CarMax, Inc. (KMX) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
September 30, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Bill Nash
executiveHello, and thanks for being with us today. You saw in this morning’s earnings release that we achieved a record amount of used sales in Q2, an all-time high for wholesale vehicle sales, plus strong growth in CarMax auto finance income. During the second quarter of FY22, our diversified business model produced total sales of $8 billion, a 49% increase over Q2 of FY21, powered by higher average selling prices along with gains in volume. Net earnings per diluted share came to $1.72, which is $0.07 lower than the prior year as we lapped the pandemic-driven expense cuts from last year and kept investing in our growth. Combining our retail and wholesale operations, we sold approximately 420,000 vehicles, which represents a 20% increase from the same quarter last year. Across the first half of fiscal 2022, we've moved around 872,000 units through both channels combined. Additionally, our consumer purchases of cars grew 59% in Q2 compared to the prior year, and we hit a record self-sufficiency rate near 70%. Performance across the entire company is being driven by our omnichannel platform, unique customer offerings, strong execution, and broader economic conditions. On the retail side, Q2 total unit sales climbed 6.7%, while used unit comps were up 6.2% versus the year-ago second quarter, despite challenges related to inventory, staffing, and overall used car valuations. During the quarter, our teams kept moving forward on expanding the inventory we can sell, and even with the heavy retail demand that continued into the second quarter, we saw month-over-month gains. That inventory is still under the levels we aim for, but for the rest of the year we expect to keep increasing it. Along with solid unit volume, retail gross profit came to $2,185 per used unit, which matches what we typically see in a second quarter. Turning to wholesale, the number of units sold climbed 41.4% compared with a record second quarter a year earlier. Per-unit wholesale gross profit was $1,005, down from $1,086 in last year's comparable period. Our wholesale unit gains largely came from the continued traction of the instant online appraisal service, which went live across the country on carmax.com in February following its debut on edmunds.com a year earlier. Another tailwind was the fact that used vehicle values across the wider market remained historically high. CarMax auto finance, or CAF, kept up its solid performance, posting $200 million in income. On top of that, both CAF and our partner lenders came through with competitive offers across every credit tier, although Tier 3 volume did slip compared with the first quarter on a sequential basis. John will walk through customer financing and CAF's contribution in more detail shortly. At this point, I'll hand things over to Enrique for additional details about how we did financially in the second quarter, and then John will speak. Once they're done, I'll share where we stand on our strategic priorities and afterward we'll take questions from participants. Enrique?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveThanks, Bill, and good morning, everybody. Gross profit in total came to $815 million, an 8% gain versus the second quarter a year ago. The drivers were wholesale vehicle margin of $189 million, which rose 31%, plus used vehicle margin of $507 million, ahead 5% from the same quarter last year. Other gross profit reached $120 million, which is $7 million below the second quarter of last year. Favorability this quarter included $22 million in margin contribution from Edmunds, reflecting our June 1, 2021 acquisition. That came on revenues of $34.5 million, labeled as advertising and subscription revenues in the earnings release. Other gross profit also gained from an $18 million swing in third party finance fees, moving to income of $3 million from $15 million in costs a year ago. The reasons were lower Tier 3 volume versus last year along with our renegotiated third party finance fees. Working against that favorability, service fell $40 million, mainly because we were rolling over favorable items from the prior year's quarter and facing short term headwinds during this quarter. To be specific, we comped over the COVID-related cost reductions from last year. In addition, we saw higher 90-day warranty cost timing tied to the significant sales increase in the first quarter of fiscal year '22 relative to last year's first quarter. We also saw lower retail service margin as production capacity went toward reconditioning retail cars; also hitting other gross profit, EPP declined $6 million, or 5.4%. Although penetration held steady above 60%, the second quarter of last year contained a benefit of roughly $8 million in profit sharing revenues that went unrecognized this year because of a timing shift in the performance period for one of our providers. Turning to the S&GA side, second quarter expenses climbed to $574 million, 30% above our COVID impacted quarter a year ago, as we kept investing in our strategic initiatives and growth. Keep in mind that last year during the pandemic, we took aggressive cost containment actions, especially in the first half. SG&A as a percent of gross profit was 70.4% versus 58.8% in the prior year second quarter. The rise in SG&A dollars from last year came mostly from three main factors: first, a $55 million increase in total compensation and benefits from staffing and sales growth and from including Edmunds payroll this quarter; second, a $41 million increase in other overhead from investments to advance our technology platforms and strategic initiatives; third, a $35 million increase in advertising expense, as previously communicated, to amplify the CarMax brand, build awareness of our omnichannel offerings, and drive customer acquisition. We estimate the COVID-related cost savings in SG&A during the prior year quarter was between $25 million to $30 million. For the first six months of FY22, SG&A as a percent of gross profit was 64.8%, leveraging five points over last year's first half rate of 69.3%. We're still focused on making sure our spending is efficient, and we expect that the specific areas we're targeting will keep producing gains as time goes on; during Q2, we delivered another year-over-year decrease from our core CDC cost structure. On top of that, our omnichannel abilities will open up fresh possibilities as we use automation to bring down costs and make operations smoother. Take our online instant offer program, for instance — it's creating a more efficient buying organization as we keep harnessing automation, AI, and data science. When it comes to capital allocation, we stay focused on putting capital into our business to expand market share and produce long-term shareholder value. That means funding digital capabilities to improve every part of our omnichannel experience, including online vehicle acquisition, which is already delivering a strong ROI. We're also still investing in strategically growing our store footprint and seeking other ways to generate incremental value. As for our share repurchase program, we're still dedicated to giving excess capital back to shareholders, and we bought back roughly 1.8 million shares during the quarter for about $220 million. At this point, I'll hand the call to John.
