CarMax, Inc. (KMX) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

December 22, 2020

New York Stock Exchange US Consumer Discretionary Specialty Retail earnings 55 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Stacy Frole

executive
#1

Thanks, Carole. Morning, everyone. I appreciate you being on the call for our fiscal 2021 third quarter earnings conference. Joining me are Bill Nash, our President and CEO; Tom Reedy, our Executive Vice President of Finance; Enrique Mayor-Mora, our Senior Vice President and CFO; and Jon Daniels, our Senior Vice President, CAF operations. I want to remind everyone that what we say today about the company's future business plans, prospects and financial performance consists of forward-looking statements made under the Safe Harbor provisions of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Those statements rest on management's current knowledge and assumptions about future events, and they carry risks and uncertainties that might cause actual results to differ materially from what we expect; when we provide projections and other forward-looking statements, the company disclaims any intent or obligation to update them. For more information on important factors that could affect these expectations, please see the company's Form 8-K issued this morning and its annual report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended February 29, 2020 filed with the SEC. If any follow-up questions come up after the call, feel free to reach our Investor Relations department at 804 to 747 to 0422 extension 7865. Finally, thanks ahead of time for limiting yourself to one question and then getting back in the queue for more follow-ups. Bill?

Bill Nash

executive
#2

All right. Thank you, Stacy. Good morning, everyone, and I’m glad you could join us. You may have seen in the 8-K we released this morning that Tom will be retiring as of February 28. Before we get started, I want to take a moment to congratulate him and to say thank you for all he has contributed to CarMax. Because of Tom’s expertise, his strategic focus, and his leadership, we have built a finance organization that is best-in-class, and he was instrumental in guiding us through the largest transformation our company has ever experienced. Tom, thank you for all you have done. We wish you the very best in a retirement you have truly earned. Jon Daniels, who many of you already know, will continue to lead our CarMax Auto Finance team and will begin reporting directly to me. On today’s call, we will start by reviewing our financial performance for the third quarter, and after that we will provide an update on our omni-channel experience and other strategic initiatives, and then we will take your questions. Our diversified business model across retail, wholesale, and auto finance, together with strong execution by our teams and disciplined cost management, delivered another quarter of excellent EPS growth, even though retail sales were constrained late in the quarter by macro factors. CarMax Auto Finance, or CAF, continued to produce solid results this quarter, with income up 55%. In addition, CAF and our partner lenders saw strong conversion across all credit tiers. Jon will provide more detail on customer financing and CAF’s contribution shortly. Our wholesale business also delivered strong results, with volumes up 10.8%, helped by a record appraisal buyer rate for a third quarter. The strength of our buyers, our algorithms, and our extensive datasets made those results possible with only a slight year-over-year decrease in wholesale gross profit per unit, to $906, and that is despite sharp depreciation in the broader market. Every auction will be conducted virtually for the entire quarter. Total retail used unit sales increased 1% compared with the same period last year, while used unit comps declined by less than 1%. Gross profit per retail used unit for the quarter was $2,151, in line with last year’s third quarter. That said, this figure does not really provide a complete picture of how the macroenvironment affected our retail business; during the first part of the quarter, we recorded mid-single-digit comp growth, continuing the positive momentum from the end of the second quarter. But as the election approached and COVID-19 cases rose again, which resulted in tighter occupancy restrictions and shelter-in-place orders, we saw demand soften. As a result, sales fell in the latter part of the quarter. That trend has continued through the first 2 weeks of December, with sales down roughly 4% year over year. Keep in mind that last year we had a strong fourth quarter plus the added benefit of Leap Day. Looking ahead, we feel good that the sales patterns we witnessed late in Q3 and continuing through December are temporary. Right now, about half the stores we run fall under occupancy restrictions thanks to state and local mandates. Inside that subset, more than 40 locations must keep capacity at 25% or below. Even with those limits, the omnichannel platform we've created allows customers to interact and transact with us across more channels than ever before. Gross profit per retail used unit came to $21.51 for the quarter. As we continue investing in technology, our team members, and our merchandise assortment, we trust that what we offer will keep attracting new customers to CarMax and serve their needs better — whether they buy online through our CECs, come into a store, or blend both approaches. I'll cover the ongoing upgrades to our omnichannel experience in a moment; first, though, let me pass it to Enrique for more detail on our financial results in the third quarter, and then Jon, who'll provide additional specifics on consumer financing. Enrique?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#3

