CarMax, Inc. (KMX) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
June 23, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
David Lowenstein
executiveThanks, Chelsea. Good morning, everyone, and thanks for being on the call for our first quarter of fiscal 2024 earnings conference. Joining me today are Bill Nash, our President and CEO; Enrique Mayor-Mora, our Executive Vice President and CFO; and Jon Daniels, our Senior Vice President, CarMax Auto Finance Operations. I want to remind you that anything we say today that isn't a statement of historical fact — including statements about the company's future business plans, prospects and financial performance — is a forward-looking statement made under the safe harbor provisions of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995; these statements rest on our current knowledge, expectations and assumptions and carry substantial risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results to differ materially from what we expect. When we provide projections and other forward-looking statements, we disclaim any intent or obligation to update them. For more information on important factors that could affect these expectations, please see our Form 8-K filed with the SEC this morning and our annual report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended February 28, 2023, previously filed with the SEC. If you have follow-up questions after the call, feel free to reach our Investor Relations department at (804) 747 to 0422 extension 7865. Finally, thanks in advance for limiting yourself to one question and then getting back in queue for more follow-ups. Bill?
Bill Nash
executiveAlright. Thanks, David. Morning, everybody, and I appreciate you being here. The first quarter was still tough because of the same things we mentioned in fiscal '23, but we're seeing quarter-over-quarter gains throughout our operations. Our attention is on managing whatever is within our control as we take measured actions to bolster the business both in the short term and over the long haul. During this quarter, we brought down SG&A excluding the legal settlement. We posted solid retail GPU, we lifted the number of saleable inventory units while lowering total inventory dollars 13% versus a year ago, we generated robust wholesale GPU as our unit volume kept bouncing back. And lastly, we expanded CAF's penetration even while we increased CAF's consumer rates to help counter elevated cost of funds and made lending standards stricter in response to today's conditions. In Q1 of FY '24, our diversified business model produced total sales of $7.7 billion, a 17% drop from the prior year, caused by reduced retail and wholesale volume and pricing. Within retail, total unit sales fell 9.6% and used unit comps dropped 11.4%, an improvement compared with declines of 22.4% and 14.1% year-over-year in last year's third and fourth quarters. Average selling price fell roughly $1,600 per unit, or 5% year-over-year. Retail gross profit per used unit for Q1 came to $2,361, matching last year's $23.39. Typically, margin runs greater in the first quarter than during the remainder of the year. Given current conditions, we anticipate that this year's second quarter and full year margins will resemble last year's, somewhat above the full year $2,100 to $2,200 range we discussed last quarter. As we always do, we'll keep testing price elasticity and watching the competitive landscape. Wholesale unit sales dropped 13.6% against last year's first quarter, reflecting ongoing gains from the 36.7% and 19.3% year-over-year decreases in last year's third and fourth quarters. Average selling price fell roughly $2,000 per unit, or 18% year-over-year. Wholesale gross profit per unit reached $1,042, consistent with $1,029 in last year's first quarter. We acquired about 343,000 vehicles from consumers and dealers in the quarter, a 5% decline from last year and better than the 40% and 22% year-over-year drops in last year's third and fourth quarters. Among those vehicles, we bought roughly 323,000 from consumers during the quarter, and slightly over half of those purchases came via our online instant appraisal experience. Consequently, our self-sufficiency stayed above 70% for the quarter. We obtained the other approximately 20,000 vehicles via dealers, a 20% increase from last year, aided by our Edmond sales team; regarding our first quarter online metrics, about 14% of retail unit sales happened online, up from 11% last year. Roughly 54% of retail unit sales were omni sales this quarter, which aligns with the prior year. For the first quarter, almost every wholesale auction we held in sales — and that accounts for 20% of total revenue — stayed virtual as part of our deliberate online transactions. Revenue coming from online transactions came to roughly 31%, matching the figure from a year ago. CarMax Auto Finance, or CAF, posted income of $137 million, a decline from $204 million in the equivalent period a year earlier. In a few moments, Jon will go into greater detail regarding customer financing, the loan loss provision, and what CAF contributed. Right now, I want to hand the call to Enrique, who will share additional information about how we performed financially in the first quarter. Enrique?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveThank you, Bill, and good morning to all of you. Staying focused on the things we can control produced yet another quarter of sequential gains in our year-over-year results across several important financial measures, such as unit sales, SG&A leverage, gross profit, and EPS. For the first quarter, net earnings per diluted share came in at $1.44, compared with $1.56 during the same period last year. Our EPS for this quarter included the equivalent of $0.28, or $59 million, tied to a legal settlement. Gross profit in total reached $817 million, a 7% decline versus last year's first quarter. Used retail margin came to $515 million, while wholesale vehicle margin was $168 million, falling 9% and 12%, respectively. These year-over-year declines resulted from lower volume in both retail and wholesale; strong margin performance provided a partial offset, since per unit margins for both retail and wholesale rose slightly compared with last year's figures. Other gross profit totaled $135 million, up 12% versus last year's first quarter; service drove this gain, contributing $4 million in margin, which is a $26 million improvement over last year. As we said on our Q4 FY '23 year-end earnings call, we expect service to post better year-over-year results in FY '24, thanks to the efficiency and cost coverage measures we implemented. Our first quarter has gotten us off to a solid start. Reductions in extended protection plan, or EPP, revenues and third-party finance fees partially offset the service improvement. EPP revenues fell $5 million, mainly because of lower