CarMax, Inc. (KMX) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

June 24, 2022

New York Stock Exchange US Consumer Discretionary Specialty Retail earnings 61 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

David Lowenstein

executive
#1

Thanks, Orlando. Morning, everyone. I appreciate you being on the call for our first-quarter fiscal 2023 earnings conference. Joining me are Bill Nash, who serves as our President and CEO; Enrique Mayor-Mora, our Executive Vice President and CFO; and Jon Daniels, our Senior Vice President of CarMax Auto Finance Operations. I want to note that anything we say today that isn't a statement of historical fact — including remarks about future business plans, prospects, and financial performance — counts as a forward-looking statement made under the Safe Harbor provisions of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Such statements rest on what we currently know, expect, and assume, and they carry substantial risks and uncertainties that might cause actual results to differ materially from what we expect. When we provide projections and other forward-looking statements, we disclaim any intent or obligation to update them. For more detail on important facts that could affect these expectations, please refer to our Form 8-K filed with the SEC this morning, as well as our Annual Report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended February 28, 2022, which was previously filed with the SEC. If any follow-up questions come up after the call, don't hesitate to reach our Investor Relations department at 804 to 747 to 0422, extension 7865. Finally, thanks ahead of time for limiting yourself to one question and then getting back in the queue for any additional follow-ups. Bill?

Bill Nash

executive
#2

Appreciate that, David. Morning, everybody, and thank you for being here. In Q1 of fiscal '23, our diversified business model produced total sales of $9.3 billion, a 21% increase over the same quarter a year earlier, powered by higher average selling prices and greater wholesale volume, partly offset by fewer retail used units sold. Through our retail and wholesale channels combined, we moved roughly 427,000 cars during Q1, which is 5.5% lower than the comparable period last year. Within retail, total unit sales for Q1 fell 11%, while used unit comps dropped 12.7% against Q1 of last year. The same broad macro forces that caused used auto sales to fall across the entire market during the quarter drove our results — among them, lapping the meaningful stimulus benefits paid out a year earlier, broad inflationary pressure that includes hurdles to vehicle affordability, and weaker consumer confidence. We entered Q1 with comp sales down by a double-digit amount during March, extending the Q4 trend we talked about on our previous earnings call. From there, comps strengthened month over month, with May finishing at a low single-digit decline. Though we don't plan to discuss it every quarter, market share data adds useful context about how we performed and shows our relative results stayed solid. According to external data, we picked up share in each month from January through April, the most recent periods for which title data exists. We think that share gain mirrors the strength of our business model and omnichannel platform, which lets us navigate cycles such as this one successfully. In short, our focus remains on providing the most customer-centric experience in the industry, and we believe we're positioned well to achieve profitable market share gains in any environment; we posted first quarter retail gross profit per used unit of $2,339, which is $134 per unit higher than the prior year period. We stay focused on hitting the right balance among covering cost increases, preserving margin, and handing efficiencies through to consumers to help with vehicle affordability. Wholesale units rose 2.7% against the first quarter of last year, even with a calendar shift that hurt auction volume relative to the prior year. Wholesale volume also faced pressure from our choice to move some older vehicles out of wholesale and into retail to satisfy consumer demand for lower-priced vehicles; absent those two factors, we estimate our wholesale unit growth would have exceeded 10%. Wholesale gross profit per unit came to $1,029, essentially matching $1,025 a year ago. We're happy that we keep generating wholesale unit growth, even while lapping last year's nationwide rollout of our instant online appraisal offering on carmax.com and despite the industry-wide drop in used sales; we see our wholesale business as an additional growth lever and a valuable piece of our diversified business model. During Q1, we acquired around 362,000 cars from both consumers and dealers, which marks a 6% increase compared with the same timeframe a year ago. We remain the biggest purchaser of vehicles from consumers nationwide, having bought roughly 345,000 automobiles in the quarter — a 3% gain over last year's record figures. That kept our self-sufficiency level above 70% for the quarter. In addition, we obtained about 17,000 vehicles via our Max offer, the digital appraisal tool for dealers we brought up on our previous call. That represents a 183% rise compared with the equivalent period last year. Just to reiterate, sourcing straight from consumers and dealers brings down what we pay to acquire vehicles, improves the mix of our inventory and delivers profitable additional wholesale volume. CarMax Auto Finance, or CAF, posted $204 million in income, lower than the $242 million recorded in the same period a year earlier, since the provision for loan losses returned to normal levels following last year's favorable adjustment. Jon will share further specifics regarding customer financing, the loan loss provision and CAF's contribution shortly. With that, I'd like to hand the call over to Enrique, who will give more information about our first quarter financial performance. Enrique?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#3

