CarMax, Inc. (KMX) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
September 24, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Stacy Frole
executiveThanks so much. Morning, everyone, and I appreciate your presence on this call covering our second quarter results for fiscal 2021. Accompanying me are Bill Nash, who serves as President and Chief Executive Officer, Tom Reedy, Executive Vice President of Finance, Enrique Mayor-Mora, Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, and Jon Daniels, Senior Vice President of CAF Operations. A quick note before we proceed: anything we say about future business plans, prospects, or financial performance constitutes forward-looking statements made under the Safe Harbor provisions of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Such statements rest on management's present knowledge and assumptions regarding future events, and they carry risks and uncertainties that might lead actual results to differ materially from what we expect. When we offer projections or other forward-looking statements, the company disclaims any intention or duty to update them. To learn more about key factors that might influence these expectations, please consult the company's Form 8-K released this morning along with its annual report on Form 10-K covering the fiscal year that ended February 29th, 2020, as filed with the SEC. If any follow-up questions arise after this call, don't hesitate to reach our investor relations department at 804 to 747 to 0422, extension 7865. I'd also like to express thanks ahead of time for limiting yourselves to a single question and then rejoining the queue for additional follow-ups. Finally, I want to pause and personally thank Celeste Gunter, who is retiring from CarMax. For almost 20 years, Celeste has been an integral part of our IR program, and I'm certain everyone would agree she will be deeply missed. Celeste, we wish you all the joy and happiness retirement can bring. Bill?
Bill Nash
executiveAlright, thank you, Stacy, and good morning to all of you for being here. You saw in this morning's earnings release that we posted a record quarter: sales rose 3.3% to $5.37 billion, net earnings climbed 27% to $297 million, and EPS grew 27.9% to $1.79. Results like these came from strength everywhere in our business — retail, wholesale, and CAF. Being the country's biggest and most profitable used car retailer is something we take pride in. I'm equally proud that during this quarter we wrapped up the rollout of our omni-channel offerings; that effort took years to complete and demanded extraordinary focus and transformation throughout our whole organization. Along the way, we've reworked practically every part of our business, from the ways we assist and engage with customers, to the ways we organize our staffing, to the ways we acquire, market, and hand over cars. Our omnichannel experience exists to deliver a personalized, multi-channel experience that lets customers purchase a car on their own terms. It's built as a world-class in-store experience, a world-class online experience, and a seamless blend of both, which hands us the biggest addressable market in the used car industry. No rival used car retailer can deliver this iconic customer experience the way we do. Now to our results: in the second quarter, total used units sold rose 3.9%, and used unit comps grew 1.2%; June brought a high single-digit negative used unit comp, yet positive comps in July and August more than made up for it. A range of factors drove the sales improvement, among them solid execution in operations, finance, and marketing, along with a strengthening used car sales environment. Web traffic grew solidly during the quarter, averaging roughly 29 million visits a month to carmax.com. In the second quarter, saleable inventory sat below our target level because demand surged rapidly from the first quarter; over the past three months, our teams have done a phenomenal job buying and producing vehicles at record levels, lifting saleable inventory by over 50% in the quarter. Today I'm glad to share that we've successfully ramped inventory to targeted levels, giving customers more than 55,000 vehicles nationwide, the most of any used car retailer; we provide a broad selection of inventory, centered on 0 to 10-year-old vehicles. This quarter, 5 to 10-year-old vehicles rose to 27% of our sales mix, versus 22% last year, which reflects customer demand for older and less expensive vehicles. Gross profit per used unit came to $2,214 for the quarter, an increase of $31 per unit from a year ago. On wholesale, strong market appreciation and excellent execution by our teams provided support. Volume rose 5.1%, helped by one more auction date in the quarter and a record buy rate. We likewise posted a record for gross profit on each wholesale unit during the quarter, at $1,086, which came from significant appreciation along with strong operational execution. As the quarter came to a close, we observed depreciation coming back into the marketplace. Just to remind everyone, every auction kept operating virtually for the entire quarter. Our results make clear that we've brought about a considerable recovery in the business. Throughout the last several months, our skilled employees have shown remarkable agility and the capacity to push through change in one of the hardest environments we have ever encountered. We're pleased to report that by the end of July, our team had come back together, and no associates remained on furlough. Right now we're hiring actively nationwide as we keep expanding our core business, improving our omnichannel offerings, and chasing new opportunities. With that, I'd like to hand the call to Enrique so he can share more about our second quarter financial performance, and to Tom, who will give further detail regarding customer financing. Enrique?