Visa Inc. (V) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
October 25, 2022
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Jennifer Como
executiveAppreciate that, Holly. Hello everybody, and thanks for joining us for Visa's earnings call covering the fourth fiscal quarter along with the complete 2022 fiscal year. Here with us this afternoon are Alfred F. Kelly, Jr., who serves as Visa's Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, along with Vasant Prabhu, our Vice Chair and Chief Financial Officer. You can access a webcast of this call through the investor relations portion of our site, www.investor.visa.com. For 30 days, a replay is going to be kept in our archives on that site. We've also placed a slide deck with financial and statistical highlights on our IR website. I'd also like to point out that forward-looking statements are part of this presentation. Such statements don't represent guarantees regarding future performance, and because of numerous factors, our actual results might differ materially. You can find additional details about those factors in our latest reports on forms 10-K and 10-Q, available on the SEC's website as well as the investor relations portion of our site. Regarding non-GAAP financial information discussed on this call, corresponding GAAP measures and reconciliation can be found in today's earnings release. So with that said, I'll hand things over to Al.
Alfred Kelly
executiveJennifer, thanks, and good afternoon, everyone — appreciate you being with us. Visa's results for 2022 came in very strong, despite all the uncertainty stemming from inflation, the conflict in Ukraine, COVID, the pace at which cross-border travel came back, and the possibility of a recession. Looking at the full year, credentials rose 9% compared with a year earlier, and they're up 13% once Russia is excluded. We passed 4.8 billion tokens, which is more than the count of card credentials and nearly twice what we had a year ago. Merchant locations, counting those from payment facilitators, expanded 11%. Worldwide tap-to-pay penetration climbed 10%, that's 10 points, to reach 54% of face-to-face transactions with Russia excluded, and 20 more countries crossing the 50% penetration threshold contributed to that. With both the U.S. and Russia left out, worldwide tap-to-pay penetration stood at 71%. On global transit systems, Visa's network handled 70% more tap-to-ride transactions in FY 2022, going past 1 billion transactions for the first time in our history. During FY 2022, we closed more than 400 commercial partnerships with Fintechs around the world, ranging from early-stage companies to growing and mature players. Visa Direct recorded 5.9 billion transactions with Russia excluded, spanning 60+ use cases and over 2,000 programs, supported by more than 500 enablers. More than half of our clients made use of 5 or more value-added services in 2022, while a third used 10 or more. All of this contributed to pushing fiscal full-year net revenues 22% higher than a year earlier, along with non-GAAP EPS of $7.50, which was up 27%. Let me now move to how we did in the fourth quarter and the main highlights, and then I'll offer a few remarks regarding 2023. Net revenue for the fourth quarter increased 19% versus a year earlier, and non-GAAP EPS came to $1.93, up 19%. Total Q4 payments volume rose 10% compared with a year earlier, or 135% against three years back, which is 1 point lower than Q3. With Russia and China excluded, payments volume was up 16%, or 145% of 2019. U.S. Q4 payments volume rose 12% versus a year earlier, or 145% of 2019, down 1 point. International volume increased 9% compared with a year earlier, or 126% of 2019, 1 point below Q3. With Russia and China excluded, international volume rose 20%, or 146% of 2019, unchanged from Q3. Q4 cross-border volumes, leaving out intra-Europe, climbed 49% versus a year earlier, reaching 130% compared with three years ago, 7 points above Q3. With Russia excluded, cross-border growth versus a year earlier was roughly 5 points greater. Travel-related cross-border volumes gained 12 points, moving from 104% of 2019 in Q3 to 116% in Q4, as travel kept recovering. Processed transactions rose 12% versus a year earlier, or 140% compared with 2019, and during the quarter we processed 553 million transactions per day. I'll now give you an update on the drivers behind this growth in consumer payments, new flows and value-added services. Our consumer payment strategy consists of three parts: growing credentials, increasing acceptance and deepening engagement. Total consumer payments revenue for both the fourth quarter and the year was up more than 20% in constant dollars; on the credentials side, we signed a number of significant deals with financial institution clients, co-brands and fintechs during the fourth quarter. Beginning with our financial institution customers in Asia Pacific, we completed signings with China Construction Bank, Bank of Communications, and Shanghai Pudong Development Bank — all leading banks in China. Over the course of fiscal year 2022, we renewed agreements with eight of our top issuers in China; over in CEMEA, we signed National Bank of Kuwait, which is the biggest bank in Kuwait, along with ADIB, the UAE's largest Islamic issuer. Turning to Latin America, we renewed and broadened our partnership with Colombia's second largest bank, Banco Davivienda, covering credit, debit, commercial, and Visa Direct. A further important renewal in Latin America during this quarter came with Dock, among the few full-stack enablers in that region offering BIN sponsorship, issuer processing, acquiring as a service, and program management through one connection. Having already served over 100 fintechs in Brazil, Dock is set to grow into new markets such as Mexico, Colombia, Peru, Argentina, the Dominican Republic, and Ecuador. In Europe, we renewed and broadened our relationship with UBS, Switzerland's largest issuer. Our progress in Germany has been excellent, with our share rising considerably since 2018, as we added over 12 million debit credentials there. Three of the market's most significant banks now offer Visa debit: ING, DKB, and comdirect. We're also happy to report that Santander Germany will start issuing in 2023, which makes Visa the single scheme of choice for Santander in that country across both debit and credit. Taken together throughout Europe, our quarterly active credentials rose 18% year-over-year. When it comes to co-brand, we keep growing our position in a number of countries through two recent wins plus one extension. The first is in India, with the Samsung co-brand card aimed at current and future Samsung users. The second is in the U.S., where Visa and Kohl's, with Capital One as issuer, recently reached an agreement to launch a Kohl's co-branded Visa credit card. In the U.S., we're delighted to share that Visa signed a multi-year co-brand agreement extension with Disney for cards issued by JPMorgan Chase. Now on to fintech and wallet clients: in Egypt, mobile network operator Etisalat Egypt, which has over 28 million customers, has signed a deal covering virtual and physical card issuance. Iraq's first digital bank, Zain Iraq Islamic Bank, aiming