets us apart is how we bring together our team members, physical locations, technology, and digital tools into one smooth experience, giving buyers the choice to shop on the web, visit a store, or do both. Our current Net Promoter Score is higher than anything we've seen since rolling out digital capabilities nationwide, and it's supported by new records in both online and omni scores, demonstrating that this approach resonates well with customers. Since what we offer is unique, we have a special opportunity to reach a broader group of buyers. To seize that chance even more fully, we’re eager to roll out a fresh marketing campaign later in the summer, one that will put our omnichannel experience and digital capabilities front and center for a wide range of consumers. At this point I’ll hand the call to Jon so he can share additional details about CarMax Auto Finance. Jon?

Jon Daniels

executive
#3

Thank you, Bill, and good morning to all of you. In Q1, CarMax Auto Finance wrote more than $2.3 billion in originations, producing sales penetration of 41.8% net of 3-day payoffs — a figure 150 basis points under where it stood a year ago. New customers were charged a weighted average contract rate of 11.4%, matching what we saw in the first quarter of last year. The decline in CAF's penetration came mostly from a wave of self-funded buyers with higher credit scores who showed up when tariffs were first announced, and to a smaller extent from greater Tier 3 penetration; together, those factors more than canceled out the expansion we've achieved since Q4. Third-party Tier 2 penetration for the quarter fell 100 basis points versus a year earlier, landing at 17.7% of sales, while third-party Tier 3 volume made up 8% of sales, compared with 7.5% a year ago. CAF income came to $142 million in the quarter, a drop of $5 million against FY '25. Net interest margin reached 6.5%, climbing more than 30 basis points from a year ago, since customer APRs grew faster than our funding cost rose. Several notable items affected CAF's loan loss provision of $102 million. To start, Q1 is a period of seasonally stronger sales and weaker credit quality, so a bigger provision is needed for newly originated volume. Next, loss performance during the quarter — especially among 2022 and 2023 vintages — combined with an uncertain economic outlook made additional loss reserves necessary. Keep in mind that 2024 vintages are still largely consistent with the loss expectation we originally set. The final item worth flagging that affected the Q1 provision involves CAF's ongoing build-out of full spectrum lending capabilities. We stay focused on raising penetration across the credit spectrum, but we also aim to carefully manage future risk from receivables that carry higher profit and higher loss. With that in mind, we designated a held-for-sale pool of loans during the quarter, drawn from our nonprime portfolio with a $632 million principal balance; the intention is to fully sell that loan pool off our balance sheet through a nonprime securitization transaction; right away, this treatment eliminates the need to reserve for future losses anticipated on these receivables. When the ABS transaction closes, CAF will record any gain from selling the financial interest in the loans; furthermore, once sold, the risk of any financial impact from this pool tied to future deterioration goes away. This added funding lever, along with other off-balance sheet funding vehicles we're considering, will give CarMax substantial flexibility and let us mitigate risk while keeping our attention on the growth plan. Our loan loss provision of $102 million leaves a total reserve balance of $474 million, or 2.76% of managed receivables, excluding auto loans held for sale. Be aware that this quarter's provision was reduced by $26 million in reserves allocated to loans booked before the first quarter that are now classified as held for sale. Looking at the bigger picture, CAF has once again produced solid income for the quarter, and we see enormous potential ahead. At this point, I'll hand things over to Enrique so he can walk us through the specifics of how we did financially in Q1. Enrique?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#4