Thanks, Bill, and good morning to all of you. Other gross profit for the quarter was up $4.7 million, which is 5%. EPP profits rose $4.6 million, or 4.8%, mainly because of favorable adjustments to cancellation reserves and profit sharing revenue recognized during the quarter. Our ESP penetration rate stayed at 60% in the third quarter, matching the prior year quarter. Turning to SG&A, we keep doing a great job holding the line on costs while still backing the growth of our omnichannel experience and chasing other investment opportunities. Third quarter expenses came down 1.2%, or roughly $6 million, to $479 million. SG&A per unit was $2,461, which is $57 per unit of year-over-year leverage for the quarter. The drop in SG&A came from a $16 million reduction in stock-based compensation expense and a $15 million reduction in other overhead costs. That decline in other overhead costs was mostly the result of pandemic-related reductions and year-over-year favorability from lower litigation expenses in the third quarter; these SG&A reductions were partly offset by the following notable SG&A expense drivers for the third quarter: a 13% rise in advertising expense, the opening of 11 stores since the start of last year's third quarter, which works out to 5% growth in our store base, and continued spending to advance our technology platforms and strategic initiatives. As we said on our last call, we are raising our marketing spend in the second half of the year. During the third quarter, that spend included additional investments in SEM, content, and social as we work to drive customers to our digital properties. This spending on the quarter takes our year-to-date advertising expense to $144 million, up 2%, or $3 million, versus the same 9-month period a year ago. On a full-year basis for fiscal year 2021, we expect advertising spend to be up roughly $25 million compared with the prior fiscal year. The vast majority of this increase will land in the fourth quarter and will be driven by heavier broadcasting behind the next evolution of our brand campaign. That campaign will focus on clearly differentiating our brand and showing the benefits of our omnichannel experience. We will also keep spending on ROI-based digital investments. From a capital allocation standpoint, our priority is funding growth initiatives. We remain focused on aggressively investing in the digital capabilities needed to enhance our omnichannel experience, the expansion of vehicle and customer acquisitions, and the strategic expansion of our store footprint. In the third quarter, we restarted construction activity on new stores that we had paused in the first quarter because of the pandemic. We currently plan to open 8 to 10 new stores in FY '22. Our unique business model generates a significant amount of cash. So although putting money into growth is still what we're focused on first, that strength means we can give capital back to shareholders too; during Q3 we started up our buyback of shares again, repurchasing roughly 1.2 million shares, which cost $109.2 million in that quarter. On the authorization we currently have, $1.4 billion is left — that's $1.4 million remaining. And to wrap up, we closed out the quarter slightly under the 35% to 45% adjusted debt to capital target for leverage that we've had historically. As you're able to see, having a diversified business model, along with operating excellence and strong cash generation, put us in an extremely good position as we navigate a dynamic environment. At this point I'll hand the call over to Jon.

Jon Daniels

executive
#4

Thank you, Enrique, and good morning to everybody. As Phil said, CarMax Auto Finance along with our lending partners kept producing strong outcomes. In Q3, after subtracting 3-day payoffs, CAF penetration came in at 45.7%, versus 43.3% during the same period one year earlier. Tier 2 made up 19.5% of used unit sales, down from 20.4% in the prior year. Tier 3 rose modestly, reaching 9.7% against 9.5% a year before. Keep in mind that how business spreads across the tiers depends on lender actions and the credit composition of applicants alike. Compared with the prior year, net loans originated by CAF climbed 7%, hitting $1.8 billion. New customers faced a weighted average contract rate of 8.6%, higher than 8.1% a year earlier and 8.2% during Q2. Turning to the portfolio, the overall interest margin rose to 6.3%, compared with 5.7% in last year's comparable period, since we captured meaningful gains from cheaper funding; we keep funding our operations efficiently via the ABS market, and investors responded very favorably to our latest deal in October. CAF income rose 55%, reaching $176 million this quarter, driven by a smaller loss provision along with gains in interest margin and average managed receivables. The loan loss provision stood at $8 million, leaving an ending reserve balance of $432 million for Q3, with the total reserve equaling 3.17% of managed receivables — somewhat below the 3.23% recorded at the close of Q2. Although we saw considerable favorability in losses relative to what was expected at the end of Q2, we feel the reserve properly captures how unpredictable the present environment is and how uncertain the consumer situation remains. Before I hand the call back to Bill, I genuinely want to use this moment to acknowledge the remarkable work of the many associates devoted to meeting our customers' credit needs. Our capacity to reliably deliver exceptional customer service from purchase through payoff has never been clearer than during this past year, and it is one more dimension of our business that distinguishes us from competitors. Bill?

