CarMax, Inc. (KMX) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

December 18, 2025

New York Stock Exchange US Consumer Discretionary Specialty Retail earnings 59 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

David Lowenstein

executive
#1

Thanks, Nikki. Hello, everybody, and thanks for being on the line for our conference call about earnings for the third quarter of fiscal 2026. Joining me are Tom Folliard, who is serving as interim executive chair of the board, David McCraight, our interim president and chief executive officer, Enrique Mayor-Mora, executive vice president and chief financial officer, and Jon Daniels, executive vice president of CarMax Auto Finance. I want to remind everyone that anything we say today that isn't a statement of historical fact — which includes, though isn't limited to, statements about future business plans, prospects, and financial performance — counts as a forward-looking statement that we're making under the Safe Harbor provisions of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Such statements rest on what we currently know, expect, and assume, and they carry substantial risks and uncertainties that might make actual results differ materially from what we expect. When we give projections and other forward-looking statements, we disclaim any intent or obligation to update them; to learn more about important factors and risks that could affect these expectations, please refer to our Form 8-K filed with the SEC this morning, our annual report on Form 10-K for fiscal year 2025, and our quarterly reports on Form 10-Q that we previously filed with the SEC. Please note that alongside our earnings release, we've also put together a quarterly investor presentation, and you can find both documents in the Investor Relations section of our website. If any follow-up questions come up after the call, don't hesitate to reach our investor relations department at (804) 747 to 0422, extension 7865. Finally, thanks ahead of time for limiting yourself to one question and then getting back in the queue for more follow-ups. Tom?

Tom Folliard

executive
#2

David, thank you, and good morning to all of you. We appreciate you being here. I'll start by sharing some thoughts about the shifts in our leadership and the process to find a CEO. Then I'll hand things over to David, who will walk through what we've seen so far and the steps we're taking in response. Following that, Enrique and Jon will cover the results for our third quarter, and then we'll take your questions. Many of you are aware that my time with CarMax spans over 30 years. During those years, we built a brand that people love, with nationwide reach, physical and digital capabilities that no one else can match, and a culture that has earned awards. That said, the performance we've seen lately is not acceptable and falls short of what this company is capable of. So while the Board had already been at work on a plan for succession, we concluded that faster action was needed, and that having David and me involved directly was the strongest way to bolster the business right away. The board has been looking for a permanent CEO urgently. We want a leader with a track record who can boost sales, get the most out of our omnichannel model, make our brand stronger, enhance how we operate, and be a champion for our culture. Talks are already happening, and we've got some encouraging candidates. What matters most is that the incoming CEO seizes the huge opportunity sitting right in front of us. In my role as interim executive chair of the board, my focus is on backing David and the leadership team. David is in Richmond 5 days each week, and I'm also devoting a great deal of my own time here; we're moving with a fresh sense of urgency to push the business ahead. I want to express my thanks to David for taking on the interim president and CEO position. As you're aware, he's been a member of our board since 2018. David brings over 20 years of executive leadership experience, gained at well-known retail companies in markets that are extremely competitive and move quickly. He's guided multiple successful brand turnarounds, fresh omnichannel approaches, and expansion efforts for digitally native brands. The very qualities that made him such a strong board member have also proven incredibly valuable during this transition. Before handing the call to David, I'd also like to thank Bill Nash for his over 30 years of dedication to CarMax.

David McCraight

executive
#3

Thank you, Tom, and good morning to all of you. It's a privilege to step in as interim president and CEO at such a pivotal moment for CarMax. Our number one focus is identifying an outstanding permanent leader, but until then, Tom and I are dedicated to steering the company and doing what's necessary so that the incoming CEO inherits a strong foundation. Having spent 30 years in retail and having guided several businesses through turnarounds, I know well the discipline and sharp analysis that success demands. The encouraging part is that CarMax already holds many of the essential qualities required to reverse course and rebuild growth momentum. These include a widely recognized and trusted brand, a robust culture backed by 28,000 skilled associates, and a broad digital and physical footprint spanning more than 250 premium locations, which places us within reach of approximately 85% of the US population. Even with these strengths, and following decades of leadership in the industry, the latest results make plain that CarMax must change; and though we've only held our interim positions for a few weeks, here is what we've noticed so far. Pricing. Our average selling prices have crept higher and seem to hold less appeal for customers. To make certain CarMax remains a preferred option, we'll strive to narrow the distance between what we offer and what the market offers. We're reducing margins and backing that move with marketing investment. At the same time, we're developing stronger methods for conveying our value to the consumer; we're also undertaking a thorough review of every cost tied to bringing a vehicle to market. We will identify what isn't productive and cut it, while protecting our reputation for a high-quality fleet. On the consumer front, we need to sharpen our focus on the customer across the entire organization. In shaping our choices, we'll revive our intellectual curiosity and question longstanding institutional assumptions as we seek to uncover what matters most to the customer when completing a purchase; we'll prioritize customer insight in our decisions, grounded in fact-based consumer research. Digital. We have a chance to establish a clear and more effective selling voice within our digital experience. We've invested several years developing capabilities that let customers shop the way they prefer and in the places they prefer. Now our efforts must center on making digital shopping simpler. And we must change our digital voice from one that dutifully presents plentiful information to one centered on generating sales. That will boost conversion and further lift customer satisfaction. Exactly as we already accomplish successfully in our stores. SG and A. Much like how we're approaching the expense of bringing vehicles to market, we believe our cost structure is too high; it's evident that we can leverage our technology platforms and process improvements to bring our spending down. We're determined to make our business model sharper and cut out costs that aren't productive; and shortly, Enrique will give you an update on how far along we are with the bold moves we're making to take out no less than $150 million in SG and A. Profitability. We'll pursue chances within the selling experience more aggressively so that our profitability improves. We're thrilled about the tremendous growth opportunity that exists for us in CAF and in our ancillary products. Today you'll hear more from Jon regarding how we're doing in full spectrum lending, plus the measures we're taking to seize added flow through in our extended protection plan business. Culture. Operations have always been our intense focus as a company. Yet with disruptive technologies having arrived, we must now rekindle that entrepreneurial spirit which turned CarMax into the industry leader across many decades. To put it plainly, we'll act with greater speed and run with less waste, while taking sensible risks. We're hopeful that our pricing and marketing moves right away will lift our sales results. But they will weigh on earnings in the near term. Looking at the business model in a more holistic way going forward, we expect unit growth, greater profitability in CAF and ancillary products, and decreases in SG and A and COGS to counter that earnings pressure. Tom, the board, and I hold the view that CarMax possesses many of the attributes required for a turnaround that succeeds. We're certain the steps we're taking will start to improve performance as the board finds the right permanent CEO to guide CarMax in the future; now I'd like to hand the call to Enrique so he can go over our third quarter financial performance in greater detail. Enrique?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#4

