CarMax, Inc. (KMX) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

December 19, 2024

New York Stock Exchange US Consumer Discretionary Specialty Retail earnings 51 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

David Lowenstein

executive
#1

Thanks, Todd. Hello, everyone, and good morning. We appreciate you being on the call for our fiscal 2025 third quarter earnings conference. Joining me today are Bill Nash, our President and CEO; Enrique Mayor-Mora, our Executive Vice President and CFO; and Jon Daniels, our Senior Vice President, CarMax Auto Finance Operations. I want to remind you that anything we say today that isn't a statement of historical fact — including statements about the company's future business plans, prospects and financial performance — constitutes a forward-looking statement made under the safe harbor provisions of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Such statements rest on our current knowledge, expectations and assumptions, and they carry substantial risks and uncertainties that might cause actual results to differ materially from what we expect. When we provide projections and other forward-looking statements, we disclaim any intent or obligation to update them. For more information on important factors and risks that could affect these expectations, please see our Form 8-K filed with the SEC this morning, our Annual Report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year 2024 and our quarterly results on Form 10-Q, previously filed with the SEC. If any follow-up questions come up after the call, feel free to reach our Investor Relations Department at 804 to 747 to 0422, extension 7865. Finally, thanks in advance for limiting yourselves to one question and then getting back in the queue for more follow-ups. Bill?

Bill Nash

executive
#2

Thank you, David, and good morning, everyone — appreciate you being here. Across our diversified operations, the positive momentum carried through Q3, and we're quite happy about that: retail, wholesale, and cap each delivered gains versus a year ago. With vehicle valuations in a steadier place, our disciplined execution let us produce strong EPS growth — unit volumes rose in both sales and buys, margins stayed healthy, the loan-loss provision was stabilized, and we captured cost efficiencies. These outcomes show how solid our business model is, and the road ahead looks exciting. Our leading omni-channel offering remains — and will remain — a crucial point of differentiation, opening the door to the biggest total addressable market within used cars and giving us ample room to grow going forward. During Q3, retail and wholesale unit volumes both climbed compared with the prior-year period. Retail and wholesale GPU came in strong, EPP gross profit grew, and service gross profit improved versus a year earlier. We acquired additional vehicles from consumers as well as dealers compared with last year, setting a Q3 record with dealers; cap income rose year over year, and we kept moving forward with our full credit spectrum underwriting approach. SG&A as a percentage of gross profit was materially levered, and EPS growth reached double digits. In Q3 of FY'25, the diversified model generated total sales of $6.2 billion — a 1% increase over last year — as higher volume was partly offset by lower prices. Within retail, total unit sales rose 5.4%, while used unit comps gained 4.3%. Average selling price fell roughly $1,100 per unit, or 4%, versus a year ago. Retail gross profit per used unit for Q3 reached $2,306, essentially matching last year's $2,277. Wholesale unit sales climbed 6.3% against Q3 of last year. Average selling price dropped about $500 per unit, or 6%, year over year. Wholesale gross profit per unit for Q3 came to $1,015, compared with $961 a year earlier. Roughly 270,000 vehicles were acquired in the quarter — an 8% rise over last year; about 237,000 of those came from consumers, and over half arrived via our online instant appraisal experience. With help from our Edmunds sales teams, we obtained the other roughly 33,000 vehicles via dealers — a 47% jump over last year; adoption of our omni-channel retail experience keeps climbing; in Q3, roughly 15% of retail unit sales happened online, versus 14% a year ago, while about 56% of retail unit sales were omni sales this quarter, compared with 55% in the prior year. Online transactions accounted for approximately 32% of total revenue, up from 31% last year. Every one of our Q3 wholesale auctions in sales was virtual and counts as an online transaction, which made up 19% of total revenue for the quarter. CarMax Auto Finance, which we call CAF, brought in $160 million in income — that's 8% higher than what we saw in the same quarter a year ago. In just a few minutes, John is going to walk through more specifics regarding customer financing, the loan loss provision, CAF contribution, and where we stand on full credit spectrum lending. Right now, I want to hand things over to Enrique, and he'll give you additional details about how we did financially in the third quarter. Enrique?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#3

