Visa Inc. (V) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
January 25, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Jennifer Como
executiveGood afternoon, everyone, and thank you for being with us on Visa's earnings call for the first quarter of fiscal 2024. Joining us are Ryan McInerney, our Chief Executive Officer, and Chris Suh, our Chief Financial Officer. You can listen to this call via webcast through the investor relations area of our site, investor.visa.com. A replay will remain archived there for 30 days. We've also posted on our IR website a slide deck with financial and statistical highlights. As a reminder, forward-looking statements are part of this presentation. Such statements don't guarantee future performance, and a variety of factors could cause our actual results to differ materially. You can find more details about those factors in our latest annual report on Form 10-K, along with any later reports on Forms 10-Q and 8-K, posted on the SEC's website and in the investor relations section of our site. Regarding the non-GAAP financial information discussed on this call, the corresponding GAAP measures and reconciliation appear in today's earnings release and related materials on our IR website. With that, I'll hand the call over to Ryan.
Ryan McInerney
executiveGood afternoon, everyone, and thank you for joining us. We've gotten off to a strong beginning in 2024. Consumers kept spending at resilient levels, and payments volume for the first quarter grew 8% compared with a year earlier. In the U.S., payments volume climbed 5% year-over-year. Internationally, payments volume was higher by 11%. Cross-border volume, when intra-Europe is excluded, was up 16% year-over-year on a constant-dollar basis, while cross-border travel hit 142% of 2019 levels, an increase from 139% in the fourth quarter. Processed transactions rose 9%. Net revenues were up 9%, GAAP EPS increased 20%, and non-GAAP EPS rose 11%. As I reflect on how we carried out our strategy during the quarter across consumer payments, new flows, and value-added services, a few key themes come to mind that I wanted to highlight. First, we remain completely focused on serving customers—traditional bank partners, neobanks, fintechs, wallets, sellers, acquirers, and others alike. Thanks to that client-centric approach, we've been able to strengthen ties with partners throughout all three pillars of our strategy. Second, we continue to chase fresh partnerships, new use cases, and additional verticals that push our business ahead, with a special focus on cross-border. Third, we've launched innovative solutions into the market across our network of networks, with the goal of delivering value for every transaction, regardless of which network is involved. And fourth, we're constantly looking for new and inventive ways to boost our brand in support of our partners. Keeping those themes in mind, I'll now share a bit more detail about the quarter. We'll start with consumer payments, where we continued to see growth across credentials, acceptance, and engagement. Credentials were up 6%, and we now have over 8.7 billion network tokens, which is a 55% increase. Acceptance locations rose 17%. I'd like to highlight two recent examples of our acceptance expansion. The first is in Brazil with Caixa, for cash conversion across their more than 10,000 lottery branches; they now take Visa credit and debit cards for utilities, tax collection, lotteries, and voucher payments known as boletos. Another example comes from Asia Pacific, where we signed an agreement with bKash, the largest mobile financial services player in Bangladesh. Visa Direct was already in their toolkit, and now those clients have made it possible for the more than 15 million people holding Visa cards in that country to pay via QR code inside the app at upwards of 550,000 bKash merchant locations; what these cases show is how we tailor our local strategy for broadening global acceptance. Tap to Pay climbed 5 percentage points versus a year ago, reaching 77% of in-person transactions worldwide when the U.S. is left out. Within the U.S., penetration came to 45%. Among first-quarter standouts, Lowe's began accepting Tap to Pay. Our view is that tapping delivers the strongest experience for both buyer and seller when they meet in person, and the numbers bear that out. A recent U.S. Visa study found that people who tap with a Visa debit card averaged two additional transactions per month and a $70 monthly spend lift compared with those who don't tap. Now, a few notable developments this quarter illustrate how we can strengthen and grow existing partnerships while also forming new ones. In Europe, we renewed our contract with İşbank — Turkey's biggest private bank — covering 33 million cards across its consumer and commercial credit and debit portfolios. Through that renewal, they'll issue the first Olympic and Paralympic Games credit card in Europe outside of France, drawing on our sponsorship. Over in Poland, we've entered into a new issuing agreement with PKO Bank Polski — the biggest issuer and acquirer in Poland and Central Eastern Europe — covering consumer and commercial debit. In Greece, we expanded our ties with Piraeus Bank, that country's largest bank, and became their exclusive payment network for consumer and commercial credit and debit portfolios. These are all excellent examples of the attractive position and strong pipeline in Continental Europe that I mentioned last quarter. In Japan, we deepened our credit issuance partnership with EPOS, one of the country's fastest-growing issuers, which is affiliated with department store Marui. They will utilize Visa Managed Services — one of our advisory offerings — whereby we embed Visa staff within a client’s organization to support key initiatives. In Korea, we renewed and broadened our collaboration with Shinhan Card, that market’s biggest issuer, across consumer and commercial as well as credit and debit. Shinhan has additionally pledged to adopt a range of Visa’s value-added services, among them consulting and marketing, to advance its business. Mexico-wise, we renewed our BBVA agreement covering consumer and commercial credit and debit, plus value-added services like risk, advisory, and data tools. Last, in the US, we extended our Bank of America agreement for several value-added services, including Visa's loyalty platform service, Cardinal Commerce 3D Secure Service, Verifi Order Insight digital service, and DPS debit processing. We also stayed a partner of choice for fintechs globally. First, in the US, we renewed with leading fintech Chime for their debit and credit builder secured card