Thanks, David. For the quarter, total sales came in at $5.8 billion, a decline of 6.9% versus a year ago, which reflects lower volume. Within our retail business, unit sales overall fell 8%, while used unit comps dropped 9%. Performance was under pressure across our age zero to five inventory, though that was partly offset by stronger sales of older vehicles with higher mileage, which made up more than 40% of what we sold this quarter. That's an increase of roughly five percentage points relative to both the second quarter and last year's third quarter. Average selling price reached $26,400, up $230 per unit from a year earlier. That gain came from higher acquisition costs, which were pushed up by market prices rising year over year, and was partially offset by a shift toward older, higher mileage vehicles. Wholesale unit sales fell 6.2% against the third quarter of last year. The average wholesale selling price dropped $40 per unit, landing at $8,100. We acquired roughly 238,000 vehicles this quarter, a 12% decrease from last year. From consumers, we bought approximately 208,000 vehicles, and over half of those purchases came via our online instant appraisal experience. With help from our admin sales team, we sourced the remaining roughly 30,000 vehicles through dealers, which is down 9% from last year. Net earnings per diluted share for the third quarter were $0.43, compared with $0.81 a year ago. This quarter took a hit from $0.08 of restructuring expenses, mostly tied to our CEO change and the workforce reductions at our customer experience centers. Total gross profit was $590 million, a 13% decline from last year's third quarter. Used retail margin of $379 million fell 11%, driven by lower volume, along with profit per used unit of $2,235. That's consistent with historical averages, and down approximately $70 per unit from last year's record high. Wholesale vehicle margin of $115 million dropped 17% from a year ago on lower volume, with wholesale gross profit per unit of $899, roughly $120 lower year over year. Steep depreciation weighed on both wholesale volume and margin. Other gross profit was $96 million, down 16% from a year ago. The main driver was the effect of lower retail unit volume on each CarMax auto finance income, which came to $175 million, up 9% over last year. Jon will give you details on CAF's growth shortly. Turning to SG and A, third quarter expenses were $581 million, up 1% from the prior year. That was driven by the marketing investment we discussed previously as we backed the launch of our new brand positioning, plus the restructuring expenses I mentioned earlier. Those were partly offset by a lower corporate bonus accrual. As David mentioned, we remain on track to reach at least $150 million in exit rate savings by the end of fiscal year 2027. This quarter we took our first major step toward those savings, cutting our CEC workforce by approximately 30%; that reduction was enabled by our ongoing process and technology improvements. These things are boosting productivity for our associates while also giving customers the ability to handle more of their shopping tasks on their own. Now on to capital allocation. We kept up our share repurchases in the third quarter. We bought back 4.6 million shares, spending a total of $2 million. At quarter's end, roughly $1.36 billion remained available under our repurchase authorization. Looking ahead, I'll address two points; we're hopeful that trimming margins and ramping up marketing will turn our sales trends in a better direction; however, that could weigh on near-term earnings; on a total unit basis, we anticipate marketing spend will rise year over year in the fourth quarter, although not as much as it did in the third quarter. With an emphasis on putting money into acquisition to generate buys and sales. Second, we anticipate service margin pressure in the fourth quarter. Because of seasonal sales and as we lap the cost coverage leverage we gained a year ago. At this point, I'll hand the call over to Jon, who will give more detail on CarMax Auto Finance and our ongoing emphasis on expanding across the full credit spectrum. Jon?

Jon Daniels

executive
#5

Appreciate that, Enrique, and good morning to all of you. In Q3, CarMax Auto Finance wrote $1.8 billion in originations, which worked out to sales penetration of 42.6% net of three-day payoffs, compared with 43.1% a year ago. The weighted average contract rate we charged to new customers came in at 11%, down from 11.2% in the prior quarter, as we keep tweaking consumer rates in response to the broader rate environment. Third-party tier two volume, on which we earn a fee, and tier three volume, on which we incur a fee, together represented 24.9% of sales, against 24.4% a year earlier. Softer tier two application volume, plus the effect of CAF's expansion in the Tier two space, was more than made up for by growth from our Tier three partners. CAF penetration keeps gaining from the underwriting and pricing changes we've made since the fiscal year began, which we estimate added 100 to 150 basis points this quarter. That said, this volume has largely been offset by weaker application volume in the prime credit segment, together with the Tier three partner lender overperformance I mentioned. CAF income for the quarter reached $175 million, an increase of $15 million over the same period a year ago. The quarter includes a $27 million gain on sale as well as an extra $5 million of servicing fees tied to the closing of the 25 b deal in September. Keep in mind that although the gain on sale is recognized in full at the time of sale, servicing fee income will carry on across the remaining life of the deal and will be proportional to the receivable volume left. Net interest margin on the portfolio was flat versus a year ago and declined to 6.2% from 6.6% in the prior quarter, mostly reflecting the higher margin receivables taken off the balance sheet as part of 25 b. Gas recorded a loan loss provision of $73 million, leaving a total reserve balance of $475 million, or 2.87% of auto loans held for investment. Losses we saw during the quarter matched our expectations, which were the basis for our reserve at the end of Q2. On the subject of growing the cat business, I'm extremely proud of what we've achieved so far. Across the last eighteen months, we've substantially broadened our funding options, including this quarter's off-balance sheet transaction, and those have been essential prerequisites for this growth. Beyond that, we keep adding underwriting capabilities and refining our modeling to support profitable expansion. On a separate note, I'm also enthusiastic about the considerable future earnings potential from both our redesigned MaxCare plan, which centers on mechanical coverage, and our new MaxCare Plus plan, which centers on cosmetic protection; these products have already moved from test phase to pilot in multiple markets, and we expect to reach near nationwide rollout during '27. I'd like to hand the call back over to David.

