CarMax, Inc. (KMX) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
April 11, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
David Lowenstein
executiveThanks, Shelby, and good morning to all of you. We appreciate you being on the line for our conference call covering results from the fourth quarter of fiscal 2024. Joining me are Bill Nash, who serves as our President and CEO; Enrique Mayor-Mora, our Executive Vice President and CFO; and Jon Daniels, our Senior Vice President of CarMax Auto Finance Operations. I want to note that anything we say today that isn't a statement of historical fact — which includes remarks about future business plans, prospects, and financial performance — counts as a forward-looking statement made under the safe harbor provisions of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Such statements rest on what we currently know, expect, and assume, and they carry substantial risks and uncertainties that might cause actual results to differ materially from what we expect. When we provide projections and other forward-looking statements, we disclaim any intent or obligation to update them. For more detail on important factors that could affect these expectations, please refer to our Form 8-K filed with the SEC this morning, as well as our annual report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended February 28, 2023, which was previously filed with the SEC. If any follow-up questions come up after the call, don't hesitate to reach our Investor Relations department at (804) 747 to 0422 extension 7865. <<operator_script>> Bill?
Bill Nash
executiveThanks, David. Morning, everyone — we’re glad you could join us. We’re pleased with how things went in Q4; we continue to lean on our biggest strengths — our people, our skills, our know-how, and our culture — to gain momentum while steering through the cycle. Even though affordability for used cars remains an obstacle for buyers, pricing improved over the quarter. We continue to find ways to run our core operation more efficiently, and we believe we’re positioned well to deliver growth once the market gets better. In Q4, we posted our fifth consecutive quarter of sequential year-over-year increases in retail used units, and we showed gains in total used unit sales and comps; we delivered strong retail and wholesale GPUs. We lifted used salable inventory units by more than 10% while holding used total inventory units flat compared with a year earlier. We continue to manage SG&A aggressively, and CAF income increased substantially as we achieved a significant year-over-year reduction in the loan loss provision while net interest margin stayed flat sequentially. In Q4 of FY ’24, our diversified business model generated total sales of $5.6 billion, down 2% from the prior year. That reflected softer retail and wholesale prices as well as lower wholesale volume, partially offset by higher retail volume; within retail, total unit sales increased 1.3%, and used unit comps grew 0.1%. Average selling price declined by about $600 per unit, or 2%, compared with a year earlier. Based on our market share data, our national share of used vehicles aged 0 to 10 years decreased from 4% in calendar ’22 to 3.7% in 2023, because we prioritized profitability over short-term share gains. As we always do, we continue testing price elasticity to validate our decisions. External title data shows our share initially accelerated relative to how we performed through the back half of 2022, but then came under pressure amid several periods of sharp depreciation. We remain confident in our ability to accelerate share growth as used vehicle affordability continues to improve and as vehicle value volatility calms down. Q4 retail gross profit per used unit was $2,251, roughly in line with the record $2,277 from last year’s fourth quarter. Wholesale unit sales fell 4% from Q4 a year ago. Average selling prices declined by about $250 per unit, or 3%, year-over-year. Q4 wholesale gross profit per unit was $1,120, a bit below $1,187 the previous year. Keep in mind, last year’s Q4 wholesale GPU was within $4 of our all-time record, aided by appreciation and strong dealer demand, particularly late in that quarter. That prior-year appreciation factor also weighed on our year-over-year results in buyers; we purchased roughly 234,000 vehicles in the quarter, an 11% decline from last year. Among those vehicles, approximately 213,000 were acquired from consumers, and slightly more than 50% of those buyers utilized our instant online appraisal tool; with assistance from our Edmond sales staff, we acquired the remaining roughly 21,000 vehicles through dealers, representing a 45% gain versus last year. Moving to our Q4 online figures, roughly 14% of retail unit sales were completed online, unchanged from a year ago. Omni sales represented about 55% of retail unit sales in this quarter, versus 52% during the prior-year period. All of our fourth quarter wholesale auctions and sales were conducted virtually and qualify as online transactions. That equals 17% of total revenue. Online transactions accounted for roughly 30% of total revenue, consistent with last year. CarMax Auto Finance, or CAF, delivered income of $147 million, up 19% from $124 million in the comparable period last year. Fourth quarter wholesale gross profit per unit was $11.20, slightly down from $1,187 a year ago. Jon will provide more detail shortly regarding consumer financing, loan loss provisions, and CAF contribution; but at this point I'd like to turn the call over to Enrique, who will share additional information about our fourth quarter financial performance. Enrique?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveThank you, Bill, and good morning to all of you. As Bill mentioned, we achieved yet another quarter of sequential gains in our used unit sales, with robust per unit margins for both used and wholesale, along with strong growth in CAF contribution, all while maintaining our focus on managing SG&A. For the fourth quarter, net earnings per diluted share came in at $0.32, compared to $0.44 during the same period last year. The prior year's quarter got an $0.08 boost from receiving Extended Protection Plan, or EPP, profit-sharing revenues, plus $0.04 from a lower tax rate, whereas this quarter saw a more normalized tax rate. Total gross profit reached $586 million, a 4% decline versus last year's fourth quarter. On used retail, we posted $387 million in margin — essentially level with last time — because although we moved more units, we gave up a bit on the profit each one brought in. Wholesale vehicle margin came in at $129 million, down 9%, driven by both fewer vehicles sold and a weaker per-unit margin versus the prior year. Other gross profit reached $69 million, which represents a 15% decline year over year; the main reason for that drop was the $16 million in profit-sharing revenues we received from our EPP partners during the same period last year. During our third quarter call, we told you we weren't counting on any profit-sharing revenues this year, given that our partners were dealing with inflationary pressure and shoppers were getting back to more typical driving habits. Working against that headwind was a favorable impact from price elasticity testing on our extended service product. In the quarter, we ran a test on raising the margin on each MaxCare contract we sell. Product penetration came down a bit as a result, but profitability as a whole went up. Those results gave us confidence, so the margin increase has now gone out across the country. We figure this move will add about $20 of incremental EPP margin for every retail unit in FY '25. Service was down $4 million versus the fourth quarter a year ago. The main reasons were wage pressure and the lower production we had