CarMax, Inc. (KMX) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

December 22, 2021

New York Stock Exchange US Consumer Discretionary Specialty Retail earnings 52 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

David Lowenstein

executive
#1

Thank you, Jerome. Good morning, everyone, and thanks for being on the call for our fiscal 2022 third quarter earnings conference. Joining me today are Bill Nash, who serves as our President and CEO, Enrique Mayor-Mora, our Senior Vice President and CFO, and Jon Daniels, our Senior Vice President, CAF Operations. I want to remind everyone that anything we say today about future business plans, prospects, and financial performance for the company constitutes forward-looking statements made under the Safe Harbor provisions of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995; those statements rest on management's current knowledge and assumptions regarding future events, and they carry risks and uncertainties that might cause actual results to differ materially from what we expect; when we provide projections and other forward-looking statements, the company disclaims any intent or obligation to update them; for more detail on important factors that could affect these expectations, please refer to the company's Form 8-K issued this morning along with its annual report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended February 28th, 2021, filed with the SEC. If any follow-up questions come up after the call, don't hesitate to reach our investor relations department at 804 to 747 to 0422 extension 7865. Finally, I'd like to thank you ahead of time for limiting yourselves to one question and then rejoining the queue for additional follow-ups. Bill?

Bill Nash

executive
#2

Alright, thanks, David. Morning, everybody, and I appreciate you being here. We feel really good about this quarter. For Q3, we hit records in used sales, wholesale sales, and EPS. On top of that, we achieved all-time high margins in used and in wholesale. During the third quarter of FY 2022, our diversified business model generated $8.5 billion in total sales, which is a 64% increase over Q3 of FY 2021, powered by both higher average selling prices and greater volume. Diluted net earnings per share came to $1.63, a 15% gain versus the prior year. Through our retail and wholesale channels combined, we moved roughly 415,000 vehicles, which is 29% higher than Q3 last year. Over the first nine months of FY 2022, we sold about 1.3 million retail and wholesale vehicles combined, setting records in every single month. We remain the biggest purchaser of cars from consumers. During Q3, we acquired around 383,000 vehicles from consumers, marking a 91% jump versus last year. Once again, self-sufficiency came in above 70%. Our customer-centric omni-channel approach, strong execution, and macro conditions are fueling results throughout the company. In retail, total unit sales for Q3 rose 16.9%, while used unit comps increased 15.8% compared with Q3 last year. Demand was robust as we increased staffing levels and grew inventory. CAF and our credit partners also helped drive sales by keeping strong credit offers coming even as our average sales price climbed by more than 30% year-over-year; we saw sequential growth in saleable inventory each month during the quarter. Although inventory and staffing are still under our targets, we're happy with our momentum and feel confident we can access the resources necessary to grow inventory before tax season, though the pace will be dictated by retail demand. Beyond strong unit sales, we posted record retail gross profit per used unit of $2,235, an $84 per unit increase versus Q3 last year; with used car prices at all-time highs, we opted to pass most of the acquisition cost savings from self-sufficiency to consumers through lower prices. We think we found the right balance between raising our margins and helping our customers during a period of elevated industry prices. Wholesale units climbed 48.5% from Q3 last year, and gross profit per unit set an all-time record of $1,131 versus $906 a year ago. The wholesale unit strength came mainly from the continued success of our instant online appraisal offering; we also gained from still elevated used auto valuations in the broader market. CarMax Auto Finance, or CAF, produced income of $166 million, down from $176 million in the same period last year. CAF margins stayed strong. The year-over-year financial results took a $68 million hit from a reserve adjustment. Just to note, the prior-year quarter got a lift from a smaller provision as we came out of the pandemic, while the current quarter shows a provision that's back to a more typical level. Across every credit tier, CAF along with our partner lenders came through with solid offers; shortly, Jon will go deeper on customer financing and what CAF contributed, plus how the auto loan receivable systems conversion affected things. At this point, I want to hand things to Enrique, who'll share further details about our financial performance in the third quarter. Enrique?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#3

