CarMax, Inc. (KMX) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

April 11, 2023

New York Stock Exchange US Consumer Discretionary Specialty Retail earnings 66 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

David Lowenstein

executive
#1

Appreciate that, Corless. Morning, everyone, and thanks for being on the line for the call covering our fourth quarter of fiscal 2023. Joining me are Bill Nash, who serves as our President and CEO; Enrique Mayor-Mora, our Executive Vice President and CFO; and Jon Daniels, our Senior Vice President of CarMax Auto Finance Operations. A quick reminder before we begin: anything we say today that isn't a statement of historical fact — including remarks about future business plans, prospects, and financial performance — counts as a forward-looking statement made under the Safe Harbor provisions of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Such statements rest on what we currently know, expect, and assume, and they carry substantial risks and uncertainties that might cause actual results to differ materially from what we expect. When we provide projections and other forward-looking statements, we disclaim any intent or obligation to update them. For more detail on important factors that could affect these expectations, please refer to our Form 8-K, filed with the SEC, this morning, and our annual report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended February 28, 2022, previously filed with the SEC. If any follow-up questions come up after the call, feel free to reach our Investor Relations department at 804 to 747 to 0422 extension 7865. Finally, thanks ahead of time for limiting yourself to one question and then getting back in the queue for more follow-ups. Bill?

Bill Nash

executive
#2

Okay, thank you, David. Good morning, everyone, and I’m glad you could join us. The challenges currently facing used vehicles are getting a lot of coverage — affordability is under pressure from broad inflation, climbing interest rates, tighter underwriting standards, and an extended period of poor consumer confidence; we continue to lean on our biggest assets, our associates and our culture, to build momentum and navigate this portion of the cycle. Many macroeconomic forces are beyond what we can influence, but we have taken deliberate steps to strengthen the business both near term and longer term. In this quarter, we reduced SG&A further. We delivered strong retail GPU through our methods for sourcing vehicles, reconditioning them, and managing margins, all while continuing to test price elasticity. We adjusted offers to produce solid wholesale GPU, and at the same time increased unit sales compared with the previous quarter. We aligned used saleable inventory units with market conditions, and reduced total inventory dollars by more than 25% versus the same period a year ago; and finally, we raised CAF’s consumer rates to help offset a higher cost of funds while still growing CAF’s penetration; we are focusing on initiatives that improve efficiency and create better experiences for our associates and customers; we believe these steps will allow us to come out of this cycle leaner and more capable, and also prepare us for future growth. Looking back at fiscal ’23, we hit several important milestones across every part of our diversified business model. Every retail customer became able to self-progress online; the wholesale shopping experience improved; and our finance-based shopping prequalification product finished its nationwide rollout. Each of these achievements keeps positioning our business for growth as the industry’s most customer centric experience. I’ll provide more detail on those later in this call; but first, let’s move to our results for the fourth quarter of FY ’23. Because of the diversity across our business, we generated $5.7 billion in total sales, down 26% from last year. The decrease reflected lower volume and prices in both retail and wholesale. In retail, total unit sales fell 12.6%, and comparable used unit sales declined 14.1%. Versus a year earlier, average selling prices declined by roughly $2,700 per unit, equal to 9%. In addition to the macro factors I already mentioned, we think temporary competitive responses to current conditions continued to affect our results. Based on our market share data, our nationwide share for vehicles aged zero to 10 years remained 4% for calendar year 2022. Looking at external title information, the share gains we made in the first six months were erased by losses in the back half of the year, because we prioritized profitability over short-term share. For context, we have surrendered market share before during earlier downturns. When that occurred, we regained it afterward and continued expanding to reach new peaks once the economy improved. In the fourth quarter, retail gross profit per used unit came in at $22.77, which was up $82 per unit year-over-year. We remain focused on capturing market share in a way that's profitable and sustainable, and we'll keep conducting a wide range of price elasticity tests. The latest findings from that testing made clear that prioritizing profitability—holding the line on margins throughout the quarter—was the correct decision. Despite a decline in average selling price, retail gross profit per used unit for Q4 came in at $2,277, an increase of $82 per unit versus the same period last year, which demonstrates our ability to price cars appropriately and manage margins effectively within our inventory. Wholesale unit sales were down 19.3% compared with Q4 of last year, but that still beat the 36.7% decline we posted in Q3 of this year, helped by sequential improvements in our total purchases from consumers and dealers. Wholesale average selling price declined by about $3,200 per unit, or 28%, versus a year ago, and we began to observe some appreciation in January. Wholesale gross profit per unit totaled $11.87, in line with what we recorded in Q4 last year. The recent price appreciation I mentioned, combined with robust dealer demand—especially toward the end of the quarter—drove the margin upward. During the quarter, we acquired approximately 262,000 vehicles from consumers and dealers, a 22% decrease relative to last year's record, though it represented a sequential improvement from the 40% decline in Q3 of this year. For the quarter, self-sufficiency stayed above 70%. We bought roughly 247,000 cars from consumers during the quarter, and slightly over half of those sellers used our online instant appraisal tool. From dealers, we sourced about 15,000 vehicles, which was a 4% increase over last year. Now to our Q4 online metrics: retail unit sales represented about 14% of the total online, up from 11% in the prior year. Omni sales made up approximately 52% of retail unit sales in the quarter, compared with 55% a year earlier. Almost all of our Q4 wholesale auctions and sales — accounting for 18% of total revenue — continued to be virtual and are counted as online transactions. During the quarter, we conducted a small simulcast test for wholesale auctions to assess dealer interest in returning to attend in person, and we'll keep exploring live attendance options through FY '24. Online transactions generated about 30% of total revenue, a slight decrease from last year. At CarMax Auto Finance, or CAF, income was $124 million, down from $194 million in the same quarter a year ago. In a moment, Jon will share more details on customer financing, the loan loss provision, and CAF's contribution. Right now, I'd like to hand it over to Enrique, who will give further detail on our financial performance in Q4. Enrique?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#3

