CarMax, Inc. (KMX) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

September 28, 2023

New York Stock Exchange US Consumer Discretionary Specialty Retail earnings 54 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

David Lowenstein

executive
#1

Thanks, Chelsea. Hello, everyone, and good morning. We appreciate you being on the call for our second quarter fiscal 2024 earnings conference. Joining me are Bill Nash, who serves as our President and CEO; Enrique Mayor-Mora, our Executive Vice President and CFO; and Jon Daniels, our Senior Vice President of CarMax Auto Finance Operations. I want to remind you that anything we say today that isn't a statement of historical fact — including remarks about future business plans, prospects, and financial performance — constitutes a forward-looking statement made under the Safe Harbor provisions of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Such statements rest on what we currently know, expect, and assume, and they carry substantial risks and uncertainties that might cause actual results to differ materially from what we anticipate. When we provide projections and other forward-looking statements, we disclaim any intent or obligation to update them. To learn more about important facts that could impact these expectations, please refer to our Form 8-K filed with the SEC this morning, as well as our Annual Report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended February 28, 2023, which was previously filed with the SEC. If any follow-up questions come up after the call, don't hesitate to reach our Investor Relations Department at 804 to 747 to 0422, extension 7865. Finally, thank you ahead of time for limiting yourself to one question and then rejoining the queue for additional follow-ups. Bill?

Bill Nash

executive
#2

Thank you, David, and good morning to all of you for being with us. Even though the results from our second quarter mostly mirror the very same broad pressures we mentioned throughout the prior twelve months, we keep witnessing quarter-over-quarter gains throughout our operations. The intentional actions we're taking to manage the things within our control, we believe, are helping the business right now and simultaneously setting us up nicely for what lies ahead. During this quarter, we posted robust retail GPU; we lowered SG&A again compared with a year earlier; we kept used sellable inventory units roughly flat versus the first quarter, even as total inventory dollars fell 18% against the prior year, divided about equally between fewer units and lower acquisition costs. We generated solid wholesale GPU in spite of facing steep depreciation, and we steadied CAF's net interest margins while holding on to penetration. In the second quarter of FY '24, our diversified business model produced total sales of $7.1 billion, a 13% drop versus the prior year, caused by reduced retail and wholesale volume along with prices. Within our retail business, although total unit sales fell 7.4% and used unit comps dropped 9%, we still delivered quarter-over-quarter gains. On top of that, comp sales got better month by month through the second quarter. Average selling price fell roughly $1200 per unit, or 4%, compared with a year ago. Retail gross profit per used unit came in at $2,251, close to the record high of $2,282 set in last year's second quarter. Our expectation remains that this year's full year per unit margin will resemble last year's. As we always do, we'll keep testing price elasticity and watching the competitive landscape. Wholesale unit sales dropped 11.2% against the second quarter of last year. Just like used unit sales, this mirrors ongoing sequential gains versus the prior year's second half and this year's first quarter. Average selling price fell roughly $1,300 per unit, or 12%, versus a year ago. Wholesale gross profit per unit reached $963, higher than $881 a year earlier. We managed this even while facing steep depreciation concentrated mainly in June and July. We acquired roughly 292,000 vehicles from consumers and dealers in the quarter, a 15% decline from last year, as we tweaked offers to account for the steep depreciation we're observing in the marketplace. Out of those vehicles, we bought approximately 273,000 from consumers during the quarter, and a bit more than half of those buyers came via our online instant appraisal experience. Consequently, our self-sufficiency stayed above 70% for the quarter. With support from the Edmunds sales team, we obtained the remaining roughly 19,000 vehicles via dealers, a 5% decrease from last year; regarding our second quarter online metrics, about 14% of retail unit sales happened online, an increase from 11% last year. Roughly 55% of retail unit sales were omni sales this quarter, up from 53% the prior year. Almost every one of our second quarter wholesale auctions in sales, which accounts for 19% of total revenue, stayed virtual and count as online transactions. Total revenue generated from online transactions came to approximately 31%, a slight rise from 30% last year. CarMax Auto Finance, which we call CAF, posted $135 million in income. That compares with $183 million in the prior-year quarter, so it's lower. In a few minutes, Jon is going to walk through customer financing, the loan loss provision, and cash contributions in greater depth. Right now, I want to hand things over to Enrique so he can share additional details about how we performed financially in the second quarter. Enrique?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#3