Appreciate that, Bill, and hello everyone. All told, gross profit landed at $837 million — up 32% compared with the record third quarter we turned in twelve months earlier. What powered it: wholesale vehicle margin hit $212 million, an 85% jump, while used vehicle margin came to $508 million, climbing 21% against last year's third quarter. Other gross profit finished at $116 million, gaining 18% over the same period a year ago. Among the tailwinds this quarter was $20 million in margin contribution from Edmunds. On top of that, other gross profit benefited as third-party finance fees improved by $12 million, yielding $1.6 million of income instead of the $10.6 million cost recorded a year earlier. Renegotiated third-party finance fees and reduced tier three volume relative to last year drove that result. On the positive side for other gross profit as well, EPP rose $5 million, or 4.8%. Penetration held steady at approximately 60%, though this year's third quarter includes a $6 million unfavorable return reserve adjustment, whereas the prior year's quarter had a $3 million favorable return reserve adjustment. Partly offsetting the gross profit favorability, service declined $21 million from the prior year's quarter. Pressure tied mainly to our efforts to grow technician staffing drove this, along with a shift of some retail service capacity toward supporting used car reconditioning. Across all three months of the quarter, service gross profit improved relative to the same period a year earlier, and we anticipate further gains as we head into Q4. Now for SG&A: expenses for the third quarter climbed to $576 million, which is 34% higher than the comparable quarter last year, driven by costs associated with growing unit volume as well as continued spending on our strategic initiatives. Measured as a share of gross profit, SG&A came in essentially unchanged — 68.8%, compared with 68.2% during last year's third quarter. The rise in SG&A dollars versus a year ago was mainly the result of three factors. To start, overall pay and benefits climbed by $100 million. That came mostly from a big jump in hiring, a $23 million bump in stock-based compensation, commissions tied to unit volume, and the fact that Edmunds payroll now sits in this quarter whereas it didn't a year earlier. Next, other overhead went up by $22 million, and that figure factors in a $23 million settlement we received from a class action lawsuit. Beyond that, the remaining shift largely comes down to money we're putting into moving our technology platforms and strategic initiatives forward, along with the effect of COVID-related savings we had booked in the same quarter last year. And third, as we'd already flagged, advertising expense grew by $17 million in order to bring in more customers and to strengthen the CarMax brand by further raising awareness of what we offer across omni-channel. During the opening three quarters of fiscal 2022, selling, general and administrative expenses represented 66.1% of gross profit, an improvement of roughly 3 points compared with the 68.9% recorded across the same nine-month stretch a year earlier. Our dedication to spending both efficiently and effectively hasn't wavered, and we anticipate that the specific areas we've chosen to prioritize will keep producing results as time goes on. Turning to Q3, when it comes to operational execution and productivity, our CECs achieved substantial improvements in service levels and in converting web leads into sales. That happened even with the record volume our CECs took on during Q3; the gain came from a mix of successful staffing ramps plus continued use of our AI and machine learning processes, which route the right work to the right associates; we're also still seeing efficiency benefits within our buying organization. Together, our instant offer program and the investments we've made in data science, automation, and AI keep materially pushing down our costs per buy. On the capital structure side, we closed the quarter with an adjusted debt-to-capital ratio sitting in the middle of our targeted range of 35%-45%. In the quarter, we signed a $700 million term loan agreement, mainly to support growth in our total inventory dollars. On the buyback side, we remain dedicated to giving back capital beyond what the business needs, and in the quarter we repurchased around 850,000 shares, spending about $115 million. With that, I'll turn things over to Jon.

Jon Daniels

executive
#4

Thanks, Enrique, and good morning, everyone. The finance side of our business has delivered solid results once again. For Q3, penetration net of CAF was 42.2%, compared with 45.7% during the same period last year. Tier Two climbed to 22.2% of used unit sales, an increase from 19.5% twelve months ago. Tier Three accounted for 6.5% of sales, against 9.7% in the year-ago quarter. The change in CAF penetration year over year stemmed from a larger portion of shoppers paying with cash or loans from outside sources to purchase their vehicles, along with CAF comparing against an unusually high penetration level in Q3 of FY 2021. We continue to observe attractive credit offers from our tier two partners as they seek more volume within the CarMax channel. The movement of volume from tier two into tier three resulted from those offers plus reduced application counts among consumers with lower credit scores. For shoppers at every credit level, CarMax continues to provide exceptional access to financing. Even with loan amounts up about 25% versus the comparable stretch of 2020, our approval rates remained above 95% during the quarter; being able to keep up such a robust credit offering demonstrates what our multi-lender credit platform—backed by CAF and our long-standing finance partners—is worth. During the third quarter of this year, fueled by record used unit sales, net loans originated by CAF reached almost $2.4 billion. For new customers, the average contract rate we charged — weighted — came to 8.3%. That's lower than the 8.6% we saw a year back, and also below the 8.5% recorded in the second quarter. What's behind the APR gap? Mostly it comes down to a shift in the credit mix among customers, plus rate testing that CAF ran during the quarter. CAF brought in $166 million of income this quarter, which is $10 million more than the prior-year period. Within that figure was a loan loss provision of $76 million — closer to normal levels — whereas the same quarter a year ago had a far smaller provision of just $8 million, a result of ongoing reductions to the reserve set aside when the COVID pandemic began. A year-over-year rise in total interest margin—$65 million, which equals 7.2% of managed receivables—essentially canceled out the provision headwind. That improvement compared with last year underscores how strong our ABS program is, how favorable capital markets have been, and how our receivables keep growing. For the current quarter, the provision came to $76 million, leaving an ending reserve balance of $427 million, or 2.75% of managed receivables. That's higher than the 2.66% recorded at the close of the second quarter, and it incorporates a six basis points adjustment tied to the additional tier two and tier three volume CAF is now originating. Implementation of our tier two origination test largely drove that adjustment. Keep in mind that for CAF originations, the contribution gets recognized across the life of the receivables, whereas the loss reserve gets recognized when origination happens. Also, remember that the biggest portion of the reserve that's been set aside for tier one loan losses remains well within the 2%-2.5% range that we've historically observed. During Q3, we transitioned off CAF's legacy systems for servicing auto loan receivables and moved to entirely new ones. That new platform went live in October, and it required scheduled downtime affecting a number of operational functions, including collections and customer service. Because this temporarily halted parts of our business, delinquencies and losses rose, and we anticipate they will return to normal across the next few months as our systems and processes settle down. The effect on this quarter's loan loss provision was immaterial. On top of that, CAF took on about $5 million of deployment expense during Q3, tied to things like short-term contractor help, outreach to customers ahead of the systems transition, and extra staff brought in to manage the higher call volume after we came back online; we couldn't be more enthusiastic about this new platform, which will give CAF a modernized base for growth and efficiency and also let us improve our customer experience and self-service options. I want to use this moment to thank the CAF organization and the related project teams, who have labored so relentlessly to create and roll out such a transformative solution for our associates and our customers alike. With that, I'll hand the call back to Bill.