portfolios, as well as for Visa Direct. In Latin America, we extended our agreements for debit and credit with Rappi — among the biggest fintech and merchant clients in that region, serving over 30 million customers. A range of value-added services will be adopted by them as well, such as CyberSource and Decision Manager. And lastly, a fresh worldwide alliance with HSBC around their fintech venture, Zing, has us very enthusiastic. Beginning in the U.K., we're supporting the goal of bringing this multi-currency offering to more than 30 markets. The combination of Visa's strengths via Tink, Currencycloud, and our consumer payment solutions delivers a compelling proposition for customers plus swift rollout for Zing and HSBC. These renewals and new partnerships show how our focus is on cultivating a strong relationship spanning the full set of capabilities Visa provides. Turning to new flows. Using the most recent market data available, we've refreshed how we size the new flows opportunity. Excluding Russia and China, that opportunity amounts to $200 trillion a year across B2B, B2C, P2P, and G2C. Obviously, that's a very large number. Working alongside our clients, we're delivering Visa's commercial and money movement solutions so that these flows can be digitized through our network of networks. Starting with Visa Direct, total transactions this quarter climbed 20% to 2.2 billion, and P2P cross-border transactions grew more than 65% versus the prior year. Turning to client highlights for the quarter: we've been developing partnerships around fresh use cases and verticals, and cross-border volumes continue to expand. Starting with the new use cases — in addition to the P2P partnership we already have in the U.S., we've expanded the Visa Direct relationship with Meta, adding the capability for content creators across Meta's family of apps to cash out their earnings onto a debit card. That launch is live now in the U.S., U.K., France, and Italy, and it gives creators fast, secure access to their payouts. Moving to cross-border volumes — we've continued advancing toward enabling global money movement via our 8.5 billion endpoints spanning nearly 200 countries and territories. Western Union stands out as a strong example.
Ryan McInerney
executiveWe’ve just entered into a long-term worldwide partnership deal with Western Union that spans issuance, Visa Direct, and additional services in 40 countries and five regions; this extended collaboration is set to deliver product innovations and digital-first customer experiences that improve cross-border money movement. We also broadened our relationship with Remitly so that customers in 30 countries can send cross-border payments to eligible debit cards and bank accounts in more than 100 countries around the world. In Canada, we recently announced our agreement with CIBC and Simplii that will give millions of clients the ability to send money to digital wallets in key remittance destinations, among them the Philippines, China, and Bangladesh. Moving to the commercial side. Constant-dollar total payments volume grew 8%, and our attention stayed on emerging verticals throughout the quarter. A few particular areas deserve mention. To start with cross-border travel: our arrangement with Nium, the Singapore-headquartered B2B platform, was expanded recently. Its virtual card B2B travel program is set to reach Australia, Singapore, Hong Kong, and Japan, having previously covered the U.S. and Europe. On the B2B travel side as well, we entered a fresh virtual card deal with Worldline, a top global payments provider, enabling travel intermediaries to settle with suppliers faster. Turning to the contractor segment: we've just finalized an arrangement involving United Overseas Bank and Doxa, a Singapore-based fintech that works with contractors. Together with Visa, the Doxa platform now carries additional embedded financing features. Subcontractors can choose to receive payment for their services through UOB virtual cards. Separately, with UOB we have renewed and broadened the commercial tie-up covering commercial debit and credit, and that includes making payment flows possible for the Singapore government. Now let me turn to value-added services. Our network-of-networks approach is also important for value-added services. As a reminder, it consists of three parts. First, moving money to every endpoint and every form factor. Second, we leverage every network available and act as one unified point of contact for our partners. Third, we deliver our value-added services across all transactions, regardless of which network is used. As part of this approach, we've kept building out and broadening those value-added services. I'll walk through three recent illustrations: processing capabilities for RTP networks, Pismo, and Prosa. During the previous quarter, I mentioned that Visa is in the process of becoming a certified service provider for FedNow, which lets financial institutions receive funds via the FedNow service. We've now made it possible to send funds as well. Pismo is the second example, and we completed that acquisition just last week. In my conversations with customers worldwide—especially those that issue cards—two concerns keep coming up more and more among chief executives. First, many of these issuing customers have either just started, or are thinking about starting, moving their technology stack away from legacy infrastructure toward cloud-native, API-based systems. Second, a great number of customers—traditional issuers as well as Fintechs—are increasingly keen to expand their issuance rapidly into new regions and countries, especially across developing markets globally. For help with both of these priorities, they are looking to Visa, and with Pismo, we'll be in a position to offer our customers the world's finest cloud-native issuer, processor, and core banking platform. Pismo provides global core banking along with multi-product issuer processing across credit, debit, and commercial, and it connects to local payment networks like Pix. Our aim is for Pismo to become the preferred platform for our issuing partners worldwide, helping them speed up global expansion and their shift to cloud-native platforms. The third illustration of our network of networks is the announcement that we're acquiring a majority stake in Prosa, a payments processor based in Mexico. A few points about the Mexican market. First, cash and checks account for over 50% of personal consumption expenditures. Second, at present Visa has limited domestic processing capability. Our belief is that we can provide better technology infrastructure and establish the groundwork