CarMax, Inc. (KMX) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
April 1, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Stacy Frole
executiveGood morning, and thanks for being with us on the conference call covering the fourth quarter and the full year of fiscal 2021. Joining me today are Bill Nash, our President and CEO; Enrique Mayor-Mora, our Senior Vice President and CFO; and Jon Daniels, our Senior Vice President, CAF operations. As a reminder, anything we say today about future business plans, prospects, and financial performance for the company constitutes forward-looking statements made under the safe harbor provisions of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Such statements rest on management's present knowledge and assumptions concerning future events, and they carry risks and uncertainties that might make actual results differ materially from what we expect. When we provide projections and other forward-looking statements, the company disclaims any intent or obligation to update them. For more detail on important factors that could affect these expectations, please refer to the company's Form 8-K issued this morning as well as its annual report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended February 29th, 2020, filed with the SEC. If any follow-up questions come up after the call, feel free to reach our investor relations department at 804 to 747 to 0422, extension 7865. Finally, thank you in advance for limiting yourselves to one question and then getting back in the queue for more follow-ups. Bill?
Bill Nash
executiveThanks, Stacy. Morning, everyone, and I appreciate you being here; there's plenty of exciting news to share today. Our remarks will cover key insights from the fourth quarter and fiscal 2021 performance, news on our digital improvements, and naturally the Edmunds acquisition that we announced this morning. After that, we'll take your questions. For the quarter, total retail used unit sales came in less than 1% below last year's record level, while used unit comps declined 2.3% versus the same period twelve months earlier. It's worth taking a moment to walk through what drove our fourth quarter results. As we mentioned on the previous call, retail sales faced pressure as we entered the quarter from a spike in COVID-19 cases, which led to tighter occupancy restrictions and shelter-in-place orders. Sales started picking up toward the end of December and through January. By early February, we were tracking toward mid-single-digit comp growth for the quarter, excluding the Leap Day impact from the prior year; however, beginning in mid-February, severe winter weather across a big part of the U.S. hit retail sales, forcing more than 65 stores to close in a single day. Sales were further affected by tax refund delays compared with last year's timing and a lower inventory position stemming from COVID and weather-related production constraints. On a two-year stack, total retail used unit sales in the fourth quarter of FY 2021 rose 13.8%, and used unit comps rose 8.7%. March sales were strong compared with both the COVID-impacted March of last year and a record March in 2019. During that month, the first wave of tax refunds and stimulus checks arrived, weather got better, and customers kept responding well to our ongoing digital enhancements and other strategic initiatives. Beyond that, the underlying metrics we monitor—website visits, online progression, and activity at our customer experience centers, or CECs—point to continued healthy demand for used vehicles as we move into April. Full-year market share data shows our share of zero to 10-year-old vehicles in our current comp markets dropped from roughly 4.7% in 2019 to 4.3% in calendar 2020; we entered the year with strong momentum and were picking up meaningful market share right up until the pandemic began, when 95% of the country was under shelter-in-place orders and about half of our locations were closed or operating with limits. As markets reopened and our omnichannel experience rolled out nationwide, we started gaining share again. Over the final five months of 2020, we recorded market share gains, and we expect them to speed up in 2021. Atlanta, where we've operated since 1995 and which is our most mature omnichannel market, keeps outperforming the company, holding its market share in 2020 despite COVID pressure. Across the last five months of the calendar year, our market share in Atlanta grew 13.8%. In the two years since we launched our omnichannel experience, our share of the Atlanta market has grown 10.9%. For the fourth quarter, retail gross profit per used unit came in at $2,086, versus $2,195 a year ago. That GPU aligns with what we expected and with what we discussed on last quarter's call; it mirrors the effect of the broader pricing and marketing tests we introduced in select markets, together with our national multimedia marketing campaign and the enhancements to our omnichannel experience. Because early results from those tests were positive, we broadened them to additional markets during the quarter. We'll keep testing while we also watch macro factors. In the first quarter, we expect to hold attractive margins above $2,000. In just a moment, Enrique will give further detail on the profitability flow-through across different parts of our business that are driving the success of these tests. Our wholesale business had another good quarter when you factor in one fewer auction day than in the same period last year; wholesale volume for the fourth quarter declined 1.2%. Wholesale gross profit per unit was in line with the prior year at $990 per unit; we estimate that the one fewer auction day this quarter affected the number of wholesale units sold by several percentage points. I'd now like to hand the call to Enrique for more information on our fourth quarter financial performance, and then to Jon, who will offer additional detail on customer financing. Enrique?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveThank you, Bill, and good morning to everyone. During the quarter, other gross profit saw a decline of $4 million, which works out to 3.2%. The reason for this drop was a $14 million fall in service profits, largely attributable to the year-end thank you bonus we announced earlier for 22,000 full- and part-time associates throughout the company — many of them working in reconditioning and service roles — along with bonuses tied to production blitzes and company support pay connected to COVID. Helping to offset some of that was favorability in EPP and third-party finance fees. EPP rose $2.6 million versus the prior year for the quarter, thanks to a favorable reserve adjustment and higher profit-sharing revenue. Lower sales volume and a somewhat reduced penetration rate during the quarter partly offset that gain. Third-party finance fees came in $7.7 million better in the quarter, mostly because of renegotiated fees with our partners, which Jon will cover shortly. Turning to SG&A, fourth-quarter expenses rose 14.7%, roughly $71 million, reaching $556 million. SG&A per unit came to 2,713, representing year-over-year deleverage of $368 per unit for the quarter. The SG&A increase stemmed mainly from a $33 million rise in stock-based compensation, or $160 per unit of deleverage, plus a $23 million increase in advertising expense, or $115 per unit of deleverage, consistent with what we previously communicated as we concentrated on heavier support for our upcoming brand campaign and kept spending to advance our technology platforms and strategic initiatives. Our stance on SG&A and costs as we move into next year is unchanged. At this inflection point in our industry, we'll keep investing