Visa Inc. (V) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
July 23, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Jennifer Como
executiveThanks. Good afternoon, everybody, and welcome to Visa's earnings call for the fiscal third quarter of 2024. With us today are Ryan McInerney, who serves as Visa's Chief Executive Officer, and Chris Suh, Visa's Chief Financial Officer. You can listen to this call via webcast on the Investor Relations portion of our site, investor.visa.com. A replay is going to remain archived on our site for 30 days. We've also posted a slide deck with financial and statistical highlights on our IR website. I'd also like to remind everyone that forward-looking statements are part of this presentation; such statements don't guarantee future performance, and a variety of factors could cause our actual results to differ materially. You can find additional details about those factors in our latest annual report on Form 10-K, along with any later reports on Forms 10-Q and 8-K, all of which are accessible on the SEC's website and in the Investor Relations portion of our website. Unless we note otherwise, our remarks today about financial results will present revenue on a GAAP basis, while all other results will be on a non-GAAP nominal basis. Today's earnings release and related materials on our IR website contain the corresponding GAAP measures and reconciliation. So with that, I'll hand things over to Ryan.
Ryan McInerney
executiveThanks for joining us this afternoon, everyone. We delivered a solid third quarter: net revenue came to $8.9 billion, an increase of 10% compared to a year ago, and EPS was 12% higher. If you strip out the impact of leap year, the underlying drivers of our business were fairly stable versus Q2. Adjusted for currency fluctuations, our total payments volume grew 7% from the prior year; within that, U.S. payments volume gained 5%, while international payments volume was up 10%. Cross-border volume, when you leave out transactions within Europe, grew 14%, and the number of processed transactions was 10% above last year's level. We just received the findings from our yearly global client engagement survey, and Visa's worldwide Net Promoter Score, known as NPS, came in at 76 — that's a 3-point improvement over the prior year. Our Net Promoter Score improved among all client categories — merchants, issuers, fintechs, and processors — and regional performance stayed solid too, with North America standing out thanks to a 6-point NPS increase. I want to express gratitude to each of our 30,000 employees, since their efforts made these outstanding results possible. As I go over some highlights from the quarter, you'll see how staying focused on serving clients — addressing what they need, pushing innovation, and supporting their growth — drives our momentum in consumer payments, new flows, and value-added services. Starting with consumer payments, we estimate a chance to capture over $20 trillion tied to cash, check, ACH, domestic schemes and other electronic payment methods. When we surveyed our clients about their engagement with us, they put our strategic partnership and our brand among the two most important elements behind successful relationships. Let me give you a few illustrations of how both showed up during the quarter. On strategic partnerships, we're always looking for ways to deliver additional value and grow alongside our clients; we're happy to report that Lloyds Banking Group has named us its Preferred Network Partner, which means our debit relationship has been renewed and our credit relationship has grown considerably, as we picked up 10 million additional credit credentials spanning the group's consumer and commercial business. Over in the U.K. as well, NatWest has rolled out a new Visa Travel Rewards credit card, which comes after we signed our partnership with them last year. Those clients are going to take advantage of a range of value-added offerings as well, such as controls for transactions and perks tied to their cards. Over in Europe, our partner was Raiffeisen Bank International AG, which holds a top position across multiple markets. Just recently, we extended our commercial arrangement in both the Czech Republic and Romania while also growing our consumer debit and credit operations there, which together represent more than 2 million possible new credentials. Turning to Korea, we strengthened the relationship we have with KB Kookmin Card, a top issuer in that country. This company already uses Visa Direct for moving money across borders and is both a consumer and commercial issuer with Visa. They're going to expand their consumer credit and debit portfolios alongside Visa, and they'll also take advantage of value-added services such as consulting and marketing. Over in Peru, we broadened our relationship with Banco de Crédito del Perú, a top issuer there, spanning consumer and commercial portfolios, and we intend to introduce more new flows offerings plus value-added services. Moving to the U.S., we renewed our deal with Wells Fargo. Through this, we continue to support Wells Fargo's ambition to reinvent its credit business and push further growth by leveraging key Visa strengths, among them consulting and Visa sponsorships such as FIFA and the Olympic and Paralympic Games. Now, on the brand side — the Olympics opening ceremony is this coming weekend, and it's really exciting to see the ways people connect with Visa. That shows up in activations around the world, from marketing efforts to experiences for cardholders to Visa cards carrying Olympic and Paralympic branding. In Europe specifically, I'm happy to report that count has now climbed to nearly 6 million cards, compared with the 5 million I mentioned just one quarter ago. We've also added roughly 100,000 more merchant locations across France in the lead-up to the Games. Another place our brand carries a lot of weight is in securing co-brand partnerships. For India, two things remain at the top of our list: growing how much credit we issue and building ties with well-off and cross-border shoppers. We are delighted to bring out a co-brand card together with Adani One and ICICI Bank. It's India's first co-branded credit card, and it gives their target base of 400 million customers solid airport-related benefits through the Adani One platform. We've also reached an agreement to launch another co-brand card with Tata Digital and a banking partner in India, which keeps up the momentum from the credit co-brand relationship we already have. This new co-brand offering includes a multicurrency prepaid foreign exchange card designed for travelers from India, and they'll get rewards from Tata Neu, Tata Digital's super app, as well. Across seven nations in Latin America, we are teaming up with Unicomer—a major retail and financial services company that owns numerous brands—to launch a co-brand credit card and simultaneously roll out CyberSource. Over in CEMEA, we signed a brand-new co-brand