Thank you, Bill, and good morning to all of you. For the first quarter, net earnings per diluted share came in at $1.56, compared with $2.63 during the same period last year. Although the main driver of this decrease was the drop in used sales, two additional items also affected the comparison. The first, which Jon will cover, is an $82 million year-over-year swing in the provision for loan losses, reflecting an environment that has become more normalized. The second is that earnings in the prior year's first quarter included a $22 million unrealized gain on an investment. Gross profit in total reached $875 million, a 5% decline versus last year's first quarter. The primary driver of this reduction was an 11% fall in total used unit sales, which was partly offset by higher retail gross profit per unit along with continued growth in wholesale units. Wholesale vehicle margin came to $192 million, rising 3% despite the headwinds during the quarter that Bill mentioned. Other gross profit was $120 million, 15% lower than in last year's first quarter. This reduction stemmed mainly from the impact of lower retail unit sales on service and EPP profits. Service results fell $31 million, as weaker sales and, secondarily, the effects of inflationary pressures produced a deleverage in results. EPP gross profit declined by $18 million, or 13%, a bit more than the rate of decline in retail unit sales. Although penetration held steady at roughly 61%, this year's first quarter also included a $2.3 million unfavorable shift in the return reserve adjustments relative to last year's period. Partly offsetting this drop in other gross profit was favorability in third-party finance income, which rose by $8 million, posting income of $3.4 million versus a cost of $4.6 million a year ago; this gain came from lower Tier 3 volume compared with last year's first quarter. The first quarter also gained from $20 million of margin contribution from Edmunds; on the SG&A side, first-quarter expenses rose to $657 million, 19% above the prior year's quarter, because of higher staffing costs and marketing, continued investment in our strategic initiatives, growth costs tied to the rise in appraisal buys and used stores, and the consolidation of Edmunds. SG&A as a percentage of gross profit deleveraged to 75%, compared with 59.9% in last year's first quarter. The year-over-year rise in SG&A dollars came mainly from three factors. First, compensation and benefits, excluding share-based compensation, increased by $61 million, driven by the annualization of the strong staffing growth we saw in the back half of last year, the inclusion of Edmunds payroll this quarter versus a year ago, wage pressures, and the ramp in field staffing in anticipation of a stronger tax season. Partly offsetting this rise was a $16 million reduction in share-based compensation. Second, other overheads grew by $26 million. The main drivers of this growth include investments to advance our technology platforms and strategic initiatives, as well as growth-related costs. Third, advertising expense increased by $16 million. The main driver of this rise was the reduced spending we saw in the first quarter of last year, which stemmed from our lean inventory levels and healthy customer demand; on top of that, spending during this quarter had factored in a more robust tax season. Throughout our company's history, we've steered through numerous tough consumer cycles, and we stay dedicated to running the business efficiently and effectively no matter what the macro climate looks like. As part of our capacity to adjust the business swiftly, we've already started improving how staffing in our stores and CDCs matches consumer demand. Looking at our capital structure, we continue to be in a very solid spot. We closed the quarter with an adjusted debt-to-capital ratio sitting in the middle of our target range of 35% to 45%. We also brought in enough cash to both reduce our revolver by over $580 million and speed up our share repurchase program compared with the back half of fiscal year '22. During the first quarter, we bought back roughly 1.6 million shares for $158 million. The first quarter also saw us enter the New York City metro market. We launched a store in Edison, New Jersey, and in the second quarter, we expect to launch stores in Wayne, New Jersey at East Meadow, New York; we anticipate adding two more stores in this market next year. Now I'd like to hand the call over to Jon.

Jon Daniels

executive
#4

Appreciate that, Enrique, and good morning to all of you. Once again our CarMax Auto Finance operation turned in strong performance this quarter, even with the broader lending market remaining choppy. CAF originated more than $2.4 billion in net loans during the first quarter. New customers were charged a weighted average contract rate of 9%, matching the figure from a year ago, yet that rate has climbed substantially from 8.2% in the quarter just before. Most of that sequential shift stemmed from higher rates passed along to consumers, not from any change in the credit mix. After the Fed gave clear signals early in the calendar year that rate hikes were coming, CAF moved quickly to test and then methodically tweak consumer rates so it could carefully balance sales, finance margin and penetration. Those proactive rate adjustments left CAF's first-quarter penetration, net of 3-day payoffs, at 39.3%, down from 43.7% a year earlier. Importantly, CAF's penetration level picked up as the quarter went on, as we watched banks and credit unions lift their own consumer rates during that stretch. Our Tier 2 partners kept competing for the desirable CarMax business, producing a penetration rate of 25.2% versus 22.8% a year ago. Tier 3 made up 7.1% of used unit sales, compared with 10% a year ago. We take this as a sign that these customers have felt the greatest impact from vehicle affordability challenges. CAF income for the quarter came to $204 million, which is a decline of 15%, or $37 million, from the same period a year ago. Let me pause here to explain the year-over-year swing in our loan loss provision. You'll remember that a year ago CAF booked $24 million of income in Q1 tied to the loan loss provision, as we kept adjusting our reserve in light of favorable loss performance relative to expectations set when the COVID pandemic began. This quarter CAF's loan loss provision was $58 million, a more normalized dollar figure that reflects the loss performance seen during the quarter. Our total interest margin substantially offset that provision headwind, growing $53 million year-over-year, which included a $36 million rise in interest and fee income plus a $17 million drop in interest expense. The reduction in interest expense was aided by a $9 million benefit from our hedging strategy. This quarter's provision of $58 million brought the ending reserve balance to $458 million, or 2.85% of managed receivables. That's a modest rise from 2.77% at the close of the fourth quarter and factors in a 5 basis point adjustment for growth in the Tier 2 and Tier 3 volume originated by CAF. We stay confident both in how resilient the CAF consumer is and in our capacity to serve them well. Although delinquency rates have risen, our Tier 1 credit losses remain comfortably inside our historical operating range of 2% to 2.5%. At this point I'd also like to give an update on our industry-leading online finance experience. Just to remind everyone, our proprietary finance-based shopping engine, or FBS, lets several lenders make decisions on one customer or co-applicants across all of our retail inventory, so a complete set of personalized decisions sits right at consumers' fingertips on carmax.com. In March, we took this experience further by piloting a pre-qualification feature that has no impact on your credit score, paired with a simplified application process delivering real-time credit decisions on our entire inventory; the results so far have us incredibly excited; roughly 25% of our online customers currently have access, and we expect to roll it out nationwide over the remainder of the year. Now I'll hand the call back to Bill.

