CarMax, Inc. (KMX) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
December 21, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
David Lowenstein
executiveThanks, Jamie. Hello, everyone, and good morning. We appreciate you being on the call for our earnings conference for the third quarter of fiscal 2024. Joining me are Bill Nash, who serves as our President and CEO; Enrique Mayor-Mora, our Executive Vice President and CFO; and Jon Daniels, our Senior Vice President for CarMax Auto Finance operations. I want to remind everyone that anything we say today that isn't a statement of historical fact — including remarks about future business plans, prospects, and financial performance — counts as a forward-looking statement made under the safe harbor provisions of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995; such statements rest on what we currently know, expect, and assume, and they carry substantial risks and uncertainties that might cause actual results to differ materially from what we expect. When we provide projections and other forward-looking statements, we disclaim any intent or obligation to update them. For more detail on important factors that could affect these expectations, please refer to our Form 8-K filed with the SEC this morning, as well as our annual report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended February 28, 2023, which was previously filed with the SEC. If any follow-up questions come up after the call, please reach out to our Investor Relations department at (804) 747 to 0422, extension 7865. Finally, thank you ahead of time for limiting yourself to one question and then getting back in the queue for additional follow-ups. Bill?
Bill Nash
executiveAlright, thank you, David. Morning, everybody, and I appreciate you being here with us. The results for our third quarter show our strategy carrying forward, and that approach has produced sequential gains year over year in the important parts of our operations for 4 quarters running. Affordability of used cars is still a hurdle for buyers, but we're pleased by what our omnichannel spending is delivering, and that strengthens our conviction that we're set up well going forward; during this quarter, retail and wholesale GPU came in strong. We acquired additional vehicles from both consumers and dealers, and we moved more wholesale units than we did 12 months earlier. SG&A came down further versus the prior year. The credit mix inside CAF's receivables portfolio kept getting stronger, which helped our loan loss provision, and we restarted the share repurchase program. In Q3 of FY '24, total sales from our diversified business model reached $6.1 billion, a 5% decline from a year ago; the reasons were weaker retail and wholesale prices plus reduced retail volume, partly offset by greater wholesale volume; on the retail side, total unit sales fell 2.9% while used unit comps dropped 4.1%. The average selling price was down roughly $1,300 per unit, or 5%, versus a year earlier. Retail gross profit per used unit for the third quarter came to $2,277, about the same as $2,237 a year ago. Looking at the fourth quarter, we expect our margin — our per unit margin — to come in below the record margin posted in last year's fourth quarter; for the entire year, we still expect per unit margin to be comparable to last year. As we always do, we'll keep managing this actively while testing price elasticity and watching what competitors are doing. Wholesale unit sales rose 7.7% compared with the third quarter of last year. Average selling price fell by about $600 per unit, or 7%, from a year earlier. Wholesale gross profit per unit in the third quarter was $961, matching $966 from 12 months ago. Similar to how we view retail GPU, we expect wholesale per unit margin for the whole year to be comparable to last year. Keep in mind, last year's fourth quarter wholesale GPU came within $4 of our all-time record and got a boost from appreciation and robust dealer demand, especially near the end of the quarter; for this year's fourth quarter, we think per unit margin will align more closely with our year-to-date results and be below last year. During the quarter, we acquired roughly 250,000 vehicles from consumers and dealers, which is 5% above last year. Out of that total, about 228,000 came from consumers, and slightly more than half of those purchases happened through our online instant appraisal experience. Because of that, self-sufficiency for the quarter stayed above 70%. With help from our Edmund sales team, we obtained the remaining roughly 22,000 vehicles via dealers, an increase from about 14,000 a year ago. Turning to our online metrics for the third quarter, roughly 14% of retail unit sales took place online, compared with 12% last year. Roughly 55% of retail units sold this quarter came through omni channels, versus 52% during the comparable period a year ago. Every wholesale auction and sale we held in the third quarter took place virtually and counts as an online transaction. That amounts to 19% of total revenue. Online transactions generated about 31% of total revenue, compared with 28% in the prior year. CarMax Auto Finance, or CAF, produced income of $149 million, a modest decline from $152 million in the same period last year. Jon will walk through customer financing, the loan loss provision, and CAF's contribution shortly. With that, I'd like to hand the call to Enrique, who will share further details on our third quarter financial performance. Enrique?