in the business — particularly in marketing and our strategic initiatives. On marketing, as we enter the next fiscal year, we anticipate spend staying elevated, with per-unit trends similar to what we saw in the second half of fiscal 2021. Our advertising dollars will keep emphasizing clear brand differentiation and showcasing the advantages of our omnichannel experience, along with ROI-based digital investments producing strong results. Within that spend is a greater emphasis on vehicle acquisition. We feel we're well-positioned to aggressively capture market share by promoting our omnichannel experience and new offerings like Love Your Car Guarantee. We're also staying focused on managing spend appropriately and targeting specific areas of opportunity. That includes our CECs, which are maturing and growing more efficient and effective through automation, data-driven algorithms, and smart routing, all aimed at making sure customers receive the right support. Over the past year, our CECs performed more efficiently than the year before. We anticipate that trend accelerating in FY 2022. On our SG&A leverage point for FY 2022, we'd expect to need a 5%-8% comp on a two-year stacked basis in FY 2022 in order to lever in FY 2022. As we've said before, during investment periods like the one we're in now, we'll need to be at the higher end of that range to lever. Looking at this two-year comparison, it really reflects the effect of lapping over COVID as well as the ongoing investments we’ve put into the business during the past year. Let me spend a moment updating you on the financial side of the pricing tests conducted in the fourth quarter. As Bill said, we’re pleased with what we’ve observed so far. These tests do confirm our historical experience with price elasticity, but a number of things have shifted, which has produced stronger flow-through from the higher sales and, as a result, greater profitability. Those factors include more profitable CAF originations, a reduced variable cost structure as we keep leveraging our centralized CECs, and beneficial adjustments to the fee structure with our third-party lenders. As noted earlier, we’ll keep running pricing tests during the first quarter while also watching macro factors. Maximizing both unit sales and long-term profitability remains our goal. Even in a difficult environment, our distinctive and diversified business model still produced a substantial amount of cash during the past year. From a capital allocation standpoint, that leaves us well positioned to reinvest in growing our core business, to fund new growth opportunities like the Edmunds acquisition we announced, and to return capital to our shareholders. On Edmunds, we intend to fund the deal through a mix of cash and equity. We expect the transaction to close in June and anticipate its financials will have an immaterial impact on CarMax’s EPS in fiscal year 2022. We’re confident this transaction will create significant shareholder value over the longer term. We kept executing our share repurchase program, and in the fourth quarter we bought back roughly 700,000 shares for $66 million. We have $1.34 billion of authorizations remaining at present, and we’re committed to returning capital to our shareholders. On capital expenditures, we expect roughly $350 million in FY 2022. Since we’ve pivoted the business to be more technology-driven, the shape of our CapEx has shifted accordingly. About one-third of our capital spend in FY 2022 will go toward technology investments, up from roughly 15% only four years ago. In FY 2022, we plan to open 10 new locations, with the first grand opening coming later this month. As with our more recent openings, these stores are predominantly cross-functional, have a smaller footprint, and can leverage our scale along with the presence of other locations in nearby markets. Our national footprint and nationwide logistics network remain a competitive advantage for CarMax, and we stay committed to an appropriate level of investment in these differentiated assets. We’re confident that the foundational investments we’re making in our omnichannel experience, our proprietary tech stack, and our highly recognizable and trusted brand position us for accelerated market share gains in 2021. Now I’ll turn the call over to Jon.
Jon Daniels
executiveThanks, Enrique, and good morning, everyone. Once again, CarMax Auto Finance and our lending partners turned in solid results. In the fourth quarter, CAF's penetration net of three-day payoffs came in at 43.5%, versus 43% in the same period a year ago. Tier 2 rose slightly, reaching 21% of used unit sales, up from 20.5% last year. Tier 3 made up 9.5%, compared with 10% a year ago. This spread across the credit tiers mainly reflects the credit mix of applicants we saw in the fourth quarter. On a year-over-year basis, CAF's net loans originated were comparable to the prior year quarter at $1.8 billion. The weighted average contract rate for new customers came in at 8.5%, compared with 7.9% a year earlier, and it was slightly lower than the 8.6% recorded in the third quarter. As in the third quarter, the year-over-year APR gap reflects the mix of CAF customers within the Tier 1 space, not any increase in the rate those customers are charged. Turning to the portfolio, the overall interest margin rose to 6.4% from 5.8% in the same period last year, as we keep realizing substantial benefits from lower funding costs. Our latest securitization, completed in January, closed with a near-record spread between the APR we charge customers and the rate we pay to fund the receivables. Investors in our ABS keep showing confidence in how steady and strong the CarMax origination channel is, and we're grateful for that backing. CAF income rose 68% to $288 million this quarter, driven by a smaller loss provision along with higher interest margin. Loan loss provision came in at $5 million, leaving us with an ending reserve balance of $411 million for Q4. That total reserve equals 2.97% of managed receivables, down from 3.17% at the close of the third quarter. Over the last three quarters, our reserve measured against managed receivables has moved lower, since customers have shown they're willing to keep paying even through these ongoing difficult conditions. We feel the reserve we hold right now is sufficient, and it accounts for both the favorable payment patterns we've seen lately and the uncertainty the macro backdrop may bring going forward. I'd also like to update you on the arrangements with third-party lenders that Enrique mentioned earlier. Under our partner agreements, CarMax has historically gotten a $300 participation fee on every agreed-upon finance contract bought in the Tier 2 space. In the deeper subprime Tier 3 space, where CAF retains roughly 5% of the volume, CarMax has historically given lending partners a $1,000 discount when they finance a customer who, in our view, would otherwise be unable to buy a vehicle from CarMax. When Q4 began, that Tier 2 participation fee went up to $400, and the Tier 3 discount came down to $750. If that structure had been in effect for all of FY 2021, with penetration rates staying the same, the outcome would have been annual savings of about $30 million, or $40 per unit. Now on the coming changes in the Tier 2 and Tier 3 area, CAF began in March 2021 steadily pushing its share of Tier 3 volume past the 5% level, and we anticipate reaching and maintaining a 10% share in Tier 3 by May 31st of this year. CarMax is going to keep evaluating conditions in the lending market, and if and when we conclude that further changes can be sustained and would serve our long-term business objectives, we'll consider making them. Bill?
