CarMax, Inc. (KMX) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
December 22, 2022
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
David Lowenstein
executiveAppreciate that, Ashley. Morning to all of you. We're glad you could be on this call covering our results for the third quarter of fiscal 2023. Joining me are Bill Nash, who serves as our President and CEO; Enrique Mayor-Mora, our Executive Vice President and CFO; and Jon Daniels, our Senior Vice President of CarMax Auto Finance Operations. A quick reminder: anything we say today that isn't a statement of historical fact — things like statements about future business plans, prospects and financial performance — counts as forward-looking statements made under the safe harbor provisions of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995; such statements rest on what we currently know, expect and assume, and they carry substantial risks and uncertainties that might cause actual results to differ materially from what we expect. When we provide projections and other forward-looking statements, we disclaim any intent or obligation to update them; to learn more about important factors that could affect these expectations, please see our Form 8-K filed with the SEC this morning and our annual report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended February 28, 2022, previously filed with the SEC. If any follow-up questions come up after the call, feel free to reach our Investor Relations department at (804) 747 to 0422 extension 7865. Finally, thanks ahead of time for limiting yourself to one question and then getting back in the queue for more follow-ups. Bill?
Bill Nash
executiveThanks, David. Good morning to all of you, and I appreciate you being here. The results we posted for the third quarter show that broad-based pressure is still weighing on the whole used car sector. Affordability of vehicles stayed difficult because of macro forces tied to widespread inflation, rising interest rates, and consumer confidence that remains weak. On top of that, wholesale values were hit all quarter long by depreciation that was both persistent and severe. So we've been making intentional moves to shore up the business both near term and over the long haul. We're drawing on our greatest strengths — our people, our know-how, and our culture — to steer through this part of the cycle. Among the actions we completed in the quarter: cutting SG&A further, shifting to a larger mix of older vehicles at lower prices, pulling back <<inaudible>> given how sharply the market has depreciated, keeping saleable used inventory units steady while pushing total inventory dollars down over 25% versus a year ago, raising CAFs consumer rates to help counter higher funding costs, halting share repurchases so we keep capital flexibility, and reducing the store growth we had planned for the coming fiscal year to 5 locations, while preserving our capacity to open additional locations should market conditions shift; for the near term, our priority is on efforts that unlock operational efficiencies and produce better experiences for our associates and our customers. We're still investing selectively in efforts that could activate new capabilities, but we've reduced how quickly we're making those investments; we think these moves let us emerge from this cycle leaner and more effective, while putting us in position to grow in the future; later on today's call we'll share more specifics about these actions; and now let's turn to our results. In the third quarter of FY '23, our diversified business model produced total sales of $6.5 billion, a decline of 24% from the same quarter a year ago, as retail and wholesale volume came in lower. Within retail, total unit sales fell 20.8% in the third quarter, and used unit comps dropped 22.4% against last year's third quarter, when we posted a 15.8% used unit comp; beyond the macro forces I already described, we think transitory competitive reactions to today's environment played a role in our performance. External title data shows we picked up market share year-to-date through October, even though we've recently given some share back. As we've noted previously, our focus is on profitable share gains that can hold up over time. Using extensive price elasticity testing, we concluded that protecting margins was the correct profitability move for the quarter. Retail gross profit per used unit came to $2,237 in the third quarter, in line with last year's third quarter. Wholesale unit sales dropped 36.7% from the third quarter a year ago, as market conditions changed rapidly, including roughly $2,000 of depreciation. That comes on top of about $2,500 of depreciation we saw in the second quarter. Our wholesale results took a hit too, since we keep shifting certain older cars out of wholesale and into retail to satisfy customer desire for cheaper vehicles. Wholesale gross profit for each unit came in at $966, a decline from the record $1,131 posted in last year's third quarter. Keep in mind that during that quarter a year ago, prices rose by roughly $2,500, which gave margins a boost. Exactly as with retail, our ongoing priority will be squeezing the greatest possible total profitability out of wholesale margins. During the third quarter, we acquired roughly 238,000 vehicles from consumers and dealers, a 40% drop compared with the equivalent period a year earlier. Sharp depreciation, plus our intentional choice to reduce buying in response to that depreciation, held back our volume. In the quarter, we bought around 224,000 cars from consumers, and roughly half of those purchases arrived via our online instant appraisal experience. Another 14,000 or so vehicles came to us through Max offer, the digital appraisal product we offer dealers, which rose 16% over last year's third quarter. Self-sufficiency stayed above 70% for the quarter. Turning to our third quarter online metrics, online accounted for about 12% of retail unit sales, an increase from 9% in the same quarter a year earlier. Omni sales made up approximately 52% of retail unit sales this quarter, a decrease from 57% in the comparable quarter last year. Since our wholesale auctions remain virtual, all 100% of wholesale sales—representing 18% of total revenue—count as online transactions. Online transactions generated roughly 28% of total revenue, a drop from 30% in last year's third quarter. CarMax Auto Finance, or CAF, posted income of $152 million, lower than the $166 million recorded in the same period a year ago. In a few moments, Jon will go into greater detail on consumer financing, the loan loss provision, and cash contribution. With that, I'd like to hand the call to Enrique, who will share additional information about our third quarter financial performance and the actions we've taken to better align our business with today's sales environment. Enrique?