CarMax, Inc. (KMX) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

June 25, 2021

New York Stock Exchange US Consumer Discretionary Specialty Retail earnings 48 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Stacy Frole

executive
#1

Thanks, Shelby. Morning, everyone. Appreciate you being on the call for our first quarter of fiscal '22 earnings conference. Joining me are Bill Nash, who serves as our President and CEO; Enrique Mayor-Mora, our Senior Vice President and CFO; and Jon Daniels, our Senior Vice President, CAF Operations. Just a reminder — anything we say today about future business plans, prospects and financial performance for the Company counts as forward-looking statements, made under the safe harbor provisions of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Those statements rest on what management currently knows and assumes about future events, and they carry risks and uncertainties that might make actual results differ materially from what we expect. When we give projections and other forward-looking statements, the Company disclaims any intent or obligation to update them. For more detail on important factors that could affect these expectations, please refer to the Company's Form 8-K issued this morning and its annual report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended February 28, 2021, filed with the SEC. If any follow-up questions come up after the call, feel free to reach our Investor Relations department at 804 to 747 to 0422 extension 7865. Finally, thanks ahead of time for limiting yourself to one question and then getting back in the queue for more follow-ups. Bill?

Bill Nash

executive
#2

Okay, thanks Stacy. Morning, everybody, and I appreciate you being here. You saw in this morning's earnings release that we turned in outstanding results for the first quarter — records on every front of the business: retail, wholesale, and auto finance — plus strong flow-through to EPS. What's driving that success is the headway we keep making on our digital transformation and the online experience, together with dependable execution and our sustained focus on keeping costs disciplined. On top of that, we got a lift from a demand environment that was already strong and was made even better by the latest round of government stimulus payments. In Q1 of FY '22, our diversified model produced $7.7 billion in sales, a 138% gain over the first quarter of FY '21, and net earnings per diluted share came to $2.63, which is $2.60 higher than a year earlier. Those figures also mark improvements of 43% and 65%, respectively, over the prior record, which was set in Q1 of FY '20. Through our retail and wholesale channels combined, we moved roughly 452,000 cars — 128% above the first quarter a year ago and 31% higher on a two-year basis versus Q1 of FY '20. We also acquired 236% more cars during this year's first quarter than we did last year, and 77% more than two years back. Many of you are aware that over the last several years, our investment priorities have centered on creating an unmatched experience through a leading e-commerce platform that dovetails seamlessly with our best-in-class in-store experience. What that has produced is a huge organizational transformation, one that involves constructing a comprehensive set of digital and hybrid processes so we can serve customers however they choose to engage with us. Our execution on this strategy has set us up for a very solid beginning to FY '22, and we stay confident in the long-term targets we announced at our recent Analyst Day: 2 million retail and wholesale combined units sold per year and $33 billion of revenue by FY '26. Turning to retail, total unit sales for the first quarter rose 101%, and used unit comps climbed 99%, both against the first quarter last year. Relative to Q1 of FY '20, total retail unit sales were 21% higher and same-store comps were up 16%. Beyond the strong unit sales, we posted $2,205 of retail gross profit per used unit for the quarter — $268 above a year ago and consistent with Q1 of FY '20. With demand for used autos so strong and inventory tight across the whole automotive industry, we stepped back from the expanded pricing test we rolled out in the fourth quarter; we'll keep watching macro factors and pricing elasticity, and we'll tweak our pricing as needed to get the most out of unit sales and profitability. On the wholesale side, units sold rose 187% versus last year's first quarter and were 50% higher than in Q1 of FY '20. For each wholesale vehicle sold, gross profit rose to $1,025, up from $978 during the equivalent stretch a year earlier, and it matched what we saw in Q1 of fiscal year '20. What powered that wholesale strength was mainly the launch of our instant online appraisal product, which went live across the country on carmax.com during February, following its debut on edmonds.com the prior year. On top of that, we gained from considerable price appreciation for used vehicles across the wider market. Income at CarMax Auto Finance, or CAF, came in at $242 million, so it kept producing dependable results. Beyond that, both CAF and the lenders we partner with achieved robust conversion across every credit tier. Jon is going to walk you through a few additional specifics on that shortly. Taking everything together, we feel very good about how we performed, though we recognize there is room to improve further. To illustrate, on the operations side, vehicles available to sell sat under our target amounts for the whole of Q1. Those reduced amounts stem from recent demand along with the short-term production deceleration caused by COVID and weather that hit us during Q4. Keep in mind that Q4 is when we build up production before the tax refund period, our busiest demand window. Our teams did a fantastic job getting inventory produced during Q1, and we anticipate inventory will keep growing as we bring on more production capacity at locations we already have. At this point, I'll hand things over to Enrique, who can tell you more about how we did financially in Q1, and after that Jon will offer further specifics regarding customer financing. So, Enrique?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#3