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveThank you, Bill, and good morning to all of you. As Bill mentioned, we achieved yet another quarter of sequential gains in our year-over-year results throughout the business and our P&L. Among the standout areas of progress were used and wholesale unit sales along with the margin dollars tied to each, total gross profit, CAF contribution, SG&A leverage and EPS. Net earnings per diluted share for the third quarter came to $0.52, compared with $0.24 during the same period last year. Total gross profit reached $613 million, a 6% gain over the third quarter of last year. Used retail margin fell 1% to $398 million on lower volume, partly offset by a marginally higher per unit margin. Wholesale vehicle margin rose 7% to $123 million, reflecting higher volume and a per unit margin that was flat versus last year. Other gross profit came in at $92 million, 55% higher than a year ago. Service drove this gain, delivering a $33 million improvement over last year, while this year's quarter posted a $21 million loss. The efficiency and cost coverage steps we implemented near the close of FY '23 kept fueling better year-over-year results in FY '24. Extended Protection Plan, or EPP, revenues were roughly unchanged from last year's third quarter. Because of the inflationary pressures our partners have faced, we do not anticipate receiving profit-sharing revenues in the fourth quarter. Third-party finance fees dropped $2 million versus a year ago, reflecting lower volume in Tier 2, where we earn a fee, and higher volume in Tier 3, where we pay one. Turning to SG&A, third quarter expenses totaled $560 million, a 5% decline from the prior year's quarter, as we keep realizing benefits from our cost management work. SG&A as a percent of gross profit levered 11 percentage points versus last year. The year-over-year reduction in SG&A dollars stemmed mainly from 3 factors: first, other overhead fell by $19 million. That decline came primarily from continued favorability in non-GAAP uncollectible receivables and, to a smaller extent, from lower spending on our technology platforms and from favorability tied to reduced staffing levels. Second, total compensation and benefits declined by $20 million, excluding a $3 million rise in share-based compensation. This reduction was chiefly the result of our ongoing push for efficiency gains and matching staffing levels at stores and CECs to sales. A lower corporate bonus accrual in the quarter also contributed to the decrease. Third, advertising grew by $5 million. This mirrors a higher per unit spend relative to last year's quarterly low level of per unit spend and was partly offset by fewer units. As we've said before, we expect our full year marketing spend on a per unit basis to be comparable to last year. As a result, we anticipate that our per unit spend in this year's fourth quarter will be above last year's fourth quarter. As we move into Q4, it's now been a full year since we kicked off those major cost management actions. We're clearly on pace to beat the goal we laid out at the start of the year—needing low single-digit gross profit growth to lever SG&A across the full year, even without counting the gains from this year's legal settlements. Even so, we're staying disciplined when it comes to what we spend and where we invest. On the capital structure side, we restarted our share repurchase program in October, buying back roughly 649,000 shares for about $42 million total during the quarter. That rate matches the guidance we gave last quarter. At quarter's end, we still had $2.41 billion in repurchase authorization available. As for other capital uses, like new store openings, we'll launch four stores in Q4. That includes 2 in the New York metro market plus 1 each in the Los Angeles and Chicago metro markets; we'll also debut our first stand-alone reconditioning center in the Atlanta metro market. Our broad nationwide footprint and logistics network remain a competitive edge for CarMax. At this point, I'll hand the call over to Jon.
Jon Daniels
executiveThanks, Enrique, and good morning to everybody. In Q3, CarMax Auto Finance wrote roughly $2 billion in originations, which produced a 44% penetration rate after accounting for 3-day payoffs. That figure rose compared with Q2 and came in fairly close to the 44.4% we saw in last year's third quarter. New customers were charged a weighted average contract rate of 11.3%, which is 150 basis points higher than the equivalent period a year ago and 20 basis points above Q2. Tier 2 penetration for the quarter matched Q2 sequentially at 18%, though it stays below the year-ago level because we have not yet fully comped the partner tightening that occurred in the back half of calendar 2022. Tier 3 represented 6.9% of sales, versus 6.1% a year earlier. Both of those outcomes were affected by CAF's reduced share in Tier 3 and the greater test volume in Tier 2. CAF income came to $149 million for the quarter, a decline of $3.5 million versus the same period last year, yet an increase of $14 million from Q2. The provision recorded in the quarter was $68.3 million, compared with $85.7 million in the prior year's Q3. That $17 million of favorability was offset by a $20 million year-over-year drop in total interest margin, which stemmed from $81 million of additional interest expense. Keep in mind that fair market value adjustments tied to our hedging strategy created $6 million of expense this year, whereas last year they generated $5 million of income. Total interest margin for the portfolio fell to 5.9%, down from the 6.1% recorded last quarter; this modest decline largely reflects higher funding costs, including those fair market value adjustments, together with CAP's intentional credit tightening that started last year, which by its nature removes higher margin, higher loss assets from new originations. CAF kept countering these headwinds through customer rate adjustments, though we watched 3-day payoffs, sales and overall CarMax profitability carefully; we take satisfaction in sustaining a comparatively steady net interest margin despite the volatile interest rate environment. The $68 million provision in the quarter left us with a reserve balance of $512 million, equal to 2.92% of receivables, versus 3.08% at the close of the second quarter. That 16 basis point decrease happened even as CAP kept investing in the Tier 2 space, and it demonstrates the expanding effect our broader credit tightening is having on the portfolio as a whole. Although cap delinquency levels are still elevated relative to historic norms, as they have been across the industry, we believe our reserve adjustment properly captures the expected future loss performance of our portfolio. The underwriting adjustments made so far have been the correct strategic steps to ensure we reach targeted loss levels, preserve our access to efficient funding and still deliver strong future CAF earnings; we are well positioned to recapture Tier 1 and Tier 3 volume as economic conditions improve, and our ongoing learning in the Tier 2 space should offer a future growth opportunity; now I'll hand the call back to Bill.