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveAppreciate that, Bill. Morning, everybody. For the third quarter, net earnings per diluted share came in at $0.24, compared with $1.63 during the same period a year ago. Total gross profit reached $577 million, a 31% drop versus last year's third quarter. Used retail margin was $403 million and wholesale vehicle margin was $115 million, with those figures falling 21% and 46%, respectively. These year-over-year declines stemmed from reduced volume in both used and wholesale, along with a lower wholesale margin per unit. As Bill mentioned, depreciation remains a challenge we're confronting, and we've been making adjustments to put ourselves in a better spot to navigate the present climate. Other gross profit came to $59 million, a 49% decrease from last year's third quarter; the main driver here was how lower retail unit sales affected service and EPP. Service results dropped $37 million, since sales were lower and, secondarily, because our choice to keep technician staffing levels steady produced some deleveraging. Technicians rank among the most sought-after associates in this industry, and holding onto them will leave us well positioned to ramp inventory up quickly once we get past the current cycle. EPP declined by 14%, or $15 million, which mirrors the sales decrease, though stronger margins and a favorable year-over-year return reserve adjustment partly offset that. Penetration held steady at roughly 60%. Third-party finance fees were about even with last year's third quarter, since lower volume and fee generating Tier 2 was offset by lower Tier 3 volume, for which we pay a fee; turning to SG&A, third quarter expenses totaled $592 million, 3% above the prior year's quarter, which reflects a deceleration from the year-over-year growth of 19% in this year's first quarter and 16% in the second quarter. Last year's third quarter included a $23 million settlement we received from a class action lawsuit. If you adjust for that settlement, SG&A would in fact have fallen 1% year-over-year this quarter. SG&A as a percent of gross profit faced substantial pressure relative to the third quarter of last year, largely because total gross margin dollars dropped 31% compared with last year's quarter. The shift in SG&A dollars versus a year ago came mainly from these factors: first, a $41 million rise in other overhead, primarily from cycling over last year's legal settlement; we're also still investing, though at a slower pace, in our technology platforms and strategic and growth initiatives. Second, compensation and benefits fell $18 million, which includes a $16 million decline in share-based compensation; and third, advertising was reduced by $17 million. Throughout the quarter, we kept taking action to bring our expenses more in line with our sales. That meant further trimming staffing via attrition in our stores and CECs, capping hiring and contractor usage at our corporate offices, and continuing to match our marketing spend to sales. Even though our advertising expense was lower year-over-year, what we invest per unit stays in line with last year's third quarter; we're still concentrated on cutting expenses and expect further progress in the fourth quarter. Moving on to capital structure. The number one thing we need to do is put money into the company. Because of how we did in Q3 and the fact that markets keep being unpredictable, our strategy for the balance sheet is cautious. Our adjusted debt-to-capital ratio came in under the 35% to 45% goal band, but even so, we're steering net leverage so we stay nimble enough to tap the capital markets without trouble, for CAF and for CarMax overall; to keep that nimbleness, this quarter we did the things listed below on top of the SG&A moves I already described. To start, buybacks have been halted. The $2.45 billion authorization is still there, and so is our pledge to give capital back to shareholders down the road. Next, we reduced how fast we're spending on CapEx. We now think CapEx will finish the fiscal year at about $450 million, compared with the $500 million we had estimated before. Bill also noted that for fiscal year 2024 we've taken a cautious view on store growth, planning 5 new locations. There's still plenty of liquidity. At quarter's end we had more than $680 million of cash on the balance sheet and hadn't touched our $2 billion revolver. At this point I'll hand things over to Jon.
Jon Daniels
executiveThank you, Enrique, and hello everybody on this morning's call. During Q3, the robustness and reliability of the credit platform we operate meant that more than 95% of shoppers seeking financing as they went through their purchase process received approvals. CarMax Auto Finance wrote $2.1 billion of originations in the period, producing a penetration rate of 44.4% after accounting for 3-day payoffs, which represents an increase over the 42.2% we recorded in the equivalent quarter a year earlier and the 41.2% posted in Q2. New customers were charged a weighted average contract rate of 9.8%, above both the 8.3% figure from the prior-year third quarter and the 9.4% logged in Q2; by continuing to draw on our scalable testing environments and agile underwriting infrastructure, we are deliberately passing along part of the higher funding costs to consumers while still growing our share of finance contracts. Tier 2 penetration reached 20.5% for the quarter, consistent with historical norms, though lower than the 22.2% achieved a year ago. Tier 3 accounted for 6.1% of used unit sales, versus 6.5% in the prior-year period. In this difficult environment, our lenders keep making their lending choices independently, and we stay happy with the competitive offers they are able to extend collectively to our customers. Cash income came in at $152 million for the quarter, which is 8.3% lower, or $14 million less, than the comparable period a year ago. We recorded a loan loss provision of $86 million, leaving an ending reserve balance of $491 million, compared with a provision of $76 million in last year's Q3. At $491 million, this quarter's reserve equals 2.95% of managed receivables, a modest increase from 2.92% at the close of this year's second quarter. That sequential 3 basis point move in the reserved receivables ratio stems mainly from the ongoing addition of Tier 2 and Tier 3 receivables into the total portfolio, as has been observed in earlier quarters. On balance, we felt good about how credit performed in our portfolio during the quarter, and we believe our reserves are appropriate for future losses. Additionally, we remain well positioned to use our distinctive credit platform to run our Tier 1 business inside our target loss range of 2% to 2.5%. Total interest margin dollars for the quarter were unchanged versus last year at $277 million, helped modestly by a $5 million benefit from our hedging strategy. The related margin to receivables rate of 6.7% declined 54 basis points year-over-year, since receivables carrying historically low funding costs were offset by those affected by the more recent Fed moves. Turning to progress in our broader credit technology: in the third quarter we finished rolling out finance-based shopping nationwide, our multi-lender prequalification product, and engagement with this experience remains high. As a reminder, this lets customers digitally obtain fast credit decisions across our full inventory through our straightforward online application without any effect on credit scores. It also enables consumers to secure financing quickly and easily at any stage of their shopping journey. Just as every other part of the company is doing, CAF is concentrating on finding efficiency gains. The modern, more agile receivable servicing platform we introduced 12 months ago is already paying off. Consumer finance operates in a heavily regulated and constantly shifting environment, and our updated system lets us respond with greater ease to the changes that are required. One recent illustration is the regulatory shift coming in California, which calls for extra disclosure and refund obligations tied to cancellation of the GAP waiver product. Under our previous system, getting that done would have taken a long time and been burdensome, and we probably would have paused sales of the product in that state during the transition. Thanks to our new, more flexible technology, though, we can fold in those requirements with no disruption. That's merely a single instance of the early gains our new system has delivered, and we can clearly see many additional ones ahead in the near and midterm. At this point I'll hand the call back to Bill.