Thanks, Bill, and hello everybody. In addition to the strong gross profit improvements in retail and wholesale that Bill discussed, our other gross profits climbed to $142 million, which is $111 million more than what we saw in Q1 of last year. That increase was made up of EPP growth totaling $61 million, or 83%, mostly from higher retail sales and a penetration rate holding steady above 60%; service growth of $42 million, or 125%, which came from labor leverage due to our solid sales results and company support pay from the prior year; plus a $6 million, or 57%, gain in third-party finance fees, resulting from our renegotiated fee structure and changes in tier penetration, though this was partially offset by increased sales. Other gross profit came in $22 million higher, an 18% gain compared with the first quarter of fiscal year 2020. The increase was driven mostly by volume-related expansion in EPP along with savings from the third-party finance fees we renegotiated, though service deleverage partially offset those gains. On SG&A, first-quarter expenses climbed to $554 million, a 71% jump versus the same period last year, when COVID weighed on results. Thanks to strong first-quarter sales and careful cost control, we achieved solid leverage: SG&A equaled 59.9% of gross profit, an improvement from 91.7% in the first quarter of the prior year. On the SG&A side, the year-over-year dollar increase came primarily from three things. First, compensation and benefits were up $108 million — mostly because last year included COVID-related payroll cuts that we're now comping against — plus higher variable costs tied to greater volume and more headcount as we keep funding our growth initiatives. That pushed compensation leverage up 25.8 percentage points compared with a year ago. Second, advertising expense rose $38 million, reflecting the investment we told you about to amplify the CarMax brand, build awareness of our omni-channel offerings and drive customer acquisition. And this year's increase was also affected by the fact that last year's spend had been reduced because of the pandemic. On the marketing side, that added 1.9 percentage points compared with a year earlier. Other overhead rose by $79 million, which reflects the fact that the prior-year quarter included a $40 million benefit from the Takata settlement. We also kept funding our technology platforms and strategic initiatives, and we were up against pandemic-related cost cuts from last year. As a share of gross profit, SG&A came in around the same level as the first quarter of fiscal 2020. We're still focused on keeping our spending efficient, and we believe the specific areas we're targeting will keep producing gains as time goes on. Our CECs, for instance, set us apart in a meaningful way and represent an opportunity for us. During Q1, our CECs kept building on prior-year improvements in both efficiency and effectiveness, thanks to automation, algorithms driven by data, and intelligent routing that connects customers with the proper support. We have tremendous confidence about what's coming, given the strength and strong positioning of the operations we run today, along with the opportunities we perceive to extend our reach into the broader used-vehicle ecosystem; we're certain we can use the top position we occupy to win more market share and generate shareholder value across the long term. That belief guides our approach to deploying capital, and it's supported by the substantial cash flows generated by our diversified business model. To start, we remain dedicated to our foundational operations, investing heavily in the digital tools needed to improve our omni-channel experience, the acquisition of vehicles and customers, and the deliberate broadening of our store network. One thing that stood out during this quarter was the exceptionally robust return on investment we're seeing from acquiring vehicles, largely via our instant online appraisal products. Next, we'll put capital toward chasing fresh avenues for growth by way of investments, partnerships and acquisitions. Our purchase of Edmunds closed on June 1. We believe this deal will generate meaningful shareholder value as time goes on. Also worth flagging on the P&L for this quarter, other income rose $29 million versus the comparable period a year ago, mostly driven by a $22 million unrealized gain tied to an investment. As we've mentioned previously, we hold a collection of fairly small stakes throughout the used auto ecosystem. Last, we'll keep sending surplus capital back to those who own our shares. Over the quarter, we bought back roughly 1 million shares, spending $125 million; $1.21 billion is still available under existing authorizations. At this point I'd like to hand things over to Jon.