Thanks, Bill, and hello everyone. The traction we've developed across recent quarters carried forward into Q3, where we hit every major financial target: comparable retail units moved into positive territory, wholesale volumes rose, vehicle margins stayed healthy, gross profit per retail unit from growth and other sources expanded meaningfully, CAF income increased, and earnings flowed through strongly to the bottom line. For the third quarter, diluted net earnings per share reached $0.81, a 56% gain over the same period last year. Gross profit in total hit $678 million, which is 11% higher than Q3 of last year. Our used retail margin landed at $425 million, rising 7% on the strength of greater volume, while per-unit margins held roughly steady. On the wholesale side, vehicle margin came in at $138 million, a 12% gain, with both volume and per-unit margins contributing. Other gross profit reached $115 million, which is 25% higher than the same period a year ago, mainly reflecting a mix of EPP and service. EPP was up $15 million, and we keep seeing the payoff from stronger Max care margins per contract. Looking to the fourth quarter, we're expecting margins per unit to rise only modestly compared with last year, less than the pace we've seen so far this year, since we'll be going up against the initial rollout of margin increases from last year's fourth quarter. Service margin came in $11 million higher than last year's third quarter, an improvement of $10 million. This improvement in our results came from effectively covering costs, taking steps to be more efficient, and growing sales. Looking ahead to the fourth quarter, we anticipate ongoing gains compared with the same period last year, though these will depend on how sales perform, since our service business carries a deleverage characteristic. Turning to SG&A, third-quarter expenses reached $576 million, which is 3% higher, or $16 million more, than the prior year. SG&A leveraged by 640 basis points, thanks to gross profit growth along with the expense efficiency actions we continue to take. Two main factors shaped the SG&A dollar figure for the third quarter relative to last year. The first was a $28 million rise in total compensation and benefits. That increase largely stemmed from our corporate bonus accrual, which had been lowered during last year's third quarter. Next, timing gave us a $9 million benefit on advertising. When it comes to advertising, our fourth-quarter spend per total unit should exceed both what we've averaged so far this year and last year's fourth-quarter figure of $219 per total unit. That's consistent with the guidance we've previously provided, which calls for roughly $200 per total unit across the full year. There's also one item worth flagging. As we mentioned last quarter, we've been reviewing our logistics operations as part of our efficiency push. This quarter, that review produced a one-time $5 million charge tied to equipment and leasing arrangements, recorded in the other expense line. Gains from our logistics side outweigh that impact. On the capital allocation front in Q3, we bought back about 1.5 million shares, spending $115 million in total. As the quarter closed, our repurchase program still had approximately $2.04 billion remaining. With that, I'll turn it over to John.

Jon Daniels

executive
#4

Appreciate that, Enrique, and hello everybody on this morning's call. In Q3, CarMax Auto Finance wrote roughly $1.9 billion in originations, which produced a sales penetration figure of 43.1%, net of three day payoffs, versus 44% in the comparable quarter a year earlier. New customers were charged a weighted average contract rate of 11.2%, which marks a decline of 10 basis points relative to the prior year. Third party Tier 2 penetration came in at 17.9% for the quarter, matching where it stood a year ago, and third party Tier 3 volume represented 6.5% of sales against the 6.9% recorded in last year's third quarter. CAF income reached $160 million for the quarter, an increase of $11 million over the same period a year prior, driven predominantly by our net interest margin, which rose 35 basis points year-over-year to reach 6.2%. Loan loss provision totaled $73 million, compared with a provision of $68 million last year, leaving us with a reserve balance of $479 million. Although the $113 million loss provision booked in this year's second quarter was outsized and carried a significant adjustment tied to the pre-existing receivable base, the $73 million provision this quarter reflects our view that, given observed performance during the quarter, the Q2 adjustment sufficiently covered future lifetime losses. That $479 million reserve balance translates into a reserve to receivables ratio of 2.7%, versus 2.82% at the close of Q2. The 12 basis point decline stems from the combined impact of the more normalized provision recorded in the quarter and the credit tightening we previously implemented, which remains in effect. As part of ordinary operations, we constantly look for ways to assist our customers via changes to our account servicing strategies. Payment extensions serve as one illustration, having historically affected under 1% of our portfolio in any particular month and having stayed beneath industry levels. This tool has demonstrated success in assisting customers as they work through short-term difficulties. During the quarter, we started piloting an enhancement to our policy that gives delinquent customers greater ability to use a payment extension and brings us closer to industry levels. Though early performance results look encouraging and resemble what we saw under the existing policy, we understand that certain customers will ultimately fall back into delinquency and end up as a charge off. For that, we have set aside reserves appropriately. Turning to our full spectrum lending initiative, in Q3 we kept testing our new credit scoring models and the strategies that go with them throughout the entire Tier 1 and Tier 2 spaces. And in November, we kicked off initial testing of our new Tier 3 model. We also completed our second higher prime ABS deal successfully during the quarter. Over the coming quarters we will stay disciplined with our testing plan, yet we are enthusiastic about the substantial growth opportunity awaiting CAF. I'll now hand the call back to Bill.