sales, partially offset by stronger margins put in place at the end of last year's first quarter. Third-party finance fees dropped $3 million versus last year's first quarter. Lower volume in Tier 2, for which we receive a fee, was partially offset by a reduction in Tier 3 volume, for which we pay a fee. Turning to SG&A, first quarter expenses were $560 million, 15% below the prior year's quarter. Excluding the benefit from the legal settlement, SG&A was 6% lower than the prior year's quarter, as we keep realizing the benefits of our cost management efforts. SG&A as a percent of gross profit was 68%. Excluding the settlement benefit, our SG&A leverage was 76%, roughly flat compared with last year's first quarter. The change in SG&A dollars relative to last year was mainly attributable to the following factors. First, other overhead fell by $79 million, of which $59 million came from the settlement. The remaining year-over-year favorability stemmed from several factors, including favorability in non-CAF uncollectible receivables, which benefited partially from timing, favorability in costs tied to lower staffing levels, and a variety of other smaller costs. Second, we cut advertising by $17 million. While our advertising expense on both a total dollar and per unit basis was lower year-over-year for the quarter, our per unit investments for the quarter remained in line with last year's second half spend level. Third, total compensation and benefits — if you leave out a $13 million rise in share-based compensation — went down by $15 million. That drop mostly came from what we've kept doing in stores and CECs, namely matching staffing to sales and finding efficiency gains. During our Q4 FY '23 year-end call, I mentioned that for the whole FY '24 year we anticipate needing low single-digit gross profit growth in order to lever SG&A, which is far under the figures we gave as guidance throughout the investment-heavy periods of our omni transformation. So we anticipate achieving a more robust flow-through from gross profit into profitability. Thanks to how we performed in the first quarter, we are on track to hit that objective. We did achieve SG&A leverage — the SG&A leverage point landed in the mid-70% range during the first quarter — yet you should keep in mind that the first quarter is generally when our SG&A leverage is strongest, since historically it is the quarter with our highest used unit volume and margin per unit. When it comes to capital structure, funding the business is still our number one priority. Although our adjusted net debt to capital ratio came in a bit under the 35% to 45% range we target, with market uncertainties persisting, we keep managing our net leverage suitably so we retain the flexibility needed to access the capital markets efficiently, for both CAF and CarMax overall. Consistent with that aim of preserving flexibility, we are still pausing our share buybacks in the first quarter. Our $2.45 billion authorization is unchanged, and so is our commitment to returning capital to shareholders over time. Also, after the quarter's calendar end, we managed to renew our $2 billion revolving lending facility on materially similar terms; we intend to put additional information in our upcoming 10-Q, which we intend to file on Monday. At this point I'd like to hand the call over to Jon.
Jon Daniels
executiveThanks, Enrique, and good morning to all of you. In Q1, CarMax Auto Finance generated $2.3 billion in originations, which produced a penetration rate of 42.7% net of 3-day payoffs, compared with 39.3% in the first quarter of last year. That penetration increase occurred even as cash credit standards were tightened in the higher risk, higher APR segment of Tier 1, and as CAF reduced its targeted Tier 3 volume starting at the close of Q4. Even with lower volume in those higher APR segments, the weighted average contract rate for new customers reached 11.1%, which was 20 basis points above Q4 and 200 basis points above the prior-year period. Tier 2 penetration for the quarter was 20.4%, higher than Q4 but below the historically high 25.2% recorded in Q1 of <<inaudible>>. Tier 3 penetration came in at 6.7%, a decline of 40 basis points versus last year. Although CAF and other lending partners have made lending standards stricter across the prior few quarters, our strong multi-lender credit platform still approved roughly 95% of credit applications in the first quarter. CAF income for the quarter totaled $137 million, down from $204 million in the same period a year earlier. This $67 million year-over-year decline was mainly caused by a $23 million rise in loss provision and a $94 million increase in interest expense, partly offset by growth in interest and fee income. Keep in mind, our interest expense felt the effect of a negative $9 million fair market value adjustment tied to our hedging strategy, versus a positive $9 million adjustment in the same period last year. In the quarter, total interest margin fell to $258 million, down $40 million from the same period a year earlier. The related margin to receivables rate of 6.1% kept declining from the 10-year peak reached in last year's first quarter, though the pace of that decline has eased relative to previous quarters, as we expected and previewed on last quarter's conference call. This slower NIM reduction reflects targeted rate increases on new originations made over the past year that effectively balance CAF penetration, finance margin and sales conversion to create the most valuable outcome for CarMax overall. The loan loss provision in Q1 of $81 million led to an ending reserve balance of $535 million, or 3.11% of ending receivables. That compares with a reserve of $507 million last quarter, which was 3.02% of receivables. The sequential 9 basis point change in the reserved receivable ratio reflects unfavorable performance within the existing portfolio as well as the uncertain macro environment. Even with this increase, the existing Tier 1 portfolio is still trending within the targeted 2% to 2.5% cumulative net credit loss range, and the recent tightening should lower the loss rate for future originations. Turning to continued improvements in our best-in-class prequalification product. In Q1, we started expanding at scale one more major lending partner inside FBS, which is our finance-based shopping platform. That brings us to lender number six, which can now deliver millions of extra tailored credit decisions within minutes for the customers we serve online. As we keep layering in improvements to the credit experience we offer online, we think the FBS platform stands today as the best in the industry, and it genuinely gives consumers power by offering straightforward access to penny perfect, multi-lender credit decisions within seconds, all with zero effect on their credit score. At this point, I'll hand the call back to Bill.