planned for the quarter, since we built inventory ahead in the third quarter because of how the holidays fell. Across the full year, Service was up $75 million compared with the prior year. We look for that sizable year-over-year favorability to keep going in FY '25. The size of that improvement is going to hinge on how sales go, because service carries inherent leverage and deleverage effects. On the third-party finance side, fees came in $3 million below the same period last year — that decline reflects greater Tier 3 volume, where we're the ones paying a fee, alongside reduced Tier 2 volume, where the fee comes to us. Turning to SG&A, we recorded $581 million of expenses in the fourth quarter, which is a 1% increase versus the comparable quarter a year earlier. Thanks to our continued discipline around spending and investment levels, we managed to land flat on a year-over-year basis once share-based compensation is excluded. One thing worth remembering: during the fourth quarter, we crossed the one-year anniversary of when we began our substantial cost management initiatives. Three things primarily drove the change in SG&A dollars for Q4 compared with the prior year. To start, other overhead came down by $16 million, which was largely the result of reduced investment in our technology platforms as well as continued positive movement on non-CAF uncollectible receivables. Beyond that, total compensation and benefits climbed $7 million, and that figure leaves out the $8 million increase in share-based compensation; a larger corporate bonus accrual this quarter was the primary driver. Finally, advertising was up $5 million, consistent with the increase we mentioned on the previous quarter's call, mostly because of the timing of per unit spend. For the whole of fiscal 2024, we blew past—by a wide margin—the target we set when the year began, which was for gross profit to rise in the low single digits so that SG&A would leverage, and that's true even if you set aside what we gained from legal settlements this year. Our ability to bring SG&A costs down a lot compared with the previous year came from favorable non-CAF uncollectible receivables, which reflect stronger execution at our stores, in our corporate offices, and among external partners. We kept our attention on driving efficiency gains in our stores and CECs, the intentional reduction in technology spending, and aligning staffing levels and marketing spend with sales. Looking ahead to FY '25, our expectation is that we'll see gross profit expansion in the low single digits, which would allow us to lever SG&A once you strip out the favorable legal settlements that benefited FY '24. This puts us in a stronger position on the path toward a lower SG&A leverage ratio. Our initial goal is to eventually land in the mid-70% range, but that depends on consumer demand showing more strength. For the first quarter, we're expecting SG&A to come under pressure. As a reminder, we recorded $59 million from a legal settlement in Q1 of FY '24. On top of that, in this year's first quarter, we're anticipating an impact of approximately $25 million, driven by share-based compensation for certain executives who are retirement-eligible, as well as by lapping the favorable reserve adjustments related to non-CAF uncollectible receivables from last year's first quarter. Now, on the marketing side: starting now, we're going to talk about what we spend relative to every unit we move, counting both retail and wholesale. We think that approach paints a fuller picture of the impact our marketing efforts have, because those efforts support vehicle sales as well as purchases. For FY '25, we're projecting that our full-year marketing outlay, measured against total units, will land close to what it was in FY '24 — somewhere around $200. Switching to capital structure: over the quarter, we repurchased roughly 686,000 shares, which cost us $49 million altogether. Starting in Q1, we intend to slightly accelerate how quickly we buy back shares, compared with what we did during Q3 of fiscal year '24. When that quarter ended, we still had $2.36 billion in authorization left for repurchases. Turning to capital expenditures, our expected investment range is $500 million to $550 million, which is above the $465 million recorded in FY '24. The reason for this planned rise in spending relative to last year is primarily the timing of when money goes out for new stores. Just like in FY '24, land along with constructing facilities to support long-term growth capacity, plus offsite reconditioning and auctions, continues to account for the largest portion of our CapEx. During fiscal 2025, our intention is to launch 5 additional store sites. In line with the approach we follow, such fresh outlets are going to be more compact, multi-purpose shops that support our omnichannel model and make the most of our size. We're also aiming to launch our second reconditioning site that stands alone, and it's going to be situated in Richland, Mississippi, plus a single off-site auction venue within the Los Angeles metro area. At this point, we anticipate launching several off-site reconditioning and auction sites during fiscal 2026. The broad footprint we have across the country, along with our logistics network, remains a source of competitive edge for CarMax. At this point, I'd like to hand things over to Jon.
Jon Daniels
executiveThanks, Enrique, and good morning to all of you. In Q4, CarMax Auto Finance wrote about $1.8 billion, which produced a sales penetration figure of 42.3% net of 3-day payoffs — a decline of 240 basis points versus the comparable quarter a year ago. For new customers, the weighted average contract rate moved up to 11.5%, which is 60 basis points higher than the fourth quarter of last year and 20 basis points higher than the prior quarter. Tier 2 penetration came in at 18.7% for the quarter, a drop from the 19.4% we saw in last year's fourth quarter. Tier 3 made up 8.2% of sales, an increase of 130 basis points over last year, as our partner started loosening the tightening it had previously put in place. Also shaping each of these full-year results were CAF's ongoing lower share in Tier 3 and the higher test volume in Tier 2. CAF income for the quarter reached $147 million, which is $23 million above the same period a year ago. The main driver of this gain was a $26 million year-over-year decrease in the provision for loan losses, partly offset by a $3 million drop in total interest margin. Keep in mind, fair market value adjustments tied to our hedging strategy created $4 million in expense this quarter, versus $1 million of income in last year's fourth quarter. The $72 million provision recorded during the quarter left us with a reserve balance of $483 million, or 2.78% of receivables, compared with 2.92% at the close of the third quarter. That underscores how strongly originations made under our tightened credit policy are affecting the reserve, since they keep growing as a share of the overall portfolio. On top of that, actual performance inside the portfolio lined up closely with the reserve expectations we held at the end of the third quarter, which helped bring the reserve down. The portfolio's margin to receivable rate held firm at 5.9% for the quarter; we're still happy with our capacity to keep interest margin steady even while our credit tightening remains in effect. As I mentioned before, CAF keeps running tests across different portions of the credit spectrum. In the end, CAF is developing the ability to expand its participation across every credit tier, which will assist in capturing finance economics, boosting sales, and fully supporting our valued lending partnerships that form a crucial cornerstone of CarMax's best-in-class credit platform. At this point I'll hand the call back to Bill.