Jon Daniels

executive
#4

Appreciate that, Enrique, and morning to everyone. The finance segment, once again, has turned in exceptional performance. CAF's penetration for Q1, after subtracting free-day payoffs, came in at 43.7%, versus 36.1% during the same period last year. As a share of used unit sales, Tier 2 fell to 22.8%, down from 28.5% a year earlier. Tier 3 made up 10%, compared with 14.5% in the prior-year period. As you'll remember, back in Q1 of FY '21, when the pandemic was just starting, we drew on our long-standing partnerships and directed part of CAF's Tier 1 volume, along with the entire allocated Tier 3 volume, toward our Tier 2 and Tier 3 partners — which largely accounts for the tier-mix shift we're seeing year over year. Keep in mind, that step was taken as a short-term measure, and it held down CAF's origination volume while safeguarding the portfolio's strong quality. By the close of Q2 last year, our routing procedures were back to normal. In Q1, CAF originated $2.5 billion in net loans — the biggest single origination quarter ever for CAF, and the first time a quarter has exceeded $2 billion. New customers were charged a weighted average contract rate of 9%, which is above the 8.4% of a year ago and the 8.5% recorded in Q4. Much like Q4, this year-over-year APR gap stems from the credit mix of customers, not from any higher rate being charged. Turning to the portfolio: the overall interest margin rose to 6.9%, versus 5.9% in last year's comparable period, as the strength of our ABS program keeps producing meaningful benefits through reduced funding costs. CAF income for the quarter reached $242 million, an increase from $51 million a year ago. This large year-over-year gain reflects a considerable reduction in the required provision for loan losses, a stronger net interest margin, and higher receivables. Total interest margin for the quarter grew by $47 million, or 24%, powered by origination growth and a lower cost of funds; on the loan loss provision side, Q1 brought $7.2 million in net credit loss, equal to 21 basis points of average managed receivables. Measured as a share of the portfolio, that's the smallest reported loss in more than 20 years. The resulting favorability relative to what we had expected, together with the matching adjustment to our outlook for future losses, produced $24 million of income tied to the provision in Q1; compare that with a $122 million provision expense in the same period a year ago; this reserve release left us with an ending reserve balance of $380 million for Q1, or 2.62% of managed receivables — down from 2.97% at the close of Q4. Our reserve as a percentage of managed receivables keeps trending lower toward more historical levels, since our customers stay steadfast in their willingness and ability to make their auto payment even with the environment's uncertainty. We think the modification we've just made properly reflects the favorable loss results recorded across the last 4 quarters, and it fits the present macroeconomic conditions. And as noted earlier, CAF raised the share of its Tier 3 volume to 10% by the close of Q1. Within that quarter, this change had only a slight effect on the reserve, yet with the larger volume steadily entering the portfolio in the quarters ahead, we anticipate that income and the provision will rise in line. On the question of where CAF will sit in the credit spectrum going forward, we will, as we always do, keep assessing the lending environment and will weigh further modifications whenever we judge such shifts to be lasting and aligned with the best interests of our long-term business objectives. I'll now hand the call back to Bill.

