Visa Inc. (V) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

October 24, 2023

New York Stock Exchange US Financials Financial Services earnings 61 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Jennifer Como

executive
#1

Thanks, Jordan. Hello, everyone, and welcome to the call covering Visa's results for the fourth fiscal quarter and the entire 2023 fiscal year. Joining us are Ryan McInerney, who serves as Visa's Chief Executive Officer, and Chris Suh, our Chief Financial Officer. You can access a webcast of today's call through the Investor Relations portion of our site, investor.visa.com. We'll keep a replay available there for 30 days. On our IR website, you'll also find a slide deck with the financial and statistical highlights. One more reminder: forward-looking statements are part of this presentation. Such statements shouldn't be viewed as promises about what will happen in the future, since numerous factors could cause our results to come in materially different from what's expected. You can locate more details about those factors in our latest Form 10-K annual report, along with later filings on Forms 10-Q and 8-K, all of which are posted on the SEC's site as well as the Investor Relations area of our own site. Regarding any non-GAAP financial figures shared during this call, you'll find the corresponding GAAP metrics and the reconciliation in the earnings release issued today. On that note, I'll hand things over to Ryan.

Ryan McInerney

executive
#2

Good afternoon, and thanks for being with us. I want to pause first and recognize the heartbreaking loss of life and the suffering taking place in Israel and Gaza; we remain in regular communication with our colleagues in Israel and across the region, and my admiration for how they support one another and their clients through this extraordinarily difficult period could not be deeper. We keep watching the situation closely, put the safety of our team first, and remain engaged with clients so business operations can continue without interruption. Now, on to the results. Entering 2023, the macroeconomic picture carried substantial uncertainty, with recession concerns looming. Questions abounded regarding FX, volatility, interest rates, and inflation. Our growth rates in early 2023 also reflected some distortion from Omicron's impact and from halting operations in Russia. Even with all of that, Visa performed. For the entire fiscal year, net revenues rose 11%, GAAP EPS climbed 18%, and non-GAAP EPS increased 17%. Credentials were up 7%. We also crossed 7.5 billion tokens. Total transactions, counting cash and payment transactions, came to 276 billion, meaning Visa credentials were used an average of 757 million times each day of the fiscal year. We entered into over 500 commercial partnerships worldwide with fintechs, ranging from early-stage firms to growing and mature ones, a 25% increase over last year. Merchant locations rose 17%, aided by robust growth in Latin America and MEA. Global Tap to Pay penetration, leaving out the U.S., rose five points from a year earlier, reaching 76% of all face-to-face transactions. Within the U.S., penetration climbed 13 points, moving past 40%. Global Tap to Ride transactions totaled 1.6 billion for full year 2023, an increase above 30%, and roughly 150 new transit systems joined us over the year, including ones in Philadelphia and Bangkok, expanding the footprint beyond 750 systems. Over 40% of the transit system launches we completed this year also featured our value-added services acceptance solutions. On the new flow side, total revenue for the full year increased 17% in constant dollars. Let me mention a few highlights. Total commercial volume reached $1.57 trillion, rising 12% in constant dollars. The count of banks signed up for Visa B2B Connect has grown by over 70% this year, and activation keeps progressing, with transacting banks more than doubling. Visa Direct recorded 7.5 billion transactions, an increase of 19% year-over-year, and close to 30% when Russia is excluded, spanning 65+ use cases and over 2,800 programs, supported by more than 500 enablers. Cross-border P2P transactions rose 65% year-over-year and hit a fresh record for payments volume in the fourth quarter. Value-added services revenue for the full year grew 18% in constant dollars. Among our hundreds of products, our 265 biggest clients averaged 22 products, an 8% gain from last year, while our clients overall averaged 11 products. Given all that robust momentum and performance, we closed out Q4 with net revenue up 11% and GAAP EPS up 22%. Additional fourth-quarter highlights, stated in constant dollars, are as follows: global payments volume rose 9%, U.S. payments volume rose 6%, international payments volume rose 11%, cross-border volume excluding intra-Europe rose 18%, cross-border travel climbed 26% year-over-year, and processed transactions increased 10%. Throughout every one of our growth levers, we kept making headway in innovation and money movement. As I noted last quarter, whenever they're asked, "Why Visa?", our clients say they're selecting us to deepen and broaden their partnerships for several reasons, among them our people, our products, our value-added services, our new flows capabilities, and our brand; we saw that continue to unfold during Q4. Let me go through each and point out a few examples. To start, our people. We have the finest team in the industry, and our clients say they place great value on the guidance, local backing, and collaboration from our exceptional teams, who are singularly focused on assisting our clients in growing their businesses. Our clients likewise value our considered leadership on significant and intricate industry matters throughout the ecosystem. One example this quarter involved U.S. Bank, among the biggest issuers in the United States. They renewed our long-term agreement covering their consumer and commercial portfolios. Beyond that, we're working together on consulting services and co-marketing projects, which include making use of our NFL sponsorship. Also in the U.S., we're delighted to have renewed our longstanding relationship with top 20 U.S. issuer FNBO across consumer, commercial, and value-added services. In Brazil, credit unions, or cooperatives, are expanding quickly, and we lately achieved a broader relationship with Sicoob, whose system covers almost 340 cooperatives and 7.5 million members; alongside our people, our payment products and innovations reliably help us win. We continuously pursue innovation and provide next-generation payment solutions and experiences that let our clients serve their customers better and expand their businesses. Regarding our ability to serve fintechs, in Colombia, we broadened our partnership with Nequi, that country's first digital wallet, to enable its more than 17 million account holders for tap-to-pay with digital credentials; we additionally offer tailored offerings for specific customers. In India, we're concentrated on delivering market-leading offerings for affluent customers. With that in mind, we've signed with fintech epiFi for a consumer credit offering aimed at high-net-worth and mass affluent customers. We also recently broadened our acceptance with fintech Razorpay to let Visa debit cards buy mutual funds and securities, giving customers greater convenience with higher payment success rates compared with traditional methods. In the e-commerce seller space, we renewed our agreement with Shopify for the Balance Card, allowing Shopify's U.S. Merchants can get their money from sales as soon as the following business day, plus earn cashback on routine company costs such as shipping and marketing; additionally, we entered into a fresh issuing deal for small business credit. Moving on, our value-added offerings are assisting us in securing wins; they enable our customers to innovate and expand, deliver risk management tools, and generate improved results for them and consequently for Visa. Our acceptance offerings, such as Cybersource, truly struck a chord with customers this year; we moved over 2,600 new acceptance services across more than 100 nations. Within North America, Costco picked Visa acceptance offerings, such as Cybersource, for every one of their U.S. and Canadian e-commerce deals. Alaska Airlines chose Cybersource for handling their kiosk payments to back their effort to overhaul the airport lobby experience; over in Asia Pacific, China Merchants Bank, mainland China's biggest issuer, renewed its consumer and small business portfolios. Beyond our leading risk management offerings, Visa Advanced Authorization and Visa Risk Manager, they will likewise broaden their usage of consulting services. Bank of China and AEON Financial Service in Japan have similarly agreed to adopt VAA and VRM. Throughout Latin America, we have concentrated on boosting our processing reach since it lets us provide additional value-added services to our clients.