Bill Nash

executive
#5

Thanks a lot, Jon, and thanks as well, Enrique. Over the last few years, the things we've prioritized and the money we've put to work have centered on creating a top-tier e-commerce platform—one that brings together purchasing and selling vehicles with our outstanding store experience. I'm happy to report that in the first quarter we hit an important milestone, since we've now made online self-progression capabilities available to every one of our retail customers. Getting here demanded an enormous organizational overhaul, and I want to express my gratitude to each of our associates for the incredible backing along the way as we join forces to build our omnichannel experience for our customers; when it comes to our first quarter online metrics, roughly 11% of retail unit sales happened online, an increase from 8% during the same quarter a year earlier. About 54% of retail unit sales this quarter were Omni sales, a modest decline from 56% in the comparable quarter last year. Online omni and in-person sales may shift quarter to quarter based on what consumers prefer and the way they decide to engage with us. Although we anticipate growth in our online and omni sales over time, what we aim for is delivering the finest experience, whether in-store, online, or a smooth blend of both. Our wholesale auctions continue to be virtual, meaning 100% of wholesale sales, which account for 23% of total revenue, count as online transactions. Revenue overall stemming from online transactions came to roughly 31%. That's an increase from 24% in the first quarter of last year. Our e-commerce engine, paired with our unmatched nationwide physical footprint, amounts to a competitive edge. Being able to integrate digital and physical transactions gives us reach into the biggest total addressable market compared with others in our industry and stands as a crucial differentiator. We're going to now direct our efforts toward further enhancing the experience for our customers and our associates by concentrating on how seamless our online and in-store offerings are. A few of our main areas of focus include, first, as Jon just noted, we're rolling out a more advanced version of our finance day shopping product. With interest rates climbing, it matters more than ever that consumers can secure financing with confidence. Once our best-in-class pre-qualification product is fully expanded, it will offer frictionless and seamless access to multi-lender credit terms on every car in our retail inventory and on every cart in our retail inventory, regardless of whether the consumer decides to browse and buy from the comfort of home, walk the lot by themselves using their mobile device, or shop side by side with one of our outstanding sales consultants. The second area we're focused on is continuing to harness data science, automation and AI to boost efficiency and effectiveness throughout our buying organizations, business offices and customer experience centers. Lastly, we'll keep using Max offer to source vehicles and extend our market leading position as a purchaser of cars. Through Max offer, we can leverage the Edmunds sales team to launch new markets and bring new dealers onto the service. This is yet one more illustration of how we keep prioritizing innovation and uncovering fresh possibilities in the blank areas next to what we already do well. Right now we operate in more than 30 markets, and we expect to add further markets during FY'23. Let me stay with Edmunds briefly — I'd like to note that on June 1, we marked one year since that acquisition closed. We're delighted to have every one of the skilled Edmunds associates joining us, and the worth generated up to now has left us quite pleased; we feel just as enthusiastic about what lies ahead as we keep jointly developing our vehicle and customer acquisition programs. Prior to wrapping up, I should recognize that the market carries uncertainty, and when it comes to consumer behavior, our fundamentals strike us as solid, and our diversified business model, we believe, lets us capture profitable market share regardless of conditions. As we move ahead, there are numerous chances to expand the business, and we're enthusiastic about what's coming. Having said that, we'd be glad to answer your questions. Orlando?

Brian Nagel

analyst
#6

Morning to you. Is my voice coming through?

Bill Nash

executive
#7

Morning, Brian — I can hear you fine.

Brian Nagel

analyst
#8

Sorry about that. I believe we had a transmission issue. Congratulations on the ongoing progress. So what I'd like to ask, taking a wider view as we examine the sales trends here, Bill — in your prepared remarks you brought up again some of those same elements, clearly the tough year-over-year comparisons from last year, again stimulus, and then higher prices, confidence, and so on. But now that we're moving into '22, are you getting a clearer picture of how the consumer truly is — how they're acting, the fundamental health of the consumer, and what's actually powering the business at this stage, especially since you referenced, I believe, a strengthening trend through fiscal Q1 — is the consumer's health improving, or is that more about comparisons?

Bill Nash

executive
#9

Yeah, Brian, look, I'd say on the whole the consumer has definitely gotten somewhat weaker, purely because of everything I've discussed. It's tough to put a number on it when you consider lapping over stimulus, what vehicles cost, the broad inflationary pressures, interest rates going up. When you look at all of those, pinning down each one's effect is difficult. Now, what I'd say is the further away we've gotten from lapping the stimulus, clearly, the better our performance was, as I mentioned in my opening remarks — we improved sequentially on comps all through the quarter, which is encouraging. That said, I believe the consumer has gotten softer, yet there's still demand out there, and that's what we're really trying to maximize, and we're taking a number of steps to capitalize on that; it's among the reasons we're — we keep finding efficiencies and passing along whatever we can to consumers so the vehicle becomes a little more affordable. In my opening remarks, I discussed selling somewhat more older vehicles, making them a little more affordable since we know some consumers want that. In fact, Brian, you've tracked us long enough to know we once had something we called ValueMax, which was really a 6-year-old vehicle, older than 6 or more than 60,000 miles, typically that — what that kind of inventory goes for, let's say, and I said in year 22% to 25% of our sales. Well, this quarter, it was closer to 35% of our sales. So there's some demand for that. And I think the other thing I'd mention is that's why we also have the lending platform we do, with great third-party lenders and CAF, just to make sure we can secure the most competitive interest rate for our customers.; so I think those are the things we're doing to kind of work through this. And while the consumer has gotten softer, there's still demand out there.

Brian Nagel

analyst
#10

No, that really does help. If I could just squeeze in one more question after that, though. So when you examine, say, the various cohorts within your business — vehicles with higher price tags, vehicles with lower price tags — are you noticing a more pronounced demand pattern right now among those groups?

Bill Nash

executive
#11

Regarding vehicle prices?

Brian Nagel

analyst
#12

Yeah, just so I can wrap my head around it — alright.

Bill Nash

executive
#13

The intriguing part here, Brian, is that going back 12 months, inventory priced below $25,000 made up 70% of what we had. Jump ahead to now, and that figure sits closer to 43% to 45%, which really stems from inflationary pressures — and that's another reason we're putting emphasis on bringing more affordable inventory to the market. So that's the big push we've got going at the moment. We do recognize there are people who want a pricier vehicle or an older one, but once again, that's where our attention is right now.

Brian Nagel

analyst
#14

Understood. I appreciate all the detail. Thanks.

Bill Nash

executive
#15

Yes.

John Healy

analyst
#16

Thank you. Perhaps we could approach that initial question from a slightly different angle. Bill, considering what you described regarding the state of the business—you've reset the merchandise, and there's been spending on the sales team and staffing—clearly those things pay off on different timelines. But looking at the shift from, let's say, low double-digit decreases in March or April down to low single-digit decreases in comps at present, what do you think is behind that gain? Could it be conversion? Could it be the staff in the stores? Or perhaps shoppers had hit pause and are now recognizing they need to complete a purchase? I'd really like to understand how you and your team explain this sequential uptick, and which efforts are tied more to the consumer?

