CarMax, Inc. (KMX) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
April 12, 2022
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
David Lowenstein
executiveThanks, Jess. Morning, everyone. Appreciate you being on the call for our Fiscal 2022 Fourth Quarter Earnings Conference Call. Joining me are Bill Nash, our President and CEO; Enrique Mayor-Mora, our Senior Vice President and CFO; and Jon Daniel, our Senior Vice President, CarMax Auto Finance Operations. Just a reminder: anything we say today about future business plans, prospects, and financial performance is forward-looking, made under the safe harbor provisions of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Such statements reflect management's present knowledge and assumptions concerning future events, and they carry risks and uncertainties that might cause actual results to differ materially from what we expect. When we provide projections and other forward-looking statements, the company disclaims any intent or obligation to update them. For more on important factors that could affect these expectations, please refer to the company's Form 8-K issued this morning and its annual report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended February 28, 2021, filed with the SEC. If any follow-up questions come up after the call, feel free to reach our Investor Relations department at (804) 747 to 0422, extension 7865. Finally, thanks ahead of time for limiting yourself to one question and then getting back in the queue for more follow-ups. Bill?
Bill Nash
executiveAlright, thanks David. Morning, everybody, and I appreciate you being here. In Q4 of fiscal '22, our diversified model generated $7.7 billion in total sales — a 49% increase over the same quarter a year earlier — powered by higher average selling prices and greater wholesale volume, though that was partly offset by fewer used units sold. Net earnings came to $159.8 million in Q4 and $1.2 billion across the fiscal year. For the quarter, diluted net earnings per share landed at $0.98, a 23% drop versus the prior-year period. On our December call, we told you we felt good about how sales were performing early in Q4. But once the holidays passed, pressure emerged and persisted right up to quarter's end. Within retail, total units sold fell 5.2% in Q4, while used unit comps slipped 6.5% against the same quarter last year. We think a number of macro forces dragged on used car sales industrywide — things like consumer confidence, vehicle affordability, the Omicron COVID surge, and comparisons against stimulus benefits distributed a year earlier. Even though the used market proved difficult in Q4, we take real pride in what we achieved in fiscal 2022, and we feel strongly that we're set up well for lasting success going forward across retail, wholesale, and CarMax Auto Finance. Looking at the full year, the results show meaningful gains in sales, market share, and earnings, plus solid headway on our strategic initiatives. In fact, the retail market share growth we posted this past year was the biggest since I became CEO, which speaks to how focused we've been on providing the most customer-centric experience out there. According to our market share figures, our national share of vehicles aged 0 to 10 years rose 13%, climbing from 3.5% in calendar 2020 to 4.0% in 2021. Even with a sales decline in our fiscal fourth quarter, when we compare our results against published used vehicle SAAR data, it appears we kept gaining share through the quarter. We're confident we can achieve profitable market share gains no matter what the environment looks like. Through our retail and wholesale channels combined, we moved roughly 343,000 cars in Q4, an 11% rise versus last year's period. Across the full fiscal year, we sold about 1.6 million retail and wholesale cars combined, up 38% year-over-year. We remain the country's biggest buyer of vehicles from consumers, purchasing approximately 324,000 cars from consumers in the quarter, 69% above last year's period. For the fiscal year, we acquired roughly 1.4 million cars from consumers, a 95% year-over-year increase. Self-sufficiency stayed strong in Q4, holding above 70%. We posted Q4 retail gross profit per used unit of $2,195, which was up $109 per unit compared with the prior-year period. Since used car prices stayed elevated, we decided to share some of the acquisition cost savings from self-sufficiency with consumers by lowering prices. We feel we achieved the proper equilibrium among offsetting inflationary expenses, preserving margin, and making our cars more affordable. Our strategy shows we remain dedicated to acting in the customer's best interest, and that is what ultimately fuels expansion of our business. Unit sales at wholesale rose 43.8% versus the fourth quarter of last year, while gross profit for each unit came to $1,191, against $990 during the prior year. The gain in wholesale units came mainly from the continued success of our instant online appraisal product. Wholesale valuations stayed at historically elevated levels throughout the quarter, and that propped up margin versus the fourth quarter of last year. CarMax Auto Finance, or CAF, produced income of $194 million, an increase from $188 million in the equivalent period a year earlier. Shortly, Jon will offer additional specifics regarding customer financing and CAF's contributions, but right now I want to hand the call to Enrique, who will share further information about our fourth quarter financial results. Enrique?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveThanks, Bill, and good morning, everyone. Gross profit came in at $711 million, which is an 11% gain versus the fourth quarter a year ago. The main driver here was wholesale vehicle margin of $177 million, which rose 73%. As our wholesale operation keeps expanding, it gives us a powerful lever for gross profit. Used vehicle margin landed at $427 million, roughly level with last year's fourth quarter, since fewer units were mostly made up for by higher margin on each unit. Other gross profit reached $107 million, a 4% drop versus the fourth quarter a year ago; that decline came from a $33 million fall in service profit, largely because of deleverage caused by lower sales along with the staffing and efficiency effects of the Omicron COVID surge during the fourth quarter. We still intend to run service as a profit center, though quarter-to-quarter it can be affected by sales trends and staffing disruptions. Partly offsetting that decline was favorability in EPP and third-party finance fees, plus $20 million of margin contribution from Edmunds. For the quarter, EPP rose $6.3 million, or 5%, year-over-year, with penetration holding steady at roughly 60%; that favorability stemmed from an $11 million year-over-year net benefit tied to recognizing profit sharing revenues and adjustments to our cancellation reserves. You may remember from our second quarter call in September that one of our providers made a timing shift in the performance period for profit sharing revenues. Every one of our providers now follows the same timing, which aligns recognition as applicable with our fourth quarter. Third-party finance fees got better by $4.7 