Ryan McInerney

executive
#3

In Colombia, our processing penetration has just grown thanks to adding 4 additional banks through our strategic partnership with Credibanco, which is the biggest acquirer and issuer processor in that market. This puts us in a position where close to 80% of domestic transactions should be within reach by the close of FY 2024, compared with basically 0 back in 2019. Under these agreements, banks have incorporated between 4 and 11 value-added services, spanning risk and acceptance offerings. As part of our network of network approach, we keep working alongside and providing our solutions within real-time payments, most recently involving FedNow. During Q4, Visa achieved certified service provider status for FedNow. Through our offering, Visa financial institution clients are able to get funds in real time via the FedNow Service, with origination capabilities coming afterward. What this means is that FedNow payments are now being processed by Visa, and The Clearing House RTP will follow within the next few months. Turning now to our new flows capabilities, which are becoming an increasingly significant point of differentiation for our clients. Over on the B2B side, we're delighted to have secured an expanded long-term global agreement covering more than 60 countries with Citibank for their commercial card business, which additionally includes over 20 value-added services. We likewise recently captured the IBM commercial card business, covering T&E, meeting and purchasing card programs across over 60 countries, again with Citibank serving as the issuer. In Singapore, we extended our long-standing partnership with DBS, Southeast Asia's largest bank, so we can keep providing commercial debit and credit services to consumers, while broadening into new commercial products for small businesses. When it comes to Visa Direct, we keep growing its reach, particularly toward wallet endpoints. Most recently, we reached an agreement with Tencent covering the Visa Direct cross-border remittance business; this pushes total wallet reach for Visa Direct beyond 2.5 billion; we've broadened our partnership with Paysend from US and UK payments so that all of Paysend's customers worldwide can send money in real time to eligible Visa cards throughout 170 countries and territories. Paysend is likewise a Currencycloud customer, delivering compelling cross-border solutions. We also just renewed with Korea's largest issuer, Shinhan Card, for consumer and business credit, which additionally brings in the provision of our data capabilities in value-added services plus the enablement of Visa Direct for cross-border remittances. We've kept adding new Visa Direct use cases alongside our partners too, including small ticket B2B payments and bill pay. Over in Brazil, Banco RCI will enable Visa Direct for low-value, high-velocity cross-border payments as part of their corporate banking business. In the US, payment platform Everyware will be enabling bill payments with Visa Direct. And finally, though by no means least important, our brand. The power of Visa's brand enables us to bring extra value to our clients and their customers—financial institutions, merchants, and partners—through a broad array of products and services, along with creative branding and marketing initiatives. We're happy to announce an agreement with Universal Destinations and Experiences making us the exclusive payment network for their new co-branded credit card, which FNBO will issue. Beyond that, Visa is now the official payment method at Universal Destinations and Experiences, and jointly we'll deliver attractive perks to Visa cardholders at their Orlando and Hollywood locations. Also within the U.S., we recently renewed the Fidelity Investments co-brand credit portfolio that US Bank issues. We signed with Coupang, a major retailer boasting 20 million customers in Korea, for its first co-brand card. In MEA, we've signed a Saudi Airlines co-brand with Riyad Bank, and we renewed our co-brand partnership with Etihad Guest, the loyalty program belonging to Etihad Airways. Looking forward, we're eager to activate our brand alongside clients and partners at the Paris 2024 and Milano Cortina 2026 Olympic and Paralympic Summer and Winter Games. Visa has proudly sponsored the Olympic Movement since 1986, which offers an unmatched chance to elevate the Visa brand regionally and globally, while also enabling partnerships and joint business initiatives with clients. The Games offer a distinctive platform to display product innovation and connect consumers and clients through exclusive experiences. We're anticipating the coming games, and we've been building business momentum throughout Europe with a specific emphasis on the continent. Let me share a few recent highlights from our European business. On the people side, payments is a local business, and we've expanded to seven new locations in the last five years while more than doubling our workforce in the market. On innovative products, we hold well over 100 fintech relationships and have broadened our capabilities via the acquisitions of Tink and Currencycloud. In new flows, Visa Direct has more than 100 enablers and over 1,000 programs, with transactions more than doubling across the past two years. In value-added services, we've grown our client penetration. In VAA alone, the number of clients enrolled in the service has more than doubled compared with three years ago, and we'll be launching nearly 20 additional products in 2024. We've been steadily establishing an appealing position on the continent and have built a robust pipeline of signed deals for the future by competing uniquely in each market. Active cards throughout continental Europe have risen nearly 50% since 2019. Over the coming few years, we expect to migrate more than 40 million cards across nearly 40 clients. And the kinds of portfolios we're winning in continental Europe tend to carry more cross-border volume, producing higher yields. So our brand, our capabilities, our people—all of these make a difference for Visa's clients. The past year brought a lot of important achievements along with strong results on the financial side. We're now 3 weeks into the new fiscal year, so I'd like to share a handful of broad comments before Chris walks everyone through the finer points. First, macro uncertainty hasn't gone away, yet as was true in fiscal year 2023, my confidence is high that we'll navigate it successfully. Our approach and priorities haven't changed, driving expansion in consumer payments, new flows, and value-added services. Second, we're committed to producing results for our stockholders; on that note, you've likely noticed the 8-K we filed back in September concerning our possible exchange offer program. We're grateful for the conversations we've had with Class A, B, and C stockholders, and while we keep engaging with investors, the board is weighing what to do next. Last, you might have seen that we unveiled a $25 billion multi-year share repurchase program today, a signal of our board's belief in our strategy and what we can achieve going forward. I still see enormous opportunity in front of us. Visa possesses the brand, the capabilities, the strategy, and above all the people, to drive our growth for years ahead. With that said, I'll pass things to Chris.

