CarMax, Inc. (KMX) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
June 19, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Stacy Frole
executiveThanks, Carol. Hello, everyone, and welcome to the conference call covering our first-quarter results for fiscal year 2021. Joining me are Bill Nash, who serves as President and Chief Executive Officer; Tom Reedy, Executive Vice President of Finance; and Enrique Mayor-Mora, Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer. I want to point out that anything we say today about future business plans, prospects, and financial performance constitutes forward-looking statements issued under the safe harbor protections of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Such statements reflect what management currently knows and assumes about upcoming events, and they carry risks and uncertainties that might make actual outcomes differ substantially from what we anticipate. When we provide projections or other forward-looking statements, the company renounces any intention or duty to revise them; for more details about significant factors that might influence these expectations, please refer to the Form 8-K we released this morning as well as the annual report on Form 10-K covering the fiscal year that concluded February 29, 2020, which was filed with the SEC. If any follow-up questions come up once this call ends, don't hesitate to reach out to our Investor Relations team at (804) 747 to 0422, extension 7865. Finally, I'd like to express my appreciation ahead of time for limiting yourselves to a single question and then rejoining the queue for any additional follow-ups. Bill?
Bill Nash
executiveAlright. Thanks, Stacy. Good morning to all of you, and I appreciate you being here. Before diving in, I'd like to address the serious societal issues our nation currently faces. Here at CarMax, we are firmly together in opposition to racial injustice, hatred, and violence. It makes me proud that our principles have consistently centered on acting rightly and giving everyone dignity no matter their race, ethnicity, or background—yet we must improve both as an organization and as a nation. I want our associates, communities, and shareholders to understand that we are dedicated to doing more. Transformation has to begin with leadership, which is why I am personally leading this effort to guarantee we create a beneficial impact going forward. Now, turning to the quarter's key points. As you saw in this morning's earnings release, the coronavirus heavily affected our first quarter results. In early April, when things peaked, sales had fallen by over 75%. At that point, 95% of the nation was under shelter-in-place mandates, and roughly half our locations were either shut down or operating with limitations because of directives from public health officials and government bodies. Operating with limitations means locations could still sell vehicles, but only through appointments, curbside handoff, at-home delivery, or any mix of those 3. Rules for social distancing and caps on occupancy further constrained how much we could operate at locations that stayed open, even our biggest ones, which before the virus typically welcomed over 100 shoppers in a single store on any day. To give even more context, over 80% of the first quarter's days were affected by locations that were shut and/or operating with limitations. By May 31, every one of our locations had reopened, yet over 50% still operated under occupancy caps and over 10% with limited operations, just as I explained before. Because we feel our first quarter outcomes don't reflect what's ahead, we won't devote much time to discussing what was in this morning's release. Instead, we'll share perspective on how we steered through the crisis, what recent patterns look like, and the near-term strategic priorities that we think open doors for us to widen the gap with other used car retailers and flourish in this new landscape. Let me begin by expressing how proud I am of how our associates handled this tough and fast-evolving situation; they kept embodying our core values daily by supporting one another, serving our customers, and contributing back to our communities. When the pandemic hit, we faced an incredibly hard choice to furlough over 15,000 associates because of location shutdowns and reduced demand. I'm happy to report that as of today, we've brought back over 85% of those associates, and we anticipate getting back to typical operating levels very soon. We achieved a great deal this quarter. When the pandemic first hit, our teams responded fast. We put strong plans in place to lower the chance of exposure and keep the virus from spreading further inside our stores, and we complied with directives from public health authorities and government bodies that shifted from one day to the next. We rolled out social distancing and sanitation measures to make things safer for both customers and associates. On top of that, we started new offerings, including contactless curbside pickup, a temporary extension of our 90-day warranty, and cash payment assistance, all aimed at serving our customers' immediate needs. Our whole wholesale operation moved quickly from in-person auctions to online ones, and wherever it was possible, we kept appraisal lanes running for customers who wished, or had, to sell their vehicles. Along with maintaining store operations and selling vehicles to buyers, we feel very good about how we handled margin and inventory across both retail and wholesale during the sharpest depreciation climate we have ever seen. We also finished the quarter with liquidity that was even better than what we started with. After reaching a low point in early April, our sales have gotten better step by step as stores reopen, limits on occupancy begin to loosen, and shoppers start to come back to car buying. Turning to how things look more recently, the patterns we saw in late May and early June give us reason for optimism. Web traffic has grown compared with a year ago and is hitting new records, which shows how well our marketing team is capturing demand through pay channels and the strength of our non-brand SEO results. Beyond that, the number of leads arriving at our customer experience centers, or CECs, keeps rising each week. Even though 4 stores remain under limited operations and over 50% still face occupancy restrictions, during the first 2 weeks of June our comp unit sales came in within 10% of last year's figure, and plenty of stores are comping positive. We understand that today's conditions have sped up the change in how consumers buy. People now want safety, personalization, and convenience more than ever when they shop for and purchase a vehicle. To us, that confirms our strategy is the correct way forward, and the present situation gives us a rare chance to speed up our omnichannel experience along with other digitally focused investments. Even before the crisis, we had already been putting substantial money into digital merchandising, online financing, and tools for managing customer leads as we introduced our new omnichannel experience. That experience lets customers buy online, in a store, or through a smooth blend of the two. We anticipate wrapping up our omnichannel rollout in the second quarter, and our efforts now center on refining this customer experience with fresh improvements. Our business model has proven itself, and our capacity to move fast let us satisfy consumer expectations while staying financially solid. That, in turn, lets us keep investing aggressively in our core business and chase new growth opportunities, which I will get to in a moment. At this point, I want to hand things over to Enrique for a financial update, after which Tom is going to give more specifics regarding customer financing.