CarMax, Inc. (KMX) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
September 26, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
David Lowenstein
executiveAppreciate that, Todd. Morning to all of you, and thanks for dialing in for the second quarter of fiscal 2025 earnings call. Joining me are Bill Nash, who serves as our President and CEO, Enrique Mayorga, our Executive Vice President and CFO, and Jon Daniels, our Senior Vice President of CarMax Auto Finance Operations. A quick reminder before we begin: anything we say today that isn't a statement of historical fact — including remarks about future business plans, prospects, and financial performance — counts as forward-looking statements made under the Safe Harbor Provisions of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Such statements rest on what we currently know, expect, and assume, and they carry substantial risks and uncertainties that might cause actual results to differ materially from what we anticipate. When we provide projections or other forward-looking statements, we disclaim any intent or obligation to update them; for more detail on the important factors and risks that could affect these expectations, please refer to our Form 8-K filed with the SEC this morning, our annual report on Form 10-K for fiscal year 2024, and our quarterly results on Form 10-Q, previously filed with the SEC. If any follow-up questions come up after the call, don't hesitate to reach our Investor Relations Department at 804 to 747 to 0422, extension 7865. Finally, thanks ahead of time for limiting yourselves to one question and then getting back in the queue for more follow-ups. Bill?
Bill Nash
executiveAll right. Thanks, David. Morning, everybody, and I appreciate you being here. Our team's performance in Q2 left us satisfied, since we posted favorable sales momentum, robust margins, expense savings, and earnings-per-share improvement even while navigating softness in auto loan losses across the sector. On top of solid operational delivery, the numbers show gains from better experiences for both associates and customers, plus falling prices and steadier conditions in vehicle valuation. During Q2, our retail unit count rose compared with the same period a year earlier. We turned in robust retail and wholesale GPU figures and grew gross profit in EPP and service. Purchases of vehicles from dealers climbed, setting a Q2 record. Cash net interest margin held steady, and we started piloting our new full spectrum underwriting model. We drove significant SG&A leverage measured as a share of gross profit, and EPS rose at a double-digit rate. In Q2 of FY 2025, total sales from our diversified business model reached $7 billion, a 1% decrease versus a year ago, driven by softer retail and wholesale pricing, partly countered by greater retail volume. Within retail, total units sold rose 5.1%, while used unit comps gained 4.3%. The average selling price fell roughly $1,250 per unit, or 5%, versus a year earlier. Retail gross profit per used unit for Q2 came to $2,269, matching last year's $2,251. Wholesale unit sales slipped 0.3% against Q2 of last year and showed sequential improvement after a decline of 8.3% in this year's first quarter. Average selling prices dropped about $1,150 per unit, or 13%, compared with a year ago. Wholesale gross profit per unit in Q2 was $975, comparable to $963 during the same period last year. We acquired roughly 300,000 vehicles in the quarter, 3% above last year; roughly 269,000 came from consumers, and over half of those purchasers arrived via our online Instant Appraisal experience. With help from our Edmunds sales team, we obtained the other roughly 31,000 vehicles via dealers, a 60% increase over last year; adoption of our omnichannel retail experience keeps rising; among Q2 online metrics, about 15% of retail unit sales happened online, compared with 14% a year ago. Roughly 57% of retail unit sales this quarter were omni sales, versus 55% the prior year. Online transactions generated about 29% of total revenue, a slight dip from last year because wholesale pricing has declined. Every one of our Q2 wholesale auctions and sales took place virtually and counts as an online transaction, making up 17% of total revenue in the quarter. CarMax Auto Finance, or CAF, produced income of $116 million, a 14% drop from the same period a year ago. CAF's performance faced pressure from rising losses felt throughout the industry; shortly, John will share further specifics on customer financing, the loan loss provision, CAF's contribution, and how we're progressing toward becoming a full credit spectrum lender. Right now, I want to hand things over to Enrique, and he's going to provide additional details about how we did financially in the second quarter. Enrique?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveThanks, Bill, and good morning, everyone. Like Bill said, we delivered on a number of fronts this quarter. We saw positive retail unit comps, strong vehicle margins, meaningful growth in other gross profit per retail unit, we held our cash net interest margin, and we got solid flow-through to the bottom line. For Q2, net earnings per diluted share were $0.85, a 13% increase versus the same period last year. ...And that was despite higher loan loss provisions. Total gross profit came to $760 million, up 9% from last year's second quarter. Used retail margin was $479 million, a 6% gain, driven by higher volume with per unit margins roughly flat. Our wholesale vehicle margin reached $138 million, up 1%, as stronger margins made up for a modest dip in volume. Other gross profit totaled $144 million, which is 33% above the same period last year, mainly thanks to EPP and service together. EPP increased by $20 million, since we keep gaining from the improved per-contract MaxCare margins we introduced earlier. Service contributed $3 million in margin, an improvement of $17 million versus last year's second quarter, a result that came from efficiency and cost coverage efforts working alongside sales growth. For the rest of the year, we anticipate ongoing gains compared with a year earlier, with sales results determining the extent, because service carries both operating leverage and deleverage effects. Turning to SG&A, second-quarter costs came to $611 million, which is 4% higher, or $25 million more, than the same quarter a year ago, yet SG&A leveraged by four percentage points, helped by the discipline we continue to apply to spending and investment levels. That SG&A leverage would have been even greater were it not for two primary influences on the second quarter. The first was a $16 million rise in total compensation and benefits, largely attributable to our corporate bonus accrual, which had been reduced during last year's second quarter. Additionally, expenses tied to occupancy increased by $7 million, which is a steeper rise than what we've seen lately, and that came from how the timing worked out for spending on store maintenance. There are also a couple of things I'd like to flag. First, when it comes to our omni-channel approach to selling — covering commissions as well as what it costs to run our CECs — we keep getting more efficient as we improve our digital progression tools and make the best possible use of CEC labor. During this quarter, compared with both the same period a year ago and the pre-omni baseline, we achieved greater efficiency on three important measures: per retail unit, per total unit, and per gross margin dollar. Second, as Bill will get into more deeply, we're still looking at every piece of our logistics operations in order to find efficiencies. That covers equipment as well as leasing arrangements. While assessing this, we could take on some costs—probably under $10 million soon—that would most likely land in the other income expense line. Down the road, savings from our logistics operations will outweigh those costs by a wide margin. On the capital allocation side, we bought back roughly 1.4 million shares in the second quarter, spending $106 million altogether. When the quarter closed, we still had about $2.15 billion left in repurchase authorization. With that, I'll turn it over to John.