Jon, thanks, and good morning to all of you. Just to remind everyone, during the prior quarter we showed you the strength of the earnings framework we've established via our omni transformation. If retail unit growth lands in the mid-single digits, that framework is designed to deliver an annual EPS CAGR in the high teens. Net earnings per diluted share for Q1 totaled $1.38, a 42% increase compared with the same period last year. Gross profit overall hit $894 million, which is 13% above what we posted in last year's first quarter. Our used retail margin came to $554 million, up 12%, aided by both greater volume and higher per unit margins. On each used vehicle we retailed, gross profit reached $2,407 — $60 better than the same period last year and the highest we've ever seen. For wholesale vehicles, margin totaled $157 million, matching last year's figure, since greater volume was canceled out by somewhat lower margins on each unit. Each wholesale unit brought in $1,047 of gross profit, a historically solid result even if it slipped a bit versus a year ago. Other gross profit landed at $183 million, climbing 31% year over year, mostly thanks to EPP combined with service. EPP rose $13 million, equal to $9 per retail unit, now that we've fully lapped the margin gains booked during the previous year. In our Service segment, margins came in at $33 million. That's an improvement of $30 million compared with the first quarter a year ago. Cost coverage, leverage from volume, and efficiencies are what drove this gain. Turning to SG&A, first-quarter expenses reached $660 million, which is 3% higher, or $21 million more, than the same period last year. The ratio of SG&A to gross profit improved by 680 basis points, landing at 74%, thanks to gross profit growth along with the steps we keep taking to hold down expenses. The year-over-year change in first-quarter SG&A dollars came largely from a $19 million rise in compensation and benefits. Unit volume growth accounted for most of that increase. We're still generating efficiency improvements throughout the business. We've made a solid beginning toward our target of reaching omni cost neutrality during fiscal year '26 — something we've never done before across 3 important measures. During Q1, we operated more efficiently than we did before omni and also better than the same period a year ago, whether you look at each used unit, each total unit, or as a share of gross profit. Keep in mind, what we're comparing here involves the variable commission expenses tied to purchasing and selling cars under the pre-omni approach against what we spend today, which covers a fresh per-unit commission plus the expense of operating our customer experience centers. One major factor behind these efficiency improvements and better experiences has been the way we've strategically put AI technology to work throughout our business. Here are some important figures that show how far we've come compared with a year ago. Skye, the virtual assistant we run on AI, lifted its containment rate by 30%. The productivity of our customer experience consultants rose 24%, and our service-level agreements for phone and web response rates climbed by double digits. We still have an enormous opportunity to expand AI applications across the entire organization, which would drive both top-line growth and stronger operational performance. Turning now to capital deployment: our commitment to creating shareholder value over the long term remains exactly the same. Our list of priorities is straightforward: put money into the core business, mainly by shifting resources around, look at fresh growth possibilities via investments, partnerships, or acquisitions, and give back any surplus capital to shareholders. In Q1, we picked up the speed on buying back our stock, repurchasing roughly 3 million shares and spending $200 million in total. At quarter's close, we still had authorization left to repurchase about $1.74 billion. For the rest of the year, I want to touch on several points. We anticipate service margin will rise compared to last year, mostly during the first half, and will produce a positive profit contribution across the full year, subject to how sales perform, because service has a leverage — deleverage characteristic. Keep in mind that Q1 tends to be the best period for service margins, since seasonal sales volumes are higher then. Moving to marketing, our expectation for the entire year is that spending per total unit will be unchanged versus last year. On CAF's funding approach, the plan we have right now is to carry out the programmatic off-balance sheet sale of the financial interest tied to the nonprime securitization on an annual basis. As Jon mentioned, we'll additionally be looking at other off-balance sheet funding options to speed up CAF penetration further, while we keep gaining insight from our full spectrum models. At this point, I'll hand the call back to Bill.

Bill Nash

executive
#5

Alright. Thanks, Enrique and Jon. Ahead of taking questions, I'd like to recap the highlights you just heard regarding our solid first quarter. For a fourth quarter in a row, we posted positive retail unit comps alongside earnings per share growth in the double digits. Unit volume increased on both the retail and wholesale sides. A further milestone came from our sourcing work, with record dealer volume through Max offer, and we keep leveraging our cost structure through significant SG&A gains. Customers are responding to our digital capabilities and the overall experiences, as our Net Promoter Score shows. Across the whole business, we're also continuing to apply AI to improve the experience for customers and associates alike and to boost operational efficiencies. In credit expansion, we're moving forward by providing a new funding method for part of our nonprime portfolio, which reduces risk, affords us greater flexibility and backs the growth of CAF income, and we doubled the pace of our share repurchases. Our associates, stores, technology and digital capabilities, all joined together seamlessly, let us offer the most customer-centric car buying and selling experience; that's a crucial differentiator in a market that's both very large and fragmented, and it puts us in position to keep driving sales, gaining market share and delivering substantial year-over-year earnings growth for years ahead. To our associates nationwide, I want to express gratitude for their commitment in producing these results and providing an unmatched experience for our customers. With that, we're ready to take your questions.

Brian Nagel

analyst
#6

Great quarter, congrats. So the thing I'd like to ask — we've noticed a solid pickup in your pre-owned vehicle operation. I realize you generally don't discuss intra-quarter patterns or what's coming in the next quarter much; still, my question is this: how do you see the durability of this? As you look at it, is this business recovering? Is there something particular behind this renewed momentum? Then a follow-up: once again this quarter you posted solid SG&A leverage, but if we think about sales continuing to regain strength, how should we think about costs returning to the model? How much do costs need to come back into the model to prop up those sales?

Bill Nash

executive
#7

Absolutely, Brian. I'll handle the first part, and then Enrique, would you like to address the expenses. On the acceleration — look, Brian, we feel quite good. First off, let me step back briefly. We're very happy that this marks the fourth quarter in a row of comparable growth. Clearly, this quarter, we're happy with the comps, particularly since all 3 months came in positive. When I consider the acceleration, and we touched on this a bit last quarter, I believe this month — I mean this quarter's results, part of it comes from macro forces, yet I also believe part comes from what's within our control; and I'd return to a few points I raised on the previous quarterly call, which is that the quarter began strongly and then we saw a bump late in the quarter when tariffs were being speculated about; and then I mentioned that bump toward the back half of March and then moving into April, we saw yet another small bump. So April turned out to be our best month. But I'd go back to even before that first bump appeared, the business was expanding — was performing nicely. And I think that mirrors a great deal of the effort we've put in internally, be it inventory management, our pricing, our savings, the omnichannel experience, constantly improving it. So I think there's — these results are partly market driven. I think they're also driven by us; so we feel terrific about the remainder of the year. As I stated at the close of last year, we'd anticipate growing sales and picking up share this year, and nothing has altered that view. Enrique?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#8