million, with income of $1.8 million versus a cost of $2.9 million a year ago; lower Tier 3 volume compared with last year's fourth quarter drove that improvement. Turning to SG&A, fourth quarter expenses climbed to $621 million, 23% above the prior year's quarter, reflecting continued investment in our strategic initiatives and in marketing, the consolidation of Edmunds, and growth costs tied to more appraisal buys, new stores, and customer support at our Customer Experience Centers, or CECs. SG&A as a percent of gross profit deleveraged to 87.3% from 79% in the fourth quarter last year. That deleverage was mainly caused by the sales decline during the quarter. Higher SG&A dollars versus last year came mostly from 3 factors. First, a $43 million rise in total compensation and benefits, driven by our ongoing strong ramp in staffing, including proactive staffing ahead of tax season and wage increases. On top of that, we saw a $16 million increase in annual bonus-related compensation, plus Edmunds' payroll now included this quarter versus a year ago. Partly offsetting this was a $42 million decrease in stock-based compensation. Second, a $40 million increase in other overhead. The main drivers there include investments to advance our technology platforms and strategic initiatives, as well as growth-related costs. Third, advertising expense rose by $19 million as part of our continuing strategy to bring in customers and strengthen the CarMax brand, through sustained efforts to increase familiarity with what our omnichannel offerings provide. Across the entire year, SG&A represented 70.7% of gross profit, which means we gained roughly 1 point relative to the prior year's figure of 71.6%. As we move into the next year, our stance on SG&A and costs is unchanged. Investing in our business will carry on. Simultaneously, we stay dedicated to making sure our spending is both efficient and effective, and we keep aiming at the priority areas we believe will produce results over time. To achieve leverage in FY '23, we anticipate needing growth in gross profit that exceeds the 5% to 8% range. The main reasons are the scheduling of strategic investments and costs tied to growth, along with stronger inflationary pressures. Although we anticipate staying in investment mode across the coming few years, we expect our leverage point to decline again following FY '23. When it comes to allocating capital, our philosophy is unchanged. We will keep putting money into our core business, evaluate fresh growth possibilities via investments, partnerships or acquisitions, and give excess capital back to our shareholders. Turning to our share repurchase program, during the quarter we bought back roughly 872,000 shares for about $102 million; across the full year, we bought back roughly 4.5 million shares for $561.6 million, and as of March 31, 2022, $721.7 million of authorizations remained. As announced today, our Board of Directors has increased our share repurchase authority by $2 billion, with no expiration time line. This authorization from the Board mirrors CarMax's continuing dedication to creating long-term shareholder value via growth and returning capital. On capital expenditures, we expect roughly $500 million in FY '23. The rise in spending comes from long-term growth capacity initiatives for auction, sales and production facilities, plus ongoing investments in technology. During FY '23, we intend to open 10 new locations, among them our first 3 stores in the New York City metro market. Our broad nationwide footprint and logistics network keep serving as a competitive advantage for CarMax, and we stay dedicated to a suitable level of investment in these differentiated assets. At this point, I'd like to hand the call over to Jon.
Jon Daniels
executiveAppreciate that, Enrique, and good morning to all of you. Once again, our CarMax Auto Finance operation turned in a robust performance. During Q4, CAF's penetration, net of 3-day payoffs, came in at 41%, versus 43.5% in the prior year. Tier 2 rose to 23.7% of used unit sales, up from 21% a year earlier, while Tier 3 represented 6.7% of sales, compared with 9.5% in the same period last year. The decline in CAF's penetration on a year-over-year basis stems from a bigger share of customers arriving with financing from outside sources. Our Tier 2 partners keep offering highly competitive credit terms as they chase additional volume in the CarMax channel; those attractive offers, combined with lower conversion in the lower portion of the credit spectrum caused by higher average selling prices and the corresponding monthly payments, drove the swap and penetration between Tiers 2 and 3. In this year's fourth quarter, CAF originated net loans of almost $2.1 billion. New customers were charged a weighted average contract rate of 8.2%, which is down from 8.5% a year ago and 8.3% in Q3. That APR difference mainly reflects the credit mix of customers who book with CAF. CAF income for the quarter reached $194 million, up 3%, or $6 million, from the same period a year earlier. Total interest margin grew $64 million, powered by $42 million in higher interest and fee income from our ongoing receivables growth and $22 million in lower interest expense from past ABS deals that keep delivering value over time. This margin improvement at CAF, plus growth in average managed receivables, more than offset a significant rise in the provision for loan losses, which came in at a more normalized $54.4 million this year's fourth quarter, versus $4.6 million in last year's fourth quarter. In last year's fourth quarter, the provision for loan losses gained from the continued reduction in the reserve set up when the COVID pandemic began. This quarter's provision of $54 million produced an ending reserve balance of $433 million, or 2.77% of managed receivables. That's largely in line with the 2.75% at the close of the third quarter and includes a 3 basis point adjustment for additional Tier 2 and Tier 3 volume originated by CAF. I'd also like to use this opportunity to call out a few accomplishments since our last call concerning our online finance experience. As a reminder, almost 2/3 of our customers start their financing process on carmax.com, applying for credit on any vehicle in our inventory or simply a requested dollar amount. Most of our customers can access our distinctive shopping engine built around financing, which lets several lenders make decisions on one buyer or joint applicants across our whole inventory, delivering a complete set of tailored choices right at the consumer's fingertips. You'll find this tool built into the search page on carmax.com, so users can sort and filter by the vehicle's traits as well as by key financing details like monthly payment and down payment. In March, we took this experience a step further and are currently piloting a feature that has no impact on your credit score, plus a simplified application flow that delivers instant credit decisions across our entire inventory. We're confident that our differentiated multi-lender platform, together with these improvements and others still to come, will keep making our digital shopping experience even stronger; at this point, I'll hand the call back to Bill.
