Visa Inc. (V) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

October 29, 2024

New York Stock Exchange US Financials Financial Services earnings 61 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Jennifer Como

executive
#1

Thanks, and good afternoon, everybody. Welcome to Visa's earnings call for the fiscal fourth quarter and full year 2024. With us are Ryan McInerney, our Chief Executive Officer, and Chris Suh, our Chief Financial Officer. You can hear this call via webcast on the Investor Relations portion of our site, investor.visa.com. We'll keep a replay archived there for 30 days. Also on our IR website, a slide deck with financial and statistical highlights has been posted. I should also note that forward-looking statements are part of this presentation. Such statements aren't guarantees of future performance, and a number of factors could cause our actual results to differ materially. You can find more information about those factors in our latest annual report on Form 10-K, along with any later reports on Forms 10-Q and 8-K, all of which are on the SEC's website and in the Investor Relations portion of our website. Unless we say otherwise, our remarks today about financial results will show revenue on a GAAP basis, while all other results will be on a non-GAAP nominal basis. Today's earnings release and related materials on our IR website contain the related GAAP measures and reconciliation. With that, I'll hand things over to Ryan.

Ryan McInerney

executive
#2

Thanks for joining us this afternoon, everyone. Our fourth quarter was excellent: net revenue came in at $9.6 billion, up 12% from a year earlier, and EPS was 16% higher. Our main business drivers were pretty stable versus Q3; on a constant-dollar basis, overall payments volume grew 8% year-over-year, U.S. payments volume was up 5%, and international payments volume rose 10%. Cross-border volume, excluding transactions within Europe, grew 13%, and processed transactions rose 10% year-over-year. Reflecting on the quarter and the entire fiscal year, I'm tremendously proud of the more than 31,000 Visa employees, whose dedication to carrying out our strategy and providing clients with strong solutions drove the company's impressive results. By prioritizing how we design and innovate our products, we sustained growth in our consumer payments segment. When it comes to new flows, the focused strategy we've applied to nonconsumer payments is producing measurable outcomes. Meanwhile, in value-added services, we've deepened ties with clients across a range of solutions and continued bringing our services to non-Visa transactions — all of which we achieved while expanding our portfolio of offerings even further. Now let's turn to a few standout items from Q4 and the full year. On the consumer payments side, we continued to expand credentials and acceptance. Our credentials now exceed 4.6 billion, a 7% increase year-over-year, and we have 11.5 billion tokens, with over 30% of our transactions now tokenized. Merchant locations worldwide climbed past 150 million. Paris 2024's summer games, both Olympic and Paralympic, gave our numbers a real boost — over seven million cards carrying the event's branding went out, and European merchants accepting our payments grew by upwards of 130,000 locations. What's got me particularly enthusiastic are the fresh ways people can pay. Take Cantaloupe, for example — a top player in unattended retail spanning areas like automated food and drink sales, running north of a million live machines worldwide and processing beyond a billion transactions each year; we've just extended our partnership there. Meanwhile, in the Netherlands, we struck a deal with Albert Heijn, that country's biggest supermarket chain, so every Visa product now works at their in-store terminals. And stateside, our arrangement with AppFolio for handling rent payments was renewed not long ago as well. In property management software, AppFolio ranks among the biggest providers, handling over 8 million units for a customer base exceeding 20,000. All year long, we've kept pushing innovation forward so that Visa's capabilities extend beyond cards into other payment types. During this quarter, we introduced Visa A2A, which applies Visa's brand strength, infrastructure, rules, and consumer protections to make account-to-account payments simpler, safer, and more secure. Working alongside banks such as NatWest and Nationwide Building Society, plus prominent fintechs like Modular, is something we're thrilled about, since together we can deliver a solution driven by the industry that unlocks the full potential of account-to-account transactions in the U.K. Visa A2A is now available, and any bank that qualifies, open banking provider, or verified biller can take part. At the start, we're aiming this at bill payments, with a U.K. launch planned for 2025. Bringing this to market is something we're genuinely enthusiastic about. Previously, I mentioned our offering for evaluating fraud exposure across accounts — Visa Protect for A2A payments. It was just awarded the Platinum Winner title for Fraud & Security Innovation of the Year by Juniper Research, and we'll conduct pilots across 10 more RTP networks at some point in 2025. Beyond that, demand has been very strong for our new Flexible Credential, which allows a person to access multiple payment methods using 1 Visa credential. Hundreds of issuers sit in our pipeline, and we've got multiple launches on the calendar for 2025 across the U.S., Asia Pacific, Europe and CEMEA. During the previous quarter, I talked about broadening the tapping use cases available on a mobile device. Tap to add card is now switched on by issuers in over 15 countries spanning our 5 regions. As we see it, transit plays a major role in driving tapping adoption, and worldwide tap-to-ride transactions passed 2 billion for the first time in fiscal year 2024, a 25% increase year-over-year. Over the course of the year, we brought on over 110 additional transit systems in cities including Boston, Athens, Beijing, Las Vegas, and Lima, bringing the total worldwide to over 870. What's more, over 40% of those newly added systems also adopt our value-added services acceptance solutions. Outside the U.S., Tap to Pay penetration worldwide stood at 82%, a rise of 6 points from 2023. Within the U.S., the figure was 54%, 13 points higher than last year, with 29 of the top 30 U.S. merchants accepting Tap to Pay. Turning now to a few deal highlights, this quarter brought some notable renewals around the world. First, Grupo Promerica — one of our largest customers in Latin America — is now handling credit, debit, and commercial across 8 countries. Second, SMCC, our top Asia Pacific client, covers consumer and commercial credit. Third, Al Rajhi, our largest CEMEA customer, takes consumer, commercial, and value-added services, including CyberSource and Visa Risk Manager, our network-agnostic risk product. Also spanning Asia Pacific and CEMEA is Standard Chartered Bank: a credit renewal across key markets in Asia, a debit renewal with key markets in Africa, plus a new credit expansion in the Middle East. On top of that, they'll continue using our value-added services. There were three particularly significant renewals in North America. First, in Canada, our relationship with RBC — that nation's biggest issuer — has been extended to cover consumer credit and debit, small business credit, plus commercial credit. Second, in the U.S., we've just widened a partnership that goes back a long way with U.S. Bank, so that it now spans both their consumer and commercial portfolios. Third, USAA has renewed with us on the consumer debit side as well as consumer credit. Finally, turning to Europe: our ties in Italy are strong, and we also work across 11 other markets there, so we're delighted that the strategic agreement with Intesa Sanpaolo has been renewed, which takes our collaboration in Italy deeper with that country's largest bank, focused on innovative solutions for businesses and consumers alike. Together, we'll also bring new value-added services to their Visa customers. Taking into account every market we operate in and each of our fintech collaborators, from those just starting out to those well established, we secured more than 650 commercial partnerships, which is a 30% increase over last year. As is evident, we've kept expanding our operations by actively engaging with our customers and maintaining an unwavering commitment to developing new products. Turning now to new flows, an area where our focused approach to seizing emerging growth opportunities is delivering results. During this quarter, revenue from new flows rose 22% compared to the same period a year ago in constant dollars. On this quarter's results, Visa Direct deal count rose 38%, hitting 2.8 billion, and commercial volumes were up 5% over last year. As we wrapped up the year, Visa Direct transactions totaled close to 10 billion, alongside commercial payments volume of $1.7 trillion. Commercial credentials grew 18% year over year, well ahead of the 7% growth in total credentials I mentioned earlier. We're still very focused on pushing B2B into additional verticals, travel among them. And we're pleased to report a virtual card issuing deal with JPMorgan Chase across Europe. That's a big opening for Visa to keep building on our strong issuing partnership in North America and to grow further in the B2B travel vertical. Also on the Europe side, we’re going to partner with Adyen, allowing them to supply Visa virtual cards to online travel agencies (OTAs) through their B2B travel offering.