Bill Nash

executive
#5

Thanks, Jon and Enrique. Like I said when the call began, I'm happy with the momentum that keeps building throughout our business. The omni-channel capabilities that set us apart, which we've developed over the last several years, have made our business model stronger and are central to how we perform; now that these core capabilities are in place, our attention is on improving the experience for both associates and customers, and we're positioned well to take what we've built and use it to drive future growth in both the top and bottom lines across our diversified business. A few examples: during this quarter, we finished rolling out customer shopping accounts nationwide. As a reminder, these make it simpler for customers to view the steps they've already taken along their shopping journey, whether they're doing it alone or with an associate's help; beyond that, these accounts point customers toward what comes next and drive operational efficiencies by letting associates search and update customer records seamlessly, no matter where those records started; alongside the customer shopping accounts, tools like Sky, our AI powered virtual assistant, are generating operating efficiencies and delivering assistance when consumers need it. According to our data, customers are finishing more remote steps compared with a year ago, and that rise in remote steps is boosting conversion across every channel we have, online, in-store, and through our CECs. We keep adding useful shopping information tools to our website. For instance, we now display vehicle specific battery health information on most EVs; we also call out tax credit eligible vehicles and let customers filter searches by cars that qualify for the used EV tax credit; on the supply side, we've improved our industry leading online appraisal experience. At this point we can extend digital offers to roughly 99% of the customers, who visit carmax.com for an appraisal; when it comes to finance, as Jon mentioned, we recently started testing our new Tier 3 origination model. We're currently testing new credit scoring models and the corresponding strategies across the full credit spectrum, which puts us in a position to grow cap income further over time; and last, we remain focused on cost efficiencies, for instance, we broadened our test of a new transportation management process that uses data science algorithms and AI to deliver new planning and execution capabilities. Essentially, this process dispatches moves and automates communication between drivers and stores. We're happy with the results and expect to see benefits to cost of goods sold over time. To wrap up, we're enthusiastic about what's ahead and about our capacity to grow sales and earnings. Our best-in-class omni-channel experience, made possible by our great associates, physical footprint, technology and digital capabilities all tied seamlessly together, is a key differentiator that reinforces our competitive mode, and we believe it will matter more and more when it comes to winning consumers down the road; we're thrilled to be able to pivot from building capabilities to leveraging and enhancing them in order to drive growth through better execution, innovation efforts and experiences. With that, we'll be happy to take your questions. Todd?

Brian Nagel

analyst
#6

First off, congratulations, nice quarter.

Bill Nash

executive
#7

Thanks, Brian.

Bill Nash

executive
#8

Alright, regarding the first portion of your question, Brian, when it comes to the normalized unit comp, my feeling is that it's somewhat difficult to make a call right now. What I'd say is that the sales momentum has us genuinely encouraged. When we examine the comps for the quarter, and you revisit a few of the remarks I made at the close of the second quarter about running slightly lighter, the truth is we ended up doing better as the quarter went on. And even after you normalize for that day of week adjustment I mentioned in the prior quarter, on a sequential basis each month improved; and frankly, looking ahead, December is obviously a bit early, but December's month to date results have accelerated past the third quarter comp. So that has us feeling good, and we're also feeling good about the sales trajectory, and all else equal, here's what I'd share as we consider the fourth quarter. What I'd share is that our view is the fourth quarter—here's what I'll share—our view is the fourth quarter will deliver a stronger comp performance than the third quarter. And that holds even with certain headwinds from a day a week. We lose a Saturday in the fourth quarter. We also lose leap day, which we had last year; so once again, the momentum ahead has us feeling good; and what was the second portion of your question?

Brian Nagel

analyst
#9

That relates to SG&A and the leverage. I can take that one.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#10

Alright Brian, our objective of reaching a mid-70% SG&A to gross profit ratio is something we keep moving toward. For that, sales volumes need to keep getting better. Bill covered the recent trends we've seen, and on top of that there are the cost management efforts we've had underway for a couple of years now. To bring back what Bill said in his prepared remarks, the heavy investment phase of our evolution is behind us. The pivot we've reached is away from building capabilities and toward leveraging and enhancing them, which drives growth and efficiencies. The implication is that gross profit growth is lower, so SG&A gets leveraged, unlike during our heavy investment phase. Our confidence in that leveraging ability is really strong. That said, we will also look at investment opportunities. Leveraging purely for its own sake isn't something we'll do. Should opportunities exist for robust growth of the top line and bottom line, we'll pursue them, but our commitment to that mid 70% SG&A leverage ratio remains as well. The trends have us encouraged.

Sharon Zackfia

analyst
#11

So, considering the gains you've made across the past six or seven months, would you say that's been driven more by conversion rather than traffic to the website or the stores? And if conversion is the bigger factor, how much of that would you tie to industry-wide price reductions as opposed to the internal efforts you've made to reduce friction in the customer experience?

Bill Nash

executive
#12

Yes, good morning, Sharon. Well, when I consider it, for instance if I take a look at this quarter, I'd say the results are mainly a result of conversion, since our web traffic was pretty much unchanged, and it's conversion for both remote, engaged customers, plus it's conversion gains inside the store when customers walk in. And I believe what's really at the core of your question is, what's causing this? What I'd say is I do believe it's a mix of internal and external factors, as you mentioned. Clearly, this is, I believe, our eighth quarter down our eighth consecutive quarter in which we've had sales prices actually decline somewhat versus the prior year. So definitely, as prices decline, I believe that's a favorable wind for us. I think having price stabilization, rather than a lot of large price fluctuations from appreciation or depreciation, more specifically depreciation. I think that's a favorable wind. But I'd say just as significant is the internal emphasis on execution through things like experiences and efficiencies. And when I consider remote progression conversion or improvements to in-store conversion, it's due to the fact that we've enhanced the experience. I mean, even this quarter, speaking of the customer shopping hub that's assisting us, convert more customers by removing friction. The CECs, we've been introducing some tools there, knowledge management tool, which we'll complete rolling out the fourth quarter, assisting our CECs to deliver better experiences. It's the efforts we're making on our cost of goods sold and removing waste from the process there so that we can take that and ensure our prices stay more competitive. It's the inventory management and the faster turns that we're achieving, there are simply many different things we're working on internally that I believe also complement some of the favorable winds we see externally. So, I wouldn't claim it's entirely one or the other. I think it's somewhere in between.

