Visa Inc. (V) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
October 26, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Jennifer Como
executiveAppreciate that, Michelle. Hello, everyone, and thanks for joining us for Visa's earnings discussion covering the fourth fiscal quarter along with the complete 2021 fiscal year. With us on the line are Al Kelly, who serves as Visa's Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, plus Vasant Prabhu, our Vice Chairman and Chief Financial Officer. You can access a webcast of this call through the Investor Relations portion of our site, www.investor.visa.com. We'll keep a replay available in our archives for 90 days. Financial and statistical highlights are included in a slide deck that has been placed on our IR website. I'd also like to point out that forward-looking statements are part of this presentation. Such statements should not be viewed as guarantees regarding future performance, and a number of factors could cause our actual results to differ materially. You can find more details about those factors in our latest reports on Forms 10-K and 10-Q, accessible via the SEC's website as well as the Investor Relations portion of our site. When it comes to non-GAAP financial information shared on this call, the corresponding GAAP measures and reconciliation appear in today's earnings release. Having said all that, I'll hand things over to Al.
Alfred Kelly
executiveJennifer, I really appreciate it, and good afternoon to all of you, and thank you for being with us today; during the fourth quarter and across all of fiscal 2021, Visa produced strong results even as economic conditions remained uncertain and the effects of the COVID pandemic continued to linger. By doing so, we showed how resilient our business is and confirmed the soundness of our growth strategy as we keep pushing the fast expansion of digital payments and make innovation possible in money movement around the world. Here's a quick recap of Q4 results. Payments volume in the fourth quarter reached 121% of 2019, roughly 0.8 points higher than Q3 and 17% greater than a year earlier. Even with a global pandemic as the backdrop, this quarter we also achieved a record, with total global payments volume hitting $2.8 trillion. Cross-border volume, leaving out intra-Europe, came in at 86% of 2019, 4 points above Q3 and 46% higher year-over-year. And processed transactions stood at 124% of 2019, 4 points above Q3 and 21% greater year-over-year. Our net revenues rose 29% year-over-year, and non-GAAP EPS came to $1.62, an increase of 44%. From talking with many of you over recent months, I realize you're asking what lies ahead for Visa and the payments ecosystem as we come out of the pandemic. So instead of giving my typical report card on the quarter, I'll take a broader approach today and discuss the 4 main reasons we think Visa is positioned for growth even better than it was before the pandemic. One, there remains a huge opportunity in consumer payments. Two, we keep strengthening our network of networks capability so money movement becomes more seamless and secure for every participant in the ecosystem and so new flows gain traction faster. Third, value-added services at the same time assist our clients in tapping our scale and sophistication while also diversifying Visa's business and generating additional volume. Four, we make possible a great deal of the disruption and innovation within the payments ecosystem, which helps speed up Visa's growth. So let me begin with number one, the huge opportunity in consumer payments. We observe that the pandemic has contributed to further digitizing cash. Over the last 12 months, global debit cash volumes, which mostly represent the amount of cash taken out from Visa debit cards, rose 4%, while debit payments volume expanded 23%, both measured on a constant dollar basis; during 2021, the count of monthly active e-commerce credentials and spend per active credential kept rising strongly; for instance, within the United States, monthly active credentials and active spend per credential each increased by more than 20% on average compared with 2019. We've expanded credentials for both established and new players to 3.7 billion, up 7% year-over-year. Having renewed client contracts representing 55% of our payments volume across the prior 2 years, we renewed contracts representing almost 20% during 2021. Let me point out just a few of those deals in Q4. In our Asia Pacific region, we renewed 3 of Visa's top 20 issuers, among them China Merchants Bank and Bank of China. And in North America, we renewed 3 of the top 15 issuers. PNC extended its prepaid consumer credit and debit arrangements, plus commercial credit and small business credit and debit portfolios. Regions did the same, renewing those prepaid consumer credit and debit, commercial credit and small business credit and debit portfolios. Meanwhile, RBC and Visa signed a renewed agreement covering the issuing of credit, debit and prepaid cards in Canada. Our growth has also been driven by fintechs. Over the past 12 months, close to 30% more fintechs issued Visa credentials, and their payments volume has grown by more than 2x. On top of that, fintechs keep scaling. Acceptance has expanded too, to over 80 million merchant locations, a 14% increase year-over-year; and if you count small businesses behind companies such as Stripe and Square, that figure exceeds 100 million merchant locations. Tap-to-pay now accounts for 70% of all face-to-face transactions worldwide. Outside the United States, we have over 70 countries where contactless penetration tops 50%. In the U.S., penetration has reached over 15%, which is more than 2x what it was only a year ago, with 400 million cards, 4x the level of 2 years ago. Other markets teach us that tapping drives higher spending and more transactions while bringing cash into digital form; we keep innovating as well, so partners find it simpler to reach and use our platforms and capabilities. Visa Cloud Connect is one recent illustration, letting clients link to VisaNet through the cloud and removing any need to invest in local data centers, telecommunications infrastructure or specialized payment hardware. In short, consumer payments represents an opportunity, and it's Visa's credentials, acceptance and innovation that give us confidence in our capacity to speed up growth going forward. Now to our network of networks. We keep strengthening what we can do to let money move smoothly and safely for every participant in the ecosystem, while speeding up penetration of new flows. That new flows opportunity totals $185 trillion. Payments infrastructure, regulations and settlement systems are each highly local, which generates substantial complexity in a world of global trade. Through our network of networks capability, Visa acts as one connection point, helping clients move value domestically and cross-border across every network, including Visa's own networks, RTPs, ACHs and future new networks, such as stable coins and public blockchains. During FY '21, we kept expanding Visa Direct's global reach, exceeding 5 billion transactions across 500 programs and almost 550 enablers, including acquirers, processors, banks and fintechs. Within the U.S. by itself, close to 120 million cards have sent or received funds through Visa Direct. What sets Visa Direct apart is that it has more end points and more use cases than the next competitor, and it provides flexible technology. Our growth plan for Visa Direct centers on 4 key levers. First, deepen existing use cases. P2P is our biggest use case; and in FY '21, we went past 200 P2P programs globally. Insurance disbursements is another use case. This quarter, we brought on Nationwide to start distributing claims. Next, we aim to seize the opportunity that exists across borders. When it comes to cross-border person-to-person payments, we brought Paysend on board in Q4. Before long, U.S. users of Western Union will have the ability to transmit money to qualifying Visa cards in the Philippines, Thailand, Colombia and Jamaica, with a strong growth roadmap for additional nations to follow. Past remittances, we are putting our cross-border strengths to work for marketplaces, payments to suppliers, tuition for students and much else. Growing the more than 20 use cases already live is our third lever. Tipping fundraising, funding of brokerage accounts and airline vouchers are among recent illustrations. Also in Q4, we brought in Yardi within the rental sector, enabling property managers to hand out security deposits. Last of all, scaling new markets. Visa Direct has expanded quickly across a number of markets, yet plenty more exist where conditions favor faster growth. In Peru, for instance, our P2P presence is solid, and we are now introducing fresh use cases such as the creative payroll offering rolled out alongside Tu Sueldo Y, a provider of salary on demand that likewise aims to boost financial inclusion. Around the world, the count of earned wage access providers on our platform has risen to more than 4 times what it was in 2019.