agreement with BinDawood, a leading grocery chain in Saudi Arabia that runs 88 locations and has over 5 million loyalty members. Turning to travel, we expanded our partnership with Malaysia Airlines, moving past a prepaid co-brand card targeting Millennials and Gen Z to add a fresh co-brand credit card designed for affluent travel lovers. Additionally, within the U.S., Turkish Airlines chose Visa as its sole network partner for the new Miles&Smiles co-brand credit card. Growing credentials, as we're doing through all the partnerships just described, plus expanding acceptance locations, sits at the heart of our consumer payment strategy. Wallets perfectly illustrate where this converges, since Visa can serve as a funding source, an embedded credential, and a payment method accepted by wallet merchants. That boosts the value proposition for wallet providers and those who use them. Two wallet standouts this quarter come from Peru and Vietnam. Yape, a Peruvian super app, has over 15 million users who already hold a Visa credential letting them transfer money between P2P apps through Visa Direct. Also, a little while back they introduced a Tap to Phone feature, which gives their more than 2 million merchants the ability to accept Visa; plus over in Vietnam, a market where about 50 million individuals are wallet users, the three largest digital wallets — MoMo, VNPAY, and ZaloPay — have started enabling their customers to fund transactions with Visa cards across over 500,000 QR acceptance spots operated by those wallets. One more area where we're putting a lot of emphasis is delivering checkout that's simple, easy, and secure. Let me share a few illustrations from the recent past. To start, we're combining Click to Pay with the Visa Payment Passkey Service, which enables a customer to confirm their identity using biometrics. Passkeys are already in use by hundreds of issuers throughout Europe, and a group of issuers that represent more than half of our e-commerce payment volume in Europe are running pilots on this offering. Also, we crossed 10 billion tokens this quarter, which is a significant milestone. In addition, Visa tokens generated an estimated over $40 billion in incremental e-commerce revenue for merchants globally during 2023 alone, while stopping more than $600 million in fraud. Another advantage involves unlocking more things you can do with a phone through tapping. Because tapping stands out as one of the best ways to handle transactions face to face, our goal is to expand tapping options for Visa cardholders. That includes using a tap to make a payment, to confirm who you are, to load a card, or to transfer funds to relatives and acquaintances.
Ryan McInerney
executiveAnd to wrap up, during this quarter, Tap to Pay rose 4 percentage points versus a year ago, reaching 80% of in-person transactions worldwide, not counting the U.S. Within the U.S., we went past 50%, and 30 American cities now show penetration above 60%. Turning now to new flows. In this quarter, new flows revenue was up 18% year-over-year in constant dollars, while Visa Direct overall transactions rose 41% for the quarter, hitting 2.6 billion, and commercial volumes climbed 7% year-over-year in constant dollars. Let me give a few updates, beginning with B2B, where our focus has been on breaking into new verticals and bringing innovative products and solutions to market. When it comes to health care, we're partnering with AXA and Paysure on a commercial virtual card offering designed to simplify how their customers worldwide handle claims. Our virtual card acceptance has grown as well, thanks to Cintas, a major business services provider serving over 1 million customers with uniform, safety, and fire protection solutions. Working together with Billtrust, we're going to help Cintas streamline payments, automate its processes, and control costs through Billtrust's Business Payments Network, known as BPN. We also just renewed our long-running BPN partnership with Billtrust, which connects suppliers and buyers so virtual card payments can be processed straight through, with rich data included that helps optimize acceptance costs. B2B offerings remain a major driver when it comes to securing new business and expanding existing relationships. Take the richer B2B data we now provide as an illustration. Through a partnership with Celero — a top provider of business financial management software — in Brazil, issuers gain a clearer picture of small business spending by pulling together information from cards, bank accounts, boletos, and other sources, enabling them to strengthen client relationships and launch attractive products. Then there's Spend Clarity, our expense program management tool that handles card issuance, controls, and reporting. Wells Fargo has put its own brand on this solution, calling it Wells One Expense Manager, and it has already attracted 6,000 corporate clients with more than 1 million users, who can now view their spending data. Moving on to Visa Direct, our transaction volume continued to rise thanks to both newly formed and broadened partnerships. Across the last twelve months, the number of Visa Direct cross-border P2P transactions has almost grown twofold, and the biggest regions were Europe and CEMEA. Within CEMEA, we're thrilled to announce that fintech Monobank has renewed its Visa Direct relationship with us, and has also renewed its consumer and commercial credit, debit, and prepaid portfolios. Over in Asia Pacific, we're working with China ZheShang Bank on cross-border capabilities that include Visa Direct and Currencycloud, enabling that bank to serve its merchant clients with cross-border payments. On the earnings call, we shared that Nuvei, a Canadian fintech, has broadened its partnership with us involving Visa Direct, covering every cross-border scenario across over 30 nations for the merchants they serve, and it just became Colombia's first Visa Direct enabler. In addition, we signed our inaugural worldwide deal with WorldRemit and Sendwave, which will let their users ultimately make Visa Direct cross-border remittances originating in 50 nations and reaching people in 130 nations. Quicklly, a top South Asian marketplace, has switched on Visa Direct cross-border remittance options for customers in the U.S., so money can now be sent to family and friends in India as well as the rest of South Asia. Turning to earned wage access, we closed a deal with Weavr, an Embedded Finance provider headquartered in the U.K. Beyond card issuance, they are going to leverage Visa Direct so that Weavr's business clients can provide employee expense reimbursement, reward and recognition, plus earned wage access. The earned wage access provider PayActiv, which supports 4,000 businesses, has renewed its contract with us and will turn on Visa+ for payouts. In a similar vein, we broadened our partnership with the enabler Astra. Beyond domestic disbursements, Astra will now provide cross-border remittances, roll out Visa+ to reach domestic wallets within the U.S., and grow into further use cases, such as payroll, earned wage access and marketplaces. Visa+ is still in its early days, though it's now completely launched and available to PayPal and Venmo customers, with more providers continuing to come on board. That wraps up new flows — we also extended a deal with FIS, a major issuer processing partner, so their clients can access a set of value-added services and new flows capabilities, Visa Direct included. Turning to value-added services: revenue there grew 23% in the third quarter on a constant-dollar basis. I'd like to highlight some of the progress we've achieved in driving adoption and growth throughout our value-added services portfolio. Let's begin with issuing solutions. Card benefits contributed a sizable chunk of the strong revenue increase we saw this quarter. Through them, our clients can put forward differentiated value propositions tailored to their own customer base across travel, entertainment, restaurants, insurance and other categories. Much of our third quarter expansion was driven by healthy premium card issuance across the majority of our regions. Take Latin America, for example, where travel perks have grown — over 370,000 separate visits have been made to our Visa Infinite airport lounge in Brazil, bringing in customers from a number of top issuers. On top of that, our Visa Infinite Fast Pass in Brazil, which gives cardholders a quicker route through airport security, has processed more than 1 million travelers since its 2022 debut. These are among the five best card perks in Brazil, and they deliver value for customers, issuers, and Visa. We continue to introduce additional benefits—for example, our recently announced collaboration with OpenTable—so eligible Visa cardholders can obtain hard-to-get restaurant bookings and experiences in the U.S., and we intend to expand that into Canada and Mexico. Within Acceptance Solutions, third quarter growth came from increased usage of both token services and e-commerce-related offerings. On the e-commerce side, one illustration is iFood, Brazil's biggest food delivery platform, which relies on our Verifi solution to prevent disputes from becoming chargebacks. Moreover, they will be adopting our authentication solutions; in Risk and Identity Solutions, we kept seeing robust adoption by new and existing clients, driven partly by growth in card-not-present transactions. Over in North America, Worldpay, which is an acquirer, is going to broaden how much it relies on the authentication offerings we provide through CardinalCommerce. That will encourage cooperation along with real-time, enhanced data sharing involving Worldpay merchants and issuers when card-not-present transactions happen, cutting fraud while letting a greater number of transactions be correctly authenticated and securely authorized. Another thing we're pleased about: Visa Protect — that's our product for scoring risk between accounts — ran a pilot with Pay.UK, and the results were outstanding. Over the three months of that pilot, fraud detection got better by 40% on average. On top of that, since the solution also did well in a pilot over there, we're now expanding Visa Protect into Argentina with COELSA, which is a core payments technology company. The remaining 2 value-added services are open banking and advisory services; working with Tink, we continue to bring on new partners throughout Europe and the U.S. And as I mentioned before, client demand keeps growing strongly for our consulting and marketing services, particularly when it comes to marquee events such as the Olympic and Paralympic Games. Our value-added services portfolio solutions remain strong and are generating meaningful growth both for our clients and for Visa. Before wrapping up, I wanted to address the fact that the court turned down the settlement that had been reached for the injunctive relief class. Naturally, we're disappointed by this ruling. It's our belief that the earlier settlement delivered meaningful relief to every merchant, and we'll keep working toward reaching another settlement.
Ryan McInerney
executiveIn wrapping up, through this fiscal year up to now, we've observed robust increases in both revenue and EPS, driven by volume and transaction growth that has been fairly steady. I'm still quite enthusiastic regarding what's in store for us going forward. Here at Visa, we show up to work in order to serve our clients and partners, and our attention is on creating and rolling out the strongest solutions we can in consumer payments, new flows, and value-added services. I'll now hand things over to Chris.
Chris Suh
executiveThank you, Ryan. Hello, everybody, and good afternoon. During the third quarter, we delivered yet another robust period, with growth that was comparatively steady across payments volume, cross-border volume, and processed transactions versus the second quarter once you account for the extra day from leap year. Measured in constant dollars, payments volume worldwide rose 7% compared with a year earlier, while cross-border volumes, leaving out transactions within Europe, climbed 14% versus the prior-year period. Processed transactions increased 10% from a year ago. Net revenue for the fiscal third quarter gained 10% on both a GAAP and a constant-dollar basis, which matched what we had anticipated. EPS rose 12% compared with last year and 13% in constant dollars. Let me now walk through the specifics. Within the United States, payment volume growth rates were broadly consistent with the second quarter once leap year is adjusted for, as total third-quarter payments volume increased 5% versus a year earlier, and both credit and debit likewise rose 5%. Card-present volume was up 2%, while card-not-present volume was up 7%. Inside the U.S., although growth among the high spend consumer segment held steady relative to earlier quarters, we observed a modest softening in the lower spend consumer segment. Turning to markets outside the U.S., total payments volume climbed 10% in constant dollars, which was fairly steady compared with the second quarter after adjusting for leap year. Looking at the quarter, we saw strong payments volume increases in the majority of key regions — Latin America, CEMEA, and Europe excluding the U.K. all delivered growth of more than 16% on a constant-dollar basis. In Asia Pacific, payments volume growth slowed to just below 0.5 point year over year in constant dollars for the quarter, driven mainly by the macroeconomic environment, particularly in Mainland China. Turning to cross-border volume, my comments today will be in constant dollars and will exclude transactions within Europe. Cross-border volume overall was up 14% in Q3, which is fairly consistent with Q2 when you adjust for the leap year. Cross-border card-not-present volume growth, once you strip out travel and adjust for cryptocurrency purchases, came in at a mid-teens rate, helped by continued momentum in