Absolutely, Brian — regarding SG&A, over the last 2 years we've managed to gain leverage on it, and that really stems from all the steps we've taken to prioritize efficiency. We remain dedicated to keeping that leverage going in the business. I genuinely believe this quarter illustrates just how powerful the model we've constructed really is. With strong comps, we achieved nearly 700 basis points of SG&A leverage in this quarter. And if you examine what drove the rise in SG&A during this quarter, it was mainly variable costs. Yet even with those variable costs, we managed once more to lever by close to 700 basis points, which brought us to the mid-70% range in Q1. So we're committed to carrying on with that, and the strength of the model is evident right here.

Bill Nash

executive
#9

Right. And Brian, the one thing I'd tack on there is that keeping up that leverage is a huge priority for us. Sure, we're happy about the extra volume and the way it supports that, but we're equally committed to hunting down more efficiencies and continuing to pull down SG&A. We simply believe plenty of chances remain on that front.

Scot Ciccarelli

analyst
#10

Bill, I realize you folks don't provide guidance, but given that comparable growth has been fluctuating somewhat the way it has, and comparisons are becoming far tougher over the remaining part of the year, how ought we, looking at this from an outside modeling standpoint, think about comp growth going forward? Should we be considering stacks? Does that matter — for instance, 2-year stacks or 3-year stacks? Obviously I understand there are numerous moving parts on the macro side, and you're implementing all the adjustments you've already mentioned. But from a wider standpoint, how should we think about comp growth for the rest of the year?

Bill Nash

executive
#11

Yes, I'll connect this somewhat to what I discussed, and Brian. But regarding — you could examine 2-year stacks, 3-year stacks; they provide a somewhat mixed picture. And I believe that's — you can't depend entirely on that, since many dynamics occur across the years. And concerning the outlook for the remaining part of the year, look, we feel we've positioned ourselves well. And as I mentioned in response to Brian's question, we don't — we aren't altering our outlook for the year based on what we set out there at the start of the year; and so we anticipate continuing to grow sales and continuing to gain market share. Nothing has altered that outlook; so...

Scot Ciccarelli

analyst
#12

All right. And I'll grab a quick follow-up while I can. Could you give us just a bit more detail about what changed on the nonprime side? If I understood you right, it seemed like another $26 million provision was coming, yet you don't have to recognize it since it's now classified as held for sale. Did I get that right?

Jon Daniels

executive
#13

Sure. Yes, Scot, I can field that one. So to start at a high level, let's discuss the held-for-sale transaction. Zooming out, we're incredibly enthusiastic about our full spectrum strategy. Looking at what we've built, we split our securitization program in two. Our new models are now in place; we've completed 2 transactions in which we retained the future cash flows, and this marks the following step. This held-for-sale transaction is something we've been considering alongside other off-balance sheet transactions, but the timing simply became right to act on it. So how it works is that, in the end, on those receivables, no loss reserve is required of you since you intend to sell them. So on those $630 million, we're able to avoid placing dollars into the reserve. So that benefits your provision line. On top of that, no future risk remains tied to those receivables should any deterioration occur, which I brought up during the prepared remarks. So that, once more, serves as a risk mitigant, and it's particularly well aimed at this nonprime space, where we're aiming to really push growth; additionally, you'll realize the gain once the sale closes, I'm not sure when that will be, but you can picture it, likely not during Q2, but at some point afterward, and that will pull all of those cash flows forward for us. So instead of earning them gradually, we receive them right away. So again, a truly pivotal item for us within our strategy and simply one more tool available to us. As for the provision this quarter, as you said, let me walk through it. So once more, you had your origination volume. We indicated roughly $100 million provision on the Q4 call. We arrived at that figure, though puts and takes were involved. You saw some bump in the provision from the true-up, the 2022 and 2023 vintages, which we've discussed. The economic view we hold, we've set aside a not insignificant amount of dollars for that too. But once again, with this held for sale, you can offset part of that using dollars you no longer must keep in the reserve. So long answer, I wanted to lay out the whole transaction, how it unfolds and how the provision was affected by it; so hopefully, that's clear.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#14

Scot, one more thing I'd throw in there is that this program has us genuinely enthusiastic. A straightforward way to look at it: it opens the door to growth in both full spectrum and CAF income while keeping risk in check. So it's a tool we feel good about. Like Jon said during his remarks, we're evaluating additional potential funding vehicles for the balance sheet too, so we can speed things up further and support expansion of our full spectrum strategy.

