CarMax, Inc. (KMX) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
June 21, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
David Lowenstein
executiveThanks, Savannah. Morning, everybody. I appreciate you being on the call for our first quarter of fiscal 2025 results. Joining me are Bill Nash, who serves as our President and CEO; Enrique Mayor-Mora, our Executive Vice President and CFO; and Jon Daniels, our Senior Vice President, CarMax Auto Finance Operations. I want to note that anything we say today that isn't a statement of historical fact — including statements about future business plans, prospects and financial performance for the company — counts as forward-looking statements made under the safe harbor provisions of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Such statements rest on what we currently know, expect and assume, and they carry substantial risks and uncertainties that might cause actual results to differ materially from what we expect. When we give projections and other forward-looking statements, we disclaim any intent or obligation to update them; for more detail on important factors that could affect these expectations, please see our Form 8-K filed with the SEC this morning and our annual report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended February 29, 2024, as previously filed with the SEC. If any follow-up questions come up after the call, please reach out to our Investor Relations department at (804) 747 to 0422, extension 7865. <<operator_script>> Bill?
Bill Nash
executiveOkay, thanks, David. Morning, everybody, and I appreciate you being here. Through the quarter, positive trends persisted, among them year-over-year price declines, better vehicle value stability, and continued expansion in upper funnel demand. What we're seeing gives us encouragement, and we keep making our business stronger by producing associate and customer wins that are both differentiated and durable. During Q1, we achieved strong retail and wholesale GPUs and expanded EPP margins; roughly 35,000 vehicles came from dealers, which set an all-time record. Used saleable inventory units rose 5% year-over-year, while used total inventory units fell 4%. CAF income increased 7% year-over-year amid tight lending standards; and after the quarter closed, we introduced our first non-prime securitization deal; we keep actively managing SG&A, and more than $100 million in shares were repurchased. In Q1 of FY '25, our diversified business model produced total sales of $7.1 billion, a 7% decline versus last year, driven by lower retail and wholesale volume and prices. Within retail, total unit sales dropped 3.1%, and average selling price fell roughly $700 per unit, or 3% year-over-year. Used unit comps declined 3.8%, and comp performance got stronger in the back half of Q1. Retail gross profit per used unit in Q1 came to $2,347, consistent with last year's $2,361. Wholesale unit sales fell 8.3% against Q1 last year, as the industry saw less seasonal appreciation year-over-year. Average selling price fell about $900 per unit, or 10%. Wholesale gross profit per unit hit a first quarter record at $1,064, versus $1,042 a year ago. We acquired roughly 314,000 vehicles in the quarter, 9% fewer than last year. The appreciation dynamics I mentioned a moment ago also affected our overall buys; roughly 279,000 vehicles were purchased from consumers, and slightly more than half of those buyers came via our online instant appraisal experience. With help from our Edmunds sales team, the remaining roughly 35,000 vehicles were sourced through dealers, a 70% increase from last year. On Q1 online metrics, about 14% of retail unit sales happened online, consistent with last year. Adoption of our omnichannel retail experience keeps progressing. Omni sales accounted for approximately 57% of retail unit sales this quarter, versus 54% in the prior year. Total revenue from online transactions was about 30%, in line with last year. Every one of our Q1 wholesale auctions and sales was virtual and counts as an online transaction, representing 18% of total revenue for the quarter. CarMax Auto Finance, or CAF, posted income of $147 million, up 7% from the same period last year. In a few minutes, Jon will give more detail on customer financing, the loan loss provision, CAF contribution, and our progress toward becoming a full spectrum — full credit spectrum lender, which enables incremental growth in finance income. Right now, I want to hand things over to Enrique, and he's going to give you additional details about how we did financially in the first quarter. Enrique?