David McCraight

executive
#6

Thanks, Enrique. Thanks, Jon. During today's session, we laid out what we've noticed so far and the short-term goals meant to produce better results. Closing the pricing distance separating what we sell from what the market offers, placing greater emphasis on the customer journey, expanding our ability to earn money digitally, cutting expenses, boosting the areas that fuel profitable expansion, and speeding up how quickly choices get made. And even though we hold a clear-eyed view of the hurdles right ahead, the competitive bedrock at CarMax is still solid; ours is a brand people trust, nationwide reach that's hard to copy, top-tier omnichannel strengths, and a digital backbone that keeps growing, a robust financing operation in CAF, plus a culture that has won awards. What we've delivered hasn't lived up to what these assets could achieve, yet that is exactly what we're now fixing. Tom, the board, and I are aimed at lifting results and laying down a firm base for the incoming permanent CEO to extend further. We're grateful for the faith you keep placing in CarMax, and we're dedicated to keeping you informed regarding how far we've come. Having said that, let's take your questions. Operator?

Sharon Zackfia

analyst
#7

Good morning. It's nice to have you on the line once more, Tom. I'm on a conference call, and David, welcome to the realm of CarMax conference calls.

Tom Folliard

executive
#8

Thanks, Sharon.

Sharon Zackfia

analyst
#9

Yes. So, I suppose, perhaps you might offer a bit of detail regarding how large that GPU reset will be that you expect to occur in February; and after that, when you examine the company from, I suppose, a newer angle, are there specific customer groups you could explore where you believe CarMax has in some way grown somewhat less competitive or somewhat less appealing, and what, you know, is the strategy for bringing those customers back?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#10

Yes, Sharon. Hi, this is Enrique. Allow me to step in. You know, the margin cuts are going to be backed by money spent on acquiring customers through marketing, which will be substantial in our plan purely to close the distance we mentioned relative to the wider market; and we feel good that those could genuinely lift our retail sales patterns. During the quarter. But they are, you know, large enough that we need to discuss them. And we will watch how they are implemented. We will watch the effect during this quarter. And afterward, once we hold our year-end call in April, we will share perspective and a forecast regarding what those margin cuts and the rise in marketing spending represent for us.

Jon Daniels

executive
#11

Okay, Sharon — Jon here. Let me address what you asked about the customer cohort. Sure, there are clearly areas all along the range where we're aiming to get better and boost sales. One that really jumps out to me would be, say, the upper FICO brackets — during the prepared remarks we referenced, within CAF and that tier two portion, roughly the 650 to 750 band. It seems like we've been losing volume in that area; we can follow that by looking at applications arriving and how they move along afterward. So there's plenty of guessing about the cause. Of course, we'll examine everything David brought up — quite a few items, including pricing. Naturally, we work to keep our rates competitive. And just the whole package we deliver to the consumer — that strikes me as one specific area with a strong opportunity to win back business and drive our growth.

Sharon Zackfia

analyst
#12

Could I pose another question? There's a rival of yours that's going to be proactively cutting finance rates during this quarter, putting some of its GPU back into the customer. My understanding is that in the past, you matched the market when it came to finance rates. Is there anything you'd be open to doing with interest rates to sort of turn that into a weapon a bit more, so you'd win more conversions.

Jon Daniels

executive
#13

Absolutely. Thanks for asking that. Yes. I'd say we constantly monitor what's happening in the market. We examine where we stand versus credit unions and banks, naturally, and against competitors too, as far as we're able to track it. Yeah. I won't comment on their plans, though we believe our APRs stack up well given the Fed's necessary rate actions; we'll make changes to match. We've consistently used a test and learn approach in this area. You know, I won't claim we'll attempt to move ahead of the market, yet I do believe that in this particular area, a gap in interest rates persists, even if it may be narrowing. But I think the larger question is about the whole offering. You know, where do we stand when it comes to interest rate, of course, and perhaps term, but naturally you pair that with the car's price and every other fee tied to it. So I believe the wider offering picture is what will truly be the main emphasis going forward. And, Sharon, what I'd add is, you know, when you look at this somewhat more broadly, the SG and A cuts, these are levers we've discussed. Those SG and A reductions, the emphasis on COGS, growth chances in CAF, in full spectrum, plus the EPP products Jon mentioned and we're glad to go into more detail on; all of these levers give us the means to compete harder in the market. Simultaneously, we're reassessing, like David said, reassessing our approach to going to market. Correct? And that approach to market, as Jon noted, involves the types of cars, the prices of those cars, how we present things on our website, all of those elements. And so we believe we now have levers that are coming together to make us substantially more competitive and ready to take to market.

