Visa Inc. (V) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
January 28, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Mike Milotich
executiveThanks, Michelle. Hello, everyone, and good afternoon. We appreciate you joining us for Visa's earnings call covering the first fiscal quarter of 2021. With us on the line are Al Kelly, who serves as Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of Visa, along with Vasant Prabhu, our Vice Chairman and Chief Financial Officer. You can access a webcast of this call through the investor relations portion of our site, www.investor.visa.com. A recording will remain available on our website for a period of 30 days. Our IR website will host the slide presentation that includes financial and statistical highlights. I want to note that forward-looking statements are part of what we're presenting. Such statements should not be viewed as assurances of future results, and a number of factors could cause our actual outcomes to differ materially. You can find further details about these factors in our latest reports on Forms 10-K and 10-Q, accessible via the SEC's website as well as the investor relations area of our site. Regarding historical non-GAAP financial information discussed on this call, today's earnings release contains the corresponding GAAP figures and reconciliation. I'll now hand things over to Al.
Al Kelly
executiveThank you, Mike, and greetings everyone for joining us this afternoon. Although vaccination programs are getting underway, the number of COVID-19 infections continues to rise, and that is driving new limitations in many parts of the world. Yet even with the pandemic ongoing, Visa delivered strong earnings for the first quarter of our fiscal year. Our unambiguous strategy remains facilitating the movement of money globally, and we pursue expansion through consumer payments, new flows, and value-added services; on this call, I'll review what happened in Q1. Following that, I'll give you details about how we progressed with clients during the quarter and the important offerings they rely on to enable money movement across the globe. Before I walk you through what we saw in Q1, I want to remind everyone that the comparison base is a period before anyone was even aware of COVID-19. On payments volume, processed transactions, and cross-border volume, every one of those metrics performed above where they landed in Q4. The gain in payments volume was half a percentage point, processing transaction growth climbed one point, and cross-border volume improved by eight points. Turning to the fiscal first quarter, net revenues hit $5.7 billion, which represents a 6% drop versus the prior year. Non-GAAP EPS landed at $1.42, down 3%. Through a combination of dividends and buybacks, $2.5 billion in capital went back to shareholders over Q1. Since Vasant plans to go into plenty of detail on spending, I'll limit what I say about holiday spending to a few brief, big-picture points. U.S. This year's holiday shopping period took a noticeably different shape, although the expansion we saw on the whole matched what the previous three holiday periods delivered. The gains came mainly from a strong retail performance, with travel, entertainment, and fuel acting as a partial drag. Within the U.S., patterns that took hold during COVID largely carried over — debit stayed strong along with e-commerce, while credit and card present remained weaker. Outside the U.S., retail spending around the holidays generally accelerated, as Canada, the U.K., Brazil, and Australia all posted increases of at least five points relative to the year before. Let me now turn to how our clients are doing. We continue to secure new deals and renew existing ones, moving money around the world via consumer payments, new flows, and value-added services. When it comes to consumer payments, our goal is still to bring digital access to the $18 trillion that gets spent globally each year in cash and checks, which we do by working with partners to grow endpoints and deepen customer involvement through innovation. New credentials are being brought on board with established issuers, fintechs, and wallets. Starting with North America: we're very pleased to have extended our long-standing relationship with Wells Fargo for another six years, covering consumer debit, credit, small business, and commercial. The Bank of Montreal — Canada's fourth-largest bank and the sole top five Canadian bank that had not issued with Visa before — has announced a fresh partnership with us to launch two affluent lifestyle credit card products for the Canadian market. The items we're discussing are built with digital as the priority, target wealthier millennials, and give cardholders compelling rewards and value through an approach that's both distinctive and inventive. Within Asia Pacific, we secured AmBank's debit operations in Malaysia, having brought in that bank's credit operations just one quarter earlier. On top of that, our ties with LINE Pay grew stronger during this quarter in a pair of ways. First off, in Japan, LINE Pay started rolling out a virtual prepaid Visa card, and on a separate note, an exclusive arrangement was formed between Visa and LINE BK, which is Thailand's inaugural social banking platform, covering the issuance of Visa debit cards. In the first month, Visa debit cards were issued through LINE BK to the tune of 180,000. Meanwhile, in Russia, YooMoney — a leading electronic payments provider in that nation, serving over 120,000 merchants globally and 40 million endpoints — joined us to roll out Visa credentials within its wallet and to switch on Visa Direct. In Europe, we booked several significant wins as our business on the continent continues to expand. A commercial deal was secured with Santander Group, making Visa the preferred credit and commercial partner for the group's banks across seven nations in continental Europe. We additionally secured the prepaid issuance business of Mooney. That company is Italy's initial proximity banking and payments provider, offering its services through digital as well as retail channels. It operates more than 45,000 points of sale and serves urban locations capable of reaching 20 million customers. İşbank, Turkey's biggest private bank, which holds 20 million cards, selected Visa for its consumer and commercial credit and debit portfolios. Lastly, we extended two portfolios with a prominent U.K. issuer — one covering consumer credit and another for commercial charge card. We are also continuing to strengthen ties with our partners, seeking new approaches to eliminate friction and improve the client experience via innovation. Earlier this week, we made public a worldwide collaboration with TransferWise, marking the debut application of Visa Cloud Connect — an innovative method for establishing secure connections to VisaNet via cloud infrastructure. Through this new platform, TransferWise will be able to broaden the reach of its multi-currency debit cards across Asia Pacific, Europe, the Middle East, the U.K., and the U.S., while also providing their customers with various financial offerings through a mobile application, such as currency exchange and P2P payments, all tied to a Visa card. Tap to Pay continues to grow its footprint, now accounting for nearly two-thirds of all in-person transactions outside the United States. Here in the U.S., roughly 300 million contactless cards are now in circulation, and we've achieved high single-digit penetration for face-to-face transactions. Taking that