Bill Nash
executiveThanks, Jon. We've spent the last several years creating a top-tier omnichannel platform, and through it we're able to provide what we consider the industry's most customer-focused experience. Because we can integrate transactions across both digital and physical channels, we reach the biggest total addressable market out there, and that sets us apart in a meaningful way. Now that our core omni capabilities are established, we keep putting priority on initiatives that improve operating efficiencies and refine the experience for our associates and our customers; we think the actions ahead of us will let us widen our competitive moat even more and leave us strongly positioned going forward. A few first quarter examples, beyond the CAF items Jon already covered, include the following. First, in our effort to provide a seamless digital-first shopping experience, we're relying more and more on Sky, our virtual assistant that operates 24/7. Through chat functionality, Sky lets us help customers efficiently while removing work from our CEC system. In Q1, we broadened those capabilities to cover work flows tied to finance applications, vehicle transfers and appointment reservations. Since launch, we've enjoyed strong results cutting CEC work volume routed to associates, which lets us respond faster at a lower cost per transaction. We expect to introduce more Sky functionality across fiscal 2024. Second, we're in the process of rolling out Express drop-off, which lets customers who have an instant offer or store-generated appraisals move the selling process forward from home. When a customer uses it, this option gives them the chance to finish their transaction at one of our stores in less than 30 minutes, and according to our research, both customers and associates are big fans of this experience. Last, we keep modernizing our auction platform to improve things for dealers. During this quarter, we introduced an integrated check-in experience providing single sign-on across our systems and simplifying access to the information dealers depend on most when they bid on vehicles. In addition, we started proxy bidding capabilities in a limited number of markets. Dealers can use it to bid on vehicles ahead of time, so they don't need to take part live in every auction. It also opens up the chance to join multiple auctions and bid on multiple vehicles at the same time. Both of these capabilities have drawn positive feedback. We intend to bring proxy bidding to more markets and to roll out other enhancements in the quarters to come. Given our focus on better experiences and greater efficiencies, we think we're positioned well to come out of the current environment as an even stronger company. We have confidence in what the future holds for our diversified business model and believe the deliberate actions we're taking will let us deliver robust growth once the market improves. With that, we're ready to take your questions. Chelsea? Chelsea, could you remind everyone how to get into the question portal.
Brian Nagel
analystMorning, everybody. To start, I have a single question, though I'll follow up with 2 pieces to it. Could you perhaps discuss the market share trend that you saw here at the beginning of <<inaudible>>? I suppose, thus far this year? Then, secondly, like you mentioned in your script, we're noticing improving traffic when it comes to used car sales — clearly, they remain down versus a year ago, yet that's an improvement over what happened during the prior 2 quarters. When you examine what's driving that? Is it mostly things CarMax is doing? Or have you noticed a broadly strengthening environment across the sector?
Bill Nash
executiveGreat. Thanks for asking, Brian. Starting with market share, Brian, you may recall that during last quarter, based on the title data available to us, we believed we had hit the bottom during the December, January period. We now actually possess title data extending through April, and the bottom did occur in December. And even though we aren't yet expanding that on a year-over-year basis, we're happy that from January through April, we experienced decent sequential growth, and we achieved that while keeping margins strong. So we're feeling positive regarding the path we're on. And when I stack that against earlier periods when we had lost market share. Once more, we discussed that last quarter, COVID in '08, '09. I'd say the recovery here resembles the COVID era more than it does '08, '09. Regarding your second point about used car sales alone, yes, I mean, the broader used market clearly remains depressed. I do believe that although depreciation acts as somewhat of a headwind for portions of the business — take wholesale, for instance — I believe it benefits the industry overall. So having vehicles lose value during the quarter, I believe, was a positive thing; it's somewhat of an odd quarter since it initially began appreciating and then ultimately wound up declining a bit. So I believe that's I believe that's beneficial for the industry. Yet I believe there are additionally factors tied specifically to CarMax and the way we handle our inventory, the way we handle our margin, having the right cars available that are distinctive to CarMax; so I believe it's likely some mix of the two.