Scott Ciccarelli

analyst
#14

Hello, everyone. Following the usual routine, I'll take another shot at the GPU question. Based on my understanding, earlier management teams have said a price reduction of about $500 per unit would be needed before we saw a real inflection in the sales pace. Clearly, using Enrique's wording, that would be substantial. Is that approximately how you're approaching cutting your GPU price?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#15

Right. What I'd say is I don't believe we've ever characterized $500 as either a meaningful or a necessary figure to drive sales. You know, we conduct price elasticity testing. We're regularly in the market doing price elasticity testing. What I'd say is the amount needed to shift sales is substantially below that number. Correct? As for what we're doing this quarter, we're trying out a few approaches. We're going out into the market. For us, again, it was significant in size. Something worth talking about here. We'll be measuring how it impacts sales, once again, along with an increase in marketing spend to try to build some momentum. Overall. Then we'll share results on the fourth quarter call in April; and and report what we saw in the marketplace. We feel good about the possibility that it'll reverse the sales trend, though I wouldn't say that $500 is the amount needed to to to shift sales, which is what you're suggesting. This ties to the $202 million figure as well.

Scott Ciccarelli

analyst
#16

Understood. Thanks. And if I could, one more quick question. It's more of a macro-level thing, I suppose. This is for Tom and David. What do you figure CarMax stands for in the eyes of shoppers right now — say, in late 2025 — with all the other options available? And in, let's say, 2 to 3 years, where would you want to be? Thanks.

David McCraight

executive
#17

Hello. Good to speak with you. This is David. You know, a lot of what CarMax has historically represented for its customers, we think, can carry forward. In our view, we're a top destination for pre-owned vehicle buyers; we've put substantial money, effort, and time into creating and expanding those abilities so people can browse whenever and however they prefer. And in the end, we think we're the brand people trust most. What's different is the position we've occupied and the results we have to adapt to, plus shifting our model in that direction, and we're confident we can reach that point soon.

Tom Folliard

executive
#18

Hi Scott, this is Tom. It’s nice to speak with you once more. From where I sit — and yes, I admit I have a bias — over the past 30 years, an iconic brand has been created by us. That hasn’t shifted one bit, in my view. Consumers understand what we stand for. They recognize the quality we stand for. Our associates in our stores, in our CECs, and throughout the organization are fully engaged and prepared to take care of the customer. A great deal of money has been spent on investments so we could serve customers in whatever way they want, whether that’s online or in our stores. And I believe we simply have to activate that. Presenting that to the customer upfront is something we must do better at. Still, when it comes to the brand, its strength, and the quality of our vehicles, all of that remains completely intact, and I believe it is the foundation for us as we move ahead. And a foundation from which we can grow once more.

Scott Ciccarelli

analyst
#19

Thanks, and a happy, happy holiday season to you.

Tom Folliard

executive
#20

Thanks, Scott. Appreciate it.

Craig Kennison

analyst
#21

Morning, and thanks for the chance to ask. Regarding SG and A, what figure are you starting from when you say you'll trim $150 million? I'm just curious, so we can measure how you're doing relative to that target.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#22

Yeah, absolutely. When we discuss that $150 million SG and A objective, it refers to a decrease in SG and A. Those opportunities, essentially, are measured against the prior year, so to speak. If you'd like to use it, our starting point was $2.5 billion, correct? Approximately. That's the number we treat as our baseline, and those are the cuts we're pursuing.

Craig Kennison

analyst
#23

And as of '27, that's the run rate we'd have on the way out.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#24

Precisely.

Craig Kennison

analyst
#25

K. Thanks. Appreciate it.

Rajat Gupta

analyst
#26

Excellent. I appreciate you fielding this, and I appreciate the frank evaluation during the prepared remarks. I wanted to ask something further regarding the margin compared with the same store expectation. Might you provide us any sort of preliminary indication? The reason I ask is that we sensed during the prior quarter as well that there was an attempt to get more competitive on price. Is there anything you could share regarding, say, preliminary indications in December, and how those moves have already begun producing some results, or is it still quite early, or have you not yet put them in place? And what sort of, like, relationship are we considering, you know, when it comes to you know, dollars versus same store volume, you know, the trade off. Dollar GPU versus same store volume trade. Any additional insights you could offer regarding how you expect this relationship to develop? I have one very brief follow-up. Thanks.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#27

Hey, Rajat. We have only just introduced the price changes. Therefore it is too soon to offer any sort of insight regarding that. And, once more, we will offer a view regarding that on a Q4 call, but we literally just introduced those changes. So we're in the process of rolling them out. They're underway. Yeah. And they're underway. Actually, they're not that's a good point. They're not completely rolled out. They're underway, but we only began this week. So

Rajat Gupta

analyst
#28

Are we hoping to return to share gains, or should we expect unit growth to pause? What sort of outcome do you anticipate in the near term?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#29

Yeah. Look, we feel good about the lever we're pulling here, and once more, it's truly the mix, correct, of having lower margins, lower prices in the market, being more competitive on price. Backing that with acquisition marketing — so things such as paid search, other direct levers of that kind, directly supporting sales — that is going to shift the trend. In our performance. So we just reported a negative nine comp. The prior quarter came in slightly above that, though still not great; and our aim is to shift the trend and get the sales flywheel moving. That is what we're seeking to do. And simultaneously, we're working very hard on putting other profitability metrics, or levers rather, into place. And once more, those items are SG and A reductions, COGS reductions, ETP growth, cap full spectrum, so cap income growth over time. All of these are levers we're pulling. Since our aim is to drive sales over time, without question, and to drive earnings power over time too.

Rajat Gupta

analyst
#30

Got it. And a fast second question about CAF. It seems, as you said, that third-party tier three penetration rose. Is there any significant tightening happening at the moment? I'd like to know how those reserves will shift later on when you return to greater in-house tier three and tier two type penetration. Perhaps any detail you can share about this CAF provision in Q4 would also be useful. Thanks.