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveThanks, Bill. Morning, everyone. Bill already noted that we posted strong per-unit margins for the quarter in both used and wholesale, plus we recorded gains in other gross profit margins and CAF contribution, and we stayed focused on SG&A management. Q1 diluted net earnings per share landed at $0.97, versus $1.44 in the same quarter a year ago. Remember that last year's quarter carried a $59 million gain — $0.28 per share — tied to a legal settlement. Gross profit totaled $792 million overall, down 3% from Q1 of last year. Used retail margin came in at $495 million, a 4% decline, driven by softer volume along with per-unit margins that held roughly steady. Our wholesale vehicle margin landed at $157 million, a 6% decline driven by reduced volumes, though higher per-unit margins provided some offset. Other gross profit reached $139 million, up 3% versus the same period last year. The gain stemmed from an $8 million bump in EPP. Keep in mind that in Q4 of FY '24, we ran a test on increasing MaxCare margins per contract, and while product penetration rate ended up lower, overall product profitability improved as a result. After that test, we rolled out those margin increases late in Q4 FY '24. Service added $3 million in margin, matching the prior year's first quarter. Efficiency and cost coverage initiatives were the primary drivers, partially counterbalanced by deleverage stemming from weaker year-over-year sales during the quarter and by timing. Assuming our sales results hold up, we expect to see improvement compared with last year across the remaining quarters, because of how service carries both leverage and deleverage effects. Now on SG&A: first quarter costs came to $639 million, which is up 3%, or $19 million, versus the same quarter a year ago, once you strip out the $59 million legal settlement benefit that we recorded in the first quarter of FY '24. Another item that pressured SG&A in this quarter was about $22 million in share-based compensation expense tied to certain executives who are retirement-eligible, plus the fact that last year's first quarter included favorable reserve adjustments for non-CAF uncollectible receivables that we are now lapping. Leaving those things out — the ones we brought up during our FY '24 year-end call — total SG&A dollars came in lower than the prior year in Q1, which reflects how we keep holding the line on spending. Two other things largely shaped first-quarter SG&A dollars. One: other overhead increased $6 million once you set aside the favorable legal settlement from a year ago. Favorability in non-CAF uncollectible receivables versus last year was more than canceled out as we cycled past last year's first-quarter favorable reserve adjustment. Two: total compensation and benefits, not counting share-based compensation expense, dropped $3 million, largely because we remain focused on efficiency in stores and CECs. When it comes to how we're deploying capital, we bought back roughly 1.4 million shares this quarter, spending $104 million in total — a faster pace than what we did in the back half of fiscal year '24. We closed the quarter with about $2.3 billion still available under our repurchase authorization. Also in Q1, we paid off the $300 million floating rate term loan that was set to mature in early June. With that, I'll turn things over to Jon.
Jon Daniels
executiveAppreciate that, Enrique, and good morning to all of you. In Q1, CarMax Auto Finance wrote about $2.3 billion, which produced a 43.3% sales penetration rate net of 3-day payoffs — a figure that rose 60 basis points versus the first quarter of last year. New customers were charged a weighted average contract rate of 11.4%, which is 30 basis points higher than twelve months earlier. During the quarter, Partner Tier 2 penetration came in at 18.7%, a decline from the 20.4% seen a year ago. Partner Tier 3 volume represented 7.5% of sales, climbing from 6.7% a year ago, since our partners' better offers were available throughout Q1. Application volume fell year-over-year in both tiers, as customers with lower credit scores continue to struggle with affordability. Also affecting these year-over-year figures, though to a smaller extent, are CAF's ongoing reduced Tier 3 volume and greater test volume in Tier 2. CAF income reached $147 million for the quarter, $10 million above the prior-year period, largely because total interest margin grew. Keep in mind that fair market value adjustments tied to our hedging strategy created $3 million of expense this quarter, versus $9 million of expense in last year's first quarter. Net interest margin percentage came to 6.2% for the quarter, higher than last quarter yet consistent with the roughly 6% we anticipated. The loan loss provision was unchanged from a year ago at $81 million, producing a reserve balance of $493 million, or 2.79% of receivables, against 2.78% at the close of last quarter. CAF's ongoing investment in Tier 2, offset by the tightening already carried out in Tier 1, helped keep the reserve-to-receivable ratio steady. As we noted last quarter, CAF has been developing the capability and infrastructure needed to scale its participation across every credit tier. To start, CAF has drawn on what it learned in Tier 2, plus its experience running in both Tier 1 and Tier 3, to build a new full-spectrum underwriting model that we'll start testing in the second quarter. On the funding side, we intend to grow our existing asset-backed securitization program from one platform into one that incorporates CAF receivables more broadly across separate prime and non-prime segments. We think this lets us match our offering more closely to each investor base and, in the end, create additional funding capacity. Along those lines, our inaugural non-prime ABS transaction is now in the market, with $625 million of offered notes. Being able to both successfully decision and efficiently fund the full credit spectrum at scale positions CAF strategically to further complement our complete roster of lending partners while also generating more finance income for the business; I'll now hand the call back to Bill.