Thanks, Bill, and good morning, everyone. As Bill mentioned, we achieved yet another quarter of sequential gains in our year-over-year results across several important financial measures, such as unit sales, wholesale margins, gross profit, SG&A, and EPS. For the second quarter, net earnings per diluted share came to $0.75, compared with $0.79 in the same period last year. Gross profit in total was $697 million, a 5% decline from the second quarter of last year. Used retail margin fell 9%, to $452 million, due to lower volume at roughly the same per unit margins. Wholesale vehicle margin dropped 3%, to $137 million, with a volume decrease partly offset by stronger per unit margin results. Other gross profit came in at $108 million, up 6% versus Q2 of last year. The main driver was service, which rose $20 million year over year, even though we posted a $14 million loss in the quarter. During our previous two earnings calls, we noted that FY '24 should bring stronger service results compared with a year earlier, thanks to the efficiency measures and cost coverage actions we've taken. The degree of improvement will depend on how sales perform, since service carries a leveraged deleveraged profile. Partially offsetting the service gain were declines in extended protection plan, or EPP, revenues along with third party finance fees. EPP revenue was down $8 million, driven primarily by reduced sales, and to a lesser degree by somewhat lower penetration rates — partly the result of recent price increases designed to offset cost pressures our third party providers are facing; favorable year-over-year reserve adjustments provided a partial offset to these factors. Third party finance fees came in $4 million lower than last year's second quarter, because of reduced volume in Tier 2, where we earn a fee; turning to SG&A, second quarter expenses totaled $586 million, a 12% decrease versus the prior year's quarter, as we continue to capture the benefits of our cost management efforts. We also benefited to a smaller extent from some favorable timing during the quarter. Selling, general and administrative expenses came in at 84% of gross profit, which represents 6.3 points of leverage relative to the second quarter a year ago. Several things drove the decline in SG&A dollars year over year. To start, other overhead fell by $41 million. That decrease reflected a number of drivers, including ongoing favorability in non-CAF uncollectible receivables, favorable costs associated with reduced staffing levels, and reduced spending on our technology platforms and strategic initiatives, which this quarter included a timing benefit. We also recorded two smaller items during the quarter that largely canceled each other out. Those were extra settlement dollars stemming from the same class action lawsuit we mentioned in the first quarter, which were offset by unfavorable self-insured losses related to multiple hailstorm events. Next, compensation and benefits overall decreased by $28 million, once you set aside a $7 million increase in share based compensation; the primary driver of that decline was our continued focus on achieving efficiency gains and aligning store and CEC staffing with sales levels. Moving on, we reduced advertising spend by $17 million. That reduction stemmed from a lower per unit spend compared to last year's peak per unit spend, along with decreased volume and timing shifts. During our fourth quarter call, we noted that as we enter the back half of FY '24, the year-over-year benefits from our cost management efforts will have largely annualized; despite that, we remain disciplined about our spending. Another factor we see affecting the second half of fiscal 2024 is when our marketing and technology investments land. When it comes to marketing, our expectation for the entire year remains that spending per unit will come in around what it was in fiscal 2023. That means the per-unit figure for the latter half of fiscal 2024 is going to exceed what we saw in the first half. Turning to technology, close to $10 million of the favorability versus last year that we've recorded so far, along with other overhead, is set to hit in the back half of fiscal 2024. Our commitment to running our cost structure efficiently is unchanged. The results we posted for the first six months leave us well positioned to hit our target of low single digit gross profit growth, which allows us to leverage SG&A across the entire year, and that holds true even if you strip out the gains from legal settlements reached this year. Turning to capital structure: we did halt buying back our common stocks in the third quarter of fiscal 2023, but our plan is to begin the share repurchase program again in the current quarter. We anticipate a modest pace at the outset, one that falls short of the average quarterly paces we had before the pause. We aim to keep our net leverage at sensible levels so we stay financially flexible and can tap capital markets efficiently for both CAF and CarMax overall, while still giving capital back to shareholders. When the quarter closed, we had $2.45 billion left under our repurchase authorization. At this point, I'll hand things over to Jon.

Jon Daniels

executive
#4

Thank you, Enrique, and good morning, everyone. In Q2, CarMax Auto Finance wrote $2.2 billion, which produced a penetration rate of 42.8% after accounting for three-day payoffs — matching Q1 and higher than the 41.2% we saw in the same quarter a year ago. During the period, CAF pulled back even more inside Tier 3 and currently holds just a small volume there; even so, we modestly raised our commitment in Tier 2 so we can keep gaining knowledge and pursue additional credit segments that we expect to offer opportunity down the road. New customers were charged a weighted average contract rate of 11.1%, which is 170 basis points above the prior-year period and consistent with Q1. Tier 2 penetration came in at 18.1% for the quarter, since a mix of earlier lender tightening and hesitant consumers — particularly in lower credit tiers — produced most of the decline relative to the 21.6% penetration seen a year ago. Tier 3 made up 6.4% of sales versus 6% a year ago, as lenders picked up a slight benefit from CAF and Tier 2 pulling back. CAF income reached $135 million for the quarter, lower than the $183 million posted in the same period last year. That $48 million decline versus a year ago comes from a $90 million rise in interest expense, partly offset by $60 million of growth in interest and fee income plus a $14 million increase in loss provision. Keep in mind our interest expense felt the effect of a negative $1.2 million fair market value adjustment tied to our hedging strategy, compared with a positive $9.4 million adjustment in the same period a year earlier. During the quarter, total interest margin across the entire portfolio fell to $265 million, which is $30 million below the prior-year period. Even so, the related margin to receivables rate of 6.1% has flattened out as we anticipated and matches Q1. I take pride in how our teams keep managing finance margin, CAF penetration, and sales conversion effectively for the benefit of CarMax overall. The Q2 loan loss provision of $90 million leaves an ending reserve balance of $538 million, equal to 3.08% of ending receivables. That compares with a reserve of $535 million in the prior quarter, which represented 3.11% of receivables. The modest drop in the reserve to receivables rate stems from portfolio tightening, partly offset by the small added investment in the Tier 2 business and revisions to loss expectations inside the existing portfolio. We expect the tightening to help lower the reserve required in the future, though we will keep seeking chances to capture long-term profitability for CarMax while holding to a targeted Tier 1 cumulative net credit loss rate of 2% to 2.5%. At this point I'll hand the call back to Bill.