Thank you, Bill, and good morning, everyone. Keeping our attention on what's within our control generated sequential improvements from Q3 in a number of key financial metrics, including EPS, gross profit, and SG&A. For the fourth quarter, net earnings per diluted share were $0.44, versus $0.98 in the comparable period last year. Total gross profit was $611 million, which represents a 14% decline from the fourth quarter of last year. Used retail margin came to $387 million, while wholesale vehicle margin was $143 million, representing decreases of 9% and 20%, respectively. These year-over-year reductions were driven by lower used and wholesale volume, though solid per-unit margin results partially compensated. Used unit margins improved relative to last year's fourth quarter, and wholesale margins per unit were flat year-over-year. Other gross profit totaled $81 million, a 24% decrease from last year's fourth quarter. This decline was primarily due to lower extended protection plan, or EPP, revenues. In addition to the impact of reduced retail units sold, profit sharing revenues from our partners decreased to $16 million this quarter, down from $33 million in last year's fourth quarter. Improved margins and a favorable year-over-year return reserve adjustment partially offset that. Penetration was about 60%, the same as a year ago. Third-party finance fees were roughly unchanged from last year's fourth quarter, as reduced volume and fee generating Tier 2 were offset by lower Tier 3 volume, on which we pay a fee. Service was also approximately flat versus last year's fourth quarter, reflecting sequential improvement in year-over-year performance; we have maintained consistent technician staffing levels and have set key efficiency and cost coverage targets for our teams. This supports our expectation for better performance in FY ‘24 compared to the full FY ‘23 year. The extent of this improvement will also hinge on sales performance, given the leveraged, deleveraged nature of service. Now turning to SG&A: fourth quarter expenses totaled $573 million, 8% under the prior year's quarter and 3% lower sequentially than this year's third quarter. SG&A as a percentage of gross profit was higher than last year's fourth quarter, mainly because total gross profit dollars declined 14% relative to last year's quarter. The change in SG&A dollars versus last year was primarily due to the following factors: first, we reduced advertising by $34 million. Second, total compensation and benefits fell $17 million, which included an $18 million increase in share based compensation. Excluding that, compensation and benefits were down $35 million, with $18 million of that from a lower corporate bonus accrual in the quarter. Third, other overhead increased by $6 million. The year-over-year increase in investments in our technology platforms and strategic growth initiatives largely resulted from decisions made in earlier quarters. A favorable year-over-year comparison partially offset this, due to costs incurred in last year's fourth quarter related to a significant ramp in staffing and favorability in various other smaller costs this year. Additionally, we have approximately $315 million in cash on the balance sheet. During the quarter, we continued to take steps designed to align our expense base more closely with sales. That involved further reductions in store and CEC staffing through attrition, a pullback on hiring and contractor usage across our corporate offices, and ensuring our marketing spend stayed connected to sales. Advertising expense, measured both in dollars and per unit, ended up lower than the same quarter a year ago, and yet our per-unit investment for both the quarter and the full year remains consistent with the full-year spend we posted a year ago. When we look at fiscal '24 in its entirety, we expect to keep per-unit spending at about the same level as FY '23, even though it will fluctuate quarter to quarter. At this point, we believe we largely possess the resources needed to meet our near-term omnichannel and other digital investment needs. As a result, we anticipate bending the expense growth curve when it comes to our omnichannel investments and overall SG&A. For FY '24, we expect that low single-digit gross profit growth will be required to lever SG&A, well under the levels we guided toward during the investment-heavy phases of our omni transformation. Because of that, we expect gross profit growth to flow through to profitability more strongly. We do expect the first half of the year to benefit from the cost management actions we took in the back half of FY '23, but the magnitude of that year-over-year gain compared with the 8% decline we recorded in Q4 may be muted, particularly in Q1. That pattern stems from lapping a more comparable period for advertising and a corporate bonus accrual in Q1 than the fourth-quarter declines I referenced earlier. Although we aren't providing specific guidance beyond FY '24, we expect this bending of the SG&A growth curve to continue past this year. That should support our path back to a lower SG&A leverage ratio, with the initial objective of returning to the mid-70% range over time. Getting to that range will also require healthier consumer demand. On capital structure, funding the business remains our top priority. In light of recent performance and continued market uncertainty, we stay conservative in our approach to capital structure. Our adjusted net debt to capital ratio came in slightly under our 35% to 45% target range, and we are managing net leverage so we preserve the flexibility that allows us to efficiently access the capital markets for both CAF and CarMax as a whole. Consistent with maintaining flexibility, we are continuing to pause share buybacks. Our $2.45 billion authorization remains in place, as does our commitment to return capital to shareholders over time. With approximately $315 million in cash on the balance sheet, we remain focused on funding the business. On capital expenditures, we expect roughly $450 million in FY '24, comparable to our FY '23 level. This spending is primarily driven by investments in land and the build out of facilities tied to long-term growth capacity for production and options. CapEx is getting an additional lift from new store growth, though that component is smaller now since we slowed how quickly we're opening locations during FY '24. As we look ahead to fiscal 2024, we intend to open 5 new locations. That figure covers 2 additional stores in the New York City metro area, along with our inaugural off-site production facility in the Atlanta metro market. CarMax continues to gain a competitive edge from its extensive nationwide footprint and logistics network. Our liquidity position remains very strong: we ended the quarter with about $350 million in cash on the balance sheet, and we didn't draw anything on our $2 billion revolver. Alongside that, we're carrying approximately $315 million in cash on the balance sheet. With that, I'd like to turn the call over to Jon.

Jon Daniels

executive
#4

Appreciate that, Enrique, and morning to everybody. In Q4, CarMax Auto Finance wrote $1.9 billion, which produced a penetration rate of 44.7% net of three-day payoffs — an increase over the 41% recorded during the same quarter a year ago, and consistent with Q3. New customers were charged a weighted average contract rate of 10.9%, which rose 110 basis points versus Q3 and 270 basis points versus the equivalent period a year earlier. We felt good about our capacity to raise consumer rates during the quarter, all while holding our sequential share of finance contracts steady and expanding that share considerably versus a year ago. Tier 2 penetration for the quarter came in 19.4% below what we'd typically see seasonally. Tier 3 penetration matched last year at 6.9%, and although our long-term lending partners kept complementing one another by delivering solid credit offers to our customers, we did see tightening on a year-over-year basis, since both higher interest rates and delinquencies probably drove those changes. Notably, CAF has likewise revised its underwriting standards in light of the present environment, which included cutting its targeted percentage of Tier 3 volume from 10% down to 5% near the close of Q4. CAF income during the quarter reached $124 million, a decline from $194 million in the equivalent period a year ago. That $70 million year-over-year drop stems mainly from a $44 million rise in loan loss provision plus a $61 million increase in interest expense, partly offset by growth in interest and fee income. During the quarter, total interest margin fell to $262 million, which is $22 million below the same quarter a year ago. The related margin to receivables rate of 6.3% declined roughly 100 basis points year-over-year and 125 basis points from the almost 10-year peak reached in the first quarter of this year, mostly because of the substantial interest rate increases absorbed over the past year. To address this, we've executed many pricing actions across the last 12 months, including during the fourth quarter, which ought to make the margin reduction decelerate and let this portfolio rate flatten out in fiscal year 2024. The loan loss provision of $98 million in Q4 brings the ending reserve balance to $507 million, or 3.02% of ending receivables. That compares with a reserve of $491 million in the prior quarter, which equaled 2.95% of receivables; this 7 basis point sequential adjustment in the reserved to receivable ratio mirrors unfavorable portfolio performance, the uncertain macro environment, and the ongoing rise in cash Tier 2 and Tier 3 volume; we keep targeting and operating inside the 2% to 2.5% cumulative net credit loss range for our core Tier 1 portfolio, and we believe our reserves are appropriate for future losses. As for additional progress in our credit technology, we keep stabilizing and enhancing our nationally available best-in-class pre-qualification product, finance-based shopping or FBS. In Q4, we completed the rollout of one more major lending partner onto the FBS platform, which means we now have five established lenders in total who are delivering decisions across an applicant's and co-applicant's entire vehicle inventory by using a soft credit inquiry. What really sets this offering apart in the used car space, keep in mind, is that we can generate more than 6 million distinct credit decisions each minute, drawing on numerous finance sources, each with its own unique credit models, and then present those offers digitally to shoppers no matter where they happen to be browsing — inside the dealership, at home, or while strolling the lot. Looking ahead to the first quarter, we expect to bring more finance partners onto the platform, since that effort is already progressing nicely. With that, I'll hand the call back to Bill.

