Visa Inc. (V) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
January 26, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Jennifer Como
executiveThank you, Jordin. Hello, everyone, and good afternoon. We appreciate you joining us for the earnings call covering Visa's fiscal first quarter of 2023. Present with us are Al Kelly, who serves as Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of Visa; Vasant Prabhu, our Vice Chair and Chief Financial Officer; and Ryan McInerney, set to take on the role of Chief Executive Officer at Visa next week. This call is being webcast through the Investor Relations section of our website, investor.visa.com. A replay is going to be archived on our site for 30 days. We have posted a slide deck with financial and statistical highlights on our IR website. I also want to remind everyone that forward-looking statements are part of this presentation; such statements do not constitute guarantees regarding future performance, and a number of factors could cause our actual results to differ materially. You can find additional details about those factors in our latest reports on Form 10-K, available on the SEC's website as well as the Investor Relations section of our website. Regarding non-GAAP financial information discussed on this call, the corresponding GAAP measures and reconciliation can be found in today's earnings release; and now, I'll hand the call over to Al.
Al Kelly
executiveJennifer, thanks, and good afternoon to everyone, and I appreciate you being with us. Visa's results for the first quarter of 2023 show steady domestic volumes and transactions along with ongoing recovery in cross-border travel. Total Q1 payments volume rose 7% from a year earlier, or 135% compared with three years back, unchanged from Q4. If you set aside Russia and China, payments volume climbed 12%, or 146% of 2019. U.S. Q1 payments volume increased 9% year-over-year, or 144% of 2019, a decline of 1 point versus Q4. International volume, leaving out Russia and China, gained 15%, or 147% of 2019, 1 point higher than Q4. Q1 cross-border volumes, excluding intra-Europe, expanded 31% year-over-year and 132% against three years ago, 5 points above Q4. With Russia excluded, cross-border year-over-year growth was 4 points greater. Travel-related cross-border volumes moved up 6 points, from 112% of 2019 in Q4 to 118% in Q1, powered by Asia Pacific, aided by China easing restrictions, ongoing modest gains in inbound traffic to the United States, and CEMEA benefiting from the FIFA World Cup. Processed transactions increased 10% year-over-year, or 139% versus 2019, and during the quarter we processed 571 million transactions per day. While first quarter net revenues grew — on the whole, I should say, first quarter net revenues grew 12% year-over-year and non-GAAP EPS came to $2.18, up 21%. Across each of our growth levers — consumer payments, new flows and value-added services — we recorded strong revenue growth. Within our consumer payments business, we achieved significant progress this quarter via large deals with traditional issuers and co-brands. And with the pandemic mostly behind us, we observed many businesses concentrating on payments through Visa's new flows capabilities. Beyond that, we keep building and broadening our global value-added services around the world. Now let me dig into each of these growth areas. In consumer payments, credentials rose 8% overall, 11% excluding Russia, with strong double-digit growth in the United States, India and Brazil. Tap-to-pay penetration of face-to-face transactions globally stood at 72%, excluding Russia and the United States; in the United States, we moved past a notable 30%, with San Jose, San Francisco and New York City each above 50%. U.S. drugstores exceeded 40% for the first time in the United States, and nearly 65% of Costco's face-to-face credit transactions were done with a tap; in the United States, we had several important renewals. First, we renewed our partnership with Bank of America in the United States, keeping our current debit and credit business, including their cash rewards, travel rewards, premium rewards and newly launched Premium Rewards Elite consumer credit cards. We're excited to keep investing together in growing our joint business and to innovate with Bank of America to deliver enhanced capabilities and improved experiences for their customers. Second, we renewed with Commerce Bank, a top 25 Visa U.S. issuer across their consumer and commercial portfolios. Finally, we also renewed our agreement with Capital One. Down in Australia, we signed again with Costco, that nation's biggest independent provider of payment solutions, which has more than 4 million cardholders on debit and prepaid, and we additionally inked a fresh deal covering credit issuance. Over in that same region, our exclusive tie-up with Kiwibank, the biggest bank owned by New Zealand, was extended. Turning to Latin America, we renewed with ICBC Argentina, among the country's biggest issuers, as well as with Banco do Brasil, which ranks among the region's largest Visa issuers; on top of that, we struck a brand-new arrangement with Banco Nacional de Panamá, one of Panama's biggest banks. Still in Latin America, a new strategic deal was reached with the fintech platform Tigo Money and its parent, Millicom, a top telecommunications services provider in that region. Visa and Millicom anticipate giving Tigo Money's over 5 million wallet users a way to digitize their cash easily and securely, letting them make purchases anywhere Visa is accepted using the Visa-Tigo Money Access Card. A further strategic fintech deal came with Niyo in India, a rapidly expanding neobank focused on cross-border with 5 million customers. Our relationship there has been extended out of debit and into credit, in order to grow cross-border spending among affluent customers as well as corporate ones. We're pleased as well to report the renewal and extension of our global partnership with HSBC. Consumer and commercial are both covered by our agreement, and it will drive growth along with digital acceleration. This deal, too, reaches across each of Visa's five regions. As everyone knows, Visa leads in travel co-brand worldwide, and I'm glad to say we've lately concluded agreements involving three significant travel relationships. To start, Qatar Airways' Privilege Club, whose portfolio today is split among networks globally, has put its signature on a new 10-year exclusive partnership with Visa aimed at enhancing and expanding its portfolio of co-branded payment initiatives alongside key financial partners in key markets around the world. Through this expanded partnership, a new world of opportunities opens up for our Visa customers and Privilege Club members to collect and spend Avios, which is Privilege Club's rewards currency. Next, with Southwest Airlines in the United States, Visa will remain the exclusive payment network for the co-brand credit card that JPMorgan Chase issues. That counts among the biggest co-brand partnerships anywhere in the world. And third, alongside Star Alliance and HSBC in Australia, this card is the first credit card globally made with an airline alliance, issued exclusively