Bill Nash
executiveAlright. Thanks, Jon and Enrique. Like I said when the call started, we're really enthusiastic about what our omnichannel investments are bringing us. Through these capabilities, customers get a car buying experience that's personalized in a way nobody else offers, letting them choose how much they handle online versus at a store. I feel good about how far we've come in our effort to provide the industry's most customer-focused experience. We've said this previously: we think people shopping for used cars will more and more want the option to move forward digitally, and our data confirms it. When fiscal year '20 wrapped up and we finished the first phase of our omnichannel rollout, roughly 40% of shoppers used at least some of our digital tools to finish their deals; this year that figure has climbed to about 70%. I know how turbulent the market has been these last few years, which makes it hard to spot what omnichannel has directly done for our business, so let me offer a few concrete examples. To start, what we're seeing in the data suggests omnichannel brings additional retail customers to CarMax. Those who go all the way through a transaction online are 10% more likely to be new to CarMax than either our omnichannel or in-store customers. We've also discovered that our online shoppers tend to be younger, giving us a chance to be part of more of their buying cycles over their lifetimes. On top of that, ever since we first finished the omnichannel rollout, we've experienced disproportionate market share gains in our 15 oldest markets, where no new stores have opened since calendar 2013. During calendar 2019, the yearly market share growth rate in those markets was twice what the average yearly growth rate had been across the prior 5 years. What's more, between the start of calendar 2019 and the close of calendar '22, the average yearly market share growth rate in those older markets kept beating the average growth rate they had before omnichannel. Next, instant offer — our online appraisal tool that customers use directly and that sits at the heart of our omnichannel capabilities — is a major driver of our vehicle purchases and wholesale sales. The year instant offer launched, we doubled the number of buys we got from consumers. That let us push our self-sufficiency past 70%, a level we've held onto since the tool came out. Online buyouts have likewise powered our wholesale volume, which rose roughly 65% in the launch year and has stayed far higher than it was before instant offer existed; worth mentioning too, the algorithms behind instant offer also power Max offer, our sourcing app for dealers. Last, our omnichannel offerings are behind double-digit growth in web traffic. Finance-based shopping ranks as our #1 lead source. This multi-lender prequalification product lets customers get fast credit decisions digitally across our inventory without any hit to their credit score. More than 80% of our customers turn to this online tool when they start the credit process. And last, omnichannel is set to deliver a leaner cost base than the model we ran with stores alone. Compared with our legacy store-only setup, the omnichannel cost base carries a larger share of fixed expenses. On the key measures of cost efficiency for the omnichannel overhead model, we keep posting quarter-after-quarter gains versus a year earlier. Because more of our costs are fixed, we anticipate gaining leverage more powerfully than the old model once demand recovers; we also anticipate that the contribution of our omnichannel abilities will keep expanding as time goes on, since shoppers want a more tailored experience that merges the online journey with what happens in the store. In our view, plenty of rivals throughout the used car sector won't manage to provide that kind of experience simply and without friction. To wrap up, we have faith that the correct plan is in place. Staying disciplined about managing whatever is within our control and providing the most customer-focused experience anywhere in the industry keeps producing quarter-over-quarter gains throughout our operations. We sit in a good spot to come out of this cycle as a company that is even stronger; having said that, we would be glad to answer your questions. Operator?
Daniel Imbro
analystJon, Enrique, I'd like to revisit the cash provision, especially after such strong results. I'm attempting to grasp the puts and takes. The allowance declined significantly, Jon, and I believe you mentioned it might just be from stricter underwriting. Yet net charge-offs appear to be sitting at what could be the highest point in more than a decade. So how do you — could you assist us in reconciling those two elements? And what's the right way to think about provisions? Does the better credit mean that, in nominal terms, this is the appropriate provision level moving forward? And as we move toward the end of the year and into tax refund season, how would you think about those trends?
Jon Daniels
executiveYeah, Dan, I really appreciate that question, and I figured it was coming. So let's start with the provision piece. There are two pieces to our provision this quarter. The first is the shift in how we view expected losses from the existing book versus the level we established at the end of Q2. The second is the reserve we need for losses on newly originated loans. So let's take that first piece. Here's what I can share on that. Looking at where we thought we'd be when Q2 began, and then comparing it with how that same portfolio performed all through Q3, the picture is largely the same. Since you raised the topic, let's walk through the results and what we've been seeing. Every month, we put out information on our securitizations and how they're doing. Keep in mind that's about 60% of the receivables we hold. A good amount of our receivables haven't gone through securitization yet. As we've mentioned before, those terms have gotten tighter. Within the securitization data, though, we definitely saw two separate pools of business. The pre-COVID accounts and the early-COVID accounts both performed noticeably under our goal, landing far beneath that 2% to 2.5% range. That return to more typical ranges was something we expected, and it matches what the recent vintages are showing us. We've mentioned before our view that some of this is being pulled forward. Take a look at the more recent securitizations — particularly '21, 3, '21, 4, and the deals from early '22 — and the shape of the loss timing is noticeably different; in our view, those losses are arriving sooner rather than later. When we established a reserve at the close of Q2, all of that was already taken into account. So for the most part, this first piece of the provision — we didn't have to make any significant adjustment. That means ultimately, the bulk of what makes up our provision comes from newly originated loans, which we've discussed before. Those new originations are much tighter. Tier 3 volume is quite minimal, there's evidence of that in Tier 2, and even with our Tier 1 loans, we've applied further tightening. As for that roughly $2 billion, it reflects a portfolio that's more concentrated and comes with a lower overall loss level. The necessary reserve against it is fairly small, and that accounts for most of what we set aside in Q3.
Brian Nagel
analystWhat you're describing is a nice, steady, ongoing improvement.
Bill Nash
executiveI appreciate that.
Brian Nagel
analystMy first question, I suppose, is about the wholesale segment, which clearly turned up more strongly during this fiscal third quarter. What I'd like to know is — can you elaborate on what drove that acceleration in sales growth? And do you see <<inaudible>> — when you consider wholesale or the implications for your used car operation, simply because those two areas are naturally connected. Then a brief follow-up. Any thoughts — based on what happened in Q3, any thoughts on how the quarter unfolded and what's happening as we move into the early part of Q4?