retail. Cross-border travel volume growth likewise came in at the mid-teens, or 157% when indexed to 2019. During this quarter, the inbound Asia Pacific Index improved 9 points at a pace similar to the second quarter, reaching 151% of 2019. However, the improvement in Asia Pacific outbound travel decelerated from the second quarter, with the index rising by under 1 point to 125% of 2019; the same primary drivers we identified last quarter remain in place, with some added pressure coming from macroeconomic conditions. Let's now go through our third quarter financial results. I'll begin with the revenue components. On the service revenue side, we saw an 8% gain compared with a year earlier, matching the 8% increase in second-quarter constant dollar payments volume. Revenue yield came in better than the prior quarter and also above last year's level, which we attribute to improved use of card benefits. Data processing revenue climbed 9%, while processed transactions grew 10%, leaving revenue yield roughly unchanged on both a sequential basis and versus a year ago. International transaction revenue was 9% higher, compared with a 14% increase in constant dollar cross-border volume when intra-Europe is excluded; the comparison was constrained because last year included elevated currency volatility. Average volatility readings were in line with what we saw in the previous quarter. Other revenue jumped 31%, driven primarily by robust consulting and marketing services revenue connected to the Olympics, along with a lesser contribution from pricing. Client incentives rose 11%. Now let's look at the three areas driving our growth. Within consumer payments, the lift was driven by payments volume, cross-border volume and processed transactions, each expanding at relatively stable rates. New flows revenue climbed 18% compared to a year earlier on a constant-dollar basis. Visa Direct transactions grew 41% versus the prior year, helped by gains in Latin America linked to interoperability across P2P apps. Commercial volumes were up 7% year-over-year in constant dollars. Value-added services revenue for Q3 grew 23% in constant dollars, hitting $2.2 billion, primarily powered by Issuing and Acceptance Solutions along with Advisory Services. Operating expenses increased 14%, mostly due to bigger general and administrative, personnel and marketing costs, which included spending related to the Olympics. FX was a 0.5 point headwind, compared with the 1.5 point tailwind we had expected. Pismo ended up being about a 1 point subtraction. We saw nonoperating income of $73 million. Tax rate was 18.8%, and earnings per share reached $2.42 — up 12% versus a year ago — though currency movements took off around 1.5 points and Pismo took off around 0.5 points. In Q3 we bought back about $4.8 billion of our shares and returned more than $1 billion to stockholders through dividends. Our buyback authorization had $18.9 billion left in it at the close of June. Now let's look at July through the 21st, focusing on volume growth in constant dollars. When we say cross-border, we're leaving out intra-Europe. U.S. payments volume climbed 4%, with debit rising 4% and credit rising 3%, both compared with the same period last year. It doesn't look like one single cause explains why things slowed down a bit compared with Q3. More likely, several smaller things are at play — the weather, when promotional shopping events landed, the technology outage, and others like that. Cross-border volume was up 13% versus the same period a year earlier, which is under what we saw in Q3, with travel-related volume expanding a little less, still feeling pressure from Asia Pacific, while card-not-present ex travel volume grew at rates comparable to Q3. Processed transactions climbed 9% year-over-year. Now let's turn to what we expect going forward. As a reminder, adjusted basis means non-GAAP results in constant dollars, leaving out acquisition impacts. More information on these disclosures is available in our earnings presentation. We'll begin with the fourth quarter. Looking ahead, we anticipate that both payments volume and processed transactions will increase by roughly the same percentage as they did in Q3. On the total cross-border volume side, our projection has it finishing a touch under what Q3 delivered. Through July 21, currency volatility is still hovering near its weakest average in about four years. Because of that, we're revising what we had assumed for currency volatility in Q4, and we now expect it to remain comparable to Q3's levels. As for incentives, this should be the smallest year-over-year rise we see across the entire year. To sum up everything, for adjusted net revenue we're looking at growth in the low double digits, which works out to a modest uptick compared with the 10% adjusted revenue growth rate we saw in the third quarter; for Q4, our adjusted operating expenses should rise in the high single digits. We expect nonoperating income to land somewhere between $40 million and $50 million. As for the tax rate in Q4, we anticipate it will come in around 19% to 19.5%, and that puts Q4 adjusted EPS growth in the upper portion of low double digits. Now let's move on to the full year. Since 3 quarters are behind us, our outlook for adjusted net revenue growth across the full year stays the same as the guidance we gave at the beginning of the year. Even as we take on the effects of reduced currency volatility along with macroeconomic difficulties in Asia that have weighed on volumes, we continue to anticipate achieving low double-digit adjusted net revenue growth for the entire year. Adjusted operating expense growth for the full year is going to land in the high single digit to low double digits, which mirrors the less favorable FX impact. That puts our full-year adjusted EPS increase in the low teens. To close things out, this quarter delivered solid performance, as revenue from new flows and value-added services grew at a faster pace than consumer payments. We deepened existing ties, added new customers, and invested capital in building inventive offerings and solutions — all of which positions us for continued expansion down the road. So, Jennifer, let's move into Q&A right now.
Jennifer Como
executiveThanks, Chris. And with that, we're ready to take questions.
Darrin Peller
analystI'd like to start right here. It's obvious that the pace of growth in U.S. volume has softened to some degree. It would be helpful if you could walk us through how much of that you view as structural and how much as cyclical — I think that's a sensible place to begin. Beyond that, though, the real question concerns your capacity to deliver revenue growth in the double digits when U.S. volume is expanding only 4%, 5%, or 6% — mid-single digits — with value-added services and cross-border providing the lift. Could you give us some insight into whether you think the company can actually grow revenues at those rates despite the U.S. volume trends we're currently seeing?