Alfred Kelly
executiveTo put it simply, Visa Direct is only getting started, and we anticipate fast expansion in the coming years as we pursue that $65 trillion opportunity. We've also got plenty of instances where partners are putting Visa Direct and our B2B tools to work. During this quarter, we're happy that BIM is going to give its more than 400,000 business clients the option to send B2B payments through Visa Direct as well as by way of Visa virtual cards. Additional wins include Credorax in Europe for travel virtual cards, plus Ignition and Standard Bank in CEMEA for fleet, and an exclusive deal covering physical and virtual cards with Ramp, a P2P and finance automation fintech based here in the United States. On top of that, we keep deepening and broadening our ties with JPMorgan commercial card, thanks to a fresh commercial card agreement and JPMorgan's involvement in Visa's Commercial Pay solution. These efforts will back virtual card functionality, encourage growth along with new payment flows, and generate incremental volume as time goes on. Visa B2B Connect has reached a milestone — it's now operating in more than 100 markets. This multilateral network runs on distributed ledger technology, and it addresses gaps in existing options, including visibility and transaction speed. On top of that, we've kicked off a collaboration with Citi, naming it a global settlement bank for Visa B2B Connect. That move expands the endpoints available to clients, bringing in cities, business accounts for cross-border money movement, and clearing capabilities for banks that haven't yet joined the B2B Connect network. Given Citi's enormous scale and reach, plus the role we play in facilitating money movement, we're very excited about how this capability can drive growth for the Visa B2B Connect network. Going forward, open banking holds a central position within the network of networks. We think Visa can speed up open banking adoption in Europe through our pending purchase of Tink. Working together, we can deliver a secure, dependable platform for innovation that might be extended around the world. Be it using account data for value-added services or enabling account-to-account or pay-by-bank money movement, open banking opens doors for Visa to give our clients and partners a one-stop shop covering money movement, security, data and worthwhile customer experiences. Blockchains, too, will keep extending our network of networks. Our settlement capabilities, along with ongoing innovation in crypto APIs and services, have proven essential to securing new partnerships. We've got roughly sixty partners on the crypto platform side who can issue Visa credentials, and in FY '21 we're already generating over $3.5 billion in payment volume. The third thing that leaves us in an even stronger position to grow once COVID passes is value-added services — here, the size and sophistication of what we offer simultaneously helps our clients do better, diversifies Visa's business, and creates more value. What our value-added solutions do is distinguish Visa's network, allow our clients to adapt to a payments ecosystem in flux, and deliver useful services across other rails, which reinforces our network of network capabilities. Looking at 2021, 40% of the clients we serve were using at least 5 value-added services, while close to 30% were using 10 or more — compared with 20% back in 2020. Allow me to call out several services that saw major growth during 2021. CyberSource brought on 28 new acquirer partners along with 45,000 merchants because of that — and because of that, our payments volume is expanding at double the pace of our wider client base, plus our risk offering on CyberSource known as Decision Manager expanded by more than 30%. Over the last year, we doubled token count to 2.6 billion and improved the tools for managing them via Visa Cloud token. Across more than 8,600 issuers and 800,000 merchants, tokens delivered a 2.5% increase in approval rates and a 28% reduction in fraud rates. Artificial intelligence and machine learning capabilities are leveraged by Visa Advanced Authorization and Visa Risk Manager, and in 2021 those tools screened 30% more transactions than in 2020 while helping reduce fraud by $26 billion. All of our work in authentication, risk, identity and authorization optimization has driven cross-border card-not-present approval rates up by nearly 2% over the past year. Consequently, value-added services revenue climbed 25% in Q4 and also produced additional volume. Our VAS revenue has averaged a quarterly growth rate in the high teens since the pandemic began and reached approximately $5 billion in FY '21. Finally, the fourth factor giving us confidence in substantial expansion opportunities is how we can drive a great deal of the transformation and new ideas occurring within payments, which accelerates Visa's own growth. Innovation has always been, and will remain, at the heart of what Visa does—supporting new collaborators, fresh offerings, and emerging applications. Those challenging the status quo get our backing. We assist them in expanding. Such challengers benefit the payments space and benefit Visa. Given the position we hold within this ecosystem, we avoid choosing who wins or loses, and we are strongly situated to grow regardless of which direction things go. Consider digital wallets. They have excelled at growing their customer numbers and, in certain instances, establishing merchant acceptance. Eventually, though, they arrive at a point where they're looking for more growth. A lot of them are putting Visa credentials into their wallets, which lets the consumer use them wherever Visa is accepted, and also send and receive P2P payments across borders. A great illustration is LINE Pay, which has 4 portfolios and 5.6 million Visa credentials spanning 3 countries, among them a new co-brand in Thailand that debuted in the fourth quarter. BNPL, or buy now pay later, is a more recent illustration, but our view is that it will end up much the same way. Even though installment plans are expanding quickly, they represent only a small slice of the roughly $100 billion to $150 billion in overall payments the industry handles — yet we're giving disruptors the scale they need. Our approach has two parts: we offer a network-based option and also build solutions alongside our buy now, pay later fintech partners. With that network offering, card issuers are able to give their existing credit account holders the ability to split payments, and retailers can give buyers an easy installment option with flexible terms. Q4 saw our partner