Craig Kennison
analystI'm trying to think ahead to when borrowers will once more have to make student loan payments. Can you give me a sense of what share of your customers also carry student debt, and whether that might meaningfully affect demand?
Bill Nash
executiveYes. Craig, that's an excellent question, and we've actually discussed it within the company, from both a sales perspective and a finance perspective. From the sales side, I think it's difficult to gauge, since people have been taking out consumer loans over longer stretches. And my guess would be that most of our buyers are past the student loan — most of our retail customers are past that stage. When you consider the CAF business, and Jon, you may see things differently here. But when you consider the CAF business, since we skew toward customers with higher credit, that likely leaves us somewhat better positioned, though I'm not sure whether you have anything else to add?
Jon Daniels
executiveAbsolutely, Bill, I'm with you on that. Sure, it's likely that our primary customer skews somewhat older. Still, whenever we examine our underwriting platform, the criteria we use for underwriting, and our models, we will consistently factor in the consumer's total outstanding debt and assess whatever factors best predict repayment of an auto loan. So all of that would be factored into the underwriting criteria we apply.
Daniel Imbro
analystI'd like to begin with the SG&A numbers, which were clearly strong this quarter. This may be a two-part question about that. First, regarding the other and maybe overhead category, I previously assumed much of it was tied to IT and e-commerce spending. Besides cutting headcount, could you discuss, Enrique, the operational adjustments you implemented that produced that gain in that line, and whether it can be sustained? And second, I believe you mentioned a onetime boost from the timing of certain CAF receivables this quarter. Could you put a figure on that so investors can better model that guidance and the SG&A line?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveAbsolutely. Thank you for asking. Let me address each part separately. To begin, I should explain what non-CAF finance receivables are. We've discussed this only briefly before. These are mainly loans that our financing partners extend to our customers, which we ultimately write off because of either title processing problems or down payment requirements. If you recall the period after COVID, we were understaffed, turnover was elevated, and DMV backlogs were significant, correct? Coming out of that, we've added staff back, trained our stores, and the DMV is processing things more quickly. That lets us catch up on these non-CAF finance receivables and perform better. Our stores are performing. Our home office is performing. And the DMVs are also performing better than before; because of that, we've recorded some favorability in that line. I did mention some favorability stemming from timing. So a portion of it comes from timing. What I would say is that this isn't timing that will reverse and hurt us later; it reflects revised estimates regarding what we expect to write off. So it's more of a hindsight adjustment, meaning it won't affect us going forward. That's point one; it was the largest source of favorability we saw this quarter compared with last year. We also recorded some favorability tied to headcount, which I referenced, connected to staffing levels. Specifically, as we reduced staff and right-sized, we gained favorability in relocation costs, as you would expect, in recruiting costs, as you would expect, and also in casual labor. Each of those falls into the other bucket. So we're seeing favorability there. We continue to face some pressure from choices made in earlier quarters regarding our technology and strategic growth. That area is still expanding somewhat within that bucket, though it's being offset quite substantially by the other items.
Sharon Zackfia
analystI'd like to ask a few things regarding Sky, since I don't remember hearing you discuss it before. So, how far do you believe you can push — I suppose, what I'd refer to as an AI technology to assist in making the CECs more efficient? And what should we consider if there might be some increase in spending tied to improving or optimizing Sky even more, if that's clear.
Bill Nash
executiveYes. No, excellent question, Sharon. To start with, regarding AI broadly, our view is optimistic on AI broadly. We have been utilizing Open AI for some time now. When we consider it, there are many chances to improve our associates' work, possibly removing the more routine tasks. Specifically about Sky, we discussed Sky, I can't recall whether we ever referred to it as Sky before, we discussed a virtual assistant. So that is what our virtual system is named, Sky. And we are quite happy. One goal we've been pursuing is truly maximizing the efficiency of our CECs and using our associates for the genuinely high-value tasks. And this quarter, with the gains we observed from Sky, we truly diverted a significant number of calls away from the CEC that Sky could manage without the caller phoning in. And the functions we included were the pre-qual, the transfer process and appointment setting. And how it operates at present, which I consider to be essentially the initial iteration, is Sky connects them with a link. We envision a future where Sky will engage in two-way interaction and might not even need to provide a link. So I believe that's an improvement. Another improvement we'll examine is simply combining IO with Sky; so I believe there's potential — still plenty of potential just within the CECs using Sky, but I also believe there's plenty of potential with AI broadly. We've applied it to train our CECs consultants, and we believe there's more possibility there; we've employed open AI to help with our vehicle reviews and customer reviews, truly enabling our content team to concentrate on more analytical work; and as I mentioned, we're developing a proof-of-concept, a knowledge proof-of-concept for our CECs so they can reach extremely detailed state information. So once more, we're enthusiastic about it.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveTo add to that point, Sky has played a significant role in making our operating model more efficient than it used to be. We've now demonstrated quarter-over-quarter cost improvements sequentially, specifically regarding the CECs and the operating model, and that is measured per retail unit. And if you look at total units — so use and wholesale — or even gross margin dollars, the progress we've made has been even more pronounced. So the effect on our model's efficiency has been quite material, and it's feeding into the SG&A gains we're experiencing.