Chris Suh
executiveDarrin, I'll take the U.S. piece first, then perhaps we can step back and tackle the more long-range part of what you asked. Within the U.S., when you strip out the effect of leap year, drivers during Q3 looked steady compared with Q2. Payment volumes rose 5% for the third quarter. Across the 21 days that followed, during July, that number slipped to 4%. Let me lay out the whole picture for you. So to put those figures in context: 4% over the 21 days, against 5% in Q3. To understand what happened during those three weeks, we looked closely at the various causes and influences, and quite a bit was happening. A few of these were brought up earlier on this call, and I can go into more detail now. To start, Hurricane Beryl, a significant storm, hit Texas along with other nearby areas of the U.S. Second, I brought up when promotional e-commerce events took place. Let me elaborate on that point somewhat. This year, those events occurred at a later point, and with e-commerce, the charge to customers happens at the moment goods are shipped. So a portion of those shipments didn't make it into the 21-day window, which explains why that period looked slightly different versus the same stretch last year. Then there's the third thing — the big technology outage late last week, which played a role too. So looking at all of it, there wasn't one thing alone that accounts for the 1 point shift between Q3 and the early part of July. Still, taking everything into account, we're feeling fairly positive about how the three weeks came out. And on the second piece of what you asked — the low double digits as it relates to cross-border, VAS, and CMS — let me work my way into that. Our value-added services have been delivering reliably robust results — revenue above $2 billion, with expansion exceeding 20% across a long string of consecutive quarters. Beyond that, we're seeing momentum throughout Issuing Solutions, Acceptance, and Advisory. That's a segment whose trajectory gives us a lot of confidence. Then there's our newer flows operation, which grew 18% this quarter, as Ryan mentioned. We've now recorded double-digit-percentage gains in the teens for two quarters running. Solid execution, dependable volumes, and Visa Direct activity climbing at a faster rate. As you know, that business can also swing quarter to quarter when it comes to the growth rates we saw in the first half of the year. Still, overall, I’m quite encouraged by how that business keeps performing strongly. Then when it comes to cross-border — well, cross-border. Perhaps I should step back for a moment and discuss cross-border and what we have witnessed over time. If you remember, before the pandemic, cross-border expanded, travel rose around the high single digits to low double digits, while e-commerce, roughly 1/3 of the business, increased into the teens, at times into the mid-teens. Naturally, the pandemic arrived. During the pandemic, travel dropped dramatically while e-commerce took off. Now that we're past the pandemic, e-commerce makes up roughly 40% of the business, and its growth has settled down—it's back to where it was before the pandemic. So you could say e-commerce, on that 40% of cross-border business, is growing in the teens. As for travel, after the big rebound once the pandemic ended, things have gotten back to normal. Pinpointing exactly where it—where it'll ultimately land is a bit tricky, but the growth we've seen has been solid. We've been watching it continue to normalize. Still, what we understand on a structural level is this: since e-commerce now represents a bigger portion of the business, that gives overall cross-border growth a tailwind. As a result, we believe that relative to what's spent domestically, this will stay solid. That's all from me — and naturally, Ryan or anybody else, feel free to chime in if there's more to cover.
Ryan McInerney
executiveNo, nothing to add for me, Chris. Thanks, Darrin.
Andrew Jeffrey
analystThe 23% increase in value-added services this quarter was really impressive, and Chris, as you noted, that segment is getting close to 25% of overall revenue, so it may be fueling over half of the growth in consolidated revenue. Could you discuss when we should expect value-added services to start lifting Visa's overall growth trajectory?
Ryan McInerney
executiveAndrew, this is Ryan. I appreciate the question. And yes, we're thrilled not just with our results in value-added services growth for this quarter. What we've consistently achieved for a number of years now, ever since we laid out the strategy for all of you and got really deliberate regarding our go-to-market strategy. I mean, going back to 2021, I believe, we generated roughly $5 billion in revenue; in 2022, $6 billion. The prior year was $7 billion. As you noted, we hit $2.2 billion this quarter, a 23% increase. So I believe what we've demonstrated is steady expansion each quarter and annually across these businesses. And we're extremely bullish on what lies ahead. I mean, we see the opportunities across really 3 distinct areas. The first is we offer a range of value-added services, a few of which Chris described in his earlier response, that are heavily aimed at boosting value for Visa transactions. Risk offerings such as Visa Secure, dispute solutions such as Visa Resolve Online, card perks, as I referenced in my prepared comments. And we've — that has traditionally been the biggest portion of our value-added services operation, and we've proven we can achieve strong growth there. More and more, we're developing a suite of services that provide value for non-Visa transactions. We've undertaken some initiatives in this area previously. A few of our platforms such as CyberSource, Authorize.net, Verifi. But then you've heard me discuss over the past couple of quarters about broadening our risk capabilities, for instance, to not only additional card networks but also to RTP and account-to-account services. And I brought up the excellent outcomes we've achieved in both the U.K. and in Argentina on that front. And then the third opportunity area for us is extending our value-added services past payments. In the past, we've offered things such as Visa Consulting and Analytics and our marketing services and a few of the open banking services provided by Tink, but we're continuing to develop a portfolio of value-added services for our clients and partners past payments. Things such as the cyber protection capabilities that we've been introducing to the market; so we've shown steady growth; we think we'll keep showing steady growth. We have a product pipeline and a go-to-market strategy globally with a varied set of clients, and we're confident about the opportunity.
Bryan Keane
analystChris, I'd like to ask about incentives and what the lowest expectation will be for Q4. Could you discuss what portion of that comes from volume versus the number of renewals you're observing? And as we look toward the next fiscal year, what type of growth, or sustainable growth, should we consider for incentives?
Chris Suh
executiveThanks for asking. Let me take us back a bit to what we expected for incentives when entering the fiscal year. When fiscal '23 closed, that was a strong year for us regarding renewal volume, somewhat above our usual normal cadence. That affected our thinking on incentive volumes in FY '24; and even last year, we experienced a different growth rate in the first half versus the second half; so as we examined this year, we had a somewhat reduced volume of renewals this year. Clearly, year-to-date incentives have unfolded a bit differently, mostly because of client performance, deal timing, and similar factors. And on the whole, it's been better than — it's been lower, I suppose, than what we expected. As we enter Q4, roughly the same pattern holds. We still anticipate Q4 will gain from lapping the elevated incentives we saw in the second half of last year, which again shapes the growth rate we expect in Q4; we don't have much to say about FY 2025 right now, but we'll say a great deal on the next earnings call.
