CarMax, Inc. (KMX) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
September 29, 2022
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
David Lowenstein
executiveThanks, Samira <<inaudible>>. Good morning, everyone, and I appreciate you all being on the call for our fiscal 2023 second quarter earnings conference. Joining me today are Bill Nash, our President and CEO; Enrique Mayor-Mora, our Executive Vice President and CFO; and Jon Daniels, our Senior Vice President, CarMax Auto Finance Operations. Please keep in mind that anything we say today that isn't a statement of historical fact — including statements about the company's future business plans, prospects and financial performance — constitutes a forward-looking statement made under the Safe Harbor provisions of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Such statements rest on our current knowledge, expectations, and assumptions, and they carry substantial risks and uncertainties that could lead actual results to differ materially from what we expect; when we provide projections and other forward-looking statements, we disclaim any intent or obligation to update them. To learn more about important factors that could affect these expectations, please refer to our Form 8-K, filed with the SEC, this morning, and our annual report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended February 28, 2021, previously filed with the SEC. If any follow-up questions come up after the call, please don't hesitate to reach our Investor Relations department at 804 to 747 to 0422 extension 7865. Finally, thank you ahead of time for limiting yourself to one question and then getting back in the queue for more follow-ups. Bill?
Bill Nash
executiveAlright, thank you, David. Good morning, everyone, and I'm glad you could join us. Before we get started, I want to share that my thoughts are with our associates, their families, and the communities hit by Hurricane Ian. Many of our stores are located right in the storm's path. And as we've always done, the safety of our associates comes first. We've already moved to assist our associates and communities, and we'll continue monitoring the situation closely and provide support whenever it's required. Now, on to results — this quarter reflects the widespread pressure the pre-owned car sector is facing. Macro forces, including vehicle affordability driven by persistent, broad inflation, climbing interest rates, and soft consumer confidence, joined together to drive used auto sales lower throughout the whole market. Beyond that, wholesale values were hurt by steep depreciation during the quarter. Even with all of this pressing on our results, we continued to grow market share. We're also still making progress on the key initiatives that will further sharpen our competitive edge over time. Across our history, we've weathered many difficult cycles. And each and every time, we've come through them successfully, applying the key lessons learned to make our operating model even stronger. We remain on track to achieve our long-term strategy and goals. In Q2 of FY'23, our diversified business model generated total sales of $8.1 billion, up 2% from the same quarter last year, driven by higher average selling prices and partially offset by lower retail and wholesale volume. Within our retail business, total unit sales fell 6.4% in Q2, while used unit comps were 8.3% below the year-ago second quarter. The macro factors I just mentioned weighed on our performance. We believe industry sales also felt the impact of consumers shifting their spending priorities away from big-ticket purchases toward smaller discretionary items. Responding to today's environment and what consumers want, we've continued offering a larger mix of lower-priced vehicles. We entered Q2 with a low single-digit comp sales decline during June, which showed softer sales continuing, though improving, as we discussed on our previous earnings call. Then comps dropped sharply as July began, and August finished with a mid-teen decline. Last quarter, we shared market share data. We'll do the same this quarter, since that data provides extra context and shows how we're performing against the industry. According to external data, we kept gaining share through July, the most recent period with title data available. We posted Q2 retail gross profit per used unit of $22.82, which is $97 per unit above the prior-year period — evidence of our ability to handle used margin in any environment. We stay focused on finding the right balance among covering cost increases, managing margin, and passing efficiencies on to consumers to keep vehicles affordable. In terms of wholesale units, we saw a 15.1% decline compared with Q2 of the prior year. A portion of that stemmed from a deliberate decision: we shifted certain older vehicles away from wholesale and over to retail, which let us serve shoppers seeking lower-priced cars. Absent that decision, we estimate wholesale units would have declined by less than 10%. Results were hurt further by depreciation of about $2,500, plus our deliberate slow-bys <<inaudible>> as we reacted to rapidly shifting market conditions. Wholesale gross profit per unit reached $881, compared with $1,005 in the prior-year period, reflecting both a softening market and the decision to route a greater proportion of older used vehicles to retail. Our ability to source these cars from consumers gives us an advantage over rivals. Even so, relative to newer vehicles, more of them get dropped during reconditioning, because they don't meet the standards we require to sell to consumers. When that happens, those vehicles head to wholesale, often earning margins below what we typically see; in Q3, we've focused on aligning our offers with current conditions and rebalancing inventory so older vehicles can be worked in more efficiently. Fine <<inaudible>> vehicles at prices suited to market conditions ranks among our core competencies. During the second quarter, we sourced approximately 343,000 vehicles from consumers and dealers. That number fell 8% versus the equivalent period a year ago, but it rose about 50% against Q2 of FY'21, demonstrating how customers respond to both our nationwide online instant offer tool and our offers. In the quarter, we purchased