Bill Nash

executive
#5

Alright. Thanks, Jon and Enrique. In this ever-changing environment, our teams keep getting the job done. Even with the short-term market difficulties that track alongside the pandemic's path, our underlying business stayed solid; our business model is nimble, produces a substantial amount of cash, and within the used car sector we hold the strongest position to grow our market share further and create shareholder value over the long run. The CarMax experience means placing the customer in control and giving them excellent service no matter which way they decide to engage with us. To achieve that, we've been overhauling every piece of our business, from the systems that support us to the way we run the physical locations, so that we create a smooth, effective process for both the customer and our associates. During the last quarter, we shared that the nationwide launch of our omni-channel experience had been finished. Today we have one shared platform across the entirety of CarMax that takes advantage of our scale, our footprint across the country, and our infrastructure, and it lets our customers purchase a vehicle on their own terms — online, face-to-face, or a smooth blend of both. Although the existing platform lets customers purchase a vehicle online, certain portions of the transaction — things like appraisals, transfers, and scheduling appointments — still need help from customer experience consultants; our current focus is on making self-service possible for every part of the sale, and we'll roll out major enhancements across the coming 2 quarters. As an illustration, we've been piloting instant appraisal offers on carmax.com. With this feature, a customer gets an offer on their vehicle in 5 minutes or fewer. Given how these early tests went, we're expanding this offering more widely and anticipate it being available for standalone appraisals across the country by the time the fourth quarter ends. We remain on track for the majority of our customers to be able to purchase a vehicle online by themselves — whichever one they pick — by the middle of next fiscal year. Even though they can complete transactions online, customers value having real-time support on hand if they want it. And we think there's unrealized value in directing resources toward assisting the online sales process, just as we recognize there's more value in having friendly, helpful associates inside stores to help with the in-person sales process. That's the reason we built centralized customer experience centers for our CECs. Once again, what makes our omni-channel model advantageous is that customers decide for themselves how they move through their experience. During the third quarter, roughly 70% of our customers who purchased a car from us engaged with our CECs, and over 50% of our customers opted to move their transaction forward online; beyond that, we observe those customers completing more of the transaction online, yet they still prefer taking ownership of their vehicle at one of our stores; in the third quarter, alternative deliveries picked by customers, which include home delivery and curbside pickup, accounted for under 10% of sales. Since we wrapped up the first phase of our omni-channel platform's rollout just last year, quantifying what it has meant for CarMax overall isn't something we can do yet — but proof is already in hand backing up the advantages of an in-store and online experience that's seamlessly integrated. Only 2 years have passed since the debut of our inaugural omni-channel offering in Atlanta. Today, following 2 years plus ongoing experimentation with pricing and advertising, the evidence shows our omni-channel approach is producing durable growth in that highly competitive market. Over this stretch, Atlanta has beaten the broader company, posting high single-digit comps during the third quarter along with 2-year stack comps of 20%. We're equally encouraged by the way our remaining markets are building momentum as our omni-channel offerings reach maturity. On top of that, alternative deliveries in Atlanta — curbside pickup and home delivery among them — are up 45% versus the third quarter of last year, even though this still represents a fairly modest portion of total sales. As we keep improving both our online experience and what we offer, educating shoppers about our omni-channel experience matters, so that we can distinguish and raise both the CarMax brand and our standing in this shifting marketplace. In under a week, we'll roll out the next stage of the national multimedia marketing campaign that kicked off last year, aimed at boosting awareness of our core omni-channel capabilities. Customers should come to understand that CarMax provides the ultimate flexibility to shop and buy on their terms, their way. Alongside the improvements and enhancements we're bringing to our omni-channel experience, we're also running extra pricing and marketing tests in select markets, separate from the national campaign I just referenced. For the fourth quarter, we expect to keep reporting an attractive gross profit per retail unit that exceeds $2,000. That said, we anticipate the year-over-year change in this metric will exceed what we've seen in recent years. Lastly, before we open the floor to your questions, I want to share that we intend to hold a large Virtual Analyst Day event after our year end earnings call. There is a lot going on at CarMax and we are excited to share it. And we believe this forum will give us the chance to delve into greater detail on the strategy and metrics behind our continued progress and the innovations we're delivering to our valued customers; we are finalizing the dates and logistics and plan to e-mail invitations in early 2021; in the meantime, please feel free to reach out to our Investor Relations department should you have any questions regarding this event. Now, we will be happy to take your questions. Operator?

Scot Ciccarelli

analyst
#6

Morning, everyone, and best wishes for the holidays.

Bill Nash

executive
#7

Morning, Scot.

Scot Ciccarelli

analyst
#8

Morning. Bill, could you give us a clearer picture of how the weaker sales pattern this quarter lines up with the way occupancy limits got stricter — any detail at all on how large an effect you believe those limits had on the business?

Bill Nash

executive
#9

Sure. Scot, like I mentioned during the opening remarks, solid growth carried on early in the quarter, and that held right up until roughly 7 days prior to the elections, which is when we noticed a decline, a step down, and I believe the election played some role, yet I also think that is the point where these tighter limits began showing up. I pointed out that over 40 locations sit at 25% or below. Looking back at June, we had far fewer such stores — I believe it was close to half as many that faced restrictions of that kind. And out of those over 40 sitting at 25% or lower, the bulk of them — most of them are at 20%. So pinning down precisely how much comes from the restrictions as opposed to shelter-in-place is tough, but we have definitely observed a step down in those markets. When you consider certain bigger markets operating under these limits, we have clearly seen a step down right after the restrictions took hold.

Scot Ciccarelli

analyst
#10

That’s quite useful. If I may tack on one brief question about a point you already covered, you mentioned a bigger marketing ramp in Q4 and then perhaps somewhat reduced GPU. Would it be reasonable to think those same kinds of patterns would carry over into the following year, as you folks attempt to help people grasp what’s changing in the business?

Bill Nash

executive
#11

Yes. Clearly — during Q3, we increased it somewhat. In Q4, we are increasing it; we believe a terrific opportunity lies ahead of us. And so, building awareness does take some time. Thus, my expectation would be a step-up next year, though we’ll discuss that further once Q4 wraps up.

Scot Ciccarelli

analyst
#12

Very helpful. Alright. Thanks, guys.

Bill Nash

executive
#13

Thank you, Scot.

Michael Montani

analyst
#14

Morning. Appreciate you taking the question.

Bill Nash

executive
#15

Morning.

Michael Montani

analyst
#16

I'd like to go a bit deeper, if I may, Bill, regarding what you've observed in Atlanta. I found that to be useful detail. So I was hoping you could tell us more; and also, just to verify, around the midpoint of calendar '21, if I understood you correctly before, it seemed as though things would essentially become seamless for online, meaning customers could opt to talk with someone in real time, yet if they preferred to simply press a button and complete the purchase on their own, that would be possible too; so I just wanted to confirm I had that right, and then additional detail on the multi-channel aspect would be excellent.