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveThanks, Bill, and good morning, everyone. Our other gross profit increased by $6.8 million this quarter, a gain of 5.8%. EPP earnings climbed $6.1 million, up 5.4%, largely because we sold more used units. This quarter, we recorded $8.2 million in revenue from extended service plan profit sharing, compared with $6.5 million during the same period last year. ESP penetration in the second quarter remained above 60%, close to where it stood in the prior-year quarter. Service profits grew $4.5 million, or 31%, driven primarily by stronger sales growth and the employee retention tax credit under the CARES Act. Higher earnings from EPP and service operations were partially canceled out by a $5 million increase in net third-party finance fees, which stemmed from a change in how our sales mix breaks down by finance channel. Turning to SG&A, costs were up 2%, about $9 million, reaching $490 million. For each used unit, SG&A worked out to $22.56, representing $44 per unit of year-over-year leverage during the quarter. If you set aside stock-based compensation, SG&A leverage reached $97 a unit. Several factors drove SG&A costs during Q2. We opened 14 new locations compared with the same period a year earlier, which lifted our total store count by 7%. Share-based compensation climbed $12 million, equal to $53 per unit. Advertising spending was up 7.7%. We also continued investing in technology improvements and in the initiatives supporting our core and omni-channel strategies. Our ability to gain leverage on SG&A benefited from the swift actions taken at the outset of the pandemic to keep expenses under control amid challenging conditions. We placed associates on furlough, stopped hiring for a stretch, adjusted the size of particular functions, brought other overhead expenses in line with the business, and put store expansion on hold, which reduced pre-opening costs during the quarter. During the quarter, we additionally benefited on a year-over-year basis from reduced expenses tied to self-insured losses and litigation. Our commitment to spending efficiently stands, and we anticipate that focused efforts in select areas will continue producing gains as time goes on. Among those areas are boosting the efficiency of our Customer Experience Centers, or CECs, along with strategic sourcing and inventory production. Meanwhile, our confidence in what lies ahead is strong, thanks to the distinctive offering we provide to customers. We see a chance to build on where we stand today and expand our market share. Because of that, we are still in an investment phase as we keep advancing our omni experience when it comes to vehicle and customer acquisition. Additionally, during the latter six months of this year, we intend to raise our marketing expenditure compared to the same period a year earlier, a topic Bill will cover soon. Regarding how we allocate capital, our priority continues to be expanding the business, though we are proceeding carefully given the ongoing unpredictability in the broader economy. There are two important developments to share. To start, we can now move forward with adding locations and have set a target of 8 to 10 new stores for FY 2022. Also, following the end of the quarter, we paid off the full outstanding balance on our revolver. With the improvement our business has seen, the strength in credit markets, and a healthy balance sheet, we feel sure our liquidity is suitable and that we can reach capital. Last, when cash is netted out, we finished the quarter slightly under our long-standing leverage goal of 35%-45% adjusted debt to capital. I'll hand the call to Tom now.
Tom Reedy
executiveThank you, Enrique, and good morning to everyone. Much like what we saw in retail and wholesale, CarMax Auto Finance along with our partner lenders came through with robust conversion across every credit tier, and CAF income grew solidly, separate from the benefit of better-than-expected loss results. As we've noted before, early in the pandemic CAF put some short-term changes into its underwriting approach, aiming to keep the portfolio concentrated in financeable tier 1. We're still careful about how we see things going forward, but the patterns so far have been encouraging. Payment extensions have fallen sharply, delinquencies are moving in a good direction, and our July ABS deal got a strong reception. So during the back half of the quarter, we started originating our usual range of tier 1 business. CAF likewise pulled back on its in-house tier 3 lending when the pandemic began and wrote no loans through that channel during the second quarter. Given the trends I just described, we've returned to the tier 3 space over the last few weeks. I'll now move to how we performed during the quarter. After subtracting three-day payoffs, they came in much lower than the prior year. CAF's penetration reached 42.6%, versus 42.2% a year earlier. Tier 2 made up 22.3% of used unit sales, compared with 19.7% last year. Tier 3 rose to 11.1%, up from 9.6% a year ago. Compared with a year ago, CAF's net loans originated rose 1%, reaching $1.8 billion, as gains in used cars sold and penetration rate were partly offset by a smaller average amount financed. For loans written during the quarter, the weighted average contract rate charged to customers came to 8.2%, lower than 8.6% a year ago and 8.4% in the first quarter. That lower rate shows our emphasis on a higher quality portfolio through much of the quarter. Portfolio interest margin, as a percent of average managed receivables, rose to 6%, against 5.7% in Q2 last year. Along with our receivables growth, that pushed total interest margin up 7.4%, with no help from any favorability in the provision for loan losses. Total CAF income for the quarter rose 29%, hitting $147.2 million. This gain mainly came from a smaller loan loss provision, together with higher interest margin and average managed receivables. The provision for loan losses was $26 million in Q2, leaving an ending reserve balance of $433 million. That works out to 3.2% of average managed receivables, somewhat below where it stood at the close of Q1. Although our loss experience across June, July, and August was considerably better than what we had expected at the end of Q1, the loss reserve still reflects how unpredictable the current environment is and how deeply uncertain the consumer situation remains. What we saw in Q2 shows why it matters to have a varied set of lenders who can consistently provide high-quality finance offers to our wide range of customers, no matter the economic conditions. Beyond that, a captive finance operation that works fully, like CAF, brings many things to the business model that are hard to copy; at this point I'll hand the call back to Bill.