Jon Daniels
executiveAppreciate that, Enrique, and morning to everyone. Our finance operation has, once more, turned in exceptional performance. Net of three-day payoffs, CAF’s penetration for Q2 came in at 43%, versus 42.6% during the same period 12 months earlier. Tier 2 fell to 21.6% of used unit sales, down from 22.3% a year prior. Tier 3 made up 7.2%, compared with 11.1% the prior year. As a reminder, during last year CAF made the strategic choice to direct part of its Tier 1 volume, along with the entirety of its allocated Tier 3 volume, toward partners so that the strong quality of its portfolio would be preserved through the early days of the pandemic. By the close of Q2 last year, those changes had been reversed. Through the quarter, we witnessed robust offers from our Tier 2 partners as they vied for extra volume inside the CarMax channel; we likewise saw application volume and conversion to sale decline among applications in the lower portion of the credit spectrum. Our view is that these declines stem mostly from the elevated average selling prices across the industry. In this year’s second quarter, powered by record used unit sales, CAF’s net loans originated totaled just under $2.4 billion. New customers were charged a weighted average contract rate of 8.5%, which is above the 8.2% of a year ago yet below the 9% recorded in Q1. Just as in the first quarter, this APR difference versus last year stems from a shift in the credit mix of customers, not from any rate increase. Across our portfolio, overall interest margin rose to 7.2%, against 6% during the equivalent period a year earlier, producing a year-over-year gain of $65 million, or 33%. This robust net interest margin underscores both the strength of our ABS program and the favorable condition of the capital markets. Because we recognize income across the life of our loans, we will reap the benefit of this elevated net interest margin over multiple years. CAF’s income for the quarter reached $200 million, up from $147 million a year ago; this sizable year-over-year rise is driven by the stronger net interest margin together with higher receivables. Our provision expense in Q2 was $35 million, leaving an ending reserve balance of $398 million for the second quarter, equal to 2.66% of managed receivables. That aligns with the 2.62% recorded at the close of the first quarter, while also reflecting a somewhat higher share of Tier 3 loans in the portfolio following our choice to retain 10% of Tier 3 volume. Given today’s macroeconomic backdrop, we consider our forward view on losses and the matching reserve to be suitable. When it comes to our lending platform and, more specifically, where CAF participates across the credit spectrum, we continually assess the landscape and stay dedicated to choices we view as sustainable over the long term and in our customers’ best interests. In Q2, working alongside our business partners, we kicked off a limited pilot for CAF within the Tier 2 segment. Just as happened when CAF moved into Tier 3, this pilot is going to stay at modest volumes over a lengthy stretch, since we're giving ourselves time to learn about the Tier 2 customer as well as how CAF's involvement in that segment can most effectively broaden the set of credit choices, make the customer experience better, and boost profitability. At this point I'll hand the call back to Bill.