to digitize payments and push toward a cashless society, will issue Visa credit, debit, and prepaid cards to its 400,000 customers. Large cryptocurrency exchange FTX, with more than 5 million registered users, has signed on to extend issuance of Visa credentials past the U.S. into over 40 countries, which lifts our total count of issuing partnerships with crypto platforms above 70. Last, GoHenry is a fintech based in the U.S., U.K., and Europe that offers prepaid cards and a financial education app for kids aged 6 to 18, serving over 2 million members. They will be expanding their U.K. Turning to card acceptance, we signed a deal with Flywire — a worldwide payments enabler and software firm serving higher education — to boost card acceptance across mainland China, Hong Kong and Korea, alongside visa issuance to continental Europe and the U.S. South of the border in Mexico, we extended our partnership with Clip, a key payment facilitator, which will help us widen acceptance among micro, small and medium-sized merchants. Acceptance in Mexico has more than doubled since 2019, reaching close to 3 million merchant locations. Our push throughout Latin America to increase acceptance and capture processing share has delivered results. Beyond Brazil, processing penetration is up by over 20 points since 2019, thanks to migrations of domestic transactions in Argentina, Chile, Ecuador, Colombia and, most recently, Uruguay. Engaging customers matters greatly, and paying by tap is among the finest methods in face-to-face settings; during Q4, penetration in the U.S. hit 28%, and in July the country recorded over 1 billion tapped transactions in a single month for the first time, overtaking the U.K. as the biggest market for tap-to-pay transactions. That figure is almost twice the transaction count from last year and over 5 times the count from two years back. Shifting now to new flows, where fourth quarter and full-year revenue climbed above 20% in constant dollars. For the full year, our B2B business processed close to $1.5 trillion in payments volume, up 30% in constant dollars.
Alfred Kelly
executiveDuring Q4, our B2B payments volume reached just under $400 billion, which represented 21% growth compared to the prior year on a constant-dollar basis. Inside B2B, we're concentrating our approach on card-based payments, cross-border payments, and both accounts receivable and accounts payable payments. This quarter, we've advanced on each of those three fronts. Visa entered a long-term arrangement with Modulr, a European payments-as-a-service provider, under which Visa virtual cards will be issued to serve B2B travel clients issuing from Europe. Also in Europe, Visa won the credit card portfolio belonging to Crédit du Nord, which includes Société Générale, and we renewed consumer credit and debit portfolios in both of those industries. In addition, we recently formed a new fleet product partnership with Edenred, which is bringing the Edenred Essentials product to commercial and public sector organizations that have vehicles in the United States. When it comes to cross-border flows, we agreed to a deal involving Visa B2B Connect with TD Bank, and that is our first bank in Canada; we also signed banks for the first time in Switzerland and Korea. A short time ago, our CEMEA region added five banks across Kazakhstan, Qatar and Azerbaijan. In the area of accounts receivable and payable, MineralTree, a U.S. A company that provides automated solutions for invoice-to-payment processes, working with middle market and enterprise clients, has just deepened its partnership with Visa to back cards for its payables customers. Now looking at additional new flows: Visa Direct's transaction count grew 36% in the past year, not counting Russia, reaching 5.9 billion transactions. In Q4, Visa Direct posted 1.7 billion transactions, a 42% increase, which is 7 points higher than Q3. Alongside expanding the current Visa Direct business, our approach to growth includes, first, scaling new use cases with a focus on cross-border. Second, moving existing use cases into additional geographies. Third, speeding things up via enablers. On the topic of expanding into additional use cases, I'm pleased to report that eBay — among the biggest third-party marketplaces globally — now lets its sellers in the U.S. receive funds more quickly via Visa Direct. We also recently finalized a U.S. agreement with Gopuff, a food and consumer goods delivery company serving millions of customers throughout hundreds of American cities, allowing its delivery partners to withdraw their earnings balance instantly. As for extending current use cases into additional markets, in addition to certain issuing deals referenced earlier, we have entered Visa Direct agreements with China Construction Bank and Etisalat Egypt. Norway is another new market as well. Vipps, the mobile payment app from Norway, is going to give its users the ability to use Visa Direct for every payment made inside the country. For the roughly 4.3 million people who use Vipps — which amounts to more than 80% of Norway's population — this should make paying by card a better experience. Turning to the enabler approach, Square has brought instant transfers to Canada, which gives its merchants a path to settle funds more quickly. Astra, a money movement automation platform based in the U.S., is drawing on Visa Direct so that developers can build real-time transfer features into their apps; as a result, millions of Astra's end users will be able to load funds onto cards, wallets, and demand deposit accounts using debit cards they're eligible for. Visa Direct's footprint is broad: it spans more than 3 billion cards and in excess of 2 billion accounts. Not long ago, Visa Direct closed a deal with Thunes, a payments infrastructure platform headquartered in Singapore, which brings a mobile wallet network spanning 44 countries and territories. Through Thunes's B2B payment platform, this collaboration lets us introduce a send-to-wallet feature via Visa Direct, and it opens the door to 78 digital wallet providers that are already integrated, which together account for more than 1.5 billion digital wallets around the world. Thanks to this tie-up, our overall reach grows to almost 7 billion endpoints spanning cards, accounts, and wallets. Within new flows, in line with the network of networks approach we're pursuing globally, we're concentrating on constructing the infrastructure that lets our clients roll out cross-border products and services to their customers. Currencycloud, one of the newest capabilities we've added in this area, brought in 35 new partnerships during the quarter, among them Paysend, an end-to-end payment platform operating worldwide with more than 7 million customers and 17,000 SMEs. Paysend plans to broaden what its Paysend business platform can do, letting clients collect and hold as many as 34 currencies and convert funds smoothly back into whichever currency is needed at attractive FX rates. Now let's discuss value-added services. In 2022, they brought in $6 billion, which was up 20% in constant dollars. During Q4, revenue hit $1.7 billion, with the same 20% constant-dollar increase. We have a three-part strategy in this