on Visa Credit. When it launched, it united seven Star Alliance carriers on one single credit card platform. We also recently moved our co-brand partnership with Flipkart forward — Flipkart being one of India's top digital commerce players, with a registered customer base of 450 million; so be it traditional issuers or co-brand partners, we keep positioning Visa well for what lies ahead. Moving to new flows, where during this past quarter they kept growing, with revenue up more than 20% in constant dollars, driven by strong growth in B2B payments volume and Visa Direct transactions. Starting with Visa Direct, we saw 1.9 billion transactions during Q1, which represents a 39% increase compared to the prior year, if you leave Russia out of the picture; growth continues on a worldwide basis. When Russia is excluded, the share of total transactions made up by Visa Direct activity outside the U.S. climbed by almost 20 points between Q1 '21 and Q1 '23. Following the achievements of the remittance initiative we run alongside Standard Chartered Bank in Hong Kong, Malaysia was introduced not long ago as another market for origination, covering six currency payers, and additional currencies are on the way. Beyond that, we keep extending established use cases into fresh markets. To begin, in Australia, driver payouts through DoorDash are now being enabled by Visa Direct. Next, together with FNB, among the biggest banks in the country, we introduced our first P2P offering in South Africa, allowing their 10 million active customers to transfer funds inside their mobile app through Visa Direct rails. Then there's our wallet cash payout initiative, which launched in Bangladesh with bKash. Thanks to this rollout, roughly 65 million bKash users are able to do wallet to money and bank transfers around the clock, 24/7, in near real time via Visa Direct. A number of use cases are being enabled by us, such as seller payouts on Poshmark in the United States, a social media marketplace with over 80 million registered users, plus card top-offs with the fintech GoHenry.
Al Kelly
executiveFollowing up on the issuance arrangement we told you about during the prior quarter alongside that company, GoHenry lets its members add funds to a child's prepaid Visa card through Visa Direct, starting in the UK, and later they intend to roll that capability out throughout Europe; beyond Visa Direct, there was notable progress during the quarter just ended on the B2B side, with commercial payments volume up 15% in constant dollars. On the traditional issuance side, a deal was struck with Raiffeisen Bank covering a fresh commercial credit partnership, plus we renewed consumer credit serving all 3 million of their clients in Austria. Stateside, UBS renewed with us across consumer credit and debit, along with multiple business credit portfolios and Visa Spend Clarity for business. One more issuing partnership came with Stone, among Brazil's biggest acquirers and focused on smaller companies. Stone recently started issuing Visa debit and credit cards capable of being embedded digitally inside its wallet. Turning to virtual cards for receivables and payables, a number of agreements were closed. To begin with, Divvy, the expense management platform that BILL owns, renewed its deal to provide Visa virtual cards to small and midsized businesses in the United States within its expense and vendor payment offerings. Next, Viewpost turns U.S. We're converting business-to-business check payments into Visa virtual cards. Together, we're expanding what's possible with cards for both issuers and corporate clients, using an approach that's simple to deploy across any commercial operation that still relies on paper checks. Third, we've struck a deal with Plate IQ, one of America's leading providers of complete accounts payable automation, which connects straight into accounting platforms. Through this partnership, Plate IQ will bring a Visa virtual card offering to business clients across a wide range of sectors, including restaurants and hospitality, retail, and accounting and bookkeeping, to name a few. Number four: in Asia Pacific, SUNRATE — a global platform for payments and treasury management — rolled out Visa virtual cards as part of what it offers to more than 1,000 B2B clients, including worldwide online travel agencies plus small business customers. Fleet issuance continues to grow as well. This quarter, we issued — we brought on Zemo, which provides fleet and mobility solutions in Europe, to issue Visa Open Loop fleet and fuel commercial cards as that company expands from three European markets to 10. Here in the United States, Highnote, which offers cloud-native card issuance and embedded finance, expanded its ties with Visa via a five-year card issuance agreement covering credit, debit, virtual solutions and fleet. Furthermore, Highnote earned certification as a Visa Fleet card processor, giving businesses more granular product category level controls along with richer and quicker data for real-time choices regarding new fleet and fuel card programs. B2B remains a busy area for fintechs, and Visa keeps teaming up with new entrants to push innovation for businesses. One illustration from not long ago is Konfio, a Mexican fintech that has issued roughly 50,000 Visa small business cards so far and has just broadened its arrangement to issue Visa Business Infinite cards. On top of that, the company is set up to increase acceptance in the market through its recently launched acquiring operation, Sr. Pago. Turning now to value-added services, which brought in around $1.7 billion of revenue during this first quarter, an increase of over 20% in constant dollars. Keep in mind that our value-added services strategy has three parts: first, getting existing clients to adopt more of our current products; second, creating and rolling out new solutions; and third, growing into new geographies. CyberSource illustrates all three of those priorities well. To start with deepening client penetration of existing products: CyberSource's Decision Manager offering delivers extensive functionality to current CyberSource clients and has grown strongly throughout the pandemic, more than doubling transactions over the last three years. In the first quarter, Decision Manager transaction volume rose by a low-teens percentage compared with the same period a year earlier. That tells us demand for this offering is still strong as we transition into a world beyond the pandemic. We've also talked about another area of growth: acquirers that leverage CyberSource's tools to deliver them to the merchants they serve. During Q1, we entered into deals with a number of acquirers covering gateway services, including Elavon in North America; in Saudi Arabia, Saudi British Bank has publicly revealed a strategic partnership involving our CyberSource Payment Gateway and Risk Platform, intended to boost SABB's payment gateway capabilities overall so the bank can grow within a fast-changing, dynamic e-commerce landscape; when it comes to expanding geographically, we've continued working to strengthen our presence around the globe. Since Q1 2019, our CyberSource activity conducted abroad has increased nearly four times