Ken Suchoski
analystI'd like to ask about VAS, and I believe the team has mentioned that a portion of VAS revenue moves in line with transaction growth. However, other pieces of that business are either more recurring or less recurring. Could you help us grasp how you view VAS cyclicality and how that business could fare if volume growth slows? Also, I believe the team has discussed pricing for value in VAS. So how much additional room remains there? And in what way does that support the business's resiliency?
Ryan McInerney
executiveKen, this is Ryan. Regarding the second part of what you asked, how well we can price for value depends on the value we deliver to the market, and we feel terrific about the value we deliver to the market. I believe you can see that in our results. Throughout the different areas — Issuing solutions, Acceptance Solutions, Risk and Identity Solutions, Advisory — we simply keep delivering products and services that in the end help our clients expand their business, help our clients cut fraud, increase authorizations, things like that. And we're confident we'll keep doing that, and we're confident we'll keep being able to price for value. As I think I mentioned earlier, the largest share of our value-added services depends on Visa transactions. So clearly, as Visa transactions rise or fall, that has an effect, but so does how well we sell additional services. On prior calls, I've noted that most of our clients still haven't reached the kind of penetration and depth that we've managed to achieve with others. So as we keep penetrating our clients everywhere in the world across the different markets we serve, as I said earlier, in response to the earlier question, I'm highly optimistic about our capacity to keep growing this business the way we have.
Tien-Tsin Huang
analystI'm just wondering — have you revised your outlook for the U.S. during the back half of the year, and do you still anticipate that transaction sizes will pick up speed domestically, particularly in Q4?
Chris Suh
executiveTien-Tsin, I appreciate that question. Absolutely — as you're aware, we'd projected that ATS growth would strengthen as this year progressed, quarter by quarter, and that's indeed what happened. ATS got better during the third quarter. In the U.S. specifically, ATS came in a touch stronger in Q3 versus Q2. It reached essentially flat on a year-over-year basis in Q3. Sequentially, we observed gains across quite a few categories — restaurant, QSR, fuel, telecom, utilities, insurance, just to name several; and we expect that in Q4 we'll again keep seeing modest sequential gains. The single thing — the single caution I'd flag is that fuel prices might affect that path, so we'll be monitoring it carefully. So yes, things are unfolding the way we expected. The pace differs somewhat from our expectations, but improvement keeps happening, and I believe that's what matters.
Gustavo Gala
analystCould we spend a moment on how far contactless payments have spread? Perhaps you could point out how much the adoption rate differs between some of your longer-standing cardmembers and the younger ones? I'm simply attempting to estimate what an ultimate ceiling on penetration might be.
Ryan McInerney
executiveWhat you're getting at — let me make sure I have this right — is Tap to Pay?
Gustavo Gala
analystYes.
Ryan McInerney
executiveYeah, sure — perhaps let me step back and frame the larger picture first. The reality is that beyond America's borders, 8 of every 10 Visa transactions done in person anywhere on the globe are now Tap to Pay, and that alone demonstrates how this spans every segment, every demographic, every use case, every kind of product. Worldwide we've reached 80% overall; I believe over 55 nations have now crossed 90% contactless penetration. So in an increasing number of countries, for an increasing number of customers, across an increasing number of products globally, tapping has simply become the standard method of payment. And here in the U.S., adoption is developing precisely as we anticipated, grounded in what we've witnessed across more than 100 countries worldwide. As I mentioned during my prepared remarks, 1 in every 2 U.S. transactions today is a tap. In a market such as New York City, where plenty of you listening spend your time, we now exceed 75%. So in New York City — an early transit adopter — we're past, I believe, 75%-plus of all in-person transactions. That figure has climbed from only 50% 2 years back. So once more, at that penetration level in a market the scale of New York City, it holds across products, issuers, segments and so forth; therefore, as this expansion keeps unfolding, buyers and sellers alike adore tapping as a payment method. And we expect that growth to keep speeding up in a market like the U.S.
Will Nance
analystA lot of inquiries have come our way regarding the updates on litigation, and I completely get why the degree of uncertainty has risen so much at this point; but I suppose the question we hear most often from investors concerns what might happen to the broader ecosystem if interchange rates end up being cut far more than what had been put forward. And I suppose more specifically, how those production and interchange rates might echo through renewal talks with issuers, and then over a longer horizon, how this could shape where incentives and net yields are headed; so I was just curious whether we might get some sense of your view regarding a possible reduction, or a bigger reduction, in the total scale of ecosystem revenue, and whether that alters where any of the main metrics we track are trending across time.
Ryan McInerney
executiveWill, I appreciate the question; and what you're asking about is the MDL litigation. I suppose I'll just start from the beginning. The initial point I'd make is that we disagree strongly with what the judge decided. Our view is that the settlement was fair. Our view is that the settlement gave all merchants meaningful relief. The next point I'd make is that a number of considerations were not taken into account by that decision, particularly the intricate multisided ecosystem in which we function, the part that — the intricate part that numerous participants across the ecosystem played; but even so, we are working toward a revised settlement. Speculating about what that settlement will look like is premature. So today I simply won't do that. But I'd want everyone to remember that a settlement may come at any moment before, during, or even after the trial. So just bear that in mind while the process unfolds.
Timothy Chiodo
analystI'd like to ask about something that covers both incentives and value-added services revenue at once — the idea of value in-kind incentives. Could you discuss whether these are getting more common, meaning you're relying on them a bit more when you talk with issuers? And then, if you could, quickly walk through the mechanics of revenue recognition, contra revenue, the addition to deferred revenue, and finally the value-added services revenue.