area too. The first part is getting clients to utilize more of the products we already have. The second is developing new offerings and launching excellent new solutions. The third involves moving into additional geographic markets. When it comes to that first part — increasing client adoption of current products — let's examine two of our largest value-added services: DPS, which stands for Debit Processing Services, along with Cybersource. Our issuer processing business, DPS, hit a major milestone by exceeding $2 trillion in annual authorization volume during FY 2022. We've also had about 30 clients sign new DPS agreements, and together they account for over $600 billion in annual processed authorization volume on that platform. For merchants, Cybersource remains an appealing gateway option, and we recently added McDonald's, Little Caesars, and JetBlue. Our work with acquirers through Cybersource is expanding as well. Starting with Bank of New Zealand, which is the largest acquirer in that country. And with SMCC, a Japanese acquirer, Cybersource continues to provide payment processing for more than 100,000 terminals spanning card present and card not present settings. On top of that, SMCC is drawing on Cybersource's value-added services, including fraud management. More recently, Cybersource has been the force behind SMCC's push to broaden where EMV transit payments are accepted, and it is also supporting commercial rollouts plus pilot programs involving 24 distinct transit operators across Japan. Through an arrangement with Deutsche Bank, merchants will be able to use Cybersource's Decision Manager, which gives them a risk score for each e-commerce transaction by combining rules with AI in order to help halt fraud in online retail. Turning to our second strategy — creating new products and bringing excellent new solutions to market — Tink, a company whose capabilities we picked up not long ago, stands out as a true illustration. Adyen was brought on board by Tink not long ago to deliver a white label pay by bank open banking offering on Tink's single platform. Tink's payment initiation technology is what Adyen will leverage, which lets companies switch on account to account payments. The initial rollout of Adyen's open banking connection is set for the U.K., and the intention is to bring it to various markets over the course of 2023. During the prior quarter, I brought up our freshly created risk-as-a-service offering, which draws on both artificial intelligence applied to data across our network and the expertise of our risk specialists. Not long ago, Navy Federal, based in the U.S., together with a number of banks operating in CEMEA, entered into agreements for this service, whose objective is to provide stronger fraud prevention and management. Extending our reach geographically, frequently by way of solutions built for specific needs, is our third strategy. Since acquiring Visa Europe, we've invested a lot of effort into providing value-added offerings to our clients. Across Europe, the count of customers enrolling in Visa Advanced Authorization along with Visa Risk Manager was triple in September 2022 compared with October 2019. Those customers span 14 distinct countries in Europe. Over in CEMEA, Emirates NBD — a leading issuer in the UAE — kicked off a network-agnostic pilot with Visa Risk Manager. Through Visa's network of networks strategy, a network-agnostic VRM empowers clients to monitor card payment risk across their entire portfolios. We have lately introduced our buy now, pay later offering in Canada and have kept making headway in signing up some of that country's biggest merchants, among them Simons and Canada Computers.
Alfred Kelly
executiveAn agreement has been reached between RBC and Visa to bring the Visa Installments solution to qualifying RBC consumer credit cards. To wrap up, 2022 was a really solid year for us, showing that the strategies behind each of our growth levers are paying off. Additional volumes and transactions can be driven by new flows, while value-added services can generate extra yield on the volumes and transactions we already have. Vasant will cover this in far greater depth, but I want to lay out four points regarding 2023. First, looking at the coming year, I see a major opportunity for the business across all 3 of our growth areas: consumer payments, new flows and value-added services. Second, there are some headwinds we're up against, especially lapping Russia and a tough FX environment. Third, a steep economic downturn or recession was not built into our numbers; should one happen, there will be some effect. Fourth, we'll keep running our business with the medium and long term in mind, and we'll put money into initiatives that are compelling and will deliver future growth; that said, we know some economies worldwide could come under greater pressure, so we'll be watching things very carefully. Just as in past periods, we'll be flexible and prudent when it comes to managing our expenses. As a leadership team, we've shown Visa's ability to navigate through many different environments, and I stay confident that our strategy will keep positioning Visa at the center of money movement for years to come. With that, I'll hand it over to Vasant.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveThanks, Al. Hello, everybody, and good afternoon. The results for our fiscal fourth quarter show domestic spending remains robust, while cross-border travel keeps bouncing back. Net revenues increased 19%, GAAP EPS rose 13%, and non-GAAP EPS climbed 19%. A powerful dollar proved a major obstacle, cutting reported net revenue growth by 4 points, with non-GAAP EPS growth also trimmed by 4 points. Pulling out of operations in Russia lowered net revenue growth by roughly 5 points. Some important points to note. Measured in constant dollars, global payments volume rose 10% versus a year earlier and stood 35% higher than 2019. If you set aside China and make an adjustment for Russia, global payments volume climbed 16% compared with a year ago and came in 45% above 2019. U.S. payments volume increased 12% year-over-year and was 45% greater than 2019. In constant dollars, international payments volume, once China and Russia are excluded, rose 20% versus the prior year and was 46% above 2019. Cross-border travel keeps improving. Even so, the speed of that improvement has slowed, since nearly all borders are open now, with China the exception. Using 2019 as the index base, cross-border travel volume, leaving out transactions inside Europe, climbed 12 points during the fourth quarter, compared with a 22-point increase in the third quarter. All three of our growth engines — consumer payments, new flows and value-added services — delivered revenue growth above 20% in constant dollars; during fiscal year 2022, we repurchased $11.6 billion of stock at an average price of $205.97. Money put into the litigation escrow account, which works the same way as a stock buyback, contributed an additional $850 million. We also distributed $3.2 billion in dividends. As of the end of September, $5.1 billion was left under our buyback authorization; during October, our board approved a fresh $12 billion stock buyback program