roster keep expanding — we brought on HSBC in Malaysia, Moneris (Canada's largest payment processor when ranked by volume), and ANZ in Australia, in addition to significant 2022 payments; on top of all that, we engage with fintechs through a variety of arrangements. Money flows in when shoppers pay off their installment plans with a Visa card, through virtual cards used for B2B or consumer transactions, and through value-added offerings. Right now, card-based repayment accounts for the bulk of installment settlements. Consider Canada: over the last twelve months, the number of Visa cards used to pay down installments climbed by more than 300%. From where we sit, the current state of things represents BNPL 1.0. Individual fintechs and individual businesses are cutting individual agreements, signing up merchants one at a time. Looking ahead, we anticipate the model will evolve into BNPL 2.0, where fintech partners become Visa credential issuers, allowing them to leverage our acceptance network and platforms — sidestepping the difficulty of building acceptance globally, merchant by merchant. You can already see that change taking shape. During the quarter we're discussing, a partner signed an international brand agreement designed to accelerate growth and help it scale across several markets. So to wrap up: Visa's position is now more solid than it was prior to the pandemic, leaving us ready to capture future opportunities. Supporting that are healthy gains in consumer payments, the breadth of our platforms, network and capabilities, and a rising revenue contribution from new flows along with value-added services.
Alfred Kelly
executiveAnd once cross-border activity comes back across the coming 2 years, that will just provide extra momentum for our expansion. On top of that, throughout our company's history, we've shown that the way we innovate, our readiness to work with partners, and our attractive, strongly competitive products have kept this business durable and thriving. So with that, I'll hand things to Vasant, who will go through Q4 and give a sense of what we think all of these opportunities will mean for Visa's financial results over the next year. Vasant, the floor is yours.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveThanks, Al, and good afternoon to all of you. Fiscal year 2021 truly split into 2 very distinct halves. During the first half, net revenues fell 4% while non-GAAP EPS dropped 2%, since we were comparing against a pre-COVID first half of 2020. In the second half, recovery was clearly underway, and we were up against some of the heaviest COVID effects from 2020. Consequently, net revenue climbed 28%, and non-GAAP EPS increased 43%. Our fiscal fourth quarter performance exceeded our expectations, with net revenues rising 29%, fueled by solid U.S. domestic activity, strong growth in value-added services, and greater cross-border volumes thanks to a travel rebound that came faster than we had anticipated. If we had recorded service revenues based on the current quarter's payment volumes, net revenue growth would have come in at roughly 22%. GAAP EPS rose 70%, which includes equity investment gains and a onetime noncash tax expense from last year. Non-GAAP EPS climbed 44%, aided by a reduced tax rate. Movements in exchange rates lifted both net revenue and EPS growth by about 0.5 point. On a constant dollar basis, global payments volume increased 17%, powered by ongoing debit strength along with improving credit spending. Versus the fourth quarter of 2019, global payments volume came in 21% higher, which is a 0.8 percentage point acceleration from Q3, as debit decelerated 1 point while credit gained 3 points compared with Q3. If you exclude China, total payments volume growth reached 18%, or 26% above 2019, marking a 1 point acceleration from the third quarter. Chinese domestic volumes remain under pressure from dual-branded cost conversion, which carries minimal revenue impact. U.S. payments volume rose 30% compared with 2019, in line with the third quarter. Credit picked up 3 points to 17% above '19, supported by consumer, small business and commercial spending. Debit decelerated 4 points yet stayed quite robust at 44% above 2019, with little help from economic impact payments. Card-present spend gained 3 points to 15% above 2019, its strongest pandemic-era level, driven by increased fuel and restaurant spending. Card-not-present volume, excluding travel, slowed 6 points to 53% over 2019, as certain food and drug spending moved back to card-present, and retail spend was weaker without stimulus payment support. International constant dollar payments volume improved 3 points versus Q3, reaching 15% above 2019 levels. A few regional highlights. Latin America came in 58% above 2019, accelerating 10 points from the third quarter, with strong performance throughout the region, driven by cash digitization and client wins. Our CEMEA region stayed strong, at 48% above 2019 levels, consistent with Q3, also driven by cash digitization and client wins. Europe reached 20% above 2019, improving 3 points from Q3, mostly on strong performance across Continental Europe. Asia Pacific remains our weakest region, at 5% above 2019 and consistent with Q3 excluding China. Many countries brought in restrictions during the quarter, among them Australia, New Zealand, Japan and Singapore, but all have begun recovering over the past few weeks. India's payment volume has made a complete comeback from the serious COVID surge experienced in Q3. Worldwide processed transactions came in 24% higher than 2019, a 4-point gain versus the third quarter, since transactions strengthened more quickly than volume. Tap-to-pay adoption rose across numerous markets, and ticket sizes began returning to typical levels in the U.S. Visa Direct transactions climbed 35%, a slowdown from the 50s recorded during the prior 3 quarters. During this quarter, we anniversary-ed an exceptionally robust Q4 of fiscal year '20, when Visa Direct reached 1 billion transactions for the very first time. Stimulus payments are finished, and we are now up against the COVID-driven P2P surge, which is tempering growth rates in the U.S. At the same time, the international business is scaling up well, along with growth from use cases including cross-border remittances, earned wage access and marketplace payouts. Recovery in cross-border volume carried on as additional countries reopened their borders, while e-commerce spending, travel excluded, stayed strong. Constant dollar cross-border volume, leaving out transactions within Europe, stood at 86% of 2019 volumes, a 4-point