Bill Nash
executiveThank you, Jon, and thank you, Enrique. Our teams have delivered impressive results this quarter across a diversified business model, and I couldn't be more proud of that — plus we're genuinely enthusiastic about the amazing opportunity in front of us. Our omnichannel platform was purposefully designed so that each customer can move toward either a purchase or a sale, no matter which way they choose to shop with us. What we've learned is that the majority of shoppers don't want buying a car to be restricted to either a dealership visit or a purely digital journey. Customers do have the option to purchase a vehicle entirely in-store or entirely online, yet what truly sets CarMax apart is our omnichannel capability, which lets shoppers tailor their experience by blending digital and physical touchpoints according to their preferences; during the second quarter, roughly 9% of retail units were sold online, which matches what we saw in the first quarter and is above the 3% recorded in the same quarter a year ago. Keep in mind that we count a sale as online retail when the customer handles all four of the major transactional steps remotely — those being placing a reserve on a car, arranging financing for the vehicle when required, trading in a car or choosing not to trade one in, and generating a sales order. Our wholesale auctions continue to operate virtually, meaning every wholesale sale — and wholesale represents 21% of total revenue — counts as an online transaction. Online transactions generated 28% of total revenues. That's higher than the 24% we saw in the first quarter and above the 18% posted in last year's second quarter. Omni sales accounted for approximately 55% of retail unit sales this quarter, unchanged from the first quarter and better than the 49% from the second quarter a year ago. We classify a sale as omni when the customer completes at least one of those major transactional steps remotely. Our efforts have centered on finishing the rollout of our 100% self-service experience, which lets customers complete the whole car buying journey on their own online should they prefer that. Right now, slightly over 50% of our customers can access a fully end-to-end, unaided online experience. We remain on schedule to extend this capability to every one of our retail consumers by the time the fiscal year ends. Keep in mind that although expanding access to these capabilities will let more customers complete a 100% self-service online experience, every customer today already has the option to purchase a car online with help from an associate; during the second quarter, we acquired roughly 188,000 vehicles from customers via our online instant appraisal, amounting to about half of all our buys from customers. That marks a 15% gain over our record first quarter figure. This growth reinforces our conviction that we have become the largest online purchaser of used autos from consumers in the U.S. and are continuing to strengthen that position. We keep improving our ecommerce offerings so we can surpass customer expectations and integrate smoothly with our best-in-class store experience. Let me give you a few examples. One area where we've made improvements is our financing process. Almost 65% of our finance customers begin the loan process online by submitting a pre-approval application, and as of Q2, all of those customers now get a digital decision featuring customized loan terms. With no extra time or effort, most of those customers are given digital access to their personal financing terms on each car in our inventory, which lets them shop more confidently. Beyond that, what sets our experience apart is the capability to offer these inventory-wide credit offers through multiple finance partners, CAF included; this guarantees we give our customers the most attractive rates and terms. We're thrilled about the strides we've made in this essential portion of the car buying journey. We also keep pushing forward what we consider industry-leading digital merchandising, which matters greatly for giving customers an immersive experience with our inventory while they shop remotely. During this quarter, we introduced 360 degree interior views taken from the driver's side and the back seat of the vehicle, and we keep enhancing vehicle hotspots, which are call-outs that help the customer grasp key vehicle features. We also keep using artificial intelligence to make sure our photos stay consistently high quality so they best represent our inventory. We're receiving very positive feedback about these improvements that help customers understand and fall in love with our vehicles while shopping online. Regarding our acquisition of Edmunds, we're very pleased with our progress, since our teams have hit the ground running on new innovations. We will keep investing in the Edmunds brand and collaborate to unlock opportunities to compete across the larger used auto ecosystem. We are really proud of the quarter and the significant progress we have made in advancing our omnichannel strategy; we are well positioned to deliver the most customer-centric experience in the used auto industry, which will enable sustainable growth and create meaningful long term shareholder value. With that, we'll be happy to take your questions, so Kevin?
Brian Nagel
analystHi, good morning.
Bill Nash
executiveGood morning Brian.
Brian Nagel
analystDavid, congratulations on the new role.
David Lowenstein
executiveThank you.
Brian Nagel
analystI suppose what I'd like to ask — and I realize you've touched on this somewhat in your remarks — is whether you could help us frame the 6.2% used unit comp for this quarter a little better. Given that context, and obviously with COVID and the recovery from the COVID crisis and all the internal initiatives, is there a way to consider that figure on a more normalized footing? How does it compare with what you'd consider the genuine health, the fundamental health of your business? And then, as a second point, from a positioning perspective, you and your team keep referring more and more to used cars alongside wholesale cars as a way to gauge total sales. Is that a sign of a bigger strategic change at CarMax? Thanks.
Bill Nash
executiveThanks for those questions, Brian. On the first one — look, we're very happy with the comps of roughly 6%, and the reason I say that is you have to add some context regarding the environment. There were a number of headwinds we dealt with in the quarter as well. To start with, inventory — it sits below the level we'd like. At quarter's end, it was probably around 30% below where we'd typically aim. Beyond that inventory pressure, we lacked sufficient staff and we still do, though not as severely. We were short-staffed essentially everywhere, and that matters not only because it limits our capacity to meet our SLAs, but sometimes we simply couldn't follow up with customers, which is never desirable, so we're addressing it. And then I believe another wider macro factor is simply used car valuations. What I mean is that compared with a year ago, acquisition prices have risen roughly $6,000, and I think Enrique mentioned during his opening remarks — or Jon mentioned during his opening remarks — how that might drive some used car shoppers right out of the market. When you consider the comp in that context, with those headwinds, all of them combined amount to significant headwinds, so we feel terrific about the quarter's comps and we also feel terrific about the progress overall; regarding your second question, how we discuss used and wholesale, yes — we do speak about it somewhat differently, but I think that truly traces back to part of what I said on analyst day, which is — you know, people always view us as this used car retailer, and that is indeed wonderful, but we're far more than that. We're a wonderful retailer, a wonderful wholesaler, a greater financier. Edmunds is now part of what we offer, dealer services are in the mix too, and that genuinely ties into the wider used-car ecosystem — so that's essentially the shift behind why we bring up both of them.