Bill Nash

executive
#17

Yes, that's a fair question, John. Of course, I'd like to claim it stems from our ongoing push to enhance the experience, secure the proper inventory, and improve pricing and so forth, and I do believe that plays a role. Yet you can't overlook that in March of last year, the largest stimulus payments were distributed. And if you consider it, this year's tax season compared with the prior year's would appear quite comparable. The sole distinction, however, is that during last year's tax season a $1,400 check was sent to consumers, and that didn't occur this year. So that certainly made a difference. Therefore I won't stand here and assert that we alone are responsible for the momentum; I believe certain macro elements are helping it get better as the distance from that stimulus grows.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#18

Also, in my view, the way we've managed to purchase vehicles straight from customers — shown by our self-sufficiency rate — genuinely makes it possible for us to acquire those older vehicles. And, as Bill mentioned, the share of our sales that came from older cars wasn't driven by demand on the consumer side. Those vehicles are hard to obtain at auction. So it's really a testament to our capacity to source cars directly from consumers.

John Healy

analyst
#19

Okay, and I have one more thing to ask about. From what I understand, you said the auction schedule hurt the wholesale segment during this period. Is that going to flip back? Are we going to make up for it in Q2? I'm just wondering about how the timing shift plays out, or whether there could be a quarter with a gain as we think about the rest of the year.

Bill Nash

executive
#20

Yeah, absolutely a good question. To start, we feel really good about how auctions did, how wholesale did overall. It makes us happy that we actually expanded it. What happened was we had 1 fewer Monday sale and replaced it with a Tuesday, and Monday brings in more auction volume than a Tuesday does, and we actually benefited from that at some point last year. So there won't be a recovery there. The other factor I brought up, though, is that we chose to take some vehicles that we typically send through the auctions and instead build them to retail, and without those 2 items, if you take them out, wholesale would have increased by over 10%, which once again is something we're thrilled about.

John Healy

analyst
#21

Great. Thank you.

Bill Nash

executive
#22

Yes.

Sharon Zackfia

analyst
#23

Morning, everyone. When you consider adding more vehicles aimed at value-focused shoppers, have you thought about moving away from what I'd call the completely reconditioned condition you've always offered, and perhaps selling from the scratches or similar issues and labeling those units as is, to boost the value proposition further? I realize that's something you've been hesitant about historically, for brand reasons. Then, separately, clearly many people worry that the situation will deteriorate before improving — so from a controllable angle, how are you preparing in case there's another decline? How should we view SG&A, and what could you trim if trimming becomes necessary?

Bill Nash

executive
#24

Sure, I'll address both, since I'm confident Enrique will want to weigh in on the worries about what lies ahead. On your initial question, regarding older inventory: Sharon, if it's going to become a CarMax car, then a CarMax car it will be. You know, when you have these older vehicles, not every one of them qualifies. We'll wind up trying to move some through retail, they won't qualify, but we're elevating them to meet the CarMax standards. So I believe that covers your first question. Another point I'd mention is that those vehicles — and we've discussed this before, though it's been some time — tend to be more profitable; so they give us a tailwind too, when it comes to managing margin, pricing inventory, that sort of thing. So we'll keep doing that, we'll keep elevating them to CarMax standards rather than settling for a lower standard. Regarding worries about what might emerge down the road with the consumer, where the consumer is headed, Sharon, we've faced this multiple times before, and whether it's the ’08, ‘09 recession, whether it's the worst of COVID, we managed to get through it profitably on both occasions, and we have plenty of levers, we've demonstrated that we can pull those levers, whether they're expense levers — and consider this, you can decelerate some of your growth, you can decelerate some of your initiatives, you can reduce advertising, your variable will adjust — or if it's simply, you know, if you want to safeguard cash, you can alter your stock buyback, you can begin deferring some of your capital expenditures. So those are just a few of the levers that, you know, we've pulled previously and we're going to keep monitoring the conditions; but I'd say that here today, yes, the consumer is soft, but now isn't the moment. I don't believe we should be scaling back our initiatives, because the initiatives are what will truly help us grow down the road. Even so, we definitely know about the external elements at play, and we'll keep watching them.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#25

Yes, let me build on that. What we're aiming for, really, is making sure our spending matches what customers need, and at the same time, we keep putting money into the important parts that will let us expand both profitability and market share down the road. And like I said during my prepared remarks, with that in mind, we've already started aligning our cost structure with present demand — via scheduling and through natural attrition. So those steps are already done, and if a recession hits, we're sure about our capacity to get through it, since we're entering from a position of strength. We're profitable. Our balance sheet is strong, and we produce cash. So we feel — again, as Bill said — that we've seen these cycles previously, and we're confident we can steer through it well while also growing our market share.

Sharon Zackfia

analyst
#26

Okay, thank you.

Bill Nash

executive
#27

Thank you, Sharon.

Rajat Gupta

analyst
#28

Thanks for letting me ask a couple of things, and congratulations on how well you did with the retail gross profit per unit. Could you walk us through what changed relative to the previous quarter and explain the reason for that increase we saw sequentially? Was it money saved through reconditioning, simply a different mix in where you source from, or does pricing play a role? I'd love for you to break those out into categories if that's doable, and then I have one more question after that.

Bill Nash

executive
#29

Sure, I appreciate that, Rajat. The way I look at it — and I mentioned this during my opening comments — is that we're genuinely attempting to strike the right balance here. There are gains we can capture, and in the past those gains have consistently been handed over to customers. At the moment, the major gains come from two places: our self-sufficiency level remains elevated, and we now have a new situation in which we've committed to a greater number of vehicles from earlier model years. As I mentioned before, those earlier-model vehicles typically deliver higher margin. That gives us a chance both to steer our margin and to hand efficiencies down to buyers. This quarter, as you can see, came in somewhat above both last year's figure and even our five-year average. The reason is that while we keep handing customers the benefits of those efficiencies through lower prices, we also retained a bit more for the bottom line, and we watch things like sales elasticity and what competitors are holding in inventory. That approach will carry on into the future. Still, at this moment we're quite pleased with where our margins stand, and assuming nothing else major shifts and we stay watchful on the testing side, we're optimistic about margins ahead too.

Rajat Gupta

analyst
#30

Understood, understood. On a similar note, regarding the shift you're making toward SG&A, is some of that modest adjustment in where we source from, or the effort to keep that GPU coming, happening while we take on more SG&A expense? Right now you're at about $2,700 per unit, and this is normally the strongest quarter of the year seasonally, so I'm wondering what brings that number lower as we move through the year? Where are the opportunities? Could you walk us through some of the positives and negatives there regarding how SG&A per unit ought to trend from here?