Bill Nash
executiveYes. Great. Thanks for asking, Brian. So yes, the wholesale growth makes us happy. I'd say several things are contributing. First, there's a bit of year-over-year comparison effect from last year, considering our position then, considering the sales we recorded, circumstances in the market, we actually reduced our offers. So a portion of that is showing up in the year-over-year growth. But I also have strong confidence in the product-side innovation. When you consider Max offer, one aspect of Max offer is that during this quarter we finished deploying the instant offer piece; a handful of markets still lacked instant offer, meaning customers had to photograph their vehicles and then receive a valuation. Today they can choose to skip taking pictures — if they prefer to take pictures, that option remains; so that's part of the innovation that I believe is helpful. So we're very positive about the innovation. And moving ahead, it will likely hinge more on market dynamics and similar factors at any particular moment. Regarding the quarter and the outlook — clearly, the industry remains under pressure, and that's widely understood. And clearly, our business isn't performing where we'd like. But I do believe there are some positive indicators. Beyond the fact that we've kept seeing sequential gains, we experienced substantial depreciation this quarter, really sharp depreciation. And although that creates near-term headwinds, and it will create some headwinds in wholesale to a degree and even on the retail side; it's temporary, and I believe it helps the broader used car industry, and it will help us since that will keep flowing through into front <<inaudible>> prices. You saw we're roughly $1,300 lower this year versus last year on sales prices. On the acquisition side, it was closer to $1,500, though we had some mix adjustment effects in there. So again, I believe the sharp depreciation is a positive. When it comes to interest rates, if they simply hold steady, I believe that's a positive. I believe it benefits the company. I believe that's going to be a boost. And should they decline, I'd view that as a bit of bonus on top. One more item I'd highlight is our market share — October, the most recent month for which we've received market share figures, marks the initial time we've truly lapped our market share on a year-over-year basis, so I find that heartening. Then the next thing I'd share with you is — we've discussed previously the matter of comps and the possible direction of sales. And we've run some analysis alongside one of the credit bureaus, simply attempting to figure out, among the customers who seek a loan via CAF, where are they headed? And based on the analysis we've carried out, it appears many customers, as soon as they conclude they aren't purchasing, they aren't purchasing. So it's nearly as though there's a — perhaps with luck, there's some accumulated demand that I believe we'll witness once the market recovers. So once more, I believe although there are a few encouraging indicators, indeed, the industry remains under pressure. We take encouragement from that. And I believe, factoring all of that in, plus keeping in mind, throughout this period we've been focused on managing costs, growing more efficient, delivering improved experiences for both our customers and our associates. I believe all of that positions us well for what lies ahead too. So with luck, that's useful.
Seth Basham
analystI'd also like to ask about CAF. Jon, can you provide additional detail regarding those securitizations dating from late 2021 through 2022, specifically around your belief that loss curves will level off, since the data hasn't shown that happening so far.
Jon Daniels
executiveSure, thanks for asking. The main point I'd highlight is that, clearly, what's available publicly at present, I believe, covers 2019 onward. Should you step back and examine the 2016, 2017, and 2018 pools, which I imagine you can get your hands on, and observe the normal form of that curve, what we're definitely observing is that the 2021-3 and 2021-4 appear to be inflecting. Of course, each person will chart it however they prefer, but examining that alongside the loss timing, we definitely see these performing within the range we've targeted. For 2022-1 and 2022-2, we're monitoring them extremely closely, and it appears that inflection is starting. Granted, 2022-3 and 2022-4, being younger, haven't inflected yet, so we're tracking those with great care. However, the earlier ones I referenced hadn't inflected either when they were at the same stage. So taking everything together, since we've modeled it out, we understand which subsegments are involved, we understand their behavior and how soon losses emerge, we firmly expect all of it to land in the 2% to 2.5% band, which is genuinely our goal. So, does that provide the detail you were looking for, Seth, or is there anything else on this?
Seth Basham
analystThat's useful. When it comes to the securitizations you currently have on the books, do you expect any of them to post losses beyond that 2% to 2.5% band?
Jon Daniels
executiveRegarding those — regarding the securitizations we hold at present, since, once more, we enjoy the benefit of analyzing that by subsegment, by various pockets. And at this moment we don't anticipate anything exceeding the 2.5%. Once more, that's — and once more, that's a goal. Yes. I'm not claiming anything will land above that level. Should something emerge at 2.5%, 2.55% when all is said and done, we'll set aside reserves for it appropriately; it will be whatever it turns out to be. But no, at this moment, we don't foresee that. And I believe the sole additional thing I'd note is, once more, this covers what has been securitized so far. Keep in mind, and I believe you're quite familiar with this, Seth. It takes 4, 5, 6 months before it winds up in securitization, and the bulk of our tightening has definitely taken place during the last year. So I completely anticipate that as that material reaches the market, you'll plainly observe the proof of the tightening we've carried out during the last year.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveLike Jon pointed out, many of those receivables we can't observe sit inside our warehouses, correct? Roughly 60%, give or take, of what shows up appears in the publicly available securitization data, yet a sizable portion of receivables isn't necessarily visible publicly since they reside in the warehouses and sit within alternative facilities. And that is genuinely the place where you witness much of that tightening. That is feeding into the total loss rate.
Craig Kennison
analystI wanted to ask about AI. During your Analyst Day a few months back, you pointed to multiple areas where your technology group was pushing innovation forward. What I'm curious about, at a very high level, is whether you view AI as something that will make things more even for other used car retailers, or instead as a kind of wedge technology that in the end truly divides winners from losers.