and raised our dividend by 20%. Now for the details. Within the U.S., credit rose 17% year-over-year and 36% compared with 2019, aided by travel and entertainment spending. U.S. debit climbed 7%. Against 2019, debit was 54% higher, remaining significantly above the pre-COVID trend line, even with credit having recovered. U.S. card-present spend increased 11% year-over-year and was 27% above 2019. Card-not-present volume, travel excluded, rose 10% year-over-year and was 68% higher than 2019. E-commerce spending stayed well above the pre-COVID trend line, even while card-present spend kept recovering. Turning to international, Latin America rose 33% year over year and was 109% higher than 2019. Our CEMEA region, Russia excluded, expanded 32% year over year and was 105% higher than 2019. Client wins, cash digitization and acceptance expansion drove growth in both regions. Europe rose 12% year over year and was 34% higher than 2019, affected by a portfolio conversion taking place in the U.K. Outside the U.K., Europe volumes increased 30% year-over-year and were 67% above 2019, reflecting share gains across multiple markets. Asia Pacific, China excluded, keeps recovering, up 26% year-over-year and 32% above 2019. Global processed transactions rose 12% year-over-year and 40% over 2019 levels. Constant dollar cross-border volumes, excluding transactions within Europe but including Russia and prior periods, were up 49% year-over-year and 30% over 2019. If we leave Russia out of the picture, growth compared with a year earlier came in roughly 5 points greater. Volume for card-not-present cross-border transactions—setting aside travel as well as activity within Europe—rose 12% from the prior year and stood 60% higher than in 2019. Spending tied to cross-border travel, again excluding intra-Europe, climbed 101% year over year and now sits 16% above where it was in 2019. The travel index measuring cross-border activity against 2019 moved from 112 in June, to 115 in July, to 118 in September. Recovery is still underway, yet the month-to-month pace of gains has eased now that borders outside China have reopened. Travel both into and out of Asia bounced back strongly during the quarter, climbing 16 points, from an index in the high 50s to one in the mid-70s versus 2019. Asia still has room for further recovery, particularly once China begins easing its restrictions. Summer journeys to and from Europe were likewise quite robust, with a travel index against 2019 in the 130s, a gain of 13 points from the third quarter. It looks like European travel gained the most from the dollar's strength. Outbound trips from the U.S. to every region kept building momentum, reaching an index versus 2019 in the mid-130s, which is 10 points higher than in the third quarter. Inbound travel, though, recovered slowly—it still indexes in the low 90s and improved by just 4 points. The robust dollar, along with visa processing delays in certain countries, seems to be weighing on travel headed into the US. Travel to Latin America and the Caribbean stayed quite strong and steady, indexing near 150 against 2019 levels. Lastly, travel both directions involving CEMEA indexed in the mid-120s compared with 2019, an increase of 10 points during the quarter. Now let me turn to a brief look at fourth quarter financial results. Service revenues rose 11%, compared with the 12% growth in Q3 constant dollar payments volume. Currency headwinds more than canceled out gains from card benefit utilization. Data processing revenues increased 10%, against the 12% growth in processed transactions. The main factor is that Russia affects our data processing revenues. Our transaction growth, on the other hand, is unaffected. Once Russia is excluded, data processing revenues rose 15%. International transaction revenues increased 52%, versus the 49% rise in constant dollar cross-border volumes outside intra-Europe. Higher currency volatility and pricing actions aided revenue growth, more than compensating for the strong dollar's effect. Other revenues rose 13%, driven by travel-related programs and pricing actions. Client incentives came to 26.9% of gross revenues, matching expectations. Revenue growth was strong across all three of our growth engines, with each expanding over 20% on a constant dollar basis. Consumer payments growth was propelled by the cross-border volume recovery, elevated currency volatility, and continued robust domestic volumes and transactions. New flows growth came from a carded B2B recovery. Commercial card volumes rose 21% year over year and are 43% higher than in 2019. With Russia excluded, Visa Direct transactions increased 42%. Value-added services growth stemmed from greater volume, deeper client penetration, and select pricing actions. Currencycloud and Tink contributed roughly 0.5 point to revenue growth. GAAP operating expenses rose 20%. Non-GAAP operating expenses increased 18%. Bringing Currencycloud and Tink into the fold contributed roughly 3 points. Currency movements gave us a benefit of around 4.5 points. During the back half of the year, with the recovery gaining speed, we increased what we're putting into the business. We also saw higher personnel costs, driven by annual salary raises that came a quarter ahead of when we'd normally grant them, plus larger accruals for incentive compensation. Losses of $122 million came from our equity investments. If you set aside those investment losses, non-GAAP non-operating expense came to $99 million, which got a lift from greater interest income as rates climbed. GAAP EPS landed at $1.86. Non-GAAP EPS reached $1.93, a 19% gain versus a year ago, and that figure includes a 4-point hit from the strong dollar; looking at the whole year, net revenues rose 22% and non-GAAP EPS of $7.50 climbed 27%, while exchange rates cut reported revenue growth and non-GAAP EPS growth by more than 2 points apiece; we've now entered fiscal year 2023, and across the initial three weeks of October, business trends have stayed strong and stable. Compared with a year earlier, U.S. payments volume rose 11%, as debit grew 9% and credit grew 14%. U.S. spend growth measured against 2019 was 47% higher, with debit up 57% and credit up 39%.