John M Stuckey
executiveThanks, Enrique, and good morning to everybody. In Q2, CarMax Auto Finance wrote about $2.2 billion, which produced a 42% sales penetration rate net of three-day payoffs, versus 42.8% in the comparable quarter a year earlier. New customers were charged a weighted average contract rate of 11.5%, which is forty basis points higher than twelve months prior. Third-party Tier 2 penetration came in at 17.7% for the quarter, a modest decline from 18.1% the prior year, while third-party Tier three volume represented 6.7% of sales, against the 6.4% recorded in last year's second quarter. At 24.4%, combined third-party penetration is still consistent with Q2 FY 2024. For the quarter, CAF income came in at $116 million. That's down $19 million from the prior-year period, and the main driver was a $23 million increase in provision compared with a year ago. Our net interest margin for the quarter stood at 6.1%, the same as last year. We recorded a provision for loan losses of $113 million this quarter, which brought the reserve balance to $501 million. In last year's second quarter, the provision was $90 million. Of that $113 million provision, $52 million reflects roughly an 11% increase in our estimate of lifetime losses on loans already on the books, which we see as a sign of credit challenges across the industry. The provision also includes $61 million tied to expected losses on loans originated during the current quarter. Our reserve-to-receivables figure landed at 2.82%. At the end of Q1, that number stood at 2.79%, and twelve months earlier it was 3.08%. Despite the increase in provisions compared with last year, this ratio moved up by just three basis points. The reason is the credit-tightening steps we implemented across the past two years, which are having a growing impact on a portfolio worth almost $18 billion. Turning to credit conditions industry-wide, it's been broadly observed that a large number of auto loan customers are feeling pressure in this inflationary climate — especially those whose contracts were written in 2022 and 2023, a period when high prices coincided with steep interest rates. Lenders, by and large, have responded to those outcomes by making their underwriting standards stricter wherever they needed to, and by revising how much they expect to lose over the life of a loan in light of deteriorating performance. Within the industry, CAF has run into comparable difficulties to some extent, yet for the most part our customers have demonstrated they can handle this extra inflationary strain. Over the past quarter, we saw the consumer facing still more pressure, so we increased our provision to match. Even with that change, the originations with higher ASPs from twenty twenty-two and twenty twenty-three are still quite profitable for CarMax, and the substantial tightening put in place early in twenty twenty-three has plainly made a real difference to the loss rates on our vintages. Beyond that, we noticed a specific group of customers—mostly clustered near the bottom of the Tier 1 credit range—that carried meaningfully greater risk. For that reason, starting in April 2024, we responded by tightening our underwriting approach even further as a precaution. Before that, during Q1, our standard loan loss modeling had already produced a loss allowance adjustment tied to this group. Then in Q2, conditions worsened more, which meant we needed an additional adjustment on the receivables already on the books. From our standpoint, the provision recorded this quarter gives an accurate picture of how the portfolio performed in the period, and the reserve we carry today is our best estimate of the lifetime losses that remain ahead for the portfolio. Naturally, CAF is going to keep weighing credit risk, driving CarMax sales, and locking in the share it wants of those very lucrative finance contracts. Beyond that, I want to bring everyone up to speed on where CAF stands with securitization and with our full spectrum lending push. We wrapped up our very first non-prime ABS deal back in June, and then July brought the closing of our initial higher prime ABS transaction. What these deals accomplished tells us we can feel good about these two programs working alongside each other — they should add a substantial amount of fresh funding capacity behind CarMax's growth, and at the same time they give us room to maneuver so we can capture more of the tier two and tier three market. Also during the second quarter, CAF began piloting updated credit scoring models covering the full spectrum, along with associated strategies, in both the Tier 1 and tier two areas, and we expect that testing of this new model at tier three will get underway during Q3. With that, I'll turn things back over to Bill.
Bill Nash
executiveThanks, Enrique. Like I said during our previous quarterly call, the lasting steps we've taken to bolster the company and set our offerings further apart make me proud. We keep honing the experience and capturing efficiencies that will underpin growth ahead. A few illustrations: the new order processing system has now been rolled out across the country in all our stores and customer experience centers. As you'll recall, this platform lets associates walk customers through every stage of the purchase journey and delivers a smoother experience for those who like to mix self-service with help from an associate. Attention has now shifted to customer shopping accounts; with these, it's simpler than ever for shoppers to view the progress made along their journey, whether they do it alone or alongside an associate. The accounts suggest what comes next and highlight MaxCare, the extended service plan we offer. Testing is underway in a handful of stores, with a nationwide launch planned for later this year. Our data science, CEC, and product teams recently built a fresh knowledge management system now being piloted in our CECs, which uses generative AI to give associates immediate access to whatever information they require. Through a chatbot, associates can pose questions and get an answer right away. We're discovering this tool is particularly useful for customer inquiries, since answers differ from one state to another. It will let our CECs operate with greater effectiveness and efficiency, and we intend to introduce the system at every CEC later this year. On finance-based shopping, we rolled out an upgrade that smoothly folds existing instant appraisal offers into our prequalification offering, so customers get more precise credit terms, and lastly, we introduced an EV Hub on carmax.com. That hub offers information and research tools covering the main questions shoppers ask regarding electric vehicles, hybrids included, and assists consumers in figuring out whether an EV suits them. As I noted last quarter, our aim is to bring down cost of goods sold by chasing incremental efficiency chances we've spotted throughout our logistics network and reconditioning operations. This helps affordability since we pass the savings along to our customers, and it also helps our margins. Once we finished a thorough examination of our logistics operation, we concluded that centralizing certain key functions would let us make the best use of our network. In the second quarter, we centralized home delivery, appraisal pickup, and MaxOffer moves by market. We expect to capture additional efficiencies in the quarters ahead as we deploy our improved transportation management system, which brings new planning and execution capabilities. To wrap up, our second quarter performance encourages us, and if today's market conditions persist, we feel good about our sales in the year's second half. We're excited about what lies ahead and our capacity to grow sales and earnings while we keep improving the best-in-class omnichannel experience for our associates and customers, reinforcing our competitive moat. With that, we're ready to take your questions. Todd?