for innovative new methods through which consumers, small businesses, and local issuers and acquirers in Mexico can pay and receive payment. This involves reinforcing safety, security, and reliability, along with offering superior experiences via our value-added services such as tokenization, risk products, and others. We are also able to bring our innovation and commitment to continued investment for in-person as well as online transactions. Combined, these initiatives will drive further digitization of payments across the country. This investment requires regulatory review, and we anticipate completing it during the second half of calendar year 2024. Finally, I want to emphasize the possibilities for creating additional growth in value-added services by forming new partnerships. Through them, we can reinforce what we bring to market as a whole and how far our distribution network extends. An agreement was unveiled yesterday with ServiceNow, a leader in digital workflows, under which we will create solutions and deliver Visa's offerings to shared clients. Initially, ServiceNow will roll out a complete disputes management offering aimed at issuers, and over time the intent is to move into further segments and products. This collaboration shows how much demand exists for our value-added services and provides an attractive distribution route for reaching additional customers worldwide; thus, when you look across consumer payments, new flows, and value-added services, the sizable opportunity is evident, along with Visa's robust client relationships, dedication to those clients, and inventiveness in fresh methods of paying and getting paid. Our brand is a key amplifier for all of this work. We just renewed a partnership with FIFA that goes back a long way, and it gives both Visa and our clients a strong chance to generate business, boost brand lift, and extend global reach as far as possible. On top of that, it lets us demonstrate and deploy Visa's innovative payment technology. We're also starting our first new worldwide sports sponsorship in over 15 years, teaming up with the Red Bull Formula One teams. Through this deal, our brand links up with two Formula One teams—the sport is among the fastest-growing anywhere on the planet—and it offers us one more avenue to generate business for our clients. As we look toward the year ahead, we're eager to bring our brand to life with clients through each of these partnerships, as well as the Olympic and Paralympic Games in Paris. Before I hand it over to Chris, I'd like to mention that our annual meeting was held on Tuesday. All the proposals the board recommended were approved, including the exchange offer program proposal. As a result, we'll waste no time in filing an S-4 with the SEC concerning the initial exchange offer. I'd also like to extend particular gratitude to my colleague, partner, and friend, Al Kelly. He officially retired as executive chairman on Tuesday. Al, on behalf of the whole Visa family, thank you for your outstanding leadership. You elevated this business to remarkable levels while simultaneously fueling innovation, making our client ties deeper, and reinforcing our culture across numerous dimensions. What you've done for Visa will leave a mark for generations to come. To wrap up, during the first quarter Visa demonstrated once more that our global strategy is being executed effectively. Even though uncertainty appears to be routine these days, Visa possesses the experience and discipline needed to navigate difficult environments, and I stay hopeful and assured regarding what lies ahead. I'll now hand things to Chris.
Chris Suh
executiveThanks, Ryan, and good afternoon, everyone. As Ryan noted, Q1 was a solid quarter: overall payments volume and processed transactions grew at a fairly steady rate, and cross-border volume showed strong growth. Now to our drivers: in constant dollars, global payments volume was up 8% versus a year ago, and processed transactions rose 9% year-over-year. Cross-border volume growth, excluding intra-Europe, increased 16% year-over-year in constant dollars. Fiscal first quarter net revenues grew 9% in both nominal and constant dollars, coming in at the high end of our expectations, largely because incentives were lower than we had anticipated and the FX drag was smaller. GAAP EPS was up 20%, while non-GAAP EPS rose 11% in nominal terms and 10% in constant dollars. Turning to the specifics, starting with the U.S.: American payment volumes rose 5% compared with a year earlier, as credit climbed 6% and debit gained 5%. Spending where the card was present went up 3%, while volume where it was not present grew 7%. Looking at month-by-month growth in total U.S. payments volume over the quarter, October was the weakest and November the strongest, with December landing in between. Overall, the roughly 80 basis point decline in total U.S. payments volume growth between Q4 and Q1 came chiefly from a less favorable weekend-to-weekday mix than a year ago, together with a handful of smaller factors, among them a softer October and a modest effect from Reg II. Spending by consumers has been fairly steady across every segment, whether low or high. Nothing in our data suggests a real shift in behavior among any consumer group. Now for holiday spending, defined as November 1 through December 31: in the U.S., holiday spend growth year over year came in at mid-single digits. Growth in consumer retail spending looked much like it did a year earlier. That said, on the key shopping days stretching from Thanksgiving through Cyber Monday, retail spending growth was considerably stronger. E-commerce gained share of retail spending compared with the prior year. Over in international markets, total payments volume growth reached 11% in constant dollars, which is flat relative to Q4. For the quarter, payment volume growth was robust across most major regions. Latin America, CEMEA, and Europe excluding the U.K. each posted roughly 20% growth in constant dollars. Now turning to cross-border, which I'll cover in constant dollars and excluding intra-Europe transactions: total cross-border volume rose 16% year-over-year. Cross-border card-not-present volume growth, excluding travel, came in slightly ahead of expectations in the low teens, after adjusting for cryptocurrency purchases. Cross-border travel-related spend was up 19% year-over-year. Indexed to 2019, cross-border travel volume climbed from 139% in Q4 to 142% in Q1. For the quarter, travel volume into Asia indexed at 132% of 2019 levels, three points higher than Q4, while travel volume out of Asia rose four points to 118%. Growth was down versus the prior