Jon Daniels

executive
#31

Certainly. Yeah. I appreciate that, Rajat. I don't believe there's a huge narrative around tier two and tier three. We simply report those figures and offer a bit of guidance regarding the change. But there's constantly shifting, perhaps a tier two lender deciding to act somewhat more aggressively or to tighten. Once more, each will make their own separate choices. Compared with the tier three partner that, once again, could receive that tightening further up the chain or, once again, be somewhat more relaxed on its end. So I don't think a significant narrative exists there, just to be clear. We're merely giving the figures. And finally, regarding your second question, I wouldn't interpret too much from that with respect to CAF provision. Once again, as we said, we're extremely enthusiastic about our chance as we move down into the tier two spectrum. Just one point worth noting, we exceeded 10% of the tier two volume. It came to cast this quarter; we pursued it, so we're truly thrilled about that. And as we keep moving further along the spectrum, we typically operate within the upper 50% of tier two, yet we believe we can capture that whole credit spectrum as we systematically introduce refinements to our model; we're enthusiastic about the funding solutions we've put in place. And so we will reserve for it appropriately, and we will take pleasure in the income, and we will reach that point.

Rajat Gupta

analyst
#32

All right. That's great. I appreciate the detail, and best of luck. Thank you.

Brian Nagel

analyst
#33

Hi, everyone. Good morning. Tom, glad to see you back at the Falls.

Tom Folliard

executive
#34

Hi, Brian. Thank you.

Brian Nagel

analyst
#35

I realize this may come across as me making the same point again, but I want to be sure it's clearly understood. So we're talking about pricing, and about taking a more aggressive stance on pricing; as long as I can remember, and forgive me, for quite a while now. You know, these pricing tests have been run by you; and what CarMax has said has stayed the same throughout, namely that they did substantially lower prices, so the result is nothing, you know, it hasn't been favorable. So I suppose the question is, you're bringing up once more, you know, either running tests or proceeding with reduced prices except with lower GPUs. How is this instance different? What makes you believe things will turn out differently this time, in a way that actually boosts unit volume more effectively?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#36

Yeah. In the past, whenever we cut prices — and we're constantly adjusting pricing, correct, Brandon? That's something we discuss. The way it used to work was this: you bring prices down, and once that works its way through the business, the question becomes whether you earn enough to make up for the thinner margin through higher sales. It definitely does lift sales. The problem was that it didn't always generate sufficient profit. What I'd say is that at this moment, the distinction is unmistakable. What makes it unmistakable is the set of powerful levers we now have that let us examine the company in a much more integrated way. So once more, consider the SG and A cuts — the forceful push Tesla is making there. Consider COGS, and how forcefully we're pursuing it. Consider the expansion of EPP. Consider the growth in CAF full spectrum income. Every one of these levers will help counter a portion of the strain we'd observed back when we examined only what price reductions were doing. Yes, there's definitely a distinction here, and our approach is to take a broader view of the business, since we have those options available to us.

Tom Folliard

executive
#37

And, Brian, I'd simply like to mention that, like Enrique said, we have consistently framed this around overall profitability. When price adjustments happen, sales definitely shift somewhat. And we've always kept some boundaries regarding overall profitability. I'd just say that our near-term emphasis, with how we're performing right now, is on boosting sales and getting things headed the opposite way. Another point to keep in mind: whenever we mention being at a lower price by $100 or $200, that doesn't imply we're reducing $100 uniformly across all vehicles. It's more akin to, if we say $100, think of it as a percentage of our cars at a thousand dollars. Or 5% of our cars at $500. So it does significantly affect how sales trend, because of how we implement price adjustments. But returning to our near-term priority, it's about reversing the situation and getting sales headed the opposite way.

Brian Nagel

analyst
#38

Thanks. And you—and then one quick follow-up. My apologies, David. But regarding marketing, so you mentioned—if I've got this right—that you've increased marketing spend at this point. It's the same story. That isn't the gas, a bit more. When you consider it, is it largely more of the same, or is Carmex genuinely focused on arriving with a fresh marketing message for the market?

David McCraight

executive
#39

Yes. Fair question. Thank you. What we're doing is this: the fresh campaign got rolled out not long ago. The team walked you through it. Right now, in the short term, our focus is on refining that campaign using the results and tests we've got. So we're moving things toward generating greater conversion and messaging, and possibly scaling back some of the longer-term brand investment in it. In the end, we believe reviewing and positioning the campaign is truly a matter for the incoming CEO, who will bring it in line with the new strategy, and we're operating with the current campaign and the resources available to us at this moment. Still, the team has been striving to improve the results according to media, according to geographies, and according to messaging.

Brian Nagel

analyst
#40

Thank you. I really appreciate the additional detail.

David McCraight

executive
#41

Thank you, Brian.

Daniela Haigian

analyst
#42

Thanks. Morning, Tom, David. I appreciate the context you gave us in the prepared remarks. First question relates to that digital platform redefinition. What exactly has to be altered inside it so a selling experience gets more emphasis? And what does that do to the operating cost structure alongside your store base? Which early signals would show progress on that redefinition?

David McCraight

executive
#43

Yeah. Let's handle the opening portion of the question to start. Over the years, we've worked very diligently to build up the capability set. Yet we haven't been as focused so far on the following stage, which means making it simpler. Look. Our digital buying process remains cumbersome. We can simplify it, and we can ensure the online sales experience mirrors what our in-store associates deliver, making it easier to guide customers toward a completed purchase. The greatest satisfaction comes when someone finds a vehicle within their budget that they truly like. Even with all the progress made so far, we acknowledge the experience is still not effortless. So while we've worked hard to supply information and many other resources, there's still room for us to make things smoother and get it to that point. When it comes to what happens further along, we'll coordinate closely with the company and the field to determine the strongest available paths. Like Jon and Enrique both said before, we have an opportunity to examine our entire business model in a unified way — COGS, SG and A, messaging, every one of those pieces — and that covers the way we make choices, not so much one at a time but in a more unified manner, plus what that translates into for a customer offer. We stay focused on whatever matters most to them. That said, my expectation is that you'll notice certain changes. Tom and I would expect that you'll notice certain changes, and they'll come in stages. Within the coming one to two months, you'll notice it, and we'll keep going beyond that point. Even so, you ought to observe that these initiatives are already in motion, and the group is quite enthusiastic regarding this upcoming phase, that digital path, and the significance of connecting it with the field team. Extremely mutually beneficial.