Ryan McInerney
executiveSure. Let me give you the top-level view here. Value in-kind is an excellent method for us, as the term suggests, to provide value to our clients. And more and more, our clients — as you can see from our performance — would rather purchase our value-added services than simply accept incentives that might flow down to the bottom line. So that's definitely something our clients are requesting more often. It's something that helps our clients expand their businesses. Earlier I discussed, over just the past several years, our product pipeline, the way we've approached the market, the way we've created new products into solutions and services for our clients. And that is what's fueling the demand. So that has sort of turned into a bigger piece of our client renewals and the conversations we have about renewing clients; and more and more, value-added services are becoming a means for us to stand apart with our clients and grow our consumer payments business. Would you like to cover the organics?
Chris Suh
executiveTim, regarding the second portion of what you asked, perhaps I’ll simply provide a summary at a high level. I believe you already have the components you mentioned. Broadly speaking, if in-kind value is provided instead of a cash incentive, it would be recorded as a reduction of revenue when it is awarded or earned, based on what the contract specifies. Then, conversely, when that in-kind value can be used by the client for services from Visa, often within our value-added services business, it is recorded as revenue at that point, and the related expenses are likewise recorded in our P&L.
James Faucette
analystI'd like to pose a follow-up regarding short-term patterns. Over the past 2 months, we've observed credit slowing somewhat more than debit, and previously that has served as something of a signal of pressure on consumers. So I'm curious what your take on that is; and it appears you expect, for the remainder of the September quarter, a slight pickup in pace once we move beyond certain problems you called out in July. I simply want to confirm I have that right and sort of how we ought to read the current slight divergence between credit and debit growth.
Ryan McInerney
executiveLet me offer a bit of background, and then Chris, please jump in or fix anything. As Chris mentioned, 3 weeks of the quarter are behind us; a hurricane hit. A tech outage occurred nationwide. A number of events took place; so we aren't treating 3 weeks as a trend. We'll watch how matters develop going forward, purely in terms of what occurs over the balance of the quarter. I don't know whether you'd like to address the credit-debit divergence.
Chris Suh
executiveYeah. So, let me circle back to something we mentioned earlier, and we're looking at how things came out in July. On that call, I also noted that we're observing some softening among what I'd describe as the cohorts in the lower spending tier; and I believe that ties somewhat to certain volume figures we're seeing this quarter, specifically around credit compared with debit; but overall, when we compare it against, once again, Q2 and Q3, it looks fairly steady once you account for the day-count effect from leap year.
Bryan Bergin
analystI'd like to ask about new flows; you've seen a good pickup in growth across the past 2 quarters on steady comps. Could you give us more detail on which specific areas have strengthened? I'm aware Visa Direct was among them. I'm just wondering whether you believe that pace of expansion can hold, or if it might ease somewhat?
Chris Suh
executiveAppreciate the question. 18% growth, as I noted, we feel quite positive about how we're executing and the momentum in the business. There's a huge opportunity ahead of us in both our commercial business and money movement with Visa Direct. You're probably aware of the figures, 41% growth in transactions along with stable commercial volumes. Regarding the acceleration you mention, we faced a unique circumstance in Q1 when certain onetime items significantly held down the reported growth in Q1. When you consider the past couple of quarters, I believe that's more indicative of the business's underlying health. That being said, as we observed in Q1, that growth rate may fluctuate quarter-to-quarter depending on deal timing and terms, plus onetime items such as the one that hit Q1. So on the whole, at the macro level, momentum is good. The underlying business is healthy, and we keep seeing that level of growth. And the growth rate ought to be healthier and ought to keep rising faster than consumer payments, with some normal expected variability quarter-to-quarter.
Ryan McInerney
executiveAdding to what Chris said, my view is that Visa Direct is still at a really nascent point in its expansion. There were lots and lots of years devoted to putting money into and constructing the platform, the infrastructure, the connectivity — home market and cross-border alike — plus collaboration with issuers, acquirers, and processors. That now leaves us in a position to sell everywhere globally, uncovering fresh use cases, a number of which I called out during my prepared remarks. Cast your mind back to 2019: 2 billion Visa Direct transactions were processed by us. This quarter, the figure reached 2.6 billion transactions. That stands as one more strong illustration of how, whenever we methodically pinpoint what the market requires, we put in the time and construct the infrastructure; we have built 8.5 billion end points, along with the connectivity, reliability, security, and fraud capabilities. My honest view is that we remain at a really nascent point regarding what lies ahead for this business's growth, the volume of use cases, and the partners — plenty of whom I called out during my prepared remarks — who will wish to develop their use cases atop this platform.
Sanjay Sakhrani
analystI believe nearly everything I wanted to ask has already been covered. However, regarding that final item you brought up, Ryan, I'm curious about where things stand in terms of how yield has developed there. As you keep growing within certain of those segments through Visa Direct, could those move upward? And regarding Reg II, has the entire effect of Reg II already been baked into the run rate, or ought we to anticipate some uncertainties tied to it?
Ryan McInerney
executiveSure. I'll address both; regarding the first, the use cases are still at an early stage of their evolution. After all, earned wage access wasn't something we discussed just a couple of years back, Sanjay; and so as we've progressed — I believe we currently have roughly 65 use cases on the platform, and our teams keep discovering new ones constantly. Thus I think we'll keep witnessing the evolution of all of that, and the economics surrounding it will unfold over time. What I'd direct you toward is something I brought up during my prepared remarks, the enormous success we're enjoying in cross-border. We've done really well selling new use cases and generating cross-border transaction growth in Visa Direct. As you're aware, yields run higher in cross-border, because of the value we provide. So once more, we feel good about all of that. Now, I'd like to stress regarding Reg II that the e-commerce debit market is highly competitive and will remain competitive for as long as we can foresee. So although Chris mentioned, I believe mentioned that the impact has stayed the same, we haven't observed any shift in impact, and we don't anticipate any shift in impact for the fourth quarter. It's a competitive business. We're out there alongside clients every single day, assisting them in grasping the advantages of processing transactions on Visa. And those advantages are numerous, which is why we feel good thus far in the evolution of Reg II regarding how we've managed to grow that business. We feel terrific about what a Visa data transaction can offer, much of which I've discussed on these calls previously. So we're out there, we're competing, we're selling, we're delivering our products, and we feel good about our win rate.