quarter, largely because of comparative softness in Australia and Japan. Two-way travel with mainland China continued to strengthen, although neither direction is back to its 2019 position. U.S. inbound travel gained several points this quarter versus Q4 when measured against 2019, and volumes into and out of LAC, Europe and CEMEA, plus outbound from the U.S., stayed healthy at 145% to 170% of 2019 levels. Next, let's walk through the first quarter financial results, starting with the revenue components. To start, since new pricing typically takes effect in April and October, every one of our revenue components got a lift this quarter, and growth rates were either pushed higher or held back by the following additional factors: Service revenues rose 11% year-over-year, against 9% growth in Q4 constant dollar payments volume, with a bit of extra help from card benefits. Data processing revenues climbed 14% versus 9% growth in processed transactions, aided by business mix and value-added services. International transaction revenues increased 8% against a 16% rise in constant dollar cross-border volume excluding intra-Europe, held back by lapping strong currency volatility from last year. Other revenue increased 18%, driven by healthy consulting growth, though it was constrained by comparison against a 31% gain in 2023 that came largely from value-added services tied to FIFA. Client incentives climbed 20% yet landed under our forecast owing to client performance and the timing of deals. Across our three growth engines, consumer payments growth was fueled by reasonably stable payments volume and processed transaction growth along with robust cross-border volume growth; in new flows this quarter, the underlying drivers remained broadly steady. Commercial volumes rose 8% from a year earlier in constant dollars, and Visa Direct transactions were up 20%. Total new flows revenue posted low single-digit year-over-year growth in constant dollars, mirroring the effect of several one-time items and business mix. Every period has its pluses and minuses, as you're aware, yet the important thing is that the underlying drivers remain steady, and our expectation for full-year 2024 is unchanged: new flows revenue will outpace consumer payments revenue in growth. Value-added services revenue in Q1 climbed 20% in constant dollars, reaching $2.1 billion, powered by strength in issuing and acceptance solutions. GAAP operating expenses dropped 6%, a decrease attributable to a lower litigation provision that was partly offset by increased personnel expenses. Non-GAAP operating expenses were up 7%, driven mainly by higher personnel expenses. After excluding net gains of $4 million from our equity investments, non-GAAP non-operating income came to $84 million. On a GAAP basis our tax rate was 19.1%, while non-GAAP was 19%, aided by tax benefits that were larger than expected. GAAP earnings per share came in at $2.39. On a non-GAAP basis, EPS reached $2.41, marking an 11% increase year over year, which includes a benefit of roughly 0.5 points from currency exchange rates. During Q1, we bought back about $3.4 billion of our stock and distributed over $1 billion in dividends to shareholders. As of the end of December, our repurchase authorization had $26.4 billion remaining. Turning now to January results through the 21st: US payment volume grew 4%, with debit up 3% and credit up 4% versus the same period last year — a figure that was below December's pace, largely attributable to severe weather in some parts of the US. Processed transactions were up 8% from a year earlier. Cross-border volume measured in constant dollars, leaving out transactions within Europe, climbed 16% compared with a year earlier. Travel-related cross-border volume, again excluding intra-Europe activity, also grew 16% year-over-year — a figure that reaches 146% when indexed to 2019 — while cross-border card-not-present volume not connected to travel was up 16%. Now let's turn to our expectations. Bear in mind that adjusted basis refers to non-GAAP results stated in constant dollars and excluding acquisition impacts. Further detail on these disclosures appears in our earnings presentation; for the full year, we anticipate no material shifts from our prior outlook regarding drivers, adjusted net revenues, or EPS growth. Note that our drivers assume neither a recession nor any additional increase in Reg II impacts. On the full year, Pismo ought to contribute a slight lift to net revenues growth, while adding about half a point of headwind to non-GAAP operating expense and EPS growth. Currency movements are expected to subtract around half a point from net revenues growth and to help non-GAAP operating expense growth by roughly one point, while barely weighing on non-GAAP EPS growth. Non-operating income on both a GAAP and non-GAAP basis should come in at $350 million to $400 million, and close to half of that is expected in Q2, stemming from the settlement of certain non-US tax matters. Bringing it all together, adjusted net revenues growth is still expected to be in the low double digits. We've revised adjusted operating expense growth upward to the low double digits, while adjusted EPS growth remains the same at low teens. In Q2, as with the full year, Pismo is expected to contribute only minimally to net revenues growth and to create about a half-point headwind on non-GAAP operating expense and EPS growth. Currency effects should have only a slight negative impact on net revenues growth and deliver roughly a half-point lift to non-GAAP operating expense growth, along with a minimal boost to non-GAAP EPS growth. Our expectation is adjusted net revenues growth in the upper mid- to high single digits, with adjusted operating expense growth in the low double digits—above 10%. Non-operating income is expected to peak in Q2 due to the resolution of certain tax matters, which I noted earlier. As a result, the tax rate for Q2 should land in the 16% to 16.5% range, while the full-year figure remains the same. That puts second quarter adjusted EPS growth in the high teens. In summary, the first quarter got off to a solid start. Our fundamental drivers remain relatively stable, and since there are no material changes to our full year guidance, we're continuing to concentrate on carrying out our growth strategy for the rest of 2024. As usual, if the environment shifts and something comes up that impacts our business, we will definitely revise our spending plans. We stay thoughtful about balancing short and long-term considerations. Now, Jennifer, let's open it up to Q&A.
Jennifer Como
executiveThanks, Chris. With that, we're ready to take questions.