Bill Nash

executive
#5

Thanks, John. Thanks, Enrique. The strong top-line momentum we've seen this year carried through this quarter as well. The investments we've made are paying off, and we're enthusiastic about what's coming. Customers can purchase a vehicle entirely at a store or entirely over the internet, and through our omni-channel capabilities, shoppers can tailor their experience by blending digital and in-person touchpoints according to what works for them. As omni-channel and online sales keep expanding, we've noticed that most buyers who complete their purchase digitally still choose to pick up their vehicle at one of our stores. That's yet another indication that seamless integration between digital and physical transactions delivers value to our customers and sets us apart. During Q3, slightly over 9% of retail units were sold online, compared with 5% in the same quarter a year ago. Our wholesale auctions are still conducted virtually, meaning every wholesale sale — which accounts for 23% of total revenue — counts as an online transaction. Online transactions generated roughly 30% of total revenue. That's an increase from 20% in last year's third quarter. About 57% of retail units this quarter were omni sales, versus 49% in the year-ago quarters; we've concentrated on finishing the rollout of our fully self-service experience, where customers can, if they wish, complete the whole car buying process on their own online. Right now, over two-thirds of our customers can access the complete end-to-end unaided online experience, which is up from just over 50% at the time of our previous call. This growth mirrors customers' ability to add trade-ins without liens into their online orders. The last two use cases we'll be addressing in Q4 are paid transfers and trade-ins that involve liens. During Q3, we acquired roughly 194,000 vehicles from customers via our online instant appraisal, accounting for about half of all our buys from customers. That marks a new record — a 4% rise over our Q2 figure and a 19% gain versus Q1; this growth reinforces our conviction that we continue to be the biggest online purchaser of used autos from consumers in the U.S; we keep improving our e-commerce offerings so we can surpass customer expectations and integrate smoothly with our best-in-class store experience. In Q3, we kept advancing our online finance experience by growing our finance-based shopping, or FBS, capability. FBS lets our customers view personalized finance terms from multiple lenders across the entire inventory of vehicles on our website, which is a major differentiator in the retail marketplace. Around 75% of our customers can take advantage of this experience today, and looking ahead, we're aiming to bring in the remaining customers and add more lenders to it. Also, in Q4, we'll be rolling out a more advanced version of the tool and making digital decisions faster. Once more, this quarter's and the year-to-date figures are ones we feel good about. If we keep providing the industry's most customer-focused experience, we'll make sustainable growth possible and build substantial value for shareholders over the long term; at this point, we're glad to answer whatever you'd like to ask. Jerome?

Sharon Zackfia

analyst
#6

Hi, good morning and happy holidays.

Bill Nash

executive
#7

Morning, Sharon.

Sharon Zackfia

analyst
#8

Good morning. I suppose I have a question regarding SG&A per car. I mean, it has risen at a rate in the double-digit percentage range across the past several quarters, and I realize that this is a comparison against capacity limits a year ago, you know, along with reduced investments in the business. Still, I'm interested in what visibility you have into SG&A per car getting back to something more like a low single-digit percentage rise, or perhaps even beginning to leverage that going forward.

Bill Nash

executive
#9

Hi there, Sharon. Morning to you. Best wishes for the holidays right back at you. So, roughly 3 quarters back during our Analyst Day, we laid out the fresh approach we'd taken toward SG&A — treating it as a share of gross margin, or of gross profit dollars, since in our view that captures far better how we truly operate the business and how efficient we are. We're putting money into our used car business, and beyond that, into technology, platforms, and resources aimed at expanding our wholesale business, which we've clearly witnessed both so far this year and in this quarter, plus our CAF business; investments are happening everywhere. When you look at SG&A measured against gross profit, that's more or less the lens through which we steer the business. So, on a year-to-date basis, we've gained 300 basis points of leverage there. Our goal is to achieve leverage this year on SG&A, and we intend to carry that leverage through into Q4 too.

Sharon Zackfia

analyst
#10

All right, that's helpful. Now I'd like to ask something further regarding the way used vehicles are priced. There's considerable discussion, as you're aware, among those who invest about the degree to which businesses like yours are gaining from those prices. Could you break out what you believe that gain amounts to — perhaps specifically in wholesale GPU, from pricing, rather than from the steps you've taken that have boosted appraisal volume overall through the online channel?