Bill Nash

executive
#5

Thanks, Jon and Enrique. As I noted when the call began, we feel the actions we're taking to address the present climate are helping our business right now while putting us in a strong position over the longer term. Our ongoing priority will be to provide what we consider the industry's most customer-focused experience, as we put emphasis on efforts that generate operational efficiencies and make our omni channel experience quicker, easier and more fluid for both our associates and our customers. A few illustrations from Q2 include, for online, we are introducing several new features that improve our digital shopping experience along with our customer experience centers, or CECs. A new order processing system has been launched. Orders placed through this new system link automatically to customers' online accounts and to our progression tracker. That tool walks customers through every stage of the car buying journey and delivers a smoother experience for those who like to combine self-progression with help from associates. Testing of this system has started in our stores, which will make this functionality available to every one of our customers, no matter where they begin their buying journey. We're also broadening what Sky, our 24/7 virtual assistant, can do. As you may remember, Sky lets us officially help customers through automated chat functionality while removing work from our CEC system. Beyond handling workflows tied to finance applications, vehicle transfers and appointment reservations, Sky can now spot customers who have an appraisal instant offer. Sky assists those customers in finishing the next steps for their trade in. In the past, associates would need to make contact to offer additional support. We've been happy with how our customers have adopted Sky as they move along their shopping journey. When it comes to our stores, we keep using data automation to cut costs and boost transaction speed and accuracy. An integrated payoff service has been deployed in our business office, letting associates get automated payoff amounts for more than 40% of the lenders holding titles for the cars we purchase from consumers. Often, this service also lets us get titles sooner by speeding up payoffs. On the auctions side, we keep testing platform improvements by upgrading the information we give dealers, which lets them place better-informed bids. As an example, we started a test using technology from our investment and partnership with UBI <<inaudible>> that supplies more detailed information about tire conditions, covering brand, speed, size and tread depth for each tire. Dealer response to this offering has been favorable and we intend to introduce other enhancements in the quarters ahead. Before we move to Q&A, I'd like to acknowledge two major milestones in the company's history. To start, in June we marked 2 years since the gifted Edmunds team members joined us, and we're thrilled about the value we've generated jointly up to now as we keep expanding our programs for vehicle and customer acquisition. As an illustration, which I've noted before, we leaned on the Edmunds sales force to enroll and assist dealers with our Max software offering, and that has let us broaden our market-leading standing as a purchaser of cars. More recently, we rolled out an appraisal instrument for dealer sites that generates immediate offers rooted in CarMax's algorithm, which customers can redeem through Max offer. Dealers using this service have given us favorable responses, and we're happy with the early results.

Recurrent

executive
#6

Additionally, we've introduced personalized range maps on edmunds.com, which let shoppers figure out the distance they can travel on one charge, according to the zip code for their particular route. Plus, third, we've created a guide that assists customers in assessing possible tax credits and incentives for EVs; it includes every federal and state EV program available, along with thousands of incentive offers from local utilities and municipalities nationwide, and there are more on the way. Also this month, we're marking CarMax's 30th anniversary. I'd like to thank and congratulate each of our associates for their efforts. They're what sets us apart, and they're essential to our success. Few companies get the chance to transform an industry two times; we take pride in having reshaped the used car industry by promoting integrity, honesty and transparency in each interaction. We're eager to transform the industry once more by providing a uniquely tailored car buying experience that lets customers do as much or as little online and in stores as they wish; we have faith in the future of our diversified business model and think the intentional actions we're taking now will fuel growth in the years to come; with that, we're ready to take your questions. Chelsea?

Craig Kennison

analyst
#7

Yes, thank you. My question is about trade-in cycles. As rates rise, are you noticing longer trade-in cycles among your customers, who may be hesitant to abandon the lower rates they locked in during the pandemic?

Bill Nash

executive
#8

Yes, Craig, good morning. What we're observing is that some customers definitely are—whether due to affordability concerns that affect their monthly payment, customers holding off—which addresses your question: are trade-in cycles somewhat longer? Yes, I'd say the trade-in cycle has stretched out a bit. When it comes to putting a figure on this, there's no precise number I can offer you. Still, we definitely observe visits arriving at the funnel's upper stage, where interest exists, and then, once again, they keep dropping away at the moment of conversion—right when individuals begin to view what they'd owe each month. That pattern holds particularly strongly among customers with lower credit scores.

Craig Kennison

analyst
#9

Thank you.

Bill Nash

executive
#10

Sure.

Brian Nagel

analyst
#11

Hey, guys. Good morning.

Bill Nash

executive
#12

Good morning.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#13

Good morning.

Jon Daniels

executive
#14

Good morning.

Brian Nagel

analyst
#15

I've got two things I want to ask, and I'll combine them. To start, on the buyback, could you discuss a bit the reasoning behind resuming it now, and then perhaps clarify what you meant by a modest start — how do you anticipate beginning at a modest level? Then my other question relates to demand: as you pointed out in your remarks, we've observed sequential improvement in your used car unit comps, and while they remain negative, they're better than before. The comparison is becoming easier based on the data — are you noticing anything indicating that in certain pockets you're genuinely seeing demand strengthen, or possibly some gains from what you've done to merchandise older, lower priced vehicles better? Thanks.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#16

Yes, I'll take the first question. A key part of our capital allocation strategy has involved giving capital back to shareholders. What we aim for with that strategy is essentially to balance putting money into the business, making sure our capital structure is where we want it, and then giving capital back to shareholders. Over the last few quarters, the sequential improvement in our performance has put us in a position to restart, even if only at a modest pace. By modest, I mean an initial amount that's below our average from the quarterly pace before the pause, which was roughly $150 million per quarter. So at first we'll start at approximately $50 million per quarter, give or take; that's a quarterly figure that, annualized, would approximately offset annual dilution. So it might be somewhat heavy, it might be somewhat light relative to our goal, but that's what we're targeting initially.