into account, America now ranks fourth globally when it comes to how many Tap to Pay transactions happen. Adoption continues to expand, since every one of Costco's 500 fuel stations, along with Chipotle and Nordstrom outlets, are now set up for Tap to Pay. Another update I'm happy to share: the New York City MTA has finished bringing this capability to its entire subway and bus network. Processing also serves as a channel for getting Visa's new offerings into the market, and during the quarter just ended we achieved notable gains across Latin America — specifically in Ecuador, Colombia, and Peru — while hitting full processing penetration, at 100%, in Chile. Before wrapping up the consumer payment portion, I'd like to mention some encouraging developments in India. We continue to grow credentials, with total credentials growing 0.5%. In India, the Amazon Pay ICICI Bank co-branded credit card has achieved a national milestone: more than 1 million cards issued within only 20 months. When it comes to acceptance, the country now counts 6.5 million acceptance locations, among them over 1 million QR points — an increase of nearly 20 percentage points versus twelve months earlier — and tap-to-pay functionality is live on 65% of all terminals. The Reserve Bank of India lifted the contactless ceiling not long ago, and that change will shortly encompass more than 90% of transactions across India. Visa has forged fresh alliances with major acquirers, FIS Payments among them, to roll out acceptance offerings like Tap to Phone and contactless. Together with HDFC Bank, the biggest acquirer in India, Visa is launching and expanding Smart Hub, an application that combines payments, banking, and value-added services so small merchants can grow their operations; beyond that, we are putting money into India's Payments Infrastructure Development Fund to spur adoption of physical and digital acceptance in underserved regions, adding 1 million points of sale plus 2 million QR points annually across the coming three years. Every one of these initiatives rests on our top credit and debit market position in India. Turning to the second growth lever — new flows — this space holds a $185 trillion opportunity. We are going after it both through our established commercial card offerings and through newer tools such as Visa Direct and Visa B2B Connect.
Al Kelly
executiveWe're seeing momentum on every one of our new flows, and I want to call out some of the quarter's developments. On the B2C side, gig economy disbursements and earned wage access keep expanding at a solid clip in the aftermath of COVID. Together with DoorDash this quarter, we brought the Dasher Direct business prepaid card to the U.S. market, which gives the more than 1 million Dashers on DoorDash's platform access to everyday deposits of wages they've earned plus a full set of card perks; up in Canada, SkipTheDishes, that country's biggest food delivery network, introduced courier payouts powered by Visa Direct under the name Fast Cash. P2P accounts for $20 trillion in flows, was Visa Direct's very first use case, and it's still rising considerably. Cross-border P2P, or remittance, stands out as a major opportunity for growth ahead. During fiscal year 2020, we brought on board four of the world's five biggest money transfer operators. Those are TransferWise, Western Union, Remitly, and MoneyGram, and MoneyGram reported a 500% year-over-year jump in real-time transfers for December by itself. Growing remittance also means reaching fintechs and banks that are able to turn this capability on. Zeepay, an African fintech growing quickly, is going to leverage Visa Direct so Africans can move money along European and North American corridors, with plans to soon extend to every major corridor worldwide. TransferGo, a worldwide money transfer firm that helps migrant workers send funds home to family members while avoiding needless bank charges, has switched on Visa Direct across 55 markets and could reach as many as 178 countries down the road through forthcoming additions including the U.K., Italy, and Nigeria. Globally, Visa Direct transactions were up nearly 60% in the first quarter; that brings me to B2B. On the cross-border side, Goldman Sachs Transaction Banking recently came aboard to use Visa B2B Connect for moving money across borders between businesses, giving its corporate customers the capacity to transact throughout more than 80 markets around the world; it makes us very happy that our relationship with Goldman keeps getting stronger in several areas; when it comes to the virtual card-based business, we've broadened our ties with U.K.-based Conferma Pay to roll out Visa Commercial Pay, which comes in three offerings, starting with a mobile app that lets businesses issue and manage virtual cards for incidental expenses. Second, a way to oversee business travel spending with better data. Third, a payables platform that's integrated and can send payments straight to suppliers. Barclays has already made this functionality available to its commercial clients. Right now, practically all of these new flows get transacted in conventional fiat currencies. Interest in digital currencies keeps building, so I'd like to spend a moment explaining how Visa views crypto overall and what our strategy is. Here, we see opportunities to deliver distinctive value to the ecosystem. Our view is that we're positioned unlike anyone else to help make cryptocurrencies safer, more useful, and more applicable for payments, thanks to our worldwide footprint, our collaborative approach, and our trusted brand; we divide the crypto market into two segments. The first covers cryptocurrencies that stand for new assets, Bitcoin being one example. The second category covers stablecoins and other digital currencies pegged directly to traditional fiat money. Within that first group, we regard every currency as digital gold — mostly kept as holdings rather than being used meaningfully for payments right now. What we aim to do is collaborate with wallets and exchanges so people can buy these currencies with their Visa credentials, or withdraw funds onto a Visa credential to make a fiat purchase at any of the 70 million merchants worldwide that accept Visa. That mirrors how we link up closed-loop wallets like LINE Pay and Paytm. Turning to the second group — fiat-backed digital currencies, which takes in stablecoins along with central bank digital currencies — these represent a developing payments innovation with the potential to serve global commerce, in much the same way as any fiat currency. Digital currencies operating on public blockchains strike us as simply more networks, comparable to RTP or ACH. We view them as fitting within our network of network strategy. Within both groups, we hold a clear leading position. As of today, 35 of the top digital currency platforms and wallets have opted to issue Visa, among them Coinbase, Crypto.com, BlockFi, Fold, and Bitpanda; these wallet relationships carry the potential for over 50 million Visa credentials. The nearest competing network has only a small share of that; obviously, if a particular digital currency were to become an accepted medium of exchange, nothing stops us from adding it to our network, which today already handles more than 160 currencies. Now let me move to the third growth lever, value-added services. Revenue there rose 19% in Q1. Let me highlight several services that made notable progress this quarter. With e-commerce booming, CyberSource continues to draw strong interest