Bill Nash

executive
#5

Thanks, Jon and Enrique. Like I said when the call began, despite working through the obstacles of fiscal '23, we hit quite a few important milestones over the course of the year by concentrating on making our omnichannel experience quicker, easier, and smoother for both our associates and our customers. The strides we've taken on our path toward providing the industry's most customer synthetic experience make me proud. A few things worth noting from this year that will leave a durable mark throughout our diversified business model: on the retail side, we made online self-progression capabilities available to every one of our customers. While we continue developing our omnichannel experience, we're simultaneously revising our operating models to generate efficiency gains in our stores. Over the year, we introduced self-checking capabilities for appraisal customers and improved e-sign functionality so that self-progression works better. Our e-commerce engine, paired with our unmatched nationwide fiscal footprint, represents a competitive advantage. Being able to deliver integration across digital and physical transactions sets us apart both in the experience we offer and in the total addressable market open to us. On the wholesale side, we introduced a modernized, mobile friendly vehicle details page that shows the most relevant information dealers need in order to preview our wholesale inventory, which creates a shopping experience for dealers much like how consumers browse our retail inventory; we also brought MaxOffer — our digital appraisal product for dealers — to roughly 50 markets, letting us strengthen our leading position as a buyer of cars. We use our admin sales team to enroll new dealers in the service, which delivers profitable incremental wholesale volume; when it comes to credit in CAFs, we finished the nationwide rollout of finance-based shopping, our multi-lender prequalification product. As Jon noted, this lets customers digitally obtain quick credit decisions from a majority of our lenders across the full vehicle inventory. More than 80% of our customers have turned to this online tool when starting the credit process. Beyond that, CAF is just as focused on emerging from this cycle leaner and more effective. The team is already putting the new loan receivable system we rolled out a bit more than a year ago to work, capturing savings opportunities, with plenty more anticipated in the years ahead. As we look toward fiscal '24, we'll continue building on last year's initiatives and put priority on projects that unlock operating efficiencies and create improved experiences for our associates and customers; we're confident that the steps we take will put us in a better position to seize the upside once the market recovers. A few illustrations: on the retail side, we're using data science, automation, and AI to make it even simpler for customers to finish key transaction steps independently and to move back and forth between assisted health and self-progression. We're also creating digital tools that will help customers through key transaction steps and their journey, giving them clearer insight into the steps they still have left. These solutions are going to boost e-commerce and simplify the process for shoppers choosing express pickup. With this fulfillment method, people can wrap up their purchase at any of our locations in just 30 minutes or even less, which is a win-win. According to what we've found through research, shoppers adore this kind of experience whenever they use it, and over time it'll let us bring costs down. On the wholesale side, we're going to use our updated vehicle detail page to introduce additional offerings. A few illustrations would be AI powered condition reports, plus proxy bidding features; we'll also enhance MaxOffer by making our instant offer process available to every dealer who takes part. Such capabilities will let us achieve greater operational efficiencies as we keep expanding wholesale volume, and at the same time deliver an improved experience. When it comes to CAF, our efforts are aimed at weaving our finance-driven shopping offering into our stores and customer experience centers in a smoother way, so every consumer gets to access the complete experience. Like Jon said, we'll keep chasing chances to bring more lenders onto the platform too, something that widens both the range and depth of deals our customers can get. Those are just a handful of solid illustrations, but everyone across our whole company, from Edmonds through Logistics, is dedicated to boosting efficiencies and experiences. Our confidence in what lies ahead for this diversified business is strong. We'll keep assessing how we perform against our long-term financial targets on a yearly basis. Entering fiscal '24, we're reaffirming the goals we revised back in April '22: moving between 2 million and 2.4 million vehicles via our retail and wholesale channels combined by fiscal '26, bringing in revenue somewhere between $33 billion and $45 billion by fiscal '26, and increasing our national share of the zero to 10-year old vehicle market to above 5% by the close of calendar '25. I'd like to express thanks and congratulations to every one of our associates for what they do. They represent our greatest point of difference and hold the key to our success. Last week, Fortune Magazine put CarMax on its list of 100 Best Companies to Work for, marking the 19th consecutive year. That recognition makes me enormously proud, especially given the tough year we've had; it reflects how our associates commit to backing one another, our customers and our communities daily. Across close to 30 years of history, we've made it through plenty of difficult periods and come out stronger every single time; what we're facing now is no exception, and I have confidence that the steps we're taking will let us achieve strong growth once the market gets better. With all that said, we're ready to take your questions. Corless?

John Healy

analyst
#6

To kick things off, I'd like to spend a moment discussing the CAF segment. Enrique, I was hoping you might share your perspective on what some of the important metrics could look like, perhaps for the upcoming quarter or thereabouts. That would include losses and recoveries, plus the opposing forces at play there. Beyond that, I'm also curious about your funding costs and the direction they've been heading recently, along with the coupon rate being offered to the customer. Does a lag exist? Is there some sort of catch-up window? We'd just like some way to frame how these dynamics may shift as fiscal '24 gets underway.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#7

Sure. I appreciate that question, John. Let me take the funding cost piece and how one should think about it. After that, I'll hand things to Jon so he can discuss the business. Looking at funding costs, here's what I'd say: the securitization market, which is the primary source we rely on, is currently open and constructive. Based on what we've observed, you saw in our first deal that funding costs declined compared with the deal that closed in 2022, correct? Consequently, we are of the belief that benchmarks will keep declining, spreads will remain healthy, and we'd anticipate that trend persisting. Regarding timing, you should expect us to enter the market in the near-term. Even so, we'd anticipate being able to complete our deal. And once more, I believe that compared with a few deals back, when the market was truly squeezed and funding costs stood at one of the highest levels witnessed in many, many, many years, they've dropped since then. They remain above what we'd obviously prefer, yet they're definitely improved from where they were running a few deals ago.