Bill Nash
executiveThanks, Jon and Enrique. The used car sector faced a tough fiscal 2024, since affordability of vehicles along with broad macroeconomic pressures kept weighing on sales. So we zeroed in on the things within our power and made intentional moves to bolster the business, for both the short term and the long haul; beyond capturing the organization-wide efficiencies Enrique described, I take pride in how far we've come in strengthening our omnichannel abilities, since we're putting priority on initiatives meant to improve how our associates and customers experience things and to generate operating efficiencies. A few illustrations: on the retail side, we use data science, automation and AI to make it simpler for buyers to handle important transaction steps such as vehicle transfers by themselves; we also upgraded digital checkout features for appraisal customers, letting them send in documents from a distance and opening up their ability to take part in our 30-minute express drop-off experience. On top of that, we broadened what Skye, our 24/7 virtual assistant, can do to cover handling finance applications, vehicle transfers, appointment reservations and appraisal offers. Customers have embraced Skye enthusiastically. This has created efficiency gains and given our associates additional bandwidth as well. On the wholesale and vehicle acquisition side, we rolled out an update to our auction platform that adds several new services, including single sign-on that works across every one of our systems, condition reports enhanced by AI, the ability to bid early, and automated bills of sale. MaxOffer also became more efficient now that our instant offer experience is available to each participating dealer. Turning to credit, every one of our lenders has joined our finance-based shopping platform, which broadens both the breadth and depth of offers customers can access. Adoption is still impressive: more than 80% of consumers use this best-in-class prequalification product when they begin the credit process. Finally, Edmunds introduced multiple tools for research and buyers, backing its goal of becoming a leader in EV research. These encompass range testing, charging efficiency measurements, battery health evaluations at the VIN level, plus guides covering EV tax credits and incentives. Looking ahead to fiscal 2025, we will continue advancing the momentum achieved last year, further expanding our competitive advantage. We are confident that the actions we are taking will enable growth in sales, profitable market share, and buyer counts, while also generating additional operational efficiencies when the market recovers. To offer a few examples: within retail, we plan to launch a redesigned hub embedded in our customers' online shopping accounts, allowing easier transitions between assisted health and self-progression. Customers will be able to view the steps they've completed along their shopping journey, whether alone or with assistance from a CEC or store associate. That hub will additionally steer next steps and highlight MaxCare, our extended service plan offering. Also, we're going to keep digitizing work to help us create a leaner, high-value assistance model for our CECs. That way, our current resources can handle more transactions as traffic grows and we push for better conversion. As part of this, we'll deepen Skye's integration into important communication channels and enhance its capacity to act as the first point of contact at many stages of the customer shopping journey. Skye is going to take care of what comes afterward on — or pass the customer along without friction to a CEC associate via whichever channel that person happens to be on. Through our work to acquire vehicles, the goal is to pull still more cars into the ecosystem we've built. A big part of that involves the partnership we continue to have with Edmunds for sourcing vehicles out of dealerships. When it comes to credit, our plan is to keep sharpening the prequalification offering by integrating the customer's instant offer directly into the application flow. We'll also, as Jon mentioned, continue running tests on CAF's participation in various segments of the credit spectrum. And as we always do, we'll pursue chances to provide consumers with outstanding offers while still driving sales and economics for the company. On our long-term financial targets, the objective of moving over 2 million units a year across retail and wholesale combined still stands. However, we're now extending the deadline for that objective to somewhere in fiscal 2026 through fiscal 2030, given the uncertainty and how the market recovery is timed, plus our continued emphasis on growing market share profitably. Once we can see more clearly how fast the industry is bouncing back, we'll update that deadline. Since average selling prices have risen, reaching the $33 billion yearly revenue goal should come earlier than the unit figure. Likewise, we anticipate crossing the 5% threshold for national market share in used vehicles aged 0 to 10 years before we hit that mark on a unit basis. Because vehicle values have fluctuated lately, we plan to provide a refreshed timeline for reaching that goal when fiscal year 2025 comes to a close. Prior to opening the floor to questions, I'd like to recognize two notable milestones. To start, during fiscal 2024 CarMax celebrated 30 years in business. My thanks and congratulations go out to every one of our associates for their efforts. They represent what sets us apart and are essential to the success we've achieved. Also, for the twentieth consecutive year, Fortune Magazine has included CarMax on its list of the 100 Best Companies to Work For. That honor means a great deal to me, particularly given how tough this past year was. It reflects how our associates show up daily for one another, for our customers, and for our communities. To wrap up, the strides we've taken toward providing the industry's most customer-centric experience make me proud. The quarter-over-quarter gains we're generating throughout our operations give me confidence, and I look forward to what we're prioritizing in fiscal 2025. Our core business is still strong, and with macroeconomic conditions improving, we're positioned well to drive growth. With that said, we're ready to take any questions you have. So, Shelby?
Seth Basham
analystI've got a question about the quarter specifically, and then a broader one. Looking at the quarter, service gross profit came in softer than we had expected. Could you walk us through what portion of that strain was temporary and what level of gain we ought to expect from the service line in 2025?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveSure. Appreciate it, Seth. That's a good question; our view is that this is transitory; on a year-over-year basis we had a few factors, including the planned reduction in production that we'd already told you about. So heading into the fourth quarter, some headwinds were anticipated on our end. Wage pressure also played a part. That said, during the fourth quarter we launched additional efficiency efforts, which will continue into the coming year, particularly around labor. To be specific, we've put money into RFID-based tracking for inventory. Our tech and engineering spending will be used to boost reporting across our stores. Driving additional MaxCare work into our shops is a priority for us. And we've simultaneously raised labor rates along with parts rates, which helps counter inflationary pressure. So improvement is what we anticipate — meaningful year-over-year improvement, matching what we achieved this year, that meaningful improvement across the full year. And we're looking for the same in the next year. Beyond that, it's clearly tied to sales results too, since service carries that leverage/deleverage characteristic.
Seth Basham
analystGot it. Then second, Bill, about market share — on your previous call, you mentioned that you'd begun seeing some gains late in fiscal Q3. It looks like that momentum faded somewhat during Q4. Could you explain what happened? And as the cycle turns, when do you think we'll start seeing share gains again?