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveThank you, Bill, and hello to everybody on this call. Because our business spans multiple areas, our balance sheet is sturdy, and we bring in plenty of cash, we were in a very strong position to navigate difficult circumstances. That same strength lets us seize near-term opportunities while also getting the most out of our longer-term expansion and profit possibilities, which puts even more distance between us and those we compete against. First, I'll walk through how operations performed, and after that I'll go over where we stand financially. Turning to GPU, our teams handled margins exceptionally well even though the market saw historic levels of depreciation and we faced restrictions on what we could do. For Q1, our GPU came in at $1,937, which is $278 lower per unit than the same period a year ago. At $978 per unit, our wholesale gross profit was healthy, dipping just $65 per unit relative to the comparable quarter last year. That happened even as wholesale values fell sharply during late March and April. The way we've managed GPU speaks to how capable our professional buyers are, to the strength of our exclusive algorithms used for purchasing, selling, and valuing vehicles, and to the know-how we've built up getting through tough stretches. In our wholesale segment, unit sales dropped 48% compared with the same period last year. The decline in wholesale units came from reduced appraisal traffic — a result of stores either shutting down or running at limited capacity — along with a lower buy rate. As the quarter's second half got underway, both of those areas started improving at a steady pace once the country started reopening and our auctions moved to an online format. Our auction sell-through rate for the quarter matched our historical figure of more than 95%. Other gross profit for the quarter fell by roughly $89 million. That figure came from a $55 million drop in profits from the service department plus a $38 million decline in EPP revenues. The EPP profit decline stems from fewer used units being sold, partly counterbalanced by a $7 million gain tied to receiving profit sharing and favorable adjustments to cancellation reserves. We also felt good about keeping ESP penetration rates above 60% during the quarter. Lower service profits come from overhead deleverage along with the pay continuity we gave our technicians even though production slowed. Service profits also kept getting squeezed by our post-sale warranty period growing from 30 to 90 days and by a crisis-related drop in retail service. As you might remember, we made that warranty extension from 30 to 90 days back in May of 2019. Given the recent pickup in sales during May and the early portion of June, we're increasing production to build up our inventory. So we anticipate ongoing service inefficiencies in Q2, since bringing production back to a normal operating state takes time. In Q1, when the pandemic started hurting sales, it mattered a great deal that we brought our operating expenses in line with where the business stood. Simultaneously, we leveraged our solid financial standing to keep funding improvements to our omnichannel offering along with other digital programs that give us an edge over rivals. SG&A for the quarter fell by over 20%, which works out to $116 million. The reasons are lower variable costs tied to reduced sales volume, plus temporarily placing associates on furlough, cutting back on advertising, and bringing other overhead expenses in line with the business. SG&A during the quarter additionally gained from a $40 million benefit from settling a class action lawsuit and a $17 million drop in stock-based compensation expense. Once business recovers, we anticipate SG&A costs will climb as furloughed associates come back, advertising spending rises alongside growing demand, and we keep putting money into strategic initiatives, which Bill will cover in a moment; now I'll give you a look at our financial position. We finished the first quarter with better liquidity than when we began it. On May 31, we held roughly $660 million in cash and cash equivalents, along with $1.08 billion of untapped capacity on our revolving credit facility; that stacks up well against the $700 million and $300 million, respectively, that we had at the close of March and that we shared on our April 2 fourth quarter call. We managed to boost liquidity by moving through inventory and swiftly bringing costs in line with the reduced volume. We accomplished that while still funding our omni and digital experiences. Turning to debt, we closed the first quarter with about $1.7 billion of long-term debt, not counting nonrecourse notes payable, made up of roughly $370 million drawn on our revolver credit facility, $800 million of senior notes and term loans, and approximately $535 million in financing obligations, mostly tied to sale leasebacks on certain stores. It's worth noting we face no near-term maturities, since the earliest one arrives in 2023. We finished the quarter slightly under our historical leverage target of 35% to 45% adjusted debt-to-capital after netting out the roughly $660 million in cash we built up. During the first quarter, we launched 4 new stores that needed very little capital spend to finish. Earlier, we said we intended to open 13 stores in fiscal year '21 and a comparable number in fiscal year '22. We're still pausing any further spend on store expansion activity in FY '21, and we'll look at that decision again later in the year. Beyond that, though we stay dedicated to giving capital back to shareholders, our share repurchase program is on hold right now too. We take great pride in how we strengthened our liquidity position through a highly difficult quarter while simultaneously pressing ahead with investments in our omni and digital initiatives. All of this leaves us well positioned to grow market share profitably once the economy and consumer bounce back. I'll now hand the call over to Tom.