Bill Nash
executiveAlright, thanks. Like I said before, the pricing and vehicle value stability trends we're seeing give us reason for optimism. The lasting steps we've taken to bolster our business and set our offerings further apart make me proud — they're positioning us for ongoing gains in how we perform and for growth down the road. A few illustrations: we've grown our ability to source vehicles by drawing additional dealers to MaxOffer through product upgrades that simplify usage; we hit a record sourcing volume in each month of the quarter and look forward to bringing this capability to New York in the second quarter. We've grown used saleable inventory units while bringing total used inventory units down, thanks to cuts enabled by new title management capabilities and focused inventory management at nonproduction stores; we've strengthened our ability to operate as a full-spectrum lender, which puts us in position to keep growing CAF income over time. We've lifted our EPP margins and made service gross profit better. We've realized efficiency gains at our stores and CECs that will scale nicely as we buy and sell additional cars. Through Edmunds, we've introduced a number of EV research tools to help educate consumers and build their trust. We've also set up test stores in California to assess new capabilities that bolster our operational readiness for higher EV sales and also improve the customer experience. Last, we've kept making our omnichannel capabilities even better. Our new order processing system is being rolled out to our stores, and we expect it to be available nationwide later this year. The system assists associates in guiding customers through every step of the buying journey and delivers a smoother experience for consumers who like to blend self-progression with help from associates. Beyond those steps, we're intent on pushing cost of goods sold lower by chasing incremental efficiency chances we've spotted throughout our logistics network and reconditioning operations. On logistics, we're piloting a transportation management system that dispatches moves via a centralized team. The system automates communication between drivers and stores and offers new planning and execution capabilities. On reconditioning, we've found chances to cut costs, including parts acquisition, moving elements of sublet work in-house and optimizing production workflow. Moreover, we think that balancing production capacity across our stores and stand-alone reconditioning centers will generate additional efficiencies and possibly let us take on more MaxCare work over time. Every one of these steps keeps putting us in a stronger, better spot to support consumers and fuels our excitement about future growth in sales and profitability. With that, we're happy to take your questions. Savannah?
John Healy
analystBill, for you folks I'd like to begin right at the top of the funnel, specifically regarding same-store sales. My recollection is you noted that comp trends got better as Q1 progressed. I'd really like to hear your perspective on how they got better and what you're observing right now; then, following up on that, how do you address the share question? Since I believe that's the number one thing investors raise — we see these figures for CarMax, but how do you believe you're doing in the market relative to peers? And should a gap exist, how would you account for it?
Bill Nash
executiveThanks, John. Regarding your first question, what I believe you're getting at is essentially comp cadence. So once more, looking back at the fourth quarter — on the last call, midway through that quarter, our comps were running negative by a mid-single-digit amount. Clearly, the latter half of that quarter outperformed the first half, and that gave us encouragement. Then, looking at June month to date for the new quarter, we've also kept — we keep witnessing somewhat better performance, and in fact for June month to date we're running slightly positive on comps. So that ongoing improvement is encouraging to us. When it comes to market share data, looking at the year's first 3 calendar months, for which we had the title data 4, we're higher in the first calendar quarter of '24 than in the fourth quarter of calendar 2023. We also came in similar to where we stood a year ago in the first quarter — calendar quarter; and just as a reminder, across the last 2, 4 quarters, we've had significant price corrections. And so that's — this one was comparable. We sort of bottomed out in December, we're climbing back up. It appears we're rising at roughly the same pace as a year ago. Thus, market share year-over-year is roughly comparable. Regarding market share, look, there's considerable volatility on short periods. And absent any other major price correction, my intention isn't really to discuss market share once more until the year is over, because already, we're seeing — we have certain markets up, certain markets down. I think examining it across a longer stretch of time is the right way to view it. So once more, I'll provide another update at year's end, unless some major macro factor emerges that has a disproportionate impact on it. But the trends leave us feeling good.
Seth Basham
analystMy questions have several parts, and they're about cash. To start, when we look at how losses are trending along with your reserves, we keep seeing greater losses in the securitized portfolio, and your reserves appeared somewhat thin. Do you believe you'll need to set aside reserves more aggressively should those loss trends keep going? Then, second, with a non-prime securitization program now in place, how fast can you increase Tier 2 and Tier 3 lending?