roughly 323,000 cars from consumers, an 11% decline from last year's record results. Another approximately 20,000 vehicles arrived via MaxOffer, the digital appraisal product we offer dealers. That represented a 130% increase from the same period a year ago and an 18% gain versus this year's first quarter. Sales efficiency remained above 70% for the entire quarter. We continue focusing on delivering the industry's most customer-centric experience, supported by a top e-commerce platform that unites car buying and selling with our best-in-class store experience. Turning to our second quarter online metrics, about 11% of retail unit sales took place online, up from 9% in the comparable quarter a year ago. Omni sales made up roughly 53% of retail unit sales this quarter, a slight decline from 55% in the same quarter last year. Because our wholesale auctions remain virtual, 100% of wholesale sales — accounting for 21% of total revenue — qualify as online transactions. Online transactions produced approximately 30% of total revenue; that's above the 28% seen in last year's second quarter. CarMax Auto Financer Cap posted income of $183 million, below the $200 million recorded in the same period a year ago. Bear in mind that last year's quarter benefited from a reduced provision as the pandemic eased. We'll keep extending strong credit offers to our customers as we adjust rates alongside the market, a discipline reflected in results such as $2,282. A bit later, Jon will take a closer look at customer financing, the loan loss provision, and contributions to cap. At this point, though, I'd like to turn it over to Enrique. He'll walk you through more of the specifics on our financial performance for Q2, along with the steps we're implementing so that our expenses align even more closely with the demand environment we're facing at present — a quarter in which we recorded $2,282. Enrique?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveThanks, Bill, and good morning, everyone. In Q2, net earnings per diluted share were $0.79, versus $1.72 in the same quarter a year ago. Gross profit overall hit $737 million, down 9.6% from last year's second quarter. The biggest driver of that decline was wholesale vehicle margin at $141 million, which dropped 26%. That year-over-year fall came from lower volume as well as reduced margin per unit. As Bill said, we saw severe depreciation throughout the quarter and have been making changes so we're better positioned to handle the current environment. Total used vehicle margin edged down slightly to $495 million, a 2% decrease. A total used unit volume decline of negative 6.4% was largely offset by stronger margin per unit. Other gross profit was $102 million, 15% under last year's second quarter. That decrease was mainly due to the effect lower retail unit sales had on service. Service results fell $13 million, since weaker sales and, to a lesser extent, inflationary pressure caused a deleverage in results. EPP was down 3%, or $3 million, reflecting a mix of stronger margins, steady penetration of roughly 60%, and fewer retail unit sales. Third-party finance fees were flat versus last year's second quarter, as reduced volume in fee-generating Tier 2 was offset by lower Tier 3 volume, on which we pay a fee; moving to SG&A, second quarter expenses climbed to $666 million. That's a 16% increase from the prior year's quarter, reflecting a slowdown from the year-over-year rise seen in the first quarter. About three points of this quarter's increase comes from a change in an accounting estimate in the prior year quarter. SG&A as a percent of gross profit deleveraged to 90.4%, compared with 70.4% in the second quarter last year. One key driver of that deleverage was a 9.6% drop in total gross margin dollars relative to last year's quarter. Two factors mainly explain the rise in SG&A dollars over the last year. First, other overhead grew by $50 million. The primary drivers there include investments to advance our technology platforms, strategic and growth initiatives, a $14 million onetime impact from a prior year change in an accounting estimate related to non-CAF uncollectible receivables, and various other smaller cost headwinds. Second, compensation and benefits, excluding share-based compensation, rose by $34 million. That was primarily driven by the annualization of the strong staffing growth we saw in the back half of last year, as well as wage pressures. Partly offsetting this increase was a $4 million reduction in share-based compensation. On our first quarter earnings call, we talked about how we had actively taken steps to better align our staffing expenses in our stores and customer experience centers, or CECs, with the sales levels we were seeing at that time; however, as Bill noted, sales fell sharply in the second quarter relative to our expectations, beginning in July. That left SG&A as a percent of gross profit at 35% above where we had planned. In Q2, we took further steps to bring our costs in line with where our sales are. Those savings should become more visible across the coming quarters. Among the actions: additional staff reductions through attrition at our stores and CECs, a pause on certain hiring and contractor use at our corporate offices, and tighter alignment of marketing spend with sales. On the marketing side, we plan to maintain a robust per-unit investment that at least matches full-year FY '22 levels; during Q2, total marketing dollars were unchanged from the prior year but still reflected a healthy per-unit outlay. As we continue our omni channel journey, we've reduced the variable cost portion of our operating structure. Given the current macro-environment, our near-term priority is steering resources toward efforts that generate greater efficiency and effectiveness across our fixed cost base. At the same time, we'll continue making selective investments in customer facing initiatives that enhance our omni channel experience and support long-term growth. Turning to capital structure, we ended the quarter with an adjusted debt-to-capital ratio in the middle of our target range of 38% to 45%. During Q2, we repurchased approximately 1.7 million shares for $163 million, which represents roughly 35% of our authorization. Now, I'd like to hand the call over to Jon.