Seth Basham
analystThank you very much, and good morning. It's really nice to witness the improvement in sales. To start, I'd just like to know whether you can bring us up to speed on what unit comps are doing so far this quarter.
Bill Nash
executiveYes, absolutely, Seth. To begin with, the way sales have moved forward makes us happy. When I check the comp pattern across the quarter, it truly improved from one period to the next, and that was wonderful to observe. As for September, with nearly a whole month of the third quarter behind us, our trend for the quarter is positive, matching what we saw in the second quarter, though somewhat weaker right now. I'd also mention that September carries some significant day of the week obstacles. We lose a Friday, we lose a Saturday, we gain a Sunday, yet all of that comes back to us during the quarter.
Seth Basham
analystThat's useful context. Then second, regarding task, could you share your perspective on where the market stands right now — does it still make sense to move ahead with full spectrum lending, considering the credit headwinds, and should we anticipate additional tightening of your underwriting standards?
John M Stuckey
executive... Sure, I appreciate that question, Seth. So to start, on the broader market, once more, I believe we said this plainly, and I think you've covered it, loss rates across the industry obviously are evident. The consumer is stressed. That, I think, explains the tightening we've implemented. April 2023, and we're definitely seeing losses improve, on those vintages. As mentioned again, additional tightening in April 2024. Let me tackle your tightening question now. At present, we feel good about our position. Everything we've tightened on, as you know, previously, was highly profitable for CarMax, but simply moves we wanted to make proactively on a cautionary basis. But as of now, we feel good about where we stand. Again, never say never. We'll monitor our portfolio very, very closely, but we feel good about what we're originating at this moment. As for whether this is the right time for tier two and tier three? Well, we're in learning mode, and we're genuinely excited about it. We rolled out our tier two underwriting model and strategies in the latter part of Q2. We're aiming to enter tier three probably in the latter part of Q3, and we're excited to learn, and we'll keep learning through probably the fiscal quarter. We will determine when it makes sense to pursue more volume; we believe it's great for the customer that CAF will be in there. We know it's great for CarMax, that CAF's going to be there; we think there's more opportunity there, as we've all said. So we'll choose the right time, but we're excited to learn, and we'll proceed prudently and when it makes sense.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveAnd Seth, what I would tell you is that despite conditions like these, these loans are extremely profitable, and John and his team are capable of going after them and doing a great job on both targeting and origination. So the entire credit spectrum has us genuinely enthusiastic, and yes, we will keep running tests during the latter portion of this year.
John M Stuckey
executiveI'd also feel like I was leaving something out if I stopped here, you know. That's the reason the securitization program we ran this summer felt like such a big deal to us; honestly, it went really well, both of those issuances did, and in my view it positions us nicely going forward, when it comes to both capacity and flexibility.
Seth Basham
analystThanks.
Sharon Zackfia
analystHello there, good morning, and I appreciate your time on this call, or rather my question. I suppose I have one more inquiry regarding the finance segment. So, taking into account that losses have risen on one side, yet simultaneously we can clearly observe that borrowing expenses are beginning to decline, what should our view be concerning CAF's profitability? Should we anticipate that this represents the bottom point as far as the decline compared with the same period last year? In other words, at what point do you foresee CAF being able to resume income growth? Any sort of insight on this matter would be quite useful.
John M Stuckey
executiveYes, I'm grateful for that inquiry, Sharon. So, I'll sort of separate it into two of our, clearly, largest categories. You brought up the matter of interest rates. So indeed, that will be reflected in our NIM. Clearly, we've felt quite good about the way we've handled NIM under these conditions. As you know, we've indicated that six seemed like the appropriate figure. We've stayed in that vicinity, and we accomplished this despite tightening, which typically tends to create pressure on NIM, and clearly, we've managed to secure our portion of finance contracts, even while rates were elevated. So we've felt good about how that has functioned. Clearly, when rates move lower, there's frequently a chance for a lender to benefit from rates that are stickier and perhaps gain somewhat more. But for the most part, you have a portfolio worth $18 billion at the present NIM. Making substantial progress against that will be difficult, yet we would anticipate that it could serve as a favorable wind for us. As for the loss situation, which represents sort of the opposite side of things, I truly wish to highlight our provision, and let's discuss it for this quarter. In the end, if you consider it, at the conclusion of a quarter when we establish our provision and our reserve, our aim, plainly, is to only need to, during the following quarter, establish a provision for whatever we newly originated during that quarter; it never works out that way, as you know well. There will be moments when sometimes it happens that you'll be able to release loans, or rather release provision, since performance is outstanding. You'll encounter, in a setting of higher delinquency, a setting of higher losses, which is what we're dealing with at present. We've observed adjustments we've needed to make within the $10, $20, $30 million range. Let's be clear, we believed the $52 million adjustment on the existing portfolio was larger than normal relative to earlier quarters, and it mattered that we pointed that out to everyone. And we would anticipate that, clearly, we have the provision and the reserve properly set for this quarter, but that is significant. Therefore, the gap between that $50 million and, as I'd put it, what happened across the past seven or eight quarters — $10 million, $20 million, $30 million at the upper end 12 months back — well, I believe $50 million is definitely above what we'd want to achieve moving ahead. So once more, you need to estimate what you believe our origination volume comes to, the provision tied to it, and then how much the true-up will amount to. Yet again, though, my sense is that on a forward-looking basis this is, with luck, larger than normal.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYeah, how I'd frame that is, out of those 50, around 20 to 25 is roughly what we've observed during this last year, I'd say. So what you're really talking about is something like a $30 million adjustment compared with what we'd normally have seen in the quarter.