Michael Montani

analyst
#15

Nice work on the quarter. I have a two-part question, if that's alright. For the first part: during the prepared remarks you made a comment that caught my attention about running a marketing campaign to make people aware of your multichannel capabilities. So I'm curious whether you can share some baseline awareness figures from before that campaign? And what specifically are you approaching differently? Then my follow-up relates to credit: does this indicate you'll be raising subprime penetration as a share of the loans you issue? How should we be thinking about that?

Bill Nash

executive
#16

Sure. Happy to. I'll cover marketing, then hand it to Jon for the subprime piece. On marketing and awareness, Mike, we've built up recognition around both digital capabilities and the fact that an online sale is possible for us. That's been growing thanks to campaigns we've run previously. I believe I mentioned on the prior call that we brought on a new ad agency, 72andSunny, and we're very happy with how that relationship is developing. I also referenced some Cox information, and that was deliberate, because when you examine how customers wish to purchase, their intent is to buy omni; yet when you examine how the overwhelming majority of them still purchase today, it's entirely in store. What I think occurs is that consumers wish to purchase in a particular manner but then they settle; they walk into a dealership and are compelled to purchase in a particular manner; and what we need to do is make sure we educate consumers that, look, settling isn't necessary. You don't have to accept the single method a dealer offers. Optionality is yours. So I think the campaign build-out is along the lines of don't settle, like CarMax delivers the best experience regardless of how you wish to purchase. And I think that will genuinely begin to resonate with people as they seek options going forward. Jon, over to you for the subprime part.

Jon Daniels

executive
#17

Right, Michael — I'll pick that one up, your question about subprime growth. And that's a reasonable thing to ask. The brief version is: without a doubt, expansion is what we're after; that message has come through loud and clear from us; we made tweaks once Q1 got underway. Pulling volume back in, we indicated growth of 100 to 150 basis points. Well, that got dampened by plenty of developments during the first quarter — tariffs and so forth. We pointed to that in the prepared remarks. Still, yes — when you examine our full spectrum strategy in action, we're establishing the pieces that permit and drive that expansion, and in particular we believe this held for sale backs it up. So if I were giving you a target figure for penetration — since, once more, we sit at 42%, 43% across our history, and we've stated our intention to increase it — a strong initial milestone in my view would be 50%; reaching it during this year isn't happening; we'll keep you informed as we grow. But yes, that's what we intend to do, and we're genuinely enthusiastic about an enormous amount of value as we build this over the coming quarters and years.

Chris Bottiglieri

analyst
#18

To start, congratulations on the clever handling of the subprime funding. That structure strikes me as interesting. I've got just one point I want clarified on that, and after that a wider question regarding credit. What share of newly originated loans got marked as held for sale? Did those fall within the $26 million figure you mentioned, or should we treat them as additional? Then my wider question is simply this: clearly, you went into detail about the allowance increase and a few of the drivers behind it? How much of that stems from the macro backdrop with student loan lending? For instance, are you observing that, as credit scores have come down and credit performance along with the wider economy has deteriorated somewhat. Does that feed into capital? Can that be quantified? What portion of your borrowers carry student loan debt? I'm just wondering whether this is having any effect whatsoever?

Jon Daniels

executive
#19

Sure. Yes, I appreciate that, Chris. Sorry, let me handle them one by one. So regarding how we view the provision reduction tied to held for sale, what portion came from newly originated loans versus originations from the fourth quarter or earlier originations sitting on our books that had already been reserved for. I would simply say most of it came from receivables that had already been reserved for. So yes, definitely a bit of it came from Q1, but the bulk had already been reserved for. So that takes care of that one. On the second question, let me add a bit more color on what we're observing with the reserve increase to 2.76%, what we're seeing in performance, and how it connects to student loans. Yes, as I mentioned during the prepared remarks, I believe the '22 and '23 vintages were certainly among those that did worse during the quarter. Again, we believe we've reserved appropriately and made adjustments accordingly. I did note during our prepared remarks that, in fact, for 2024, we feel really good. We're basically right on target there, a year into that, more than a year into that. On student loans, let me share a few statistics. Within the CAF portfolio, roughly 30% of — those we're able to see from the credit bureaus, 30% of our borrowers have student loans. We've been monitoring them, as you can imagine, for years now, thinking about whether our payment will be made, what forgiveness gets done for those, and how they perform. In the end, what I'll say is we haven't observed a material shift among those borrowers over the recent year relative to what we'd typically see; so we're tracking this extremely closely as payments are anticipated and how it might affect their credit report, and so on; we'd hope auto still stays top of wallet share for them, but we'll keep a close eye on them, though no change so far.

Bill Nash

executive
#20

Also, Chris, one more point on that — regarding what I refer to as the true-up, the main cause was the '22 and '23 vintages. Let me also remind everyone that despite this, those remain extremely profitable. Then, to a smaller extent, the economic factors as you look ahead — not insignificant — but I want everyone to be clear that it's mostly the '22 and '23 behind this. And even so, those are still quite highly profitable.