Ryan McInerney

executive
#3

We're also concentrating on cross-border B2B, an area where our card offerings and Visa B2B Connect deliver considerable value for complicated payments. With Visa B2B Connect, the count of banks signed on grew by close to 40% compared with a year earlier, while transacting banks rose by almost 60%; in Korea, we secured 2 agreements with Hana Card. The first covers commercial and consumer credit and debit issuance, adding enhanced multicurrency features aimed at its customers' cross-border requirements. The second involves Hana Card and KOTRA, the government trade agency, enabling small business exporters to get cross-border B2B payments through card; in Canada, we're delighted to have captured the multicurrency credit issuance with Loop, a fintech cross-border banking platform serving Canadian-based SMBs. Beyond that, our cross-border capabilities via Currencycloud will deliver FX solutions spanning accounts, digital wallets and international payments. Down in Australia, we signed a multicurrency commercial debit deal with OFX, a top global money transfer firm providing foreign exchange services, international payment and spend management controls; shifting now to Visa Direct, which keeps expanding via new and broader relationships. In Europe, we grew our current cross-border P2P partnership with Revolut, which now permits real-time card transfers for its business customers through the Visa Direct platform in more than 78 countries covering over 50 currencies; in the U.S., we're enthusiastic about a broader partnership with DailyPay, whose users presently access earnings on demand through Visa Direct and can now seamlessly send those earnings as international remittances to friends and family worldwide. In Brazil, we concluded a new arrangement with Travelex Banco de Cambio, among the biggest foreign exchange banks there and the first to focus on FX operations regulated by the Central Bank. This client will leverage Visa Direct for import and export payments as well as remittances to a wide array of destinations. Thus, throughout our new flows, our targeted strategies are clearly winning in the marketplace; turning now to value-added services, where revenue climbed 22% in the fourth quarter and for the full year in constant dollars. Let's review our progress in value-added services; within issuing solutions, Pismo, our core banking and issuer processing platform, has a solid pipeline and its offerings are connecting well with clients, generating nearly 12 billion API calls monthly. Not long ago, Pismo renewed its agreement with Itaú in Brazil. And during 2025, we intend to broaden Pismo's offerings to clients in more than 5 countries spanning 4 regions. In Risk and Identity Solutions, we recently shared our plan to purchase Featurespace, which builds real-time AI technology for protecting payments; this acquisition will let Visa offer improved fraud prevention capabilities to our customers and safeguard consumers instantly across multiple payment methods; additionally, Worldline, which is already a Visa partner and a top European acquirer, will shortly introduce a streamlined fraud management offering, leveraging Decision Manager to give businesses AI-driven e-commerce fraud detection abilities; regarding acceptance, foodpanda, a food delivery platform, has been a longtime CyberSource customer throughout Asia in multiple markets. They will also soon adopt our AI-powered data token product, which we introduced earlier this year, allowing customers to govern how their information is used to enjoy personalized shopping experiences. In Advisory Services, Visa Consulting and Analytics completed over 3,000 consulting projects during the year, and we estimate that we assisted clients in generating more than $5 billion in additional revenue as a result. Thus, our value-added services have kept up robust momentum across both Visa and non-Visa transactions and nonpayment value-added services. Before I finish, I wanted to offer a few remarks on the recent lawsuit from the Department of Justice. We consider the lawsuit to be without merit and it demonstrates an obvious misunderstanding of the payments ecosystem in the United States; we will defend ourselves strongly and are confident that we can show that Visa competes for every transaction in a vibrant debit market that keeps expanding and attracting new participants; to conclude, I am proud of our team and everything we have achieved; we met our financial expectations while also investing in Visa's future through significant product innovation. Back in 2020 at our Investor Day, we established a target for new flows and value-added services revenue to account for over 30% of net revenue by the end of 2024. I am happy to report that we have surpassed that target. And we will host another Investor Day on February 20, 2025, here in San Francisco, where we can discuss more about our approach to keep growing value-added services, new flows and consumer payments. I see enormous opportunity ahead and feel confident in our strategies to reach it. Now I'll hand it over to Chris.