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveThe picture we just described for the fourth quarter matches what happened across key markets worldwide. Year over year, our processed transactions rose 12%, which represents a 40% increase compared with 2019. Cross-border volume on a constant dollar basis, leaving out intra-Europe transactions, climbed 42% year over year and stood 33% higher than 2019. Non-travel card-not-present volume was up 61% relative to 2019. Cross-border volumes tied to travel came in 18% above 2019. Let me turn to how we see the year ahead. Through the COVID period, looking out 4 quarters has proven hard. The COVID effect is mostly in the rearview now, but as everyone is aware, the macroeconomic and geopolitical backdrop is highly uncertain. We have noted previously that economic forecasting is not our role. A worldwide recession is clearly a serious possibility, yet we hold no particular view regarding whether one occurs, its timing, or its character. Our internal planning assumes no recession. Naturally, we will remain highly vigilant, watching our trends on a daily basis. Flexibility will be our watchword. Contingency plans will be ready in the event of an economic or geopolitical shock hitting our business, and if action is needed, we will be ready to move quickly; that sets up the planning assumptions I will now describe. Let's begin with revenue drivers. For 3 quarters now, payments volumes and processed transactions measured against 2019 have shown great stability both in the U.S. and worldwide. Put differently, on the domestic spending side, we consider the COVID recovery complete. We expect that stability to hold during fiscal year 2023, with typical year-over-year growth in the low double digits for each business driver. Regarding payments volumes, Russia will weigh on growth during the first half. Reported processed transactions growth will see no Russia effect. Trends in cross-border e-commerce have similarly been steady, particularly once Russia and crypto-related swings are factored out; our assumption is that cross-border e-commerce growth holds in the mid-teens when Russia and crypto are excluded, and in the low double digits once Russia and crypto effects are included. Cross-border travel, omitting intra-Europe, keeps recovering, though more slowly, rising 6 points from an index of 112 to 118 against 2019 between June and September; in our planning we assume this latest month-to-month recovery rate continues through fiscal year 2023. Just like a year ago, stretches of slowing and speeding up will occur. Our hope is that China begins loosening restrictions once we reach calendar year 2023. Two factors will significantly shape our reported revenue growth in fiscal year 2023. Those are Russia and the dollar, which climbed to remarkable heights across fiscal year 2022. Because we halted operations in late March, Russia will cut first half fiscal year 2023 revenue growth by more than 4%, including 4% during the first quarter and up to 5% in the second quarter, when, if you remember, we booked service fees covering two quarters in fiscal year 2022. Clearly, Russia won't play any role in the back half. For the entire year, Russia is going to cut net revenue growth by 5%. As we move into fiscal year 2023, we're up against really strong currency headwinds. Given the dollar's current level and the forward curve, foreign exchange is going to lower our reported net revenue growth by roughly 4% in fiscal year 2023. Because the dollar got stronger throughout fiscal year 2022, the hit is bigger in Q1 — about 5% — then roughly 4.5% in Q2, and it eases as the year goes on. Putting all of that together, the assumptions behind our plan take us to mid-teens constant dollar net revenue growth on a run rate basis, meaning adjusted for Russia. Add a 2-point hit from Russia and a 4-point currency drag, and reported nominal dollar net revenue growth for fiscal year 2023 lands in the high single digits. As a percentage of gross revenues, client incentives should come in between 26.5% and 27.5%. With Russia subtracting 4 points and currency headwinds growing stronger, reported nominal dollar net revenue growth in the first half should come in below the second half. The weakest growth happens in Q2, which absorbs the biggest Russia impact, then improves in Q3 and Q4 with no Russia drag and, we hope, a currency headwind that eases. Turning to operating expenses. We're keeping expense growth aligned with what we expect for revenue growth, and we're being strict about prioritizing our investment plans. As you're aware, this business runs on long cycles. What we invest now produces revenue growth two to three years, three years down the road. We need to keep funding the key growth initiatives spanning consumer payments, new flows and value-added services. Like Al mentioned, we have remarkable growth opportunities and must make sure we're investing to capture their potential. Under our present plans, non-GAAP operating expense growth in constant dollars will be low double digits, and high single digits in nominal dollars. Tink and Currencycloud, which closed during fiscal year 2022, contribute about 1% to expense growth, offset by winding down Russia operations and currency movements, each of which should give us roughly a 1.5% benefit. Non-GAAP operating expense growth will run higher in the first half for two reasons. First, Tink and Currencycloud tack on two points to expense growth in the first half. Second, in the first half we're comparing against a lower expense base from last year, since we ramped up investment spending as the cross-border recovery picked up speed. So non-GAAP expense growth in nominal dollars should be in the low double digits in the first half and at the high end of mid-single digits in the second half. It peaks in Q1, which also takes a hit from the FIFA World Cup, then moderates as the year progresses. If a recession were to occur, or a geopolitical event were to hit our operations and cause revenue increases to fall short of what we had planned for, then naturally we would revise our expenditure strategy. That would mean shifting priorities among investments, reducing or postponing certain initiatives, and making suitable cuts to costs related to staff, advertising, travel, and other areas we can control. For a company such as ours, striking the right balance between near-term and longer-term factors is always necessary. Because rates have gone up, non-operating expense stands to gain from greater interest income generated by our cash holdings; at present, we anticipate non-operating expense landing somewhere between $200 million and $250 million for fiscal year 2023. Updates will be given each quarter throughout the year. We expect our tax rate to stay within 19%-19.5% for FY 2023. Turning to the first quarter, taking into account all that I have just described, we anticipate reported nominal dollar net revenue growth in the high single digit range, with client incentives matching those of the fourth quarter of fiscal year 2022. Growth in nominal dollar non-GAAP operating expense is anticipated to be in the low teens. Depending on how certain matters are resolved, the tax rate in the first quarter might come in below the 19%-19.5% range. Net revenue growth for the second quarter is anticipated to be less than the first quarter, since the Russia impact is greater. Operating expense growth in the second quarter is likewise expected to ease to the low end of double digits.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveTo wrap up, our planning assumes things stay steady across fiscal 2023, though we're ready to move quickly if the situation shifts. Even with short-term unknowns, our confidence in the remarkable opportunity for growth over the long run has never been stronger. Core consumer payments still hold a great deal of cash waiting to go digital. Through our New Flows business, we're broadening the range of use cases we support, which speeds up volume growth, and by adding value-added services, we're improving transaction yield across our network; having said that, I'll hand things back over to Jennifer.
Jennifer Como
executiveThanks, Vasant. With that, we're ready to take questions, Holly.