Bill Nash

executive
#17

Yeah, and Brian, regarding the latter portion of what you asked, I'll circle back to something I mentioned to Craig; at the top of the funnel we're noticing solid traffic from shoppers. The issue arises at the point of truly handling those monthly payments — that's where things drop off. As for what you specifically raised, demand is still elevated for somewhat older vehicles. Looking at our quarterly sales, when I consider autos beyond 6 years in age and 60,000 miles, that particular segment's numbers rose sequentially, both quarter-over-quarter and definitely year-over-year; so that demand remains. And I believe market data would show you that for vehicles above 10 years old, that portion of the market is in fact doing slightly better right now than the zero to 10 group.

Brian Nagel

analyst
#18

That's quite useful. Thanks, I'm grateful.

Bill Nash

executive
#19

Thanks, Brian.

Seth Basham

analyst
#20

Much appreciated, and good morning. I'd like to ask about how competition is shaping up. Given that demand has been moving toward those older vehicles, plus the possible knock-on effects from the UAW strikes, what's your read on where things are headed across the coming six months or so?

Bill Nash

executive
#21

Morning to you, Seth. On the UAW strikes specifically, my sense is that we can't yet say with any certainty what the exact price impact will turn out to be. Naturally, we're watching things closely so we can spot how vehicle supply pricing and parts get affected further down the line, and much of that hinges on the strike's duration. This certainly isn't our first time dealing with a challenge of this kind, and having been through cycles like this before and managed to steer our way through them strikes me as one of our strengths, and I see no reason that would change now. Turning to competition, as I said, consumers are under pressure at the moment, and we'll keep watching and keep offering vehicles that are somewhat older. Remember that a big portion of the zero to 10 year old cars simply don't meet our parameters all that well. Our technicians are excellent, and regardless of how skilled they are and how much money we invest in them, those cars just can't qualify as a CarMax car, so quality is not something we'll compromise on. Even so, we'll keep rolling out vehicles that fit our quality standards and that customers are seeking as well.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#22

On the affordability side too, more than 25% of what we have in stock carries a price tag below $20,000. So when it comes to reaching that affordability point, it's definitely something we're focused on.

Seth Basham

analyst
#23

As a second question, regarding how well you can obtain recent-model cars — those still make up most of what you sell — is it getting harder, or do you think that will shift down the road?

Bill Nash

executive
#24

No, that's not happening anymore. Actually, during this quarter, versus the one before it, our sales in the 0 to 4 bracket did tick upward somewhat; plus, as I mentioned, the reality that we're more than 70% self-sufficient, and that figure excludes whatever comes to us via our Max offer — and Max offer includes a solid assortment of retail vehicles too. So I genuinely haven't noticed much movement on that front, and like I said, we've cycled through periods when late-model car scarcity was even more severe than what we face today.

Seth Basham

analyst
#25

Thank you.

Bill Nash

executive
#26

Thank you, Seth.

John Healy

analyst
#27

John, thanks for that. I'd like to ask something that builds on what you said, Bill, regarding the conversion cycle. Once that first letdown happens — the customer realizes the vehicle is out of reach — what follows? Do you observe them returning after roughly 14 days? Is your sense that they're heading into the private market? Or are they simply staying on the sidelines? I'm aware that your salespeople don't give up easily, so it would be helpful to hear your perspective on what takes place once they run into that unexpected affordability obstacle.

Bill Nash

executive
#28

Bill: Sure, John, that's an excellent question. If I simply consider web traffic and treat it as a rough indicator, across the quarter we were likely averaging somewhere around 37 million hits, a figure that's climbed considerably compared with the same period a year earlier, and has even risen within the quarter itself — by roughly 3 million, somewhere between 2 million and 3 million hits — which suggests to me that, look, plenty of people are out there showing interest and doing their window shopping, and a portion of those are certainly repeat visitors. Those aren't unique visits. As for where they end up going, look, my view is that many of them — unless their car has simply stopped running — are merely putting the purchase off. For those who genuinely can't put it off, I definitely believe a number of them are stepping down to a lower tier of vehicle purely so they can manage the monthly payments and keep reliable transportation.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#29

Right, and let me add something to that, John. In my view, that's among the genuine strengths of our finance offering. You're able to submit an application online with ease, and once you've supplied responses for each of the vehicles, you can once again shift direction quite simply and locate an option that fits your budget, then sort and filter as needed. So I'd say that's something we're truly thrilled to be able to make available to our customer.

Bill Nash

executive
#30

And also, when you’ve got that many lenders on the platform essentially vying for the customers, it ends up giving them the most favorable interest rate, which plays a major role in what the monthly payment comes out to.

John Healy

analyst
#31

Great. Thanks guys.

Bill Nash

executive
#32

Thanks, John.