Chris Suh

executive
#4

Thank you, Ryan. Good afternoon, everyone. Another solid quarter brought our year to a close. Compared with Q3, during Q4 we observed fairly steady expansion in payments volume, cross-border volume, and processed transactions. Measured in constant dollars, payments volume worldwide rose 8% from a year earlier, while cross-border volume excluding intra-Europe climbed 13% versus the prior year. Processed transactions increased 10% compared with last year. Fiscal Q4 net revenue rose 12%, exceeding what we had anticipated, largely because incentives came in lower than expected, other revenue came in stronger than expected, and FX proved less of a headwind than anticipated. Net revenue also rose 12% in constant dollars. EPS increased 16% from a year earlier and 17% in constant dollars, coming in above expectations thanks to the robust net revenue result and a tax rate that came in lower than expected. Let's turn to the details. Within the U.S., total payments volume rose 5% versus the prior year, matching Q3. Credit and debit each also rose 5%. Card-present volume increased 2%, while card-not-present volume increased 6%. Consumer spend across every segment, from low spend to high spend, stayed fairly steady relative to Q3. Our data shows no significant behavior shift among consumer segments compared with last quarter. Turning to international markets. Total payments volume rose 10% in constant dollars, unchanged from Q3. Across most major regions, year-over-year payments volume growth rates in constant dollars were robust for the quarter, with Latin America up 24%, CEMEA up 19%, and Europe up 12%. Asia Pacific payments volume showed a slight improvement over Q3 in constant dollars for the quarter, yet still delivered under 1% year-over-year growth, mainly because of the macroeconomic environment, particularly in Mainland China. Asia Pacific payments volume growth, excluding Mainland China, was fairly consistent with Q3. Now on to cross-border volume, which today I'll discuss in constant dollars and excluding intra-Europe transactions. Total cross-border volume rose 13% in Q4, below Q3, matching our expectations. Q4 cross-border e-commerce, measured as card-not-present volume and excluding travel and crypto purchases, grew 15%, outpacing cross-border travel volume growth of 12%, matching our expectations. Indexed to 2019, cross-border travel was fairly consistent with Q3. Looking at travel corridors, the main reason for slower year-over-year cross-border travel volume growth was Asia Pacific inbound and outbound, which kept facing the same primary factors we've cited all year: macroeconomic conditions, currency weakness, and flight bookings below pre-COVID levels. We also saw a step-down in CEMEA outbound travel volume growth relative to Q3 because of Ramadan timing. Once normalized for this, CEMEA growth was stable. Now let's review our fourth quarter financial results. I'll begin with the revenue components. Service revenue rose 8% from a year earlier versus the 7% growth in Q3 constant dollar payments volume, driven by mix and improving utilization of card benefits. Data processing revenue rose 8% versus 10% processed transaction growth, mainly because fees and penalties were lower than the prior year. International transaction revenue rose 9% versus the 13% increase in constant dollar. Cross-border volume, not counting transactions within Europe, took a hit because we were up against elevated currency volatility from the prior year, and that happened even though average quarterly volatility in Q4 was a bit above what we saw in Q3. Revenue from other sources climbed 30%, mostly fueled by robust growth in marketing services tied to the Olympics, along with consulting and, to a smaller degree, pricing. Client incentives rose 6%. Q4 turned out to be the yearly trough for year-over-year growth, which is what we anticipated, since we were lapping sizable renewals from the previous year. On top of that, it dropped further because of certain onetime adjustments tied to client performance. Ryan noted a considerable amount of renewal activity during his comments, but most of that effect won't kick in until Q1 of '25. Moving now to our 3 growth engines. Growth in consumer payments revenue came from payments volume, cross-border volume and processed transaction growth, all of which were relatively steady. New flows revenue rose 22% year-over-year in constant dollars, aided by a onetime rebate adjustment stemming from deal timing. Visa Direct transactions increased 38% year-over-year, supported by expansion in Latin America for interoperability among P2P apps. Commercial volume went up 5% year-over-year in constant dollars, lower than Q3, mainly because of days mix. Value-added services revenue increased 22% in constant dollars, reaching $2.4 billion, driven by strong growth in marketing services and consulting and issuing solutions. Operating expenses rose 11%, primarily from higher marketing and personnel expenses. FX turned out to be a slight drag rather than the 0.5 point benefit we had anticipated. Our purchase of Pismo also created a drag of roughly 0.5 point. Nonoperating income came to $69 million. Our tax rate stood at 16.5% because of an update in our tax position across jurisdictions. EPS reached $2.71, a 16% increase over last year, with exchange rates creating a drag of approximately 1 point and Pismo creating a drag of approximately 0.5 point. During Q4, we repurchased roughly $5.8 billion in stock and paid out more than $1 billion in dividends to our stockholders; we additionally funded the litigation escrow account with $1.5 billion, which carries the same effect as a stock buyback. At September's close, we had $13.1 billion left in our buyback authorization. As we wrapped up fiscal 2024 and prepared for fiscal 2025, I thought about our full year performance compared with what we had anticipated when the year began. Thanks to the strong Q4, full year net revenue rose 10%, matching our expectations, and EPS rose 15%, surpassing our expectations, which speaks to Visa's diversified business model. Volatility began the year strongly in Q1 but then fell and stayed below expected levels for most of the year. On incentives, we had expected year-over-year growth to come in lower than fiscal 2023, mainly because renewals would have smaller impacts in fiscal 2024. The growth rate wound up even lower than we had anticipated because of client performance adjustments and deal timing. Turning to business drivers, processed transactions rose 10%, as expected. Payments volume rose 8% in constant dollars, falling short of expectations because of a mix of weakness in Asia Pacific, which we have already discussed, and in the U.S. because the average purchase amount wasn’t rising the way we’d anticipated, and to a smaller degree, because of what Reg II did. Overall cross-border volume increased 15% in constant dollars when you leave out intra-Europe, which was broadly what we had initially projected, but cross-border travel volume grew more slowly, mostly because of Asia Pacific travel, while card-not-present volume apart from travel did better than we’d assumed. As has been true this year, volume and transaction levels can move up and down from one quarter to the next. When those forces shift, we focus on running the business carefully so we hit what we’ve told you to expect. So when we set our budget and our guidance approach for fiscal 2025, it’s basically the same method, and it reflects the best picture we have as of right now. Let’s turn to the specifics of the guidance, with one quick clarification. Any time I mention 2024 and 2025, those are our fiscal years. We say this often: forecasting the economy isn’t our job, so our assumption is that macro conditions remain broadly at today’s levels. Given that, we anticipate payments volume and processed transaction growth will stay solid and roughly match where they landed for all of 2024. On cross-border volumes, we look for the trend from Q4 ’24 to carry on in much the same way, with card-not-present volume apart from travel rising a bit faster than travel volume.