Lisa Ellis
analystThank you. I appreciate you taking my question. Hi Al, I'd like to build on what you said during the prepared remarks regarding Visa currently having 4.3 billion tokens, which has doubled — that is, grown by more than 2x compared with a year earlier. Could you go into more detail on a few elements of tokenization? First, regarding selling your tokenization services as a value-added offering into other networks, alternative networks, what progress have you achieved, or how much progress have you achieved? Since you don't earn money from tokens directly, how should we consider the indirect advantages of tokenization for Visa at this point, when the quantity of tokens exceeds the card credentials in existence? Thank you.
Alfred Kelly
executiveYes; that figure is 4.3, Lisa. That's $4.8 billion. So far, we've enjoyed some success, though not an enormous amount, when it comes to selling tokens into other networks. As you know, we hold a vital position within the ecosystem, and we regard tokenization as essential to the ecosystem's security and, in the end, to the ecosystem's trust when it comes to card transactions that convert, whose payments get converted into tokens. In the future, we anticipate this will generate strongly favorable effects for our issuers and merchants where fraud is concerned. In a handful of instances — The Clearing House is one, Global Payments is another — I'm aware that we currently receive revenue from the tokenization capability we are developing on their behalf.
David Togut
analystCan you estimate what effect there will be on growth in processed transactions for FY 2023 from the Federal Reserve System requiring two unaffiliated networks to handle all online U.S. debit transactions, starting 1 July 2023? On a related note, are there any strategies you have to mitigate that effect, such as possibly changing prices?
Vasant Prabhu
executiveSure, I'll take the first portion of that question. I'm certain Al will want to weigh in with additional thoughts regarding the second portion. Naturally, we need to observe how quickly that second network gets turned on for cards and e-commerce purchases. Based on our present assumption — since our fiscal year, as everyone knows, runs until September — any impact during 2023 ought to be negligible, or possibly nonexistent. We'll make sure to keep everyone informed. On a wider note, regarding how we see things playing out over a longer horizon, customers choose us owing to the worth we generate, and that worth shows up through operating a dual message network along with all the accompanying elements. The safety and dependability that we deliver, which nobody else matches, plus the dispute resolution and various other offerings, tokenization, and all the risk management services we stack on top — we've vied for business previously, and merchants have picked us because of what we bring to the table, and I'm confident, Al, that you've got additional points to contribute here.
Alfred Kelly
executiveWell, I'd say our capabilities are simply outstanding. When it comes to e-commerce, David, it's the merchant who bears the fraud liability. So they're going to be extremely cautious regarding whom they partner with. They've partnered with us for many years and understand we possess exceptionally robust risk capabilities, exceptionally robust fraud prevention capabilities. Based on what we've seen since Durbin in 2010, those are the sorts of things that lead a substantial number of merchants to stay exclusively with us and never route to the unaffiliated network, thanks to those security and fraud capabilities we offer. Also, as Vasant mentioned, we can be dual messaged, and that creates a significant difference in car rental, hotel. In the online space, it'll create a significant difference when shoppers order multiple items from a merchant. It lets the merchant ship in separate shipments rather than waiting until all the products have been collected and then being forced to ship everything at once if you're relying on a single messaging capability. I believe we have extensive history and numerous important capability differences, and many of our merchants in the United States are quite familiar with the advantages they receive from working with us.
Darrin Peller
analystHi there, and thank you. The guidance and the plan you shared with us were clearly useful, and they really highlight how well the consumer has held up until now. Just to address the hypothetical for a moment, I believe roughly one-third of your revenue is currently being generated by new flows and services, a lot of which are still in the early phases of growth. Combining that with elevated inflation, Al, would you anticipate a different pattern of results on the top line if we were to experience a significant downturn? And then Vasant, perhaps you could speak to the adaptability you believe exists on the cost side to assist in navigating any kind of shift.
Alfred Kelly
executiveDarrin, to clarify, roughly one-third is correct when you include VAS along with new flows, rather than new flows alone. Like you mentioned, at this moment, we're honestly seeing only stability. That's held true across the past several quarters. Our company today looks quite unlike how it did when the previous downturn occurred. We now lean far more heavily toward everyday spend categories. Tremendous changes have taken place in e-commerce. Cash digitization has advanced a great deal; our debit portfolio is quite substantial, and that type of portfolio generally holds up better through downturns like these. Honestly, I suspect none of us can predict what the effect will be as we emerge from the pandemic, since considerable pent-up demand appears to remain for things such as travel, which counts as a highly discretionary purchase. We're in a strange period in which employment has proven quite resilient. Should payment volumes take any sort of meaningful hit, we will definitely be monitoring that, returning to the heart of what you asked. Clearly, our revenue line will absorb some impact. On the expense side, we'll keep managing things, and I'll hand that portion of your question over to Vasant.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveOkay, just staying on revenue for another moment — obviously, at this point we've got new flows and value-added services, and those are businesses in new use cases that look quite different from what existed during earlier downturns; in many instances, they're still scaling up too. Value-added services, obviously, represent an entire set of new offerings that aren't all necessarily connected to, you know, economic swings. Obviously, there are plenty of distinctions compared with prior periods. But like Al mentioned, recessions arrive in every kind of form and shape and size, and they may be global or regional, deep or shallow, they may be, you know, downturns that affect consumer spending less and so forth. When it comes to expenses, as I mentioned in my, you know, remarks about planning assumptions, I'd put it in three parts. First, we're slowing expense growth as we move into the year. Expense growth is obviously, you know, declining from the levels that you've observed. For the year, our starting planning assumption is nominal growth of about 9%, though I'd point out that during the second half of the year — the fiscal year — growth is actually in the high-end to mid-single digits. It's moderating as the year progresses and, you know, we don't know when a recession might happen or whether one will happen at all, but if you consider what all the different prognosticators are saying, it seems most people believe that if a recession comes, it's at some point, you know, next year, likely six months from now. Well, that would place us in the second half of our fiscal year, so, you know, we already have expense growth moderating to the, you know, sort of high-end to mid-single digits. Obviously, we'll look to reprioritize, scale back, postpone, et cetera. You know, based on what kind of recession it is and how it's affecting our revenue, we'd try to manage our expenses to be, you know, even better than what our planning assumptions might be and push the growth rate lower. We'll calibrate as we go along.