Sharon Zackfia
analystVery helpful. Thank you.
John M Stuckey
executiveThank you, Sharon.
John Murphy
analystMorning. Perhaps I should stick with the credit topic here. So, the direction has gotten somewhat worse, as you can see, yet it remains, you know, inside what we'd consider the usual boundaries. I'm simply wondering how you assess this in absolute terms — how you're thinking about it moving forward, or regarding the pace of change. Are there particular metrics, you know, that your team reviews on the inside? You mentioned tightening in April, then more tightening as the quarter went on, so it appears, you know, that you're responding as this develops; but how, I mean, do you judge where this might end up settling?
John M Stuckey
executiveSure, thanks for asking that, John. I'll highlight a single measure, and that is, once more, the ratio of our Reserve to Receivables, sitting at 2.82, and what I believe that figure makes clear from one quarter to the next, given a provision of $50 million, which as we just noted is fairly large, is how much we've tightened, and you brought that up. The tightening we've carried out, we've reviewed our portfolio, we've reviewed what we originate, loans that are highly profitable; we feel good about what sits on our books, no question there, but we truly wanted to zero in on those receivables and those customers we believed could endure or truly excel in a stressed environment like RID, and that's what we've accomplished. And we've tightened, and we're observing the relative performance come through at our vintage level, early glimpses of losses. How bad might it get? Well, once again, tough to say. We feel good about what we hold. You've seen a provision that we believe genuinely reflects where we think losses are going. We've tightened into the correct pockets. You know, everything is extremely, extremely profitable; it's a matter of what loss rate are we prepared to accept provision for as a result; we have the funding we believe in place to truly do whatever we want to do moving forward. But once again, we're going to be cautious and careful and do what we think is sensible in the quarters ahead. So hopefully that answers your question.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveAnd John, I just want to clarify something. I believe you mentioned tightening during this quarter; in fact, what we did was tighten-
John M Stuckey
executiveYeah, sorry. We didn't do any tightening in this quarter.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYeah; we didn't see the need to. We tightened in the previous quarter.
John M Stuckey
executiveYeah, thanks for the clarification.
John Murphy
analystOh, okay.
John M Stuckey
executiveTwenty-three April and twenty-four of April, we have not done anything significant-
John Murphy
analystYes.
John M Stuckey
executive… starting from April 2024, and at this moment I don't see anything coming up ahead.
John Murphy
analystAll right, that's really useful. Just a single quick question as a follow-up about where you're getting the cars. I mean, everyone we speak with in this business is struggling to locate recent-model cars. It looks like you folks performed quite well during the quarter and in fact secured the 31,000 from dealers. So I'm just wondering, what's shifting in that area, what is Edmunds doing to assist you in obtaining vehicles from dealers who appear to be holding onto them pretty tightly and aren't willing to part with them? And, you know, what sort of effect might that have down the road? Because there's a genuine scarcity, yet you managed well this quarter, so I'm just attempting to figure out what's different.
Bill Nash
executiveSure, John — I'd say the off-lease situation really makes that shortage stand out. As you're aware, it seems like it hit its lowest point back in 2022. Then there's a slight decline coming in 2025, and after that it should begin climbing again. But the truth is, thanks to how varied our purchasing is — with more Instant Appraisal offers and definitely MaxOffer — the Edmunds crew has performed excellently. If you compare this year to last, we likely have 50% more dealers actively engaged with it than was the case 12 months ago. Take leases, for instance: they've never made up a big portion of what we sell. What's fascinating, though, is that through our IO and MaxOffer, our ability to reach those customers is actually stronger than it used to be, despite lower volume. So from our standpoint, supply simply hasn't been a problem.
John Murphy
analystOkay. Impressive when maintaining grosses. Thank you.
Bill Nash
executiveThanks, John.
Brian Nagel
analystMorning, and thanks for taking my questions. I've got two, and I'll combine them. First, on the better used car unit comps — congrats on that. But is there something specific from the quarter you could highlight that supports the momentum we saw in earlier quarters? Second, on finance: when you look at the larger loan loss provision you recorded in the fiscal second quarter, does that mostly reflect what's happening in your portfolio, or the inputs that come out of your analysis of the broader environment?
Bill Nash
executiveOkay, I'll handle the first part, and John will take the second. Brian, on the comps improvement and what's driving it — I touched on this a bit in my opening remarks. I believe it's a mix of internal efforts on our side plus some macro tailwinds. Internally, I'm very happy with the team and how well they're executing everywhere, including finding cost of goods sold efficiencies that let us do different things with stronger conversion in our CECs and stores. The experience — I mentioned we now have order processing. Last quarter I noted we were testing it, that it was in certain stores, and that we intended to roll it out everywhere by the end of the year; instead we actually completed that rollout in this very next quarter, which we're thrilled about, because it puts every one of our stores, the CEC, and the customer all on one format. That makes moving back and forth between assistance and help far easier and seamless. So I think that's great. On the macro side, look, prices keep falling, and I think — Enrique, help me here — this is the seventh consecutive quarter of year-over-year price declines in our ASP.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveCorrect.