Tom Reedy
executiveAppreciate it, Enrique, and hello everyone. Given that the overwhelming share of people buying a car end up with some form of financing, we need to make sure our wide customer base can tap lending no matter what the economy is doing. That's why having CAF, together with a varied set of partner lenders who understand what CarMax's origination channel brings, lets us reliably extend strong finance offers to our shoppers. During Q1, our lending channel kept performing, extending offers to 97% of customers seeking a vehicle. A captive finance operation brings many things to the business model that are hard to copy. Inside the origination channel, CAF picks up meaningful finance income while also driving a bit of incremental sales. CAF handles full servicing for every customer it finances, carrying forward CarMax's excellent brand promise across the entire life of the finance contract. We count over 800 CAF associates, and the whole team was outstanding this quarter, moving fast to work remotely while meeting rising customer demands. In mid-March, when the pandemic worsened, we implemented several steps at CAF to assist our customers. These included halting repossessions, forgiving late fees, and offering payment relief through our disaster policies. Our service offering did shift over the quarter, as we concentrated on helping customers while safeguarding our portfolio. Much like our auto — our retail and wholesale operations, CAF's results were hit by the coronavirus; for the quarter, originations fell sharply because stores were closed and sales demand was lower. Additionally, CAF penetration net of 3-day payoffs dropped to 36.1% from 41.4% a year ago, driven by the shift in customer credit mix, certain temporary underwriting adjustments in select pockets aimed at preserving our high-quality portfolio, and some testing of loan routing to our third-party partners. Tier 2's penetration rose to 28.5% in Q1 from 20.3% last year, helped by CAF's routing tests and a change in customer credit mix during the quarter. Tier 2's conversion also stayed strong. Tier 3 for the first quarter climbed to 14.5% from 11.5% a year ago, also gaining from the change in customer credit mix. CAF income for the quarter came to $51 million, mainly driven by the effect of this quarter's increase in the provision for loan losses to $122 million, which is understandably far above the $38 million in Q1 of last year; for the first quarter, the ending reserve balance stood at $437 million versus $147 million a year ago. The big jump in the loss reserve came from 2 factors: first, the mandated adoption of the new current expected credit loss accounting standard, commonly called CECL; and second, an unfavorable adjustment for experience stemming from the coronavirus. When we adopted CECL, we booked a $202 million bump to the allowance for loan losses on the opening consolidated balance sheet for the first quarter, along with a $153 million after-tax adjustment to retained earnings. As we've said before, the biggest piece of CECL is that it makes us reserve for expected lifetime net losses, while in the past we only reserved for the next 12 months. CECL also calls for economic adjustment factors to be built into the lifetime loss projection. To be clear, that initial adoption adjustment went through retained earnings and had no effect on the Q1 provision for losses. After adoption, any shifts in loss expectations get applied across the whole remaining life of the portfolio and flow through the provision, as CECL dictates. The $122 million provision for loan losses in Q1 contains an $84 million increase in our estimate of lifetime losses on receivables on the books at the close of Q4. That's an almost 25% rise in our expectations, mostly driven by the coronavirus turmoil and deteriorating economic factors. The other $38 million mostly reflects our estimate of lifetime losses on loans originated this quarter. So our loss reserve now stands at 3.32% of ending managed receivables, which total $13.4 billion. Remember, that figure includes CAF's Tier 3 receivables, which make up about 10% of the reserve and 1% of the portfolio. With the underwriting changes I mentioned earlier, we're presently aiming for new loan originations at the upper end of our historical target range for cumulative net loss, which spans 2% to 2.5%. As we noted last quarter, CAF isn't originating Tier 3 loans right now; we think our work to help customers minimize defaults and maximize the ultimate flexibility of loans is making a difference. Right now, delinquency rates are down year-over-year. That said, the number is somewhat distorted because of payment extensions that have been granted. As you'd expect, payment extensions spiked in April and have fallen significantly in recent weeks as customers have shown both the ability and the willingness to pay. Moving forward, we'll keep managing payment extensions with an eye toward giving our customers appropriate relief while also protecting our portfolio. We've shown we can finance CAF receivables and support the core business, having executed a $1.15 billion ABS transaction in April; and we kept warehouse lines with $3.5 billion of total capacity, of which $1.55 billion was available at the end of May. Lastly, we aim to give our customers an iconic experience throughout the car buying process and their multiyear finance experience. As with our omnichannel investments, we've been putting a large investment into our auto finance customer platforms, which will create more chances for customers to self-serve and give us flexibility to offer a more customized experience; we look forward to rolling out this technology in FY '22. The knowledge we've built up, the tools at our disposal, and the solid relationships we have with lending partners are still key to steering us through these tough and constantly shifting conditions. Let me pause here to express appreciation to everyone on our Atlanta and Richmond teams for how committed and hardworking they've been. With that, I'll hand things back to Bill.