Chris Suh

executive
#4

Thanks, Ryan. Good afternoon, everybody. As Ryan mentioned, the fourth quarter was yet another solid one, wrapping up a robust fiscal 2023, powered by healthy expansion in payments volume, cross-border volume, and processed transactions, plus ongoing strong execution of our strategy, with new flows and value-added services revenue increasing more rapidly than consumer payments. I'll begin with a top-level overview of how we did in Q4, then move into further specifics. Turning to our drivers, on a constant-dollar basis, global payments volume rose 9% from a year earlier, while processed transactions climbed 10% compared with the prior year, both holding steady relative to Q3. Cross-border volume, when intra-Europe is excluded, was robust, rising 18% from a year ago in constant dollars. Net revenues for the fiscal fourth quarter increased 11%, or 10% in constant dollars, with FX having only a negligible effect, matching what we had anticipated. GAAP EPS rose 22%, while non-GAAP EPS increased 21%, on both a nominal and a constant-dollar basis; now, moving into the specifics, beginning with the U.S. Payments volume rose 6% versus a year earlier, unchanged from Q3. Credit volume increased 6% from the prior year, and debit volume was up 7%. Card-present spend rose 3%, while U.S. card-not-present volume, excluding travel, increased 9%. U.S. processed transactions growth held steady at 8%. Throughout the quarter, we observed payments volume growth accelerating from July into September, largely fueled by sequential gains in ticket size growth that came mostly from fuel, thanks to higher gas prices and simpler year-over-year comparisons, along with a favorable days mix effect. Consumer spend across every segment, from high to low spend, has stayed stable since March. Our data showed no behavior shifts among consumer segments. When it comes to international markets, total payments volume growth reached 11% in constant dollars. Payments volume growth rates were robust throughout the quarter across most major regions, with Latin America, MEA, and Europe, ex-UK, each expanding roughly 20% or more in constant dollars. Now on to cross-border, which I'll discuss in constant dollars, excluding intra-Europe transactions. Total cross-border volume rose 18%, and was up 152% compared with 2019. Cross-border card not present volume growth, excluding travel, increased 9% from a year earlier and 173% versus 2019. Once adjusted for cryptocurrency purchases, cross-border e-commerce spending rose year over year in the low double digits, matching pre-COVID growth rates and aligning with the trends we've observed through most of the fiscal year. Cross-border travel-related spend increased 26% from a year earlier. The cross-border travel volume index against 2019 climbed from 139% in June to 143% in September, averaging 141% for the quarter, a five point gain over Q3. We kept seeing healthy travel volume levels in and out of LAC, Europe, and MEA, ranging from 145%-165% of 2019 levels. Travel volume into Asia kept improving, indexing at 128% of 2019 levels for the quarter, up 10 points from Q3, while travel volume out of Asia rose seven points to 114%. Looking specifically at mainland China, cross-border travel volume kept improving but stayed beneath 2019 levels. Travel volume outbound from the U.S. Every region kept performing well, sitting in the mid-150s on a 2019 index. Recovery in U.S. inbound travel picked up speed during the quarter, lifting that index past 2019 levels for the first time, even though the dollar stayed strong compared with pre-COVID levels; now let's go through our financial results for the fourth quarter. Service revenues rose 12% year-over-year against 9% growth in Q3 constant dollar payments volume, mostly because of business mix, pricing, and card benefits. Data processing revenues climbed 13% against 10% processed transaction growth, driven by value-added services and pricing. International transaction revenues increased 10% against an 18% rise in constant dollar cross-border volumes, excluding Intra-Europe. The reason revenue growth trailed volume growth was mainly declining currency volatility. Other revenues rose 35%, led by pricing, consulting, and marketing services, while client incentives rose 20%. Now allow me to go into revenue growth across our three growth engines. Consumer payments growth came from stability in domestic volume growth and processed transactions, plus strong growth in cross-border volumes. New flows revenue rose 14% in constant dollars. Commercial volumes increased 9% in constant dollars and 156% versus 2019. Keep in mind that revenue gets recorded based on payment volumes growth from the prior quarter, which came in at 9% in constant dollars in Q3. Visa Direct transactions rose 19%, and as we noted last quarter, they were affected by a client that shifted its domestic P2P transactions onto an internal ledger system, which had no meaningful impact on revenue. Value-added services rose 19% in constant dollars, mainly on strong advisory services, select pricing actions, and higher volume. GAAP operating expenses rose 13%. Non-GAAP operating expenses increased 9%, mostly because of personnel expenses from headcount growth, and FX created a drag of nearly 2 points. Excluding net gains of $7 million from our equity investments, non-GAAP, non-operating income came to $79 million, helped by higher interest income from rising rates. Our GAAP tax rate was 16.9%, and non-GAAP was 17%, reflecting a tax benefit tied to the extension of the U.S. foreign tax credit regulations, which produced an indirect tax expense on the operating expense line and a much bigger tax benefit in the income tax provision. GAAP EPS came in at $2.27. Non-GAAP EPS was $2.33, a 21% increase over last year, including a drag of a little more than half a point from exchange rates. During Q4, we repurchased roughly $4.1 billion in stock and paid out $928 million in dividends to our stockholders. We also put $150 million into the litigation escrow account, which works the same way as a stock buyback. As of the end of September, $4.7 billion was left in our buyback authorization. For the full fiscal year 2023, net revenues rose 11%. GAAP EPS of $8.28 was up 18%, and non-GAAP EPS of $8.77 was up 17%, including a drag of over two points from exchange rates. Now let's turn to fiscal year 2024. Before we give our perspectives on the year, I'd like to make a few brief comments. For fiscal 2024, it should feel in numerous respects like the most typical year we've experienced in some time. The effects from Russia and Omicron are now entirely behind us, and across a lot of our markets, inflation on the whole keeps easing. Because of that, we're happy to bring back the guidance approach we used before COVID and to share our FY 2024 outlook, which we'll refresh every quarter. Meanwhile, we'll stop issuing those intraquarter 8-Ks tied to interim driver updates. Let's move on to what we observed during October's first three weeks. U.S. payment volume rose 5%, as both debit and credit each gained 5%. The drop versus September on a sequential basis came mostly from September's days mix effect plus falling fuel prices during October. Once you set those 2 factors aside, payments volume growth held fairly steady going from September into October. So far, Reg II hasn't had any meaningful effect on volume. Processed transactions climbed 10% compared with a year earlier. Cross-border volume in constant dollars, leaving out transactions inside Europe, increased 19%, while travel-related cross-border volumes stood at 144% when indexed to 2019. Now for our main assumptions. As we've repeatedly stated, forecasting the economy isn't our role, so on a macro level, our outlook assumes no recession.