Bill Nash
executiveAppreciate that, Jon, and thanks to you as well, Enrique. When we kicked off today's call, I mentioned that we're putting steps in place to strengthen the business, and that means focusing first on efforts that drive operational efficiencies while delivering better experiences for both our associates and our customers. The starting point is making our omnichannel experience faster, simpler, and smoother. A few examples: we're enhancing our online tools so customers feel more confident completing key transaction steps on their own, and we're making it simpler to switch between assisted health and self-progression. On top of that, we're making it easy for consumers to opt in to express pickup through self-progression. With this fulfillment method, buyers can complete their purchase at one of our retail locations in a minimum of 30 minutes, and it's a win-win situation. When customers take advantage of this option, our studies indicate they're very happy with it, and over time it will let us bring our expenses down. As our last illustration, we're striving to make our finance-based shopping offering mesh smoothly with our stores and customer experience centers, so that every consumer gets to take part in it, rather than only people buying online. In parallel, we're bringing more lenders onto the platform, which broadens both the range and the depth of what we can offer our customers. As our omnichannel approach keeps developing, we're likewise revising the way we run things so that our stores can achieve greater efficiency. In our business offices, for example, appraisal customers can now check themselves in, and we've strengthened e-sign features so customers can move forward on their own more easily. On top of that, we're piloting a better digital queue for customers, which should help with managing appointments, plus new software aimed at making title work faster and more transparent. We expect these capabilities to cut down the time each associate spends with a given customer and to make transactions quicker for customers. Delivering a standout customer experience depends on our associates, and our aim is to put their abilities to use in ways that add the most value. We'll keep making targeted investments in important initiatives that could give us new abilities and bring our expenses down. To illustrate: first, we're refreshing Max offer, the appraisal tool we provide to dealers, and it's currently live in roughly 50 markets. A large number of our dealers haven't moved off the original release yet — that version lacks instant offers and makes them photograph vehicles on the spot. So we're introducing a new offering that gives every dealer a completely digital, instant offer experience. Our view is that this puts us in a strong spot to expand dealer purchases more efficiently and handle greater volume as time goes on. Second, we're using technology to strengthen our logistics operations; we transport about 2 million vehicles annually. Based on what we've found, handling logistics ourselves gives us a cost edge of roughly 20% compared with outside providers, and it also makes our moves faster, more predictable, and easier to control. As we upgrade our transportation management system, we'll be able to combine loads, shift more of our volume toward full loads, and cut down on the number of trucks going into and out of our stores. That approach keeps our costs in check while we complete relocations faster and with fewer hiccups. Third, we continue to refine the way bidding works on our site. During Q3, we rolled out our newly designed vehicle detail page to 50% of dealers. This page performs well on mobile devices, gives dealers more valuable information, and improves the search and filtering experience. It also serves as the jumping-off point for rolling out features we think will boost our wholesale operation further, such as condition reports powered by AI and proxy bidding. We have faith that these targeted efforts will create efficiencies and expand what we do over the long haul. To wrap up, we've devoted close to 30 years to constructing a varied operation capable of earning profits while weathering the highs and lows of the pre-owned auto sector. Our balance sheet is solid and we can reach capital. Our know-how in handling inventory and margins is a real asset, and we'll stay deliberate and control our spending, making adjustments whenever needed. Though we cannot forecast how much longer the sector will stay under strain, we regard these difficulties as temporary and think we're positioned well to get past them and come out as a company that's even more robust. I'd like to express gratitude to our associates for all they do to back one another, our customers and our business—our foundation stays solid, and we're eager about what lies ahead for our diversified business model. Having said that, we're ready to answer your questions. Ashley?
Brian Nagel
analystSo I suppose what I'm wondering about relates to sales. And Bill, maybe you could go into a little more depth about how sales moved across the quarter. That way we get a clearer picture of how the business is doing right now; and then, you also said in your remarks that you observed some market share declines, I suppose, toward the later part of the period. From what it sounds like, that happened because others got more aggressive with pricing. Could you say more about that? Which group — what segment of your competitors is taking that approach? And how long should it — how long do you think that situation will last? And then, I suppose, following on from that, when you look at your business, CarMax has traditionally been extremely, extremely strong when it comes to handling inventories; but if you're beginning to see others get more aggressive with pricing now and you've kept your margins steady. Might there be brewing problems inside your inventory?
Bill Nash
executiveAll right. That's quite a lot to address, Brian; so let me begin with sales for the quarter. When we last talked, it was the middle of September — the latter part of September, we discussed sales falling in the mid-teens; by the close of September it actually softened somewhat, and it carried on — we kept seeing even greater softness during October and November. I'll spare you from having to rejoin the queue since I'm certain your following question is, well, how is December shaping up? December is in fact tracking roughly where the quarter — where the third quarter averaged out. So it's marginally better than November, but I'd simply note that we're also going to be — we're lapping somewhat easier performance, clearly, than what we had from the third quarter that we'll be facing in the fourth quarter. Regarding market share, giving you some specifics on the market share declines. Year-to-date, as you mentioned, we've still got — we still hold gains in share. We did observe declines most recently during September and October, which is the newest title data available to us; but this illustrates why I always hold back when discussing market share over the short term because occasionally there are some fleeting pressures, and we saw competitors cutting prices and margins to clear inventory, which, frankly, doesn't surprise me. I mean, we witnessed the — a quite similar scenario back during the '08, '09 recession. That's also why we conducted far more extensive pricing elasticity testing. And through those tests, we're confident that although we would have moved more cars had we cut the prices, we would actually have we earned less money; and as I mentioned in my opening remarks and what I've consistently said is we're always — what we're pursuing is profitable long-term market share gains. And I believe our history and performance in this area are strong. I think your second question was simply about who is receiving that. Well, this is a very fragmented industry, with a great many participants. I'm unable to single out any one of them. I only know there are broad pressures from people attempting to shift their stock and clear it out.