Tien-Tsin Huang
analystHi, thank you very much. I have one point I'd like clarified, and then a broader question. On the clarification: new flows came in at low single digits against mid-teens in the prior quarter — how did that land relative to plan? Did any one-time items play a part? Because it seems the remaining metrics were in line. Then my question concerns U.S. volume, which is running at mid single digits; that's quite close to PCE. I realize many factors are at play, such as gas, e-com, and Reg II, but could you clarify how you see U.S. volume relative to PCE growth over the short to midterm? Thank you.
Ryan McInerney
executiveHi, Tien-Tsin, this is Ryan. Let me begin with the second part of what you asked, and then Chris can share his view on the first part and add to or correct anything on the second. Let me step back briefly to the U.S. The U.S. still represents a major opportunity for us in consumer payments. I mean, plenty of cash remains, plenty of checks, plenty of ACH; we're doing excellent work with fintechs and banks to bring more people onto cards. We're working, you know, on growing acceptance, you know, in the service sector, whether plumbers or contractors, charities, vending, parking, tap-to-pay. I mean, we remain very, very enthusiastic about the US market. As you mentioned, and Chris could provide some detail, there are certain Visa-specific factors in the quarter affecting the U.S. growth rate, you know, in relation to PCE, like you were discussing; but looking ahead, it's still a big opportunity for us; we remain excited about it. Chris, would you take the first part of Tien-Tsin's question and add anything on the second?
Chris Suh
executiveAbsolutely. In terms of new flows, the core fundamentals underpinning our commercial business are still solid. Commercial payment volumes rose 8%, while Visa Direct transactions were up 20%. The key point is that new flows remains a growth engine for Visa. We do anticipate that revenue growth for the full year will outpace consumer revenue growth. Turning to your question about the first quarter specifically, a couple of factors weighed on it. First, there was the business mix, as cross-border volume growth decelerated in Q1 while travel kept normalizing. Second, a few one-time items that turned out bigger than what we'd normally see in any given quarter also affected growth. Overall, we feel very good about the business and the long-term growth trajectory that lies ahead.
Tien-Tsin Huang
analystGreat, that helps. Thanks to the two of you.
Jennifer Como
executiveJordan, let's take the next question.
Dan Perlin
analystThanks. Hi, I wanted to pose one question about the fresh partnerships in value-added services. Ryan, it seems as though, as one of the priorities, you're aiming to have value-added services available across every network, and I believe you were hinting that with this expansion in partnerships, this may become a somewhat larger shared responsibility. ServiceNow is clearly a strong illustration, but I'm simply attempting to work out how we ought to view Visa potentially unlocking those chances through all these additional partnerships, and what that might eventually mean for the company's financial picture. Thanks.
Ryan McInerney
executiveYes. And again, if I step back before addressing the specific question about ServiceNow and partners, we're quite enthusiastic about how far we've come with our value-added services strategy; we're enthusiastic about the momentum we're seeing in the marketplace; we're enthusiastic to see our sales efforts genuinely driving success and performance across issuing, acceptance, risk and identity, advisory, and open banking. And it's just as you said, with partners such as ServiceNow. What we're discovering is that we can put strong effort into selling directly to partners around the globe, but we're also seeing considerable demand from a range of platforms that already have relationships with thousands or tens of thousands, or sometimes even more customers in any single country or region. They're very eager to sell through our value-added services as a means of differentiating their platform and deepening ties with their users and their customers. So in ServiceNow's case, they had been speaking with their bank clients, and those bank clients had requested and shown interest in some of the dispute services that we offer. So we're going to market first, as I mentioned in my prepared remarks, with our dispute services through ServiceNow; we have a pipeline of other products and services that we're working on with them, and we're in deep discussions with other platforms worldwide about bringing our money movement solutions and our value-added services solutions as a way to differentiate their platform and add value for their users.
Jennifer Como
executiveNext question, Jordan.
Jennifer Como
executiveCraig, are you there?
Craig Maurer
analystYes, my apologies. Are you able to hear me now?
Jennifer Como
executiveWe definitely can.
Craig Maurer
analystAll right, great. I'd like to ask whether you could give a bit more detail in the comments on Reg II and how you see volume moving, maybe off your network; and second, if you could add some detail on the one-time items that hit Visa in the U.S. this quarter, I'd appreciate it. Thank you.
Ryan McInerney
executiveSo why don't I do that. Let me spend a little time on the business side of Reg II, and then, Chris, you can take both of those specific questions, Reg II and the one-time items. I think it's worth noting at this point that we're six months in now since Reg II in the U.S., and we've had the chance to really engage with our clients and partners on the merchant side of what we do, and we're having really good discussions, really good dialogues. It's been a great opportunity for us to showcase our products, our services, and especially the various things that set a Visa debit transaction apart from other alternatives. Honestly, we're getting to have conversations at more senior levels in the organization about the details of our products than we've ever had before, which is great. So far, we're having great success. The sales conversations have been positive. The results, client by client, that we're finding as we're able to talk with them about the features and benefits of Visa Direct are great so far, and I feel really good about our results six months into this so far. So, Chris, do you want to take the two pieces specifically?