John Murphy
analystOne more brief question from me. Could you put a dollar figure on how much SG&A benefited, in terms of timing, from the non-CAF uncollectible receivables?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveSure. In the grand scheme, I'd characterize that timing as fairly immaterial. I can provide a dollar amount, though within the overall picture it isn't particularly significant. What truly drove most of the gain was better execution — across our stores, our home office, and the DMVs too.
John Murphy
analystAll right. Then, Bill, one more thing: when you consider the same-store sales comparisons, it's hard to pinpoint precisely when things leveled off. I'd really like to hear what you think about when they might turn upward. However, should they not, could there be a chance to become more forceful regarding SG&A expenses by cutting headcount or in other places, in case we find ourselves in a climate where affordability and supply stay a fairly significant problem?
Bill Nash
executiveYeah. So, John, here's what I'd say concerning the timing of being able to turn that around. But honestly, the sole thing I can reference, which is what I've mentioned previously, is simply that when we've witnessed this before, what length of time does it typically require? And I believe if you look back at '08, '09, I think roughly 7 to 8 months passed for us before we leveled off and then began increasing it year-over-year. If you consider COVID, it fell more within the 4- to 5-month span. So once more, I feel positive about the advancement we're observing there. Now regarding the second portion of your question, the SG&A reduction, look, ideally, we've made it quite clear that we are extremely concentrated on this SG&A, so reduction; so wherever market share ends up, we will keep pushing that; but no matter what, we will keep focusing on further enhancing SG&A through items like what we've discussed with Sky and gaining greater efficiency, plus the CEC, gaining greater efficiency in the stores. There truly isn't a single area of the business where we lack efficiency opportunities that we're presently reviewing. So it makes no difference whether it's a business office, service operations, merchandising, each department has internal targets we're pursuing. So no matter the market share, we're pursuing ongoing efficiency.
John Murphy
analystThat low 70% goal — is it something you aim to hit in 1 or 2 years, or is it more of a longer-term eventual thing? How should we frame the path to it? What's the timeframe?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveWe'd like to reach it as quickly as possible. It's also going to depend on gross profit getting better too. So it matters a lot that both the underlying business and the macro environment improve, and once that happens, we'll get there; this quarter was especially strong. The first quarter, as I said, tends to be the best one for the reasons I laid out in my prepared remarks, correct? But for the remainder of the year, we do expect to keep delivering on the commitment we made for this year, which is a low single-digit gross profit so we can lever, and that's a big shift from where we've sat during the last few years, when we were investing heavily. But 70% is the next step, as we said. And beyond that, hopefully we can lever even further in the years ahead. But 70% is the next step.
Bill Nash
executiveYeah, John, I believe we discussed during the prior quarter that, well, assuming macro conditions keep getting better, we'd reach that point this year. Should that fail to occur within this year, we wouldn't view it as something taking 2 years. Our expectation would be to return to that level next year.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYes. And that's in the mid-70% range, right?
John Healy
analystOn this call, the term affordability hasn't come up, unlike the previous two or so. My sense is that what you're delivering likely shows that you folks are sort of shifting and tweaking the inventory sitting on the lots and the website so it matches what retail customers want. Could you perhaps describe how the blend in terms of vehicle age or mileage of what you're moving right now compares with a few months back? And perhaps also the longer-term view on supply, since I believe there's a bit of worry in the market regarding your capacity to obtain vehicles in that late model segment, given that they may not be around for the coming couple of years; so I'd really like to hear your perspective on what you're moving today and how you expect your inventory blend to shape up over the next year or 2?