over, and those transactions now make up the bulk of our total, with Asia Pacific standing out as the strongest driver. New products have also been rolled out by CyberSource. While CyberSource traditionally operated as an e-commerce tool, we have accelerated work on our card-present and omnichannel solutions across the last several years, partly by acquiring Payworks in 2019. In the quarter just ended, authorized CyberSource card-present transactions rose close to 50% compared with the same period a year earlier. Additional value-added services highlights for this quarter include our innovative dispute capability through Verifi, which experienced almost 40% growth in cases processed this quarter as we broadened our reach globally, with over 1/3 of our cases originating outside North America. This rapid dispute resolution solution automatically resolves disputes between merchants and issuers through the acquirer of rails, cutting the average time to resolve a dispute from 24 days to typically seconds. And Tink, our open banking platform, continues to deepen and develop relationships across Europe. Tink recently signed a master agreement with BNP Paribas to be their main open banking and money movement services provider for millions of customers across Europe. Tink is up and running across multiple companies within the group. At BNP Paribas Fortis in Belgium and BNL in Italy, 3 million customers rely on Tink's money management, data enrichment and transactions products. In a similar vein, Tink has expanded and widened the scope of its partnership with ABN AMRO, integrating Tink's Money Manager and data enrichment offerings into that bank's app, which serves over 3 million customers. In closing, Visa delivered remarkably strong results in the first quarter and continues to execute our growth strategy well. Vasant will go into detail about how we're thinking about the rest of the year, but I'd like to make a few more brief closing points. Our business will keep being run with a medium- to long-term horizon, and we'll put money into initiatives that are persuasive and will generate growth down the road, while staying highly attuned to today's conditions. Looking toward the rest of this year and past it, I still foresee a bright future for Visa, and I think our strategy is the right one to keep producing excellent results. As was announced in November, starting February 1, 2023, I will step away from the CEO position and take on the full-time job of Executive Chairman. My gratitude to the Board and to Visa's leadership is immense, and equally to our devoted 26,500 employee colleagues, who made this role so fulfilling. Since I began in 2016, I take pride in everything we've achieved as a team.
Al Kelly
executiveRyan McInerney is going to take over as CEO of Visa, and honestly, I can't imagine a better person to keep positioning Visa right at the heart of how money moves, in ways that get more inventive all the time. For close to 6.5 years, Ryan and I worked alongside each other. Our business and our clients are things he understands, and our employees hold him in deep regard. He and his team are going to do a fantastic job, and my expectation is that this transition goes completely smoothly. Keeping that in mind, and as Jennifer mentioned, I've invited Ryan to take part in the Q&A section of today's call. Before we get to that, though, let me pass things to Vasant so he can walk through the financial highlights for the quarter along with what we're thinking about the second quarter and further out.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveThanks, Al, and good afternoon to all of you. The results for our fiscal first quarter show us continuing to grow domestic spending, along with an ongoing rebound in travel across borders. Net revenues rose 12%, GAAP EPS climbed 8%, and non-GAAP EPS increased 21%. The strong dollar cut roughly 3 points from reported net revenue growth and about 3.5 points from non-GAAP EPS growth. Pulling out of Russia lowered net revenue growth by around 4.5 points. If you set Russia aside, net revenues in constant dollars rose nearly 20%. Growth in net revenue came in above what we had expected, since value-added services and new flows posted very strong growth, currency swings remained elevated, and client incentives came in below what we had forecast. A handful of notable points. In constant dollars, global payments volume rose 7% from a year earlier and stood 35% higher than 2019. Leaving out China and adjusting for Russia, global payments volume increased 12% year-over-year and came in 46% above 2019. U.S. payments volume rose 9% from a year earlier and was 44% above 2019. In constant dollars, international payments volume, once China and Russia are excluded, grew 15% year-over-year and was 47% above 2019. U.S. holiday spending grew in the high single digits from a year earlier and was up more than 41% compared with 2019. E-commerce held onto its share of retail spending relative to last year, and it is up over 5 points since 2019. Holiday season spending continues to even out, with Black Friday and Cyber Monday remaining major shopping days but carrying less weight now that the pandemic has passed. Holiday spending worldwide broadly tracked U.S. trends. Cross-border travel keeps recovering. That said, as we anticipated, the recovery has slowed now that most borders are open, including Japan in October and, as of January, China. Keep in mind that October and November of 2021 brought a very sharp rebound in cross-border travel, and that is the comparison we are up against. Measured against 2019, cross-border travel volume, excluding transactions inside Europe, gained 6 points in the first quarter, versus a 20-point increase in the third quarter of fiscal year '22 and 10 points in the fourth quarter of fiscal year '22. New plans — new flows and value-added services revenue kept growing strongly, above 20% in constant dollars; during the first quarter of fiscal year '23, we repurchased roughly $3.1 billion of stock at an average price of $198.74. Money put into the litigation escrow account, which works the same way as a stock buyback, contributed an additional $350 million; we also paid out $945 million in dividends. Now for the details. Within the U.S., credit was up 10% year-over-year and 35% above 2019, as we lap last year's credit recovery, and on a sequential basis versus last quarter it was affected by retail spending and fuel prices. U.S. debit rose 8%, an increase over last quarter sequentially. Compared with 2019, debit was up 55%, holding well above the pre-COVID trend line even after credit's recovery. U.S. card present spend rose 8% year-over-year, held back by fuel prices and retail spend on a sequential basis versus last quarter. U.S. card present spend stood 26% above 2019. U.S. Card-not-present volume, travel excluded, rose 9% versus a year earlier and came in 65% above where it stood in 2019. Even with card-present spending having bounced back, e-commerce outlays are still running well ahead of the path they followed before COVID. Turning to international results in constant dollars, Latin America climbed 25% compared with a year ago and stood 107% above 2019. Our CEMEA