Jon Daniels
executiveAppreciate that, Enrique, and good morning to all of you. The CarMax auto finance operation once more turned in strong performance even as it navigates a shift away from a lending backdrop marked by credit losses at historic lows and funding costs that were exceptionally favorable. CAF originated more than $2.3 billion in net loans during the second quarter. After accounting for three day payoffs, CAF's penetration came to 41.2% in Q2, versus 43% a year earlier and 39.3% in Q1. New customers were charged a weighted average contract rate of 9.4%, above the 8.5% recorded in the prior year's second quarter and the 9% posted in Q1; this higher rate, paired with the sequential rise in penetration, shapes CAF's capacity to deliberately share some of the increased funding expense with consumers while continuing to offer highly competitive terms. Our lending partners keep complementing one another by also extending attractive credit offers. Our Tier 2 penetration rate matched last year at 21.6%; Tier 3 made up 6% of used unit sales, against 7.2% a year ago. Even though the lower credit consumer keeps demonstrating demand by actively shopping and applying for credit, affordability and the ability to finish the purchase remain obstacles for them. CAF income for the quarter totaled $183 million, down 8.6% or $17 million from the equivalent period a year ago. A year ago, our loan loss provision of $35 million acted as a substantial tailwind, since consumer performance overall stayed remarkably strong. This quarter's provision of $76 million left us with an ending reserve balance of $478 million, equal to 2.92% of managed receivables, an increase from 2.85% in the prior quarter. That seven basis point adjustment is again mostly tied to the proportionately larger quarterly volume of Tier 2 and Tier 3 loan originations relative to the pre-existing $16 billion portfolio. Notably, with macroeconomic conditions creating difficulty for the credit consumer, we stay confident in our capacity to draw on our extensive experience and sturdy credit platform so that our Tier 1 credit losses remain comfortably inside our targeted operating range of 2% to 2.5%. As occurred last quarter, our provision headwind was largely offset by our total interest margin, which rose $31 million year-over-year, while our margin of 7.29% climbed 11 basis points above last year's second quarter, aided by a $9.4 million benefit from our hedging strategy. Turning to our industry-leading online finance experience, we greatly broadened our pre-qualification product, which launched in March, during the quarter. As a reminder, this distinctive multi-lender product has no impact on your credit score, and produces customized real time credit decisions across our full inventory. By the close of the second quarter, this product reached over 50% of our consumers, and should become nationwide in the third quarter. I'll now hand the call back to Bill.
Bill Nash
executiveThanks, Jon. And thanks, Enrique. In light of what's happening in the broader economy, we're going to concentrate even harder on generating more operational efficiencies as we keep working through the short-term challenges that the used car sector is dealing with. At the same time, we're going to stay dedicated to pushing forward on our long-term objectives, which include making our omni channel experience even better for customers and associates alike, and also expanding our diversified business model. A few of our main initiatives are as follows: first, we're using data science, automation, and AI to boost efficiency and effectiveness in our customer experience centers. In Q2, we took our Associate Facing Guided Action software beyond chat and into phone calls, and we built out more work streams for our consumer facing digital assistant. Down the road, we expect these tools to let us cut down on the associate time required per customer while strengthening our capacity to deliver live interactions at the moments of greatest value. Second, as Jon noted, we're continuing to grow our industry leading finance base shopping experience. This best-in-class pre-qualification product relies on a streamlined, simple application and produces multi-lender credit terms on cards within our retail inventory in only a matter of minutes. Thanks to this tool, customers possess all the information required to rapidly grasp APRs and monthly payments across varying contract terms, and to easily compare vehicles so they can ultimately lock in the right financing options for themselves. Third, we're growing Max offer to source vehicles and reinforce our market leading position as a purchaser of cars. As a reminder, sourcing directly from consumers and dealers brings down our acquisition costs, improves our inventory selections, and delivers profitable incremental wholesale volume. We're currently live in more than 40 markets and expect to launch additional markets later this year. Finally, we're enhancing our auction experience to make it even more user friendly; we're testing a modernized vehicle detail page that's mobile friendly and efficiently shows the most relevant information dealers need in order to preview our wholesale inventory, much like how customers shop our retail inventory. We're also testing AI capabilities to improve our online vehicle condition reporting. On top of that, we have rolled out self-service checkout capabilities across the country. These tools will let us drive incremental operational efficiencies as we keep scaling our wholesale volume, all while giving our wholesale dealers an even better experience. To wrap up, I want to restate that although market conditions and consumer behaviors remain challenging, we believe these pressures are transitory and that our foundation remains strong. We're well-positioned to navigate this environment, just as we have during challenging times in the past, and we remain excited about the future of our diversified business. With that, we'll be happy to take your questions. Samira?