Jon Daniels
executiveYes, thanks for asking, Seth. Regarding losses and delinquencies during the quarter, I'd say that by and large, we're very much where we thought we'd be for the quarter. And I believe the provision shows that, with year-over-year essentially unchanged. When you look at our reserved receivable ratio, it's flat on a sequential basis. Of course, we put out data every quarter. Keep in mind, that represents about 60% of our portfolio; but once again, the trends are what we expected. And remember, this quarter tends to be one with high volume, so your actual provision will usually be greater since you've originated more, and it also tends to be a quarter with lower credit quality due to tax time as well. So I'll add that. But mostly, it was a nonevent for us when it comes to delinquency and losses, since it matched our expectations exactly. On your second question, how fast can we increase the Tier 2 and Tier 3 volume? I think the simpler way to respond is to anchor to what we originate now. So 43% of sales, more or less, at any given point is largely what we're doing now. The vast majority, obviously, sits in Tier 1. In Tier 3, we used to be bigger, but we're at a small piece because we're really putting investment into Tier 2 and trying to understand it; it's in the higher portion of Tier 2. Our non-prime securitization program has us really excited. We believe it's truly going to allow growth both at the lower end of the credit spectrum, so we can capture a larger percentage of sales, and also to expand what we do at the higher end, in what we call our higher prime segment; so we're looking forward to that. Now when it comes to ramping and the timing of the ramp, I'd say in the near term, perhaps for the rest of the year, we're going to keep just learning about the Tier 2 space; we're going to roll out our new models — sorry, test our new models in the quarter; we're going to start learning about the entirety of the Tier 2 spectrum. And that will take some time; and as we grow that, we will certainly let folks know. But past that, we do think there's room for us to grow beyond 43%. Will it be 45%, 47%, 50%, remains to be seen, the timing of how much and when. Even so, our view is that it's sizeable, yet likely won't contribute a great deal beyond what we're already achieving at present through the remainder of the year.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveLooking further out too, as you evaluate things, as you consider our funding capacity, as you consider us moving into this market — which has us genuinely enthusiastic — that's likely an additional $2 billion to $3 billion in funding capacity we'll be providing ourselves, considering how far we can ultimately reach as time goes on. So this program is truly an exciting one, and going forward we anticipate pushing our financing income up incrementally.
David Bellinger
analystThis relates to costs. When you examine advertising expenditures divided by total units, my understanding is that figure rose roughly 5% compared to the same period last year, whereas your outlook had suggested it would stay relatively flat. Could you perhaps explain any shifts you're observing on that advertising spending line? And more broadly, what's the right way for us to think about SG&A figures for Q2 as well as across the remainder of the year?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveI appreciate the question. What I'd say is that this is fairly harmless, correct? My view is that from one quarter to the next, you'll see it tick up in one period and dip somewhat in another when measured against total units, and that's simply how we oversee our overall advertising budget. So I'd regard it as nothing more than ordinary shifts between quarters. That said, we remain dedicated to keeping it at approximately $200 for each total unit across the rest of the year — actually, for the full year.
David Bellinger
analystWhat's the outlook for SG&A over the remainder of the year?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveRegarding the rest of the year — apologies, could you say the question once more?
David Bellinger
analystYeah. Then regarding the second item, broadly speaking, total SG&A expense dollars. How ought we to view that amount for the rest of the year?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYeah. For the full year, I'd say our attention is squarely on the first quarter, and we take real pride in this: after you strip away a few of those distortions I mentioned, SG&A actually declined compared with a year earlier. For the remaining portion of the year, my expectation is that on a total dollar basis, it will prove somewhat tougher. What I want to stress once more, though, is where our attention sits. Our attention sits on using aggressive cost control to place ourselves where we can gain leverage from gross profit growth in the low single digits. That is genuinely where our attention sits. So if you consider our position across the last several years, during that stretch of substantial investment, the picture looks quite different, correct? It really points to our shifting toward a cost structure that is somewhat more fixed, plus a capacity to gain leverage once sales arrive, and arrive they will. That's the way we regard our capacity to leverage going forward.
Brian Nagel
analystTwo things, and I'll combine them. First, on that initial non-prime securitization — I believe this follows up on what Seth asked earlier — but when we consider this step, what does WAM replication look like for CarMax over a longer horizon? Could this serve as a tool to generate stronger share, stronger profitability, or both? Again, how should we view the model adjusting now that we have this ability? Then my second item, which is separate. You continue to highlight vehicles sourced from dealers. My question is whether that can be sustained, plus what possible benefits it brings for margins or for other sourcing.