Bill Nash
executiveThanks, Jon, and thanks, Enrique. Like I said before on this call, I feel a great deal of pride in what we accomplished during fiscal 2022. Through both our retail and wholesale channels, we moved more cars than at any point in our history. We've kept pushing innovation forward, investing heavily in the parts of the business that matter most, and chasing fresh avenues for growth. Thanks to all of that work, our market share grew by a double-digit rate compared with the prior year, and we think we're sitting in a strong spot to capture still more share; we've kept rolling out new and improved capabilities, and whenever those have reached the market, we've kept seeing favorable results. A few things stand out from this year that will leave a durable mark: first, turning on online self-progression capabilities, which roughly 90% of our customers can use right now, with every customer expected to have full access by the time this first quarter ends. Second, using our online instant appraisal offering to purchase a record number of cars straight from consumers, which lets us almost double our self-sufficiency as we drive — and also drive wholesale unit growth that can be sustained. Third, shifting CAF's legacy auto loan receivable servicing system onto brand-new technology, giving CAF a modernized base for growth and letting us improve the experience our customers have. And last, introducing the finance-based shopping capabilities that Jon just walked through. Our e-commerce engine, paired with a nationwide physical footprint that has no equal, delivers real value to our customers and helps us provide what we consider the finest experience in the used car industry. Being able to offer seamless integration across digital and physical transactions opens the door to the biggest total addressable market, and that's a major differentiator — one we'll keep improving. Turning to our fourth quarter online metrics: roughly 11% of retail unit sales happened online, compared with 5% in the same quarter a year ago. Our wholesale auctions are still virtual, meaning 100% of wholesale sales — which make up 23% of total revenue — count as online transactions. Online transactions generated about 31% of total revenue; that's up from 17% in last year's fourth quarter. About 55% of retail unit sales this quarter were omni sales, versus 51% a year earlier. During the fourth quarter, we purchased roughly 162,000 vehicles from customers via our online instant appraisal. That's around half of all our buys from consumers. Across this fiscal year, we purchased approximately 707,000 cars through that channel, which again works out to about half of our total consumer buys. Looking ahead, we'll keep evolving our online and in-store capabilities so associates and customers alike get a smoother experience. I want to call out 4 key focus areas for FY '23. First, as Jon said earlier, we're rolling out a more sophisticated version of our finance-based shopping capability, one that makes real-time decisions possible and gives customers the chance to prequalify for a loan without any hit to their credit score. Second, we're introducing self-service features to make in-store experiences better, such as appraisals and express pickups. Third, we're expanding vehicle acquisition by bringing in new customers and forming partnerships, as we broaden our appraisal services to dealers and other businesses. And last, we'll keep using data science, automation, and AI to boost efficiency and effectiveness throughout our buying organization, business offices, and CECs. Once again, we take great pride in the impressive results for fiscal '22, largely driven by our unwavering commitment to delivering the best customer experience in the industry; we're well-positioned going forward, and we'll keep investing and innovating to drive profitable market share growth. At our Analyst Day last May, we shared long-term goals of reaching 2 million combined retail and wholesale units sold and $33 billion in revenue in FY '26, compared to $1.2 million and $19 billion, respectively, in FY '21. While we don't plan to update our targets every year, our strong FY '22 performance has given us a fresh view on these goals that we think is worth sharing now. We're updating our FY '26 targets to a range of 2 million to 2.4 million combined units, with revenue from $33 billion to $45 billion. These ranges take into account the macro factors mentioned earlier that could lead to continued volatility in consumer demand and vehicle pricing; when it comes to market share, I'm excited about the future and confident we'll grow it past 5% by the end of calendar 2025. Finally, and most importantly, I want to thank all our associates for their efforts. They're truly the foundation of our success. Just yesterday, Fortune Magazine recognized CarMax as one of its 100 Best Companies to work for, for the 18th consecutive year. I'm extremely proud of this honor, as it reflects our associates' dedication to supporting each other, our customers, and our communities every day. I want to thank and congratulate all our associates; with that, we're ready to take your questions.
Craig Kennison
analystSo I have some interest in this online instant appraisal tool. There are several things I'd like to ask regarding it. In that market, how do you view your position versus competitors and the overall competitive environment? What sets you apart? Given that you hold this edge, are you allocating sufficient marketing resources toward it? And Bill, I believe you brought up intentions for fiscal 2023 to expand this to additional dealers. Could you perhaps elaborate on that?