Brian Nagel
analystThat's useful, Bill. As a quick follow-up to what I asked earlier, can you put a number on what that 6.2 figure would have looked like without those headwinds hitting us during the quarter?
Bill Nash
executiveSure, Brian, I'll answer that — it's tough to pin down, and here's one illustration. With inventory sitting that low, having inventory down to that substantial degree would on its own represent a sizable headwind. That said, let me say this: I don't believe typical elasticity is in play at the moment, since so many people are running short on inventory; however, what I can share is that our sense is, once you combine all 3 of those factors, they amount to material headwinds, so once more, we're happy with how the quarter turned out on the comp side and in general.
Sharon Zackfia
analystHello, good morning. Anyone who's been checking out your site has probably noticed how the inventory situation has played out over the quarter. How much visibility do you have when it comes to bringing inventory back to something closer to normal levels? You said you anticipate continued improvement, the way it happened in the August quarter, but is this a matter of three, six months away? To put numbers to it, is staffing the problem, or is it vehicle acquisition? Give us some clarity on where the bottleneck sits today regarding inventory.
Bill Nash
executiveThanks, Sharon. Well, to start, vehicle acquisition isn't the problem. In my opening remarks I noted that we're roughly 70% self sufficient, so sourcing definitely isn't it. As I said in response to Brian's question, it has certainly been a headwind, and it all traces back to what took place in the fourth and the first quarter. Normally the fourth quarter is when we grow our inventory — we couldn't do so thanks to COVID and some winter disruption production, and then the first quarter brought record sales, so we're still climbing out of that hole. As I told Brian, we're roughly 30% light to target, and about 15% year-over-year. Comparing last year's second quarter with this second quarter, we're roughly 15% light. Sequentially, we made strong progress each month. Our inventory grew, and look — we intend to keep building inventory through the remainder of the year, and I believe the timing really comes down to — when we return to where we want to be will depend to some degree on demand. On staffing, yes — although we managed to build inventory during the quarter, we did face some headwinds on the staffing front too; but again, on staffing overall, we're making strong progress; we made strong progress staffing across the board all quarter and we keep making strong progress this quarter too.
Sharon Zackfia
analystYou told Brian it's difficult to put a number on how inventory affects things, and I understand that, but I'm wondering whether you've noticed a drop in conversion — since clearly each used car is unique, and with a narrower selection you must be missing out on sales. Could conversion be used as a metric to show what opportunities have slipped away?
Bill Nash
executiveSure — I'd say conversion dipped somewhat. There are a few lenses we use for conversion: the top-of-funnel stage, and then what happens inside the store. In-store performance held up pretty well, though at the top of the funnel we did see a decline, and we view that as a significant opportunity, since as we've long said, a leading reason customers choose not to purchase from us is that we lack the vehicle they want — and that effect is definitely amplified when your inventory is low.
Rick Nelson
analystThanks, good morning. I wanted to ask a follow-up about CAF and the plan to shift more Tier 3 business there. Could you compare how profitable a Tier 3 unit sale is versus one made to a third party lender, and what risks come along with that approach, I suppose?
Jon Daniels
executiveSure, yes. Thanks for asking, Rick. When it comes to a Tier 3 unit, meaning a Tier 3 sale from the finance side, clearly the cost to fund is usually higher, and that customer carries more risk, yet it will land only slightly below what a more prime loan would be, so to speak, which depends on the funding environment and clearly the APR we're able to charge, but let's say somewhere between $2,000 and $2,100 if you can capture the full finance economics possibly; however, greater risk exists there, so there's a funding element involved. Now clearly, thanks to our partners, we managed to renegotiate fees. Right now we pay $750 on those Tier 3 loans that our partners take on, and clearly as we noted at the beginning — during Q1, we began taking roughly 10% of the volume in the Tier 3 space. That volume makes us happy and we're grateful for it, and we'll keep evaluating the mix we ought to have. But in the end, for us, we want to ensure that whether we take on more Tier 3, or our partners take on more Tier 3, we're able to give excellent credit offers to those customers. Under our present credit platform construct, we believe we accomplish that, so those are the economics in play that respond to your question. Yet again, we're very pleased with how it's built today and we deliver strong offers to those customers.