Bill Nash
executiveYes. Great. Thanks for those questions, John; so regarding affordability, look, an affordability problem persists out there even with our average selling price having declined, it remains significantly above what it once was; and I believe on earlier calls, we've mentioned, hey, when you consider affordability, 85% has come from the vehicle price, 15% comes from the interest rates. I think we're likely closer to a 75 to 25 split, which is more about the prices declining, which naturally makes your interest rates contribute a bit more. But I think we've, knock on wood, I think we've sort of hit the peak on the rise in payments. I think we were running. If you look at just the CAF business, we were running roughly 150 monthly above pre normal times, and I think we're probably down to 130 or so. So an affordability problem absolutely remains. I think your question is excellent when you consider the mix. Our prices were down approximately $1,600; but the interesting part, while your acquisition price is down almost and that accounted for more than 50% of the price swing. There's also somewhat of an age mix element at play here too. And what I mean is if you look at the 0- to 4-year-old cars that we sold a year ago versus the 0- to 4-year-old cars that we sold this year, we had a lower percentage of those; so we dropped a few points, which means fewer of those newer cars and what you've moved toward is we've actually seen a slight uptick in the 8 plus. And so that clearly will push down your overall selling price. It's also somewhat of a tailwind for us on margins too, which showed up in the quarter. I think the final part of your question, which was the supply. We've received this question before. So what I'd say to you is this: the pace of new car sales has fallen below what it normally is, and that's not a setting we don't know how to operate in, because looking back, we've dealt with this before — during '08 and '09, the drop in new car sales was honestly steeper than what we're seeing today. When you look at the new car sales we've had more lately, we still haven't reached some of those figures you saw coming out of '08 and '09. And so we managed our way through that stretch quite successfully; and I'd also say, this time around we've got a stronger instrument available to us, since self-sufficiency is so elevated. So inventory availability isn't something that concerns us, just as it really hasn't concerned us over the last year.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveFrom the perspective of what's sitting on our lots, the one thing I'd tack on is this: when it comes to customers, more than 25% of the vehicles we have are priced below $20,000. A year ago, during quarter one, the figure sat nearer to 20%, correct? Which means today we've climbed past 25%. So where customers are concerned, we're getting the mix of inventory right so that we stay as affordable as possible.
Scot Ciccarelli
analystCould you assist us — could you assist us in grasping the exit comp rate for the quarter? And tied to that, your 95% credit approval rate. Is it in fact greater compared to a year ago? Put differently, did traffic fall more than what you observed in — or what we observed in the comp results?
Bill Nash
executiveI'll handle the comps, and I'll hand it over to Jon to address the remaining questions; so how I think about the sort of comp cadence, it remained fairly consistent across the entire quarter. I mean there was no notable variation from one month to the next. When you consider the quarter overall, that's roughly how every month essentially came in. And then Jon, I'll throw it to you regarding the credit.
Jon Daniels
executiveYeah. Regarding that 95% credit approval figure — again, this covers everyone who applies for credit, whether they begin online or right there in a store. That matches what we've said previously. And honestly, given the current climate, with partner lenders and CAF both tightening up, I believe it really demonstrates how solid our platform is that we can hold at that level. So that number makes us feel quite good.
Scot Ciccarelli
analystCould I ask something else related to that point? When credit is getting tighter across the board, what keeps approval percentages unchanged? Is the explanation simply that the pool keeps shrinking while the applicants who remain are more creditworthy? Should I read it that way?
Jon Daniels
executiveAbsolutely. That's a reasonable thing to ask. It really highlights what makes this platform distinctive. Take a scenario where approval is still granted, yet the rate attached is higher, you're being asked to put somewhat more cash down, or you get shifted from lender A over to lender B somewhere lower on the platform. Still, the upside of working with all those lenders and all those tiers is that we can continue extending at least some amount of credit to the consumer so they can at least consider buying the vehicle.
Scot Ciccarelli
analystTherefore, the terms themselves are among the things being modified under that approval. So I <<inaudible>>.
Jon Daniels
executiveYes, that's right, it does. As a result, the approval may not carry the same weight, and that reflects the tightening, rather than what you might see with a single lender platform, where the stance is simply, look, I'm unable to approve view period. We have other lenders putting other options to work.
Michael Montani
analystTo start, I wanted to ask whether you could talk about how comps have been trending so far this quarter. Also, regarding inventory levels, I believe we saw a rise versus the same period last year as the quarter began, so I just wanted to get clarity on that. Then I had one more question.
Bill Nash
executiveSure. When it comes to comp trends quarter-to-date, I'd say they resemble where we finished the quarter. On the inventory side, honestly, I was quite happy — the team has performed exceptionally well. Like I mentioned during my opening remarks, we brought the total dollar amount down while still growing our sale <<inaudible>> they're doing a fantastic job ensuring we keep moving cars through despite parts delays and similar issues. Normally, inventory comes down somewhat. And this month — this quarter, in fact — when you move from Q4 into Q1. This year, it actually rose somewhat. So we're feeling good. We're still — thinking about the traditional stores, we're somewhat lighter than our usual position, though I believe that's suitable given the kind of selling environment we have. So from an inventory perspective, I'd say we're in good shape.
Michael Montani
analystAll right. As a quick second question about the share components — I know that in the past this has tended to be a problem lasting roughly 7 to 9 months. If it keeps dragging on, though, should we expect you to spend more, whether on GPUs, or maybe on advertising or staffing? Or is your view that this isn't really needed, since industry demand dynamics are what's mainly behind it?
Bill Nash
executiveYes. Where we stand at the moment feels good to me. Naturally, you have to keep watching how the competition is doing. You have to keep watching price elasticity as well, particularly for the GPUs. Still, as I mentioned before, we're pursuing efficiencies no matter what our market share is. Once more, though, let me just repeat that the growth we've seen up to now feels good to me. And regarding what lies ahead of us, I'm positive.
Seth Basham
analystWhat I'd like to ask about is GPU, plus the stronger retail GPU results this quarter. Could you help us understand what portion came from pricing behavior in the market versus other things happening internally?