John Murphy

analyst
#13

Let me try a different angle on the same store sales comp. Everyone in the industry, and even people at the auction houses, keeps saying used supply is genuinely tight and finding vehicles is a struggle, yet your numbers look strong. Clearly your sourcing operation is performing well. One thing that stands out, though, is that the average price dropped roughly $1,000 versus a year ago. So I'm wondering whether you've deliberately chosen to source a bit further down market in terms of age, and perhaps in trim, to broaden your own access to the market and step away from some of the competitive pressure where things are more constrained at the high end; and could that carry on in future periods to keep supporting the same store sales comp?

Bill Nash

executive
#14

Yes, John, that's a terrific question. To start, we're very pleased with how diversified our sourcing is, from consumers as well as dealers, and to address what you asked specifically, if you think about age, looking at the year over year mix, say 0 to 5, 5 to 7, and 8 plus year over year, those are pretty comparable. I mean, 0 to 4 is up a point. In fact it's slightly higher, meaning slightly newer vehicles; so a major mix shift in vehicle age really didn't happen; and from a supply perspective for us, since we purchase so many vehicles directly from both consumers and dealers, I think that's a real advantage and it helps us source vehicles that are simply difficult to locate out there. As you mentioned, if you have to depend on third party.

John Murphy

analyst
#15

So nothing's different — yet nothing's different regarding what you're actually out there doing when it comes to age, clearly, like you just referenced, or trim. What I'm getting at is, can you sort of step down through trim levels to try and unlock improved pricing? Since, I mean, typically pricing moves in sequence and it isn't really stepping down. In this industry, it's really ticking up somewhat.

Bill Nash

executive
#16

Yeah, I wouldn't characterize anything as particularly noteworthy on that front. The one item worth flagging, I'd say, is that the team has performed really well. When you look at the vehicles we sell below $20,000, we've performed really well at pushing that figure higher on a year-over-year basis, quarterly, sequentially, it's fairly comparable; however, measured against a year earlier, it's a decent modest increase; and once more, I believe that traces back to the effort the team's putting in around sourcing.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#17

Right, so vehicles priced under $20,000 accounted for 30% of what we sold. That's a huge effort by the team. A year ago, that figure stood at 25%. So it's a fairly significant shift.

Seth Basham

analyst
#18

First off, I'd like to ask about how your GPUs are doing in retail, and after that, wholesale. On the retail side, could you update us on the cost reduction programs? Is that $200 per unit target still on schedule? What portion have you gotten so far, and where is that money going? How much of it is being put back into pricing?

Bill Nash

executive
#19

Sure — regarding that $200, just as a reminder, it's mainly coming from two big areas: our reconditioning work and our logistics. I've mentioned before that the right way to look at it is roughly a 50 to 50 divide, so $100 and $100. And I'd say we're probably capturing around half of that at this point. Of that, I'd break it down as about half from reconditioning and half from logistics, with the rest arriving over the next few quarters; there's a lot of solid effort happening there, and we feel quite good about it. What we've done so far is hand most of those savings over to the shoppers, though it also lets us keep healthy margins in place. I'd suggest you keep that in mind as we move forward. I mean, we'll keep watching it and there will be choices to make as things develop. But at this moment, the majority of it is going to the consumer.

Seth Basham

analyst
#20

Then, to follow up regarding the wholesale segment, what portion of that gain would you attribute to market conditions versus initiatives you have underway, such as Max offer? You reported some very strong figures this quarter.

Bill Nash

executive
#21

Yeah, I'd say much like what Sharon said, it's a mix of factors. What I mean is, the current climate is definitely improved compared with 12 months ago. You'll recall there was significant depreciation; and, you know, whenever depreciation — that kind of sharp depreciation occurs, we typically stay ahead by reducing our offers. That therefore affects your buy rate. So you definitely can't overlook that. And a more stable pricing backdrop has also contributed; however, regarding Max offer, I have to say, the team, the Edmunds team has performed incredibly well on that product; and from my perspective, we grew our active dealers on it quite a lot from our prior position to the present one. I believe our active dealers have risen by roughly near 40% or so compared with a year ago; and thus, with additional dealers participating, engaging in Max off, you're able to purchase volume as well; so I'd call it a mix of both.