Chris Suh

executive
#5

Now let’s go over the key assumptions we’re using for net revenue growth. First is volatility. Our expectation is that currency volatility levels for the entire year will be approximately consistent with the average seen in Q4 ’24, which means volatility should stop acting as a headwind beginning in Q2 ’25. Next is pricing. In 2025, we’ll keep pricing according to value, and the pricing effect should be broadly similar to what we saw in 2024. The timing pattern, though, is likely to differ, since we anticipate that the great majority of the additional pricing impact will land in April rather than being spread more evenly across October and April, as happened in 2024. Turning to incentives, first, a substantial number of renewals were mentioned in Ryan’s comments, and those will affect Q1 ’25 incentives. Altogether, we anticipate that renewals will touch over 20% of our payments volume in 2025, versus under 15% affected during 2024. Second, keep in mind that during the first and second quarters of 2024, we highlighted client performance and deal timing as factors that aided incentives. And in Q4, we had further one-time performance adjustments. If you add all of that together, incentives growth on a year-over-year basis in 2025 should be much higher than in 2024. The Prosa and Featurespace transactions should close sometime in 2025, and after they do, we'll update our figures to reflect what those acquisitions bring. Our assumptions were put together using an adjusted view — meaning non-GAAP numbers, measured in constant currency, and leaving out any effects from acquisitions. You can find those details spelled out more thoroughly in the presentations we've shared on earnings. Looking at 2025, we're expecting adjusted net revenue for the entire year to rise somewhere between the high single digits and low double digits, and incentives are the main factor explaining why ’24 and 2025 differ. Like always, several things can influence how revenue turns out. So if deals get pushed back, or if there are significant adjustments to how deals perform, and/or if the broader economy is unstable while driver results come in stronger than we anticipate, then adjusted net revenue growth would come in at the top of that range. As for differences from quarter to quarter, we anticipate that revenue in the back half will be higher than the front half, given certain dynamics I've already mentioned—namely volatility, pricing and, to a lesser extent, incentives. Moving on to costs. Right now, we anticipate that adjusted operating expense will climb somewhere in the high single digit to low double digit range, since we'll continue putting money into new flows and value-added services projects, along with our sales efforts and growth initiatives in select countries. Due to lower interest rates, nonoperating income ought to land somewhere between $150 million and $200 million. As for our tax rate, it should fall between 18% and 18.5%. Regarding capital return, the Board has announced a 13% bump to the quarterly dividend, and we intend to give excess free cash flow back to shareholders through buybacks. All of this combined yields adjusted EPS growth at the high end of low double digits. Let's now move on to Q1. During October’s first 3 weeks, through the 21st, with volume growth measured in constant dollars, U.S. payments volume rose 6% versus a year earlier, as debit increased 7% and credit increased 6%. Cross-border volume, once intra-Europe is excluded, was up 13% compared with the prior year. Processed transactions climbed 11% year-over-year. Now, turning to financial expectations: we anticipate Q1 adjusted net revenue growth in the high single digits. There are three things to note as we consider the step-down in adjusted net revenue growth between the fourth quarter of 2024 and the first quarter of 2025. First, incentives. A number of factors are affecting incentives, particularly in Q1 and H1, so let me walk through each part. Like I mentioned before, the growth in Q4 incentives ended up being even weaker than we had anticipated. That was due to two things working together: we were up against tough comparisons from significant renewals in 2023, and we also had onetime adjustments related to client performance. I also noted earlier that for 2025, a much bigger portion of our payments volume will be impacted by renewals—roughly 20%, compared with less than 15% in 2024. This is a result of both the substantial number of renewals from Q4 '24 that will kick in, plus the renewals we're anticipating in 2025. On top of that, because of how the deal terms are timed in 2025, we anticipate that around 60% of the 2025 renewal volume will go into effect during Q1. Putting those factors together, we anticipate that the dollar value of incentives will rise considerably when moving from the fourth quarter of 2024 into the first quarter of 2025. The second factor is when pricing changes take effect. As I mentioned earlier, the pricing effect was fairly even across all four quarters in 2024, but for this year we're looking at a smaller pricing impact during the first six months compared with the final six months, and Q1 will see the least of it. The third factor involves other revenue. Because Q1 doesn't include a big event along the lines of the Olympics or FIFA, we expect growth in revenue tied to consulting and marketing services to come in below what we saw in Q4. For adjusted operating expense growth, our expectation is somewhere between high single digits and low double digits. When you look at how this compares to a year ago, keep in mind that Q1 2024 saw operating expenses rise at a slower pace. That was partly because 2023 included FIFA-related costs that didn't repeat, and partly because Olympic marketing spending landed in different quarters. For nonoperating income, we're looking at a range of $35 million to $45 million, with a tax rate near 18.5%. That translates to adjusted EPS growth for Q1 in the low double digits. Naturally, should conditions shift or developments arise that affect what we do, we'll stay adaptable and deliberate about weighing near-term against longer-term priorities. Now that we're a few weeks into fiscal 2025, Visa's core business remains solid, and there's substantial room for growth. At the Investor Day coming up, we're eager to talk through this along with our long-term growth algorithm. Jennifer, at this point I'll turn things back over to you.