gain over Q3, powered by the ongoing travel recovery that began in May. Cross-border card-not-present volume, travel excluded, remained extremely strong at 43% above 2019, falling 13 points from the third quarter yet matching Q2. As a reminder, the lift we experienced in Q3 came mainly from cryptocurrency purchases. Cross-border travel-related spending, excluding intra-Europe, compared with 2019, gained 13 points from Q3 to Q4; it climbed from 40% of 2019 in April to 50% in June to 61% in September. Regarding where travel-related spending is strengthening, apart from Asia Pacific, outbound spend in every region is indexing at comparable levels versus 2019, and each rose by between 10 to 20 points in Q4 versus Q3. The biggest gains occurred in Canada, the Middle East and throughout Europe. Europe inbound spend rose by 24 points versus 2019 as popular travel destinations like France and Italy eased their border restrictions. As we have witnessed consistently throughout the pandemic, pent-up demand for travel exists as bookings speed up whenever a border opens. Latin America stays by far the strongest destination, well above 2019 levels. U.S. to Mexico travel stayed robust, with spend more than 60% above 2019 levels in Q4. Asia Pacific stays mostly closed and did not meaningfully improve during the fourth quarter, remaining below 30% of 2019, both inbound and outbound. Turning now to a quick review of fourth quarter financial results. Service revenues rose 41%, matching 39% nominal growth in third quarter payments volume and aided by small pricing modifications. Data processing increased 20%, in line with 21% processed transactions growth with a minor impact from unfavorable country mix. International transaction revenues climbed 41%, 7 points below nominal cross-border volumes, excluding intra-Europe, because of lapping high currency volatility last year and unfavorable regional mix. Other revenues rose 36%, led by consulting and data services as well as travel benefits. All told, our revenue from value-added services was up 25%, with security and identity together with consulting and data services leading the way, and we saw some favorable impact from comparisons against COVID-affected periods. Client incentives came to 26.7% of gross revenues, which matched what we had anticipated. The rise of 90 basis points versus Q3 came mainly from robust results in the U.S. and Latin America, along with fewer underperformance adjustments in some geographies, partly counterbalanced by strengthening cross-border volumes. Operating expenses were up 15%, consistent with our forecast. Marketing costs rose 58% during the quarter, reflecting our increased outlays as well as comparisons to reduced spending in Q4 of the prior year. Spending on personnel and professional services likewise picked up as we keep putting money into our growth initiatives. We booked gains of $101 million from our equity investments. If you set aside investment gains, non-GAAP nonoperating expense stood at $118 million. Our non-GAAP tax rate came in at 16.5%, below what we had expected, thanks to settling a tax matter. GAAP EPS reached $1.65. Non-GAAP EPS was $1.62, which is 44% higher than a year ago. During the quarter we repurchased 13.2 million shares of class A common stock, paying an average of $231.33 per share, for a total of $3.1 billion. Counting our quarterly dividend of $0.32 per share, we gave back more than $3.7 billion in capital to shareholders over the quarter. On October 22, Visa's Board of Directors approved raising the quarterly dividend by 17%, bringing it to $0.375 per share.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveOn a full-year basis, net revenues rose 10%, while non-GAAP EPS came in at $5.91, an increase of 17%. Through share repurchases of 39.7 million class A common stock shares at an average price of $219.34, totaling $8.7 billion, plus dividend payments of $2.8 billion, we gave back $11.5 billion in capital to shareholders. Before turning to the year ahead, I want to walk through how we performed during the first 3 weeks of October. U.S. payments volume came in 32% higher than 2019, matching September's level, with debit 44% above 2019 and credit 22% above 2019. Processed transactions stood 26% above 2019. Cross-border volume, excluding intra-Europe transactions, measured on a constant dollar basis, reached 94% of 2019 — an improvement of 8 points versus Q4 and 2 points versus September. Travel-related spending compared with 2019 rose 4 points relative to September, reaching 65% of 2019. Card-not-present non-travel was 49% above 2019, which is 6 points higher than the fourth quarter but 2 points lower than September. Now looking toward fiscal year 2022. Over the past 3 to 4 quarters, our business has been recovering. Globally, though, we have not yet returned to normal. As we project how the recovery will unfold, numerous factors deserve consideration. Even while credit rebounds and in-store shopping comes back, debit and e-commerce have delivered strong results and remained resilient. What the ending of stimulus payments and support programs will ultimately mean is still unclear. Cross-border travel is bouncing back nicely but remains far under pre-COVID levels, with how quickly it recovers hinging on cross-border — on borders opening. Asia has not reopened to the same extent as other regions. When key Asian countries reopen, both for domestic and cross-border travel, is a crucial variable. Above all, COVID variants continue to circulate, and vaccination rates are still low across large portions of the world. Against that backdrop, predicting the path back to normalcy stays challenging. Visibility 4 quarters out, though better, remains limited. Over the last few quarters, we've given you our best read on the business one quarter at a time, and we'll keep doing so in fiscal year '22. If current trends hold through December, we'd anticipate first quarter net revenue growth in the high teens. Client incentives as a percentage of gross revenue should land in the 26% to 27% range, consistent with the fourth quarter of fiscal year '21. With sustained investment spending and low comparables from last year, operating expenses should keep growing in the mid-teens. Nonoperating expense is projected in the $120 million to $130 million range, and the tax rate in the 19% to 19.5% range. When looking 4 quarters out, forecasting gross revenue growth is the hardest part. It depends heavily on how fast cross-border travel recovers, along with the other factors I just listed. Everything comes down to what you assume about these variables. To