Bill Nash

executive
#5

Thank you, Jon and Enrique. During our Analyst Day back in May, I mentioned how proud we are of what our teams have accomplished in getting CarMax to the strong position we enjoy now, and the huge opportunities that lie before us have us genuinely thrilled. The investments we've made across multiple years in the omni-channel experience have made our offering even better — it's now the most customer-focused experience in the pre-owned auto sector. We don't concern ourselves with the channel our customers choose for shopping and purchasing, since we're set up to deliver a top-tier buying experience to everyone no matter how they engage with us; that in turn opens the door to the biggest addressable market in the country; roughly 8% of our retail unit sales during the first quarter happened online. Keep in mind that we count a sale as an online retail sale when the customer handles all four of the key transactional steps remotely — that means putting a reserve on the vehicle; arranging financing for it, when required, choosing to trade in a vehicle or deciding against a trade-in; and generating a sales order. Since every one of our wholesale auctions went virtual during this quarter, all wholesale sales — amounting to 18% of total revenue — qualify as online transactions. Consequently, 24% of total revenue in the first quarter came from online transactions. Omni sales accounted for roughly 56% of retail unit sales, which is up from 51% in the prior quarter. To reiterate, omni sales are retail sales in which the customer completes at least one of those key transactional steps remotely, and although every one of our customers is able to purchase a car online with help, our focus has been on delivering a fully self-service experience. Right now, 40% of our retail customers are able to complete an online sale on their own, compared with 25% at the close of the fourth quarter; we anticipate making this capability available to the majority of customers by the time the second quarter ends. We keep using digital innovations to fuel growth through our online instant appraisal offerings, where a customer can get an online offer for their car in under two minutes and receive payment that same day. During the first quarter, we purchased roughly 163,000 vehicles via these online offerings, accounting for 48% of all the vehicles we buy from consumers. And after the nationwide rollout at the end of last quarter, we believe we've grown into the biggest online purchaser of used autos from consumers within the U.S. That's a major competitive edge that lets us source vehicles efficiently, particularly when demand is high, which helps us stay competitively priced while generating appealing GPUs; on the retail side, we're speeding up our online experience by enhancing our finance approval and flow process. We're simplifying things by letting customers request card transfers and then handle and monitor those transfers entirely online. And we're giving our customers more power by supplying financing details across our full inventory as the very first step in their shopping journey. This leaves our customers feeling more confident that they can afford whatever vehicle they pick out. When it comes to broadening our reach and making the digital side of what we offer even better, we have to keep reminding people about the new things CarMax can do and why those things matter to shoppers. Ever since we rolled out the new brand campaign along with the Love Your Car Guarantee at the close of last year, awareness of our omni-channel approach has climbed significantly, with traffic on the web and Google search volume both still rising. Consumer and dealer adoption of digital keeps climbing, so we will continue to add to what we have invested in omni, in our proprietary technology stack, and in the solid reputation of our brand, so that growth in our core businesses is maximized. Beyond that, we are chasing further chances to grow within the wider used auto ecosystem, which is worth more than a trillion dollars, drawing on our capabilities and our industry strength. Enrique already noted that we just finished buying Edmunds, which stands among the best-known and most trusted online sources for automotive information and is a acknowledged innovator in digital car shopping. Through Edmunds we get closer to a wider group of consumers, and closer to dealers as well. Our teams could not be more thrilled and are still working together on new products that will serve Edmunds dealer partners and consumers; the opportunity we see is tremendous, and once we bring new offerings to market more widely, we will share updates. To sum up, this quarter was genuinely outstanding, and we could not be more enthusiastic about what lies ahead. What our results show is strong, disciplined execution throughout our diversified business model, and they further confirm that our strategies can enable sustainable growth and significant long-term shareholder value creation. Our attention stays on improving our online capabilities so we can provide the market's most customer-centric offering. We will keep speeding up our growth and our market share gains while also preparing the ground for initiatives and growth opportunities to come. At this point we are glad to take your questions. Shelby?

Craig Kennison

analyst
#6

Morning, and thanks for the opportunity to ask. Nice work on the wholesale momentum. I'd like to ask about the GPU. Did you say you scaled back the GPU experiment while the market was hot? Once things settle down, will you return to experimenting?

Bill Nash

executive
#7

Yeah, that's a good one. So indeed, we halted it. And if you recall, during the fourth quarter, last quarter, I mentioned that we'd keep watching those macro factors; and while tracking them, particularly the inventory constraints and elasticity, it just wasn't logical to keep going with it. Like I said in my opening remarks, we'll keep an eye on those macro factors, and we're quite willing to keep trying various approaches with pricing. Honestly, at this moment, I'd probably say we won't do it, but we'll hold that option as the quarter moves along. Regardless, we can deliver excellent GPUs priced above $2,000.

Sharon Zackfia

analyst
#8

Morning, everyone. Apologies if this already came up, but could you share the breakdown of where your customer sourcing came from on the retail side during the quarter? Then, when it comes to purchases made online, which clearly have grown very fast, how does the GPU on those online appraisals stack up against appraisals done in person? Do the two look pretty comparable, or is there a gap that might shrink down the road?

Bill Nash

executive
#9

Excellent question. When I look at all the buys we made from consumers, the mix runs roughly 50 to 50 between retail and wholesale. That holds whether you're thinking about the usual situation of a customer walking into a store and getting an appraisal, and it's also quite close to what we see with online purchases. On the question of how productive an online purchase is relative to a traditional in-store appraisal, both perform very well and are quite alike, which once more is a big plus when it comes to sourcing inventory and being able to handle GPUs, pricing, and so on.

John Murphy

analyst
#10

Maybe I could ask something brief as a follow-up about supply buildup. You bought 341,000 cars from customers in the quarter. That's close to — I think one quarter in your history had 345,000 vehicles total. So you basically acquired almost as many as your all-time peak for selling. I'm curious what's going on with your ability to purchase straight from the consumer. And on the supply side, from consumers and auctions too, when do you think things will loosen up more naturally? I mean, you've got bizarre situations out there — like Davis and Hertz showing up at auctions to buy cars, when historically they've been the ones supplying and selling them, right? So there's definitely some strange activity going on when it comes to supply. How much room is there to grow when it comes to sourcing vehicles straight from consumers? How big a role is that going to play going forward? And beyond that, at what point does supply — which is completely out of whack at the moment — get back to normal, both in terms of flow and overall availability?