Bill Nash

executive
#31

Yes, I'll hand it over to Enrique momentarily, but let me clarify: these margin gains aren't being achieved by sacrificing SG&A, and in terms of how we view margin, while we were building the cars we've definitely encountered inflationary pressure in car construction, which shows up in COGS; yet we're also putting in a lot of effort to counterbalance that. So we're not only giving back some savings to the customer via certain efficiencies, but I also believe that since we're counterbalancing these costs, that too flows through to customers, because a number of competitors lack levers, and should costs rise, which is what everybody is witnessing whether it's fuel, components, or wages, if they have no levers available, their prices climb. So I view that as an efficiency on price too.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#32

Sure. And to add to what was just said, I'd point out that our SG&A is feeling some strain because of how many buys we're doing. We've seen incredible results from the volume of buys, so we need to bring on more people to handle that, and that fluctuates along with our self efficiency rate. So SG&A is under some strain, but what I'd share with you is that in Q1, a key part of the story behind the deleverage really comes down to a few factors, when you compare year-over-year and look at the deleverage. First, we didn't have enough staff during last year's first quarter — you remember, with the pandemic and as we came out of it, we were short-staffed; and throughout the back half of last year we remained short-staffed — or rather, we were building up staffing. Since we were short-staffed last year, we also spent less per unit on marketing during last year's first quarter, since our inventory was pretty constrained; so we spent somewhat less while demand was very strong, so we're up against those 2 factors in Q1, which created a fair amount of strain on that leverage rate. I believe the second factor is that, expecting a stronger tax season, we added staff in our stores and in our CDCs, and we had to put more into marketing, and those sales didn't materialize, but as I've mentioned, we're quite nimble and we can bring those back down, which is what we've already started doing with staffing in the CDCs and in our stores; and once again we're accomplishing that simply through attrition and through improved scheduling. But we can bring that down, though I think it matters to grasp what caused the Q1 deleverage.

Rajat Gupta

analyst
#33

Understood. That's helpful context, thank you. I'll rejoin the queue.

Bill Nash

executive
#34

Thanks, Rajat.

Daniel Imbro

analyst
#35

Yes. Hey, good morning everyone. Thanks for taking our question. I'd like to ask about the competitive environment for CAF at this point. I believe during the prior quarter we discussed how a number of the other lenders had been stretching terms out to 84 months. They weren't passing through higher cost of funds; it seems, as you noted in your prepared remarks, that they began passing through some of those higher cost of funds over the quarter. But I'm just curious how the competitive backdrop is shifting, and clearly CAF penetration declined during the quarter. I mean, was that deliberate on your side, walking away from business? Or could you tell us what caused that? Thanks.

Jon Daniels

executive
#36

Absolutely, and I appreciate you asking, Daniel. And yes, thank you for mentioning it — we did cover that in the prepared remarks. I'd say the main thing that shaped the narrative, the headline number, around penetration this quarter came from our moves on cash pricing. We aren't exiting any business. When you look at the average APR we charged customers, it went from 8.2% last quarter to 9% this quarter, and that's mostly because we're passing on higher costs under the consumer. It's a tricky balance — you're working out how to manage it while staying very competitive for your customer. Keep in mind our competition is mainly credit unions, and to some extent external banks. Regarding installation, what we're seeing is that we simply wanted to act a bit earlier than they did. The lowest point for penetration during the quarter landed more in the February-March window. We were monitoring our rivals, and they were increasing rates across the quarter, but we moved just a bit ahead of them, which is why our penetration recovered as the quarter progressed. So I expect this pattern to persist—we're constantly trying to balance our penetration levels, capture on net interest margin, and of course remain highly competitive for our customers. It's a fine line to walk, and it will keep going this way, but we'll stay attentive to what our competitors are doing and what the Fed decides.

Bill Nash

executive
#37

And as for Jon — well, among those customers, our penetration declined while the share who arranged their own funding rose.

Jon Daniels

executive
#38

Okay, that's basically the trade-off. Typically in our business, someone comes in, spots a vehicle, decides they want it, and then either goes with financing through CAF or — and this is the nice part of what we offer — they're free to go elsewhere without feeling forced to give up the car, and that's usually the path taken. So this quarter, that's simply what they opted for.

Daniel Imbro

analyst
#39

Understood. I’ll rejoin the queue. Thanks a lot, everyone.

Bill Nash

executive
#40

Thank you, Daniel.

Nathan Friedman

analyst
#41

Hi there, this is Nathan Friedman calling in for Seth. I appreciate you taking my questions. What I first wanted to ask about is retail gross profit per unit — with the used car pricing environment as it stands and depreciation possibly going back to normal or even speeding up for the rest of the year, do you expect this GPU level to continue? And what should our thinking be around that?

Bill Nash

executive
#42

Yes, Nathan. Like I mentioned before, our margins are something we feel good about. There are some tailwinds working in our favor. I'd say we've made it through depreciation periods in the past, and I believe we do really well in those situations. During those earlier stretches of depreciation, we managed to hold our margins. So my expectation is that things will play out similarly. The only stretches I can point to where our margins got squeezed somewhat are when you get swift, swift depreciation over a really brief window. Yet even in those cases, it doesn't last long. So we're quite confident in our capacity to keep holding margins. That said, as I mentioned before, we'll also be trying out many different things and keeping a close watch on where the consumer stands, sales elasticity, competitors, and all of that.

Nathan Friedman

analyst
#43

Understood. Appreciate it. My follow-up concerns the impressive net interest margin you posted in this period, plus the quarter-over-quarter gain, even though margins on your most recent ABS securitizations saw quite substantial declines sequentially. Could you elaborate or put a figure on the amount of advantage your hedging approach delivered during this quarter? Also, how do you see net interest margins shaping up ahead?