Rajat Gupta
analystThanks. First off, regarding retail GPU — once again, clearly handled very effectively this quarter. You mentioned that you aren't cutting prices to the degree that a few of your rivals are. Yet eventually, those units have to be sold; they appear to be sitting around and growing stale in the lot. So what ultimately gives? In other words, might you need to think about offering discounts at some stage to get that stock out the door, if not during this quarter, then perhaps the following one? So how do you handle that shift? And what should we expect for the impact on Retail GPU, maybe over the next quarter or 2, given that pricing stance? I also have one more question after this.
Bill Nash
executiveSure; so Raj, excellent question. This is the area where I believe we truly excel with regard to managing inventory. I'm quite happy. In case you observed — I mentioned how significantly our overall inventory has declined, yet we still manage to keep saleable units; that's due to the team doing an outstanding job genuinely tidying up what we were holding, whether it involved awaiting components or absent titles. We put in serious effort to tidy up quite a bit. So as you said, that older stock is among the reasons why you saw less fluctuation in our ASPs, our average selling prices, considering the depreciation. The team did an outstanding job pushing through that, moving it out; and afterward, using our refined price testing, we simply concluded, look, it makes no sense to hand this over. And so once more, we believe we've placed ourselves in a very strong spot moving ahead. And I believe what you'll observe moving ahead is that your retail average selling prices will decline far more than what you've witnessed until now. So we're confident about retail GPU. Naturally, we'll keep evaluating the elasticity as we move ahead. But should elasticity remain steady, I believe you'll see us keep enjoying strong retail GPU.
Rajat Gupta
analystUnderstood. And perhaps take the other gross profit line as an example. When I look at the volumes from 3 years back, they're quite close to what you're doing now — actually a bit lower at present. That other gross profit stood at $94 million, and today it sits at $59 million, even though your third-party financing fees have in fact improved. So why has it fallen by nearly 50% at a comparable volume level? I mean, is there any chance to bring that cost down? I realize you said you want to keep the technicians, but for how long will we keep seeing this sort of run rate before it can reconnect with what you had previously?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYes. When it comes to the other margin in particular, what you truly have to do is examine the service business from the inside. This quarter, a few factors. First, with sales volumes sitting where they were, down 20% year-over-year, that puts a good deal of deleverage strain on the service business; that's the first point; but second, of nearly the same significance this quarter, roughly $15 million year-over-year came from our choice — and it's the right choice — to keep our technicians, correct? Staffing that role is extremely tough. Retaining and recruiting technicians matters most, because once we exit the cycle, we want to be able to ramp up our inventory quickly, faster than our competitors; that said, it's an investment running through that service line; and once more, this quarter it came to about $15 million at current sales levels. Still, for the medium term and certainly for the longer term, it is absolutely the right call. That was the largest pressure this quarter, Rajat.
Bill Nash
executiveAbsolutely. Rajat, one more point from my side: clearly, when you look at it against what things were like a few years back, our production capacity is much greater today, since our technician headcount has grown. Our footprint has expanded too. So that factor is contributing to the picture as well.
Rajat Gupta
analystSorry — I just wanted to ask a follow-up. What's your take on how the cycle recovers? I mean, do you expect some sort of bounce at some point in the next year? Or, I mean, how confident are you about that? Like, so — just because you might need to take some of these kinds of actions in a more aggressive way. I'm just curious about how you're thinking about it.
Bill Nash
executiveYeah. Well, Rajat, when it comes to what will happen in the next year, your guess is as good as mine. I think what we're attempting to do is get ourselves into a position where, no matter what occurs in the quarters ahead, we'll flex up, or if we need to pull other levers, we'll pull other leverage. So at this point, we're simply trying to give ourselves flexibility.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveAbsolutely. What I mean is that our attention is fixed on the things within our power, and those are the areas where we're making moves. So you're able to see our SG&A and the way we've changed its trajectory. You're able to see service — sure, it has risen. But once more, the cause behind that increase is our spending on technicians, since we understand, and we will make it through this cycle. And once we come out the other side, our goal is to be positioned very strongly and to turn cars around fast.
John Healy
analystI was hoping you could give us a bit more detail on how SG&A is trending. The comp cadence is helpful, but could you walk us through what you did during Q3, and perhaps what the run rate looks like — or is there a way to think about SG&A relative to gross for the coming couple of quarters? Even just some sense of what's reasonable for you folks would help, since SG&A has grown a lot and it now sounds like you're recalibrating that bet. Anything you can offer would be useful.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYes. Great. Thank you, John. Sure. Like I said during my prepared remarks, we've made a pretty dramatic change in the trajectory of our SG&A. If you look back at the entire first half of the year, it had risen 16% to 17% compared with the same period a year earlier. This quarter, we've brought that growth rate down to 3% versus a year ago. That said, once you exclude the $23 million settlement we got in last year's third quarter, what you're actually seeing is a modest reduction in total SG&A. So that's a substantial shift in the trend. Our expectation is that this will continue through Q4 and on into next year. What's driving it? It comes down to the initiatives we've been discussing, correct? Essentially, there are 2 categories of initiatives. Number 1 is on the more variable perspective, we've been lowering our headcount, lowering our staffing from an attrition basis in our stores; so that actually takes a little bit more time, right, because you're managing it through attrition, but we believe it's the right thing to do from a culture standpoint; and that has been bleeding down really since the second quarter when we start talking about it. We expect that will carry forward to the fourth quarter and into next year. The second piece is really taking a look at our fixed costs and actively managing there as well. I mentioned before that we were examining how many contractors we rely on at the corporate home office, and we've reduced that, correct? On top of that, we've basically stopped bringing new people into the corporate office; even so, we continue to fill backfills for certain essential roles we have, along with some strategic roles too. But on a significant level, we've also halted adding to our corporate overhead headcount. As a result, we've made decisive moves. In our view, these moves suit the market conditions we're facing. Should more steps become necessary, we're prepared to take them too. That said, our current position feels very solid. As for how things will trend, my expectation is that Q4 will resemble Q3, provided you exclude the prior year's settlement.