Bill Nash
executiveAbsolutely. Craig, that covers quite a bit; so to begin with, I feel genuinely positive regarding our IO results. My sense is that it has done so well owing to several factors. First, I believe it truly comes down to how the product feels to use and how simple it is. I also think it carries the support and the name recognition of CarMax, and honestly, let's keep in mind, this is our core business. We have purchased vehicles from customers starting in 1993. We have begun promoting it, clearly. When I consider the fourth quarter and reflect on what we put into advertising, we separate that into roughly brand awareness and acquisition awareness. Regarding acquisition awareness, my answer would be that we directed somewhat more toward vehicle acquisition awareness during this past quarter compared to earlier quarters, so we're pleased with the advertising. Now, clearly, I believe everyone in the marketplace is gaining somewhat from increased valuations, yet my view is that accounts for only a small portion of the increase we've experienced. So that has us enthusiastic. Regarding what I said before, yes, look, to start with, we will keep enhancing that experience for our customers. However, we are also — we have been piloting and we will keep expanding this so it becomes accessible to additional dealers. It's a simple method to clear out inventory that they want to move, and we will also pursue other partnerships through which we can make use of this.
Sharon Zackfia
analystI'm certain all of you want to know how the company can adjust amid today's consumer backdrop, especially given where pre-owned vehicle pricing stands. You mentioned passing along some improved pricing to buyers during this quarter, but I have a few things I want to ask. First, do you have any further detail about how much stimulus helped you during the comparable period a year ago, in both Q4 and March, now that you've cycled past it? Was there any clear Omicron effect confined to Q4? I believe that information would be useful. Also, considering current gasoline costs and used car costs, have you noticed any drop-off in demand for SUVs? What steps are you taking to adapt? And are you making your inventory's average age somewhat older so that price points become more within reach? I realize that's a great deal to ask, yet I feel it matters to address each part — apologies; it's essentially a 12-part, single-part question.
Bill Nash
executiveYes. That's an inventive method of squeezing something like 14 questions into the very first one. Still, I'm glad to address every one. Let me begin with the final 2 items you raised — gasoline costs. For the quarter, we honestly saw little effect from gasoline costs when it came to any shift. When I examine gas guzzlers in terms of sales, they were quite comparable versus a year earlier; thus I believe this is something we must keep watching going forward. We have observed a rise, for instance, in areas such as EV searches, and Edmunds has noticed the same thing. Yet we've definitely dealt with this situation previously and come through quite well — when customers seek something else, we're available for them. So this truly doesn't concern me, and we'll manage to adapt. Regarding your question about the average age of vehicles: on the retail side, we did observe a move toward somewhat older cars, which clearly cost somewhat less. As for the mix, when I look at 0 to, say, 0 to 4 year-over-year, roughly 10 points shifted out of that bucket toward the slightly higher one, perhaps the 5 to 7 bucket. So a modest shift has occurred there; and once more, what's great about our operation is that whenever customers want various kinds of inventory, we ensure that inventory is available. So we feel fine about it. As for remarks regarding the comps, well, I listed a large number of macro factors that I believe are pressuring the pre-owned vehicle sector generally. If I needed to order them by size — and again, precisely measuring each one is difficult. I'd likely put expensive pricing right at the very top, with the COVID spike coming next — and indeed, we experienced a COVID spike during January. Then, as we emerged from that COVID spike, my sense is it shifted into this broader decline in consumer confidence. After that, I'd also point to the anniversary effect of the federal stimulus. Some stimulus was disbursed around last December and January, mostly in January, and then additional stimulus arrived in March. So I believe that definitely had an impact on the quarter, and I suspect it's also contributing to the weakness as we head into the first quarter too. How did I do? Did I address all of your questions?
Sharon Zackfia
analystYes, I believe that's right.
Rajat Gupta
analystExcellent. Perhaps regarding the SG&A run rate, that $130 million of overhead cost, would that be a reasonable baseline to use for that specific line item moving forward? I'm simply wondering how that interacts with any shifts on the volume side, since conditions are somewhat softer in the near term? And then maybe if you could share thoughts on CAF, given the affordability backdrop that's deteriorating somewhat. How sure are you about your ability to pass through any benchmark rate increases or widening in the ABS market? How sure are you about your ability to pass that along to the consumer under these circumstances? And if you can't manage that, how should we view the consequences for the gas business?
Bill Nash
executiveYes. I'll have Enrique address the SG&A. And as for the CAF business, we'll let Jon handle that, so.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYeah. So let me try to make sure I got what you're asking. Is it specifically other overhead that you mean, or are you referring to SG&A in general?
Rajat Gupta
analystWhat about other overhead?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYeah. So when it comes to other overhead, what happened this quarter was basically more of the same from our tech spending push, plus some growth-related expenses; you have to remember just how many vehicles we're acquiring via the A Lane and through the Appraisal Lane, along with more activity in our wholesale operation. So I'd say that figure definitely rose this quarter. My expectation is that it keeps rising. Still, if you zoom out and examine SG&A in total along with every piece of it. As we head into next year, we do anticipate — just like I told you in my prepared remarks — that we'll need gross profit growth beyond that 5% to 8% range in order to lever, and the reason for that comes down to when our investments landed this year. We managed to get the business fully staffed. You might remember that early in the year we ran into some staffing difficulties and we built that staffing up over the course of the year, and that creates a comp for next year. So really, when we consider that higher and 5% to 8% gross profit for next year, the main driver is the timing of those staffing investments that we require in order to keep this business growing.