Chris Suh

executive
#5

We aren't factoring in anything from Reg II or student loan repayments either, because, like I mentioned before, we haven't seen anything significant on that front so far. As the year goes on and we get a better handle on these assumptions, we'll continue to provide updates. When it comes to the key drivers, we're assuming the trends from Q4 mostly persist throughout the year. Generally speaking, we anticipate that payments volume growth and processed transaction growth will come in at low double digits versus the prior year. On cross-border, Card Not Present, ex-travel, and ex-crypto, volume growth ought to remain in the low double digits year-over-year on a constant dollar basis. When it comes to cross-border travel volume, excluding intra-Europe, year-over-year growth will moderate to the low twenties in constant dollars, and when you measure that against 2019, it amounts to a four to five point improvement each quarter. This outlook is driven primarily by strengthening AP cross-border travel volume, mostly from China, and to a lesser extent by strengthening US inbound travel volume. As for what that means for the financials, I'll walk through the numbers on an adjusted basis, which we define as non-GAAP results presented in constant dollars and excluding acquisition impacts — more detail is available in the footnotes of our earnings release and earnings presentation. Alright, let's begin with net revenues; for the full year, we expect low double-digit adjusted net revenue growth. Based on current currency forward curves, FX will be about a one point headwind for the year. We're assuming currency volatility moderates somewhat from Q4 levels but remains relatively stable throughout the year; versus a year earlier, incentives should increase somewhat less than in FY 2023. For new flows and value-added services, we continue to expect growth that outpaces consumer payments in FY 2024. Now, moving to expenses. Our current plans involve growing adjusted operating expense in the high single digit to low double digits, with about 1.5 points of FX benefit to nominal non-GAAP growth. Nonoperating income is expected to be between $250 million and $300 million. The tax rate should be somewhat better than our typical 19%-19.5% due to some offsetting factors. On one hand, tax rate increases in certain countries push our new run rate closer to 19.5%-20%; on the other hand, we anticipate some one-time tax benefits in the second half related to resolving certain tax matters. Taken together, that puts us between 18.5% and 19% for the full fiscal year. Putting it all together, we expect full year adjusted EPS growth in the low teens, with roughly half a point of FX drag to nominal non-GAAP growth. Additionally, FY 2024 will likely be a tale of two halves, with our growth rate differing from the first half to the second half. A few things to keep in mind. To begin, cross-border volume excluding intra-Europe climbed 31% year over year during the first half of FY 2023, then rose 20% in the second half. Also, keep in mind that foreign exchange swings were quite pronounced during the opening six months of FY 2023, then calmed down a lot in the closing six months. And third, incentives ended up 16% larger across the latter half of FY 2023 versus the earlier half, mostly driven by the timing of deals plus how clients performed. As a result, we expect overall adjusted net revenue growth to be lower in the opening half than in the closing half of FY 2024. The same is true when looking at nominal figures, despite the fact that an FX drag in the latter half of FY 2024 ought to be a bit larger than in the opening half. Moving over to costs, as Ryan pointed out, this year features the Olympics, and we expect Q2 and Q3 expenses to show the largest percentage increases as we scale up. That said, adjusted operating expense growth along with the FX impact ought to be roughly the same in both halves. The tax rate ought to be smaller in the latter half than the former, thanks to the anticipated one-time tax benefits I mentioned; so for the first quarter in particular, given the factors I just described, Q1 should record the weakest adjusted year-over-year net revenues growth rate, with gains strengthening as the year goes on, while Q4 should record the strongest adjusted growth rate; we expect first quarter net revenues growth in the upper mid to high single digits on an adjusted basis. A number of things to keep in mind. Again, first, currency volatility reached its peak in Q1 of 2023. Second, cross-border volume climbed 31% in Q1 of 2023. And third, Q1 2023 other revenue was strong because of FIFA World Cup-related value-added services revenue, while incentives landed under expectations owing to client performance and other items. Adjusted operating expense growth ought to come in at high single digits, driven by growth in headcount and raises in salary. We expect about 0.5 point of FX drag on nominal net revenues growth and about 1.5 point of lift to nominal non-GAAP expense growth. The tax rate ought to be closer to our new run rate of between 19.5% and 20% in Q1. Nonoperating income is projected to land somewhere between $250 million and $300 million. That leaves first quarter adjusted EPS growth in the upper mid-single digits with negligible FX impact. Keep in mind that adjusted basis refers to non-GAAP results presented in constant dollars and omitting acquisition impacts. Non-GAAP expenses and EPS leave out acquisition-related items along with the litigation provision for the first quarter of 2023. For FY 2024, the estimated results exclude about $20 million, or $0.01, of acquisition-related costs and about $40 million, or $0.02, from the amortization of acquired intangibles. Finally, on capital return. As Ryan mentioned, the board has approved a $25 billion multi-year share repurchase program and lifted our quarterly dividend by 16%. To sum up, Visa's underlying business stays healthy and stable, and the growth opportunities are considerable. Even though macro uncertainties continue, our confidence stays firm that we can guide this business through changing conditions and generate value for our stockholders. So, Jennifer, at this point let's hand things over to Q&A.