Bill Nash
executiveThank you, Tom and Enrique. Last year's record results across sales, earnings, and market share gains, along with shifting consumer preferences toward omnichannel options, confirm that our strategy is the correct direction. We think CarMax stands alone in this industry as an omnichannel used car retailer, and customers today, more than at any prior point, are seeking a personalized, seamless, multichannel experience that lets them shop however they choose — online, in a store, or some mix of the two. Across the last several years, our digital initiatives, technologies, and associates have received over $300 million in investment. The aim of these investments is updating our systems, broadening our digital offerings, and restructuring our organization so we can innovate rapidly while leveraging the natural benefits that come with being a bigger company. I take great pride in the way these investments have enabled us to adjust swiftly to a consumer and operating environment that never stops evolving. I'm also enthusiastic about what we've positioned ourselves to pursue going forward. Our near-term strategic investments will prioritize the customer experience, vehicle acquisition, and our wholesale business. Beyond that, over the long term we'll keep evaluating chances to become leaner, more agile, and more cost-effective as an organization, which in turn provides funding for fresh approaches to evolve and grow. The exceptional customer experience CarMax is already recognized for takes its next step forward through our omnichannel offerings. Delivering a genuinely distinctive retail experience by tailoring each customer's journey across multiple channels sets us apart in a meaningful way. Now that omnichannel has rolled out almost everywhere, we're shifting attention to refining and advancing that experience. As one illustration, we started testing a post-sale home delivery process last year, in which a customer can complete a car purchase entirely online ahead of delivery to their home. Although the majority of customers would rather see and drive vehicles prior to buying, certain ones wish to buy without doing those things; our aim is to scale this capability quickly across the country by the end of this year, wherever the law permits, for any customer who prefers to shop that way. Our centralized CECs represent another experience area deserving continued attention. We recognize they'll deliver substantial long-term benefits, but in the near term they'll operate with certain inefficiencies while ramping up. There are opportunities to boost effectiveness via better associate training and role specialization; we likewise see chances to capture efficiencies using automation, data-driven algorithms, and smart routing so the right customer reaches the right associate at the right moment. On vehicle acquisition, we rank as the biggest buyer of used vehicles, giving us distinctive pathways to source cars efficiently; in the near term, our investments will center on strengthening our core buying channels and launching new buying channels. We'll keep putting money into modernizing our wholesale auction platforms as well, which will let us run every auction at the same time, both online and in person. To wrap up, we're examining numerous opportunities to operate with less waste, move faster, and achieve better long-term economics. Among these are gains in how our stores run and how we recondition vehicles, plus reshaping our workplaces for what lies ahead — which sets us further apart as a top-tier employer in America. Shifting consumer preferences are increasingly rewarding businesses that serve customers across channels, and in our view nobody in the pre-owned vehicle space matches what we offer; through a tailored, multi-touchpoint approach, buyers get to purchase on their own terms, and throughout that journey we act to protect them. What we've built pairs a top-tier physical store setting with a top-tier digital one, joining the 2 together without friction. No rival in pre-owned auto sales can match our ability to provide this legendary customer experience, thanks to our skilled team members, our real estate, our digital platform, our operational backbone and our nationwide brands. We look forward to what's ahead as we keep drawing on everything we've built while pushing forward with fresh ideas. With that, we'd be happy — we'd be glad to take your questions.
Scot Ciccarelli
analystI hope everybody's doing well and staying healthy. I've got a question about your performance. We clearly saw a really solid sequential gain from roughly late March into early April. But the reality is you're still reporting negative comps — around 10%, or slightly below that — while I believe we've watched both e-commerce rivals and franchise rivals move into positive comps for their used business. So I suppose I'm asking whether there are structural reasons CarMax would lag others by that much, particularly considering your outperformance — roughly speaking — in Q4?
Bill Nash
executiveYes. Scot, first off, I'd say comparisons are somewhat tough to make right now. You need to consider the growth rates coming into this. You need to consider the growth rates they're sitting at now. I think geographic distinctions matter too. I'd also say you should factor in how differently the mandates were handled, because I can tell you that although we comply with mandates in each and every market, we're aware that others weren't complying with mandates. But the largest factor, the structural one I believe is worth reminding everybody about — and I mentioned this during my opening remarks regarding limited operations and occupancy restrictions — is this. Remember, we average selling over 300 cars per month. Some of our locations sell upwards of 1,000 cars per month; and once you bring up limited operations or occupancy restrictions, let me make it concrete. In a number of markets we had occupancy restrictions where the only allowance was 10 customers inside your store at once. That means 10 customers total; it makes no difference whether they're there for appraisals, for purchasing, or for retail, the cap is 10. So that by itself, the occupancy restriction plus the limited operations, likely did more damage to us simply due to sheer volume. Because once more, if you're a dealership moving 60 to 100 cars, capping it at 10 customers at once doesn't hit them the way it hits somebody like us.
Scot Ciccarelli
analystSo considering that, can you give us any sense of how much these occupancy limits have affected your business over the past couple of weeks?
Bill Nash
executiveYeah, it's tough to nail down exact details. During my opening comments, at the peak, half of them had either been shut down or had reduced operations. At that moment, most of them were closed. So roughly 70 stores were shut, 35 had limited operations, and then the remaining 100-plus faced occupancy restrictions. As time went on, we observed a shift from closures to limited operations and eventually from limited operations to occupancy restrictions; the good news now is that although we still have half of our stores with occupancy requirements, those are beginning to loosen; so rather than only 10 customers or 20% occupancy or 30% occupancy, you're seeing a move more toward 50% occupancy, which makes a significant difference. We still have 4 stores operating under limited operations at this time, but we're hoping to bring them back to full operations based on the mandates soon. Also remember, with the virus rising in certain markets, at any moment, we might need to shut a store here or there due to a positive test result in that store. And our standard procedure is to close, perform a thorough deep clean, and then reopen. So looking back at Q1, it was probably — around 73% of the days we operated with limited operations, about 70% — slightly over 70% of the days we operated with closed — fully closed operations. And combining those, roughly 62-ish percent of the days in the quarter had both situations occurring, closed and limited operations.