from merchants, as well as from fintechs and acquirers wanting to use our capabilities to serve their own clients; this quarter, 2 more leading acquirers signed up for CyberSource — KBank in Thailand and NAB in Australia. As one of the biggest processors for debit and prepaid issuers, we've sought to take Visa DPS global; along those lines, we're happy to report that we're launching our Visa Debit Processing Service in Europe. DKB, our biggest issuing bank in Germany, selected DPS as its debit processor and recently completed Visa's first European DPS transaction through their platform. Through this connection, DKB can also access close to 20 value-added services. For years we've held the view that installments are a major opportunity in payments. To make this possible, we provide our own network solution that issuers, merchants, and fintech installment providers can use directly, and we likewise partner with numerous installment providers to build new solutions. This quarter brought updates on both fronts. We struck a global agreement with Afterpay, extending our U.S. We also have partnerships with seven more nations, and in those places Afterpay is going to leverage Visa’s technology to speed up its worldwide growth. On top of that, Visa and Afterpay are going to run tests and work together on using emerging technologies such as tokenization and Visa Direct. Back in July, we told you that Commerce Bank down in the United States was running a pilot of the network solution, and now it has gone live with roughly 300,000 customers active. Visa additionally brought Scotiabank on board as the first bank in Canada to roll out a post-purchase installment pilot, starting with employees in December, and a launch across the full market is planned for the middle of 2021. Every one of these growth levers — consumer payments, new flows, and value-added services — comes from our network of network strategy, which makes possible all kinds of payment, drawing on all networks, and delivering the value-added services that you'd anticipate from Visa as we facilitate money movement. To wrap up, a handful of things. Domestic volumes, fueled by debit and e-commerce, are genuinely maintaining strength. Holiday spending, even though it varied by category and by timing, was pretty strong. Q1 on the whole was a really strong quarter and positive momentum carried on, even though COVID-19 is still affecting us. We keep working extremely hard to strike a balance between managing expenses, in light of near-term realities, and putting money into a thrilling set of growth opportunities, since we always run this business with the long term in mind.
Al Kelly
executiveOur attention remains fixed on the three levers for growth, each backed by what we call our network of network. And finally, our hope is that with vaccines being distributed and getting easier to obtain, lockdowns, restrictions on travel, and limits on capacity will diminish or go away entirely, which would let travel, entertainment, and other commerce expand; with that said, I'll hand things to Vasant for additional detail on our volumes and our financials.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveThanks, Al. Good afternoon, everybody. Back in our fiscal first quarter of last year, the term COVID-19 hadn't even entered the English vocabulary yet. This marks the final quarter in which our results will be measured against a period that had zero COVID-related effects. Because of that, what we're reporting this quarter gives a transparent view of how the recovery is progressing. On the whole, the quarter came in above our expectations, with net revenue falling 6%, mostly because of the cross-border segment. EPS was down just 3%, aided by reduced expenses and a lower tax rate. Currency movements compared with a year ago lifted reported net revenue growth by under half a point, and boosted EPS growth by under one point. With the one-year mark of the pandemic approaching, how are we doing on our main business drivers compared with where we could have been if the pandemic had never occurred? Global payments volume sits four to five points below where it could have been. Debit has done better, boosted by faster cash displacement. Credit continues to be a weight. Here in the U.S., we've actually returned to the growth path we had before the pandemic, with debit well ahead while credit underperforms. As you're aware, the area where we lag substantially is cross-border; during the first quarter of fiscal 2021, our cross-border volumes ran almost 40% below what they could have been absent the pandemic, not counting intra-Europe volumes, mainly because of travel. Cross-border travel volume, covering both card present and card not present, remains nearly 70% below where it could have been at this stage. Let's begin with a look at the main business drivers for the fiscal first quarter. Global payments volume and transaction growth rates came in slightly above the previous quarter. Cross-border volume kept recovering, even though the majority of borders are still fully or partly shut. How domestic spending recovers differs by region around the world. Certain regions and countries are bouncing back quickly, others are flat, and a few have decelerated in recent weeks because of fresh restrictions. What's uniform everywhere is extremely robust debit and e-commerce spending, partly counterbalanced by softer credit and in-store spending. Even though constant dollar cross-border volume, excluding transactions inside Europe, remains down 33%, that's an eight-point gain over last quarter. Payment volume in constant dollars rose 4.5%. Debit climbed 17%, 3 percentage points below last quarter, whereas credit fell 6%, 3 percentage points better than Q4. Growth outside China reached 7%, nearly one point higher, as Chinese domestic volumes keep being affected by dual-branded card conversions, which carry almost no revenue impact. U.S. payments volume growth hit 8%, half a point above last quarter. Debit growth stayed robust at 21%. Debit growth came in three points under the fourth quarter, chiefly because of a step-down in unemployment benefits paid out through Visa prepaid cards. Spending on credit fell 3% compared with the same period a year earlier, which is a four-point gain relative to the previous quarter, helped by quicker growth in retail purchases and a partial rebound in travel and restaurant activity. Card-not-present volume, leaving out travel, kept expanding by more than 30% during the quarter, mostly because of retail spending. The drop in card-present spending matched what we saw in the prior quarter. Even so, results did weaken as the quarter went on, since climbing COVID cases prompted additional restrictions imposed by governments in a number of states and cities. The most notable slowdowns in card-present spending occurred in restaurants, and also over the Thanksgiving holiday weekend across most segments. Looking across spend category, growth was fairly in line with the prior quarter. Categories that have been expanding beyond their pre-COVID levels stayed elevated, such as food and drug stores, home improvement, and retail goods; in categories hit hardest by this pandemic, such as travel, entertainment, fuel, and restaurants, spending stayed depressed, with year-over-year declines matching the prior quarter. International payments volume rose 2% in Q1, or 6% if China is excluded, and both figures are one point higher than last quarter. A few regional highlights. CEMEA is still our strongest region, with 