Jennifer Como
executiveLet's take the next question.
Bob Napoli
analystThanks. I appreciate that. I was thinking, could you maybe share some perspective on what excites you the most as we move toward 2023 and 2024, and what has caught you off guard, if anything? Vasant, could you offer a bit of detail regarding goods compared with services? What have you observed in terms of the growth rate trends for those two categories?
Alfred Kelly
executiveRegarding what gets us excited, look, across all three businesses, we're witnessing some truly fantastic green shoots; in consumer payments, we're definitely enthusiastic about how cash digitization is becoming increasingly evident worldwide. We're also enthusiastic about the ongoing strides we're making with tap-to-pay. The reality that our e-commerce business has expanded so significantly. I really like what we're observing on the continent in Europe regarding the growth there, which is genuinely robust. When we look at India, Brazil, Germany, Canada, Japan, every one of them is expanding at quite healthy levels. The dynamics differ greatly across those markets, yet all of them are expanding quite nicely. Not long ago, I traveled to Nigeria and the Democratic Republic of the Congo. You know, Africa won't necessarily assist us in 2023 or 2024, Bob, but we currently have offices, I believe, in 13 countries there, and the most recent five or six offices we've launched there were opened around the world in Africa. In New Flows, since we've restructured that business into a single unit, Oliver Jenkyn is bringing tremendous focus to it and ensuring we're generating new use cases globally, attracting more and more enablers who assist us in driving those use cases, and we're placing a specific emphasis there on cross-border. Where previously, you know, many of the early use cases in new flows were in areas such as domestic, like P2P and B2B. Then in VAS, certainly, we're enthusiastic about the two recent acquisitions we completed of Tink and Currencycloud. I believe both will deliver some very intriguing and solid capabilities to us. In each instance, we've devoted considerable time in planning sessions between the individuals leading those businesses and our people, and I believe a tremendous opportunity lies ahead. Vasant, do you want to address the goods versus services question?
Vasant Prabhu
executiveYes. A handful of points regarding goods compared with services. As you're aware, we typically examine how different segments are doing relative to where they stood before the pandemic, back in 2019; that gives us a clear baseline. Even though plenty has been said about goods supposedly lagging, the majority of goods categories, when indexed to 2019, have in fact performed pretty strongly and are remaining fairly steady. What that tells us is they expanded much more quickly during the earlier stage of the recovery, and after that didn't keep growing at the same pace once people moved their spending toward services. On the whole, measured against 2019, the goods side of the business has performed really well, indexing strongly relative to its prior position and, you know, essentially sitting right at or past the pre-COVID trend line. Lately, even while services and, you know, restaurants, travel, entertainment keep expanding, goods is beginning to improve; it went through a stretch of extremely strong growth, you know, particularly during the stimulus period and so forth, bouncing back far quicker than services did, and then services began returning. At this point we're beginning to observe some rebound in goods as well. All in all, you know, goods is performing quite strongly on a three-year index too.
Jennifer Como
executiveLet's take the next question.
Harshita Rawat
analystThanks for taking my question. Vasant, could you discuss and drill down into cross-border revenues for 2023? I realize there's still recovery left if you simply examine the trend line on travel compared with 2019, and likewise if you examine metrics that go beyond spend, which includes inflation; conversely, this carries very high beta to macro. The U.S. dollar has appreciated considerably, which can affect cross-border inflows into the U.S., and FX volatility provided a big boost to revenue this year, but next year you're up against difficult comparisons. Many moving pieces. What's your view on it? Thank you.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveYeah. As you noted, there are clearly many moving pieces, so I'll simply address them one at a time. Yes, we did gain from extremely high currency volatility during the second half of this year. That assists us, as you're aware; it sits in our international fees line, international revenue line. You know, what volatility will be is anyone's guess. For planning purposes, we've assumed that it begins to moderate as the year progresses. It remains high and we're assuming that, you know, it might be above normal in the first quarter and then, you know, moderate as we move through the year to what we've observed previously to levels that are normal, you know, across a long period of time. That's, you know, the effect of volatility. When it comes to, you know, the dollar and how it affects cross-border travel. You know, we've informed you that we've witnessed roughly a 2-point monthly improvement in that index over the last few months. Again, I mean, predicting these things is very difficult. You know, we got it wrong last year. The recovery was far faster than we anticipated. We'll probably get it wrong again, but we've been very clear about our assumption, which is that, you know, the recovery we've witnessed for the past several months we believe is probably the new rate of recovery. There'll be accelerations and decelerations and perhaps if China opens up and lifts restrictions, there could be some acceleration. That's roughly what we're assuming for travel. What effect a recession might have on it remains to be seen. As Al said, there's pent-up demand and how much will that offset it? You know, we'll wait and see. The main message is there's still recovery in cross-border taking place but we're also lapping much stronger cross-border levels from last year. As you know, cross-border travel really began to recover last September and so we're now starting to lap some really stronger periods last quarter. The rate of growth inevitably has slowed and it will continue to slow as the year goes on; it's still above the long-term trend line because we still are in recovery mode. Hopefully that helps a bit.
Jennifer Como
executiveLet's take the next question.
Ashwin Shirvaikar
analystThanks. From a big-picture standpoint, I understand that what you're observing is purely steadiness. That's been the case for several months now, as you noted. On a finer level, is there anything worth calling out if some specific areas are performing well or poorly? That's the first part. And it also sounds like you're suggesting the overall business has greater resilience, since you now have new flows and value-add services alongside consumer pay. Once again, I'm on board with that, but could you perhaps discuss the new flows in value-add and what you might anticipate during a downturn?