Bill Nash
executiveAnd while they haven't returned to prior levels, any improvement counts. Lower interest rates ahead should also provide a boost, I believe; we managed to source and offer for sale vehicles priced under $25,000 as well as more zero-to-four-year-old cars, which I consider a positive; beyond that, we're now operating in a far more steady pricing climate. We've discussed this repeatedly across recent quarters — what occurs when large price fluctuations hit, and we experienced two of those in the last fiscal year, plus one the year before. Sure, depreciation moves both directions, yet it's far closer to typical now. So I'd call it several factors working together.
John M Stuckey
executiveOkay, Brian — I'll handle your second question. What you were really asking, in essence, was this: given that we had a bigger provision this quarter, does that stem from our own portfolio, or does it come from the wider economy? That's my paraphrase, though I want my response to be exact. So when it comes to CECL and the way we set reserves, we examine the economic conditions present, as you'd expect, and we factor those into what we decide. More precisely, though, the changes we make reflect what we've seen in our own portfolio plus performance we think is widespread across the industry. Consider banks — clearly, the Ally banks nearby, plus other banks and other finance companies — you'll notice they're pointing to comparable performance problems. So my sense is that this is showing up on books throughout the industry; we saw it on ours; we do consider economic conditions, yet it's mostly about us, meaning us, meaning industry performance.
Brian Nagel
analystSo thanks for reaching out, I appreciate it. Thanks, guys.
Bill Nash
executiveThanks, Brian.
Rajat Gupta
analystThanks, that's great, and I appreciate you fielding my question. There's one point I'd like clarified, plus one more question. Regarding the September comps, am I right in understanding that on a same-store basis, you're currently seeing positive results versus the prior year?
Bill Nash
executiveCorrect, for September. Actually, what I'm referring to is that for the quarter, the trend is positive. That matches what we saw in the second quarter — slightly weaker, though — but I should emphasize, Rajat, that we're definitely facing a day-of-week headwind, since we have one fewer Friday and one fewer Saturday, while gaining a Sunday, when many of our locations are shut. That will all even out over the course of the quarter.
Rajat Gupta
analystOh, I see — so when you say that, you're still expecting the quarter to come out positive? That's what you were saying back in September, right?
Bill Nash
executiveYeah, that reflects how sales are moving right now.
Rajat Gupta
analystAll right, understood. Moving to ad spend — I have to admit that sharp decline caught my attention. What's going on there, exactly? Is it that you're realizing some kind of efficiency on the advertising side? Should we treat that as the proper per-unit level going forward? Any additional color you can give would be great. Thank you.
John M Stuckey
executiveYeah, sure, of course. What I'd say is that from one quarter to the next, some fluctuation is inevitable, correct? That said, when you look at the opening six months of this year, we're essentially right where we told everyone our target sits. Then when it comes to the latter six months, the picture will look much the same; so nobody should draw conclusions from this one quarter regarding marketing dollars either year over year or measured per total unit. It's simply normal ups and downs inside a quarter. Still, to repeat, the first six months essentially match our expectations, and the second six months match what we've already laid out.
Rajat Gupta
analystGot it. Yes, that's great. Thanks a lot.
David Bellinger
analystHi, I appreciate you taking the questions. Starting with the deteriorating situation across the wider auto loan space — you're at roughly a 7% penetration rate for tier three as things stand. You've gone ahead and tightened once more. So what does next year look like? Are you starting to run the business with any sort of contingency plans in case volumes take a downward turn across the coming quarters? Perhaps walk us through any additional offsets or expense reductions available to you if credit conditions get weaker.
John M Stuckey
executiveYes. Let me address... You brought up the tier three percentage. In my view, several factors are at play within the industry. Once again, you have the declining performance we've discussed, and, well, you know, CAF mentioned, you know, that they are tightening. I believe, once more, that tightening has taken place throughout the industry too. That fact is, that's also well documented. So, I think we've managed to handle that tightening quite well. When it comes to our lenders and our book of business, we believe our credit platform ranks best in the industry. Our partners are extremely loyal, and they have tightened to some degree, without question. Each lender will act according to its own approach, but they've tightened somewhat just like we have. Right, and, and we have no idea what their next moves will be. When we talk with them, they say they're in a position much like ours, feeling confident about what they're putting on the books. I'd like to bring up, respond to what you said about tier three sitting at 7%. My sense is that has less to do with tightening. Certainly, a portion of it is in there, but much of the decline in tier two and tier three volume, I believe, is truly an affordability problem that we've brought up many times, where the consumer, you know, who's looking to buy, who is out shopping, simply isn't able to commit, because of the payments and the circumstances involved. A bit of that may stem from tightening, without question, but when you consider the raw price and the monthly payment, that's where I think they're having the hardest time. So my view is that this stems as much from the consumer as from tightening. So I'm not aware of anything-
Bill Nash
executiveRight, the sole additional point I'd make, David, is this: we're feeling really good, honestly, about what we've accomplished with our actions. The tightening we've implemented feels like a positive for us. As for our lenders, through the conversations we've had with them, they've already moved in that direction; they're comfortable with the CarMax book of business. John touched on this — the lower income customer — and he's completely correct. Where Tier 3 is showing up, I don't think it's necessarily tied to tightening. Certainly, in spots where tightening happened, the real driver is affordability. And when I consider consumers with lower household income, it remains a fraction of what it once was. So our view is that at some point, it will return.
David Bellinger
analystUnderstood. Could I squeeze in one additional question regarding those digital progression tools? You brought up order processing. There's what I believe is a new capability allowing customers to finish, from their house, a deal that began at a store. So is that now live across all locations? And could you discuss any conversion lift you're seeing in these early days?