Bill Nash

executive
#17

Yes. Thanks for asking, Michael. Yes. So as I mentioned, in Atlanta — Atlanta was where we initially introduced this, and Atlanta has served as sort of the initial location where we try out new initiatives. In fact, we currently have a fresh user experience live there and in certain other locations that lets the customer construct the order — begin constructing the order on their own. So, I believe Atlanta's results are telling as those locations develop over a longer period. Because when we examine other locations, we have roughly 70 stores and then the matching locations those stores belong to that have been operating for no less than 12 months; and we observe results from that set surpassing the remainder of the company, which simply demonstrates that with maturity, they keep building. And actually, we have — a number of those initial waves are right now generating solid, robust comps; so, all of that gives us encouragement. I think, certain initiatives we've undertaken in Atlanta and a handful of other locations we haven't introduced elsewhere, which is among the reasons we wish to prolong some of the trials, namely the remarks about advertising and pricing. Regarding the latter portion of your question, the seamless part, yes, I mean, at present, a customer is able to purchase from us online. But as I noted, there are aspects where the customer experience consultant has to become engaged and collaborate with the customer, and we'll achieve significant progress. Our current priority is self-serve, so we'll achieve significant progress over the coming 2 quarters. And I believe most of our customers will be offered that choice to move forward with self-serve minus the CEC <<inaudible>> should they opt for it; and we anticipate being in solid shape during the second quarter, midway through the following fiscal year.

Michael Montani

analyst
#18

Thank you for that update.

Bill Nash

executive
#19

Sure.

John Murphy

analyst
#20

Morning, everyone, and congratulations to Tom and Jon on their retirements and the new positions. I've got one question for you, Bill. Clearly, there's plenty of worry about same-store sales declining, and I get that the regulatory framework, or in other words the shelter-in-place mandates, are causing part of that, but if you look at wholesale sales, those rose 10.8%. So certain segments of the market are performing quite well even with these restrictions, and a doubter might say, hey, look, there's a major issue here, since your wholesale sales are so robust. Someone on the other side is selling some vehicles at retail, and you aren't, while an optimist might say, hey, look, that 10.8% shows that without these restrictions, you'd truly be dominating. I mean, how do you read that sizable disconnect between wholesale and retail? I can't recall any disconnect that large previously, so I'm just trying to figure out what's happening?

Bill Nash

executive
#21

Absolutely, John. Well, I believe many elements are at play for the third quarter. I mean, clearly we discussed the COVID surge along with the lockdowns and restrictions; we discussed the election. You're raising an interesting point. Higher used prices during the third quarter, remember, many of the vehicles sold in the third quarter were purchased earlier in the month before that period. And you know from the prior months that there was extremely sharp appreciation. So what occurred is, the other element I hadn't really mentioned this quarter is, you've got a narrowing of the spread between late-model used and new. So I think that's another element in there. And then, I think the external — some external sources exist that would indicate the used car industry has become softer. And we're observing that. We've seen depreciation in the marketplace across the quarter. Now, value compared to a year ago is still higher than it was 12 months back, but we're definitely seeing depreciation take hold.

John Murphy

analyst
#22

Alright, though it does look to me like there's a signal — what I'm getting at is that cheaper prices don't automatically translate into fewer units sold or reduced earnings for your business, and in fact it can work the other way around. If you handle reduced pricing properly, you end up moving more product and making more money. So as the market settles back to normal, it appears to me there's a genuine chance for meaningful gains in volume, and perhaps that wholesale figure tells us more about the future than the recent same-store sales comparison does. That's basically how we're reading the direction things are taking?

Bill Nash

executive
#23

Just remember, on the wholesale side, when you're dealing with it — that inventory turns over extremely fast for us. And clearly, what sits in our wholesale inventory looks vastly different. The vehicles we move at our auctions are vastly different from those we sell at a retail lot. However, with wholesale, you receive vehicles immediately and dispose of them immediately; over on retail, we have stock that we've been steadily clearing out, which we acquired before the quarter began.

John Murphy

analyst
#24

Sorry to interrupt — the limitations on wholesale aren't identical to those affecting retail, obviously, correct? Meaning wholesale doesn't face any restrictions of that sort. Right?

Bill Nash

executive
#25

That's not the case. On the wholesale side, we made the decision to keep every one of our sales virtual. In certain markets, we actually had the option to resume in-person sales. However, because of what it involves to bring groups of people into our store locations while keeping our associates safe, we opted to keep it all virtual for the quarter.

John Murphy

analyst
#26

Great. Thank you very much.

Bill Nash

executive
#27

Thank you, John.

Sharon Zackfia

analyst
#28

Hi. Good morning.

Bill Nash

executive
#29

Good morning, Sharon.

Sharon Zackfia

analyst
#30

I was hoping — hello. By the way, I have a feeling Tom will be spending his entire retirement surfing, so congratulations to him. But I wanted to dig a bit further into what appears to be happening in Atlanta, which sounds quite encouraging. And Bill, I believe you brought up some pricing and marketing tests that might speed up that trend across the rest of the country. So I suppose my ultimate question is this — can awareness of the omni-channel offerings be raised more quickly? Since it appears to be occurring, yet it appears to be occurring perhaps more gradually than some of us had initially expected; so I would really like to hear more about how effective various types of marketing are and/or programs you could implement to speed up national awareness? And then secondly, regarding the pricing test, I didn't catch whether any of that involved pricing for delivery rather than actual unit pricing?