Bill Nash

executive
#11

Sure thing, Sharon. So when I look at what's happening with used car pricing, there's a bit of pressure coming from one direction and a bit of support coming from another. I'd say you've zeroed in on the piece where it actually works in our favor, and that's wholesale. Whenever the valuation on used vehicles rises, that benefits any company out there purchasing cars, and it definitely benefits us. When I consider the expansion in wholesale, or really our overall progress toward self-sufficiency, I'd still point back to our belief that most of that improvement comes from the innovations we've introduced, such as instant appraisal or the instant offer feature we provide for appraisals. In my view, that's what's fueling the bulk of the growth. Because if I look back at the first quarter, before this steady climb in valuations really took hold, we still posted a massive gain in wholesale along with buys overall. And although it's tough, as you mentioned, to separate those two factors, I'd say we're confident that most of the uptick stems from the initiatives we're running on our own end.

Sharon Zackfia

analyst
#12

Okay, great. Thank you.

Bill Nash

executive
#13

Thank you, Sharon.

Rick Nelson

analyst
#14

Many thanks. Morning to you. Solid quarter. I want to pick up where we left off regarding that online penetration figure. It came in at 9%, compared with 5% during the same period 12 months earlier, yet on a sequential basis it held flat. Do you have any perspective on why sequential growth didn't materialize there?

Bill Nash

executive
#15

Yes. Morning, Rick. It did tick up somewhat. That's correct. Relative to the prior quarter, the gain was rather modest. When I reflect on it, a key factor behind our self-progression reaching roughly two-thirds was the addition of certain functionality for trades lacking liens, and that enhancement landed more toward the back half of last year's quarter. What I believe we're truly observing is that customers are being given choices to pursue various approaches. Even though someone might plan, alright, I'll handle this online, as I mentioned during my opening remarks, certain individuals still, you know, walk in and prefer to complete delivery at the store. They wish to accomplish a few things at the store. My sense is that a major force here is simply having choices. Consumers are offered options by us, so they might intend to take one route, then in reality follow a different one, and honestly, that's precisely what we stand for. We don't, you know, we don't mind whichever route a consumer chooses for purchasing or however they'd like it delivered. Our only concern is ensuring the experience we provide is as personalized as possible. My expectation is that this percentage will keep climbing. Once again, customer behavior will be the bigger influence here rather than us pushing anyone toward one particular path.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#16

Great. Thanks, Bill.

Bill Nash

executive
#17

Sure.

Craig Kennison

analyst
#18

Morning, and happy holidays to everyone. I'd like to ask about affordability. Given that your ASPs have climbed by more than $6,000, now sitting above $28,000, do you find that these steeper prices are pushing away any portion of your buyers, particularly those with less wealth?

Bill Nash

executive
#19

Yeah. Craig, I believe this ties back somewhat to what Sharon asked earlier, when I mentioned that we face certain headwinds alongside certain tailwinds. On the subject of ASPs, the favorable push comes mainly from wholesale. On the retail side, I'd say there's a bit of an unfavorable drag. You're gaining because fewer new vehicles exist in the market, so presumably you're attracting some new car shoppers who want a wider selection. Since the price has risen, that likely squeezes certain buyers out, above all those at the lower end of the credit spectrum. It may become harder for them. That's likewise why we remain intensely focused on ensuring we keep delivering efficiencies through to customers, so we can offer them the strongest deal we possibly can. And that, once again, explains why we channeled a great deal of our self-sufficiency gains into pricing.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#20

Yes, Craig, I want to emphasize what I said earlier during my prepared comments. I think this gives us even greater confidence, considering the average selling prices tied to our approval rate of over 95% for those who actually came in, along with our lending platform and the lenders we work with in that segment, who are still capable of making solid, high-quality offers. We certainly understand things can be difficult in that area, but we believe our credit position allows us to serve those customers.

Craig Kennison

analyst
#21

Great. Thank you.

Bill Nash

executive
#22

Thank you, Craig.

Aileen Smith

analyst
#23

Morning, everyone. Aileen Smith here, filling in for John. I'd like to pose a question and revisit one of those goals you laid out during your Analyst Day in May — namely, moving two million vehicles annually by 2026 through both retail and wholesale channels. Back then, your volume figures sat nearer the 1.2% range, yet judging by how Q4 is shaping up, you'll likely land around 1.6%, 1.7% for the current year, which is quite impressive. First off, compared with when you gave that outlook six months ago, which part of the business has exceeded expectations — retail or wholesale? And second, what reasons would you point to for that? Mostly building up inventory via sourcing initiatives, or gaining ground with your customers on omni-channel or other offerings?

Bill Nash

executive
#24

Yeah. I mean, the way I see it, a few of our innovations have caught us pleasantly off guard. We figured sales would rise, in both wholesale and retail, and that's the reason we put that goal out there. Clearly, you know, wholesale has performed very strongly, but retail has too. The top of retail has also been strong. We're quite happy, and I think it's a bit too soon. We only set those targets out there, you know, a short while ago, but we'll be revisiting those targets probably later in the year once the year-end passes, you know, and possibly updating them. I think it's a bit early right now.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#25

Yes, I'd go along with that. On earlier calls, as we've mentioned, our performance and instant offer have gone well beyond what we anticipated. That product launched during the first quarter, and it has simply taken off — consumers have connected with it, the marketplace has connected with it, and that has powered a substantial share of our business via self-sufficiency, while also boosting wholesale business too. It has surpassed what we expected, and our instant offer program has grown more robust with each passing quarter. The second quarter came in stronger than the first, and the third quarter came in stronger than the second. Momentum appears to be accumulating out there in the marketplace.