Bill Nash

executive
#11

Yeah, so John, it's clear that purchasing directly from consumers has become a key priority. I've talked about the investments we're making in that space. And what you're seeing now, I'd say, is that effort really starting to pay off. Take, for instance, the more than 340,000 vehicles we bought from consumers — that's a 236% increase, and it's 77% higher than FY '20. That's genuinely extraordinary. A major part of this, clearly, is simply that our online offering gives us easier access to consumers. But we're also encouraged by the traditional side, with new customers visiting the store and getting appraisals done that way. So we feel good about both. The supply side is interesting. There are some unusual things you brought up there. But I'll go back to what I said in the fourth quarter: supply has not been an issue for us. Right now, the amount of inventory we can sell is definitely below our target. But when you consider all inventory, supply is actually right around FY '20 levels. So it's really a production issue more than anything. And with the online option plus the traditional appraisal lane, we don't need as much outside supply from those other channels. As for how long this lasts — yes, there are definitely some supply pressures, since different players are doing different things. You've also got demand from new car buyers who might be shifting to used cars. My guess is that only time will reveal the answer. I don't believe the new car situation will resolve within the coming one or two quarters; my sense is that we're aiming more toward the later months of the year. As a result, I don't expect much movement on supply across the next few quarters. Still, availability remains a non-issue — a substantial number of vehicles keep changing hands in the marketplace. It may be that buying outside of a dealership location demands somewhat more work from you. All the same, when it comes to our total inventory situation, we feel quite confident.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#12

Absolutely, John. What I'd tell you is that the 163,000 vehicles we acquired via our instant online offers genuinely went beyond what we had anticipated. Customers have responded to it extremely positively, and I believe it's a strong illustration of the money we've been putting into innovation to keep ourselves top of mind with consumers. And once more, that's 163,000 cars through our online offer. And honestly, we only launched that product a quarter ago. So that performance has us really, really happy.

John Murphy

analyst
#13

Is it possible for that to push the number of consumer source vehicles far beyond 50%? In other words, is that where you're going? I'd just like to know what that goal could be.

Bill Nash

executive
#14

Yes. Look, we aim to push that goal as high as we can. In the past — over the last several years, we've stayed within a range of 35% to 45%; for this quarter we're already above it; for this quarter we're between 45% and 50%. And I think, once again, our objective is to push that as high as we can; and what we're seeing makes us very, very encouraged.

Michael Montani

analyst
#15

I'd like to hear whatever perspective you folks might offer regarding how pricing looks, on the wholesale side and on the retail side too? And what are you picking up on lately when we talk with Manheim? From what I gather, they may have just hit a turning point where prices are at minimum beginning to ease. So I would really appreciate any additional insight you folks can share; and second, assuming we do witness some easing, what would that mean for the company, for both retail and wholesale?

Bill Nash

executive
#16

Yes. Good morning, Michael, yes, that's an excellent question. You've tracked us for a long enough stretch to understand that this pricing backdrop is genuinely — it's genuinely unlike anything we've seen before. Consider the period from January through today, the $5,000 to $6,000 of appreciation that has shown up, that is truly extraordinary. Our average selling prices climbed by a couple of thousand dollars. On the acquisition side, they're in fact up somewhat more than that, though that was partly offset by mix and age. I do believe we're approaching a turning point. When you examine the consumer price index and the spread between new vehicles and late-model used vehicles, that gap has certainly gotten smaller. Although new cars are rising, they haven't risen at the speed of used cars. And that's fairly self-correcting and arrives at a point where, okay, late model used cars are pressing right up against the new car. And I believe we're nearing that turning point. And I believe that's I believe a good thing because clearly, as the gap shrinks, it becomes a headwind for used car purchases. When the gap grows, the spread between used and new, that's a wonderful thing for used car sales. So I believe that's a favorable development.

Brian Nagel

analyst
#17

Great quarter, congrats. My question ties closely to the one just before, specifically on pricing, Bill. We've all discussed — we've all heard about this, you could say, extraordinary pricing situation in used cars. So what I'm wondering is, when we examine these results across the different areas of the business, did pricing act as a tailwind or a headwind for CarMax? And this also builds on the earlier question. How should we view this moving forward for the rest of the year?