Bill Nash

executive
#31

All right. That question contains a lot, Sharon. Let me try to address everything. I might need you to repeat a portion of it. But first, I believe it matters that we worked very hard to get a common platform launched, which we achieved in the third quarter. And for us that was a major milestone, since we truly needed — we wanted everyone on one platform before we began educating the consumer; and as I mentioned, during the third quarter, we planned to launch this new multimedia marketing campaign by the end of the year, which we're very excited about. And I believe it does a great job distinguishing us from either traditional dealers or online dealers and truly showcases the capabilities and flexibility we possess. And so, we're excited. It will include everything you could imagine, from broadcast to digital, to social, to out-of-home, so think about billboards, that sort of thing. So it truly is a wide-ranging effort, because we do believe there's a chance to educate the consumer and build that awareness; now, with any awareness advertising, it doesn't — it requires some time, because when you run awareness advertising, most of the people who are hearing it aren't necessarily in the market. But the goal is to ensure that whenever they are in the market, we're top of mind. So that will be the true focus. And I believe that will serve as a catalyst. I mean, we really haven't done that until now; so we're excited to get that out there. I think the other portion of your question concerned pricing on delivery. Is that — could you clarify that portion?

Sharon Zackfia

analyst
#32

So, you mentioned pricing experiments happening this quarter and how that affects GPU. I was just wondering whether that would also involve a price elasticity element tied to what it costs to deliver to the customer?

Bill Nash

executive
#33

Yeah. So, we are always — when I said what I said earlier, I was referring more narrowly to GPU pricing, or retail pricing. We never stop running tests on delivery for consumers, and that will keep being the case too. That's something we've already been doing. And my expectation is that moving ahead, we take a very analytical approach with these kinds of things, whether it's pricing, it's advertising, whether it's the transfer fees. We're going to try combinations. We're going to try them individually. There's going to be an entire set of various things we're testing this quarter.

Sharon Zackfia

analyst
#34

My apologies. Might I pose a single additional question? Therefore, during this quarter, you are running a test of pricing and marketing in certain markets. Should you observe promising results there, how fast are you able to change course?

Bill Nash

executive
#35

In my view, we are capable of changing course extremely fast. To begin with, an awareness campaign will be running in all locations. After that, we will provide some of those markets with extra marketing. A portion of it could be awareness, and perhaps more acquisitions. Thus, I have a great deal of confidence that a quick change of course is possible for us.

Sharon Zackfia

analyst
#36

Thanks.

Jon Daniels

executive
#37

I'd simply say that at this point, the moment truly is ideal, and it's the correct juncture for us to put money behind a marketing boost, behind trying out cheaper prices; our omni platform has been launched. We keep on improving what omni can do. So we feel that right now is when we should be doing this. And as Bill mentioned, we're enthusiastic about what lies ahead for us in expanding the brand and expanding our share of the market.

Seth Basham

analyst
#38

Much appreciated, and good morning, plus congratulations, Tom. Mine relates to the pricing tests too. You're indicating a decline of up to 9% in free cash GPU compared with the same period last year during Q4, and that kind of drop would be unheard of unless the market had suffered a shock. So presumably this is a fairly broad experiment you have in mind, or an especially aggressive one given the reductions you intend to make. Can you share additional detail about precisely what you have in mind versus earlier pricing experiments, and what our expectations ought to be going forward?

Bill Nash

executive
#39

Yes. Good morning, Seth. I appreciate the question. Yes, this will involve — with the pricing test, we'll be attempting it across a number of distinct markets. And here's how I'd suggest you frame it: looking backward at our history for any particular quarter, when examining GPU on a year-over-year basis, we've likely fallen within a range of roughly $30 to $50 for a given quarter; that's approximately the band. Across a full year, it's likely somewhat narrower than that; and I'd put it this way — what I'm conveying is that you ought to anticipate it falling beyond that typical band. And that's going to let us carry out some — as you know, we conduct testing continuously through the quarter, but this is going to provide us greater latitude to try out some various approaches. So once more, we're enthusiastic about certain combinations of things. And we recognize as well that different levers won't produce identical responses in every market. So that's what we'll be examining.

Seth Basham

analyst
#40

Understood. OK, then I’m guessing that this is somewhat broader than usual when it comes to your test, and the reductions in price might go further than what you’ve previously implemented. Would that be the correct way to read it?

Bill Nash

executive
#41

That’s right.

Seth Basham

analyst
#42

Great, I appreciate it.

Bill Nash

executive
#43

Thanks, Seth.

Rajat Gupta

analyst
#44

Morning, everyone, and thanks for letting me ask. I've got one question plus a follow-up, both about CAF. Can you help lay out how much of the quarter's benefit came purely from economic factors, and how much came from losses on the underlying growth? I think you gave that breakdown last quarter — can you do something like that again for this quarter? And then, how should we think about it as we head into Q4? Thanks.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#45

Absolutely. Thanks, Rajat. So honestly, from a losses standpoint, Q3 was a fantastic quarter for us, without question. Net losses came in at $10 million, which is way below what we'd anticipated entering the quarter, and I can walk through the pieces. Several factors broke our way. To start, execution at CAF was excellent. The consumer was both very willing and very able to pay. And clearly, when unit volumes are lower, a quarter's losses will look good. On top of that, we had a backlog of charge-offs from earlier quarters that we managed to liquidate during the quarter. That was a real tailwind, and it's probably not something we'd count on continuing. And obviously, as those vehicles went through our auctions, they did very well on wholesale recovery rate too. So many elements came together to deliver a really strong quarter — one I wouldn't necessarily count on repeating. That said, given the strong quarter, our provision came to $8 million, which genuinely mirrors the positivity we experienced, and we do think some benefit carries forward. Within that $8 million provision, we also had $1.8 billion of originations, including the restart of Tier 3 originations, which had paused over the summer — so several items leave us feeling fairly positive and drove the provision. That said, when we run our model and the economic adjustment factor together and set the reserve, there's substantial uncertainty looking at the coming quarter and beyond. So we feel good about the reserve. Keep in mind that within that reserve you've got Tier 1, Tier 3, and recovery cost volume; our cumulative loss factor is likely a bit above what we'd typically see in normal times. But on the whole, uncertainty persists out there. The reserve is adequate, it was a great quarter, but we remain cautious about what's ahead.