Jon Daniels

executive
#8

Yes, and let me add some color on the remaining metrics. To build on what was said about cost of funds, the APR embedded in the deal is clearly the other piece there. Previously we sat at 9.09%, and we just noted 10.9% on what we originated during this quarter, so pushing rates upward over the course of the year has been a real success on our part. That gives you a sense of how it will carry into deals ahead. So assuming the spread stabilizes and our APRs come in higher, that ought to work in our favor. Turning to losses and delinquencies, as we said in the prepared remarks, we've once again lifted our reserve to $507 million, which equals 3.02% of receivables. We did note that part of this stems from unfavorable trends in the portfolio and the broader macro backdrop. My sense is that across the whole industry, consumers are showing more delinquency, and for us that's within the current book of business. There's certainly elevated inflation, which makes things harder on consumers. The loans we're originating now carry a higher average selling price, which means a bigger payment; so borrowers are dealing with an auto payment larger than what they'd typically be accustomed to. So we're monitoring all these factors or items very closely; we've set reserves appropriately for them, yet delinquencies have clearly climbed, and while we've managed that well, it hasn't completely flowed through into losses, and we believe we can keep serving the consumer effectively. One more point to add: we noted in the prepared remarks that we have tightened — plenty of lenders have tightened their standards on our platform and beyond the industry, and we've tightened too. But this is something we do routinely — we did it during the great recession, we did it when the pandemic began; we've done it numerous times in between; so our tightening is simply to be a bit more conservative while we keep a close watch on the consumer. Still, thanks to our tightening, our partners are glad to take on that volume, just as they have before. So it's tough to predict where losses and delinquencies will land, though we believe we remain in that 2% to 2.5% range as we always have; we believe our reserves are solid and we'll keep a careful eye on the consumer.

John Healy

analyst
#9

Great. Thank you.

Michael Montani

analyst
#10

Great. Thanks for taking the question. I wanted to ask about retail and wholesale GPUs; I think both were stronger than we were anticipating. Could you provide an update on the pricing volatility we're seeing that's pretty unprecedented, I think both at retail as well as at wholesale? And then competitively what you're seeing in the market, how sustainable is this kind of strong discipline in GPU, I guess for those two segments?

Bill Nash

executive
#11

Sure. Good morning, Michael. Yes, on the retail and wholesale GPU, obviously, they did come in stronger. On the wholesale side, there was a modest benefit — we experienced some appreciation late in the quarter, and when that typically occurs, we tend to lag behind, regardless of whether values rise or fall. So I'd say that contributed a slight tailwind. Looking ahead at wholesale, I'd probably settle closer to our historical range of $900 to $1,000. Turning to retail, we ran extensive price elasticity testing and concluded we might have moved a few additional vehicles, yet our profitability would actually have declined. As a result, we maintained retail GPU levels, which are fairly close to what we saw in the third quarter. Those figures increased compared with the prior year, and that mostly reflects our ongoing shift toward an older vehicle mix, since those units bring slightly stronger margins. As for retail pricing overall, we saw some depreciation early in the quarter and then a bit of appreciation toward the end. Looking back twelve months — not this year, but the year they had just wrapped up — prices for cars in the zero-to-five-year-old range rose roughly $7,500. When the calendar year wrapped up, roughly $5,000 had been recovered, I'd guess. Despite some appreciation showing up lately, my expectation is that we'll likely begin encountering somewhat more depreciation moving ahead. So that ought to keep providing a bit of easing when it comes to the retail sales price overall.

Michael Montani

analyst
#12

Thank you.

Bill Nash

executive
#13

Sure.

Craig Kennison

analyst
#14

Morning, and thanks for fielding my question.

Bill Nash

executive
#15

Word we're getting is that a number of banks <<inaudible>> Bill Nash: Corless, seems like Craig's line may have dropped.

Craig Kennison

analyst
#16

Yeah, hello. Am I coming through clearly?

Bill Nash

executive
#17

Craig, yes, you're coming through. Please continue.

Craig Kennison

analyst
#18

Thanks. Yeah, we've been hearing about certain banks reducing floor plan credit lines for a few of the companies you compete with. Given that you finance your own inventory, do you think that gives you an edge when it comes to acquiring vehicles right now?

Bill Nash

executive
#19

Yeah. Honestly, that's tough to answer. What I can say is that since we're so self-sufficient, sourcing really hasn't been a problem for us. We're not out there bidding in auction lanes nearly as often as we once were. As for how this affects competitors and where their funding comes from, we'll just have to wait and see. In theory, if they can't get financing to keep vehicles on the lot, that could push prices lower. But we don't know yet.

Craig Kennison

analyst
#20

Thank you.

Bill Nash

executive
#21

Yes.

Rajat Gupta

analyst
#22

Thanks a lot for taking my question. I've got something about SG&A, and then a piece inside of that. Perhaps starting with store occupancy cost — it came in about 10% below the prior quarter, even though we added five new stores. Is there anything we're not seeing? Given those new openings, we figured it would rise on a sequential basis, so I simply want to confirm there aren't any one-time items we've overlooked. Then I have a brief follow-up.

Jon Daniels

executive
#23

Thanks, Rajat. No, I don't believe anything is being missed; there are a couple of things worth noting. First, spending timing shifts between quarters, so things move around. This quarter gave us some favorable timing relative to the one before. Beyond that, with volumes where they stand, our rent came down somewhat as volumes flex — when volumes rise, we add off lot short-term capacity to handle them. Since volumes sit where they do, we reduced our off-site capacity, and that shows up in occupancy as a smaller rent bill. Those are the two main items I'd point to for the quarter.

Rajat Gupta

analyst
#24

Understood, that's useful. Now, when you're mapping out SG&A budgets for the year, what kind of view are you taking on the used car market? Are you expecting the industry — especially that zero to 10-year old bracket — to grow this year, and do you think you'll gain share there, considering the ad spend guidance you've given? I'm just wondering what type of recovery you're assuming in your budgeting plan?

Bill Nash

executive
#25

Yes, Rajat, appreciate the question. Well, we're definitely not economists, but I believe there are some publications out there, and I think COGS, for instance, has the used market overall declining somewhat this year. My sense is you're also seeing it as weaker during the earlier stretch — meaning somewhat less strong at the start, with somewhat stronger results toward the latter half. That's roughly how we view it too, though only time will tell. And when it comes to market share, as we've always said, regardless of whether conditions are favorable or unfavorable, our aim is to grow share in a profitable way, and I already mentioned the temporary pressures on market share that we're still experiencing during this quarter. Still, based on what's happened before, we'd anticipate a reversal, after which we'd resume growing market share.

Rajat Gupta

analyst
#26

Understood. Thank you.

Bill Nash

executive
#27

Sure.

Brian Nagel

analyst
#28

Hi, good morning.

Bill Nash

executive
#29

Good morning.