region, leaving out Russia, posted 25% year-over-year growth and sat 108% above 2019, since as we observed throughout FY '22, both regions drew their momentum from client wins, cash digitization and acceptance expansion. Europe rose 10% versus a year earlier and was 34% above 2019, held back by a portfolio conversion that has now almost wrapped up in the UK. Outside the UK, European volumes increased 28% compared with a year ago and landed 71% above 2019, thanks to share gains across a number of markets. Barring portfolio conversions, UK volume patterns stayed steady. Asia Pacific, China excluded, kept recovering, gaining 16% year-over-year and running 34% above 2019. Globally, processed transactions increased 10% versus a year earlier and 39% relative to 2019 levels. Constant dollar cross-border volume, which leaves out transactions inside Europe while counting Russia in earlier periods, rose 31% year-over-year and 32% against 2019. When Russia is taken out, year-over-year growth came in roughly 4 points higher. Cross-border card-not-present volume growth, travel and intra-Europe both excluded, expanded 3% versus a year earlier and was 55% above 2019. Once cryptocurrency purchases and Russia are adjusted for, cross-border e-commerce spending rose at a low double-digit rate. Cross-border card-not-present, travel excluded, accounted for more than 40% of overall cross-border volume during the first quarter. Cross-border travel spending, intra-Europe excluded, increased 63% versus a year earlier and now sits 18% above 2019. The cross-border travel figure, Europe excluded, indexed against 2019, moved from 114 in September to 121 in December. Travel into and out of Asia bounced back strongly during the quarter, climbing over 12 points from the mid-70s indexed to 2019 up to 85 for outbound and beyond 90 for inbound, aided by Japan. Japan by itself gained roughly 50 points after opening its borders in October; now that China has lifted restrictions on January 8, we anticipate further recovery ahead. Europe inbound and outbound stayed robust, with travel indexed to 2019 sitting in the 120s for outbound and 130s for inbound, each modestly higher than the fourth quarter. Outbound travel from the U.S. to every geography remains strong in the low 140s indexed to 2019, 6 points above the fourth quarter. Inbound travel to the U.S. drew close to 2019 levels and picked up 4 points during the quarter, probably because of the weakening dollar. Travel into Latin America and the Caribbean stayed very strong and steady, indexing near 150 against 2019 levels. Travel in and out of CEMEA indexed in the 130s and mid-120s, respectively, versus 2019, with outbound gaining over 10 points in the quarter and inbound over 15, aided by the FIFA World Cup. Lastly, a bit of color on Mainland China following the removal of COVID zero policies. Mainland China's 40-day Spring Festival season, the biggest travel event worldwide, is now underway. Domestic travel is climbing sharply. When it comes to revenue, the impact here won't be significant. As for travel departing mainland China, momentum will build once additional flight capacity becomes available, fares come down, fresh passports and visas get secured, and certain corridors see restrictions removed. Hong Kong and Southeast Asia — Thailand, Singapore and Malaysia specifically — appear to be the first places mainland Chinese visitors will go. Travel into Mainland China hasn't risen by much and probably won't until the COVID situation stabilizes. Let me shift to a brief look at how we performed financially in the first quarter. Our service revenues rose 10%, compared with the 10% increase in fourth quarter constant dollar payments volume. Growth from business mix, pricing and card benefits made up for the exchange rate drag. Data processing revenues climbed 6%, against the 10% growth in processed transactions. The main explanation is Russia's effect on our data processing revenues. Our transactions growth, though, is unaffected by that. Once you adjust for Russia, data processing revenues gained 10%. International transaction revenues climbed 29%, compared with the 31% rise in constant dollar cross-border volumes, leaving out intra-Europe. High currency volatility, though below what we saw in the fourth quarter, along with pricing actions, gave revenue growth a boost, and exchange rate shifts offset that.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveMarketing and consulting services drove other revenues up 31%, along with pricing measures and acquisitions. Client incentives accounted for 26% of gross revenues, falling short of what we anticipated because of certain adjustments tied to client performance and other matters. Looking at the full year, roughly 20% of our payments volume should be renewed, with a healthy portion already done during the first quarter. All three of our growth engines delivered strong revenue growth. Within consumer payments, the rebound in cross-border volumes, significant currency volatility, and ongoing robust domestic volumes and transactions drove growth. New flows revenue climbed more than 20% in constant dollars. Commercial card volumes rose 15% compared to a year earlier and stand 45% higher than in 2019. Without Russia, Visa Direct transactions increased 39%. Value-added services revenue also rose more than 20% in constant dollars, fueled by greater volume, deeper client penetration, and certain pricing measures. Currencycloud and Tink contributed roughly 0.5 point to revenue growth. GAAP operating expenses rose 25%. Non-GAAP operating expenses rose 15%. That non-GAAP operating expense growth came in above what we expected, largely because of a reduced exchange rate benefit. The main factors behind expense growth were personnel costs stemming from hiring during the second half of last year and into the first quarter, plus G&A expenses caused by smaller exchange rate benefits and greater travel and expenses from new acquisitions. Marketing rose 18%, mostly because of FIFA World Cup spending and client marketing. We posted losses of $106 million from our equity investments. Setting aside investment losses, non-GAAP non-operating expense came to $7 million, helped by increased interest income from rising rates and certain other items. Our tax rate came in below expectations because of the resolution of a tax initiative, landing at 16% GAAP and 16.5% non-GAAP. GAAP EPS reached $1.99, while non-GAAP EPS reached $2.18, a 21% increase from last year, including an approximately 3.5-point drag from the stronger dollar. Business trends stayed strong and stable during the first three weeks of February. Compared with a year earlier, U.S. payments volume rose 14%, with debit up 13% and credit up 14%. Strong January month-to-date growth has been helped by lapping last year's Omicron-related weakness. That Omicron-related uptick will diminish as February progresses. Performance in major markets worldwide is broadly in line with these trends. Processed transactions rose 14% from a year earlier. Constant dollar cross-border volume, excluding transactions within Europe, rose 36% from a year earlier, and was 42% above 2019 and 32% above 2020. Card-not-present non-travel growth stood 75% above 