Bill Nash
executiveYeah, good question, Seth. You're correct. On the last call, I said that October had actually turned positive on a year-over-year basis. But I also mentioned during that period — Q3 — the sharp depreciation. It was going to be fascinating to watch how rivals responded. When I look at share from the broadest perspective, the 2 factors weighing on us this year, and honestly some of it happened last year too, are affordability and — more applicable to this year — those stretches of severe depreciation we've experienced. On affordability, we've discussed it all year in terms of consumers potentially trading down, moving into older vehicles, into 0- to 10-year old cars that perhaps we don't sell, or simply staying on the sidelines, since we can see demand exists, yet folks aren't actually pulling the trigger. The other thing we observed this year was 2 extremely sharp depreciation cycles. Looking at last calendar year — and I brought this up in my prepared remarks — we were gaining share as we exited last year. Then we hit a stretch, roughly 4/5 months, of severe depreciation beginning around April, and it was roughly $3,000. After that it settled down somewhat. Then we closed the year with yet another sharp depreciation, likely the sharpest in the shortest window, of approximately another $3,000. As we've said previously, when depreciation gets steep, that's when our pricing elasticity really gets tested, because we recognize competitors, for their own reasons and business models, might cut prices to clear inventory and so on; and what we've stated is that we'll keep pursuing profitable market share growth. So I think what we saw in Q4 was dealers trying to sort that out in October, because a year earlier, if you recall, we had steep depreciation. There was a significant wave of dealers releasing inventory; then early in Q1, they wound up purchasing a lot of cars since they'd sold through too much, and that pushed appreciation higher. So I think this year dealers were somewhat slower to react, which explains why you saw a bit of an inflection in October. However, a downturn hit us during November and December. The positive development is that with the January figures available to us, we're able to identify precisely where our market share is gaining in January. As for February, actual numbers aren't in our hands at this point, yet our confidence regarding February remains strong. Consequently, when it comes to market share, such value fluctuation presents difficulties, and we'll keep addressing it. That's among the factors behind our desire to observe how this situation unfolds across this year prior to revising that target. So with any luck, that context proves useful.
Sharon Zackfia
analystTwo questions, I hope you all don't mind. First, regarding media improved affordability, could you share some metrics on that? It's obvious used car prices are declining, and ideally rates have peaked; so what was roughly the typical loan payment you originated during this quarter compared with, say, the third quarter or some historical reference point, just so we understand how that's getting better for the customer? Then secondly, about that market share dynamic, is there a specific region or demographic group where you've been more vulnerable to losing share because some competitors acted less rationally?
Jon Daniels
executiveSure, Sharon; this is Jon. I'll handle the first one about the loan payment; so essentially, our average used car was $20,000 forever. That meant usually, depending on the interest rate, $400 monthly payment. I think that's a solid round number to keep in mind. With the appreciation you witnessed, a peak probably occurred around later calendar '22 at roughly $570, $580, that was — I believe we mentioned it was mostly caused by that financed amount. I mean rates are climbing, but that finance amount truly was the driver. So that increase, we'd attribute it to perhaps an 85 to 15 split between the finance amount and the interest rate rising. Now as we've mentioned, clearly, the vehicle prices are declining. The financed amount is dropping somewhat, and rates are moving the opposite way. So we'd probably say this quarter, we probably observed approximately a $520, $530 payment, still 2/3 of that driven by that vehicle price still elevated. Now the rate is a larger factor, but hopefully, that provides some perspective on how affordability has gotten somewhat better. Still somewhat of a shock to a consumer that's accustomed to a $400 monthly payment facing a $530 monthly payment; they'll need to figure out how they fit that into their budget going forward; but yes, that hopefully gives you some context.
Bill Nash
executiveSharon, regarding the latter portion of what you asked, it isn't really a geographic distinction. As we've mentioned previously, your Tier 3 buyer — clearly, our Tier 3 volume is far below what it used to be. Households bringing in under $3,000 monthly, those consumers have essentially been reduced by 50%. So without a doubt, that customer with weaker financing and lower incoming income has taken a hit. Yet we're also noticing — and I brought this up during the third quarter, based on collaboration with a credit bureau — that people who ultimately don't purchase had applied for a loan at CarMax, and it isn't as though we're observing significant deterioration where they're turning to a competitor instead. They're simply staying out of the game; and I believe that partly connects to what Jon mentioned a moment ago. Another point I'd like to remind everyone regarding market share: throughout our history, we've consistently expanded market share; it's only during extraordinary situations — look back at the great financial crisis, look at COVID, and I'd include the current stretch — that we've encountered these extremely sharp depreciations. I mean, we experienced 2 this year and 1 last year. We'd simply never encountered these previously. So I believe as we navigate through them, we'll come out the other side. And afterward, as always, we'll keep expanding market share.
Rajat Gupta
analystUnderstood. Excellent. I just wanted to briefly inquire about how the first quarter was shaping up, since you showed or had positive comps during the fourth quarter. Should we anticipate that pattern continuing, because seasonality would suggest comps ought to decline or turn negative once more in the first quarter? But I'm curious what you're observing. Any information you can share with us on that. Then a wider question regarding the long-term targets; it's a 4 — it's nearly a 4-year span, 2026 to 2030. Could you walk through the reasoning behind having such a broad range? And where does the uncertainty actually stem from? Is it demand-related? Or does it come from supply? Additional detail would be useful.
Bill Nash
executiveYes. Thanks for asking, Rajat. Regarding the first question, sort of comp cadence, during the quarter, December, January, negative comps. February delivered a positive comp, producing a positive result for the quarter. After the quarter closed, things have been somewhat choppy. We've observed a bit of softness at present, quarter-to-date, though it's early and again, choppy. At this moment we're seeing roughly a mid-single-digit negative comp. But once more, it's early, and it has been choppy across the last 1.5 months; regarding the second question, the market — oh, the long-range targets. Well, remember, on market share, we'll return at the close of this year and update that; on the units figure, yes, you're correct, it is a broad range. We're going to return and offer more visibility into that once we simply gain a clearer picture of the market recovery. Remember, I believe Cox's most recent figures had this year ending at roughly 35.5 million units, whereas historically, we sit at 40 million. And so I think the expectation for ours is going to be relatively flat, perhaps slightly higher in total used units within the 0 to 10, it might be flat or even rise somewhat less. So I think you're anticipating when it comes to total used units, there's likely more growth among the over 10-year-old vehicles versus the 0 to 10; and so that's something of — we want to obtain some visibility into that, particularly regarding the units. The volatility also factors in, though, since it likewise affects — vehicle volatility factors in since it affects your buy rate, which in the end can affect your wholesale; so as we gain more visibility into this market recovery, we'll return and narrow that time frame for you.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveRight, the expectation isn't that we'll reach the upper bound of that range. What we're really going to do is give visibility once the market has just a little more stability, like building.