assist with your understanding, we'll outline the internal planning assumptions we're using. For transactions and volumes within the US, we're not factoring in any interruptions caused by COVID lockdowns. Therefore, we anticipate that the current rebound trend in processed transactions and payments volume will carry on through fiscal year '22; regarding cross-border travel, we expect the ongoing recovery to proceed consistently through fiscal year '22, hitting 2019 levels by summer 2023. We're projecting the index relative to 2019 to rise from approximately 60 now to roughly 80 by September 2022. Additionally, we anticipate that robust expansion in cross-border e-commerce will persist. We foresee growth in new flows and value-added services reaching the high teens. For the year, we expect client incentives as a share of gross revenues to fall within 26% to 27%, matching the levels seen in the fourth quarter of fiscal year '21. Before COVID, this percentage went up by 50 to 100 basis points annually because of new deals and renewals; in fiscal year '22, we expect gains from improved revenue mix as cross-border travel keeps recovering, partly offset by the overlapping of incentive cuts we implemented in fiscal year '21 owing to COVID's effects. These projections lead to net revenue growth at the high end of mid-teens for fiscal year '22, factoring in more than 0.5 point of exchange rate headwind from the stronger dollar. Growth in the first quarter will be in the high teens but will taper off during the year as we overlap the fiscal year '21 recovery. As mentioned, these are our internal planning assumptions; we'll keep offering business outlooks one quarter at a time throughout fiscal year '22. Regarding other P&L components, we anticipate operating expenses to increase in the low teens during fiscal year '22 as we ramp up investments across all 3 business lines to build a base for sustained higher growth after COVID. We've already boosted marketing spending; we'll invest significantly in our tech platforms to further improve functionality, flexibility, security, and reliability. We'll invest to maintain the rapid growth in our new flows and value-added services segment, and we'll keep adding market resources to assist clients in leveraging all our new capabilities. Expense growth will be greater in the first half and slow in the second half as we overlap the fiscal year '21 investment spending resumption. Nonoperating expense should be between $120 million and $130 million per quarter, and our annual tax rate is expected to remain in the 19% to 19.5% range. These assumptions don't factor in Tink or Currencycloud, which we anticipate closing in the first half of the fiscal year. They won't significantly affect fiscal year '22 revenue or non-GAAP EPS. Visa stays the preferred network for innovators and money movement; we support the innovators and disruptors. We assist them in expanding, and consequently, those building new things fuel our expansion. We've kept improving what our network can do and how adaptable it is so that we greatly widen the payment scenarios we handle, backing the latest wave of fintech companies while also fueling expansion in our new flows segment. The services we offer on top of the core bring distinct advantages and deliver greater worth to our customers than what competing networks are able to. Our approach of building a network out of networks markedly boosts our endpoints, and we think this can generate more benefit for every participant in the network than any system that's closed off or confined to a certain geography. Just like we mentioned during our Investor Day, an opportunity for growth that's 10x sits in front of us, and our position is strong for seizing it. We closed out fiscal year '21 carrying solid momentum, a debit and e-commerce operation that's both fast-growing and durable, credit and cross-border travel on the mend, plus new flows and value-added services acting as fresher engines of growth that push acceleration even further; so with that, I'll pass things to Mike for Q&A.
Mike Milotich
executiveThank you, Vasant. We're ready to take questions, Michelle.
Lisa Ellis
analystAl, I'd like to dig deeper into item number 2 on your list, the one about Visa's network of networks. You pointed to open banking as something you see as beneficial for Visa, since it opens up new flows and value-added services. Yet the common perception — and really, it's often stated — is that open banking hurts Visa, because volume can be pulled away from debit. Could you expand on that and explain how Visa comes out ahead with open banking?
Alfred Kelly
executiveThank you, Lisa. So, look, I'd say this — open banking, as you're aware, is still in its early days; our view is that by stepping right into the center of it, we can assist the ecosystem in figuring out the optimal routing for various transactions. Some transactions, no question, will be suited to an A2A type of method, and we recognize that's among the things people will regard as a threat. However, there are a tremendous number of transactions, a great many transactions, in which consumers value the safeguards a network such as Visa delivers — dispute resolution, fraud, security, that sort of thing. Having money move in an instant is appealing on one level. Yet if — after it has moved, getting it back is extremely difficult. And so much of this comes down to factors beyond mere speed. We also believe that by engaging with Tink, where we're positioned right at a — where we have the chance to genuinely learn as we proceed, we see a chance to perhaps deliver value-added services even for transactions that could route across a different network. So, Lisa, I'd put it this way: the bottom line is that you might see certain transactions that are incremental, that could shift off VisaNet or off our usual rails. But our perspective is that by leaning in, we'll gain more knowledge about it, we'll be in a position to shape what's taking place, and we'll likewise be able to ensure we can offer other capabilities and value-added services across the various transactions.
Dave Koning
analystSomething I picked up on: across the past 6 fiscal years, U.S. volumes expanded at the same rate as, or at a quicker pace than, volumes in the rest of the world. Could you talk about that a bit? COVID, of course, drove part of it in the most recent year, I realize that; but looking ahead 5 or even 10 years, a, does that pattern flip? And, b, when it comes to American growth, is all the recent fintech activity in the U.S. providing a boost that lets it keep outpacing other regions?