Jon Daniels

executive
#21

Right. And just to make that clear, the final point I'll address regarding it is that the jobless figure is the major factor behind that. Yeah. Once more, it's a contributor that isn't insignificant, though it doesn't account for most of it.

Bill Nash

executive
#22

On the economic factors?

Jon Daniels

executive
#23

Correct. Yes.

Sharon Zackfia

analyst
#24

My question is about CAF and the shift toward full spectrum lending. How much of the full spectrum have you covered up to now? And how should we be thinking about that for the back half of the year? Also, when it comes to boosting that CAF penetration — I realize there were several moving pieces this quarter — do you expect CAF penetration to be up year-over-year in the August quarter?

Jon Daniels

executive
#25

Yes, absolutely. Thanks for asking, Sharon. Let's take penetration apart the way it usually breaks down. CAF has historically landed at 42% to 43% where it's originally — where it's normally originated. We've said our Tier 2 and Tier 3 players combined account for, call it, 26% of volume. That's definitely the area we're aiming at as we expand. So we intend to penetrate it. When you consider — I believe your real question is how quickly we'll grow where — that's really the area down there we're targeting. I think the key for us will be that we have 2 securitizations in play. We need the held-for-sale transaction to close. That has to get done. We're just reaching the anniversary on our models; at the start of the quarter we built in 100 to 150 basis points of growth. Now, as we've said, the tariffs really introduced a bit of a snag into that and into showing that growth we achieved. But progress has been made. As that volume normalizes — since so much of it arrived with our own financing, and as that normalizes — you're going to see that we've made progress on it. And once again, we're going to aim to grow it; we'll signal when that occurs; but I think you're going to see material growth we'd expect in the — you won't reach that 50% number I mentioned this year, Sharon, but hopefully you're going to see material growth in the quarters ahead.

Bill Nash

executive
#26

Sharon, just one more item — regarding how quickly adoption happens, two factors really control that. The first is whether your funding is in place, and that piece is definitely handled. The second, as Jon mentioned, is your credit model. Keep in mind, we had extensive experience with the top end. We had extensive experience with the bottom end, but then we introduced the full spectrum credit model, and testing on that is still ongoing. I mean, Jon, how much time has that actually been running that...

Jon Daniels

executive
#27

Right. It came out in August.

Bill Nash

executive
#28

Correct. So you simply need time to confirm your model is precisely right; those 2 factors are what hold it back.

David Bellinger

analyst
#29

Good numbers. Now, on the topic of what we're spending on marketing and the fresh campaign — the idea that customers will have flexibility is going to be the main focus. That said, is part of this new effort being fueled by the omni cost neutrality you brought up earlier, when you indicated CarMax is now positioned to handle a greater share of digitally initiated volume while making more profit moving forward? I'm simply attempting to work out whether there's a step change happening in the digital economics of this business and whether you're choosing to direct additional marketing funds toward it at this point.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#30

Yes. What I'd say is that absolutely supports the drive toward efficiency, productivity, customer service — every one of those areas — once again, powered by AI, powered by our associates, absolutely delivering an improved experience, and beyond that, it gives us far more confidence to go out and advertise and inform our shoppers about the amazing experience, one that's highly differentiated, that they will receive from CarMax.

Bill Nash

executive
#31

Yeah. And David, the way I look at this as well is that fiscal '25 was a significant year for us when it comes to experience, and we truly closed some of the final major gaps by rolling out order processing and shopping card. So we feel as though we've reached a stage where, if you're going to go out and celebrate that and really steer direct customers toward the fact that you aren't required to accept a fixed path, you'd better have best-in-class in-store, you'd better have best-in-class omni, and you'd better have a best-in-class online-only experience. And we believe we've hit that stage where we need consumers to grasp that you don't have to settle. So much of the push behind why we're considering this right now, along with the efficiency items Enrique has already brought up, comes from that.

Rajat Gupta

analyst
#32

I've got a few quick points I wanted to clear up based on some of what's been said. First off, is there anything you can share about how the second quarter has been shaping up so far? We've been hearing stories in the wider macro about a pretty significant step back, basically the prebuying that happened before tariffs. I was wondering whether your business has seen any of that effect yet in June? Anything you could tell us about the comps there? Then regarding CAF — clearly there's been a lot of talk about it — during the prior quarter, you'd shared some direction with us on how provisioning would be paced across the year. It would really help if you could tell us anything about what the second quarter might look like, particularly given all the shifts that are going on.

Bill Nash

executive
#33

Alright, Rajat. As far as June goes, we're 19 days in. We'll address June at the same time we cover the second quarter, once the second quarter wraps up. The one other thing I'd note is this — and you might not be aware of it — during the second quarter, one Saturday is lost, and it lands in June, and after that you don't get it back for the remainder of the quarter. That Saturday won't be recovered until the rest of the year is done. Jon, I'll hand it over to you regarding the provision.