Aileen Smith

analyst
#26

Excellent. That is quite useful. I appreciate you answering my question.

Bill Nash

executive
#27

You are welcome.

Rajat Gupta

analyst
#28

Thanks. Morning. Appreciate you answering this. I wanted to build on something — given where labor and capacity stand right now, what's your level of confidence about how quickly you're bringing people on board, and about having enough staff in your stores to handle the demand expected over the near to medium term? I have one more question after that.

Bill Nash

executive
#29

Sure. As I mentioned in my prepared remarks, we're very pleased with the momentum, on both the inventory side and the staffing side. When I consider hiring for that three-month period, we brought on over 2,000 associates, and clearly most of them work in the field and at the customer experience centers. So the direction there looks positive. We're somewhat below the level we'd prefer, and this is also the point in the year when we begin scaling up ahead of the usual tax season. We're very confident about that; we're also very confident about how many cars we can make. Like I mentioned before, our output grows month after month, and that pattern has carried over into the beginning of this fourth quarter. We have no doubt that we can bring each of them to the level we're aiming for, and we possess the means and the ability to handle them both.

Rajat Gupta

analyst
#30

Understood. That helps. Let me just build on the gas topic. Within gas, you've raised your tier two and tier three blend over, you know, the past several quarters. If I look back at 2 years ago, it seems your third-party tier two mix has gone up too, while you've also boosted the tier two mix inside gas. I'm just wondering, what's shifting across your broader customer base? Is something more lasting happening with the tier two, tier three mix, or is this more of a one-time event? I'm just curious how that will evolve.

Jon Daniels

executive
#31

Yeah, thanks for asking. So regarding that tier two percentage, clearly it rose during the quarter. There are a few dynamics at play. The penetration, or how much sales a tier or a lender will accept, is definitely tied to who is applying for credit; we did note that volume was lower in the lower subprime area, so that removes volume from tier three; yet another key point is that the credit offers coming from our tier two lenders have been outstanding, and they're likely drawing some volume up from tier three, which is clearly good from a participation perspective. So that's solid. Clearly, you noticed that CAF sits in the tier two space as well, so we're picking up some of that volume there. I'd say the mix of credit quality among applicants plus the strength of tier two offers is what's shifting in the tier two and tier three space.

Rajat Gupta

analyst
#32

Got it. That's great, thanks.

Brian Nagel

analyst
#33

Hello there, good morning. Strong quarter, congrats once more.

Jon Daniels

executive
#34

Thanks, Brian.

Bill Nash

executive
#35

Thanks, Brian.

Brian Nagel

analyst
#36

So the thing I'd like to ask — and this may partly build on a few of the earlier questions. There was clearly a good pickup in the used car business between fiscal Q2 and fiscal Q3. Bill, during your prepared remarks, and in some of your answers to questions about inventory, you mentioned that maybe inventory constraints are easing up. What I'd like to know is this: how are we supposed to interpret that acceleration? What drove it most? Did supply play the bigger role, or demand? And I understand you don't provide guidance. Still, how should we view whether what we're seeing in the business can last, at least based on where things stood at the close of Q3?

Bill Nash

executive
#37

Yes. Brian, I appreciate that question. To begin with, I have to recognize the team, since from an execution standpoint they have performed absolutely remarkably, seizing the opportunities available. As I've said, I believe the reality that we were light on inventory, particularly during the second quarter, and the way we kept working through that situation, counts as a major factor. Staffing, I'd say, is another major factor, since we don't have enough people in the stores and our customer experience centers. We keep improving our omni-channel experience. If I just look at it year over year, online and omni-channel, this year accounted for approximately — let's say 66% of sales, while 12 months earlier it was 53% of the sales. I'd also point to passing along pricing efficiencies. The prior quarter was truly the first one in which we saw self-sufficiency exceed 70%. That carried on through the quarter we just reported. Being in a position to hand those savings to customers, I believe, was a positive as well. A great deal is contributing here, and it's genuinely difficult to say, "All right, this portion comes from that, or that portion comes from this." We felt terrific about the quarter; it was strong in each month of that quarter. You're correct that we don't provide guidance, but I can say we're pleased with how the fourth quarter has begun.

Brian Nagel

analyst
#38

Great. If I may add a second question to that. When we look at the company, what limitations remain? Is it stock, staffing, or something else? And then, how do you expect those limitations to ease, once more, over the coming, let's say, several months or so?

Bill Nash

executive
#39

Yes, I believe you brought up staffing. Staffing is one area we will keep prioritizing. Although we have achieved significant improvement, we want to bring on additional people there, and that applies pretty much throughout the entire company. That is another area we will keep prioritizing and keep improving, along with stock. We will keep expanding stock. As I mentioned before, I believe we possess the necessary means and we are headed in the correct direction to ensure that, as you know, we can get our stock to the level it should be before any kind of tax season. The other item I will mention is, looking ahead across the coming year, we are also, as you know, as part of our anticipated growth, we have, roughly, let's say 10 additional production centers coming online. A number of them belong to geos, a number of them belong to expansion efforts we had already begun. We have the means required and we are moving along well; those are, I believe, our nearer term priorities for sure.