Bill Nash
executiveI want to thank Jon and Enrique. Fiscal 2021 presented one of the toughest operating climates we have ever encountered. Because we could move swiftly as conditions shifted rapidly, we rolled out new customer experiences and kept innovating while staying financially solid. That financial strength has let us keep investing aggressively in our core business and chase fresh growth opportunities. A few highlights from this year stand out for their lasting impact. First, we finished the nationwide launch of our omnichannel experience, which gives us one shared platform throughout CarMax that draws on our scale, our nationwide footprint, and our infrastructure. Second, we transitioned every wholesale auction to a virtual setting. Third, we expanded nationally our new online instant appraisal product on carmax.com and edmunds.com, which reinforces our position as the biggest buyer and sets us up to become the biggest online purchaser of used autos from consumers. Last, we launched the Love Your Car Guarantee, a signature customer experience that leads the industry. None of this would have happened without our outstanding associates. They supported one another and our customers while also innovating for what lies ahead. Customers have responded strongly to our omnichannel offering, and we keep working to further refine and elevate the digital customer experience at each stage of the sale. A key benefit of our omnichannel model is that customers can decide how they move through their experience. As we discussed before, our initial omnichannel rollout let customers purchase a vehicle online. Certain parts of the transaction might have needed help from our CECs. During the fourth quarter, we made substantial strides toward enabling self-service across every component of the sale. As we exited the quarter, roughly 25% of our customers could, if they wished, complete an online vehicle purchase independently — a big increase over the third quarter. We anticipate that most of our customers will have that ability by the close of the second quarter. Also, in Q4, roughly three out of four of our customers shifted their transactions to digital channels, and about 5% bought the vehicle online. We classify a purchase as online when every major step leading up to it is completed without involving our stores. We expect strong growth in our online sales as we continue to bolster our marketing and digital capabilities. As a reminder, a virtual Analyst Day will take place on May 6th, where we'll take a deeper look at our online capabilities along with our technology and data advantages. At that time we'll also discuss new metrics on online orders and how they are fulfilled, and we'll share insight into our longer-term outlook and expectations. I'd like to briefly highlight a few recent upgrades to the customer experience. First up is our instant online appraisal offer, which provides shoppers with a fast quote on their vehicle. We initially launched and piloted this feature on edmunds.com back in June. In February, we completed the nationwide rollout of the offering on carmax.com. Early response has been strong, with online buyers exceeding our expectations rather quickly, giving us a clear path to becoming the largest online buyer of used autos from consumers. As the fourth quarter came to a close, we added the ability for customers to get penny-perfect transactable financing offers right within our online checkout process. With this improvement, people can submit a credit application and take a finance offer without needing an associate to help them, whether by phone or at a store; we're rolling that capability out quickly across the broader customer base in Q1. Our customer-focused approach is what distinguishes CarMax, we believe, and we'll keep innovating for our customers without pause; in January we introduced Love Your Car Guarantee, a new signature customer experience that leads the industry. Through it, customers get a 24-hour test drive before they commit to buying, and our seven-day money-back guarantee becomes a 30-day money-back guarantee — something no other player in the automotive industry offers. While it's premature to draw conclusions about trends, early data indicates customers place significant value on these offerings. As we continue improving our digital experience and service lineup, we need to make sure customers understand our omnichannel model, which allows us to stand apart and lift both the CarMax brand and our standing in a shifting marketplace. During the fourth quarter, we launched the next stage of the national multimedia marketing effort that started last year, aimed at boosting familiarity with our key omnichannel capabilities. That effort performed very well; since its debut, we posted weekly records for web traffic, surpassing 8 million weekly visits by the close of February. Once the campaign kicked off, website visits and Google search volume each rose more than 25% compared with the months before; we aim to build on that momentum and make sure customers know CarMax gives them the ultimate flexibility to shop and buy on their terms, their way. So, as Enrique said earlier, we intend to boost what we spend on both awareness and acquisition marketing in FY 2022. We'll keep evolving as an omnichannel retailer by innovating faster, drawing on our scale in technology, data, talent, and physical assets to open up opportunities to compete throughout the used auto ecosystem. That's why we're happy to share that a definitive agreement has been signed for us to acquire Edmunds, which ranks among the most influential and widely used automotive research destinations globally. In recent years, our teams have collaborated with Edmunds on several strategic initiatives, among them our instant online appraisal offer and the use of its proprietary content on carmax.com. Its technology, content, and online experience have impressed us greatly, and so have its skilled tech and creative teams. We think that by joining forces we can unlock added value—streamlining the user experience throughout the whole car-buying and selling journey—while also spotting further digitally focused opportunities. One thing that's become evident is that both sides are dedicated to giving customers and dealers the best possible online experience. Edmunds is a brand that's broadly recognized and very deeply trusted. Its core business will keep running on a standalone basis, and it will stay focused on giving consumers confidence and delivering excellent value to its dealer and OEM clients. We're confident this transaction will create shareholder value, since we can use our combined size, scale, and broad industry expertise to benefit both businesses. In summary, we're very proud of how we performed in this difficult year. We feel even greater enthusiasm about the way our continued spending on the business we already operate, plus on Edmunds, is positioning us to stand apart more sharply and compete even harder. For the year ahead we anticipate robust growth in revenue, earnings, and market share — fueled both by comparisons against the COVID period and by demonstrating what our investments have delivered and the experiences we now offer. With that, we're ready for your questions. Carol?