Chris Suh
executiveYes, I’ll take that. So, on Reg II, as we said, there was a modest effect. U.S. Payments volume growth declined roughly 80 basis points between Q4 and Q1. That deceleration came mainly from two factors. First, the mix of spend days, and second, a handful of smaller items — a weaker October and the modest Reg II impact we’ve been discussing. So those are the factors. It’s worth noting that we haven’t actually observed any material shift in volumes being routed elsewhere since October. Overall, the effect is modest, it really hasn’t moved during the last quarter, and that is in fact what we built into the outlook we provided for the remainder of the year. Now, regarding the second part of your question on one-time items: I mentioned some of the U.S. factors, Reg II and the soft October. The other area where I referenced one-time items was in the new flows business. As I said, revenue growth was affected by a couple of things. First, I discussed cross-border normalization as it relates to travel. And second, there were those one-time items, and I’ll give you one example. In the ordinary course of business, we routinely true up or true down incentives and rebates with clients according to the metrics they report; and during the first quarter, the net effect of those adjustments turned out to be bigger than what we’d typically see in a quarter. But overall, it isn’t something that worries us. The underlying business fundamentals are still healthy, it doesn’t alter our expectations for full-year growth in new flows revenue, which will keep outpacing consumer revenue.
Jennifer Como
executiveLet's take the next question from Jordan.
Sanjay Sakhrani
analystThank you, and good evening. My question concerns the softer volumes we've seen so far this year in severe weather. I'm wondering whether any weakness has shown up outside of that. And then, do you anticipate that spending will pick back up now that conditions have improved, or could you elaborate on that a bit? Thanks.
Chris Suh
executiveYes, thanks Sanjay. And we did observe growth decelerating during the first week of January — we've examined that very carefully, and it ties directly to the severe cold weather that struck a lot of the U.S. Let me offer a few illustrations; anybody in Kansas City knows this well: temperatures went from 45 degrees during the last week of December down to -10 degrees across the first few weeks of January, so nobody was going out, and Kansas City's growth shifted from mid-single digits growing to declining mid-single digits. Another example: in San Diego, where those who are fortunate enough to live there enjoy 60 degrees, we've had steady mid-single digit volume growth carrying into January. Perhaps a third example that shows the swings we witnessed — in Dallas, it was close to 60 degrees during the first two weeks of January and then fell to under 20 degrees in the third week, and our card present volumes in that third week followed precisely the same pattern. So, on the second part of your question, the good news is that we've witnessed these kinds of weather-driven patterns previously. They usually prove to be brief blips, and across the quarter they generally smooth back out.
Jennifer Como
executiveLet's take the next question from Jordan.
Ken Suchoski
analystHi there, good afternoon, and thank you for taking my question. I'd like to ask about the EPS growth outlook. So it seems you're guiding toward high teens EPS growth for fiscal 2Q, which, as I understand it, implies a mid-single-digit decline in the share count on a quarter-over-quarter basis. What I'm trying to work out is why that doesn't carry through to the full year EPS growth figure, where your guidance is into low teens growth. So it would be great if you could help us reconcile those two. Perhaps there are some tax or OpEx impacts in the back half of the year that we aren't accounting for. Thanks so much.
Chris Suh
executiveYeah, no, it, yeah, it is specific to Q2. I think I mentioned on the call that there were some tax matters resolved outside of the U.S. that brought our tax rate down in Q2 into the 16% range; that same matter also had some benefit that hit the NOI line, which also helps the high teens growth rate on EPS in Q2, specifically. For the full year, it doesn't change the tax rate, doesn't change our prior outlook for EPS growth.
Jennifer Como
executiveMoving on to the next question, Jordan.
Harshita Rawat
analystGood afternoon. I'd like to dig deeper into services. Since they're becoming more and more critical to your revenue growth, could you share some insights and quantification regarding the mix of your value-added services — DPS, CyberSource, Risk, and so on? And perhaps also elaborate on what's driving growth there in terms of attach rates, processing penetration, and geographic expansion. These services are expanding at nearly 2x the pace of your card volumes overall, so we're trying to get a handle on what's fueling that growth. Thank you.
Ryan McInerney
executiveYeah, thank you; it's... To build on what I said before, I think our strategy is truly hitting on all cylinders. Our execution is hitting on all cylinders. Demand from clients is still robust. The TAMs are big, as you pointed out. You know, last year, you know, we brought in roughly $7 billion in revenue in the value-added services business. I think we mentioned in the quarter it was a bit over $2 billion and up 20% in constant dollars. Those are excellent results. The, to dig a little into the specifics of your question, I mean, we operate these businesses, you know, segment by segment. In issuing solutions, you know, we're achieving great success with our network products around the world. DPS keeps achieving strong results with customers in the United States. During my prepared remarks, I noted that we renewed our agreement with Bank of America — which, as you'd imagine, ranks among DPS's biggest clients and is a wonderful partner — along with several of the additional value-added services I brought up. In the acceptance solutions segment, CyberSource keeps enjoying substantial worldwide success, covering both its omni-channel offerings and certain value-added services such as Token Management Service and similar products. Our disputes business, apart from the ServiceNow relationship I referenced earlier, is also performing very well. Verify is performing exceptionally well across the board, particularly as it grows beyond the United States. Our Risk and Identity Solutions segment is demonstrating remarkable resilience along with strong growth. This includes our sophisticated authorization platform, Visa Risk Manager, Visa Secure, and all the other offerings we've been launching; additionally, our advisory services remain successful. In my prepared remarks, I brought up a few client wins and the success we've had with our managed services platforms. There, we place teams of Visa employees inside our clients, collaborating closely with our client partners every day, every week, every month, helping them move their business forward. That drives revenue growth and diversifies our revenue, but more importantly, it puts us right in the building with our clients, helping them grow their businesses, which makes our core business even stickier. So yes, it comes down to execution, our product pipeline, and delivery — and we feel genuinely good about how things turned out. Thanks for asking.