Jon Daniels

executive
#44

Certainly. Enrique and I will likely split this one. Let me begin by addressing the net interest margin expansion we recorded over the quarter. The thing to keep in mind, once more, is that under our business model and accounting methods, we recognize income across time instead of using a gain on sale approach. That means the assets generating our net interest margin this quarter trace back to one year ago, two years ago, three years ago, when spreads were extremely strong. So clearly, what we add this quarter, along with the latest ABS transaction, will largely counterbalance what is leaving our portfolio. It simply works out that the timing leaves such high-margin assets still sitting in our portfolio, and they will stay there for a while. And in time, provided we sustain our margin at a high level and keep managing it effectively, then the decline could be reduced, or at minimum, gradual when things turn down. As for the hedging approach, I'll hand that over to Enrique.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#45

Right. So like Jon said during his prepared comments, this quarter brought us a $9 million gain tied to a hedge benefit, and I want to unpack that a bit. Most of what we're owed gets financed via the securitization market, and on every bit of that we carry an accounting hedge. That said, we've also got other funding structures, which we've discussed for several years now, correct? Through our banking partners, some of those receivables carry a cash flow hedge rather than an accounting hedge. The reason comes down to wanting to keep our funding mix flexible. As a result, those receivables lacking an accounting hedge get marked to market each quarter. Given how sharply and significantly interest rates moved recently, that worked in our favor this quarter, though going forward we'd only anticipate this mattering to any real extent during periods that again feature abrupt and substantial rate shifts.

Nathan Friedman

analyst
#46

Alright, that's encouraging. I appreciate you making room for us, and I wish you all the best.

Jon Daniels

executive
#47

Thanks so much.

John Murphy

analyst
#48

Morning, everyone. I'd like to revisit the move toward vehicles that are older. Bill, when we consider the coming years, the population of cars aged zero to 6 years will probably decline quite sharply, or at minimum won't bounce back much, assuming that's what new vehicle sales show us — those cars simply aren't there in practice. So when you look at going older, past 6 years, there appears to be a genuine opening in vehicles aged 7 to 10 years. Our high-quality offerings look quite different from what they were 10 to 20 years back, so you can present them to buyers quite convincingly, meaning they're solid products for you to represent and sell. So I'm just wondering, thinking about that concept, and as you mentioned you moved from 25% Valuemax or Valuemax-type vehicles to 35% this quarter — might that climb substantially over time? And is this the sort of thing that wouldn't merely help offset part of the supply shortfall on the zero to 6 year side, but could be more structural, and if you look 5 to 10 years ahead, might it sharply expand your addressable market per store or overall?

Bill Nash

executive
#49

Yes. Morning, John. Yes, that's an excellent question. What's wonderful about our business is that whatever consumers want, we'll make it available. Clearly, though, locating some of these vehicles and reconditioning them is somewhat tougher. We've faced a comparable set of circumstances before. Looking back at '08 and '09, during the recession, when the new car SAAR fell sharply — it was actually even more extreme at that time — I believe what that produced was something like a 10-year supply of newer-type cars, since, as you know, the SAAR had fallen to really low double-digits. At one point, I think it may even have gone beneath that. So a bubble existed that needed to work its way out. And I'd anticipate a comparable situation, though nowhere near the scale we witnessed in '08 or '09. I'd say the big difference now — back then, we could still manage, but what we possess today that we lacked then is simply our self-sufficiency, and when I consider that category of inventory, our finest source for it comes from consumers, so the fact that our self-sufficiency is so elevated. It simply provides us with a great deal of that stock. You know, I mentioned a bit about those vehicles older than six, but honestly the breakdown doesn't really matter — zero to four, you know, that's typically around 66% of our sales a year back or so, while this quarter it's roughly 50%. Five to seven year old vehicles, again, that was 20% to 25%, and now it's 30% to 35%. Eight-plus, it's around 15%, and that holds across the board. Plus we now have a better inventory source, so we're enthusiastic about the opportunity ahead.

John Murphy

analyst
#50

All right. So perhaps as a quick follow-up on that point — regarding the acquisition side, I mean, it appears you're performing well when it comes to self-sufficiency; however, when we consider the consumer who purchases that vehicle; it sounds as though they actually possess a stronger inclination compared to the younger vehicles to complete the purchase online. I mean, when you examine your omnichannel initiatives and the actual conversion rates across age groups. I mean, is it accurate that essentially this vehicle that's seven plus years old is actually — that purchaser is actually more likely to buy online than, say, the one to three year old bucket. I mean, I'm just wondering what you're observing in that area?

Bill Nash

executive
#51

Yes, John. Honestly, right off the top of my head, I'm not sure whether that's necessarily the case, I mean from an online sales standpoint what we're observing is it's a broad range of consumers seeking various merchandise. So I don't believe it's necessarily the case that it's the older stuff which sells online. A portion of it is, I don't think it's disproportionate.

John Murphy

analyst
#52

Alright, thanks a lot.

Bill Nash

executive
#53

Thanks, John.

Michael Montani

analyst
#54

Thanks a lot for fielding my question. Morning to you. First off, I'd like to ask, if possible, whether you folks might offer a bit of extra detail on the purchasing patterns you're observing. I'm not sure whether you're able to break that down according to income bracket — say, households at 40k and under as opposed to those at 100k and above. Still, could you perhaps describe what you noticed on that front during the quarter? And beyond that, how things have shifted since then — have sales more or less leveled off, declining by a low single-digit amount?

Bill Nash

executive
#55

Mike, the household income cohort you're asking about isn't something I have available. Both our online and in-store appraisal lane has genuinely struck a chord widely among every kind of consumer. What I'd note is that, interestingly, during the quarter we purchased — this may not come as a complete shock — we acquired a greater number of what I'd describe as bigger SUV pickup trucks from consumers, which could be tied to gas prices. Conversely, we also moved more of those; there were consumers who, you know, I think when the right price is paid and your pricing is right, they will sell, and we truly did — we witnessed that. However, I don't have the figures before me to inform you. Alright, household income — what does that look like on a sale? What I can say is that the product we've got available has genuinely drawn appeal across the entire spectrum.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#56

Yeah. I suppose the thing I'd tack onto that is a bit of the credit angle — attempting to match up, say, household income with the credit quality of the person walking in. As we've said previously, I believe demand exists out there. You observe that customer with weaker credit who's still out shopping, still filling out credit applications — it just appears that at points they may be priced out of the markets, given what a vehicle costs and, in the end, what the monthly payments come to. So I'd say demand is present, and I think once inventory declines they'll be in a position to get there; so once more, assuming there's some relationship between that consumer and the consumer with lower income. Demand, in my view, is there.