Bill Nash
executiveAlright. Thanks, Tom and Enrique. Like I said before, our omni-channel offering has now been fully rolled out. Combining our online and in-person experiences in such a strong way gives us the biggest addressable market in the used car industry. Beyond being able to purchase online, customers also want guidance through the experience; with our centralized CECs, seasoned floor sales consultants, and personalized e-commerce capabilities, we are uniquely able to deliver that help at any time and in any place the customer chooses. A used car purchase remains a highly considered, complex decision. Nobody wants to be pushed into interacting 100% in store or 100% online. Our differentiator is that customers get to decide how much of their banking they do digitally versus face-to-face, and the experience stays smooth either way. We've brought Omni to the entire country at this point, yet it's still in the early stages of developing, and we'll continue rolling out improvements so we can satisfy and go beyond what our customers need today and will need down the road. The CECs represent one thing we're concentrating on. This capability hasn't been around that long for us and is still developing, but even so, they're rapidly outperforming the model we used before. To illustrate how we sharpen performance, we take advantage of our data edge along with machine learning so that the correct task gets to the correct associate at the correct moment. We take the interactions our customers have online, merge those with what's held in their data mart, and deliver a genuinely personalized experience — one that does a far better job of serving customer needs and lifting our conversion rates. Our view is that no one else has the same opportunity we do to build a better customer experience, drawing on the advantages our data and technology give us both on the web and inside our stores. Continuous improvement also applies to digital merchandising. Roughly 95% of our photo studios will have been rolled out by the time this year ends, and those studios deliver a more immersive experience featuring high-quality photos, 360-degree interior and exterior views, feature scoring, hotspots, and reconditioning with new part callouts. Additionally, we keep enhancing the material available on our site so that shoppers can do thorough vehicle research entirely within carmax.com. Thanks to these efforts, people feel more assured as they move forward through the digital experience. Another omni priority I want to mention involves our customer hub, where buyers are able to monitor what they've accomplished across both digital and physical channels. Within this space, they can handle various pieces of their purchasing process: saving or bookmarking specific vehicles they find online, turning in a pre-approval request for financing and weighing different financing choices against one another, plus obtaining either a projected value or a firm bid on the car they want to trade in. To wrap up, once a customer has picked out a vehicle either on the web or at one of our locations, they're able to finish the buying steps right in the hub. At that point, they decide between having the car brought to their home or picking it up at the curb. The response to our omnichannel approach has been positive. This quarter, roughly 70% of shoppers used our CEC in some way. On top of that, about half — 50%, give or take — chose to handle their purchase remotely, which is up from approximately 42% in the pre-COVID period. Even so, a sizable portion of that group ultimately came to a store to close things out, and around 30% of buyers opted for nothing but the in-store route. As always, the strength of our model comes down to letting the customer determine which journey they take. That is precisely what hands us the biggest addressable market. Our attention is on pushing customer engagement approaches so we stay top of mind and remain the number one pick for people buying and selling cars. A nationwide marketing push went live last year, and it has strengthened our brand while creating a dependable foundation for campaigns to come. Our omnichannel option is now available across the country. So looking ahead, our messaging will aim at sharply setting our brand apart from digital-only names and traditional dealer names by showing what our omnichannel model delivers. During the back half of the year, we will spend more on marketing than we did a year earlier, growing our teams and putting money into things like SEO, SEM, messaging, content, and social. What we want is to bring high ROI customers onto our digital properties and give ourselves the ability to build multi-channel personalized campaigns. We offer a distinctive retail customer experience, and we keep refining it so we surpass what our customers expect. Simultaneously, we are finding and funding new initiatives that we think will likewise add solidly to growth in our earnings. Everything here points to a genuinely thrilling future, yet none of it could happen without our outstanding associates. I'd like to acknowledge every one of them and the high-performance culture they sustain at CarMax — a culture that respects all individuals and perspectives. Across the last several years, we've undertaken the biggest transformation in our company's history, changing almost every part of our business. And we pulled off all these strong results in one of the hardest environments we have ever encountered. Throughout it, our associates kept living our values daily by putting people first and looking after one another. What we have achieved makes me extremely proud, and the opportunities in front of us excite me. Right now, we'd be glad to take your questions.
John Murphy
analystMorning, everyone, and fantastic work given these conditions. That's genuinely impressive. Bill, one line in the release caught my attention. You mention that inventory acted as a drag on sales during the quarter. I'd love to hear you unpack that a bit — do you expect relief soon? Sounds like by September it had eased somewhat. And as these omnichannel initiatives start paying off and draw shoppers in, how are you thinking about the shift in how you handle inventory as your addressable market expands so much — do you have to stock more, or approach inventory differently than in the past?
Bill Nash
executiveYes. Thanks, John. Well, to start, omni or not omni, the way we handle our inventory won't change. I'd say it's among this company's strengths that we've refined across the past 27 years, and we keep at it. I can't praise the team enough. Raising our inventory 50% within the quarter is truly extraordinary. In any ordinary setting, dealing with that level of inventory shortage would be a major drag on sales; that said, we're nowhere near an ordinary setting, and pinning down precisely how much it hurt our sales is tough, beyond the fact that it definitely did hurt sales; during COVID, plenty of other competitors were short on inventory. There was stimulus money in the mix, so figuring out what offset that drag is difficult. Again, I'll simply repeat that the team has done an outstanding job, both purchasing and manufacturing, to get us where we stand now. We remained short on inventory at quarter's end, yet as of today, we feel quite good about our overall inventory position.