Jon Daniels

executive
#40

Yes. Brian, something I'd put on top of that is this: thanks to both the gains we've made in staffing and, without question, the physical capacity available to us now and going ahead, here's what I'd say to you — we hold a firm conviction that on the operations side we're strong and set up to grow. Our position for that is a good one.

Brian Nagel

analyst
#41

Understood. Congratulations once more. Thanks. Enjoy the holidays.

Bill Nash

executive
#42

Same to you.

Seth Basham

analyst
#43

Much appreciated, and good morning to everyone. Regarding my first inquiry, it concerns the self-sufficiency ratio, which once more exceeded 70% during this quarter — marking the second consecutive period that has happened; in this quarter, we observed a genuine acceleration in your retail unit comps, plus your GPU came in far stronger on a year-over-year basis than was the case last quarter. Could you assist us in grasping the dynamics behind those substantial shifts as we move between quarters?

Bill Nash

executive
#44

Yeah. As you know, I believe I touched somewhat on the comps along with all the elements that largely propelled that. To be clear, the self-sufficiency figure sits at a peak for a second — a full second — quarter. As you know, we managed to hand those efficiencies onward. As I mentioned during my prepared remarks, what we are attempting to accomplish is maintaining a delicate equilibrium here. We recognize that prices have risen 30% on our side. We recognize that creates strain for certain customers, so our aim is genuinely to make the vehicles as affordable as we can; we will keep doing this in the current quarter exactly as we did in the prior one. We keep monitoring inventory levels, probing elasticity, and reviewing competitors' inventory. Numerous factors feed into this. I genuinely believe we achieved the appropriate balance, including from a margin perspective, arriving at what is historically elevated. When you examine the recent margin ranges across the past few years, I think we landed at the upper end of that. Even so, we managed to deliver some excellent efficiencies through to the consumers.

Seth Basham

analyst
#45

All right. As a quick follow-up, during the prior quarter, we didn't observe nearly as much progress on GPU or comp. So does that mean the gap between the prior quarter and this one comes from market dynamics, like the spread between retail and wholesale pricing in the market, or is it driven by something different?

Bill Nash

executive
#46

Well, my take is that this is the case. You know, the previous quarter marked the first occasion when we'd truly gotten self-sufficiency above 70%. You know, what we came to understand in that prior quarter was that we were largely handing those savings through. You know, what I'd say to you is that if you examine the market — and we hold off on discussing market share until the year wraps up, since a lag clearly exists, and because of that lag you need to evaluate it on a calendar-year footing. You know, there are certain outside sources out there indicating that the used car market as a whole has been either level or possibly even down, you know, across the past few months. Our view is that this is a favorable sign for the gains we're beginning to witness. I think what you're genuinely observing here is simply a mix of a great many items that truly sort of reached fruition, as I mentioned regarding all the various elements for comp. What I believe you're starting to witness is that a lot of factors genuinely influenced the third quarter results.

Seth Basham

analyst
#47

Great to see you. Thank you. Congratulations, and happy holidays.

Bill Nash

executive
#48

Thank you, Seth. Same to you.

Michael Montani

analyst
#49

Oh, excellent. I appreciate you fielding my question, and congratulations on the quarter.

Bill Nash

executive
#50

Thanks, Michael.

Jon Daniels

executive
#51

Appreciate it, Michael.

Michael Montani

analyst
#52

There's one point I'd like to get straight, and after that I have something to ask about provisioning. On the clarification side, Enrique, heading into Q4, I simply want to confirm I understood you right — that you folks would aim to potentially lever the SG&A to gross ratio during the fourth quarter. That's the first thing I hoped to pin down, and then I had something else to raise afterward.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#53

Yes. No, those were my words. We intend to lever in Q4.

Michael Montani

analyst
#54

All right, that's helpful. My second question relates to provisioning. I just want to get a sense going forward of how you're all viewing that particular line item inside CAF, since clearly there's room for additional gains in the unemployment rate, plus used car prices that remain stubbornly elevated, which in theory ought to work in your favor. There's clearly additional tier two activity you're engaged in, and so on. Now that the reserve has been rebuilt somewhat, should we think about $75 million per quarter, more or less? Any additional detail you could offer would be very helpful.

Jon Daniels

executive
#55

Yes, excellent question, Michael. Sure, when we consider the reserve together with the provision, just like you said, our reserve at present, the measure we rely on is the 2.75% reserve versus. Keep in mind, as you noted, there's tier one, but also tier two and tier three volume, plus a certain amount of expense for recovery. If you strip out that tier one, as I said earlier, we believe we're within our typical range of 2%-2.5% for that tier one business. Also, looking at what we originated during this quarter, $2.4 billion, again acknowledging that tier one is present, along with higher losses from tier two and tier three within those originations, and the recovery expense as well. $76 million seems quite near normal for that origination. I believe you've got it exactly right. From a loss rate standpoint, we feel we're at a typical percentage, and that's how I'd think about it moving forward. One point I want to mention as a reminder, once more, the provision was sizable when the pandemic first hit. $122 million recorded back in quarter one of FY 2021. As performance got better, with truly outstanding results from our consumers, we managed to bring that provision down gradually. The fact that we comped over last year's quarter three is wonderful. Understand we still have that comping left to do. Yes, I agree, we're in a normal environment at this point.

Michael Montani

analyst
#56

Thank you.

Bill Nash

executive
#57

Thank you, Michael.