19% growth in constant dollars for the quarter, a more than four-point gain over Q4. Looser COVID-related restrictions, especially in the Middle East, along with client wins, powered that robust growth. Latin America rose 16% in constant dollars, nearly a 10-point acceleration from last quarter. This faster growth comes from limited COVID-related restrictions in most countries, e-commerce spending that is elevated relative to other regions, and market share gains from client wins in a few of the larger countries. Europe rose 5% in constant dollars, a four-point deceleration from last quarter. That slowdown came partly from renewed restrictions during the second half of the quarter, caused by COVID infection rates rising quickly, especially in the U.K., France, Italy, and Germany. And, as you may recall, Europe's growth last quarter got a boost from a non-recurring event in the U.K. tied to purchases of higher interest-bearing savings funds. Asia Pacific fell 8% in constant dollars. With China excluded, Q1 spending was flat, a four-point gain since last quarter. More COVID-related restrictions remain in place across Asia than in other parts of the world. Still, several larger markets, such as New Zealand, Australia, Korea, and Japan, have gone back to growth. Processed transactions growth was 4%, one point above last quarter. Growth picked up faster than payments volume because transaction sizes kept normalizing outside Europe. Tighter COVID-related restrictions in Europe are pushing average ticket sizes higher, which is causing transactions growth to slow. Latin America is gaining from processing wins in several countries, among them Ecuador, Colombia, Peru, and Chile. Visa Direct keeps doing very well, with transactions up almost 60% globally this quarter. Growth is still strong in every region as we keep launching new use cases, deepen existing ones like earned wage access and cross-border remittance, and bring existing use cases into new geographies. In the first quarter, cross-border volume in constant dollars—leaving out transactions inside Europe—fell 33%, which is an eight-point gain compared with the prior quarter. Spending tied to travel dropped 64%, yet that was six points better than what we saw in the fourth quarter. Non-travel card not present growth came in at 20%, three points higher, driven by robust retail spending during November and December. When transactions within Europe are included, constant dollar cross-border volume for the quarter was down 21%. Cross-border travel did get better at a steady pace as the quarter went on, but those gains were clustered in just a handful of markets where borders are open. U.S. travel to a number of Latin American countries, among them Mexico and the Caribbean, is still strong. The UAE has kept its doors open to travelers, drawing visitors from Europe, Russia, and other Gulf countries. On top of that, travel among countries in the former Soviet Union has been expanding. Sadly, most borders are still shut or place heavy requirements on international travelers. In December, the World Tourism Organization said that of 217 countries, 118 countries—54%—had borders either fully or partly closed to foreign visitors. Among the other 99 countries, most require COVID tests along with quarantines. Only a very small number of countries have no COVID restrictions at all. Major hurdles to crossing borders continue to be the number one factor behind the sluggish rebound in cross-border travel. Now a brief look at first-quarter financial results.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveWe saw net revenue decline by 6%, and that actually came in ahead of our expectations. The main drivers were better-than-forecast cross-border volumes along with lower client incentives. Our value-added services continued to deliver strong results, growing 19%. One thing worth noting: had we recognized service revenues against this quarter's payments volume, the impact on Q1 net revenue growth would have been negligible, because payment volume growth was quite similar across both quarters. Service revenues increased 5%, which roughly aligned with the nominal payments volume growth we saw last quarter. Data processing grew 6%, as continued high teens growth in value-added services was partially counterbalanced by the mix shift away from higher-yielding cross-border transactions. International transaction revenue declined by 28%, which came in four points ahead of cross-border volume when intra-Europe is excluded, driven by a favorable country mix and gains from currency volatility. We kept facing pressure from reduced usage of card benefits tied to travel. Client incentives accounted for 24.6% of gross revenues, about one point under our expectation. Three things caused that. To begin, a number of sizable deals we had anticipated closing during the first quarter were pushed into the second quarter. Next, cross-border volume turned out stronger than we had forecast, particularly in December. As we have mentioned previously, client incentives are mostly linked to payments volume, so when high-yielding cross-border volumes outperform, our incentives decline as a percentage of gross revenues. Number three: our growth in payments volume was better by just 0.5 points versus the prior quarter. As a result, client incentives for the current quarter were barely affected by the volume we saw. Now, on the operating expense side, the steps we took last spring continue to pay off. We have fewer employees, we're spending less on outside services, travel is still largely curtailed, and we've trimmed certain marketing costs. Operating expenses on both a GAAP and non-GAAP basis were down 10%, which beat what we had anticipated, in part because of shifts in timing for client co-marketing and because some product and technology investments were pushed into later in the year. For the fiscal quarter, non-GAAP non-operating expense totaled $112 million, which came in over $30 million under our expectations, and that was due to two non-recurring items. Higher deferred-compensation-related investment income was more than offset by personnel costs, so the net effect was neutral. Next, the completion of some tax audits allowed an interest expense reserve to be released. At 16.6%, the non-GAAP tax rate ended up below what we had anticipated. Finishing tax audits in certain jurisdictions during the quarter generated an $81 million benefit. Apart from that particular benefit, employee equity vesting typically makes our tax rate lower in the first quarter. GAAP and non-GAAP EPS came to $1.42, a decline of 3%. This quarter we bought back 8.7 million shares of Class A common stock, paying an average of $202.30 per share, which totaled $1.8 billion. The board gave the green light to a fresh share buyback plan of 8 billion shares, lifting the total amount we can spend on repurchases past $11 billion. Add in our quarterly dividend of $0.32 per share, and we returned about $2.5 billion of capital to shareholders in the quarter; meanwhile, in December, $3 billion of debt was settled when senior notes issued five years prior reached maturity. Now for some perspective on the second fiscal quarter, starting with how business drivers trended through January 21st. As of January 21st, U.S. payments volume was up 12%, with U.S. debit climbing 30% and credit declining 6%. On the debit side, growth is running 10 points higher than what we saw during November and December, and that's largely because of government stimulus money that went out near the