Jason Kupferberg
analystI'd like a bit of clarification regarding revenue, and then I have a question about volumes for this fiscal year. From what I'm hearing, for Q4 you're expecting revenue growth of roughly 11% to 12%. My sense is that would land you at the bottom of the low double-digit guidance you're keeping for the year. That's the piece I hoped you could clarify. Then, on volumes: I believe you mentioned Q4 ought to match Q3, which as I understand it would take the full year to roughly 7%, compared with the high single-digit updated guide given last quarter. So, as we begin adjusting our models for next year, which possible accelerants above that 7% mark ought we to be thinking about?
Chris Suh
executiveJason, let's break that down. Several items were packed into your question, and I want to be — I believe this matters, so let's make it completely clear. For Q4, the guidance I'm giving, meaning our guidance, for adjusted net revenue in Q4 is low double digits. Beyond that, the directional guidance I provided is that it would come in a bit higher than the Q3 figure we reported, which represented 10% growth during the quarter; so take those 2 elements and I'd triangulate somewhere in that vicinity; and that still brings you, mathematically speaking, to the bottom of low double digits, to use your phrasing, for the entire year. The second item concerned drivers between Q3 and Q4. I did state that for payment volume and payment transactions, our expectation is that Q4 will be consistent with Q3. The single exception involves cross-border, which I said would come in a bit under Q3 levels. That is essentially driven by the travel circumstances and situation in Asia that we've discussed at length, with outbound travel in Asia, specifically, taking a hit and bouncing back more slowly than we had expected when the year began. So those are the 2 variables that — to make the Q4 guidance align with the intent I communicated. Now, regarding FY '25, we're at the early stage of planning, and as is always our practice, our expectations for '25 will be shared at the end of Q4.
Dan Perlin
analystI suppose this is more of a broad, strategic one for you, Ryan. Regarding what you've put into AI and GenAI, I believe at conferences you've mentioned wanting to create your own large language model. So first, where do those efforts currently stand? Second, what do you anticipate for initial applications of that spending, and what sort of payback timeline? And third, could there be a chance to generate genuinely additional revenue or improved results for your merchant partners, rather than only for the banks?
Ryan McInerney
executiveYeah. Dan, I appreciate the AI question. To begin with, the way to think about it is that at Visa we are fully committed to GenAI, just as we have been fully committed to predictive AI for over 10 years; we're putting it to work in 2 distinct, broad ways. The first involves rolling it out throughout the organization to boost efficiency, and we're achieving tangible outcomes there; we're experiencing excellent outcomes, strong uptake, significant efficiency gains spanning technology, accounting, sales, everywhere in the company. The second involves using generative AI to improve the whole payment ecosystem. As for the second part of what you asked, without a doubt. Maybe I could offer a single group of illustrations, or a few of the risk instruments and functionalities we've brought to market. I brought up the risk offerings we employ on RTP and account-to-account transactions. That presents a chance to cut fraud, for merchants as well as issuers. I believe I noted during an earlier call that we have our Visa Provisioning Intelligence Service, which relies on artificial intelligence to anticipate token provisioning fraud ahead of when it occurs. That too helps both issuers and merchants; and there are many more examples; so we're quite enthusiastic about the beneficial effects generative AI might deliver, not merely for our internal efficiency but for our capacity to assist in generating higher sales and diminished fraud throughout the ecosystem.
Harshita Rawat
analystRyan, Chris, a 5% rise in U.S. card volume on the surface points to a market that's somewhat more mature. I do get that card volume growth and PC growth sit in different categories, and that's what drives the gap here. Ryan, you went over your worldwide data figure of $20 trillion for consumer payments at Visa. When it comes to the U.S., your largest market, how should we frame the secular digitization opportunity and the growth algorithm?
Ryan McInerney
executiveOkay. Harshita, we had a bit of trouble hearing you, but I believe I caught the essence of what you asked regarding the growth algorithm for consumer payments, particularly in mature markets. So, as I've mentioned previously, we look at an opportunity exceeding $20 trillion globally. Incidentally, roughly 1/4 of that sits in the U.S. And that covers cash, checks, ACH, electronic transactions, cards running on domestic networks, and so on. We're seizing that opportunity in a few distinct manners. First is to keep broadening acceptance and broadening the locations where cards can be used. Rent in the U.S. would be a prime illustration; we've enjoyed quite solid success making inroads into the rent vertical. Second is to make it simpler to fuel e-commerce growth and e-commerce transactions, which has an outsourced effect on what we can do to drive growth at Visa for those sorts of things; and third is simply to keep innovating with new products and services that make our issuers want to issue Visa and consumers want to use them. At our Visa Payments Forum this year, we rolled out a full slate of new product innovations. And those are the kinds of products that we think will help us prevail in the marketplace and help us capture and digitize a substantial portion of that opportunity on the Visa network.
Jennifer Como
executiveThat brings us to the end of today's call, and we appreciate your time with us. Should anything else come to mind, you're welcome to reach out by phone or email to our Investor Relations team. Thanks once more, and enjoy the rest of your day.
Operator
operatorWe appreciate everyone joining us for Visa's earnings conference call covering the fiscal third quarter of 2024. That wraps up the call for today. You're free to hang up now, and we hope the remainder of your day goes well.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Visa Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Visa Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Visa Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.