John Murphy
analystAll right. My apologies — just a quick additional question. Looking ahead, when omnichannel keeps growing, do you figure you'll have to raise your inventory levels to match, or would you simply be cycling through stock far more efficiently? I'm only attempting to get a sense of whether inventory might climb 10%, 20%, 30%, 40%, 50% once these initiatives genuinely gain traction, and whether anything else would have to enter the picture, or whether you'd just be far more efficient with inventory.
Bill Nash
executiveYes, we chose the omni route since we anticipate a superior experience for customers, and we anticipate moving more vehicles. If we move more vehicles, that will likewise show up in what we hold. Our inventory will be larger. I believe that's how we've run this business across the last 27 years, and I don't see that changing. When sales grow, our inventory will grow too.
John Murphy
analystGreat. Thank you very much.
Bill Nash
executiveSure. Thank you.
Sharon Zackfia
analystHi, good morning.
Bill Nash
executiveGood morning, Sharon.
Sharon Zackfia
analystMorning. My question concerns how much customers know about omnichannel. It's good to hear that you'll be ramping up marketing on that front, and that it can be done during this fiscal year. Are there any metrics showing what broader customer awareness looks like nationally compared with, say, Atlanta, where you first launched? A related question concerns the tail. Since this is a lengthy purchase cycle, in those initial markets, are you still seeing that omnichannel tail compared with the newer markets where it's been introduced? If that makes sense.
Bill Nash
executiveSharon, regarding broader awareness, I believe now is the moment to truly inform customers that, hey, all the things that made CarMax great remain, but we now offer plenty of new capabilities. Up to this point, we really haven't set that loose, and we've run some marketing campaigns. I can't provide any market-specific awareness figures about omnichannel, but that's one reason we intend to increase advertising going forward. As for how we feel, looking at our older markets, like Atlanta, we feel terrific. We feel terrific about the gains we're seeing in those markets; we also feel terrific about the awareness, since obviously it's existed there a bit longer. I do believe the advertising message going forward will be different. We'll ensure people grasp the distinction between us and traditional dealers and online competitors.
Sharon Zackfia
analystHi Bill, one more question from me. When can we expect the fresh marketing to show up?
Bill Nash
executiveIt'll arrive before this year is over.
Sharon Zackfia
analystYeah. Thank you.
Bill Nash
executiveAbsolutely. Thank you, Sharon.
Craig Kennison
analystHi there, and good morning. I appreciate you fielding my question. Celeste, I'm wishing you the very best. Thank you for everything you've done to help. I'd like to ask about the wholesale segment. Wholesale GPU rose by $174. What portion of that comes from increased pricing as opposed to a reduction in the expense of processing the vehicle? And to what degree has shifting toward digital auctions brought in more bidders from a wider geographic area? Thanks.
Bill Nash
executiveMorning, Craig. The results in wholesale were excellent, and I'd say much of that resulted from appreciation. What's fascinating is that when COVID hit, we witnessed among the fastest depreciation over such a brief window. We likewise witnessed the fastest appreciation. From COVID's lowest point, vehicle values moved by roughly $3,000 to $4,000. Naturally, with values climbing and appreciating, that's definitely a favorable wind at our back. I also don't want to downplay how well our teams executed. Particularly in the early part of the quarter, supply was scarce for a lot of this, since certain traditional auctions simply weren't operating or available. Our team adapted fast and moved all of our sales to virtual. They remain fully virtual today. We're navigating each local mandate individually regarding when we're able to reopen them. Our aim is to have our sales operating in person once more, while also pairing them with simulcast. That's our approach as we launch the new auctions moving ahead. Regarding what digital brings, in my view, digital can only improve the overall experience, since ideally it widens access to additional participants. If you've got more people attending your auctions, ideally that pushes pricing higher, which lets us provide more within our appraisal lane. I believe that's what you observed. We take real pride in it; this quarter we achieved that record buy rate, and the margin isn't small — it's large. Lately, under the traditional approach, we'd been sitting in the low 30s. With what we achieved this quarter, it reached the high 30s. That's a meaningful jump upward.
Craig Kennison
analystThank you.
Bill Nash
executiveThanks, Craig.
Seth Basham
analystThanks a lot, and good morning.
Bill Nash
executiveMorning, Seth.
Seth Basham
analystCould you provide a bit more detail regarding the gross profit per unit on the retail side during the quarter, how it moved, and what you expect going forward on that front?
Bill Nash
executiveSure, I'd say the GPU stayed pretty steady across the entire quarter. We've demonstrated, I believe, that we're capable of handling the GPU in every kind of environment. Looking ahead, I can't think of any reason we wouldn't keep operating within that usual range. As always, I'll add the note that we keep testing and examining pricing elasticity, since our goal is ensuring we generate the greatest possible total gross profit dollars. Going forward, I don't foresee any obstacle to us sustaining those GPUs.