Brian Nagel

analyst
#30

So here's something I'd like to ask. From your remarks, it seems you're signaling a reduced leverage threshold for this year. What I mean is, you'll be investing in expenses at slower growth rates. So my question is really just to confirm that I've got that right. And beyond that, what shifted? What exactly were the — which levers could you pull to make that possible? Then, once more, returning to what you said so I can be clear: ought we to expect that when the business finally recovers from this down cycle, that leverage threshold will stay more tilted than it was before?

Bill Nash

executive
#31

Yes, everyone. I appreciate the question. Let me share my thinking first, and I'm certain Enrique will also have some input. But you've got it exactly right, we are — putting out the word that we anticipate this happening at a reduced rate going forward. And when you look at recent years, each year we refresh things and say, all right, here's what will be needed to lever, and we ran that five day during the last year, while the year before we told you, hey, it's going to demand more than that, on account of the investments we were aware we were making along with some investments carrying over. We had not provided longer-term guidance, since frankly, although plenty of companies have moved from being purely brick and mortar into something more omnichannel, there genuinely isn't another instance of businesses doing so in what I'd describe as a considered purchase, where there's substantial back and forth involving physical and digital properties. That's why I nearly compare it to fixing up an older home, which sadly I've been through as well. You can't know what you can't know until you're in the middle of it. And whenever you tear down a wall in an older home, a fresh surprise is waiting. Well, in this case, whenever we turned over a stone related to the omnichannel experience, two more stones sat beneath it; and I believe where we've arrived is that we've finished building our product organization. We feel genuinely confident about the resources there. We have the foundation of the capabilities. Now the focus is on improving, and as we improve and complete certain items, we'll move people over to work on other items. So we feel confident about the resources we now have. And I'll let Enrique add anything else…

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#32

Yeah, just to add a bit more onto what Steve (ph) mentioned, like I said during my prepared remarks, the heavy investment period for omni transformation is behind us. By and large, we feel the resources are now in place, we've got appropriate staffing, and at this point it's genuinely about carrying out our plans, with a real focus on boosting efficiencies along with improving and strengthening the experiences our customers and associates have, right? Still, we're confident that point has been passed. So we do believe that at present, and based on the guidance we provided, low-single-digit gross profit growth is what we'll need to lever. And I'd think about that as something that carries past FY ‘24 and into — though I won't give specific guidance — I'd think about it that way. That's roughly where we sit on our maturity curve as a company, and that's roughly how I view it for the period ahead.

Brian Nagel

analyst
#33

All right, everyone. Thanks for the additional detail.

Sharon Zackfia

analyst
#34

Hello, and good morning. I've got a few items regarding SG&A. I'd just like to confirm I grasp the framing for leverage. So when you mention SG&A leverage, do you mean it as a share of sales, or SG&A relative to gross profit? I just want to be certain — let's establish which metric you're actually using. I'd also like to pin down the pattern in the first quarter: are you talking about a sequential easing in the decrease, or an easing on a year-over-year basis? I believe that matters to quantify too. And finally — apologies, this is a question with several parts — it concerns ad spend. I was somewhat taken aback, and I believe I heard it right, that advertising expense per vehicle would stay flat compared with last year. I'm curious what reasoning sits behind that, given the conditions we're facing, where it sounds like many consumers are simply priced out of cars, full stop. So I'm wondering about holding that advertising expense roughly level rather than pulling back, perhaps further toward the $300 mark you used in the past?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#35

Yes. Sharon, thank you for the several questions; and let me see here whether I can…

Sharon Zackfia

analyst
#36

A few points to clear up — I'm working from the clarifications

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#37

I suppose the rest of them, and your question was framed differently here, correct? So regarding the first item, definitely, we shifted to defining leverage as SG&A over gross profit. Not retail units, and not sales, since as you're aware, as we've transformed and migrated the business, it isn't only about per retail unit anymore. There's also a stronger wholesale operation, a stronger CAF operation. So we look at it holistically, and our specific leverage measure sits on gross profit. So that likely addresses your first clarification. As for the second one, about the first quarter — yes, that's a key point, and I had noted it in my notes and mentioned it. So during the fourth quarter, right, on a year-over-year basis, SG&A came down 8%. So what we're signaling here is that for the first quarter of FY ‘24, the upcoming year, that reduction could be muted — the year-over-year decline in Q1 against last year's first quarter would be muted relative to that 8%. And the reason is simply that we'll have — there will be tougher comparables around the corporate bonus accrual, which during the fourth quarter was down quite substantially, as I flagged in my notes. Also, in last year's fourth quarter, our marketing spend ran far higher than it did in this fourth quarter, and that gave us some relief this fourth quarter. So that creates somewhat more of a hurdle for Q1 of FY ’24 on a year-over-year basis, versus FY ‘23. And finally, regarding marketing spend per unit, a few years back we made the call to raise our marketing spend per unit in step with our journey and our transformation, and that's where we are now — what we plan to maintain. We feel we have solid visibility into ROI and highly accretive properties and investments here. Our marketing team performs wonderfully and can track what's accretive. What generates ROI and what doesn't generate ROI. So we understand our marketing investment portfolio quite well, and at present, we believe roughly 350 per unit in spend is the right level for where we stand.

Bill Nash

executive
#38

Also, Sharon, one more point I want to make on top of what was said — Enrique brought this up during his remarks — is that it can shift from one quarter to the next. Some quarters you might see an increase, other quarters a decrease, and what drives that is really the ROI we're observing. There will always be some level of brand spending, since I believe that matters for the long term. Another thing worth pointing out is that with advertising, we're not only focused on acquiring customers — acquiring vehicles matters too. So at times we might spend somewhat more as we attempt to purchase cars from consumers; so once again, we'll keep watching this.

Sharon Zackfia

analyst
#39

Okay. Thank you.

Bill Nash

executive
#40

Thank you.

Scot Ciccarelli

analyst
#41

Hi, everyone. This is Scot Ciccarelli. Clearly, sticker prices remain elevated by a fair amount. Typical rates have climbed as well, which means monthly outlays have risen considerably, correct? I realize this is producing a comp decrease in the double digits, but I suppose what sort of effect is that specifically having on your conversion rate? Put differently, when we examine the sales drop, is it mostly coming from fewer people walking in, or from that initial opportunity you get with a shopper? Or does it lean more toward customers reaching the final stage and then simply determining they truly cannot afford what they're considering? Is one of those bigger than the other, or are they — are those elements roughly equal?

Bill Nash

executive
#42

Yes, excellent question, Scot, and it's good to have you back on the call.

Scot Ciccarelli

analyst
#43

Thanks.

Bill Nash

executive
#44

What we observe is strength at the top of the funnel — so the issue isn't there. The real decline occurs when it comes time to convert, and that stands to reason: once you locate a vehicle you want, you begin the process, and suddenly it hits you that the monthly payment exceeds what your budget allows, and at that point you can see where they drop off. That's exactly why vehicle affordability has been a subject we keep raising as among the largest influences on our sales. So conversion is the whole story — the top of the funnel, not so much.