Craig Kennison
analystAll right, and good morning to everyone. I appreciate you fielding my question. I realize a number of macro-oriented questions are likely coming, but what I want to focus on is the sourcing tool. Seeing an 11% decline in vehicles sourced from consumers caught me somewhat off guard. With the secular momentum your online instant appraisal tool has generated, could you provide a bit more detail regarding the traction that tool is generating, and let us know whether this deceleration reflects slower online traffic or instead reflects a choice to purchase with greater selectivity?
Bill Nash
executiveYes, good morning, Craig, and thanks for asking. Look, I believe this traces back to a few items. To begin with, we're quite enthusiastic about our online offer tool as well as the MaxOffer I mentioned previously. Although a decline did occur, regarding the environment, I think the primary drivers behind that decline are, first, the one I already noted, specifically that we're shifting — altering retail selectivity in order to accept some of those wholesale vehicles, and moving them into retail, and were you to exclude that, our decline would have come in under 10%. On depreciation, you know, having tracked us for a long enough stretch, whenever we find ourselves in a depreciating market, our offers get reduced. That affects what you wind up purchasing from consumers. Then I'd point to a third item, which carries less weight than the first two, but we did — we pulled back on some purchases in specific pockets across specific geographic areas, at specific price points, either because we didn't have the cars or simply because of how quickly the environment was changing. So those three items, I think, are what truly drove the decline.
Craig Kennison
analystThank you.
Bill Nash
executiveSure.
Brian Nagel
analystHello, and good morning. I appreciate you taking my question. I'd like to zero in on how used car unit sales performed during the quarter. Bill, during your prepared remarks you mentioned a market slowdown that started in July. So what I want to know is whether there's anything specific — obviously, macro pressures are widely reported right now — but did anything stand out to you that might account for that slowdown? Was it some kind of regional softness, or something related to your product cost range? And I have a quick follow-up bundled in: any thoughts on how business is shaping up as we move through Q3, especially September?
Bill Nash
executiveYes, Brian, that's a great question. If you recall the prior call, I spent a moment discussing June and how we felt positive about it, since it outperformed the first quarter. And like I mentioned, we experienced a significant drop-off in July. That weakness then carried over into August, and we finished with a mid-teen decline for comps. There isn't any single factor I can identify where we'd say, "Well, this thing that occurred in July is the reason we saw the drop-off." What I mean is, there are many pressures at play, in my view. I mentioned the widespread inflationary pressures. Clearly, consumers have to make choices; grocery prices are higher than they've ever been. I believe we've witnessed additional interest rate hikes, and consumer confidence, certainly across the quarter, hit an all-time low relative to recent history — I mean even below where it stood at the peak of the pandemic. So my sense is that consumers are simply prioritizing their spending somewhat differently; however, there isn't a single factor I can identify, like, "Well, this occurred, and that explains why we saw the decline." I think it's simply the continuation — the worsening, really, of the overall consumer. As we head into September, the same weakness we experienced in August is showing up. And I'd say, more recently still, with the hurricane, as you might expect, that's adding to the softness too. Now, when it comes to hurricanes or any weather events, typically you'll recover — you'll get that back afterward. But regarding September, it will definitely create pressure. We have roughly — let me check, 22 stores are closed right now, and they've been shut for differing lengths of time.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveWe've also observed this on the wholesale side, and purely from a depreciation perspective, it's really just that same declining trend carrying on from what we experienced in the first quarter. So that has persisted through September.
Brian Nagel
analystAll right. Would you mind taking one more question? I promise to be brief, and I'm sorry for that. But here's the thing — you mentioned depreciation in the wholesale side. Does that mean we should expect better pricing over in used vehicles, and could that end up eroding what's been a real pain point for buyers?
Bill Nash
executiveYes, I'd say your line of thinking is correct there, Brian. As a matter of fact, I'd guess this marks the first quarter in, wow, likely 6 or 7 quarters where the spread separating used from new actually widened somewhat. So it's going to take a while. Still, I believe depreciation plus price adjustments on the used side will definitely help the used — the used market eventually. That said, we need to remember this quarter was a tough one. What I mean is, $2,500 in depreciation isn't something we've witnessed; in raw dollars, that's comparable to what showed up during the worst of the Great Recession, and it's comparable to what showed up when omni peaked. So this is highly out of the ordinary, and it creates difficulties. Even so, I think we've demonstrated across time that we can steer through those, and that we'll manage it better than just about anybody else.
Brian Nagel
analystI appreciate it. Thank you.
Bill Nash
executiveSure.
Sharon Zackfia
analystHi, good morning.
Bill Nash
executiveGood morning.