Rajat Gupta
analystTo clarify what you said about the 0- to 10-year-old segment. If we consider recent years' new car sales and the leases that came from them, could that 0- to 10-year-old market decline once more in calendar '25 prior to going positive? Since that ought to be pretty apparent, correct, based on what we already know occurred across the last 3, 4 years?
Bill Nash
executiveYes. Regarding the 0 — once more, for the 0 to 10, projections available suggest it will be flat to up a little bit; so let's see how that truly shakes out. The — bear in mind, a new car factor exists here in which fewer vehicles were sold a couple of years ago. Yet once more, I would also point back to — we witnessed larger drops during the great financial crisis. So let's see, projections indicate it will be flat to up a little bit.
Brian Nagel
analystMy first question is about used sales, and maybe a slightly broader view. But I suppose it's largely about the business. Look, you had a positive comp, even if only slightly. You had a positive used car unit comp in Q4. And then, answering the earlier question, you mentioned perhaps some incremental softness in early Q1. But what I want to ask is, as you examine this business, knowing that you don't provide guidance, there are many moving pieces out there. What needs to occur? Because it appears many of the key factors are beginning to shift in a more favorable direction for CarMax, whether that's used car pricing easing, rate stabilization, the data we're seeing, a stronger tax refund season. So I guess, from your perspective, what's the sort of equation, so to speak, for returning to that normalized used car unit comp?
Bill Nash
executiveYes. I believe we've touched on a couple of the main issues. Affordability must keep moving lower. I felt encouraged. I mean, this quarter marked the first occasion in roughly 2 years that we were below a $26,000 average selling price. So that represents progress in the right direction. I think there are many positives out there that you mentioned, such as interest — hopefully interest rates are at minimum stable. And once they begin declining, I think that's certainly a favorable signal too. I think building on some of the things we've been working on, the efficiencies we're pursuing that we've discussed, is the fact that we have sequential improvement. Jon mentioned CAF becoming more of a full credit spectrum lender. There's opportunity there. I think there's opportunity in omni. I mean, we have many good things that are positive, but we do need a little assistance on the affordability side. And I think we also — just that volatility, don't underestimate it. I mean, when you have a year in which you see depreciation of $6,000, keep in mind, we saw some appreciation at the beginning, so it offset some of that; but $6,000 really across 2 different time periods. We simply haven't seen that. And we had another one of those last year, I would call them price corrections. And I think having some visibility into that and stabilizing it. If you get a — we've demonstrated things like continued market share growth over the years, whether it's been appreciation, whether it's been normal depreciation, keep in mind, normally at the end of the year, there is depreciation. It's probably $1,500, $1,600 a year. We've been able to take market share in all those environments. So I think those are the 2 big factors for us.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveBeyond that, there are a few additional signs of demand we've noticed. Once more, web traffic increased during this quarter compared with the same period a year earlier. Applications in finance also climbed again in this quarter. So the indications of demand that we're observing in the market essentially come down to — as we've been discussing — really the matter of affordability.
Brian Nagel
analystThat's quite useful. If I may, just one more quick question. You've discussed — set aside stricter lending criteria for a moment; in the CAF figures, and especially, I believe, in the loan loss provision, we are obviously witnessing the advantages of that. What I'm wondering is this: how much is — are your — what kind of possibility exists that your stricter lending at present is affecting demand for pre-owned vehicles at CarMax?
Jon Daniels
executiveYes, I appreciate that question. I mean, without a doubt, I think that is what our platform gives us, correct? CAF has the ability to tighten, and it can decelerate toward partners who are prepared to — perhaps they will request somewhat additional cash upfront, and the rate will be somewhat greater. Yet they will still have the choice to purchase, and we observe individuals being taken on later. We are extremely cautious when we set rates. And whenever we make any underwriting modifications. We monitor it very closely. We put it through testing. We understand what will be taken on, and we are quite deliberate regarding the sales effect and every choice we make, whether that involves pricing or underwriting. So without a doubt, a handful of individuals may not select that elevated rate or larger down payment from our lenders later on. However, we think, on the whole, they are quite eager, Tier 2 partners are, when CAF declines things, and they can go take them on.
Bill Nash
executiveYeah, but Brian, it's absolutely working against us. What I mean is, we are making things stricter. We have fantastic partners, and they are taking on part of that, yet they aren't taking on all of it. After that, it moves down to Tier 3, and you have observed how our Tier 3 volume looks overall. So without question, the broader tightening across the industry is creating an effect.
Craig Kennison
analystI'd like to ask about sourcing, Bill. The number of cars you purchased dropped by 11%. Depreciation is obviously a challenge, but you've also got these creative new offerings, such as instant offer and MaxOffer, which I believed could deliver something like a secular boost. So regarding instant offer, I'm curious whether you can share anything about appraisal activity in general and buy rates, so we get a sense of how much traction that tool is gaining. Then for MaxOffer, of that 45% growth, even though it comes off a small base, what portion comes from bringing on new dealers as opposed to momentum among the dealers you already have?
Bill Nash
executiveYes. Appreciate that question, Craig. On the — from consumers, again, I believe it's more — I believe when we discuss that decline, it's largely a year-over-year effect. This year's buy rate came in slightly lower than last year's. But remember, a year ago, I believe during the fourth quarter, we experienced roughly $2,000 of appreciation. That didn't happen this quarter. By the time the quarter ended, it was far, far smaller than that. That matters, since consumers invariably believe their vehicles are worth more. When you're able to add more to it, that supports buying. Regarding MaxOffer, that increase is really — well, we've grown the total count of deals. The way we look at it is how many dealers are active. And among the deals we have, we saw roughly a 50% rise in active dealers who are actually using the tools. So that encourages us. We haven't moved into additional areas; we believe there's substantial opportunity to keep pushing this forward, which is what I mentioned earlier during my prepared remarks. It will be a priority for us.
Michael Montani
analystTo kick things off, I just wanted to ask. Looking at this year, is there anything that would stop CarMax from gaining more market share again? And do you have to either give up gross profit per unit or maybe ease credit standards in order to gain share?