Jon Daniels

executive
#34

Alright, yes. If you consider how provisioning is likely to flow across the year, our expectation is that Q1 will represent the peak. On those older vintages, we've taken the adjustment we think is necessary; regarding the '24s, we're feeling positive, clearly, even with the consumer and whatever might occur down the road. That said, we're comfortable with our reserve, and ideally we'd simply be setting aside provisions for newly originated loans. The one factor that might disrupt that is our growth strategy. Naturally, should we expand, additional provisioning would be required in line with that for the nonprime segment, but we'll make that clear whenever we plan to pursue anything more substantial in terms of growth there. So...

Bill Nash

executive
#35

Yeah, here's how I'd frame it: like we discussed during the prior quarter, over the short term we're moving past that 100 to 150 basis points — and we're making solid progress toward it. There was just a bit of arithmetic involved on my end this quarter.

Craig Kennison

analyst
#36

That was a useful call, and I'm grateful for it. There's something I'd like to ask about. The press release mentioned that 80% of sales were digitally supported. That figure had slipped from 82% during the February quarter. So my read is that you gave up a point in omni and a point in online. I realize omnichannel is where your attention really is, but digital had been picking up share and it plainly looks like where things are headed. So I'm just wondering whether you could shed light on why it seems to have retreated this quarter.

Bill Nash

executive
#37

Yes. Part of that, I believe, is simply seasonal. Craig, I don't truly — I mean — my sense is omni is in fact up a point, and online is possibly flat, or possibly down a point. But I mean, I'd say the seasonal factor explains more of it. What I find more interesting, and more pertinent, is that we keep — within the omni bucket, we keep observing additional transactions, additional pieces of these digital capabilities getting used. And I'd argue that matters more than, oh, did everyone move to online or did everyone move to omni. It's more like, okay, within your omni bucket, you're seeing the count of steps they're taking keep rising.

Craig Kennison

analyst
#38

Then, as a follow-up regarding what you said about marketing, in what ways is AI altering your thinking around search engine optimization within this fresh marketing push?

Bill Nash

executive
#39

Yeah. So, the major new term people are throwing around is GEO rather than SEO — generative engine optimization, that's the whole idea. It comes down to how you appear favorably. That makes it essential. My view is that focusing solely on SEO means you'll fail to seize the opportunity. SEO remains extremely important. You still need to keep your attention there, but on top of that, you now also have to be genuinely strong at GEO. So within the marketing campaign, it's going to be significant. And broadly speaking, when it comes to marketing overall, I believe generative AI holds a great deal of promise.

Jeff Lick

analyst
#40

Congratulations on an excellent quarter. Clearly, there were many positives and negatives this period, including your broadening of the credit range and the sudden tariff spike. Also, you folks have been — during your Analyst Day, you signaled a shift toward focusing more on value vehicles, those 6 and 7-plus years old. Could you perhaps just take us through anything — any notable items as the quarter unfolded, and how those categories affected your strong comp?

Bill Nash

executive
#41

Yeah. Thanks for asking, Jeff. Look, I believe if we remove some of the distractions, such as the credit range expansion, set that aside, it remains an excellent quarter, all right? We're quite happy with it. And regarding the credit expansion, look, that's the following phase. We've been progressing on that. It wasn't — we didn't account for it in the fourth quarter's provision, but it's something we've been developing; so we're thrilled about that. I think you raised a fascinating point about age alone. We did sell — if I examine our, shall we say, vehicles older than 10 years, we boosted — we likely sold about 25,000 additional such vehicles. When I mention it, consider the 10-year-old, the 11-year-old, the 12-year-old, and that's through our ongoing efforts to really drive growth in that segment, since we know customers are interested, they wish to purchase. Yet even in this last quarter, when we experienced increased no finance, those are individuals with better credit; but curiously, examining their purchasing behavior, they acquired autos throughout the range. Actually, our largest expanding source of sales this quarter was somewhat barbell-shaped. It was the cars below $20,000 and those above $40,000. So I think providing a solid solution for all of those will be essential. And that's something we'll keep prioritizing without compromising CarMax's quality standards. That is an initiative we're certainly committed to.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#42

Yeah. The thing that really moved our comps was the jump in vehicles priced below $20,000 — that's what happened between those 2. So affordability was the focus there. And on our side, as you're aware, we refer to some of our cars, or the older ones, more as value max cars, and that was up 5 points year-over-year for the quarter too. So it's those folks who buy into a car under $20,000; so it's about emphasizing affordability and being able to reach the customer wherever they want to be met.

David Whiston

analyst
#43

I'm wondering whether you could share anything about what direction you expect repurchase outlays to take over the remaining fiscal year, compared with what was spent in Q1. And in your view, how much financial strain is the consumer under at this moment?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#44

Regarding the buyback of shares, here's what I can say: as we came into this year, our intention was to pick up the pace of repurchases somewhat versus the prior year. Then during Q1, taking into account where the stock was valued, along with the way cash flows were moving, we identified a chance to boost the volume of share repurchases considerably. So in setting the baseline for Q2 and afterward, the factors we'll weigh are the same ones — valuation, the dynamics of cash flow, and the wider macroeconomic environment.