Bill Nash

executive
#18

Yeah. Typically, that kind of pricing situation would work against the used car sector overall. What I believe made this quarter different is that since new cars weren't readily available, it drove shoppers toward used vehicles, and that contributed to pushing used car prices higher; so it's genuinely — it's tough to separate those elements. Many factors are at play, given that you now have new buyers entering. You also have the stimulus that's boosting demand. So, I think the usual — what you'd typically expect from really steep increases in used car prices, it's difficult. I don't believe it was the same — it carried the same elasticity impact you'd ordinarily expect; going forward, without some of that stimulus present, I think typical elasticity and pricing will begin to come back. And returning to Michael's point, if this inflection point has started to decline, I believe that's a positive.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#19

Right. And I'd add that the variety built into how we operate lets us do well no matter what conditions look like. So even if pricing works against us in one way, it works in our favor elsewhere in the company. You can see that play out in what we reported, and you can see it shift from one quarter to the next in what we reported — that variety simply has no match anywhere else in the sector.

Bill Nash

executive
#20

Right. And I believe there's another factor in play here — look, we've been at this for so long that it doesn't matter if you're seeing quick appreciation or quick depreciation. The way we handle our inventory, the way we purchase the data we use and the technology we use — I think that's definitely a competitive advantage.

Rick Nelson

analyst
#21

Thank you; therefore, we observed the reserve reversal during this quarter, with the allowance presently sitting at 2.62% of receivables. In the past, I think that figure was closer to the 2% to 2.5% range for Tier 1. I suppose how ought we to consider that allowance account and the possibility of additional reversals?

Bill Nash

executive
#22

Yeah. Thanks for asking that, Rick. Yeah, exactly right, 2.62% represents our reserve as a proportion of receivables at this moment. And that's correct. In prior periods, we stayed within 2% to 2.5%, which is our intended range for the Tier 1 portfolio. But keep in mind that 2.62% includes both Tier 1 and Tier 3 within it; therefore, if you removed that, you'd notice that we truly are inside the operating range we mentioned before; and we've moved down favorably since then. I believe it's quite a significant shift we've achieved from the close of Q4 until now. And clearly, that mirrors the excellent performance witnessed during the quarter. Thus, looking ahead, we believe 2.62% is a very strong figure for us covering both the Tier 1 and Tier 3 portfolio, and we'll monitor how the customer does going forward.

John Healy

analyst
#23

I'd like to dig a bit into the SG&A numbers. You've mentioned a range of investments, I know, and obviously those are delivering results at the moment; but I was hoping to hear your take on the more traditional advertising campaigns you've rolled out? You've done the NBA stuff, plus some new TV spots and, I believe, radio ads. What's your feeling on that spending? Does it still work as well as it used to? Are you pleased with it at present? And do you expect it to remain a major piece of SG&A as we head into next year? Or should we anticipate some recalibration there?

Bill Nash

executive
#24

Sure, John. Let me begin by addressing how well the ad spend is working. First off, we're very pleased with the results. Ad spending during the quarter actually came in below the guidance we had outlined for this year, and I see that purely as a timing issue; we remain dedicated to advertising in a way that delivers thoughtful ROI. As for what we've been up to, I can tell you we achieved a record. The typical number of visits to our site this quarter reached 34.5 million, a sharp increase over any previous high. Web traffic has grown about 60% compared with a year ago, or 40% measured against FY '20. Google searches have risen by double digits. We're really pleased with the fresh initiatives we've launched and the way we're taking that omni-channel experience out to shoppers. That said, let me be clear: this won't be resolved in a single quarter. We have to keep pushing on it, and we're dedicated to putting more money behind it. Enrique, is there anything else you'd like to add regarding SG&A?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#25

Indeed, without a doubt. When it comes to advertising, we shared during the prior quarter as well as at our Analyst Day that our plan is to increase our outlay. What we indicated was that our per-unit expenditure this year will be roughly equivalent to what we laid out during the latter half of the previous year, which represented a step-up in costs; so when you examine that figure and set it beside where we were 2 years back, in FY '20, definitely a year that was more typical. We are anticipating a rise exceeding 40% on a per-unit basis when it comes to our advertising expenses, and that aligns with what we've already told you. However, simply to provide a bit of background and a way of thinking about how we view the significance — and even more crucially, the returns we are realizing from the money we put into advertising.

Rajat Gupta

analyst
#26

Nice work on that impressive sprint. One thing I wanted to ask — earlier you said something about pricing getting to a point where it might be beginning to have some effect on demand. Can you share some detail on how things moved during the quarter — March, April, May — for the pound against the 2019 level? And any insight into how the first three or four weeks of June have looked would also be useful.