Bill Nash
executiveSure. Here's how I'd put it — when it comes to the test we run on price elasticity, there's really been little movement, and that's the reason our margins are still solid. Our self-sufficiency remains excellent. We still carry a blend of older vehicles, and those bring in more profit. Every one of those things definitely contributes. During my prepared remarks, I noticed I mentioned that since the prior quarter, we had been discussing, if you look at the whole year, $2,100 to $2,200, and now we're slightly revising that to sit between $2,200 and $2,300, which is closer to what we saw last year, particularly when you consider the second quarter; so once more, I'm pleased with our position. We'll keep tracking the macro factors, but we've captured some good efficiencies that we've managed to bring partly down to the bottom line while also continuing to pass them along to the customer. So our pricing is something we feel great about.
Seth Basham
analystAnd then, to follow up on that, do you believe you can reach $2 million in unit sales for fiscal '26, with retail GPUs sitting in that 2,100 to 2,200 normalized range?
Bill Nash
executiveYeah. Like we mentioned last quarter, those long-term ranges are what we're staying with. When the year wraps up, we'll refresh them. Over the course of 1 year, plenty can change. That said, at this moment we aren't revising that guidance.
Rajat Gupta
analystI’ve just got a few quick items. First, on that other gross profit line—the services efficiency you brought up—can you give us a bit more detail about the $25 million improvement versus a year ago, since revenue didn’t rise all that much? Is it mainly from lower headcount, or are there other places you’d point to?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYes. Thanks for asking, Rajat. Really, 2 factors caused that, right? In the service bucket, service is truly where we saw the increase compared with last year, roughly $26 million. And in fact, we were able to produce profitability in service, something we hadn’t achieved for a couple of years in the quarter here. So we’re genuinely happy with the progress we’ve made. Two items have caused that. First, we introduced cost coverage metrics—measures, sorry. As you remember, inflation hurt us for a substantial stretch of time here; and we raised rates in labor. We raised rates in parts, and that let us offset the inflationary pressures we’ve been dealing with. That’s first. Second, a very strong emphasis on efficiency—still a headwind compared with last year, particularly with sales still under pressure; but we’ve now demonstrated sequential gains in driving efficiency within the service department. So we cut labor while keeping our tech, which matters, right? But we managed to cut labor. We’re also in a somewhat more stable sales environment, which enables better scheduling. And so those are the main reasons we’ve seen that benefit. I’d expect that benefit versus last year to persist through the remainder of the year. Whether service will be profitable for the year, we’ll see, right? But what we do know is that we do expect, on a year-over-year basis, to show some fairly sizable improvements compared with last year through the rest of the year.
Rajat Gupta
analystUnderstood. That helps. Could I squeeze in a single fast question about CAF, as I haven't had much chance to ask about it yet? Regarding the improvement in provisioning, whether we look at it versus a year ago or more on a quarter-to-quarter basis — is there some piece tied to recoveries that you could describe, which may have given a sequential lift? Or perhaps you could broadly share what you observed on the recovery side, whether in terms of how often they happen or how large they are, plus any framework for thinking about provisions across the coming two quarters?
Jon Daniels
executiveSure. Yes. I'm grateful for that question, Rajat. Yes, let me address the provision on a sequential, quarter-over-quarter basis. My sense is that it's mostly a result of certain tightening moves we've made. Naturally, you set aside reserves for fresh originations made during the quarter. So when you tighten and those come with reduced loss rates, the amount of money you must allocate toward those receivables simply shrinks. Of course, we subsequently revise our assumptions on the book that already exists. So my take is that this accounts for part of what shows up there; as for your recovery rates, let me address that in broad terms. In the past, our recovery rate has fallen somewhere between 40% and 60%. Of course, given that vehicle values are extremely elevated, we benefited from recovery rates sitting in the 70% range. Compared with a year ago, we're likely lower by 13 points — 12 to 13 points, though in fact we rose on a sequential basis. So yes, my view is that the recovery rate isn't a major contributor to that. My view is that units remain the dominant factor here and, once more, I hope that clarifies why provisioning fell quarter-over-quarter.
Rajat Gupta
analystUnderstood. Only to make sure — did you say 70% regarding the recovery during the quarter?
Jon Daniels
executiveThe rate of recovery for that quarter came in at — I believe the figures were, let me check, I think once everything was tallied we'll show something like 59% to 60%. That compares with 73% to 74% in the same period a year ago, and roughly 57% in the prior quarter; so clearly lower versus a year ago, though slightly higher than the previous quarter.
Chris Pierce
analystBill, during your prepared comments you mentioned that you feel more positive regarding the macro picture since wholesale prices are arriving faster than they typically would at this point in the year, assuming I heard that correctly. Do you feel more optimistic about the used car macro backdrop getting back to a 40 million unit figure sooner than you'd previously expected, given what you're observing in the market? I just wanted a sense of your thinking on the larger picture.