Bill Nash
executiveYeah. Look, I think if you cut your prices, you'd definitely move more vehicles; but let me return to what I mentioned before. What I mean is, profitable market share is what we care about. And look, you can observe this with the publicly traded auto retailers — they trade it back and forth, at times units for GPU; and when you examine total comp GPU, it just — that hasn't really been a good call. So we're going to keep testing the elasticity. Obviously, our aim each year is to gain market share. Just from watching depreciation trends, I'm hopeful that this year will bring more normal depreciation and appreciation cycles, but we'll see; and I believe that will be a factor. And once more, I always frame it by saying we will always test the elasticity to determine whether lowering margins makes sense in order to get more units and more total gross profit.
Jon Daniels
executiveWhen it comes to CAF's lending criteria, that's actually something I feel pretty good about. We've made things stricter. Those tighter rules were put in place for a very deliberate purpose. Clearly, we've got partners further down the chain. Yet, as Bill pointed out, tightening at CAF does cost you sales; even so, our view is that the cycle is going to shift. Consumers are going to be in better financial shape. And we're eager to capture additional market share across the whole credit spectrum. So on the far side of this, I'd say it's definitely an opportunity.
Bill Nash
executiveYeah, I feel good about CAF. And I realize the Fed—they've got a call to make about the timing of rate cuts. What I mean is things are steady, and it doesn't seem like they're heading higher. Let me touch wood as I say this; yet once that number drops, it definitely gives us a boost in a few ways—both for CAF and for margins, and for sales too.
Michael Montani
analystAlso, how should we approach that SG&A ratio goal in the mid-70s? Can we realistically get there during this year? Or what's the right way to look at it?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYeah. Regarding the mid-70s, like we've discussed, that's definitely the next stage of our improvement. As far as the year ahead goes, we're going to require robust consumer demand to come back as well. Clearly, that equation contains 2 variables, correct? One is SG&A, and I believe we've achieved quite a bit on that front over the last year, and we'll keep prioritizing it. But for us to reach that mid-70%, we truly need the gross profit figure to speed up. Given where things stand — the unit sales volumes we've seen across the last couple of years — getting there in FY '25 would honestly be a difficult ask.
Bill Nash
executiveAnd plus, I figure, considering their view that things will stay pretty level across the board.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYes. Exactly.
John Healy
analystI wanted to ask a little about wholesale. It's a good spot where we sort of finished the year with GPUs in wholesale. I was curious how you view that business performing in '25 for GPUs, given what's expected with the used car market's sending in terms of values as supply improves. Do you think we can stay at this roughly $1,000 level for some time? And could you discuss a bit what you're doing on the auction side? In your prepared remarks, I think you said you'll build a standalone auction facility, which I believe would be the company's first, maybe where you're taking that business and does separating auctions from the retail location potentially open a new business line you're entering, not just from self-sufficiency but perhaps from revenue?
Bill Nash
executiveYes. Thanks for the questions. On wholesale margin, yes, I was particularly happy with the wholesale margin. Given some of the year-over-year dynamics, the team did an outstanding job. And I think it reflects some of the enhancements we made in our overall auction process with technology, that sort of thing. I think you're thinking about it correctly. If you look at it annually, I think a good target, give or take a little, is comparable to what we ran for the year this year on wholesale margins. So I think you're thinking about that correctly. And I think it reflects a lot of the enhancements we've made in the business. As for the standalone auction facility, it is — it's interesting because we actually have a couple of standalone auction facilities we've built over time, just that are generally located very close to one of the stores for extra capacity. But this — you're right, this will be the first time we've gone out and really built the facility with the intention of it having to be an auction facility. I think going forward, you're going to see some of the standalone auction/production. The one we're talking about for next year is just an auction facility; we may run some logistics hub out there. But right now, it's an auction facility. And it's really going to help us in a couple of different ways. The facility will be close to existing stores; and we'll be able to take wholesale vehicles out of existing stores, allow them to leverage the lots more from a service standpoint, more from a sales standpoint. We're still relocating plenty of vehicles from satellite and XF stores as it is; and bringing them over to this site now is simply going to assist us in keeping up the gains or enhancements at standalone facilities, and I believe those will work out nicely for us down the road. So what we aim to do moving forward is construct additional sites like these, pull more of certain wholesale sales out of the stores so we can open up space, open up capacity that we expect will deliver other advantages to the business, whether that's, hey, you're able to handle slightly more MaxCare retail service. That brings plenty of upside, and on top of that, simply standardizing by having these larger sites situated near stores will likewise enable us to innovate even faster than we've managed so far.
Scot Ciccarelli
analystHere's one more question about market share. Bill, what's your explanation for why share tends to slip when things get chaotic? In the past, the top players across different retail segments have actually sped up their share gains when the market was disrupted. Why does CarMax's approach differ such that it might not see the same outcome?
Bill Nash
executiveWell, when you mention chaotic stretches, I'm thinking of the 3 of them — the Great Recession comes to mind, and COVID too. What we're up to now looks somewhat different. Lately, it's the vehicle volatility I mentioned before. When the system gets hit with steep depreciation in a brief window, you know the way we operate the model. We ask ourselves, should we cut our prices? Does that work out better on the profitability side overall? What we've found is it simply doesn't work out that way, and that's the reason we keep margins where they are. Of course, plenty of rivals don't operate that way. They act in whatever way suits their business. Their demands differ. They've got credit lines, that sort of thing. So they must act in whatever way suits their business, and we must act in whatever way suits ours. So you'll notice — this year we've noticed that while we keep prices where they are and others are clearing out inventory for one reason or another, we — are essentially surrendering market share.
Scot Ciccarelli
analystSo speaking in broad terms, is that really the correct call as time goes on? I get that you're able to lock in greater earnings. Yet if your aim is to be a growth vehicle, and that's what you've been for more than 20 years — I believe you mentioned 38 — is it right to essentially stand firm on pricing and safeguard profit? Or ought you to be chasing market share? I'm simply curious, philosophically, what your thinking is on that.
Bill Nash
executiveYes. No, I mean, that's a fair question. And clearly, in a philosophical sense, we believe, look, the purchasing cycle runs 5 years. And who — had you posed that question to me back at the start of this year, do you figure there could be a price correction? My answer would be possibly, yes, likely one more price correction following last year. I didn't anticipate 2 price corrections. I can't see this kind of environment being something that repeats itself annually. These are, in my view, quite unusual conditions. So I do believe that in the near term, this is the correct approach; it isn't as though this will keep happening again and again. Were that the case, then we'd reconsider the business model. But I simply think we hold the view that this is the proper step.