start of January. When you look at the weekly numbers, there's a clear jump in growth in week one of January, followed by a pullback in week three. Over on credit, January growth has slowed by three points compared with December, putting it closer to the pace we saw in November. As for U.S. On the payments volume side, growth has strengthened. At the same time, in a lot of countries, constant dollar growth is decelerating as restrictions tighten while COVID-19 infections rise. Across Asia Pacific—Japan, Australia, India, and Singapore—payments volume growth is down four to five points compared with December. In Europe, markets including the U.K., Italy, Denmark, and Germany are all posting January growth that is slower by at least 10 points. So far, rates of growth in both CEMEA and Latin America have stayed fairly stable. As of January 21st, processed transactions growth was unchanged at 4%, as faster growth in the U.S. was offset by slower growth in Europe and Asia Pacific. On a constant dollar basis, cross-border volume outside of intra-Europe transactions dropped 33%. That matched what we saw in the first quarter, though it trailed the patterns from December. Forecasting with precision is still hard when conditions shift so quickly. We don't know how long stimulus-fueled spending will stay elevated. It's unclear how much longer tighter restrictions and lockdowns will remain in effect. And we can't yet say how those two opposing forces will net out from one country to the next. Another open question: will cross-border travel keep inching toward recovery even as fresh restrictions are introduced? Those are merely a few of the unknowns we face over the coming three months. Looking at how things have gone so far, we figure second quarter gross revenue growth will bounce back to roughly level with a year ago, and international revenues should account for the bulk of that gain. We also expect a slight rise in the other revenue lines, helped by softer year-over-year comparisons during the latter part of March. Client incentives in the first quarter came in a point under what we had projected. For the second quarter, client incentives might land a point above the top of the 25.5%-26.5% range we're forecasting for the full year. That would leave first-half incentives sitting squarely in the middle of that range. A number of factors explain why client incentives, measured as a share of gross revenues, rose in the second quarter, and that happened despite cross-border continuing to get better. A few sizable deals shifted out of the first quarter and into the second, as I noted before; Wells Fargo was one of them, and Al pointed out that it was signed in January. Back in October, we told you that certain customers had missed their volume targets for calendar year 2020, so the associated incentives were not paid out to them. Now that volumes are recovering in 2021, we expect those customers to hit the growth thresholds and collect those incentives. Starting in Q1 of the new calendar year, we accrue incentives on that basis. That creates a bigger bump that is specific to the recovery year. Number three, the effect of renewals that we had already anticipated during Q2. Because client incentives as a share of gross revenue step up, the drop in net revenue for Q2 should be similar to what we saw in Q1, even while the revenue growth rate keeps improving. Changes in exchange rates might add under one point to second quarter net revenue growth. We anticipate that OpEx will rise in the low to mid-single digit range during Q2 as we start to lap the cost cuts we made a year ago. Our plan remains to increase expenses by double digits in the back half as we ramp up spending on important growth efforts, expecting a return to normal by the close of fiscal 2021. Non-operating expense ought to be roughly $145 million, comparable to Q1 if you take out the two one-time items I referenced earlier. Our expectations for the tax rate remain unchanged.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveWe can't yet tell how the U.S. elections might affect our taxes. We'll keep giving updates as the year goes on, just like we always do; to sum up, our business is still resilient, as you can see. Debit growth and e-commerce growth are both holding up well above where they were before COVID-19, since the faster move toward digital payments is turning into a routine. Once vaccines help borders reopen and we get past last year's sharp drops, cross-border growth should rebound strongly. Throughout the hardest stretch of the pandemic, our new flows business and our value-added services business kept expanding at a healthy pace. Like Al said, we've remained concentrated on our long-term growth initiatives, and in the second half we'll raise our investment level in expectation of a post-COVID-19 world where growth speeds up. With that, I'll hand things back to Mike.
Mike Milotich
executiveWe're now ready to take questions, Michelle.
James Faucette
analystThanks a lot. What I'd like to understand is how you're approaching things strategically now that you've walked away from the Plaid deal. I'm hoping you can share some thoughts on where your relationships with regulators stand and what direction makes sense going forward when it comes to acquiring future technology, and so on. Appreciate it.
Al Kelly
executiveThanks, James. Let me start with the second part of what you asked. What we had here was one regulator filing one lawsuit concerning a single M&A transaction. My view is that this doesn't signal anything regarding what lies ahead or our capacity to keep pursuing company acquisitions. A couple of weeks back, we said that we ultimately reached the conclusion that this process was simply going to drag on for too long. It's common knowledge that the payments marketplace is advancing extremely quickly across numerous dimensions. The prospect of getting ourselves bogged down in this transaction, and honestly, of Plaid getting bogged down in prolonged litigation that might even run through an appeal on its own, held no appeal for us when weighed against all the other opportunities we believed we could put investment into, devote management attention to, and direct our money toward. We remain committed to pushing forward on the path of ensuring we are a genuine participant in open banking, and we think we already possess many of the necessary assets. What the Plaid acquisition would have accomplished was to bring us specifically into the data extraction line of business, which would have enhanced our network of networks, yet that alone doesn't stop us from pursuing more down the road. We likewise retain the option in that area to work with Plaid; we can work with other participants globally, and frequently, that could open the door to working with companies that grasp the particular intricacies of the individual markets where they operate. We'll keep examining things to ensure that, to whatever extent use cases emerge here, the one with the greatest likelihood of breaking out and having real staying power would be account to account. I believe our position there is quite strong. We're set up well to ensure we can deliver payment capabilities to the many fintechs we currently serve, and we can keep selling value-added services to each of those players. Ultimately, just as we've done before, we'll put money into growing organically. We'll pursue partnerships, and we'll pursue acquisitions, and it will be a blend of capabilities and approaches that keeps us a participant in this area.