John Healy
analystAnd whenever you mention comparable to what we saw in Q3, are you referring to the dollar figure? Or is it more about the SG&A-to-gross-profit kind of ratio?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveRight; what I mean is really the year-over-year trend in SG&A and the direction it's taking. Growth isn't the goal there. So John, I'd say the difficulty with the leverage ratio — that SG&A-to-gross-profit measure — is that SG&A sits within our control, and I think we've managed it well. What's hard is the gross profit figure. So where that gross profit figure lands, plus big swings from one quarter to the next, makes managing that leverage ratio extremely tough. So as far as — like I said before, we'll handle whatever falls within our control, and that's where our attention is. Our attention is on that SG&A line. So my remarks really concern one thing: SG&A growth on a year-over-year basis during the quarter.
John Healy
analystGreat, and I have a single additional question regarding the gross profit per unit figures. It seems like you may have addressed this already, yet I'd like to pose it in perhaps another manner. Let's say, purely as a hypothetical, that average selling prices decline by another 5% to 10% across the coming two quarters, whether because of market circumstances or simply a shift in mix. Do you remain confident that the $2,000 to $2,200 GPU level can still be reached under those conditions? I simply wanted to put that question forward more directly.
Bill Nash
executiveYes. Honestly, I believe we're quite at ease with how we're operating the retail GPUs. We'll keep watching the test. That said, I do anticipate average selling prices will keep dropping, which in my view is beneficial for the industry as a whole since it helps create some separation between new and late-model use; therefore we're at ease with the position of our GPUs, and we'll keep testing.
Daniel Imbro
analystI'd like to ask a bit more about costs. Enrique, could you give us additional detail on what's really fueling the biggest inflationary pressures within that other overhead expense category? My understanding is that you scaled back, you mentioned some of the labor in the CECs, and it remains $40 million higher versus a year ago; so does any portion of that reflect a onetime bump? And then, stepping back to look at expenses overall. I believe it was just last quarter when we discussed that one reason you don't want to cut headcount too fast is that you'll need to rehire, and that becomes more difficult next year. But at this point it seems we're anticipating a weaker environment over the next 12-plus months. So then, why not trim expenses or staffing more aggressively in other areas of the company?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYes. What I would tell you is that we did; and so when sales became more challenged in the third quarter, we moved further on reducing staffing levels in the field. And so it's still being done through attrition, so it does take a bit more time. But simultaneously, we did bring our staffing targets down to reflect the current sales environment. So as I'd put it, we did move further on managing those expenses. And as for your first question, I believe you're asking about the other expense line and what's included there, since it was a 41% increase if you simply look at the release, correct? That is mainly due to the fact that we're comping against the $23 million settlement from last year. If you exclude that, you're looking at an increase of less than half of that. And what's really behind it is our investments in technology and product, correct? And that's what's driving it. What I would also tell you, though, is that if you compare it with prior quarters, there's a slowdown in the pace of that investment on a year-over-year basis. And so we've been pulling back there too. You can also see that reflected in our CapEx guidance for this year. We've reduced that from $500 million to $450 million. The biggest portion of that reduction really stems from slowing down certain projects. Beyond simply slowing some of the capacity initiatives we have underway regarding expanding our capacity amid lower volume, we're just slowing down some of those investments.
Bill Nash
executiveAlso, Daniel, one more point on that: our culture puts people first. The success we've achieved comes from our people. That's why we've decided to let attrition take us to the level we require. Naturally, we'll keep watching how things develop, but letting attrition bring us to the level we require is something we're quite at ease with.
John Murphy
analystFor a moment, I'd like to zero in on the supply side. When we consider the fleet of cars aged 1 to 6 years, it will likely keep gaining strength over the coming couple of years. As you said, Bill, competition concentrates more on those in the dealership. So it appears the supply of available 1 to 6-year-old vehicles will keep contracting. Certainly, regarding what's available to you and others in the secondary market, you've sort of mentioned moving down in age and price range to push volume, and you've demonstrated you can handle that pretty well. So I'm just wondering how quickly you can act on that to potentially push volume back up, at lower price points, yet with higher grosses and perhaps improved returns on capital employed.
Bill Nash
executiveYes. Thanks for the question, John. It's interesting, since we're basically experiencing a life much like what followed the '08 and '09 recession. You recall how you emerge from that with fewer newer cars, and it simply has to work its way through. I'd say we're in a stronger spot now than we were then, simply because our self-sufficiency is so high; and we'll manage to sell what consumers want, and we're going to achieve that in a manner that's really better than we could after '08, '09, since our self-sufficiency is so high. In my opening comments, one reason our buys dropped so much was clearly depreciation as the biggest lever, but there's also — we made certain choices just to slow down purchases. And so there were retail cars we deliberately chose not to buy due to the risk of those cars in a heavily depreciating kind of market. So again, I'm quite comfortable with where we stand, and I believe we're better positioned than we were in '08 and '09, and I think we did a phenomenal job in '08 and '09 navigating that period.
John Murphy
analystBut perhaps, to continue on that point, Bill — how quickly are you able to act on this to get comps into positive territory? We get the challenges, of course, in what used to be your traditional core business. That's clear, and you're aware of it. You're pursuing it. So when do you really lean in and perhaps significantly boost the penetration of those older vehicles to lift volumes? Because one thing that stands out — and it's quite impressive — is the variable focus on GPUs, a variable cost analysis, yet you carry these high fixed costs, especially as Enrique mentioned regarding those technicians; so at some stage you have to cover costs, not — and I'm asking, when are you able to do this? It's something you're consistently working toward but haven't yet done.
Bill Nash
executiveWell, regarding penetration of the older vehicles, look, the penetration and the amount we release into the market is dictated by what consumers want. And not everyone is seeking an older, higher mileage vehicle that costs less; so once more, demand is what drives all of it. And if we observe consumers continuing to want that, we'll keep supplying it. But then again, not everyone is — not everyone is seeking that.
John Murphy
analystAlright. So — what I really mean is that it comes down to availability of the main product, more so than the push holder.