Bill Nash
executiveSure, we only recently made it available everywhere. That's precisely right. It creates a smoother experience regardless of whether your starting point is the store or online. Previously, the situation was this: if you began online, collaborated with the CEC, and completed everything via the CEC online, that was fine, since every one of our CECs had it up and running. However, if you began online, worked with the CEC, and afterward walked into a store, things weren't as smooth, given that our stores weren't yet on the new order processing system. Now it's deployed at all of them, so your starting point is irrelevant, and both the customer and the associate gain from this. When a store associate assists a customer who has been doing things online, what that person did is now fully visible. The upcoming thing we're working on, which I mentioned, is essentially this shopping cart, as I tend to call it, where the consumer—since getting order processing into every location had to come first—now, upon logging into a MyCarMax account, can view everything done at the store along with everything done online. So once more, it's a pleasant bit of continuity, and it nudges them toward the following step; thus it's somewhat early to discuss what it produces from a conversion perspective, even though conversion rose in both the CECs and the stores; we believe it's simply an improved customer experience, and it will deliver dividends down the road, since consumers will keep wanting more.
David Bellinger
analystVery good. Thanks, Bill.
Bill Nash
executiveThank you.
Craig Kennison
analystMorning, and thanks for taking my question. It's kind of a follow-up to what was just asked. Online sales as a share of total sales rose to 15% from 14%. I believe it had been sitting at about 14% for some time. Where do you see that figure going in the years ahead? And as you move toward a lower touch process, should unit profitability begin to improve given how low touch that transaction is?
Bill Nash
executiveYeah, regarding the 15%, it had been roughly 14% for, I think, a couple quarters, and it did move up a bit more. Honestly, what gets me more excited is the two-point gain in Omni, since that's where the bulk of customers are. There are only so many people who want to handle everything online, and I'd note that of the 15% who did it online, the large majority still preferred coming to the store to do the pickup, to discuss the car, that sort of thing. As for more. Look, the more self-progression customers do, from an efficiency standpoint, that's a win, and I'll let Enrique speak to that a bit.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveAnd, like I said earlier when I was going through my prepared comments, there's a lot of excitement on our end about how far we've come with the Omni selling model when you set it against the period before Omni existed. Not just when you look at it year over year, but also when you stack it up against pre-Omni too. This quarter, on those important metrics, we were actually more efficient, correct? Those same key metrics that have come up again and again in these discussions for some time now — that means per total unit, per gross margin, and per retail unit as well, and on all of those we're more efficient. So we'd made a commitment to move the needle on this and to be efficient, or even more efficient, and that's what we're doing, and that ought to keep speeding up going forward in a climate where sales return, and we should keep seeing that carry through; so we couldn't be happier.
Craig Kennison
analystBill, I'd like to challenge what you said there — for customers who prefer an entirely digital experience, there are really just two options available, your company and one leading rival.
Bill Nash
executiveMm-hmm.
Craig Kennison
analystMy sense is your view would be that an appropriate portion of that belongs to you. Do you believe that's happening?
Bill Nash
executiveRight, the way I look at it, I've got no specific goal for any... If their preference is to handle it entirely at the store, or if they'd rather mix the two approaches — which is essentially the whole point of Omni — or if they'd prefer to do it all, we aim to provide the strongest possible experience across each of those options. So in terms of how they choose to receive it, we remain neutral. I'd say the fact that 15% of them do is excellent, though we don't, you know, push them toward any particular channel. So, yeah, I want my... I certainly want an appropriate portion of that for us, but I'm equally fine if that's their preference and they wind up visiting in person or completing everything online, at the store.
Craig Kennison
analystThat's fair. Thanks, Bill.
Bill Nash
executiveThank you, Craig.
Scot Ciccarelli
analystMorning, everyone. Sorry ahead of time for yet another question on the finance side. In the past, you folks were reducing provisions even while delinquencies were climbing. And John, I realize you mentioned many different elements that you take into account, but did that provision shift mostly stem from delinquencies turning into write-offs at a growing rate within your portfolio? And tied to that, given delinquencies reaching 8% rates on your subprime after roughly three months, what initial loss expectations do you have for the subprime pools? Thanks.
John M Stuckey
executiveSure. Yeah, regarding your first question, yeah, if you look at sort of, and once more, we've stated our provision will be a function of our origination mix, which is going to carry varying levels of provision at any given moment, but there's definitely this additional piece, and you know, if you look, we have been, we refer to it as truing up, adding volume based on the performance we've witnessed within the delinquency level. You know, in any particular month, and I believe we said this, you know, we've absolutely observed our customers behaving fine in delinquency. They might enter, they might exit, but they weren't rolling to loss anywhere near the historic levels that you know, we might have witnessed five, 10 years ago. It clearly was someone navigating the environment rather well. It just so happens this quarter, we saw that deteriorate somewhat, and that's the reason we made the outsized adjustment. But once more, it's always sort of based on our performance, what we're observing, combined with obviously the external or the economic factors, but it's mainly the performance on us. We feel good about where we stand today with our reserve. We've made the adjustment. It was definitely outsized. It captures the performance, and we believe our tightening will drive through to actually ultimately hopefully not having to make further adjustments.
Bill Nash
executiveAnd Scott, that's a really good point, and I want to be sure to emphasize it: the fact that you're bringing the provision down in earlier months doesn't mean you aren't also doing true-ups. True-ups were happening; the origination side is simply a reflection of the tightening we've been carrying out. So once more, I want to make certain that point lands with everybody.
John M Stuckey
executiveAll right, and now I'll address the final thing you raised. I believe subprime was what you mentioned; so let's break down those separate segments. And once more, the way I'd characterize it is more of a continuum than something divided into distinct buckets; but clearly, our tier one portfolio is, as we've pointed out, the core of what we do. That's the area where we've been active. Over time, that has fallen within a 2% to 2.5% loss range. Clearly, we're eager to move toward a fuller spectrum. We have played in the tier three segment. As you know, we've acknowledged that yes, losses there are certainly greater; long ago, it might have represented around 1% of our portfolio, yet accounted for 10% of our losses. So the math on what loss level to anticipate is something you can work out. Meanwhile, Tier 2 sits somewhere between those, along a varying continuum. So, you know, whenever we consider a book with greater delinquency, it's, you know, something we handle. Our view is that it's very profitable. We extend a strong credit offer to the consumer. As I think came up in an earlier question, you know, we'll enter that area when we judge it to be sensible and when the volume justifies it. We're simply pleased to have the flexibility to pursue it, to have the models we're going to refine in order to pursue it, and, once again, we regard it as simply sound business to participate in.