Bill Nash
executiveYes. Well, thanks for asking that, Craig. Well, to start, I believe we need to distinguish AI from generative AI, since AI has existed for quite a while. We've been using it for quite a while across many parts of the business; and when we discussed it most recently on the day you mentioned, it was really more about generative AI. And I believe eventually, people will be adopting generative AI. I believe those who adopt early are the ones who gain in the short term. And as you said, I mean, we're using it in many places. We're using it in our creative. We're using it in our coding; we're developing some generative AI assistance on a knowledge base for our CECs, which we believe will be extremely powerful; we're using it for a conversational search. We have some tests running at this moment where rather than entering key search terms, we can actually conduct conversational search with consumers. So again, I don't — I believe it's among those things that ultimately, you simply have to have it; and if you lack it, you'll be at a disadvantage. So I believe those who adopt it sooner actually gain an early advantage from adopting it.
Rajat Gupta
analystI wanted to ask something else regarding CAF and net interest margin. Is it reasonable to treat that 5.9% as a floor, with things holding steady near there moving forward? I'd also like a brief clarification on SG&A.
Jon Daniels
executiveOf course. Thanks for asking, Rajat. That seems like a reasonable way to think about it, correct? What I mean is, a few quarters back we indicated that roughly the 6% area was where we expected things to settle. Keep in mind, we're exiting a fairly historic peak. So we've been happy with how we've managed to transfer this rate over to the customer. Clearly, the interest rate market experienced a shock. It was anticipated, those elevated interest rates were on their way, and that has definitely assisted us in settling. So we're happy with where we are at present. And I believe we'd expect to hold steady at this point. Clearly, everything depends on where the Fed goes. With luck, rates won't rise. Should they stay put, we believe we're well positioned. Should they decline and move lower, as a reminder, usually rate hikes lag when rates rise and rate cuts lag when rates fall. So with luck, possibly, we might gain some extra margin as they come down. But at this moment, I think we're in a steady place.
Bill Nash
executiveYeah, Rajat, let me just jump in on that. I mean, Jon has already laid it out pretty well — we anticipate landing inside this range. We told you we were at 61 across the last couple of quarters, so allow us some slight flexibility based on where the cost of funds sits; it has ticked down somewhat, though what we're seeing genuinely mirrors the cost of funds. So the way we look at it, the story hasn't really shifted at all, just like Jon said.
Rajat Gupta
analystGot it. Turning to SG&A — it seems like you're still making some ongoing moves when it comes to staffing levels. Could you tell us where exactly those are happening? Are we talking about the CECs, the sales team, or Edmund? And does this signal anything about how you see the market shaping up over the near to medium term? Also, on that same topic, can you put a number on how much the bonus accruals affected things this quarter?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveRajat, that question had several parts to it. If I leave one out, just...
Rajat Gupta
analystMy apologies.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveIf there's something I forget, please remind me which question it was. Regarding the areas where cuts have occurred on the compensation side, which I believe was the first thing you asked, they've genuinely happened everywhere. Versus a year ago, our head count is down by nearly 10% in SG&A; and that's occurred throughout our CECs; it's happened in the business offices, the stores, and the field, with sales staff and consultants also reduced. So essentially, what you're seeing is strict management of our compensation overhead, improved alignment with sales, and a real push on efficiency. We keep observing gains in omni model efficiency both quarter-over-quarter and year-over-year. And we've discussed this regarding 2 of the 3 metrics we monitor for omni's effect on total units, meaning used plus wholesale — at this stage, we operate more efficiently than we previously did. If you consider it as a share of total gross profit, we operate more efficiently than we did back when omni launched; and there's one measure where we still aren't as efficient, though we're making progress toward it, which is the omni operating model measured on a per retail unit basis. Our aim is greater efficiency, yet we haven't fully achieved that. So we're feeling very positive about the headway we're making. And the real effect of that — concentrating on efficiency — puts us in a strong position for when sales recover, and they will. And once that happens, we anticipate converting those sales at a higher rate. I believe that was among the things you asked.
Rajat Gupta
analystThe second thing was regarding those ongoing cuts — is that somehow a signal about what the market looks like? Do you have a take on how volumes will bounce back across the coming few quarters? Then the third piece was, if possible, could you put a number on how much the bonus accruals affected the third quarter?
Bill Nash
executiveRajat, Bill here. I'll handle the first portion. Enrique, you cover SG&A. Regarding — well, when you look at where we stand on staffing, I'd say things have stayed pretty steady throughout this entire year. As Enrique mentioned, we're roughly 10% lower, yet overall head count has remained pretty much in line with what we saw in the prior few quarters; and I believe we've truly positioned ourselves so we're able to be extremely nimble here. Therefore, whatever direction the business takes, should it improve, we have strong confidence in our situation staffing-wise — we can control hours and things of that nature. Were the business to decline for whatever reason, we likewise believe we retain some flexibility. So I'd say we've genuinely created a level of nimbleness that gives us confidence moving ahead; and with that, I'll hand it over to you.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveRight. However, when it comes to the pace of corporate bonus inside compensation — to be very specific, that came to roughly $5 million of favorability during the quarter.
Scot Ciccarelli
analystSo, as a follow-up, I want to ask about affordability. Do you believe you have to return to where things stood in 2019, in terms of what people can afford, to bring your per-store volume back to the 2019 level? And connected to that, is there anything you can share about 4Q? My sense is that investors have broadly anticipated comps flipping positive in 4Q, simply because the comparisons are easy, yet I think certain third-party data point to trends that remain negative. I appreciate that.