Sharon Zackfia
analystHi there, and good morning. Two questions from me, though I believe the first one's fairly quick. Inventory dropped significantly during March — an unusually large decline. Could you discuss how you're set up on the inventory side to satisfy demand, and whether any atypical costs will hit this quarter as you rebuild inventory? My second question concerns CAF and the Tier 3 expansion. Can you share any sense of Tier 3's profitability per car compared with the $750 you discount to third-party lenders?
Bill Nash
executiveGood morning, Sharon. I'll begin with inventory, and then hand the CAF question to Jon. Once again, this stems from the fact that we experienced some COVID and weather shutdowns. As COVID rose, we had to close certain production locations. Some production locations were also closed because of weather. That's truly the reason we're somewhat behind on saleable inventory. At quarter end, I believe saleable inventory was down roughly 20%. I'd note, however, that on a year-over-year basis our overall inventory is actually up slightly. The inventory exists; it's simply a matter of producing. I think we closed the quarter north of 155,000 units. It's simply a matter of working through it; we're confident. Capacity is there. Now it's simply a matter of restoring inventory to our target. I'll let Jon address the CAF question.
Jon Daniels
executiveYes, Sharon, thank you for asking. Regarding Tier 3, where CAF moves from 5% to 10%, the profit per unit for that vehicle is fairly similar to what we see on our Tier 1 vehicle. Depending on funding costs, it will land somewhere between $2,000 and $2,500 in the current funding environment. We'll watch how things develop across the year. You can set that against the $750 discount we would pay. One key thing worth noting, though: because of CECL regulation, as we book those loans, we'll need to reserve immediately for the full loss impact. So this will likely be a headwind for us in the coming year. Naturally, the lifetime profit will unfold over time.
Sharon Zackfia
analystMind if I follow up on that? Your website shows 24,500 cars at this moment. Is there a mismatch between what the site lists and what you really hold?
Bill Nash
executiveYes. Sharon, what you're seeing on the website is only saleable inventory. There's very little we post as coming soon. What isn't shown there is customer transfers. Transfers moving between stores — a hub store and a satellite, for instance — aren't visible. A sale pending isn't visible either. If you factored all of that in, the count you see on the website would at minimum double. Naturally, it leaves out work in process, and that is really what brings you to roughly 150,000 total units in our possession.
Sharon Zackfia
analystThat really helps a lot. Thanks.
Bill Nash
executiveAbsolutely. Thanks, Sharon.
Craig Kennison
analystHey there, good morning. Appreciate you taking my question. Bill, you mentioned wanting CarMax to become the biggest purchaser of used autos from consumers. What's your estimate for that total addressable market when it comes to car count? And related to that, could you share any metrics showing how active we are, or the buy rate, on the online appraisal tool being used to source those cars?
Bill Nash
executiveSure. Good morning, Craig. First, let me clarify one thing. It isn't that I want us to be the biggest buyer of used cars from consumers. We already hold that position. I definitely want to keep purchasing every single one we possibly can. When I think about the total addressable market, 40 million used cars change hands annually; within that figure, obviously, a lot is person-to-person. That's roughly how I view the overall market. Regarding the online appraisal offer, yes, we're quite excited about it. It's beating our expectations; on carmax.com, we got it up around mid-February, so we only have a partial month. Of course, we'd been testing it, so we'd observed some trends prior to that. Looking at the quarter overall, online buys represented about 10% of all appraisal lane buys we made. Of those, simply because we launched carmax.com near the end of the quarter, most came via our relationship with Edmunds. As I mentioned, given the trajectory we're seeing, we believe in very short order we'll buy more than anyone else online from consumers.
Craig Kennison
analystThanks.
Bill Nash
executiveThanks, Craig. On top of that, CAF income rose 68% to $188 million for the quarter.
John Murphy
analystGood morning, all. I want to continue with this line of questions regarding where vehicles originate. Obviously, the market is extremely tight right now, with little volume coming into the secondary market, the used market. There are also many dealers, and perhaps even some new competitors, who are snapping up vehicles or buying vehicles as well in order to resell them. And particularly with the new vehicle dealers, they occupy a higher position in the funnel, and they're gaining access to some trade-ins, obviously, as people sell new vehicles. Bill, I’m curious—looking forward, how much of the supply tightness you’re able to lock down for retail is temporary, and how much reflects a more secular shift plus sharper dealer focus, maybe from other competitors too, simply making inventory a bit harder to get? With this Edmunds purchase or acquisition, is the real point sourcing vehicles online? Is that really what this is? Because I know it’s a major lead generator for many dealers, so Edmunds offers plenty of other angles. For you, is the key getting these vehicles directly from consumers online?
Bill Nash
executiveOkay, John, let me do my best to address everything there — you certainly fit a lot into that question. To begin with, something we've talked about across multiple quarters now: acquiring vehicles is a strategic priority we've kept our attention on. As you point out, when you look at what's available in the market, supply seems to have come down somewhat compared with earlier years. What works really well in our favor is the huge volume we source through the appraisal channel, and that goes a long way toward offsetting any shortfall beyond CarMax. When it comes to the online side, our aim is to keep pushing as hard as we can to purchase vehicles directly from consumers. We view this as an opportunity to substantially boost our self-sufficiency, and we regard that as a major competitive edge. Once more, that's among the reasons we've concentrated on it, and our investment here will keep going. Turning to Edmunds: the online portion of Edmunds is just a minor element — merely a modest gain within the overall transaction. That isn't what led us to decide to buy Edmunds. On that particular front, the partnership has certainly been a successful one, and we believe there's considerable opportunity remaining in the acquisition. There are additional components as well. We've been collaborating on the content side, for instance. At Edmunds, we see additional areas where bringing the two organizations together should make each of these strong businesses even stronger. Driving more self-sufficiency and more purchasing via the A lane—whether that happens online or through the conventional A lane—is clearly a priority for us as we move ahead.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYeah, and another thing worth keeping in mind is that nobody purchases vehicles better than we do. That's always been true, and it's going to stay true. What we're doing at this point is simply carrying that over into the online space. With the mix of physical stores and digital channels, we'll just keep on outperforming everyone there too.