James Faucette
analystThat's useful background, Al. One brief question on operations as a follow-up. Clearly, over the past year you removed costs from the expense structure because of the pandemic. How should we frame which pieces of that expense structure will probably come back as conditions normalize, and which ones might represent more lasting shifts?
Al Kelly
executiveWell, if you examine our expense structure, the largest elements are personnel, marketing, and technology. We believe the Tokyo Olympics are arriving during the summer months. Some folks think that could be somewhat at risk right now; it is proceeding. We kept marketing at fairly restrained levels during the quarter just ended, and I would definitely anticipate that we will be pushing marketing higher. Essentially, whenever we take our business to market, it involves combining people resources, technology resources, and marketing strength behind whatever initiative we're pursuing. Those are the areas where I would anticipate growth ahead. And then, naturally, we have sharply reduced T&E and professional services. To the extent that later in the year some employees start returning to offices and some travelers start boarding planes again, I think we'll see modest upticks in those expense categories; we have been quite disciplined regarding spending at the people level, the technology level, and the marketing level. As circumstances justify, I believe we will be increasing those. Vasant provided you with some perspective on where we expect expenses to land in the second half. We see some very strong opportunities, and I want to ensure that if, as we anticipate, we reach some version of normalcy by the conclusion of this fiscal year, we are positioned with solid momentum entering fiscal 2022.
James Faucette
analystNice detail, Al. Thanks.
Tien-Tsin Huang
analystHi, many thanks. I appreciate the detail regarding volume trends. I'd like to ask about value-added services. That rose within the high teens. I'm curious how long-lasting that might be and whether that expansion might actually accelerate once volume eventually recovers. I'm simply attempting to grasp how procyclical that business is, or isn't.
Al Kelly
executiveTien-Tsin, thanks. I suppose a bit of detail for everyone. Roughly 2/3 of our value-added services sit within data processing; those are essentially transaction-based revenue streams. That includes CyberSource, our risk and identity products, and DPS — every one of those should keep generating really strong volumes, and they will track transactions as transactions shift. Roughly a third of our value-added services divide between our services revenue, which tends to consist of card benefits provided as a package, and then within other revenue we have services not linked to volumes, such as consulting, our practice, and travel-related card benefits that clearly have declined. I believe that if travel were to return at some point, that clearly would benefit that volume. With that detail, we observed, clearly, in a landscape where e-commerce and omni-commerce are growing important, cyber volume was really strong and fueled revenue; we kept having additional customers engage with us regarding risk and identity services. As I mentioned before, we're now thrilled that we will extend our data processing system past the United States, and we've started using it in Europe. I believe that provides us a solid foundation for growth ahead too.
Tien-Tsin Huang
analystVery good. Thank you.
Al Kelly
executiveThanks, Tien-Tsin.
Don Fandetti
analystHey there, good evening. Al or Vasant, regarding the improvement we saw in cross-border, I actually thought that was a fairly decent quarter-over-quarter gain in the growth rate. When it comes to U.S. to LatAm, you mentioned it stayed strong — did it get better? Was that part of what drove the overall year-over-year improvement?
Al Kelly
executiveDon, when it comes to Latin America, the volume in North America was really driven by U.S. to Mexico along with U.S. to the Caribbean. On top of that, Dubai opened up somewhat. Dubai is experiencing a bit of a resurgence, and just went back under some restrictions earlier this week. Dubai has been open, and there's been a decent amount of travel within the Middle East. Among the countries in the former Soviet Union, there's been a slight opening, and then within South America there's been some improvement or some movement in intra-travel. Those are sort of the spots where improvements in cross-border have shown up for us. As Vasant said in his remarks, most of the other corridors globally continue to be either closed or subject to really tough restrictions, which make it very difficult for somebody to take on traveling.
Don Fandetti
analystAl, when you look at those figures, do you still get the sense that the data points point to a decent amount of pent-up demand for when things start opening up?
Al Kelly
executiveDon, when it comes to consumer travel — and over the years that's represented the vast majority of our payment volume in the travel sector — I do believe we will definitely see some opening. My sense is there's substantial pent-up demand. Plenty of folks haven't seen their family, parents haven't seen their grandchildren, children haven't seen their parents, and they're going to want to get on planes. I also believe many people are stir crazy and eager to get out. You have people who are genuine global citizens crossing items off their to-do list — destinations they want to visit and sights they want to see. Consumer travel, at the right moment, provided we see these restrictions eased or reduced in fairly significant ways, I believe will rebound quite strongly. Business travel, in my view, will take longer to recover. Honestly, returning business travel to its prior state could take years. All of us have grown used to holding discussions via video conferences and so on, and I suspect we all recognize there were trips we took or approved in the past that, looking back now with video calls in mind, make us ask, "Why did we send somebody to that meeting for a 1.5-hour presentation that could just as easily have been done over video?" That's how I see it going forward, Don.
Don Fandetti
analystThanks.
Lisa Ellis
analystGood afternoon, and thank you. I have a follow-up regarding Visa Direct, which you mentioned once more — it expanded by nearly 60% during the quarter. During your Investor Day this past February, you estimated the B2C, G2C, and P2P sectors at roughly $60 trillion in total payment volume. My understanding is Visa Direct handled around $350 billion in the prior year, which works out to approximately half a percent of that figure. Could you discuss, as Visa Direct continues to evolve over time, what portion of those sectors do you believe Visa Direct could potentially serve? Is there any indication of the monetization level we ought to consider — something comparable to domestic debit, or would it differ? Thank you.