Rajat Gupta

analyst
#46

Understood. That is useful detail. Regarding CAF, I saw that captive channel sales volume rose about 7% compared to the same period last year, whereas Tier 2 and Tier 3 together saw their total volumes decline versus a year ago. Was this simply an intentional move? Would it affect your same-store comparisons for the quarter? Also, should we anticipate that this mix reverts toward more typical levels in Q4 and the following year, or will CAF stay at this combined level? Thank you.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#47

Certainly. Yes, that is a reasonable question. As I said during my remarks, ultimately the penetration, or how things are distributed among the tiers, will generally depend on two factors: lender behavior and mix. During this quarter, it was truly a matter of mix. I don't believe lenders changed much, and certainly not CAF. So, I think that is what primarily caused it, and as for mix in the next quarter, it's difficult to predict; we will just have to observe how it unfolds.

Jon Daniels

executive
#48

Yeah, and Rajat, my take is this: if CAF hadn't taken them on, someone else would have, and that ties into what you asked about same-store sales.

Bill Nash

executive
#49

There's another item regarding cap, Rajat, that I feel received somewhat less attention this quarter, since the adjustment to the loan loss reserve essentially reflects nothing other than the fundamental profitability of the CAF business. If you look at what the net interest margin was for the quarter, and you factor in that this represents earnings we will keep realizing across the life of the loans, that is a meaningful tailwind for us going forward. Because gain on sale is not something we use in our financing, you will keep seeing that advantage across the life of the loan once more. So, once again, a meaningful benefit this quarter and ahead, purely from the profitability of our CAF business.

Rajat Gupta

analyst
#50

Understood. That sort of adds up, and I appreciate all the detail — best of luck.

Bill Nash

executive
#51

Thanks.

Jon Daniels

executive
#52

Thanks.

Brian Nagel

analyst
#53

Hello, and good morning.

Bill Nash

executive
#54

Morning to you.

Brian Nagel

analyst
#55

Thanks for fielding my questions. To start, Tom and Jon, congrats on the retirement and on the new position. So, at the risk of, you know, flogging a dead horse. On the sales trends, maybe I'll combine a few questions into one. But obviously, the comparisons — the year-on-year comparisons became — were tougher in the fiscal third quarter. And when you stack it up, so to speak, the business in fact got stronger in Q3 compared with Q2. So what I want to ask is, when you look at how the quarter trended, where you pointed to that slowdown, did that line up with comparisons becoming — getting tougher? And then my second question alongside that is, we've discussed the COVID restrictions in the stores quite a bit. Could you talk about any difference across the business between stores that had more significant COVID restrictions and perhaps stores that were less restricted — where those restrictions weren't in place?

Bill Nash

executive
#56

Yes, Brian. So, I won't get into specifics about particular stores or really markets. On the COVID restrictions and the shelter-in-place, I'll tell you this. I mean, certainly there are states such as California, the Chicago area, that have some of the strictest requirements. And if you compare pre-restrictions with post-restrictions, as I mentioned earlier, we definitely saw a step-down. Of course we can compare that with the rest of the country, and particularly the ones with no restrictions at all. On the — I think, the first part of your question, could you repeat that part?

Brian Nagel

analyst
#57

Yes. Purely from a relative perspective. So, when you examine — your comparisons became harder in the third quarter; overall, pre-owned vehicle unit comps actually got better on a two-year basis in Q3 versus Q2. Thus, what I wanted to ask is, while you were reviewing the business during the quarter, did trends weaken as the comparisons became tougher?

Bill Nash

executive
#58

Yes. So, when I look at it year over year, definitely in the prior year, both Q3 and Q4 were solid quarters, and it strengthened somewhat as the quarter went on; so I believe it's a mix of — the comparisons became slightly more challenging, but at the same time you've got plenty of these other outside elements that are having an impact.

Brian Nagel

analyst
#59

Understood. Alright, thanks.

Bill Nash

executive
#60

Very well. Appreciate it, Brian.

Craig Kennison

analyst
#61

Hi there, thanks, and well done, Tom and Jon. I'd like to revisit the wholesale side regarding your shift to digital. In retail, you're refining that omni-channel approach. If that comparison holds, how would an omni-channel approach appear on the wholesale side? It seems there's a great deal of upheaval in that area as well.