Jennifer Como

executive
#6

Thanks, Chris. And with that, we're ready to take questions.

Harshita Rawat

analyst
#7

There's a great deal happening on the U.S. regulatory side when it comes to the DOJ lawsuit, Reg II, MDL, CCCA. Could you give us your broad view of the regulatory and litigation landscape in the U.S.? And Chris, as a quick follow-up, could you perhaps help us size how much revenue you're exposed to in U.S. debit, both with Visa DPS included and with it excluded?

Ryan McInerney

executive
#8

Yes, thank you for asking. As you point out, there's a great deal happening, and not only in the U.S. but across the globe. I believe regulators are rightly examining the payments ecosystem and want to make sure there's fair competition, that there are multiple options, for consumers as well as merchants. And that's an engagement process we have in the U.S., as you asked about, but also with regulators and elected officials worldwide. And we feel very good about our capacity to handle that complexity. We feel very good about our capacity to keep running and growing our business; and we feel very good about our capacity to keep innovating and to keep serving our clients. When it comes to revenue exposure, that isn't something we disclose with respect to U.S. debit or other parts of the business of that kind. But when it comes to our capacity to compete, we feel really, really good about it.

Ramsey El-Assal

analyst
#9

Could you share what you're now thinking about the competitive landscape, particularly when it comes to pay by bank? Walmart is pushing ahead with a new offering, and there's chatter about a few other products. We've encountered these kinds of offerings before, but I'm curious whether anything has actually shifted on the ground that makes them somewhat more appealing to consumers. I realize your company is also active in that segment of the market today, so I'd like to hear what you have to say.

Ryan McInerney

executive
#10

Sure. There's a great deal happening with account-to-account payments across the U.S. and globally, as you're aware. Pay by bank isn't a fresh capability. It isn't a fresh capability here in the United States. It isn't a fresh capability for Walmart either. In fact, I believe that right now you're able to load 3 separate bank accounts into your Walmart.com wallet in order to pay for purchases. And as you pointed out, they've also released some news that a new partnership is coming which, in my view, will take that even further. Our expectation is that account-to-account payments will keep spreading both here and internationally. We believe there's plenty we can contribute when it comes to the value of account-to-account payments. Some of that I touched on during my prepared remarks. Yet, as I've said multiple times on this call, the environment we compete in is extremely, extremely competitive; even so, we feel extremely, extremely confident about our offerings, our innovation, our capacity to deliver value to end users, meaning buyers as well as sellers, and consequently, our capacity to keep expanding the business.

Sanjay Sakhrani

analyst
#11

One thing I wanted to ask about was commercial volumes. I realize they slowed down as a result of the days mix, but I'm curious what rate of growth we ought to be looking at going forward. I mean — I understand there are certain macro effects at play. Perhaps you could address that point directly.

Chris Suh

executive
#12

Sanjay, it's Chris here. Yeah, like you said, we did experience a days mix effect on commercial volumes in Q4; but stepping back quite a bit, the chance we have in new flows is something we're thrilled about. The scale of the opportunity in front of us makes us optimistic. And as time goes on, we do expect that commercial volumes will keep growing ahead of consumer volumes.

Paul Golding

analyst
#13

Given that the Featurespace acquisition is still being worked through, I wanted to check how you view AI fitting into the business model. Is it mainly a way to boost VAS, or an additional business model, driving revenue higher or costs lower? Or does it act more as an edge that keeps you ahead of rivals?