Alfred Kelly
executiveTo start with, Ashwin, I would say stability has been evident for somewhat over a few months, though likely quite near the past 12 months — definitely the most recent nine months. Well, as I mentioned, even with that stability, the truth is we recognize there are shifts taking place in how consumers behave, yet they continue to spend an equivalent sum of money and continue to pay the same way, and those things matter greatly to us; we recognize some substitution is happening, in which consumers are, you know, choosing generics rather than brands. We recognize that people are allocating a particular sum toward — that's a growing sum toward — food and drug items, and that leaves them with reduced funds for discretionary purchases. We continue to observe, you know, as I pointed out, I believe during last quarter, you know, that the affluent customer continues to re-enter the market, and that's a really positive development given how much they spend. We continue to observe employment figures at a very healthy level. There are things happening, but the truth is that although consumers, you know, may be modifying somewhat what they purchase across various categories, the reality is that, you know, as I stated, they continue to spend an equivalent sum of money and use the same payment methods as previously. Regarding value-added services and new flows, clearly value-added services depends somewhat on transactions. We deliver extra value on transactions. Should those transactions decline, that clearly affects the value-added services business. The New Flows business genuinely suffered somewhat because of the volume of business we had in Russia. As I disclosed, you know, it rose 42% in the fourth quarter, excluding Russia, which was a gain of seven points compared with the third quarter. The momentum there is extremely, extremely strong. I believe that relates largely to the fact that across the last 15 months, we've accomplished a very solid job of further diversifying that business regarding use cases, enablers and geographies, and all of that has assisted us considerably.
Jennifer Como
executiveLet's move on to the next question.
Timothy Chiodo
analystThank you very much for taking my question. I'd like to talk about the Visa Direct decision — specifically, when businesses, platforms, and governments are deciding whether to use Visa Direct versus other alternatives, such as RTP systems globally. I completely understand that Visa Direct relies on many of these RTP and other ACH systems worldwide. So what is driving them to select Visa Direct? And as a second question, you've frequently mentioned the pricing for Visa Direct — it's very much based on the use case. Perhaps you could give some directional examples of what a higher-priced use case would look like and what a lower-priced use case would look like.
Alfred Kelly
executiveLet me start by explaining the reasoning behind Visa Direct. The primary benefit it offers is its reliance on the VisaNet platform, which means it inherits every one of that platform's capabilities. Next, as I mentioned, Visa Direct gives us extraordinary reach — nearly 7 billion endpoints, spanning accounts, cards, and wallets. As you pointed out, we've grown somewhat indifferent to the precise mechanics of how that flow occurs. Whether the first or last mile runs over an RTP network, an ACH network, or a payment gateway, we're perfectly happy with that. We keep putting money into capabilities tied to Visa Direct. On top of that, you receive many of the safeguards you'd expect: zero liability, chargebacks, and robust, dependable dispute management. Add to that the security you get, plus the resources we devote to safeguarding consumer data and fighting cyber security threats. Compared with a transaction where funds leave your bank account instantly over an RTP network to pay someone, all these capabilities deliver a great deal of reassurance to a consumer. Suddenly, when a problem arises, there's no one to approach. No rules exist to dictate what takes place. No one is available to help resolve the situation. Everything our network handles is what positions Visa Direct as a truly, truly compelling substitute for an RTP network.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveAbout your second question — perhaps a couple of illustrations will help. On one side, you've got a use case with significant value: cross-border remittances. Visa Direct provides remarkable versatility there. Whether it's card to account, account to account, or card to card, you can complete it while at home. There's no need to visit a person and hand over physical currency. And on the receiving side, the flexibility is equally impressive. The money arrives instantly. It carries every other advantage Al referenced. As you're aware, sending funds across borders currently comes at a very steep price. We're able to handle the same thing at a much lower cost while still delivering a yield that looks quite appealing next to what we'd call our conventional yield. On the opposite side of the range sits P2P, and the strongly favored approach involves keeping your debit credentials on file, since that makes things considerably safer and brings in all the value we're capable of adding; this is a use case with large volume yet modest returns, and quite frequently it's how we launch in the majority of markets. That covers two illustrations. Sitting between those extremes are insurance disbursements, earned wage access, marketplace payouts, and similar things, each of which differs from the others.
Jennifer Como
executiveHolly, let's take the final question.
Tien-Tsin Huang
analystThanks. I really appreciate it. I realize we're past the hour, so I'm grateful for your time. If you don't mind, I have just 2 quick items. First, regarding that other revenue line — I understand services, and you noted there's a transactional component involved, yet you achieved 20% growth at scale in fiscal 2022. Assuming things stay relatively stable, any perspective on how 2023 could shape up? Second, I hoped to get clarity on the base case for operating leverage. On a nominal basis, it appears we ought to expect minimal operating leverage. I simply want to confirm we're interpreting that the right way and how that could shift should circumstances evolve. Thanks.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveSure. Regarding operating leverage, like we mentioned, we're attempting to strike a balance between near-term and longer-term considerations. As you've heard, we believe there are remarkable opportunities when it comes to new flows and value-added services; these businesses take a long time to mature. You need to put money in today for tomorrow. Indeed, we're opting to put money into the business, and that's reflected in, you know, the costs we've budgeted, our planned cost increase compared with how much revenue grows. The second portion of the question concerned other revenues. Correct. When it comes to other revenues, certain items within that category will experience a sequential deceleration as well, since you have things such as auto-related perks and similar items sitting in the other revenue line that move with travel. When you lap a more robust rebound in travel from the prior year, some sequential decelerations will occur. A handful of additional value-added services sit there as well. You know, much like the broader business, where a sequential deceleration happens owing to lapping effects plus certain currency consequences in Russia and similar factors, that same pattern will show up in the other revenue line as well.
Jennifer Como
executivePerfect. On that note, we want to express our appreciation for your participation in today's session. Should any further inquiries come up, don't hesitate to reach out by phone or send a message to our investor relations group. Once more, thank you, and enjoy the rest of your day.
Operator
operatorThis concludes today's conference. Thank you for participating. You may disconnect at this time.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Visa Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Visa Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Visa Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.