Jennifer Como

executive
#6

Thanks, Chris. With that, we're ready to take questions.

Darrin Peller

analyst
#7

Hey, everyone. Appreciate you making room for me, and nice work on this quarter. Turning to what you've laid out for the coming fiscal year, the double-digit constant currency expansion is encouraging to see. I just want to confirm we've got the moving pieces right and hear how you're viewing structural growth across items such as value-added services and new flows. First, could you share a bit more detail on the assumptions behind the potential growth for those areas — the VAS and new flows? And second, and this matters more, do you see that as the correct algorithm over the medium term? Can this company's structural growth keep holding at that same 10%-12% pace it has maintained, or is something different now? Thanks, everyone.

Chris Suh

executive
#8

All right. Hi, Darren. Sure, I'll take that one. This is Chris. So yes, a few points regarding the FY 2024 guide. To begin, the underlying drivers, as we discussed, are payments volume along with processed transactions, and both should expand at a low double-digit clip, which is highly consistent and speaks to the stable business trends visible in those underlying drivers. I also mentioned during the call commentary that VAS — value-added services — and new flows ought to remain our growth engines, expanding more quickly than the consumer payments portion of the business. And so I'd say that structure you outlined aligns in many respects with 2023, and that is definitely what we expect to witness in 2024.

Jennifer Como

executive
#9

Jordan, you're up next.

Dave Koning

analyst
#10

Thanks a lot. Nice work, everyone. I've got two quick items, I think. Constant currency volume growth in Asia Pacific came in at 4%, which is somewhat below the usual level. Could you dig into the reasons behind that? And then on the tax rate over the longer haul — essentially in the out years — is 19.5%-20% the right way for us to model it? Thanks.

Ryan McInerney

executive
#11

Dave, I'll cover Asia, and I might frame it within the broader global picture, and after that, Chris, you can handle the tax rate. To address your question directly on Asia: like you mentioned, growth excluding China decelerated by four points versus Q3. A few factors are at play. First, we're up against a strong COVID ramp from Q4 of 2022, but beyond that, we're noticing some softening in a few markets — Australia stands out as the one I'd highlight. If you step back and consider the larger picture, what are we observing worldwide? Outside Asia, as it seems you've reviewed the figures and would have noticed, we're seeing resilience. Outside North America and Asia — take Europe excluding the UK, Latin America, MEA — most of those regions are expanding at roughly 20% or higher, so we're pleased with what's going on there. On the tax rate, Chris, I'll hand it to you, the long-term tax rate.

Chris Suh

executive
#12

Okay, absolutely. Hello there, Dave. Yes, I believe that's the correct perspective, at least from what we currently understand. The updated run rate, I would estimate at roughly 19.5% to 20%. This ties into our tax situation, the composition of our tax jurisdictions globally, and specific tax hikes in certain regions. As we mentioned, in the upcoming fiscal year, we'll be under that because of some advantages we expect in the latter half of the year. However, from what we know at this point, the updated run rate matches your estimate.

Jennifer Como

executive
#13

Jordan, let's take the next question.

David Togut

analyst
#14

Thanks. It's encouraging to see Visa Direct transactions up 19%, especially with cross-border P2P transactions climbing 65% compared to a year ago. Looking ahead to FY 2024, which new use cases for Visa Direct strike you as the largest and most promising ones you're developing?