Alfred Kelly
executiveDavid, I'd say several factors are at play; the surge of neobanks and fintechs is definitely one, though you're watching those take off everywhere across the globe. On top of that, our Visa Direct platform has reached a far more advanced stage here in the United States compared with other markets. Vasant touched on something along those lines during his comments. That's clearly played a part in fueling growth too. Another factor, I'd argue, is that America — at least before the pandemic — had more developed e-commerce infrastructure and adapted far faster than other markets likely did when the swift shift toward digitizing cash arrived with COVID in March of 2020. Having said all that, our plan is to put money to work worldwide, and we want growth in each market and territory where we operate. We'd be delighted for the U.S. to keep expanding. Still, when I think about where this business goes across the next 5 to 10 years, I anticipate solid growth continuing in America, yet I also anticipate our volumes carrying on growing at a healthy clip globally. You witnessed that last quarter. Strong as American growth was; during that quarter, Latin America and CEMEA both posted extremely robust results; and the international figure was genuinely constrained by Asia Pacific, which lockdowns and restrictions tied to the pandemic have struck incredibly severely.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveThere's one more point I'd throw in when we think about what's coming. Everything Al mentioned matters here. The reason our international business is somewhat constrained at the moment comes down to Asia — that region represents nearly 20% of the payments volume we handle — and it's expanding only in the low single digits, since for the most part those markets remain closed. Here's what to keep in mind going forward: as we noted before, and as Al pointed out in his remarks, outside the U.S., contactless payments have already reached 70% penetration. So for the U.S., that remains a source of growth, and it's really just starting to accelerate. Considering how big the U.S. market is, that's going to add meaningfully to growth in transactions. We're also aware that tap-to-pay turns cash into digital payments and lets us grab a far bigger portion of transactions at the point of sale.
James Faucette
analystAl, I'd like to revisit something you said regarding buy now pay later — specifically its expansion and why you view it as a growth channel for Visa. Could you elaborate a bit? Conceptually, I grasp the notion of broadening acceptance and the benefits Visa can deliver there. Still, I'm hoping you can shed more light on how you expect this to develop and what those transactions will look like in a manner that helps Visa.
Alfred Kelly
executiveIn the near term, James, what we observe is a great number of these companies relying on us and on our credentials — be they virtual cards, debit cards, or credit cards — to settle the different installments. So rather than a single transaction, we wind up with 4 transactions. That is clearly quite favorable for us. What I was getting at is that BNPL, in numerous respects, functions as a closed-loop offering not unlike what wallets looked like 3 years back. And closed loops ultimately run into a barrier. They reach a point where scaling becomes difficult. Delivering the breadth — and the depth of options that customers deserve becomes difficult. Consequently, my expectation is that BNPL companies will transform into issuers, issuing Visa credentials with their installment value proposition built into the product itself, enabling them to scale extremely rapidly by instantly reaching the 100 million merchants I mentioned earlier in my remarks. That, grounded in historical patterns, is my belief about what lies ahead. That is what I mean by BNPL 2.0.
Sanjay Sakhrani
analystThe U.S. border reopening ought to serve as a fairly significant catalyst for your company. What I'd like to know is whether you're noticing anything on the bookings side that sheds light on the path you described, and perhaps what's baked into your assumptions.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveRight. Regarding the U.S. border and inbound traffic to the U.S., we've pointed out that international revenues haven't increased to the same degree as international volumes. One factor is that inbound travel has been very robust into the CEMEA region across Latin America, where borders have been quite open. It has also picked up considerably in Europe; and since the U.S. has remained largely closed to inbound travelers apart from American citizens, inbound to the U.S. is still — it beats Asia, yet it's, I would say, softer than every other region outside Asia; so there's an obvious opportunity there; that corridor yields more; and so without question, gains will come as travel from Canada and travel from Europe gets allowed. Broadly speaking, predicting the mix is difficult; it is factored into our expectations for how cross-border will strengthen. For cross-border travel to rise from where we said it was to the levels we project at the close of fiscal year '22, you'd need to factor in gains in inbound to the U.S., and that's all included in the calculation.
Harshita Rawat
analystAl, I'd like to build on what you said about enabling disruptors being a growth engine for Visa. With the emergence of two-sided networks globally, digital wallets, buy now pay later, and super apps, and given your point that they're becoming issuers of Visa credentials — which we already observe — do you see them as a threat too, if they adopt account-to-account payments via open banking, and what that means for the funding mix on cards over a longer horizon?
Alfred Kelly
executiveWell, once more, when it comes to all these new entrants, my stance has consistently been that we treat them as potentially additive to the ecosystem and potentially something we can assist. That's why we engage with all these new entrants extremely early. That's part of why we hold the position we do today in crypto, with partnerships involving more than 60 players — we engaged from the very start; each of them has the ability, and a number already issue Visa credentials. I believe several of these participants will assist in further digitizing payments and shifting money off cash. I believe it's highly probable that certain transactions will be A2A. Yet A2A transactions exist now. Much of ordinary bill pay, across all sorts of purposes, is A2A; so I'm not convinced it's all that novel, or that significant a matter. Even so, we believe we're much better positioned by engaging and collaborating with these participants. And even if the transaction doesn't run over our network, or we're absent from processing the transaction entirely, there remains the opportunity to offer other capabilities from our toolbox of solutions and value-added services that we can contribute. So exactly how everything unfolds, time will tell, but I'm hopeful that the stance we're adopting — engaging with all of it — will place us in the strongest spot to succeed.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveAbsolutely. Our strategy around a network of networks essentially means connecting with partners through offerings that address every aspect of how they move money. We've shared before how this works across different types of participants. Take cross-border remittance companies — we enable them to handle account to account, account to card, or card to account transfers, in whatever direction they need; a single integration lets them route funds wherever they need to land. Essentially, we move your money from point A to point B. Not every leg of that trip necessarily runs on our infrastructure. Certain portions might travel over other networks, but we still deliver it. On top of that, we bring everything you'd associate with Visa — the confidence our brand carries, dependability, adaptability, protection, dispute handling, and those kinds of services. So at its core, this is really about delivering solutions, not merely about providing rails.
Darrin Peller
analystThis is sort of a question with two parts, but the first concerns the medium to long term. Looking at debit coming in stronger, and of course recognizing an acceleration in e-com plus the other structural tailwinds you've observed, with cross-border at 94% of '19 even though travel sits at only 65%. Service looks solid. I'd be interested to hear what you consider structurally sustainable about these trends running above what would likely have been expected before the pandemic, versus what won't last. Then, regarding your qualitative '22 outlook, which areas would you say you attempted to bake the most conservatism into, in terms of macro assumptions?