John Murphy
analystCould you give us a sense of where you expect to land on buying vehicles directly from consumers rather than at auction? I know we've usually figured it at roughly 50/50, though at different moments it moves around. Is this the sort of situation where you'll shift to 60% or 70% or 80% sourced from consumers and pull back from auctions?
Bill Nash
executiveJohn, my thinking leans more toward the self-sufficiency angle. To start with, retail car or wholesale car, we want every one of them. But on the self-sufficiency side, we've run somewhere in what you might call the 35%-50% self-sufficiency over what you might call the past five years. My expectation is this takes us to levels that are genuinely historic highs, perhaps even pushing through the ceiling on self-sufficiency. Our aim is to keep seeing how far we can drive that figure on the north side.
John Murphy
analystVery helpful. Thank you.
Bill Nash
executiveThank you, John.
Seth Basham
analystMuch appreciated, and good morning. Bill, I was hoping you might give us a bit more detail on those price tests. How widely do you plan to roll them out? What have you discovered about where the discount sweet spot sits, and what kind of lift are the tests generating so far?
Bill Nash
executiveYeah. Seth, I'll say a few words about how far the tests reach, and then I'll have Enrique cover where the focus is. Like I mentioned in the comments, we did broaden the test. It's running in a bunch of stores now; that said, I'd tell you we never expect to run it across every store; that simply doesn't make sense, and we understand how markets differ and how stores differ, and elasticity varies a great deal from one market to another. As I also noted in my opening remarks, we'll keep this going through the first quarter, and we'll be watching the macro factors. Clearly, plenty is happening at the moment from a macro perspective; we touched on it a bit with Jon's question, in that supply has tightened somewhat, and you've got developments on the new car side regarding new car availability. Tax refunds have been delayed and are spilling into March. There's stimulus money in the mix. A lot of different forces are at work. On macro factors, what you have to watch is simply staying on top of what competitors are up to, whether that shows in their sales price or their margins, and you have to weigh all of it. We'll stick with these, as Enrique said earlier, we're happy with them, but I'll hand it to Enrique so he can go deeper on the profitability side of things.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYes, definitely. It's worth keeping in mind that we're addressing two objectives here. We're working toward generating higher sales by means of reduced prices, yet simultaneously we're pursuing better profitability. In this test, we've really observed a couple of things. First, sales elasticity has stayed at the same level. That said, what we've found is that more profitability is flowing through, and there are genuinely two explanations for that larger flow-through. First, there's higher finance income. CAF origination is considerably more profitable in the current environment, along with the renegotiated third-party finance fees. Second, variable costs are simply lower as we shift toward our CECs. The results have left us quite pleased; we've again seen both higher sales and better profitability; we plan to keep testing, and, as Bill noted, while keeping an eye on the macro environment as well.
Seth Basham
analystThat's useful. As a quick follow-up, at what point do you think you'll have clearer information about whether you intend to take this across the whole chain? Clearly, this is an unusual stretch of time given all the macro factors you brought up. Might this end up being a test lasting several quarters before you get a clear read?
Bill Nash
executiveI'd say that's a great question, Seth. Precisely because of those macro factors, we tend to get reads on these quite fast. As I mentioned, we got a read where we like the results, but once more, we need to see how the remainder of this quarter develops; it's more about the macro factors than anything internal. I'd suggest staying tuned on that. My guess is we'll likely have an update on it at the Analyst Day in May.
Seth Basham
analystUnderstood. Thank you.
Bill Nash
executiveThanks, Seth.
Brian Nagel
analystGood morning.
Bill Nash
executiveMorning.
Brian Nagel
analystAppreciate all the detail today. I have a couple of questions, and I’ll combine them. First, regarding what Bill said about the business through fiscal Q1 or March: could you help us better size that sales re-acceleration, especially relative to what I think you described as a mid-single digit increase in used car units in February before the weather hit? My second question is somewhat unrelated, but about renegotiating the fees and the finance business. Those of us who’ve followed CarMax for a long time have discussed this for quite a while. Why now? What made it possible for you as a company to make this change at this point?