Al Kelly
executiveWell, Lisa, I appreciate that question. Visa Direct can expand along multiple vectors. The two I consider most evident — actually, I'd say three — are continued penetration of existing use cases, newly developed use cases, and third, geographic expansion. This remains a business we are still constructing. Much work remains across all three of those categories. Regarding a question asked earlier, I believe it came from Don, we will keep investing in that area. Look, there are markets where we haven't yet laid any track for Visa Direct. There are use cases where no track has been laid, and we intend to keep doing that. If we examine the very first Visa Direct use case, which keeps growing substantially — P2P payments — much remains to be done, both in domestic P2P payments. We believe a key future growth area lies in cross-border P2P and remittance, and we are starting to take steps there to make that possible. I noted during my remarks that we hold relationships with four of the five top global money transfer operators, and that is assisting us considerably. I think earned wage access remains a genuine opportunity. I discussed a few of those cases briefly, yet there are still many geographies and many organizations we can penetrate to grow that. Then there are all these B2C use cases — things such as food and grocery delivery, online gaming, and insurance claim payouts. All of those are, I would say, in the early innings of a baseball game when it comes to our capacity to keep making progress and drive those. I remain convinced that this platform, from which we can generate dozens and dozens of use cases, will be really important to us from a growth perspective for quite some time.
Lisa Ellis
analystSuper exciting. Thank you.
Al Kelly
executiveThank you, Lisa.
Chris Brendler
analystHello. Thank you. Good afternoon. I appreciate you taking my question. Al, it's great to speak with you. I'm very curious to hear what you think about this buy now, pay later trend that appears to be gaining momentum, and I'm aware you offer a solution in that area, and how significant do you believe that solution might grow, and is there any competitive risk stemming from consumers selecting another payment method at checkout when they're making online purchases?
Al Kelly
executiveWell, Chris, this is quite an intriguing area, and my sense is we're still in the early stages across most markets. There are several distinct models out there. As I believe I've mentioned previously, and I think Vasant has mentioned previously, our company doesn't engage in selecting winners and losers. We view our role as providing enablement regardless of what the model happens to be. In certain instances, the player itself is the lender. In certain instances, they bring in a lender. In certain instances, the installments are extremely short-term, just weeks at a time. In certain instances, they extend long-term. Certain providers offer only installments. Certain ones permit several payment choices, pay now, pay on delivery, pay off across various quantities of installments. Clearly, the exciting part for us is having multiple methods to pay off installments, virtual cards, debit cards, ACH. It's also a payment model today that receives substantial funding from the merchant. Our approach, Chris, is to remain broad, to collaborate with numerous third-party providers and deliver a Visa platform that lets issuers provide buy now, pay later capability. We aim to engage with all these options, and clearly, what we're after is having virtual cards from Visa established as one repayment option. We likewise want to have Visa cards on file as an additional option. I'd like to point out that these installments do break, at their foundation, these installments split a transaction or a purchase into three or four or five payment transactions, which benefits us since it generates more transactions for us to earn fees on.
Chris Brendler
analystExcellent. A brief additional question, should I be permitted one. In markets such as Sweden, where that payment method now accounts for the biggest portion of transactions, are you truly observing a volume effect, or do sufficient numbers of consumers opt for your cards such that volume really will be affected, considering the scale of expansion occurring in buy now, pay later within that region?
Al Kelly
executiveA handful of nations exist. You brought up Sweden. Australia is another. Not very many. Just a small set of countries where adoption has genuinely surged. My view is it has definitely made some difference for banks operating in those markets. Frequently, thanks to the sorts of settlement features I described earlier, card on file, virtual cards, and so on, a substantial share of that volume returns to us through repayments.
Chris Brendler
analystThat's great. Many thanks, Al. I appreciate that.
Darrin Peller
analystHey, thanks, everyone. Just a quick question for Vasant, and then Al, one that's more about structure. If I can ask both at the same time. Vasant, on the incentive side, I know you said the reason it came in under the range this quarter was timing, but it will come in — I think you said above the range, or it potentially could be, for the next quarter. When you first gave guidance of 25.5 to 26.5, that was embedding cross-border activity like what we saw in the September quarter, which turned out better. I just want to know, are you now assuming some deterioration or added conservatism in cross-border before it possibly improves later in the year? And Al, maybe I can squeeze in a structural one, again, things like debit seem somewhat sustainable. It isn't only people spending more on non-discretionary. I'm curious what you'd point to now, after nearly a year of the pandemic, as the top two or three things you believe are structurally affecting your business longer term and potentially here to stay?
Vasant Prabhu
executiveYeah. Just on the incentives question: we try to give you our best sense of a range, and right now visibility is greatest in the first half since we're halfway through it, and we believe we'll land right in the middle of the range. A lot of variables feed into it at a time like this when things are shifting around quite a bit. Of course, cross-border performing better helps. Renewals will matter. Sometimes they occur when we expect, sometimes they don't. There are also the year-over-year improvements our clients have. As you know, a year ago, many clients, because of the pandemic, didn't reach certain thresholds. This year, things are recovering faster. We think they'll all reach their thresholds and more. That creates a year-over-year impact, and it differs by client. A bunch of these things are moving around simultaneously. The good news is, we believe we're right in the middle of the range, and we'll give you more as the year goes on.