Ryan McInerney

executive
#14

Sure, thanks; put simply, I'd say it's both, though let me break down a few points you raised. To begin with Featurespace, we're quite enthusiastic about the chance to complete that acquisition. Wherever I go globally, fraud and financial crime sit at the forefront for clients, partners, and regulators everywhere; and Featurespace leads the world in delivering AI-powered tools to fight that fraud, cut it down, and let our clients and partners keep serving their customers safely. So that has us quite enthusiastic. Turning more broadly to generative AI especially at Visa, I view it in 2 distinct buckets. The first: we're embracing it strongly throughout the company to lift productivity. And we've gotten some strong outcomes from all over, from our engineering teams, our accounting teams, our sales teams, our client service teams; and we're still early in what I believe will be a very substantial effect on how productive our business is. I also view it as a genuine edge for the products and services we bring to market. You've heard me discuss some of the new risk capabilities, risk management capabilities, for instance, that we've rolled out in the account-to-account space, all of which are powered by generative AI. You brought up Featurespace. We've enjoyed some really solid wins in other areas of both our value-added services business and the wider consumer payments business too. And our product pipeline leans very heavily toward some generative AI capabilities that we think are quite exciting and that hopefully you'll hear more about from us soon. One of them I referenced in my prepared remarks, the data token we're beginning to pilot with foodpanda, which is one illustration of that.

Tien-Tsin Huang

analyst
#15

I'd simply like to know how growth in '25 could differ from '24 when it comes to consumer payments, new flows, and value-added services.

Chris Suh

executive
#16

Tien-Tsin, Chris here; we don't provide guidance broken out by consumer payments, new flows, and value-added services; however, allow me to offer a bit more detail regarding how we're thinking about the guidance we actually provided. At the broadest level, our method for guidance matched what we used twelve months back, meaning we essentially set guidance according to our strongest projection of what we anticipate occurring over the course of the year; therefore, should every one of our assumptions unfold exactly as we've laid them out, we would anticipate total revenue growth, adjusted net revenue growth landing in the middle of the range we gave. And clearly, should those assumptions, those variables come in stronger, that might drive us toward the high end of revenue growth, and the reverse holds if those assumptions come in somewhat weaker. The main variables I'd highlight number 3 — actually there are probably 4 worth discussing. First is incentives. Our plan rests on our strongest projection for renewals and deal activity. Yet, as we witnessed in FY '24, those outcomes can shift quarter-to-quarter alongside client performance and deal timing, and slower growth might push revenue growth toward the upper end of the range. Second would be cross-border volumes. Greater or lesser growth in cross-border volumes would likewise move things toward a higher or lower point within that revenue range. Third would be volatility. We've assumed FY '25 full year on average at the levels we observed in Q4, and any meaningful swing could affect revenue in '25; and naturally, underlying everything is what we assume about the macro economy. As we've consistently stated, forecasting the economy isn't something we do. But should the U.S. — within the U.S. or worldwide, if PC expands more quickly than what's presently forecasted, then we ought to see stronger growth too. So every one of these factors may matter; we feel good about the plan we laid out here for the full year at the beginning of the year, and we'll clearly keep updating you as the year progresses.

Rayna Kumar

analyst
#17

The CFPB put out a final open banking rule for the U.S. last week. From Tink's vantage point, could you discuss what opportunities this might open up for Visa, and what possible headwinds might arise?

Ryan McInerney

executive
#18

As I understand it, the new rules they finalized, I believe, line up mostly with what the CFPB initially proposed; and we strongly support consumers gaining greater control over and greater access to their financial data, provided that it happens in a safe and secure manner. We're still working through all the specifics of how these more detailed regulations could affect the industry as a whole. Yet it should go without saying that our own offerings will adhere to the CFPB's rules, along with our clients' extremely demanding standards for security and privacy. Broadening the lens a bit toward the opportunities this generates, I think when open banking becomes even more widespread in the United States, similar to what you see in markets such as Europe, what we've observed is that the Visa brand can serve as a significant differentiator. The Visa brand can instill confidence in end users and data providers, and if we can deliver our capabilities to market as we have in Europe with Visa A2A, we can boost confidence across the entire ecosystem and help untangle many of the complexities that plague open banking. So we're still enthusiastic about the chances to add value, particularly in the U.S., where all of this remains at a fairly early stage.

Andrew Schmidt

analyst
#19

I'd like to inquire about how value-add services are growing. It's genuinely encouraging to witness how steady that has been. Perhaps you could discuss the predictability, and then offer a bit more detail on the planning side — how you essentially keep fueling the engine and sustain that expansion. I realize there are organic and inorganic pieces plus penetration elements involved, but if you could break that down for us. I know that covers quite a few items, but unpacking it would be terrific.