Bill Nash
executiveYeah, I'd say it's actually a broader problem than that. You need to look back at what vehicles cost and whether people can afford them. That alone is causing many folks to hold off at the moment. And it isn't just affordability of vehicles. That's the largest share, sure, but you've also got interest rates climbing. Take CAF payments — just Tier 1, for instance — the amount paid each month, which matters most in someone's decision about purchasing a car, has risen by $150 compared with a year earlier, and most of that increase comes from the price of the vehicle, while a lesser portion comes from interest rates. So you've got that situation, which clearly keeps people waiting on the sidelines, plus the broader inflationary strain. What we're attempting to do, I think, is ensure we hold the proper quantity of stock, the proper assortment of stock available, so we can satisfy what customers want, while being very deliberate regarding our margins so that costs get covered, and we're applying a people-first mindset to the way we run this business.
Seth Basham
analystLet me get one thing straight—given this selling climate, where comparable sales keep dropping at 20%, are you still counting on SG&A being flat to up versus a year ago during Q4 and beyond?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveNo. I pointed out that you have to strip out the $23 million received during last year's third quarter. Consequently, our forecast is a decline compared with a year earlier in the fourth quarter; admittedly, I suppose it gets somewhat complicated since, as you're aware, things can shift from one quarter to the next, yet what we anticipate is a decrease versus a year ago in Q4.
Seth Basham
analystAll right. And once more, what's the size of that drop? And as you consider that 20% decrease continuing, at what point do you choose to take a more forceful approach with SG&A?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveRight, we won't give guidance regarding the magnitude of the decline in Q4, since, once more, there is quarter-to-quarter variability. What I can say, though, is that our expectation is a year-over-year decrease. And when you examine the sort of pattern we've been operating toward, I believe our attention has been on SG&A, and up to this point we've been pulling the correct levers. Now should business fail to improve, and worsen, there are additional levers available for us to pull, correct? For now, though, we feel we've pulled the correct levers; and we will keep managing the business prudently, just as we always have.
Seth Basham
analystUnderstood. My second question concerns the wholesale segment. Measured by units sold, the proportion of wholesale to retail dropped significantly, reaching 66% during this quarter. Do you view that as the new normal?
Bill Nash
executiveNo — what I see here is typical of a market experiencing steep depreciation. When values are falling substantially, as has been happening, and for the past year consumers have heard that now is the ideal moment to sell their vehicle, since they can receive more than ever before, a disconnect exists; consequently, whenever prices decline, our buy rate is always pushed lower. One additional point: because of market volatility, we reduced our appraisal advertising; therefore, no, I don't view this as the new norm.
Sharon Zackfia
analystTo build on what was asked about SG&A. Is there a method to frame the amount of SG&A you've removed so far this year and what the current run rate looks like in Q4? My assumption is that those efforts carried on through the third quarter and into the fourth quarter.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYes. The superior approach to consider this, Sharon, or the optimal approach, is simply the cadence — the year-over-year cadence we've experienced — since seasonality always exists, correct, from one quarter to the next in our business, and that likewise affects SG&A. But if you — once more, if you look back at the first half of the year, Q1, our SG&A rose 19% up year-over-year during the first quarter. During the second quarter, it increased 16% year-over-year; in this quarter, if you exclude the legal settlement we received last year, we're down 1%. Therefore, that represents a substantial slowdown in the rate of SG&A. And so we remain focused on it. We are managing to the current environment, right? We believe we're doing so suitably. Now if the business remains challenged, there are other actions we can take; but at present, we've implemented some fairly material steps to manage our SG&A.
Sharon Zackfia
analystYes. I believe some of the uncertainty comes from this — it sounds like your expectation is that SG&A will decline in a comparable way, roughly 1% lower in the fiscal fourth quarter versus the same period last year, yet it also sounds like you keep actively managing SG&A. So I think many of us are attempting to square that in our minds: why wouldn't SG&A fall somewhat more compared with a year ago than what showed up in the third quarter, if that tracks.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYes. Well, we anticipate that SG&A will keep declining, so to speak. I think when you look at any single quarter, it becomes somewhat difficult to hand you a figure that we're steering toward. A lot can occur during the quarter. But here's what I'd say: in terms of themes and in practice, our expectation is that we'll keep managing SG&A lower on a year-over-year basis.
Sharon Zackfia
analystAll right. And then, on a different note, I suppose, when it comes to SG&A for the entire next year, what's the right way to frame it? There are so many variables in play. You have to preserve your capabilities in case things bounce back, yet the macro backdrop is extremely tough at the same time. So looking ahead to next year, especially given the curtailment and the new unit openings, how do you think about growth in SG&A dollars?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYeah. Our approach to SG&A is this: previously we provided guidance, saying something like, we require gross profit expansion of 5% to 8% in order to lever. In the current type of environment, in this type of macro backdrop, that guidance matters less than the following point; our actual goal as we manage is to reach the mid 70% ratio of SG&A to gross profit. That represents our initial step toward bettering our SG&A. Of course, we will require growth in gross profit for that. Still, that's step one for us. As time goes on, we've discussed an operating model that is more efficient than it once was, and that remains our expectation. That will happen gradually, though. Omni transformation — you can look at other retailers who have been through it — reaching a better, more efficient operating model requires time. But we do expect to return to our former position. It will simply require time. Our initial step is reaching the mid-70% ratio of SG&A to gross profit. Yet once more, we'll need gross profit support in order to get there. Meanwhile, we will keep managing our SG&A in a way that suits the market, which is our practice. You can see that is precisely what we did during the third quarter. We expect to continue that through the fourth quarter and on into next year.
Bill Nash
executiveAbsolutely, Sharon. On top of that, once we get through the fourth quarter, we should have far greater clarity, which will let us share more with you based on how things go with the business from now until that point.
Craig Kennison
analystLet me approach the SG&A subject from another angle. The competitive landscape has shifted, and my sense is that shift has benefited you. So I'm curious whether, in terms of philosophy, you could adjust how aggressive you get with SG&A, since coming out on top in this market might no longer be a sprint — it could genuinely be a marathon. Would that let you dial things back more forcefully than merely cuts in the low single-digit percentage range?