Ian Davis
analystThis is Ian Davis, filling in for Chris. Over the past few years, outside of the Tier 2 and Tier 3 pilot, it looks like you've leaned more on warehouse facilities than on ABS; so I was hoping you might go into a bit more detail on how the average FICO expected losses on loans sitting in those warehouse facilities stack up against what you'd see for similar loans and ABS facilities?
Jon Daniels
executiveSure. Yes, I'll handle that one, Ian. Yes, I mean, I believe you mentioned leaving out Tier 2 and Tier 3, so what we're really discussing is the Tier 1 business. Yes, I mean, generally our approach is to pull all the Tier 1 volume into our warehouse facilities, and our aim would be to eventually place all of it into the ABS market. Now at a basic level, there are items you have to trim away. There are specific standards they have to satisfy. A title is required, the first payment has to have been made, and so on. So some of the riskier loans are going to drop out. That's inevitable. But our aim is to shift all of that volume from originations through the warehouse and into ABS. Naturally, given those exclusions, the FICO on the ABS deals is probably going to be somewhat higher. If you examine deal after deal after deal, that shift in FICO stems from us altering what we originate and that eventually working its way through. Keep in mind, once we originate a loan, it takes 6, 7 months before it lands in an ABS deal. But that longer-term movement in ABS is really what we're underwriting, and probably not so much what we're holding out for in a warehouse line.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveWhen you look at overall capacity, using the ABS market is definitely how we fund this business most efficiently. Beyond that, as you mentioned, we've expanded funding that isn't ABS-based through our banking partners. Our banking partners are outstanding, and we've established some facilities — added more of them there. Several years back we discussed this, about bridging out and keeping alternative finance options available as the business keeps growing. That's exactly what we've carried out.
Ian Davis
analystUnderstood, that helps. And if I might squeeze in one more item — we came across something saying CarMax could be doing away with its 30-day return policy. Does that hold any water? If so, might you frame how significant dropping that policy would be for earnings? And maybe whatever else you can share about how customers value it, or whether they actually use it — anything along those lines would be useful.
Bill Nash
executiveRight. What you're bringing up is our 30-day money back guarantee. We are changing it to 10 days money back, and that remains best in the industry. The reason really comes down to some experiential headwind, for customers and associates alike, and that also brings higher expenses when you consider that most of our customers — many of our customers use it long before those 30 days are up. Once you're beyond the 10, a few folks are simply gaming the process. With others, we bump into headwinds involving DMVs and municipalities getting title work squared away, checks back, taxes back, that sort of thing. So I believe that's what you mean.
Ian Davis
analystYes, that's correct.
Chris Pierce
analystI simply wanted to inquire, are we positioned for yet another stretch of outsized depreciation within the wholesale market, since as tax refund season arrives — and honestly, we've kind of already moved past it on the wholesale side — there will be the usual depreciation. But are we lined up for additional outsized depreciation, and what could put a cap on outsized depreciation? Because from what I can gather, dealers are already holding smaller inventories than what's typical. So how — is there any action the industry could take to fight that? Or do we just have to accept that outsized depreciation, since we need to return to a $22,000 average used car?
Bill Nash
executiveYes. Chris, what you're describing as outsized depreciation isn't really what I'm seeing. What I'm actually seeing is depreciation that aligns more closely with what you'd observe from 2015 to 2019. In fact, if you look at it, it's even appreciating somewhat more. Then again, your average sales price sits higher. Only recently have we begun to witness some depreciation. So I haven't observed what you're calling outsized depreciation. And my sense is we might experience a more historical pattern of appreciation and depreciation across the year, but we'll find out.
Chris Pierce
analystIs that due to reduced dealer volumes or stock levels? Or does that explain why you're confident you'll witness that — no unusual depreciation this year, unlike what happened last year?
Bill Nash
executiveWell, I'm only basing this on observations from calendar year-to-date and stacking them against historical norms. Over the past 2 or 3 years, things have swung wildly regarding both appreciation and depreciation. If you set those years aside and examine a more historical period, say 2015 to 2019, how does the depreciation curve appear? How does the interpolate data appear? I'd say this year, calendar year-to-date is tracking more closely with what those cycles resemble. So that's what I mean.
John Murphy
analystI'd like to hear your thoughts on how sales broke down between vehicles aged 0 to 6 years and those aged 7 to 10 years during the quarter, and perhaps how that compares with the same period a year ago. As we look ahead, barring some huge economic surge that nobody is really forecasting, it appears that throughout '24 and '25, the population of cars in the 0 to 6 range will keep getting smaller, and that's a supply problem on your end — unless you tilt somewhat more toward the 7- to 10-year-old group, which would also be a big help on affordability. So it strikes me there might be a modest strategic adjustment available here that could ease some of the pressures we're dealing with. I'd be curious to hear your take on that too. So first the mix, and then the idea of leaning a bit more into 7 to 10s.
Bill Nash
executiveYes. So when I look at the quarter, comparing 0 to 4 against, say, 5 plus, we came in about the same as a year ago. We skewed a little older than we did in the third quarter. So I'd say our mix is — it's interesting. It's nearly an even split, 50 to 50, between 0 to 4 and 5 plus. If I look at 0 to 6 versus 7 plus, it's — a year ago, it's quite comparable. Roughly a 70 to 30 split, with 0- to 6-year-old at 70% and 7-plus at 30% for us. Last quarter was slightly — and I noted last quarter that we'd seen somewhat of a shift toward some newer cars. So last quarter leaned a bit more toward 0 to 6 than what we're seeing this quarter. And I think, look, going forward, and I said this earlier, you're right that when it comes to new cars, a year or 2 year ago, not as many new cars were sold. But again, I'd just point out that you're still right around a 15-plus million SAAR run rate, which is far above what we experienced coming out of the great financial crisis. And another thing I'd note is that our self-sufficiency for a couple of years now, measured on a yearly basis, keeps coming in above 70%, which we never had before, and we view that as a strong tailwind. So from our standpoint, supply really hasn't been the problem — it's price; now you might argue, well, the supply of vehicles overall in the market is driving price higher, but our capacity to source inventory hasn't been the problem. It's more about the price.