Bill Nash
executiveYeah, and Rick, the one thing I’d tack onto that — regardless of whether we’re talking Tier 3, or Tier 2 too — the real issue is striking a balance among keeping the program sustainable, its profitability, and the experience the customer has, so every one of those factors goes into our thinking.
Rick Nelson
analystThat's reasonable. Appreciate it, and best of luck.
Bill Nash
executiveThanks, Rick.
Craig Kennison
analystHi there, and good morning. I appreciate you taking my question. Bill, the jump in cars coming through your web-based valuation tool is truly remarkable. Can you tell what those sellers might have done if that tool didn't exist — would they have turned up at a CarMax location, would they have visited a different dealership, would they have moved their vehicle through some kind of peer-to-peer listing site? What's the origin of these people?
Bill Nash
executiveCraig, I'd say — listen, the online piece has us feeling good. A great deal of incremental units are coming our way through it, I believe, since even the appraisal channel we've always had remains quite robust. Where those sellers would have otherwise ended up, I can't say for certain, yet we firmly believe the incremental value here is enormous, simply because this service is something we provide, so perhaps they'd have gone off and sold via other avenues, which avenues I couldn't tell you, but the incrementality is something we feel great about.
Craig Kennison
analystWhat share of online offers can you actually buy, and does that reveal anything regarding how competitive your offer is?
Bill Nash
executiveSure. So when it comes to our buy rate — the way we've historically described it is via our appraisal and our trade — the appraisal lane buy rate remains — well, it's extremely elevated, sitting in the low 30s. Regarding online offers, the way we truly view this right now is that if someone receives an online offer, since keep in mind we're sending out millions of online offers every quarter, our thinking is this: fine, after we've made an offer, how many of those customers come into the store, and among those customers who do come into the store, how many end up actually selling? As you'd expect, that buy rate — customers who arrive with an online offer and then actually sell — is in fact significantly greater than the traditional A-lane.
Rajat Gupta
analystThanks, and good to be able to ask a few things. My first one concerns certain investments you made during Q2. Obviously, advertising improved, the other investments improved, and you've brought on additional staff. Can you share any detail regarding how much of that has begun helping comps? Perhaps some insight into how September is shaping up would help too. And then regarding GPU, since used vehicle prices are climbing, you're back at it, with a strong August carrying into September, and probably through October-November too, and you'd earlier shared some detail on the <<inaudible>> figure for retail GPU. Could you give us comparable detail for Q4? That would help, and that's everything, thank you.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveHi Rajat. On SG&A, we strongly feel the present moment is the correct one to put money into expanding our company. We hold a very optimistic view of what's ahead, because of how strong and how our business is trending, and we will keep putting money into our growth, we will keep putting money into omni and ecommerce capabilities going forward; however, we remain on schedule to reach, by the close of this year, the ability to give as much as all of our retail customers 100% self sufficiency online, our self service online. We will keep putting money into bringing in customers through marketing. The spending on marketing is one we told you about a year ago, that we would increase our marketing advertising and other channels too. Once more, we think our platform is superior and we want to be sure we're conveying that effectively to our consumers, yet simultaneously there's also a highly targeted ROI chance in advertising too that we're putting money into, and finally we will keep putting money into bringing in vehicles. The instant offer program we rolled out, which has seen enormous success, is merely one illustration of those investments that delivers an excellent ROI, so we will keep putting money in; having said that, we do anticipate levering over the longer run since while we put money in, we likewise have cost efficiency efforts, be it the CECs or be it the buying organization or be it other channels too. We have chances to become more efficient in the way we operate, and so we'll keep doing that; though I believe it's key to keep in mind that we're on schedule with our investments, we're on schedule with our performance right now.
Bill Nash
executiveYeah, and Rajat, the one other thing I'd tack onto that is regarding — take advertising, for instance — we're genuinely happy with how that's performing. Web traffic rose roughly 19%. Typically we get a bit over 34 million visits to our site each month, so that's yet another case where it feels like the money we're putting in is delivering returns. On the second piece of what you asked, about GPUs, that's a really good question. The way I tend to view it — our current circumstances closely mirror what we had a quarter ago when this came up. Testing never stops around here. A few quarters back we mentioned running some tests at a wider scale, purely because of certain other elements, certain other profit channels flowing into the business, and although those are still present, exactly as was true a quarter ago, we genuinely wanted to confirm — you have to keep an eye on macro conditions and ask whether it's sensible. You have to examine where your inventory stands, you have to grasp the elasticity, and once more, we're still getting a handle on elasticity through the tests we routinely run, you want to know what rivals are up to, and ultimately it simply wasn't sensible to move further away from that historical pattern we follow on margins. In the end, we aim to carry inventory that's priced very, very competitively. With the self sufficiency piece, that definitely is a plus. Looking ahead, the way you ought to think about Q3 is that GPUs will likely land closer to historical averages, much the same as happened in Q2.