Vasant Prabhu
executiveSure, I'll address your first question first; when it comes to the structural shifts that have occurred and can be sustained, the cash digitization engine is obviously very healthy. That's a major contributor to debit, since debit serves as the — the initial entry point to digital payments for consumers. And we've observed debit maintaining its growth nearly everywhere even as card-present returns, reopening took place, and seamless payments disappeared. Debit strength has shown considerable resilience, with Visa Direct also helping. So everything points to the cash digitization engine, particularly across emerging markets, having truly taken off, because habits are forming and consumers have grown accustomed to digital payment methods; so we believe there's a lot of resilience in that area, and the evidence supports it even as conditions began returning to normal. The move toward e-commerce has also proven notably resilient. We've seen — if you check the charts accompanying our press release, card-present shows a fairly solid rebound over the last few quarters; and when you examine how well e-commerce has endured, card-not-present has endured. Once again, there's been considerable resilience there. Across many new categories, consumers have grown used to doing — using e-commerce. And the most significant piece is cross-border e-commerce. Cross-border e-commerce has proven extraordinarily resilient. Looking at it, it's indexing in the 140s. We saw a spike during the last quarter driven by cryptocurrencies, but it's returned to the 140s just as it was in the second quarter, which represents very substantial growth relative to its earlier growth rate, and it has endured even as cross-border travel rebounds and even as card-present spending rebounds. So those 2 structural shifts have demonstrated considerable resilience. Beyond those, our value-added services have performed very well throughout the pandemic. Looking at average growth for our value-added services across the past 6 to 8 quarters during the pandemic, it's been in the high teens. And our new flows businesses have experienced extremely high growth as well. Looking ahead to next year, our expectation is high teens. Those 2 newer growth engines have proven fairly resilient throughout the whole pandemic, and that obviously puts a strong foundation in place going forward, since they're becoming an ever bigger portion of our business when their growth outpaces that of our core consumer payments business. So you get a structurally higher growth rate as a result of their greater share of our mix.
Bryan Keane
analystAl, a number of your competitors have made the choice to acquire the ACH rails, while Visa has chosen a different path, leaning more heavily on Visa Direct. So I was hoping you might share your most recent thinking on why owning the ACH rails isn't necessary, and how that approach holds up competitively against what you offer through Visa Direct.
Alfred Kelly
executiveWell, Bryan, whether we're talking about ACH or RTP rails, those are available to us just as they are to anyone else. And our belief is that operating them isn't a requirement for succeeding with our network of network strategies. In our view, there are other areas where our time and our money are better spent. And at the heart of our position is this: we want to serve as the traffic cop, the facilitator, and the enabler, so that a sender can hand us the funds and let us know where in the world the destination is. And by way of Visa Direct or B2B Connect, while relying on an ACH network or an RTP network for the first or last mile, we gain a tremendous capability to reach what we see as an unprecedented level of end points across the globe — something we consider very, very much a differentiator. And Visa Direct, beyond its reach — since our VisaNet platform is what we're using — delivers incredible operating scale. It lets us harness our value-added services that run on VisaNet. So — and we've enjoyed great success in commercializing the capabilities across the various use cases I mentioned in my remarks. So we believe the place to invest is in the capabilities to move funds seamlessly, with great transparency and good economics. And continuing to invest there is where — we think is the smart thing to do.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveI'd like to maybe clarify something that might be misunderstood in your question. Around the globe, the majority of ACH rails belong to either bank consortiums or central banks. Perhaps you mean — if I'm thinking of the same competitor you have in mind, then you're actually talking about the RTP rails. Those rails aren't owned by that company. Typically, RTP rails always belong to bank consortiums or central banks. Their business consists of constructing the rails, then transferring them, and afterward, in certain instances, running them — which, as Al mentioned, are available for anyone to use at rates that are regulated. So as far as I know, the competitor you have in mind doesn't own RTP rails anywhere. In certain instances, they get the chance to run them as compensation for constructing them. In other instances, they simply construct them and then move on. Also, these aren't proprietary rails; anyone can use them, us included. We examined this closely and reached the conclusion that constructing these rails isn't an appealing line of business; whereas utilizing these rails, along with enhancing them through value-added capabilities and intelligence, is a solid line of business — and that's the one we've decided to pursue.
Trevor Williams
analystI’d like to ask about yields within data processing. I realize several factors are shifting around in that area, yet I was somewhat taken aback, at least for this quarter, to observe them decline by a few percent compared with the September quarter even though cross-border improved. So I believe it would help simply to understand which key variables were at play there. Based on what Vasant said, it appears there was merely some country mix involved; but when we think about 4Q and '22, given the assumption that travel continues recovering toward the 2019 level as you all have built in, just — how much could that yield line gain next year? And whether any pricing should be considered that would carry into next year.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveYes. I’m not certain there was any effect on yield. If you simply examine — first, regarding the data processing line, volumes as well as revenues are — no delay exists, correct? Thus revenue ought to track volumes during the quarter, and that happened this quarter. My recollection is it was 20% and 21% or so, volumes and net revenues. So they tracked together. So truly there wasn’t any shift in yield; now obviously, the cross-border business is, comparatively speaking, still rebounding and under its previous level. Consequently, yields have been affected by mix moving away from cross-border. And mix getting better is obviously aiding yields. Yet between one quarter and the next, yields stayed fairly steady. Nothing out of the ordinary was happening there. I’m certain following the call, should any confusion remain, Mike and Jennifer could clarify it; but my brief response would be yields were perfectly fine, and nothing out of the ordinary existed there.
Tien-Tsin Huang
analystI realize the hour is late. I'd simply like to ask: when you're assembling your internal budget and investment plans for fiscal '22, apart from cross-border coming back, which products or initiatives, Al and Vasant, excite you the most this year? I realize you opened with the 4 points regarding the larger growth picture, but what I have in mind are simply near-term products and initiatives we ought to be watching.