Bill Nash
executiveYes. Craig, my way of thinking about it differs somewhat. Like you, I recognize that we clearly have rivals who are struggling. Given the strength of our finances, I don't believe this is the moment for us to retreat substantially on SG&A. We have already retreated quite a bit. Yet at the same time, as I mentioned during my opening remarks, we also need to ensure we keep building for what lies ahead. What everyone should keep in mind, I believe, is that this business isn't run by us on a quarter-to-quarter basis. We run it for success over the long term, and certain things we're investing in will unquestionably serve us well further out. Does that create a headwind for EPS at present? Absolutely. But is it the correct call for the company over the long term? Absolutely. So once more, my thinking regarding your question really comes down to this: we're going to keep walking that fine line. We want to keep building out the muscle. We want to keep funding near-term efficiencies, and that's what we'll do. And we'll keep managing the business with a long-term view rather than just a quarter-to-quarter view.
Craig Kennison
analystAnd perhaps only to add on. I mean, clearly, the stock is experiencing a lot of pressure. It seems as though you possess the long-term philosophy, yet not sufficient shareholders agree with it. Is there anything you might do to enhance the messaging or the guidance offered to perhaps lessen the degree of surprise with which your results are received?
Bill Nash
executiveYes. Well, I believe the surprise stems from macro factors, as Enrique mentioned, those really are things beyond your control. So what you must concentrate on is what you can control. And clearly, I think our long-term messaging remains more intact than ever. Yes, we have some pain here in the short term; but guess what? We have experienced pain before in the short term. We have seen — if you examine market share, for instance, which serves as a proxy for how I believe success is progressing, if you examine market share, we have historically — we have gained market shares. I mean even during the time of '08, '09, we lost a bit of market share in the near term, but then we rapidly recovered it and then some more. Even if you look over the last few years, when you reflect on like FY '20, when we began really rolling out our online capabilities, we observed a step-up in market share gains. Unfortunately, we entered COVID; we gave a little back; but the following year, we regained that plus more. Now we are in a recessionary period. So again, I think everyone just needs to kind of maintain a perspective of what we are pursuing long term. And yes, the short term can be a little noisy, but the long-term message remains intact.
Michael Montani
analystI was hoping to get a bit more detail from Jon regarding the credit side. You referenced that 2 to 2.5 is roughly typical for Tier 1, so could you share some additional insight? What loss ratio expectations would apply in a comparable way to Tier 2 and Tier 3? Then, as a follow-up, if you're able, some extra detail on delinquency trends and roll rates broken out by tier would be extremely useful.
Jon Daniels
executiveAbsolutely. Yes, exactly — I appreciate the question. That 2% to 2.5% is, once again, the range we aim for. I believe we've performed very well keeping it there. Our involvement in the Tier 3 segment goes back to 2014. Historically, as we've stated, it's essentially 1% of our receivables at the outset. It isn't 2%, and clearly loss rates are much greater. Often we've noted 10% of our losses back when it was 1%; so what you're observing is potentially a 10x, tenfold gap in loss rate for Tier 3. Tier 2 falls somewhere between those. It hinges on where we decide to participate in that space. There is, of course, a broad range. So ideally that provides you some insight into what to anticipate for losses, provisioning, whatever applies across those different buckets. Broadly speaking, macro factors along with delinquencies and losses are affecting our portfolio. It seems quite evident that delinquencies are climbing across the industry. There's no question about that. That's visible in our ABS deals; as we've said before, pressure among consumers is definitely present. I believe we've done an exceptionally strong job engaging with that consumer. And even when they may reach 30, 35 days past due, assisting them in finding solutions so it avoids becoming a charge-off. So we keep up that worthwhile effort and continue working with our consumers. As Bill noted, monthly payments have clearly risen. I think we've done well being prudent in our lending to consumers and supporting them through it; and in the end, we set reserves in line with expecting all of this. So from a reserve perspective, I'd say we're positioned well. We'll monitor the credit environment and the consumer very closely; and ideally that addresses your questions.
Michael Montani
analystCould you perhaps draw a quick comparison between the delinquency trends we're currently observing and those from '07 and '08?
Jon Daniels
executiveAbsolutely. What history shows, I'd say, is that during '07 and '08, the hit was felt heavily right across the whole credit spectrum. What we've pinpointed now, though, is somewhat greater strain on the lower-end credit customer — Tier 3 moving into Tier 2, possibly even the weaker portion of our Tier 1 segment. That strikes me as clearly distinct; and once more, there's delinquency strain suggesting some difficulty for the borrower, yet it isn't actually showing up as losses. Naturally, we'll monitor this closely and observe how it develops. In contrast, '08 and '09 brought a far broader effect spanning the credit spectrum and extending into losses; and once more, that was a totally different set of conditions. Everyone can concur on that point. Labor-related strain at that time versus worker earnings today; so we'll find out how it plays out. Still, those strike me as the core distinctions we've observed.
Chris Bottiglieri
analystI'd like to discuss how you get to your goal for SG&A as a percentage of gross. From what I hear, that depends to some degree on gross profit, yet certain gross profit levers, such as service and used volumes, strike me as beyond your control. I think that's probably a reasonable thing to say. Wholesale declined quite sharply this quarter, but you've achieved substantial gains in that area. So my question, I suppose, is this: where do you expect the gross profit gains to originate? Is there any basis to think wholesale might recover very soon?
Bill Nash
executiveAs Enrique mentioned before, this is an equation with 2 parts — we're managing the expense side and the gross profit; we'll need the business to recover. We'll need it to recover to some extent. When it comes to wholesale gross profit, clearly, we achieved some solid gains there. Retail. In fact, wholesale and retail GPUs, in my view, are both robust at this point. What matters is recovering some of the volume. Regarding wholesale, I'm optimistic we can expand it somewhat further. As I mentioned, we took certain actions this quarter that likely held that back somewhat; yet I believe that's where the dependency lies. That's going to — that will matter quite a bit.