Michael Montani

analyst
#57

And if I could just ask a quick follow-up about profits — at the start of this year, you folks said that to get leverage, gross profit dollars had to increase, roughly, in the high single digits, because of certain investments being made; so I just wanted to consider that for the second half of the year. Does add expense sort of rise now that multi-channel has first been launched, and head count sounds like it might ease somewhat? So just assist us in grasping, roughly, how to think about the rate of SG&A dollars across the back half?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#58

Yes; and so what we told you on the previous call is that in fiscal year ’23 we actually anticipate needing an amount beyond that historical high single-digit range, correct. So to achieve leverage in the year ahead, more than that is required, since, as I mentioned before, it's mostly that annualization of the staffing success, and once more Q1 truly is the quarter in which we observe the bulk of that effect; we remain committed to making certain our expenses match customer demand. And again, I discussed that we've already — the actions we've already taken. So for Q1, from a year-over-year leverage standpoint, it is our most difficult quarter.

Michael Montani

analyst
#59

Thank you.

Bill Nash

executive
#60

Thank you.

Craig Kennison

analyst
#61

Morning, and thank you for allowing me to ask something too. I'd like to explore how you source vehicles and get a clearer picture of the Maxoffer product. Could you describe the unit economics behind it? Also, what makes dealers pick it when you're competing against them in the same local area? On top of that, do those vehicles generate margins comparable to ones you acquired straight from a consumer or through auctions? Thank you.

Bill Nash

executive
#62

Sure, Craig. As mentioned before, Maxoffer has us enthusiastic; it's something we've devoted effort to developing, though it temporarily ranked below the IO, yet we apply comparable algorithms. Regarding profitability, clearly — well, to start, vehicles purchased via Maxoffer are definitely more lucrative than those acquired offsite. If I were to rank them, I'd say the highest earners are certainly the IOs where consumers bring vehicles to us, for clear reasons like avoiding logistics and similar costs. When it comes to Maxoffer, they aren't as lucrative as a consumer deal, yet they remain more lucrative than offsite purchases, which again is logical since we avoid paying buy fees. On the question of why dealers — we opt to use it, but many deals exist where they hold inventory they aren't keen on, or they're reviewing appraisals they genuinely can't figure out how to price. So this is a service offered at zero cost with a guarantee behind it, and it's shown it connects. As I mentioned during the call, we're slightly above 30 — operating in 30 markets, with ample room to keep growing it. Edmunds works with 1,000s of dealers through our auctions. We also have 1,000s of dealers, so we see substantial potential in this area.

Craig Kennison

analyst
#63

Could you provide some detail regarding how the fees are set up? Is it you who receives a fee, or is it them?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#64

Yes, we do — actually, we structure it so that it's somewhat worthwhile for our time, meaning they do earn a certain amount from these, and that's roughly the way we handle it.

Craig Kennison

analyst
#65

Perfect, thank you.

Bill Nash

executive
#66

Yes.

Evan Silverberg

analyst
#67

Morning, everyone. This is Evan Silverberg, sitting in for Adam Jonas. I realize you gave us a bit of detail in the prepared remarks regarding comps per month on a year-over-year basis. I'm wondering whether you could share anything further on an absolute basis? What was the sales trajectory like across the quarter? And how are you viewing the exit rate as we head into 2Q?

Bill Nash

executive
#68

Sure. As I mentioned during my opening remarks, they improved steadily as the quarter went on, going from double-digits to a low single-digit negative comp by the time the quarter ended. So that trend has left us pleased. And clearly we'll discuss June when we get to second quarter at that point, but once again, we feel good about how we came out of the quarter.

Evan Silverberg

analyst
#69

Also, during this quarter, are any patterns showing up among consumer tiers, or would you say things are fairly stable across the various classes?

Bill Nash

executive
#70

No. My sense is it's quite stable across the various groups, and as Jon mentioned before, the customer with the lower FICO score is likely feeling the greatest effect from vehicle affordability. Yet once more, that's how things looked when the quarter began, and that's how they looked when it finished. So I'd call it pretty consistent across the quarter.

Evan Silverberg

analyst
#71

Great. Thank you very much.

Bill Nash

executive
#72

Thank you.

David Whiston

analyst
#73

Thanks, good morning. It's wonderful to witness free cash flow being generated, plus buybacks and the debt reduction. I was simply wondering about the approximately, as I figure it, $1 billion that comes due in two years' time. Is the plan just to eliminate that revolver via internally generated free cash flow prior to then? Would you consider doing a five year, 10-year bond offering at some point?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#74

Yes. Well, we would. As you mentioned, I mean, we're extremely happy with how our cash flow performed this quarter. You know, even with a difficult sales quarter, certainly our business model can produce cash, and we're really delighted that let us reduce a substantial amount on our revolver, nearly $600 million, and speed up our share repurchase program. So regarding what we'll do going forward, I think the way to consider it is, we'll be nimble to the environment, we're going to do what's right for our shareholders. And while examining how we're performing and kind of what the options are for us. I think the way to consider it is we intend on managing within our capital structure at 30% to 45% adjusted debt-to-cap, and that's how we kind of run the business we do that by taking on debt, we're pulling down debt and also by our share repurchase program; so those are the levers that we use. So going forward, you know, we'll end up managing to that rate.

David Whiston

analyst
#75

Alright. Turning to how much free cash flow you generated, it seems inventory cuts gave you considerable support, something you hadn't received from working capital across the prior several quarters. I'm just wondering, was that drop in inventory deliberate on your part, aimed at producing some free cash flow? Or might it instead stem from purchasing a greater number of older vehicles?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#76

Yeah, it was somewhat more tied to seasonality; during this period of the year, in Q1 and heading into the first half, we brought inventory down as we move through tax season — that accounts for part of it. We additionally observed that from one quarter to the next, the average cost of our inventory declined somewhat; so we did notice that, and it gave us a bit of a lift too.

David Whiston

analyst
#77

All right, thanks.