Scot Ciccarelli

analyst
#33

Thanks. Morning, everyone. So Bill, I believe during this call you mentioned that same-store sales got better month over month, though if I recall correctly, the comparisons also became less difficult. Given that, how would the monthly progression look when measured on a two or three-year stacked basis? And tied to that, I realize you don't provide guidance and haven't done so for quite a while, but is there any reason to think comps couldn't go positive in the second half, simply given where trends and comparisons stand right now?

Bill Nash

executive
#34

Yeah, Scot, taking the quarter on its own, I believe on the prior call I discussed how we entered the period relative to how the previous quarter had finished on average. And as I mentioned during this call, we did record gains in each month of the quarter, and September thus far looks quite comparable, perhaps slightly better than where August landed. We won't offer guidance for the remainder of the year, but like you said, because of how last year went, the comps do become somewhat less challenging.

Scot Ciccarelli

analyst
#35

All right. So if I were to dissect 2Q, you're clearly not saying anything about 3Q, if I was examining stacks, is there a method to sort of view it on a two or three-year stack and assist us in grasping whether things got better on that basis?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#36

Well, the two-year stack for the second quarter came in stronger than the first quarter. So I think regarding intra quarter, we attempt not to discuss excessively the specifics of month-to-month, particularly when looking across a year, but I would say to you that second quarter, on a two-year basis, better than the first quarter, just as Bill said.

Scot Ciccarelli

analyst
#37

All right, I'll handle whatever's left outside this call. Appreciate it, everyone.

Bill Nash

executive
#38

Thanks.

Sharon Zackfia

analyst
#39

Morning, and sorry in case you already covered this — my phone dropped the call, so I had to dial back in. Clearly, though, you're restarting the buyback. So where do things stand right now regarding new store openings? I'm not sure whether you even restated the target for this year, and I recall you'd sort of kept the possibility on the table of perhaps speeding up next year. So any thinking on that, or has the approach maybe shifted toward capturing additional sales from current locations instead of expanding the footprint in a significant way?

Bill Nash

executive
#40

Morning, Sharon. Right, as far as where we stand today, nothing we've previously stated has shifted; we'll open a handful of additional locations during this year, bringing the count to 5 for the year, along with that single standalone production site in the Atlanta market we've mentioned. As for precisely how many locations we'll add next year, we haven't announced that figure yet; we'll address it further along in the year, likely during Q4, and share it with you then.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#41

Right, and that's just how we normally do things. Each year we give that update, and we include our CapEx guidance for the year with it.

Sharon Zackfia

analyst
#42

Okay, thanks.

Bill Nash

executive
#43

Thanks, Sharon.

Michael Montani

analyst
#44

Thanks for taking my question. I wanted to ask about the credit side of things — can you give us an update on how available credit is right now? And if some of the credit behavior has been a bit less favorable, how should we think about provisioning? With the current backdrop, is roughly $90 million the right figure for the time being? Any insight you can offer would be appreciated.

Jon Daniels

executive
#45

Sure. Yes, I'll address them one at a time. When it comes to credit availability at CarMax, I think having so many lenders is part of what makes that work. Our customers still enjoy excellent credit availability. Obviously, it comes as no shock within this industry that lenders constantly aim to strengthen their portfolios, so they have made necessary adjustments to tighten standards. The majority of the tightening we observed came from our partners, if you will, likely during the latter portion of the prior calendar year. Throughout this year, CAF has also tightened, which I believe simply reflects normal lending practices you will see at present. Still, I think we offer outstanding credit access — certainly within the high 90% range from a mid to over, and roughly a 95% approval rate for customers upon application. And once more, my view is that we let them look at other cars they could choose. As for how CAF did overall during the quarter specifically, we keep reviewing the whole portfolio. I'll frame this through our Tier 1 operations. Every asset gets securitized, and each month we disclose how those deals are doing. When you examine those earlier vintages — the ones you'd stack up against more recent ones, meaning 2017, 2018, 2019, and even 2020 — the losses came in extraordinarily low, far under the 2% to 2.5% band where things are heading today. That's for every reason we've already mentioned: people had access to cash, there was government stimulus, and so on, so those deals genuinely beat expectations. As for what the newer vintages are showing us right now, it's really quite in line with what we'd expect; it's simply a return to the more typical levels this industry has historically experienced on the lending side. So we are — we had been expecting the 2021 to 2022 deals to revert to that 2% to 2.5% range. With the larger monthly obligations customers are facing right now, my sense is that we've moved toward the upper end of that band, and that's the reason behind the tightening actions we've taken. Over the past year or so, we've applied those measures partly in Tier 3, and in certain pockets of Tier 1 where we identified chances to scale back. Our goal is to stay comfortably inside the 2% to 2.5% range, and I believe we've managed that well. So when you look ahead at the provision, it really comes down to a mix of the various factors I mentioned during the prepared remarks. As for the book we already hold — and yes, I believe we've got a solid grasp of it — my expectation is that it will perform within a range of 2% to 2.5%, and that's an area where we've performed well. Then there are the fresh originations, and because of the tightening those will definitely land lower; we've eased off somewhat when it comes to Tier 3. That represents only a modest slice of what we do, and regarding Tier 2, that segment has us enthusiastic and we perceive a strong opportunity there. Bringing all of that together, our reserve, I'd say, tells its own story. We've moved from 311 down to 308. It strikes me as fairly steady; our sense is that we're reserved appropriately, and how the consumer behaves remains to be seen, though at this moment I'd say our position is a favorable one.