Bill Nash
executiveGreat, Brian. I’ll have Jon discuss CAF in just a moment. I’m surprised it took five or six questions before someone actually asked about sales performance, but I appreciate you asking. Look, if I think about March, as I said in the opening remarks, it’s robust. In fact, March has been an excellent month for us. It’s been a record month for us. We sold more than 100,000 cars in March for the first time in the company’s history. I’d tell you, it doesn’t really make sense to think about comps this year versus last year simply because of the COVID impact. The way I think about them is that we should really compare them with March of 2019, so two years ago. March of 2019 was the previous record for the number of vehicles we sold. What encourages me most is that if I compare our March performance this year with two years ago, we’re seeing double-digit growth on top of that March, which really speaks to a lot of what’s going on. Sure, some of what’s happening involves macro factors beyond our control. When you consider some tax refund money being pushed into March, and you consider the stimulus, I absolutely understand that, and it’s helping drive some of that tailwind. We’re really excited about the tailwind beyond that. As we said in our opening remarks, we’re excited about 2021. I mean the quarter—sorry, 2022, FY 2022. Unfortunately, the quarter is the ending of a very volatile year for us. I’d just remind everyone that if you go back to FY 2020, it was a great year. Double-digit top-line growth, high mid-single digit comp growth. We continued that into the start of FY 2021 until the point we hit the pandemic. Since the pandemic has been in place, it’s obviously been a very volatile year. Looking at the fourth quarter, the pandemic also began to cause some of the volatility at the start of the quarter with December, and we discussed that on the last call. COVID cases rose sharply, and a number of our markets returned to lockdown conditions. One illustration: California, normally among the strictest states, capping occupancy at 20% and 25%, went back to that 20%, 25% mode in December. In a market like that, what we observe is that an occupancy cap makes that market perform roughly more than 10% worse on average than the rest of the company. We faced that headwind from occupancy limits in December and January. During both months, over 50 stores ran below 50% occupancy, and under 50% is tough for us. Once you reach 50% or higher, we can work through it. Given the traffic that enters our stores, it's hard to manage. That said, December opened at -4%. By the end of December we managed to do better than that; we were still negative. Moving into January, and looking at January, it was the most normal month, if such a thing exists; there were no tax refund delays and no bad weather. What we truly had to deal with was those occupancy restrictions. Even with the occupancy restrictions, we saw comps above 7% in January, which makes us feel great. I genuinely believe that continues some of the trends from the prior year in our investments coming forward. We entered February moving along, and as I said in the opening remarks, although we began in the hole, we were looking at a mid single-digit comp excluding the Leap Day effect. Remember, Leap Day last year fell on a Saturday, and for our stores that's the busiest day of the week. Excluding that, we were at a mid-single digit comp, and then we ran into the weather constraints and simply the tax refund delays. In February, I believe returns were down roughly 30% year-over-year. That's a bit more color on that. Let me hand it to Jon to address the other question.
Jon Daniels
executiveAbsolutely, Brian — I appreciate the question about the fees. You asked, essentially, why now? That's a reasonable thing to ask. There are really three factors I'd highlight. The first is that lending conditions are simply very favorable at the moment. Customers, I think, are performing well, and finance companies and lenders are eager to put money out to customers who are performing well. It is unquestionably a favorable funding environment — that part is very clear. Those two factors definitely made it easier. I think every one of our lenders on our platform is genuinely enthusiastic about CarMax growth. They're enthusiastic about what lies ahead. They love CarMax collateral. Taken together, all of that just made it feel like the right moment. One thing I'd want to emphasize, though, as we think about fees or our whole platform — whether it's the fees and discounts, the partners we have on the platform, where CAF participates in the platform — the most important thing we aim to deliver from our finance platform is highly competitive offers across the credit spectrum in all economic environments; we want to do that in a way that lets us scale it as CarMax scales. We're always going to examine that platform and look to optimize it. It felt like the right time to make the fee changes now, but we were very careful and looked at what the impact to sales were there. If we make any changes in the future, we will stay very focused on providing those strong credit offers; that's most important to us.
Bill Nash
executiveHey, Brian, one more thing as well. I just want to highlight that I mentioned the occupancy limits. I’ll knock on wood, but right now, even though roughly a third of our stores are still under occupancy restrictions, the crucial point is that at this stage we have just one store below that 50%. Again, that threshold matters a lot to us, so.
Brian Nagel
analystUnderstood. Thanks for all the detail. Bill, I just want to make sure — you sold 100,000 cars in March, if I heard that correctly. That's up by double digits compared with the figure for 2019, right?
Bill Nash
executiveYes, that's right. That's how I believe all of us should be looking at this year. Trying to compare this year with last year — I simply don't think that's a worthwhile exercise. I think we ought to measure it against 2019, which was a strong year for us, and we sold plenty of cars then. What's genuinely encouraging is that, when you look at it, March of 2019 had been the previous record, and we surpassed it by double digits.
Brian Nagel
analystUnderstood. Thanks for that. Many thanks.
Bill Nash
executiveThanks, Brian.
Scot Ciccarelli
analystGood morning, guys.
Bill Nash
executiveMorning, Scot.
Scot Ciccarelli
analystBill, may I just confirm the double-digit figure you mentioned a moment ago in response to Brian's question? Does that refer to comp, or does it cover total including new stores?
Bill Nash
executiveIt's both of those. Both. Comp as well as total.
Scot Ciccarelli
analystUnderstood, that's useful — particularly since you're working to help all of us grasp the variances in sales pace and so on. Could you share more specifics about what you're observing in Atlanta from a market share or sales standpoint, given how long your omni-channel offering has been in place there? Tied to that, is there anything distinctive you're doing in that particular market? Because at one stage, I know there were some atypical things happening with marketing and pricing that you hadn't yet taken everywhere. Is it all just a blanket offer and blanket testing now?
Bill Nash
executiveYes. Scot, regarding Atlanta, as I mentioned during the opening remarks, we actually held our market share there. Looking at the fourth quarter, comps in Atlanta came in at roughly 6.5%. Once again, that encourages us. Look, we have some older waves where we've launched omni that also posted comps during the quarter; it becomes difficult to assess the waves because certain stores within them were affected by weather while others were not. Again, Atlanta is essentially the clean way to view it. On the subject of different initiatives, when we began the expanded pricing test and examined the marketing, much of that stemmed from what we learned in Atlanta. Naturally, we've begun rolling that out to additional markets. I think another point to keep in mind is that when we launch new things, for instance, if you consider self-serve, Atlanta is the first market where we introduced it. Typically, we deploy things there initially. They consistently receive things slightly sooner than everybody else. That's the other distinction I would highlight as well; on self-serve, once more, we're enthusiastic about it because I believe the team has put in an enormous amount of effort. As we came out of the second quarter, 25% of our customers were able to use it, and we expect that most customers will have that option by the conclusion of the second quarter.
Scot Ciccarelli
analystThat's useful. If I could, just one more quick follow-up. When it comes to people using the omnichannel, are there any demographic differences compared with what your typical customer cohort would be?
Bill Nash
executiveYeah, no, it's interesting. We don't really see any major demographic shift; it mirrors the typical CarMax customer who would come into the store very much.