Daniela Haigian

analyst
#44

Understood. Understood. That's useful, and I appreciate you being open about it. My next question concerns COGS. Correct? Both you and Enrique continue to describe COGS as a major lever. What's the plan for bringing that line item down, and are you still making headway on that regional reconditioning center strategy?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#45

Yes. Here's what I'd say: look, COGS has been a focus for us — I mean, COGS is always a focus. What we've done is highlight it across the last couple of years. For instance, a year ago, we put out a target of $125. Per unit. We achieved it. This year, we again put out a target. $125 per unit. I'd say, based on where sales stand, or have stood across the last two quarters, we're likely somewhat behind on that target. Not because the initiatives don't exist or the teams aren't performing well; it's simply due to deleverage. In a difficult, difficult sales climate. But we'll keep setting even more aggressive targets internally to pursue COGS opportunities. A portion of that comes via the reconditioning centers. Correct? A portion of that — here's a concrete illustration. We recently introduced a parts selection tool; at our stores; we're already realizing gains. From it, right, essentially pushing our store associates to weigh speed against quality against cost and making it very simple for our associates to do so; and we're seeing results quite quickly, and that's merely one illustration of the things we're pursuing in COGS. As for the reconditioning centers, yes, we've launched at this moment five Only two have been operating for roughly a year. It remains somewhat early to determine what the targets are. I mean, the ultimate aim is definitely to make them more efficient. We're already observing logistics savings throughout the system since we've launched these; and we anticipate that they'll deliver in line with certain of our bigger reconditioning units located in stores such as Murrieta. In LA that we've observed. They're a highly efficient store given the volume we push through. And we hold the same expectations for these more regional reconditioning centers. But once more, we've only launched a handful at this moment. Yes.

David Bellinger

analyst
#46

Morning, everybody. Tom, it's great to speak with you once more. During the prepared remarks, you all brought up reevaluating what it costs to get a vehicle to market. But what about how long it takes to move cars? For quite a while, CarMax has led in that space. It seems a number of rivals have ramped up their pace to market quite sharply. Can you do anything with AI deployment to shorten that window, leverage your more than 30 years of information, and maybe sidestep some of those bigger depreciation fluctuations that have hurt the business across recent quarters? How should we view that chance?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#47

Yes. I'd say, look, reconditioning, speed, and bringing down our WIP are always top of mind for us. You know, take this quarter — we grew sellable inventory while shrinking total inventory. Right? So that shows a real emphasis on WIP. In fact, during this quarter that aided per turns versus a year ago even though comps fell 9%; so the organizational push toward simply improving at turning vehicles is clear. I believe our off-site reconditioning sites will assist too, since that would be still more efficient; so those are just a few illustrations of where the focus is headed.

David Bellinger

analyst
#48

Then, Enrique, perhaps a follow-up question. Could you bring us up to date on the real estate approach? Is anything shifting in that area? A large portion of your real estate is owned by you folks. Might that be a place where you could unlock value and apply it toward funding additional investment in the business should the need arise?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#49

Yeah. Look. I believe that possibility always exists — we hold ownership of many of our sites where our stores sit. What I'd say is that we have superior alternatives for capital compared with pursuing something like a sale leaseback. So our banking relationships are strong. We have excellent partners, providers of capital, and, you know, a revolver is available to us, a $2 billion revolver we can draw on. And you know, those are simply more efficient routes for us to obtain capital. Instead of sort of monetizing our stores. Or the land. Beneath our stores.

David Bellinger

analyst
#50

Understood. Thanks.

Chris Bottiglieri

analyst
#51

Hi, everyone. Appreciate you taking my question. The first one is more of a housekeeping item, I guess, and then I have a broader one. Did you provide the service profit? I believe it came to $4 million in the prior quarter. I'm wondering what it was in Q3. With volumes in Q4 looking a lot like Q3, does that make it a solid run rate for Q4? Then for my real question, could you explain more about what's going on with credit penetration? On the prime side, it sounds like you're getting fewer appraisals or less traffic coming through. With a K-shaped economy, wouldn't that be the healthier portion of the market? I'm just curious about the cause and what you're observing. Thanks.

Jon Daniels

executive
#52

Want to handle that together with Chris? Let me verify. Sure. That works. Chris, it's Jon here. I'll address the credit part. As we said in the prepared remarks and, yes, even thinking back on Sharon's question, whenever we examine the whole credit spectrum, yes, we can truly tell who is arriving and shopping with us by way of our, you know, our prequel product, which is an excellent tool for that. You know, customers are big fans of it. They make the most of it. You know, eighty-plus percent of our customers begin with credit online. Yes. I believe we clearly see a chance within that roughly six fifty to seven fifty credit range. And like I said before, it's difficult to guess what's causing that, you know, is it, you know, we believe our rates are pretty competitive in that area. But inventory, price, availability, all of that is always a factor. As we said during this call, taken as a whole, every bit of that is open for discussion, and we will look at, once again, enhancing our overall offering in that area. So even though you'd call it a K-shaped economy, you know, in the end, we do see the other folks are likely less pressured by affordability. We want to ensure we have the right product at the right price at the right time for them whenever they're ready to buy; so I think there's room for improvement there. That's genuinely what those comments, I believe, are about in that area.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#53

Yes. And when it comes to service during the quarter, there was certainly strain in services, as you're aware, and like we discussed, it's a line item service margin that deleverages when sales become more challenged. Look, it's sort of like, across the last two years, the teams have achieved significant progress. In service margin over the last two years, and we'd even mentioned at the start of this year that we anticipated it would be, I believe, marginally positive for the year in service margin. Of course, our sales expectations back then weren't where we're presently actualizing; but I'll tell you, for the full year, what we're looking at right now is, you know, perhaps a little unprofitable or a little profitable. That hinges on sales performance in the fourth quarter. And that just shows you the the the amazing work the teams are doing in for service margin there. But we did have a negative margin in the third quarter, and we do expect, as I mentioned in my prepared remarks, some pressure in the fourth quarter. We'll be comping over some cost coverage cost coverage that we took last year. But, again, if I step back and I look more holistically at it, the teams have done tremendous work You know, it's gonna be borderline whether or we hit that positive margin for the full year; but, again, sales have been definitely more pressured than what we had anticipated. Compared to the beginning of the year.