Ryan McInerney

executive
#20

Yeah. We're equally thrilled about the steady expansion we've managed to produce annually with our value-added services operations; and that gets delivered via planning — sales planning, client planning, product road mapping — everything you'd anticipate us doing across each business: issuer solutions, acquirer solutions, risk and advisory, and so forth. Regarding the potential, here's how I'd urge you to consider it, which mirrors how we basically intend to approach the market. For Visa transactions, we provide value-added services. These offerings exist to help Visa become the finest method to pay and get paid, in every market globally. And we keep investing to introduce new functionality that boosts payment success along with network security. So these include items and solutions such as Visa Account Updater, the risk offerings we frequently mention like Visa Secure, the dispute instruments we provide such as Visa Resolve Online, the benefits we extend; that represents roughly one piece of the potential. A second piece of the potential involves services for transactions that aren't Visa's; you've heard me and us discuss this space considerably more across recent quarters. This covers acceptance services including CyberSource, Authorize.net, Verifi, risk instruments like Decision Manager, processing solutions such as DPS, such as Pismo, and once more, these represent capabilities we're taking to market for clients that create value across every kind of payment transaction. Then the third group of opportunities we're pursuing involves services past payments. That's a far wider category. It covers items such as our consulting and analytics groups, our marketing services groups, open banking offerings like Tink — we mentioned them earlier regarding their data aggregation solutions. Through the Pismo acquisition, we now also provide core banking platform services. So ideally that provides a sense of how we view the opportunities, view the competitive sets, create and ship products, create and ship our sales motions and go-to-market, and in the end produce the steady expansion you mentioned.

Dave Koning

analyst
#21

Regarding the cross-border segment, top-line expansion held steady at 9% during this quarter, matching the prior quarter, yet volumes we report rose 1% faster. Also, I'd guess currency swings were somewhat less severe, which likely gave a small lift, and the mix looked roughly unchanged; therefore I wanted to ask, are there any additional factors, perhaps other minor drags starting to appear? What — could something explain why that difference opened up?

Chris Suh

executive
#22

Absolutely, of course. There are two factors; as you mentioned, overseas revenue increased more slowly than overall cross-border volumes. The reason truly came down to currency fluctuations. Thus volatility in Q4 did get somewhat better versus Q3, though it remained below what we experienced a year earlier. And second, the related volume, that cross-border volume, came in at 13% in Q4, in line with expectations, yet it too was beneath the volume increase we recorded during Q4 a year ago. Consequently, once those elements are put together, that is what affected the spread you observe separating volumes from revenue.

Timothy Chiodo

analyst
#23

I'd like to examine 2 particular elements of value-added services — DPS first, then CyberSource. As I understand it, together those 2 account for a fairly substantial share of transaction-based value-added services. From what I recall, the most recent figure shared on DPS was around $2.5 trillion in volume, while CyberSource sits at approximately $1 trillion. Could you share how each is growing compared with the other value-added services, and perhaps any fresher figures if you have them?

Ryan McInerney

executive
#24

Yes, thanks for asking; we're extremely proud of what we're achieving with DPS and CyberSource — DPS mainly in the U.S., while CyberSource is now a genuinely global platform operating at real scale. That said, we don't disclose transaction volume growth or break out additional metrics at that level of reporting. So I appreciate the interest. I'm sorry we can't offer any further detail.

Bryan Keane

analyst
#25

I'd like to inquire about the acceleration you've observed in October when it comes to volume growth, particularly on the debit side. It appears to have ticked up somewhat, reaching 7%. Is there anything you're noticing there regarding new wins, or could that be a stronger economic backdrop fueling it? And then, just briefly, on the second point about price to value, regarding the shift in timing — what caused that change? Why does the timing differ this year?

Chris Suh

executive
#26

Absolutely. All right, I'll begin with what you asked regarding October, and then I believe Ryan will take the second portion of your question. So where October is concerned, as we have said consistently, 3 weeks don't make a trend. That held true in July, when we got off to a somewhat slower start, and then Q4 turned out to be stable, and we believe it holds true now as we witness a robust beginning to October. That being said, here are a couple of items we observe regarding relative strength between the month of October and how we closed out Q4. Two things I'd highlight: first is days mix. So September's growth came in lower because of days mix. A year ago, September contained an additional Friday and Saturday, which rank among 2 of the highest spend days of the week; and this September, those were swapped for a Sunday and Monday, which rank among 2 of the lower spend days; and so that affected September growth; and then second, in the U.S., on top of that days mix factor, we are beginning to lap the modest impact of Reg II that we started discussing a year ago in Q1. And so those factors together are driving what we're seeing as the start of October; but as we said, it's 3 weeks. Let's see how the quarter plays out.

Ryan McInerney

executive
#27

Bryan, right — like you pointed out, and like we've repeatedly mentioned, our approach is to price according to value. That means we need to get products out the door. We need to get services out the door. We need to provide solutions that bring added value and grow value for our customers; and our 2025 product pipeline leans somewhat toward the back half of the year, particularly as we introduce some new and exciting offerings and services into the market, and that's genuinely what causes the shift in how pricing is paced across 2025.

Jason Kupferberg

analyst
#28

If we zero in on card-present volume growth within the U.S., my sense is that we've been sitting around 2% for the last 2 or 3 quarters. So I'm curious whether you anticipate that picking up in fiscal '25. And Chris, could you put a number on what that positive adjustment to Q4 new flows revenues came to?

Chris Suh

executive
#29

Understood. Jason, you faded out a bit there at the end. Could you repeat the second half of what you asked, Jason?

Jason Kupferberg

analyst
#30

Regarding that one-time boost to new flows revenue during Q4, could you put a figure on it?