Ryan McInerney

executive
#15

Hey, David. Cross-border remittances stands out as a major one. Since you brought it up, I'll focus there. As I've noted, I believe on this call and others, there's the work underway with Paysend and Shinhan, plus efforts in various parts of the world. On earlier calls, we've talked about collaborations with both traditional and fintech remittance companies. That 65% growth versus last year is solid, and we'll keep investing in it with additional partners and aim to push even more growth ahead. Our attention is on bill payments, on earned wage access, and on insurance disbursements. We remain focused on P2P more widely across new geographies globally, covering both domestic and cross-border. Stepping back, as I've said, I think on prior calls, I believe right now Visa Direct ranks as the biggest at-scale money movement network worldwide. We've invested steadily year after year to reach a stage where we have 8.5 billion endpoints, 3 billion cards, 3 billion accounts, and with news I shared in my prepared remarks, 2.5 billion digital wallets; we'll keep investing to grow the network further, yet today we can collaborate with enablers globally, introduce new use cases, and activate this network, and we'll keep at it and hope to discuss more positive results ahead.

Jennifer Como

executive
#16

Jordan, you're up next.

Ramsey El-Assal

analyst
#17

Hello, and thanks for taking my question. There was a lot of excellent commentary from you folks regarding commercial and B2B progress along with deal wins during the quarter. Could you provide a wider update on your commercial strategy? Going forward, where do you see the larger opportunities?

Ryan McInerney

executive
#18

Yeah, thank you. We did indeed secure some very strong commercial wins this quarter. You know, I'd sort it into a few categories. First, we aim to grow our partnerships, correct? So, as I said, Citi and IBM came up this quarter, SAP came up last quarter, and we're simply, you know, achieving solid results in building and growing those partnerships across the globe. The second area of focus for us is broadening verticals. And you've heard us discuss government, travel, fleet and fuel. I brought up agro, I believe, last quarter, working and selling into marketplaces, like I noted, healthcare. So taking these products — innovating, developing new use cases, and bringing them into new verticals. And then, you know, simply making the products simpler to use. Yesterday, we revealed that in fact we had a new product to make accepting virtual cards simpler. We call it Virtual Card Acceptance Platform. You know, virtual cards are the preferred acceptance method of many suppliers, but, you know, they aren't as simple to accept as sometimes we'd like them to be. So launching new platforms to make the core products such as virtual cards simpler to use. And then, you know, continuing to put money into the partnerships that we've announced over the last couple of years. You know, WEX is a fantastic example of a partner that, you know, we announced a couple of years ago that we've been investing in and growing with, and really getting to witness some of the benefits of that around the world. So I suppose the final thing, you know, I would say, Ramsey, is just also taking these products more widely around the world. In so many different countries outside of, you know, the most developed markets that we operate in, there's a chance to get some of the basic products into the hands of small businesses, for instance. In a lot of countries where we're doing business, there are still plenty of small businesses that are in fact using consumer products rather than the more sophisticated, advanced small business products, not to mention the large and middle market products that we can get out there; so, you know, more partners, more use cases, more verticals, more countries, we'll keep investing in that business.

Jennifer Como

executive
#19

Jordan, let's take the next one.

Will Nance

analyst
#20

Hi, everyone. Thanks for fielding the question. You offered some quite interesting remarks regarding gains in processing market share. Could you give us something like a state of the union on where things stand with that, and are there any geographies that come to mind as opportunities to grow processing share — what might those be? Thanks.

Ryan McInerney

executive
#21

Yes, absolutely. We pay a lot of attention to processing share, and there are several reasons for that. The main one I mentioned earlier in my prepared remarks is quite important: if we are the party handling the transaction, we are able to provide more of our value-added services. Obviously, we also generate higher yield when we serve as the transaction processor, purely on the core processing side. But our ability to serve clients more effectively—delivering our risk capabilities, our issuing capabilities, our loyalty capabilities, and similar offerings—is strengthened when we are the one actually processing the transaction. So we devote considerable effort to it. I believe we've achieved quite a lot over the past several years. I brought up Colombia in my prepared remarks, and it serves as a solid example. In many of these markets, unlocking processing really requires partnering with the local processor — that's what we did in Colombia — and then bringing clients onto that processor. From there, they'll run a transaction test, evaluate how things are performing, and eventually shift those transactions onto VisaNet, which is what we want; Latin America has been a major focus for us. We've made solid progress across a number of countries in that region, and I think there's still opportunity ahead for us in Latin America. Our progress in Europe is coming along, and we'll keep zeroing in on processing chances across a number of the various nations there that run their own local programs, plus a few spots in Asia Pacific; so that gives you a sense of the openings in front of us, Will. Appreciate it.

Jennifer Como

executive
#22

Jordan, you're up next.

James Faucette

analyst
#23

Thanks. Hi, everyone. I'd like to revisit the cross-border travel piece and what your thinking looks like for next year. I understand that, as you've frequently mentioned, forecasting the economy isn't really your role, but could you restate the assumption you're working from for the year ahead, and perhaps share some detail on the inputs behind how you get to that expectation and target for the year? Thanks.

Ryan McInerney

executive
#24

I'll offer some background on our overall view of cross-border travel, and then, Chris, feel free to chime in and/or cover anything I leave out regarding the assumptions we've set for the year. This is how I see it. In and out of Asia, things still haven't normalized. So, as Chris mentioned or noted in his prepared remarks, there's room for us to keep catching up to pre-COVID travel levels in and out of Asia. There's also room to keep catching up into the United States. But on a broader global basis, I'd say cross-border travel has kinda normalized. What I find interesting, though, is that we've normalized at a growth rate above pre-pandemic levels. At this new normal, people are traveling internationally at a faster pace than they would have, all else equal, before the pre-COVID levels. So in a couple of corridors, we still have room to catch up to what normalized levels would be. Across the other corridors worldwide, I think we've normalized, but at higher growth rates than we saw pre-COVID. You want to-

Chris Suh

executive
#25

Yes.

Ryan McInerney

executive
#26

...could you bring up any of those figures for the year?