Scot Ciccarelli
analystVery helpful. Thanks, guys.
Bill Nash
executiveThanks, Scot.
Michael Montani
analystHi there, good morning. I appreciate you taking my question. I just wanted to ask, if possible, what the self-sufficiency ratio came in at for fiscal fourth quarter, and also for the prior year, and then I have a quick follow-up after that.
Bill Nash
executiveYes. Michael, self-sufficiency for the quarter came in a little bit above 40%, around 41-ish%. That is up from the fourth quarter of the prior year, when it was down in the 30%s. Really kind of mid-30%s, around 35% or so.
Michael Montani
analystMy follow-up was simply to get a rough sense of how big the potential tailwind to GPUs from self-sufficiency could be. I've been framing it as perhaps $600-$1,000 per unit, all else equal, and I suppose I wouldn't suggest that all of you would pass every bit of that through, but it does seem that if GPU is still going to be down even with a tailwind of that kind, that implies you're getting very sharp on price and doing plenty of free transfers. I just wanted to hear how you think about hitting that competitive balance as well.
Bill Nash
executiveYeah. I think that's a good point you raise. The more we're able to buy through the appraisal lane, the better it clearly is from a profitability standpoint, because when you think about it, in a lot of cases you aren't paying auction fees. In all of the cases right now, we aren't having to transport them from an auction. They're actually at the store. We treat that as part of how we manage our overall margin. At times, we'll take some of those synergies, and we'll clearly pass them along in prices, which would be really hard for you guys to see. Other times, obviously, we have the option to manage our margin and get to the margin where we want to be. It's a balancing act, and it's one that we'll keep taking into consideration, as well as continuing to look at the macro factors as we go forward on our pricing tests.
Michael Montani
analystThank you.
Bill Nash
executiveThank you.
Rajat Gupta
analystWell, hi there, good morning, and I appreciate you taking my question. I just want to follow up on that figure of 100,000 for March. You mentioned stimulus and tax refund timing shifts, possibly some bounce-back from the bad weather in Texas, and some purchases that got deferred because of that. Is there any way to put a number on how much of those 100,000 units might have been pulled from Feb into March, the way you'd see in any ordinary year? Along those same lines, could you give us a feel for how alternate delivery channel volumes were mixed in the fourth quarter and in March as well? I have just one more follow-up. Thank you.
Bill Nash
executiveOkay, Rajat. On the sales shift, it's genuinely difficult to quantify, particularly splitting it between weather and the tax refund delay. I think the best frame is roughly what I said earlier: heading into February, around the middle of February, if you exclude the leap day effect, we would have been running a comp in the mid-single-digit range, and clearly that isn't where we landed. That's one way to look at it; we finished at negative two, three. That's one way to view weather and taxes together, but parsing it apart is really tough. It's hard to know precisely, obviously, how much of an impact there is. On alternative delivery, just a reminder that alternative delivery covers home delivery as well as express pickup or curbside pickup; what we're still seeing is that it's under 10% of overall delivery. Again, that's a figure, and while we have reported on it, it's not like we're trying to push that. Again, this is all about giving the customer the experience they want. If they want home delivery, great. If they want to pick it up in the store, great. To answer your question, it's under 10% of the overall. I think the other thing, Rajat.
Rajat Gupta
analystUnderstood.
Bill Nash
executiveWhat I brought up — online sales — is that item. It's a somewhat novel approach, a fresh measure we discussed during this call. Clearly, more detail on these measures will come in May. Essentially, 5% of our customers completed the entire transaction online. As far as we're concerned, it makes no difference how they receive it, be that in the store or at home. That 5% should keep rising, in our expectation.
Rajat Gupta
analystUnderstood. I just want to raise this question — have you managed to get any read on the effect of the stimulus package, particularly the way it may have given March a boost? Do you have any sense of that, such as how much it might have contributed to your growth in March?
Bill Nash
executiveYes. Clearly, it is making a difference. Again, much like the weather and the delayed tax refunds, it's difficult to measure. What I think we're excited about is that you have various ranges, and this isn't an exact science, but our feeling is that the increase we're seeing goes beyond the stimulus. It goes beyond the weather rollover; it goes beyond the tax refund delay. It truly reflects all the investments we've been making across so many different fronts. That's what excites us.
Rajat Gupta
analystUnderstood, that helps. So regarding the SG&A line specifically, you mentioned higher investment. That overhead cost category went up sequentially. From what we gathered—based on remarks made during earlier earnings calls—there had been some permanent cuts in that area. So I'm just wondering how we ought to view that particular line item as we head into fiscal 2022 and past that. What sorts of investments are being made there? What portion is fixed as opposed to variable, and so on? Any additional detail on that would be genuinely useful.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYes. As we see it, right now is exactly the right moment to put money into expanding our business. That's the direction we've been pursuing. Within the industry and at CarMax, we've reached an inflection point. Our view is that now is the correct moment for investment. I think it also matters to acknowledge that the investments we're making are affecting our appraisal and wholesale operations too, and those are areas where we've directed a portion of our investment. We'll discuss that at the upcoming Analyst Day. We'll address how we view SG&A given these investments, which are truly growing several parts of our business, not only our used unit business. To respond to your question, I'd point specifically to the other line within SG&A. That is actually where a number of our strategic investments sit, and we anticipate that line rising. It has been offset during the last year and will keep being offset by the efficiency gains we achieve throughout the business and that we always concentrate on; that particular line item also maps to our strategic investments in technology.
Bill Nash
executiveRajat, one more thing I'd tack onto that. If our sole focus this year had been on making the omni-channel experience better and better, then from an SG&A perspective you'd have noticed the cost curve bending. As Enrique put it, right now is when we should keep putting money in, and that money is going into every area of the business. That's also the reason Enrique said you need to consider the two-year, five to eight in order to lever. I simply wanted to mention that too.