Jon Daniels

executive
#45

Right, and I’ll build on what you said there, Scot. Just one thing to mention first: when we talked about the FBS platform, one aspect we’re really enthusiastic about is this — a huge number of customers are browsing for that monthly payment on the web right from the start, not necessarily while at the dealership. So if someone selects vehicle X and that turns out to be a steeper payment for them, we give them the ability to view payments across all the vehicles with several lenders, letting them shift fairly fast. So again, we believe that once the sticker shock from higher ASPs eases with time, simply having that tool available to fine-tune the price within that payment as needed is going to be a real plus for us. And we’ll launch forward from this.

Scot Ciccarelli

analyst
#46

All right. So the overall demand hasn't gone anywhere. The real obstacle, if you like, is whether people can afford it or manage to complete a purchase?

Bill Nash

executive
#47

That's right, the interest is absolutely present. And part of the reason web traffic has kept up its momentum, I believe, is that finance-oriented shopping tool Jon mentioned — folks are simply attempting to work out what fits their budget. Perhaps they aren't at the point of purchasing a vehicle yet, but perhaps they're merely checking to see what they can afford?

Scot Ciccarelli

analyst
#48

Great. Thank you very much.

Bill Nash

executive
#49

Thanks, Scot.

Daniel Imbro

analyst
#50

Yes. Morning, everyone. Appreciate you answering my questions.

Bill Nash

executive
#51

Morning.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#52

Morning.

Daniel Imbro

analyst
#53

Enrique, I'd like to probe SG&A from a slightly different angle. You've been discussing attrition for several quarters, and it appears you're achieving solid headway in bringing that compensation line down? How do store or CEC staffing numbers stand right now compared with twelve months back or prior to this attrition? Might we be 15% below? Could headcount be down 20%? And where ought that figure head once growth picks up? Since on one side, Bill, I believe, just said you should remain leaner going forward, yet in your prepared remarks, as I recall, you mentioned aiming toward the mid-70s SG&A to gross ratio eventually? So I'm simply attempting to fit those pieces together — if you could address roughly where staffing sits, where it heads, and what that implies for long-term SG&A margins?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#54

Yes. What I'll say is that we feel we're mostly staffed at the right level, so to speak. Certain areas still likely carry some excess staffing that we're addressing, correct? And, we handle it in a sound manner, simply via attrition. That's been our method throughout this recent stretch. But broadly speaking, we consider ourselves appropriately staffed, more or less, in every area. Versus a year ago, correct? We were lower regarding what runs through SG&A, since we have a sizable service department plus service associates that land in our COGS. Yet purely within SG&A, we're roughly 10% below the prior year, correct? That mostly reflects staffing at our CECs as we've rightsized our stores as we've rightsized too, and there you'll notice it partly offset by our corporate overhead staffing, though net-net we're roughly 10% lower. So that's roughly our position. As for that 70%, mid-70%. Yes, we genuinely are pushing to reach it. Our aim is to return to a leverage rate that better reflects stronger flow through and the business model we're pursuing; to hit that figure, though, we'll also require some assistance from sales, correct, to underpin it. And we anticipate arriving there eventually. Reaching it in FY ‘24, I'd say, would be quite a stretch, simply given where we finished FY ‘23 and roughly where volumes sit; plus the climate we're operating within; but we're managing what falls within our control, and I believe we've done a fairly effective job of lowering our SG&A and rethinking our business model and the maturity curve regarding where we stand with our omni transformation. And now it's simply about, more or less, reallocating resources internally toward the most accretive projects we have.

Bill Nash

executive
#55

Yes. And Daniel, one more point I'd tack onto that: even while business comes back, our attention is squarely on locating efficiencies. With omni, the model inside the store has genuinely shifted. That means we're hunting for additional efficiencies within the CEC, so when more volume arrives, the CECs aren't required to expand at the same pace. We've already made cuts — we shrank the sales force, thanks to the CECs, since customers are moving further along, which is one more reason we're so committed to self-progression: the more customers advance by themselves, the more associates our floor sales consultants can take on. So when we consider the model ahead, we're pursuing efficiencies not just on the corporate side, where we feel quite good about the teams in place, but also simply by making field operations more efficient.

Daniel Imbro

analyst
#56

And if I may add a quick point of clarification, rather than posing an additional question. My understanding is that you previously operated in the mid to high-60s range, and it appears that a 10% reduction in headcount has occurred while the CEC is becoming more efficient. So why wouldn't that level, or perhaps something even better, serve as the objective you're pursuing, Enrique, instead of the mid-70s? Have there been additional costs stemming from omni and admins that have pushed up that long-term SG&A margin?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#57

Yes. What I stated is that the first step for us, correct, meaning our initial target, is the mid-70s, and then over a longer horizon, getting back to approximately where we once were is included in our aspirations. Whether we'll fully return to our prior position within the medium term, I'm not certain, but our first step, without question, is reaching the mid-70s.

Bill Nash

executive
#58

Yeah. And Daniel, regarding that, bear in mind that a portion of the omni transformation involves moving from a company that operated with all legacy systems, which truly cost us nothing, to a mix of systems we developed internally plus software-as-a-service. And software-as-a-service represents a cost we didn't have before. So items such as software-as-a-service, the product organization we assembled — we now have 60 product teams that really make possible this omni channel experience for both the store and the digital side; so that cost isn't disappearing. Previously we didn't carry that cost. In theory, the CECs will be offset by the sale. So that ought to be watched, but there are things such as cybersecurity that, since we now have such a large digital presence, you had to increase your spending there. So there are certain items, which is why, as Enrique mentioned, our first objective is, hey, let's return to the 70s because we recognize we face some headwinds from things we didn't previously have, and after that we'll keep working to bring it down further.

Daniel Imbro

analyst
#59

Excellent, thanks for all the detail, and good luck out there.

Bill Nash

executive
#60

Thanks.

Seth Basham

analyst
#61

Much appreciated, and good morning to everyone. I'd like to ask about retail GPU, which turned in fairly strong results during this quarter. I'm wondering if you believe market conditions gave you a lift on that measure? Then, thinking ahead, ought we to model that as unchanged versus last year for fiscal 2024, or is some shift likely given what we expect from price elasticity along with other considerations?

Bill Nash

executive
#62

Yes. Morning, Seth. I'd agree that market conditions provided a boost, since, to repeat what I mentioned before, we were running pricing elasticity tests, and we had the option to move additional vehicles, yet total profitability would have come out lower; so in my view, that was a benefit. Regarding what comes next, I suspect I'd land closer to the range we've seen historically. Part of this, you know, will hinge on macro forces, since testing elasticity will remain part of what we do; still, when you consider that we've generally sat around 2,100 to roughly 2,100, 2,150, 22,000 — within that band — my sense is that a figure in that vicinity makes a sensible target to keep in mind for the year ahead. That said, it will once again come down to what the market factors show us.