Scot Ciccarelli
analystGreat. Thanks a lot, guys.
Bill Nash
executiveThanks, Scott.
Chris Pierce
analystMorning. I have a couple of things to ask. First, in your view, did CDK provide any boost to the comps this quarter, since a larger number of independent dealers depend on that software package? Then, regarding other gross margins, you mentioned a few. We have observed pressures, and you noted certain benefits. I simply want to understand how we should properly view that component moving ahead.
John M Stuckey
executiveAlright. Regarding CDK, honestly, my view is there wasn't any meaningful effect. Many dealers, I believe, found alternative methods. Also, when I examine how our comps trended month by month across the quarter, they improved sequentially. So, as you know, July was lower than August, and by that stage CDK had largely resolved itself; therefore, that's my reasoning for saying I simply don't believe there was a meaningful effect. Now, what else did you want to ask? Other gross margin.
Chris Pierce
analystRegarding those other gross margins — yes, the trend has been pretty favorable, and we did get those EPP tailwinds, though you flagged certain equipment headwinds. I'd simply like to understand the proper framework for thinking about this, assuming I caught that correctly.
John M Stuckey
executiveYes, indeed, absolutely. As for other margins — well, our results in other gross margin have us genuinely encouraged. This quarter it climbed $36 million. That works out to a 33% rise versus the prior year, and it truly comes from two pieces, correct? Service keeps posting gains compared with a year ago, something we pledged to deliver when the year started. I anticipate that same progress persisting through the latter half of the year. Sales activity exerts a fair amount of influence over it, since it carries that leverage characteristic. Still, absent other changes, my expectation is that we keep improving against the prior year. Turning to EPP, once more we simply keep witnessing gains. That should continue, I believe, since this largely reflects margin we captured during earlier periods. Consequently, I anticipate a Q3 uptick, and then once Q4 arrives, we'll begin lapping a portion of the margin testing conducted during the earlier year. Even so, we would still anticipate a degree of favorability compared with a year ago. So when it comes to our other margin results, we hold a bullish view; regarding what I mentioned during my prepared remarks, I noted a possible — there could be as much as a $10 million effect. That wouldn't land in gross margin. It would sit within other income and expense, meaning an impact outside both gross margin and SG&A. And that essentially amounts to a possible charge connected to refining our logistics network — we examined the associate dimension. We also need to examine the truck dimension. So we must confirm we possess the appropriate quantity of trucks internally, and that our dedicated partners likewise possess the appropriate quantity of trucks, and we anticipate a possible charge there, though we're still working it through, and it would represent a one-time hit. So I simply wanted to flag that for the third or fourth quarter.
Chris Pierce
analystAll right. And then just one final item. We've noticed some strength in the wholesale market, a sort of non-seasonal strength, and I don't believe, you know, used car retailers currently have much pricing power; so what's the right way to think about GPUs going forward? Might there be a modest GPU compression related to that, or am I reading too much into, you know, one month of strength in the wholesale market?
Bill Nash
executiveWhat you're asking is whether we expect our GPU to come under strain down the road? Is that what you mean?
Chris Pierce
analystYes. For used car dealers, acquiring vehicles in the wholesale market has gotten more expensive, and given where things stand regarding affordability, the ability to set prices is kind of constrained at the moment.
Bill Nash
executiveYes, so, when you consider what we purchase via the appraisal channel and via dealers, our self-sufficiency is comfortably above 70%. I believe that contributes significantly to our capacity to secure inventory. I have strong confidence in our own wholesale operation. The team is performing exceptionally well; this likely addresses what you're getting at, you know, when I consider the ratio of dealers to each car, that keeps getting better, which, you know, clearly assists us in continuing to control margin, and to give the customer as much as we can for their vehicles. So, once more, I think a few of the worries regarding the supply side, once more, simply have not materialized because our self-sufficiency is so elevated, you know, we just have not encountered a problem.
Chris Pierce
analystOkay, perfect. Thank you.
Bill Nash
executiveThank you.
Ian Davis
analystHi everyone, Ian Davis here filling in for Chris. Appreciate you taking my question. This is another credit-related one, though I'm hoping it's a bit more big-picture. A competitor of yours in the online space has managed to grow its credit penetration substantially, to a level we'd put at roughly the mid-80s%, while you sit in the low 70s% right now. So, keeping in mind some of the market conditions you've referenced before, what's holding you back from reaching those numbers at present? And could you also share something about who makes up that remaining 30% of customers who aren't getting financing through CarMax or your lending partners?