Seth Basham
analystThat helps. To build on that, you brought up certain initiatives related to strategic sourcing. Can you give us additional detail about what you mean by that?
Bill Nash
executiveI'd say the top priority is speeding things up and getting better within the buying channels that are central to us. This applies to both the off-site option and the in-store appraisal lane. How I'd frame it is that it involves not just our processes, but also making smarter use of data and technology. That matters, in my view, since we purchase more used cars than anyone else in the U.S., and each year we appraise over six million vehicles. Making ongoing, step-by-step improvements in that area carries real weight. We're also looking to launch additional buying channels and grow what we can do through certain partnerships and other businesses. One more piece I'd place under the vehicle acquisition heading is that our wholesale operation will keep receiving investment; a new auction platform is in the works. That auction platform has existed since my earliest days at CarMax, and an upgrade is overdue. That's how we're approaching it, across quite a few different fronts.
Seth Basham
analystThank you very much.
Bill Nash
executiveAbsolutely.
Scot Ciccarelli
analystGood morning, guys.
Bill Nash
executiveGood morning, Scot.
Scot Ciccarelli
analystBill, you mentioned feeling really good about how things are going in Atlanta and some of those more established markets. Could you put some numbers behind how much your omni-channel tools are actually being used in places where you've had them running for several quarters now? And on a similar note, is there a way to estimate the total sales boost you believe omni brought in during the quarter?
Bill Nash
executiveYes. Scot, to start with, measuring the true incremental impact of omni is genuinely hard, since you can't simply look at whether someone had something delivered to their house or walked into a store — there are plenty of situations where a customer was already going to buy from us, they begin on the website, then choose home delivery. Others come to us specifically because they want it sent to their house and want to do the whole thing online, yet they wind up in a store anyway. From our standpoint, we're clearly rolling this out because we're confident it's a better way to serve the customer. Ultimately, what matters is sales and market share. Along the way, I'd say the key priority for us is tracking the customer experience, regardless of which channel they prefer. We'll monitor various measurements — CEC engagement, online progression, customers who only shop in-store, customers using alternative delivery — but our real focus will be on how those customers experience things and how they feel about it, and we'll keep pushing that forward. Everything we've observed, in both older and newer markets where we've launched this, is that it's been received very positively. That's true even with some built-in obstacles. I'd point back to the CECs; they're still maturing, and we've got many new people working there. There's also new technology. We anticipated that customers would shift toward this, but we didn't anticipate the speed at which they'd do so. During this quarter, at certain points we had more leads coming into our CECs than we were able to process. That's an obstacle, and I believe there are some areas where we can do better on that customer experience too. Still, we feel terrific about where we stand right now. Even though this marks the completion of the omni rollout, we honestly view it as day one. We're only beginning, and this is essentially our launching point toward what comes next.
Scot Ciccarelli
analystOkay. Very helpful. Thank you.
Bill Nash
executiveAbsolutely.
Brian Nagel
analystHi, good morning.
Bill Nash
executiveMorning, Brian.
Brian Nagel
analystTo begin, Celeste, congrats, and thank you for every bit of assistance across the years. It has been greatly valued. My question, I suppose, Bill, is broader in scope: if I take in what you're saying today — congratulations on the execution in such a difficult climate. You're truly doing well.
Bill Nash
executiveThanks, Brian.
Brian Nagel
analystFrom what I'm hearing both you and your partner say, it sounds like you've nearly gotten through the worst part of the COVID situation, and on top of that, you're starting to really put to work all those omni-channel investments you've made. So here's my question: if the two of you pull back and take a broader view of everything around you, how would you describe demand — consumer demand — right now? And I know you don't provide guidance, but maybe you could talk about the demand dynamics today and looking ahead compared with how things stood before COVID?
Bill Nash
executiveYeah. Brian, as you can imagine, that's not an easy one to answer. Look, there's still plenty of uncertainty out there in the marketplace. Obviously, we've got high unemployment. COVID cases are climbing. It's an election year. That can always add a little wrinkle to things. We've got social challenges that keep going. Having said all that, I think when you look at the back half of the quarter — when you look at how July and August performed and how that trend has carried on month to date into September — we feel good about where we are given all those uncertainties. Yeah, there could be — just given the external environment — there could be some bumpiness from certain macro factors. Again, what we focus on is things. We look beyond the next quarter. I'll tell you, I feel great about where we are right now, and we're going to keep progressing.
Brian Nagel
analystMight I quickly squeeze in a single additional question?
Bill Nash
executiveSure.
Brian Nagel
analystNo worries, Stacy. I believe you might have touched on this already. I realize the two of you generally avoid discussing monthly revenue patterns, but how has business performed so far in fiscal Q3, or September, compared with what you observed during the final couple of months of Q2?
Bill Nash
executiveWell, to begin with, you're correct, Brian — I'm not fond of addressing those patterns, but I do believe given the current climate — and honestly, I'm looking forward to the day when we no longer need to discuss the climate at all, since that would signal things have improved considerably. Given this climate, I think it makes sense. For September so far, the patterns from July and August are carrying through, which is excellent when you consider that headwinds remain. We're very pleased with that.