Seth Basham

analyst
#63

All right. And as a second question, when you think about balancing the number of units sold against GPU share of the market, that's obviously a key objective for you. Is there a moment when you would get more aggressive with pricing in order to win back share and hit your longer-term goals? Do you genuinely think this situation is temporary? Are there any grounds on which it might not be?

Bill Nash

executive
#64

Yes. No, that's a terrific question. And once more, we've consistently talked about this notion of the right level of market share, and nothing about that has shifted. You know, when I look at share for 2022, it was relatively flat. One could make the case it was marginally higher, but we describe it as relatively flat; during the first half of the year, we recorded solid share gains. As a matter of fact, a number of those months showed double-digit increases; we got to August, August, which I'd describe as pretty flat, and after that we saw shrinking gains really from September through December. And this has happened to us before, if I look back at ’08, ’09, if I look back at COVID, even though those are quite different situations, we've experienced periods where share was lost for a while, and then it levels off. We begin on a month-over-month basis, we begin building it back up. We return to where we stood before the decline began, and then we keep growing it further. My expectation is that this time will be no different. I take encouragement from the data we have thus far, if you examine August through or really September through December, share was falling month-over-month. With December, January, my hope is that we've more or less bottomed out. We don't yet have the February data, but I'm hoping we've bottomed out, which would mean that, okay, share on a month-over-month basis will probably still be under the year-over-year figure, but we ought to begin climbing back out.

Seth Basham

analyst
#65

Thank you.

Bill Nash

executive
#66

Sure.

Chris Bottiglieri

analyst
#67

Chris Bottiglieri here. I’d like to follow up about CapEx and have you expand on that a bit. Omnichannel seems to be decelerating somewhat, and only 5 stores are being launched. I’m just attempting to understand why CapEx is increasing. Do you intend to speed store expansion back up in FY ’25, with some upfront capital expenses tied to that? Then you brought up — apologies, this is a lengthy question, and you covered a lot during the call. You said you’re launching those off-site recognition centers and auction centers. Do those require more capital than your stores? I’m trying to grasp which strategies are involved and what these investments are meant to achieve. If you could expand on that, it would be very useful.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#68

Yes, Chris, thanks for asking. So compared with the prior year in FY ‘24, our CapEx spending should be approximately unchanged from what it was, though the components making it up are shifting somewhat, correct? Thus, by far the biggest piece of our CapEx in FY ‘24 will really be spending that begins constructing our off-site production and our off-site auction capabilities, so that eventually, across the longer horizon, we can achieve our long targets, correct? We’re confident about the near term and our capacity to reach our sales and auction levels, yet we must simultaneously prepare for what’s ahead. That involves purchasing land throughout the country. It also involves, during this year, constructing and launching our first off-site production auction — pardon me, production site, which is going to be located in Atlanta and that metro market. How to conceptualize it: its scale will be approximately — and this is how to think about them going forward at our off-site production locations — roughly matching the scale of the biggest production locations we currently have within our stores, correct? Considerable acreage, so think of them as 20 plus acres too. Regarding CapEx spending, for those alone they will resemble the CapEx we previously spent on our production locations; however, that is in fact fueling the biggest portion of our CapEx spending. There’s some expectation that stores will keep expanding in FY ’25, correct? Even so, we’ll need to observe how the market behaves, how we perform, and what the macro environment looks like. As you know, we reduced that figure for FY ’24, we’re at 5 new stores, and we’ll find out in FY ‘25, but some planning for that proceeds even this early in the year, since getting a store open requires a considerable amount of time.

Bill Nash

executive
#69

Right, and Chris, on top of what you said, regarding the money we intend to spend on capacity, this is really the same approach we've taken before. In the past, when entering new markets, we would construct production facilities alongside stores. Lately, though, since we haven't launched a large number of those production sites, we've instead been making use of the production capacity already in place. So adding capacity was always part of the plan. Honestly, there's nothing new here compared with our historical approach. It's simply that the moment has arrived for us to move forward with some extra production builds. And the one real distinction is that a portion of these won't be connected to stores, though they'll still sit nearby, since that gives us a significant edge over competitors.

Chris Bottiglieri

analyst
#70

Yeah, that's a big help. And on a similar note, I believe you brought up something about how opening up simulcast could help with wholesale. Could you expand on that a bit? It looks like you're seeing very solid wholesale volumes in GPUs, so I'd like to understand the reasoning behind it and what it means for revenue and cost. Any insight would be useful.

Bill Nash

executive
#71

Yes. No, that's a fair question; we simply want to be sure we're getting the most out of the experience for our dealers while also getting the highest possible price our cars can sell for. So we're only running small tests to find out, hey, with a — a physical sale plus broadcasting it virtually at the same time, are there new dealers who might come? Or do you wind up with an extra bid; so we — in our push to be as efficient as we can, we don't want to leave any stone unturned. So I don't really view it as a large SG&A expense, since a lot of — the testing we're doing is more what I'd call a post card sale. So you actually have the cars running through, but you keep the auction lane open so folks can bid and that sort of thing. So again, small tests, and we'll keep seeing what we can learn. But as you said, we feel great about the margins we can put on cars. But again, we're always trying to get a little better.

Chris Bottiglieri

analyst
#72

No problem at all. Thanks for making room in your schedule. I appreciate it.

Bill Nash

executive
#73

Thanks to you.

John Murphy

analyst
#74

Morning, everyone. I have a couple of quick clarifications and follow-ups. In the press release, you mentioned that total interest margin is going to level off in 2024. Looking back over the previous three years, in 2021 and 2020, you were achieving collateral spreads of roughly 7% in those pools, and during the last four, those spreads came in at 4%. I'm wondering whether there's anything in the forward market or in what you're getting ready to roll out that leads you to believe spreads will widen considerably. It's just difficult to grasp how — when we think it through — spreads could level off rather than potentially compress? Then my second question, Bill, regarding the franchise — pardon me, regarding market share gains. Is there opportunity to gain within the six to 10-year old segment? In other words, considering that 4% figure in the zero to 10-year old market, is there meaningful room among these older vehicles, where grosses could potentially be higher down the road?