Chris Suh

executive
#31

All right, understood. Since you brought that up, I'll take the second one first. Absolutely, the momentum behind new flows has us feeling very good. It went from 18% in Q3 to 22% in Q4. That said, as I mentioned during the call, a one-time rebate adjustment tied to deal timing gave Q4 a lift; basically, we had anticipated a client would receive a rebate, and that depended on hitting a milestone, but they fell short. Consequently, we booked a one-time adjustment to that rebate, and it hit in Q4. Then I believe your first question concerned card-present and, more broadly, volumes as we think ahead to FY '25. Perhaps that's the one I should tackle. Let me widen the lens slightly: consistent with our call, our broad assumptions about underlying drivers are that during '25 they stay fairly steady versus the trends we're observing, for the whole year on payment volume and payment transactions compared with '24, and on cross-border versus what we're seeing in Q4. So they'll stay reasonably strong and healthy, and as I said, we'll keep updating you across the year.

Craig Maurer

analyst
#32

First, I'd like to ask — it's been quite a while since I brought this up — about how you view operating leverage, because in the fiscal year '25 forecast, your expenses are rising at roughly the same pace as revenue. And over the longer term, is there a pledge to make revenue increase more quickly than expenses, or should we expect only modest operating leverage ahead? Second, when it comes to the fiscal year '25 guidance, what assumptions about APAC are baked into it? To hit that, do you require an acceleration in China, or does it essentially presume the same steady, no-growth conditions there?

Ryan McInerney

executive
#33

I'll handle the first one, and you can handle the second, Chris. On what you asked first: as I've mentioned on this call and on prior calls, we have a tremendous array of opportunities we're chasing; and how we operate the business each day, each quarter, each year is by working through our evaluation of those opportunities, determining the product pipeline we're able to launch; we're examining both inorganic and organic possibilities. And we're assembling a plan that we believe maximizes the long-term growth we can achieve; that's our approach; that's our mindset. And you can see the outcomes we've produced, and you heard what Chris said in the guidance for this year. So that's roughly where things stand on that.

Chris Suh

executive
#34

Let me respond to what you raised regarding AP in particular. Once more, looking at things worldwide, we anticipate that the general patterns will look fairly close to how we're finishing up FY '24. As for what's happening in AP, a great deal of it stems from the macroeconomic climate in China. Just as we've said all along, we don't make predictions about the economy. So then, assuming the underlying drivers stay fairly steady, we'll watch how AP does, though once again, that's going to hinge largely on how healthy the broader economy turns out to be.

Trevor Williams

analyst
#35

I'd like to dig deeper into value-added services. The overall outline you provided suggests that around two-thirds of VAS revenue has some kind of transaction connection. Within that share tied to transactions or volume, what proportion currently has to run across VisaNet for you to collect those substantial revenue streams? Ryan, from what you're saying, the bulk of it still travels over your network at present, though perhaps the off-network part ought to grow as a share of the total mix down the road; still, any further detail on that would be useful.

Ryan McInerney

executive
#36

Right. So the biggest piece of our VAS revenue right now is that initial bucket of services I brought up for Visa transactions, and clearly, that's what we've been doing since the earliest days; and just to add on that point, what it actually accomplishes is generate extra yield on top of our Visa transactions. That means we're putting more value into the transaction. We're putting more value into the client relationship and in the end generating extra yield on top of the Visa payments volume growth we're seeing. Yet like I said, we also see — we've achieved substantial headway in developing our platforms to handle non-Visa transactions. CyberSource I brought up, Verifi I brought up, Pismo I brought up, Decision Manager I brought up. All of these are turning into substantial platforms for us with substantial opportunity. And you can easily picture the TAM we can pursue once we're not only providing services for Visa transactions but can also partner with clients to provide services built on a far wider range of payment transactions — it's simply enormous; so we stay quite enthusiastic about both.

Darrin Peller

analyst
#37

So, looking back at the 12% increase in incentives and rebates in '24, and now you're indicating it'll clearly be higher in '25 — that's obviously encouraging to see, and these activities ought to help keep growth going. Could you give us a bit more detail — you brought up a lot of renewals, but what about net new business and market share gains specifically? How do those factor in? And along those lines, it seems like this year stands out as a big one for that contra revenue growth rate; so does that affect how you're viewing growth for this year compared to the long term? Our sense is it might actually be even stronger this year, since it's somewhat of an outlier year when it comes to growth in incentives and rebates, if we're reading that right.

Ryan McInerney

executive
#38

Yeah, Darrin, I don't think we'll get into the outer years, but let me say a few things. First, we're winning. We're winning across regions and across markets globally. When you consider the scale and sophistication of some of those names I brought up in my prepared remarks and have brought up over the last couple of quarters, we are winning, and that makes us feel really good market by market worldwide. Second, as we've said before, we can't really forecast the timing of when these renewals will occur, or when a competitive situation will arise with our client. We need to be prepared at any moment to deliver our best and hopefully come out on top. And as you were hinting at, there's been a series of those lately, and more of them this quarter that have us excited. So we'll keep deploying a great product. We'll keep — we've got a great team that I recognized during the prepared remarks who serves these clients, which is ultimately a major reason they decide both to keep doing business with us and to grow the business they do with us, grow the consumer business, grow in the commercial business, grow into new flows, and we feel really good about it.

Jennifer Como

executive
#39

That brings us to the end of today's call, and we appreciate everyone taking the time to be with us. Should any further questions come up, you're welcome to reach out by phone or email to our Investor Relations team. Thanks once more, and enjoy the rest of your day.

Operator

operator
#40

We appreciate everyone for joining us on Visa’s earnings conference call for the fourth quarter of fiscal year 2024 and the full year. That brings today’s call to a close. At this point you’re free to hang up, and we hope the remainder of your day goes well.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Visa Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Visa Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Visa Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.