Michael Montani
analystHello, and thank you for addressing my question. I simply hoped to get more detail on how comparable sales moved through the quarter and how they began in Q3. Based on what our team observed, momentum seemed to pick up considerably by August and might even have reached double-digit growth by September. So I was hoping you might speak to that, ideally with specific figures, or if that isn't possible, at least explain what might have driven the improvement — whether it's inventory levels or a stronger multi-channel operation.
Bill Nash
executiveMorning, Michael. As I've mentioned, we're happy with how comps performed across the quarter. Each month came in positive, and the momentum has genuinely carried forward. This has been the case since March. That month set not just an all-time record but also a monthly record. Every month from April through August has likewise been a record for us individually, which leaves us feeling very good. As you noted, we're also quite encouraged by how Q3 has begun; naturally, we'll share more specifics once the third quarter wraps up.
Michael Montani
analystAlright, and if I may, regarding the margin side, I have a couple of questions. First, some people had expected a bit of upside on GPU because demand is fairly inelastic right now. I just wanted to see whether there's anything else we should factor in when it comes to how volatile pricing is in this environment, or whether maybe you're all putting more investment in. Then the second one was about advertising spend for the year and whether there are any cost reductions to think about as we move through 3Q and 4Q. What you mentioned for 2Q was useful — $25 million, $30 million.
Bill Nash
executiveOkay, yes. On margins, look — our margins are something we're always watching, and I know we likely have some competitors where a big jump in average selling prices means they'll take more margin. You've followed us long enough to know that ASPs don't really drive our margins. We feel very comfortable about where our margins are; for us, it's about making sure we get a great margin but also having great prices, so again to the question I answered earlier, I think the third quarter, you can think about margins more in the historical trend. Could you have taken more margin? Yes, but again, we're in this for the long haul and we want to make sure our prices are super competitive all the time, and we feel great about that. I'll let Enrique speak to the advertising.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYeah, so I’ve got 2 questions. When it comes to advertising, we said earlier in the year that what we expected to spend per unit for this year would be close to what we laid out during the back half of last year — so roughly the mid-300s for each unit — and through this year so far we’re tracking toward that, and we expect to hit it across the full year. As for comping over COVID and that $25 million to $30 million we think represented more or less one-time savings last year, the focus was really on the first half of the year. Some of those will still roll into Q3, though not at the same level of materiality as what we definitely saw in the first 2 quarters of the year.
Seth Basham
analystThank you very much, and good morning. I'd like to ask about GPUs and what's going on with pricing. Bill, could you perhaps share your thoughts on the direction of wholesale prices and retail prices during the quarter, and what effect that had on your retail GPU?
Bill Nash
executiveSure. From a mix adjustment perspective, obviously on the retail side, acquisition pricing rose by roughly $6,000. On the wholesale side, the increase was likely near $3,000. So both — honestly, in all my time in this business, those are the largest increases I can ever recall witnessing. That said, given how strong our self sufficiency is, I believe that opens up plenty of opportunities going forward, since it affects not just margin but also how you structure pricing. During the quarter, what we observed was this — we entered the first quarter with prices very elevated. That held steady for a bit; then we did see some depreciation occur, but to our surprise it began appreciating once more, so looking back, we likely ended the quarter at the same high point where we ended the first quarter. That's quite an intriguing dynamic. I can only guess — perhaps due to chip shortages, it appears the situation for new cars will last longer than what most people initially expected. Possibly some buyers are out there purchasing additional used cars to refill their lots, given that new cars won't be available, but it's certainly an intriguing dynamic we're witnessing.
Seth Basham
analystYeah, so the fact that pricing began climbing once more during the latter part of your quarter, which wasn't anticipated, ought to suggest you might have picked up extra margin on those unit sales, meaning your GPU as you closed out the quarter was likely doing better than when the quarter began? Is that how we should be looking at it?
Bill Nash
executiveNo, I'd simply say that more or less — you know, the manner in which we run our GPU truly doesn't — it doesn't factor in average selling prices. Other things play a role there, so I'd say it stayed pretty steady across the quarter, and that's how you ought to view it.
Adam Jonas
analystWhat's the reason you're continuing to repurchase shares? I mean, you've got this incredible — an opportunity for growth that comes along once in a generation, and your rivals are companies with a license to lose money and no expectation whatsoever of returning cash. I get that the business throws off cash and all of that, but hasn't the moment arrived to shift the philosophy and simply go all in on expanding the business and stop the buyback activity?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveAs you put it, we produce — we're fortunate to have an operating model and a business model that throws off a substantial amount of cash, and we're making the investments we believe are the correct ones at the correct moment, able to drive our growth, and even so — even with that in mind, we think we've got surplus cash to repurchase stock and give it back to shareholders. We aren't restraining our level of investments, and that's visible in our spend and in our capex, that we're investing aggressively. We'll keep doing that and even under that scenario, we have sufficient cash to repurchase shares. We are not restraining our investments.