Adam Jonas

analyst
#58

Thanks, everybody. Happy holidays.

Bill Nash

executive
#59

You too, Adam.

Adam Jonas

analyst
#60

Okay, understood. I'd really like to find out how the online figure compares when it comes to GPU against that $2,235. Does it come in above or below that amount? And as a second question, you said that most of your shoppers, within the online category, continue to favor picking items up at a store. I'm wondering whether you could share how many, or what share, out of that 9% actually chose to have things delivered to their homes. Thanks.

Bill Nash

executive
#61

All right. Regarding your initial question about online GPU, there's no difference from what you'd find in a store. Whether the purchase happens over the internet or at a physical location, the GPU is basically identical. When it comes to that 9% figure for online sales, our perspective is that we describe it more as alternative delivery, covering both home delivery and express pickup. Thinking about that share of overall sales, clearly it's under 10%, and the larger portion consists of express pickups, where people arrive at the store having already completed everything, perhaps with one or two small items remaining, yet we move them through very fast. That represents the bigger slice compared with home delivery.

Adam Jonas

analyst
#62

Right, I wasn't sure whether you intended to put a number on that. You mentioned a vast majority, but I couldn't tell if that meant 90% of the nine or 70% of the nine.

Bill Nash

executive
#63

Oh, you mean for the.

Adam Jonas

analyst
#64

For home delivery.

Bill Nash

executive
#65

Are you asking about GPU and delivery to homes? That figure is significantly lower. It represents a far less substantial share of that total.

Adam Jonas

analyst
#66

<<inaudible>>

Chris Bottiglieri

analyst
#67

Hi everyone, I appreciate you giving me the chance to ask.

Jon Daniels

executive
#68

Good morning.

Chris Bottiglieri

analyst
#69

I wanted to ask something quick that follows up about credit, and then I've got a separate credit question too. On the first one, from what you said when answering Mike's question, Montani's question from before, it sounded as if there was no effect. What I mean is the systems effect — you appeared to suggest gross losses recovery took some kind of hit, yet then you said it wasn't producing a provision. I'm just attempting to reconcile those two things. Did gross losses recovery take any hit during this quarter, or does it land more on the overhead expense side?

Jon Daniels

executive
#70

Yeah, that's a reasonable question, Chris. Yeah, like I mentioned during my prepared remarks, a significant systems transition brought plenty of, you know, a good deal of disruption, which we had completely anticipated and built into our plans. Once we came online and got caught up on the volumes, those delinquencies have moved downward toward more typical levels. There's definitely zero effect, or in our view it's immaterial, when it comes to the full lifetime loss of the portfolio. That's, you know, clearly nothing sitting in there within the provision and the matching reserve, so.

Bill Nash

executive
#71

Yeah, Chris, to build on what was just said — during the prior quarter, that item didn't matter at all, since we expected it, and once more in this quarter, it had no material impact.

Chris Bottiglieri

analyst
#72

Understood. That's useful. All right. A broader question here. Could you share more detail about why new loan rates came in lower during this quarter versus the prior one? You brought up rate testing, if I recall. Your competitor — one of the big online players — said something comparable during the previous quarter. The timing strikes me as a bit odd, experimenting with rate cuts while we're actually observing the opposite trend, with the market pushing rates higher right now on those tier rates. So I suppose my first question: against that background, have you observed that customers tend to grow more sensitive to rates as they climb, and is that what's driving the testing? Drawing on whatever historical precedent exists, what should we expect regarding how rates affect customers during stretches when funding costs rise? How long of a delay typically occurs before those increases get passed through?

Jon Daniels

executive
#73

Yeah, those are great questions, Chris. Yeah, like I said during the prepared remarks, we did run some rate testing this quarter. You know, it's always about keeping tabs on market conditions. We track quite a few internal metrics. Again, our capture rate, or booking rate, which feeds into penetration, three-day payoffs — several metrics we monitor. But the thing that matters most for CAF is that, being the only tier one lender, we aim to stay highly competitive for our customers and deliver the strongest offers we can; so it was logical. You know, we simply wanted to take the market's pulse; we ran some rate testing, and we're monitoring it closely. As you pointed out, the Fed certainly did step forward and indicate that rate hikes are coming down the road. Again, we'll handle that the way we always have. We'll observe peer behavior and how the market responds. Frequently when rates are climbing, as you noted, a lag shows up; it doesn't get handed to the customer immediately. Getting ahead of that isn't our aim, but we'll set rates and we will test. We'll test accordingly, just as we always have; we'll track market movement and what those take rates look like, and then if passing something along to customers makes sense, we'll do it; however, if it hurts sales of cars, the experience, or our CAF capture rates, then we might hold off. Whatever the testing shows will guide our actions.

Bill Nash

executive
#74

Right. Chris, what makes CAF so impressive, I'd say, is that their attention isn't solely on squeezing out the most profit for themselves. The wonderful part, you know, is that while they do pursue profit, they're simultaneously striving to boost sales as much as possible. At times, the choices we make could differ from those of competitors who operate strictly within the financing space.

Chris Bottiglieri

analyst
#75

Understood. That's logical. Thanks for the assistance. I appreciate it.

Bill Nash

executive
#76

Thanks.