Brian Nagel
analystI appreciate it. Thank you.
Bill Nash
executiveYep.
Michael Montani
analystHi there, and good morning. I appreciate you fielding this question.
Bill Nash
executiveGood morning.
Michael Montani
analystI wanted to dig a bit deeper into the digital process. I suppose there are three components to my question. First, an update on remote appraisals — could you walk us through what capabilities exist today and what enhancements are coming? Second, Bill, in the past you've said that roughly 1 in 10 multi-channel transactions involved home delivery. I'd like to hear how that figure is moving now. Finally, it sounded like 70% of transactions were multi-channel. My question is how that share looks in the more established markets versus the ones that only recently started gaining these capabilities.
Bill Nash
executiveYeah. Okay, Michael. Starting with remote appraisals, as I mentioned during my opening remarks, when a customer goes through our customer hub to purchase a vehicle and have it brought to their home, we definitely offer them the choice of an estimate or an appraisal. We currently have tests running in certain markets around instant cash offers, and we plan to grow that. You'll hear more about it soon. Regarding that 1 in 10 home delivery figure, the way I've described it previously is really alternative delivery. Alternative delivery combines both curbside pickup and home delivery. During the first quarter, we watched that rise; by the close of the first quarter, we landed near that 10%, slightly below 10%. Once again, I'd tell you we remain under that 10%. Even as most customers move forward online, they still would rather visit the store. Then, on the 70% CECs, once again, that means 70% of our customers are interacting with the CEC. That doesn't mean all of them are completing online progression. That's where the 50% figure I provided comes from. As for how that stacks up against older markets and so on, look, I believe it keeps growing; that 70%, if you recall, I discussed it in the first quarter, and it was north of 60%, so we've actually seen growth there too. Part of that reflects the fact that we completed the rollout, but I'd anticipate that number to keep climbing, just as I'd anticipate the progression of customers to keep climbing going forward as customers seek a more personalized experience.
Rajat Gupta
analystMorning, and thanks for fielding my question. I've got a pair regarding SG&A. You mentioned that marketing costs will rise across the fiscal year's back half — could you help us gauge or put a figure on how much that expense growth might be? And going forward, what's the right way to view the normalized cost per unit? I have one more after that. Thanks.
Bill Nash
executiveYes. That's correct — I did say it would climb in the year's latter half, though my view is you should frame that within total SG&A; as we've noted before, look, leverage requires comps of 5%-8%. Some SG&A efficiencies have been captured by us. Our clear expectation is to plow those right back into the business. Despite that step-up, my concern would be less with advertising cost per car and more with how it fits inside SG&A. Even after the step-up, on a yearly basis we'd still anticipate levering at that 5%-8% of comps. Remember, it can swing wildly from one quarter to another.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveI'd like to build on what was just said. When the pandemic hit, we moved aggressively and decisively to bring down our cost base. As conditions have gotten better, a significant portion of that operational spending has been restored. Certain structural adjustments were made to our staffing and to operations, and those are things we anticipate will generate savings going forward; beyond that, our attention—as has been brought up a few times—remains on efficiency along with our CECs. That said, we're currently in a mode of growth and investment. My view is that the savings we're aiming for will be at least partly redirected toward higher ROI and toward strategic investments that fit with our growth plan. Those savings are going to help finance our growth. As Bill noted, the way to frame it is leverage, combined with that same 5%-8% comp figure we've shared previously.
Bill Nash
executiveRight. What I'd say is that we've got cost reductions pretty much everywhere. That includes not just what we're doing in stores and not just CEC. I'm also thinking about gains we've made in logistics and in wholesale, and all of those, I believe, open up possibilities — whether that means savings in SG&A, putting SG&A money back in, or putting money back into cost of goods sold. This isn't limited to a couple of spots. My view is it spans the whole company.
Rajat Gupta
analystUnderstood. Regarding SG&A, this is more of an administrative detail. That additional overhead expense of $65 million appears to be running significantly under typical levels. Is there any further catch-up expected in that area during the upcoming quarter? I'm simply wondering whether any lasting decreases occurred there, or what framework should we use when considering it moving forward?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveMy view is that approximately 50% of that year-over-year benefit stemmed directly from the expense-reduction initiatives we implemented, along with some limits on spending imposed by current conditions. We lowered spending on contractors, on pre-opening activities, and on relocation. Those represent expense-reduction initiatives. The remaining 50% relates to what I referenced during my prepared remarks: elevated self-insured losses during the prior year and litigation costs from last year compared with this year. So, about half can be seen as expense reduction, while the other half I would characterize as more of a non-recurring item.
Rajat Gupta
analystGot it. Sorry, to close this out, that figure of 5%-8% you mentioned — should we take that as something that keeps rolling ahead? I'm just wondering when it falls to a smaller level, or whether we ought to still anticipate that across the coming 12 to 18 months, or 24 months? I'm just wondering how we should think about that leverage going down further. Thanks.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYeah. My take would be that this is an annualized figure as we go forward. Once more, on a quarter-by-quarter basis, plenty can occur inside a single quarter. I'd look at it that way again, going forward for no less than the upcoming 12 months, which is the way we're looking at the business.