Jennifer Como
executiveLet's take the next question from Jordan.
Bryan Keane
analystHey there. I just have a couple of things I'd like clarified. Chris, I believe on last quarter's call you mentioned that growth would bottom out in the first quarter, and after that you'd see that trough speed up as we move ahead. One nuance in the guide is mid to high-single digits. So I'm just checking whether there's anything new to share regarding Q2 versus Q1 being the trough. And second, operating expense in constant currency looks a bit higher than what I recall as high-single to low-double, and now you're saying low-double. Is there anything we should factor in for that? Thank you.
Chris Suh
executiveYep. Thanks, Bryan. Yeah, so to go back to your point, as we entered Q1, you know, you laid out the guidance I provided. At that time we set an expectation, using similar language, high to mid single digits, to high, sorry, mid high to high single digits. And we did land at the high end of that range, which again was largely a benefit from the timing of incentive performance.
Chris Suh
executiveOur expectation for the growth range in Q2 is comparable, though several of the factors I mentioned a quarter ago regarding the first half versus the second half remain in play as we see it. Those include lapping elevated volatility, lapping strong cross-border results from the prior year, and lapping softer incentive growth from a year earlier. We still believe those dynamics hold, and we do expect growth to pick up as we move through the back half of the year. As for your OpEx question, yes, the adjustments you noticed in the full-year guidance stem mainly from two items. First, we are now factoring the effect of the Pismo acquisition into the OpEx outlook, and second, there have been minor revisions tied to FX, reflecting prevailing exchange rates.
Jennifer Como
executiveJordan, you're up next with a question.
Andrew Jeffrey
analystThank you. I appreciate you fielding the question. Ryan, I'd like to explore a bit the impressive 17% growth in merchant acceptance; it seems that really underscores the potential, or the opportunity, for ongoing volume growth, even in markets where perhaps the secular growth rate is decelerating somewhat. Is that something that can be sustained? Should we keep viewing that sort of mid-teens acceptance growth as a major driver behind overall volume expansion?
Ryan McInerney
executiveLook, whenever I speak with our sales teams across the globe, I'm urging them to deliver as much as they possibly can and then some. I mean, there's — you know, if you go around the world, hundreds of millions of small businesses still aren't on our network. And on top of that, Andrew, you add on top of that the creator economy and what's going on there, and you can literally think of the acceptance opportunity in the billions. So, you know, our sales teams worldwide are out there putting in the effort, getting creative, finding different approaches across the globe to serve those, you know, 100+ million small and micro, micro businesses, and in the end, you know, 1, 2, 3+ billion individuals worldwide who all ultimately could turn into acceptors of our products, when you consider things like Tap to Phone being rolled out at scale. I mean, you can picture a world where every handheld device turns into a tap acceptor, and every, you know, device is a Tap to Pay opportunity, where, you know, we can not only go deeper into the C2B space, but the, the P2P space, and others too. So we felt really good, as you were mentioning, over the last, I believe it's the last several quarters, we've posted 17%, 18%, 19% growth in acceptance locations. I tried, in my prepared remarks, just to provide a bit of color, you know, the kinds of things that, you know, we're out there doing alongside players such as bKash and Caixa. And we'll be working hard to, you know, keep lighting up all those remaining opportunities in emerging markets and developed markets worldwide.
Jennifer Como
executiveLet's take the next question from Jordan.
James Faucette
analystThanks. I'd like to ask about the growth in cross-border travel volume. It seems it decelerated from about 25% to perhaps 16%-17% in January. Earlier, when you were laying out your assumptions for fiscal 2024, you expected something in the low 20% range, and we're seeing a four to five percentage point gain versus 2019. I'm just curious how we should treat that as an assumption going forward. Do you think we'll return to that low 20s level, or does something nearer to what you saw in January seem more reasonable? I realize this is an area where you sometimes have at least some forward visibility, so I'm trying to get a sense of how we should think about that component.
Chris Suh
executiveYes. Great. Thanks, James. We had a really strong quarter in Q1 to kick off the year in our cross-border business. Cross-border volumes, as you mentioned, rose 16%. We feel great about that. And if you dig into those, e-com growth was in the low teens and travel grew 19%, with the index moving from 139 to 142. And let me clarify one point you made: regarding the guidance we had given pointing to the low 20s, that concerned the travel portion of it, which came in at 19%, or almost 20%. I do think that understanding the regional composition of our performance is worthwhile, and some of this is a bit repetitive, but I think it's important to walk through. Looking at it region by region helps. In LAC, CEMEA, Europe, and U.S. outbound, results were strong, indexing between 145 and 170 against 2019 levels. Second, U.S. inbound, which had lagged 2019 until Q4, also kept improving in Q1 and matched our expectations. In AP, we did see continued expansion in and out of AP, though somewhat slower than in Q4, and that was specific to Australia and Japan. It's probably also worth noting that, while not necessarily a large number, the war in the Middle East did have some effect on the cross-border figures as well. But again, stepping back, we feel really good about our cross-border business overall. The Q1 results were strong, with 16% growth and healthy growth for both travel and e-com, and we feel good about the outlook for the remainder of the year.