Michael Montani

analyst
#46

Thanks.

John Murphy

analyst
#47

Morning, everyone. I've got a question for Bill. When you hit stretches of sharp depreciation, the kind you're describing, and we've witnessed that in used car pricing, usually more supply comes along with it, and that pushes same-store sales up. So I'm wondering what you're seeing in the market today regarding how many vehicles are available and how they're flowing, perhaps in that 0 to 6 year old range, which is the sweet spot, and then perhaps in the 6 to 10 year old range, which over time is becoming a bigger target for you?

Bill Nash

executive
#48

Yes, morning, John. When I reflect — think back on the quarter's depreciation, as I mentioned, June and July brought steep depreciation, and frankly it began in May. So looking at May, June and July, you'd have seen roughly $3,000 of depreciation, and that is absolutely steep. The largest effect on us clearly lands more on the buying side, since we'll make adjustments to match, and customers always believe their cars are worth more, so it hits the buys early until the rest of the market catches up. So from a purchasing perspective, it's a short-term headwind. But once more, I believe the team did an outstanding job not just holding retail margins, but wholesale margins too, which we haven't discussed since versus last year they rose even amid this steep environment. On availability, look, if you must depend on outside sources, there's simply, it's a, supply is constrained. And thinking back over at least my time here at CarMax, fewer vehicles come available via third party auctions, and that's been the case for some time. So, and I don't see that shifting much in the near-term, which is also why we're delighted our self-sufficiency is so high and we keep hunting for ways to keep sourcing inventory, retail or wholesale, whatever avenue we can beyond those sources.

John Murphy

analyst
#49

And then perhaps as a quick follow-up, do you figure you might ever manage to push well past that 70% self-sufficiency level where you sit today, which is honestly quite impressive as a starting point, but what I'm asking is, could there be additional paths, perhaps via Edmunds or through some other route, to raise it substantially?

Bill Nash

executive
#50

Yeah, listen, we could reach 100% as soon as tomorrow. Everything hinges on what gets installed on the vehicles. My guess is, and I'll say it this way, we most likely would never achieve 100% self-sufficiency, since you'll always need small pockets of inventory that you'll want to top off or what have you. That said, once more, what we're aiming for is to push it as much as — push it as high as we can. It has remained fairly consistent around that 70-ish mark, within that band, and we feel good about that. And once more, the crucial point here, I believe, is that it applies not just to retail cars, since we'll purchase every wholesale car too, so that's absolutely where our attention is.

John Murphy

analyst
#51

Fine, that works. Sounds good. I really appreciate it.

Bill Nash

executive
#52

John, thanks to you.

Chris Bottiglieri

analyst
#53

Hello, and thank you for fielding my question. I'm hoping you can provide more detail regarding compensation expense. I understand you mentioned that you're up against prior cost reductions, yet it appears those compensation-related savings have increased step by step every quarter. So what I'm asking is this: when you consider the full-year CAGR, which has improved notably relative to units—especially Q2 against Q1—are you still cutting staff, and if unit trends hold to typical seasonality going forward, what would happen with compensation? Would it follow the usual seasonal pattern, or come in above or below that norm?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#54

Thanks for asking, Chris. Yes, regarding compensation right now, as I noted during our prepared remarks, we've essentially reached the anniversary point for the gains from several of the more powerful actions we implemented. So as you think about compensation, I'd view the second half of the year as facing one or more clients under pressure, so to speak, compared with how things stood across the last couple of quarters. In other words, those actions no longer give us the same lift. Meanwhile, around this time each year we work through the decision process concerning staffing for tax season, correct? And based on what we anticipate for tax season, we begin increasing our associate-level ranks as well; therefore, I do expect compensation to be among the line items going forward that faces somewhat more pressure compared with how it's been across the last few quarters.

Jon Daniels

executive
#55

Correct, Chris, and to put some figures behind that, when you compare our headcount to 12 months ago, across the whole company we've got roughly 3,000 fewer associates, and that lines up pretty well with how the first quarter looked too; so essentially, so long as we hold staffing at the level where we believe sales need to be, as Enrique mentioned, then it'll be — during the back half of the year it's just going to be you, you won't really see much of a pickup there.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#56

Right, and our belief is that we've got the right amount of people in place. So the cost management steps we carried out — at this stage those have worked out, and we're mostly at the right staffing levels, properly staffed, so…

Jon Daniels

executive
#57

Right, the only additional point — and Enrique mentioned this earlier so everyone should bear it in mind — is that as we move through the second half of the year, that period is typically when, from a seasonal perspective, we begin planning for next year's tax season and staffing up for it, which usually calls for somewhat more personnel. So we'll be keeping an eye on that throughout the latter half.

Chris Bottiglieri

analyst
#58

Understood. That's clear. Then, turning briefly to vehicle acquisitions, I believe you flagged that period — it appeared to be July along with August when prices hit their lowest point, or rather, pardon me, June and July, since pricing somewhat settled during September and, to a smaller degree, August — have you observed whether you're purchasing vehicles with greater regularity or at a higher rate, with improved conversion coming from customers, and has that pattern kept up its momentum?