Chris Bottiglieri

analyst
#22

Yeah, I just wanted to dig into the allowance with a bit more granularity. Hopefully you can give us a feel for — I believe previously you shared the expected loss on new originations, and help us understand what drove the reduction in the allowance. Is it mostly the remaining vote, or are you also lowering the provision on new originations?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#23

Let me clarify how to think about that cut to provision. As we've described, our provision will obviously be tied to new originations. Chris, you brought up how we handle new originations—specifically what loss we anticipate over the life of those receivables—along with any adjustment required for the receivables already on the books, based on how they actually performed during the quarter. Like we've said before, some kind of adjustment is inevitable. Last quarter, as you know, we flagged a pretty significant one, and that clearly pushed the provision up to $113 million. Those two pieces are always what the total is built from. When you examine the provision we recorded this quarter in relation to both of those items, it comes in at a far more typical level, which supports what you're saying — the new originations combined with the true-up, where our true-up simply wasn't as large as it used to be, is genuinely the outcome we'd prefer to see. As for your origination question, regarding how we reached $1.9 billion this quarter, keep in mind that figure applies to Tier 1 along with the testing taking place in Tier 2 and Tier 3. Should you apply some loss rate to that, you'd arrive at roughly $60 million on the origination side. To reiterate, we did make adjustments in Tier 1, which is giving us some benefit, though our trials in Tier 2 and Tier 3 will counter that somewhat. The rest, clearly, will come down to the true-up — yet once more, a true-up at a sensible magnitude, quite unlike what we saw three months ago, and that's likely the reason we describe it as a provision at a normalized level.

Craig Kennison

analyst
#24

Bill, I realize your preference is to gauge market share on a yearly basis, yet my sense is that how your share is perceived has likely weighed on your stock compared with peers, at minimum during this year. What I'd like to know is whether pricing has settled down, and do you see anything indicating that you're gaining share once more?

Bill Nash

executive
#25

Sure, Craig. What I'd say is that during the past 2 quarters, I've noted that where market share is concerned, my aim is to return to that yearly rhythm. Assuming no significant price volatility occurs, and we simply haven't witnessed any significant price volatility, we'll provide an update once the year wraps up. What I can share is that our sales momentum feels terrific to us, and our capacity to pick up market share feels terrific as well.

Scot Ciccarelli

analyst
#26

I've got two things to ask. To start with, apart from the stabilization of pricing, what other factors would you credit for how big the improvement across the industry has been? Bill, since you've got so many years of experience in this business? And then for the second part, could you folks give us a bit more detail on the payment extension? For instance, what does that process look like and in what way does it show up in the P&L?

Bill Nash

executive
#27

Absolutely. Scot, regarding your first question, when it comes to the market, I'd say the numbers being reported on how much the overall used car market is growing don't agree with each other. My view is that it swings a great deal when you look month to month; yet apart from pricing stabilization — and my guess is what you mean by that is the way I describe it, where you don't get much appreciation or depreciation, and in fact, if you go back and look at the historical depreciation curves for this period of the year, they match up pretty well, which hasn't been the case for some time. Another factor, I believe, is what I mentioned before: prices keep softening, and when there's a spread between a late model used car and a new car, I believe that spread has gone on widening somewhat. In my view that's a plus for the industry, particularly when it comes to late model used cars. The one other point I'd make is that I believe consumers remain squeezed when it comes to inflation, so they're hunting for other options, and used cars fit that, whether that's a two year-old used car or 14 year olds used car. I think that's another plus for the industry.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#28

Scot and I will handle your question about payment extensions first. Let me establish how we approach extensions in general, and then get into what we specifically did. We truly wanted to point to an instance where we keep seeking ways to assist the consumer in getting through. Once again, short-term hardships — that's something we have consistently addressed. It's quite common across this industry. In the past, as I mentioned during my prepared remarks, that typically represents under 1% of our units in any particular month, and we ran some tests, which pushed it just a bit beyond that mark. But we view this as a genuinely strong chance to support the consumer and, in the end, reduce losses; that's what we're aiming for, helping people remain in their vehicle. So to be specific, what took place during the quarter is this: if you examine our extension policy as it stood previously, it had been — and we truly focused on that particular customer. Someone who is a couple payments behind. So when a few payments were missed, in the past we'd say, look, you need to make both of those payments, and after that we can grant you a payment extension; in the current environment, with certainly higher payments, people couldn't take advantage of those chances. So we examined customers and said, if you're unable to make two, we attempted to determine whether they could make both, but if that's not possible, could you make one payment? And there were additional customers who managed to do so. That then lets them take a stretch of time to sort of get their finances straightened out. Now, we launched that at the start of the quarter. We've been able to observe people exiting that extension period and then monitor their behavior. And we're quite happy with what we're seeing; it aligns very closely with our prior policy. So we feel truly good about this step we've taken for the consumer. That said, we recognize some customers may sadly fall back into delinquency and loss. Given that, we must ensure we've reserved appropriately for the steps we've taken. That's how it lands on the P&L — it's reflected in our provision and in our reserve. And we know that will occur, but we feel good about what we've done; we like the early results. Once again, a fairly small number of customers were affected, but we like what has happened.