Sharon Zackfia
analystI've tracked this company for a long enough stretch that I've witnessed it work through many distinct cycles. And congratulations on the market share you keep capturing, even though I realize that's only a minor comfort given the comparable sales patterns you're facing. I believe that in the past, yours hasn't really been an organization that carried out meaningful workforce reductions, if any at all. Clearly, you've absorbed, from the sound of it, staffing acquisitions and open positions. But what I'd like to understand, considering this profitability pullback — or you essentially wiped out, I think, 7 years of profit during this quarter. I mean, how should we view those actions, Enrique, that you described regarding reducing SG&A spend, because — and there are definitely situations I can envision in which SG&A spend surpasses gross profit in the back-half of the year, and as we move into what is typically the slower season; so, assist us in thinking about roughly how much money you're able to remove at this point, whether measured as SG&A as a percent of gross profit or SG&A dollar growth, just any sort of gauges whether it would be mark-to-market, where sales stand, we have a sense of where that SG&A spend is roughly landing?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYes, I appreciate the question, Sharon. And our goal centers on prevailing over the long-term. And that truly demands we stay focused on making the proper investments to keep setting ourselves apart from our rivals; so, we have an active and accretive portfolio of omni-related initiatives that we've been investing in that we've managed to do, largely thanks to our strong balance sheet and our performance, but having said that, certainly — so, given the present macro environment, we have begun pulling the levers, I noted in my prepared remarks, to better align our cost structure to the present environment. And we're also going to be directing our resources more toward initiatives that generate efficiencies that I discussed, and Bill discussed in our prepared remarks too. So, be slowing some of the velocity down on our growth-related investments, but certainly not pulling back. So, I believe we're taking the right steps at this moment when it comes to better managing our costs. We have a strong and active eye on the consumer, and we stand very experienced in managing through these cycles. But we also want to make sure that when the industry picks back up, that we're in a really strong position to capture the upside; so, I think regarding the balance of the year and how to look at SG&A, we do expect the levers that we pulled during the second quarter will start to manifest themselves more fully over the next few quarters. I'd say the second piece — and this definitely isn't about leverage — is really just gross profit, correct, and where that's going to land in Q4 and as we head into the next year; that's one more variable. But what's squarely within our control, and we can do so quite decisively, is SG&A. So we're encouraged that we've pulled the levers — the right ones for right now.
Bill Nash
executiveRight. And Sharon, one more point I'd tack on there: we are definitely walking into this from a strong position. Like Enrique said, there's plenty of leverage available. Take costs alone — a great deal of growth spending is still underway as we get ready for what's ahead, plus these initiatives, plus advertising, plus variable spend. Every one of those is something we can still draw on, and beyond that there's a wide array of additional levers available purely to safeguard cash should the need arise. So I'd say where things stand right now is this: we've already used the levers, we recognize these are difficult times, and we're approaching all of it from strength. There are initiatives we're confident will serve us in both the short run and the long run. Let's finish them. That way, once the market rebounds — and rebound it will — we'll be positioned to surge, since all of this work is already behind us. Still, we will most certainly keep watching what's happening outside.
Sharon Zackfia
analystAll right. May I follow up by asking — considering the decline in the mid-teens we're seeing in comp trends, I suppose, in <<inaudible>> — could you essentially mark-to-market for us how that translates regarding SG&A as a percentage of gross profit? In other words, have you allowed it to exceed 100, or does that represent roughly the point where you'd say, okay, at this stage we need to pull back further?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYes. No, I believe, as we've mentioned, we're pulling back on levers within our control at present. We feel we're better positioned relative to today's environment. Those savings will become apparent as we move ahead. Stronger levers were indeed pulled around the midpoint of Q2; therefore, this quarter's P&L doesn't reflect it entirely, though going forward, a greater portion of the savings ought to become visible.
Bill Nash
executiveRight. So Sharon, the way I'd frame it is this: in absolute dollars, SG&A got better from the first quarter to the second, as Enrique mentioned. Those dollars should show up to a greater degree, in our view. A decrease is what you'll see there. The other unpredictable piece in this calculation was simply gross profit dollars, and macro factors are what will drive that, as Enrique mentioned.
Sharon Zackfia
analystOkay, thank you for that.
Bill Nash
executiveSure.
Michael Montani
analystHi there, I appreciate you fielding my questions. To begin, I wanted to ask about the wholesale segment. Should we expect comparable patterns regarding volume and GPU strain as we head into Q3 and wholesale, considering how tough the macro backdrop is?
Bill Nash
executiveYeah, Michael, good morning. On earlier calls, I've addressed this since people have asked me about margins on retail and margins on wholesale; what I've stated in past quarters is that all of us are — we remain fairly confident about sustaining robust retail margins. Wholesale, though, would face mounting pressure. And should we move into a depreciation cycle, that will create the squeeze, as I've mentioned previously. Another factor I brought up for why it might face pressure is simply due to that selectivity in retail, plus the fact that we're shifting certain vehicles — older ones — into retail. Then there's the related thing we refer to as kicks. You go, fine, this belongs to the retailer, you go ahead and build it. Or, you begin building and then figure out, fine, we can't bring this up to standards. We then send that back into wholesale. And typically we do worse on those compared to standard wholesale. So, we anticipated there would be some strain. I believe if you examine how things have gone lately, let's say — definitely the prior year, I believe each quarter in that prior year from a GPU perspective for wholesale exceeded $1000. Then when you check the year before that, I think we had one more quarter that exceeded $1000. If you take that and stack it against the 5 years before, there were likely as many or more quarters in that recent year than we saw across the last 5 years exceeding $1000. That's driven by the enormous appreciation we experienced in that prior year. So, I believe the way to approach it moving forward is likely closer to what you'd typically observe as the average wholesale we earn in any particular quarter across a 3, 4, 5 year span. I think that's how to approach it, particularly in this depreciation cycle and particularly as we keep pushing more, or attempt to push more, of these older vehicles, mainly for affordability reasons.