Jon Daniels
executiveBrian, thanks for asking. I'll address the first one regarding the non-prime securitization. Sure, I'll keep tying us back to roughly 43% of sales, as I said, and we believe there's meaningful volume we could capture beyond that level. The clearest way to convey the scale of the long-term value is this: under today's financial conditions and today's economics, each single point of sales we're able to capture should generate between $10 million and $12 million in value for CarMax. Keep in mind, though, that doesn't materialize on day 1 once you start adding that volume. At the outset, you're originating that extra volume, and you have to provision for loan losses. Over time, though, it turns accretive. Once you reach steady state, that's when the $10 million to $12 million figure applies. So, as you'd expect, each additional point you take on adds more value for CarMax. And over the long term, we view it as quite substantial and something we're eager to pursue.
Bill Nash
executiveAbsolutely. Now, regarding the second thing you asked about, Brian — dealer sourcing — the way we see it, we're focused on getting vehicles from any place we can. Historically, our approach has been to source them via consumers. After that, whatever we can't obtain from consumers, we've purchased at auctions held off-site. This represents simply one more move toward diversification. We purchase from consumers. We're able to purchase straight from dealers. And for those we're acquiring via dealers, the bulk of that is somewhat different from what we've bought via consumers. Among those, a larger share are retail cars that come to us from dealers. So even though they aren't as profitable as the ones acquired from consumers, they're definitely more profitable than what we'd have to go off-site to get. So that gives us encouragement. We believe this is a space where we can keep expanding. The feedback we're receiving from dealers is excellent. We've implemented some platform enhancements, which I believe partly explains the ongoing demand you're seeing; and comparing a year ago with today, the number of dealers actively utilizing it has risen by, let's say, approximately 50% over the past year. And honestly, we haven't really added — I mean, a few additional markets came on, but truly not that many more markets. So that gives us encouragement.
Sharon Zackfia
analystI suppose this relates to the sales gains you've been posting. In other words, do you attribute it to wider sector trends, or is there something you're doing operationally? I realize the top of the funnel is clearly growing while conversion has slipped somewhat. Has that begun to turn around for you? And if it has, roughly where and for what reason?
Bill Nash
executiveYes. Thanks for asking, Sharon. See, I'd say it's several factors combined. I believe it speaks to a few of the ongoing internal efforts on our part. Yet it's also — see, vehicle prices, despite rising quarter-over-quarter, and they always climb from the fourth to the first, came in $700 lower year-over-year. Thus vehicle values appear somewhat more steady. Take depreciation trends, for instance — over the past 2 years, they swing wildly, ranging from appreciation to depreciation, and both directions are steep. This year feels a bit more, as I'd put it, typical, even though there's a variance in the first quarter last year. To build on a few points I made earlier, a year ago, we witnessed appreciation during this initial stretch of the year of roughly $2,500. Then we saw depreciation of about $1,100 this year. Ours rose only around $1,000, after which it was roughly level by the quarter's close. So you get some year-over-year effects. Still, once more, simply the stability in values, that's welcome. I mean we've forever operated in a setting featuring appreciation and depreciation. What's hit us harder across the last 1.5 years, 2 years would be those sizable price corrections. So I'd call it a mix of factors.
Rajat Gupta
analystThanks. Bill, I wanted to ask about strategy and operations. As everyone can probably tell from the hard numbers on unit comps and market share, CarMax isn't performing at the level it once did historically. And when you look at margins and EBITDA per unit, once you back out the onetime items for this quarter, there's been no movement or gain. So I'm wondering whether you believe the approach you're currently taking on sourcing, plus how omnichannel has affected the culture inside your stores — whether all of that remains the correct path? Or do you feel something has to shift? Is the plan basically just to wait and count on the sector's conditions to improve, so that CarMax can make gains across these measurements — especially since some publicly traded competitors are doing better?