Chris Bottiglieri

analyst
#78

Hi, everybody. Appreciate you taking my question. I just had a follow-up on the CAF funding cost, if I could. So, a few things, I suppose, starting with the interest rate hedge question — do you expect rates to remain where they are, meaning that $9 million hedging benefit would reverse, and could you help me understand how long you said that would last? Then, separately, regarding the warehouse facility, in the K, what is the benchmark rate for that warehouse facility — is it LIBOR, or whatever has replaced LIBOR, or a SOFR-type figure, whatever it's called? And then, sorry, one final follow-on to that bigger picture: I think you probably passed along that 50 bps of rate to some customers. Of that 300 basis point increase in benchmark rates, how much do you ultimately expect to pass through? That's all from me.

Jon Daniels

executive
#79

I'll actually take the last one first. Yes, as you said, we certainly have passed rates along to consumers. Like I mentioned before, this will always be a test we assess — you know, recognizing what we're attempting to manage: penetration, margin, customer experience, all of those things. So we'll monitor it very closely. What pleased me greatly this quarter was that it wasn't merely one move and then we forgot about it and absorbed it — it involved identifying specific pockets of populations that we believe are less elastic, more elastic, testing, adjusting, you know, watching what our competitors are up to, and that's broadly how we run things. So again, we aren't trying to absolutely lead the market in passing that along. We want to ensure we stay highly competitive. Again, luckily, we have that three day payoff option. Customers might use it to ensure we still sell the car. So I can't predict precisely how much will be passed along, but you get a sense of how we're handling it.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#80

Right, and regarding those remaining two items: when it comes to what our warehouses are priced off, it's essentially LIBOR, and increasingly SOFR as that mechanism gradually reaches maturity. On the hedging side, specifically that $9 million figure, we don't hold an accounting hedge — what we have is a cash flow hedge. Once more, that's genuinely going to shift; it will help just as it did this quarter, and it could hurt only in the event that interest rates move — shift abruptly and substantially, that's the point at which they'll move, given that hedge we hold. Those hedges extend across the loan's life that we have, correct? Yet once more, it's truly only going to vary between one quarter and the next. When a sudden and substantial shift occurs in those rates, that's the reason we observe a gain or <<inaudible>>. And once more, that's on — as I said before — the overwhelming bulk of our receivables owed to the securitization market won't be affected quarter by quarter by that; it's genuinely a — quite small and considerably tinier pool of receivables owed to our banking partners for alternative funding where we'll observe that. Yet once more, if we don't — those rates continue to move abruptly or substantially, you're genuinely not going to get anything with real impact quarter by quarter.

Chris Bottiglieri

analyst
#81

All right. Moving to a broader matter, the GPUs — I mean, this looks like a shift of two to three standard deviations in GPU, since normally you're quite disciplined regarding how much the consumer is capturing share. You're sort of taking that GPU and letting your ASP's in output. So I suppose it boils down to this: when could I say you feel at ease operating at that elevated GPU level, and what's shifting philosophically that makes you lean toward GPU and perhaps under market share, or maybe I've got this wrong and am not following properly — how would you describe it?

Bill Nash

executive
#82

No, I believe you're correct, it's uneven; during any single quarter you might see a $50 to $80 variance, this is always somewhat greater and it was a deliberate choice. Yet once more, our method is that we truly seek efficiencies above all else; and when we locate those efficiencies, then a choice must be made. Should you direct a bit more toward margin, you must weigh many considerations to arrive at that. And how much goes to price, and given all the considerations, we applied some of these efficiencies. So it's truly not at the expense of the consumer, what they paid previously; we're in fact handing along some of the efficiencies, some of these extra ones from the older vehicles and the sub-sufficiency, we keep passing those along, and then we took slightly more this quarter. So it was a deliberate choice; regarding the future, we'll keep watching things and what rivals are up to and the elasticity, and decide as we always do throughout the quarter.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#83

And we managed to accomplish this even as our share of the market expanded during that period, correct. So as far as our position in the market goes.

Bill Nash

executive
#84

Yeah.

Chris Bottiglieri

analyst
#85

Thanks.

Chris Pierce

analyst
#86

Morning, everyone. You’ve mentioned improving expense alignment, and we’ve also discussed expanding share of the market? Then, regarding that final question, if you’re comfortable with GPU at this elevated level. I’m just wondering how we should view advertising moving ahead. Is it possible to leave a competitor struggling out there? Yet I realize the end market isn’t exactly booming either. So I’m interested in how you’re approaching advertising and advertising per vehicle going forward?

Bill Nash

executive
#87

Yeah. Thanks for asking, Chris. Look, I believe our position on advertising remains what we’ve had as we’ve stated for the coming year; we anticipated an increase, I mean, remember, going back before COVID, I think Enrique we were up 70% in —

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#88

In total dollars and then on a per unit basis, most up 60%.

Bill Nash

executive
#89

Yeah. So on the advertising side, there's plenty of positive stuff we could point to. Even with the consumer clearly soft, everybody's still spending a lot of ad dollars; and the way I see us moving ahead is sticking with the guidance we gave at the start, which sat more around — let's say — $350 per unit, a touch above that this quarter, but I figure that's a decent — kind of a solid — solid frame of reference going forward. Then there are all sorts of new capabilities, and with online self progression, we expect at some point later in the year to begin advertising it; once we do, we'll move some dollars around, since we're constantly shifting things between acquisition and awareness, be it appraisal awareness, be it consumer, retail, consumer awareness, we're constantly shifting things around in any given quarter. So later this year I'd expect some new messaging.

Chris Pierce

analyst
#90

Great. Thank you.

Bill Nash

executive
#91

Thank you.

Bill Nash

executive
#92

Okay, thanks. It’s been good speaking with everyone on this call, and as usual, I appreciate both the questions you’ve raised and the support you’ve shown. Just like we always do, I’d like to express gratitude to our associates — for all their efforts and for their dedication to creating a beneficial difference for customers, for one another, and for the communities we serve. That includes, in particular, the environment; our 2022 responsibility report was released not long ago, and if you haven’t seen it yet, I’d strongly suggest you check it out. The principles we put into practice daily make us very proud, along with the promise we continue to keep to every stakeholder in pursuit of lasting, sustainable value creation. So once more, I’m grateful for your time today, and we’ll be back in touch next quarter.

Operator

operator
#93

And that brings us to the end of today's call, everyone. Once again, we appreciate all of you for joining in. At this point, you're free to hang up.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete CarMax, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to CarMax, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in CarMax, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.