Jeff Lick

analyst
#29

Nice work on delivering a second straight quarter of improvement. My question is about the wholesale operation. There are some fairly compelling growth trends here — 73 or 74 wholesale units for every retail unit, a 50% jump in purchases by dealers, plus gross profit margins have risen too. I'm simply wondering how far you believe you can push that. To me, it looks like a somewhat overlooked driver of gross profit and dollar growth for you. I'd really like to hear where you see this heading and whether these gains can hold up.

Bill Nash

executive
#30

Sure, Jeff. Well, listen, my aim is to grow it as much as possible. What I mean is, there's considerable internal attention on this. For some time now, we've been focused on acquiring additional vehicles, be they retail cars or wholesale cars. As I mentioned before, this is a priority, and Edmunds has managed to bring on significantly more dealers for it. When I think about the offering, it's present in, say, most of the population — yet within that large share of the population, there remains far greater potential among dealers. So we're going to keep driving this forward as aggressively as we can, since once again, we're after every last vehicle, regardless of whether it's a wholesale car or a retail car.

Jeff Lick

analyst
#31

And from whom do you believe you're gaining that share?

Bill Nash

executive
#32

Well, I'd say it simply serves as a good option for dealers. You know, there are various channels they can use to move vehicles they no longer want — maybe via your standard physical auctions, maybe via online sales with other wholesale companies; this is simply another instrument available to them that they can take advantage of. And we notice that many dealers enjoy utilizing it, so our expectation isn't that it will take the place of those other methods, but rather it provides them with an additional chance to consider a separate valuation.

David Bellinger

analyst
#33

When it comes to the operating environment, has anything stood out recently, or has the tone shifted at all among your lending partners? Since the election, have they become more aggressive and open to taking on more volume, perhaps even in lower credit tiers? Is there anything else you could share as we try to get a sense of lending appetite heading into 2025?

Bill Nash

executive
#34

Yeah, I'd say the brief response is that things seem fairly steady at the moment. There haven't really been any major changes from them. I think that shows up in the penetration they're seeing; and again, that will depend on the lender and on the consumers who come in to shop; but yeah, overall, I'd say our partners really like the CarMax business; they stand by us when conditions are difficult, and they clearly stand by us when conditions are good, but they're being as cautious as any lender ought to be at this point. So I don't believe much has shifted during the quarter.

David Bellinger

analyst
#35

Let me just tack on one more brief item. This quarter, you posted fairly substantial earnings growth on that 4% comp. This might be more of a big-picture thing, but as you start to get leverage from and reap the rewards of a great deal of the investment spending from the last few years and move additional volume through the system — should we be looking for a comp in that low single-digit to mid-single-digit kind of range to produce double-digit earnings growth going forward? And on top of that, perhaps the buyback acts as an accelerant. What's the right way to frame the earnings growth and how sustainable it is from here?

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#36

Well, our goal is solid growth on both the top line and the bottom line. And I believe that's where the investments we've made have positioned us. The operating environment has been tough over the last couple of years, which has somewhat muted some of those benefits; but as we exit that, I think, here, we've posted two consecutive quarters of positive comps. And per what Bill mentioned, those comps picked up speed as we came into the fourth quarter; and going forward, I'd anticipate that, as you put it, we're positioned to reap the rewards of the investments we've made. So we're enthusiastic about where we stand today and, you know, the path ahead of us.

Michael Montani

analyst
#37

Nice work on the quarter. I just had a question — I'll follow that two-part format. First, Bill, could you speak to the fact that we're at, I believe, 245 stores today? Is there a chance to push that back up to 300 stores? And how should we think about the pace of openings? Or is multichannel something you can lean on at this stage? Then I suppose the follow-up is about labor compensation and benefits growth, since the model now leans more toward fixed costs — should we expect compensation and benefits to increase more slowly than top line units at this point, giving us some nice leverage? Or what's the right way to frame that?

Bill Nash

executive
#38

Sure, I'll handle the first piece, and then Enrique can address the second piece. So yes, we're actually at 249 stores; Michael, I'd like some credit here since there are another four; so 249 stores; and look, we believe we can move past that over the long term, we've said 200, 300 stores. Clearly, we went back to 200 stores; we're able to exceed 300 stores. And I think our approach is that each year, we review the pipeline and there are plenty of locations available to pursue. And even though we're covering a large share of the population, there's still substantial room to add locations even within markets where we already operate; and then there are certain markets we haven't entered yet. So our approach is to examine that pipeline annually. Occasionally locations get added to the pipeline, sometimes locations get removed from it. And what I'd say is I believe we have a strategic footprint, and as we keep moving forward with the omni-channel experience. If customers keep doing more and we're able to sell more from the footprint we already have and we wind up removing some locations from the tail end of the pipeline, that's been great. But I think you should feel fairly confident about exceeding the 300 stores even with omni improvements, because I believe a strategic footprint matters a great deal.