Chris Bottiglieri

analyst
#54

Got it, thanks.

John Babcock

analyst
#55

Good morning, and I appreciate you taking my questions. First off, I was hoping you might share a little more about what the Board is seeking in its next CEO, and also how we ought to think about timing regarding when an announcement could come?

Tom Folliard

executive
#56

Acknowledging that could shift. Yeah. What I'd say is that this is the Board's top priority at present; as I lead the search together with the other members of the search committee, it's also my own personal number one priority. We're seeking an individual who has run a complicated company with a varied collection of assets. We're also hoping to bring in someone who has guided some form of digital transformation. It doesn't have to come from the auto industry necessarily. It doesn't have to come from retail either; but one of the things that matters most is finding a person who grasps our culture and can guide this team into the next chapter of our success. As far as timing goes, we're moving as fast as possible, but I don't really have an update on timing.

John Babcock

analyst
#57

All right, that makes sense. Moving on, given what you've been working on for the past 2 months, and just from knowing the business, I was curious how you're viewing the omnichannel operation. Do you see this as the kind of setup you'd want to maintain over a longer horizon? Would you rather gradually lean more toward digital? What exactly does omnichannel give you that digital doesn't, or that a heavier brick and mortar approach wouldn't?

Tom Folliard

executive
#58

For us, honestly, it's a combination of everything. As the team has been saying across the past several years, we've put hundreds of millions of dollars into our infrastructure, which gives us the ability to serve the customer wherever they want. I'd say a national physical footprint works in our favor, with more than 250 locations, as David said at the start of the call, reaching close to 85% of The US population. So I'd frame it as a strategy that includes all of the above. Some of what you've heard today reflects that we aren't satisfied with how we present to the customer on the digital side. You'll see us deliver some meaningful enhancements there. Still, we believe our stores hold tremendous value, and our store team excels at converting customers once they walk in. That said, we obviously have to improve when it comes to digital.

David McCraight

executive
#59

Sure. To give a bit more context around what Tom mentioned, CarMax has developed a tremendous number of capabilities over time. As we now examine our entire business model in a holistic way, it's clear we've created many potential capabilities, and while a lot of them are useful, certain ones are likely adding complexity due to choices we've made and efforts to serve every possible need for every customer. We now have a chance to simplify, make some choices, and prioritize certain areas, guided by concrete, quantified consumer insights, so we can streamline and enhance the benefits that Omni ought to deliver, rather than getting bogged down in the complications Omni can also bring. So I think you'll see that happen soon, as the team wraps up building that infrastructure, and then really sharpens and refines it into a competitive advantage.

John Babcock

analyst
#60

Alright, thanks a lot. That really helps.

Jeff Lick

analyst
#61

Good morning, and thanks for taking my question. Tom, hearing your voice is just fantastic.

Tom Folliard

executive
#62

Thank you.

Jeff Lick

analyst
#63

So here's the thing, David. I've got something to ask you. You've held senior positions at retailers that were born online, and also at retailers that are sort of a mix — they've got both brick-and-mortar operations and e-commerce operations. I'm curious whether you could address what's hard about this, since CarMax is that kind of mixed model, where, as you know, some folks head into the physical side of things, and that creates a certain inherent friction, which makes achieving an optimal digital operation tougher.

David McCraight

executive
#64

Yes. Jeff, that's a sharp observation, and I appreciate it. Yes. There are instances of exactly that, and it's partly what I was hinting at. Now, bear in mind Tom and I have only occupied these seats for roughly 2.5 weeks, but the thing that stands out most to me is that this is a genuinely exceptional team, very eager to make a breakthrough, and an unbelievably skilled and committed bunch. We simply have to operate across those channels so that the customer sits at the center of those choices, rather than letting operational preferences or old ways of doing things seep in. So it isn't one side fighting the other, but our job is to supply some direction and get the team focused so we can begin delivering more on that front. What matters most to the buyer? Simplify. Ensure the offer is competitive. Since we recognize that we hold the brand, and we recognize that we hold the trust. Across a significant portion of the American consumer base. But you're completely correct. Lots of companies find omnichannel trips them up. I'd put it this way: we're currently wrapping up something like an off-road adolescence, and we'll shift into a far more polished approach soon; that said, you'll want to verify that response with the incoming CEO once they arrive, but meanwhile, that's the reason we feel such optimism regarding the improvement; so many of the pieces are already there.

Jeff Lick

analyst
#65

I wanted to circle back quickly to what Sharon asked initially regarding possible customer groups you may have shed or become less successful with. I doubt she had the FICO score specifically in mind. Right? That ties into how you advertise. Tom, I'm curious — years ago, it seemed you consistently drew more than your share of younger professionals, often women, who had no interest in haggling at a franchise dealership. You gave them a far simpler, more professional encounter. Do you figure your main rival perhaps blocked your lane previously and hasn't even delivered a superior experience for that type of buyer, where now it's, like, hey, this is incredibly simple.