Jon Daniels

executive
#62

Right. Craig, I believe your thinking matches ours; we serve two groups of customers: those in retail and those in wholesale. Each matters just as much. We discuss often how we deliver an omni-channel approach for our retail buyers. Yet wholesale is likewise something I've previously described as a strategic initiative we keep putting money into. We aim for our wholesale buyers' experience to align with whatever they're looking for; much like retail buyers, their needs differ. Certain dealers prefer attending in-person sales, certain ones enjoy a mix, and certain ones prefer only the online option. We've now positioned ourselves so we can handle each of those. Once we restart in-person sales, simulcasting will be part of it. You may show up in person, or you may place bids online. We believe this is — this is going to be excellent. As we push the business ahead, it lets additional dealers take part without needing to be there physically; and we believe additional dealers participating, additional dealers purchasing, that's beneficial. It will push prices higher and lets us include more on vehicles. So, your thinking mirrors ours, we're working to create the finest experience for both groups of customers.

Craig Kennison

analyst
#63

Thank you.

Jon Daniels

executive
#64

Thank you, Craig.

Adam Jonas

analyst
#65

Hey, thank you everyone. Bill, I truly value the additional detail regarding the KPIs and the omni, which will be extremely useful, particularly moving forward. Could you provide some insight into the penetration rate for items such as F&I and other front-end offerings — specifically for the alternative distribution units — as well as detail on the GPU for vehicles sold through alternative distribution compared with non-alternative distribution, if I might put it that way?

Bill Nash

executive
#66

Absolutely, Adam. Yes. So regarding items like the financing, the MaxCare, when you examine alternative delivery, financing is quite comparable to what happens in-store. I believe, with MaxCare, there is — it's very alike on the — one type of alternative delivery such as an express pickup or a curbside, that is reasonably in line with the store process. It's somewhat lower with home delivery, but that's something I think we can typically keep concentrating on and improve. When it comes to GPU, the way we run our business, the GPU does not differ for a vehicle delivered to somebody's home or through alternative delivery, whether done at the store, curbside, or express pickup, versus one on our lot; therefore I don't perceive any difference there.

Adam Jonas

analyst
#67

Appreciate it, Bill.

Rick Nelson

analyst
#68

Hey there, morning to you. Congrats also to Tom and Jon. Alright, my question is about CAF — this quarter the contract rate climbed to 8.6%. Last quarter we sat at 8.2%. So you're pushing APRs higher while funding costs are falling. What I want to understand is why that's happening, and could CAF instead accept thinner spreads, I suppose, to push more same-store sales?

Bill Nash

executive
#69

Absolutely. Yeah, I appreciate that, Rick. As we've said previously, with the penetration split across Tier 1, Tier 2, Tier 3, mix played a major role. In the same way, inside CAF, there truly wasn't any rate hike for the folks walking in the door — it's actually the blend of who walks in; a customer with a higher rate came through rather than any change to rates. As for what rates CAF ought to set, can we operate in a lower interest rate setting — clearly, given where interest rates overall stand, I believe we've consistently said we watch the market extremely closely; CAF's role is to put a highly competitive offer in front of the market as a Tier 1 lender on its own, and that's what we always do; we'll track key metrics such as 3-day payoffs and, clearly, whatever we observe from rivals in the marketplace, and our feeling is that at this moment we're sitting in a really strong spot — but yeah, no rate increase caused that, it's entirely a mix matter.

Jon Daniels

executive
#70

Yeah, I agree, and it's the same as that earlier question, Rick — regarding the effect on same-store sales, if we hadn't brought that customer on board, another company would have.

Rick Nelson

analyst
#71

All right, I appreciate that. Could I ask a second question about CAF, specifically how it ties into reserves going forward? The allowance balance has fallen to 3.2% of receivables managed. My recollection is that you previously mentioned expected future loss rates between 2% and 2.5%. Do you anticipate that allowance ratio declining over time?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#72

Absolutely. Rick, your figures are spot on. For the quarter it was 3.17%, and I believe a few key points deserve mention when comparing that figure against the 2% to 2.5% we've reported in the past; the Tier 3 business is included within that 3.17%. Our historical commentary has been that this represents approximately 1% of receivables and drives 10% of losses, while the 2% to 2.5% figure we cited generally applies to our Tier 1 business. So you truly need to strip that out. Beyond that, adopting CECL in our reserve means we must also set aside funds for the actual recovery cost, and once more that was never factored into the 2% to 2.5%. So after netting those elements, we're likely still somewhat above that range. Still, I consider that sensible given the conditions we face. Clearly, our hope is to move back toward normal as circumstances normalize. At present, though, uncertainty persists on both fronts, and we'd note that applies both to our origination volume of $1.8 billion and to the portfolio we already hold. So once more, slightly elevated relative to our target range after those adjustments, but ideally matters return to normal before long.

Rick Nelson

analyst
#73

All right, that's clear, and I appreciate the additional detail.

Bill Nash

executive
#74

Thanks, Rick.

Chris Bottiglieri

analyst
#75

Hello, and thank you for fielding this. I have a small point I'd like clarified before moving to something more substantial. Regarding CAF, could you describe the amount set aside for newly generated loans? In the past two quarters or so, I believe you provided figures, though there was considerable distortion, making it hard to grasp what you're reserving against for fresh loans.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#76

Absolutely, glad to address that. We referenced $1.8 billion in originations. Of that, $66 million in reserves was tied to it. A few reminders, following up on the earlier inquiry — within that figure sits Tier 3 volume. Also, remember we paused during the summer months, then resumed and restarted in September. That factor will be embedded in the $66 million along with net recovery expense, but to confirm, $66 million against the $1.8 billion.