Bill Nash

executive
#59

Right, so June and July represented the low point. August, in fact, came in slightly higher, and after that September <<inaudible>> figures are likely about level or marginally improved when viewed through depreciation, or rather appreciation, terms. Thus I'd describe August and September as roughly comparable, though it marked a turnaround from the sharp depreciation. And looking ahead toward the remaining portion of the year, my expectation is that we'll likely witness — this assumes nothing else shifts on the macro side, and clearly many variables exist, particularly once you factor in the strike, yet setting that aside — I'd anticipate that we'd keep experiencing what is likely a more typical seasonal depreciation pattern, unless some fresh development emerges.

Chris Bottiglieri

analyst
#60

Does that support the car-buying side, meaning you’d expect it to recover from this point, or do you view it as staying around this level?

Bill Nash

executive
#61

What it does, I believe, is accomplish a few things. First, with depreciation still occurring, that clearly flows through into the prices on your front lot, so I think that provides some relief regarding affordability. I also think steadier depreciation simply makes operating the business easier; we perform extremely well, and the team performed extremely well even amid that sharp depreciation we experienced during the quarter, yet once you begin to see depreciation return to normal, that is essentially routine for us.

Chris Bottiglieri

analyst
#62

Understood. That's clear to me. Thanks for the assistance. I appreciate it.

Bill Nash

executive
#63

Thanks.

Rajat Gupta

analyst
#64

Great. Thank you for taking my question. I have just one question and one clarification. On retail GPU, the drop from Q1 to Q2 was somewhat bigger than what we'd typically see seasonally. Over the past 10-plus years, the usual sequential change has been a decline of $50. I mean, this quarter it exceeded 100. So I'm just wondering whether any one-time items played a role, or whether there were pricing tests, or anything else you'd flag? And then the clarification.

Bill Nash

executive
#65

Yes. Thanks for the question, Rajat. Yes, when I look at this quarter, honestly, I'm pleased. I'm pleased since we said last quarter that it would come in closer to where we stood a year ago, and as you'll recall, that year was a record high for us, and like you said, $30 falls within the noise for us. So I feel good about that, particularly given the environment out there. Obviously, Q1 was a record high, and I think certain dynamics were at play that quarter, where you bought the vehicles and then we saw some appreciation during that quarter, which prevents you from needing to take markdowns, that sort of thing. So I view the first quarter as more of an anomaly, which is why we set the, said what we did last quarter. We expected to be closer in Q2 to the second quarter of last year. And we reiterate, we expect to be closer for the full year to the full year of last year, which is still an increase over where we've historically been, at $80 to a $100.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#66

And Rajat, just to jog your memory, Q1 also comes with a bit of a seasonal tailwind, correct? I mean, when you look at GPUs, Q1 is usually our peak, partly because of tax season, so is that playing out too?

Rajat Gupta

analyst
#67

Got it, got it. That's useful. Earlier you brought up the supply picture and the reality that plenty of vehicles in that 0-to-10-year-old band might not fit what your reconditioning operation requires. Looking ahead to the back half of this year and the couple of years after, it seems you're leaning more heavily on cars older than 6 years to drive growth. So how do you work around the quality and reconditioning limitations attached to those vehicles? After all, the 0-to-4-year-old supply will probably deteriorate before it improves. How do we steer through that and get the business growing again over the next couple of years? Thanks.

Jon Daniels

executive
#68

Sure. One thing I'd point out, Rajat, is that if you rewind to the last major bubble in late-model vehicles, during the financial crisis, the new car sales pace across 2008, 2009, 2010, and 2011, swung somewhere between $10.5 million and slightly above $13 million. Now compare that with 2020, 2021, 2022, and even what's projected for this year — you're looking at 2014 up to above 2015. What I'm getting at is that we've already weathered much tougher conditions than the current one, in terms of the 0-to-4 or 0-to-6-year-old vehicle bubble we're about to confront. And once more, our position is stronger than it was then, since our self-sufficiency is so elevated and we source those vehicles straight from consumers and other channels. So we're quite confident in our capacity to handle what's ahead, whether buyers want 0-to-6-year-old vehicles or prefer something somewhat older.

Rajat Gupta

analyst
#69

Understood, that's helpful color. Thank you.

Bill Nash

executive
#70

Thank you.

Daniel Imbro

analyst
#71

Yes. Hey, good morning guys.

Bill Nash

executive
#72

Good morning.

Daniel Imbro

analyst
#73

I'd like to follow up regarding CAF, and perhaps this connects to what we discussed about affordability, yet the weighted average rate in this case didn't move, I believe on a sequential basis it stayed at 11.1%, even with benchmark rates possibly climbing and your latest pattern of pushing through price. So, I suppose, are customers resisting rates? Might we interpret that as evidence buyers have hit their ceiling regarding affordability, and are you possibly at the point where you can't push through additional APR at CAF even though the rate environment keeps rising? Just wondering why it's flat from one quarter to the next?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#74

Sure. Yes, excellent question Daniel. There are a few things that are subtle in that to highlight. To start, the unchanged quarter-over-quarter — also keep in mind we did some tightening during that period. If you step back in the Tier 3 space, we select pockets within the Tier 1 space, that will offset whatever sequential increase in the APR. I can tell you that during the quarter we kept testing and increasing APRs, but remember, I think one of the crucial elements for us is, our aim isn't to maximize finance margin. When we run our testing and pass this along to the customer, we're factoring in, can they buy the car? Will they wind up paying it off with somebody else where we wouldn't gain any finance income? So we very carefully test various rates and then tweak those rates in smaller pockets to optimize the overall CarMax value. So I think that explains the sequential piece. But certainly, obviously there are payment pressures as Bill mentioned, so we continue to be very careful with that. But that's why you're seeing sequential quarter-over-quarter flat. It's — the tightening is offsetting it.