Jon Daniels
executiveAbsolutely. Rajat, I’ll address the affordability issue. I’m glad you brought it up. As we’ve said previously, among non-CAF buyers—those with lower credit scores—it seems affordability has frequently pushed them out of the market. That’s likely mirrored in the share of sales coming from Tier 3. But when you consider the CAF buyer, there’s an effect there too. Looking at it from a granular level, a customer last year might have walked in to buy a $20,000 vehicle and perhaps put $1,000 down. Today, in that scenario, they’d be financing $19,000; instead, they come in borrowing $28,000—and if they still put that same $1,000 down, they’re requesting $27,000. Like any lender, CAF must decide whether to allow that person to take on significantly more debt. So affordability is definitely a factor. What we’re observing with CAF—and this ties into our penetration this quarter—is that CAF wasn’t simply approving that $27,000 loan. It’s possible their income hadn’t risen to match the amount they wanted. Other lenders, though, might have been ready to offer that bigger sum, which hurt our penetration. Buyers are extending their loan terms. Currently, you’ll notice a far greater share of used-car loans stretching beyond 72 months. That’s obvious, and it’s a sharp change from a year ago. CAF doesn’t offer loans longer than 72 months at all, even though people are attempting to handle affordability by stretching the term; whether that’s a wise choice for them is uncertain, but CAF is intensifying the issue. So a few factors hurt penetration and clearly show how affordability is hitting customers. Lastly, on your point about rates: we’ve seen clear signals that rates will rise. They’ve already increased at the start, and they’ll likely keep climbing this year. During the latter part of this quarter, CAF actually ran some upward price tests. We’ve often mentioned that we test prices randomly in both directions. This quarter, we moved them up. That visibly cut into our penetration, but we believe it’s the correct move as we protect our margin. As prices rise, we expect to keep testing, and we think other lenders will either do the same or face pressure. So we’ll pass along increases when appropriate; we aim to stay very competitive in the market, but yes, we also need to safeguard our margin.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveRajat, let me add a bit more detail on that SG&A point. I believe it's also worth keeping in mind that our attention is on seizing the chances present in an industry that is transforming and fragmented, correct? So when it comes to whether now is the moment for us to put money in, and whether we're in stretches where the industry performs strongly or stretches where it's more challenged, such as what we encountered in Q4, what we're aiming for is profitable market share gains — and as Bill mentioned during his prepared remarks, we do think that in Q4, even with sales declining, we still held market share within our segment. And once more, that remains our objective as we keep moving ahead, meaning we will keep investing. For us, this is simply an enormous opportunity, and that's where we'll stay.
Bill Dossett
analystWilliam Dossett here, filling in for Brian Nagel. The thing we were hoping to ask about is what's behind the slowdown in the used car business between fiscal Q3 and fiscal Q4. You mentioned the drivers before. How should we frame the role of falling consumer confidence? At what point in Q4 did that show up? And how do we think about that dynamic as we head into fiscal Q3?
Bill Nash
executiveYeah. Like I mentioned earlier, consumer confidence was clearly among the drivers. I think we actually — immediately after the COVID surge, as we were sort of moving past that period, what we began to observe was simply a absence of confidence among consumers. And I'd say we're in a pretty comparable spot at present, for the very reasons we've already discussed. On affordability, interest rates are climbing. Inflation, plus the Ukraine-Russia war. There's simply a great deal pressing on the consumer at the moment. So regarding when things reverse, I can't say; but once more, picking up on what Enrique said before, I mean, we'll keep managing this. We've steered through cycles of this kind previously, and we believe we're positioned to handle it in a manner that lets us keep taking market share.
John Healy
analystThanks. Bill, I'd like to pose something fairly broad here. You mentioned affordability acting as a drag on the business, and that stands to reason — it makes everyone understand that when rates are elevated, perhaps values have to decline. So could you share your perspective on how units and ASP relate to one another, and how you expect ASPs along with the used car market might move around across the coming 6 to 12 months? Also, does a lot of confidence remain that you'll defend GP, possibly sacrificing same-store sales to do it? And do you consider the $2,100 GP benchmark reachable even if the used car market softens and the values of what sits in inventory come under some pressure?
Bill Nash
executiveYes, John, I appreciate that. To begin with, affordability — you're correct that it's a drag on retail, yet it genuinely helps wholesale, as our wholesale margins demonstrated. I believe that's among the advantages of running a diversified business, since, as you observed, our GPU for wholesale rose. On unit ASP, had you asked roughly 3 or 4 months back, I'd have told you my hope was that later this year we'd witness some easing. I simply can't be certain. Particularly with the conflict involving Ukraine and Russia, whether new car supply recovers later this year is unclear — that remains to be seen. That's a major element that would assist in tempering a portion of the general price inflation across both new and used vehicles. What I can say, though, regarding your GPU question, is that I believe our position is excellent. Consider the advantage self-sufficiency gives us — I touched on this briefly — everyone else faces inflationary pressure too. The good part is we possess a lever that counterbalances such inflationary pressure. Without a lever counterbalancing inflationary pressure, you'd clearly either see it eat into your margin or force your average selling prices upward. Beyond that, we still retain additional benefit to hand over to retail customers. I'd argue our self-sufficiency gains continue to mature. There's additional room, I think, in the way we steer that and the way we structure our offers and similar items. So when I look ahead, even entering a depreciating setting — and over time we've demonstrated that within a depreciating setting, we can still hold very steady GPUs. When it comes to self-sufficiency, given the range of operations we have, and considering the profit CAF can produce, plus the extra wholesale profit we can bring in, my sense is that we're able to keep margins per unit quite strong while still offering excellent retail front prices. So however the market evolves from here, I believe our position is a solid one.