John M Stuckey
executiveSure. Yeah, I think, you know, talking about us in particular, yeah, and let me just walk through how our penetration breaks down. Once again, our aim is to be a lender across the full spectrum, giving every customer access to credit; so we believe, yeah, that's the reason we have, you know, a large number of lenders on our platform who've been with us for quite a while, and we believe we deliver strong credit offers spanning that entire credit spectrum; our focus isn't on a lower segment, a middle segment, or a high segment. We aim to serve every customer. And because of that, we bring on more lenders. CarMax is going to be a benefit to everyone. Our partner lenders are seeking volume too. We've got volume. We recognize there may be room to expand that volume, but our goal is delivering excellent offers to every customer across the credit spectrum. That's simply one of our broader objectives. As for, you know, what's stopping CAF from expanding significantly, I think we've made the choice, and we're quite enthusiastic about being able to grow when the timing is right. But once more, we won't zero in on any single pocket. We want to ensure we're extending offers throughout Tier Two, throughout Tier Three, while remaining faithful to who we are in Tier One. That's what we do. So that covers CAF specifically. You raised the point about those who don't get financing from CarMax and instead go with a third party. Again, those customers are definitely going to be your higher-end buyer; it's going to be those who come in and pay cash upfront because they'd rather not face the higher interest rates existing in this environment; they belong to a credit union, which definitely enjoys a cost of fund advantage; so they're extremely rate sensitive, and those are people we attempt to compete for at CAF, but at times the environment makes that hard to do. And so long as we're aiming to sell cars to those consumers and keeping our focus on them, which we do, we're going to have some percentage of volume. Here, it's perhaps somewhat more outsized, over 30% this quarter coming from external financing; that figure will decline once the low-rank consumer returns. Our confidence on that is complete, since they are once again going to expand the overall pie, which shrinks the portion outside of finance. There's quite a bit packed into what I just said, and quite a bit packed into what you asked. I want to be certain I've addressed all of it as a whole.
Bill Nash
executiveYeah, I'm gonna add a little bit more-
Ian Davis
analystYeah.
Bill Nash
executiveLet me expand on that response a bit. Here's the thing — sure, we could make that move tomorrow. We'd simply cap how many partners we work with; three-day payoffs wouldn't be permitted. But realistically, when you're moving that many vehicles across such a broad range of buyers, particularly those who care about rates, having additional partners is beneficial for many reasons. So, is there room for us to keep growing our penetration? Without a doubt, and we certainly will as time goes on. Still, my view is you need to approach it carefully, particularly when your volume is rising.
Ian Davis
analystUnderstood. I really appreciate what both of you shared.
John Healy
analystThank you for letting me ask. I just have one question that's more of a big-picture nature. You've discussed certain efforts on the logistics front that essentially move you toward your target, yet I haven't picked up much discussion regarding reconditioning, so I was wondering whether you might speak to that — whether you feel good about where things stand and how you're approaching reconditioning, along with your capacity to generate, you know, healthy margin from that area, or whether perhaps you're reevaluating or adjusting certain elements behind the scenes? Thanks.
Bill Nash
executiveYeah, no, John. I mean, look, this is something we're focused on. I brought it up during the prior quarter. I referenced it in my comments, only at a high level. I didn't offer any particular examples, but I feel terrific about what we're doing when it comes to reconditioning. What separates reconditioning from logistics is that reconditioning involves many small pieces accumulating. So consider, you know, we're observing really strong gains in certain areas of part utilization, whether that's OEM, non-OEM, the timing of replacement versus not replacing. We've started moving certain work in-house, so we're subletting less, achieving better use of capacity, addressing stores that perform as outliers, you know, improvements in WIP, time frames. Many elements will combine to reach certain internal targets we've discussed. Honestly, you know, during the prior quarter, I said, "Look, we're pursuing a couple hundred bucks across, you know, reconditioning and logistics," and that's not a trivial amount. Naturally, once you achieve that, you gain the freedom to choose what to do with it — hand it back to customers, or, you know, direct it toward margin. So we're pleased with how far we've come on both fronts, whether that's logistics or reconditioning, and with both we'll keep delivering benefits over the coming year.
John Healy
analystUnderstood. Now I have a small detail to ask about. From what I can tell, your advertising expense actually declined compared with the prior year, while costs rose. So I'm simply curious whether some timing issue was at play, or whether you might be pulling back or altering your approach to ad spending. Thanks.
John M Stuckey
executiveYeah, no, that was entirely a matter of timing. If you take a look at the opening six months of the year, we're basically where we said we'd be, tracking toward the goal we shared for the full year. So for that first half, my expectation is it will look much like the latter half when it comes to spend per total unit. So it came down only to some timing during the second quarter.
John Healy
analystAll right, thanks.
David Whiston
analystThank you, and good morning. I'd like to revisit what you said regarding the alternative financing avenue. You mentioned these are consumers who react strongly to interest rates, yet you also noted they have a greater capacity to pay with cash. So within that group, would you say most are watching their budgets closely, or are they wealthier folks who can simply pay cash? Put differently, are they taking on more debt, or are they predominantly all-cash purchasers?
John M Stuckey
executiveYes, that buyer tends to be your higher-end customer, without question. Once more, they show up with an affinity check from their bank or credit union, but on the whole they're extremely sensitive to rates, though a clear majority of that involves cash. It comes as cash in one form or another. That could be actual cash, it could be a home equity loan, it could be a personal loan, but these are individuals who typically possess the means to avoid paying the elevated interest rates existing in today's market, and you'll see folks doing that regardless of what interest rate environment we're in, but particularly right now; it's cash users, highly rate sensitive.
David Whiston
analystAll right, and when it comes to where the capital is going, should we expect repurchases to keep happening, or has the deterioration in credit quality made you more hesitant?
John M Stuckey
executiveMy sense is that we're moving along at the rate we told you about, and for the rest of the year, you know, I'd anticipate that same rate carrying on.
David Whiston
analystAll right, thanks.
Bill Nash
executiveThanks, Todd. I'd like to express my appreciation to all of you for being on this call, for your questions, and for your backing. Clearly, we're pleased with where we stand in terms of progress. In addition, I want to say that my thoughts are certainly with our associates, their families, and the communities as Hurricane Helene gets closer. A number of our stores sit in the storm's path, and the safety of our associates remains our top priority, just as it always has been. To those associates and anyone who has been impacted, please stay safe, and we'll speak again next quarter. Thank you.
Operator
operatorThank you. That brings us to the end of this conference call covering our second quarter fiscal year 2025 earnings release, ladies and gentlemen. At this point you're welcome to hang up, and we hope the rest of your day is wonderful.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete CarMax, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to CarMax, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in CarMax, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.