Bill Nash

executive
#45

Yes, and when it comes to shoppers, regarding how much pressure they feel — listen, I wouldn't say it's significantly higher than during the previous period; actually, I'd definitely say the pressure is lower. What you're picking up on, I believe, is that certain shoppers are — clearly, we brought up student loans. You're able to observe some defaults among people who hold student loans. No effect has appeared in our business. That said, I believe there's also a bit of a hold-back-and-watch mentality around tariffs. Tariffs have driven up certain prices. I believe there's — plenty of merchandise had already — plenty of items had already arrived in the U.S. prior to tariffs taking effect. So really, I believe we simply have to monitor what happens down the road as prices rise for daily consumables, and how that could influence them. Still, I'd say from the perspective of consumer sentiment, they're likely somewhat less optimistic regarding what's ahead, yet I don't believe that has necessarily manifested that much in purchasing behavior right now.

Chris Pierce

analyst
#46

Could you take me through what cost avoidance looks like within other cost of sales? I'm just — the way this shapes up ahead isn't clear to me. It fell by $33 million compared with a year earlier and contributed a fairly large — yes, I'd really like to understand the cost avoidance in that line and how we should view it ahead.

Bill Nash

executive
#47

My apologies — which line do you mean?

Chris Pierce

analyst
#48

Is that $7 million in other cost of sales compared to $40 million for the same period a year ago?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#49

If service is what you mean, our gross margin in the service line improved by $30 million. If that's the subject you're asking about, then once more, we benefited there from cost coverage we've implemented — what I mean is we've charged certain fees to get past some of the cost pressures from last year; we observed leverage on our — on a service cost base that's largely fixed. Correct? So healthy sales will generate some leverage. And beyond that, we keep pursuing efficiencies in that business too, and we keep delivering on those as we've promised on a yearly basis. That's the reason we recorded that $30 million gain in service.

Chris Pierce

analyst
#50

So that remaining 95% of gross margin — that's a factor — I mean, I suppose, considering how it affects EPS, what's the right way to think about gross margin moving forward?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#51

Yes. Gross margin definitely fits with what I mentioned regarding our earnings model and our emphasis on achieving high-teen EPS growth over time alongside mid-single-digit comps. We're concentrated on steadily expanding that margin — the other margin. The main elements within other margins will include service, as I just mentioned; plus our EPP products, correct? This quarter, our EPP margin rose once more. Last quarter I noted we're running some trials involving product enhancements for our EPP products; those trials have produced encouraging results; regarding product enhancement, they relate to deductibles, terms, and we anticipate a modest rollout during the back half of this year, followed by the full financial impact, or a more complete financial impact, as we move into FY '27; we remain laser-focused on other gross profit as a growth vehicle to fuel our EPS growth.

Bill Nash

executive
#52

Yeah. Chris, looking at it from how you're modeling this, I think it ties back to a few points made earlier, since a big chunk of that comes from service, and service in Q1 is always at its peak, which is what we'd anticipate. As we mentioned during the prior quarter, we expect it to be profitable across the year, but you shouldn't count on service improvements staying the same as what showed up in Q1 for the remaining months.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#53

Yeah, and I can — yeah, I also put a note about that in my prepared remarks. Service tends to peak in the first quarter simply because, seasonally, that's when our volume is highest. And once again, you're getting leverage off a cost base that's fairly fixed. So the leverage you get there is stronger. That said, we're still committed to growing our other gross profit overall as part of our earnings model going forward. And that's what you've been seeing over the last couple of years.

Chris Pierce

analyst
#54

All right. And finally, returning to that initial question, SG&A for each retail unit declined in the mid-single digits versus a year earlier, though it appeared roughly flat when compared with 2 years back. I'd simply like to understand where we stand regarding the complete leveraging of omni costs and what the right way to view this going forward might be?

Bill Nash

executive
#55

Yeah. I don't — there remains room for us to keep leveraging our costs, whether that's specifically on the sales side, such as when you consider CEC expense, that sort of item, or simply throughout the entire business. Plus, we've got initiatives in essentially every area; therefore, we continue to believe more opportunity exists there.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#56

Absolutely. What you're definitely seeing from our side is a real dedication to making that happen. For 2 years at this point, we've continually reduced our SG&A as a percentage of gross profit, regardless of whether comps were up or weather-driven comps were down; we've managed to successfully bring down that SG&A ratio, and our plan is to keep at it.

Rajat Gupta

analyst
#57

Thanks. My apologies for the second question. I simply wanted to dig a bit deeper into that new off-balance sheet strategy; and can we reasonably presume that much of the added penetration you're seeing in the CAF book, moving from 42% to 50%, will all flow through this off-balance sheet strategy. Essentially I'm trying to get a handle on what the mix will look like, or what you're aiming for regarding on versus off balance sheet for CAF?