Daniel Imbro
analystOne thing I wanted to ask about is tax refund season. I believe it kicked off sooner in 2023, and the overall amount disbursed has risen. Enrique, you said you'd brought people on proactively before tax season began. So I'm wondering whether you actually observed the anticipated acceleration once those payments went out, perhaps in transit volumes. And has what you've witnessed as refunds have been issued shifted how you view the fundamental strength of the consumer as we look at the remainder of fiscal '23?
Bill Nash
executiveYes. Daniel, looking at this year's tax season, it strikes me as quite typical of the prior year; keep in mind that last year's tax season arrived later than usual. So the timing this year closely mirrored last year. My sense is refunds have come in somewhat larger now than they did then; however, another wrinkle that's absent this time around but was present before was the stimulus distributed during January and March, making it genuinely difficult to separate those effects. I'd simply return to what I said regarding consumer confidence previously, which I believe holds true no matter what happens with tax season — the consumer simply isn't as well positioned as was the case 12 months ago.
Michael Montani
analystI'd like to ask, if that's alright, about the capacity side — could you update us on where things stand regarding the additional hires you planned to make and your ability to recondition vehicles given COVID-related disruptions and so on? Do you believe you're now adequately staffed, and can you complete all the recon work you'd been aiming for? That was my first question.
Bill Nash
executiveYes; at this stage we feel terrific about our capacity — both production capacity and our staffing. For much of the year — the first, second, and third quarters — I discussed efforts to build up staffing, and I discussed lower inventory. And as we exited the third quarter, I'd noted that we were well on our way to bringing inventory to the level it needs to be. Inventory wasn't really a major subject in the fourth quarter, in my view. Whenever I examine our inventory levels, my habit is to look at them per average store, and historically what I've consistently observed is an average of roughly 320; we haven't quite reached that 320. Still, I'd say it wasn't a significant story. I genuinely believe we possess the capacity required. Clearly we can — correct, at present, we have — we're capable of building over 1 million cars annually. And the capital expenditures Enrique mentioned previously are entirely part of our normal planning approach. Looking ahead, we already have certain production facilities underway, but these represent additional production facilities, and given how well our wholesale business has performed, we want to ensure we can fit all the space. So really, it's simply us conducting business the way we ordinarily do.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveRight. When you look at it through capital expenditures, what we're doing is aligning our capacity with demand over the longer term. And as Bill mentioned, these are simply the natural sorts of steps we're taking, being quite deliberate in how we go about adding capacity, so that as time goes on, we're able to hit the longer-term targets we've laid out there.
Bill Nash
executiveRight. What I'd point to as the sole distinction on the CapEx side — and Enrique has flagged this during a few separate calls by now — is simply that we've increased our spending on technology. It's just a larger share of what we spend on CapEx overall.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYeah, it's pretty fascinating, honestly. I brought this up during Analyst Day, but if you look back several years, roughly 15% of what we spent on CapEx went toward technology. And at this point, since we've been going through a transformation of our business, when we think about this year and the next one, we see that around 30% of our total CapEx spending is tied to technology. So it's definitely not a move toward turning into an omnichannel retailer.
Michael Montani
analystAlso, one of your big rivals just bought something in wholesale; what I'd like to do is expand on what you said a moment ago. So, with the increase in CapEx going toward technology, and with some of the other ways you can make profit, do you believe you have enough internally? Or could there be a chance to strengthen your main capabilities through acquisitions?
Bill Nash
executiveDo you mean in terms of production capacity?
Michael Montani
analystI figure the first thing relates to wholesale, correct? Over the last year, you folks have performed really well in that area. Could there be a chance to expand that platform at an even quicker rate through acquisitions? And then, on the technology front, with the increased CapEx spending, is that roughly sufficient? Or might there also be some inorganic capabilities you're looking at targeting?
Bill Nash
executiveYeah. Well, we're feeling terrific about the auction side of things. As you're aware, at present we're still running it entirely virtually. Regarding CapEx, your auction costs are considerably lower than your total production costs. The reason is that with production, you're putting up facilities, and those are costly. For auctions, at this stage you basically just require space. I mean, there's a bit of build out for certain bigger auction sites, but — in order to store this inventory. Still, we're feeling terrific about the plans and quite at ease with the way we've been running things, and with the fact that we're able to keep growing wholesale, really, at a faster rate than merely keeping up with the typical growth it experiences as we move more retail cars.
Seth Basham
analystMarket share has come up quite a bit during this call. I realize you folks don't track it every three months, but according to Cox data, used vehicle retail in the fiscal fourth quarter showed a 4% drop. Your retail unit sales fell by a larger amount, which means you'd have given up share. Could you help us understand whether that's a result of defending GPU, or are there different factors behind losing share during the quarter?
Bill Nash
executiveSure. Seth, when it comes to market share, even during Q4, our share expanded nicely, and our benchmark is <<inaudible>> data, which is title data. We review it only yearly because there tends to be a lag of roughly 2 to 3 months. So we have strong conviction that we picked up share both for the full year and during the fourth quarter. As I mentioned before, we feel truly terrific about share gains in Q1 regardless of what the macro factors are doing; and looking at market share, whether you slice it as 0- to 4-year-old vehicles, 5 to 7, or 8 to 10, every one of those buckets delivered double-digit growth; so we're very pleased. Another point worth making is that our share gains mostly come via comps. We haven't launched a large number of new markets, and that isn't what's fueling the share improvement, which, once again, has us excited.