Seth Sigman
analystI'd like to build on what was just mentioned. Bill, you talked about certain locations getting back into positive territory during the past few weeks. If the overall quarter-to-date figure is down 10%, that suggests there's still quite a substantial disparity among the store base. So I just want to check — is it entirely about occupancy limits? Or do other regional factors play a role? And are there any additional patterns you could describe across the store base. Also, if possible, any way to give us a sense of how positive things are, or how many stores are positive compared to those that aren't, that would be useful.
Bill Nash
executiveYes, Seth. Looking at it by region over the quarter, clearly, certain markets faced far tighter rules for a much longer stretch. A few of the West Coast stores come to mind. Right now, I'd say the occupancy restrictions along with limited operations are the main reason behind the gap between — remember, there are many different mandates at the local level. The stricter those mandates get, the greater the effect on our business. So that's really what's causing, in my view, the varying performance, plus a number of these markets have now been open for 3, 4 weeks, while other markets are only beginning to reopen; so I think that's been — that's the main reason behind the disparities. Still, we're happy both that occupancy restrictions are beginning to loosen, and we're happy that a bunch of our stores are already comping well above last year's sales.
Seth Sigman
analystAll right. Is there a way to put a figure on what you'd call significant — how much growth during the past 12 months?
Bill Nash
executiveAt this stage, it isn't exactly most of the locations, though a large number of our stores are posting positive comps.
Sharon Zackfia
analystI'd love to hear more about a few of those changes in how shoppers are behaving that you mentioned, with additional figures attached. Clearly, you've been expanding your omnichannel efforts, and curbside pickup was introduced quite rapidly earlier in the quarter. So what sort of opt-in rate did you see for delivery or for curbside pickup? It would be helpful, I think, to also get some sense of how that is trending as markets reopen.
Bill Nash
executiveYes. Sure, Sharon. Well, to start, when I consider our omnichannel experience, I don't really gauge it by way of alternative delivery, though I will address that to respond to your question. My view of the omnichannel experience centers on how many customers interact with us online through our CECs. Before the virus arrived, around 50% of our sales came via engagement with our CECs. Jump ahead to today, and that figure sits above 60%. I believe that reflects customers' desire to handle more activities online. Turning to alternative delivery, which for us means home delivery plus curbside, at the peak, when most stores were shut and operating under limited operations in the markets where those services exist, together you're looking at close to roughly 15% penetration. What's interesting, though, is that with markets beginning to open, we continue to see substantial online engagement, with people doing things in advance, yet customers still choose to visit the store. So that figure has now come down to somewhere between those 2, at about 10%, just a touch below 10%.
Sharon Zackfia
analystAnd one more thing I'd like to ask about, if that's alright. Regarding the GPU pressure that showed up during this quarter — clearly, your inventory management was excellent. Do you anticipate any further GPU pressure as we head into Q2? Or is it your sense that you've already dealt with it and now hold lower-cost inventory?
Bill Nash
executiveYeah. No, I'd say our situation is very strong. And I — as I mentioned earlier when I spoke, the team performed extraordinarily well. To give you some context, looking back at '08 and '09, during The Great Recession, across the most severe depreciation cycle, meaning roughly a year, we experienced $3,500 in depreciation; this time around, in only about a 5-week span, depreciation came to roughly $2,500; the scale of depreciation we just witnessed is unlike anything before. Our inventory was resized remarkably well by the team, and we absolutely avoided any kind of firesale approach, not even close. That said, we applied targeted markdowns to specific inventory items to bring things to the appropriate level. So my confidence in where we stand is very high. My confidence in our future margins is very high. And provided the economy — there's clearly a great deal of uncertainty surrounding the economy at present, but provided this cycle keeps going, I believe the GPU headwinds are behind us.
Seth Basham
analystMy first question concerns limits on sales that haven't come up yet in the Q&A. The first involves inventory, and the second involves CAF underwriting. Do you have any sense of how to quantify how much those two things restrained your sales in recent weeks?
Bill Nash
executiveYes. Let me address the inventory piece. Obviously, once the virus arrived, our instant priority during — once the virus arrived, our instant crisis priority really concerned, okay, the health and safety along with the financial well-being of our associates, the health and safety of our customers, and beyond that the financial security of the organization. Part of that financial security involved rightsizing the inventory; and we always ensure we hold inventory that suits sales; so this situation was no exception. Once we observed demand decline, we definitely shifted into the mode of, okay, let's get our inventory rightsized; now the wonderful news is sales have rebounded beyond what we anticipated over a shorter time frame; and we've got our production facilities all back up and operational, yet it's somewhat of a headwind at present if you examine the sales demand and our inventory sits lighter than where we want it, but honestly I'd prefer to be on this side of the equation rather than the other side of the equation. So once more, I believe the team did a wonderful job. And we'll work across the coming weeks to get the inventory rightsized. We've already begun to fill back up our pipeline. Our salable inventory is less down — I mean it's more down year-over-year than our total inventory. So at this point it's just a matter of getting it produced, which our teams do a phenomenal job on. And then I'll let Tom talk a little bit about CAF.