Chris Bottiglieri
analystUnderstood. Alright, so let me ask something about cash, and I'll be quick. Even with a fairly significant rate increase, penetration has climbed a great deal. My guess is you've been faster when it comes to res rates, and bring your own financing also rose somewhat, while Tier 2 and Tier 3 both saw declines. If I caught that right, you're bringing additional partners into the Tier 2 and Tier 3 network as well. So could you describe what you're observing overall — are Tier 2 and Tier 3 getting stricter about credit at the margin? And that new instant appraisal tool you're adding, which seems to involve the partners more, will it help push penetration for Tier 2 and 3? Any perspective on that would be useful.
Jon Daniels
executiveYes. Alright. I'll address them one at a time; first, a comment on penetration generally. Yes, as we said in the prepared remarks, CAF penetration has risen alongside the fact that we've actually been raising rates. That's something I think we're quite happy about. We understand that typically, you'll trail the market. Again, at the higher end we're up against credit unions, but I believe we've done a tremendous job lifting rates 40 basis points quarter-over-quarter and 150 basis points year-over-year, and still getting that penetration. So that pleases us. You can see Tier 2 penetration lower than last year, and Tier 3 penetration also lower. I'd attribute that to 2 factors. You clearly observe the consumer struggle there, and as Bill said, affordability remains an issue there. But yes, certainly, as we noted, instant lenders are being very — doing whatever they must to function on their own and retreat where necessary. And I think our platform offers an advantage. You have a group of lenders who will collaborate to determine what suits them best, yet together deliver a solid credit offer over time; so I think that's — you definitely see a pullback there. Chris, on the final part of your question, I believe you said instant — not the instant appraisal tool, but our pre-qual tool, just to be clear, we said we keep adding lenders to that tool. Again, we consider it a best-in-class tool. It demands a lot of agility from our lenders. They're all joining. Are we seeing engagement there? Yes, though I'm not sure that's really pushing much into the penetration story, even though that tool does deliver a better credit quality consumer into the application process. But — so does that cover your questions? What else did I leave out?
Chris Bottiglieri
analystNothing. You've got my full list of requests, and I appreciate you fixing my slip of the tongue. Right there <<inaudible>> my apologies, I repeated it once more, the financing penetration tool.
Chris Pierce
analystI was just hoping to get a bit more detail. You mentioned rivals behaving aggressively when it comes to preference units rather than price, whereas you folks essentially take the reverse approach. Is that a good thing since it signals the sector is returning to normal? Or does it hurt in the near term since they'll wind up with newer stock, which will drag your unit counts down. I'm simply trying to figure out how to frame that, and how it has moved over time. You've mentioned witnessing this previously.
Bill Nash
executiveYes. Yes, Chris. So my take on what you're describing is that some competitors simply aren't — weren't shifting any inventory, and depreciation has been extremely sharp; therefore, what they're doing is attempting to shift a portion of that inventory. We've witnessed this before. Frequently, it can't be sustained across the long run since you simply aren't generating the cash you require, yet you're attempting to get units moved; so it's, once more, the reason we ran the expensive price test; we wanted to see what the elastic was. And we ran price tests in both directions. So we ran a price test downward. We also ran price tests upward purely to gain a clearer understanding, which once again, simply reassures us that we chose correctly when it comes to profitability.
David Whiston
analystSeems like this quarter brought exceptionally strong free cash flow, driven by bringing inventory down. So I'm wondering, first, how much further can inventory be trimmed to keep delivering that free cash flow upside while still having enough vehicles available to sell? Then, you used part of that free cash flow to clear the revolver. Would you also like to retire that June '24 term loan to strengthen the balance sheet further, and would the cash be available on hand?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYes. In an environment like this, I'd say holding some cash isn't a bad thing; and we definitely rely on truly effective inventory management. As Bill mentioned, our total inventory came down versus a year ago, yet sellable inventory actually went up. So that reflects impressive effort from the teams working through our WIP. That was genuinely good news; we deployed that cash, basically as you said, to pay down the revolver this quarter, bringing it to 0. There's no draw on our revolver, and simultaneously we hold some cash. David, I simply believe that in an environment like this, keeping some cash on hand isn't a bad thing either. Ultimately it gives us flexibility to navigate an environment like this. We also have a very strong balance sheet and are proud of it. And we have flexibility that others in the industry lack; I think that places us in a position of strength.
David Whiston
analystAnd in a way tied to that halt in buybacks, I get the desire to be careful, but ought we read this as meaning you folks feel less hopeful regarding the near to medium term than was the case 3 months back?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveWell, in conditions like these, maintaining a cautious balance sheet matters. And like I said during my prepared remarks, we treat our net leverage ratio as something requiring very careful management, so that we keep maximum flexibility for having funds and for managing CAF. Our captive finance organization is quite large, and that's simply a crucial factor factored into this. So I believe that until the business improves and, equally important, the macro backdrop improves, my expectation is that the share buyback will stay paused. Having said that, our commitment to the share repurchase program remains complete, and we will re-enter it at the right moment, once things get better and the outlook gets better.
Bill Nash
executiveYeah, David, the point isn't that our thinking has shifted to, oh, conditions are going to deteriorate. It's really more a matter of how much is unknown.
David Whiston
analystYeah, I get what you're saying. With any luck, the break won't drag on too much. From where I sit, your shares look really appealing right now. .
Bill Nash
executiveAppreciate that, Ashley. All right, look — thank you, everybody, for being on today's call and for the questions you brought. Like I've mentioned several times over the course of today, we feel we're in a solid spot to handle what's in front of us; and my honest view is that we'll come out of this as a company that's even stronger. Once more, I'd like to express my gratitude to our associates for all their efforts and for how dedicated they are to one another, to the customer, to the communities, and to the environment; and I hope each of you enjoys a wonderful holiday season, and we can't wait to speak with you again when the next quarter comes around. Thanks.
Operator
operatorThanks, everyone. That wraps up the CarMax conference call on our earnings release for the third quarter of fiscal year 2023, ladies and gentlemen. You're free to hang up at this point.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete CarMax, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to CarMax, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in CarMax, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.