2019 and 52% above 2020. Travel-related cross-border volumes were 25% above 2019 and 20% above 2020. Domestic volumes and transactions have now moved beyond the pandemic recovery stage. Because of that, beginning next quarter, we will stop giving comparisons to 2019 for payments volumes and processed transactions. With the cross-border recovery still underway, we will keep giving comparisons to 2019 for cross-border volumes throughout this calendar year. Turning to what we expect in quarter two. For Q2, our assumption is that the patterns we've seen in domestic payments volume and processed transactions will hold, plus we get some lift from lapping January of last year, when Omicron hit. Just a reminder—pulling out of Russia will affect the growth rates we report for payments volume in Q2. On reported processed transaction growth, Russia has no effect. Cross-border e-commerce has also been steady, particularly once you strip out Russia and the swings tied to crypto. We're going back to assuming cross-border e-commerce growth rates that hold up through Q2, excluding Russia and crypto. In Q1, the rebound in cross-border travel largely matched what we had anticipated. Our assumption is that the trends seen lately will carry into Q2. For the reasons I laid out before, we think the bulk of Mainland China travel recovery arrives in the back half of the year and after. Outbound travel from Mainland China, we believe, will bounce back first. How quickly inbound travel recovers hinges on the COVID situation. Because we booked close to two quarters' worth of service fees in Q2 of fiscal '22, ending operations in Russia will cut Q2 net revenue growth by nearly 5 points. Given where the dollar sits right now and the forward curve, FX will lower reported net revenue growth in Q2 by roughly 2 points. Putting that all together, our planning assumptions take us to mid-teens constant dollar net revenue growth for Q2 on a run rate basis—meaning adjusted for Russia. With Russia costing almost 5 points and exchange rates creating a 2-point headwind, Q2 net revenue growth in reported nominal dollars lands in the high single digits. In Q1, client incentives came in under our 26.5% to 27.5% range of gross revenues. For Q2, client incentives should be higher, at the top end of that range, leaving the first half in the middle of the range. As we said in October, operating expenses growth rates will ease over the course of the year as we slow the rate of increase and lap elevated levels from a year ago. For Q2, non-GAAP operating expense growth in nominal dollars should come in 2 points to 3 points below Q1 expense growth. Our Q3 non-GAAP operating expense growth rate should drop another 2 points to 3 points, then fall a further 2 points to 3 points in Q4. Non-GAAP results leave out certain acquisition-related items and the litigation provision from Q3 of last year. Right now, we expect non-GAAP non-operating expense to land in the $40 million to $50 million range in Q2, mostly because of higher interest income on our cash balances. For the remainder of the year, we anticipate our tax rate landing at the top of that 19% to 19.5% band. Given the 16.5% non-GAAP rate we saw in Q1, our expectation for the full year non-GAAP tax rate now sits in the 18.5% to 19% span. As mentioned during the prior quarter's call, if a recession or geopolitical event were to hit our business and push revenue growth beneath the planning assumptions we hold for the back half, then naturally we'd rework our spending plans — reshuffling investment priorities, trimming or postponing initiatives, and exercising restraint where suitable across personnel costs, marketing outlays, travel, and other areas we can control. In a company such as ours, striking the right balance between near-term and longer-term priorities is always essential; contingency plans exist and we'll put them into action if circumstances demand it. Through this year so far, our business has shown resilience. Cash digitization and client wins fueled robust consumer payments growth in Q1, as our results made clear. Momentum across new flows and value-added services continues to be quite powerful. Economic conditions over the coming months remain highly uncertain; we'll stay watchful and prepared to respond. Looking beyond fiscal year '23, our optimism regarding this business's long-term growth potential has never been greater. One last thing before I wrap up — today is personally a difficult day for me. This marks Al's final week serving as CEO. Among all the CEOs I've reported to over my career — and there have been many — Al stands out as the finest. Al is a marvelous person, a remarkable leader possessing outstanding business judgment.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveThe past six years have certainly been full of activity. Even with a worldwide pandemic lasting three years, our revenues have grown to nearly twice what they were, non-GAAP EPS has risen by more than 2.5x, and the share price has tripled while Al was in charge. Al, I'll miss having you as CEO — as will roughly 26,500 other people here at Visa. With that said, I'll hand things back over to Jennifer.
Jennifer Como
executiveThanks, Vasant; and with that, we're ready to take questions, Jordin.
Sanjay Sakhrani
analystThank you, and my congratulations go out to Al and Ryan too. Vasant, when we consider the forecast in your baseline plan, in what way are you incorporating the economy? To put it another way, is a resilient consumer and a stable economy what we're assuming, or is some mild downturn what you're assuming?
Vasant Prabhu
executiveWell, on the previous call for the full year, we walked through what we refer to as our planning assumptions, and we informed you that no recession had been assumed. Business trends, as you're able to see, have been extraordinarily stable. All over the world, spend levels have indexed in the mid-140s for close to 4 quarters at this point, and no sign of a trend change exists; our second quarter outlook reflects that. Right now, no expectations for the second half are being changed by us. I mean, obviously, the dollar has weakened somewhat, so the exchange rate impact in the second half will shift because of that, but none of our views in the second half are being changed. I mean, these are planning assumptions. And should a slowdown occur, we will respond in line with it.
Darrin Peller
analystIt's encouraging to see that — from the patterns you're observing in Q1 and your Q2 guidance, there appears to be some conservatism baked in given how things have gone so far versus what might materialize in the back half, which is likely what The Street was hoping for; but if we focus on the fundamental trends briefly, I mean, among the areas showing momentum, like debit still rising at high single digits in constant currency within the U.S. despite really challenging comps, paired with other services. Could you maybe walk us through what's fueling both of those figures since they came in somewhat stronger than we anticipated? And I'm not sure whether Visa Direct on the debit side is contributing or whether it's other elements around share, and then could you also weigh in on the other revenue momentum?