Tom Reedy
executiveYeah, Seth, since there are so many moving parts, I really hesitate to try pulling out exact figures about what's driving sales. But what we observed in the quarter wasn't only a change in the mix of overall customer credit — there was also a change in the mix inside Tier 1. What that means is a bigger share — when you consider how CAF does approvals, we have segments that we purchase, and a larger portion of the Tier 1 mix sat in the lowest — the higher loss segments. So to protect our portfolio and our financeability, as we aim going forward, we did what I'd describe as fine-tuning by carving out, at least for now, a few of those segments with the highest losses; and what's the result of that? Those loans get moved down to Tier 2, and those lenders see them before we do. We're aware that, on the whole, conversion faces some pressure once you move to Tier 2, since the offers aren't as attractive as what customers get at CAF. Still, for the most part, our Tier 2 lenders are happy to get those and work with them, because it's the top end of what they normally purchase. So we did see them picking up most of it. I believe there was some pressure, perhaps 1 or 2 points on sales, from the adjustments we made; but as credit mix returns to normal — meaning both the rise in the overall FICO score and the mix inside Tier 1 — that pressure will fade, because a smaller percentage of the portfolio is — lands in those categories and gets pushed down to Tier 2.
Bill Nash
executiveSeth, one more point I want to bring up that you didn't touch on regarding the headwind: I'd say the CECs also acted somewhat as a headwind during this quarter, and that's because of the significant surge we witnessed from people participating online. We knew we'd eventually reach that level, but we had no clue it would happen across roughly a 4-week span. So we needed to scale the CECs up quickly, and in the short term, that creates a bit of a headwind. Our service levels weren't where we'd like them to be. That said, we're addressing it at this moment, and things will keep getting better too.
Seth Basham
analystAnd as a quick follow-up, Tom, regarding the provision for loan losses, your present balance sits at 3.3% of loans, which has climbed into territory we observed when The Great Recession was at its worst. And for loans you originated during the quarter, 3.8% is far higher than that, recognizing that the credit mix of what you originated this quarter has shifted somewhat. But how should we think about where that loan loss rate and provision are headed from here?
Tom Reedy
executiveWell, it is — the way things operate, we gather all our best information and then estimate where we believe the portfolio will wind up; so for loans already on the books, that 3.32% reflects our expectation given everything we know as of today. We wouldn't anticipate that changing unless we were to receive new information or new developments were to occur in the economy. When it comes to new originations, as I mentioned, we've made certain adjustments to our origination strategy, and we anticipate that those should move toward the upper portion of our target range of 2% to 2.5%; that's what we're aiming for. And that, I believe, guarantees a financeable portfolio and keeps things moving.
Rajat Gupta
analystI want one thing cleared up regarding an earlier question, then I have another item to ask. About that clarification — those penetration figures of 10% to 15% for omni you mentioned before — does that indicate that right now, 10% to 15% of sales, meaning unit sales, come entirely by way of the alternative delivery channels? Or — I simply want to confirm that I've got that definition right.
Bill Nash
executiveYes; so the 10% to — so when the virus was at its peak, when the largest number of our stores were shut or running with limited operations, what we observed in the markets, the eligible markets offering home delivery and curbside, was a peak — taken together, a peak near 15%. If you measured it as a share of total sales for the entire organization, it came to roughly 10%, and then it settled in — it was slightly above 10%, but at present it has settled back to a little — near 10%, just a bit below 10%.
Rajat Gupta
analystUnderstood. So does that mean roughly 15,000 units in the last quarter went via the alternative channel? Is that about right?
Bill Nash
executiveAbout right, yes. Possibly slightly more.
Rajat Gupta
analystUnderstood. Then regarding expenses, considering everything we're doing through the crisis — the furloughs and the cuts to headcount — is it reasonable to anticipate some lasting decrease in SG&A once sales return to more typical levels? Also, looking back at the '08/'09 downturn, there were notable gains in efficiency around reconditioning. In other words, your retail GPU underwent a structural change. Should we look for a comparable outcome, or perhaps one that's smaller in scale, this time? I just want those 2 points made clear.
Bill Nash
executiveSure. I'll cover reconditioning first, then hand it to Enrique for SG&A. On reconditioning, like I mentioned before, we'll keep searching for opportunities to remove cost. Reconditioning is going to be one of them. If you recall '08, we achieved considerable gains in that area. My view is that we'll see step-by-step gains in reconditioning. So I wouldn't claim you'll witness — back then, it exceeded $250 per unit. There's no single big directive, alright, go do this, and it yields $250. Instead, there will be many incremental items. We're going to introduce our new version of flow across all the stores. That will deliver efficiencies too, and we'll keep pursuing procurement savings, on the reconditioning side and in the stores as well. Now I'll let Enrique address the SG&A.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveAbsolutely. When it comes to SG&A, during the quarter we took forceful steps to bring what we've historically treated as fixed expenses into much closer alignment with reduced demand. That meant things such as staffing reductions via furloughs, cutting back on advertising, fewer contractors, store-level projects, and projects based at the home office — all of those were addressed decisively during the quarter. Yet once sales recover, we do anticipate those costs will rise, as I mentioned before, though we're constantly exploring ways to operate more efficiently. Determining whether systematic opportunities exist is somewhat premature at this point. What I can say is that we'll keep investing in our business too. We have a solid balance sheet and a strong financial position, which enables us to keep investing in our growth as well.