Jon Daniels

executive
#58

Yes. I value that question, Rajat, and it's a reasonable follow-up. So one point we want to make clear here is that we view this as a periodic play for us. It's — clearly, we have our higher prime deals. We don't believe it's necessarily built for this strategy, since there's less volatility there, less risk with those customers under the nonprime strategy, particularly as we expand from 42% to 50%, which you've mentioned. And I think it truly does position itself so that at some point, perhaps we do want to hold onto that risk and all the extra cash flows that accompany it, because additional value exists there, whereas we're prepared to shed some of that risk and take the cash upfront. And again, perhaps there's a bit of a haircut there. But I think it's an opportunistic play, as we're going to see. So maybe it happens once a year. We'll watch how it unfolds. But I wouldn't view it as an all or nothing play here at all.

Bill Nash

executive
#59

Right, that's absolutely not how I'd frame it. Regarding the Tier 1 business — no changes are being made there. What I mean is, we're keeping that intact — really it's about having room to grow certain areas that, honestly, in the end, we likely don't want to keep. So, as Jon mentioned, it shouldn't be viewed as belonging entirely to one category or the other. The two will work together as a solid combination.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#60

Yeah, there are certainly subprime receivables we'd like to retain and hold as investments, and that's something we'll keep doing. For sure, when I look at this initiative — and I brought this up before — to put it in very simple terms, it's going to allow our full spectrum along with CAF income to grow as time goes on, while reducing a portion of that risk. So this program has us genuinely enthusiastic, and that's the way I see it.

Rajat Gupta

analyst
#61

Understood. That's completely clear.

Jeff Lick

analyst
#62

Great. I'd like to return to the topic of retail GPUs. It's amusing that this hasn't come up until now. We're at a record figure of $2,407 — the $2,400 threshold has been reached for the very first time. During the previous quarter, you touched on this briefly and highlighted improvements in logistics, plus recon — if you're able to go into detail — could you elaborate on the independent recon facilities, and address whether those produce an instant effect? Or do they in fact dilute results across several quarters, or even a year, prior to becoming visible? The final item, I believe, is about GPUs and vehicles that are more than a decade old. My assumption is that those could be running above the average GPU for the chain. Could you discuss what kind of gains you're observing in that area and what direction things may be heading?

Bill Nash

executive
#63

Sure, Jeff, I'll do my best to address this. That question contains several parts. I'll attempt to cover all of them, though feel free to correct me if I miss anything. So, yes, we're happy with how retail GPUs are performing. And the key point you ought to be focusing on there. During the previous quarter, I touched on this subject when somebody inquired about how we view retail GPUs. My response was that when building your model, you should look at it annually and assume it will be comparable to the prior year's figure. That said, I noted that for any given quarter, the number could rise or fall. What led me to say that is that you have to examine what's happening in the quarter; when you consider each element that plays into the choice — elasticity, how competitive your pricing is, variable costs and the gains you're making there, plus the ancillary services or products you bundle in — certain quarters will come along where, well, this happens to be one of them, and the thinking is: let's take a portion of those savings you mentioned, the ones from reconditioning and logistics, and simply send them straight down to the bottom line. Now, when it comes to the stand-alone reconditioning centers, the advantages we're realizing from reconditioning and logistics — I want to remind everyone — up to this point we've operated large reconditioning centers, since when you stop and think about it, we run 250-plus stores, yet we have just a little over 100 locations where we actually produce cars. The advantages are showing up everywhere. On the reconditioning front, we're still very early. A few additional big recon facilities have just been brought online. Some gains are appearing there, though they lean more toward logistics, since we're now able to avoid shipping vehicles out of market as much and instead place them directly within the market. As for those facilities, I think only one is probably at full capacity at this point. Apart from that, my expectation is that we'll continue capturing synergies; but with reconditioning specifically, synergies are reaching us in all areas, and I expect that to continue going forward. Did I miss anything? Yes, actually. There is indeed.

Jeff Lick

analyst
#64

You mentioned vehicles that are 10 years old.

Bill Nash

executive
#65

That's right, the car that's 10 years old. Correct — traditionally, when we've discussed cars of greater age, once you get them meeting the CarMax standard, they tend to be somewhat of a unicorn. On those vehicles you'll see somewhat more margin, and you're in a position to earn somewhat more margin. So that's a fair point.

Bill Nash

executive
#66

Alright, thanks. Well, I appreciate everyone being on today's call, and for the questions you keep sending our way, plus your backing. And like every time, I want to give thanks to our associates for all they do, and for the way they look after one another and the people who shop with us. We'll be back to speak with you in the next quarter. Thanks.

Operator

operator
#67

Thanks, everybody. That brings us to the end of the conference call covering our Corporate Earnings Release for the first quarter of fiscal year 2026. You're free to hang up now.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete CarMax, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to CarMax, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in CarMax, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.