Vasant Prabhu
executiveSure. Regarding debit, it's consistent with what we shared previously. Broadly speaking, if you examine the — using 2019 as a reference has kept us honest, if you will; it provides a solid picture of the current situation. And there's — across total spend, there's impressive steadiness. What's taking place is that while goods spending decelerated somewhat, services spending fully absorbed the gap. Consequently, consumers have simply reallocated where their money goes yet they're outlaying the same total, and that explains why debit has remained resilient. Debit has benefited most from the worldwide shift toward digitization, the U.S. included, with more e-commerce, more tap-to-pay, more individuals relying on digital credentials for essentially every payment scenario. So certain folks feared that once conditions normalized, debit could begin experiencing a deceleration; yet as you've observed, debit has continued to be resilient even while credit has bounced back, which has kept our overall payment volumes extremely steady. Those are the main trends and the other question?
Jennifer Como
executiveNow turning to other revenue.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveThe gain there came primarily from marketing services plus consulting work, with a good chunk tied to the FIFA World Cup. We saw substantial client-driven marketing and outlays connected to that tournament. When clients bring us in to launch all sorts of initiatives, that clearly gave the top line a lift.
Will Nance
analystI wanted to dig a little deeper into a few of the points you raised regarding China. From what you're saying, it sounds like that market is being viewed as a pretty significant source of ongoing rebound in cross-border travel. This morning, I believe we heard from a competitor of yours that those volumes, taken together, represent only around 1% to 2% of total pre-COVID cross-border volumes. So I was curious — since this is such a big area of focus for investors when it comes to a driver of sustained strong growth — whether you could give us some boundaries for how to think about how large an impact China will have once it has fully reopened, compared with what we saw in the quarter just reported?
Al Kelly
executiveWell, there are a few things there. To begin with, our figures are quite similar to our competitor's; as Vasant mentioned, we genuinely believe that, initially, we will see outbound travel from China to Southeast Asia. My sense is that it will still take some time before a Chinese traveler returns to Europe at pre-pandemic levels, or comes back to the United States at pre-pandemic levels; and I think that — people will hold off and watch how things unfold with COVID inside China; so Vasant mentioned that we are not factoring in any sort of recovery in inbound travel to China until the latter half of the year. However, my own expectation is that we will likely see a gap of three to five quarters before, beginning in the second half, China returns to a pre-pandemic level, or to 2019. So it is — as far as we're concerned, it's — we have constructed our plan essentially around what Vasant stated in his comments and what I have just described; and should China bounce back more quickly than we're projecting, then clearly, that would be a benefit to us. Should it bounce back more slowly, the effect would be the reverse.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveSure. When we consider the effect, everyone on your side and ours has been monitoring the way cross-border business is bouncing back compared with where it stood before COVID, and whether we've returned to the original trajectory, right? And for several quarters now we've been telling you that a lot of corridors—and I covered much of this—sit comfortably above where they were in 2019. Of the three that weren't and remain below, the U.S. is getting close: U.S. inbound is nearing its 2019 mark and was restrained by the strong dollar, yet Asia continues to lag—and I ran through those figures—fairly far under its 2019 mark. Nearly all of Asia has reopened; China alone has not. So should Asia return to where it was before COVID and to its prior trajectory, that is precisely where China's effect will show up; and after that you'd anticipate, as would we, that the cross-border travel index continues climbing across the year. For that to occur, plainly China has to return. So it matters.
Lisa Ellis
analystI wanted to ask about how Visa Direct has been developing. You pointed out that during the quarter it grew 39% year over year when Russia is excluded. For the past few years, when discussing tap-to-pay and contactless, you've often described an inflection point pattern — once a certain level of critical mass is reached, growth speeds up considerably. Does Visa Direct follow a comparable pattern? And could you help us understand how we ought to be thinking about that developing across the coming 2 years?
Al Kelly
executiveLisa, I believe you're completely correct. Right now our emphasis with Visa Direct is on expanding into additional geographies, additional use cases, and more cross-border activity. Those, I'd say, are what we're concentrating on. At the outset, when Visa Direct launches in a market, it moves through Phase 1, which is typically P2P, before progressing to areas such as gig economy payouts and transactions like remittances or insurance payments, that sort of thing; so in the United States, and each country will undergo this sort of evolution, beginning with P2P, moving into areas such as gig economy payouts, then into more sophistic and remittances, and afterward more sophisticated use cases. And the United States sits much further along that continuum. In other nations, we are — some solid progress in that first phase or 2, but we haven't moved into more sophisticated use cases. And then in still other geographies, honestly, we aren't there yet; so I believe there is an enormous amount of gas remaining in the tank for Visa Direct. When I consider the chances to bring use cases to more sophisticated levels across more markets, to unlock more markets, and to place genuine emphasis on cross-border Visa Direct transactions, which will also give us better yields. So I think the bottom line theory behind your question is — carries some genuine legitimacy, though I'd say it will likely be a bit longer elevation — a somewhat longer stretch of time before maturity is reached, simply because of the differing quantity of use cases, whereas tap-to-pay is really sort of one single type of initiative.
Dave Koning
analystNice work. So here's what I want to ask — international debit stands out as the area where the figures came in somewhat softer than our expectations, sitting at minus 2% on a constant-currency basis. Should we chalk that up to portfolio deconversions, Russia, and a few of those one-time items? And at what point does it swing back to growth?
Al Kelly
executiveDave, if you strip out both China and Russia, I believe the growth rate was above 10%. Beyond that, yes — the migrations in the UK specifically are moving along more quickly than we had anticipated. As Vasant mentioned during his comments, those are essentially complete now, so that too is weighing down the growth number.