John Murphy
analystMorning everyone. I want to ask about a couple of areas of strain. The first is inventory. Bill, you mentioned it a moment ago, and from what we understand about new vehicles, this shortage of new vehicle inventory will last deep into next year — almost certainly beyond the middle of next year, calendar year 2022. I'm wondering whether you expect those dynamics to ease before we reach that point. And then, thinking about staffing levels, it's becoming more and more difficult to find people at sensible wages, so cost inflation on the SG&A side and building up staff could prove tough too. I'm trying to figure out whether you can shift strategy, modify strategy, or simply adjust your growth strategy while dealing with these two macro factors, and when they might ease, since this is somewhat hiding all the positive things you're doing and clouding the narrative — though that isn't your fault, and these are macro issues you simply have to push through.
Bill Nash
executiveYes, whatever I say about the chip situation, the one thing I can probably promise is that I'll get it wrong. That said, I agree with you — I believe it will last all through this year, which could keep used cars at an elevated — you know, it will continue through this year and, I think, more or less through next year or a substantial portion of next year, which will keep prices elevated. But that's also why I'm so enthusiastic about the investments we've made in vehicle acquisition and things such as our instant offer, because that genuinely helps offset some of those headwinds and truly gives us a great deal of opportunity. As I mentioned earlier, we're making progress, continuing to build our inventory up, so we feel good about that. On staffing — look, we've always put money into our associates. They're the cause of our success, and right now, you know every employer out there is searching for staffing, and we're no different. We've kept investing more this quarter in our associates, we've implemented pay changes that we feel really good about. We also — look, for 17 years in a row, we've been one of the best places to work, which is terrific from an employer brand standpoint, so again even when it comes to staffing, we feel great about the trajectory we're on. So yes, there are some headwinds there, but we're making progress both on the inventory side and both on the staffing, and feel great about some of the opportunities that things like self sufficiency and IO give you.
John Murphy
analystWould it be accurate to say — or perhaps this is just a follow-up — that achieving SG&A leverage will prove tough during this stretch of macroeconomic strain? It appears as though — I mean, your team has performed remarkably well on same store sales and grosses in spite of these headwinds. I believe certain investors are worried about it, yet what you accomplished this quarter on the grosses and the volumes is quite extraordinary. Will you be in a position to achieve SG&A leverage before we make it through the conclusion of calendar year 2022? It appears as though pulling that off will be difficult. What do you think regarding that, and where ought we to consider that inflection point?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYes, we are definitely in investment mode, as we have stated clearly, and if you revisit our analyst day, our real focus is on driving our top line. Our focus is on driving market share and hitting and surpassing the target we set out there, which is greater than 5% market share by FY26, and that indeed calls for investments like those we have discussed, the investments in the various areas we referenced, without a doubt. Will leveraging be more difficult? Well, under that sort of environment, leveraging is somewhat more difficult, correct, and what we expect is that our gross profit will keep growing, it will grow robustly, and riding on that gross profit growth, opportunities exist to leverage specifically for this year for the entire year. What we expect remains that we ought to be able to leverage for this year. Looking quarter to quarter is difficult. You simply cannot look in quarter to quarter merely because so many things pop in and out of a quarter; but for the full year, we feel pretty good about that. Then going forward, once again we are in growth mode and we are investing accordingly, and at the same time and as I mention every quarter, we do examine opportunities to become more efficient. There are investments we are making to drive the top line, there are investments we are making to help pull out cost as well, and we always keep a sharp eye to that, so we will continue to do our best on that. At the same time, we are focused on market share growth and the opportunities that lay ahead of us, and we are really excited about them.
Ali-Ahmad Faghri
analystMorning, and thanks for letting me ask. Apologies in advance, but I have one more retail GPU question. I understand CarMax’s GPU isn’t really pushed by retail pricing, yet the gain in self sourcing alone—from below 50% to 70% during this quarter—ought to have delivered a sizable lift to GPU, since buying from consumers carries a cost edge over auction. You mentioned keeping your prices competitive, but judging by what we’ve seen, it also doesn’t appear that you’re beating competitors on volume in any meaningful way, so how should I reconcile those pieces?
Bill Nash
executiveYeah, so to start, our pricing position feels very strong to us, and we’ve studied it for quite a while, so we’re comfortable with where we stand on price. That said, this is only one quarter. Certain items take longer to play out, but I’d also point back to the fact that we faced some significant headwinds, and taken as a whole, they proved difficult to surmount, which I’ve already discussed—the inventory, the pricing itself, the staffing. Those pressures sit on top of self sufficiency. What excites us most, I think, is that self sufficiency and what it opens up for us going forward.