Daniel Imbro

analyst
#75

So as a follow-up to that, would your approach lean more toward selling as many units as possible rather than getting the highest margins at CAF — is that what we heard?

Jon Daniels

executive
#76

No. What I'd say is that we take that into account when making the call. We examine units sold, we examine how much finance margin CAF captures, and we also bear in mind — remember, they're able to pay off in three days. So the car might get sold, but CAF might lose that financing if they decide to go down the street to their bank or their credit union. So we factor all of that in to optimize for CarMax overall, rather than just maximizing a single dimension; that's CarMax's total profitability, correct? That's how we think about it; that's right.

Daniel Imbro

analyst
#77

Great. Thanks for that detail. I appreciate it.

David Whiston

analyst
#78

Thank you. Morning. Staying on those alternative financing avenues you brought up, Enrique, I'm wondering why, during this year, the other category is picking up so much while Tier 2 loses ground? Is it simply that more buyers are paying cash these days, or are Tier 2 consumers unwilling to make a purchase, or are competing lenders seizing that chance away from you?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#79

Absolutely. David, several factors are at play here. To start, what you truly observe is that affordability poses a real obstacle at the lower end of the credit spectrum, roughly the mid-tier through subprime range; demand is strong throughout the credit spectrum, yet once the monthly payment comes into view, it's the higher-end customers who can complete the purchase. That ends up helping both cash buyers and the outside financing group. There was some retreat, as I noted in the latter half of last year, within the Tier 2 segment, so additional tightening is also weighing on penetration there, and around Tier 3, those buyers gained from that tightening, correct. Those customers migrate down into Tier 3. Still, my view is it's mostly affordability. Higher-end customers are able to purchase, which explains why the share of sales leans somewhat more toward the high end. Demand exists everywhere, in my view, but that's genuinely the main driver.

David Whiston

analyst
#80

All right. Could you quickly provide a few illustrations of what receivables that can't be collected, excluding CAF, actually consist of?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#81

Sure. Those fall within the SG&A category, correct? They're receivables generated and approved by our finance partners that wind up with either a title processing problem or a down payment issue, which forces us to repurchase them; that's something we're watching closely. During the last 12 months, we've achieved meaningful gains, as I've mentioned in earlier quarters, in how our stores execute and in our home office. The DMVs have improved too when it comes to getting those titles turned around, and the banks have gotten better at handling the processing side. So this quarter brought yet another benefit, and we anticipate additional benefit during the back half of the year. It likely won't be as strong as what we saw in the first half, since we're beginning to lap that heightened emphasis from last year on ensuring these are properly managed.

David Whiston

analyst
#82

Sorry, one more thing — when it comes to collections, are you handling all 100% of the servicing work for those third-party lenders?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#83

Nope, that isn't the case. Underwriting isn't something we do on that; the third-party partners are the ones doing the underwriting and then the servicing. Correct.

David Whiston

analyst
#84

All right. Thank you.

Michael Montani

analyst
#85

Hey everyone, I appreciate you squeezing in one more question from me. What I'd like to understand is whether you can offer any additional detail regarding how sales are trending across different income brackets, and as you consider the sequential gains from that down 9 comp through the rest of the quarter, what patterns are you observing among higher-income shoppers compared with those earning less? And after that, how does that shape your willingness to put money into advertising for the second half of the year?

Bill Nash

executive
#86

Okay. Yes, like I mentioned before, the heaviest pressure — not probably, definitely — we're observing it among the lower consumer. Consider this: for monthly household income somewhere between $3000 and $4,000, that portion of our sales has contracted enormously. So over roughly the past couple of years it has fallen, and for households at $3,000 and below it's likely declined roughly 50%, around 50% lower than it previously was; so that's definitely a headwind, which once more ties back to affordability. When it comes to advertising, that's something Jim and Sarah and the team are continually evaluating; and one thing I believe everyone should remember is that since we also have this large buying engine, when we discuss advertising, it's advertising for sales, yet it's also advertising for buy. So even though you might reduce spending on sales, you might increase it on buy. So it's a balancing act we perform, and that team excels at measuring the ROI. So regarding Enrique's earlier remarks, what we plan to do in the back half could definitely change if we notice something in the marketplace indicating, hey you don't need to spend as much, it's not fruitful, or conversely, hey you might want to spend a bit more, so we're always tracking that; but I believe the guidance Enrique provided is truly the right way to approach it, and then we'll keep monitoring it.

Michael Montani

analyst
#87

Thanks.

Bill Nash

executive
#88

Good. So, I appreciate everyone coming onto today's call, and thanks for the questions and the ongoing support. Once again I'd like to congratulate the CarMax team on hitting our 30th anniversary, and I simply want to express my thanks to them for all they do daily to look after one another, our customers, and the communities, and next quarter we'll speak once more. Thank you.

Operator

operator
#89

We appreciate you joining us, everyone; that brings us to the end of the CarMax earnings release conference call for the second quarter of fiscal year 2024. At this point, you are free to hang up.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete CarMax, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to CarMax, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in CarMax, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.