Seth Basham
analystUnderstood. Alright, so if you're okay with it, one more question regarding the CAF segment. Your provision for loan losses fell within a typical band, I believe, as you had anticipated, Jon. When you consider the credit landscape at present and looking ahead, we've observed some weakening; yet in your view, you're not anticipating additional weakening, meaning there's no reason to boost your loan loss provisions down the road?
Jon Daniels
executiveYeah, those are reasonable points, Seth. Yes. No, what I'd do is simply highlight that our ratio of reserves to receivables held flat between last quarter and this one; we noted that in our view we've essentially gone back to levels seen before the pandemic. We believe we've reached that point. We currently feel quite confident in our reserve, and we possess solid command of the operation. So assuming everything unfolds the way we anticipate, honestly, the key focus for upcoming provisioning will be on freshly generated loans. And beyond that, clearly, there's a combination of Tier 1, Tier 2, Tier 3 along with the amount we originate, though I'd say we're fairly stable and positioned well.
Chris Bottiglieri
analystFirst up, regarding EPP — clearly that adjustment tied to the shift in accrual status. What's our thinking for the coming year? Do we simply average the 4 quarters and treat that as the fresh baseline? Or will it resemble this year, with Q4 carrying the EPP weighting?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveRight. With EPP, a few distinct factors come into play. You've got what I'd call the underlying operation, which sales drive along with an attach rate from our EPP and ESP offerings. On top of that sits the year-end profit sharing arrangement we hold with our partners. So looking at the earlier year, I'd say as our business expands and our penetration deepens, that growth should carry on. As for what happened in Q4 of this year, the reason was that profit sharing revenue came in greater than what we'd seen in Q4 of the prior year; this time around it was elevated. Because of when we book that, as you may remember, a year ago one of our partners' profit sharing revenue landed in Q2 and got recognized quarterly. Starting in fiscal year '22, they switched to an annual schedule, so at present our entire profit sharing recognition falls in Q4, and that explains why this year's Q4 profit sharing came in somewhat higher. Still, when you examine our business — the underlying sales, plus EPP attachment rates, which have performed quite strongly and hold steady around 60% — we'd anticipate that trend persisting going forward too.
Bill Nash
executiveRight. The sole additional point I'd make on that, Chris, is that generating a pile of profit sharing isn't what we're aiming for. What we're after, really, is fair pricing for the consumer on these items. There was some profit sharing — my sense is it came mostly from folks simply not driving much, that kind of thing; still, pushing a large revenue recognition at year-end isn't something we're necessarily trying to do.
Chris Bottiglieri
analystUnderstood. I'd like to ask something broader regarding where customers come from; you mentioned the instant appraisal side of things and expansion in customer acquisition, and I realize it's tough to separate out. But if you look at things like the model year of the cars you're purchasing through those channels, what portion of this represents added volume that, if we're talking about TAM, you believe would otherwise have been sold by an individual owner, versus what portion do you think is being pulled away from competing dealerships — maybe in an indirect way, vehicles that otherwise would have ended up at auction or been traded in at retail? Can you make sense of this internally in terms of what — for instance, how much of the payment growth comes from taking share? And finally, could you give some perspective on buyer rates — after you've appraised a vehicle, what does the buy rate look like now compared with what it was before COVID?
Bill Nash
executiveAll right. So Chris, regarding that incremental share point specifically, we're currently building out something like a buy share metric that examines cars whose most recent owner, before us, was basically the consumer themselves. So we're putting together a metric around that. Our confidence is high — that buy share has definitely gone up. That much we know, and at this point we're simply working toward measuring it more precisely; so that's an area we're focused on. Still, we're quite comfortable saying most of these are coming from other consumers. Turning to buy rate: in the past, the way buy rate was described prior to instant offer was the number of individuals who visited the store and wound up receiving an appraisal, and then what share of those vehicles did we end up purchasing. After that we introduced the online instant appraisal, and how we purchase — our current method of measuring buy rate is that you take — since we're putting out roughly 2 to 3 million instant offers each quarter, and plenty of people are just sort of browsing to check what their car is worth. So under our present method, buy rate is calculated based on instant offers, and when those people arrive at the store, what portion of them actually convert, on top of the older method we used; and we're at 40% on buy rate. Looking at it through the older method we previously used, it's likely in the low 30-ish — 30-ish percent. So with any luck, that gives you the color you were after.
Chris Bottiglieri
analystYeah, that's a lot more involved. Thanks for that. That helps.
David Whiston
analystRegarding CAF penetration, there are more 3-day payoffs. If you look at fiscal '17 or thereabouts, it's lower, and I'm just wondering. Clearly, Tier 2 seems to be capturing additional business. Is that simply something you're doing on purpose? Or is another factor behind that drop? And then around the middle of the decade, what level do you want your penetration to reach, gross or net?