Bill Nash
executiveRight, and there's one more point worth making here. Before the coronavirus came along, our plan was that as we entered this year, we'd keep on investing. Over the last 2 years, we've said we needed comps between 5% and 8% in order to lever. Looking at where we stood as we headed into this year, if omni — the omni experience — had been our sole focus, our leverage would have come out above that. Well, we've decided to pursue certain new strategic initiatives; a few of them we're still pursuing this quarter, while others have been paused. That should give you some color. Had this been a typical year, we'd still have landed in that 5% to 8% range, but at this stage it's simply too difficult to tell. Once sales recover, we'll keep adjusting.
Armintas Sinkevicius
analystCould you put some numbers on how much web traffic has grown, and how much the leads into the customer experience center have grown — the ones you mentioned in the press release?
Bill Nash
executiveSure. The increase I referred to covered the initial 2 weeks of June, and in that period leads and traffic each rose by a double-digit percentage.
Armintas Sinkevicius
analystAlright, so both leads and traffic; and how did that look for the quarter?
Bill Nash
executiveDuring the quarter, web traffic declined by roughly 11%, and leads were pretty close to that figure.
Armintas Sinkevicius
analystOkay. And now a fast one here. When we consider fewer fresh autos reaching the market, with some strain on new car supply, perhaps you could discuss your portfolio's age and whether you're positioned well or poorly to move nearly new cars into a market that might be asking for them?
Bill Nash
executiveYes. Regarding where we get them, we don't sense an issue locating the autos. At present we're in production mode, which is genuinely rebuilding inventory, yet the worry isn't whether we can locate the autos. Sourcing them is something we'll manage. I'll say this: across the quarter, essentially the wholesale market, the external market, froze up since many sales were shut, with a drastically small number of vehicles put up for sale; however, back then we weren't truly out purchasing in any case; so it made no real difference; and things have now reached a stage where, if you examine the volume showing up in the sales and you examine the sales rate appearing in the external sales, they genuinely have recovered. They're extremely close to returning to previrus levels.
Armintas Sinkevicius
analystAll right. That said, is it younger vehicles or older ones that you're moving? Which segment shows the strongest appetite?
Bill Nash
executiveRight. So across the quarter, we did experience somewhat of a mix change — away from autos aged 0 to 2 years, toward those 5-plus; that's the pattern we observed in the period. Another thing we noticed, looking at the average selling price in that quarter, is that it rose slightly, though the main driver there is a mix shift toward big SUV gas categories, which cost more than they did year-over-year. On that, we're ahead by several percentage points, and that's because much of the inventory sold in March and April had been bought during the prior appreciating market stretch.
Brian Nagel
analystBill, during the prior quarter's earnings call—essentially at the very start of the COVID-19 emergency—I raised this with you, and we talked about how demand was shrinking so rapidly back then. Now today you're indicating it's quite heartening that we're witnessing a fairly substantial uptick in sales late in the quarter and continuing into the present quarter. You've clearly become far more sophisticated with analytics, monitoring your shoppers. As all of us attempt to determine what kind of recovery we're heading toward—undoubtedly this applies to CarMax and to retail broadly—how would you describe the demand at this moment? Is it accumulated from the softer sales perhaps a few weeks back? Or are you observing genuine, fundamental demand establishing itself that will probably persist?
Bill Nash
executiveYes. Brian, it's difficult to determine with certainty. I believe there's definitely a degree of accumulated demand since individuals remained at home for multiple weeks; so some portion of that exists, I think. I believe the CARES Act provided certain people with funds; and that, I think, is among the reasons you're noticing a rise in Tier 3. It resembles tax refund proceeds somewhat. Once people possess it, they typically head out. And the largest group we observe fueling this are customers with lower FICO scores. Regarding whether it lasts, that's tough to predict. At present, the environment is so unpredictable. We have elevated unemployment. There are these surges in coronavirus infections. There are social difficulties occurring. So I believe we're positioned well, and having made it through this, I think we're nimbler and more resilient than previously. Thus I think we're ready for whatever direction things take, yet I think it's premature to declare, hey, this will be—where this heads and whether this continues? I think much will hinge on numerous macro factors, but what I can say is that we'll be prepared to shift in whatever direction necessary.
Brian Nagel
analystThat's quite useful. My next question — and it probably echoes a few of the earlier ones — concerns inventory. I realize many things are in flux at the moment. Still, when we consider that spread, so to speak, between pricing on new vehicles and used ones, based on what you're currently observing, how does that look like it will develop going forward? What I mean is, are there — do you see, for whatever reason, since the dynamics are shifting or have shifted, in fact improved chances to acquire inventory that could essentially assist in supporting sales later on?