Al Kelly
executiveDarrin, regarding that second question of yours. To start with, plenty of factors explain why debit has performed so well. Stimulus funds loaded onto prepaid cards are part of it — and prepaid counts within our debit segment. With e-commerce expanding into more routine spending categories, consumers are turning to debit. During difficult circumstances, individuals feel more at ease spending funds they already possess rather than taking on borrowed money they lack. Structurally speaking, when I think about what lies ahead for your question — well, e-commerce penetration likely jumped ahead by three to five years over the last year, and I doubt that reverses. Those who've become accustomed to buying via phone, tablet, or computer will keep doing so. Another structural element I find genuinely thrilling is the substantial room to expand both sides of this two-sided marketplace — purchasers and merchants alike. Wallets keep multiplying, and we're putting in serious effort to secure credentials inside those wallets, which essentially means wallets are turning into issuers, and that fuels additional buyer growth. Acceptance costs are declining globally as an increasing number of participants enter the space, and that will boost the count of merchants on our network. As the network expands, I believe that will prove quite beneficial for us. I also think concerns around cash keep rising, combined with Tap to Pay in the physical world, where a card never has to be handed to anyone else to complete a transaction. Add to that the reality that cash simply isn't an option online. Structurally, all of these developments strike me as quite favorable for us. On the other hand, as I noted, business travel represents a modest portion of our total travel — and that will be one area that turns out somewhat softer.
Darrin Peller
analystUnderstood.
Al Kelly
executive...taking longer to recover, and possibly it will never return to where it stood before COVID-19.
Darrin Peller
analystOkay, that's genuinely useful, thank you both.
Mike Milotich
executiveLet's take the next question.
Bryan Keane
analystHey, everyone. Vasant, I'd like to ask about cross-border as it recovers, particularly probably during this latter half of the calendar year. How should we think about the greater yields and profitability, how will that reach the bottom line relative to the extra investments you mention? What exactly would those investments be? Would they fully cancel out the gain we'll get from that cross-border?
Vasant Prabhu
executiveThere's no doubt that cross-border returning has a significant effect on our revenue line. You already saw that during the first quarter. Our cross-border performed better than we had anticipated. Because of that, our revenues were also considerably better than we had anticipated. We're stating that we will increase our investment during the second half and anticipate our expenses to rise double digits. If the cross-border business returns in a significant manner, that's obviously going to mean far better growth on the top line than that double-digit rise in expenses we're planning. You should keep in mind that we begin lapping the expense declines from last year. During the second half of last year, our expenses fell by 5% or so. When we increase them double digits in this fiscal year's second half, across a two-year period, we're only raising them roughly 5%. Ultimately, cross-border returning is going to have a very favorable effect on our business, especially if it returns faster than we might anticipate; regardless, the comparisons improve, so you'll start to see growth in the cross-border business simply due to what occurred last year.
Bryan Keane
analystUnderstood. That's useful. Many thanks.
Harshita Rawat
analystHello. Good afternoon, and thanks for taking my question. I'd like to ask about your volume metrics. When I look at your figures next to those of your nearest competitor across the past 2 quarters, a reversal has appeared: your volume growth in Europe and the U.S. has outpaced that of your peers. What's the right way to interpret this? Does it reflect deal flow arriving, your FinTech partnerships, Visa Direct showing up in the results? Any detail you can offer would be appreciated. Thanks.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveWell, the reasons always vary, and they depend on which part of the business you examine. Obviously, how the business is mixed between debit and credit matters. Everyone is aware that debit has plainly done better as the main engine of cash conversion worldwide; and then in certain regions, such as the U.S., where debit has served as a channel for distributing stimulus payments, it has gained from that too. The business mix is a major factor. We see no cause to expect debit to stop outperforming. Credit is coming back, which is a favorable development. Looking at various geographies, in Europe, most of the deceleration between Q1 and Q2 came from the benefit we enjoyed during the first quarter. Restrictions have had a minor effect on us. As long as restrictions don't grow more severe, the trend appears to be getting better nearly everywhere. You observed that in Latin America and EMEA, where we recorded substantial acceleration, and additional cases aren't affecting those trends much as far as we can tell. Broadly speaking, in the U.S., as I mentioned in my remarks, it's nearly as though the pandemic never occurred, correct? We posted roughly 8% growth in the first quarter of last year. We posted 8% once more in the first quarter of this year, so if you accept that our growth rate is 8% or 9%, we've essentially returned to that growth rate. On the international side, we're getting close. In our view, that trend is improving substantially, as you've seen. The place where we trail, and where the trend definitely remains weak, is Asia, where restrictions are still considerable; in Europe, restrictions are now rising somewhat, and we'll find out how they unfold.
Harshita Rawat
analystThanks.
Mike Milotich
executiveThanks, Harshita. There's time for one more question.
Ashwin Shirvaikar
analystThanks. Hello, Vasant. I have some questions about pricing. I realize your approach is value-based, but I'm curious how you're thinking about pricing if the economy improves as we hope. Could there be some catch-up on pricing? Would you go back to the usual long-term approach? Or do you simply expect a harder landscape for pricing under the interchange model? As a follow-up, is there an inherent upside from Brexit? That news came out a few days ago, so how are you factoring that in?
Al Kelly
executiveOkay, I'll offer a few thoughts, and then Vasant can definitely chime in. Ashwin, regarding your final point, I won't say anything about the Brexit matter; nothing has been announced by us, so commenting doesn't seem wise to me. I believe we chose to hold off on some pricing during the last year given what COVID made real, yet we intend to proceed with price increases that were postponed earlier, starting in April of this year; we also have a handful of smaller pricing adjustments. The effect will be fairly limited. Looking ahead, if we keep providing the value we aim to provide, then I believe there's a chance to examine pricing across all three of our growth strategies: core payments, new flows, and value-added services. Vasant, anything you'd like to add?
Vasant Prabhu
executiveNo, that's all I've got.
Ashwin Shirvaikar
analystExcellent.
Mike Milotich
executiveThanks to all of you for being with us today. Should any further questions come up, don't hesitate to reach our investor relations team by phone or email. Once more, thank you, and enjoy the rest of your evening.
Operator
operatorThanks. That wraps up the conference call for today. At this point, you’re free to disconnect.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Visa Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Visa Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Visa Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.