Tom Folliard

executive
#66

Regarding your point on customer groups, during Q2 we saw a 6% decline. The prior quarter brought a 9% drop. So improvement is needed everywhere; that said, I'd simply refer back to what we've already shared. We aren't as convenient as we must be for buyers. Our processes require simplification. Purchasing things on the internet is so effortless nowadays, no matter the item. That holds for cars too; it isn't merely one or two rivals. It applies universally. And once more, we've spent the capital to position ourselves as the leader in this area. There's still work ahead to reach that point. But we must make things simpler for customers as they navigate doing business with us, be it through our site, our app, or our locations.

Jeff Lick

analyst
#67

That's plenty. Wishing you the best, and I'm eager to hear from you once more.

Tom Folliard

executive
#68

Thank you, Jeff.

Chris Pearce

analyst
#69

Morning. I want to pick up where Jeff left off. Do you believe your existing customers are willing to handle a greater share of tasks through digital channels, which could help offset operating expenses? Specifically within GPUs — or is a brand refresh needed to attract a younger audience? Or would you push back on that way of putting it?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#70

Could you repeat that? Apologies. Yeah, sorry — we didn't catch it.

Chris Pearce

analyst
#71

Yeah, I'm just wondering. Do you figure your customer base is interested in completing more of this work through digital channels? For instance, do you believe this fresh advertising push needs to target a younger demographic? Or is it really all about the price point and the kind of experience you provide?

Tom Folliard

executive
#72

I definitely believe our customers are eager to handle a greater portion of this process online. The reality is, as you move down in age, your funds are lower, and your odds of possessing the necessary credit to purchase a vehicle priced at $26,000 drop as well. So, yes, I think we have ample customer traffic, and we must capitalize on that more effectively.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#73

As David and Tom both mentioned, we clearly possess assets others would envy, correct? Our brand recognition sits at an extraordinary level. The people who buy from us show tremendous loyalty and genuinely adore what we offer. The team members we have are truly exceptional. Across this nation, we run over 250 locations, and every one of them performs at a very high standard. We've put money into our digital tools, and those capabilities are solid — we simply need to adjust slightly how all these pieces fit together. Yet when it comes to the question of whether buyers exist who'd want to purchase us, my answer would be without a doubt; that isn't something worrying us. What we do have in front of us is the chance to build the most persuasive proposition possible around what consumers want, and that is where our attention lies.

Chris Pearce

analyst
#74

Okay. Thank you, good luck.

Tom Folliard

executive
#75

Thank you.

Michael Montani

analyst
#76

Hello, and good morning. Thank you for taking the question. Tom, it's nice to hear from you once more. I'd like to explore what is essentially a three-part question, though the parts are interconnected. First, I was hoping for some additional detail on depreciation trends and what you're observing. Second, on the competitive landscape — the level of intensity seems to be escalating. And third, regarding reinvestment into GPUs, how significant a reinvestment should we anticipate going forward?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#77

Sure. Let's take depreciation separately. My remarks pertained specifically to the wholesale segment, correct? Within the quarter, we experienced a very pronounced depreciation — more than 10% during that period. That was really pronounced, and it hurt how we did during the quarter. Once that fades, our expectation is that results would have recovered; regarding GP, we did bring that up. Look, it's significant enough that we needed to address it here. Even so, we've just introduced pricing changes at various levels; we'll watch how things go over the quarter; then on our Q4 call, we'll return and discuss what we observed. Plus what that implies for our strategy going ahead. I mean, that's what I'm saying, though at the same time we feel good about turning around how things have been selling — those comps of negative six and negative nine, one after the other. That's the pattern we want to reverse. Reversing it is the goal, and we'll report back on that. As for your second question, I've lost it — but the one with three parts.

Michael Montani

analyst
#78

Regarding competitive intensity, that's the first and third items. I'm not certain.

Tom Folliard

executive
#79

Yeah, let me address the pricing aspect and expand on it—our approach isn't a fixed system where we cut all prices and keep them unchanged; instead, it's going to be highly flexible over the course of the quarter. You know, one key point that David, I, and the rest of the team evaluated quickly is that you want to shift things in the opposite direction. There are several major levers available to pull, but the most significant two are undoubtedly pricing and marketing; so we're taking actions on those fronts to attempt to reverse the trend. However, it will remain very adaptable during the quarter. That's why, you know, we aren't attempting to dodge questions about our expected margin effects, but we're striving to maximize our impact. And once more, we're 18 days into the quarter, so this will be an evolving effort over the coming 3 months.

Michael Montani

analyst
#80

I appreciate it.

David McCraight

executive
#81

Many thanks. The thousands of CarMax associates deserve our gratitude — they're the ones who built the business we have now, and they'll be part of our next leg of growth going forward. We're glad all of you could be on the call with us today, and just before we wrap up, Tom would like to offer a few closing remarks.

Tom Folliard

executive
#82

Yes, I want to express my gratitude to everyone for your backing. A lot of you I recognize, and I've listened to your voices before, and while returning feels good, I would have preferred somewhat different conditions. However, what I'd share with you is that from where the board sits, we are fully dedicated to doing this properly. While we look for our next CEO, David is the ideal individual to occupy this position. I'm glad to devote more of my time to the business. Over these past 2 weeks, what has energized me most is the level of involvement from all our employees and their eagerness to succeed. As we've said repeatedly and Enrique basically summarized completely, this company holds amazing assets. Our balance sheet is strong. Our brand is iconic. We have 250 locations. And above all, what has consistently set us apart from everyone else is how engaged our more than 28,000 associates are; and none of that has changed. So I simply wanted to end by stating the board is fully dedicated to doing this properly. I also wanted to express my appreciation to David for the part he is playing while this search is ongoing. And finally, I wish everyone a joyful holiday season. Thanks for being with us. And, we'll speak with you next time.

Operator

operator
#83

Thank you. That brings us to the close of the CarMax Earnings Release Conference Call for the third quarter of fiscal year 2026, ladies and gentlemen. At this point, you are free to disconnect.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete CarMax, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to CarMax, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in CarMax, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.