Bill Nash
executiveYes. Sure, Scot. Regarding the first portion of your question, I believe you're referring to affordability. And my assumption is that you mean the price of cars, where it stood in 2019 compared with where it stands now? Is that how I should read your question?
Scot Ciccarelli
analystIs that right?
Bill Nash
executiveHonestly, I doubt we return to how things stood in 2019 — I'd struggle to claim otherwise. There's still a lot of headroom, though. During 2019, the average selling price came to $20,000; in this stretch, it sat slightly above $27,000, and my hope is we ease back toward the low 20s, low 20s or thereabouts, perhaps around the mid- like $25,000 mark — any of those figures beats where we sit right now. We're already noticing, on a year-over-year basis, that our cars priced under $20,000 along with those under $25,000 are moving in the right direction. That strikes us as an encouraging signal. Whether they'll fully close the distance, I doubt it — partly since brand-new vehicles keep getting pricier. The larger question, then, is how that spread shapes up down the road. Turning to comps: sure, the market has felt somewhat uneven, and judging by consumer demand across the quarter's 3 months, it was uneven. September stood out as our strongest month, even though it remained negative. October came in weakest, November resembled October, though it was a touch — it outperformed — November did better than October, even if the two were alike; December then mirrors November, though at present it's marginally stronger. So we keep watching elasticity and taking the steps required. I'm hopeful that once some of this depreciation shows up, but at the front line, that should benefit the industry down the line.
Scot Ciccarelli
analystBill, my question centers on affordability. To restore your volume per location to the level seen in 2019, how much better does affordability need to become?
Bill Nash
executiveYeah. Honestly, pinning down precisely what that figure should be is tough. That said, I believe we can return to comp growth without needing to reach 2019 levels again. Also, throughout this year we've observed sequential gains despite the fact that prices haven't dropped sharply since the year began. So Scot, it's a difficult thing to answer, but our aim is to get back to comp growth. Actually, when I examine the initial 10 months of this calendar year, for which market share data exists, against the final 6 months of last year, our market share performance across those first 10 months outpaces what we delivered in the last 6 months of last year, and I find that encouraging. We haven't yet comped on a total year-over-year basis, given how strong the first half of last year was. Still, as I mentioned before, it's encouraging that October marks the initial month with month-over-month market share — that is, year-over-year market share growth.
John Healy
analystI just wanted to ask you, Bill, what your expectations might be for this year's tax season — it's nearly here. And what you'd consider possible positives or negatives. I'm not sure <<inaudible>> all of us get fixated on the monthly trends, but anything tied to tax season, how you folks are feeling that could affect this year's business, or any other outside factors that might shape how we see demand levels in February or March actually play out?
Bill Nash
executiveSure, I'll tell you what, John — if you happen to know the answer to that, I'd appreciate a call afterward, and we can discuss it. I don't — as of right now, I don't anticipate — there's nothing I could point to that would suggest, okay, tax season is going to look dramatically different from last year. I mean, during tax season, you expect to sell more cars, and I think it will be comparable. What I think will be interesting is that last year, at the start of the calendar year, vehicles appreciated really steeply. And I think that will be interesting. We aren't banking on that steep appreciation; so watching the year-over-year dynamics of that from a pricing standpoint will be interesting; but as we sit here right now, we're sort of planning for a tax season similar to last year, since we don't really see any signals suggesting it will be dramatically different.
Sharon Zackfia
analystI'll ask something else related to that. Has the method for displaying inventory on the website been altered? Since it really appears there has been a significant buildup of inventory during the past few months. And assuming you don't anticipate some kind of dramatic shift in tax refund season, I'm simply wondering why that inventory accumulation is occurring?
Bill Nash
executiveSure, Sharon, excellent question. What you are observing is this: when you examine average saleable inventory for the quarter, compared with the same period a year ago, the average is quite close to what it was then. When you look at the quarter's end, as you mentioned, it is higher; and the truth is total inventory has risen somewhat, and the increase is in salable rather than nonsalable. And the cause of the rise in salable is that we are arranging some production shutdown. As you may recall, a year ago, the holiday landed on the weekend — well, we don't build cars on weekends; this time around, it lands on a day, both January, but the 1st and December 25th land on weekdays. And we wish to provide our people time off and let them enjoy the holidays. So we in fact did a bit of a prebuild earlier to ensure we accounted for our desire to keep the shops closed and give time off for the holiday. So it's really — that's roughly what you are observing. There is a small amount of year-over-year dynamics too, but that represents the majority of what you are observing.
Sharon Zackfia
analystAll right. Has there been any movement on how you're thinking about unit growth for next year?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveRegarding new stores? Yes, that guidance will come in — typically we give it during our Q4 call, and that's our plan.
Chris Bottiglieri
analystI was hoping you might expand on what was said regarding no profit share being anticipated in ESP. Should we expect F&I in Q4 to look like Q3? Is the usual seasonal gap mainly driven by profit share? Then, does any of that carry over into the next fiscal year — for instance, in how you establish the — I'm not sure, regardless, is there any carryover impact from the reduced Q4 profit share?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYes. Appreciate the question, Chris. That seasonal pattern is tied much more to sales, correct? And since sales map, so does ESP penetration in dollars. Therefore, the sole item we've observed across the last couple of years is actually in the fourth quarter, when we've seen that profit share from our partners come through at the end of the quarter. And last year it was fairly significant. My recollection is it exceeded $15 million. So I wanted to be sure we highlighted that. Given the inflationary pressures our partners have faced over the past year, their profitability has simply become somewhat more squeezed. And ultimately, when we seek profit share, there has to be a certain amount that they're seeing for us to have that — to share in it; so what we've projected thus far for this year is that we won't see that profit share. But once more, that's truly because of inflationary pressures our partners are experiencing.