Bill Nash
executiveYes. No, I don't — my view is that it's too soon to reach that conclusion. Regarding my remarks on depreciation, what I believe we're witnessing now is depreciation of the sort you'd ordinarily encounter. If you look back at the old normal — the normalized environment, which is difficult to recall from that period, generally you'd observe depreciation at this point in the year heading into the fall. So I think that's what we're seeing in — and once more, though it may act as somewhat of a headwind for the wholesale business, on the whole I believe it benefits the industry since it simply makes those vehicles more affordable, particularly for a consumer dealing with budget pressure; so I think it remains a bit too soon to claim we'll return to 40 million immediately, though I think the further prices decline, the better that is for the industry.
Chris Pierce
analystAll right. Now regarding used GPU — someone brought up how weak new car sales cause weak used car sales, plus you're selling older models, assuming I got that correct. If you keep selling vehicles that are older for several years ahead, does that create a multiyear tailwind for used GPU? I realize you lifted that figure to 2,200 to 2,300, and what we just witnessed landed higher, at 2,361. So I'm wondering whether there's room for that figure to rise even if you're selling a greater number of aged vehicles than you typically would before?
Bill Nash
executiveYes. No, I wouldn't view it as additional upside. As Enrique mentioned during his remarks and in the script, from a margin perspective the first quarter tends to be your best quarter. Inventory turns, fewer markdowns, things like that. So although a mix with older vehicles certainly benefits us on margin. We've watched this unfold across the last year, since a larger share of what we've sold has been older vehicles. And honestly, the customer is the one deciding that. So should the customer keep wanting older vehicles, we'll ensure we've got plenty of such inventory available. Should pricing return to normal, after some time, and suddenly your later model vehicles become more affordable, particularly relative to new cars, then certain consumers might move in that direction. That, I believe, is what's great about the business models we can place on the lot, whatever customers seek; and we're able to go older and we're able to go newer, it just comes down to what the customer seeks.
David Whiston
analystDavid, thanks for asking. Regarding EVs, given the massive jump in demand on the new side, I'm wondering whether you're also observing that on the used side, or whether affordability concerns are suppressing EV interest among pre-owned shoppers?
Bill Nash
executiveYeah, David, I appreciate the question. When you look at CarMax overall and the volume of EVs we move, it represents a very tiny share. I believe during the prior quarter, for pure EVs specifically, the figure was about 1%, perhaps slightly higher. That percentage has edged up somewhat. Naturally, there simply haven't been many EVs available in the market for pre-owned purchase. Of course, every automaker is rolling out additional EV models. You raise a valid point about affordability — I agree they need to get somewhat more affordable for the typical buyer. That said, we are the used vehicle retailer. Our aim is to be the biggest retailer of pre-owned EVs, so we're getting ready for that. Although it's only a minor portion of our volume today, we expect it to expand in the future. That's why we're already taking action to ensure we're ready.
David Whiston
analystAll right, and one more item regarding FBS. Is it possible that down the road, FBS borrowers' loans could be included in a CAFs securitization? Or is it required that they remain with a lending partner from outside?
Jon Daniels
executiveNo. Among the 6 lenders presently active on FBS, CAF is 1. And to reiterate, that's the online shopping tool, so yes, without question, every lender — each one of those lenders is taking part in CAF loans — we will without question underwrite individuals within FBS, and it will move through our usual funding channels.
Bill Nash
executiveCorrect, David. When we talk about FBS, we mean every one of the lending partners involved. In the marketplace, this offering stands apart, since it includes not just CAF but also those extra lending partners who've been with our company for a very long time. Ultimately, for consumers—particularly those who care a lot about what they pay each month—that's the thing that secures them the most favorable rate.
David Whiston
analystWas there a figure you shared for FBS penetration?
Bill Nash
executiveAre you asking, in terms of the number of consumers who are using FBS?
Jon Daniels
executiveYeah, I'd put it this way: among those who submit credit applications, more than 80% begin on the web, using our online platform.
Bill Nash
executiveAbsolutely, and an FBS experience is available to anyone. The only variable is the manner in which they prefer to shop.
Bill Nash
executiveOkay, thanks a lot. So, I appreciate everyone taking the time to be with us, for your questions, and for your backing. Like we always do, I'd like to express gratitude to our associates for everything they contribute, looking after one another as well as the shoppers. They truly set us apart. I'd also like to make sure everyone participating in this call knows that our 2023 responsibility report came out not long ago, and I'd urge all of you to give it a listen. Let me actually read it — that's tuning in today. It offers some excellent news about several important efforts, among them those tied to climate, and the real difference we're making for communities. So once more, the principles we put into practice daily make us proud, and I believe we're in a strong spot to generate lasting, sustainable worth for every one of our shareholders. So once again, I'm grateful for your time today, and we'll be speaking again in 3 months.
Operator
operatorAppreciation to everyone, men and women; that brings FY '24 Q1 CarMax Earnings Release Conference Call to a close. You're free to hang up at this point.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete CarMax, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to CarMax, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in CarMax, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.