Jennifer Como
executiveLet's go to Jordan for the next question.
Ashwin Shirvaikar
analystHi Ryan, Chris, Jen — how's everyone doing? I'd like to dig into the expectations, or perhaps the implied expectations, for the back half of fiscal 2024, since Q1 came in at upper single digits and Q2 is expected to grow mid to high single digits; that implies an acceleration, and my question is: what's driving it?
Chris Suh
executiveYes, thank you. Let me split that into two questions, because first you asked how we feel about the revenue guide, and then I believe the second question implied was about drivers; so allow me to address both, since they differ somewhat. Perhaps I'll even begin with the second part, namely drivers. We're one quarter into the fiscal year with a solid quarter, with trends that are stable and stable versus Q4; and importantly, the consumer has stayed resilient. Looking toward the remainder of the year, we do expect drivers to keep ticking up modestly during the second half for two reasons. First, average ticket sizes ought to improve, especially as we lap lower ticket sizes from the second half of last year in the U.S., and we're seeing continued inflation in certain international regions. Second, we keep executing our growth initiatives across our global markets — for instance, the processing wins in LAC that we've previously shared progress on. So those are, roughly speaking, the underlying drivers; and then your first question was really about revenue; we got off to a solid start this year, a really good Q1, with stable Q4 trends. As of today, we've reaffirmed our full-year guide on net revenue in constant dollars, and that factors in the modest Reg II impact we discussed. So we feel good about Q1, we feel good about the outlook for the rest of the year, and we'll stay focused on execution.
Jennifer Como
executiveLet's take the next question from Jordan.
Timothy Chiodo
analystThanks a lot for fitting us in. I'd like to explore Pismo a bit more. On the website, they reference large banks, marketplaces, and fintechs, and earlier you talked about the shift away from legacy systems toward more modern cores. I'd like to hear about the ambitions and the potential when it comes to bank sizing, and also whether these core conversions are aimed at new products and what you might call sidecar cores? Or are we talking about the possibility that your core and issuing clients in the U.S., mid-sized banks, could eventually move their legacy core over to something Pismo offers?
Ryan McInerney
executiveLet me back up and, and spend a moment on how we came to find Pismo, and then I'll answer your question directly, Timothy. As I said in my prepared remarks, these narratives and priorities keep coming up from CEOs of banks all around the world, in the U.S., everywhere, medium-sized and large banks, and there are two: one, they're attempting to make the transition from their legacy tech stacks to the cloud, and two, they want to expand, particularly in emerging markets, where they, they lack sufficient options among issuer processors to support them. Hearing that repeatedly — over and over and over again — is what pushed us to scour the globe for what we judged the best cloud-based processor and core bank provider available, and that's how we arrived at Pismo. So although Pismo is headquartered down in Brazil, its platform operates globally. Its clients today span some of the largest and most sophisticated banks in the world along with medium-sized banks and fintechs. So they already serve a mix of different client types today; and our ambitions? Our ambitions are exactly what I stated in my prepared remarks, which is that we want this to become the preferred provider for banks around the world. You asked specifically about mid-sized banks in the U.S. and their core banking platform. The short answer is absolutely. When you consider large banks and their issuer processing capabilities, not just for debit, which we have today in the U.S., but for debit, credit, prepaid, commercial, not just in the U.S., but globally, we believe Pismo is absolutely a solution our issuers could be using around the world; so yeah, it is, it is a global platform. We have global ambitions. Given the relationships that we have, the privileged relationships that we have with banks big and small in the U.S; and around the world, we feel good about our ability to distribute the product to them.
Jennifer Como
executiveOne final question, Jordan.
Jason Kupferberg
analystThanks. I just wanted to check whether we remain comfortable with low double-digit growth in processed volume and transactions for this year. I know both began the year in the high single-digit range and then dipped somewhat in January. And has anything changed in your thinking on fiscal 2024 incentive guidance? As I recall, we expected modestly less dollar growth than in F-2023, yet you came in a bit better than expected in Q1. Thank you.
Chris Suh
executiveYes. Thanks, Jason. I believe I covered some of the driver questions, but let me quickly recap at a summary level. We are reaffirming the full-year outlook on drivers. The second half benefits from average ticket sizes in the U.S. and inflation in certain international regions, and we continue to execute against a number of our growth initiatives in global markets, with processing wins in LAC being the example I used a minute ago. So yes, on your first question about reaffirming the guide on drivers. And then, sorry, repeat your second question for me.
Jason Kupferberg
analystTurning to the incentive guide.
Chris Suh
executiveRegarding incentives — yes, yes, yes. On incentives, correct, and there's also no change to the full-year outlook. As you're aware, we run this business with an eye on net revenue growth. That is what we concentrate on. We've refreshed our full-year guidance, and Q2 as well on that front, and we'll keep doing what I said — concentrating on execution.
Jason Kupferberg
analystThank you, Chris.
Jennifer Como
executiveWonderful. On that note, we want to express our appreciation for your presence with us today. Should any further questions come to mind, don't hesitate to reach out by phone or email to our investor relations group. Once more, many thanks, and enjoy the rest of your day.
Operator
operatorThank you for your participation in today's conference. You may disconnect at this time.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Visa Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Visa Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Visa Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.