John Murphy
analystUnderstood. Then I have a single additional question regarding the procurement channel you mentioned. You noted that dealer sourcing rose by 21,000 units, roughly 45% compared with the same period last year during the quarter. Do you believe that figure might grow? I mean, I think there's a worry that vehicles, late-model vehicles, move deeper into the pipeline since openly, Manheim, and ATB each assist through their virtual auctions to keep vehicles deeper in the pipeline. Yet it seems you actually contradict that given the rise in dealer sourcing. What size of an opportunity do you believe dealer sourcing might represent over time, or perhaps a danger if they retain more vehicles?
Bill Nash
executiveYes. Look, the MaxOffer pleases me. I mean, we keep purchasing additional vehicles for it. We believe it's an excellent product that genuinely connects with dealers. And if you examine the blend of vehicles we purchase, it's in fact weighted more toward retail than wholesale, and that's a massive advantage. I think it's an extremely competitive product. And as I mentioned, we have plenty of dealers actively utilizing it, and we intend to keep promoting that. And when we discussed — we have historically discussed self-sufficiency. We have always discussed it from the perspective of only the consumers. Well, it truly ought to begin incorporating this category too, which, once more, simply assists in keeping our self-sufficiency extremely elevated.
David Bellinger
analystPerhaps I could ask something further regarding what we just discussed, specifically sourcing pre-owned vehicles straight from individual sellers. Could you describe what condition those cars tend to be in? Do they differ in any significant way from what you'd find at auction? And broadly speaking, at this moment, does the supply coming from consumers in that $20,000 to $25,000 bracket feel sufficient? Or would you characterize it more as a narrow window of opportunity?
Bill Nash
executiveYes. In fact, I felt good about it, since during this quarter, when you examine our unit sales, under 20% — that is, cars priced below $20,000 — although compared with the same period a year earlier, the figure was comparable. It genuinely came in stronger than what we saw in the third quarter. As a result, we moved a greater number of vehicles under $20,000. Regarding how those cars appear when sourced from individual owners, purchasing from consumers delivers an enormous advantage. What I mean is, you're acquiring vehicles that folks in that particular market typically favor; and the reason this matters for self-sufficiency is that such units generate better margins than ones you'd have to bring in from elsewhere. And when you must go out and obtain every vehicle from outside sources, that channel proves costly; fortunately, we enjoy the advantage of such strong self-sufficiency that we only need to seek vehicles from outside sources in a restricted manner.
David Bellinger
analystUnderstood. And one more quick follow-up, if I may, regarding your quarter-to-date remark about down mid-single digit. Has anything actually shifted that would account for that move away from positive comps in February — perhaps some tax refund flows played a role — but also, could there simply be some hesitancy among consumers given sharper price depreciation recently? And should that be the case, what kind of duration might we expect?
Bill Nash
executiveYes. I believe it simply — it likely just reflects the consumer. My sense is the consumer remains in a difficult position. The tax season — on the whole, this year's tax season has come in somewhat softer; even though refunds are larger, the actual dollar amounts of those refunds are bigger, the total count of refunds trails where it stood a year ago; and despite prices declining, clearly, interest rates sit higher than they did 12 months back. I think consumers still face pressure on all the other things they're essentially purchasing — food and housing — with inflationary pressure there. So I think it reflects more the consumer mindset right now. And as I mentioned, it's been choppy. I mean there's been a — some weather-related events have occurred. It's just — a lot has been happening. So we'll keep watching and make adjustments where we can as we move forward.
David Whiston
analystI've got a two-part question regarding affordability. You said ASPs keep dropping, and that's a positive. Still, at this stage, do buyers even register those reduced ASPs? Is their attention completely on the unfavorable monthly payment because of interest rates? Then, regarding that trade-offs scenario around affordability, is the consumer shifting into cars rather than light trucks? Or is it mostly a move into vehicles older than 5 years?
Bill Nash
executiveYes. Well, for consumers, I believe the monthly payment has always been the central issue. Prices are declining. As Jon mentioned, the actual monthly payment is declining too, yet it remains over $100 higher than it previously was. So when a consumer considers purchasing a car, suppose they currently have a car. Well, they're paying a particular monthly amount. Then suddenly, they take a look and say, "Okay, well, I'm ready to swap out." They're like, oh my gosh, I'd need to pay an additional $100; that's where we're noticing it. And again, plenty of data points indicate consumers are simply waiting on the sidelines at the moment, either for monthly payments to decline or to find a way to fit it into their budget alongside all the other expenses. So I think that's what you're seeing. Was there another portion of your question?
David Whiston
analystYes. Are they additionally shifting away from light trucks and toward cars? Or do they simply have their attention on an older vehicle in an effort to...
Bill Nash
executiveThat's interesting. If you examine the figures for the quarter, in terms of class, we truly sold more — from a mix perspective — of the bigger SUVs, the pricier kind of cars. Currently the average age, for both our wholesale and retail, has risen compared with what you've sold. Yet it isn't the case that they're opting for compact over larger SUV types, at least not during the quarter.
David Whiston
analystAll right. Does it concern you that the shortage of off-lease vehicles could intensify once we hit the anniversary of when the chip shortage began?
Bill Nash
executiveIt does. You know, vehicles coming off lease have never represented a major part of how we source our inventory. I mean — we've gone through cycles in the past when leased cars were available, and we've also gone through cycles when they weren't. My sense is we've been in a period where leased cars really haven't been available, since many manufacturers insist that lease customers bring the vehicle back to the franchise dealer. We have customers who want to sell us a leased vehicle, and those restrictions prevent us from purchasing them; and honestly, it's — my view is this has been a nice windfall for the franchise dealers, because they can acquire these vehicles at a favorable rate base from leases that were essentially originated some time ago. That situation will run its course and stop being as much of a windfall as we move forward. But historically, it simply hasn't been a significant source of inventory for us.
Bill Nash
executiveOkay, so first off, I'd like to express my gratitude to each of you for being here on this call today. Clearly, there's a great deal happening on our end. And we truly value the questions you've raised along with the backing you've shown. Just before wrapping up, once more, I'd like to offer my congratulations to every one of our associates on the recognition as a Great Place to Work, which marks the 20th consecutive year for that honor. That's something all of us take real pride in, and it genuinely reflects our people and the culture they've done so much to strengthen and bring to life here at CarMax. So, I appreciate the time you've given us today, and we'll be speaking again in the next quarter.
Operator
operatorThank you. That wraps up this conference call covering CarMax's earnings release for Q4 of Fiscal Year 2024, everyone. You're free to hang up at this point.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete CarMax, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to CarMax, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in CarMax, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.