Bill Nash

executive
#27

Sure, Rajat; overall we're happy with the entire quarter. When we look back at FY '20, keep in mind that Q1 of FY '20 had a 9.5% comp, and now we're comping 16% on top of that. Every month of the quarter showed strong growth. On the previous call I noted that March set a new record for us. April also set a record as far as April goes. May likewise set a record for May. So we're quite happy with that strong performance across the board. And we're quite happy with how things look as we head into the new quarter. Honestly, I'm looking forward to reaching the second quarter, because if you recall, last year we posted a positive comp in Q2; and I'll knock on wood that we won't need to keep referring back to FY '20, since there are so many figures to keep straight. We'll definitely discuss that quarter more once the second quarter wraps up, but we feel terrific about how this quarter began.

Scot Ciccarelli

analyst
#28

Morning, everyone. This is Scot Ciccarelli. With what we're witnessing right now in the pre-owned car sector — clearly, that segment is extremely hot — and you took a more aggressive stance on buying vehicles. Is it possible to trim your reconditioning timeline even more to boost throughput, or perhaps increase daily capacity? Because, Bill, as I hear you describe things, it seems like your internal production capacity might have constrained some of the inventory you could offer, and therefore your sales results.

Bill Nash

executive
#29

Yeah. No, Scot, that's exactly correct. What I'd say is our current inventory position — clearly, throughout the entire quarter we sat under target, and we're likely 40% beneath the level we'd prefer. In an ordinary setting, holding that much less inventory is definitely a drag. My view is that it was a drag. I don't believe it behaved according to the typical elasticity you'd expect, simply because of everything else happening across the broader market; however, production is truly the core issue. Typically we build in advance to be prepared; that wasn't possible for us. Our operations team is performing incredibly well. We're bringing on extra capacity within those same facilities; therefore, I'd anticipate that figure continuing to rise. One thing I've mentioned before regarding efficiency, as we aim to remove waste from the process, is flow production — that's one of the key things we've concentrated on; and we've in fact just completed the rollout of essentially the following iteration of it; and we'd anticipate achieving greater throughput using our current facilities and resources; so that's something we're enthusiastic about, and it will keep benefiting us. Beyond that, naturally, in order to reach our longer-term objectives, we'll bring on more capacity moving ahead. That said, yes, I believe it's completely reasonable to describe inventory as a drag on us. And the supply side isn't the issue. It leans more toward production. And once more, I can't praise our operations team enough, since they haven't just been keeping pace with that demand — they're expanding on it. And if you've been tracking your inventory lately, you've noticed we're beginning to build it back up.

Scot Ciccarelli

analyst
#30

So what's the duration required right now to recondition what you'd describe as a typical vehicle? And how much better might that get down the road? For instance, is a meaningful chunk of time removable? Or are you basically already near the point where things are as efficient as they can be?

Bill Nash

executive
#31

No, my view is there's room for further optimization when you talk about a conventional car. Keep in mind, the blend of vehicles matters too. Older ones require somewhat more time compared with newer ones. I'd say we're likely — if I consider the entire picture — what you're getting at is really cycle time. Cycle time, and remember, that refers to the period before the car is set to be worked on. You must wait on parts and everything along those lines. When you consider cycle time, it's likely — it falls somewhere from 5 to 10 days, and that varies by vehicle; of course, certain vehicles need far less than that. And clearly we have stages in production that get tracked in minutes. But my belief is this represents a chance for improvement. My sense is this is something we already, thanks to our new flow production system. I believe we're already beginning to see greater throughput, which is excellent.

Chris Bottiglieri

analyst
#32

Thanks for taking my question. Solid quarter. I wanted to ask briefly about GPU; so, it seems as though you reduced spending on pricing, the blend of where customers are coming from is the highest I have ever witnessed; it seems as though pricing on used vehicles provided a boost to GPUs. I'm not sure whether that's accurate or whether you could verify it. But did anything work against that, such as does it simply require effort to recondition vehicles in this environment, or anything else that might offset a portion of those GPU benefits that you could discuss?

Bill Nash

executive
#33

Well, to begin with, on our end, used car pricing isn't really a boost to GPU. How costly a vehicle is doesn't govern how we handle our margin. Many other variables come into play. So that isn't really a boost for us the way it possibly is for certain other companies. I believe looking ahead, achieving — pushing greater self-sufficiency will definitely be a boost for us. And I have consistently stated that we have — our pricing is extremely competitive. And I would say, I believe our pricing is more competitive than it has ever been at this moment; so I feel wonderful about where we are headed. I feel wonderful about our pricing. I feel wonderful about the adaptability we possess to not only deliver world-class GPU per car for retail car, but also to accomplish that in a manner where our pricing is extremely, extremely competitive.