Bill Nash
executiveYes. During the quarter, the widening or narrowing of that gap was really something of a nonstory. And looking ahead, I think you have to weigh a lot of factors. What will happen with new cars, the vehicles they build and how much output they can genuinely achieve. They're having a hard time reopening and getting new cars delivered; so I believe that will be one element that factors in. I think there's likely a substantial amount of wholesale inventory that has to be moved out via the sales that got somewhat delayed. So my expectation would be that more wholesale inventory gets made available. So I think it simply hinges on things; it hinges on the new car and how that keeps developing, plus when the timing of some of this wholesale inventory actually begins to emerge. I mentioned the depreciation during the quarter. But what is remarkably — which is as remarkable as the decline was — how fast it has recovered; and so I think the wholesale market is fairly self-regulating; and eventually, should it climb too high, it will simply decelerate sales and it fixes itself. But I think supply will be — we'll be okay when it comes to supply. But regarding the gap between new and cars, it's genuinely going to hinge on, I think, production from the manufacturers.
Craig Kennison
analystI'd like to inquire about the wholesale segment. The shift toward conducting every wholesale auction online occurred extremely quickly — that reflects outstanding execution by that group. Could you help me grasp how the economics work under a digital-only approach compared with what you've traditionally done? Are you seeing any variation in something like proceeds for each unit, or in what you regard as your cost for each unit? Also, do you view this shift as something that will stick?
Bill Nash
executiveYes. I appreciate that question, Craig. And you're correct. It was awesome. The team performed incredibly well; we have discussed previously how we'd been trying out certain simulcast technology. And essentially across roughly a 2-week span, every sale was moved onto the virtual platform — that's genuinely remarkable. And the team performed incredibly well. When it comes to the economics, it's a bit too soon to discuss that. What I can say, though, is that throughout that stretch, we saw no drop-off in dealer participation. So our dealer-to-car ratio was already quite high to begin with. And clearly, the greater the number of dealers present, the higher the price your vehicles will command. So I believe that our physical footprint plus having online auctions, while also supplementing it — pardon me, having the physical footprint and running these auctions, then also supplementing it through the online side is excellent, because I believe it will keep expanding the sales to yet more dealers; and with more dealers, in theory, you ought to be able to extract greater value from your cars; and if you can extract greater value from your cars, then you — from our standpoint, you want to pass along as much as possible to the consumer, so we can acquire as many units as we can. So I think it's a bit soon, but my expectation is that the — having the online option will extend it to additional dealers.
Michael Montani
analystTo kick things off, I'd like to focus on the advertising side. Bill, I'm wondering if you might share some perspective on where ad spend per vehicle is headed for the full year and also for next quarter, especially given that sales are coming back? Then I have a second question about multichannel.
Bill Nash
executiveSure. Absent the virus, as we discussed previously, during the prior year we increased things somewhat on a per-unit basis with regard to advertising. This year, our plan was — and this is how we view it, on a per-unit basis — to spend somewhat more. A big portion of that, in fact, related to rolling out omnichannel. Of course, we reduced every element of advertising throughout the quarter, but we've been building it back up since then. So my expectation is that over the remainder of the year, we'll move closer to parity. If business keeps performing the way it is now, I'd anticipate getting closer to parity with what our expectations would have been without the virus.
Michael Montani
analystAll right, that's great. And turning to the multichannel side of things. In the release, you said a large portion of that rollout was now more or less finished; so I wanted to dig into that to get a clearer picture, such as how many stores right now offer ship-to-home or home-delivery capabilities? And second, when it comes to the CECs, when do you think those would begin producing net favorability and efficiency gains as they build scale?
Bill Nash
executiveAll right; regarding the omnichannel experience, when the quarter closed, we had it, let's say, available — the omnichannel experience was available in roughly 65% of the markets. Right now we're at 70-ish percent, mid-70-ish percent. Rolling out the omnichannel will be finished next quarter. Now when it comes to home delivery, once everything is said — once we've rolled out omnichannel everywhere, home delivery at that moment will likely only be available to roughly 85% of the markets right away, simply because a few small one-off markets and certain logistics remain that we'll need to work through. On the CEC efficiencies, as we entered this year, we didn't anticipate the CEC efficiency — we didn't anticipate the CECs becoming truly efficient, since we knew the omni ramp would continue, and while ramping up, we knew they would be inefficient; so my expectation is that the efficiencies really — truly take hold in next fiscal year; but I'll tell you, I'm quite pleased with some of the progress already achieved on the conversion. When you compare the conversion of the CECs against the conversion of our old process, we keep seeing improvements there. So we're excited about it. We believe it's going to deliver a lot of great benefits going forward.
Bill Nash
executiveAlright, thanks, Carol. Sure. So here's what I'd say — honestly, we've never faced an environment shifting this quickly across every part of our business, whether that's retail, wholesale, or CAF. During my opening comments, I went through the various accomplishments; and I'd tell you, it's truly — it's thanks to how strong our culture is, our distinctive business model, and our financial structure that have genuinely allowed us to steer through all of this; we feel quite good about the investments we're making and where we're headed. And we think our omnichannel experience is fundamentally unlike that of any other used car retailer, since it's built as a world-class in-store offering, a world-class online offering, but just as importantly, it's a world-class blend of the two. I appreciate all of you for the questions today. Thank you for your support. And as I always do, I must thank our associates for their continued dedication to living our values each and every day. You are the success of CarMax. So thank you for what you do, and we will talk again next quarter.
Operator
operatorEveryone, we have reached the end of today's conference call. Thanks for joining in. You can now hang up.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete CarMax, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to CarMax, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in CarMax, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.