Bill Nash
executiveYeah, Rajat. Honestly, I have a lot of confidence in the strategy. I have a lot of confidence in everything you brought up. What has really defined our situation, I'd say, is what you've witnessed across the past 18 months, and it's centered far more on those significant price adjustments and the market dynamics, plus the reality that from an affordability perspective, we're selling high-quality, late-model vehicles. When you examine the figures, what stands out is that during the past two years, a growing number of vehicles older than ten years have been sold in this market. My understanding is that the first calendar quarter shows the same pattern. So as I see it, the pressures on our business have stemmed largely from broader macroeconomic forces, yet we have definitely not simply sat around hoping conditions would improve. Instead, we have focused on strengthening ourselves. I believe those benefits will keep flowing back to us. They will yield returns down the road as sales recover. Bear in mind that the used car exchange totaled $35.5 million last year. Usually, that figure sits above $40 million, and those under six years old make up the hardest-hit portion of that population. Once more, it comes down to what people can afford, so our approach gives us a lot of confidence, and the lasting steps I mentioned that we've already put in place give us that same confidence—those will keep paying off for us down the road.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveOne thing I want to highlight too — and Bill mentioned this during his prepared remarks — is that we're pursuing reconditioning costs hard, pursuing logistics costs hard and getting them lower. Looking ahead, those are significant items that we expect can help sales and help margin, both of them. So those have us excited; so Rajat, it comes down to also aggressively pursuing whatever sits within our control, and that is within our control.
Bill Nash
executiveOne more point I'd make on that, Rajat: after going through something like this, your goal is to come out of it a stronger, better business. So should the same thing occur down the road, what would we change. A few of the items we've already covered — broadening where we source from. Enrique just mentioned the real emphasis on cost of goods sold. Jon brought up the financing side. To my mind, the financing doesn't just let us grow CAF income, I believe it also opens a chance to grow units, since there appear to be smaller pockets our partners may not be capturing that look like genuinely good little pockets we can now pursue. Take the work we've done on variable cost — many of those factors, the EPP, the increase, all of them also feed into the elasticity equation when you're figuring out whether to cut prices or hold them steady; so once more, we've learned plenty. We've made quite a few improvements. So if that situation has to come together, our tool chest holds more tools.
Rajat Gupta
analystSo, regarding what you said about June — would it be reasonable to think those favorable patterns you're observing will simply keep improving as the quarter goes on? Or should we bear in mind some month-to-month seasonality or comparisons?
Bill Nash
executiveNo, listen, listen, what has us feeling optimistic is really the direction things have taken since the back half of Q1. As I mentioned, that momentum has carried right into June as well. So that gives us encouragement, and we'll stay at it. I can't peer into a crystal ball and say precisely what will unfold this year, but the trajectory is something we feel good about.
Craig Kennison
analystBill, you brought up a few cost-of-goods-sold programs tied to logistics and reconditioning. Should we expect those savings to reach the bottom line, or will they push prices down? Also, can you put any kind of number on what these programs do per unit?
Bill Nash
executiveYeah. Thanks, Craig — those are excellent questions. And yes, in terms of putting a number on it, here's how I'd frame it: we're chasing roughly 200 bucks for each retail unit over the coming 12 to 24 months, combining reconditioning and logistics. So, as you're aware, that's a meaningful figure, no question. And it has us energized. It won't show up on day one or by tomorrow. Still, when you combine the 2, we believe that level of opportunity exists. Then, regarding the rest of what you asked...
Craig Kennison
analystShould we expect that to affect the bottom line? Or is it more of a...
Bill Nash
executiveIndeed. What I'd share with you is that, clearly, once you begin to bring that in, a choice has to be made. From where I'm sitting at this moment, I'd say we would likely pass that along by way of pricing. Yet you definitely face choices as those efficiencies start to materialize.
Craig Kennison
analystThen, as a quick follow-up — if the pricing you've got right now is competitive, what's the reason for not letting those efficiencies flow through to the bottom line?
Bill Nash
executiveWell, once more, there are choices you've got to make. And once more, affordability is something we'll examine, and elasticity too. There are plenty of — it's tough for me to predict how things will look by the time we reach that point, since so many variables feed into it. It's possible we keep part of it. It's possible we keep — historically — I mean, you've tracked us for a long enough stretch, there was a moment when we captured some reconditioning savings and let them flow to the bottom line. Yet across many of the years afterward, we've handed them over, and that assists us in simply controlling overall margin, which assists in controlling the price. So my view is that many things feed into the calculation, and we'll need to review them when that moment arrives.