Chris Bottiglieri
analystUnderstood. All right, so next I was curious whether you might expand a bit on the warehouse portfolio. It's about two-thirds as large as the securitized book, roughly. Could you perhaps walk us through what it actually holds? What does the typical age look like at present compared with the securitized portfolio? If you examined those receivables that aren't securitized and aren't Tier 2 or Tier 3 test assets, how would the loss experience of those vintages stack up against the comparable vintages sitting in the securitized book? You seem to be implying the results are stronger, but I was hoping you might go into a bit more detail on that.
Jon Daniels
executiveAbsolutely. Yes, Chris, I'll handle that one. Sure, our warehouse lines give us that near-term financing before we move things into the ABS market or consider other instruments for a longer-term funding answer there. Right now, though, our conduit lines mostly hold the most recent assets until we bring them to market. So you have — the current quarter's assets will remain in there. The prior quarter's assets will remain in there. Let's say that comes to $4 billion. Some overflow is possible too. So as we've said, we've done a lot of tightening, particularly around Tier 3 and Tier 2. But looking only at Tier 1, we've tightened within that Tier 1 bucket as well. So we would definitely anticipate that Tier 1 collateral will do better than the collateral inside the securitization. Again, we believe all of it performs quite strongly; but when it comes to losses specifically, that conduit collateral should produce a smaller loss than what shows up in the latest securitizations.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveThose receivables are usually going to remain in our warehouses for a period of 3 to 6, 7 months, correct, up until the point when we make payment and they move into the securitizations; that is the reason a slight timing lag shows up, right, when it comes to how those two buckets of receivables perform.
Chris Bottiglieri
analystUnderstood. One final quick item, and this was something you raised. Seasoning has been creeping upward slightly. Is there any — I realize a portion of this relates to Tier 2 and Tier 3, but is it simply that the ABS markets remain not entirely loose, so you aren't as confident as you'd prefer, or why — I suppose why is seasoning rising somewhat compared with what we saw before COVID?
Jon Daniels
executiveCertainly. Yes. I believe volume is truly the reason. I mean, clearly we have an enormous number of sales, CAF keeps originating $2 billion per quarter, we examine the securitization market and attempt to align how much volume we place in every deal with existing demand, obviously, alongside our growth. Each deal runs about $1.5 billion across four deals. We originate roughly $8 billion. That's substantial — annually. That figure has expanded over time. Consequently, it must naturally remain in place somewhat longer than the warehouses. I don't believe anything unusual is happening there. It's purely a timing matter.
Michael Montani
analystYeah. The first thing I wanted to ask about is provisions. We had figured something like $90 million or more looked like the trend for a run rate, and clearly it came in stronger than that. So should we view it that way, perhaps beginning with a six handle in the near term, given some of the tightening you've implemented and everything we're aware of? And then I had one more question about SG&A.
Jon Daniels
executiveAbsolutely. So let me address the provision one more time. Once again, there are two primary pieces. One is any movement we see in the current portfolio relative to the amount we set aside in the prior quarter, and the other is newly originated loans. Here's how I look at it — let's handle the latter first. New originations. This year we did $2 billion. Within that there's a Tier 1, Tier 2, Tier 3 component. As we've said, Tier 3 is small. Tier 2 is at test volume. Tier 1 makes up most of it. You establish an expected lifetime loss rate and add the cost of recovery through repossession, which isn't very large, but you're setting an overall expectation for that $2 billion. That's one portion of your provision; the rest depends on how adequately we reserved for it in the prior quarter. As we said this quarter, we believed we had done a solid job. Nothing in the quarter's performance indicated we were significantly off — which is why the figure came to $68 million. So you need to split those two components apart, and that's how you determine your provision for each following quarter.
Michael Montani
analystThen I suppose, as a follow-up, regarding SG&A to gross — should we still view the mid-70s as the right near-term target for that level? And more broadly, do we believe SG&A dollars can keep declining soon given this demand environment? Or do we begin increasing SG&A dollars in order to drive volume and share?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYes; there are a couple of questions there. As for the mid-70% SG&A as a percent of gross profit, that is definitely the next step we've communicated; we've achieved material progress in generating efficiency within our business. And reaching that mid-70 is our next objective; yet alongside the cost management efforts we've carried out, we'll also need the consumer to come back with some strength. SG&A efficiency also depends on gross profit. So to reach that mid-70%, we will need to see reasonably solid gross profit growth too, but that is definitely our next step. Regarding SG&A going forward, once again, we take pride in the material year-over-year reductions we've managed to deliver; and what I'll note is that we've accomplished that while simultaneously improving our customer and our associate experience as we move further along in our omnichannel, correct? And this emphasis on efficiency truly puts us in a good position for when sales rebound. Now for Q4, it will be somewhat more difficult since we've mostly anniversaried our cost levers; so Q4, I would say it will be more affected by our sales performance when it comes to that year-over-year SG&A dollar movement.
Bill Nash
executiveRight. And broadly speaking, looking back over time, from Q3 into Q4, your SG&A typically rises for the factors you just mentioned — that being higher volume. And like Enrique mentioned, it's driven by volume.