Chris Suh

executive
#27

Yes. Well, the sole point I would genuinely include — within the call commentary I addressed quite a few of those assumptions. What I might simply stress is this: it's fairly robust growth, you know. And when you consider what we've put out regarding our expectation for the index to expand at 4 to 5 points each quarter, I believe that mirrors what Ryan mentioned — namely, normalized in numerous instances while remaining elevated growth.

Jennifer Como

executive
#28

Jordan, let's take the next question.

James Friedman

analyst
#29

Hello, and thank you for taking my question. Ryan, during your prepared remarks, you mentioned Cybersource. I recognize that it has always been an extremely important asset for you, but what is the reason? Should I take that to mean the business is picking up pace? And if that's the case, what would explain it? Thank you.

Ryan McInerney

executive
#30

Yes. Jamie, like I mentioned during my prepared remarks, we are experiencing terrific, robust demand from clients globally when it comes to Cybersource. What's the reason? I believe it stems from the many investments we have put into the platform across the past several years; we've, you know, we've been extremely deliberate about putting money into our omnicommerce capabilities for Cybersource. We've been extremely deliberate about putting money into our tokenization capabilities, our risk management and fraud prevention capabilities. And much of that came from sitting down with our clients and partners, learning about their roadmaps, learning about what they required us to deliver, making those investments, and then, you know, finding success expanding alongside our partners. You know, in any particular market globally, when clients begin adopting the Cybersource platform and other people observe the success they're achieving with authorization rates or transaction success or others, that creates new opportunities, and, you know, we've been able to sell into those. So thank you for the question.

Jennifer Como

executive
#31

Let's take the next question from Jordan.

Sanjay Sakhrani

analyst
#32

Thank you. I want to ask about Reg II. Chris, you said there's been no impact so far, and you also hedged a bit on the outlook. I'm curious whether anything is making you hesitant about it. And then, Ryan, is there anything you're doing ahead of time to prepare for potential negative effects? Thanks.

Ryan McInerney

executive
#33

Let me give some background on Reg II first, and then you can address whatever else Sanjay asked. So obviously there are two developments with Reg II. Let's cover both of them. The first is the modification introduced last summer, which took effect, concerning routing in the e-com space. As we said in our prepared remarks, we have not observed any significant impact. That said, plenty of activity is taking place across the ecosystem, and, you know, we are engaging with clients and partners regarding our products and our value propositions, ensuring they grasp the advantages of a Visa transaction, particularly in e-commerce, where the merchant frequently carries the fraud liability. So our sales teams meet with merchant clients and acquirer clients every single day, describing the worth of our products, demonstrating the worth of our products, and looking ahead, you know, we feel confident in our capacity to compete. The second development with Reg II, which I'm certain many would have noticed, is that the Fed has said that, they will, I believe it's tomorrow, reveal some modifications, possibly to the debit interchange rate, in the U.S. We have no idea what they will announce. You know, we will, we will of course monitor it very carefully, and, once they publish something, we will examine it and determine whether it warrants a response from us. And just to remind everyone, interchange is a transfer of value between the merchant and the issuer. You know, I think what stands out about our business model is we have demonstrated that we can remain resilient and maintain a strong business in regulated interchange markets, outside regulated interchange markets, in markets with higher regulated interchange and lower regulated interchange. So, you know, as you pointed out, there's a lot happening in the U.S. with Reg II, but we're fully on top of it, and we feel confident in our capacity to compete.

Chris Suh

executive
#34

Yes. From a guidance standpoint, I want to build on that — hopefully it's been made quite clear during this call: up to now, we haven't observed any significant effect, so none of that has been factored into what we've given for FY 2024 guidance. That said, we're still in the early stages, and as Ryan went into in detail, quite a lot is happening, so we'll continue to update you as the situation develops over the next several months.

Jennifer Como

executive
#35

Let's take the next one from Jordan.

Dan Perlin

analyst
#36

Thank you. I'd like to pose a question regarding tokenization and what it means for improvements in authorization rates more broadly; and I mean not only within the U.S., but also across borders. It really seems as though many of your partners can achieve better authorization rates because of the token. So I'm curious how you think about that when it comes to bringing additional transactions to Visa. Thanks.

Ryan McInerney

executive
#37

Yeah, I appreciate that question. As a quick refresher for everybody, tokenization is a technology we employ that basically assists in safeguarding issuers, merchants, and consumers, and as you asked, in the end it produces higher authorizations and less fraud. I believe I mentioned during my prepared remarks that we surpassed 7.5 billion tokens by the close of September. We operate in 198 markets. I believe we had 14 billion token transactions during the fourth quarter, expanding at roughly 60%. So here's yet another illustration of a platform and a service we've put money into for many years, and now we're expanding it widely across the globe. Regarding your question, yes, we are. On average, we observe somewhere in the range of 4%-5% better approval rates among our partners, and we additionally observe it alongside a decrease in fraud, a 30% decrease in fraud. So you might ask, why do we have 7.5 billion tokens now present in the ecosystem? Well, if you happen to be one of our partners, as you noted, and you're able to cut your fraud rates by 30% and boost your auth rates by 4 or 5 percentage points, that represents a fantastic opportunity. That means more sales, less fraud, and a superior customer experience. And as you know, we keep putting money into that platform too. We observe plenty of advantages for our issuers, for our consumers, who are the ones ultimately using the products; we will be. You know, you'll hear more from us about improving the platform when it comes to leveraging the FIDO biometrics and, you know, and letting merchants authorize and authenticate customers across multiple devices and those sorts of things. So yes, higher off, lower fraud; we're fond of the platform, and we keep investing in it.

Jennifer Como

executive
#38

Jordan, you're up next.