David Bellinger

analyst
#77

Hello there, and good morning. I appreciate you giving me the chance to ask something. Regarding those close to 200,000 cars obtained from customers by way of the instant appraisal, could you give us some idea of the number of bids you extend every quarter? Has the rate at which those convert been getting better from one quarter to the next? Also, with all the information you currently have at your disposal, and in practice, are you noticing stronger involvement, or perhaps even repeat business, from people who bought from you before?

Bill Nash

executive
#78

Yes. Morning, David. Regarding the online offers, as you might expect, we generate quite a few of them. Some customers, you know, are simply hunting for value and have no real interest in selling or even purchasing a vehicle. We're producing a couple million offers annually. When I think about how those convert, the way we've described it previously is this: for customers who come into our store to have their vehicle appraised — regardless of whether they got an online appraisal beforehand — we examine the buy rate from that angle. Looking at the traditional appraisal lane, where the customer hasn't received an online appraisal, we're seeing a mid-30 buy rate, which is excellent. On the online side, as you'd expect, if they've already had their vehicle valued online and then visit the store, that certainly results in a higher buy rate. It lifts the overall buy rate. I don't believe we should view it as: out of those who received offers, how many actually sold. We do observe some solid improvement there, but that isn't really how we approach the business.

David Bellinger

analyst
#79

Understood. Regarding repeat activity, is there anything happening there? When it comes to the instant appraisal, are you noticing increased engagement from customers who have used it before?

Bill Nash

executive
#80

Honestly, David, I would need to revisit the data and check how many of those folks were already customers who'd gotten an appraisal before. That figure isn't something I can pull from memory right now.

David Bellinger

analyst
#81

Okay. Well, thanks for the color. I appreciate it, Bill.

Bill Nash

executive
#82

Yeah.

David Whiston

analyst
#83

Thank you. Good morning. If you're willing, I'd like to peer a bit into what lies ahead. What's your take on how a new vehicle inventory situation shapes up as the chip shortage eases across, let's say, the coming 18 months? Does that push used pricing into a steep, sudden collapse? Or does it look more like a gentle descent? Should the landing prove rougher, do you fear your customers might carry excessive negative equity, enough to keep them away from the store or out of the market during 2023?

Bill Nash

executive
#84

Yeah. Honestly, it's a hard question to pin down regarding when I believe the chip shortage will sort itself out. Whatever answer I give you is likely going to miss the mark. My belief is that we'll begin seeing some relief, perhaps in the latter portion of next year. It won't resemble a faucet that simply switches on in one night. As additional chips arrive and additional new cars arrive, the effect on used vehicle prices will begin to show. Whenever sales prices climb 30% year-over-year, there's a risk that later on, additional negative equity could exist out there. But I can say we've spent a long time in this business. Many cycles, both up and down, have come and gone, and we've demonstrated an ability to navigate any such factors, be it negative equity or be it depreciation in the marketplace. Actually, I'd say we can manage that and perform far better than anyone else, simply because of our experience. So stay tuned. Knowing when we'll get some relief on overall used car prices is difficult. Just one other thing.

Bill Nash

executive
#85

Oh, that—

Bill Nash

executive
#86

One more item regarding what David asked earlier about the IO—my team just let me know I got that wrong. What I actually said, I believe, was 2 million dollars annually. In fact, it's 2 million dollars each quarter. I said it incorrectly. I should have said quarter, not year. I simply wanted to make that clear for him too.

David Whiston

analyst
#87

You brought up ways to lessen the problem of owing more than a vehicle is worth. Could CAF take a bolder approach when someone is in that kind of upside-down position?

Jon Daniels

executive
#88

Sure — what I'd say is, I don't believe we'll really change how we assess risk just because of a specific set of circumstances involving where average selling prices sit, being underwater on a loan, and so forth. Look, once again, taking everything together, with CAF serving as the captive financier, it's a fantastic position from which to keep sales in mind and factor that into the calls we make. That said, we still want to extend credit to a borrower with solid creditworthiness, or else we're heading to the ABS market, where we have to move a portfolio of loans. Honestly, my sense is that our attention stays squarely on generating sales while maintaining credit quality.

Bill Nash

executive
#89

Yeah. We deal with negative equity customers all the time.

Jon Daniels

executive
#90

Of course.

Bill Nash

executive
#91

Our CAF group performs outstanding work in that area, much the same as the outside lending partners we work with.

David Whiston

analyst
#92

Okay. Thanks, guys.

Jon Daniels

executive
#93

Thank you.

Bill Nash

executive
#94

Alright, thanks a lot. So, I appreciate everyone being on today's call, for the questions you brought, and for your backing. Like I mentioned before, the possibilities ahead of us have us genuinely energized. In keeping with what I always do, I want to express gratitude to each of our associates for all they contribute, the way they look after one another and those we serve. They truly are the foundation of our achievements and the reason we continue to be such a constructive and disruptive presence within the pre-owned vehicle sector. To every one of our associates and to all of you, I hope you enjoy a wonderful holiday season, and we will speak again in the next quarter. Thanks for giving us your time.

Operator

operator
#95

Appreciate it. That wraps up the CarMax Earnings Release Conference Call for the third quarter of fiscal year 2022, everyone. You're free to hang up now.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete CarMax, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to CarMax, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in CarMax, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.