Adam Jonas
analystHi, Bill. I'm certain your group has been monitoring the rulemaking proposal from the FTC — the trade regulation rule for motor vehicle dealers — which is currently gathering comments. Its purpose is to boost clarity around pricing and advertising, plus certain downstream items such as aftermarket add-ons. So, should this rulemaking get the green light, I realize there will be plenty of pluses and minuses. Have you folks performed any initial analysis regarding what effect this could have on CarMax when it comes to compliance cost or SG&A expense, or any possible revenue consequences? Thanks.
Bill Nash
executiveYeah, Adam, that's an excellent question. Clearly, we submitted comments during the comment period, as a lot of people did, simply because the requirements are, in certain instances, somewhat burdensome. We've begun examining whatever ends up being decided — naturally, we'll ensure we comply — but we haven't put — at this stage we aren't ready to actually discuss extra expenses or anything like that, since, once again as you mentioned, so much remains undecided, and there's so much conversation and argument surrounding it. A great deal is genuinely unclear.
Jon Daniels
executiveThere's one more thing I want to mention, though—to the point you raised, Adam, about the language used around add-on products and their pricing, meaning transparency and clarity there. My feeling is that the way our business is built puts us in an ideal spot for exactly that; being open and honest on the web is already what we do. Our EPP products can be displayed on the web, along with what they cost. So I'd say our position for handling that is a strong one; and clearly, anything that's asked of us, we'll do.
Bill Nash
executiveAnd I think the motor bear complication for us, and I think really need to be looked as is some of the requirements on signing paperwork, physical signatures, managers that kind of thing. Everyone is functioning in an internet-based world now. So, once again, it will be intriguing to observe how it turns out.
John Murphy
analystMorning, everyone. I'd like to raise one point about pricing. Comparing to the same period a year ago is always useful, but when you look at how things are shifting right now, going quarter to quarter may matter even more than it usually does. On retail price, you were off roughly 2% from one quarter to the next, while wholesale dropped 7%. And you mentioned handling more aged vehicles within that, on the retail side. So that 2% is soaking up vehicles with even lower stickers. That means the spread between the two could really be wider still. And Bill, what's your read on the market, since what we keep hearing from plenty of others is that retail pricing is standing up quite a bit better than wholesale pricing? Do you figure the market is in some way front-running dealers, or front-running some form of softness, or trying to keep growth going? It feels like conditions are weakening, yet far more so in wholesale than in retail.
Bill Nash
executiveYeah, John, I'd say part of this comes down to timing. Consider it this way: even though we saw depreciation during the quarter, and even though, as you noted, our mix skews toward older vehicles, each of those pushes your total retail prices lower, yet that wasn't sufficient to counteract the comparison against roughly a year ago. So, thinking it through, we closed out last year with appreciation of about $7,500. We've seen only around $2,500 of depreciation. That effect will keep shrinking as we move further into the year. Even so, it simply wasn't sufficient to counteract that total appreciation, which explains why we remain above where we were last year. Another factor to keep in mind, I think, is that many of the cars sold during the second quarter had actually been purchased — most of them were bought before that quarter had even begun, meaning they carry a higher price. So there's definitely a timing element at play. On the wholesale side, clearly, when you shift some of the nicer, pricier units over to retail, that hits your wholesale a bit harder. That, I believe, is the dynamic you've got working there.
Chris Bottiglieri
analystHey everyone, I appreciate you fielding my question. I'm honestly still somewhat unclear about the way those hedges influence profitability — we put numbers to that this quarter. And beyond that, taking a broader view, considering the drop in used volumes, the narrowing in securitization market spreads, and defaults starting to climb somewhat, could you walk us through again how movements in these variables shape loan originations and net margins, so we're better able to model the cash cadence going forward?