Seth Basham

analyst
#34

Much appreciated, and good morning. I'd like to ask about the proportion of sales made over the internet — 8% in this quarter compared with 5% in the prior one. Is the only reason the fact that more customers now qualify to complete purchases fully online? Or do other elements play a part? And once eligibility reaches 100% rollout, should we anticipate that figure rising to somewhere near 20%?

Bill Nash

executive
#35

Right. So the move from 5% to 8% came about because of expanding into new geographies plus a few extra capabilities. My expectation is that this figure will keep climbing. Like I mentioned, we've seen some solid progress; and in fact — my apologies, your question concerns the overall online total, not merely self-serve. So for self-serve — what I mean is, online climbed from 25% to 40%. And my expectation is that this figure will keep climbing as we introduce further capabilities down the road. And regarding the segments we're concentrating on, I believe the main thing that will keep pushing adoption forward will be, once again, bringing in additional self-service features; so with that in mind, what we're concentrating on is making transfers and trade-ins somewhat simpler and more seamless.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#36

We definitely anticipate that the share of sales and the share of revenues coming from online will rise. Yet at the same time, what's great about our business model is that it truly rests with the consumer and with omni, correct? So if the consumer wishes to purchase online, that's available to them, and increasingly so. If they prefer to walk into the store and shop in that manner, that's available to them too. We anticipate those figures will climb. But once more, it's genuinely going to be shaped by the consumers and how they choose to engage with us, whether that's in-store or online.

Seth Basham

analyst
#37

Understood. And when it comes to total gross profit for each unit, for each vehicle bought completely over the internet compared with via the stores — how do those stack up currently?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#38

Roughly comparable, roughly comparable.

Bill Nash

executive
#39

Yes.

David Whiston

analyst
#40

Thank you. Morning to you. Honestly, regarding the Edmunds purchase, I remain not entirely sure what the reasoning behind it is. I recognize the advantages of vertical integration, I believe, in buying and selling. But — meanwhile, some CarMax rivals are compensating them for generating leads. So how do you guarantee they still receive equitable treatment, since otherwise they won't be interested in working with Edmunds while CarMax enjoys favored status? Could you clarify how this fits together for me?

Bill Nash

executive
#41

Yes. Once more, both teams and we are delighted to have closed the deal. Keep in mind, they represent that top-tier name in automotive research. Our plan is to keep running them as an independent brand and an independent business. We're eager to partner with them to keep expanding the offerings for their shoppers, their dealers, and their OEM allies; we'll put money into their brand, yet we're also eager about the teams carrying on their joint work and making headway on initiatives that serve both firms, and instant offers is a prime illustration. We built that alongside them, first launched it on Edmunds, and afterward we made it available on carmax.com. We believe there's plenty of potential remaining there, and we believe there's plenty of potential in content. Thus, I consider it crucial that we maintain the Company as a distinct entity, and we go on ensuring they keep delivering value to their own customers. And I believe we're capable of doing both. And as we keep creating things cooperatively that advantage both firms, we'll keep bringing attention to those down the road.

David Whiston

analyst
#42

All right. And are you able to reveal which investment generated that gain?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#43

No, we don't typically discuss — we do have — like I said, we hold a collection of fairly small stakes throughout the pre-owned vehicle sector, mainly strategic in nature so that we stay informed and aware of developments in that area. So we simply recorded an unusually large gain during this quarter from one of those holdings, though we don't actually reveal the names of the businesses we put money into.

Bill Nash

executive
#44

Okay, thanks, Shelby. I think it's clear from what we've said that the first quarter results have us very happy, and we're genuinely enthusiastic about what lies ahead. It's not only the possibilities created by owning the biggest total addressable market in used auto retail, but also what's available across our other core businesses. Take wholesale, take CAF, and then further out into the broader auto ecosystem. Everything rests on an enormous transformation — our omni-channel experiences, our proprietary tech stack, data, or the other offerings we discussed on today's call. Thank you for the questions today. Thank you for sticking with us; and as I always do, I want to thank our associates for continuing to devote themselves to living our values, looking after one another, and looking after our customers and communities. They really are what makes CarMax succeed; so we're eager for CarMax to keep succeeding. So we're eager to speak with you again next quarter. Thanks for your time.

Operator

operator
#45

Everyone, that wraps up the call for today. We appreciate you joining us. You're free to hang up at this point.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete CarMax, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to CarMax, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in CarMax, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.