Chris Bottiglieri
analystTo start, I'd like to pick up on that previous question. Could you say more about the parts acquisition? It sounds fairly significant. Are you going straight to the vendor and handling sourcing on your own? Or are you requesting that your retail partners lower their pricing? Then I have something on credit. I realize I'm violating David's rule, and I apologize. I hope it isn't intentional on my part, so I'm sorry. But the prospectus for the new non-prime securitization would imply there's $5 billion of this kind of receivable. How does that $5 billion legacy portfolio sitting behind securitization, how does it differ when it comes to Tier 2? For instance, is Tier 2 simply a higher CNL than the legacy 5? Could you just explain, like how is this different and where is it heading?
Bill Nash
executiveSure, Chris. Well, to begin with, on violating David's rule, you're the only person who said sorry, and everyone has violated it so far; so you're forgiven. I'll take the first portion of the question, and I'll hand it to Jon for the non parts. So look, we have incredible part partners. Parts partners have existed for a long time, so — where we maintain national relationships with; so that's been wonderful; we simply see that there's some parts optimization internally that we can improve on and which parts we're receiving from which source and which parts are being applied and not being applied. So that's just one of many items we're working on. But I don't want you to leave thinking we had this — we lack good parts partners or anything like that because we do, we have excellent national relationships, and we're happy with those partners. We simply believe we can do a better job optimizing the parts. So Jon?
Jon Daniels
executiveYes. Thanks for asking, Chris. So when we consider that $5 billion from the legacy book you mentioned, and if I look at our whole portfolio, or what we generate across 43%, well, we've run our existing program that way historically. The bulk of it has been Tier 1 that goes into the current ABS program. Thinking about those receivables, we'll essentially divide them, and we'll set up a higher prime program, which will aim at, again, in our view, a different set of investors and really give us scale across what we'd regard as the upper part of those receivables that have historically been securitized. And then we carve out — the remainder there, including — and on top of that, the Tier 2 and Tier 3 volume that we haven't securitized in the past, can all be combined into this non-prime program. So that's the way to think about what we generate now. If you consider what we may pursue later on, there are minor areas of Tier 1 that we've pulled back on currently, which we could win back, and we're constantly seeking to do so; but then when you look at Tier 2 and Tier 3 in their entirety, let's say right now, that's 27% of sales; that's a broad range, frankly, within that 27%; and so we believe there's volume to be gained throughout all of it, and we'll determine the appropriate place to be. So — but again, this will let us expand down there. Now the final point I'd like to stress is that our partners have benefited from that volume, and we're glad they benefit from that volume. We expect to sell plenty of cars going forward, and we want our partners beside us throughout the journey. So we'll pursue some of that volume in the — within that Tier 2 and Tier 3 area. We don't want all of it, but we do see a chance to expand there. So ideally, that broad response addresses your question.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveChris, let me just tack on one more point. When you're looking at how that program divides between high prime and non-prime on the FICO side, a rough rule of thumb works well: non-prime means below 650, while high prime means above 650 — that's simply a loose way to picture those two groups.
Scot Ciccarelli
analystBill, I realize there have already been a few questions about market share, but let me try a slightly different angle here. Looking from the outside, we can observe the growth rates of Carvana and the public dealers. Based on what you said earlier regarding mix, do you believe your mix of late-model product is essentially the main driver behind the relative growth rates we're seeing? Or might other factors be involved, such as credit approvals or something along those lines?
Bill Nash
executiveNo, Scot. What I'd say is the largest factor really stems from that significant price correction that occurred at the end of the calendar year last year. Keep in mind, we maintain our margins. Clearly, this is a highly fragmented market. Plenty of players out there don't maintain their margins. They're clearing out the inventory. So I believe that has been a major factor most recently in the decline in the fourth quarter and now as we begin to climb back out. But certainly, beyond that — look, as I mentioned earlier, I think more cars are being sold, for instance, that are 10 years and older, and that's simply not a space where we really participate. And I think another thing is our bread and butter has always been kind of 0 to 4. That's probably 70% of, historically, what our sales are; and that's been an expensive ticket for folks. And so there — we've seen people migrate down. We've seen like — throughout the last couple of years, when you look at credit apps, people are looking for a little bit cheaper car, and that's across all the credit spectrum; so I think there's a combination of things that are going on; and the other thing is we're just not going to — we've spent 30 years making sure that we have a high-quality product, and we want to maintain that high-quality product. And so we understand that there's going to be some consumers that have traded down; so I think it's a combination of things.