Chris Bottiglieri

analyst
#77

That's a big help. Now, to piggyback on what was asked about appraisals — the buyer rate is genuinely impressive, particularly with used car pricing settling down. I just want to get a handle on this. Again, apologies if this was already covered, but has anything shifted structurally in the appraisal rate that lets you push it up so significantly while holding that GPU steady? For instance, are you seeing stronger auction proceeds that keep GPU level or hold costs down? What exactly is enabling you to lift the buy rate while keeping GPU where it is? Any insight you can share would be welcome.

Bill Nash

executive
#78

Sure, Chris. If you've been following our recent calls, you'll know our buy rates have stayed strong, and honestly I see that as proof of the quality of our buyers — the professional ones — along with their algorithms and some of the tech we've deployed. So I'd say we're simply getting better at reacting faster to shifts in the market. As I mentioned in my earlier comments, depreciation occurred across the quarter. Depreciation typically works against buy rate. So even though buy rate dipped somewhat versus the prior quarter, we remain very happy with our position. It also shows us that customers are responding well to the offer we put out there. So I'd call it several factors working together. And given the turnout at our sales, I believe our auctions are drawing strong values, which is a further boost.

Chris Bottiglieri

analyst
#79

Got it. Okay, thank you.

Bill Nash

executive
#80

Thank you, Chris.

David Whiston

analyst
#81

Thank you, and good morning. Regarding the upcoming pilot for the price reduction, was this something that had been fully scheduled for quite a while, once your capabilities were in place, or is part of it a reaction to increased competition?

Jon Daniels

executive
#82

It has sort of developed from the insights we keep uncovering. And it falls into that category of things where we believe the moment is now right, the opportunity is now right, and that view comes from certain outcomes we have observed in additional trials we are running. So I would say it truly represents a progression of what we have been experimenting with, and it builds on that.

David Whiston

analyst
#83

All right. And over a longer horizon, with omni-channel expanding, is there room for greater optimism regarding SG&A scaling?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#84

Yes. For sure, as we emerge from — well, a few points. As we emerge from the pandemic, our approach to managing costs is very strong and disciplined. We do anticipate certain structural savings as we emerge from the pandemic, particularly in corporate overhead, CEC efficiency, perhaps to speak to a few of the things you raised, and also in vehicle reconditioning. That said, what we're doing is reinvesting those savings into growth. As I said before, now is the right moment for us to invest. We will keep investing and expanding our omni functionality, customer and vehicle acquisition, and our new store growth. So that's our thinking on the savings — really, we're a growth company and we will keep investing, but we do expect some efficiencies in our CECs to answer your question specifically.

Bill Nash

executive
#85

Yeah, David, in my view the CECs are merely a single area where we can keep finding efficiency gains. I believe there's still room for store-level efficiencies when it comes to reconditioning as well as procurement. I think we're even — I think we've also picked up some efficiencies simply from corporate overhead and on facilities, that sort of thing, and we've got improvements underway in logistics. So I think there are plenty of efficiencies. I think, to Enrique's point, we want to keep investing in the business; so while we're capturing efficiencies, we want to keep moving the business forward. So, hopefully that gives you a bit more color.

David Whiston

analyst
#86

Yes. I appreciate it. Thanks, guys.

Bill Nash

executive
#87

Thank you.

Chris Bottiglieri

analyst
#88

Hi everyone, Chris here once more. I've got a fast question about advertising—actually, I suppose it's two. First, based on my rough calculation, it seems like it's likely up around 50% in Q4. But is that mostly just operational spending aimed at boosting familiarity with your new offerings and similar things? And then, how are you viewing the payback—is it simply a longer-term return? Second, as the company increasingly moves toward digital with your omni-channel efforts being introduced, what's your thinking on the future amount spent on advertising? Do we pull back from where we are now, or do you see this as the updated standard that just slowly rises as operations go more online? Thanks.

Bill Nash

executive
#89

Yeah. Chris, that increase is mainly for awareness or brand development; and like I mentioned before, it'll be a multimedia type of campaign with many elements involved. The point is truly to inform the consumer about our new offerings and the distinct way we deliver an experience. When you run awareness ads, sure, there will be some gain from that, but the focus is really on shifting what consumers know, which takes place gradually; thus, it won't occur right when you launch it. So looking ahead, past Q4—and we'll definitely share more specifics following Q4, as I noted before, I'd—I believe it's reasonable to state that we'll keep increasing advertising compared to the prior year, since once more, awareness can't just appear instantly, nor can it remain on its own without reinforcement.

Chris Bottiglieri

analyst
#90

Understood. That clears things up nicely. I appreciate the response.

Bill Nash

executive
#91

You're welcome.

Bill Nash

executive
#92

Alright, thanks. Once again, I'd like to express my appreciation for everyone being on today's call. Thank you for the questions you've raised and for the backing you've given us. Delivering an outstanding experience remains the heart of what will make us successful going forward, and that applies not just to the people who shop with us, but equally to the people who work alongside us. Our purpose and our values will stay at the center of what we do, and we'll keep expanding while generating worth for those who hold our stock. To every one of our associates, thank you for all you do each day — looking after one another and looking after the people we serve. You're the very reason we're able to deliver the most compelling customer-centric experience in this industry. I'd like to wish every associate, and all of you, a happy holiday, and we'll speak again next quarter. Thank you.

Operator

operator
#93

Everyone, that brings us to the end of today's conference call. We appreciate you joining us. You're free to hang up now.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete CarMax, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to CarMax, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in CarMax, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.