David Whiston
analystThank you, and good morning. I heard your comment that you're satisfied with pricing, yet when I turn to Page 6 and examine GPU, the gross margin per unit shown there, it has fallen substantially compared with a year earlier, and it's also lower than what we saw in the same quarter 2 years back. Of course, it's clearly a competitive marketplace as well. Do you <<inaudible>> to raise prices?
Bill Nash
executiveOkay David, let me make sure this is clear — regarding the GPU, when you take a look at it — for instance, during last year, the second quarter set a record for GPU, and we're just slightly below that level, so my take would be that if you consider our average over history, we sit at the upper end for GPU. My sense is there could be a slight disconnect in that view. Is raising GPUs something we could do? Without question, and listen — we will keep watching the macro factors to determine what's sensible. Being self sufficient hands us many opportunities moving ahead, though I believe simultaneously, our commitment here is for the long term and we want to be certain customers receive excellent value each day, and as a result we will keep balancing all factors going forward.
David Whiston
analystAll right, so I want to make sure we’re on the same page — my reference was to 8.3% against 11%, plus the 10.5% from two years back. That’s the reason my question was about pricing.
Bill Nash
executiveAh, my apologies. Your point had more to do with ASP? Right, and once more, I’d simply put that out there —
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveWhen you examine things unit by unit, the picture gets distorted — that percentage-of-revenue figure is artificially thrown off simply because retail prices have climbed roughly 30% since the year started, which makes it tough to evaluate that way. Our approach is to view the business on a per-unit basis.
Bill Nash
executiveYeah, and our approach to running it sets us apart from many of the other auto retailers that are publicly traded.
Chris Bottiglieri
analystHi, appreciate you fielding this. I had a couple of rapid questions regarding the other gross profit line. First off, I'm trying to get my head around why service gross profit appears to have turned negative in this quarter as a result of the warranty matter. In the coming quarter, or at some point, will it revert to that 20% to 30% gross margin level that has been the norm for you, or should we be factoring in something like a delay related to all of this warranty activity?
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveYeah, on service during this quarter, we were negative $40 million versus the prior year for the period, and our assessment is that a significant portion of that came from headwinds we encountered in the quarter that were truly more near term in nature. The biggest two, I'd say, first was the 90-day warranty you brought up, and if you consider it, our comps in Q1 of this year stood at 99%. In Q1 of the prior year, they were at negative 42%, so what you have is significantly greater volume from a 90-day standpoint for warranty work that flows into the following quarter, so that is very much a timing dynamic; the second item is, much like SG&A, we simply had one-time COVID-related savings from the prior year in support pay along with the employee retention credit plan, and those are also more near term in nature. A significant portion of that is genuinely near term. What I would say is that historically, service has been a positive margin contributor for us. Last year was the outlier — obviously it wasn't during COVID, but in earlier years it had contributed positively to margin, and going forward on an annual basis, we do anticipate that it will keep contributing positively to margin as well. That said, in this quarter, those two headwinds definitely made things somewhat more difficult.
Rajat Gupta
analystI appreciate the chance to rejoin the queue. My question is a follow-up, more of a housekeeping item regarding SG&A. What portion of the sequential increase in SG&A came from the Edmunds acquisition, and could you also outline a few of the components within SG&A? That would be quite useful. Thank you.
Enrique Mayor-Mora
executiveSure. On the Edmunds side, I mentioned during my prepared remarks that on a gross profit basis, Edmunds added roughly $20 million. You will see that reflected in the 10-Q when we file it tomorrow. Broadly speaking, since it’s an operating segment, Edmunds is—we will report it as an operating segment rather than a reporting segment, so going forward we will disclose their revenues and their gross profit, but that is as far as our reporting on them will go. What I can share with you, Rajat, is that on the whole, they were slightly accretive to CarMax, so you can essentially derive their SG&A by working backward with that method.
Bill Nash
executiveOkay, thanks Kevin. So, we appreciate you being with us today, for the questions and for sticking with us. We feel good about our capacity to bring together our top-tier physical and digital offerings without a hitch, and when you factor in our varied business approach, we’ll keep generating expansion and picking up market share going forward. As ever, I’d like to express gratitude to our over 27,000 team members for your ongoing commitment, for embodying our principles daily, for looking after one another, the shoppers and our neighborhoods. Each of you is why we continue to be a constructive disrupter in the pre-owned vehicle sector. Once more, thank you all for your time today, and we’ll speak again in the next quarter.
Operator
operatorEveryone, that brings today’s presentation to a close. You’re welcome to disconnect at this point, and I hope the rest of your day is wonderful.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete CarMax, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to CarMax, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in CarMax, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.