Alfred Kelly
executiveSure, I'll take that and then let Vasant chime in too, Tien-Tsin. Look, I'd say that across each of the last 3 or 4 quarters, the recovery has been taking on clearer shape. And I'd say — my feeling is quite positive regarding how the business is progressing at present. My sense is consumer payments is set up to remain strong. Yet, answering what was asked a few questions back, my view is e-commerce will keep going. My view is tap-to-pay will keep going; we're beginning to observe certain gains from our acceptance footprint expanding in markets such as Latin America, and we're beginning to observe a greater move toward PV and away from cash across that region. So consumer payments remains the core of what our company does, and adding credentials, adding acceptance points and continuing to collaborate with our issuing partners on engagement and extracting the most from their current customer base stays an extremely high priority for us. And I believe we've achieved genuinely strong traction across our 2 other revenue streams in new flows and value-added services; and we have new flows, value — Visa Direct. We've discussed that a great deal and feel quite positive about it; and I believe that as the world begins to watch people head back to the office and travel begin to resume, that should benefit the B2B space; and I believe much of what I mentioned concerning wins and advances in value-added services in fiscal '21 will carry forward into fiscal '22. So in sum, I'm pleased that we now have a more diversified business model and additional levers available. Naturally, we wish to keep planting flags in geographies where the business remains — or payments and money movement is somewhat more nascent. Yet on the whole, I'm fairly bullish about how the business appears as we move into fiscal '22. Vasant, is there anything you'd like to add?
Vasant Prabhu
executiveAbsolutely. Tien-Tsin, to give you a rough picture of where every dollar of that investment is headed, the overarching story is that the range of services we provide and the use cases we support have grown enormously. Because of that, we're putting substantial money into keeping our network increasingly adaptable and into layering on additional features. Each day, our network becomes more adaptable and gains further capability. At this point, we have far more offerings available to sell to our customers, along with a great many fresh categories of issuers and fresh categories of acceptance locations. As a result, we're adding considerably to the ranks of personnel on the ground who sit nearest to our customers. So a major commitment exists in those frontline teams positioned closest to customers, both to help our customers weave these offerings into their operations with ease and to draw all those new varieties of fintechs — the innovators, if that's the label you prefer — into the ecosystem we've built. A third facet involves extending the reach of our brand. You've all seen the fresh positioning we've introduced. Anyone who tuned into the Olympics could hardly have overlooked it. It captures what lies ahead for Visa. Consumer payments aren't the whole story anymore, so money is plainly being spent to ensure that message lands. Broadly, then, it's about unlocking fresh use cases, fresh geographies, and fresh customers, and then repositioning the entire brand as, in essence, the frontrunner in the movement of money.
Tien-Tsin Huang
analystYes, I saw that commercial. Thanks to you both for the latest information.
Timothy Chiodo
analystLet me frame this a bit more as a question about the industry, though Al hinted at a point you brought up before regarding safeguards for consumers, charge-backs, and the ways disputes get handled when transactions are card-based. Perhaps you could speak somewhat generally about — naturally, plenty of account-to-account and bank-based payment options exist around the world. Broadly, what sort of safeguards, if any, do those provide? Then my second question is, in what ways might Visa be able to collaborate with certain of those account-to-account and/or bank-based payment options to assist in adding some of this regarding the scheme, the process, the safeguards, security, and so forth?
Alfred Kelly
executiveThe safeguards matter a great deal. What people usually — the most significant consumer safeguards in our view are clearly fraud, ensuring consumers aren't held responsible when fraud occurs, and charge-back protection so that when you buy a red large shirt and receive a blue medium one instead, the ecosystem backs you up and either provides a replacement or returns your funds. As far as I know, Tim, I don't believe the A2A choices currently provide any such safeguards to consumers, based on what I'm aware of. And I believe we'll need to observe, as A2A progresses and as open banking develops further, especially beginning in Europe, which truly is ground zero for open banking and clearly one reason we're thrilled about owning Tink, we'll need to observe whether there's a path for us to intervene and attempt to help deliver certain of those safeguards for A2A, or it may be that A2A simply aligns with a different profile of — for a different profile of safeguards or the absence of them for those transactions compared with transactions on — that operate over a network such as Visa.
Ashwin Shirvaikar
analystVasant, in what you said earlier, you brought up the idea of stronger growth continuing after COVID, and you broke that down between the U.S. and the rest of the world, plus some of the debit and credit pieces, which I found pretty useful. What I want to ask is this: once the revenue mix settles back to normal and then perhaps rises above where it used to be, how should we think about the margin structure?
Vasant Prabhu
executiveWhen it comes to the company's average operating margin, our stance, as we've stated previously, is that we aim to expand volume and revenue in line with the openings in front of us, and those openings, as we've talked about, are large. After that, we put in whatever spending is needed to capture them. Margin is what falls out of that; it isn't the target. A high fixed cost base is something our business tends to carry. The next transaction costs very little on the margin. Our value-added services operations earn solid margins. Our new flows operations earn solid margins. Yield and margin aren't the same thing. New flows operations may generate yields that differ from those of our core payments operations; still, because it rides on the infrastructure and is very much a scale operation, it does arrive with quite attractive margins. So you've seen how margins moved this year. There was a good recovery from the decline we saw during the COVID period. All told, from a margin standpoint we don't anticipate anything dramatically different going forward; the same drivers will continue to shape it. As I mentioned, it's a result rather than a goal.
Mike Milotich
executiveOkay, thanks to all of you for being here today. Should any further questions come up, don’t hesitate to contact Jennifer or me, and we’ll gladly assist. Thanks once more, and enjoy the rest of your evening.
Operator
operatorThank you. This concludes today's conference. You may disconnect at this time.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Visa Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Visa Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Visa Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.