Ramsey El-Assal
analystAl, what's your current take on how we're using the balance sheet, our approach to M&A, the kinds of things you'd be hunting for, and whether conditions like these are throwing up more possible targets or transactions? Or has the moment arrived when we perhaps shouldn't chase further acquisitions, given how unstable the macro picture still is?
Al Kelly
executiveOur playbook hasn't shifted at all. Organic growth comes first and foremost, then expansion via M&A, and after that dividends along with share repurchases — that's the sequence. Obviously, some of the valuations have seen a bit of air let out, especially across the fintech space. That's a useful feature of today's landscape. Still, my expectation is that we'll keep seeking out capabilities and management teams capable of adding more value to Visa than our own organic efforts could generate. We're always assessing the possibilities. Our corporate development group is very strong. It's an area where Ryan and Vasant, above all, devote considerable time. And whenever we spot something that would improve us as a business and comes with a reasonable price tag, we don't hesitate to pursue it.
James Faucette
analystAlso, thank you, Al, for the time and energy you've put in over the years. What I'd like to do is ask a broader question of you, and perhaps Ryan as well: one thing investors ask us frequently is how should we view the difficulties that may arise once card penetration eventually reaches some degree of maturity, particularly in the U.S. and developed markets, above all considering the preferences observed elsewhere for building domestic schemes or at minimum giving domestic schemes an advantage. So I'm curious whether you could offer some thoughts on what has happened so far, and perhaps, Ryan, some perspective on how maturation and expansion matters ought to be considered moving ahead.
Al Kelly
executiveI'll go first, and then of course, Ryan, you can chime in. To begin, my belief is a strong one: the opportunity in cards — the traditional card world — is enormous, in consumer as well as B2B. Hundreds and hundreds of millions of individuals have yet to be brought into the financial mainstream. Trillions of dollars continue to be spent using cash and check. And within B2B, we estimate a total addressable market of roughly $120 billion spanning carded opportunities, cross-border, payables and receivables — and I discussed quite a few examples of work we did during the most recent quarter. RTP systems are aiding the digitization of money movement. That's beneficial. Consider the disruption brought about by monetization in India — the outcome was extremely favorable in terms of the growth it produced in card credentials and acceptance, and incidentally, I should also have mentioned that within the traditional world, there remains a huge chance to expand our acceptance footprint beyond where it stands now. These RTP systems are likewise assisting us, and we're embracing them. They assist us in broadening Visa Direct's reach as we use them within our network-of-network strategies. Through Tink, they assist us with open banking, enabling us to provide greater access to additional developers at one end and additional financial institutions at the other. In my view, RTPs give us a chance to market value-added services; and I continue to believe the benefits of — and the capabilities tied to the carded space remain much better than account, including consumer protections, and so forth. And when you consider PICs in Brazil, or UPI in India, these emerged and were introduced into the market, and we're observing a considerable amount of — hearing frequently from clients about fraud connected to these networks. And in numerous respects, that is logical. They haven't put in the many years or the enormous sums, hundreds of millions of dollars, that Visa has devoted to creating security, fraud-fighting tools, and risk management abilities that keep the ecosystem safe and trusted by consumers. And I believe that as time goes on, within the A2A space, we have a chance to deliver some of those capabilities and generate solid revenue and yield from doing so. So, Ryan, what else would you like to add?
Ryan McInerney
executiveNothing much for me to tack on there, Al. That's excellent. I mean, James, to put it briefly, we continue to see enormous runway. Our products are something we love. Our people are something we love. Our brand is something we love. Our position is something we love, along with all these markets, whether mature or emerging across the globe; so enormous runway.
Dan Perlin
analystAl, I wanted to pose something regarding the new business you've secured, say across the last 12, possibly 18 months, and how that positions Visa as we consider what's ahead — I'd frame it as the coming two years, not much further out. What I'm really getting at is whether it's leaning more toward capitalizing on debit patterns, credit patterns, global hospitality? I ask partly because MasterCard highlighted this morning its stance in travel, and it sounds like you were likewise suggesting some positioning for your business. So I'd be curious to hear what that pipeline of new business you've brought aboard indicates across the next two years for your company.
Al Kelly
executiveWell, a few points, Dan. First, regarding travel, that's been an area of emphasis for us for quite a while. I believe we have roughly 650 co-brands globally. A large number of those are travel co-brands, and I think we're the top co-brand player worldwide. When I survey the globe, there are definitely chances with traditional issuers. We've gained considerable ground in markets such as Brazil and Chile, the Netherlands, Germany, Japan during the past year; we've secured some excellent renewals in the United States across the last couple of years from JPMorgan Chase to Wells to those I mentioned today regarding Bank of America, Cap One, Commerce Bank. Yet we've also achieved significant progress with fintechs and neobanks. We've built a strong record of wins over the last 24 to 36 months. And many of these players are reaching scale within their respective markets. And for us, I think we need a broader perspective on who can deliver services. We're striving to — ensure we place Visa cards into as many wallets as possible worldwide. And then I'll return to acceptance. One excellent method to keep expanding our business is to enlarge our acceptance footprint, which still needs substantial growth globally. One area we've focused on for that over the last 1.5 years is Latin America. And if you examine the share of spending in Latin America that shifted from — moved from cash to PV across the last couple of years. Back in full year 2020, just 46% of Latin America's volume was PV, while 54% was cash. This past quarter, we just concluded with 59% of their PV — 69% of their volume was purchase volume, so that's a 13-point swing in the Latin America region over the last not even quite three years. This results from succeeding alongside established financial institutions as well as with fintech companies, plus taking a tailored strategy for each individual market, which has delivered a great deal of — genuinely strong advancement in nations across Latin America, for instance Brazil and Chile.