John Murphy
analystI have a question about inventory. I'm not sure whether you're able to share this, or whether you even have the data, but what would you estimate the typical ASP to be on the inventory you'll eventually sell off? I mean, you've watched ASP decline roughly $2,000 from its high point, and even with that price dropping, we still aren't seeing the same-store sales comp increase you'd anticipate. So I'm simply wondering what's sitting in inventory? And can you buy inventory at cheaper prices down the road, purely to push the comp higher?
Bill Nash
executiveYeah. Appreciate that, John. Within what we're holding right now — bear in mind, of what we moved during the quarter, over 50% had been purchased before the quarter began. So the inventory on hand today consists of items bought while the quarter was underway, and as we mentioned, there's been significant depreciation over that period, and depreciation keeps showing up; so prices ought to come down as a result. Remember, though, just to give everyone some context, in any particular year, you need roughly — across that single year, you need roughly $1,500 of depreciation just to hold your selling prices level, and that's purely because each new model that arrives costs more. So you truly don't capture much upside until you've cleared $1,500 on an annual basis. So I do — we do believe, even though we won't reveal our estimate of the average price, that our inventory — the saleable inventory right now is priced below what we sold during the quarter.
John Murphy
analystThat's really useful. Then I have a single additional question about market share. Clearly, that figure results from market conditions, the moves you make, and competitive pressures. How are you viewing the current competitive environment? Take a business such as an automation, which handled roughly 1.3 million used vehicles in the prior year. Or looking at it on an LTM basis, they recently increased purchases made outside their dealerships, completing around 100,000 units beyond the dealerships compared with what they had previously done; so it appears the franchise side—and that's just one particular case—is pursuing some of the same vehicles you target, even beyond the usual channels. As you go out and source inventory, do you notice that, or is it more of a one-time situation?
Bill Nash
executiveAre you referring to how vehicles get acquired?
John Murphy
analystSo, franchise dealers have usually gotten their supply from new-car flow, trade-ins, and other places. But they've gone beyond that usual pipeline, reaching out — not through auctions, but to third parties and straight to consumers too, and on an LTM basis that gave them an extra 100,000 units, and that's purely new, correct? It's purely additional, new business. So I'm wondering whether that's something only they do, or whether you're seeing it more broadly.
Bill Nash
executiveYeah. No, I think — listen, you know well the kind of volume available in auctions, particularly vehicles aged 0 to 4 years. And when people want that inventory, they need to get a bit more inventive. So it doesn't shock me that others are doing the same. Our 0 to 4 sales actually rose slightly year-over-year. So I'd say — well, that's a single data point you've got. I think every dealer is simply scrambling to source vehicles however possible. That's why I'm enthusiastic about certain product innovations, such as Max offer. Regarding sales efficiency, that only reflects consumers, we don't include what we obtain from other dealers. And that product leans more toward retail than wholesale. So it doesn't shock me that you've found such an example. I think those capable of doing such things will attempt it. Plus, there are plenty of rivals. Bear in mind, there are tens of thousands of competitors selling cars aged 0 to 10 years. A number of them lack that capability.
David Whiston
analystI’d like to inquire about advertising expense, since it rose compared with a year earlier, while across the 9 months it has declined. What prompted the higher outlay this quarter is what I’m interested in learning?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveRight, that will largely be driven simply by what we put into CapEx and the related depreciation. Beyond that, regarding what we put toward technology, a sizable share of that technology outlay is going to run through depreciation, correct? So that effect will show up <<inaudible>> in our DNA.
Bill Nash
executiveYeah, I believe regarding the ads side of things. Look, our commitment here is for the long term. That means we'll put dollars toward brand, and we'll put dollars toward acquisition. Just remember, and as we head into the new year, we're figuring out how to frame advertising. When we bring up advertising, just remember, that covers advertising for sales, advertising for buy, advertising on Edmund. So from the start, we've stated, hey, we'll devote more during the back half of the year, yet on a full year basis it will be comparable. So we're truly doing that; now please don't assume we're simply diving into advertising. We're definitely tracking the ROI. But what you need to understand is occasionally if the ROIs <<inaudible>> on sales, you might move some toward buys or you might move some toward Edmund. So it simply hinges on what's happening in a particular quarter, but we would anticipate — and typically, you devote somewhat more in the fourth quarter since it's — you've got tax season approaching, which means a rise in volume. So that's genuinely what you're witnessing.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYes, David, sorry, I apologize. I thought you were asking about depreciation. .
David Whiston
analystThanks for clearing that up.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveThat's one more response than you were expecting.
David Whiston
analystWith wholesale units up almost 8%, are you becoming more aggressive with the offers you make to consumers who want to sell us a vehicle? I was just wondering whether you're aiming to buy more vehicles.
Bill Nash
executiveLook, every vehicle out there is something we'd like to get, but we'll do it in a way that's very thoughtful and profitable. I mean, you could — we could purchase far more cars, but from a profitability standpoint that wouldn't make sense. So I think the team has done a phenomenal job, especially given the steep depreciation that we've seen, how they've been able to stay on top of it because that's definitely a short-term headwind.
Bill Nash
executiveOkay. Thanks, Jamie. So, I appreciate everyone being on this call today, and I appreciate the questions and the ongoing backing. As usual, I'm grateful to our associates for all they do so we can look after one another, plus the customers and the communities. I'd also like to wish each of them a joyful holiday season, and the same to all of you, and we'll speak once more in the next quarter. Thank you.
Operator
operatorTo all of you, one more time, that brings an end to what we had scheduled for today. We appreciate everyone taking part. At this point, you're free to hang up.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete CarMax, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to CarMax, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in CarMax, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.