Bill Nash
executivePerhaps I'll take the hedge piece first. It's a very comparable situation to what we encountered in Q1, correct. So, the bulk of our receivables get funded via the ABS market, as we're aware, and we have accounting edge on those. That said, we do hold alternative financing vehicles alongside our banking partners — partners we've worked with a long time — and a subset of those receivables carries a cash flow hedge rather than an accounting hedge. That stems from our wish to preserve flexibility in our funding profile; consequently, those receivables get mark-to-market each quarter, just as occurred last quarter. And truly, the place where you observe a shift, whether favorable or a possible negative, is during abrupt and significant increases or declines in interest rates; that is precisely what took place once more this quarter; thus, we'd only anticipate this mattering again when capturing stretches of substantial changes. It's quite close to Q1. We witnessed abrupt shifts and movements in the interest rates. That's what occurred. And the figure was $9 million, matching the amount from Q1.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveAbsolutely, and let me address your other point, Chris. If I miss anything you raised, please let me know. As for the interest margin overall, clearly, with funding costs climbing, as we mentioned — I believe we indicated this during the prior quarter — you might start to notice a shift in our net interest margin, possibly it has reached its high point and may decline. And once more, that is where the way we handle our accounting works in our favor. Naturally, as the margin grows over time, that larger receivable stays on the books for a longer period; yet clearly, our margins have narrowed, and without the hedge in place, we likely would have experienced a decline this quarter; and we are clearly heading into a more constrained environment. So, we might keep seeing that decrease. On our end, we are clearly continuing to handle margins very cautiously through how we set prices. So, we will do everything we can, while still staying competitive for our customer. Thus, once again, I believe there will be strain on our net interest margin moving forward. But once again, we will handle that to the best of our ability.
Chris Bottiglieri
analystUnderstood. Many thanks.
Rajat Gupta
analystExcellent. I appreciate you fielding this. Perhaps a handful of rapid-fire items — to start, regarding retail GPU, Bill, assuming I caught your point properly, you said you think it's still possible to hold retail GPU at its present level, given how pricing stands now, across the coming few quarters. Was that right? I just want confirmation, and I've got something else afterward. Thanks.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveAbsolutely, Rajat. So, during my earlier remarks — what I was referring to — while I genuinely feel confident about sustaining solid retail margins, I'll always attach the caveat that this hinges on numerous variables: sales elasticity, competitor moves, inventory levels, including our own inventory levels, so many factors play a role. Yet we truly continue to see some pleasant gains, and though we've lacked self-sufficiency, we still sense there's a bit remaining. Beyond that, the reality that we're moving these older vehicles hands us somewhat extra margin, and during this quarter, we managed to hand part of that over to consumers by offsetting certain inflationary pressures, while also keeping a little extra. So once more, we feel confident about retail margins and their present position. And we'll simply keep monitoring some of those items, or other outside factors, going forward.
Rajat Gupta
analystUnderstood, understood. And perhaps to build on what Enrique said regarding advertising, it seems you're asking us to keep a solid ad spend for each unit. But I'm just wondering, when it comes to where the company is focused at this moment, is the priority making certain you can keep growing your share of the market, or is it more about controlling total profitability given possibly higher interest rates or possibly an absence of pricing discounts? I'm just wondering, what actually is the plan over the near term? Does one come at the expense of the other, or do you believe you can achieve both simultaneously — the volume and the profitability?
Bill Nash
executiveYes, so I'll respond and then I'll let — I'll simply offer you a few other thoughts and Enrique, as you're aware, but when it comes to advertising, as Enrique mentioned, look, we still are, we're genuinely enthusiastic about this industry, and about where this industry is headed. Admittedly, we've got a few difficult things at the moment, but we still wish to keep putting money into advertising, we're going to do that, we sort of think about it at a per-unit basis; so, in the end advertising overall will decline if sales decline, but we feel like continuing to put money into the business, not obviously you might alter where you spend it, during this quarter, most of it was awareness and from an acquisition perspective as additional customers rather than purchasing vehicles. But it's also something we can keep watching, every single thing we do when it comes to advertising, we measure ROI. And so, we have specific targets that we're going to have to if we observe things that aren't working out, we'll definitely scale back or shift to something different that is. So, Enrique, do you have any thoughts about that?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYeah, so what I'd say is that versus a few years back, the marketing group as a whole has accomplished an incredible amount in truly providing us with visibility into profitability and the money we're putting in, and how that ultimately converts into an ROI. So we're feeling quite confident about the investments we've made across the last couple of years. When you look at us relative to two years ago, my view is that we've pushed up the dollars per unit by more than 50%, correct. And the reason is that we're feeling quite confident in our capacity to achieve visibility. So I believe we can keep building awareness while simultaneously generating that profitability. So, Rajat, my sense is that we can achieve the best of both worlds.
Bill Nash
executiveYeah, and Rajat, there's another point worth keeping in mind as well — there are plenty of positive developments happening, so let me share one. Take the pre-qualification that Jon and I both brought up; we haven't marketed it at all up to this point. That makes it a real opening for us. So when we're looking at advertising, it gives us the flexibility to decide what deserves the spotlight — we need to feature online offers, we want the omni experience front and center, we want to showcase the ability to purchase online, pre-qualification is going to get highlighted, and there are many other options. Because of that, we keep shifting things around. So that's basically the way we approach it.
Rajat Gupta
analystUnderstood, understood. Perhaps regarding the cash aspect, do you still believe you can keep passing higher interest rates along to customers, or will that become more cautious given that lenders out there are increasingly competitive?