Harshita Rawat
analystAl, I want to wish you all the best, and it won't be the same without your voice on these calls. Ryan, congrats to you. Could you share how the strategy for growing the business within the organization has changed while you've been leading it? Are you now leaning more or less toward particular areas, or approaching certain things in a different way? And Vasant, if I could just quickly ask, would you speak to the slowdown from your fourth fiscal quarter into 1Q? You mentioned a few of the factors, but how does that compare with what you had originally anticipated?
Al Kelly
executiveHarshita, I believe the latter portion of what you asked didn't come through for us, so perhaps we can set that aside, and then Ryan can weigh in — did you?
Vasant Prabhu
executiveI believe your question was regarding — you mentioned decel, so I'm taking it you were referring to deceleration occurring from the first to the second?
Harshita Rawat
analystYes.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveYeah. So, a few points, really. In Q2, the effect from Russia is somewhat bigger, since during last year's comparable period we essentially had service fees covering close to 2 quarters. Keep in mind, service fees get recognized with a delay, meaning what we booked in Q1 reflected Q4's growth rates. Consequently, since Q1 came in somewhat softer on a sequential basis, Q2's service fees will feel that. On top of that, currency swings are calming down right now. They've been settling for several weeks. And as you noticed, incentives are growing somewhat faster. Taking all of that together, things came in slightly above our forecast. As you're aware, our expectation was high single digits for Q1. We landed above that for the reasons just described, and Q2 should also be high single digits. That's where our expectation stands at present.
Al Kelly
executiveRyan?
Ryan McInerney
executiveYeah, regarding the first part of what you asked, I've now served as President for almost 10 years, so I've stood side by side with Al and Vasant and everyone else on our team while we reached every one of our major decisions, while we built our strategy, and while we carried that strategy out. So it likely won't—or shouldn't—catch you off guard that I'll keep concentrating on the 3 growth pillars we've set out: consumer payments, new inflows, and value-added services. My priorities will center on doing whatever we can to speed up our progress and speed up our momentum. That means how we go to market, how we engage with clients, how we get product out the door faster, how we sell solutions to our clients more effectively. And on part of what you asked—how we organize—earlier this month I announced a fresh organizational structure that genuinely mirrors the strategy we discuss with all of you constantly. We think it will help us speed up our progress across all 3 of those growth factors. To give you a quick picture of it, Oliver Jenkyn, a longtime Visa veteran lots of you know, will head a new global markets organization that includes driving consumer payments growth in every one of our markets worldwide. So our 5 regional presidents will report to Oliver. Chris Newkirk, who previously led our strategy organization, will head our new flows business unit and report straight to me. Antony Cahill, our former Deputy CEO of Europe, will head our value-added services business unit and report straight to me. So our global markets team, our value-added services business unit, and our new flows business unit will all report straight to me. Then, just to fill that in a bit more, Jack Forestell, who many of you also know, will take on the role of Chief Product and Strategy Officer and will work closely with our President of Technology, Rajat Taneja. The two of them are concentrating on delivering a strong product and innovation road map, shipping world-class products and services that help our clients grow their businesses and strengthen their relationships with their customers. So that gives you a sense of where things stand with strategy and the organization.
Ken Suchoski
analystAppreciate you fielding this, and congratulations to Al and Ryan. I believe you said earlier that the guidance for the second half is staying as is. Could you remind everyone what that guidance looked like, whether we're talking volume or net revenue? I ask because I think all we have is the earlier full year guidance, and I'm aware that FX is turning into less of a headwind as we move into the second half.
Vasant Prabhu
executiveYes. During our conversation last quarter, we indicated that for the full year, revenue growth on a constant dollar basis adjusted for Russia would land somewhere in the mid-teens. Then, once you adjust for Russia and factor in, at that time, a full year impact of roughly 2 points from FX, nominal dollars would come in at high single digits. So you have a sense of where we sit in Q1 and Q2. Exchange rates have shifted a bit, so you can work through some of the math yourself. At this point we aren't revising any of our second half views, since trends remain pretty stable. The one item you might want to revisit is what FX impact the second half could see, given where rates stand now. I also provided you with reasonably clear operating expense expectations. In the first quarter we grew about 15%. We told you growth in nominal dollar terms would come in 2 points to 3 points lower in the second quarter, then drop another 2 points to 3 points in the third quarter, and fall a further 2 points to 3 points in the fourth quarter. That matches what we stated last quarter: expense growth will ease as the year goes on, both because we slow the pace of increases and because we lap the higher expense levels from the prior year. So that's essentially the broad picture of what we shared last quarter. We'll bring you up to date again on our next call regarding any adjustments based on trends.
Tien-Tsin Huang
analystMany thanks, and congratulations to Al and Ryan. I'm thrilled for the two of you. Regarding renewals and new agreements, I'll pose a question on that if that's alright. Any notable points about pricing terms in contracts, things along those lines? I'm aware you mentioned several major companies when it comes to renewals. MasterCard discussed the Citizens victory there. I'm just wondering what's going on across the entire balance of trade space?
Al Kelly
executiveTien-tsin, as you're well aware, this is a highly competitive environment. My view is there's a rate you've got to reach, and beyond that much depends on whether you're the incumbent or not, the skills you possess, who your customers' clients are in that particular market, the type of background you've had, the creative concepts you offer, plus the additional sorts of competencies we bring in areas like services and new flows. So no two deals are alike, and they may turn on varying factors based on what a given client requires. And when we examine deals and speak with clients, we aim to be extremely tailored, since their requirements and circumstances will always lean toward being somewhat distinct.
Jennifer Como
executiveThat brings us to the end of today's call, and we appreciate everyone for being here. Should any further questions come up, don't hesitate to get in touch with the Investor Relations team. Thanks once more, and enjoy the rest of your day.
Operator
operatorThank you for your participation in today's conference. You may disconnect at this time.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Visa Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Visa Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Visa Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.