Scot Ciccarelli
analystAll right. May I pose another question? When you examine all of your markets — I realize that in earlier times, the prior leadership group would mention something like a 10% share in particular markets. So just to give us a basis for comparing that 4% average, what's the largest market share you have in any single market?
Bill Nash
executiveSure. Our strongest markets remain above 10%; and as I've mentioned before, when we first launched back in '20, we examined the 15 markets that had been around the longest, and we genuinely observed a modest uptick in share. Clearly, those markets expand far more slowly than the newer locations. But where that ceiling sits, I can't say — though for the older ones, it's beyond double digits — above 10%.
Chris Pierce
analystCould you discuss availability? We're clearly watching commercial vehicles at auction increase compared to last year, and there's more expansion on the way. However, does that incoming supply of cars that you require return in order to assist newer vehicles in the market to capture a larger portion against the older segment — older vehicles, which then helps you capture a larger portion? What are you observing regarding supply?
Bill Nash
executiveSure, plenty has been written, and people say — and that we face a supply issue. The truth is, sourcing the cars isn't a problem for us. Should supply have any effect, or if it comes from supply, that simply feeds into the broader affordability matter, yet supply is obtainable; that said, I believe it's excellent that the SAAR keeps rising. The latest figure I noticed was approximately 15.7% eventually, and we've already begun to witness it. As you mentioned, additional cars entering the market once more assist in lowering the price of pre-owned vehicles and, more precisely, 0 to 4. So as more inventory arrives, I believe that benefits the industry, and I believe it benefits us.
Chris Pierce
analystAll right, then — so you aren't struggling to obtain inventory, but you're making the call not to buy vehicles that are older, and that's roughly what's damaging the share. Still, I simply want to confirm that I'm sort of grasping where inventory is headed and the inventory choices you're making.
Bill Nash
executiveYeah. So no, I'm grateful you clarified that, since when you posed the question, I believed you meant more the availability of newer-model cars. Should there be any inventory problem, it's only that when someone wants an older vehicle — on our end, we purchase plenty of older vehicles, yet only a certain quantity of those can be elevated to meet the quality standards. So should we face any inventory problem whatsoever, it would lean toward the older vehicles that satisfy the CarMax standards. Yet once more, I mean, we've had — approximately 1/3 of our cars are, shall we say, older than 6 years. That's significantly up — it's risen a great deal compared with what it used to be. But should any inventory concern exist, it ought to lean toward that bucket rather than the late-model bucket.
Chris Pierce
analystSo, basically — is the number of cars that fit the CarMax standard increasing? Or has it stayed level, without movement? What is the best way to think about the supply of vehicles that you plan to sell at retail?
Bill Nash
executiveYeah, I think as we look ahead, you take a holistic view, whether it's an older CarMax vehicle that fits our parameters or a younger one. I think supply is getting better simply because of the dynamic that you mentioned earlier. Since the SAAR keeps rising, eventually, those cars arrive. So and the effect it has on us too is prices just begin to decline. And I think that's beneficial for the industry, and it's beneficial for us.
David Bellinger
analystOne more thing. About the CDK and dealer software problems that are pretty widespread at the moment, is there any exposure for CarMax there? Are you noticing any shifts in volumes or consumer activity? Any clarity you can give on some of the near-term effects of this widespread issue?
Bill Nash
executiveYeah, it's tough for those dealers because I'm aware there are a lot of them. CDK isn't our DMS. The effect on us is small; and how it affects us is that clearly we deal with many other dealers when it comes to parts. And when their systems go down, it can cause delays in parts, and there's a slight effect on title work too. But I'd call it just minor in the grand scheme of things regarding how it hits us.
Bill Nash
executiveOkay, first off, I'd like to express my gratitude — like I always do, my thanks go out to each of our associates for the work they're putting in. I'd also like to say thanks to everyone for being on the call with us today. And I just want to mention, the 2024 responsibility report came out not long ago, and I'd really urge each of you to take a look at it. It offers excellent updates on a number of our key initiatives, from climate to the concrete difference we're making in our local communities. I believe we take pride in it. I believe it showcases our values and the way we live them. And it also puts us in a strong position to generate long-term sustainable value for every one of our shareholders. So once more, we're grateful for your time today, and we'll speak again in the next quarter.
Operator
operatorThat brings us to the end of today's call. We appreciate everyone for joining in, and at this point you're free to hang up.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete CarMax, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to CarMax, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in CarMax, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.