Enrique Mayor-Mora

executive
#39

When it comes to comp and benefits as a leverage item, our expectation is that we'll pull harder on that lever than we did previously, since we've been bringing down the variable cost side of the business. We've talked plenty about the direct selling model, the omni-channel approach, correct? What I'd say is that with that direct selling model, we're now in the very late innings on efficiency. Compared with the earlier model, it's more efficient — this quarter, versus the prior pre-omni model. During this quarter, on a year-over-year basis, we were also more efficient on a per retail unit and total unit gross profit basis. Let me highlight a couple of items that really show you what's behind that. In this quarter, compared with a year earlier, web chats through Sky rose 10% year-over-year. So once again, that's the consumer handling more of those tasks themselves, with less labor required. Containment rate climbed 50% to 51%, up from 41%. That works out to an increase in containment rate of more than 25%. Again, it's the customer completing more of the work independently. Meanwhile, our SLAs on web and phone improved year-over-year. So from a customer service standpoint, things are getting better. You can see, then, that we're truly fine-tuning that model, and we feel really good about it. What that ultimately means is less labor, but more effective labor, and that ought to help us push down comp and benefits compared with where we'd been from a leverage standpoint going forward. So we're really excited about it.

Christ Pierce

analyst
#40

Bill, you touched on this in one of your answers to an earlier question, but do you folks track information about how much consumers are squeezed and are moving away from new toward used? For instance, do you have information showing you're gaining new customers, which explains why they're favoring used, and could that debut because these markets have been strong?

Bill Nash

executive
#41

Yes. The information, if I think about it, we examine roughly the entire used — the entire used sector. So if I look back at the previous calendar quarter, normally, million — 40 million used cars are exchanged. The previous calendar year, just about 35.5 million were exchanged. And so when you consider that drop, the largest portion of that drop was in the 0 to 4%; so although the total drop was down, whatever that is 12%, I think the 0 to 4%, 0 to 6% was down closer to 18%. That's clearly a sweet spot for us; so I think on the whole, consumers have been squeezed. I think the reality that the used car sector has been soft somewhat and I think it's affected anybody selling late model cars somewhat more across the last couple of years has been something to navigate. But I also view this as a chance that look, consumers will return. We will get back to the $40 million plus. I just think right now, consumers have been handling their own pressures that they're seeing from an inflationary standpoint and everything else that they essentially must deal with every day.

Rajat Gupta

analyst
#42

Nice work controlling expenses here. One thing I want clarified regarding the comps, and then a CAF question. About comps — I'd like to dig into a few of your remarks concerning the industry acceleration observed in November, which appears to be carrying over into December. Your results obviously are gaining from that too. John said earlier that used car prices have likely risen as of late. So I'm wondering what you believe has genuinely shifted when it comes to the consumer mindset? Is it simply pent-up demand getting released somewhat, plus election anxiety — I don't know, was there a hurricane boost? Just curious whether you could give more detail on those points? And I had a quick one about cash reserves.

Bill Nash

executive
#43

Yes. I don't — I can't really claim that anything has shifted in the consumer mindset. I'd point back to certain remarks I made before regarding what we've accomplished internally to enhance the experience, reduce friction, boost conversion. The fact that our prices are lower year-over-year, I think that definitely helps too. I mean, some consumers are still stretched out there; for instance, the consumers, I've discussed this previously, who earn under $3,000 monthly for the household. They remain half of what they once were for us. And so they're still having a hard time. So I'm not certain the consumer mindset has really changed. I think it's more being pushed by what we're doing and simply broader kind of macro factors. Regarding hurricanes, I mean, it was immaterial. I mean, you are below 0.5 point, I would think it's small.

Rajat Gupta

analyst
#44

That's useful. So it seems there was a notable change tied to the omni experience specifically during this quarter. At the October analyst event, you noted that you were in later innings when it came to reaping returns on fruit service investments. It really appears that delivered a sizable gain, would you agree, for this quarter versus the one right before?

Bill Nash

executive
#45

Well, I'd say we've been — it isn't as though it occurred only in this quarter. This has been a build; and I believe we enjoyed some of those favorable results in the prior quarter. During the second quarter and then this one, the third quarter, I think what we're seeing is that build continuing. Take conversion — particularly remote — when you allow customers to accomplish additional tasks, their likelihood of converting goes up. And if we examine remote activities, such as a vehicle reservation, a pre-qual, an appointment, an instant offer — the greater the number of customers who complete those, the greater the number who will convert. And we noticed a pleasant, modest ongoing gain in customers completing remote progression. Beyond that, as I mentioned, we likewise noticed favorable conversion gains inside the stores, where the stores are performing excellently simply by executing and making use of some of the tools provided to them — some of that seamlessness when dealing with customers who might begin in the store, perhaps move online afterward, and having that information available for our sales folks. There's simply a great deal of goodness. After we finished building the capabilities, our focus has truly been on eliminating that friction now. And I think last quarter, with order processing being rolled out everywhere — this quarter, you had to have order process anywhere. We have the shopping count this quarter, getting the shopping account out there. There's simply a great deal of positive momentum here, and we're going to keep this up. And as I stated in our — in my opening remarks. I believe this is going to matter as we move ahead. I believe consumers are going to — they're going to desire this kind of experience; and the more you're able to make it seamless and frictionless, I think that's who's going to win.