Bill Nash
executiveYes. And another point I want to make is something I mentioned during one of our earlier calls: had omni been our sole focus for this year, the number in that guidance would have come in lower. Achieving that would require less. Clearly, as Enrique noted, we're currently in a mode of investment. Certain areas we're putting money into will generate returns in other segments of the business. Take enhancements in wholesale, for instance — they might not create leverage on a retail cost per car sold, but they will produce gains in wholesale, and those bring top line and bottom line advantages to the company. I believe that's another key thing to keep in mind throughout this entire conversation too.
Rajat Gupta
analystGot it. Thanks a lot, and best of luck.
Bill Nash
executiveThanks.
Rick Nelson
analystThanks. Good morning.
Bill Nash
executiveGood morning.
Rick Nelson
analystA fast one for Tom about CAF. During the prior quarter, you mentioned anticipating a loss rate between 2% and 2.5%. Looking at the provision for this quarter, $26 million, that comes to 1.4% of receivables originated. The charge-off rate sat under historical norms. Wondering what the outlook is as we move ahead?
Tom Reedy
executiveAll right. Yeah. Let me handle a few things. I'll begin by offering a bit more detail on the loss provision, then we can discuss that expected range; we mentioned income received material support from a lower loss provision. At $26 million compared to $45.5 million a year ago, that mirrors roughly $55 million of added reserve for originations during the quarter. $30 million of favorable development stemming from the loss performance we observed in economic adjustment factors. I should note that the economic adjustment factors actually softened the effect of our strong loss performance and where we ended up on the provision. Although we experienced loss performance substantially better than what we had booked at the close of Q1, that justified some release of the reserve, yet as I noted in my prepared remarks, at 3.2%, the overall allowance still captures some uncertainty confronting the economy and consumer behavior; regarding our target range, clearly there's nothing we can do about the portfolio that's already out there. What is is what is. We've observed improving performance. We feel pretty confident about the capital markets and our capacity to finance. Looking at our most recent deal, we enjoyed a pretty significant spread between APR and cost of funds, among the highest in recent memory. Even with a somewhat higher loss environment, that spread lets you still earn a good return on the business. We considered all those factors and we're comfortable for a period of time running a little bit above the 2%-2.5% range. Given how everything's falling out, we believe it's worth the investment to capture the return on that money rather than handing the profit to someone else right now.
Rick Nelson
analystUnderstood, thank you. That's useful. A 6% net interest spread in this quarter — we haven't seen that since 2016.
Tom Reedy
executiveYeah
Rick Nelson
analystDo you have any spread targets going forward?
Tom Reedy
executiveThat's difficult to answer. That 6% expansion during this quarter came about mainly because funding costs declined. Clearly, regarding the rates we offer to customers, what we aim for is to remain a market lender, stay competitive, and avoid upsetting anyone over the offers they receive from CAF. We saw no reason to lower APRs during the quarter. As I consistently say, we'll evaluate that going forward. Should competition let us hold onto those margins, we will hold onto them. Should competition turn aggressive and the market require somewhat less margin in the finance business, we'll respond appropriately. At present, we feel good about our position.
Rick Nelson
analystExcellent, I appreciate the insight, and best of luck.
Tom Reedy
executiveMuch appreciated, Rick.
David Whiston
analystThank you, and good morning. I have a question about used gross margins per unit. Those rose 50 basis points, since your dollar profit stayed fairly level even though ASPs declined. How could ASPs fall while auction prices were higher? Was it simply that you relied more on your own resources during the quarter?
Bill Nash
executiveYes, that's a wonderful question. ASPs did decline. The main reason for that decline comes from the mix shift I mentioned before, in which we sold a greater share of older vehicles. That pushes it lower. Acquisition price stayed roughly flat. My sense is that a substantial amount of inventory purchased by us in the quarter has not yet been sold, and that inventory is somewhat more costly. What drives what you're seeing there, above all, is the shift in the age mix.
David Whiston
analystAll right. So would it be reasonable to say you likely won't treat that as something that persists over the long run, particularly if conditions in the economy improve?
Bill Nash
executiveWhich part do you mean? The change in mix, or simply the average selling price declining?
David Whiston
analystThe mix.
Bill Nash
executiveThe mix. Honestly, the wonderful thing about this business is that whatever our customers ask for, we'll have it available. Should buyers prefer vehicles that are older and cost less, we will ensure those get offered. Customer demand is what dictates all of that.
David Whiston
analystOkay. Thank you.
Bill Nash
executiveThank you, David.
Michael Montani
analystHi, I appreciate you letting me ask a follow-up. I had a couple of items. The first one concerned the credit side. I'm just wondering whether there's any additional detail you folks might be able to offer regarding roll rates, how forbearance government programs have mattered, and deferrals too. Broadly speaking, what's your sentiment regarding CAF? That's my quick follow-up.