Jon Daniels
executiveYeah. Thanks for asking, David. Yeah, I brought up affordability in what we said earlier, so let's focus on penetration and I appreciate you referencing pre-pandemic levels. Traditionally, Q4 won't be among the strongest CAF penetration quarters, clearly since it's pressed right up against tax season. Having said that, it is lower, and outside financing is taking penetration from us. As I said before, we firmly think this comes down to affordability. Given the ASPs out there, customers arrive wanting to borrow additional funds. As a lender, we face a choice: do we require a larger down payment? Or do we allow them to borrow the entire amount? With the higher ASP, in certain instances we aren't permitting them to borrow the whole sum they request, and maybe an outside lender is prepared to give them that entire amount, even if their income hasn't risen by the same degree; so in that situation we believe we're losing out. I also brought up longer terms. Clearly, people are handling affordability by stretching out the term. That lowers the monthly payment far more than any rate change would. So right now we don't offer a used loan term beyond 72 months, CAF doesn't, and it actually affected CarMax. None of our lenders offer that. So we believe there are certainly people out there offering it. The data has demonstrated that; so I think those 2 factors are driving penetration. I also mentioned that we ran price testing upward which, again, was an effort to align with where interest rates are going so we could manage our margins; so we did observe some effects there; so I think that's what's shifting the actual penetration this quarter. As for where we want it to land, I think we tend to think of it more as wanting to be highly competitive. There are constant ebbs and flows depending on what outside players do, but we want to stay highly competitive and give our higher-end customers a chance to finance internally. But that's what we love about our platform. You can do a 3-day payoff; we have other lenders who can pick that up, but we don't want to extend the full amount, and we can still sell the car in CarMax. Accordingly, hitting some specific penetration level isn't really our aim, and my expectation is that this will naturally rise and fall as time goes on, particularly once pricing declines.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveHonestly, that's the mindset behind CAF that truly allows us to build a genuinely robust book of receivables and to keep CAF delivering steady, dependable results.
Bill Nash
executiveAnd I think that's also why it makes sense to bring additional lenders on board, so that if we hold our portfolio in paper very, very consistently, having other lenders in CarMax's camp is a wonderful thing.
David Whiston
analystLet me get one thing straight regarding what you mentioned. Was it that the Tier 2 and Tier 3 partners, not just capital, avoid terms beyond 72 months?
Jon Daniels
executiveAs things stand in CarMax stores, or within the CarMax business, a used loan exceeding 72 months isn't something we provide. That could change down the road, or it might not. At present, though, that isn't what's happening at CAF or with our other lenders.
David Whiston
analystAll right. So, inevitably, do you believe you'll need to exceed 72?
Jon Daniels
executiveWe've decided against doing so. Once more, our aim is to do what's right for the buyer. We aren't really certain that 84 months is the ideal option on a pre-owned vehicle, so we'll let the market determine that; and clearly, we recognize that costs are climbing and loan terms are stretching out, yet we also anticipate that prices will likely settle back down, and it may not be needed; but once again, we want to make the finest choice for the buyer, and we believe we can still move cars without offering that right now.
Sharon Zackfia
analystI've got one more quick thing to ask. You've said you'd put additional money into marketing, I realize that, yet CAC rose significantly during Q4. My understanding is that it came to roughly $350 million across the whole year. Does $350 million represent the appropriate run rate? Also, with consumers potentially facing enormous distractions right now, how do you view the guardrails surrounding marketing?
Bill Nash
executiveGreat question, Sharon. Sure. When I look back to roughly the pre-pandemic period and examine our total advertising outlay, we are — just as we promised — putting more money in. Compared with pre-pandemic levels, we're up roughly 70%, and on a per-unit basis that works out to an increase of approximately 55% or so. This year, I'd say we landed squarely within the range we'd described. We entered this year at that mid-$300 per unit. And I'd say we've reached a stage where particular items need advertising and visibility, particularly given new functionality we've introduced. Honestly, I don't see us pulling back on advertising. As for your question about whether we keep increasing it — that's where we'll assess the dynamics, determine where consumers stand, and decide whether to go past that level. Still, a useful frame is this: this year's per-unit spending will land close to last year's figure.
Daniel Imbro
analystI'd like to build on the instant offer topic as it relates to consumers. At present, people have positive equity in their vehicles. My thinking is that this makes purchasing from them simpler, since they're turning a profit on every one; however, when we go back to negative equity in vehicles in the years ahead, do you believe that will complicate your ability to source customers? Or what's your expectation for how that will affect your capacity to source and, you know, achieve success with instant offer once negative equity returns? Is it possible to simply fold that into financing, or what's your approach there?
Bill Nash
executiveYes. So Daniel, I mean, believe it or not, there are still people out there right now with negative equity, even though it's lower simply because prices have risen so much. But that's a situation we've existed in for nearly 30 years now. Consumers do come to us with negative equity. Obviously, you've got this price appreciation at the moment. Is there a possibility later on? For some customers, it might be more difficult since they can't put together a large enough down payment or whatever. But again, the way I look at it is — and Jon touched on this a bit. When you examine loan-to-value, loan-to-values have in fact declined. People are making larger down payments. So I believe that's a positive indicator. I think another factor is that all these customers purchasing today, it's not as if they'll all choose to trade in 1 year from now or 2 years from now or 3 years from now. They'll be distributed across time, and we'll run the business exactly as we have previously with other customers who have negative equity. So we feel we'll be able to handle it both from a sales perspective, but also, as you mentioned, on the buy side too.
Bill Nash
executiveOkay. Thanks, Jess. So, I'd like to express my gratitude to everyone for being on today's call, for your inquiries, and for your backing. When I reflect, fiscal '22 proved to be an excellent period—strong revenue, strong profits, strong share of the market; we have been putting money into initiatives and those initiatives are delivering returns, and we are genuinely thrilled regarding the possibilities in front of us as we keep being that constructive and disruptive presence in the pre-owned vehicle sector. And once more, I wish to thank each of our team members since they are the source of our achievements. I value all that they do every day, and we'll speak again in the next quarter. Thanks, once more, for your time.
Operator
operatorEveryone, we have now reached the end of the CarMax earnings release conference call for the fourth quarter of fiscal year 2022. At this point, you are free to hang up.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete CarMax, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to CarMax, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in CarMax, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.