Rajat Gupta

analyst
#46

That's useful detail. And I believe you likely addressed my CAF question too. What I mean is, it doesn't appear that the macro backdrop shifted much. So the reserve — that reduction in the CAF reserve, was it purely driven by the recent tightening in the initial performance you observed? Is that accurate? And then nothing in your macro outlook has changed that would push that reserve down?

Jon Daniels

executive
#47

Yes. And once more, I probably wouldn't frame it as the reserve being cut. I realize you're comparing against a benchmark from the prior quarter, but I'd likely flip that logic and say, if you look at last quarter, we reviewed the overall performance and we made an adjustment that really refilled that reserve bucket substantially, and we believe that was sufficient, and that's essentially what we stated in our prepared remarks. So I view this return to normal, so to speak, as simply an acknowledgment that the volume we set aside at the close of Q2 was sufficient for the receivable base we have; so that's just how I'd ask you to reconsider it.

Bill Nash

executive
#48

Yeah, absolutely — I'll back up what Jon said, but let me frame it another way. Had that adjustment not come through in the prior quarter, the figure would've been larger. We'd anticipate it declining, since during the last quarter our thinking was, hey, this is the amount we need; yet as it turned out, Jon and the team nailed that estimate; so a decrease is what you'd naturally expect. That's why I'm with Jon on this. Try not to view it as a reduction, because had things gone the opposite direction, that would've meant — we simply got it wrong in the previous quarter; so my take is that this is — and honestly, on a year-over-year basis, it's actually slightly higher, so.

David Whiston

analyst
#49

It seems like inventory ended up being a drag on free cash flow during the quarter. I'm just wondering, is that a buildup ahead of tax season? Or is there another factor at play when it comes to working capital?

Bill Nash

executive
#50

Yeah. So inventory — total inventory rose somewhat. And yeah, that's genuinely the whole story, it's simply that we've built it up since we're in production mode at the moment, clearly, given the tax season that's coming. That's a typical seasonal pattern for us. I believe the team has performed incredibly well on managing inventory this year. They put a lot of emphasis on it. I think our turns are better for the quarter compared to a year ago and we believe we're positioned well for the tax period ahead.

David Whiston

analyst
#51

Regarding EPP penetration, or rather EPP growth — did that come from deeper penetration, or was it driven by price increases?

Jon Daniels

executive
#52

Right. Beginning in Q4 of the prior year, we implemented higher prices; ours is a product that's fairly price inelastic, and we did push prices up during that period. Consequently, we'll be anniversarying that come Q4 of this year. As a result, we'd anticipate a smaller year-over-year gain. In terms of the rate, my expectation is actually a modest year-over-year uptick, though essentially that represented a margin improvement we captured in the prior year. Correspondingly, penetration is down, yet ultimately, once again, we're earning more profit in that area.

Michael Montani

analyst
#53

I was hoping to hear any initial perspective you may have regarding the tax season that's coming up, and what your approach and preparation look like for it? Plus, we picked up on a bit of a recent increase in pricing that someone mentioned earlier. So given where we are near the start of the quarter, are your prices beginning to climb compared to the same period a year ago?

Bill Nash

executive
#54

Yeah. So Mike, when it comes to tax season, honestly, for our business it's entirely a matter of adaptability; our expectation is a reasonably solid tax season. You simply establish a solid foundation, consider how things went a year ago, and ensure you're ready for something similar. Yet what matters more, I'd say, is making certain you've got the inventory required, while retaining the ability to scale up or scale back based on whatever conditions emerge. And the team, in my view, has positioned us really well on that front whether it plays out like a year ago, whether it exceeds a year ago, or whether it comes in weaker, I'd say our position is strong. On the subject of prices, once more, considering certain lasting steps we've implemented along with a more varied sourcing base, I'm optimistic regarding where our pricing stands, though off the top of my head I can't give you December figures or say how we're tracking, yet my sense is we're likely somewhat lower versus a year ago. So we'll find out how it turns out.

Bill Nash

executive
#55

Okay, Todd, thanks. Well, look — I appreciate everyone being on this call today, asking questions and backing us. Same as always, I’d like to express my gratitude to our associates for all their efforts, the way they look after one another, our customers, and the communities. To each of our associates and to all of you, I want to wish a wonderful holiday season, and we’ll speak again in the next quarter. Thanks.

Operator

operator
#56

That wraps up today's call covering CarMax's earnings release for the third quarter of fiscal year 2025. You're free to hang up at this point.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete CarMax, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to CarMax, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in CarMax, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.