Bill Nash
executiveYes, Rajat, thanks for asking. Indeed, as I mentioned during my prepared remarks, I felt very happy about the penetration achieved—it demonstrated our capacity to hand some of those increases over to our customers while still controlling elasticity and grabbing whatever volume was available. Again, the three items we're attempting to handle here are remaining very competitive with our offers for consumers, controlling that margin, and then ensuring we secure the appropriate sales level. It's a fine balance, but I believe we've performed very well and I think we'll keep doing so.
Seth Basham
analystMuch appreciated. To start off, I'd like to ask about cash, and specifically when you consider the reserves you hold for loan losses and your present position, what does that tell us regarding the amounts you're setting aside and the allowance rate on your core Tier-1 securitized managed receivables?
Bill Nash
executiveSure. At this moment, Seth, we're sitting comfortably inside that 2% to 2.5% band. The bump you observed, as I noted, is mainly driven by that Tier-2 and Tier-3 volume. Within new originations, that represents a bigger share than it does within the portfolio. So we're feeling quite confident about remaining within that target range. And the reserve mirrors that.
Seth Basham
analystUnderstood. So even though collateral values have dropped significantly and the broader economy has worsened, you still haven't increased the allowance rate on those receivables? How are we supposed to view the mechanics here, and what's the chance of bigger loan losses on those core receivables?
Bill Nash
executiveRight, we ran that modeling quite thoroughly. And we concluded that, once more, as long as values don't simply collapse entirely, you've got customers who are purchasing cars from us that they originally bought 5 years back, 3 years back. So clearly, the buildup has happened gradually. And ideally, the decline will also be gradual, but when we modeled it, it turned out to be fairly immaterial against a $477 million reserve; therefore, we believe our reserves are solid, and we can definitely handle that with what's on hand right now. So yes, we looked at it, but we believe the reserve we have at present is the correct one.
Seth Basham
analystUnderstood. Thanks.
Joe Enderlin
analystHello everyone, and thanks for fielding our question. Regarding the older vehicle mix, once the purchase of vehicles returns to normal, do you anticipate that those older models will continue to be included in the mix, helping to sustain higher GPUs than in past periods? Or what's your outlook on that going forward?
Bill Nash
executiveYeah, it's an excellent question. What's really beneficial is that since we have far more of that inventory on hand now, we're able to offer exactly what the customer is looking for. So going forward, if we move toward a more typical range or timeframe, and buyers want that, we have a source to ensure we make it available. I believe this will also work in our favor. Consider that currently not as many new cars are being sold, so something has to fill that void; this is a fantastic — I think it will be a fantastic instrument for that. So once more, we'll provide whatever consumers desire.
Joe Enderlin
analystGot it. Thank you, guys.
Bill Nash
executiveThank you.
David Whiston
analystThank you, and good morning. Share repurchases came in at about the same level as Q1. Clearly, shares are much less expensive at this point, though naturally macroeconomic strains exist, and those can create a desire to hold onto cash — that's the tricky balancing act. Still, do you expect to manage at minimum a level second half matching the first half? Will you scale back on repurchases, or perhaps act even more boldly?
Bill Nash
executiveHi, David. Appreciate the question. As you noted, during the second quarter we're moving at the identical rate we had in the first quarter, so we keep repurchasing our stock. That said, I'd note our approach to allocating capital stays unchanged: above all else, funds are directed toward expanding the core operation. That means our retail operations, our wholesale operations, and our cash business, ensuring each is positioned to keep expanding. Beyond that, we also seek out avenues for growth and make investments, after which we give capital back to shareholders. Thus, our approach has not changed.
David Whiston
analystAll right, and regarding your SG&A management, I simply want to confirm that I grasp what you said before about personnel levels. If somebody departs on their own accord, are you bringing in new people to fill those spots?
Bill Nash
executiveYeah, so, definitely — right now there is no freeze on bringing people in; we take a very deliberate approach. We rank our recruiting needs. So when individuals exit and those roles are essential, without question we will fill them, yet simultaneously, when there's an opening, you need to ask yourself, okay, does this role help with what we're focused on in the short term, that sort of thing, but even though we've set priorities, we haven't stopped bringing people in across the board.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYeah, and I want to make it clear that we've also handled staffing levels by letting people leave naturally, correct — that's the approach we've taken for managing it. So those advantages are going to show up even more noticeably as we move ahead into the coming quarters.
David Whiston
analystOkay, thank you.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveThank you.
Bill Nash
executiveThanks. Like I always say, I appreciate everything our associates do — the way they look after one another, our customers, and the communities. Once again, my heart is certainly with everyone in the path of the Hurricane. Please, please be careful. I appreciate all of you being on this call; and we'll speak again in 3 months.
Operator
operatorThis concludes today's call. Thank you for your participation. You may now disconnect.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete CarMax, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to CarMax, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in CarMax, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.