Jon Daniels

executive
#75

Absolutely. Thanks, John, for asking. I'll address the NIM question. First, the key thing to note is that you're coming off what was likely a 10-year peak in Q1 earlier this year. You truly gained from low funding costs. Lenders could capture substantial margin there. When you examine some of those deals you mentioned, I mean, extremely strong margin. So although we would have liked to remain at that level, it probably was never going to be sustainable, and you've watched us decline sequentially each quarter. If you consider how — the way we've managed to increase rates for our consumers, and clearly, Enrique brought this up before, we believe the ABS market is improving somewhat; we're likely better aligned with our rates relative to how our long-term funding costs will play out. Therefore, we believe that looking ahead, there's no way to predict where funding costs will head, and there's no way to predict which consumers will come through the door. At the end of the day, we must stay competitive and ensure we can move cars and offer competitive rates to our consumers. But looking forward, we've declined from that peak. We believe our rates are well aligned against what we can fund this stuff for going forward, and we do believe we can level off in ‘24.

John Murphy

analyst
#76

Sorry, when you say the match, do you mean you expect to return to collateral spreads of 5% to 6% before long? That's the pattern you've observed, though conditions are a bit more typical now. So I'm just wondering whether that's the level you believe you'll reach shortly?

Jon Daniels

executive
#77

Sure. Yes. If you simply examine those earlier deals, consider the '23 one deal, again, with an APR of 9.09%, we just mentioned that this quarter we're at 10.9%, and I can say that isn't where we finished the quarter, so in later deals you will see a higher APR if funding costs are more sensible, I believe we will definitely have funding costs that align better with rate out there, and that is precisely what I'm talking about.

John Murphy

analyst
#78

Thanks.

Bill Nash

executive
#79

Now John, regarding market share in the six to 10 year range, keep in mind that our measurement of market share has always been zero to 10. In my view, six to 10 does represent an opportunity. Take our sales as of late — this quarter included — vehicles older than six years with more than 60,000 miles. Looking at the year-over-year comparison, we're likely 10 points up, and as a percentage of sale we're probably in the high 30s. Whether prices decline is the real question. Will consumers shift back toward newer model vehicles? We'll find out, but I think our position is excellent. We've clearly demonstrated the ability to source those vehicles and recondition them. So going forward, it's a strong lever.

John Murphy

analyst
#80

All right. If you're describing that as a structural opportunity, is that accurate? I mean, if those shoppers shifted back to younger, cheaper vehicles, you would still have those 10-year-old cars on hand to sell. Wouldn't that just contribute to your long-term structural growth, more or less? I'm only asking out of curiosity — it just looks like a huge opportunity.

Bill Nash

executive
#81

Yes, I think that's correct; though again, some of it will hinge entirely on consumer demand. If the folks coming into our stores are looking for later model vehicles with lower mileage, we'll certainly put more of those on our lot — somewhere between 2,100 and roughly 2,100, 2,150, 2,200 in that range — so we'll adapt to whatever the consumer wants.

John Murphy

analyst
#82

Okay. Thank you.

Bill Nash

executive
#83

Yes. Thank you.

Chris Pierce

analyst
#84

Hello, and good morning. Since we're roughly midway into the first quarter, I wanted to ask whether you could share thoughts on used average selling prices and retail ASPs, and what trends you're observing? In the fourth quarter they declined 7% on a sequential basis, though I realize the third quarter was somewhat artificially elevated. Given all the discussion around wholesale demand plus significant wholesale price gains as a trace, is that carrying over into retail or less so, owing to the retail-wholesale spread? I'm just wondering what you're seeing so far this quarter when it comes to retail ASPs?

Bill Nash

executive
#85

Sure, Chris, I'd say it's somewhat early for that, since the vehicles we're currently selling were sourced during the prior quarter. So my sense is it won't really have an effect at this stage on what your retail ASPs look like. So what I'd say about the current quarter is that our retail ASPs are likely comparable to the level they reached during the quarter. And once more, there was a bit of appreciation we observed in that area. Remember that depreciation moves through far faster on the wholesale vehicles, since you're rotating that inventory every seven days.

Chris Pierce

analyst
#86

Okay. Perfect. Thank you.

Bill Nash

executive
#87

Yes.

David Whiston

analyst
#88

Thanks. Good morning. I'm just wondering whether you've noticed a significant reduction from CAF's lending partners — sorry, from the partners on your lending side — given that CAF's gross penetration rose by 330 bps. And on that same topic, Jon, I believe you mentioned before that your aim is simply to bring on additional lenders. Did that refer to ABS lending, or does it also cover Tier 2 and Tier 3 partners?

Jon Daniels

executive
#89

Sure. Yes, regarding your first point, David. Of course, whenever partners scale back, the pie still totals 100, so CAF stands to gain from that. That said, I'd say CAF's penetration really reflects us staying competitive within that tier segment and capturing the volume outright. But yes, our Tier 2 partners definitely did scale back, and Tier 3 usually gains from that, since those customers who normally fall into Tier 2 might shift downward and be captured by Tier 3. Still, I think that simply demonstrates the strength of our platform, correct? If CAF scales back, Tier 2 steps in; if Tier 2 scales back, Tier 3 steps in, or other Tier 2 partners do, but we certainly did observe a reduction in the Tier 2 segment. And your second question probably related to my prepared remarks about bringing on a subsequent lender — we meant the FBS platform. We have five, once again, long-term lenders there, meaning they operate with a soft pull, they decision all the vehicles using their models within minutes, and they return it to us so we can deliver that to the consumer and offer as rich a deal as possible. Each lender you bring on — we brought on one in Q4, and we're hoping to bring on another in Q1 — only makes the set of offers stronger across all the inventory the customer sees and helps them convert. So that's what I meant.

Bill Nash

executive
#90

And those are — David, these are lenders we’ve had for the long term, and we’re bringing them into Multiples Speakers.

Jon Daniels

executive
#91

Sure, what’s happening isn’t the addition of a completely new lending partner, even though I’m confident there are many lenders who’d be eager to enter this area of ours. What this involves instead is bringing what already exists in our usual in-store settings into this FBS setting, which is again quite rich.

David Whiston

analyst
#92

All right, thanks. Are repossessions ticking up at all, or do you think that will come about later in the year?

Jon Daniels

executive
#93

So, to address whether repossessions are rising — clearly, when losses climb, and with delinquencies rising across the industry as you're observing, that produces losses, and then additional repossessions follow. So my sense is that the whole industry is experiencing this. To some extent, we're experiencing it too, if that's what you're asking.

David Whiston

analyst
#94

Yes. Thank you very much.

Jon Daniels

executive
#95

Yes.

Bill Nash

executive
#96

Excellent. Thanks. I appreciate all of you for being on this call, for your questions, and for your support. Once more, I want to congratulate each of our associates on being recognized as a great place to work for 19 years straight; and as I mentioned before, we feel we are in a strong position to steer through these conditions and come out even stronger. We can't wait to speak with all of you again in the next quarter. Be well.

Operator

operator
#97

Appreciate it, everyone. That wraps up the conference call for CarMax's earnings release covering the fourth quarter of fiscal year 2023. You're free to hang up at this point.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete CarMax, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to CarMax, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in CarMax, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.