Trevor Williams

analyst
#39

Thanks, appreciate it. Chris, I was hoping you could clear something up regarding incentives in the guidance. My understanding is you mentioned assuming somewhat slower growth compared with fiscal 2023. I just want to confirm whether that refers to dollar growth on a year-over-year basis or growth expressed as a percentage of gross revenue. Then, for the second part, since you're describing this as a more normal year, should we take that to mean that, all else equal, in a normal year incentives ought to rise by roughly 100 basis points, give or take, as a percentage of gross revenue? Thank you.

Chris Suh

executive
#40

... Hey, Trevor. Sure, let me try to shed some light on that. Like I mentioned, 2024 is in lots of respects a normal year. Certain aspects are still normalizing, yet in lots of respects, it is normalizing. So because of that, we've implemented some changes. On quite a few fronts, we've gone back to pre-COVID practices; we've given formal guidance, as you walked through, as we detailed, and we've discussed on this call, covering the full year and next quarter, and that's a practice we'll keep up. That guidance concerns the net revenue guide, specifically, along with directional commentary regarding growth in incentives, which, to address your particular question, is a dollar year-over-year growth rate that we stated will grow more slowly in 2024 compared with 2023. Importantly, this is extremely, extremely consistent, and it's aligned with the way we think about the business, the way we manage the business moving forward. We haven't given guidance on the percentage, which is the remaining part of your question, because, once again, this is consistent with the way we manage the business. What we do track very importantly is that we look at the yield across our net revenue yield, specifically, and that has stayed very stable, and that's very consistent, once again, with the way we think about deal economics.

Jennifer Como

executive
#41

Jordan, you're up next.

Tien-Tsin Huang

analyst
#42

Hello, and thank you. I'm here at Money 20/20, where the energy is genuinely fantastic. Ryan, I'd love to know whether you'd say the deal pipeline looks any different today versus twelve months back. What's your read on it? And, if I may, on the credential side — I believe you mentioned a 7% increase. Same question there: does the pipeline exist to back that sort of high single-digit growth for credentials in fiscal 2024? Thanks.

Ryan McInerney

executive
#43

Hey, Tien-tsin. Good to hear the energy is strong at Money 20/20, and I hope the members of my Visa team who are on site are serving clients, uncovering sales opportunities, and expanding our business. Yes, our pipeline looks excellent. Truly, with clients issuing fintechs and co-brands, plus chances to grow credentials. I brought up a few of the fresh items during my prepared remarks, and we're enjoying solid success. Take some of the wins mentioned on this call — Citi, U.S. Bank, FNBO, Fidelity, Shinhan, China Merchants Bank, Shopify. The list keeps going, doesn't it? IBM, DBS, Etihad, Saudi; we're confident about the pipeline; we're confident about how our teams are out there serving clients across the globe. We're confident about the wins we've secured and confident about the growth that's coming from them.

Jennifer Como

executive
#44

Let's take the next one, Jordan.

Ashwin Shirvaikar

analyst
#45

I am on the line, and hello, Chris. Nice work on the quarter. My questions are about open banking. As you know, the CFPB proposed that rule a few days ago to kind of kick off a competitive shift toward open banking. You folks have worked with open banking regimes beyond the US across lots of different regions. I am just sort of wondering how that carries over when it comes to, you know, products, and when it comes to deals you have done, such as Tink, Pismo, and others, to bring that into the US.

Ryan McInerney

executive
#46

Appreciate the question. I believe the, you know, the rule the CFPB issued benefits Americans. I think it is, you know, it is excellent for making the structure and the regulatory framework in America clearer. I think it will probably act as a spark for expansion of open banking in the United States since it brings clarity to all the many different participants in the ecosystem. You know, when you consider it, like, it is a terrific chance for Americans to be able to put their own data to use in various kinds of digital tools that will assist their own personal financial management, help them manage their financial lives more effectively, get a stronger picture of their finances across numerous different providers. And then, as you mentioned, you know, we have observed varying regulatory frameworks in varying markets globally. Our Tink business keeps performing very strongly in Europe, which clearly was among the leaders when it came to setting up a regulatory framework for open banking; we are excited about the chance to take Tink beyond Europe; so when we look at the proposed rules here in the U.S., we welcome that since we want to grasp what the regulatory expectations are, so that we can create a business that will flourish and serve our clients and serve consumers well; so thank you for the question.

Jennifer Como

executive
#47

Jordan, we have time for one more.

Harshita Rawat

analyst
#48

Hello. When you look ahead to the coming fiscal year and past it, I'd like to raise the matter of the chance to digitize cash within your business. You're aware this subject comes up constantly with these investors, and people are considering it once more because of the pull forward from the pandemic, plus inflation payments. So what's your view of the runway, particularly when splitting it between developed markets and also EMs, where competition is somewhat greater? Thanks.

Ryan McInerney

executive
#49

Yeah, I appreciate that question. We remain enthusiastic about the chance to digitize cash and checks across the globe. We keep digitizing cash and check worldwide, and economies keep expanding worldwide. So I believe it still amazes lots of people when they examine developed markets such as the United States, how much cash and checks remain, and definitely when you consider the developing world, how much cash and checks remain. So we, we remain enthusiastic about the runway. We believe it gives us an enormous growth chance, and we'll keep collaborating with our partners throughout the ecosystem to place more credentials in consumers' hands, generate more acceptance in the ecosystem, particularly among micro and nano merchants, and partner with others to push more activation and usage among the credentials, and feel good about that whole algorithm.

Jennifer Como

executive
#50

That brings us to the end of today's session, and we appreciate everyone taking the time to be here. Should anything else come to mind, don't hesitate to reach out to our Investor Relations team by phone or email. Once more, thank you, and enjoy the rest of your day.

Operator

operator
#51

Thank you for your participation in today's conference. You may disconnect at this time.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Visa Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Visa Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Visa Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.