Rajat Gupta
analystUnderstood—that's really useful. If I may fit in one additional item regarding Edmunds: you described things as roughly neutral from an accretion perspective, factoring in the financing and the equity, as I understand it. Is there any way to frame just, say, gross profit or EBIT contribution stemming from the deal? Will you report that? Specifically, where would it land—or would it simply appear as a separate line item or similar? Any additional detail on that would be appreciated. Thank you. That's everything.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYes; we do expect to report Edmunds as an operating segment. You'll be able to see, certainly, their revenue—which we announced today, along with what their revenue was last year—as well as profitability. What I would say, though, is that if you step back from the impact—accretion or dilution—of the transaction, it's truly immaterial to CarMax. Near term, what I would say is that we anticipate generating a substantial amount of shareholder value from the acquisition, and we expect that to begin fairly soon as well. We've been working alongside Edmunds and the wonderful people there for more than the past year at this point. We are quite familiar with the benefits both sides can gain from our relationship. We chose to exercise our option and proceed with the full acquisition mainly because we've witnessed the advantages over the past year of our partnerships.
Rick Nelson
analystAppreciate you fielding my question. Solid results. Everyone's fairly aware of how tight things are on the new car side. What I'd like to know is how you expect that to play into your business, and do you have a sense of when new car inventories might get back to normal, and what that would mean once they do?
Bill Nash
executiveYes, Rick. Good morning. It's hard to predict how much longer new car supply will continue climbing; they're obviously wrestling with a significant chip shortage. My sense is that tighter supplies will stick around for some time. Still, I come back to points I made earlier — namely, that a substantial number of our vehicles come from our appraisal lane. The more of this we do, the greater the benefit to the company. We don’t depend on wholesale sources for our entire inventory, and I believe there’s ample supply available—you just have to put in a bit more effort. On top of that, since we purchase such a large volume through the appraisal channel, it doesn’t really affect our business much, except that it could push up the overall average selling price for everybody.
Rick Nelson
analystThank you. Good luck.
Bill Nash
executiveThanks, Rick.
Chris Bottiglieri
analystHi, thanks for taking my questions. For the first one, I'd like to dig a bit deeper into Tier 2 and Tier 3. Congratulations on securing that reduced Tier 3 fee — it never really made sense to begin with. Once we get out of this strange credit environment we're currently in, where losses are lower, right, yet unemployment is higher, if things revert to roughly pre-COVID patterns, do you think that fee structure change will hold? Is it permanent, or is it more that the piece was misunderstood — whether it's driven by the environment or continues indefinitely, will that $750 stick?
Jon Daniels
executiveYeah. Thanks for the question, Chris. It's difficult to say whether it will stick. Conditions are shifting a lot right now, and we're constantly searching for ways to make the platform better. It's definitely a favorable credit climate at the moment. Our lenders, I believe, are committed for the long term. They recognize the room for growth. We'll collaborate with them thoughtfully and evaluate whether the fee structure is right. We don't anticipate it swinging wildly from one quarter to the next. We'll monitor it closely. Once more, what I really want to emphasize is our arrangements with our partners. We have numerous partners involved. They deliver the quality deals that we can offer our customers through every kind of economy—strange ones and strong ones alike. Over the years they've been essential to the success we've achieved, and that includes Tier 3, a space we see as genuinely incremental business. We appreciate them, and we collaborate closely with them so that everyone comes out ahead on this platform and we're ready to grow. At this moment we feel really good about our platform.
Chris Bottiglieri
analystUnderstood. That's genuinely useful. My follow-up concerns the allowance. Clearly there's been a lot of noise this year owing to the loss environment we mentioned a moment ago and then CECL implementation. Could you help frame for us how we should think about the allowance? Say the world returns to normal, credit losses normalize, CECL remains in place. What would your allowance look like given the risk characteristics profile you're examining today? What's a normalized allowance for a typical cycle? What should that figure look like? Frankly, it's difficult to forecast.
Jon Daniels
executiveSure. Yeah. The metric I'd direct you to once more is reserve divided by receivables; it stands at 2.97% for this quarter, and remember it came down from 3.17% the prior quarter. Also remember that metric includes the Tier 1 allowance, the Tier 3 allowance, and the required recovery expense for CECL. I'd say we remain in what we regard as normal times. We've consistently cited 2%-2.5% for the Tier 1 business. Obviously, again, you have that Tier 3 and the recovery in there, but we're still above it. I'd direct you to that 2% — 2.5% for a Tier 1 business is probably where we'd expect to revert to once things return to normal.
Bill Nash
executiveAppreciate that, Carol. Well, we've gone through quite a bit today. A handful of key points. First, we're very positive about how the business is tracking and what fiscal 2022 holds for us; our view is that earlier investments, the ones we're making now, and our capacity to move fast on innovations such as the online appraisal and self-serve will produce an omnichannel experience and a value proposition that truly has no equal in the auto sector and will let us take a bigger slice of the market. The Edmunds acquisition has us energized, and we're eager to collaborate with that gifted team so that both businesses come out stronger. Last, I'm looking forward to our Analyst Day on May 6th, where we'll go a bit deeper into the business, talk through new metrics, and share our thinking on what lies ahead. I'd also like to pause and thank every one of our associates for what they've given; this past year was incredibly tough for everybody, and our associates did an outstanding job not just looking after one another and the customers but genuinely helping us push the company forward through innovation. I'm enormously proud of everything they've done, and I'm proud to be their colleague. And finally, to everyone listening on the call, we're grateful for your ongoing backing of CarMax, and we can't wait to speak with you once more at our Analyst Day on May 6th.
Operator
operatorThat wraps up the conference call for today, everyone. We appreciate your participation. You're free to disconnect at this time.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete CarMax, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to CarMax, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in CarMax, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.