Tom Reedy
executiveAbsolutely. Regarding how the quarter looked on quality from CAF's standpoint on losses, our feeling is that it was a genuinely strong quarter. Worth pointing out that a few factors explain why we believe losses came in better during the quarter. To start, you may recall that during Q1 we were actually unfavorable on losses, whereas in Q2 we were favorable; our view is that some swapping occurred between the two. You brought up payment deferrals. Without question, we also managed to give our customers payment relief. Our team performed excellently on that front across the quarter. Earlier in the quarter, payment deferrals ran at a higher level; we mostly went back to standard procedures. We recognize that this delivered some relief to our customers, prevented losses, and contributed to bringing delinquency down. Past that, the federal stimulus during the quarter definitely placed money into our customers' pockets, which enabled them to cover their bills. Honestly, there were simply fewer venues where they could spend that money. Our guess is that likely contributed to the loss figures too — though that's speculation. When it comes to roll rates ahead, it's difficult to predict what will unfold going forward. There's a great deal of uncertainty in the environment. During the quarter, we felt quite good about our ability to look after our customers, and we're pleased with where the numbers currently stand. On the reserve side, clearly, that uncertainty shows up in our reserve. On the whole, a solid quarter where losses are concerned.
Michael Montani
analystThanks; that's useful context; and then the other big thing people have been asking me about both before and while we've been on this call today has to do with market share. I've heard from some folks who are somewhat worried since a few smaller rivals may be expanding more quickly. What we've seen out of Cox indicates that across the summer, the sector shrank by roughly a mid to high single-digit percentage. So I suppose I'm wondering what sort of metrics you'd rely on to measure that yourselves. And how do you expect that to play out over the back half of the year, especially when we consider the multi-channel capability set.
Bill Nash
executiveWell, I believe we touched on this somewhat at the start of, during Q1, how our sales, I think, took a disproportionate hit simply because of the volume we push through our locations and the occupancy limits we had to deal with, the operating models we had to deal with, meaning having locations that could only do appointment only or only curbside pickup; we discuss market share annually. Well, I think the entire purpose of omni clearly is to provide this improved customer experience. Ultimately, it's about growing market share no matter what macro factors exist out there. We'll keep moving ahead. Clearly, this quarter, once more, I can't express how proud I am of the team. You go from a quarter with negative 40+ comps to the very next quarter beginning to comp again alongside record earnings, and you've managed that even though we're still dealing with occupancy limits. Roughly half of our locations still face an occupancy limit, though most of them sit at 50%, and I think the locations have done an amazing job operating within that 50%. Go below that, and it truly becomes difficult. Plus with the CEC and how mature the CEC is and the inventory. Again, I feel good about where we stand, and I think this serves as a springboard for us to keep growing sales and market share.
Michael Montani
analystGot it. Thank you.
Bill Nash
executiveSure.
Chris Bottiglieri
analystHello, and thank you for addressing my question. I'd like to hear additional details regarding the 2022 store opening strategy. My sense is that it's somewhat under the usual pace. My assumption is that conditions are likely responsible, but would you mind reviewing once more what is involved in launching a location? How long does that process typically require? Or, to put it more bluntly, should we view this as the standard rate for new locations past 2022? Is this purely a matter of the product climate? I have another question after this.
Bill Nash
executiveSure, Chris. What I'd say is that you ought to view this primarily as a consequence of how long it takes to build up. Our intention was to launch 13 locations during this year. For multiple years, we've been launching 13 to 16 locations. Opening 13 was what we planned. Considering our position this year and what's needed to begin building up, that figure reflects the scheduling of construction more than any other factor. At this moment, I wouldn't draw any larger conclusion from it.
Chris Bottiglieri
analystAll right, that's useful. Regarding pre-opening, could you remind us of how that functions? Clearly, you're in the process of opening locations at this time, so for the coming several quarters that ought to be an advantage to other overhead. Could you remind us what it is — clearly it hinges on how many locations you open — but what serves as a decent guideline for pre-opening expense for each store? Anything else you could provide for us to consider the effect of zero store openings on our doing that? Thank you.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYes. Those costs will begin coming in substantially a solid three to four months prior to a store opening. On average, I'd say a pre-opening cost will come to roughly $1 million, $1.5 million, though that will be distributed once more across that span.
Chris Bottiglieri
analystUnderstood. All right, that's useful. Thanks a lot.
Bill Nash
executiveThanks, Chris.
Bill Nash
executiveCarol, thank you. Well, look, I appreciate everyone being on the call today, and I appreciate the questions and the support. We have no doubt at all about our capacity to combine smoothly our top-tier face-to-face experience with our top-tier digital experience, together with our varied business model, and that this will keep producing earnings growth and market share gains for many years ahead. I need once more to express my gratitude to each of our associates; they are the reason we continue to be a disruptive presence in the pre-owned vehicle sector. Last, I must recognize Celeste too, and send her my best wishes. She has been with us a long while, and she understands CarMax better than anyone I know. She will certainly be missed, and I wish her nothing but good things. Once more, thanks for spending time with us today, and we will speak again in the next quarter.
Operator
operatorEveryone, that wraps up today's conference call. Thanks again for joining us, and at this point you're free to hang up.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete CarMax, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to CarMax, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in CarMax, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.